TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
NOTE
This file was generated by Descript
00:00:00.176 --> 00:00:02.366
Martin: Good morning, and
happy Monday everyone.
00:00:02.366 --> 00:00:04.066
Welcome to The Grand Roundup.
00:00:04.086 --> 00:00:07.476
We've got Kevin and Martin
here from Health Tech Nerds.
00:00:07.936 --> 00:00:11.526
Today, on The Grand Roundup, we are
talking about Proper, Assort, and the
00:00:11.526 --> 00:00:15.666
race to be the winning platform for
agentic voice AI for care delivery.
00:00:15.666 --> 00:00:17.146
Boy, that's a mouthful.
00:00:17.656 --> 00:00:22.096
Uh, a couple other fundraising rounds
that caught our attention, Alan,
00:00:22.096 --> 00:00:24.326
Trase, Cadence, Hera, and Upside.
00:00:24.936 --> 00:00:26.586
CityBlock is acquiring Homeward.
00:00:27.536 --> 00:00:29.336
Kevin, I think you have
to read this next one.
00:00:30.016 --> 00:00:30.816
Kevin: What's up, doc?
00:00:31.556 --> 00:00:33.736
Martin: What, what, what is up with UpDoc?
00:00:34.816 --> 00:00:37.896
And lasers, and later
on, we're welcoming Dr.
00:00:37.946 --> 00:00:42.106
Jeremy Fries, CEO and founder of
Humata Health to talk about WISeR,
00:00:42.376 --> 00:00:48.616
prior auth, and how to make payers
and providers sit and sing kumbaya.
00:00:49.126 --> 00:00:53.026
But before that, uh, let's,
let's get into the Proper and
00:00:53.026 --> 00:00:55.826
Assort, um, fundraising rounds.
00:00:55.836 --> 00:00:57.226
So there's a- Prosper.
00:00:57.226 --> 00:00:58.346
Prosper, excuse me.
00:00:58.346 --> 00:00:58.436
You're
00:00:58.436 --> 00:01:00.316
Kevin: going, you're going
proper on Monday mornings.
00:01:01.696 --> 00:01:03.176
Martin: Uh, whoops.
00:01:03.246 --> 00:01:03.606
Okay.
00:01:03.676 --> 00:01:08.866
So Kevin, we had a couple of large
and notable fundraising rounds
00:01:08.876 --> 00:01:10.976
last week in the same space.
00:01:11.066 --> 00:01:11.706
What was going on?
00:01:12.826 --> 00:01:15.206
Kevin: So two big rounds
caught our attention.
00:01:15.256 --> 00:01:19.106
Prosper AI raised 30 million bucks.
00:01:19.146 --> 00:01:22.536
Um, Andreessen Horowitz,
a16z led the round.
00:01:22.536 --> 00:01:26.516
Others were, uh, also involved in
the round, and then on Wednesday,
00:01:26.576 --> 00:01:30.286
Assort Health announced their latest
funding round, 120 million bucks,
00:01:30.326 --> 00:01:32.956
Menlo Ventures and others at a 1.2
00:01:32.956 --> 00:01:33.896
billion valuation.
00:01:34.956 --> 00:01:41.066
Both, um, uh, talk about their, uh, growth
trajectory in the funding rounds, right?
00:01:41.106 --> 00:01:45.286
They, Prosper reported that in the
last six months it's grown revenue 5X,
00:01:46.106 --> 00:01:47.906
an impressive growth rate obviously.
00:01:47.996 --> 00:01:52.556
Assort reported it has grown revenue
by 20X over the last 15 months.
00:01:53.156 --> 00:01:56.206
If you go back from one of their
previous announcements, I think
00:01:56.206 --> 00:01:59.996
it was in TechCrunch, it reported
that they were at a 3
Load full transcript
million ARR.
00:02:00.616 --> 00:02:04.806
Um, so if you do the math, uh, on
that, which was about 15 months ago I,
00:02:04.846 --> 00:02:09.256
I believe, um, it implies they're at
around 60 million in ARR today, which
00:02:09.286 --> 00:02:11.536
you can do the valuation comps on today.
00:02:13.146 --> 00:02:17.046
It was, what caught my attention in
the funding rounds is, um, they both
00:02:17.046 --> 00:02:22.106
included customer quotes, and the
customer quotes from each, uh, caught my
00:02:22.106 --> 00:02:25.496
attention in, in how similar they sounded.
00:02:25.536 --> 00:02:29.066
For Assort, talked about how,
"We evaluated every AI solution
00:02:29.066 --> 00:02:32.376
on the market, and Assort was
onl- the only true platform."
00:02:32.396 --> 00:02:34.976
This was from the CEO of
a dermatology practice.
00:02:35.916 --> 00:02:38.636
For Prosper, it was, "We evaluated
seven different vendors through an
00:02:38.636 --> 00:02:42.946
extensive RFP and live demonstration
process and concluded that Prosper AI
00:02:42.956 --> 00:02:44.646
had the most comprehensive platform."
00:02:44.996 --> 00:02:48.616
This was from a, a provider consortium
representing a group of providers.
00:02:51.688 --> 00:02:55.548
I, I, I find those quotes really
hard to decipher personally.
00:02:55.688 --> 00:02:58.448
I, you know, Martin, if, like, you're
putting together a press release, I can
00:02:58.448 --> 00:02:59.938
imagine why you're doing that, right?
00:02:59.978 --> 00:03:02.818
You wanna, you wanna convey to
the market that you are building
00:03:02.818 --> 00:03:04.548
a platform in this space.
00:03:05.008 --> 00:03:08.998
Um, a lot of these companies are starting
off as point solutions that are getting
00:03:08.998 --> 00:03:13.258
in the door with organizations with one
specific use case, and you are telling
00:03:13.258 --> 00:03:17.138
the narrative that, that you are going
to be the full end-to-end platform
00:03:17.158 --> 00:03:19.438
offering for these organizations.
00:03:19.458 --> 00:03:21.898
It makes sense from a positioning
perspective, it makes sense from a
00:03:21.898 --> 00:03:24.698
financial model perspective, 'cause
that is how you get larger contracts.
00:03:24.728 --> 00:03:27.748
That is how you justify these
really large valuations.
00:03:28.658 --> 00:03:31.688
But the way in which we get these two
large funding rounds on back-to-back
00:03:31.688 --> 00:03:36.038
days, and you have these two quotes come
out at the exact same time talking about
00:03:36.048 --> 00:03:41.528
how medical groups are comprehensively
evaluating doing RFPs on the market and
00:03:41.528 --> 00:03:46.108
coming to completely different conclusions
on what the only platform offering is,
00:03:46.898 --> 00:03:49.758
it feels indicative of where things
are at to me in this space, right?
00:03:50.058 --> 00:03:51.798
So that, that caught my
attention in the round.
00:03:52.028 --> 00:03:52.848
What'd you make of it?
00:03:53.608 --> 00:03:55.638
Martin: Yeah, feels a
little, a little frothy.
00:03:55.638 --> 00:03:59.048
I think the It is interesting.
00:03:59.048 --> 00:04:02.758
I would love to, to know, I would
love to see the scorecards from those
00:04:02.848 --> 00:04:07.898
evaluations and see if they were going
head-to-head- Yeah ⦠or if, um, or
00:04:07.898 --> 00:04:11.218
if not, you know, if there was a, a
d- sort of different competitive set.
00:04:11.528 --> 00:04:14.288
I will say, outside of these
two companies, there are a lot
00:04:14.288 --> 00:04:17.508
of companies that are sort of
adjacent to this agentic voice AI-
00:04:17.508 --> 00:04:17.978
Kevin: Mm-hmm
00:04:17.978 --> 00:04:20.428
Martin: that are thinking
about this space as well.
00:04:20.628 --> 00:04:22.618
Some quite large, some quite small.
00:04:22.888 --> 00:04:26.438
They're all sort of, I think, focused
on different niches, and I, I feel
00:04:26.438 --> 00:04:31.978
like in the near term, there's really
plenty of space for all of them to keep
00:04:31.978 --> 00:04:36.128
on posting impressive month-over-month
and year-over-year growth.
00:04:36.128 --> 00:04:39.398
I mean, the, the, all of the
press releases cite the huge
00:04:39.398 --> 00:04:43.398
amount of administrative spend
in American healthcare, and,
00:04:43.398 --> 00:04:45.228
like, that's your TAM, right?
00:04:45.288 --> 00:04:48.008
Uh, and there's a lot of that.
00:04:48.008 --> 00:04:53.868
There's a lot of independent practices
and PE roll-ups and hospitals.
00:04:53.878 --> 00:05:00.898
And so it does not seem impossible to
me that there is, uh, r- a few more
00:05:01.148 --> 00:05:05.078
months or years where we can keep
getting press releases like this.
00:05:05.478 --> 00:05:08.268
But- sure ⦠in the
long run, I don't know.
00:05:08.318 --> 00:05:13.278
Like, that seems, I think, a little
bit harder, is, is that long run story.
00:05:13.918 --> 00:05:14.318
Kevin: Yeah.
00:05:14.848 --> 00:05:16.898
There, there are certainly
a lot of companies right now
00:05:16.898 --> 00:05:17.998
going after this market, right?
00:05:18.008 --> 00:05:22.618
Like, if you, if you type in Prosper
AI or Assort into Google, the
00:05:22.618 --> 00:05:26.658
sponsored results indicate how many
companies are going after this space.
00:05:26.678 --> 00:05:28.188
I just typed in Prosper AI.
00:05:28.528 --> 00:05:32.618
They show up, Elise AI shows up,
SuperDial shows up, Sierra shows up.
00:05:33.088 --> 00:05:35.918
Um, I see Align in other interviews.
00:05:35.948 --> 00:05:38.728
I mean, it goes o- like,
it goes on and on, right?
00:05:39.318 --> 00:05:42.828
Uh, which is indicative of, I
think, the activity in the market.
00:05:43.238 --> 00:05:46.598
One of the interesting things that
I find about this space too is that
00:05:46.598 --> 00:05:50.128
because it's patient-facing, we can
interact with these things, right?
00:05:50.168 --> 00:05:53.938
Like, it is not hard to call
up these practices and- I think
00:05:53.938
--> 00:05:54.758
you have ⦠see what theseâ¦
00:05:54.968 --> 00:05:57.418
I, I, I have done this in the past, yes.
00:05:57.728 --> 00:06:02.318
I, I do not believe it was appreciated
that I have done it, because I, I, as I
00:06:02.318 --> 00:06:08.138
understand it, I jammed up a practice's,
um, potential visits, which I think is
00:06:08.138 --> 00:06:12.758
another set of questions on, on how that
happens when these tools are supposed to
00:06:12.768 --> 00:06:14.878
be AI to help prevent that from happening.
00:06:15.158 --> 00:06:16.978
But nonetheless, like,
you can experience them.
00:06:17.228 --> 00:06:20.488
And I, I think it'll be
interesting to keep an eye on
00:06:20.488 --> 00:06:22.388
that over time, because I- Iâ¦
00:06:22.768 --> 00:06:27.998
current state, it, it feels a bit
like an IVR solution to me, that I,
00:06:28.568 --> 00:06:32.298
I, I get the bigger pitch of how AI
is gonna transform these practices.
00:06:32.478 --> 00:06:36.128
When I call them up and I experiencing
the IVR solution, it doesn't, it
00:06:36.128 --> 00:06:37.748
doesn't feel like that yet, you know?
00:06:38.198 --> 00:06:43.234
And- I think that, plus the way in which
these press releases come out, plus
00:06:43.234 --> 00:06:46.744
the amount of activity, it naturally
invites some skepticism to your point on
00:06:46.744 --> 00:06:48.484
how durable this is over the long term.
00:06:48.494 --> 00:06:51.964
Like, it feels to me, and I saw
this a little bit in the, in the
00:06:51.964 --> 00:06:56.814
Prosper announcement, there clearly
is an opportunity for practices
00:06:56.814 --> 00:07:03.774
where staffing is really challenging
today, and it, y- y- you can u- use
00:07:03.774 --> 00:07:08.864
tools like this to drive revenue
growth and, and cost savings, right?
00:07:08.934 --> 00:07:11.664
And that was one of the things I mentioned
in the newsletter this weekend, is like
00:07:11.934 --> 00:07:17.364
they have a ton of really impressive case
studies of small practice that's seeing
00:07:17.364 --> 00:07:19.154
a million dollars of revenue increase.
00:07:19.634 --> 00:07:22.774
And if you can do that, and you
can show that increase in a matter
00:07:22.774 --> 00:07:25.964
of weeks, like of course you're
gonna get the uptake, right?
00:07:26.194 --> 00:07:27.544
It's, it's pretty impressive.
00:07:28.414 --> 00:07:32.324
Martin: Speaking of uptake, should we go
to the dueling up into the right slides?
00:07:32.324 --> 00:07:32.714
Let's do it.
00:07:32.714 --> 00:07:38.634
These were like m- master class, and we're
building, we're building an awesome, uh,
00:07:38.684 --> 00:07:44.054
a- awesome slide to show our, our growth,
and we're gonna cherry-pick our metrics
00:07:44.054 --> 00:07:46.414
to make it look especially awesome.
00:07:46.724 --> 00:07:49.184
So on the left, we have Assort Health'sâ¦
00:07:49.434 --> 00:07:55.084
They did patient interactions with voice
AI, and like wow, that's an incredible
00:07:55.094 --> 00:07:57.984
uptick in, in patient AI, and then, uhâ¦
00:07:57.984 --> 00:07:59.774
Or patient interactions with voice AI.
00:08:00.094 --> 00:08:04.424
And then on the right, Prosper
has their, um, their patient care
00:08:04.474 --> 00:08:06.669
dollars managed by Prosper AI.
00:08:06.669 --> 00:08:07.184
Mm-hmm.
00:08:08.144 --> 00:08:09.204
Super impressive.
00:08:09.384 --> 00:08:11.774
S- very steep up into the right curves.
00:08:11.974 --> 00:08:16.154
Like I said, I think that there's enough
headroom in this market, and the market
00:08:16.154 --> 00:08:21.194
structure is such that, um, on either
of these metrics, like if you land at
00:08:21.194 --> 00:08:28.374
one PE-owned asset and you can expand
across those assets, you can, you know,
00:08:28.854 --> 00:08:33.904
double, triple, quadruple year over
year relatively straightforwardly just
00:08:33.904 --> 00:08:39.244
by going through and saying, "Hey, we
saved 100 grand for, for so-and-so.
00:08:39.254 --> 00:08:40.384
We can do that forâ¦"
00:08:40.444 --> 00:08:42.364
Or, "We added 100 grand in EBITDA.
00:08:42.404 --> 00:08:44.154
We can do that for all of your practices."
00:08:46.004 --> 00:08:46.404
Kevin: Yeah.
00:08:46.534 --> 00:08:51.904
I, I can't imagine a more straightforward
pitch to a private equity group that
00:08:51.904 --> 00:08:56.524
is, you know, owns some practices, and
to that end, we've seen some of these
00:08:56.524 --> 00:09:00.524
organizations with jobs posted that
are purely about being a strategic
00:09:00.524 --> 00:09:03.734
partnership leader for private equity
groups that own medical practices.
00:09:03.744 --> 00:09:07.214
Like, like clearly is a key
part of the go-to-market mission
00:09:07.214 --> 00:09:08.914
here that is, that is winning.
00:09:09.774 --> 00:09:15.544
But if you're like, "Hey, you've got
front office issues in your practices.
00:09:15.984 --> 00:09:20.364
This is resulting in phone calls
not being answered and wait times,
00:09:20.364 --> 00:09:22.524
which is a bad customer experience."
00:09:22.524 --> 00:09:26.014
It, yeah, it like, uh, it seems
like a win-win-win, right?
00:09:26.034 --> 00:09:30.034
That, uh, answer your phones, make more
money as a practice, provide a better
00:09:30.034 --> 00:09:34.894
patient experience, have access into your
providers in a way that you didn't before.
00:09:34.894 --> 00:09:37.414
Like, uh, there's nothing
wrong about that, right?
00:09:39.088 --> 00:09:43.168
Martin: No, I think to me the questions
are, number one, how many of these
00:09:43.178 --> 00:09:44.818
platforms can the market support?
00:09:45.158 --> 00:09:45.248
Yeah.
00:09:45.248 --> 00:09:51.148
Number two, h- how do the employed
physicians of these practices feel?
00:09:51.158 --> 00:09:56.948
Like th- there is a, there was a
Health Affairs article a little while
00:09:56.948 --> 00:09:59.718
back which talked about how it's
like when private equity takes over a
00:09:59.718 --> 00:10:03.118
practice, uh, patient
access increases.
00:10:03.518 --> 00:10:09.348
And it is a nice thing for a doctor
to have a slower, unoptimized
00:10:09.348 --> 00:10:14.328
schedule, and having a AI-optimized,
completely full schedule is
00:10:15.108 --> 00:10:18.468
less fun, as you could imagine.
00:10:18.478 --> 00:10:22.388
And so I'm curious, like, what the dy-
how the dynamics of that shake out.
00:10:22.398 --> 00:10:22.428
Mm-hmm.
00:10:22.708 --> 00:10:28.658
And then the third question that I
have is, holy smokes, like we are,
00:10:29.058 --> 00:10:37.258
we are pushing a lot to voice AI,
and the channel that, you know,
00:10:37.268 --> 00:10:39.418
voice AI uses is the, the phone.
00:10:40.018 --> 00:10:44.648
And right now that is a pretty
valuable channel because you know,
00:10:44.668 --> 00:10:47.408
for the most part, or you historically
knew when someone called you or
00:10:47.408 --> 00:10:48.938
texted you that it was a person.
00:10:50.894 --> 00:10:52.354
And it was not spam.
00:10:52.584 --> 00:10:58.754
And a reminder or something like
that seems like a great u- like a, a
00:10:58.754 --> 00:11:03.664
reminder or a phone tree or a scheduling
thing seems like a great use of AI.
00:11:03.684 --> 00:11:08.154
But like- Yeah ⦠if, if it is the case
that this stuff becomes cheap enough
00:11:08.174 --> 00:11:17.494
that, like, scammers and political
fundraising phone calls and salespeople
00:11:17.504 --> 00:11:21.244
start using it, then the channel just
gets a little bit muddier, right?
00:11:21.274 --> 00:11:25.244
And so it's like, yeah, someone
calls in and they can get
00:11:25.244 --> 00:11:26.924
scheduled, but your reminderâ¦
00:11:27.604 --> 00:11:31.634
I get a lot of, you know, pa- uh, yeah,
patient reminder emails and phone calls
00:11:31.634 --> 00:11:34.534
right now, and it's becoming one of
those things where, like, I see it,
00:11:34.574 --> 00:11:38.464
I don't recognize the number, or I,
I assume that it is going to be a, a
00:11:38.464 --> 00:11:39.854
robot and I just send it to voicemail.
00:11:40.164 --> 00:11:41.084
So I don't know.
00:11:41.154 --> 00:11:43.204
Those are my, I, I guess,
like, three questions.
00:11:43.264 --> 00:11:46.204
Any reactions on those, on those three?
00:11:46.344 --> 00:11:47.054
Kevin: That all tracks.
00:11:47.074 --> 00:11:51.184
It reminds me of a few years back,
I remember hearing a startup story.
00:11:51.224 --> 00:11:54.514
Uh, there's an organization that was
getting a lot of traction because they
00:11:54.514 --> 00:11:57.734
had figured out how to spoof numbers
so that it looked like provider's
00:11:57.764 --> 00:11:59.314
phone call or provider's number.
00:11:59.323 --> 00:12:01.063
if you can spoof their
number, so you know, Iâ¦
00:12:01.283 --> 00:12:04.103
There's gonna be all sorts of little stuff
like that that happens in the space that,
00:12:04.803 --> 00:12:09.873
uh, we're gonna have to pay attention
to as we enter into this new world.
00:12:10.233 --> 00:12:13.963
I, I think
those are the right,
um, I think those are the
00:12:13.963 --> 00:12:15.123
right questions to be asking.
00:12:15.133 --> 00:12:20.813
The only other thing that comes to mind in
all of this is it was interesting to me to
00:12:20.813 --> 00:12:25.523
see in the Assort press release that they
are now working with John Muir Health.
00:12:25.993 --> 00:12:32.053
Which John Muir system in California,
notably back in like 2019, 2018,
00:12:32.053 --> 00:12:35.863
entered into a huge outsourcing
deal with Optum for all of its rev
00:12:35.863 --> 00:12:41.083
cycle and IT around core rev cycle
opportunities, but then also your
00:12:41.083 --> 00:12:44.733
broader set of IT patient experience
opportunities, so on and so forth
00:12:46.911 --> 00:12:50.271
Obviously there's advantage from
a contract size perspective if you
00:12:50.271 --> 00:12:51.981
get into the health system market.
00:12:52.041 --> 00:12:57.681
Health system have more patient revenue,
uh, and that should flow down to larger
00:12:57.681 --> 00:12:59.261
contracts with these organizations.
00:13:00.001 --> 00:13:03.401
I am-- We have, we have talked a lot
about the kind of private equity, small
00:13:03.401 --> 00:13:08.021
medical practice, go-to-market mission
as being core to the narrative right now.
00:13:08.511 --> 00:13:12.921
I'm curious to keep an eye on do they
go upstream into health systems more?
00:13:12.981 --> 00:13:17.081
Do we see Assure starting to sell
more and more of these deals,
00:13:17.501 --> 00:13:20.421
and what is the implication of
that for the market as a whole?
00:13:20.431 --> 00:13:24.341
Because right now, to the previous
conversation, it seems like the
00:13:24.341 --> 00:13:28.891
go-to-market playbook has been,
uh, a pretty well-oiled machine
00:13:28.931 --> 00:13:32.561
of private equity practices that
wanna see that margin improvement.
00:13:32.581 --> 00:13:35.281
You can show that immediately, off you go.
00:13:35.921 --> 00:13:40.141
How you do that in a system like
John Muir, which is much larger,
00:13:40.161 --> 00:13:43.381
presumably you're not seeing
that uplift in a matter of weeks.
00:13:43.981 --> 00:13:46.991
I'll be really interested to keep my eyes
on that too, because that, that feels
00:13:46.991 --> 00:13:50.911
like a different, different go-to-market
strategy entirely, a different,
00:13:51.021 --> 00:13:52.351
different ball game, if you will.
00:13:53.709 --> 00:13:57.189
Martin: Different pond to swim in
and different competitor set, right?
00:13:57.189 --> 00:13:57.559
Like y-
00:13:57.559 --> 00:13:57.879
Kevin: Uh-huh
00:13:58.179 --> 00:14:03.379
⦠Martin: there, there are a lot of health
system focused agentic voice AI companies-
00:14:03.379 --> 00:14:04.899
For sure ⦠or would like- Yes ⦠to be.
00:14:04.959 --> 00:14:09.499
And so- Yeah ⦠that is like a, that is
gonna be a fascinating thing to watch.
00:14:09.849 --> 00:14:12.619
I think another point you made in
the newsletter that has kind of
00:14:12.709 --> 00:14:17.579
stuck with me is all of these things
are increasing healthcare costs.
00:14:17.579 --> 00:14:18.199
It is aâ¦
00:14:18.229 --> 00:14:22.589
The pitch is like, for not very much
money we can create more revenue, and
00:14:22.589 --> 00:14:24.719
that is increases healthcare costs, right?
00:14:24.719 --> 00:14:28.619
Like, that was spending that didn't
happen before and it's happening today.
00:14:28.779 --> 00:14:29.649
It would be good spending.
00:14:29.669 --> 00:14:32.399
I'm not saying that, you know,
it's not a, a derogatory thing.
00:14:32.409 --> 00:14:35.789
But it is, like, increasing
utilization of the healthcare system.
00:14:36.499 --> 00:14:42.199
There'll inevitably be pushback on
that from taxpayers, payers, et cetera.
00:14:42.399 --> 00:14:45.919
And so that is one thing
that can kind of hem this in.
00:14:46.179 --> 00:14:50.349
The other question that I have, and
we're getting a bit out over my skis
00:14:50.349 --> 00:14:54.079
here, but one thing you read in, like,
the Wall Street Journal, and the FT, and
00:14:54.079 --> 00:14:59.019
Bloomberg is companies are talking about,
"Holy smokes, my token spend is high."
00:14:59.539 --> 00:15:02.069
Uh, they're, like, waking
up with these large bills.
00:15:02.979 --> 00:15:06.429
I would imagine voice AI
is pretty token intensive.
00:15:06.469 --> 00:15:10.229
Like, it, it, it- Yeah ⦠it strikes
me as a, a token intensive activity.
00:15:10.439 --> 00:15:11.219
Maybe I'm wrong.
00:15:11.639 --> 00:15:17.429
I wonder to what degree there
is a, a subsidy happening today,
00:15:18.109 --> 00:15:23.509
and to what degree this is, like,
valuable versus a, a human call
00:15:23.509 --> 00:15:25.849
center once the subsidy expires.
00:15:26.459 --> 00:15:26.759
Kevin: Yeah.
00:15:26.939 --> 00:15:33.539
I would love to see the unit economics
and gross margins of voice AI
00:15:33.569 --> 00:15:36.189
versus humans in call center today.
00:15:36.369 --> 00:15:41.799
And to your point, how much of voice AI
is being subsidized right now, and what
00:15:41.799 --> 00:15:46.899
does that cost look li- Like, what are
you implying, assuming from a, a how
00:15:46.899 --> 00:15:51.829
much costs go down over time to make this
actually work from a P&L perspective?
00:15:51.849 --> 00:15:52.509
Iâ¦
00:15:53.929 --> 00:15:55.919
It'd be, it'd be interesting
to have somebody come on and,
00:15:55.939 --> 00:15:57.489
and describe that P&L for sure.
00:15:57.889 --> 00:15:58.369
Martin: Yes.
00:15:59.229 --> 00:16:01.019
Should we switch gears and
talk about some of the other
00:16:01.019 --> 00:16:03.049
fundraising rounds from last week?
00:16:03.269 --> 00:16:03.739
Kevin: Let's do it.
00:16:03.789 --> 00:16:06.149
There were a lot of funding rounds
to go through from last week.
00:16:06.159 --> 00:16:06.899
Martin: Yeah.
00:16:07.449 --> 00:16:10.869
Um, okay, so first up is Alan.
00:16:11.859 --> 00:16:14.439
Raised 480 million euros.
00:16:14.629 -->
00:16:15.399
I think weâ¦
00:16:15.479 --> 00:16:19.069
Yep, 555 million American
dollars at a $6.3
00:16:19.069 --> 00:16:20.769
billion valuation.
00:16:21.509 --> 00:16:23.039
This caught, I think, both of our eyes.
00:16:23.049 --> 00:16:27.949
So the, the LinkedIn post
from, uh, Jean-Charles shared
00:16:27.949 --> 00:16:28.699
some interesting stuff.
00:16:28.699 --> 00:16:29.259
1.1
00:16:29.259 --> 00:16:33.689
million members, 800 million in euros.
00:16:34.109 --> 00:16:35.869
Sorry for switching back and forth.
00:16:35.889 --> 00:16:40.929
In ARR, growing 53% year over
year, profitable in France.
00:16:41.119 --> 00:16:44.399
Live across France,
Belgium, Spain, and Canada.
00:16:45.329 --> 00:16:46.119
What do you make of this?
00:16:49.005 --> 00:16:53.105
Kevin: I, I think it is cool to see it
in InsurTech that is gaining momentum.
00:16:53.135 --> 00:17:01.075
Obviously, here in the States we, we had
our experience with Oscar, Bright, Clover,
00:17:01.445 --> 00:17:07.755
Harken, um, there were a few others back
in like the 2015 to 2020 era, right?
00:17:09.709 --> 00:17:14.299
It is really hard building a health
insurance company from the gRoundup,
00:17:14.599 --> 00:17:16.209
um, and trying to grow that.
00:17:16.249 --> 00:17:19.439
And so m- part of me, kudos to them, 1.1
00:17:19.439 --> 00:17:22.349
million members is pretty incredible.
00:17:22.499 --> 00:17:23.939
Um, that's cool to see.
00:17:25.059 --> 00:17:30.049
The other is, the other side of the,
the spectrum here is it's a bit funny
00:17:30.049 --> 00:17:34.099
to me to see comments like, "We're
profitable in France, live across
00:17:34.109 --> 00:17:35.639
France, Belgium, Spain, and Canada."
00:17:35.899 --> 00:17:39.289
It's like, how do you tell me
that you are actually unprofitable
00:17:39.299 --> 00:17:42.559
organizationally without telling
me that, a sentence like that?
00:17:43.219 --> 00:17:45.139
Because otherwise you would
have said, "We are profitable."
00:17:45.149 --> 00:17:45.169
Yeah.
00:17:45.759 --> 00:17:51.349
Like, so France, I would presume, given
how you pronounce, pronounced the, the
00:17:51.349 --> 00:17:54.629
company name, I would have pronounced
it as an uneducated American, Alan.
00:17:55.149 --> 00:18:00.999
Uh, presumably France is their core
market where a majority of their 1.1
00:18:00.999 --> 00:18:02.839
million members are located.
00:18:03.409 --> 00:18:06.829
Uh, they're in three other
markets that must be notâ¦
00:18:06.929 --> 00:18:10.599
I, I, I mean, the profitability
of France must be marginal and
00:18:10.609 --> 00:18:16.089
being offset by unprofitability in
Belgium, Spain, Canada as it expands.
00:18:16.129 --> 00:18:21.669
And to me, that, like, it invites
the question, the issue that these
00:18:21.689 --> 00:18:26.539
insurance companies have faced,
which is insurance just isn't a great
00:18:26.649 --> 00:18:31.319
business at the end of the day, despite
how much time we spend talking about
00:18:31.359 -->
00:18:35.989
health insurance and its role in the
American economy and so on and so forth.
00:18:36.009 --> 00:18:39.689
Like, at best case scenario,
you're generating 3% margin
00:18:39.759 --> 00:18:41.109
on your book of business.
00:18:41.669 --> 00:18:46.199
More normal state, maybe they're
at, like, 1% margin, uh, in France
00:18:46.199 --> 00:18:49.999
right now, and they're probably
at negative, I don't know, 3 to 5%
00:18:50.029 --> 00:18:53.189
margin in those other, uh, countries.
00:18:53.259 --> 00:18:56.349
It's just a hard business
to, to scale up and run.
00:18:56.559 --> 00:18:56.889
I don't know.
00:18:57.579 --> 00:18:57.829
Martin: Yeah.
00:18:58.029 --> 00:18:58.819
Kevin: What do you think about it?
00:18:58.819 --> 00:19:04.169
Martin: So I, I know the company because
the company that I worked at when I
00:19:04.169 --> 00:19:08.429
lived in France used Alan for their-
00:19:08.859 --> 00:19:10.609
Kevin: Can you, can you
pronounce it the French way?
00:19:11.029 --> 00:19:11.149
Martin: Alan.
00:19:11.969 --> 00:19:12.169
Alan.
00:19:12.339 --> 00:19:15.919
Uh, no, I'm n- I'm not, uh, like any of
the actual French people are gonnaâ¦
00:19:17.219 --> 00:19:17.579
Kevin: Is that, is that-
00:19:17.579 --> 00:19:17.849
Martin: It's been a while.
00:19:17.849 --> 00:19:20.229
Kevin: Is that the correct pronunciation?
00:19:20.229 --> 00:19:20.389
Martin: Alan.
00:19:21.089 --> 00:19:22.359
I, I-
00:19:22.389 --> 00:19:22.409
Kevin: Yeah.
00:19:22.409 --> 00:19:23.019
Martin: N- no.
00:19:23.029 --> 00:19:23.999
You shouldn't ask me this-
00:19:24.019 --> 00:19:24.049
Kevin: Okay.
00:19:24.049 --> 00:19:25.879
Martin: Because my French is very bad.
00:19:25.879 --> 00:19:27.179
We should ask an actual French person.
00:19:27.479 --> 00:19:32.699
Um, but yeah, so, so the French
employees at the French company had
00:19:32.699 --> 00:19:36.489
access to Alan, and they loved it.
00:19:36.929 --> 00:19:43.089
So the way that, that French health
insurance works is you've got single payer
00:19:43.379 --> 00:19:47.979
from the government, and you use that.
00:19:48.069 --> 00:19:52.619
When, when you go to the doctor, you go
and you pay 100% of the cost up front.
00:19:52.689 --> 00:19:55.599
Now, the, the, the cost is
a lot less than it is here.
00:19:55.609 --> 00:19:58.879
It's like 25 bucks, uh, to go see a
primary care doctor, but you, you pay
00:19:58.879 --> 00:20:04.909
100% of that up front and The government
reimburses their share, about 70%,
00:20:05.669 --> 00:20:07.339
via direct deposit in a couple days.
00:20:07.749 --> 00:20:13.569
And then if you have something like
Alan, a mutual, they reimburse the rest
00:20:13.569 --> 00:20:16.959
of that 30%, like, th- your 30% to you.
00:20:18.039 --> 00:20:22.369
So your employer is paying them, I
don't know, 50 bucks a month, and
00:20:22.369 --> 00:20:25.209
they're holding onto that, and then
when you go to the doctor they're
00:20:25.219 --> 00:20:26.809
just basically h-
handing that back.
00:20:26.849 --> 00:20:31.399
And so the main way that Alan, you
know, the, Alan makes money is the float
00:20:31.529 --> 00:20:33.829
on that 50 bucks a month or whatever.
00:20:34.459 --> 00:20:38.869
The second way, and they, on their
website they have a helpful infographic
00:20:39.529 --> 00:20:43.189
of, like, revenue and, and where it
comes from, is a per member per month
00:20:44.309 --> 00:20:45.949
acc- uh, y- fee that they charge.
00:20:46.349 --> 00:20:50.149
And it's just the float is, like,
gonna not be very much, right?
00:20:50.179 --> 00:20:55.359
I mean, it's, like, gonna be, it's gonna
be pretty narrow and competed away.
00:20:55.749 --> 00:20:59.129
The, uh, or, or, or bid away.
00:20:59.309 --> 00:21:04.359
The, the per member per month fee buys,
like, oh, y- y- you can get glasses.
00:21:04.639 --> 00:21:06.639
It's like a Warby Parker but, but French.
00:21:06.899 --> 00:21:10.379
Um, you can get, like,
uh, musculoskeletal, you
00:21:10.379 --> 00:21:11.659
know, alignment stuff.
00:21:11.659 --> 00:21:15.069
Like, it is basically a platform
play saying, like, "Give us, you
00:21:15.069 --> 00:21:16.799
know, $5 per member per month.
00:21:17.099 --> 00:21:22.399
We will use that to bring some cool stuff
on the platform, but also, um, you know,
00:21:22.409 --> 00:21:27.609
like, let people sort of use our platform
to get access and, and buy market share."
00:21:27.929 --> 00:21:31.029
It does, it doesn't strike
me as a bad business.
00:21:31.029 --> 00:21:36.259
Like, I, I think that in a, in a
single-payer or government world,
00:21:36.259 --> 00:21:39.719
like, it is an, an interesting way
as an employer to, like, do something
00:21:39.719 --> 00:21:44.709
that's cooler than the random old
mutual run by, like, three guys who
00:21:44.709 --> 00:21:46.539
just like, you know, send you a check.
00:21:47.859 --> 00:21:54.079
The valuation is what I think is,
is hard, which is six X revenue.
00:21:54.259 --> 00:21:56.349
More than six X revenue,
almost seven X revenue.
00:21:56.399 --> 00:22:00.829
Like, that's, that's a lot for
an insurance company that is, you
00:22:00.829 --> 00:22:02.699
know, probably doing 1% margins.
00:22:03.139 --> 00:22:03.499
Kevin: Mm-hmm.
00:22:04.089 --> 00:22:04.399
Martin: Best case.
00:22:04.399 --> 00:22:04.669
Kevin: Yeah.
00:22:05.269 --> 00:22:05.659
Yeah.
00:22:05.829 --> 00:22:10.339
Publicly traded insurance companies
right now in the US are sub one.
00:22:11.099 --> 00:22:11.309
Martin: Yeah.
00:22:11.319 --> 00:22:11.599
Kevin: Right?
00:22:12.009 --> 00:22:15.439
Martin: I think, uh, Oscar is, like, .5.
00:22:15.449 --> 00:22:15.469
Yeah.
00:22:15.919 --> 00:22:17.759
So, so that's tough.
00:22:18.119 --> 00:22:18.649
That's tough.
00:22:18.689 --> 00:22:21.779
But cool company, interesting
to get a taste for what's
00:22:21.779 --> 00:22:23.219
going on outside of the world.
00:22:23.709 --> 00:22:24.399
People loved it.
00:22:24.679 --> 00:22:28.269
People like- Yeah ⦠they, the
companies in France, startups in
00:22:28.269 --> 00:22:31.899
France brag about having Alan versus
the other mutuals that you have.
00:22:32.009 --> 00:22:36.639
So it is like a genuine
perk, but, you know.
00:22:37.129 --> 00:22:37.439
Kevin: Yep.
00:22:37.719 --> 00:22:40.829
If you were gonna try to articulate
the narrative that would get it to be
00:22:40.839 --> 00:22:47.029
worth the multiple that it's at today,
what, what would the narrative be?
00:22:47.029 --> 00:22:48.719
Is it more international expansion?
00:22:50.591 --> 00:22:57.101
Martin: Uh, like my, my sort of cynical
take on, on French tech companies,
00:22:57.141 --> 00:23:01.531
and I'm sorry Emmanuel Macron, is
like probably what Alan has is a
00:23:01.531 --> 00:23:04.651
slide on this thing that's like,
"And then we're gonna go to the US."
00:23:05.511 --> 00:23:09.241
Like, the $6 billion valuation
hinges on you entering a market where
00:23:09.241 --> 00:23:11.961
you can do better than 1% margins.
00:23:12.251 --> 00:23:16.061
And if your 1% margins are mostly, like,
employer opt-in fees- Mm-hmm ⦠like,
00:23:16.061 --> 00:23:18.111
you need to be able to charge actualâ¦
00:23:18.201 --> 00:23:21.941
You need to be able to make actual money
on your underwriting business, and the
00:23:22.141 --> 00:23:23.481
place that you can do that is the US.
00:23:24.051 --> 00:23:26.361
Um, so I don't know.
00:23:26.381 --> 00:23:30.601
I mean, like, I, I, I think it's,
like, it's entering the US and-
00:23:32.919 --> 00:23:33.879
I wouldn't recommend it.
00:23:35.069 --> 00:23:41.149
Um, but it's kind of fun to think
about, like, Oscar, Oscar and Alan
00:23:41.149 --> 00:23:44.899
are s- sort of some combination that
could, that could facilitate that.
00:23:45.019 --> 00:23:47.439
It is just not gonna
happen at that valuation.
00:23:47.449 --> 00:23:47.469
Yeah.
00:23:48.059 --> 00:23:51.259
Because I think we looked, like Oscar's
at, like, an $8 billion valuation.
00:23:51.259 --> 00:23:52.129
Kevin: Mm-hmm.
00:23:54.739 --> 00:23:57.279
The benefit of being a private
market company these days.
00:23:57.739 --> 00:23:57.769
Martin: Sure.
00:23:57.779 --> 00:24:01.769
Kevin: You get priced at, like, the one
end of the spectrum versus public markets,
00:24:01.769 --> 00:24:03.079
which get dragged out into the middle.
00:24:03.239 --> 00:24:05.999
Uh, you know, uh, that's
how the markets are working.
00:24:07.039 --> 00:24:12.009
Martin: There was, speaking of insane, not
insane, but eye, eye-popping valuations,
00:24:12.299 --> 00:24:15.449
uh, $107 million seed round for Trase.
00:24:16.579 --> 00:24:16.979
Kevin: Yeah.
00:24:17.279 --> 00:24:17.759
This wasâ¦
00:24:17.789 --> 00:24:20.429
I, I mean, that's a lot of
money at the seed round.
00:24:20.569 --> 00:24:25.929
I, um- Yes ⦠uh, so Trase is another
company in kind of the agentic,
00:24:26.419 --> 00:24:29.179
uh, AI operating system space.
00:24:29.839 --> 00:24:34.469
It is coming out of a
venture
studio called Red Cell Partners.
00:24:34.469 --> 00:24:40.599
Red Cell Partners, um, the, the gentleman
who founded it, Grant Verstandig, um, sold
00:24:40.609 --> 00:24:43.699
the business to Optum 10-ish years ago.
00:24:43.729 --> 00:24:48.549
Kind of one of the big original, uh,
at least in this last digital health
00:24:48.559 --> 00:24:52.319
startup life cycle, one of the big
exits in, in that time, Rally Health.
00:24:52.589 --> 00:24:58.591
Um- Red Cell is focused on
regulated industries in general.
00:24:58.601 --> 00:25:03.111
So I think it's, if you go to their
website, uh, it's healthcare, but
00:25:03.111 --> 00:25:08.771
it's also cybersecurity, national
defense, um, type stuff as well,
00:25:08.771 --> 00:25:13.051
and it seems like Trase is kind of
picking up that theme across healthcare
00:25:13.051 --> 00:25:14.551
and other regulated industries.
00:25:14.921 --> 00:25:17.801
Healthcare is clearly a
big part of the talk track.
00:25:18.311 --> 00:25:23.031
In the press release, it talks about their
rollout with Duke Health, and I think
00:25:23.031 --> 00:25:26.461
in particular the cardiology practice
at Duke Health, and they talk about how
00:25:26.461 --> 00:25:31.831
they are automating, um, faxes inside of,
inside of Duke Health's cardiology group.
00:25:32.441 --> 00:25:36.481
And to me it's like, that's a pretty
straightforward use case for how you'd
00:25:36.481 --> 00:25:39.921
go in and deploy AI agents if you were
going into a health system and like,
00:25:39.921 --> 00:25:43.961
how do we start making this better
and more streamlined using AI to help
00:25:43.961 --> 00:25:45.621
improve operations of the system?
00:25:46.161 --> 00:25:48.241
That seems like one of the
natural places to start, right?
00:25:48.261 --> 00:25:51.511
Have AI just automatically read
through every fax you're getting
00:25:51.511 --> 00:25:55.331
and you're sending out and, um,
and automating that data process.
00:25:56.101 --> 00:25:56.671
I, Iâ¦
00:25:56.721 --> 00:25:59.201
It's fascinating to me
to then juxtaposeâ¦
00:25:59.231 --> 00:26:03.351
That, that seems like a really interesting
exercise of process improvement that,
00:26:03.351 --> 00:26:05.091
that health systems should be doing.
00:26:06.301 --> 00:26:12.121
Juxtaposing the startup raising 170
million, $107 million at the seed
00:26:12.121 --> 00:26:16.651
round to support that is where I
start to go, what, like what is,
00:26:17.091 --> 00:26:19.111
what are you using $107 million for?
00:26:19.291 --> 00:26:22.451
Which I think will be fun
to continue noodling on.
00:26:23.441 --> 00:26:23.651
Martin: Yeah.
00:26:25.171 --> 00:26:30.581
Another large round, same sort of
similar order of magnitude, Cadence
00:26:31.201 --> 00:26:33.411
raised a Series C led by Spark Capital.
00:26:34.081 --> 00:26:37.491
Uh, what, what is the Cadence business?
00:26:37.681 --> 00:26:40.081
It's also, by the way,
Duke, Duke on here again.
00:26:41.553 --> 00:26:43.653
Kevin: Love
to see Duke
logo everywhere these days.
00:26:44.443 --> 00:26:49.243
Uh, Cadence has grown as a remote
patient monitoring platform, right?
00:26:49.893 --> 00:26:52.603
It was kind of one of the leading
fee-for-service remote patient
00:26:52.623 --> 00:26:54.503
monitoring platforms that's taken off.
00:26:54.853 --> 00:26:59.393
That space in general, as we followed
along with, has started to receive more
00:26:59.393 --> 00:27:01.763
scrutiny in terms of billing practices.
00:27:02.053 --> 00:27:06.083
UnitedHealth notably tried to change
their policy on remote patient monitoring
00:27:06.093 --> 00:27:10.213
on the whole, but walked that back
after some pushback on that policy.
00:27:10.213 --> 00:27:14.893
But that's where Cadence's core
business has been, and, um, there's some
00:27:14.893 --> 00:27:19.563
questions in there of, like, there's
a lot of good in the remote patient
00:27:19.573 --> 00:27:21.313
monitoring space happening there.
00:27:21.323 --> 00:27:25.733
There's also seemingly a, this
rising sentiment of concerns
00:27:25.733 --> 00:27:28.473
over what's happening from a
billing perspective for practices.
00:27:28.773 --> 00:27:33.443
I personally get a ton of emails from
just, like, random people suggesting
00:27:33.443 --> 00:27:37.753
that I should, uh, adopt remote patient
monitoring solutions on top of Health
00:27:37.753 --> 00:27:40.643
Tech Nerds because we could grow our
revenue from that, which seems indicative
00:27:40.643 --> 00:27:44.533
of, of the concerns that, that, that
people have about this space when
00:27:44.533 --> 00:27:47.773
those sorts of emails are just getting
mass blasted out to the industry.
00:27:47.783 --> 00:27:51.933
Like, "Oh, hey, increase your
collections by X percent by having this
00:27:51.933 --> 00:27:53.113
remote patient monitoring tooling."
00:27:53.803 --> 00:27:57.223
I do not expect Health Tech Nerds to be
getting into remote patient monitoring,
00:27:57.273 --> 00:27:59.293
nor peptides as we discussed last week.
00:27:59.293 --> 00:28:03.673
But nonetheless, it is an indicator
when you start getting those emails of
00:28:04.103 --> 00:28:07.223
perhaps the billing activity that is
going on in the broader market, when
00:28:07.223 --> 00:28:10.603
those emails start coming through and
those pitches starting, start to happen.
00:28:11.663 --> 00:28:16.673
Interestingly, Cadence in this
funding round, their, their narrative
00:28:16.673 --> 00:28:18.043
is, is much broader than that.
00:28:18.133 --> 00:28:20.403
I'd be curious your take on
the, the broader narrative
00:28:20.413 --> 00:28:21.543
and, and how they pivoted it.
00:28:22.333 --> 00:28:25.713
Martin: Yeah, I thought it was, I
thought it was a nice sort of story
00:28:25.713 --> 00:28:30.303
and transition about, yeah, there,
there's like a little bit of a, an odor
00:28:30.313 --> 00:28:32.413
associated with remote patient monitoring.
00:28:32.413 --> 00:28:35.293
It, it, it feels, can feel a little
bit scammy, but
they're, they're
00:28:35.293 --> 00:28:39.233
talking about chronic care ma-
like chronic disease management-
00:28:39.383 --> 00:28:39.783
Kevin: Mm-hmm.
00:28:39.783 --> 00:28:42.023
Martin: That's fully
automated, leveraging AI.
00:28:42.783 --> 00:28:46.583
And it, and they're specifically
calling out, you know, for
00:28:46.583 --> 00:28:48.513
underserved rural areas.
00:28:48.523 --> 00:28:51.843
Like, that is a narrative I
think that is very of the moment.
00:28:52.293 --> 00:28:57.383
Um, we are going into an environment,
I just saw another story of a hospital
00:28:57.403 --> 00:29:01.343
that closed a couple years ago in North
Carolina, and they'd been hoping to
00:29:01.343 --> 00:29:03.073
get it back open, and it's still not.
00:29:03.163 --> 00:29:05.423
Um, and it's like, yeah, those,
those people are gonna end up at
00:29:05.503 --> 00:29:11.153
Duke when things degrade sufficiently
or they decompensate sufficiently.
00:29:11.463 --> 00:29:16.153
And Duke would like to be able to
make some money offering them remote
00:29:16.163 --> 00:29:20.693
care, and a part of that is gonna be
remote patient monitoring, even if
00:29:20.693 --> 00:29:23.953
we call it something else that, that,
that feels a little bit less scammy.
00:29:23.963 --> 00:29:29.997
So I, I, I- It is a, it is a, I think
that, that is maybe going to be the
00:29:29.997 --> 00:29:33.807
theme for the next, e- for, for both
Cadence and for our next conversation,
00:29:33.807 --> 00:29:37.217
is this is a thing that you hear
someone describe it and you're like,
00:29:37.217 --> 00:29:38.797
"Oh yeah, makes a ton of sense.
00:29:39.017 --> 00:29:40.327
We should definitely be doing that.
00:29:40.357 --> 00:29:42.607
Medicare should definitely
be paying for that."
00:29:42.987 --> 00:29:45.307
And it becomes an implementation question.
00:29:45.337 --> 00:29:48.987
Like, how do we do it and make sure
that we're getting actual value for
00:29:48.987 --> 00:29:55.067
the Medicare dollars, and it's not
just, um, like getting blasted out to
00:29:55.067 --> 00:29:56.837
everyone, including Health Tech Nerds.
00:29:57.757 --> 00:30:02.257
Not a Medicare, uh, billing
entity asking if we would like
00:30:02.257 --> 00:30:03.967
to add it to our, our stack.
00:30:04.407 --> 00:30:04.867
Kevin: Yes.
00:30:05.567 --> 00:30:10.227
Cadence in the press release talked about
they're implemented at 20 systems today.
00:30:10.477 --> 00:30:13.117
They're trying to grow to a h- they're,
they're at 100,000 patients today.
00:30:13.117 --> 00:30:16.707
They have bish- ambitions to
get to 10 million patients,
00:30:17.887 --> 00:30:20.187
um, in a future state, which
00:30:22.543 --> 00:30:25.983
I, I think it's interesting to think
about how they, they get there.
00:30:26.023 --> 00:30:30.653
It, to your, to your point on current
state of health systems, it rhymes a
00:30:30.653 --> 00:30:35.123
little bit with the narrative I feel
like we've heard from John Kao and others
00:30:35.143
--> 00:30:39.503
at Alignment, where when he talks about
alignment and their conversations with
00:30:39.503 --> 00:30:44.033
health systems, part of it is this works
really well with branded systems that are
00:30:44.053 --> 00:30:46.093
over capacity from a beds perspective.
00:30:46.473 --> 00:30:50.403
In which case, you wanna prioritize
commercial volume inside the hospital.
00:30:50.403 --> 00:30:56.103
You wanna figure out how do you, how do
you provide remote type care to Medicare
00:30:56.103 --> 00:30:58.963
Advantage, Medicaid populations that
pay you less so that you can manage
00:30:58.963 --> 00:31:03.873
your profitability while being kind
of the holistic solution for, for your
00:31:03.873 --> 00:31:05.873
market and take care of everybody.
00:31:05.973 --> 00:31:11.953
And I can very much see how Cadence's
expanded narrative fits squarely
00:31:11.953 --> 00:31:13.393
into a conversation like that.
00:31:14.193 --> 00:31:17.623
It has been a conversation going
back a decade now, since I was in a
00:31:17.623 --> 00:31:20.973
health system leadership role of like,
yeah, conceptually that makes sense.
00:31:21.833 --> 00:31:25.953
Historically, health systems never
actually seemed to like really act on it.
00:31:25.983 --> 00:31:30.253
You could have that conversation and yes,
talk about how if you're over capacity,
00:31:30.263 --> 00:31:35.173
it would make sense to shift, you know,
Medicare, Medicaid, uh, uh, to commercial
00:31:35.183 --> 00:31:39.083
inpatients and do more remote monitoring,
more upstream preventative care.
00:31:39.093 --> 00:31:42.513
But it was hard to actually
like fully get there.
00:31:42.973 --> 00:31:48.433
I am curious if the headwinds that are
now facing health systems are strong
00:31:48.433 --> 00:31:52.213
enough that that is actually changing
that behavior, so that they are now
00:31:52.233 --> 00:31:56.843
saying, "Oh yeah, like this is the, our
profitability situation is dire enough
00:31:56.853 --> 00:32:00.733
that we need to act on this, and we're
going to act on it, and here's the handful
00:32:00.733 --> 00:32:01.633
of ways in which we're gonna do it.
00:32:01.783 --> 00:32:05.953
We're gonna think about what our
plan partnerships look like in MA.
00:32:06.263 --> 00:32:11.283
We're gonna implement tooling like this
to help do more remote monitoring, um, out
00:32:11.283 --> 00:32:13.003
in the community, keeping people at home."
00:32:14.193 --> 00:32:18.263
It's a really interesting narrative,
um, that I'll be, we- uh, think
00:32:18.263 --> 00:32:19.203
is worth keeping an eye on.
00:32:20.253 --> 00:32:21.023
Martin: Absolutely.
00:32:21.633 --> 00:32:25.263
Let's talk about Hera, which
is care coordination forâ¦
00:32:25.273 --> 00:32:29.143
I mean, it feels to me like
sort of a similar narrative.
00:32:29.173 --> 00:32:33.263
I think Hera conceptually, you
know, cool company, 27 million
00:32:33.263 --> 00:32:34.753
led by Bain Capital Ventures.
00:32:35.033 --> 00:32:39.343
They are serving seniors, they're
billing chronic care management
00:32:39.413 --> 00:32:41.353
Medicare fee-for-service codes.
00:32:41.623 --> 00:32:46.213
Um, so basically that is where a
provider is saying, you have, you
00:32:46.213 --> 00:32:48.083
know, two or more chronic diseases.
00:32:48.293 --> 00:32:53.203
We are going to help manage those chronic
diseases, um, and get reimbursed for it.
00:32:53.203 --> 00:32:56.613
And typically, those are not
done by the provider, but done
00:32:56.613 --> 00:32:59.503
by a, uh, billed incident two.
00:32:59.713 --> 00:33:05.253
So in the case of Hera, they are using
1099s, paying them 30 to 60 bucks an
00:33:05.253 --> 00:33:10.673
hour, and not required, but a plus they're
saying licensed clinical social worker
00:33:10.673 --> 00:33:13.523
or master's level social worker or RN.
00:33:14.003 --> 00:33:19.093
Um, I believe to bill those to Medicare
you have to be a healthcare professional.
00:33:19.193 --> 00:33:21.543
That includes medical
assistants, um, which isâ¦
00:33:22.643 --> 00:33:24.893
They, they let me get certified
as a medical assistant, so it's,
00:33:24.903 --> 00:33:26.873
it's not that, uh, not that-
00:33:26.873 --> 00:33:27.133
Kevin: Anybody could do it.
00:33:27.793 --> 00:33:29.183
Martin: Basically anyone
could do it, yeah.
00:33:30.003 --> 00:33:33.043
As long as you don't get
squeamish about doing blood draws.
00:33:33.673 --> 00:33:34.273
Even if you do.
00:33:34.643 --> 00:33:37.373
Um, I'm, again, I, I made it through.
00:33:37.373 --> 00:33:37.873
They let me.
00:33:38.143 --> 00:33:42.353
So I- it is one of those areas, we've
seen a, a handful of these, these
00:33:42.363 --> 00:33:44.213
fundraising announcements recently.
00:33:44.273 --> 00:33:47.503
Hera seems like a, a
sort of smart take on it.
00:33:47.623 --> 00:33:50.343
They're also mentioned
partnering with health systems.
00:33:51.243 --> 00:33:56.623
It- it's one of those things that you're
like, yeah, Medicare and chronic disease
00:33:56.743 --> 00:34:01.833
navigation are confusing, and it would
be nice if we could have some people
00:34:01.953 --> 00:34:04.973
who helped the people navigating them.
00:34:05.643 --> 00:34:10.223
Um, a- and if we could pay them,
if we could pay for those services.
00:34:10.413 --> 00:34:15.183
It also seems like an area that I, I,
I would not be surprised if we get med
00:34:15.183 --> 00:34:20.693
pack reports in the next couple of years
about an explosion in CCM code billing,
00:34:20.733 --> 00:34:25.813
and what are we gonna do about this
crisis in CCM billing, and maybe we
00:34:25.813 --> 00:34:30.753
need WISeR but for CCM, and- You know?
00:34:30.793 --> 00:34:31.463
And so I don't know.
00:34:31.573 --> 00:34:34.983
That's, that's kind of my reflection
on it is, like, absolutely to me
00:34:34.983 --> 00:34:40.643
seems like something that would be,
would be good to have, um, or nice-
00:34:40.753 --> 00:34:41.583
Right ⦠if we could afford it.
00:34:41.683 -->
00:34:46.253
And I, I do worry that the implementation,
not of any sort of one specific
00:34:46.293 --> 00:34:51.053
company, but the sort of secondary
and tertiary, um, effects of this are,
00:34:51.053 --> 00:34:55.773
like, in a couple months, Kevin, you're
gonna get an inbound saying, "Increase
00:34:55.773 --> 00:35:00.323
your revenue for Health Tech Nerds
by adding CCM billing capabilities."
00:35:00.353 --> 00:35:01.303
And we'll say, "Okay."
00:35:02.093 --> 00:35:02.623
Kevin: Yes.
00:35:03.143 --> 00:35:04.843
Uh, I, I mean, it'sâ¦
00:35:06.353 --> 00:35:09.063
It almost seems like a natural
part of these narratives in the
00:35:09.063 --> 00:35:11.173
healthcare market when you haveâ¦
00:35:11.183 --> 00:35:14.533
Uh, I mean, when you go to these
companies' websites, it seems
00:35:14.893 --> 00:35:19.133
unambiguously good to me to s- like, when
you read the narrative around, nobodyâ¦
00:35:19.193 --> 00:35:20.393
uh, I'm on another company's website.
00:35:20.413 --> 00:35:22.243
Nobody should navigate healthcare alone.
00:35:22.963 --> 00:35:24.563
Yeah, you, you can't argue with that.
00:35:24.593 --> 00:35:27.943
Healthcare is hard to navigate for
seniors going through health conditions.
00:35:27.953 --> 00:35:28.203
Itâ¦
00:35:28.203 --> 00:35:33.423
Like, I would want for my family
members to have access to a individual
00:35:33.433 --> 00:35:35.513
who can help them navigate healthcare.
00:35:36.003 --> 00:35:38.323
That seems unambi- like, y- yes, right?
00:35:38.333 --> 00:35:39.713
Who's gonna say no to that?
00:35:40.163 --> 00:35:43.563
And then the question becomes,
how do we societally implement
00:35:43.563 --> 00:35:44.863
that as a health system?
00:35:45.163 --> 00:35:47.343
Well, you implement these CCM codes.
00:35:47.343 --> 00:35:48.613
That allows for billing for it.
00:35:48.613 --> 00:35:52.053
You have incident two, so then
you can, you can bill under the
00:35:52.053 --> 00:35:57.063
provider so that there's more margin
to collect, um, uh, for the group.
00:35:57.123 --> 00:36:02.233
And you start to then get into these
scenarios where for good actors, it is
00:36:02.283 --> 00:36:05.363
unambiguously a good thing, and for a
lot of these companies raising in the
00:36:05.373 --> 00:36:09.413
space, uh, like, it'll be fun to watch
their journey, the impact they have.
00:36:09.723 --> 00:36:13.753
Inevitably, to your point, it
also seems right for companies
00:36:13.753 --> 00:36:18.033
saying they're doing the right
things who may or may not do that.
00:36:18.363 --> 00:36:23.033
And that's just the dynamic of the
industry in all of this, right?
00:36:23.063 --> 00:36:27.093
And it's a subjective belief of
like, is this actor good or bad?
00:36:27.103 --> 00:36:28.163
Do I know these people?
00:36:28.173 --> 00:36:29.543
Do I trust them?
00:36:30.003 --> 00:36:34.403
A- and that's part of what makes
this industry so hard to grasp.
00:36:34.673 --> 00:36:39.153
Um, because both of those things
happen at
the same time under the
00:36:39.153 --> 00:36:43.133
same billing program, and depending
on your view of it, uh, and how you
00:36:43.133 --> 00:36:46.532
weigh the trade-offs of those things,
it can, it can go either way, right?
00:36:46.532 --> 00:36:52.462
Martin: My modest proposal is in addition
to medical assistants and nurses, and
00:36:52.642 --> 00:36:55.922
we should add MA brokers to the list-
00:36:56.742 --> 00:36:56.752
Kevin: Ooh.
00:36:56.762 --> 00:37:02.162
Martin: And let MA brokers ha-
add a little sideline in CCM.
00:37:02.882 --> 00:37:05.922
'Cause they're already regulated
and much easier to regulate
00:37:05.932 --> 00:37:08.162
than, like, a random person.
00:37:08.162 --> 00:37:13.682
You can yank their, their ability to
sell MA, and they know the programs.
00:37:13.792 --> 00:37:14.972
So that's my-
00:37:14.982 --> 00:37:15.002
Kevin: Yeah.
00:37:15.932 --> 00:37:20.992
It's, it's interesting to me because,
like, a, a general theory I have is the,
00:37:21.012 --> 00:37:26.572
the core unit of scale in healthcare,
like the good thing, is a, a trusting
00:37:26.572 --> 00:37:28.342
relationship between two humans.
00:37:28.432 --> 00:37:32.532
That can be a patient-provider, but
that can also be a patient-MA broker.
00:37:32.542 --> 00:37:36.992
If it's somebody that they trust who
is, um, equipped to help them navigate
00:37:36.992 --> 00:37:41.102
the system, yeah, to your point, like
that, uh, to me that is a good thing.
00:37:41.242 --> 00:37:41.922
The, theâ¦
00:37:43.012 --> 00:37:45.972
And that is both the blessing and curse
of American healthcare is there's a
00:37:45.972 --> 00:37:49.732
lot of people who, who are deserving
of trust who we should be supporting
00:37:49.752 --> 00:37:55.442
and enabling to do more, and then
there are a lot of folks who see that
00:37:55.492 --> 00:37:59.532
and take advantage of that trust, and
that is where we start to have issues.
00:37:59.582 --> 00:38:03.882
And again, it's just ki- it's,
it's how the world works.
00:38:05.206 --> 00:38:05.796
Martin: It is.
00:38:05.866 --> 00:38:09.686
Well, let's quickly talk about
Upside, and after Upside I think
00:38:09.686 --> 00:38:11.596
we got, we got a packed agenda.
00:38:11.616 --> 00:38:14.506
But I do wanna hit on Upside,
'cause it is a fascinating business.
00:38:14.506 --> 00:38:18.406
They raised $20 million, and they
are helping with housing instability.
00:38:18.456 --> 00:38:19.286
I think youâ¦
00:38:19.316 --> 00:38:21.806
When we were talking about them
and reflecting on them, they're
00:38:21.806 --> 00:38:23.096
focused on the payer market.
00:38:23.136 --> 00:38:27.506
They're saying, "Okay, there are these
payers that have money that they need
00:38:27.516 --> 00:38:31.956
to spend," and housing instability
has a lot of sort of downstream
00:38:31.956 --> 00:38:36.086
impacts on health outcomes and spend.
00:38:36.786 --> 00:38:39.936
When I lived in Colorado, we used
to say that Denver Health, the
00:38:39.936 --> 00:38:43.296
local safety net hospital, was the
most expensive hotel in the city.
00:38:43.366 --> 00:38:44.706
It was like seven grand a night.
00:38:45.076 --> 00:38:49.276
Um, and so if you can get someone
into stable housing versus at Denver
00:38:49.276 --> 00:38:54.376
Health, then there is some, some, uh,
real savings to the payers and, and
00:38:54.376 --> 00:38:57.266
then, you know, their Medicaids are
downstream from that, the taxpayers.
00:38:57.866 --> 00:39:00.766
Um, so it's a, it's a good story if it-
00:39:00.806 --> 00:39:01.216
Kevin: For sure.
00:39:01.706 --> 00:39:02.056
Yeah.
00:39:02.486 --> 00:39:06.546
I, as I understand it, they are working
largely with Medicaid plans today.
00:39:06.626 --> 00:39:10.866
They're going to those Medicaid plans,
and, um, they are helping with housing
00:39:10.876 --> 00:39:15.706
for folks under those plans that,
um, have instable housing situations.
00:39:15.996 --> 00:39:20.606
What caught my attention, the
engagement numbers that they cite for
00:39:20.606 --> 00:39:22.536
this population are striking to me.
00:39:22.536 --> 00:39:26.606
Like, as I think about that
population, uh, from, like, traditional
00:39:26.606 --> 00:39:29.836
healthcare payer/provider lens,
that is the hardest to reach of
00:39:29.866 --> 00:39:32.046
populations in, in healthcare, right?
00:39:32.046 --> 00:39:37.156
This is, like, the most complex
medical, social, um, group out there,
00:39:37.186 --> 00:39:41.286
and they are citing that they are
connecting with 90% of eligible
00:39:41.286 --> 00:39:44.676
members, so the members that the payer
are sending to them to connect with.
00:39:45.076 --> 00:39:49.696
They are enrolling 85% of the 90% that
they connect with, and then they are
00:39:49.696 --> 00:39:55.666
stabilizing housing for 50% of everybody
eligible who is sent to them, which
00:39:55.666 --> 00:39:58.156
is really impressive numbers, right?
00:39:58.196 --> 00:40:02.506
Now, I'm sure it's, it's small and
early days still, and to me, that'll
00:40:02.526 --> 00:40:06.206
be the most interesting part of, of
this sort of model to watch, is how
00:40:06.206 --> 00:40:09.306
does it scale up over time and how
do they consistently do it across
00:40:09.346 --> 00:40:10.946
payer types with broader populations?
00:40:10.956 --> 00:40:12.746
How big can that population get?
00:40:13.116 --> 00:40:15.356
'Cause to me, this is always
the question with these kind of,
00:40:15.376 --> 00:40:18.506
like, tip-of-the-spear, top 0.1%
00:40:18.506 --> 00:40:23.546
cost, uh, populations is, uh, as you
expand that initiative from that, like,
00:40:23.576 --> 00:40:28.878
top cost bucket to- populations that
cost less or aren't the persistent
00:40:28.878 --> 00:40:32.438
super utilizer types, it becomes
harder to justify the financials.
00:40:32.998 --> 00:40:36.368
And that is why I reference in the
newsletter, one of my favorite, favorite
00:40:36.378 --> 00:40:42.058
articles on healthcare
was, I think it was
2019 or 2020, Bloomberg was highlighting
00:40:42.358 --> 00:40:47.338
what United was doing in Medicaid
housing, a program called My Connections.
00:40:47.598 --> 00:40:48.868
Jeffrey Brenner was running it.
00:40:48.868 --> 00:40:51.258
Jeffrey Brenner is Camden Coalition.
00:40:51.498 --> 00:40:53.518
They did the RCT on the hot spotter model.
00:40:53.518 --> 00:40:58.018
This is, like, the original
thinkers on these sorts of programs
00:40:58.018 --> 00:40:59.748
for these sorts of populations.
00:41:00.178 --> 00:41:05.308
And it highlights both the incredible
opportunity that we have for
00:41:05.618 --> 00:41:09.908
helping these populations, and
also how hard it is to scale as
00:41:09.908 --> 00:41:12.508
you get outside of that, like, 0.1%
00:41:12.508 --> 00:41:15.728
of population that costs
over $50,000 a year.
00:41:15.978 --> 00:41:20.458
Because when you start to add all
the costs together, uh, from these
00:41:20.458 --> 00:41:23.128
initiatives, they become challenging.
00:41:23.298 --> 00:41:26.838
Now, this is a slightly different
model, as I understand it, so it
00:41:26.838 --> 00:41:31.498
doesn't have some of the same, um,
dynamics that, that My Connections did.
00:41:31.508 --> 00:41:35.098
So the, the analogy isn't totally spot on.
00:41:35.108 --> 00:41:38.628
But nonetheless, I think it's
interesting to, to learn from previous
00:41:38.628 --> 00:41:39.928
efforts that have been in the space.
00:41:39.958 --> 00:41:43.938
And I, like, it- that article does
a great job highlighting dynamics
00:41:43.938 --> 00:41:45.028
at play in the housing market.
00:41:45.038 --> 00:41:45.058
Yeah.
00:41:45.708 --> 00:41:48.908
So I think it'll be a, a really
interesting company to keep an eye on.
00:41:49.538 --> 00:41:52.828
Obviously, there are a lot of
general headwinds facing Medicaid
00:41:52.828 --> 00:41:56.478
right now, but this actually strikes
me as a market where there seem
00:41:56.478 --> 00:41:57.558
to be some interesting tailwinds.
00:41:58.508 --> 00:41:58.738
Martin: Yeah.
00:42:00.704 --> 00:42:04.204
Let's move on and talk a little bit
about some big news from last week.
00:42:04.294 --> 00:42:06.804
Cityblock and Homeward are combining.
00:42:06.804 --> 00:42:10.114
So Cityblock, uh, we got the
news sort of in rapid succession.
00:42:10.154 --> 00:42:14.104
Endpoints, I think, broke the news
that they were talking, and then Axios
00:42:14.384 --> 00:42:18.614
said that they had, uh, they had, uh,
you know, they had sort of signed.
00:42:18.644 --> 00:42:20.304
They, they were moving forward with it.
00:42:20.824 --> 00:42:25.294
Cityblock is, of course, the
Medicaid and duals business
00:42:25.354 --> 00:42:29.614
focused on, um, urban environments.
00:42:29.874 --> 00:42:33.124
They've had some good
success in the clinicalâ¦
00:42:33.894 --> 00:42:35.294
on the clinical side of things.
00:42:35.294 --> 00:42:36.754
They've reported some great outcomes.
00:42:37.304 --> 00:42:43.284
We tried to tally up how many markets they
were in, and it's between seven and nine.
00:42:43.544 --> 00:42:47.564
Um, last week, their website,
the website's differed.
00:42:47.564 --> 00:42:53.814
But, uh, yeah, that's their focus, is, is
urban Medicaid and dual patients with a,
00:42:53.944 --> 00:42:59.694
a model that is thinking about the patient
holistically, using that dual capitated
00:42:59.724 --> 00:43:03.944
payment or the, the Medicaid capitated
payment to make some investments in stuff
00:43:03.954 --> 00:43:09.474
that is, um, you know, f- more focused
on upstream or preventative health.
00:43:10.534 --> 00:43:14.814
Homeward is focused, uh, sort of
similar in spirit, but focused on
00:43:15.124 --> 00:43:17.334
rural areas and Medicare Advantage.
00:43:17.464 --> 00:43:19.124
And so theâ¦
00:43:19.154 --> 00:43:23.194
On its face, I mean, it seems like a
pretty sort of logical combination, right?
00:43:23.534 --> 00:43:23.564
For sure.
00:43:23.564 --> 00:43:28.924
Cityblock is adding MA as a, like,
general MA as a line of business.
00:43:29.154 --> 00:43:35.164
They're diversifying from purely a urban
focus to urban and, and rural, and they're
00:43:35.164 --> 00:43:39.814
adding, uh, some payer contracts and payer
partnerships, which should make business
00:43:39.814 --> 00:43:45.634
development, um, a little bit easier as
they go and, uh, broaden that, thatâ¦
00:43:45.644 --> 00:43:48.084
Like, they can bring the MA
business to their current payer
00:43:48.084 --> 00:43:51.334
contracts, and they can bring their
Medicaid and duals business to
00:43:51.334 --> 00:43:53.114
their, the, uh, Homeward contracts.
00:43:53.374 --> 00:43:55.514
So makes sense.
00:43:55.554 --> 00:43:59.254
I think part of this story we would be
remiss is saying both of these companies
00:43:59.254 --> 00:44:03.974
were sort of high-flying companies
with, with sort of lofty valuations.
00:44:03.974 --> 00:44:07.144
I'm gonna pull up the Forge
chart for, for Cityblock.
00:44:07.744 --> 00:44:14.934
Um, but you can see, uh, that in the
sort of pandemic and post-pandemic era,
00:44:14.954 --> 00:44:19.514
they, they raised at a pretty large
valuation, and then that got cut pretty,
00:44:19.854 --> 00:44:22.064
um, pretty significantly last year.
00:44:22.204 --> 00:44:23.624
And so it is aâ¦
00:44:23.634 --> 00:44:28.324
I think part of this story is, like,
frothy market, a ton of, uh, like,
00:44:28.324 --> 00:44:32.074
really high valuations, and now we're
kind of seeing the shakeout happen.
00:44:34.470 --> 00:44:34.490
Kevin: Yeah.
00:44:34.500 --> 00:44:39.290
I, I mean, I-- you can kind of see the
cautionary tale of s- SoftBank coming
00:44:39.290 --> 00:44:45.120
into healthcare 'cause they saw massive
opportunity and led the, the massive
00:44:45.120 --> 00:44:49.630
round in Cityblock at that point in
time, which it was indicative of the
00:44:49.630 --> 00:44:51.260
market environment back then, right?
00:44:51.290 --> 00:44:56.510
There was a
lot of excitement around the
opportunity, rethinking how the industry
00:44:56.510 --> 00:45:01.910
works, so on and so forth, and k- the
laws of gravity of the industry took
00:45:01.910 --> 00:45:06.190
hold and, uh, you know, the last couple
years that we've been tracking along
00:45:06.220 --> 00:45:12.480
have been challenging across Medicaid
funding, um, uh, in those environments.
00:45:12.510 --> 00:45:15.290
And, you know, we were just talking
with Upside about some of the
00:45:15.290 --> 00:45:16.900
tailwinds emerging for the market.
00:45:16.950 --> 00:45:20.410
Uh, this has been where the headwinds
have, have hit really hard, right?
00:45:20.460 --> 00:45:25.020
And I think it's been a tough road for
organizations like Cityblock and Homeward,
00:45:25.020 --> 00:45:29.770
even in Homeward, kind of more MA duals,
but generally speaking, both under the
00:45:29.770 --> 00:45:32.160
broader headline of value-based care.
00:45:32.670 --> 00:45:37.880
Uh, Homeward had a similar s-
trajectory, uh, back in that 2022 era
00:45:37.880 --> 00:45:42.690
where they launched with 20 million
and then five months later I think,
00:45:42.880 --> 00:45:48.060
um, they were raising another 50
million at a 345 million valuation.
00:45:48.070 --> 00:45:54.730
Like, that is r- really rapid growth
and heavy valuations for a really small
00:45:54.740 --> 00:45:58.970
organization trying to do something really
hard, which is reinvent rural healthcare.
00:45:59.090 --> 00:46:05.000
And, um, I think ultimately it serves
as a, as a reminder of how hard that
00:46:05.020 --> 00:46:08.860
is despite the investor interest and
excitement in those models at the time
00:46:08.930 --> 00:46:13.750
and I think for future entrepreneurs
thinking about the space, like it, it's
00:46:13.750 --> 00:46:17.030
a, it's a good reminder of thinking
about funding alignment coming into
00:46:17.030 --> 00:46:21.190
the model and, um, how to grow your
business sustainably over time.
00:46:21.620 --> 00:46:25.920
Ultimately it, it strikes me as a
useful move for Cityblock to drive the
00:46:25.920 --> 00:46:29.920
diversification as you mentioned, as
Cityblock attempts to kind of reach
00:46:29.940 --> 00:46:34.600
the scale it needs to be a meaningful
organization in Medicaid markets serving
00:46:34.600 --> 00:46:40.000
these populations, can't be displaced,
can't be kind of, um, jostled about
00:46:40.010 --> 00:46:44.980
by local market issues and I'm curious
to see how this plays out for them.
00:46:44.980 --> 00:46:48.590
I, I would love to see Cityblock succeed
and show that a company can do this in
00:46:48.590 --> 00:46:52.770
the Medicaid market and work through
the, the headwinds of the last several
00:46:52.770 --> 00:46:55.530
years and it'll be fun to keep an eye on.
00:46:56.370 --> 00:46:56.640
Martin: Yeah.
00:46:57.370 --> 00:47:01.440
I'll also say there's, you know,
the sort of near term headwinds in
00:47:03.520 --> 00:47:05.250
call it urban Medicaid, right?
00:47:05.250 --> 00:47:08.750
We talk a lot about how, uh,
the Rural Health Transformation
00:47:08.750 --> 00:47:13.180
Program is $50 billion against
120 or $30 billion of cuts.
00:47:13.550 --> 00:47:19.720
Um, it's the, the sort of, and th- that's
the headline for rural impact, but it's
00:47:19.720 --> 00:47:24.750
about a trillion dollars in overall
impact on Medicaid, and that the rest
00:47:24.750 --> 00:47:30.030
of that trillion dollars, right, the
trillion less 120, is in urban areas.
00:47:30.060 --> 00:47:35.150
And so that is, that is headwinds
for the CityBlocks of the world,
00:47:35.160 --> 00:47:39.340
um, and, and how they will digest
that, less so in the dual space.
00:47:39.720 --> 00:47:46.230
Um, but it is, I think, uh, rural
is, is definitely an area of interest
00:47:46.230 --> 00:47:51.800
right now, and so it, it strikes
me as sound to be adding some rural
00:47:51.800 --> 00:47:53.580
capabilities at the moment when-
00:47:53.580 --> 00:47:54.190
Kevin: For sure.
00:47:55.346 --> 00:47:59.176
Martin: Large bites of the apple are
happening at, uh, on the, the urban side.
00:47:59.796 --> 00:48:01.176
Should we talk about UpDoc?
00:48:02.076 --> 00:48:02.926
Kevin: Yeah, let's do it.
00:48:03.616 --> 00:48:11.426
So UpDoc last week announced a FDA
clearance for its LLM alongside 18
00:48:11.426 --> 00:48:12.926
million in seed funding to go with it.
00:48:13.566 --> 00:48:18.176
But they had a, a, a, a article worth
reading in Wall Street Journal Pro that
00:48:18.176 --> 00:48:22.616
framed UpDoc as future of concierge
doctor, medicine between doctors
00:48:22.626 --> 00:48:24.846
visits using LLM to manage care.
00:48:25.526 --> 00:48:30.826
Um, and notably, it's the
first call it LLM that's been
00:48:30.826 --> 00:48:32.656
approved by the FDA for that.
00:48:33.456 --> 00:48:35.616
The interesting part of this is thatâ¦
00:48:35.936 --> 00:48:39.196
So we went back and tried to
find the fi- the FDA clearance.
00:48:39.576 --> 00:48:43.806
The, what we can find that's publicly
available is this 510K that was issued
00:48:43.806 --> 00:48:47.956
in December, which is, is much more
narrowly scoped than what I would
00:48:47.976 --> 00:48:51.286
think of as like a concierge doctor
when we're talking about that, right?
00:48:51.576 --> 00:48:56.106
The, the 510K that was approved in
December is around adjusting insulin
00:48:56.106 --> 00:49:00.916
doses, and it's based on a, a pre- the
510Ks are based on predicate devices, so
00:49:00.916 --> 00:49:03.916
things that are out there on the market,
and the FDA looks at the thing that's out
00:49:03.916 --> 00:49:07.846
there on the market and says, "Is your new
thing similar enough to that where we're
00:49:07.846 --> 00:49:10.266
not worried about the clinical impact?"
00:49:10.536 --> 00:49:12.926
If yes, you get approved,
uh, via this 510K.
00:49:13.536 --> 00:49:17.376
And so it's looking at this predicate
device that's called the D-Nav system,
00:49:17.856 -->
00:49:22.746
um, which itself was approved, I
think, in 2019, and says, "Yep,
00:49:22.876 --> 00:49:25.156
you guys can, can do this UpDoc.
00:49:25.166 --> 00:49:29.496
You can titrate insulin dosing in
this, like narrowly defined use case."
00:49:30.096 --> 00:49:31.276
Which makes total sense to me.
00:49:31.306 --> 00:49:35.136
I, I, I think it's great that
they got that approval for this
00:49:35.136 --> 00:49:37.106
defined insulin dosing use case.
00:49:37.616 --> 00:49:42.616
I think it is then worth keeping an
eye on how they intend to expand from
00:49:42.616 --> 00:49:46.956
there to kind of this broader concierge
doctor use case, and how they think
00:49:46.966 --> 00:49:52.616
about FDA approvals within the scope
of that because the FDA approval isâ¦
00:49:53.146 --> 00:49:55.966
I, I don't fully understand it
as it works in this use case.
00:49:55.976 --> 00:50:00.396
The Wall Street Journal Pro article was
talking about how after this clearance,
00:50:00.526 --> 00:50:05.756
the Cleveland Clinic will now start a
six to 12-month pilot, uh, to determine
00:50:05.756 --> 00:50:07.146
its impact on patient outcomes.
00:50:07.646 --> 00:50:13.136
Which Martin, I, I, fundamentally,
I do not understand what is the FDA
00:50:13.146 --> 00:50:17.176
approving if a health system like
the Cleveland Clinic says, "Okay,
00:50:17.216 --> 00:50:21.396
now after the approval, we're gonna
do our study for 12 months on how
00:50:21.396 --> 00:50:22.726
this impacts patient outcomes."
00:50:22.946 --> 00:50:24.586
It just doesn't compute for me.
00:50:24.586 --> 00:50:27.546
Like what the, what's the
point of the FDA approval then?
00:50:27.846 --> 00:50:31.416
Beyond like a stamp that allows
you to put out a press release
00:50:33.662 --> 00:50:34.292
Martin: I do not know.
00:50:35.002 --> 00:50:35.292
Kevin: Yeah.
00:50:35.442 --> 00:50:36.972
I- it's confusing to me, and this isâ¦
00:50:36.972 --> 00:50:37.722
I, I, Iâ¦
00:50:38.002 --> 00:50:42.432
We've talked in, in previous
newsletters and shows about how we're
00:50:42.432 --> 00:50:46.132
in this really interesting regulatory
environment for clinical AI, and it's
00:50:46.132 --> 00:50:47.882
not clear to me how this plays out yet.
00:50:47.912 --> 00:50:53.732
But it does strike me that it makes more
sense to be following the route that
00:50:53.742 --> 00:50:59.172
Utah's going with Doctronic and others
of test these things out live, learn how
00:50:59.172 --> 00:51:01.132
they're working, and use that to build.
00:51:01.142 --> 00:51:05.112
Which is ultimately what UpDoc
is now doing with the Cleveland
00:51:05.112 --> 00:51:07.062
Clinic in a pilot, right?
00:51:07.102 --> 00:51:09.862
Like, they're gonna test it out for 12
months, see how it works and scales.
00:51:09.872 --> 00:51:15.942
Like that, that makes more sense
to me than the, the FDA 510K, "Hey,
00:51:15.942 --> 00:51:20.872
we're gonna have, uh, clinical
studies off 32 patients that are in
00:51:20.882 --> 00:51:24.212
2023 and have approvals in 2026."
00:51:24.222 --> 00:51:26.122
Like, I- it just, umâ¦
00:51:27.882 --> 00:51:30.102
I don't know what I think of
the FDA's involvement here.
00:51:32.310 --> 00:51:36.390
Martin: You can understand why there
would be a desire for, from the
00:51:36.400 --> 00:51:40.060
startup community and the innovation
community for the FDA to preempt this
00:51:40.080 --> 00:51:43.200
happening on a 50-state basis, right?
00:51:43.210 --> 00:51:43.230
Yeah.
00:51:43.660 --> 00:51:52.998
Uh, like going and navigating 50, 51,
um, state laws on AI regulation of
00:51:53.048 --> 00:51:58.768
the practice of medicine and having
50, approximately 51 fights with, uh,
00:51:59.538 --> 00:52:02.128
doctor, like, uh- Boards ⦠boards
of medicine in those states-
00:52:02.128 --> 00:52:02.368
Kevin: Yeah.
00:52:02.668 --> 00:52:05.598
Martin: Is, sounds deeply
unpleasant and expensive.
00:52:05.858 --> 00:52:12.138
On the other hand, like, it is, I think,
how you build a sustainable, a, a sort
00:52:12.138 --> 00:52:17.618
of a, a sustainable body of evidence for
how we regulate this thing, is not by
00:52:17.648 --> 00:52:21.408
just, like, kinda one-shotting and hoping
that the FDA has thought of everything
00:52:21.408 --> 00:52:22.668
and then, and then throwing out.
00:52:23.208 --> 00:52:25.818
And not saying that that's what they're
doing here, but you can see why.
00:52:26.108 --> 00:52:26.128
Kevin: Mm-hmm.
00:52:26.138 --> 00:52:27.878
Martin: Uh, you can see
why there's the appeal.
00:52:28.448 --> 00:52:34.358
I want to talk about lasers before
we, uh, invite our guest on, and
00:52:34.358 --> 00:52:40.598
so I'm gonna stop us there and talk
about lasers, because holy smokes.
00:52:41.668 --> 00:52:44.468
So how does, how do lasers work, Kevin?
00:52:45.458 --> 00:52:50.118
Kevin: I, I still feel relatively
uneducated on the answer to this question,
00:52:50.188 --> 00:52:54.778
having learned about lasers for the first
time in the past couple weeks, uh, after,
00:52:54.818 --> 00:52:56.628
you know, a while working in the industry.
00:52:57.238 --> 00:53:00.858
So the stop loss market has
been, has piqued my interest
00:53:00.858 --> 00:53:01.808
for some time now, right?
00:53:01.808 --> 00:53:05.948
We heard, I forget when the earnings calls
were, but Cigna and others were talking
00:53:05.948 --> 00:53:11.198
about how stop loss market has issues
because, as the narrative goes in my
00:53:11.198 --> 00:53:14.878
head, you've got this rise of high-cost
claims that have been happening because of
00:53:14.878 --> 00:53:19.418
specialty pharma, because of more complex
inpatient, um, things like that, that are
00:53:19.418 --> 00:53:24.638
driving up the number of claims that are
exceeding, call it, a million dollars.
00:53:24.688 --> 00:53:29.798
And that is impacting the stop loss market
because that invokes stop loss coverage
00:53:29.798 --> 00:53:32.168
and makes stop loss less profitable.
00:53:32.828 --> 00:53:37.258
So we, we heard about that and how
groups like Cigna were trying to adjust
00:53:37.268 --> 00:53:42.588
their stop loss plans to, uh, adjust
for driving profitability and stop loss.
00:53:43.148 --> 00:53:48.048
So last, I think it was last week,
maybe two weeks ago, I saw, uh, a
00:53:48.188 --> 00:53:52.228
story from Marsh & McLennan about
how they were effectively using a
00:53:52.228 --> 00:53:57.768
laser to help employers manage, um,
and to help provide stop loss to an
00:53:57.768 --> 00:54:00.168
employer for a high-cost, uh, group.
00:54:00.488 --> 00:54:02.038
So effectively, what these
lasers- And is this, like, a
00:54:02.038 --> 00:54:03.208
Martin: Laser pointer-
00:54:03.438 --> 00:54:04.518
Kevin: Yes ⦠or- No.
00:54:04.848 --> 00:54:13.108
The, the laser is a moniker for lasering
in on the one individual or handful
00:54:13.108 --> 00:54:17.708
of individuals inside of an employer
who have a very high expected spend
00:54:17.778 --> 00:54:21.708
for that year, and essentially carving
them out of the stop loss program.
00:54:21.908 --> 00:54:26.648
So this is what Marsh- Marsh's
case study was 600-life employer.
00:54:26.778 --> 00:54:31.148
There's one employee who they
expect to have a really high-cost
00:54:31.168 --> 00:54:35.304
procedure in the next 12 months And
so for that employer, their options
00:54:35.304 --> 00:54:38.364
were either, one, you pay a $1.3
00:54:38.364 --> 00:54:42.184
million increase in premiums
for the entire plan, which
00:54:42.194 --> 00:54:43.564
impacts everybody, right?
00:54:43.844 --> 00:54:48.164
Or two, you implement this laser
for this one individual where you
00:54:48.164 --> 00:54:52.544
essentially, the employer, has a super
high deductible where the employer has
00:54:52.544 --> 00:54:54.354
to pay for it if the event happens.
00:54:54.564 --> 00:54:58.314
The stop-loss carrier says, "W-
we want nothing to do with this,
00:54:58.354 --> 00:55:00.374
this one employee and their event."
00:55:01.334 --> 00:55:06.064
And in this case, Marsh & McLennan talks
about how they have a team that went and
00:55:06.064 --> 00:55:09.934
looked at the data around this employee
and determined that they didn't think
00:55:09.954 --> 00:55:13.724
that this employee was going to need
the procedure in the next 12 months.
00:55:14.454 --> 00:55:17.664
And so they recommended to the employer
that you should get this l- you,
00:55:17.694 --> 00:55:20.824
you should go the route of getting
this laser because you are not going
00:55:20.824 --> 00:55:23.774
to be ultimately on the hook for
paying this because your employee
00:55:23.774 --> 00:55:25.324
isn't going to have the needed care.
00:55:25.874 --> 00:55:31.054
W- so Marsh & McLennan's case
study is, "Hey, look, we saved this
00:55:31.054 --> 00:55:34.934
employer roughly a million dollars
because we were correct and patient
00:55:34.934 --> 00:55:37.014
didn't need this care in the year."
00:55:37.674 --> 00:55:42.904
Which Martin, to me, is like, o- on the
one hand, I a- I appreciate the innovative
00:55:42.904 --> 00:55:48.764
spirit and ability to, to figure out
how to navigate this cost environment.
00:55:49.144 --> 00:55:53.494
On the other hand, it like, it, it
breaks everything in my head about how
00:55:53.494 --> 00:55:55.414
insurance should work and the, the, theâ¦
00:55:55.704 --> 00:55:56.964
What cost pools do.
00:55:57.304 --> 00:56:00.884
Because like, it, it effectively seems
like you are targeting the one really
00:56:00.884 --> 00:56:05.234
high-cost person and saying, "Mm, no,
we're, we're not covering that anymore."
00:56:05.254 --> 00:56:06.084
Which is likeâ¦
00:56:08.376 --> 00:56:09.366
that's what insurance is here for, no?
00:56:11.576 --> 00:56:14.816
Martin: It's so funny that they call
it lasering, because you really get
00:56:14.816 --> 00:56:16.236
this mental image of, like, you'reâ¦
00:56:16.236 --> 00:56:21.466
It's a 600-person all hands, and you're
like, "Yep, Steve, laser pointer.
00:56:22.176 --> 00:56:23.936
He's, uh, yeah, he's been lasered."
00:56:24.326 --> 00:56:24.456
Kevin: Yeah.
00:56:24.576 --> 00:56:24.876
Martin: Yeah.
00:56:24.876 --> 00:56:32.856
I, I think that we are seeing,
like, the promise of, you know,
00:56:32.906 --> 00:56:34.846
maybe everyone will get on ICHRAs.
00:56:34.896 --> 00:56:36.056
Like, that, that, that isâ¦
00:56:36.666 --> 00:56:39.836
I'm, I'm still bullish in the long run
on ICHRAs, but clearly in the short
00:56:39.836 --> 00:56:43.756
term, everyone is kind of being like,
"We gotta work on employer costs.
00:56:43.756 --> 00:56:46.096
Like, that's our lever for,
for fixing this stuff."
00:56:46.316 --> 00:56:50.306
We've seen a bunch of fundraising rounds
that are focused on the employer, uh, in,
00:56:50.366 --> 00:56:53.006
sponsored insurance space, and I saw aâ¦
00:56:53.006 --> 00:56:56.886
I think it was a JAMA article, and
it was like the, the, sort of the
00:56:56.886 --> 00:57:00.256
secret weapon of fighting healthcare
costs, self-insured employers.
00:57:00.636 --> 00:57:04.406
And this feels like, you know, it's like,
okay, every 10 years we're gonna do this.
00:57:04.676 --> 00:57:06.486
Um, I remember when that was, like, theâ¦
00:57:06.536 --> 00:57:09.066
I was doing a startup and I
was talking about the secret,
00:57:09.346 --> 00:57:10.486
the secret weapon of this.
00:57:10.716 --> 00:57:13.926
But yeah, we're, we're seeing lots
more interest, activity in the
00:57:13.926 --> 00:57:20.116
self-insured space, ways to get smaller,
uh, smaller groups self-insured.
00:57:20.126 --> 00:57:26.076
And you have to wonder, is, like,
with the introduction or the, the
00:57:26.086 --> 00:57:30.256
spread of lasers, is that going to
be, continue to be a viable move?
00:57:30.616 --> 00:57:34.276
Like, if you're like, yeah, you, you
could do self-insured for your 20-person
00:57:34.426 --> 00:57:37.986
group, 'cause we'll bundle you up with
a bunch of other people, but hey, oops,
00:57:37.986 -->
00:57:40.016
we bundled you with someone whoâ¦
00:57:40.036 --> 00:57:42.256
Or you have a lasers, we're actually
kicking you out of the bundle.
00:57:42.276 --> 00:57:45.576
Or your one person is not part
of the bundle- Yeah ⦠anymore.
00:57:45.586 --> 00:57:47.226
And I don't know.
00:57:47.386 --> 00:57:49.156
I, I, it seems like an open question.
00:57:49.806 --> 00:57:50.086
Kevin: Yeah.
00:57:50.216 --> 00:57:53.616
It's one of the things I was reading
that was explaining lasers and,
00:57:53.626 --> 00:57:54.366
you know, there's all theseâ¦
00:57:54.456 --> 00:57:58.346
You can imagine that somebody is, is
willing to work up different financial
00:57:58.356 --> 00:58:00.036
versions of what a laser might look like.
00:58:00.056 --> 00:58:03.126
There's your green laser pointer,
there's your blue one, there's various-
00:58:03.156 --> 00:58:03.366
Martin: Yeah
00:58:03.366 --> 00:58:05.306
Kevin: Degrees of intensity
of light, so on and so forth.
00:58:05.716 --> 00:58:08.196
Uh, you can, you can make up
different versions of these.
00:58:08.406 --> 00:58:12.066
But ultimately, the, the article was
like, this is a, it's a controversial
00:58:12.086 --> 00:58:15.876
practice, both because of the
implications for the individual, but
00:58:15.876 --> 00:58:20.616
also because- The, the Marshall McLennan
is the good outcome for an employer.
00:58:20.616 --> 00:58:24.126
You don't, you don't bear the
costs associated with that.
00:58:24.536 --> 00:58:28.066
In the, in the scenario where the
employee actually needs that care,
00:58:28.076 --> 00:58:32.736
all of a sudden you've got the
employer now on the hook for, uh, a
00:58:32.736 --> 00:58:36.986
significantly higher deductible that the
employer has as part of their policy.
00:58:37.596 --> 00:58:38.416
And I justâ¦
00:58:38.936 --> 00:58:43.276
It, it seems like we are in an
ever-evolving pass the bag of healthcare
00:58:43.306 --> 00:58:44.786
costs from one group to another.
00:58:45.036 --> 00:58:48.946
Cigna and the stop loss carriers get
annoyed because their profitability goes
00:58:48.946 --> 00:58:50.956
down because the rise of high-cost claims.
00:58:51.226 --> 00:58:51.936
What do they do?
00:58:51.956 --> 00:58:55.976
They figure out ways to pass the bag
to the employers and say, "Oh, we're
00:58:55.976 --> 00:58:59.466
gonna introduce these lasering policies
so you, employer, have to take the
00:58:59.466 --> 00:59:01.446
risk on for that increased cost."
00:59:01.796 --> 00:59:03.406
What is the natural next step in this?
00:59:03.566 --> 00:59:06.846
Employers aren't just going to
accept that risk and take it on and
00:59:06.846 --> 00:59:10.356
be like, "Oh, I as a small group
employer might now go out ofâ¦
00:59:10.636 --> 00:59:15.086
go bankrupt because I have these
high-cost claims that might come through
00:59:15.086 --> 00:59:18.826
because of one or two employees' health
issues that I have inside my business?"
00:59:18.836 --> 00:59:21.596
Like, what are you, what are you
doing if you're a small business owner
00:59:21.796 --> 00:59:22.976
and that's what's presented to you?
00:59:23.586 --> 00:59:30.046
I, I, I, like, you know, you continue
passing the bag, which has really bizarre
00:59:30.046 --> 00:59:35.776
implications for the insurability of folks
with these, um, high-cost conditions.
00:59:35.966 --> 00:59:39.666
So I, I, I remember one of the
conversations we were having on
00:59:39.666 --> 00:59:42.156
specialty and gene therapies about howâ¦
00:59:42.866 --> 00:59:45.716
And this was in the, um, it
was in the 60 Minutes episode.
00:59:45.736 --> 00:59:49.576
An employer didn't wanna cover the
cost of gene therapies for, uh, their
00:59:49.576 --> 00:59:52.736
employees because it wasn't written
into their policies, and the state
00:59:52.756 --> 00:59:56.706
Medicaid agency ended up paying for
it because they were, you know, um-
00:59:56.766 --> 00:59:57.576
Martin: Payer of last resort.
00:59:57.616 --> 00:59:58.546
Kevin: Payer of last resort.
00:59:58.626 --> 01:00:02.316
And if that's, like, again, we're
passing the bag from group to group.
01:00:02.416 --> 01:00:06.846
If that's the g- group we pass the bag to,
I- I've got bad news for what's happening
01:00:06.846 --> 01:00:12.986
to healthcare costs and for states in
those groups because the underlying
01:00:12.986 --> 01:00:14.656
high-cost conditions aren't changing.
01:00:16.116 --> 01:00:16.346
Anywayâ¦
01:00:16.366 --> 01:00:21.776
Martin: I think that is actually a great,
perfect segue for our guest today, Dr.
01:00:21.806 --> 01:00:22.836
Jeremy Fries.
01:00:23.476 --> 01:00:25.916
Welcome to the show.
01:00:26.006 --> 01:00:27.286
How are you today, Jeremy?
01:00:28.026 --> 01:00:29.546
Jeremy: Greetings, fellow nerds.
01:00:29.546 --> 01:00:30.746
I just learned something.
01:00:30.806 --> 01:00:32.136
That is fascinating.
01:00:32.316 --> 01:00:32.602
I have to say-
01:00:32.602 --> 01:00:33.796
Kevin: Have you heard of
lasering before, Jeremy?
01:00:34.256 --> 01:00:35.516
Jeremy: Well, I kind of feel likeâ¦
01:00:35.536 --> 01:00:36.806
I'm gonna use Martin's laser.
01:00:36.806 --> 01:00:40.306
I kind of feel like there's one of these
pointed straight on Prior Auth right now.
01:00:40.306 --> 01:00:43.846
So that's, that's the only
laser that I know, but, uh, no.
01:00:43.846 --> 01:00:47.656
I've, I, I have not, so that's gonna
require some education on my part.
01:00:47.756 --> 01:00:50.146
Kevin: Yeah, I was like,
I was mind blown by it.
01:00:50.226 --> 01:00:51.716
Anyways, Martin, kick us off.
01:00:52.016 --> 01:00:52.386
Martin: Well, yeah.
01:00:52.406 --> 01:00:56.146
So we are Prior Auth respecters
and appreciators here.
01:00:56.886 --> 01:01:01.276
And so we, uh, at Health Tech Nerds, so
we are really happy to have you to come
01:01:01.286 --> 01:01:05.536
and, and talk about how you're helping
kind of make that a, a, a better process.
01:01:05.726 --> 01:01:07.346
Can you give us a quick refresh?
01:01:07.456 --> 01:01:08.276
We wanna start with WISeR.
01:01:08.276 --> 01:01:11.806
Can you give us a quick refresh on the
WISeR model, what it's focused on, how it
01:01:11.806 --> 01:01:17.936
works, and what Humata is implementing,
um, to, to kind of help that in Oklahoma?
01:01:19.256 --> 01:01:20.916
Jeremy: Uh, first, good
to see you again, guys.
01:01:20.946 --> 01:01:21.006
Yeah.
01:01:21.996 --> 01:01:23.056
S- My name is Jeremy.
01:01:23.136 --> 01:01:24.646
I run a prior auth company.
01:01:24.706 --> 01:01:29.036
All we care about all day long is
solving prior auth for patients.
01:01:29.116 --> 01:01:32.346
Most of our customers
are big health systems.
01:01:32.706 --> 01:01:36.246
We help them submit better prior
auths to every plan in the country.
01:01:37.266 --> 01:01:40.276
And we've decided to participate,
uh, and are proud to participate in
01:01:40.276 --> 01:01:41.966
the WISeR program, which is a CMMI,
01:01:44.046 --> 01:01:45.216
CMS-sponsored program.
01:01:45.226 --> 01:01:50.946
We have the great state of Oklahoma,
where we help, uh, say yes immediately
01:01:50.946 --> 01:01:55.116
using our artificial intelligence for
the very limited set of prior auth
01:01:55.126 --> 01:02:00.356
codes, again, in under traditional,
uh, fee-for-service Medicare.
01:02:00.886 --> 01:02:02.686
And folks submit to us.
01:02:02.826 --> 01:02:06.856
If our AI can say yes immediately,
great news, you go forward
01:02:06.856 --> 01:02:08.176
and deliver care immediately.
01:02:08.646 --> 01:02:12.236
If we can't say yes immediately,
then we've got an army of doctors
01:02:12.236 --> 01:02:16.056
and nurses that take a look at every
single one of those and give an answer.
01:02:16.306 --> 01:02:21.366
And this, the, the program in general is
being done across six different states.
01:02:21.826 --> 01:02:23.906
As I said, we, we have one state.
01:02:23.956 --> 01:02:27.576
Uh, there are five other participants
that also each have one state.
01:02:27.876 --> 01:02:30.756
And like I said, ours is
the great state of Oklahoma.
01:02:30.766 --> 01:02:35.466
Went live in January of this year, so
we've now got almost six months under
01:02:35.466 --> 01:02:36.806
our belt, which is kind of crazy.
01:02:38.566 --> 01:02:42.616
Kevin: Jeremy, I was reading a, I think
a CBS News article you were quoted in
01:02:42.616 --> 01:02:47.126
about rollout of WISeR, what's going
on in Oklahoma, and it included this
01:02:47.146 --> 01:02:50.416
interesting example of a, I think it
was a cattle rancher in Oklahoma, who's
01:02:50.416 --> 01:02:53.326
talking about how they feel like they
might need to go to Kansas for their
01:02:53.326 --> 01:02:57.206
care moving forward because of concerns
about how the program's been rolling out.
01:02:57.576 --> 01:03:01.396
Can you give listeners here, uh, from
your perspective, what's going on with
01:03:01.396 --> 01:03:04.776
the program, the rollout, and what you
would say to cattle ranchers like the,
01:03:04.786 --> 01:03:08.846
the gentleman who was referenced in the
CBS News article about their concerns
01:03:08.846 --> 01:03:10.446
about access to care in the state?
01:03:11.686 --> 01:03:13.106
Jeremy: Yeah, so, um-
01:03:15.176 --> 01:03:18.956
A-as you, as you all have been talking
about, prior auth is a process in
01:03:18.956 --> 01:03:22.516
the United States that is a, is
a laborious, friction-laden one.
01:03:22.656 --> 01:03:26.636
And so we're on a mission to make
that as seamless and as streamlined
01:03:26.636 --> 01:03:30.686
as possible for both providers and
payers, and firmly believe that the
01:03:30.686 --> 01:03:35.196
only way that you're gonna solve this
problem for the patient who's stuck
01:03:35.196 --> 01:03:39.266
in the middle is if you automate the
submission and you automate the decision.
01:03:40.156 --> 01:03:45.526
And what that, you know, what that means
is a provider has to submit an auth,
01:03:46.416 --> 01:03:50.436
and, you know, that's done through the
traditional channels if, you know, if
01:03:50.436 --> 01:03:52.496
they're not using us or someone like us.
01:03:52.916 --> 01:03:56.046
And y- you know, if, if, uh,
and that has, and that needs
01:03:56.046 --> 01:03:58.156
to be done in advance of getâ¦
01:03:58.196 --> 01:03:59.196
of delivering care.
01:03:59.326 --> 01:04:05.876
And so what that means is practices, uh,
across Oklahoma, but frankly across the
01:04:05.876 --> 01:04:09.496
entire United States, this is already
being done broadly across commercial
01:04:09.496 --> 01:04:11.256
insurance, Medicare Advantage, et cetera.
01:04:11.546 --> 01:04:16.356
And so practices need to plan, and they
need to submit their prior auths upfront,
01:04:16.456 --> 01:04:20.156
and if that's the case, then we can give,
uh, we can give an immediate answer, and
01:04:20.156 --> 01:04:22.696
care can be delivered forward immediately.
01:04:22.776 --> 01:04:27.196
And so this process, uh, is not a new one.
01:04:27.526 --> 01:04:33.586
It is new under these 20 codes, and in
some circumstances, providers, you know,
01:04:33.776 --> 01:04:35.806
submit these maybe later than they should.
01:04:35.886 --> 01:04:39.856
And when that happens, it, you know,
it takes some time to turn around.
01:04:39.856 --> 01:04:42.866
The, uh, the great news is, in
that example, we turned it around
01:04:42.866 --> 01:04:46.966
immediately, and, and care could
have been delivered immediately, but
01:04:46.966 --> 01:04:48.756
it was, you know, elected not to.
01:04:49.166 --> 01:04:52.316
So it does take, it does take
some preparation and planning on
01:04:52.316 --> 01:04:55.646
the provider's part, um, so that
we can get to an immediate yes
01:04:55.696 --> 01:04:57.036
and, and care can be delivered.
01:04:58.944 --> 01:05:02.284
Martin: One of the things that's going on
right now is there's been a ton of media
01:05:02.284 --> 01:05:03.954
attention on prior auth, as you mentioned.
01:05:03.954 --> 01:05:04.494
There's
a, a-
01:05:04.494 --> 01:05:04.654
Jeremy: Yeah
01:05:04.654 --> 01:05:08.434
Martin: Big old laser pointed at
it, specifically WISeR as well.
01:05:08.474 --> 01:05:12.614
And I think in, in our view, or I,
I won't speak for Kevin, I'll say
01:05:12.614 --> 01:05:16.384
in my view it feels like it is an
election year and so some of this is,
01:05:16.384 --> 01:05:20.734
like, convenient and some of it is
there's just, like, a negativity bias.
01:05:20.754 --> 01:05:23.654
Like, the, theâ¦
01:05:23.674 --> 01:05:27.614
There are not stories about where
doctors are running out and saying-
01:05:27.684 --> 01:05:28.084
Jeremy: Yeah.
01:05:28.144 --> 01:05:29.244
"Yay, let's do prior auth."
01:05:29.244 --> 01:05:31.894
Martin: Right ⦠"My, my prior
auth was approved instantly."
01:05:32.194 --> 01:05:35.444
Uh, they're saying like, "Oh,
in this one case where maybe I
01:05:35.444 --> 01:05:36.584
forgot to submit it on time."
01:05:36.614 --> 01:05:37.544
All right, so, soâ¦
01:05:37.874 --> 01:05:42.764
But taking a step back, you're
focused on prior auth all day, 24
01:05:42.764 --> 01:05:44.484
hours a day, seven days a week.
01:05:44.514 --> 01:05:47.904
It is a, I think, sort of in a,
as I mentioned in the lead-in,
01:05:48.084 --> 01:05:49.964
we're prior auth respecters here.
01:05:49.964 --> 01:05:53.574
We understand that, like, you can't
just say yes to everything, that,
01:05:53.584 --> 01:05:58.634
that, th- that we wouldn't have any
money left for things like roads or, or
01:05:58.644 --> 01:06:00.154
schools if we said yes to everything.
01:06:00.154 --> 01:06:05.754
So how are you, like, how are you
managing or navigating this, like,
01:06:06.174 --> 01:06:10.844
persistent sort of negative overwhelming
bias against prior auth and then
01:06:11.184 --> 01:06:15.104
the sort of the necessary, like, th-
that sort of necessary component?
01:06:15.104 --> 01:06:17.754
It's like, it's not like they
picked these 20 codes at random.
01:06:17.754 --> 01:06:21.684
They were codes that, that,
that were sort of hi- Yeah.
01:06:21.804 --> 01:06:23.334
So I'll, I'll kind of pass it over to you.
01:06:23.334 --> 01:06:25.894
But that's, I, I think a question
on our mind is, like, how,
01:06:25.934 --> 01:06:26.624
how are you navigating that?
01:06:27.702 --> 01:06:30.232
Jeremy: Yeah, the, the mac-- uh,
you know, I'll call it the macro
01:06:30.232 --> 01:06:33.062
environment around prior auth, I think
you've described very well, Martin.
01:06:33.092 --> 01:06:36.802
It i- it is challenging, and
it's because of the way prior
01:06:36.802 --> 01:06:38.072
auth has been done in the past.
01:06:38.932 --> 01:06:43.442
And yet, if we're gonna save the
American healthcare system, we need
01:06:43.442 --> 01:06:45.022
to be able to help control costs.
01:06:45.232 --> 01:06:50.812
And, and we need to make sure that grandma
and moms and dads aren't having surgeries
01:06:50.822 --> 01:06:53.482
that aren't, aren't medically necessary.
01:06:53.592
--> 01:06:58.672
And so we need this balance of checks
and balances on both providers and
01:06:58.672 --> 01:07:02.692
payers to make sure that we can get
the right care, but we can't keep doing
01:07:02.692 --> 01:07:03.982
it like it's been done in the past.
01:07:04.302 --> 01:07:09.532
The reason prior auth has such a bad name
is because it does delay care in today's
01:07:09.532 --> 01:07:15.452
world, and it, and it does have all
the negative connotations for a reason,
01:07:15.682 --> 01:07:17.012
so it needs to be done differently.
01:07:17.592 --> 01:07:20.302
And that's what, that's the reason
that we're participating in WISeR.
01:07:20.342 --> 01:07:23.492
We're trying to prove that
it can be done differently.
01:07:23.492 --> 01:07:28.732
You can say yes immediately and get
care swiftly, and make, and make
01:07:28.732 --> 01:07:32.592
sure to protect both the American
taxpayer from paying too much
01:07:32.602 --> 01:07:33.592
for things that aren't necessary.
01:07:33.592 --> 01:07:39.132
But you guys, there's a whole bunch
of patients across the United States
01:07:39.192 --> 01:07:44.872
that are having things done to
them that aren't, aren't valuable,
01:07:44.942 --> 01:07:49.062
aren't driving to better care, and
we know there's enormous variability
01:07:49.062 --> 01:07:50.372
of care across the United States.
01:07:50.372 --> 01:07:52.592
That's been known for decades and decades.
01:07:52.602 --> 01:07:53.532
That's not new.
01:07:53.812 --> 01:07:58.672
And so how do we balance this process of,
you know, saving the American taxpayer,
01:07:58.672 --> 01:08:03.492
but also saving the American patient and
making sure that this process isn't done
01:08:03.492 --> 01:08:05.092
like it's been for the last thirty years?
01:08:05.272 --> 01:08:09.412
We need to do it with technology
in such a way that we can submit
01:08:09.422 --> 01:08:13.362
instantly, we can make decisions
instantly so that care can get delivered
01:08:15.488 --> 01:08:19.648
Kevin: Jeremy, I wanna ask you a question
on the, the adversarial relationship
01:08:19.658 --> 01:08:22.538
between payers and providers, and how
much of that can be automated away.
01:08:22.578 --> 01:08:23.078
Iâ¦
01:08:23.438 --> 01:08:26.958
One of the most interesting Substack
articles I've read in the, in recent
01:08:26.958 --> 01:08:32.758
weeks was from a, I think it was a spine
surgeon, and he was lamenting how Highmark
01:08:32.778 --> 01:08:37.908
Health moved to their own internal AI
prior auth, um, approval process away
01:08:37.908 --> 01:08:43.368
from eviCore, which he preferred because
eviCore had a human who interpreted the
01:08:43.368 --> 01:08:48.518
ambiguity of some of, like, the spinal
biologics that were being used in favor
01:08:48.518 --> 01:08:53.448
of the surgeon, whereas the AI was denying
it because it was, it, it interpreted
01:08:53.448 --> 01:08:57.678
the ambiguity differently and did not
think it was, uh, appropriate for care.
01:08:58.028 --> 01:09:01.798
To me, it was, it was a crazy
moment because, you know, eviCore
01:09:01.808 --> 01:09:05.058
has been referred to as evil
core in various press over time.
01:09:05.068 --> 01:09:08.988
Physicians in general do not like it,
and yet here is a doc being like, "I
01:09:08.988 --> 01:09:12.688
actually prefer what happened in the
past because human was involved because
01:09:12.688 --> 01:09:16.828
they would interpret the ambiguity in
my favor and ultimately approve care."
01:09:17.668 --> 01:09:21.598
To me, it is, it was such a reminder
of the tension that exists in these
01:09:21.618 --> 01:09:25.248
payer-provider conversations, how
goalposts are moved over time, and it
01:09:25.248 --> 01:09:30.208
invites the question of how much can
be actually be automated away in these
01:09:30.228 --> 01:09:33.738
tense negotiations and conversations,
and a little bit of what I hear going
01:09:33.738 --> 01:09:36.458
on in Oklahoma is revolves around that.
01:09:36.488 --> 01:09:42.598
How do you think about, as a company
working on resolving those issues via data
01:09:42.598 --> 01:09:46.878
infrastructure, via real-time processing,
et cetera, how do you think about getting
01:09:46.878 --> 01:09:49.588
in the middle of that conversation
and resolving it in a productive way?
01:09:49.758 --> 01:09:51.278
And how much can actually be resolved?
01:09:52.758 --> 01:09:56.128
Jeremy: I, uh, believe very
strongly in several things, but
01:09:56.148 --> 01:09:59.358
two things that specifically, uh,
relate to what you asked, Kevin.
01:09:59.398 --> 01:10:04.748
Number one, we need, we need dramatic
transparency in prior auth We need to know
01:10:04.748 --> 01:10:06.638
what requires prior auth, what doesn't.
01:10:06.678 --> 01:10:09.068
We need to know what the
rules of the game are, period.
01:10:09.528 --> 01:10:11.168
That, that's a huge step forward.
01:10:11.168 --> 01:10:14.638
That can be d- that can and
only be done with technology
01:10:14.668 --> 01:10:15.978
to make it visible to folks.
01:10:15.998 --> 01:10:20.588
Part of what we've done in Oklahoma
is, is show what the rules of
01:10:20.588 --> 01:10:22.338
the game are right in our portal.
01:10:22.398 --> 01:10:24.948
These, this is the existing NCD/LCD.
01:10:24.948 --> 01:10:29.448
This is the clinical criteria that CMS
has set to drive that transparency.
01:10:29.448 --> 01:10:33.988
So number one is transparency, and I do
think that technology, both willingness
01:10:34.068 --> 01:10:37.208
from, you know, both parties, but
also technology helps drives that.
01:10:37.628 --> 01:10:40.428
And then number two, AI can,
can and should only be used to
01:10:40.428 --> 01:10:45.708
say yes And I, I'm not-- I can't
speak to the Highmark example, the
01:10:45.708 --> 01:10:47.418
accuracy or inaccuracy of that.
01:10:47.698 --> 01:10:47.858
Kevin: Yep.
01:10:47.878 --> 01:10:48.888
Jeremy: Um, that's not us.
01:10:48.888 --> 01:10:54.868
But what I can tell you is our AI can
and
will only be used to say yes, and
01:10:54.868 --> 01:10:58.488
that means that if you've got the right
clinical information and it meets the
01:10:58.518 --> 01:11:03.838
clinical criteria that CMS has set or
a payer has set, yes, go deliver care.
01:11:04.038 --> 01:11:08.218
If the answer is, "Hey, it's not
quite right," then 100% it needs
01:11:08.218 --> 01:11:11.708
to be adjudicated by a human, and
whether that's Evicore or Highmark
01:11:11.708 --> 01:11:16.078
or, you know, somebody else, um,
but it needs to be done by a human.
01:11:16.098 --> 01:11:17.198
So that's the way I thinkâ¦
01:11:18.038 --> 01:11:22.228
The reason I think prior auth is the
use case that you can get providers
01:11:22.228 --> 01:11:26.658
and payers to actually sit down,
guys, and I've seen it so many times.
01:11:26.688 --> 01:11:29.748
In, in fact, just a couple
weeks ago in DC with Dr.
01:11:29.748 --> 01:11:34.218
Oz, leading providers and leading
payers sitting down together say, "How
01:11:34.218 --> 01:11:39.278
can we automate the 90 or 95%," or
whatever the number is that get to yes?
01:11:39.488 --> 01:11:43.718
Because it's expensive and a pain in the
butt for providers, and it's expensive
01:11:43.718 --> 01:11:46.618
and a pain in the butt for payers
when the answer should just be yes.
01:11:46.658 --> 01:11:51.158
And so use computers to submit
better auths, use them to make yes
01:11:51.158 --> 01:11:55.328
decisions, and then have the humans
involved on the ones that you have
01:11:55.328 --> 01:11:57.678
to battle over, these 5 or 10%.
01:11:57.678 --> 01:12:00.858
And that's the way-- And you deliver
transparency in that process.
01:12:00.858 --> 01:12:04.728
That's the way prior auth turns from
being, you know, sort of the evil word
01:12:04.738 --> 01:12:09.958
that it is today to something that
actually is done behind the scenes and
01:12:10.308 --> 01:12:15.338
affects very, very few people because you
have that, you know, that friction area.
01:12:16.988 --> 01:12:18.898
Martin: We had Zeke Emanuel
on a couple weeks ago.
01:12:18.898 --> 01:12:22.448
He was, he wrote that article in The
Bulwark we really liked about how
01:12:22.448 --> 01:12:25.218
we're all gonna have to make some
trade-offs to have- Yeah ⦠the
01:12:25.218 --> 01:12:26.678
healthcare system that we want.
01:12:26.898 --> 01:12:30.358
It, it strikes me that a platform like
Humata, like you're kind of sitting
01:12:30.388 --> 01:12:34.048
at the center of asking the payers
and providers to come together and say
01:12:34.048 --> 01:12:38.978
like, "We can do something positive
sum for everyone, but it's gonna
01:12:38.978 --> 01:12:41.518
require some coordinated activity."
01:12:41.668 --> 01:12:46.088
I'm curious, like where are the sort of
pockets where there's actually really
01:12:46.088 --> 01:12:50.138
good alignment and it just takes getting
someone like you in the room between them?
01:12:50.358 --> 01:12:53.348
And where are there areas where
there is just like, you know,
01:12:53.358 --> 01:12:55.298
f- uh, still a lot of friction?
01:12:55.298 --> 01:13:03.298
Like w- how, uh, d- does the, the, uh,
do the codes sort of like map onto that
01:13:03.298 --> 01:13:08.338
80/20 where it's like these sort of codes
end up in the like a lot of friction and
01:13:08.368 --> 01:13:12.298
need humans, and these ones are actually
areas where there's a tremendous amount
01:13:12.298 --> 01:13:14.728
of room for, for this positive sum win?
01:13:14.728 --> 01:13:15.008
Jeremy: Yeah.
01:13:15.008 --> 01:13:15.408
Weâ¦
01:13:15.468 --> 01:13:19.848
Well, first of all, I like to say, uh,
our goal is to be Switzerland between
01:13:19.848 --> 01:13:22.788
the providers and payers, and just
get to the right answer, and get to
01:13:22.788 --> 01:13:26.348
the right answer as fast and cheap as
possible so that care can get delivered.
01:13:26.988 --> 01:13:31.078
And there is, there is a bunch
of varied variability, Martin,
01:13:31.078 --> 01:13:32.928
but among different codes.
01:13:33.428 --> 01:13:37.358
And, you know, as you, as you
referred to, these codes in
01:13:37.448 --> 01:13:39.058
WISeR were chosen for a reason.
01:13:39.578 --> 01:13:44.778
They're, they're ones where there's, you
know, reasonably known, uh, variability.
01:13:45.408 --> 01:13:49.098
And when you have that variability,
there's, you need to have some oversight,
01:13:49.128 --> 01:13:51.758
and that oversight means you have
to check some clinical information.
01:13:52.168 --> 01:13:55.288
And so that process of checking
clinical information requires
01:13:55.718 --> 01:13:58.648
effort on the provider side and
effort on the payer side today.
01:13:58.958 --> 01:14:00.478
And so the, the, theâ¦
01:14:01.028 --> 01:14:05.968
I mean, my answer would be all across
the board, all of these prior auths,
01:14:06.468 --> 01:14:09.828
uh, there's most of them get to yes.
01:14:10.838 --> 01:14:14.658
The number of yeses depends on
a back surgery versus a, a head
01:14:14.658 --> 01:14:17.118
CT, but most of them get to yes.
01:14:17.178 --> 01:14:21.748
And so how can we be transparent, use AI
to submit better auths and make better
01:14:21.748 --> 01:14:26.448
decisions, faster decisions, and then let
the, let the humans on both sides, you
01:14:26.448 --> 01:14:30.588
know, sort of duke it out on the, on the
few percent that need to be discussed.
01:14:30.608 --> 01:14:35.698
So that that spine surgeon you referred
to, Kevin, uh, can talk to a spine
01:14:35.698 --> 01:14:38.718
surgeon on the payer side and say, "Hey,
this is why I think it should be done."
01:14:38.718 --> 01:14:39.468
"Okay, I agree.
01:14:39.468 --> 01:14:40.118
Let's move on."
01:14:40.708 --> 01:14:46.628
I'll have to say having done that for
a decade, and, uh, uh, I mean, having
01:14:46.628 --> 01:14:50.108
done that as a provider at Mayo Clinic
for a decade, that's still not fun.
01:14:50.268 --> 01:14:53.668
Like, uh, there were still many, many
times where it
should've, you know,
01:14:53.668 --> 01:14:56.908
it should've just been yes and didn't,
didn't get to that point of needing
01:14:57.228 --> 01:14:58.588
the doctor to doctor phone call.
01:14:59.694 --> 01:14:59.914
Kevin: Yeah.
01:15:00.744 --> 01:15:06.064
Jeremy, I wanna ask on, as I think
about Humata in general, uh, outside
01:15:06.064 --> 01:15:08.964
of WISeR program, as I understand
it, you're working a lot with health
01:15:08.964 --> 01:15:12.214
systems, provider organizations on,
on prior auth side of the world.
01:15:12.294 --> 01:15:12.494
Jeremy: Yeah.
01:15:12.634 --> 01:15:17.044
Kevin: It sounds like in WISeR, in
particular, um, part of the challenge
01:15:17.064 --> 01:15:19.844
is getting providers aware of the
process, how they go through the
01:15:19.844 --> 01:15:21.714
process, how they submit information.
01:15:21.994 --> 01:15:24.844
At least as I, like, sit here, I'd be
curious if that's your take as well.
01:15:24.904 --> 01:15:24.924
Jeremy: Yeah.
01:15:24.924 --> 01:15:28.004
Kevin: But it, it seems like an
interesting, on the one hand, you're
01:15:28.004 --> 01:15:30.714
normally working with providers
and rolling out via providers.
01:15:30.714 --> 01:15:34.614
In this one scenario, one of the
challenges, getting providers
01:15:34.634 --> 01:15:38.234
aware, trusting in the tools, using
the right processes, workflows.
01:15:38.234 --> 01:15:43.234
Is that, is, is the explanation
for that as simple as the starting
01:15:43.234 --> 01:15:44.724
point of the implementation?
01:15:44.734 --> 01:15:48.984
In one scenario, it's CMS as payer
saying, "Hey, we're doing this," versus
01:15:49.294 --> 01:15:50.694
provider saying, "We wanna do this."
01:15:50.694 --> 01:15:54.314
And how do you think about kind of the
trust-building exercise that has to
01:15:54.314 --> 01:15:58.434
happen with providers in the market to
get them using these tools in the, in
01:15:58.434 --> 01:16:00.014
the right process, right manner, right-
01:16:00.014 --> 01:16:00.214
Jeremy: Yeah.
01:16:00.214 --> 01:16:01.394
Kevin: Portal, all that kind of stuff?
01:16:01.994 --> 01:16:05.204
Jeremy: I mean, I see the w- I see the
world through the lens of a doctor.
01:16:05.224 --> 01:16:11.624
And so, uh, when we were awarded that,
that contract in, in Oklahoma, you
01:16:11.624 --> 01:16:16.204
know, the second CMS allowed us to
start talking to folks, we did so.
01:16:16.294 --> 01:16:19.984
And doing webinar, just as you said,
doing webinars, doing individual
01:16:19.984 --> 01:16:21.324
phone calls with providers.
01:16:21.864 --> 01:16:25.414
You know, literally everything that
we could think of to make sure that
01:16:25.414 --> 01:16:27.994
they knew that, you're right, this
was a new process where they had to
01:16:28.034 --> 01:16:32.004
s- they had the choice of, they could
either submit the prior auth before
01:16:32.004 --> 01:16:35.994
care is delivered, or they can submit
clinical information with the claim.
01:16:36.384 --> 01:16:40.004
One, uh, so they still had the same
process that they could do, but they
01:16:40.004 --> 01:16:42.724
could choose to do the submission upfront.
01:16:43.204 --> 01:16:48.184
And, uh, one of the things I'm really
proud of is in the few short months
01:16:48.194 --> 01:16:53.274
since we've been live, providers
in Oklahoma could submit these auth
01:16:53.274 --> 01:16:57.774
directly to CMS, or they could submit
it to Humata, a company that they had
01:16:57.774 --> 01:17:00.044
never heard of before this process.
01:17:00.444 --> 01:17:06.444
And this last month, every single
auth was submit directly to us
01:17:06.514 --> 01:17:09.194
through our portal, except for one.
01:17:10.444 --> 01:17:11.204
Except for one.
01:17:11.264 --> 01:17:16.384
And, and that's because we've worked so
hard at providing that sort of physician
01:17:16.414 --> 01:17:21.204
and health system customer service so that
they know, here's the proce- Again, how do
01:17:21.204 --> 01:17:26.184
you bring transparency to this pr- process
that is typically not transparent, and
01:17:26.184 --> 01:17:31.824
just, and give them a, a technology tool
that is pretty seamless and easy to use.
01:17:31.864 --> 01:17:35.324
And then, oh, by the way, when you
get transparent visibility in the
01:17:35.324 --> 01:17:39.844
portal and you get an immediate
answer, turns out that's pretty cool.
01:17:41.582 --> 01:17:43.842
Martin: That's an impressive
stat, all but one.
01:17:43.852 --> 01:17:47.112
I would love to know what that one doctor
is like, "No, I really prefer faxes.
01:17:47.152 --> 01:17:47.772
I really think that-
01:17:47.772 --> 01:17:48.862
Jeremy: I love a fax machine.
01:17:50.222 --> 01:17:51.682
We love a fax.
01:17:51.682 --> 01:17:51.732
The fax is pretty easy.
01:17:51.732 --> 01:17:52.212
Yeah, I mean, you just
push a button, you know?
01:17:52.232 --> 01:17:53.242
But yes, thank you.
01:17:53.352 --> 01:17:54.332
But we're pretty proud of that.
01:17:54.982 --> 01:17:57.662
Martin: Um, that's all
the time we have today.
01:17:57.662 --> 01:17:59.752
This was very informative.
01:17:59.762 --> 01:18:02.362
Thank you so much for giving
us an update on WISeR, fighting
01:18:02.362 --> 01:18:03.692
the good fight on prior auth.
01:18:03.802 --> 01:18:06.612
Where can folks find you if they
wanna learn more, if they're a health
01:18:06.612 --> 01:18:10.162
system thinking this sounds like a
great, a great thing, or a doctor?
01:18:10.662 --> 01:18:12.282
Jeremy: Love to have a conversation.
01:18:12.332 --> 01:18:14.172
We're at humatahealth.com,
01:18:14.582 --> 01:18:15.522
and I'm at jeremy@humatahealth.com.
01:18:16.792 --> 01:18:17.792
Thanks for having me, guys.
01:18:17.912 --> 01:18:18.922
Martin: Jeremy, thanks so much.
01:18:18.922 --> 01:18:19.002
Kevin: Appreciate it very much.
01:18:19.002 --> 01:18:19.452
Good seeing you.
01:18:19.662 --> 01:18:19.872
Jeremy: See ya.
01:18:19.872 --> 01:18:19.962
Bye.
01:18:23.292 --> 01:18:25.622
Martin: Um, someone in the
community pointed outâ¦
01:18:25.632 --> 01:18:29.442
So there's been obviously some, some
congressional pushback on WISeR, and
01:18:29.442 --> 01:18:34.262
someone in the community pointed out that,
um, in the absence of WISeR, doctors will
01:18:34.262 --> 01:18:39.992
just be doing prior auth by faxing their
MAC, their Medicare Administrative, uhâ¦
01:18:40.492 --> 01:18:42.072
And, and so you won't actuallyâ¦
01:18:42.192 --> 01:18:47.712
Instead of a nice u- user ex- venture
funded user experience like Humata, uh,
01:18:47.712 --> 01:18:53.626
you will get, uh, a fax machine, so,
always fascinated to see how, you know,
01:18:53.636 --> 01:18:57.286
the, it's like the, the reaction happens,
but then it's like, well, I don't know if
01:18:57.286 --> 01:18:58.916
you're gonna like what, what happens next.
01:19:00.706 --> 01:19:01.236
Kevin: Yes.
01:19:01.356 --> 01:19:02.106
It isâ¦
01:19:02.426 --> 01:19:05.916
It's gonna be an interesting conundrum
to see how it gets worked out over time.
01:19:06.676 --> 01:19:10.226
You know, it's, as you mentioned, it's
an election year, and it seems like
01:19:10.226 --> 01:19:14.506
there are a lot of, a lot of talking
points in DC to be had around prior
01:19:14.506 --> 01:19:18.196
auth at the moment, which, to Jeremy's
point, I can imagine why working in
01:19:18.206 --> 01:19:20.596
the industry, it feels like you got
the laser pointed on you at the moment.
01:19:20.838 --> 01:19:23.688
Martin: If you wanna chat about
this stuff, the best way to do that
01:19:23.698 --> 01:19:25.928
is to go to healthtechnerds.com,
01:19:25.938 --> 01:19:28.718
sign up for an HTN Pro
membership, and join the Slack.
01:19:28.738 --> 01:19:33.398
We'll be chatting about prior auth,
about WISeR, and about, uh, Assort
01:19:33.458 --> 01:19:36.438
versus Prosper, all things like that.
01:19:36.518 --> 01:19:41.568
And if you're not already, sign up for the
newsletter, healthtechnerds.com/subscribe.
01:19:43.248 --> 01:19:46.048
You know, I'm, I'm a little biased, I'm
on the line with my boss here, but I
01:19:46.058 --> 01:19:47.628
think it's a great read- ⦠every Sunday.
01:19:48.438 --> 01:19:50.148
So, uh, that's my pitch.
01:19:50.908 --> 01:19:52.388
Kevin, thanks for your time today.
01:19:52.408 --> 01:19:54.338
Have a great rest of your Monday everyone.
01:19:54.408 --> 01:19:54.998
We'll see you soon.
01:19:55.438 --> 01:19:56.348
Kevin: Yep, see y'all.
01:19:56.418 --> 01:19:56.608
Bye.
01:19:56.738 --> 01:19:57.018
Martin: Bye.