TRANSCRIPT 🔗
speaker-0: Good morning, JT.
speaker-1: Good morning, Karen. Good morning, world.
speaker-0: Welcome to welcome back to good missus.
speaker-1: Absolutely.
speaker-0: Before we start today, I have a a shout-out. And the shout out is to internet memes. And specifically just, you know, just like the fluff like comedy memes. Yeah. And I'll tell you why. I I think that memes are the last.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: Positive place on the internet. the last place where there's actual goodness and unity, right? Because what do you think about a meme, right? Like most of the these are the things that we're mostly like sharing, you know, on socials and stuff like that, right? And like you're sharing because you think it's funny and you're like, I'm gonna share it with JT because he'll get a laugh out of this, right? It's like you want to share like a little bit of joy with somebody, right? Yeah. you know, we're trying to like uplift each other in little ways, right? So that's nice. But also, the comment section, right? Because the comment section generally in social media is is just a war zone. if you post anything online that takes a stance, is an opinion, you know, even what we're doing here, obviously. Absolutely. or is even just information, like a statistic. or or especially news, an article or something that's topical in the news. If you post anything like that, the comment section immediately devolves into civil war. Or or or eventually, I should say, where it's like the you get these real crazy personal attacks. It has nothing to do with the topic very quickly, and it just becomes all these people going at it. Like, and it can be anything. Like, like, there was a
speaker-1: Just involved in one recently, right?
speaker-0: yeah, you know what? It's funny. It's ironic because I wasn't even thinking about that. Yeah. You and you and I were both involved in it. And our boss called us and said, Hey, this is funny, you know. But
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: like it's innocuous stuff. Like, there can be like like I there was a post a couple whatever months ago I saw. It was like an ESPN post, right? Right. And it was like a picture of LeBron with some of his career stats. And and then it just said, like, you know, something the GOAT, right? Yeah. And then And then obvious immediately the comment section is, you know, this is a you know constant debate topic, who's the goat and anything. But it's like one of the first comments is like, I bet this is written by an effing Democrat. And then it's like, you know, like right. And then it just like then so then that just takes over the the conversation. Now that no one gives a shit about LeBron anymore. Here we go. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But when you look at a look at the comment section on a meme, on a popular meme. It's just people just making more jokes. Like, you can be some in some ways it becomes a bit of a competition, I think, that people are trying to like make the best joke. Like they're trying to get like
Load full transcript
the most likes or be like, make the funniest comment. But like we're all actually united on, hey, we find this funny, let's kind of layer on top. Like those ones never turn into divisive stuff. It is a happy, unified place. The comment section. On on just trash miemes.
speaker-1: My favorite ones are the ones where, you might have a mediocre meme, but the comment section is absolute gold. a lot of times the comment section is more of a draw than the meme itself, just because there's so much hilarity going on. For sure.
speaker-0: Will send those ones to friends and be like, go to the comments to write the top
speaker-1: Right.
speaker-0: 10 comments. Anyways, yeah, it's just interesting that that's yeah how things have evolved. So, like I find more in my life, I how how do I say this? I'm like actually kind of like exposing myself to a bit more of that fluff on a daily basis, like rather than going online to be like, I'm gonna use this time super productively and and do some research or some comparison or something. Like, which you know, I do some of that, but it's like The fluff sometimes is just a nice escape from the friction that you run into out there. So all right. Anyway, so shout out to Memes. Thanks for keeping a light out there. making your internet somewhat redeemable.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: okay, we're talking about these like these myths, these golf myths and unraveling some of them last time. And like, you know, I should say too that it's like, I don't we're not here to be like, no, you're wrong. or you're an idiot. Stop saying that, right? I think there's a kernel of truth in a lot of this stuff. Absolutely.
speaker-1: Sure.
speaker-0: Or it just in a lot of cases, it's like, well, that could be valuable information, but is it solving whatever you're working on right now? Right. Like it's often coming from, you know, someone who's not a coach. Yeah. And so it just might be like one of the two or three, you know. golf rules or swing thoughts that they have in their brain that it's like, when I if I ever, you know, I'm teaching my son or if I see my friend who's swinging a golf club for the first time, this is what I'm gonna say to him or them, whether or not it's applicable to what they need for their game. So what
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: could be factual information, just is how it's applied is usually just incorrect. So so did a few classic ones last time starting with keep your head down, all that stuff, right? What one of them that I is that that I hear a lot from players, and they're they tell me this. I'm trying to hit down on the ball, or I'll tell players, or I hear people tell them, no, no, hit down on the ball. You gotta hit down on the ball.
speaker-1: Right.
speaker-0: Right. now for me personally, it's not in it's not language I've ever used in lesson. Yeah. Right. We definitely know if the ball's on the ground, we'd like somebody to have a, somewhat descending angle of attack, hitting down on the ball. but for
me, J JT, I've never told somebody, hey, no, you gotta hit more. You gotta hit down on it. Yeah. there's other ways to achieve that, I find. Yeah. and the the problem I have with this, this one, where I think it's more the cliche or the misleading one, right? Is like Well, there's a real fine line between hit down and absolutely run into the ground.
speaker-1: Absolutely.
speaker-0: Like down, when you just start injecting down as an idea for players, that can have a lot of effects where it's like, okay, well, okay, so I want the club going down, but then all of a sudden it's like, well, you know, you need other body parts to sort of maybe go down to achieve that. The hands go down, the head, the chest go down. All of a sudden you're just sort of like shrinking the gap. Between you and the ball, you and the ground. And here come a host of other issues, shanks and chunks and all sorts of things.
speaker-1: Absolutely.
speaker-0: so down is for me like that's where I always caution that one that I'm like hit down because it's like, well, like, you know. I mean, I I'm I'm anyways, give me a little bit of your take on that one or how you would use that language or how you would counter that language in your own lesson.
speaker-1: Yeah, we we talked about this a little bit, I think in I can't remember what episode it was now a couple weeks ago. Yeah. Yeah. I think I mean I see it all the time where somebody will come in and tell me that they're trying to hit down on it and they're just making this gargantuan hack down into the ground. You know, and so usually I'll my first thing is I always go to the definition of attack angle and kind of talk about how we manipulate attack angle and start explaining low point and arc-up control and all that. glorious stuff that we've talked about in the past that starts to make a little bit more sense and then you can start to implement and really affect that you can get that downward attack angle, but you're you're nowhere near trying to swing the club down into the ground. You know, I I hear that one a lot. I mean I and and rarely when somebody tells me like, I just started trying to hit down on it or I'm trying to hit down on it, are they making a good move at the golf ball doing it? Right. Like it's Very much like you're saying, there's a lot of the times you're doing some weird things with maintaining your posture and your height and then your arms, if you go down too far, then your arms start to come in and it just there's a lot of weird stuff that goes on. And like I said, I I think the simplest way to get around that is just brush the mat and make sure that that brush is on the front side of the ball, or take a divot and make sure that divot's on the front side of the ball. and it and when I say take a divot, obviously you could say, Well Then you're hitting down on it. But it it's one of those things that really I I like the idea of brushing them at. And then even if you're not taking a divot, but make a divot where it's not necessarily just a gouge out of the earth, make a nice little pass through the golf ball and and brush the grass down. Or, we've all hit those little crispy pitch shots where you didn't take a real divot. you know, that you just kind of see the mud and and and the grass laid down where the club came through. So if you can get real specific about how you're interacting with the turf and making sure that that turf interaction is happening on the forward side of the golf ball, you're gonna hit down pretty much as much as you're ever gonna want or need to.
speaker-0: Right. That that was well said. And I think it also kind of like you it brought up like another sort of myth myth or misnomer. And it's that like you have to take a divot to compress the ball.
speaker-1: Mm.
speaker-0: Right. And I mean, I I'm I'm sure you can attest. like I have lots of players who don't take much of a divot. And sometimes within the first few swings of seeing them on track man or just outside, I go, I bet you don't take much of a divot on the golf course, do you? Right. And they say, No, I never take a divot. Right. Now, sometimes I'm saying that 'cause like they're way too shallow into it and they're they're bouncing behind it or their their path is way too much, you know, sort of way too hooky. Yeah. But sometimes they it's very functional too. And it's just like like my dad is a good example. He's like, I don't think I've ever seen him take a divot in his life. Hits it pro hits it really well, right? Yeah. Manages the depth, the depth of his arc so that he, skims the ground. But no need to no real need to take a divot for anybody, right? Yeah. Would you agree?
speaker-1: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. notably, Tiger Woods says when he's hitting at his best, he doesn't actually take a divot.
speaker-0: Right. Scotty Sheffield's just
speaker-1: I personally am not much of a divot taker at all. But it and even with that, I know the track band numbers well enough that my attack angle with a seven iron tends to be four and a half to five degrees down pretty consistently, and I can I can do that without taking a whole lot of a divot. you can get into some of the semantics of swing plane and arc depth or vertical swing plane and how you know that whole 3D model looks coming down into the golf ball, but and we don't need to do that now. But generally speaking, you know, like it is very, very possible to hit down on the golf ball and not take a divot or not take much of a divot. You can be incredibly steep with your attack angle and have a very mild interaction with the turf.
speaker-0: Yes. Yeah, ultimately, right? It's just like it all that matters is like if here's your ball and your target's over here, let's just try to get the lowest point of that swing, you know, somewhere in between that zone.
speaker-1: Sure. Right. Absolutely.
speaker-0: Whether you really take a divot or just barely clip the grass, both of them are going to produce a very good result.
Right. And you can compress it even without taking that divot. So That was just a little I don't know, a tangent. I saw that from your other comments. So it was a good one. But yeah, yeah. What about here's one I hear a lot, JT, right? working on an issue with a player in a lesson, right? Whatever, contact issue, directional issue. And we're we're working on we have some very clear, concise information that we're we're using to try to guide the, you know, the changes, the improvement. And and we're struggling with it. And then all of a sudden, like flushed one. Yeah. And then I say to the player, okay, hey, that was great. So what what what did you do there? What was the thought there? Right? what helped you execute that? And then they turn around and they say, I just slowed it down. Yeah.
speaker-1: That's a good one.
speaker-0: And I don't know if you can sense or see my frustration.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: Yeah. Now I do a good job of laughing at this
speaker-1: Sure.
speaker-0: with players on the range, right? Because I say if somebody ha plays a fifty yard hook with the driver, slowing down their swing is not gonna change a dead shut club face. Right. but they look right back at me and they No, I just slowed it down. Yeah. Why do you what what's your what's your take when you get feedback like that from a player when you hear that? I just need to slow it down, or I slowed it
speaker-1: This one could be this this could get pretty loaded. there are times that I will intentionally make a player slow down. I would say it's rare that they just slow down. I do think that with good tempo, you can mask a lot of issues. Right. but it's not, you know, it's not just gonna magically fix whatever's going on. Like you're saying, like if you're hitting a fifty yard hook off the T and you just slow down a little bit, you know, like we've there's some dynamic things in that release pattern that are happening to cause that. And regardless of the speed that you go, even if it helps for a a few swings, you generally speaking, you you're just going to start hooking it again at that slower speed. Right. I think, you know, I will say and it's funny because we I think we talked about this a couple of weeks ago. And it kind of comes up with those videos that pop up on Instagram, you know, and it's some Some instructor and he's got, an alignment stick through his belt and he makes this big, exaggerated, steep to shallow move. And he's going, he's swinging the club head probably 35 miles an hour and just hitting these little full swing chip shots. And and the caption is usually imagine if you did this for 15 minutes a day, right? How different would your game be? And I I mean, I'm not sure it would be that different. I'm not a motor learning expert, but I think that there's just it's one of those trends that's gone on and and sure, surely it's great for some people. absolutely I would say it depends on what you're working on, how you're working on it, the types
of drills that you're doing. it's not that it's not gonna work, but but to throw it out there like, hey, this is just do this for 15 minutes a day and it's gonna solve all of your problems. I mean, I have seen people make some very good slow swings, and then when they go back to their normal. Athletic dynamic motion and they try to strike the golf ball and put it down range, they go straight back to that old pattern.
speaker-0: Sure, of course.
speaker-1: I will say, in stark contrast, though, one of my all-time favorite drills to do, especially with a really good ball striker, really good player, is to have them take a seven iron with a full swing. And a lot of these players can hit their seven iron 185 to 200 yards in the air, right? And how do I get them to swing at a speed a full swing? Full length backswing, but hit that golf ball about 120 yards. Right. So like dynamically, that really forces them to kind of feel their weight shift and their tempo and their rhythm. And then feel because ultimately to hit those shots successfully, you still have to be accelerating through the golf ball. And so a lot of times that creates, you know, some really good spatial awareness and just a a dynamic. understanding of where you're at in the golf swing. But I would argue that that's a little bit different than this trend that we're seeing on the internet. you know, it it's a it's a specific drill, like it's a great thing to do when you warm up, but I'm not necessarily having a player change their motion while they're doing that. It's really just more an awareness and control thing. You know, like with those better players, like you need you've It's such a fine line to be able to control that club face the way that you need to. And when you when you slow it down like that and you try to hit your seven iron 120 yards, you really can kind of feel where everything's at and how it's releasing, and then you can start to make some adjustments from there, in my opinion. But I'm an idiot. So
speaker-0: That's a that's a very good qualification to that point, right? Sure. Now I I'm with you too on the the school or the trends around the coaches or the schools of thought that say, Hey, you have to do this in in real slow motion to build the pattern, right? Yeah. And I've done some of that in the past, but I'll tell you, if I when a player and I are working on something, I give it to them at full speed right away. That it's like, let's see if you can do it, right? let's just see if you can translate the concept. Yeah, absolutely. And a lot of the times they can. Yeah. Or it's like they're making some solid progress in that direction. And ultimately, you know, that's the speed you swing at. So it's like I want them to put it together, the concept and the feeling together with the swing they're gonna be using. So yeah, sometimes if they really if if they're like the, you know, their existing motor pattern takes over so much that there's no evidence of of the new information of the new feel. Okay, yeah. Sure. We're we're gonna shorten it up or we're gonna. I do a lot of I do a lot of chippy punch stuff with players to tr start to make some changes, right? Not so much slow motion, but it's like, hey, can you hit this? Can you swing left of this stick but make the ball go just a bit right of the stick, but we're only gonna hit it twenty yards for about the next two or three minutes, right? Right. Just build that build that segment of the swing that's around the impact area. Yeah. But but still with some speed, still with some of the the dynamics that they're used to. So Yeah. Maybe that's more my bent, my method. but I don't think you know, I'd I've never a guy who's like, Okay, we're gonna do this a hundred times in slow motion. That's just me.
speaker-1: So now and and I will say, I I think you and I are both in the same boat conceptually that if there is information or data out there, like if you're watching this and you are a PhD in motor learning, please reach out. Like show me some literature on the benefits of slowing things down and really, you know, like grooving these things out and trying to change the pattern that way. Like if there's data and research backing that and there's some substance to it, like.
speaker-0: Well,
speaker-1: I'm I want to hear it. I'm it you could change my mind. If you show me some data and some truth, you can change my mind in a heartbeat. So I'm not sitting here, I don't think we are sitting here saying that that, there's absolutely that's never gonna work. You know, we we just the only thing that we have is the experience on the lesson tea daily, right? And that we see work and and what doesn't work.
speaker-0: And because our these methods do work right now without going into slow motion, then they're obviously viable, right? So yeah. No, that's good. Let's see if we get any challenges on that. Yeah. I I like the way that you qualified that because I sort of brought that up as like big myth, slow down. But I think you like as always, you see the more complex big picture to these these ideas, and you go, Well, you know, on the one hand and that. So
speaker-1: Fair enough.
speaker-0: Why we love you around here, JT. That's you carry this thing along. Yeah. this isn't so much a myth. I mean, these are we're we're getting a little bit loose on the definition here, but here this is more like competing schools that you hear a lot. Okay. So, like don't roll your hands or hit it with your hands.
speaker-1: Sure.
speaker-0: Right. Complete opposite sides of the spectrum. and the easy, the easy answer, or if somebody looks looks at you and says, What should I be doing with my hands? Right? Or when how do when do I release it? Am I releasing it? All these things, right? The easy answer to right now to this is it depends. right. Or or let's say But maybe the misconception, this is more maybe the myth side, right? Yeah. Let let's say somebody has a big hook, which is really more
than, you know, kind of like 10% of players are less than that. But there's a big still a big population that does that, right? They have a big hook and they say, Yeah, I I know, I know I roll my hands too much or I roll my forearms too much. Right. Right. That's their analysis subjectively. Sure. But you're looking at it going, well, as soon as they're about halfway up the backsling, the face is like 50 degrees shut. about 20% into the motion, they're already set up for a massive hook just because of how the club face looks, right? Yeah. but their perception is that they're too handsy, right? Yeah. which obviously we get a lot of this. We're here as as coaches and as consultants to be like, okay, well, you you you're seeing the you're seeing the effect, but maybe you're misanalyzing the cause, right? Here's more of the cause. It's it's club face. Yeah. Some players might be hooking it because they're they have a really high rate of Higher rate of closure at impact. They're really rolling the forearms or slamming the hands shut and the face shut. But for you, it's really like that face is just there early, right? Right. First thing I'm going to do with a player like that is just broadly say, can you just show me a shot that goes right? Or or you know, like obviously right-handed player. Or I just say, like, hey, do you know how to hit a fade? Like, do you if I if you were on the golf course right now and you had to hit a a little fade, like what would you do? Right. And usually everybody has. Some idea, even if they can't do it or they're not comfortable. And then we we start to talk through that and we see if some change results from that. We see if based on their concepts and their versatility and ability, maybe they already have the answer. Maybe they just needed a little nudge to go, nah, it's not so much the hand thing. It's just maybe more think about ball flight and what you wanted to achieve with it.
speaker-1: And what do what do they recruit to create that change? Right. So like Yeah. That player who's excessively shut, they may successfully keep that face open, but are they going into a bunch of side bend and tilt, holding that face off like crazy to do it? Right. Or do they do it in the backswing? Because hypothetically, I mean, that player has rotated their forearms too much. They just did it in the first three feet of the back swing, whereas they think they're doing it through impact. And they're They're doing it in the opposite direction, right?
speaker-0: Yes.
speaker-1: I had the opportunity maybe about a almost a year ago that I was I was on the phone with a guy named Dr. Scotland, who's the head of research for swing catalysts. And he's a PhD in biomechanics. And I I believe motor learning. I could be wrong about that. I'd have to look that up. but one of the things that he told me very early on, you know, and you're talking to a Brilliant guy. And he he's like, Yeah. So when I get these issues, when we were talking about pressure and force, and he was just, you know, and I I had just gotten a pressure plate and I was like, Hey man, how do I use this thing? Right? Like what what do I need to be looking for? And he was just like, Honestly, man, like you really you you can't mess it up that bad. The general rule of thumb is like if you have a problem, I always use what I call the Goldilocks principle, right? And so the Goldilocks principle, as simple as it sounds, is Goldilocks got three bowls of porridge. One's too hot, one's too cold, and one's just right. And so, when we see these patterns and movements present themselves on the lesson tee, if someone's catastrophically hitting it right or catastrophically hitting it left, can they reverse that pattern? You know, and then the the way that you worded is is simple and brilliant and right along those lines is like, hey, can you reverse this pattern? Can you hit a golf ball to the right? and I will use a lot of the time. vocabulary that's pretty extreme where I'm like, hey, I want, I need you to, if there are a slicer, I want you to hook this thing off the face of the planet left. I want to see this thing turn 90 degrees left about 10 yards out, right? just reverse it as hard as you can. A lot of times when you take when you when you know where both extremes are, it becomes much easier to calibrate the center. Right. And you can apply that to almost Almost every problem in golf where yeah, if the low point's too far behind, let's get the low point too far ahead. If the face angle's too far open, let's get it too far close. If the wrist is super bowed at the top and the club face is shut, let's get it cupped and see what that feels like, right? and you
speaker-0: You just you just trained the whole internet on how to be a golf coach. Tell
speaker-1: Right, right.
speaker-0: that to people all the time. As soon as I tell them, listen, you you might fire me after this. I this is I'm gonna give you the secret to doing my job. Yeah. You can come out here and start charging a hundred and eighty an hour. So Right. Problem.
speaker-1: Reverse reverse the
speaker-0: Do the opposite. Yeah.
speaker-1: I Yeah, and and I think and and ultimately it's that's not news to you. You're already doing that. I just had a phrase for it, right? That I got from somebody brilliant. There's these little tips and tricks that we pick up from other coaches and things like that along the way. But I think you're a hundred percent right in in number one, the way that you fix that. But then number two, when it comes to club face control, how many times do you hear I'm I'm rolling my forearms over too much? For somebody who hits it left, and I can't roll my forearms over for somebody who hits it right.
speaker-0: Right.
speaker-1: And usually for me, what I'll do is I'll dive into okay, hey, I saw a video of this the other day. I saw a guy that was like, there's four ways to close the club face, right? And I was like, okay, that's I want to hear
this, right? option number one, yeah. Use your pivot. Your pivot closes the club face, which is adamantly. Not true. That is not true. Your pivot will play club club head and the club face around, right? But your pivot is not going to close that club face to your midline or your center or whatever, whatever point of reference, right? If we start at setup, my spine is here and the club face is here. And I go into my backswing and I open that thing up. All I did was just pivot from the top. That club face is still open. That's undisputable. You cannot close the club face with the pivot. You can bring the club face around, right? The other three that he listed off were pretty correct. He said you can use your wrists, and your wrists do two things. So you can ulnar and radial deviate or hinge and unhinge, and you can flex extend your wrist or bow your wrist or cup your wrists, right? And that controls the club face. And then you can supinate and pronate your forearms individually, right? So those are kind of the last three. And those all do a pretty damn good job of con controlling that club face. but the pivot doesn't do it. It does not do it. Now I granted this guy was from one of the schools that is very I don't want to let's say really you you're there you're kind of getting into the positions at the top, right? So like the the top of the backswing is very close to where they're gonna want you to impact, right? Okay. And so a lot of times we see bowed wrists, we see, you know, the the arm structure in a very specific spot. Oftentimes they're a little bit laid off, you know, and the whole thing is that they've got to sidebend and rotate pretty heavily and but if the club face is already in that closed condition and I rotate hard enough, yes, I can bring it around to the golf ball, but the club face kinda needs to be closed in the first place to do that. A la Dustin Johnson.
speaker-0: Right, of course. Yeah. for me, one of my biases is like the hands are incredibly important for every player. Absolutely. Like quite obviously, because it's the only thing you're holding the club with. Right. Yeah. right. The guys who are a player who tells me like they're struggling with something and then, you know, it's it's direction related or whatever, and then they're like, Well, I'm trying to, you know, I'm trying to get that left hip to fire and out of the way. And and it's like You're not holding the club with your pelvis. what are your hands doing? get a you're holding something, get a grip on it and use it, use, you know, figure out how to use that tool properly.
speaker-1: There's great video of like all those videos that Taylor made does, like the Trotty, and he'll go out with Colin Morkawa and and Rory and Jason and Tiger. he did a video with Tiger just fully about hitting irons. And it was, I mean, it's one of the greatest golf videos on the internet, right? Because you're listening to the goat talk about you know all the little nuances about how he controls and flights his golf ball and and changes the direction and shape and yada yada yada. Trotty asks him, Tiger, how do you hit a draw? He goes, Well, I move it about this far back in my stance. And that's it. And Trotty's like, What do you mean? He's like, that that gets your path far enough to the right or closes the face. He's like, No, no, no. He's like, the rest, I just I do it with my hands. That's how I was, that's how Pops taught me how how to play golf was, you know, I I feel it with my hands. I do everything with my hands. And so, you know, I think we're also kind of barking up that tree of like, How how do you educate your hands to control the club face? It's a lot
speaker-0: Educate your hands. Thank you. Yeah.
speaker-1: simpler than it it It should be simpler. I'll put it that way.
speaker-0: It should be simpler. Yeah. But it's like I think if I had a a bias or if I had a simple way to approach how to coach like a new player, somebody just uninitiated in golf, I would want them to figure out how to get the ball doing different things, just thinking about what their hands are doing. And thinking about what their hands are doing to the club, the tool that's in their hands. And how do you really close it and how do you really open it? And you know, yeah that for me and and the players that I coach with with the technical stuff that we work on, I always tell them, when you get to the golf course, if you're having a rough day, you can't go into I'm gonna inject these two or three techniques or or feelings. you have to look at your ball flight. This is what every good player does. You have to look at your ball flight and just go, okay, like what does that tell me about what's happening? Right. Right. It's it's going okay, it's going left. Base basically, like one of the knowns there is like my face is too closed somehow. Right. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, it might be a path thing as well. But we know, like face is definitely over there. Yep. So it's like when I when they're on the golf course, then I'm just, you know, like that first drill example I gave of the person who hooks it off the planet. I Hey, can you hit one that goes a little right? That's the same stuff that I want them to do on the course. And like if they're going into okay, tuck the right elbow and clear the left hip, like none of none of that stuff gets to the root cause of. why it's going left. It it's in your hands. It's in your hands. So that's the that's ultimately the athletic and intuitive adjustment that I'm expecting them to make on the golf course.
speaker-1: Yeah, absolutely. And and as when you when you look at some of these numbers on track man, let's say somebody has they make a pretty damn good swing, but let's say their path is two degrees to the right and their face angle is basically half a degree to the right. And then, the ball finishes left of the target line and they're like, hey, what why did I pull that? Right. that's not that's not a terrible pull.
You're let's say you're fifteen to ten to fifteen feet left of the target line. Right, Bravo.
speaker-0: From a hundred and fifteen yards or a hundred and fifty yards, right? So yeah. Yeah.
speaker-1: And and so the adjustment that that player needs to make to that club face, I always say is generally speaking, you want a two to one relationship between the path and the face, right? So if my path is four degrees to the right, I need a face at two degrees to the right. If my path is five degrees to the right, I need my face at two and a half degrees to the right. So if my path was two on a given swing, then yeah, you could you could argue well, I need to take my my path out for the to the right, which I would probably say is true. But if I wanted to hit that ball on target, I need my face angle about one degree. And so when you look at track man gives you a standard deviation number on the bottom right of each tile and tells you what your standard deviation is relative to your average of all the swings that you've taken. I believe the best players in the world are going to be anywhere from maybe a degree and a quarter to two degrees of standard deviation for face control with let's say it's a seven iron. which is pretty damn good. I mean, that's very consistent, right? But if you take that standard deviation, let's say for the sake of example, you have two degrees of standard deviation, and your goal is a two-degree path with a one-degree face, but you have two degrees of standard deviation of the club face, then you've just created a pattern that goes like this, right? And you kind of have you end up, you know, at at that small of a a window, it's probably not quite what you would consider a a gargantuan two-way miss. but your golf ball, like you're you're not gonna draw the golf ball every time and you're not gonna fade the golf ball every time because it's it's too narrow of a window for you to fit a reasonable standard deviation of that club face into. You know, one thing that I always demonstrate to players is I'll take, I'll take an an iron and I'll put it down on the mat in front of them. And I'll say, okay, do you know what a one degree adjustment to the club face looks like? Right. And then they're always like, No, I have no idea. Right. And so I'll take it there. And then I'm like, okay, are you ready? And I make that tiny adjustment. I'm like, did you see it? Right. And they're like, I mean, barely. That's it. And a lot of times I overshoot it. Like, I'll go like one and a half or two degrees. And I'll tell them, I'm like, that was way too much. And they're like, get out of here. Right.
speaker-0: That was a five. Yeah, yeah.
speaker-1: But then once you show them that and you're like, hey. So now that you know what that adjustment looks like and you just hit a draw with a, a two degree path and a and a half a degree face that missed 10 yards left of the target line, and you don't want that to happen again. I need you to make a half of
a degree adjustment to the club face at impact. And how are you going to do that? Are you going to adjust your grip? Is do you think it's something in the top of your swing? Do you think you need to rotate harder? and the answer is that it is. None of those things because there's nothing that I can tell a player to do that is going to inherently make that half of a degree adjustment at impact. It is 1000% hand-eye coordination and timing. That is all that there is to it. and I don't care how good you get, you're not making adjustments to your physical motion in space, the dynamic motion of a golf swing to account for a specific, let's say one degree adjustment to the club face at impact. It is just not feasible. It's not possible. You can't do it.
speaker-0: You just need to be good. You need to the timing, it's skill. And the players who are the most skilled have better timing more often. Yeah. I love that when you put the club down, you're like, here, I'm gonna move it a degree, right? You ready? Yeah. Right. It's like looking at the same two pictures and being like, What's the difference here? Yeah. I I always say to somebody, when somebody comes in and they're like, man, I'm really struggling. I got a big path, you know, with my driver. And it's, you know, seven degrees in in either direction, right? And then I go, Well, like I always just like. I have a piece of paper here, right? But I go, I go, a degree is like the width of this piece of paper, the the the fine edge of this piece of paper, right? So I you know, I just tell players, I'm like, don't, don't, don't blow path and stuff like that too far out of proportion because it's like it's not as extreme as it looks. And and however, I mean, tell me if I'm wrong, but the description you just gave about that player with the pattern, the two degree path to the right. with a two-degree standard deviation of face angle control. It almost is an argument for trying to have a zero path.
speaker-1: Mm. That's come up a lot recently.
speaker-0: And but like maybe I'm wrong. I'm I'm I'm sort of inferring that based on how you were talking there, that it's like, do you have a bit of a preference for that? I I don't mind it. And I will admit that, you know, not not even that many years ago, I would have said to players, I like I don't mind you having a little bit of a path one way or another, you know, three or four degrees in one direction, because if if here's the target line and here's the path, right, you can just fit a face somewhere in there and that shot's gonna do relatively something good, something that you want, right? But you're right that by also swinging that far right a target, and then all of a sudden the odd time that I do have the open face, that's bringing in a shot that can be very bad, especially for the, more recreational novice golfer. Right. Yeah.
speaker-1: So that's a great question. I've seen this come up on the internet a couple of times and I've seen some stuff, people quoting tour data. And and the truth is, is that there's not a lot of poor data out there on this. I think the closest that you can get is like the trackman library, right? So if you own a trackman and you have all of those those model swings in there, there's a lot of really great data in there. The problem is that you've got like one or two swings with each club. In there. So you don't really see, and then the other thing is you have no idea how that on that given day, in that that space or that volume, where that track man is calibrated to and where the player is is intending to swing in relation to that, right?
speaker-0: Very good point.
speaker-1: And so it is you would really like somebody would have to spend a day out on the driving range on tour and have like 50 tour players come and hit balls to the same target in front of the same track man, basically out of the same spot, and describe what their intention is, whether they're trying to hit a high fade or a mid mid flight draw or whatever it is. But then you would be able to collect that data and see some of those standard deviations. Or, who has that data is probably guys like Scott Hamilton, who just has it in his track man because that's the caliber caliber of player that. That he works with, right? So there's a there's a brilliant guy that we could go ask about that that would probably have some answers. But there is no real published data on, track man publishes their their tour averages. I've got it above my desk here, but it doesn't show any standard you don't know what the sample size is, you don't know a lot of those variables that I just covered, and it doesn't show you the standard deviations. it's it's just an average. And so Now, I know that gets a little bit off track, but I it is it's very nuanced because I hear a lot of people talk about well, the data says that tour players are more zeroed out than not. My hunch is that's not necessarily true. however, we don't have, you know, the other guy doesn't have the data to prove that I'm wrong, and I don't have the data to prove that he's wrong. Right. So the way that I've always approached it is I try to stay away from a zero, zero, zero face and zero path. Now, if you're Mr. Havercamp and you're a 30 handicap and I can get you in a in a zero, zero-ish range, I'm jumping for joy. Absolutely by all means, right? because your standard deviations are gonna be a little bit higher. But let's say, you know, worst case scenario, you've got a path that's a degree and a half or two or three degrees to the right, and then maybe your face gets half a degree close to that. But generally speaking, as a 30 handicap, you're getting a golf shot that is going in the air. Towards the intended target, right? That's fantastic. Right. I would say for the better players that I work with, I prefer them to shape their shots because there is you get some feedback in that when things are off, right? So if I hit, let's say my stock shot is a little pull
fade-ish, or even doesn't have to be a pull, but let's say it's a player who who aims left and likes to fade it. when that ball goes straight or turns left. I know exactly what I did wrong with my golf swing, right? Yeah. The club face was too closed relative to the path. If I'm playing tournament golf and I'm zero, zero, then I don't necessarily, I don't know if it's more of the path or more of the face or how much of a combination of the two that it is. I I'll get some pushback on that. But I would say generally, like these really good players, they know exactly where the club is moving and what it's doing at impact. And I think when you look at those standard deviations, when I have a good player, what I try to do is I try to fit their standard deviation inside of their path numbers, right? So like if you look like a Zach Johnson, somebody who's a prominent drawer of the golf ball, like that golf ball is gonna draw every single time that he swings that golf club. let's say that his path on average is six degrees to the right. Therefore, he would need about a three degree face to put that ball on target. Well, if he has a degree and a half, let's say for a round numbers, let's say he has two degrees of standard deviation of face control. Worst case scenario, he has a five face with a six path or a one face with a six path. And every ball that he hits is going to take off and it's going to curve, it's going to start semi to the right and curve. To the left, right? You're not gonna see him block fade a bunch of them. You're rarely gonna see him snipe one to the left. Like he's created a big enough window to fit that face in with the standard deviation to create a consistent ball flight. And then you can start really looking at like dispersion, right? Yeah. So I know that gets a little bit long-winded, but to me, and again, I'm just one guy and I've got my ex experience and biases, but I've always looked at it. that way that for a good player to be able to diagnose on the golf course what's going on with their golf swing, if they if they have that stock shot, it's much easier to do.
speaker-0: Yeah, that that was a great a great description, especially with using that Zach Johnson example and you know fitting the face and the standard deviation of the face into their path pattern. that's really good. And I also I think like I could have said this earlier, but it's like, you know, because you you referenced it a few times there, that two to one ratio of path to face. And that's I think that's one of the greatest things that we learned when we first got on track man. Absolutely. that there was like this pretty concrete ratio that it's like, if my face is half of my path, I get the ball to basically curve to target, accounting for, con centeredness of contact and gear effect with the woods and things like that. But with an iron, that's pretty close to what it's going to do. So know that ratio. Right. So it's like if you know your okay, my path always
goes seven left. Okay. Maybe you want to work on that. But it's like right now all that means is can you get a face that's about three or three and a half left. And then you could go, you could play golf for the rest of your life like that, right? I liked I liked the way he described that a lot. And it's interesting because I I made the point that I said it sounds like you're maybe arguing for a zero path, and then you you really made the other argument, which is good. I'll admit that I've kind of gone back and forth on that, and I I'd say it just kind of depends for me with the player, like what sort of where their skills lie. I mean, like the best players are gonna be good at controlling. all of those club delivery elements. Right. But some players, it's like, they got this guy's got a very repeatable path, but the face is faces all over the place, or vice versa. And so then, you know, you might tailor the the instruction or the suggestions more to their strength. Yeah. Absolutely, hey, we're going to get better at managing this path thing. But in the meantime, if your face is really good and aimed roughly, you know, where we want the ball to start. We can play good golf and then then nothing else really matters, right? So yeah.
speaker-1: Think I think that's the one important thing I want to stand out too is I'm not I'm not so one-sided in this. I think I have a little bit of flexibility there. It depends on the player and their ability and the situation at hand and and kind of how that all presents on the lesson T. It's very much case by case. I have my preferences and then I you know, I have some good players that get they can get pretty damn close to zero pretty consistently, right? And like I tell people all the time, like If you you could come in here and be like, hey coach, look how much I can cut my wrist at the top, or you know, I can look how hard I swing left and come over the top, right? And you're striping it and you're putting shots on target. I'm like, hey, that that looks great, dude. Like, let's get it. Right. If your standard deviations are low and you've got command and control over that golf ball and your your proximity to the hole is is reasonable, then like let's do it. You swing the loop de loop 15 times over your head for all I care. but until you show me that, right, I'm gonna make some suggestions that I believe are gonna push you in the right direction. but it's it's not never zero, zero. There's there's no doubt. And even I say, you know, for my better players, I'm excited.
speaker-0: Sorry, it's not never zero zero. Is that what
speaker-1: Sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. It's
speaker-0: You're not you're not coaching zero zero.
speaker-1: Yeah, I'm getting all I'm on a rant. I'm getting all fired up. I'm all jacked up on Mountain Dew.
speaker-0: What are you? No, I Baha Blast guy? Yeah.
speaker-1: Yeah. I've never it doesn't have to I don't even know how to word it now. I'm all fired up. sometimes it can be zero zero.
I was like Yeah.
speaker-0: Sometimes it can zero zero.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: Okay. I got I'm trying to groove my swing, slash I want, or or I'm waiting for this to feel natural. Yeah. I often think of players like Jordan Speth or pick a player who you see on TV who has a really contorted, wild looking pre-shot rehearsal. Yeah. It might never feel natural. That doesn't mean that you're not doing it right or that you can't live that way for the rest of your life playing golf. What what's your sort of take on that?
speaker-1: There's a video or there's this account that I've seen online on Instagram a couple of times of this guy. And you know, he kind of has this shtick that he's like an ex-golf pro. And he just basically spouts off a bunch of negative stuff about the golf industry and golf instruction and lessons. And here's what the industry will never tell you is you can't actually change your golf swing, right?
speaker-0: Ooh.
speaker-1: And I can't remember his name. I mean, it's really not even worth saying, but He has these videos that he'll make and he talks about how if it takes Tiger Woods two to three years to make a swing change and he's hitting a thousand golf balls a day every day of the year, and what makes you think that you as a twenty handicapper can go and take a lesson and hit a bucket of balls once every two weeks and make any sort of reasonable change? And I I don't necessarily think it's a terribly flawed logic. No. But I do find it to be just terribly untrue. we see, I see, you see, players on a daily basis consistently changing their movement patterns with great success. Now, to sit here and say that it's gonna feel natural for everybody, I think is ludicrous, right? you will get to, I've been playing this game for 20 plus years, and I don't think I've I may have played. Two rounds ever where it just felt like, wow, yeah, I really don't have to think about my golf swing at all. Right. Like it just you just set up, swing and the ball goes where you want it to go and everything's hunky dory.
speaker-0: I would say the same, probably two rounds and a couple thousand. Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-1: it it just it's not really out there. You may experience that for a period of time, but things drift. My for me, it's my grip and my ball position are constantly drifting. Like I'll play great for two months and then you know, I'll go see, I'll have one of my buddies look at me or I'll go see a another coach and they're like, you know, is your grip always that strong? And I'll look down, I'm like, No, it's not, right? And
speaker-0: What am I doing?
speaker-1: then I'll start working it back to the weaker side. I'll play great for another two months. And then I start hitting it like dog shit again. And I'll go back and and see the guy and he's like, Well, well, now you're way too weak. And I'm like, shit, you're right. And then I'll go start going back stronger. I'll hit it good for another two months. Same thing with ball position. that it just things drift and you're never I think we've talked about this before, but feelings are rented, not owned, you know, and and you could take the same swing today versus a year from now. And measure that you're making pretty much the same movement on gears or whatever 3D motion capture system you want to use. and and force plates and track man. And you can be like, yes, this is the exact same golf swing that I took before, as close as it can possibly be. But last time I felt like I was coming over the top, and now I feel like I'm coming into out as hard as I possibly can. Right. motor learning is very weird. There's there's a reason there's people that have dedicated time and effort into becoming PhDs in motor learning. It's very weird, but I'm trying to trying to educate myself on it a little bit more each day. how do you feel about some of the things that I said? And then and then really what what's your opinion on the whole thing? I it's a very it's a pretty deep topic.
speaker-0: Yeah, it's I I I I agree with you on it and you're expanding more than than than I would and adding some really good information there. but one of the classic examples of this, so that people could relate to it, is when I meet a slicer, one of the, you know, kind of one the first things I'll give them after after I've had them try to problem solve some things on their own, the the sort of concrete information that I like to give them is. If the face doesn't go crazy open in the back swing, it's harder to slice it. In other words, if you keep that face strong going back and throughout the swing or or feeling like that for these slicers, right? If the face is never open, the ball can't slice. So we we work on, you know, kind of quickly, okay, they have to roll the forearms, you know, a certain way to sort of twist the shaft and shut the face, or there's some combination of some. Some, some way that the wrists move and the forearms move. And by and large, they all these slicers look back at me and go, Whoo, that feels weird.
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: Right. But then, like, for the first time in their life, they've hit like three straight five-yard draws with a driver, like, you know, better than any shot they've hit in the last five years. And so, like, you know, the the proof is there. And, but they're they're like, there's objections because they're like, Man, that is so weird. That can't that can't be right. Right. Yeah. And and for them, I say, like, you know, yeah, that the it's all that is gonna feel weird because you're so used to the opposite of, you know, how the forearms roll the other way. And I tell everybody that feels very comfortable and it feels like it generates speed and all that stuff. It just creates a terrible club face. Yeah. but I say, hey, like you as long as you go if you go out on the golf course with your driver and have that uncomfortable feeling. It's probably gonna help you hit it better than you've ever hit it out there.
Absolutely. And that uncomfortable feeling might go away. in a lot of cases it diminishes, but it also might be something that for some players is like long term that they're like, this has to feel a bit awkward and a bit weird. Right. For me to just arm wrestle my normal pattern somewhere into the middle because that pattern is just so strong in this regard that I need to constantly give it this awkwardness. So I'm of the school that it's like, yeah, it might you you're making the changes. You want it to feel natural. Like you said, there might be two one or two moments in your life when you when you rent that or short periods where you're you get to experience that. There's always gonna be some sort of conscious element that's sort of often countering something your body used to do or wants to do. Right. So
speaker-1: And that doesn't mean it's, I think there's a level of comfort as awkward as it could be to start out, it will get maybe not comfortable, but it will get more comfortable than it was, and it'll get easier to repeat. And, you know, even though even though you still have to consciously do it, it gets easier to do it over time.
speaker-0: Well, just like your example of when you go and get those, you know, some of those setup things checked on and my grip is really strong and I'm gonna go back weak, right? Well, what what do you like? You see this, right? Like we have players who slice it, we we give them some of those ideas and techniques about the club face and things like that. Yeah. And then a lot of those players will come back to me in a few months or the next season and go, Hey, I'm hooking it. Yeah. Right? Yep. And then it's like, okay, absolutely. Right. So like if you
speaker-1: I'm usually like, Good, that's awesome. Yeah, good.
speaker-0: Right. yeah. Right. It's it's and that it's just part of the progression of okay, you you bounced it way over to the other spectrum. Now, okay, now let's find our way back to the middle. And that's always a funny conversation because now you're you're a year later you're talking to this formerly career slicer and telling them, Hey, can you try to slice one for me here? Right. Yeah. Yeah. The shot that they had nightmares about for years and
speaker-1: It's funny, just even in my own game and I and I'm sure in your own game, you go through these patterns. I had a I had a really successful run of golf when I was hitting a fade. But my natural body motion and pattern is very much a draw bias, right? So for the past five years I've been playing and I'm like, if I could if I could fade it again, if I could just f if I could kind of get back into in and really it's time and practice that I haven't sure I can fade it. But it's like, man, if only I, you know, I would love to just play a fade again. and then as a pro, for me, I I'll jump on my mat or go go to the the range or something and I'll hit a couple balls and try to hit a couple fades and I'm just like I don't I don't have time for that,
right? Like I just like I know how to hit it, know my golf ball, I'm just gonna keep doing it. But like the
speaker-0: Keep doing
speaker-1: grass is always greener on the other side. It's like, man, I used to play so good when I when I used to fade it. Then you start fading it, and then you get like a couple months into that, pattern gets too extreme. You're like, Man, I wish I could go back to hitting a draw, or like yeah.
speaker-0: I want a couple more yards out of this, Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Totally
speaker-1: I did it yesterday. I I I hit a couple shots yesterday. I've been I've been over hooking it quite a bit and had a couple of just horrendous rounds of golf here recently. Decided I was gonna hit some fades yesterday and I did it successfully, right? But now instead of my eight iron going 172 in the air, now it's going 158, 156,
speaker-0: I know.
speaker-1: and I'm like I don't like I'm having a really hard time reconciling playing only hitting my eight iron that far, right? and I
speaker-0: I know.
speaker-1: can I can repeat it and I can do it. And I'm sure if I keep doing it, then I'll pick the speed up. But it's just that it's that little barrier that I'm like, I don't know if I really want to do this.
speaker-0: Dude, the I've been going through that same thing too. And some of the we've I talked about some of the injuries that I've had that have come through golf and and and the assessment of it being a lot of action at the at the end of the chain, a lot of hand and forearm action. And yeah, having to now I'm starting to rebuild this this pattern. And I'm I've actually my last two rounds, I'm like, I thought this was gonna be like a two year project and I still think it will, but like things have come together. Like I hit 14 greens each of the last two ground rounds, and it's like, okay, ball's doing what I want. But yeah, like. It's more of a fade and and I'm like, it's and eight irons going, yeah, like you know, I I've lost a club and it's like there's that ego in you that's like, yeah, but I want this to go, I wanna be able to step on it and it goes over 170. Yeah.
speaker-1: And I would much rather it go where I'm looking. There's no doubt about that. No doubt. But man
speaker-0: I can't argue with the results. I'll tell you one too, like, because we're just talking about how you make these adjustments and these on course adjustments. And and and I I guess in the in this case, we're talking about can you ever groove your swing, right? So like, okay, so for for the last season and certainly at the start of this season, where I'm not playing a lot of like golf, but like for whatever reason with my fairy woods, I'm like getting these terrible, like this terrible toe contact. and it's like sometimes super ugly high pop-up or just low hook. And, you know, I've like looked at it on track, man. I've looked at it on video. I'm like, man, I'm not getting this with anything else. And like gone down the rabbit hole of like dissecting it and like haven't been able to put it together. And then I went out on the weekend and I played this round. And, you know, I was playing with some guys who I haven't seen in a long time. And admittedly, I was like kind of like, I hope I don't have to hit many of these fairy woods today. Cause like, I'm gonna look like an idiot out here. But you know what? I all I said to myself was exactly what I would say to my students. And the more that coat you and I as coaches do this, the more we're actually, we always go like, duh. And like we're like sort of happy and proud for ourselves. But I was like, you know what? I'm gonna try to hit every fairway wood off the heel today. I'm just I don't care where it goes, but I'm not gonna get this stupid toe contact. Yep. And I hit three fairway woods and I hit them ball right out of the middle. Yeah. Flash every one of them. I I have not seen those were the three best Farrowwood flights I've seen in hundreds of days in in in in you know probably 80 rounds. I literally just gave myself a broad thought of like, shank this one, right? hit him in the heel. Yeah. And I created the change because all the stuff I've been doing was was not working or the analysis was just not leading to the right, you know, the right outcome. So finally it's like, what if I just do the opposite? Like I tell everybody else. all right. A couple of good chats on the on the myths or the the misconceptions out there. Hopefully it's helping, you know, the average player. That's what we're here trying to do. So absolutely. we'll talk about more of them. Okay, man. And hopefully the rest of your day goes pretty smoothly. Yeah. Use well, sir. Okay. Enjoy your day.