TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.120 --> 00:00:12.650
[on-hold music] Welcome to the Foundation Series, your deep dive into startup compensation with industry leaders from across the startup world.
2
00:00:13.240 --> 00:00:21.960
Join me, Matt McFarlane, a people operations leader turned compensation specialist, as we uncover the strategies and practices driving success in tech startups around the world.
3
00:00:22.680 --> 00:00:33.720
Hear insights from heads of people, founders, and experts as we explore how to build robust compensation frameworks that not only fuel growth and retention, but do so in the dynamic startup environment that we all know and love.
4
00:00:34.200 --> 00:00:49.920
Let's get into it. [on-hold music] Steve, thank you so much for joining me today. I'm, I'm really stoked to have you on the pod.
5
00:00:50.160 --> 00:00:56.980
I knew as soon as you sort of cropped up in my LinkedIn feed that you were someone that was definitely on my list to, to have this conversation with.
6
00:00:57.020 --> 00:01:08.760
I think you've just got such a fascinating background, not least of which is that you're obviously LinkedIn's first CHRO. You were also recently announced as a top one hundred, uh, influencer when it comes to HR.
7
00:01:08.840 --> 00:01:16.560
So I think this just speaks a little bit to your background, which is, is certainly colorful. Welcome to the Foundation Series. Thanks so much for joining me. Yeah.
8
00:01:16.620 --> 00:01:25.860
I'm really looking forward to it, Matt, and I think given some of the exchanges we've had, I think we've got-- we're-- we've got lots of fodder to, uh, to have a good discussion. I think so. I think so.
9
00:01:25.920 --> 00:01:29.160
I've, I've touched a little bit on your experience, but I know it goes so much deeper.
10
00:01:29.180 --> 00:01:35.640
Would you sort of bless us with a few minutes of an introduction and tell us a bit more about, you know, your background and, and kind of what interests you in the space? Sure.
11
00:01:35.720 --> 00:01:40.320
Well, on the professional side, I sort of fell into the world of human resources pretty early on.
12
00:01:40.380 --> 00:01:47.910
About one year out of college, I was asked to move into a recruiting team in a fashion company, and I immediately fell in love. I mean, it didn't take long. Mm-hmm.
13
00:01:47.940 --> 00:01:57.480
And I think a lot of that stemmed from my joy and love of sport, which is organizing teams, trying to find the best people who play with the best people to create some good value.
14
00:01:57.720 --> 00:02:01.570
And, uh, I was surprised that people actually pay you to recruit other people.
15
00:02:01.570 --> 00:02:10.000
[chuckles] And I started recruiting and then moved by-- moved into bigger responsibilities over the course of, you know, the next twenty, thirty years.
16
00:02:10.259 --> 00:02:16.880
Uh, moved from fashion insurance to insurance and went from wearing a T-shirt and shorts to a coat and tie, which was quite a
Load full transcript
radical change.
17
00:02:16.960 --> 00:02:27.690
But also went from a tiny team where the HR team was five to a company where the HR team was five hundred. Mm-hmm. And, uh, really got a chance to sample all the pieces of the HR pie.
18
00:02:28.160 --> 00:02:37.370
And as you know, there are so many of them. Compensation, immigration, relocation, benefits, conflict resolution, employment law. Recently, you know, data analytics and insights- Mm...
19
00:02:37.370 --> 00:02:45.140
and employee surveys and culture and coaching, uh, and then outplacement and alumni communities. And so, you know, it's such a beautiful landscape.
20
00:02:45.300 --> 00:02:56.460
What's really c-curious and interesting and problematic about the HR profession is there really is no formal accreditation as there is in finance, like the CPA or... You know, there are no exams.
21
00:02:56.560 --> 00:03:00.660
And it's highly, highly relationship dependent because it's a, it's a big world of trust.
22
00:03:00.840 --> 00:03:10.380
So probably around my thirtieth birthday, I was sitting in my first high-tech company at Advanced Micro Devices, and I said, "You know what? I love this. I wanna do this for the rest of my life."
23
00:03:10.420 --> 00:03:19.030
And I decided to go get a master's degree at the University of San Francisco while I was working. So those of you who are, who are doing that or have done that, shout out. It's not easy.
24
00:03:19.040 --> 00:03:26.690
But I was smart enough to do it before kids. So [chuckles] if you're gonna do- [chuckles]... a job and get a master's degree with kids, you're adding the degree of complexity.
25
00:03:26.920 --> 00:03:37.260
But what was really great about that experience was just being able to sit around a table every, you know, every week with people who are doing what I was doing in different organizations and just compare notes.
26
00:03:37.380 --> 00:03:45.900
How are you handling this? How are you handling expansion in India? How are you expand... handling- Mm... staff reductions? How are you, uh, handling, you know, having to reduce costs without lowering headcount?
27
00:03:45.940 --> 00:03:52.360
And so forth and so on. So... And that was great, you know, to build your network, um, was wonderful. Let's see.
28
00:03:52.440 --> 00:04:02.680
Over the course of my career, I had a chance to live in Singapore for two years, and I was the responsible for all of Asia Pac for Cisco Systems. So I got down to Australia a few times, which was wonderful.
29
00:04:02.920 --> 00:04:10.460
Uh- Still nine hours away [chuckles] even from Singapore. Yeah. All over the region. And it was curious to me, like, what are all these Australians doing here in Singapore?
30
00:04:10.490 --> 00:04:19.920
And like, that was my first realization that when a country only has so many opportunities, if you hit a certain ceiling, you gotta go to another country to experience that.
31
00:04:19.969 --> 00:04:27.600
So that was a really par-- good part
of my education too, going over there. From Singapore, I went to Canada for four years, and that was when I was the first ti- first time head of HR.
32
00:04:27.860 --> 00:04:35.200
I never thought I wanted to be a head of HR, but I got conned into it. [chuckles] And then once, once you taste being at the top, you never wanna go, go, go down, so.
33
00:04:35.920 --> 00:04:53.810
And then as you mentioned, the sort of the capstone of my regular operator role was I was offered in 2009 to be the first chief HR officer at LinkedIn, taking the company from a five, six-year-old company to, uh, four hundred to a company of four thousand, two offices to twenty-six and two countries to seventeen- Wow...
34
00:04:53.840 --> 00:05:04.300
through the IPO, a massive expansion, introduction of multiple new product lines, and ultimately building what I think's t- even to this day, I'm very proud to say, is one of the best company cultures, uh, that's out there.
35
00:05:04.880 --> 00:05:14.840
Mm-hmm. And so after doing that for about four years, which felt like twenty, I decided to take a break and invest in becoming a dad and being more present.
36
00:05:15.180 --> 00:05:21.860
I was carrying a lot of parental guilt as the only one on our executive team at LinkedIn that had three young kids. Wow. So I don't regret that decision at all.
37
00:05:22.070 --> 00:05:28.430
And then my phone started ringing with people saying, "Can you help us with culture? Can you help us with hypergrowth?" Mm. "Can you help us with recruiting?
38
00:05:28.430 --> 00:05:33.780
Can you help us manage some craziness in the-- in, you know, in the process of growing an organization?"
39
00:05:33.820 --> 00:05:50.780
And so the last twelve years, I've just built a portfolio of being a dad, being a member of the community here, coaching lots of s- kids' sports, and also traveling around the world teaching, coaching, helping leaders, countries, in some cases, cities and organizations build better people strategies.
40
00:05:50.880 --> 00:05:52.160
Amazing. I love that background.
41
00:05:52.200 --> 00:06:05.820
And, and I think, you know, I mean, obviously the sports team analogy was really popularized by Netflix and their, their culture book, but I love that, you know, you had this kinda concept back then of just assembling the best team that you could and, and kinda, you know, helping us move in the same direction towards whatever our goal is as a company.
42
00:06:06.060 --> 00:06:10.300
You're so right thatYou know, it's great at the top, but it's lonely too, right?
43
00:06:10.320 --> 00:06:19.240
And you kinda touched on the power of networking and, and using that as a, as a mechanism for building your skill set and understanding how to, you know, traverse some of the challenges that you're facing.
44
00:06:19.720 --> 00:06:25.120
How do you think that space has changed a little bit in the last, you know, even few years? 'Cause I, I find it particularly relevant to comp.
45
00:06:25.180 --> 00:06:34.860
It's a little bit of a taboo topic, um, but for me, that's been such a great accelerator of my understanding of comp and how it works has just been going, "Hey, [laughs] so talk to me about what you're doing.
46
00:06:34.920 --> 00:06:39.180
I'll talk to you about what I'm doing." Like, tell me a bit about- Yeah... that space as a catalyst for, for development.
47
00:06:39.220 --> 00:06:48.700
Well, clearly, I mean, we don't need a podcast for all of us to be aware that the world of complexity just grew dramatically during the pandemic, and it was rising before the pandemic.
48
00:06:48.760 --> 00:06:56.440
But here's the tricky part of this profession. There's a lot of tricky parts of, of the world of talent, but one of them is it just covers so many different domains.
49
00:06:56.609 --> 00:07:05.180
And, and you, if you're leading this function, are fortunate if you're really good in three or four. Like, you know, you're not gonna be good at all 40 of the disciplines.
50
00:07:05.360 --> 00:07:14.900
You're gonna be probably really strong in a few, and then you're gonna be good enough in a few others, and then you're gonna have a good network to cover all the spaces that you don't know, right? Yeah.
51
00:07:14.910 --> 00:07:24.080
For example, I'm sitting at LinkedIn. I'd never been in a startup before. I'd never been in a private company before. I'd never built an HR function from nothing before, and I'd never been IPO.
52
00:07:24.320 --> 00:07:34.140
And that was the draw for me is I wanted to face something new and apply- Mm... some of my other learnings. But I didn't want that leap to be as big as it [laughs] ultimately was.
53
00:07:34.180 --> 00:07:40.710
Probably is good that I didn't know how big a leap it was, because nothing prepared me for taking HR down to the studs and building it from nothing.
54
00:07:40.860 --> 00:07:51.380
Like, literally every job I'd ever been in, you're going in and you're fixing what someone else did before you. Mm. And most of us in the HR startup community, when you go in, there's no binder on the wall.
55
00:07:51.420 --> 00:07:55.779
There's no, you know- Yeah... policy and set of practices that have been covering it.
56
00:07:55.820 --> 00:08:26.460
And what's particularly tricky right now is I feel like with whether it's remote work, hybrid work, whether it is political polarization and the growing, um, incapacity for society at large to talk about hard things and how that manifests in the office, whether it is greater transparency to all the things that I don't have in my company 'cause I can see what everyone else has in another company, which has just been bubbling up, to I know more about my colleagues today as a coworker than any time in history.
57
00:08:26.550 --> 00:08:30.940
Mm. And things were a lot calmer when we didn't know everything about everyone else.
58
00:08:31.269 --> 00:08:39.040
And now that we do, we're sort of faced with this set of, you know,
information that oftentimes presents us with, "Well, I don't like that.
59
00:08:39.480 --> 00:08:44.980
I don't like that they are part of that group, or that they do those things, or that they say these things," and we never saw that before. Mm.
60
00:08:45.060 --> 00:08:55.000
And that's creating this, like, huge gray area of, you know, sort of challenge to the harmony of building value in organizations. And so that... There's a whole host of things that...
61
00:08:55.020 --> 00:09:00.200
And then the need for new skills has never been greater- Mm... and the need for new skills faster.
62
00:09:00.590 --> 00:09:07.420
And then artificial intelligence, which could be a whole nother 10 other podcasts that we could do on that topic, is just another new dimension.
63
00:09:07.440 --> 00:09:14.790
Like, wow, this is really reshaping how we build value in really fundamental ways like we've never seen. This is not software that we implement. Yeah.
64
00:09:14.800 --> 00:09:18.300
This is something that challenges how we create value at a very core way.
65
00:09:18.360 --> 00:09:27.030
So that's really, really a challenging time that we sit and have this conversation today, you know, at the end of, uh, the end of 2024, where there is a lot in motion.
66
00:09:27.040 --> 00:09:42.810
And that, you know, as I was starting off answering this question for you, the trap you can fall into as a early, uh, in career HR executive or CHRO is that the organization is looking to you to know everything. Mm.
67
00:09:42.840 --> 00:09:50.580
And if you let them think or you lead them to believe that you do know everything, you're toast. [laughs] You know? Mm. You gotta go and say, "This is my core.
68
00:09:50.960 --> 00:09:57.590
That's not my core, and I will do my best to fill that core, but you as leaders need to help own this talent agenda with me." Yeah.
69
00:09:57.620 --> 00:10:10.420
But if they look to you to solve diversity, if they look to you to solve, you know, equity and inclusion, if they look to you to solve all these other things, that's gonna be a surefire one-way r-route to, uh, you know, anxiety [laughs]- Yeah...
70
00:10:10.440 --> 00:10:10.920
burnout.
71
00:10:12.040 --> 00:10:25.280
One of the things that I personally, and I'm sure many others find as well, is that the startup space is so fascinating because it is such a greenfield environment because you do get to have such an impact and, and really leave your fingerprints on such, you know, diverse things.
72
00:10:25.480 --> 00:10:32.600
You know, versus coming in and kind of just iterating on, on stuff that's already there and kinda, you know, knowing what, what about it doesn't work and, and what doesn't.
73
00:10:32.620 --> 00:10:51.040
But you're right, like, you know, professing to be the expert of all things when it comes to each domain, you know, that the, that the HR brand covers or discipline covers is, is impossible, and it's like how do you lean on your network or experts or,
or others or something to make sure that you can kinda navigate it, but don't, don't pretend that you, you can kinda do it all by yourself.
74
00:10:51.650 --> 00:10:59.590
That's right. And man, I wanna reinforce something you just said, which is something that hadn't really hit me until recently. I was listening to a graduation talk that someone gave that...
75
00:10:59.620 --> 00:11:01.490
Someone said, "Hey, you gotta listen to this graduation talk."
76
00:11:01.680 --> 00:11:12.340
And the speaker, whose name I should remember but I forgot, said something like, "The beautiful thing about an entrepreneurial experience is you're, there are no rules."
77
00:11:12.370 --> 00:11:18.060
And when you go into bigger or more evolved, you know, long in the tooth organizations, there's a whole bunch of rules.
78
00:11:18.840 --> 00:11:29.240
And I think a lot of the brain science and a lot of the experience we have understanding what unlocks energy and creativity, it's operating in that white space, can be really scary- Mm...
79
00:11:29.260 --> 00:11:37.960
but it also tends to reveal real breakthrough moments. And that's why I think a lot of folks are gravitated to that. If you've never tasted it, there's nothing, [laughs] there's nothing like it.
80
00:11:38.040 --> 00:11:48.280
I mean, it's just cr- it's crazy, but the lack of order and the, and the chaos builds a whole bunch of energy, which, you know, if channeled in the right way, can be really, really exciting and positive. Oh, yeah. Yeah.
81
00:11:48.460 --> 00:11:59.040
Yeah, it's a drug, isn't it? Mm-hmm. Speaking of which, I absolutely wanna understand the environment at LinkedIn when you got there. I think there's... We'll take it down the comp street in a minute, but, um- Mm...
82
00:11:59.080 --> 00:12:04.510
tell me a bit about... You know, you, you kinda touched on, uh, the initiation of, of the role and the opportunity.
83
00:12:04.840 --> 00:12:23.488
Talk to me a bit about, like, what LinkedIn looked like when you got there and, and kinda the journey ahead in those, those four years.Well, when I joined, I, I don't think anyone on the leadership team, any of the founders, any of the investors, any of the board ever thought the path, you know, that we were gonna pursue was gonna blow our minds.
84
00:12:23.518 --> 00:12:33.288
[chuckles] Mm-hmm. Like, I, I think there was optimism, and there was excitement, but I walk in the door, and I'm the first hire of the third CEO. Mm-hmm. So Reid, the founder, was a CEO.
85
00:12:33.348 --> 00:12:43.288
Then he hired a guy named Dan Nye, and what Reid learned with his first CEO hire is that everyone went to Reid, and they didn't go to the new CEO, and that wasn't setting up the new CEO for success.
86
00:12:43.868 --> 00:12:51.648
And so that kind of failed. Mm-hmm. And so when he brought in his third CEO, Reid says, "I'm just the strategy guy. I'm not showing up every day.
87
00:12:52.148 --> 00:12:59.248
I'm gonna make myself a little more absent, and I will be a advisor to the CEO but really... And chairman of the board, but that's it."
88
00:12:59.328 --> 00:13:07.548
And, uh, a- a- you know, and high-level strategy conversations if and when it was necessary. So that's what I walked into. The CEO had never been a CEO before.
89
00:13:07.928 --> 00:13:18.228
The entire leadership team over the course of the next few years, just to give you a flavor- Mm-hmm... we were all managing more people, more scale, more growth than any of us had ever done in our entire lives.
90
00:13:18.388 --> 00:13:31.208
Like, I had probably managed... The, the largest organization that I had under me was maybe 20. Mm-hmm. And now I'm sitting on a 200-person, you know, talent, training, development, you know, organizat- Just huge.
91
00:13:31.348 --> 00:13:41.228
Lots of recruiters and so forth. And so if you were an investor at the time back, you know, prior to us filing to go IPO, and you looked at our filing to go public, you go, "Yeah, I don't think so.
92
00:13:41.368 --> 00:13:44.388
Bunch of rookies," [chuckles] you know? Yeah. "A bunch of people playing out of their depth."
93
00:13:44.528 --> 00:13:53.368
And it really took me many years, Matt, and, uh, to get perspective to sort of say that was our superpower, was not knowing what we shouldn't do- Mm-hmm... or not knowing the way it's supposed to go.
94
00:13:54.008 --> 00:14:03.698
Uh, but it was pretty, it was pretty chaotic. I mean, I was literally breaking up fights in the hallway between managers saying, "That's my candidate." "No, that's my candidate." And we were,
95
00:14:04.708 --> 00:14:14.848
dare I say it, failing at recruiting- Mm-hmm... as we're building LinkedIn. Wow. And so just to give you a flavor of the stress of why my hair, which was black, is now [laughs] gray.
96
00:14:14.858 --> 00:14:23.288
[laughs] It's like, "I used to have hair." [laughs] So I know you can relate. [laughs] But this is... You know, our CEO would walk in my room and say, "You know, we can't have this," you know? I'm like...
97
00:14:24.008 --> 00:14:33.708
So his name was Jeff Weiner. I said, "Jeff- Mm... I can't pay what Google, Apple, Facebook, Twitter can pay. I can't provide the office environment. Reid's not even giving me a bonus.
98
00:14:33.748 --> 00:14:37.678
We don't have a, the RSP equivalent in the States is called a 401[k]. We don't have a 401[k].
99
00:14:38.188 --> 00:14:48.548
We don't have anything, and you're pissed at me that I'm not getting the great candidates to take a pay cut, a bonus cut, a stock cut, and a work environment cut?" Mm-hmm. " 'Cause that's what they're doing here, okay?
100
00:14:49.008 --> 00:14:58.608
So if you and the leadership team can give me something that offsets their eye on what they're losing and shows them what they can win, then maybe we've got a chance." Mm.
101
00:14:58.648 --> 00:15:09.828
"But don't come in here looking at me like, oh, it's a bunch of weak recruiters." Mm. I said, "Give me
something to sell," right? Mm-hmm. Uh, and so that's where we were, you know, back in 2009, 2010.
102
00:15:09.868 --> 00:15:17.818
Our offer decline rate was off the charts. I, I'm embarrassed to tell you- Wow... it was probably north of 60%. Wow. And listen, I... At the time, and it's still a battlefield. You're...
103
00:15:17.948 --> 00:15:27.148
If you wanna become a good recruiter, come on to Silicon Valley, and you try to fight the sexy giants that have all the resources and, and tools and work environments. Good luck.
104
00:15:27.208 --> 00:15:32.678
And it's just a, you know, perk, glitter dome of distraction, right? I call it a career candy store. Mm.
105
00:15:32.708 --> 00:15:40.938
Which is wonderful if it's your kids who, who are experiencing that, but if you're trying to build a company, good luck. Yeah. And so what, what that did was it really forced us to sharpen our sword, you know?
106
00:15:40.948 --> 00:15:57.148
And I think through lots of discussion, lots of hashing, lots of really difficult long days and nights, we finally hit a point one day sitting around a table where, I think it was our head of sales said, and I said at the same time, "Maybe we should ask a different question, like, why we're failing recruiting.
107
00:15:57.188 --> 00:16:03.788
Let's ask a different question. Why would anyone wanna come here? Like, what are we solving? What assets do we have?"
108
00:16:03.948 --> 00:16:10.588
And that led us very quickly to, oh, the problem we're solving is more, more important, more valuable, more worthy than any th- other company in Silicon Valley.
109
00:16:11.288 --> 00:16:16.888
And when we got clarity around that, like, "Hey, we're here to help people find their dream jobs." Mm. "Is there anything more valuable?
110
00:16:16.968 --> 00:16:26.268
Do you wanna go over to Facebook and help kids develop their short attention span capability and proliferate fake news? Well, you go for it. But over here, we're trying to help people find their dream jobs.
111
00:16:26.408 --> 00:16:32.408
And do you wanna solve that problem? Because it's gonna change, you know, Third World countries. It's gonna bring them closer to the First World country.
112
00:16:32.448 --> 00:16:40.748
We're gonna help companies and countries understand where the talent is and where their opportunities are and help connect those." Mm. "And that's worth going after. Do you wanna do that?"
113
00:16:40.808 --> 00:16:50.008
I mean, I'm still getting goosebumps talking about it now. And so... And that was a pivotal moment for us, that the biggest asset we had wasn't the buildings, wasn't the, you know, compensation.
114
00:16:50.028 --> 00:17:01.848
It was the problem we're solving. Mm-hmm. And so I'll be honest with you, I would say 80% of the people we hired the first two years I was there, nine in 10, took a pay cut. Yeah. I took a massive pay cut to go.
115
00:17:02.068 --> 00:17:11.308
Don't cry for me because it worked out, because the equity more than compensated for the loss of cash when I went there, but we didn't know at the time. And I think it was- Mm... it was the battle.
116
00:17:11.368 --> 00:17:20.928
It was the force of necessity. It was having a leadership team that didn't know what... how it should go and, and a really phenomenal CEO. I mean, Jeff Weiner was really...
117
00:17:21.668 --> 00:17:28.088
He was really great, and he used to drive me crazy. Like- [laughs]... he would let us fight as a leadership team. Like, he would just let us fight.
118
00:17:28.108 --> 00:17:39.348
I'm like, "Why don't you speak up and take a stand so we don't thrash and kill each other?" And he says, "But," he said, "this is the process we have to go through. We've gotta hear everyone's point of view."
119
00:17:39.748 --> 00:17:44.688
Like, just for- Mm... say, say, um, give you an example. Performance reviews, right?
120
00:17:45.388 --> 00:17:54.708
Tell, show me an executive who says at any point in their career, "You know, that moment that really changed for me was that performance review I had." Nobody says that. It's usually a horror show. And so,
121
00:17:55.688 --> 00:18:02.298
um, at some point, you know, my first six months there, you know, it's time for performance reviews, and everyone's like, "So Steve, what are we doing?" I go, "What do you mean, what are we doing?"
122
00:18:02.398 --> 00:18:10.068
"What'd you do last year?" Ah, it was a joke. It was horrible. We used unsuccessful factors or successful factors- [laughs]... whatever they're called. So we used that piece of garbage.
123
00:18:10.638 --> 00:18:16.118
And then we went through the next two or three years, every time we did a performance review, it was organ rejection. Like, everyone hated it. Mm-hmm.
124
00:18:16.548 --> 00:18:25.828
And so finally I just threw my hands up and I said, "Why don't we just have quarterly conversations?" Like, let's just depressurize this. Let's just talk about development and focusing people.
125
00:18:25.888 --> 00:18:34.044
And when you're, when you're doubling the size of the company every year-I mean, that is such a hard act to do- Mm... because you're digesting new people.
126
00:18:34.124 --> 00:18:43.934
Every department's got new practices and policies and procedures, and it's really, really tough. And so you're trying to build muscle around something like that. So we finally- Mm. You know, are you gonna have a review?
127
00:18:44.044 --> 00:18:52.964
Are you gonna give a rating? If you give a rating, what scale of the rating? And if, and if you give a rating, do you tell the employee, do you not tell the employee? Are you gonna rank? Are you gonna force rank?
128
00:18:53.024 --> 00:18:59.564
Are you going to have distribution curves? You know the story, right? And so going through that process I thought was really thrashing at the time.
129
00:18:59.604 --> 00:19:09.684
I was really fru-frustrated, and then years later, I'm like, "Man, that was really good," because
where we landed was something we all were good with, you know? Yeah. But it took about three years to [laughs] get there.
130
00:19:09.704 --> 00:19:12.044
Three painful years. Yeah. And then you just...
131
00:19:12.104 --> 00:19:26.724
Everything, you know, compensation philosophy, how many levels we should have, what's the promotion scheme like, you know, what's our communication plan like, what's the culture, the, the, the values, all that stuff we thrashed through [snaps fingers] like that, and where we landed was in a really, really great spot.
132
00:19:28.164 --> 00:19:36.614
Yeah, I love that. And I, I wanna go back to a point you said around really getting clear on your why. Like what... Why are we here? What are we trying to achieve? Mm.
133
00:19:36.624 --> 00:19:41.554
Because I think so many companies I speak to are looking for the best practice.
134
00:19:41.624 --> 00:19:50.004
They're looking for what others are doing in the space without realizing that a lot of the reason someone's coming to work for you is not because of the pay.
135
00:19:50.124 --> 00:20:00.924
Like, yes, the pay needs to be at a certain, you know, level and, and, and kind of achieve these things, but fundamentally, they're often coming to work with you for the problem you're solving and the mission that you're on and these sorts of things.
136
00:20:00.944 --> 00:20:10.084
And I think, like, you know, crystallizing that and, and turning it into something compelling is not only important when it comes to recruiting, it's obviously important for keeping people there. But it...
137
00:20:10.144 --> 00:20:19.194
I really wanna understand how that formed the basis then for when you went to flesh out your total rewards offering and, and kinda how it was used as that North Star. Yeah.
138
00:20:19.194 --> 00:20:28.064
I think, you know, first off, recognizing that not everyone wants to work for you, not, not everyone has the values that you have, that this- Mm... you're not the right place for everyone.
139
00:20:28.284 --> 00:20:36.224
That's a bit of a humbling exercise because when you're starting off, you, you're so in love with your company and your product that- Mm... you think everyone should love this. You know? Like, how could you not like it?
140
00:20:36.324 --> 00:20:44.694
And once you start realizing that you've made a few hires and you sold them, and you convinced them- Mm... to go, and then they hate it, and you're like, "Why did I convince them?" Mm.
141
00:20:44.704 --> 00:20:47.384
Like, they need to opt in, you know? And so that sort of...
142
00:20:47.424 --> 00:20:54.724
You know, one of the big lessons that we had is, like, most of the people that you had to sell, if they had to take a pay cut, you're really just renting them for, like, six months, and then they're out.
143
00:20:54.764 --> 00:21:03.604
You know, they're, they're gonna be unhappy most of the time. You know, sometimes it works. But I think that, that was a really good grounding moment for us. Like, who are we? What assets do we have?
144
00:21:03.654 --> 00:21:11.513
And there's a whole bunch of other, you know, big moments that happened to us as a leadership team that sort of defined what we're about, what's our character, and so forth. Mm-hmm.
145
00:21:12.084 --> 00:21:24.614
Um, I think probably to, to be honest, we didn't give a lot, a lot of deep thought to our comp, you know, framework, our total rewards- Mm-hmm... strategy, if you will, until we went public. Because now- Yeah. Okay...
146
00:21:24.644 --> 00:21:34.764
when you go public, if you succeed in going public, now you start publishing what your highest paid executives are making, and now you got some sort of trickle-down. Mm.
147
00:21:34.774 --> 00:21:43.274
And before we could file to go public, we had just a hodgepodge, just as you can imagine. Every executive had different kinds of things in their agreement. Like, oh, if we get bought, you're gonna get this.
148
00:21:43.484 --> 00:21:50.104
If, if you get fired, you get this. And it was all different, so we had to harmonize all that, which was something that took, it took a little bit of time, but- Mm-hmm... you know.
149
00:21:50.564 --> 00:21:57.864
Then we had to go through a process of like, well, what's our philosophy? Mm. And, you know, we had to call in a bunch of people from Netflix. We had two Netflix people on our board.
150
00:21:57.884 --> 00:22:07.324
One was Leslie Kilgore, the former head of marketing, and one was Skip, Skip Battle. He was the chair of the, um, uh, board of directors at Netflix, and he was just awesome.
151
00:22:07.364 --> 00:22:18.024
And he was also the former boss of our CFO, Steve Sordello- Yeah, right... at a prior company. And so, you know, talking to them around, "Well, how did you guys handle this?" Because one thing- Mm...
152
00:22:18.034 --> 00:22:27.024
that you know when you're growing a company, doubling in size every year, is you're having to keep a pulse on the evolution because you're going to need to change it.
153
00:22:27.444 --> 00:22:38.344
And usually, j-just speaking very, very generally, you're lower cash, higher equity at the beginning 'cause you don't have a lot of cash. Mm. So the bet is on the company does well, your equity's gonna be worth a lot.
154
00:22:38.354 --> 00:22:44.704
Yeah. And then as you start getting more and more revenue and the risk profile diminishes, then you've got more cash. Mm.
155
00:22:44.764 --> 00:22:51.614
You don't wanna give a lot of equity because it's not as risky, and you may switch to a different mechanism like an RSU, which is ultimately what we did.
156
00:22:51.824 --> 00:22:55.834
The night after we went public, we switched to [laughs] RSUs 'cause the stock was just going, going crazy.
157
00:22:56.624 --> 00:23:07.954
So we tried to keep everything simple, and that was one of the strong mandates from our CEO was like, "I don't want, I don't want any employees to have to hire a calculus
professor to understand how they got paid." Yeah.
158
00:23:07.954 --> 00:23:15.264
Uh, and this happens a lot with salespeople. They get a check, and like- Mm... I don't know even know where that came from. Like, what is that about? Yeah. And that's so demotivating, you know?
159
00:23:15.324 --> 00:23:25.754
Well, I was gonna say, it diminishes the incentive, right? If they go, "I've got this magical number that makes no sense to me," then what effect- Yeah... is it having on the work that they're delivering? That's true.
160
00:23:25.784 --> 00:23:36.854
And just in case anyone, uh, listening in doesn't believe this, this happens in most sales organizations. I promise you. Most of those people are like, "I got a check. I'm just not sure how they got that number." Mm.
161
00:23:36.884 --> 00:23:44.984
You know? And then most organizations, if the number's really big, then they're gonna say, "Oh, we're gonna need to change your targets because the money's too easy." Yeah. [laughs] Right? And that's another thing.
162
00:23:45.044 --> 00:23:56.324
Like, okay, salespeople usually are rewarded with higher cash and lower equity, you know? Mm. And, and that's just sort of a historical, you know, practice that seems to be passed down.
163
00:23:56.564 --> 00:24:05.554
For many years that I was at LinkedIn prior to going public, I mean, even after we went public, most of the top salespeople made more cash than anyone on the executive team, and we were fine with that. Yeah.
164
00:24:05.584 --> 00:24:15.044
Like, that means you're selling, great. Yeah. We're winning, you know? Yeah. But we're talking, you know, cash in the, in the tune of, you know, a million, two million bucks cash, you know- Wow... um, from doing so well.
165
00:24:15.104 --> 00:24:16.124
So... And good for them.
166
00:24:16.144 --> 00:24:28.684
And our CEO, I think when I was there, when I left, was somewhere around 375,000 US with 100% bonus and an equity that probably got him to, you know, half a billion dollars [laughs] by the end of it.
167
00:24:28.804 --> 00:24:39.628
I don't know, maybe more. So, but that, you know- Wow... recognizing, going back to what you're saying, recognizing that you're going to have to not so entrench your-... philosophy because you know you're growing- Mm...
168
00:24:39.637 --> 00:24:49.268
and you don't wanna be too deep in something that changing it's gonna be hard. 'Cause you know this, when you give something to employee, it's really hard to take it back, you know? Yeah. So- Yeah, yeah... how do we...
169
00:24:49.308 --> 00:24:56.668
And even if it's, like, free soda. Like, if you was, "No more free soda." "What?" You know- Yeah... even though the value that small, it's the symbolism of takeaway. Mm.
170
00:24:56.708 --> 00:25:04.368
So being thoughtful, and for us, what was really important to us was building that trusted relationship with our- Yeah... with our employees.
171
00:25:04.468 --> 00:25:11.708
And more important was what you said earlier, uh, which is a really good call-out, which was we would never sell someone on comp.
172
00:25:11.748 --> 00:25:21.628
We would always sell someone on the role and the impact and the growth opportunity, and then say- Mm... "Okay, if we can just be in the ballpark here of what's fair, you know, are you good?"
173
00:25:21.877 --> 00:25:29.818
And they would go, "Yeah"- Mm-hmm... "I'm good." I'd say, "Okay, let's go." You know? Uh, rather than say, "Okay..." 'Cause some recruiters will call you and say, "Listen, this is what they're offering.
174
00:25:29.868 --> 00:25:35.968
If that's not good for you, let's not even have a conversation." It's like, mm. Mm. That's thinking the short, short term because any...
175
00:25:35.988 --> 00:25:44.768
And I s- I talk a lot to college students about this, like, don't take the job that pays the most now. Take the job- Mm... that has the longest tail of growth opportunity.
176
00:25:44.828 --> 00:25:54.608
Because you could wait tables and make a ton of money right now, but the growth opportunity is zero there. Yeah. So think about, you know, think about that and think about, you know, where am I gonna learn?
177
00:25:54.668 --> 00:26:01.248
Because with the earlier you are in your career, the biggest asset to you is just you becoming better, you know? Mm-hmm. Not what's going in your pocketbook.
178
00:26:01.628 --> 00:26:10.908
And that's easy to say because some people have financial needs, I get it, but the long-term play is to really think where is that. In, in Silicon Valley, it's who are you around?
179
00:26:11.268 --> 00:26:18.508
Are those people gonna go places and invite you for bigger opportunities down the road? Yeah. That's really important, you know? And I thought about that.
180
00:26:18.538 --> 00:26:25.968
When I went to LinkedIn, I'm like, listen, if this thing goes belly up in a year or two, I can always go back to some big company 'cause I've proven I can do that.
181
00:26:26.148 --> 00:26:37.788
So I've always got that safety net here, but man, even if it goes down, like I'm, I've met some venture capital people, I've met some really interesting entrepreneurs, maybe that'll lead to another opportunity, so I think it's worth the risk, right?
182
00:26:37.888 --> 00:26:45.577
Yeah. Yeah, I think that's really great early career advice for anyone. Um, and, and I think you touched on something as well that I'm, I'm keen to explore, not only in- Mm...
183
00:26:45.608 --> 00:26:54.868
I guess your, your journey with LinkedIn where you got to see such a spectrum of, of evolution of organization, but you're obviously consulting with a lot of companies that are facing these things on a, on an ongoing basis.
184
00:26:55.328 --> 00:27:01.648
Just how does, you know, or I guess what are the key ways in which comp tends to evolve beyond that equity cash split?
185
00:27:01.688 --> 00:27:08.748
Are there other things that you see from a, you know, whether it's seed, Series A, all the way
up to maybe IPO, where compensation tends to, to evolve?
186
00:27:08.778 --> 00:27:13.088
And I guess maybe sprinkle in some of the generational things that are starting to crop up as well, right?
187
00:27:13.148 --> 00:27:19.308
Like you, you know, you're talking to college students where I'm seeing a lot of, um, uh, you know, emphasis on work-life balance.
188
00:27:19.368 --> 00:27:28.598
I mean, cash is still important, but, you know, maybe, maybe it's very different to, to what a, a Gen X-er or, or a, you know, millennial or someone's looking for in the market too. Yeah.
189
00:27:28.598 --> 00:27:40.778
Well, you're l- you're giving me some good leads here in terms of how I would like to express how I think about it, which is the compensation stack includes time off, includes, you know, your relationship with your boss, includes how much you're learning, inclu- Mm...
190
00:27:40.788 --> 00:27:48.958
cludes how your network is growing. Are you gonna be s- put in a small silo and not allowed to interact on other stuff? Are you gonna have a chance to work on other projects and other things like that? Mm.
191
00:27:48.988 --> 00:27:56.808
One of the things that we felt we needed to differentiate ourselves on at LinkedIn was this notion of burnout. Like, we were really...
192
00:27:56.828 --> 00:28:01.448
This is before, you know, burnout's now top of mind, but back then it wasn't necessarily.
193
00:28:01.628 --> 00:28:11.088
And I used to see, on Sunday and Monday mornings, I used to see emails over the weekend from the engineering team saying, "Hey, congratulations for pushing that code out at 3:00 AM on Sunday.
194
00:28:11.468 --> 00:28:22.268
I'd like to thank Sanjana and Mohanjit and, you know, Susie and Jim." And I'm like going to Siegel like, "This is not okay." Mm. Like, we're pushing code out at 3:00 in the morning on Sunday and we're thanking people?
195
00:28:22.328 --> 00:28:30.128
Like, at what point do we know we're doing too much? Mm. And like any good CEO, he didn't wanna hear, you know, he didn't wanna hear the reality of the fact that we're working people really hard.
196
00:28:30.308 --> 00:28:44.608
And so one of the things in the whole spirit of trying to differentiate ourselves in a very, very competitive market for talent that we started to pursue was this notion of let's try to give the team a day a month- Mm...
197
00:28:44.648 --> 00:28:56.327
to just do whatever they want, like a working day. And this was largely the, an idea that kinda came from our head of marketing and our head of finance iterated on it. But, uh, Patrick Crane and Steve Sordello,
198
00:28:57.348 --> 00:29:04.668
uh, and it, p- the first i- idea that came forward was like, maybe we should give everyone every other Friday off. Like just give it off. Mm. Like, not even do it.
199
00:29:04.808 --> 00:29:12.668
And then the more we thought about it, like that's disingenuous. Like this is, you know, we, we need to work seven days a week here. [laughs] Mm. Like, you can't give someone every other Friday off.
200
00:29:13.268 --> 00:29:18.998
That's, that's gonna be really, you know- Yeah, it'd be in name only 'cause you know that the incentives- Yeah... aren't gonna work... that's gonna be a joke. Yeah. People will laugh at us, right? Yeah.
201
00:29:19.048 --> 00:29:27.948
So, so then the engineering team is just, you know, showing us that it's really hard for us to recruit really good engineers, so everyone's doing double duty until we can fill these jobs, and they're getting really tired.
202
00:29:28.148 --> 00:29:37.428
So finally we go to engineering and say, "Hey, we got an idea. We're gonna allow you every other Friday to just work on something, whatever you want, like a passion project." Mm. And they said, "No."
203
00:29:38.048 --> 00:29:45.608
We said, "What do you mean no?" They said, "No, we don't wanna do it." And we're like, "But you're the guys telling us you're burnt out. We've got a solution for you."
204
00:29:46.128 --> 00:29:54.888
And they're like, "No, we don't believe you can turn the company off every other Friday, which means if we do that fun stuff, we're gonna be spending all weekend doing- Mm... our regular job.
205
00:29:54.948 --> 00:30:02.268
We don't trust you management that you can turn the company off." And that was a gut punch followed by a shot to the head. Yeah. Like, okay.
206
00:30:02.728 --> 00:30:10.428
So finally we ha- we said, "Why don't you give us a shot to just try this, just one Friday a month?" And they said, "Let's do a hack day."
207
00:30:10.498 --> 00:30:20.768
You know, and so most of the engineering said, you know, "Let's try to hack some new products or hack a better, better procedure in the company," or even something like, "Let's figure out how to reserve conference room on an iPad or whatever."
208
00:30:20.908 --> 00:30:30.138
Like something s- Mm... from the mundane to the really profound. And that was such a good experience that we tried it for a couple of months, that it just became, you know- Mm...
209
00:30:30.158 --> 00:30:39.668
a world unto its own where people would say, well, this, this... We called it In Day. Yeah. You got, get into it and tap into your passion. That became part of who we were and our identity. Mm.
210
00:30:39.678 --> 00:30:48.438
And it was part of the comp stack was like, hey, we know this is nuts, man. You know, what we're, we're asking ourselves. But back to the, the whole point of, like, the problem we're solving really, really matters.
211
00:30:48.528 --> 00:30:58.339
If you really hit that-Work doesn't feel like work, doesn't feel like a grind as much. Yeah. It's like, wow, this is a really cool thing that we're solving. Yeah. That gets you to the Simon Sinek, you know, the why.
212
00:30:58.470 --> 00:31:01.180
Got it. Like, it's really, really powerful, and I saw that at play.
213
00:31:01.190 --> 00:31:11.400
And then the other thing is creating a culture of trust where you talk about
the stuff that's broken, that's messed up, that's wrong, that's uncomfortable. A lot of companies will sweep it under the rug.
214
00:31:11.520 --> 00:31:21.240
We tried hard to sort of say, if we ever have a company meeting and someone doesn't ask a really hard question, like, that's not a good sign. Mm. Like, we wanna make sure someone's saying, you know, "I don't know.
215
00:31:21.330 --> 00:31:30.520
Why are we doing that?" Like, that's... "Who came up with that idea?" [laughs] And or, like, one of the sore points was why don't we have better maternity benefits, or why don't we have a bus to San Francisco, right?
216
00:31:30.730 --> 00:31:36.180
And so we would go research it, and we would say, "Let's take the bus to San Francisco," and say, "Okay, I did the research.
217
00:31:36.260 --> 00:31:45.400
So I called all the people from San Francisco that want the bus to San Francisco," which is an import- Like, hey, Google's next door. They got hundreds of buses every day to San Francisco. So I researched it.
218
00:31:46.180 --> 00:31:52.740
Well, first I called Google and said, "Can we get on your buses?" And they're like, "Oh, hell no." [laughs] I was like, "What do you mean? We're, you know, we're, you know, we're partners here. We buy from you.
219
00:31:52.800 --> 00:31:57.760
You buy from us." Yeah. They're like, "No confidential information on the buses. Can't do it." So like, "Okay. Shoot."
220
00:31:58.000 --> 00:32:08.950
So then I researched it, and to have two buses in the morning and two buses in the evening to and from San Francisco and Mountain View, which is probably a 40-minute on a good day to an hour and a half on a bad day drive- Mm...
221
00:32:09.020 --> 00:32:16.300
was gonna cost us a quarter of a million dollars. Okay? So and then I looked at where's the spread of all our employees. Like, where are they?
222
00:32:16.510 --> 00:32:24.990
And we only had, like, 15% of our employees were in San Francisco, and 40% were even further away from San Francisco but just different directions, and there was no cluster. Mm.
223
00:32:25.020 --> 00:32:27.040
So I went to the group and I said, "Here's the data.
224
00:32:27.080 --> 00:32:38.020
You are 15%, you know, and this is what it's gonna cost us, and if we agree to do that, do you think that's the best use of money when 40% of the company's in a w- in a worse place than you?" Mm.
225
00:32:38.260 --> 00:32:42.680
And they, you know, to, to, to their credit said, "Yeah, thank you for doing the research. Yeah, probably not a good use of money."
226
00:32:43.520 --> 00:32:47.430
At the end of the day, we wound up having to do it just for recruiting purposes because- Yeah...
227
00:32:47.660 --> 00:32:56.610
the way the, the Bay Area works is that the younger talent tends to wanna be in the city where the action is, and they don't wanna be in the boring suburbs where the schools are good, and you have- Mm-hmm...
228
00:32:56.670 --> 00:33:06.640
a bigger house where the older senior talent wants to be. So we're like, well, if we want to attract that talent, we're gonna probably need to invest in that. So it was sorta like a branding play versus a expense play.
229
00:33:06.660 --> 00:33:12.620
But that was when we had- Yeah... a little bit more money. But, but the, but the overall aggregate here is sorta like belief in the company's really, really important.
230
00:33:12.690 --> 00:33:18.250
All that other stuff, you know, you need to get it right, but that shouldn't be your lead. You know what I'm saying? Like, your- Yeah...
231
00:33:18.280 --> 00:33:28.280
comp plan shouldn't be the draw of how you're getting people a- a- as far as that, as far as, you know, my perspective. Mm. Did I always want more money? Of course I did 'cause it would be easier for me to recruit.
232
00:33:28.340 --> 00:33:35.890
Did I wish I had a bigger budget? Yes. [laughs] But I'll tell you- Let me just hammer that point home is that the CHRO of LinkedIn [laughs] at the time, you know, and this...
233
00:33:35.940 --> 00:33:43.800
I had this conversation with someone the other day. No one ever has enough money, right? So it's like how can you use it, how can you emphasize it to get the, you know, the most mileage? Yeah. But yeah.
234
00:33:43.860 --> 00:33:46.700
It's- It's, it's a common thing, right? I'll tell you how we got our first bonus plan.
235
00:33:46.760 --> 00:33:58.310
We never had a bonus plan 'cause we weren't making money [laughs] that was producing enough surplus to give us a bonus really until a few years in. And so but everyone was leaving a bonus- Mm... right, to join us.
236
00:33:58.520 --> 00:34:05.750
So what we would do is say, "We're gonna give you a signing bonus because you're 50% through the year, so we're gonna give you 50% of whatever your bonus was." Yeah.
237
00:34:05.750 --> 00:34:08.750
"Assuming the target was gonna come in, you know, we're gonna give you the benefit of the doubt."
238
00:34:08.870 --> 00:34:15.390
And so we took a look back and said, "Oh my gosh, like 80% of our offers have a signing bonus, so we actually have a bonus plan." Mm.
239
00:34:15.400 --> 00:34:24.240
So I went to the CFO and I said, "Do you realize we're doing this with almost everyone? Like, we're just pushing this can down the road. We're gonna need to do this.
240
00:34:24.360 --> 00:34:32.620
So I can stop doing the signing bonuses, which is really hard for you to budget 'cause you don't know how many signing bonuses I'm gonna do, and that's uncomfortable on the cash hit." Mm.
241
00:34:32.730 --> 00:34:38.920
"Or we can be more predictable- Mm... and have, you know, a, a bonus plan." And that's, you know, after...
242
00:34:38.940 --> 00:34:47.810
You know, the words were a lot more colorful than what I'm explaining to you in the discussion with HR and finances. It usually is, but ultimately that was the, the ammunition that got me to- Mm...
243
00:34:47.820 --> 00:34:58.160
be able to put a bonus plan on the table. And
then also, you know, the retirement, like, the senior members of our board are like, "No, you don't need a 401[k] plan 'cause everyone's gonna get rich on the stock."
244
00:34:58.220 --> 00:35:07.280
I'm like, "No." I said, "Okay, well, let's model it out. Let's take a swath of, I don't know, 500 employees, and if we get this amount of share price, this is what it's gonna be worth to them.
245
00:35:07.319 --> 00:35:16.170
Is that meaningful that you think they can retire?" They go, "No." I was like, "That's right because we've been giving people less and less and less [laughs] and the share price growth is coming down as, a- Mm...
246
00:35:16.170 --> 00:35:27.420
as we become more mature." So, you know, just having those hard conversations as you, as you grow to try to put some kinda package together that's competitive in one of the most competitive markets there is. Yeah.
247
00:35:27.460 --> 00:35:44.130
And I think you're so speaking to something that has been such a critical, um, a- and growing skill set and necessary skill set within that HR people domain, which is this, you know, this data analysis capability, this ability to tell stories and to be data informed and to, and to give, uh,
248
00:35:45.100 --> 00:35:49.250
I guess, evidence to the decisions that you're trying to make and, and help kind of point in a direction. This is...
249
00:35:49.280 --> 00:35:54.620
It's so important, and I think, I mean, there's 1,000 different threads that I'd, I'd, I'd love to pull on in the conversation that we're having here.
250
00:35:54.700 --> 00:36:01.510
But another one that just seems to weave through everything you're talking about is just kind of this power of transparency in a lot of ways.
251
00:36:01.540 --> 00:36:07.910
And I know, you know, transparency's been such a dominant thing because of all the laws that are coming in and, and just the general appetite for it from an emerging workforce.
252
00:36:08.140 --> 00:36:16.780
But I think that so often people think pay transparency is and only is when you can see everybody else's salary, when actually there's, there's so much that precedes it.
253
00:36:16.820 --> 00:36:23.840
And actually just being able to be upfront about why we're trying to do the things we're doing, how we're landing on bonuses, how we're landing on buses or not buses.
254
00:36:23.880 --> 00:36:26.380
Like, just being able to work with an organization and, and to...
255
00:36:26.480 --> 00:36:33.020
with its people and speak about the types of problems that you're traversing, how you're trying to navigate them, you know, whether it's gonna work or not.
256
00:36:33.060 --> 00:36:45.596
Like, so much of that is a, a foundation for what, you know, pay transparency's trying to achieve. But it also just gives a lot ofFaith and trust from your team that actually you, you have their best interests at mind.
257
00:36:45.656 --> 00:36:53.006
It's not these decisions being made in a vacuum. It's not you trying to impose something on them. It's, it's, you know, we're all here to solve the same problem fundamentally. Here's how- Mm-hmm...
258
00:36:53.006 --> 00:36:58.736
we're trying to go about it, so let's work together in doing that, and, and here's what's on my mind, here's what's on your mind. How are we doing it?
259
00:36:58.756 --> 00:37:07.016
But I mean, pay transparency in and of itself could be its own podcast, but how do you, how do you... have you seen that thing change, that, that issue change in the time you've been- Yeah.
260
00:37:07.056 --> 00:37:20.396
The issue with pay transparency is it involves human beings. Mm. I was with a, a company that I'm advising, and they said, "We wanna publish everyone's salary." And I said, "Okay."
261
00:37:20.976 --> 00:37:31.276
And I said, "Let me ask you a couple of questions. Have you ever run into someone on your organization that thinks someone else should be making a lot more money?" Mm. They said, "Yeah, probably not."
262
00:37:31.285 --> 00:37:35.216
"Have you ever run into someone who thinks someone else should be making a lot less money?" "Oh, yeah, all the time."
263
00:37:35.556 --> 00:37:46.956
I said, "So the, the challenge with this gets to the root, uh, uh, cause of one of the biggest challenges that we face in, at work in general, which is assessment of performance is so subjective." Yeah.
264
00:37:47.816 --> 00:38:00.066
And not, you know, I'm gonna see someone in a department over there, and my interaction with them is gonna show me one dimension of them, and I'm not gonna like it, and so I'm gonna, you know, halo the rest of them as horrible and, and- Mm...
265
00:38:00.116 --> 00:38:01.656
not think that they're worthy, right?
266
00:38:02.236 --> 00:38:16.996
And that's, um, that's a, just the tip of the iceberg of what's challenging about pay transparency is that everyone has such a small view of what someone's fully contributing, and they may not be taking into consideration their prior history- Yeah...
267
00:38:17.366 --> 00:38:29.696
or, you know, various other elements of that, and it's a very, it's a very mature conversation which, not to say it's not worth going after, like I love the spirit of what transparency is going after, which is essentially if you break it down, it's really trust, right?
268
00:38:29.756 --> 00:38:41.536
Mm. That we are -- we believe that regardless of your age, your gender, your, you know, your background, that we're gonna treat you similarly if you have similar attributes. The problem is no one has similar attributes.
269
00:38:41.656 --> 00:38:51.336
Mm. Nobody, you know? And we're all different, and we're all unique, and we all think we're worth more, [laughs] you know, like always. So- That's the one constant, isn't it? [laughs] And that's, that's tricky.
270
00:38:51.436 --> 00:39:01.206
So, uh, you know, I haven't run into a lot of people who are getting specific about salary. I'm running into ones who are being transparent around this is the
range of these positions- Mm...
271
00:39:01.236 --> 00:39:09.966
and the why, and that's leading- Mm... to good conversations. And then they tell me, "But we're not being transparent about the equity we're giving people." I'm like, "Well then- Mm... are you really being transparent?
272
00:39:10.016 --> 00:39:16.786
Because to me, the equity's easier." Yeah. "Why aren't you doing the equity?" "Well, we haven't really thought it through yet," and, you know. And that, especially for younger stage companies,
273
00:39:18.256 --> 00:39:27.836
who is your competitor that you're benchmarking against? Are you doing someone in your space? Are they the same age, or do they have the same revenue? Do they have the same- Mm... international challenges that you do?
274
00:39:28.056 --> 00:39:36.716
Do they have the same investment? You know, like who are you putting yourself against? Because what we did all the time at LinkedIn to try to get more budget was we're like, "Look what Salesforce is doing."
275
00:39:36.976 --> 00:39:44.296
And the- Yeah. [laughs]... the, the board would laugh at us and go, [laughs] "They have like 100X revenue compared to you. Like that's not a comparator," you know?
276
00:39:44.816 --> 00:39:53.056
I'm like, "Yeah, but, you know, we wanna be like them, so shouldn't we pay like them if we wanna have people that are gonna get us to like them?" Like, and they're like, "Yeah, nice try," you know?
277
00:39:53.146 --> 00:39:57.836
[laughs] "Ni- nice try." But it is, it is really hard, and I think it's a worthy conversation to have.
278
00:39:58.016 --> 00:40:05.336
I don't think society in general is ready to, to, to swallow, you know, the full depth of, of what transparency is, and- Yeah...
279
00:40:05.356 --> 00:40:13.456
I've even, you know, in my HR team and when everyone knows what everyone else is making, there's still, you know, people who are, you know, elbowing each other and- Mm...
280
00:40:13.496 --> 00:40:21.306
throwing darts and trying to torpedo other people because they disagree with some of that stuff. Yeah. Um, so it's -- we got some, we got some work to do. I think
281
00:40:22.316 --> 00:40:29.136
it, it's, like I said, it's a, it's a worthy aspiration, but there's gotta be a lot of education that comes with that, you know? A lot.
282
00:40:30.356 --> 00:40:35.916
Yeah, and I often say that, you know, when I, when I speak to organizations that are thinking about this, it's not a case of just flipping a switch.
283
00:40:35.956 --> 00:40:52.336
There's a lot of work that needs to be done to get to a stage where pay transparency is going to have the impact that you want it to have versus just turning it on and thinking that it's magically gonna solve all of your problems because, you know, it's likely that a lot of people aren't paying consistent with what they think they should be, and there's, there's all these sorts of issues fundamentally.
284
00:40:52.416 --> 00:41:01.476
You know, if you're saying to people, "Here's, nominally, here's what the, the pay range is for your role," the natural question they're gonna ask is, "How did you land on this number?" You know, "Where did it come from?
285
00:41:01.496 --> 00:41:10.396
What's determining it? Who are we comparing ourselves to?" All these sorts of things. Mm-hmm. So if you haven't done that kind of groundwork, then I would say don't, you know, don't do pay transparency just yet.
286
00:41:10.496 --> 00:41:15.836
You know, think about getting those ducks in a row first because it's just going to create a lot of challenge for you. Yeah.
287
00:41:15.996 --> 00:41:24.036
I am seeing, by the way, some former HRCHROs start businesses almost becoming quasi agents for- Mm...
288
00:41:24.046 --> 00:41:30.805
professionals to help them get a fair shake and help them have a constructive conversation, help them, you know, seek fairness, and that's always my judgment.
289
00:41:30.876 --> 00:41:33.976
You know, like, if you're getting a number that doesn't make sense to you, you know...
290
00:41:34.036 --> 00:41:42.076
And I was just talking to this, uh, friend of mine the other day, like, go to management and say, "Hey, can you just help me understand how did you get that number?" Mm. Like, based on what?
291
00:41:42.516 --> 00:41:52.216
Because, you know, so he's a massage therapist for a professional sports team, but he also does acupuncture, but all the other people on his group don't do acupuncture. Ah.
292
00:41:52.296 --> 00:42:02.546
So he's being paid the same as everyone else, but the acupuncture is actually requires almost like a PhD. Like that's- Mm. And all the players that he's supporting want the acupuncture. Yeah. So he's like, "Hey."
293
00:42:02.996 --> 00:42:11.696
I'm like, "Yeah, you need to go say, 'Does this include my expertise with acupuncture?'" 'Cause I'm not sure it does. I'm not, I'm not saying that you're trying to screw me. I'm just trying to understand, right? Yeah.
294
00:42:12.976 --> 00:42:17.856
In tech, I'm seeing a similar concept. I think Levels.fyi is a, a company that I've seen that are almost...
295
00:42:17.876 --> 00:42:26.476
I'm seeing this as well, where it's like they kinda advocate for you and help you kinda navigate and, and negotiate salaries. I'm finding it ironically almost like, it's like a union, right?
296
00:42:26.576 --> 00:42:30.876
But for you as an individual rather than for a collective. But it's, it's such a fascinating concept.
297
00:42:30.896 --> 00:42:44.536
But I think it just speaks to this shift that's happening in the compensation space, which is that it's traditionally been something that has been hugely imbalanced from a power perspective towards the employer because they're the ones paying $20,000 for Radford Salary Data.
298
00:42:44.576 --> 00:42:49.376
They're paying for all these things. They're the ones that are informed around what we should be paying for a role.
299
00:42:49.436 --> 00:42:57.346
Whereas as an individual,
the only certainty you have is what you're being paid now, and then you kind of know what the people around you in your network are being paid. Mm.
300
00:42:57.396 --> 00:43:36.480
We're seeing this really big swing through, you know, these agents, through Levels, again, where, you know, they're having self-disclosed, um, salary ranges just ha- starting to swing this, you know, balance back towards individuals to have more and more confidence around what their value is, and it's, it's creating this really interesting dynamic that I think is really what's fueling a lot of the pay transparency, uh, you know, discussion at the moment.There's a lot that needs to be addressed, so let's, let's go to a, a very uncomfortable topic for a lot of organizations, which is the world of work and the architecture of compensation, let's just say, many pieces of the world of work are broken, and they weren't built for the level of fluidity that we're seeing in the workforce right now.
301
00:43:36.520 --> 00:43:45.120
So turnover's up, more and more people leaving jobs sooner than ever before. Nobody thinks it's gonna end, it's gonna reverse. Mm. And go, "Oh, yeah, people are gonna stay longer in the future." Nobody does.
302
00:43:45.180 --> 00:43:57.180
So best case scenario, we're gonna see a flat-lining, a plateauing of turnover. You know, right now, 25 to 35 in North America, it's two and a half years that you stay with an employer, median, okay? Mm.
303
00:43:57.740 --> 00:44:11.470
In Silicon Valley, like, 10 months is like two years. So if you think about this, one of the elements of compensation that's broken is that everyone knows that I can get a pay increase by going over there. Mm.
304
00:44:11.490 --> 00:44:21.840
But if I stay here, I won't get as much as if I go over there. Now, why is that? Well, we budget what our merit budget is every year as a company.
305
00:44:22.120 --> 00:44:32.760
So around review time, we're gonna go w- anywhere from zero to eight, 10%, whatever, cost of living, blah, blah, blah, and we're gonna adjust. But no company has a new hire budget. Mm.
306
00:44:32.900 --> 00:44:45.580
We have a target salary, but, you know, if we... We gotta do what we gotta do to get that person, right? And so there is no budget for that. That door is, you know, wide open for you to get more to go there.
307
00:44:45.760 --> 00:44:53.740
Now, you can't play that incessantly, right? You can't play that infinitely. You've got a few chances to make a move, and then someone's gonna go, "Bro, you know, you haven't added any value anywhere.
308
00:44:53.840 --> 00:44:55.810
You're just job hopping and popping up your salary." Yeah.
309
00:44:56.080 --> 00:45:04.620
But some companies who are desperate for talent are willing to take someone who's moved around quite a bit without being, you know, certain that that's the, that's the right investment.
310
00:45:05.240 --> 00:45:12.380
And that's, that's the craziness of a talent-constrained marketplace
right now, particularly for technology talent- Mm... is people are bidding it up.
311
00:45:12.900 --> 00:45:24.070
They're being really, you know, I think irresponsible, because they've got real compelling needs that they need to meet right now. And the architecture of how compensation is built was not to take into account- Mm...
312
00:45:24.120 --> 00:45:34.190
for this level of fluidity. And until you have a budget for that front door as well as what's in your house, we're gonna continue to see people doing that. Now, I'm, I'm not advocating for that. I'm just- No...
313
00:45:34.220 --> 00:45:43.140
calling it out, so. And I don't... Honestly, I don't have a solution for it. Mm. But I do know, 'cause I did it myself, I walked across the street in Silicon Valley and got a 50% pay increase one time. Yeah.
314
00:45:43.180 --> 00:45:51.340
And I was like, "Wow, that was awesome." You know, I'm the same person, you know? [laughs] It just goes to show that n- really [laughs] nobody knows what, what skills are worth really.
315
00:45:51.500 --> 00:46:00.620
It's touching on something that I think is only going to deepen though, right? Like, I mean, I, I've certainly noticed the continued sort of growth of this concept of fractional people doing...
316
00:46:00.680 --> 00:46:10.360
I mean, I'm a, I'm a- Mm... new consultant. You know, there are these people that are moving into these sorts of arrangements which only seeks to up the fluidity really of someone's work with multiple companies.
317
00:46:10.420 --> 00:46:17.790
How do you see that changing the comp dynamic? How do you think companies can manage that kind of arrangement when they're so used to just having an annualized- [laughs]... figure?
318
00:46:17.800 --> 00:46:27.220
Well, if the, you know, not budgeting for new hires is exhibit A, exhibit B is most financial plans are built around full-time exempt employees. Mm.
319
00:46:27.400 --> 00:46:34.269
This is my financial model, and most investors who are looking for if I'm gonna invest in the plan is, how many people do you need? Mm.
320
00:46:34.280 --> 00:46:42.580
Now, I think that's br- increasingly broken because more and more organizations are using, you know, design houses, design shops, or they're using contractors.
321
00:46:42.600 --> 00:46:51.660
And, and, you know, in your neighborhood, what we are hearing is Canva is offering senior technical talent two offers, and they're saying- Mm... "Here's to be a contractor. Here's to be an employee.
322
00:46:51.700 --> 00:47:00.290
We don't know what you want to do." Oh, interesting. "We just want you adding value here." Mm. Now, for an intellectual property lawyer, that's a nightmare come true. Yeah.
323
00:47:00.300 --> 00:47:10.860
Like, because I want you to be fully beholden to me, and anything you think about, I own. You know? And but I, I think that's gonna limit the, you know, your pool of high-quality people.
324
00:47:10.920 --> 00:47:20.040
Just like I love how Brian Chesky, the CEO of Airbnb, said, "How can any company be so naive to think that the best people for that company are the only ones that live within a 30-minute commute?"
325
00:47:20.340 --> 00:47:26.840
Like, how is that possible? Like, you're gonna have to have remote people, and that's... Over my career, that's how I got into India most of the time.
326
00:47:26.940 --> 00:47:35.580
Someone was amazing who's from India, their parents are sick, and they're like, "I gotta quit, 'cause I gotta go take care of my family." I'm like, "No, you don't. We'll build you an office around you. Is that okay?"
327
00:47:35.610 --> 00:47:39.619
And they're like, "Yeah, great." "Okay, we've got an office in Delhi or Bangalore or wherever."
328
00:47:39.780 --> 00:47:48.040
Um, and so I, I think that's part of the, part of the challenge is, and you bring up a really good point, that we gonna need to evolve the model- Mm...
329
00:47:48.629 --> 00:47:57.250
to, you know, pay for value, not for someone fully being dedicated to us. And that, you know, that's gonna get us, I think, in a better place. But I- Mm...
330
00:47:57.310 --> 00:48:00.760
I do believe, okay, here's, here's another thing that the pandemic forced.
331
00:48:00.960 --> 00:48:18.340
I don't have the data to back this up, but all my instinct and all my circumstantial data to me leads me to believe that most companies, when they're uncertain about the future, don't wanna have a lot of regular hires and wanna have a lot of contingent people, and they wanna be able to flip them to full-time, uh, if I seem to have a lot of confidence in the future of the company.
332
00:48:18.400 --> 00:48:25.690
But when we're in a pandemic, my supply chain's messed up, my customers are behaving differently, I don't know, you know, I don't know that I wanna carry that. Mm.
333
00:48:25.720 --> 00:48:33.440
Look what's happened to a lot of technology companies in the last year and a half post-pandemic. Massive reduction in the extra talent that they were carrying- Yeah...
334
00:48:33.510 --> 00:48:41.840
which they always were carrying for, like, hey, if there's a new market, we got people, we can attack it fast. Now, you know, we're not seeing the appetite to do that.
335
00:48:41.980 --> 00:48:54.400
So, you know, I, I believe most companies have a bigger proportion of their value creation people that are not employees than any time in history right now. Mm-hmm. And they don't...
336
00:48:54.420 --> 00:49:00.580
People don't report that, and it's not... Like, the government agent, when they talk about employment and unemployment, they're not talking about people in that category. Mm.
337
00:49:00.660 --> 00:49:10.550
So it's a really hard one to measure, you know, the whole gig workforce, if you will. Plus, the increasing number of people that are believed to have multiple employers. So it's going to put pressure- Mm...
338
00:49:10.550 --> 00:49:21.140
on this system, right? So I was talking to an Uber driver
yesterday. He's like, "Yeah, I'm stopping doing this. I've been doing it for seven years." He goes, "And I've gotten five stars, and my, my income's going down."
339
00:49:21.180 --> 00:49:28.636
Mm. "They're, they're cutting into my income. It's going down."And I said, "Well, why are, why are you making the move? You know, in addition to obviously lower income?"
340
00:49:28.656 --> 00:49:36.776
He goes, "Yeah, but I need health insurance, I need stability, and I need... You know, can't put, put in all these, you know, ten to twelve hours a day to make two hundred dollars." Mm.
341
00:49:36.786 --> 00:49:41.756
He goes, "And that's before I pay for my gas." Yeah. I was like, "Whoa," you know. That's so...
342
00:49:41.796 --> 00:49:50.276
You're gonna see, you know, the companies that are really relying on the gig workers like that, whether it's a DoorDash, Instacart, you know, Uber, Lyft, I think they're gonna have a reckoning.
343
00:49:50.456 --> 00:49:58.976
You know, but, you know, a lot of those companies- Mm... are playing on the driverless cars as their future, [laughs] right? So it's a different, uh, that's a different conversation. Yeah, I agree.
344
00:49:59.016 --> 00:50:08.936
I think the, the headline for me is, like, comp is already such an interesting space because of pay transparency, because of, you know, emerging dynamics around technology, because of also, you know, globalization, all sorts of things.
345
00:50:09.016 --> 00:50:21.816
But maybe the next frontier, and actually it's, it's still a watch this space, is, you know, gig economy and how a company's going to, to challenge that with an ever, you know, more gigifying workforce and, and so on.
346
00:50:21.986 --> 00:50:31.596
So maybe you and I will have to get together a- again in 12 months' time and talk about how that's, uh, how that's evolved. Yeah. Yeah. Super interesting topic, right? It is. Yeah. It really is.
347
00:50:31.936 --> 00:50:43.436
Steve, thank you so much for your time. I really appreciate it. This, um, has been, you know, as interesting and, and, uh, topical as I had hoped. So thank you so much for, for spending this time with us today.
348
00:50:43.876 --> 00:50:53.656
Thanks, Matt, and thanks for what you're doing too, which is shining a light on something that doesn't get enough light and doesn't get enough, uh, attention. So as you mentioned, I think you're onto something here.
349
00:50:53.696 --> 00:51:00.676
It's, uh, it's a conversation worthy of having. So thanks for leading the charge. Thanks for joining us on another edition of the Foundation Series.
350
00:51:00.686 --> 00:51:07.446
[upbeat music] Make sure to head over to our website to subscribe to the Foundation Series for monthly editions featuring future interviews on startup compensation.
351
00:51:08.416 --> 00:51:13.676
In each edition, we'll explore the different strategies, trends, and challenges faced by startups around the world.
352
00:51:14.536 --> 00:51:23.836
If you have a burning topic you'd like me to cover or a standout guest that you wanna hear from, drop me an email so I can dive deeper into the compensation topics that matter most to you.
353
00:51:23.876 --> 00:51:30.876
Join me next time as we continue to uncover the strategies and practices driving success in global tech startups around the world. Thanks for listening.
354
00:51:33.076 --> 00:51:42.696
[outro music]