TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Hello, friends, and welcome into Fantasy Pros. This is the Week 11 Running Back Ranks episode. I am Chris Welsh. That is Pat Fitzmaurice and the great and powerful Andrew Erickson, the Undertaker, the Prop Master, as we are calling him around these streets. We are going to be going through the top 36 running backs for this episode. Tiers, the plays, the kind of craziness. It's a little bit of a bipocalypse, if you will. There are six teams on by, so the ranks look kind of crazy. And obviously, your fantasy playoffs are right around the corner. But we have got you covered with those 36 and a few other deeper names as we step into week 11 and the chaos of next week with a holiday weekend and early rank show. And just it's the craziness and the chaos feels really good, boys.
00:00:44
Speaker 2: Mr.
00:00:44
Speaker 1: Pat Fitzmaurice, how are we doing?
00:00:46
Speaker 3: Doing well, Welsh, except trying to do waivers this week was a nightmare because it seemed like every team I had had four or five open lineup spots, some of which I didn't have the bench players in.
00:00:58
Speaker 4: To fill it with.
00:00:59
Speaker 3: It's going to be a really hard week to fill out lineups this week, and I would not be surprised if we saw some people win games with scores of like 53.
00:01:06
Speaker 1: Hey, Laquan Treadwell not looking so bad now, boys, is it? Laquan Treadwell might be in some lineups this week, Erickson. You going to put him in?
00:01:14
Speaker 2: I checked one of my dynasty teams, and my two starting quarterbacks are Jordan Love and Michael Penix. So I'm taking a zero. Because it's not super flexes. You've got to start quarterbacks. So I have no idea. I'm actually starting Justin Fields this week. Because I have to start a quarterback.
00:01:30
Speaker 1: Well, you'll get one play.
00:01:31
Speaker 2: You'll probably get.
00:01:32
Speaker 1: One play of a run.
00:01:33
Speaker 2: If they're smoking the Arizona Cardinals, he might get some action.
00:01:37
Speaker 1: We'll have to see. All right, let's get into the action of this episode. Before we get into any of it and we get into the ranks, we do like to talk about the accuracy contest, as we do. We celebrate the top three, and then we can get some shout-outs and boys. There's some shout-outs this week that we're going to be rolling with. But the top three, let's focus on them for a second. Coming in with the most accurate rank from Week 10, Points Over Expected's Mike Bland. Congratulations, Mike, with the number one spot. Coming in at two, Hayden Winks from Yahoo. Hayden's awesome, and that's a great rank. And Lucas Wenzel, who we all know around these parts from Fantasy Football Fellas, with the top three spot. Mike Bland, Hayden Winks, and Lucas Wenzel, top three most accurate rankers. Those dudes rocked it out. There's a couple others. A couple fantasy pro shoutouts, guys. Kelly Kirby does it again with a top 10 finish, finishing 8th overall. Dang, Kelly. I think
Load full transcript
Kelly was 8th at RB, if I remember correctly, when I was looking positionally. So Kelly did really good. Boys, not to toot some horns here, but your boy finally got a top 25 finish. You know, we don't need to go nuts, but 22. It's my number, birth date as well. Finishing 22 overall. It wasn't spectacular in any great spot, but I think it was just the balance. So I'm pretty happy about that, finishing with my highest spot of the year. And right behind me, Mr. Pat Fitzmaurice with a top 30 finish, finishing 30. So a couple top 30 finishes. Erickson was so good. We're just going to save it for another time to talk about his rank there. But I finally got one, boys. So I get to be better than you for just one week. And of course, it's in the past. So I don't know what celebration is there. But Fitzy, any thoughts on the top 30 finish? Feeling good?
00:03:19
Speaker 4: Atta boy, Welsh. Good job.
00:03:20
Speaker 1: Thank you.
00:03:21
Speaker 4: Good job, Kelly. Kelly's had some awesome weeks this year.
00:03:25
Speaker 1: Good job, Erickson. I feel left out.
00:03:27
Speaker 4: I feel bad.
00:03:29
Speaker 2: I think of the props again, so that's all I care about.
00:03:31
Speaker 1: Yeah, I don't feel that bad because this dude over here is 13-1 over three weeks of doing a show. on our prop show that we do the most insane prop run I have seen ever, ever. And it's why not? Like one week was good. It was five and oh, and then four and oh, and then this week it was four and one. Absolutely ridiculous. So the prop master over there, I'll take a top 25 finish. Fitzy taking that top 30 finish. We did pretty good. So hopefully we can roll that over into this week because, as mentioned, this week is chaos. All of those bye weeks are going to make it blah. Before we jump in, if you guys want to follow along with us, fantasypros.com slash NFL slash rankings. That's fantasypros.com slash NFL slash rankings. That is what we're going to be going off of half PPR. Just know that they're going to change. As more rankers submit their ranks, you're going to see alterations even from the first iteration of the sheet we do till right before we record. These are big changes, you know, because when it's a lower amount of rankers, things are going to start to go. So this is just a time capsule as we talk through the ranks. And let's look at the big board for the top 12 at RB this week. We've got Jameer Gibbs at the top spot versus Tampa. James Cook at two, Christian McCaffrey at three, Chip Hubbard at four, Javante Williams, and Bayshel Tootin. That's your top six. Seven through 12, Jalen Warren, DeAndre Swift, Derrick Henry, Tony Pollard, Chase Brown, and Bucky Irving. After a 10-carry for 10-yard performance, should we be a little bit more concerned about Derrick Henry? He comes in with a nine spot. It's a great matchup. Maybe you could play a world where Jacoby Brissett's high volume of passes is going to lead to them being able to set up the run more. He was just. Derrick Henry was so inefficient last week. He loved the touchdowns. It saved everything. But 10 for 10. does not leave inspiring minds excited. He did get involved in the passing game a little bit. ECR running back, actually number nine on this list. You guys are not as inspired either. You both have him lower. Fitzy, you got him at 12, but Erickson, not an RB1 for you this week. So Erickson, why don't you start us off here? Derrick Henry, 14th among running backs for you. Probably not sitting him, but you definitely are not enthused.
00:05:43
Speaker 2: Not enthused because Derrick Henry has not been his usual self this season. He's actually averaging career low 3.8 yards per carry, negative 0.16 EPA per carry among qualified running backs. Henry ranks bottom 10 in yards after contact per attempt. So he is starting to show the signs of decline for a 32-year-old running back that is running behind a bad offensive line that had another injury. One of their star offensive guards, Figo Juane, he got hurt on Monday Night Football against the Los Angeles Chargers. So you're really just hoping that Derrick Henry finds the end zone.
00:06:17
Speaker 3: Good.
00:06:18
Speaker 2: Scored twice against LA. They're facing the Carolina Panthers this week. So you figure that's a good matchup. But what if they're trailing in this game, right? Like that's totally in the cards here because this Ravens defense has also not played well this season. So I'm concerned about the game when it comes to Derrick Henry. I'm concerned about the lack of efficiency, which again, Jacoby Brissett boosts volume. That's not the issue with Derrick Henry. Derrick Henry always gets volume. That's been the case for him all year long. It's been the lack of efficiency. He's so touchdown dependent. And I feel like fantasy majors got bailed out, right? Where a guy has 10 rushing yards and he scores two touchdowns. Again, it's Carolina, but we saw a couple of weeks ago, right? How did Green Bay do against the Carolina Panthers run defense? They couldn't run the ball. And The Baltimore Ravens have not been able to really run the ball effectively at all this season, especially with all of the carousel at the quarterback position. So Jacoby Brissett is helping the receivers with all this passing volume, not helping Derek Henry nearly as much. Again, five-game streak of fewer than 60 rushing yards after never failing to do that in two consecutive games in any season. from 2019 to 2024. It's not quite D Hember yet. So, uh, yeah, he's going to be outside of the top 12 for me.
00:07:26
Speaker 1: Have you also ever seen somebody that catches a ball and just is so odd? He's like an alien. Like you ever see those videos of like alien walking on, like he catches the ball and then he just falls down. Like he's such a hard person to tackle and, He's so dominant, but man, when that ball goes in the air and he catches it, cause he got like five, every single one of them was like, he catches it and he
just falls down and you could just blow a little bit of wind and he would fall over. You'd love to be, tell a story that the passing came to be more involved. I don't know why Derek Henry is just so awkward about it, but, um, Fitz, you got him at 12. So you haven't bumped him outside of the RB one again, where We're picking hairs here. We're thinning the line of what running backs, what matter when they're RB1s to high-end RB2s. The bye weeks stink. We're going to be playing them, but there's confidence levels a little bit lower than what the majority of the rankers have on him right now.
00:08:12
Speaker 3: Yeah, and I feel like Erickson might have it right having Henry outside of RB1 range.
00:08:18
Speaker 4: Look, father time comes for us all. Came for me a long time ago.
00:08:21
Speaker 3: I've been washed for years, but Yeah, Erickson mentioned Henry averages 3.8 yards per carry this season. He had that huge game against the Colts and their terrible run defense in Week 1. Since then, 3.4 yards per carry. And in Henry's defense, the Baltimore run blocking was just abysmal in that game. Like, their infrastructure is just crumbling.
00:08:44
Speaker 4: And obviously.
00:08:46
Speaker 3: the Derrick Henry experience of 2026 would be a lot more fulfilling if Lamar Jackson were playing. That pairing had been really magical in 2024 and 2025. But I know this dude's coming up on 33 years old. He's at or near the age cliff for running backs. I think we'll still get a few good games from Henry down the stretch and maybe he has one against the Panthers. They are giving up the third most fantasy points per game to running backs. Although Some of the metrics suggest that their run defense really isn't that bad. The Panthers are 12th in DVOA against their run, 14th in EPA per rush allowed. So not super enthusiastic about Henry this week.
00:09:22
Speaker 1: You guys have a gap between this running back and not to go back to let you guys start each different one, but I'm going to go back to Erickson on this because Erickson, you were kind of the difference or the high man on it. But Bucky Irving comes in at 12 on this list. This is one of those where Fitz, you've kind of pushed him out. Again, you're not that far off from ECR. You have him as the number one RB1 at 13 when he's 12. But Erickson, you have pushed him up to RB7 this week. That's a spot that Jalen Warren has on ECR. So you are five spots higher than ECR, six spots higher than where Fitz he's got. So talk to us about Bucky Irving this week for you.
00:09:56
Speaker 2: He's averaged at least 20 touches in five straight games. Longest average. streak in the NFL. So it's bell cow, Bucky Irving coming off a bye week. So I'm expecting even with Jalen Daniels as the presumed starter for the Buccaneers, it's just going to be more of loading up Bucky Irving with as many touches as he can handle. So even though his points per game has fallen off with Jalen Daniels compared to Baker Mayfield, 14.1 points
per game and half PPR in the games with Daniels, three games started, and then 17.6 with Baker Mayfield. So that's something that you do need to consider. The targets and touchdowns have fallen off a little bit when Daniels has been on your center, which is kind of be expected. Daniels is a more mobile quarterback. So he throws to Bucky Irving less than Baker Mayfield does. And obviously the offensive output overall is going to fall off a little bit when you have a backup quarterback. That being said, like who is left on this line of defense? Like they just lost eight Hutchinson now. And what's the game plan going to be? It's, We need to keep the Lions offense off the field at all costs. So we're going to run, run, run, run, run with Bucky Irving as many times as possible. And he has just been out of this world productive this season. So Kenny Gainwell kind of samples here and there. I know that the coaches have talked to him about trying to get him more involved because Bucky, they don't want to wear him out because they are in a division winning kind of chase here to try to come away with the NFC South crown. But they got to win these games. And the best formula that has worked for them is just to run the crap out of the football with Bucky Irving, who has been their best offensive player by far this season. So that's why I have him at RB7.
00:11:22
Speaker 1: Fitzy, anything to kind of add or share? We're not going to pick on you being down as an RB2. You're just right there with it. But you don't share maybe some of the like offensive upside that he could be a top 10 guy this week. It's a good point on the Lions defense, even being a little bit more shattered, but where are you at on Bucky Irving?
00:11:38
Speaker 3: So I'm the official Bucky Irving bandwagon driver. And if I'm below consensus on him, there's probably a good reason for that. Um, I'm not sure how to handle the defensive matchup on this. Cause Erickson, like you mentioned, I mean, no Aiden Hutchinson, no Jack Campbell. Uh, although the, the Lions run defense has been really good for like the last five or six weeks, but, um, I don't know if it's a tough matchup anymore. I'm looking at it from the Jalen Daniels perspective. That's kind of my angle on this. Bucky's fantasy finishes in half-point PPR scoring in the three weeks where Jalen Daniels was starting for Baker Mayfield when Baker Mayfield had that broken thumb.
00:12:17
Speaker 4: RB40, RB3, and RB32. The RB3 day was against the Cowboys. Surprise, surprise.
00:12:26
Speaker 3: 165 rushing yards, a touchdown run, and a touchdown catch. But in the other two games, 61 yards from scrimmage against the Packers, 49 yards from scrimmage against the Steelers. He didn't have a touchdown in either of those games. I do think Erickson makes a really good point about the Buccaneers probably trying to be really run heavy this week and just keep that Lions offense off the field. And We probably do see Kenny Gainwell get more work than usual because of that.
00:12:54
Speaker 4: I'm just a little.
00:12:55
Speaker 3: Worried that the ceiling is lowered for Bucky with Jalen Daniels at quarterback.
00:12:59
Speaker 1: I do think there's like an interesting battle you two have of like Fitzy gets Derrick Henry versus Erickson's Bucky Irving because you guys have them. You know, Fitzy's higher on Derrick Henry than Bucky, and obviously Bucky is Erickson's guy. Kind of just an interesting split, but again, you're going to be starting these guys. This is just what RB1s are going to look like. Not much question as far as what your starts are going to look like. RB2s are going to be a little bit different here, so let's jump into those. But before we do, I want to talk to you guys about Polymarket. Basketball season is here, and there's a new way to trade on it, and it's called Polymarket. Polymarket is a prediction market. You can see it as a stock exchange for sports, buying in and selling out on your terms. They're so confident you'll never go back to the other guys that are giving you a free $ 25 on your first trade when you deposit just $ 10. Every bucket, every block, every matchup in basketball trades on Polymarket. So download the Polymarket app today and use code FPPOD when you sign up. That's FPPOD to get $ 25 free after you deposit just $ 10. All right, boys, let's talk about this secondary board here. This is the RB2s. And we've got Jonah Coleman coming in at the top spot at 13th overall. I think his highest rank of the year. Emmitt Johnson at 14. That's obviously going to be a big part of our conversation. Jonathan Taylor, Brees Hall, Cam Scadaboo, Ollie Gordon. The back half looks like Ashton Gentry at 19. Saquon Barkley, Omerian Hampton at 21. David Montgomery, Kamananga, and Aaron Jones. You can see where it falls off. You can like, this is the board where you're like, oh, look, look, and it's gone. Look over the edge and be careful. Let's talk about the Emma Johnson situation. This is going to be paired with Ken Walker. We kind of thought last week when they told us, shame on us for believing anything, that it would just be one week with Ken Walker. And now there's conversation that they're like, nah. maybe two, maybe, you know, they're not going to rush it. I think if it's just like a playoff situation, he'd be playing, but you know, they're, they're kind of dangling out that, you know, they might not push this out. So that's why you're seeing Emmett Johnson in the top spot. Ken Walker actually shows up in the next range, but that's like a hedge ranking. ECR 14th overall. You guys are very split on this and we're going to have to figure this out. Fitzy, you've got him at 22 and Erickson has him at five. So, Very, very split on this. It's Cardinals matchup, which looks great, even though it's not star graded out very well. This is a fine matchup receiving and rushing side. So, Fitzy, let's start with you. Is your 22... Like, what is your 22 about? Is that what Ken Walker
is going to play? Is it a hedge rank? Because I find it hard to believe you would rank him 22 if Ken Walker was out.
00:15:39
Speaker 4: Correct.
00:15:40
Speaker 3: I tentatively have Kenneth Walker playing. So, which might not be.
00:15:45
Speaker 4: I just.
00:15:46
Speaker 3: tend to err on the side of assuming guys are going to play, and then I can always take them out a little later. But if Walker's out again, I'm going to rank Emmitt Johnson either RB3 or RB4. And the question is whether I rank him ahead of or behind Christian McCaffrey, who is that matchup against the Vikings. That's it, because, man, if Walker sits again, you've got the Chiefs as home 16.5-point favorites against the hapless Arizona Cardinals. Emmitt Johnson coming off a game in which he had 28 touches, 22 carries, 101 rushing yards, six catches, 70 receiving yards, two TD catches.
00:16:27
Speaker 4: Yeah, it's an amazing spot for him.
00:16:30
Speaker 3: And I know there are a couple leagues where I've got Emmitt Johnson and do not have Kenneth Walker. And I'm hoping that the Chiefs take the cautious approach with Kenneth Walker yet again.
00:16:38
Speaker 1: So you're, you're 22 is if Ken Walker is active, you think, you think.
00:16:44
Speaker 4: Standalone value.
00:16:45
Speaker 2: Absolutely.
00:16:45
Speaker 1: Standalone Emmett. Yeah. That's what I was trying to say. Standalone value is 22 with an active Ken Walker.
00:16:51
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:16:51
Speaker 3: And I've, I've got Ken Walker ranked kind of conservatively at RB seven thinking that even if he does play, they're not going to beat him into the ground with 25 touches against the Cardinals. They're going to have Emmett Johnson help out even if he does play. So I think it's, Either way, I think Emmitt Johnson is very playable this week. But obviously, if you have Emmitt Johnson, you want to see him getting. And if you have both guys, I think you'd almost rather prefer that Kenneth Walker sits this week. So you just have that one guy and there's no ambiguity about who's getting the touches.
00:17:24
Speaker 1: I have a tough spot. I got a really important league that I've got Ken Walker in that I need. And then I've got another league where I have Emmitt Johnson. And I really just like we're dominating that league. I just don't. even need him to roll out there. So I'm kind of voting for Ken Walker. Erickson, clearly your rank, excuse me, is based around Ken Walker not being active and you saying Emma Johnson is going to be a top five running back if he's given the opportunity, because that's where you have him at.
00:17:50
Speaker 2: Yes. And I agree with all the points that Fitz made about if we do see both running backs that I think that Emma Johnson, again, the RB3 tier is really gross, right? So I would just kind of put Emma Johnson right at the top and be like, He's facing the Arizona Cardinals. No reason to run Ken Walker into the ground. I don't think Ken Walker's going to play. I think we got a report that suggested that early on this week that he is not going to play. Just look at the schedule, right? They're facing the Arizona Cardinals as massive home favorites, and then they have at Buffalo, at the Rams, at the Bengals. Those are the games the Chiefs actually need Ken Walker to play in to win for playoff seeding, etc. Whereas, dude, they don't need him to beat the Cardinals, even if they... maybe they don't cover the 16 and a half points, but I mean, nothing about the Cardinals offense last week suggests that they can even score 16 points. So I think they sit Ken Walker for another week, make sure that he is 120% recovered from this growing injury, especially with how well Johnson played. Again, he had 93.5% of the opportunities, 29 out of 31 backfield opportunities went to Emma Johnson. And like he's looked all year. Absolutely fantastic. Why this guy fell to what the fifth round just, blows my freaking mind that the Chiefs were able to get this guy so late. With so many teams that need running backs, how fun would it have been if the Vikings had just drafted Emma Johnson? Like I said, no, like we got to roll with Jordan Mason and Aaron Jones and Demon Claiborne. Well, they could have just drafted Emma Johnson and they would have had a sick running game to go along with now Kirk Cousins.
00:19:17
Speaker 1: And so, yeah, but I mean, you can make similar arguments to be like, man, wouldn't it be cool if the Cardinals had Emma Johnson and not Jeremiah Love? I mean, from a talent perspective, you don't want to play that, but I get what you're saying with with Emma Johnson there. Yeah, it's a really interesting spot, too, because I think a lot of the reports out there were saying they would be surprised that If Ken Walker played, I did see a report too that said like at least this week, which is kind of disastrous. But at the end of the day, as long as you're not like in a dogfight for a playoff spot, the best thing that could happen for Ken Walker owners is for him to retire. 100% fully healed. That is for the fantasy playoffs. You don't want there to be some weird situation where they're babying him in the playoffs because of this, but I guess you kind of overall kind of do hate to see it. Going to the next RB, Jonathan Taylor, ECR 15. Fitzy got him at 14. Erickson, you've got him at 17. We kind of set the stage for this last week in that they were going to use them 1A, 1B.
00:20:15
Speaker 2: They did.
00:20:16
Speaker 1: Jonathan Taylor actually got some good usage, but Seth McGowan is just not going to go away. That is becoming clear. And I think your ranks are kind of telling this story now. Erickson, you've got him at 17. You're lower than Fitz. You're lower than ECR. You and I have talked about this on a couple shows that are coming up about maybe moving off of Jonathan Taylor. as time goes on, but this last game, I think created some hope for people. Where are you at being lower on ECR and Jonathan Taylor this week going up
against, I believe it was the Houston Texans. Is that correct here that yeah, against Houston.
00:20:48
Speaker 2: Yeah. Playing on Thursday night. So this is the early game for week 11. I think the matchup is significantly tougher though, against the Houston Texans defense on the road, instead of playing at home against the Miami dolphins, where the Colts were able to keep that game competitive. They are massive underdogs on the road here against this Texans defense. And I don't trust anything with this Colts offense if Daniel Jones is the quarterback. He's playing so bad that his numbers look like Curtis Painter from the Indianapolis Colts days in the aforementioned or the infamous tank for Andrew Luck season where Curtis Painter basically looked like he'd never played quarterback when Peyton Manning was injured. That's what we're dealing with the quarterback with Daniel Jones at the head of this offense. So the coaches have been very vocal about this is not a bell cow usage for JT anymore. This is a one-two punch. Taylor, over the last four games, he's RB20 in expected fantasy points per game. So just kind of capturing his usage in terms of his snaps are below 70%. And all of those games, his opportunities in the last four games, 21, 13, 18, 20. So, yeah, he's still in the fantasy RB2 conversation, but it's a really bad matchup. It's a matchup we already saw this year where he finished the game against the Houston Texans. He had 23 carries for 68 yards. He was the RB28 on the week, and that was when he was getting all the touches. If he had 23 carries in this game again, that would be the most carries he's had or opportunities he's had since then. Before Seth McGowan became a bigger part of this backfield. So I just don't think this is a ceiling play for Jonathan Taylor. Again, he averaged three point yard, three yards per carry against the Texas in week three point eight yards per carry becoming before contact two point six yards after contact per carry for JT this year. the fewest in any season of his career. So he's actually not creating that many yards after contact. Two of the starting tackles for the Colts look like they're going to probably miss this game. They already don't have Quinton Nelson. So the offensive line is missing three of the guys they had the last time they faced the Houston Texans, who are coming off a brutal loss to the Cleveland Browns. And I feel like, to me, that they're going to take it out on the Indianapolis Colts offense, which just, to me, is tough sledding for JT, where you don't even have the volume to to kind of fall back on. So you need him to score a touchdown and he's not even the goal line back every single time. Both him and Seth McGowan both see red zone opportunities. So I am very squirrely on JT as a fringe, like fantasy RB1, which is why I have him at 17.
00:23:09
Speaker 1: So, I mean, a lot of negative stuff built around him. He's 15, 50 or one spot higher than UCR. What I'm curious about is like,
there has been a lot of negative. I think there's a lot of unknown negative that we talked about last week. For you to put him at 14, do you feel at all like a little bit more optimistic regardless of those things that Erickson was just saying in that like they didn't just sit him on the bench and they didn't just say you're done. Like he still got volume of carries. And is that why he could still deservedly or should deservedly be like a top 15 RB? Or should we be more cautious where, you know, not many people are going to have options of being like, oh, I can sit the 15th overall running back. But like, you know, 10-man leagues, maybe there is an option out there. Where are you at on Jonathan Taylor?
00:23:48
Speaker 3: It's so sad that it's a 16 bye week and a healthy Jonathan Taylor has an ECR of RB15.
00:23:54
Speaker 4: That is just depressing.
00:23:57
Speaker 3: And I guess I'm encouraged that he did have 103 scrimmage yards against the Dolphins last week. I guess I see this new arrangement with Taylor and Seth McGowan as being sort of like the early season deployment of Kyron Williams and Blake Corham for the Rams. So last week it was 40 snaps for Jonathan Taylor, 17 for McGowan, which is kind of how it was early in the season or last year with the Rams, where Kyron gets about two-thirds of the snaps, Corum about one-third. But Corum gets a high percentage of touches, a carry or a target, like on more than half his snaps. That's what we saw last week with McGowan. He got carries on 12 of his 17 snaps and finished with 77 rushing yards. So, yeah, I mean, it's like I'm not. leaning on history for this because Jonathan Taylor has historically destroyed the Houston Texans. He's averaged 104 rushing yards per game in 10 career games against them.
00:24:56
Speaker 4: 11 career games, sorry.
00:24:57
Speaker 3: 10 touchdowns in 11 career games against the Texans. But then again, he has had a much better supporting cast in past meetings with Houston than he will have this time.
00:25:07
Speaker 4: So yeah, it's just Jonathan Taylor being really good.
00:25:13
Speaker 3: As bleak as the situation is, I find it hard to move him much past RB14.
00:25:20
Speaker 1: Bleak is a fun word. To the next running back in the offense built around Philadelphia Eagles, Saquon Barkley comes in at ECR 20. And it has been kind of bleak in what the production looks like and the quarterback play. And just overall, there's actually a really interesting rank in here, but we're not going to start with that one because of the sentiment from one person here. But Fitzy, you got him at 21. You got him around ECR. Have we, I mean, the matchup stinky against Pittsburgh, but like, have we lost all hope that Saquon Barkley is even a trustworthy fantasy option, especially as we're getting into these, this, you know, like week 12, week 13, as we're moving into like a fantasy playoff run here. running back 20 starts to dictate a player that is not necessarily going to be played
every single week. This is really where we've gotten to with Saquon Barkley.
00:26:07
Speaker 3: He's averaged two yards per carry over his last two games. And that is a reflection of how bad the Eagles offensive line has become this year. And now Barkley gets a matchup against the Steelers. Pittsburgh's been sort of a neutral matchup in terms of fantasy points allowed to running backs. But that's mostly been about the Steelers giving a passing game production to running backs. They've given up 70 rushing yards per game and 3.6 yards per carry to running backs this season. But the Steelers have given up a league-high 58 catches and 439 receiving yards to running backs. So a pass-catching running back can maybe do some damage against Pittsburgh. That's not really Saquon. He's got seven receptions in seven games this season. So, yeah, I mean, I think you need a touchdown to get any sort of satisfying result from Saquon this week.
00:26:58
Speaker 1: Well, Erickson, we've continuously talked kind of negative about Saquon Barkley. So I was a little surprised to see you have him at 16. You've got him four spots higher than consensus going up against Pittsburgh here. So is there a positive case or did the, you know, did that just fall this way and you're just kind of like, ooh, what happened?
00:27:18
Speaker 2: I think this is probably the healthiest you're going to get Saquon Barkley ever this season. Coming off of the bye week, he's been dealing with his hamstring injury, which is why he's only had two games played with over 70% of the snaps in six games total played. So that's really my angle on it is that you just get a Saquon Barkley that's not hampered by a hamstring injury that he's constantly thinking about. So that's why I'm just a little bit higher than ECR. I think that he's going to see the bell cow workload. I also think that the Eagles are going to get back their starting wide receivers. So kind of just opening things up a little bit more for the run game with Devonta Smith, with Dontavion Wicks. And I do think that Joe Milton, as the starting quarterback with his mobility, does kind of open things up a little bit for Saquon as well, just because you don't have a statue back there anymore like he had with Tanner McKee. So that's another angle that I'm looking at when it comes to Saquon. So This isn't all this. I mean, technically, this actually could be his best finish of the year because he has zero top 20 finishes. And just the fact there are six teams on by. I think that this is a week he actually could finish as a top 20 running back because that's where he has an ECR.
00:28:20
Speaker 1: It's just brutal that it's on the heels of the trade fantasy trade deadlines, because like just as a little promotion, Erickson and I did. I was on the like the trade buy sell shows, but we also did a special show. completely dedicated to the fantasy playoffs. It was funny. Erickson sent me a message. Didn't you get, when you get like DMS from someone like message you like, you know, it'd be really cool. It'd be like a show about the playoffs. And you were just like, Hmm, funny, funny. You say that we did a show complete. And the reason I'm saying this, we did a show dedicated. It is like matchups players to look at for weeks, 15 through 17, little bit of a spoiler, not a great run for the Eagles during the fantasy playoffs. It's a pretty, pretty brutal. So, It would have been super cool for Saquon Barkley to have like a good game when you could still move and trade off of him. But this might be one of those kind of last opportunities. So just interesting and all we talked about seeing him rank this high. But yeah, this is probably the highest you're going to rank him the rest of the year.
00:29:15
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:29:16
Speaker 2: I mean, look, if you still have your trade deadline after this week and he does do something well, immediately trade him. Like just like wipe your hands clean, like goodbye, Saquon.
00:29:26
Speaker 4: All right.
00:29:26
Speaker 1: Final one in this range. This guy actually moved up into it pretty aggressively. I think he was in the later 20s a day ago, and he's jumped up into the RB2 range. It's David Montgomery, who is now RB22. David Montgomery himself. I think it was today or maybe earlier this morning, had said that he's trending in a good direction. He's trending in a direction that he thinks he could play.
00:29:47
Speaker 2: We'll see.
00:29:47
Speaker 1: It's Thursday Night Football. But RB22, Fitzy, you've got him at 24, and you guys are splitting the uprights. Erickson, you've got him at 28. So, Erickson, why don't you start with us? You're a little bit higher on David Montgomery. We had all talked a lot about how Amari DiMarcato might be kind of a fun option. If there's no David Montgomery, he kind of kills that a little bit. But what do you think the prospects of David Montgomery are overall going up against Indianapolis? A really great matchup if he is playing.
00:30:13
Speaker 2: I think that he's just a carbon copy RB2. I think you just kind of view him like we viewed Woody Marks over the last couple of games where you're not really excited to play him, but you're going to kind of bank the volume, hope that he falls into the end zone and against the Colts with the Texans being heavy home favorites by more than double digits. Like this should theoretically be a good spot for Dave Montgomery, even though he's obviously been really bad this season, even back in week three against the Colts defense. 11 carries for 33 yards, like not a good outing. Finishes the RB 36, but he was still splitting with Woody Marks in that particular matchup. And Woody Marks actually ended up scoring in that game in the red zone. So. you know that Dave Montgomery is at least going to have some red zone equity in this spot. We know the Texans are going to move the football up and down on this Colts defense. Colts are 30th in rushing EPA. And specifically, they're
actually been really bad against inside the tackles runs. And that's actually the only thing Houston has been decent running the ball this year is they rank sixth in terms of total rushing EPA on inside the tackle rushes. So I think maybe Dave Montgomery, if he is healthy and ready to go, which I expect him to play after he logged a couple of full practices to start the week. So hopefully, I think we're going to get back to pretty much bell cow Dave Montgomery. That's why they acquired him through trade this offseason. There's no woody marks and DeMarcato getting more of a pass catching special teams type of player where I don't think they're going to need to necessarily check the ball down to a running back when they're protecting a lead. So I think just the optics of this matchup set up really well for Dave Montgomery. And even if it's like an ugly Derrick Henry game where it's like three yards to carry, but he scores two touchdowns, I think for the most part, you're probably plugging him in.
00:31:44
Speaker 1: Yeah, Fitzy, this would have been a spot where if we weren't, I think you mentioned before, if we didn't have six by weeks or six teams on by. And this is probably even if he was, you know, there's no Woody Marks and he's the starting running back. He probably still is going to have a really tough time cracking like the top 24. But because of the optics of this position, he's just a player you're probably going to have to get out there if he's active. You got him at 24, so slightly lower than ECR, but you still have him as an RB2. What are your thoughts on David Montgomery?
00:32:10
Speaker 3: 2.7 yards per carry over his first five games. Had the three touchdowns in week one, then zero touchdowns over his next four games. I do think the badness of the Colts' run defense sort of supersedes Montgomery's inefficiency early in the season. I guess where Erickson and I fundamentally disagree, he's more optimistic about bell cow usage for Montgomery. I just wonder if Montgomery gets a full workload in his first game back from a soft tissue injury. So I tend to think that we're going to see a pretty good dose of Imari DiMercato this week.
00:32:47
Speaker 4: But we'll see. Erickson could be right.
00:32:49
Speaker 3: If it is, as predicted, a convincing Texans victory over the Colts, maybe we do get 20 carries for Montee.
00:32:57
Speaker 1: All right, let's go take a look at the board for RB3s or the flex running backs 25 through 36. We got a couple of names we'll hit on and then in some deeper plays here. Coming in at 25 is Rashad White, followed by Braylon Allen. Ken Walker, kind of a placeholder rank, so people are assuming Emmitt Johnson over him. Jordan Mays and Rico Dattle. Travis Achan. 31 through 36 is Tyler Algier, Alvin Kamara, Kalon Black, Justice Hill, Kenny Gainwell, and Austin Eckler. You guys see what's going on there in the 30s. that is the repercussions of the bye week. And that's why some big decisions are going to have to be made. There are two running backs that fringe kind of into the mid-20s to the 30 range here, mid-30s. And Travis Aitken, I think, is one that we've kind of talked a decent amount about. But what is he going to be? In that first game back, it was unfortunately just like a three-headed monster of versions. Adric Estimé led in snaps. You got Alva Kamara getting more goal line touches. Like what the hell is going on? It is on paper a good matchup against Chicago. He comes in at RB 30. Erickson, you've got him at 27. Fitzy, you've got him at 31. Fitzy, let's talk about maybe the negative side for a second, if there is a negative for you. In what is such a bad RB week, you still don't have him as a top 30 running back. So did that like first game back usage of Estime and Kamara kind of scare you off that this is going to be a three back system or where are you at on Travis HM?
00:34:22
Speaker 3: Partly it's the ambiguity about his role. And last week we saw Audrick Estime lead the Saints backfield with 27 snaps, ETN 21, Alvin Kamara 16. I do think ETN probably passes Estime and snaps against the Bears. But man, my main reservation is that the Saints just can't.
00:34:43
Speaker 4: Run the ball.
00:34:44
Speaker 3: They've had 55 or fewer rushing yards as a team in four of their last six games, and Saints running backs have combined average 3.4 yards per carry this season. Saints did not have center Eric McCoy or tackle Talese Fuaga in their last game. I don't know if Fuaga has a chance to come back, but McCoy has a biceps injury. I don't think he's coming back this week. So banged up offensive line, bad running game, road game against the Bears, who.
00:35:09
Speaker 4: Have gotten tougher. against the run. I just, I don't like the spot for Etienne that much.
00:35:17
Speaker 1: It feels very reminiscent of how you feel about like the Packers too, the Packers running back situation where we turn, you get, you're like, oh, about them. It's like the Saints kind of have the same thing. Erickson, you seem to have a little bit more optimism. You have him at 27. It's still not a RB2 or anything like that, but I think we have talked about this on a show or two. Do you think that this split or this usage thing that we saw in his first game back, that was just him getting his feet acclimated and he is going to be able to take over a bigger role?
00:35:47
Speaker 2: I do think his role should continue to expand. I think that's usually the trend that we see when guys first come back from their injuries. If they see not their full role, usually the following week, you start to see an uptick in the terms of usage that they get now. They had a great matchup here against the Carolina Panthers run defense. The Saints have not been able to really run the ball effectively on anybody this year, not name the Cleveland Browns. But I don't think that's the angle how Travis A. Chan would even score his fantasy points. The thing that was encouraging for me last week is he
had five targets. And Alvin Kamara didn't see a single touch until midway through the third quarter of the game. Now, the thing that sucks about A-Chan is he has, like, zero red zone equity, right? They're using every other running back on the roster in the red zone, and that was something that even kind of plagued A-Chan back in his Jacksonville days, where he was really inefficient rushing near the goal line, and clearly the Saints have kind of went away from him in that capacity. I don't think he has any rushing touchdowns this season. But despite that, he's been RB22, RB36, RB29, and RB40. RB40 was his latest game. So he is still kind of on that RB2, RB3 fringe with six teams on by. Look, I mean, you went down the list of these names in this tier. it's kind of gross up and down the board. So at least with 8chan, you look at, okay, well, his role should expand. He catches passes. If the Saints are trailing in this game against the Chicago Bears, we see this from them every single week where they do nothing in the first half of the game. Then they're chucking the ball all over the field in the second half of the game as they try to crawl their way back in. We know the Bears are going to score points on their offense. So I think that with Captain Checkdown, which we saw last week from Tyler Shuck, if we see more targets from 8chan, I think that he can at least give you a floor. But no ceiling play for him in a backfield that I do think will still kind of involve three different guys, but at least a chair, I think can be the one a to the one B to the one C that estimate and Camara are.
00:37:35
Speaker 1: I find it interesting too, that Camara is like 32 on this list, but again, that's a whole bi-week thing that people have a trust. He had the least amount of snaps of any of those saints running backs, but the goal line. So that's weird. And as you mentioned, you know, there's names like Kenny Gainwell and Austin Eckler that are sneaking in, but one that's just, it's just fun. But the matchup, should scare the crap out of everybody. And it's Kalon Black. Kalon Black comes in at UCR RB 33. The reason it should really scare you too is just because of just how aggressive the Minnesota Vikings defense can be on offenses. And if the 49ers are not successfully rolling like they do where they're putting up 40 points, you have less opportunities to potentially see a guy like Kalon Black. But you know you're going to see him in some roles. So this is one of those weird RB 2 spots. You guys are both higher on him. He is 30th. For both of you versus ECR RB 33, Erickson, talk to us about Kalon Black in that like in a week where you're having to make decisions between Tyler Algier and Kalon Black or Alvin Kamara or Justice Hill or Kenny Gainwell. Why is Kalon Black a better play?
00:38:39
Speaker 2: I have trust in the 49ers offense under Kyle Shanahan, under Brock Purdy, no matter what defense they're facing. And when I look at how they may approach this Brian Flores defense, we saw this back in 2024. It was a while ago, but Shanahan, Brock Purdy, and this offense went up against this Brian Flores Vikings defense. And what did they do? They had their running back rush for over a hundred yards. Jordan Mason was the starting running back in that game for the San Francisco 49ers. And I think that Brian Flores, part of his defense is he's okay letting up some rushing production on the ground. Like if you look at their season long numbers, they're not some juggernaut on the ground in terms of defensive rushing yards allowed. They're 16th in rushing yards allowed per game. That's average. 4.2 yards per carry. That's the same as the Arizona Cardinals, right? A defense that we are actively targeting with our running backs. So I think that to help Brock Purve take some of the heat off of him and all these blitzes that Brian Ford is going to be throwing his way, I think they're going to try to establish the run. And who has been the best pure rusher this season for the San Francisco 49ers? I know a lot of people look at me like, dude, Callum Black is like, excellent. when he's been able to run the football in between the tackles, where obviously McCaffrey's doing so much damage as a receiver. Obviously, McCaffrey's also looked good as a rusher, but you got to give credit to Black, right? Very ridiculed draft pick at the time, but he has delivered as a compliment to CMC in a big way. Obviously, last week, 11 for 53 and a rushing touchdown. That touchdown score was also fantastic. The dude just looked like Marshawn Lloyd. I'm like, excuse me, Marshawn Lynch.
00:40:08
Speaker 1: You did what I did on the other show. Didn't I do that on the show? I think I did the exact same thing on the show.
00:40:13
Speaker 2: You called Marshawn Lloyd, Marshawn Lynch.
00:40:14
Speaker 1: I called Marshawn Lynch, Marshawn Lloyd.
00:40:16
Speaker 2: Please don't let anyone see that from Marshawn Lynch that I said that.
00:40:20
Speaker 4: Can the Packers trade Marshawn Lloyd for Marshawn Lynch?
00:40:24
Speaker 2: But yeah, so that's why I think that Black is he is kind of flex worthy, I think, because I just think that there are orange people to run the football a little bit here on this defense. And I think that Black will be part of that approach or strategy.
00:40:37
Speaker 1: One of my favorite things, too, is like. That game had one of the coolest plays all season. It was that end-to-round reverse, and it was Kalon Black that flipped it over to Debo, and it was a great run by Debo. But it also shows you just like when Kalon Black comes in, people know and defenses know like, all right, he is going to run the ball. And the focus he got to be able to pull the defense to his side once they got him the ball because he's such a menace, and then they were able to get creative play calling around it. It's not like a big crazy thing to Kalon Black, but I think it also proves just like the defensive– focus that happens and
their play calling you know he doesn't mess around when he's in those and he does look like one of the better pure runners but you got him at the same rank uh where are you at especially versus just like a lot of these fringy names you're not guaranteed incredible volume or anything like that but you just know like there's going to be some significantly fun runs that are going to come out of caitlin.
00:41:26
Speaker 3: Black yeah uh the only day two running back drafted this year after not being invited to the nfl scouting combine which is kind of crazy um so many guys who got invited to combine and weren't even drafted. Yeah, Kalen Black has double-digit carries in three straight games. He's had a touchdown run in two of his last three. I know the Vikings aren't an easy matchup. They have allowed the sixth-fewest fantasy points per game to running backs, but it is easier to run on the Vikings than it is to throw on them, and I suspect that Kyle Shanahan is going to want to make an effort to run the ball to protect Brock Purdy against the Minnesota pass rush.
00:42:04
Speaker 2: All right.
00:42:04
Speaker 1: Those are the top 36 in the names that we're looking at. But you guys both got a running back that's a little bit deeper. I mean, again, deeper is tough in this regard. I think one of these guys might have not been top 36 like 24 hours ago, and he did move up. And then, Erickson, that's your name. Your name kind of bumped into it. So give us the deeper play that you're into for this week.
00:42:26
Speaker 2: I wouldn't say I'm into any of these deeper running back plays. I would rather play wide receivers than any of these running backs, to be totally honest. But Kenny Gainwell is the guy that I have in as a deeper play. I just think that the Buccaneers are going to have to try to run the football with Jalen Daniels on her center, take advantage of a compromised and depleted Lions defense.
00:42:46
Speaker 1: All right, Fitzy, who do you got as your deeper RB? Really, it's like desperation play for this week.
00:42:52
Speaker 3: Yeah, Amari DiMercato, and it is a desperation play, and I'm starting him in two leagues this week. As I mentioned before, I think DiMercato might share the workload with David Montgomery coming off the groin injury and with no woody marks due to the concussion. He can't clear protocol by Thursday night in time for that game. Di Marcato can give you passing game production, and if he gets a few carries, the Colts run defense 31st in DVOA, 29th in EPA per rush.
00:43:20
Speaker 4: It's a pretty good matchup.
00:43:21
Speaker 2: Pretty good.
00:43:22
Speaker 1: You guys want to check out the ranks, go to fantasypros.com slash NFL slash rankings if you want to see how the RBs are going to pair out throughout the rest of the week. You can even go back in a couple days and re-listen to this episode and kind of compare to what changes have happened to what we've been talking about here. That's going to do it for the running backs, but guess what? We've got more ranks episodes coming up, wide receivers and the quarterback and tight end ones, so make sure you guys are locked in and tuned in for that. That's going to do it for the RBs, though, for Week 11. For Andrew Erickson and Pat Fitzmaurice, I'm Chris Welsh. Thank you guys for watching and hanging out with us, and we'll talk to you next time right here on Fantasy Pros.
00:43:53
Speaker 3: Thanks for listening to the Fantasy Pros Fantasy Football Podcast.
00:43:57
Speaker 1: If you love the show, the best free way to support us is by leaving a positive review on Apple Podcasts at fantasypros.com slash review or on Spotify.
00:44:06
Speaker 3: Follow us on X, Instagram, and TikTok at Fantasy Pros, and subscribe to our
00:44:10
Speaker 4: YouTube channel at youtube.com slash fantasypros.