TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Do you reckon that we need to go back to the drawing board with MMP? Since the election outcome at the weekend, I have become more and more convinced that we need to do more than just shrug our shoulders and accept that we're going to have 11 extra MPs. And I'm with this politics professor who was saying today that we definitely need to go back to the drawing board because it's just not, operating the way it should. So Victoria University's Jack Vowles, he thinks that with the manufactured overhangs on both sides of the House, something needs fixing. His concern, and this is my concern too, his concern is that with 11 extra seats, Parliament isn't going to accurately reflect the proportion of party votes cast by you and me. And that's where my thinking has landed too. Since we discovered on Saturday night this was going to be the case. I know some people aren't happy about it because of the extra cost to taxpayers of having more MPs. Honestly, I'm not too fussed about that part of it. But I am fussed about the proportional being taken out of mixed member proportional MMP. You know, taking the proportional bit out by the gaming of the system that's been done on both the left and the right. So this is maybe the trickier bit. If we decided to do something about it, what could we do? Well, this Professor Vowles is saying today that one option could be to do what they did in Germany. And what they did there is they excluded candidates in any overhang seats, which I like the sound of. So when they started getting overhangs in Germany, they created more seats in Parliament to maintain the proportional representation. But then that went a bit nuts and they ended up with truckloads of MPs. And that's when they came up with this idea of capping the number of seats. And what it means, and this is probably the only bit about Germany's solution that I'm a bit wary of, because what it means is if there is an overhang and the numbers are capped, some electorate MPs miss out. And what that means is that because of that, everyone tries to avoid creating an overhang at all costs because it can mean electorates ending up with no local MP. Now, our man at Victoria University who's calling for these changes to the MMP system, he's thought about that and he's got his own idea of how we could do it slightly different here. He says, he's saying today that if numbers were capped but there was still an overhang, We could let those electorate MPs into Parliament, meaning they'd still be representing their area. But when there's any vote on something in Parliament, they wouldn't necessarily be able to take part because it would only be the proportion of the party, the party share of the party vote that would determine how many MPs could vote. Now, look, I think that'd be overcooking it myself. And I think a straight out cap on the number of MPs would be the way to go. Because then, think about it, no one would bother trying to get an overhang, would they? In fact, they'd do everything to avoid it. And the mix of MPs in the House would be proportional to their share of the party vote. I'm not the only one concerned how the way this has played out. Former Prime Minister and Labour leader Helen Clark is saying that it could well be seen by observers that this year's election has been flawed. She says, quote, this outcome is not what MMP was designed to deliver. She's spot on. And the current Labour MP isn't happy either. Chris Hipkins says, He's accusing National today of manipulating the system. He says, quote, there are a lot of people very angry about the direction the country's been heading under this government. And you actually see that in the fact that after only one term, National has lost the party vote. They're only holding on to the prospect of power because they have manipulated the electoral system, end of quote. Now, my challenge to Chris Hipkins and Helen Clark is to do something about it instead of just complaining on the sidelines. They've got some sway, surely. Because I agree that it's wrong that the make-up of Parliament isn't going to represent the way people voted, but nothing's going to happen if we don't do anything about it.