TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.190 --> 00:00:04.269
Is civil society dying? And if so, does it even matter?
2
00:00:05.089 --> 00:00:07.360
We need to be part of our community. We need
3
00:00:07.379 --> 00:00:10.359
to be civil and inviting and willing to deal with
4
00:00:10.400 --> 00:00:13.660
people who don't necessarily agree with us. It'll make us happier.
5
00:00:14.019 --> 00:00:15.359
It'll make a better society.
6
00:00:15.960 --> 00:00:18.429
This week, we talk about why all the parts of
7
00:00:18.500 --> 00:00:21.750
life that are not your job and not national politics
8
00:00:21.769 --> 00:00:25.309
are actually way more important than you think. And they're
9
00:00:25.329 --> 00:00:29.039
in danger. This is Defending Ideas. Defending Ideas is a
10
00:00:29.059 --> 00:00:32.899
weekly podcast produced by Sutherland Institute. On this show, we
11
00:00:32.960 --> 00:00:36.320
are committed to renewing the principles of common sense conservatism,
12
00:00:36.859 --> 00:00:40.859
making you a better champion of sound ideas. Welcome back
13
00:00:40.899 --> 00:00:44.000
to Defending Ideas. I'm your host, Nick Dunn, and my
14
00:00:44.039 --> 00:00:47.539
guest this week is Michael Tanner. He's a senior fellow
15
00:00:47.700 --> 00:00:51.950
over social mobility for FREOP, the Foundation for Research on
16
00:00:52.109 --> 00:00:55.450
Equal Opportunity. Michael, welcome to Defending Ideas.
17
00:00:56.049 --> 00:00:57.710
Well, thank you. It's a real pleasure to be with you.
18
00:00:58.640 --> 00:01:00.719
I'm grateful to talk to you because you have a
19
00:01:00.740 --> 00:01:04.459
new paper from FREOP called Civil Society Under Threat. That's
20
00:01:04.500 --> 00:01:06.530
kind of very much aligned with a lot of the
21
00:01:06.549 --> 00:01:09.409
things we talk about here at Sutherland Institute. And it's
22
00:01:09.569 --> 00:01:14.430
not really necessarily about politics per se and government policy
23
00:01:14.510 --> 00:01:17.790
per se, but really about all the other ways we
24
00:01:17.890 --> 00:01:20.459
interact with one another as Americans in the form of
25
00:01:20.540 --> 00:01:24.799
civil society. So first, can I ask you, what is
26
00:01:24.920 --> 00:01:27.239
civil society? What does that mean? And why is it
27
00:01:27.280 --> 00:01:27.780
under threat?
28
00:01:28.719 --> 00:01:31.500
Sure. Well, in a sense, it's an interesting time because,
29
00:01:31.540 --> 00:01:34.799
of course, everybody's all geared up for the midterm elections
30
00:01:34.920 --> 00:01:37.420
one way or another, and everybody's very political right now.
31
00:01:38.439 --> 00:01:40.510
And what my paper is really is a plea to
32
00:01:40.549 --> 00:01:46.670
be less political, if you will. Civil society is generally
33
00:01:47.569 --> 00:01:52.359
thought of as being this third space between the government
34
00:01:52.420 --> 00:01:55.719
on one hand and for-profit business on the other hand.
35
00:01:55.760 --> 00:01:59.090
And then there's this whole thing that we do with
36
00:01:59.159 --> 00:02:02.040
each other in between that is neither about work and
37
00:02:02.079 --> 00:02:06.079
making money nor about the government. That third thing is
38
00:02:06.120 --> 00:02:11.750
what we call civil society. And it's basically everything from
39
00:02:12.000 --> 00:02:17.409
the Parkinson's Foundation and charities of that sort to human
40
00:02:17.469 --> 00:02:21.530
services charities and local soup kitchen or homeless shelter. It
41
00:02:22.930 --> 00:02:26.439
is the friends of a local park. It is your
42
00:02:26.759 --> 00:02:31.069
local sports league. the bowling team you're on. It's all
43
00:02:31.110 --> 00:02:33.969
those things we do as a community that don't have
44
00:02:34.009 --> 00:02:36.969
anything to do with making money or running other people's lives.
45
00:02:37.969 --> 00:02:39.270
Why do you say it's under threat? I mean, don't
46
00:02:39.289 --> 00:02:42.409
those things still exist? I can still join sports leagues.
47
00:02:42.469 --> 00:02:47.919
There's religions in my community. There's other civic groups. Don't
48
00:02:48.060 --> 00:02:51.319
so many of those aspects of civil society still exist
49
00:02:51.379 --> 00:02:53.539
and function? Or why do you say they're under threat?
50
00:02:54.219 --> 00:02:56.780
Well, they do still exist. In fact, large numbers of them.
51
00:02:56.800 --> 00:03:00.800
There's somewhere between one and a half and two million
52
00:03:01.319 --> 00:03:05.669
civil society organizations in the United States. They employ about
53
00:03:05.669 --> 00:03:10.310
10% of the workforce. It's a major part of our society,
54
00:03:11.289 --> 00:03:15.520
but it is less than it was. People participate less
55
00:03:15.539 --> 00:03:17.979
than they used to. The number of people who volunteer
56
00:03:18.520 --> 00:03:21.949
for something in their community is down considerably. People don't
57
00:03:21.990 --> 00:03:25.389
go to church anymore. The lodges, like the Eagles, the Elks,
58
00:03:25.449 --> 00:03:28.219
and the Masons, their membership is one-tenth of what it
59
00:03:28.280 --> 00:03:32.800
was at its height. So we're still there. It's not gone,
60
00:03:33.400 --> 00:03:36.060
but it is hurting a little bit from what it was.
61
00:03:37.240 --> 00:03:38.800
Michael, one other thing that stands out to me, too,
62
00:03:39.240 --> 00:03:42.120
this idea you mentioned of the third space. I've heard
63
00:03:42.159 --> 00:03:45.280
it sort of described this way as there's kind of
64
00:03:45.379 --> 00:03:49.909
me as the individual, and then there's also the government,
65
00:03:49.990 --> 00:03:54.069
especially the federal government on the national side. And if
66
00:03:54.090 --> 00:03:56.159
you think of it, I don't know where this came
67
00:03:56.189 --> 00:03:58.819
from initially, but in terms of concentric circles, sort of
68
00:03:58.879 --> 00:04:02.280
my concentric circles that are, you know,
Load full transcript
people or organizations
69
00:04:02.360 --> 00:04:05.300
close to me and I interact with, that there's this
70
00:04:05.500 --> 00:04:09.159
middle band of concentric circles that are bigger than just me,
71
00:04:09.680 --> 00:04:13.340
but smaller than like my national political party or those
72
00:04:13.379 --> 00:04:19.089
kinds of things. And is that why It's kind of important,
73
00:04:19.129 --> 00:04:21.000
I guess, you know, you tie this into the midterms,
74
00:04:21.040 --> 00:04:22.600
you said part of the call of your paper is
75
00:04:22.639 --> 00:04:26.579
people should be less political. Is part of the problem
76
00:04:26.620 --> 00:04:30.220
that we view ourselves as individuals, and so many Americans
77
00:04:30.860 --> 00:04:33.360
derive their meaning and purpose and sense of community from
78
00:04:33.399 --> 00:04:36.720
a national political partisan identity, and that's it? That seems
79
00:04:36.740 --> 00:04:38.410
like a recipe for disaster to me.
80
00:04:39.329 --> 00:04:40.579
That's not a good way to be.
81
00:04:40.879 --> 00:04:43.980
And I would say that you're right in the sense
82
00:04:44.120 --> 00:04:47.660
that it's bigger than the individual, but it's also voluntary.
83
00:04:48.500 --> 00:04:52.259
Some people refer to civil society as the voluntary sector
84
00:04:52.300 --> 00:04:55.519
of society. It is things we do because we meet
85
00:04:55.600 --> 00:04:57.360
up with someone else. We say, why don't you and
86
00:04:57.439 --> 00:04:59.579
I get together and do whatever it is and fix
87
00:04:59.620 --> 00:05:03.629
this problem? It's often best at the local level. It
88
00:05:03.649 --> 00:05:06.889
can be national. You can have large nationwide charities, although
89
00:05:06.910 --> 00:05:08.889
that's part of the problem now is that we sort
90
00:05:08.930 --> 00:05:13.389
of over-professionalized charity to some degree. The fact that these
91
00:05:13.990 --> 00:05:17.170
organizations exist in huge numbers and they're run by experts,
92
00:05:17.209 --> 00:05:19.870
so the average individual doesn't get to be part of
93
00:05:19.930 --> 00:05:23.170
it the same way as they once could. But it
94
00:05:23.230 --> 00:05:26.180
can be nationwide, but it is best when it's at
95
00:05:26.220 --> 00:05:29.120
the local level, if it's your neighbor helping your neighbor.
96
00:05:30.060 --> 00:05:32.920
Michael, two of the things you mentioned that have been
97
00:05:33.000 --> 00:05:35.939
on the decline, well, you mentioned volunteering is down, you
98
00:05:35.980 --> 00:05:40.250
mentioned church attendance is down. also sort of family formation.
99
00:05:40.290 --> 00:05:42.379
There's been a lot of talk lately on the national
100
00:05:42.389 --> 00:05:45.480
level about the declining fertility rate, just the rate of
101
00:05:45.540 --> 00:05:48.980
folks getting married and having kids. So let me ask
102
00:05:49.000 --> 00:05:51.379
you this, and this might ruffle some feathers, but kind
103
00:05:51.420 --> 00:05:54.279
of tell me if you think I'm wrong. Part of
104
00:05:54.339 --> 00:05:56.439
my reaction to seeing all of this is, okay, the
105
00:05:56.519 --> 00:05:59.339
civil society is declining and eroding, and it's bad for
106
00:05:59.360 --> 00:06:01.000
all those reasons, which we can get into in a
107
00:06:07.680 --> 00:06:12.879
Get married, have kids, work hard. Is that the antidote
108
00:06:12.920 --> 00:06:17.220
to civil society decline? What's wrong with just saying the
109
00:06:17.259 --> 00:06:19.800
solution to civil society decline is to go to church
110
00:06:19.839 --> 00:06:20.279
and get married?
111
00:06:21.120 --> 00:06:23.240
Well, those are things you can do as an individual
112
00:06:23.279 --> 00:06:25.759
to some degree. The question is how much you're going
113
00:06:25.819 --> 00:06:29.050
to tie into other people to help do that. And
114
00:06:29.370 --> 00:06:31.689
things that have to be sort of larger, there's people
115
00:06:31.709 --> 00:06:34.509
who can't necessarily do those things that are going to
116
00:06:34.529 --> 00:06:38.480
need help. There are things that are outside of the
117
00:06:38.920 --> 00:06:42.370
purview of those type of organizations, outside the family or
118
00:06:42.449 --> 00:06:46.129
the individual. How do you handle the park in your
119
00:06:46.180 --> 00:06:52.170
town that needs maintenance? people to volunteer to clean it up,
120
00:06:52.230 --> 00:06:54.250
to go out there and pick up the trash and
121
00:06:54.290 --> 00:06:58.129
things of that nature? How do you deal with overseeing government,
122
00:06:58.149 --> 00:07:00.509
the sort of democracy movements, the people who are out
123
00:07:00.550 --> 00:07:05.670
there watching to preserve free speech and things of that nature?
124
00:07:06.209 --> 00:07:10.250
How do you deal with people with human services needs
125
00:07:10.300 --> 00:07:12.199
who are poor and need someone to go out and
126
00:07:12.240 --> 00:07:14.160
find them a house or a job or things of
127
00:07:14.199 --> 00:07:17.529
that nature? How do you deal with disease that are
128
00:07:17.589 --> 00:07:20.829
out there that need to have research? All these things
129
00:07:20.870 --> 00:07:23.250
can be done by us as a community on a
130
00:07:23.310 --> 00:07:28.220
voluntary basis, working with one another. The more politicized it becomes,
131
00:07:28.800 --> 00:07:34.019
it actually begins to turn people off. It's obviously that
132
00:07:34.060 --> 00:07:36.500
the government itself can get in and attacking these groups.
133
00:07:36.540 --> 00:07:40.470
You're seeing, for example, the Trump administration within the last week,
134
00:07:40.870 --> 00:07:42.870
there was a leak to the New York Post that
135
00:07:42.889 --> 00:07:45.050
they're going to use the IRS to take away tax
136
00:07:45.129 --> 00:07:49.639
exempt status from the Soros Foundation and CARE and Southern
137
00:07:49.680 --> 00:07:53.879
Poverty Law Center and other groups that clash with the administration.
138
00:07:54.750 --> 00:07:57.110
So the government can get directly involved in these sort
139
00:07:57.129 --> 00:07:58.810
of things. And don't forget, we can go back to
140
00:07:58.850 --> 00:08:03.009
the Obama administration with Lois Lerner and not clearing through
141
00:08:03.029 --> 00:08:07.420
the C3 status, the tax-exempt status of conservative groups. So
142
00:08:07.480 --> 00:08:09.699
it's not one party or the other. It's not red
143
00:08:10.360 --> 00:08:13.079
or it's not blue. It is just the nature of
144
00:08:13.139 --> 00:08:18.040
government to kind of hate competition. And people on either
145
00:08:18.060 --> 00:08:20.379
side now begin more and more to use it to
146
00:08:20.420 --> 00:08:25.000
punish civil society. It's also, I think, that just kind
147
00:08:25.060 --> 00:08:28.279
of a cynicism sets in. If everything you do becomes
148
00:08:28.319 --> 00:08:33.360
a political statement, whether your child plays peewee football or
149
00:08:33.419 --> 00:08:37.049
Little League baseball or youth soccer, there's a political statement,
150
00:08:37.110 --> 00:08:41.789
which one of those you've chosen somehow. People tune out
151
00:08:41.909 --> 00:08:43.889
and just say, I don't want to get involved. There's
152
00:08:43.950 --> 00:08:48.500
no neutral organizations. Everything... It's that team or my team.
153
00:08:48.519 --> 00:08:51.740
And people kind of run away from that. And I
154
00:08:51.779 --> 00:08:54.100
think that that's going to be a legacy that we're
155
00:08:54.120 --> 00:08:55.379
going to have to overcome.
156
00:08:56.100 --> 00:08:57.820
I want to pinpoint something you just alluded to and
157
00:08:57.840 --> 00:09:00.340
you talked about in your report, this idea of the
158
00:09:00.379 --> 00:09:06.580
role of government. Is government itself, bipartisan, a threat to
159
00:09:06.659 --> 00:09:10.539
civil society? Is sort of government implicitly or explicitly attacking
160
00:09:10.750 --> 00:09:12.370
these institutions of civil society?
161
00:09:13.200 --> 00:09:16.220
Well, it's both directly and indirectly a threat, I think,
162
00:09:16.340 --> 00:09:19.340
to civil society. It is directly attacking it. We've seen
163
00:09:20.480 --> 00:09:24.490
dozens of congressional hearings and investigations of civil society organizations
164
00:09:24.529 --> 00:09:27.110
because one party or another doesn't like the group that's
165
00:09:27.169 --> 00:09:30.970
out there. We've also seen the fact that as government
166
00:09:30.990 --> 00:09:34.960
gets bigger, it begins to crowd out. uh, the things
167
00:09:34.980 --> 00:09:37.659
that civil society used to do. Why should civil society
168
00:09:37.700 --> 00:09:40.879
get involved? There's the big daddy, big mommy government can,
169
00:09:40.990 --> 00:09:43.509
can come in and do it with millions and millions
170
00:09:43.529 --> 00:09:47.350
of dollars and resources that the local groups don't have. Uh,
171
00:09:47.629 --> 00:09:50.309
I think that that's a mistake because the government doesn't
172
00:09:50.350 --> 00:09:52.029
actually do a very good job on a lot of
173
00:09:52.070 --> 00:09:56.860
these things. Size and money isn't necessarily the answer, and
174
00:09:56.879 --> 00:10:01.279
they don't necessarily do a better job. But also you
175
00:10:01.340 --> 00:10:07.019
lose that sense of community, that sort of meaning that
176
00:10:07.059 --> 00:10:09.519
you have in your own life from when you choose
177
00:10:09.559 --> 00:10:12.539
to help someone else. That goes away when you're kind
178
00:10:12.580 --> 00:10:13.460
of forced into it.
179
00:10:14.809 --> 00:10:16.639
Here's a pop culture reference for you to see if
180
00:10:16.960 --> 00:10:18.840
this aligns with what you're saying, because this just came
181
00:10:18.879 --> 00:10:21.059
to mind. For folks who are familiar with the movie
182
00:10:21.120 --> 00:10:23.279
The Kid, it's a Disney movie from years back with
183
00:10:23.320 --> 00:10:27.379
Bruce Willis, where the eight-year-old version of himself essentially comes
184
00:10:27.480 --> 00:10:30.450
and it comes into his time, and so he's interacting
185
00:10:30.490 --> 00:10:33.330
with his child self. So that's the premise of the movie.
186
00:10:33.350 --> 00:10:36.330
But I remember there's a scene where he has an
187
00:10:36.370 --> 00:10:39.750
estranged relationship with his father, and his father keeps calling him,
188
00:10:39.870 --> 00:10:42.549
asking him to come help him move something around the
189
00:10:42.580 --> 00:10:46.210
house and And what Bruce Willis's character does is he
190
00:10:46.549 --> 00:10:48.309
writes him a check and says, well, I gave you
191
00:10:48.330 --> 00:10:50.289
a bunch of money to pay for movers to come
192
00:10:50.340 --> 00:10:52.440
help you. And the father was like, no, I wanted
193
00:10:52.559 --> 00:10:56.720
your help. I mean, that to me is an example
194
00:10:56.740 --> 00:10:58.720
of this sort of on a micro level, that part
195
00:10:58.779 --> 00:11:02.659
of the need for civil society is those human interactions.
196
00:11:02.700 --> 00:11:07.480
And in that instance, the familial sort of role of
197
00:11:07.539 --> 00:11:11.250
civil society that families play, that I guess I would
198
00:11:11.259 --> 00:11:15.629
interpret that as government cannot or should not replace the
199
00:11:15.690 --> 00:11:20.590
functions of civil society simply through advanced material resources, through
200
00:11:20.629 --> 00:11:26.250
more cash, because there's something intrinsic about the human relationship
201
00:11:26.929 --> 00:11:30.759
within a family, within a faith, within a neighborhood organization.
202
00:11:31.720 --> 00:11:34.039
Can you comment on that? Is there something that we're
203
00:11:34.120 --> 00:11:37.440
missing if we think, well, we can, quote-unquote, solve problems
204
00:11:37.620
--> 00:11:41.919
with government resources that we used to solve with civil society?
205
00:11:42.669 --> 00:11:44.679
Yeah, and I would say it's not just government either.
206
00:11:44.700 --> 00:11:47.720
What you're seeing is we're still one of the most
207
00:11:47.779 --> 00:11:50.919
generous nations on earth when it comes to charity. We
208
00:11:50.980 --> 00:11:56.360
give enormous amounts of money to help people, but as individuals,
209
00:11:56.379 --> 00:11:59.399
not government, as individuals writing a check. But writing a
210
00:11:59.450 --> 00:12:04.269
check isn't the same as getting involved. And we're still
211
00:12:04.289 --> 00:12:08.049
keeping that money coming in, but we're volunteering less and less.
212
00:12:08.110 --> 00:12:11.429
And I think that that's, in the long run, a loss.
213
00:12:12.529 --> 00:12:16.629
When you say getting involved, I think most people interpret
214
00:12:16.669 --> 00:12:21.210
that as political, that civic engagement has become synonymous with
215
00:12:22.509 --> 00:12:27.840
advocating for particular candidates from a political party or advocating
216
00:12:27.889 --> 00:12:30.759
particular pieces of legislation. I say this as someone who
217
00:12:30.799 --> 00:12:32.740
works for a think tank where that is what we
218
00:12:32.779 --> 00:12:35.340
do professionally, as you do as well. We talk about
219
00:12:35.379 --> 00:12:37.419
politics and public policy, and that's what we try to
220
00:12:37.539 --> 00:12:40.779
influence constructively. But also, and I think this is something
221
00:12:40.820 --> 00:12:45.409
that differentiates what you've put out in your new paper,
222
00:12:46.409 --> 00:12:51.179
that there's a whole world of productive activities that should
223
00:12:51.240 --> 00:12:56.779
not be governmental. So why is it that most people assume,
224
00:12:57.039 --> 00:13:01.120
quote unquote, getting involved is only political or partisan and
225
00:13:01.159 --> 00:13:03.929
not these other things they could be doing? What's caused that?
226
00:13:05.509 --> 00:13:08.740
I actually think part of it is a general deterioration
227
00:13:09.019 --> 00:13:14.350
in interaction society, a social disconnection in society. We've become
228
00:13:14.850 --> 00:13:18.409
a country, actually a planet of people wandering around with
229
00:13:18.470 --> 00:13:21.929
a cell phone in front of their face. not connecting
230
00:13:21.980 --> 00:13:24.580
with other individuals generally. And I think that sort of
231
00:13:24.940 --> 00:13:30.490
atomization of the population is an overall larger problem. We've
232
00:13:30.539 --> 00:13:33.409
seen it with the results COVID contributed to, the fact
233
00:13:33.450 --> 00:13:36.590
that that isolated us, kept us in our houses, kept
234
00:13:36.649 --> 00:13:40.259
us from work. Even now, we're not necessarily returning to
235
00:13:40.299 --> 00:13:42.240
the office the same way. We're losing out on that.
236
00:13:45.259 --> 00:13:46.879
I think there's a lot of reasons we've sort of
237
00:13:46.919 --> 00:13:49.169
broken down as a society, and that's part of it.
238
00:13:49.600 --> 00:13:52.600
And then you layer that over with the intense partisanship
239
00:13:52.620 --> 00:13:56.000
we're seeing right now. It's not just the usual, what
240
00:13:56.019 --> 00:13:57.980
we saw back, let's say, in the 60s, when you
241
00:13:58.000 --> 00:14:00.529
had the Democrats and Republicans, and you could talk about
242
00:14:00.549 --> 00:14:06.009
what party you were in, and people participated politically, but
243
00:14:06.049 --> 00:14:08.870
they didn't sort of hate their neighbor the way they
244
00:14:08.889 --> 00:14:11.149
do now. And I find more and more that that
245
00:14:11.190 --> 00:14:14.350
sort of lack of civility, if you the sort of
246
00:14:14.370 --> 00:14:18.149
online culture of spinning over into the rest of culture.
247
00:14:19.250 --> 00:14:21.250
And I think that that makes it very hard for
248
00:14:21.309 --> 00:14:24.080
us to come together and work for a common goal.
249
00:14:25.019 --> 00:14:30.440
Michael, why is the deterioration of civil society bad for America?
250
00:14:30.600 --> 00:14:32.620
Why is it bad for us individuals? Why does it
251
00:14:32.659 --> 00:14:35.639
cause problems? Can you go into any more depth there?
252
00:14:36.269 --> 00:14:38.169
Well, I think it's going to be bad for us
253
00:14:38.190 --> 00:14:39.870
in a number of ways. Number one is it means
254
00:14:39.970 --> 00:14:43.120
a lot of problems aren't going to get solved. because
255
00:14:43.200 --> 00:14:45.659
if you don't have civil society and they're trying to
256
00:14:45.720 --> 00:14:48.399
fix problems, what are you left with? You're left with
257
00:14:48.440 --> 00:14:51.450
big government, which we know is not very successful at
258
00:14:51.470 --> 00:14:54.389
solving a lot of things, especially local things, especially things
259
00:14:54.409 --> 00:14:57.909
that have to do with people's hearts and minds. It's
260
00:14:57.929 --> 00:15:01.009
not very good there. So you're having to rely on government,
261
00:15:01.090 --> 00:15:03.029
and that's not going to be the answer. So I
262
00:15:03.049 --> 00:15:05.669
think we lose that. I also think we lose those
263
00:15:05.710 --> 00:15:08.350
things that connect us one with another, and I do
264
00:15:08.409 --> 00:15:12.190
think there's more to life uh, my boss says there's
265
00:15:12.250 --> 00:15:14.309
more to life than GDP. And I, and I think
266
00:15:14.350 --> 00:15:17.830
that that's correct. Uh, not that I'm not for economic growth.
267
00:15:17.850 --> 00:15:20.860
I think that's hugely important. In fact, I think economic
268
00:15:20.929 --> 00:15:24.480
instability is another reason why civil society is breaking down.
269
00:15:24.539 --> 00:15:27.039
If you're worried about where your next paycheck's coming from,
270
00:15:27.059 --> 00:15:30.019
you're not taking
time out to worry about what is
271
00:15:30.059 --> 00:15:32.600
going down, down at the local community center. So I
272
00:15:32.639 --> 00:15:37.570
think that that's, uh, part of it as well for
273
00:15:37.610 --> 00:15:40.370
economic growth. But there's things that we do that make
274
00:15:40.470 --> 00:15:43.580
us happy, that make us more fulfilled as people that
275
00:15:43.620 --> 00:15:46.340
have nothing to do with GDP growth. And I think
276
00:15:46.360 --> 00:15:49.440
that that will be ultimately lost. And this is part
277
00:15:49.480 --> 00:15:53.139
of sort of what makes America unique. As I mentioned
278
00:15:53.159 --> 00:15:56.000
to Tocqueville earlier, it's always been part of the American
279
00:15:56.059 --> 00:16:01.720
character that we could come together and work outside of
280
00:16:01.779 --> 00:16:05.299
the normal structures I think if we lose that, we
281
00:16:05.320 --> 00:16:06.899
lose part of what America is.
282
00:16:07.960 --> 00:16:09.820
One of the things that strikes me is if I
283
00:16:09.840 --> 00:16:11.340
were to look at my own life and say, okay,
284
00:16:11.379 --> 00:16:13.799
where do I fit in with this debate about civil
285
00:16:13.840 --> 00:16:16.940
society and our overall civility as a nation and our
286
00:16:16.980 --> 00:16:21.570
sort of civic health as a country? Part of me
287
00:16:21.629 --> 00:16:23.950
thinks that it's really instructive to boil down to, okay,
288
00:16:24.669 --> 00:16:27.230
in fact, I'll borrow language from Arthur Brooks, where I
289
00:16:27.289 --> 00:16:29.529
saw him speak a year or so ago, where he
290
00:16:29.590 --> 00:16:34.350
said some really essential questions that we all need to answer,
291
00:16:34.549 --> 00:16:36.570
and this ties into his work on happiness, but some
292
00:16:36.610 --> 00:16:40.409
really essential questions are, why was I born or why
293
00:16:40.490 --> 00:16:43.220
am I alive? And what would I be willing to
294
00:16:43.340 --> 00:16:46.240
give my life for? And those are deep kind of
295
00:16:46.259 --> 00:16:50.379
philosophical purpose questions, but the reason I articulate those is
296
00:16:50.419 --> 00:16:52.419
when I think of it, okay, in terms of civil
297
00:16:52.460 --> 00:16:54.740
society and our health as a society and a community,
298
00:16:55.899 --> 00:17:00.309
for me, it's my faith and my family. And those
299
00:17:00.350 --> 00:17:03.009
are the things that are at the core most important
300
00:17:03.070 --> 00:17:06.670
to me on a deep level when it comes to purpose.
301
00:17:07.289 --> 00:17:10.509
But then also, those are also the things that encourage
302
00:17:10.549 --> 00:17:15.440
me to engage outside myself, outside my home in ways
303
00:17:15.480 --> 00:17:18.740
that are constructive, again, that ties into the civil society component.
304
00:17:19.420 --> 00:17:22.920
And so I guess one question is, how do we
305
00:17:22.980 --> 00:17:27.230
convince people to care less about national politics and and
306
00:17:27.269 --> 00:17:31.019
more about their own faith and family and neighbors.
307
00:17:31.910 --> 00:17:33.000
Yeah, I think that's interesting.
308
00:17:33.160 --> 00:17:37.940
Faith and family are two things that I would not
309
00:17:38.000 --> 00:17:40.440
want the government involved in. I mean, can you imagine
310
00:17:40.460 --> 00:17:42.339
what a mess they would make of the average family
311
00:17:42.400 --> 00:17:45.339
or the average church? So I would definitely not want
312
00:17:45.359 --> 00:17:47.779
the government involved in those things. But as you mentioned,
313
00:17:47.799 --> 00:17:50.019
they're hugely important, and they're hugely important to a lot
314
00:17:50.059 --> 00:17:55.049
of people individually, and then they're important to society at large.
315
00:17:56.519 --> 00:17:57.859
And I think one of the things that we can
316
00:17:57.920 --> 00:18:01.460
do in regards to making the changes you're talking about
317
00:18:01.480 --> 00:18:05.500
is to simply be more civil. And the civil and
318
00:18:05.539 --> 00:18:08.880
civil society is a very important part of it. It
319
00:18:08.940 --> 00:18:11.130
is the idea that you can talk to somebody who
320
00:18:11.170 --> 00:18:13.329
might not agree with you on 100% of the things.
321
00:18:13.369 --> 00:18:16.809
You can work with somebody who might disagree with you.
322
00:18:18.529 --> 00:18:21.650
No one's expecting that the Democratic Socialists of America and
323
00:18:21.670 --> 00:18:25.470
the Hayek Society are going to hold joint meetings. Although
324
00:18:25.490 --> 00:18:26.950
that wouldn't be a bad thing if they did. They
325
00:18:26.970 --> 00:18:31.480
probably both learned something from each other. But certainly when
326
00:18:31.500 --> 00:18:34.400
you go out to sign up your kid for, let's say,
327
00:18:34.539 --> 00:18:38.420
the youth sports league, does the people who are in
328
00:18:38.460 --> 00:18:40.880
that sports league have to have exactly the same faith
329
00:18:40.940 --> 00:18:43.789
as you? Do they have to have the same ethnic background?
330
00:18:44.289 --> 00:18:46.990
Does it matter whether they voted for Trump or Harris?
331
00:18:47.630 --> 00:18:51.210
Those things are very different. And I think that people
332
00:18:51.230 --> 00:18:53.910
should be able to work with people and talk to
333
00:18:53.950 --> 00:18:57.170
people And simply be nice to people. We're not a
334
00:18:57.329 --> 00:19:00.170
nice society right now. And I think we need a
335
00:19:00.190 --> 00:19:03.130
lot more niceness. We need more Ted Lasso in our lives.
336
00:19:04.710 --> 00:19:06.670
I have not watched Ted Lasso, but I've seen enough
337
00:19:06.759 --> 00:19:09.759
clips for that to resonate with me and say, yeah,
338
00:19:09.819 --> 00:19:13.000
that makes sense to me. I'm hearing the critics or
339
00:19:13.039 --> 00:19:15.039
the counter arguments in my head of people saying, well,
no,
340
00:19:15.059 --> 00:19:17.700
we can't be, you know, you see this all the time.
341
00:19:18.359 --> 00:19:20.220
There are those out there who say we can't be
342
00:19:20.400 --> 00:19:23.500
civil or we can't quote unquote disagree better, one of
343
00:19:23.559 --> 00:19:28.339
Governor Spencer Cox's initiatives. And the reason they give is because, well,
344
00:19:28.500 --> 00:19:31.759
the other side, so to speak, is just too bad
345
00:19:31.920 --> 00:19:34.589
or their ideas or positions are too bad or destructive.
346
00:19:35.549 --> 00:19:37.990
I mean, social media is rampant with these views. Our
347
00:19:38.029 --> 00:19:40.660
national politics is rampant with these views that the other
348
00:19:40.700 --> 00:19:43.700
side is just too bad, so to speak, for us
349
00:19:43.799 --> 00:19:46.240
to be civil. Because I think in these folks' eyes,
350
00:19:46.769 --> 00:19:50.609
being civil or being kind or disagreeing better is... to
351
00:19:50.670 --> 00:19:52.730
some folks, it feels like, well, that means we just
352
00:19:52.789 --> 00:19:56.990
have to cede territory on principles or on policies. How
353
00:19:57.019 --> 00:19:59.240
do you respond to that? How do you answer the
354
00:19:59.279 --> 00:20:03.339
question of, to some people, being civil just sounds like
355
00:20:03.380 --> 00:20:06.359
being squishy and then losing important political battles?
356
00:20:07.130 --> 00:20:08.900
Well, first of all, I think a lot of these
357
00:20:08.920 --> 00:20:11.180
things that we're talking about are not political at all.
358
00:20:12.440 --> 00:20:17.970
If you're cleaning trash out of the creek, I don't
359
00:20:18.049 --> 00:20:21.970
know whether Democrats do that in one way, Republicans do
360
00:20:21.990 --> 00:20:23.849
it in another way. As far as I know, everybody
361
00:20:23.869 --> 00:20:26.099
goes out and picks up trash the same way. So
362
00:20:26.130 --> 00:20:29.019
I'm not sure that it matters what the politics are
363
00:20:29.059 --> 00:20:31.779
of that. The other thing is, I think most people
364
00:20:31.859 --> 00:20:35.720
actually share the same goals. Yes, there's fringes on both sides,
365
00:20:35.880 --> 00:20:38.240
far left, far right. There's people out there who have
366
00:20:38.279 --> 00:20:41.920
very different ideas. But the vast majority of people, regardless
367
00:20:41.980 --> 00:20:45.019
of what their politics are, want the same things at
368
00:20:45.059 --> 00:20:47.799
the end of the day. They may be entirely, in
369
00:20:47.859 --> 00:20:50.460
my opinion, misguided about how they're going to get there.
370
00:20:50.569 --> 00:20:55.390
They may be supporting a bill that I think is stupid.
371
00:20:56.210 --> 00:20:58.369
But that doesn't mean they don't want what I want
372
00:20:58.410 --> 00:21:00.589
in the end, and I should be able to identify
373
00:21:00.630 --> 00:21:02.690
with them in that and work with them in that.
374
00:21:03.690 --> 00:21:05.450
And if we have to say, go your own way,
375
00:21:05.470 --> 00:21:10.799
you be you, I'll be me, then that's ultimately where
376
00:21:10.819 --> 00:21:11.420
we need to go.
377
00:21:12.359 --> 00:21:16.019
Michael, there's a great book called A Time to Build
378
00:21:16.119 --> 00:21:18.160
by Yuval Levin that's kind of one of the seminal
379
00:21:18.180 --> 00:21:20.859
works on the decline of civil society and the need
380
00:21:20.900 --> 00:21:23.759
to restore it for not just a healthier politics, but
381
00:21:23.799 --> 00:21:26.440
a healthier country. And I would say also a more
382
00:21:26.630 --> 00:21:31.210
purpose-filled country for more of our fellow Americans to feel
383
00:21:31.250 --> 00:21:34.130
like they have a purpose, that they're part of a community,
384
00:21:34.170 --> 00:21:37.670
part of a society where there's meaning. And again, that's
385
00:21:37.690 --> 00:21:39.509
why I always come back to this idea of faith
386
00:21:39.569 --> 00:21:44.349
and family. What would you say are the things that
387
00:21:44.470 --> 00:21:47.190
must be done moving forward? If everyone out there watching
388
00:21:47.210 --> 00:21:51.259
and listening to this says, okay, I'm persuaded, yes, these non-governmental,
389
00:21:51.779 --> 00:21:56.869
you know, civil society things, whatever that's defined as to them,
390
00:21:57.470 --> 00:22:01.970
are really important. We need more of those. What should
391
00:22:02.009 --> 00:22:05.509
people do? What advice would you give to someone in
392
00:22:05.549 --> 00:22:08.309
our audience out there that says, I'm with you. I
393
00:22:08.349 --> 00:22:09.349
don't know what to do about this.
394
00:22:10.099 --> 00:22:12.759
Well, I think there's things that government can do.
395
00:22:12.839 --> 00:22:16.500
They can do things more to encourage charitable giving and
396
00:22:16.519 --> 00:22:22.230
things of that nature. We charitable credit or deduction to
397
00:22:22.250 --> 00:22:25.569
encourage people to give more. We should find a way
398
00:22:25.630 --> 00:22:28.890
that people can write off time that's donated as also
399
00:22:29.130 --> 00:22:32.440
as a way of contributing charity rather than just money.
400
00:22:34.019 --> 00:22:37.200
If a doctor goes and treats people for free, they
401
00:22:37.240 --> 00:22:38.779
don't get to write off the time they're doing that.
402
00:22:38.819 --> 00:22:40.740
But if they write a check to an organization that
403
00:22:40.779 --> 00:22:43.369
does exactly the same thing, that's a charitable contribution. We
404
00:22:43.390 --> 00:22:46.490
should be able to deal with that. Local municipal planners
405
00:22:46.599 --> 00:22:50.819
should make sure that communities have community space, whether it's
406
00:22:51.380 --> 00:22:55.000
a community center or a park or someplace where people
407
00:22:55.039 --> 00:22:58.140
come together and can meet up and run into their
408
00:22:58.180 --> 00:23:01.519
neighbors and talk and have those sort of communications with
409
00:23:01.559 --> 00:23:04.680
each other. So I think there are some things the
410
00:23:04.720 --> 00:23:08.420
government can do. But on the individual side and the
411
00:23:08.539 --> 00:23:11.700
organizational side of civil society organizations, part of it is
412
00:23:11.759 --> 00:23:15.049
to avoid getting entangled in red tape and government money
413
00:23:15.069 --> 00:23:19.190
uh if you start taking money you start dancing to
414
00:23:19.210 --> 00:23:21.210
the strings of the people who gave you that money
415
00:23:21.309 --> 00:23:23.509
and uh i think that that's a problem when it's
416
00:23:23.690 --> 00:23:27.890
government grants that society needs to avoid that uh civil
417
00:23:27.930 --> 00:23:31.490
society and individuals need to say just to be open
418
00:23:31.529 --> 00:23:34.509
to other people and other things uh in the end
419
00:23:34.569 --> 00:23:37.500
i think it's a If I could break it down
420
00:23:37.559 --> 00:23:39.660
into sort of one word, it is that be civil
421
00:23:41.279 --> 00:23:44.079
to your neighbors. Love your neighbors as you love yourself.
422
00:23:45.220 --> 00:23:49.390
I think the golden rule is important. Do unto others.
423
00:23:49.769 --> 00:23:52.970
I think all those things are part of how we
424
00:23:53.029 --> 00:23:59.029
make ourselves a better society, a better community, a better country.
425
00:23:59.950 --> 00:24:03.009
And it's not about winning all the time. Sometimes it's
426
00:24:03.049 --> 00:24:03.750
about doing.
427
00:24:04.720 --> 00:24:07.819
But we have to get people to want to do it, right?
428
00:24:07.839 --> 00:24:11.440
I mean, your points about charitable contributions totally make sense.
429
00:24:11.460 --> 00:24:15.170
You know, very pro sort of making it easy for
430
00:24:15.230 --> 00:24:19.509
folks to contribute to charitable causes, whether that's faith organizations
431
00:24:19.569 --> 00:24:22.670
or something else. And the idea of urban planning, making
432
00:24:22.730 --> 00:24:25.109
sure there are spaces. You know, I'm a dad with
433
00:24:25.150 --> 00:24:27.730
two kids, so I want there to be places where
434
00:24:27.779 --> 00:24:29.400
my kids can go and play and be safe and
435
00:24:29.420 --> 00:24:31.900
where we can gather as a community. So I'm with
436
00:24:31.940 --> 00:24:35.000
you on all that, but also thinking there are— you know,
437
00:24:35.039 --> 00:24:37.819
there are lots of empty parks. There are lots of
438
00:24:38.339 --> 00:24:41.660
charitable contributions that don't get given, I guess, if that
439
00:24:41.700 --> 00:24:45.210
makes sense. And so part of me is thinking, how
440
00:24:45.250 --> 00:24:47.589
do you get people to want to do this, to
441
00:24:47.650 --> 00:24:52.609
want an off-ramp from our hyper-polarized, hyper-atomized culture to say,
442
00:24:52.990 --> 00:24:56.710
I want to engage more, or honestly, I feel an
443
00:24:56.829 --> 00:25:01.109
obligation to engage more in my community, in civil society,
444
00:25:01.690 --> 00:25:04.549
in these kinds of ways. I'm thinking of... Another great movie,
445
00:25:04.569 --> 00:25:07.289
The Hunt for Red October. I grew up on that
446
00:25:07.329 --> 00:25:09.490
movie as a kid. And there's a scene where Alec
447
00:25:09.509 --> 00:25:13.250
Baldwin's character, Jack Ryan, he's talking to himself in the
448
00:25:13.269 --> 00:25:15.630
mirror because he's trying to figure out how... I just
449
00:25:16.430 --> 00:25:18.009
feel like this is turning into a movie show. I'm
450
00:25:18.049 --> 00:25:21.410
recapping movie scenes, but it feels relevant where he's trying
451
00:25:21.450 --> 00:25:24.160
to figure out how this Russian submarine captain is going
452
00:25:24.180 --> 00:25:26.279
to get the crew off of the submarine because the
453
00:25:26.299 --> 00:25:28.920
captain plans to defect. And he's like, how do you
454
00:25:28.960 --> 00:25:31.759
get them off without them knowing he's defecting? And he's like,
455
00:25:32.140 --> 00:25:35.099
they have to want to get off. And so how
456
00:25:35.140 --> 00:25:37.880
do we get people to want to get off of
457
00:25:37.940 --> 00:25:43.009
this hyper-polarized, hyper-atomized existence that so many Americans are stuck
458
00:25:43.089 --> 00:25:45.789
in and to actually say, I want to be more
459
00:25:45.970 --> 00:25:46.829
civilly engaged?
460
00:25:47.710 --> 00:25:49.369
I guess I would ask people, are they happy with
461
00:25:49.390 --> 00:25:50.390
the way things are now?
462
00:25:50.490 --> 00:25:52.839
Are they happy with a society in which you're constantly
463
00:25:52.880 --> 00:25:56.279
in fight or flight mode, where you're constantly butting heads
464
00:25:56.359 --> 00:25:58.940
with your neighbors rather than working with them?
465
00:25:59.819 --> 00:26:02.380
And, you know, there are consequences.
466
00:26:02.799 --> 00:26:04.670
The Surgeon General's report of a couple of years ago
467
00:26:04.809 --> 00:26:08.049
on loneliness, if we look at what's happened in our society,
468
00:26:08.769 --> 00:26:14.009
how we disconnected from our neighbors and our co-workers and folks,
469
00:26:14.700 --> 00:26:18.240
It's actually physical consequences. I mean, other than things, it's
470
00:26:18.259 --> 00:26:20.940
more addiction, more alcoholism, things of that nature. But it's
471
00:26:21.440 --> 00:26:24.259
just physically, you have more mental illness, you have more
472
00:26:24.380 --> 00:26:28.940
physical illness, all of which stems from being alone. And
473
00:26:28.980 --> 00:26:31.559
I think that if people look around and they say,
474
00:26:31.579 --> 00:26:33.809
am I happy with the way things are now? Am
475
00:26:33.920 --> 00:26:36.410
I happy with my life now? A lot of people
476
00:26:36.430 --> 00:26:38.890
are going to say no. And if they're saying no,
477
00:26:38.950 --> 00:26:40.670
then my answer to them is get involved.
478
00:26:42.039 --> 00:26:45.480
Michael, I'm going to invoke Arthur Brooks again in some
479
00:26:45.500 --> 00:26:47.720
of his work on happiness. And I believe he initially
480
00:26:47.759 --> 00:26:50.500
mentioned this, as I recall, in the book, The Conservative Heart,
481
00:26:50.539 --> 00:26:53.740
when he's talking about this idea. So Arthur Brooks has
482
00:26:53.759 --> 00:26:56.880
this idea called the happiness portfolio, that all of his
483
00:26:56.940 --> 00:27:00.160
research has shown that the four things that correlate the
484
00:27:00.240 --> 00:27:04.910
most with someone's happiness are faith, family, community, and work.
485
00:27:05.569 --> 00:27:08.630
And so, you know, I guess I would offer that,
486
00:27:08.670 --> 00:27:13.410
that why couldn't we say to folks out there who, again, think,
487
00:27:13.950 --> 00:27:16.549
I don't like the status quo in our culture right now,
488
00:27:16.609 --> 00:27:19.730
especially in our political culture. I want to be more
489
00:27:19.769 --> 00:27:22.670
civically engaged in ways that are constructive. What do I
490
00:27:22.710 --> 00:27:25.069
do about it? Why couldn't we just say to folks,
491
00:27:26.289 --> 00:27:30.430
invest in these four buckets of your happiness portfolio, faith, family, community,
492
00:27:30.450 --> 00:27:32.490
and work. If you're not part of the faith community,
493
00:27:33.009 --> 00:27:35.630
become part of one, find one, and engage with it,
494
00:27:35.690 --> 00:27:39.450
and develop that sense of deeper, richer meaning and purpose
495
00:27:39.519 --> 00:27:42.390
in life. And engage in family. Again, there's a lot
496
00:27:42.410 --> 00:27:46.230
of debates right now about family formation and marriage and
497
00:27:46.269 --> 00:27:50.400
childbearing and ways to try and encourage that. And then
498
00:27:50.500 --> 00:27:53.099
community and work. You know, community maybe is the more
499
00:27:53.140 --> 00:27:55.000
broad bucket that you talk about a lot in your paper,
500
00:27:55.079 --> 00:27:58.119
this idea of these other community elements. Arthur Brooks talks
501
00:27:58.140 --> 00:28:01.349
about it as friendships, just lots of close friendships. And
502
00:28:01.369 --> 00:28:06.029
then meaningful work where you're employed or doing something constructive
503
00:28:06.329 --> 00:28:08.930
for your fellow man. So I throw all that out
504
00:28:08.950 --> 00:28:12.210
to you. Is the solution to the erosion of civil
505
00:28:12.250 --> 00:28:15.579
society just as simple as saying, invest in your faith,
506
00:28:15.730 --> 00:28:18.579
your family, your community, and your work? Can that just
507
00:28:18.619 --> 00:28:20.359
be part of the solution or is that too short-sighted?
508
00:28:20.480 --> 00:28:22.400
I think it is part of the solution. I think
509
00:28:22.460 --> 00:28:23.660
it's something that we need to be a little bit
510
00:28:23.720 --> 00:28:26.940
careful of because there's
definitional questions for all these things.
511
00:28:27.900 --> 00:28:31.309
What about faith? What constitutes that? What constitutes a family?
512
00:28:31.329 --> 00:28:34.990
I don't want to sort of turn this into yet
513
00:28:35.029 --> 00:28:38.130
another weapon in our culture wars that we're facing where
514
00:28:38.150 --> 00:28:40.750
you're going to beat up on people because they're view
515
00:28:40.789 --> 00:28:42.950
of what a family is is different than yours. But
516
00:28:42.970 --> 00:28:45.390
I do think having something that's a family to you
517
00:28:45.569 --> 00:28:49.230
is vitally important. Having something that you believe in that's
518
00:28:49.329 --> 00:28:51.789
bigger than yourself, if we want to think of faith
519
00:28:51.890 --> 00:28:54.950
as being that, something that's larger than yourself, I think
520
00:28:55.089 --> 00:28:58.529
that we want to encourage people to have. We want
521
00:28:58.549 --> 00:29:01.490
them to invest in their community and care about their community.
522
00:29:01.509 --> 00:29:04.769
And I think we do want people to work because
523
00:29:04.829 --> 00:29:08.359
it offers a great deal of satisfaction and as well as,
524
00:29:08.369 --> 00:29:10.910
of course, making it possible for society to function. So
525
00:29:10.950 --> 00:29:14.230
I think the things you identify are hugely important. I
526
00:29:14.269 --> 00:29:16.710
think it's a question of how we approach them and
527
00:29:16.750 --> 00:29:19.589
how we invite people. Basically, we want to invite people in,
528
00:29:19.609 --> 00:29:21.450
not go out and pummel them.
529
00:29:22.809 --> 00:29:26.630
Well, there's a book by Brad Wilcox over at the
530
00:29:26.670 --> 00:29:30.269
Institute for Family Studies and University of Virginia called Get Married.
531
00:29:30.349 --> 00:29:32.450
And we've had him on the show before. And that's
532
00:29:32.490 --> 00:29:35.380
a very directly titled book, kind of on purpose, where
533
00:29:35.410 --> 00:29:37.579
he says, you know, I just want to encourage folks
534
00:29:37.619 --> 00:29:39.130
to get married. Of course, he talks about all the
535
00:29:39.170 --> 00:29:42.259
research that the into that. But I take your point
536
00:29:42.299 --> 00:29:46.819
that there is a conversation about inviting people in to
537
00:29:46.859 --> 00:29:50.200
these mechanisms of stronger civil society. I might want to
538
00:29:50.240 --> 00:29:53.380
be a little bit more strident with telling folks, go
539
00:29:53.440 --> 00:29:56.299
to church, find a faith community that gives you that
540
00:29:56.359 --> 00:30:00.519
sense of deep personal fulfillment that aligns in a way
541
00:30:00.559 --> 00:30:03.200
that kind of forces you to be better. Invest in
542
00:30:03.240 --> 00:30:06.690
your family. And I would, of course, encourage marriage and
543
00:30:07.210 --> 00:30:11.150
childbearing as a mechanism of civil society. In a lot
544
00:30:11.190 --> 00:30:13.089
of
ways, I think it's safe to say that the
545
00:30:13.150 --> 00:30:17.940
family is the most foundational institution of civil society. With
546
00:30:17.980 --> 00:30:19.880
all of that, I guess that kind of the only
547
00:30:19.900 --> 00:30:23.779
questions lingering in my mind are, is there anything we're missing?
548
00:30:23.960 --> 00:30:27.359
If you're talking out there to regular folks listening or
549
00:30:28.029 --> 00:30:32.470
civic society leaders in some capacity or even policymakers. Is
550
00:30:32.490 --> 00:30:34.890
there anything else from your paper that you think this
551
00:30:34.970 --> 00:30:38.730
is what's been missing in our national conversation about civil
552
00:30:38.769 --> 00:30:40.880
society being under threat and how to fix it?
553
00:30:41.619 --> 00:30:43.779
Well, I think it's whether or not we think that
554
00:30:43.839 --> 00:30:46.839
civil society is important and whether or not we believe
555
00:30:47.440 --> 00:30:48.980
that it makes a difference. And you can go back,
556
00:30:49.019 --> 00:30:51.539
you know, on the other side, you get sort of
557
00:30:51.599 --> 00:30:55.509
lots of different varieties of it. Bernie Sanders says he
558
00:30:55.549 --> 00:30:59.769
does not believe in charity. Government should run everything. That's
559
00:30:59.809 --> 00:31:03.670
certainly not going to get us there. We're seeing some
560
00:31:03.690 --> 00:31:07.220
stuff increasingly on the illiberal right that sort of takes
561
00:31:07.259 --> 00:31:09.400
the same thing. Government needs to step in and do
562
00:31:09.460 --> 00:31:13.099
things that we can't trust individuals as sort of an
563
00:31:13.220 --> 00:31:17.380
anti-civil society approach to these things. So I do think
564
00:31:17.420 --> 00:31:19.200
we have to be on the lookout for those things.
565
00:31:19.660 --> 00:31:21.920
And then we have to decide for ourselves if we want,
566
00:31:22.400 --> 00:31:26.450
if we believe it matters whether or not we're involved
567
00:31:26.569 --> 00:31:28.789
working with other people, whether or not we want these
568
00:31:28.829 --> 00:31:31.089
problems solved in our society. And I think we do.
569
00:31:32.329 --> 00:31:34.910
And I think we want that meaning that you talk
570
00:31:34.930 --> 00:31:37.000
about that you get from faith and family. People might
571
00:31:37.180 --> 00:31:38.700
get it from that or they get from other things,
572
00:31:38.740 --> 00:31:41.759
but people want whatever it is. And then we can
573
00:31:41.779 --> 00:31:44.200
have a discussion on what is it that brings that
574
00:31:44.240 --> 00:31:47.579
to you? Is it faith and family? Is it meaningful
575
00:31:47.640 --> 00:31:53.579
charity work? What is it that is going to be
576
00:31:53.619 --> 00:31:56.700
in your life that is going to make your life
577
00:31:57.750 --> 00:32:00.029
a reason why you're here, as you put it earlier
578
00:32:00.069 --> 00:32:00.849
in the podcast?
579
00:32:02.190 --> 00:32:04.670
Michael, maybe one question or two before we start to
580
00:32:04.730 --> 00:32:06.670
wrap up. We're almost at time, but I want to
581
00:32:06.710 --> 00:32:08.309
lean into that a little bit. If you were to
582
00:32:08.390 --> 00:32:14.319
persuade someone as to why they should care about civil society. And,
583
00:32:14.339 --> 00:32:16.599
you know, if you imagine someone said, well, you know,
584
00:32:17.000 --> 00:32:18.779
I have a job and I can get all my
585
00:32:18.859 --> 00:32:21.700
food from Uber Eats, I can get all my social
586
00:32:21.740 --> 00:32:24.839
interaction from Tinder or video games, I can, you know,
587
00:32:24.859 --> 00:32:26.380
you go down the list of kind of all the
588
00:32:26.420 --> 00:32:28.519
ways modern society, in some ways, some of the blessings
589
00:32:28.559 --> 00:32:32.500
of modern technology have made it easier than ever to, again,
590
00:32:32.720 --> 00:32:37.319
kind of be a hyper atomized individual where many folks,
591
00:32:37.359 --> 00:32:40.569
I think, are not sort of forced to interact with
592
00:32:40.650 --> 00:32:43.890
other people or other civic institutions because of all these
593
00:32:43.930 --> 00:32:46.950
other things we have access to now, and maybe they think, well,
594
00:32:46.970 --> 00:32:49.700
I get my sense of purpose by being part of,
595
00:32:50.289 --> 00:32:53.630
you know, quote-unquote, the correct political coalition and voting for
596
00:32:53.769 --> 00:32:58.910
the quote-unquote correct candidates. For someone like that specifically, how
597
00:32:58.950 --> 00:33:01.259
do you persuade them that there's a lot more to
598
00:33:01.319 --> 00:33:03.900
life when it comes to happiness and meeting and for
599
00:33:03.940 --> 00:33:07.380
societal health, and civil society should play a role? What's
600
00:33:07.420 --> 00:33:10.559
the best persuasion for that yeah.
601
00:33:10.420 --> 00:33:13.460
They're out there living the introvert's dream right now and
602
00:33:13.480 --> 00:33:16.289
i i mean i i guess i would say to
603
00:33:16.329 --> 00:33:18.569
them more power to them if that's if that's what
604
00:33:18.630 --> 00:33:22.549
makes them happy in their life but if everybody behaves
605
00:33:22.589 --> 00:33:27.509
that way the society is going to crumble and it's
606
00:33:27.690 --> 00:33:30.839
it's less about persuading that one individual than it is
607
00:33:31.400 --> 00:33:36.019
persuading the more people who are not living the introvert's dream.
608
00:33:36.079 --> 00:33:38.880
They are not happy getting all their stuff, money, stuff,
609
00:33:38.900 --> 00:33:41.140
food from Uber's eat and they never have to drag
610
00:33:41.200 --> 00:33:44.759
or somebody. They can live online playing video games. We
611
00:33:44.819 --> 00:33:50.400
know there's numerous studies about the physical and mental damage
612
00:33:50.420 --> 00:33:53.500
that that does to individuals. People are not happy that way.
613
00:33:53.579 --> 00:33:56.859
If you do the surveys of people and you ask them,
614
00:33:56.900 --> 00:33:58.980
are you happy with you in your life? The people
615
00:33:59.019 --> 00:34:03.339
who don't have friends or social connection, they are not happy.
616
00:34:04.099 --> 00:34:06.990
Beyond that, things happen in your life. The number of
617
00:34:07.009 --> 00:34:09.690
people who tell us that they couldn't find a friend
618
00:34:09.730 --> 00:34:13.889
to lend them $ 500 in a crisis, that's really painful
619
00:34:13.929 --> 00:34:18.989
because things happen in people's lives. There's emergencies. What happens
620
00:34:19.070 --> 00:34:22.760
if you're in a hospital? You're going down to grab
621
00:34:22.780 --> 00:34:24.500
your Uber Eats and you're headed back down to play
622
00:34:24.519 --> 00:34:26.380
your video game and you fall down the stairs and
623
00:34:26.440 --> 00:34:29.699
something happens. If there's no one you can call for help,
624
00:34:30.679 --> 00:34:35.849
you're in trouble. And I think that that's, we don't
625
00:34:35.889 --> 00:34:37.369
want that to be our society.
626
00:34:38.309 --> 00:34:40.289
But Michael, I think it goes deeper than that, too,
627
00:34:40.349 --> 00:34:43.010
because even that, some of that survey data you mentioned, that,
628
00:34:43.030 --> 00:34:44.929
you know, how many folks out there say, well, I
629
00:34:44.949 --> 00:34:47.239
have a friend that I could call in an emergency
630
00:34:47.260 --> 00:34:51.340
to lend me $ 500, or to invoke another term, a
631
00:34:51.380 --> 00:34:53.980
local nonprofit here in Utah called the I Love You
632
00:34:54.000 --> 00:34:57.480
Bro Project, Joe Tuyana, who's the founder of that, he
633
00:34:57.539 --> 00:35:00.739
said that it's sort of a men's health support group
634
00:35:00.780 --> 00:35:03.849
that term doesn't give it proper justice, but for time,
635
00:35:04.250 --> 00:35:05.829
I'll leave it at that. We have great links we
636
00:35:05.849 --> 00:35:08.269
can send people towards on that. He's been on the
637
00:35:08.289 --> 00:35:10.380
show as well, but he describes it as he's trying
638
00:35:10.400 --> 00:35:14.179
to create 2am bros, meaning the kind of guy that
639
00:35:14.219 --> 00:35:16.500
you can call at 2am and he'll be there and
640
00:35:16.539 --> 00:35:18.719
he'll help you out. The reason I say it goes
641
00:35:18.780 --> 00:35:21.429
deeper than just that, well, if I have a financial emergency,
642
00:35:21.469 --> 00:35:24.269
I need $ 500, I don't know who to call. Some
643
00:35:24.349 --> 00:35:26.230
may say, well, hey, that's a great idea for a
644
00:35:26.289 --> 00:35:30.269
government program that says, hey, when you're in trouble, call
645
00:35:30.309 --> 00:35:34.710
this hotline and a government program will give you $ 500
646
00:35:34.110 --> 00:35:36.389
to address some of your immediate material need. And we
647
00:35:36.429 --> 00:35:38.449
have programs like that. And I'm not saying there's no
648
00:35:38.530 --> 00:35:42.710
place ever for emergency financial resources from the government. But
649
00:35:42.730 --> 00:35:46.150
there's something different about if I find myself in an
650
00:35:46.210 --> 00:35:50.150
emergency scenario, knowing, well, there's a government program out there
651
00:35:50.210 --> 00:35:53.820
that can probably help me versus this friend who or
652
00:35:53.860 --> 00:35:57.119
this person in my church, or this family member, I
653
00:35:57.159 --> 00:35:59.510
know I could call them. And whether it's financial need
654
00:35:59.550 --> 00:36:01.550
or something else, if it's 2 a.m. and I really
655
00:36:01.590 --> 00:36:04.789
need help, they will be there. Isn't there something different?
656
00:36:04.829 --> 00:36:07.869
It's not just about having the need met through some mechanism.
657
00:36:08.210 --> 00:36:11.289
There's something about the relational human experience that's that X
658
00:36:11.329 --> 00:36:13.489
factor of civil society that we still need.
659
00:36:14.269 --> 00:36:18.789
You're absolutely correct. I forget who the quote was from,
660
00:36:18.829 --> 00:36:22.440
but the idea of charity is ennobling of everybody. the
661
00:36:22.519 --> 00:36:25.780
giver and the recipient. If you call your bro at
662
00:36:25.780 --> 00:36:27.360
2 a.m. and he comes over and helps you out
663
00:36:27.389 --> 00:36:30.610
with whatever your problem is, that's good for both of you.
664
00:36:31.829 --> 00:36:35.309
And that's something that you'll benefit from and be better
665
00:36:35.369 --> 00:36:37.730
off and be happier for. And so will the guy
666
00:36:37.750 --> 00:36:39.550
who came over at 2 a.m. to help you out.
667
00:36:39.590 --> 00:36:42.710
He'll feel good about it. Everybody walks away feeling good.
668
00:36:44.150 --> 00:36:45.909
I'm not sure we could ask for much more than that.
669
00:36:45.949 --> 00:36:50.190
Everybody walks away feeling good. Talk about your win-win situations.
670
00:36:52.719 --> 00:36:55.139
Going back to the politics earlier that we talked about,
671
00:36:55.880 --> 00:36:59.579
politics too often is a zero-sum game. It's about I win,
672
00:36:59.619 --> 00:37:03.000
you lose, or you win and I lose. What we're
673
00:37:03.039 --> 00:37:06.719
talking about with civil society is win-win. Both people walk
674
00:37:06.739 --> 00:37:09.260
away from that transaction and they're happier than they were
675
00:37:09.300 --> 00:37:11.500
when they went in. I don't know what else we
676
00:37:11.519 --> 00:37:12.019
could ask for.
677
00:37:13.269 --> 00:37:16.329
Well, Michael, we're about there at time. Final question, and
678
00:37:16.369 --> 00:37:18.530
I do this as kind of my elevator question. If
679
00:37:18.550 --> 00:37:22.210
you've got 30 seconds with someone who says, hey, you know,
680
00:37:22.409 --> 00:37:25.070
you wrote that paper on civil society. I like civil society.
681
00:37:25.579 --> 00:37:28.119
What's
the most important thing I need to know? What's
682
00:37:28.159 --> 00:37:30.380
the most important thing I need to do? And if
683
00:37:30.400 --> 00:37:32.719
you have 30 seconds to answer their question, what's the
684
00:37:32.940 --> 00:37:34.119
biggest takeaway from all this?
685
00:37:34.900 --> 00:37:40.599
Civil society is vital to the American character. and to
686
00:37:40.639 --> 00:37:43.550
helping us solve the problems that we're facing in society.
687
00:37:44.130 --> 00:37:48.210
But it's fading. It doesn't have the power and authority
688
00:37:48.269 --> 00:37:51.349
it once had in our society. We really need to
689
00:37:51.409 --> 00:37:54.050
revitalize it. We need to be looking to civil society.
690
00:37:54.409 --> 00:37:56.699
We need to be part of our community. We need
691
00:37:56.719 --> 00:37:59.699
to be civil and inviting and willing to deal with
692
00:37:59.739 --> 00:38:03.000
people who don't necessarily agree with us. It'll make us happier.
693
00:38:03.360 --> 00:38:04.679
It'll make a better society.
694
00:38:05.599 --> 00:38:07.940
Well, Michael, I think we'll leave it there. The only
695
00:38:07.960 --> 00:38:09.320
thing I can add is that we need to make
696
00:38:09.559 --> 00:38:12.719
civility sexy again, make civil society the thing that this
697
00:38:12.760 --> 00:38:14.949
is what it means to be a great American, is
698
00:38:15.159 --> 00:38:17.429
I'm for civil society, I'm gonna do everything I can
699
00:38:17.449 --> 00:38:19.190
to build it back up. So thank you for your
700
00:38:19.210 --> 00:38:22.429
role in doing that with your new paper. Again, Michael Tanner,
701
00:38:22.469 --> 00:38:25.809
he's a senior fellow over at FreeOp over social mobility,
702
00:38:26.289 --> 00:38:29.909
and the paper is Civil Society Under Threat. We'll link
703
00:38:29.989 --> 00:38:32.659
to the FreeOp website so folks can read the whole thing.
704
00:38:32.699 --> 00:38:34.849
And Michael, just thanks for everything you're doing and thanks
705
00:38:34.869 --> 00:38:36.289
for being with us on Defending Ideas.
706
00:38:36.710 --> 00:38:37.429
It was a great day.
707
00:38:38.369 --> 00:38:41.449
Well, we will give you one final break before we
708
00:38:41.469 --> 00:38:44.070
leave you with some talking points. This is Defending Ideas.
709
00:38:44.090 --> 00:38:45.010
We'll be right back.
710
00:38:47.800 --> 00:38:50.400
Sometimes it's hard to keep up with the latest policy
711
00:38:50.420 --> 00:38:55.139
debate that affects your life. The solution? Subscribe to Sutherland
712
00:38:55.199 --> 00:38:59.579
Institute's weekly newsletter. where you'll find in-depth insights from seasoned
713
00:38:59.639 --> 00:39:04.610
policy experts, compelling multimedia, and advanced notice of special events.
714
00:39:05.369 --> 00:39:12.130
Visit SutherlandInstitute.org. Welcome back, and thanks again to Michael Tanner
715
00:39:12.210 --> 00:39:16.110
for his insights. Look, I don't want to oversell the point,
716
00:39:16.289 --> 00:39:19.590
but I might just a little. So here goes. The
717
00:39:19.659 --> 00:39:21.960
most important thing you or I can do to heal
718
00:39:22.119 --> 00:39:27.000
our nation's toxic, broken political culture is this. Take account
719
00:39:27.119 --> 00:39:30.449
of your life and identify who or what would I
720
00:39:30.489 --> 00:39:34.550
be willing to die for? My faith? My family? My friends?
721
00:39:35.369 --> 00:39:37.719
I borrowed that concept from Arthur Brooks, where I heard
722
00:39:37.760 --> 00:39:41.099
him speaking at an event where he said, essentially, that
723
00:39:41.119 --> 00:39:43.460
the two most important things to figure out in life are,
724
00:39:43.920 --> 00:39:46.619
number one, why you are alive, and number two, for
725
00:39:46.699 --> 00:39:49.280
what would you give your life? I get that that's
726
00:39:49.320 --> 00:39:52.500
kind of a dramatic way to demonstrate an important point.
727
00:39:53.079 --> 00:39:57.219
Your relationships with other people, such as through family, through
728
00:39:57.300 --> 00:40:01.219
churches or other faith communities, and other civic organizations, are
729
00:40:01.360 --> 00:40:06.030
much more important to happiness and meaning than national tribal
730
00:40:06.110 --> 00:40:10.630
politics are. So, we should orient our lives and society
731
00:40:10.650 --> 00:40:15.559
in general around those priorities. In other words, care more
732
00:40:15.900 --> 00:40:19.880
about what happens in your own home, neighborhood, congregation, and
733
00:40:20.059 --> 00:40:23.519
so on. That's it for this episode of Defending Ideas.
734
00:40:23.619 --> 00:40:28.550
If you enjoyed this discussion, please visit defendingideas.org, where you
735
00:40:28.590 --> 00:40:31.789
can access previous episodes and watch or listen on your
736
00:40:31.849 --> 00:40:36.309
favorite platform. Don't forget to subscribe to Defending Ideas on
737
00:40:36.429 --> 00:40:40.579
Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you like to get
738
00:40:40.599 --> 00:40:43.690
your shows. And please share this episode with a friend,
739
00:40:44.130 --> 00:40:48.110
family member, or co-worker who may find it valuable. And lastly,
740
00:40:48.139 --> 00:40:51.320
if you want to support the broader work of Sutherland Institute,
741
00:40:51.860 --> 00:40:54.840
and if you want more conversations like this, please make
742
00:40:54.880 --> 00:41:00.880
a contribution at sutherlandinstitute.org slash donate. Thanks again for joining
743
00:41:00.900 --> 00:41:04.389
us on Defending Ideas from the Sutherland Institute in Salt
744
00:41:04.409 --> 00:41:06.590
Lake City. I'm Nick Dunn. We'll see you next time.