TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:15.199 --> 00:00:16.399
Welcome to Deep Dives.
00:00:16.480 --> 00:00:16.800
I'm Dr.
00:00:16.879 --> 00:00:22.399
Justin Smith, pediatrician dad, in your guide through some of the most complex topics in child health and parenting.
00:00:22.640 --> 00:00:31.920
This season, we're taking a deep dive into vaccines, exploring the science, the controversies, the questions, and the conversations that have become some of the most challenging in modern parenting.
00:00:32.159 --> 00:00:35.679
In our first episode, we explored why vaccines became divisive.
00:00:35.840 --> 00:00:45.280
We talked about trust, we talked about social media, we talked about how reasonable people, because of their backgrounds and influences, can look at the same information and come to very different conclusions.
00:00:45.520 --> 00:00:49.679
Today we're going to discuss a story that changed vaccine conversations around the world.
00:00:49.840 --> 00:01:02.240
A story involving autism, a study in a prestigious medical journal, concerned parents, financial conflicts of interest, and a controversy that still influences public opinion nearly three decades later.
00:01:02.479 --> 00:01:08.319
If you spend enough time in vaccine discussions, you'll eventually hear one name, Andrew Wakefield.
00:01:08.480 --> 00:01:15.680
Some view him as a courageous whistleblower, others view him as the architect of one of the most damaging scientific scandals in modern medicine.
00:01:15.920 --> 00:01:26.159
But regardless of where you stand, or even if you've never heard of him, understanding his story is essential because the effects of what happened in the late 1990s are still shaping conversations today.
00:01:29.760 --> 00:01:32.000
Imagine you're a parent in 1998.
00:01:32.159 --> 00:01:34.400
The internet exists, but not in its current form.
00:01:34.640 --> 00:01:38.480
Most people get information from doctors, newspapers, magazines, and television.
00:01:38.719 --> 00:01:41.599
Autism is becoming a growing concern for many families.
00:01:41.760 --> 00:01:46.079
Researchers don't fully understand what causes it, and parents are searching for answers.
00:01:46.239 --> 00:01:48.959
What is the cause of such profound developmental delay?
00:01:49.120 --> 00:01:52.879
Parents would have been willing to do anything to prevent it from happening to their family.
00:01:53.040 --> 00:01:55.280
Then headlines began appearing around the world.
00:01:55.519 --> 00:02:02.959
A British doctor suggests that the MMR vaccine, the vaccine protecting against measles, mumps, and rubella, may be linked to autism.
00:02:03.359 --> 00:02:07.359
For parents already worried about autism, the headline is impossible to ignore.
00:02:07.519 --> 00:02:08.719
What if this is the answer?
00:02:08.879 --> 00:02:11.039
What if the medical community missed something?
00:02:11.199 --> 00:02:14.000
What if a routine childhood vaccine is causing harm?
00:02:14.240 --> 00:02:22.240
Questions spread rapidly, fear spreads even faster, and one of the most influential medical controversies in modern history begins.
00:02:24.159 --> 00:02:26.479
Why did this episode from the 90s matter?
00:02:26.639 --> 00:02:29.840
Because it really isn't about Andrew Wakefield, it's about trust.
00:02:30.000 --> 00:02:47.680
Because this story contains nearly every ingredient that still fuels vaccine debates today: scientific uncertainty, parental observations, media amplification, financial conflicts, institutional failures, questions about transparency, and competing claims about who deserves our trust.
00:02:47.840 --> 00:02:53.680
Understanding this story helps us understand why vaccine conversations remain so emotional today.
00:02:58.240 --> 00:03:00.879
So, what do the supporters of Wakefield say?
00:03:01.039 --> 00:03:05.280
Before examining what happened, it's important to understand why many defended Wakefield.
00:03:05.439 --> 00:03:08.879
Supporters argued that he was asking questions that deserved investigation.
00:03:09.120 --> 00:03:14.080
They would point out that many parents reported noticing developmental changes in their children after vaccination.
00:03:14.319 --> 00:03:24.000
They argued that medicine should investigate concerns rather than dismiss them, and definitely no one deserves to have their concerns dismissed without a true investigation and sincere discussion.
00:03:24.240 --> 00:03:28.240
Some believe Wakefield became a target because he challenged powerful institutions.
00:03:28.479 --> 00:03:33.360
Even today, many who distrust vaccine recommendations view Wakefield sympathetically.
00:03:33.520 --> 00:03:37.360
To them, he wasn't trying to create fear, he was trying to raise concerns.
00:03:37.599 --> 00:03:40.719
Whether that's true is part of what we're exploring today.
00:03:41.520 --> 00:03:44.400
The critics of Wakefield tell a very different story.
00:03:44.560 --> 00:03:47.439
They argue that his work was scientifically weak from the beginning.
00:03:47.599 --> 00:03:50.319
His famous study included only twelve children.
00:03:50.479 --> 00:03:57.599
Compare that to most widely publicized study with hundreds, thousands, lots of times even tens of thousands of participants.
00:03:57.840 --> 00:04:06.400
More importantly, critics argue that later investigations uncovered serious ethical and scientific problems that went far beyond ordinary scientific disagreement.
00:04:06.560 --> 00:04:13.599
From this perspective, the issue wasn't that Wakefield asked questions, the issue was how he conducted and presented his research.
00:04:18.399 --> 00:04:20.399
So, what do we know about the original study?
00:04:20.560 --> 00:04:27.279
In 1998, Wakefield and 12 co-authors published a paper in The Lancet, one of the world's most respected medical journals.
00:04:27.439 --> 00:04:32.480
The study described 12 children with developmental concerns and gastrointestinal symptoms.
00:04:32.639 --> 00:04:37.279
Several parents reported that
Load full transcript
behavioral changes seemed to occur after MMR vaccination.
00:04:37.439 --> 00:04:39.360
It's important to understand something here.
00:04:39.519 --> 00:04:42.639
The paper itself did not prove the MMR caught autism.
00:04:42.800 --> 00:04:43.439
It couldn't.
00:04:43.600 --> 00:04:46.560
The study designed wasn't capable of proving cause and effect.
00:04:46.720 --> 00:04:50.480
Andrew Wakefield has since acknowledged this limitation himself publicly.
00:04:50.639 --> 00:04:53.600
At most, it could raise concerns for future research.
00:04:53.759 --> 00:04:58.720
But during a press conference associated with publication of the paper, Wakefield went much further.
00:04:58.879 --> 00:05:04.959
He publicly suggested that parents might consider using separate vaccines rather than combined MMR vaccine.
00:05:05.120 --> 00:05:12.000
He said, and I quote, I can't support the continued use of these three vaccines given in combination until this issue has been resolved.
00:05:12.240 --> 00:05:18.800
This was a clear departure from the very cautious wording of the paper itself and effectively says that the use of MMR should stop.
00:05:19.040 --> 00:05:21.519
These comments generated enormous media attention.
00:05:21.680 --> 00:05:31.199
The hospital where Wakefield work released a video news release where Wakefield went on to say that the MMR vaccine should be, quote unquote, suspended in favor of the single vaccines.
00:05:31.360 --> 00:05:35.680
And even though the scientists debated nuances, the public heard a much simpler message.
00:05:35.920 --> 00:05:38.319
MMR vaccine may cause autism.
00:05:38.480 --> 00:05:40.319
That message spread around the world.
00:05:40.560 --> 00:05:50.079
Suspending use of MMR might not have been a bad idea if the study was conducted on a larger sample size and the science was sound, but I'll share more about why that might not have been the case.
00:05:53.199 --> 00:05:55.839
So why did this idea get so much traction?
00:05:56.079 --> 00:06:00.319
To understand why Wakefield's theory gained traction, we need to understand something about autism.
00:06:00.480 --> 00:06:03.920
The symptoms of autism often become noticeable during the second year of life.
00:06:04.079 --> 00:06:08.800
Coincidentally, that's around the same time period when children receive the MMR vaccine.
00:06:08.959 --> 00:06:12.959
Parents often remember a specific period when development concerns became apparent.
00:06:13.120 --> 00:06:18.720
A child stops speaking as much, a child becomes less socially engaged, a child begins missing milestones.
00:06:18.959 --> 00:06:24.959
When those observations occur close to a vaccination, it's normal and natural to wonder if the two events are connected.
00:06:25.199 --> 00:06:27.439
Human beings are wired to look for causes.
00:06:27.600 --> 00:06:30.240
We look for explanations, we search for patterns.
00:06:30.399 --> 00:06:37.120
Sometimes those patterns reveal genuine relationships, sometimes they don't,
but our brains are designed to notice them regardless.
00:06:37.360 --> 00:06:43.120
Wakefield's theory offered a possible explanation during a time when families desperately wanted answers.
00:06:44.720 --> 00:06:48.160
As concern grew, researchers around the world began investigating.
00:06:48.319 --> 00:06:49.600
This is an important point.
00:06:49.839 --> 00:06:52.480
The scientific community did not ignore the concern.
00:06:52.720 --> 00:06:54.560
Researchers studied it repeatedly.
00:06:54.720 --> 00:06:57.120
Large studies followed, then larger studies.
00:06:57.279 --> 00:07:02.079
Thousands of children, hundreds of thousands of children, even some with millions of children.
00:07:02.240 --> 00:07:06.879
They were conducted in different countries, different healthcare systems, by different research teams.
00:07:07.040 --> 00:07:08.240
And the question was simple.
00:07:08.399 --> 00:07:10.639
Does MMR increase the risk of autism?
00:07:10.879 --> 00:07:14.240
Study after study failed to find evidence supporting that claim.
00:07:14.399 --> 00:07:15.920
But here are just a few examples.
00:07:16.079 --> 00:07:23.600
A Danish study in the New England Journal of Medicine followed over 500,000 children and showed no difference in autism rates in the general population.
00:07:23.839 --> 00:07:28.959
Another question that came up could MMR trigger autism in someone who is genetically susceptible?
00:07:29.199 --> 00:07:33.759
So maybe not a risk to the whole population, but maybe individuals who might be at higher risk.
00:07:34.000 --> 00:07:40.560
Another study in the Journal of the American Medical Association examined 96,000 children who were higher risk.
00:07:40.720 --> 00:07:50.319
Most of them had an older sibling with autism, so they had a higher genetic risk, but they found no difference in the autism rates of those vaccinated against MMR and those who were not.
00:07:50.480 --> 00:08:00.399
Finally, a meta-analysis, which combines the results of multiple studies published by Luke Taylor in the journal Vaccine, looked at all available studies on the subject of MMR and autism.
00:08:00.720 --> 00:08:11.759
This included over 1.2 million children and showed no association between MMR and incidentally, they also looked at thimerosol or mercury and found no connection to autism.
00:08:12.079 --> 00:08:14.800
There'll be more on these things to come in a future episode.
00:08:14.959 --> 00:08:21.360
But while scientists were examining the autism question, another investigation was at beginning, and that was an investigation into Dr.
00:08:21.519 --> 00:08:22.800
Wakefield himself.
00:08:29.759 --> 00:08:34.799
When people hear that Wakefield's work was discredited, many assume scientists simply disagreed with him.
00:08:35.039 --> 00:08:36.639
The reality is more complicated.
00:08:36.879 --> 00:08:40.000
The concerns eventually extended far beyond scientific disagreement.
00:08:40.240 --> 00:08:43.039
One major issue involved financial
conflicts of interest.
00:08:43.200 --> 00:08:49.039
Investigators discovered that Wakefield had received funding connected to attorneys pursuing lawsuits against vaccine manufacturers.
00:08:49.519 --> 00:08:50.480
Here's the details.
00:08:50.720 --> 00:08:59.440
In 1996, a United Kingdom solicitor, Richard Barr, was organizing a class action lawsuit on behalf of parents who believe MMR had injured their children.
00:08:59.840 --> 00:09:04.879
Barr approached Wakefield based on some earlier work he had done with measles virus and inflammatory bowel disease.
00:09:05.279 --> 00:09:08.399
But this work began two years before the Lancet article was published.
00:09:08.720 --> 00:09:16.240
In addition, Barr was able to obtain 55,000 pounds to support Wakefield's study that eventually became the grounds for the Lancet article.
00:09:16.559 --> 00:09:24.799
Not only that, later financial records showed that Barr had paid a cumulative 435,000 pounds to Wakefield in exchange for expert witness and other work.
00:09:25.279 --> 00:09:27.919
Again, researchers receiving funding isn't unusual.
00:09:28.159 --> 00:09:31.279
The concern was whether these relationships had been adequately disclosed.
00:09:31.519 --> 00:09:37.279
The Lancet was not made aware of this financial relationship between Wakefield and Barr or Wakefield and a legal defense fund.
00:09:37.759 --> 00:09:40.000
In addition, investigators uncovered something else.
00:09:40.240 --> 00:09:47.759
Wakefield had been involved in patents and business interests related to alternative vaccine approaches, including the single antigen vaccines.
00:09:48.159 --> 00:09:55.120
Remember what Wakefield had publicly suggested after publication that parents consider separate vaccines rather than combined MMR vaccine?
00:09:55.679 --> 00:10:01.440
Critics argued that declining confidence in MMR could potentially benefit alternative vaccine strategies.
00:10:01.840 --> 00:10:06.720
Whether this was his intention remains debated, but the financial relationship raised serious questions.
00:10:07.039 --> 00:10:09.519
Then investigators turned their attention to the data itself.
00:10:09.840 --> 00:10:17.440
Investigative journalist Brian Deere spent years examining medical records and comparing them to descriptions in a published paper.
00:10:17.679 --> 00:10:20.159
His reporting suggested significant discrepancies.
00:10:20.480 --> 00:10:27.360
In some cases, developmental concerns appeared to have been documented before vaccination, even though published descriptions implied symptoms appeared after.
00:10:27.679 --> 00:10:29.919
If that's true, those differences weren't trivial.
00:10:30.159 --> 00:10:32.879
They directly affected the central narrative being promoted.
00:10:33.120 --> 00:10:37.039
Additional concerns emerged regarding laboratory fightings and data interpretation.
00:10:37.279 --> 00:10:42.960
Some researchers involved with related work later reported concerns about how results had been handled and presented.
00:10:44.320 --> 00:10:48.960
Some of them claimed that they found negative findings under slides that Dr.
00:10:49.120 --> 00:10:51.679
Wakefield came behind them and changed to positive.
00:10:52.080 --> 00:10:54.879
Then came perhaps the strangest detail in the entire story.
00:10:55.039 --> 00:11:01.200
According to testimony and later reports, Wakefield collected blood samples from children at his own son's birthday party.
00:11:01.360 --> 00:11:05.200
The children reportedly received small payments in exchange for providing blood samples.
00:11:05.519 --> 00:11:07.679
The images sounds almost unbelievable.
00:11:07.919 --> 00:11:13.120
Children at a birthday party, supposed to be playing games and cake, but instead they're getting blood draws.
00:11:14.159 --> 00:11:17.120
Wakefield later joked publicly about the event.
00:11:17.360 --> 00:11:23.120
But many researchers and ethicists viewed it as evidence of poor judgment regarding research standards involving children.
00:11:23.279 --> 00:11:26.320
As investigations continued, the questions grew.
00:11:26.960 --> 00:11:29.120
Were conflicts of interest fully disclosed?
00:11:29.279 --> 00:11:30.879
Were data accurately reported?
00:11:31.120 --> 00:11:32.720
Were ethical standards followed?
00:11:32.960 --> 00:11:34.720
Could the findings be replicated?
00:11:34.879 --> 00:11:39.919
Increasingly, regulators and investigators concluded the answer was no.
00:11:41.120 --> 00:11:44.399
In 2010, the Lancet fully retracted the paper.
00:11:44.559 --> 00:11:45.519
That's significant.
00:11:45.759 --> 00:11:47.679
Retractions are relatively rare.
00:11:47.919 --> 00:11:50.559
Retraction isn't simply scientific disagreement.
00:11:50.720 --> 00:11:54.240
It means the journal no longer stands behind the publication.
00:11:54.559 --> 00:12:02.879
Around the same time, the UK's General Medical Counsel concluded that Wakefield had acted dishonestly and irresponsibly in multiple aspects of the research.
00:12:03.039 --> 00:12:06.559
He ultimately lost his license to practice medicine in the United Kingdom.
00:12:06.720 --> 00:12:09.440
For many physicians and scientists, the case was settled.
00:12:09.679 --> 00:12:11.759
The original findings could not be reproduced.
00:12:11.919 --> 00:12:13.279
The paper had been retracted.
00:12:13.440 --> 00:12:16.879
The controversy should have ended, but it didn't.
00:12:19.759 --> 00:12:22.000
Why did the controversy continue?
00:12:22.320 --> 00:12:23.519
The reason is simple.
00:12:23.679 --> 00:12:25.360
This was never only about a paper.
00:12:25.519 --> 00:12:31.200
It was about parents, experiences, stories, fear, trust, and unanswered questions.
00:12:31.440 --> 00:12:34.639
Many parents remained convinced that they had witnessed changes in their children.
00:12:34.799 --> 00:12:38.559
For them, hearing that Wakefield was wrong did not erase what they believed they had seen.
00:12:38.720 --> 00:12:41.120
And this highlights
something important about human nature.
00:12:41.360 --> 00:12:45.120
Personal experience is often more persuasive than scientific consensus.
00:12:45.279 --> 00:12:49.519
Not because people are irrational, but because personal experiences feel real.
00:12:49.679 --> 00:12:52.480
They're immediate and powerful and emotional.
00:12:52.639 --> 00:12:54.559
That's true for all of us.
00:12:55.679 --> 00:12:59.039
So what we actually know, what can we confidently say?
00:12:59.279 --> 00:13:02.159
We know the original study involved only 12 children.
00:13:02.320 --> 00:13:04.559
We know it could not establish causation.
00:13:04.799 --> 00:13:07.759
We know major conflicts of interest were later identified.
00:13:07.919 --> 00:13:12.799
We know investigators reported discrepancies between medical records and published descriptions.
00:13:12.960 --> 00:13:16.159
We know ethical concerns emerged regarding research practices.
00:13:16.320 --> 00:13:18.559
We know the paper was ultimately retracted.
00:13:18.639 --> 00:13:21.759
We know Wakefield lost his medical license in the United Kingdom.
00:13:21.919 --> 00:13:27.679
And we know numerous large studies involving millions of children have not found evidence that MMR causes autism.
00:13:28.399 --> 00:13:30.159
But there's still things we don't know.
00:13:30.399 --> 00:13:32.799
There are still important questions surrounding autism.
00:13:32.960 --> 00:13:35.279
Why have diagnoses increased dramatically?
00:13:35.440 --> 00:13:38.320
How much is explained by broader diagnostic criteria?
00:13:38.480 --> 00:13:40.639
How much reflects improved recognition?
00:13:40.879 --> 00:13:42.639
Are environmental factors contributing?
00:13:42.799 --> 00:13:45.039
Are genetic factors responsible?
00:13:45.279 --> 00:13:46.320
Are both involved.
00:13:46.559 --> 00:13:49.200
Researchers continue exploring these questions today.
00:13:49.440 --> 00:13:54.879
The existence of answered questions about autism, however, is not evidence that MMR causes autism.
00:13:55.039 --> 00:13:58.720
Those are two separate questions, and keeping them separate is important.
00:13:59.519 --> 00:14:03.200
As we close today, I think the important lesson from the Wakefield story is this.
00:14:03.440 --> 00:14:05.519
Science is not a collection of perfect people.
00:14:05.759 --> 00:14:13.919
Science is a process, a process that includes mistakes, corrections, challenges, debates, and investigations, and unfortunately sometimes misconduct.
00:14:14.080 --> 00:14:16.960
The Wakefield story reminds us that experts can be wrong.
00:14:17.200 --> 00:14:19.440
Researchers can be wrong, and journals can be wrong.
00:14:19.600 --> 00:14:25.279
But it also reminds us that science contains mechanisms designed to avert cover errors and correct them over time.
00:14:25.519 --> 00:14:30.320
It's also important to separate Andrew Wakefield from the families who were influenced by his claims.
00:14:30.480 --> 00:14:33.440
Many parents weren't following Wakefield because they hated science.
00:14:33.600 --> 00:14:37.440
They are following him because they were looking for answers and he seemed to be providing them.
00:14:37.600 --> 00:14:40.799
That desire for answers deserves our respect.
00:14:41.600 --> 00:14:48.000
I don't think that many people today who are questioning vaccines would point back to Wakefield as a core source.
00:14:48.159 --> 00:14:55.679
However, his skepticism and his challenges underlie a lot of the negativity that we see around vaccines to this day.
00:14:56.000 --> 00:14:59.679
Next time we'll tackle one of the most common concerns parents raise today.
00:15:00.000 --> 00:15:02.960
Can children's immune systems really handle the vaccine schedule?
00:15:03.039 --> 00:15:06.159
Or as many parents put it, is it too many too soon?
00:15:06.399 --> 00:15:07.759
I'll see you next time.