TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:08.257 --> 00:00:16.809
Welcome to Doyle Clayton Podcasts, DC Talks, a series of podcasts where we take a deeper dive into legal topics or HR issues.
00:00:17.469 --> 00:00:21.795
I'm Emma O'Connor, a partner in the employment team and head of HR training.
00:00:22.495 --> 00:00:30.786
I'm joined in this podcast by Peter Daly, a partner in the employment team who was involved in the recent Four Women Scotland and Scottish Ministers case.
00:00:31.207 --> 00:00:32.469
Peter, thank you so much for joining me.
00:00:32.628 --> 00:00:33.469
Thanks for having me.
00:00:33.601 --> 00:00:37.204
Peter, can you just start by explaining a little bit about your involvement in the case?
00:00:37.945 --> 00:00:46.073
So we were acting for three separate organisations who jointly provided an intervention to the Supreme Court.
00:00:46.353 --> 00:00:52.918
The organisations were Scottish Lesbians, the Lesbian Project and LGB Alliance.
00:00:53.359 --> 00:01:05.736
Their submission was about the importance of this case to lesbians, and in particular, the case was determining what the meaning of the words woman, man and and sex were under the Act.
00:01:06.578 --> 00:01:21.706
And for lesbians, who are emphatically same-sex attracted women, all of their legal rights under the Equality Act were dependent upon a biological interpretation of the words woman and sex in the act.
00:01:22.548 --> 00:01:26.013
So there's been lots of press coverage and lots of reports about the case.
00:01:26.072 --> 00:01:34.986
And I think it would be helpful just to take a step back and actually discuss what the background to this case was and who 4 Women Scotland were.
00:01:35.298 --> 00:01:35.778
Yeah.
00:01:35.798 --> 00:01:55.796
So For Women Scotland are a feminist campaigning organisation up in Scotland who had become engaged on issues around sex and gender and what they thought as being a move towards defining women other than by biology, which has, in their view, incredibly detrimental effects.
00:01:56.036 --> 00:02:10.211
And in Scotland in particular, this was very live because the Scottish government were bringing in the Gender Recognition Reform Bill, which would have effectively enabled cell ID in Scotland, and this was in about 2017, 2018, and carried on for a while afterwards.
00:02:11.013 --> 00:02:24.132
Four Women Scotland are three incredible women who I had the pleasure of meeting, who they are Marion Miller, Trina Budge, and Susan Smith, who in their own time started campaigning on these issues and informing themselves about these issues.
00:02:24.973 --> 00:02:34.679
And they campaigned around the GRR Bill, the Gender Recognition Reform Bill, but they also saw this piece of legislation come up, which formed the basis of this case.
00:02:34.718 --> 00:02:49.233
And that legislation was brought in by the Scottish government with the intention of ensuring that in the appointment of people to public boards by the government, there would be a guarantee
Load full transcript
of 50% female appointments.
00:02:50.018 --> 00:03:04.120
However, when the guidance for the legislation was brought forward, Forewoman Scotland noticed that the definition of women was not a biological definition, but initially, at least, was purely on the basis of self-ID, anybody who identifies as a woman.
00:03:05.001 --> 00:03:10.689
Forewoman Scotland brought a judicial review against that and was successful.
00:03:11.681 --> 00:03:16.606
The Scottish government then went away and came back and said, OK, fine, it's not on a self-ID basis.
00:03:17.127 --> 00:03:20.050
It's on the basis of a gender recognition certificate.
00:03:21.111 --> 00:03:24.776
And that was the Scottish government position all the way through up to the Supreme Court.
00:03:25.097 --> 00:03:33.425
So Four Women Scotland launched a second case about the updated guidance on certification.
00:03:34.186 --> 00:03:36.169
They lost in the outer house in Scotland.
00:03:36.209 --> 00:03:40.993
They lost in the inner house in Scotland and then appealed it to the Supreme Court.
00:03:41.409 --> 00:03:44.663
So what is a gender recognition certificate?
00:03:44.703 --> 00:03:51.049
It's a document issued by the government under the Gender Recognition Act 2004, which...
00:03:51.490 --> 00:03:56.316
In order to get a certificate, one must jump through some legislative hoops.
00:03:56.575 --> 00:04:00.941
So you have to have been living in the opposite gender for two years.
00:04:01.562 --> 00:04:02.902
You need to pay a£5 fee.
00:04:04.044 --> 00:04:11.073
You need to have a formal diagnosis of gender dysphoria and you need a supporting letter from two practitioners.
00:04:11.713 --> 00:04:23.541
You then submit your application to what's called the gender recognition panel and they will assess it, make sure that you've met the requirements and will then issue you with a gender recognition certificate.
00:04:23.581 --> 00:04:31.216
Using that certificate, you can then go back and change the sex on your birth certificate and do various other things.
00:04:31.235 --> 00:04:38.069
And about somewhere north of 95% of all applicants are successful in being granted it.
00:04:39.050 --> 00:04:40.031
There are about 8,000...
00:04:40.994 --> 00:04:43.581
roughly, gender recognition certificates that have been issued.
00:04:44.704 --> 00:04:50.461
But it's important to note that this case was only ever about people with gender recognition certificates.
00:04:51.223 --> 00:05:06.738
It was never the case, and it was made explicitly clear in the second appeal in the inner house that a person without a gender recognition certificate, regardless of how they identify, is, for the purposes of the Equality Act, their biological sex.
00:05:07.238 --> 00:05:11.843
This case was only about the biological sex of people with gender recognition certificates.
00:05:12.202 --> 00:05:12.463
Thank you.
00:05:12.483 --> 00:05:14.805
I think that's really helpful to clear up that confusion.
00:05:15.406 --> 00:05:20.250
So we get to the Supreme Court, and obviously we have an 80-page judgment.
00:05:20.411 --> 00:05:22.673
What decision did the Supreme Court come to?
00:05:23.194 --> 00:05:28.684
Well, in a nutshell, that in the Equality Act, sex means biological sex, full stop.
00:05:31.168 --> 00:05:34.153
But importantly, this was not any kind of departure.
00:05:34.192 --> 00:05:36.416
This is what the law has always been.
00:05:37.459 --> 00:05:47.093
And I think on one view, the judgment is a kind of fairly measured and sensible.
00:05:47.613 --> 00:05:49.475
But on any view, it's a measured and sensible judgment.
00:05:49.797 --> 00:05:55.062
But on one view, it's simply the Supreme Court saying the law is what it is and what it has always been.
00:05:55.103 --> 00:06:07.055
The reason why I think it's had such effect and has got such coverage is because the law has been misapplied so extensively over the past 10 years or more.
00:06:07.716 --> 00:06:12.262
A large number of people walking around with it have very significant misapprehension as to what the law was.
00:06:12.737 --> 00:06:16.221
I think there's also been some confusion.
00:06:16.281 --> 00:06:17.384
I think you're absolutely right.
00:06:17.584 --> 00:06:18.785
This judgment didn't change the law.
00:06:18.824 --> 00:06:20.747
The law has been what the law has been.
00:06:21.088 --> 00:06:31.060
But I think the other confusion has been there's some suggestion that this is somehow up for negotiation, that employers don't have to comply with this judgment.
00:06:31.100 --> 00:06:32.221
What's your view on that?
00:06:32.781 --> 00:06:44.374
You don't really get much more of a helpful guidance, if you like, than the Supreme Court's issuing an 88-page judgment, reaffirming what the law has always been.
00:06:44.394 --> 00:07:05.956
One of the reasons why it's an 88-page judgment is because there's such a granular approach line by line to the Equality Act in examining what are the protections determined for sex, men, women, what would be the implications if the meaning of those words was certificated sex, i.e.
00:07:06.338 --> 00:07:20.185
not a biological approach, and explaining why the implications of having a certificated sex approach would create a complete confusion and a nonsense which would defeat the original intentions of the act.
00:07:20.865 --> 00:07:41.824
Looking in particular at our clients, the lesbian interveners, the implications of sex being on a certificated basis would be very, very severe because it would mean that no lesbian group or association would be able to set up or hold events and be able to say, we do not allow males in our presence.
00:07:42.084 --> 00:07:55.105
And if a male attended who asserted a sexual attraction towards women and a gender identity of being a woman, him or herself, there would be no lawful basis to exclude them.
00:07:55.586 --> 00:08:02.557
And this is something that's really come up a lot for lesbian organisations and
lesbian businesses over the past three, four, five years.
00:08:02.598 --> 00:08:16.612
On occasions where, for example, lesbian dating apps or lesbian events have been set up, on the basis of being explicitly female only, they've attracted huge amounts of vitriol, they've been shut down, they've been kicked out of venues.
00:08:17.192 --> 00:08:19.336
This is a genuine, very, very substantial thing.
00:08:19.375 --> 00:08:29.274
And what makes it shocking as well is that it's often been done by the antagonists on the basis that this is not just a lawful thing to do, but a morally right thing to do.
00:08:29.834 --> 00:08:49.514
So having this reassertion by the apex court in the UK of there being, firstly, meaningful protections for same-sex attractive people, and secondly, explaining what they are and making it explicit as to how they work and why they work and the purpose of that legislation is incredibly helpful.
00:08:50.596 --> 00:08:58.135
So if the definition of man and woman for the purposes of the Equality Act has not changed, This judgment hasn't changed that.
00:08:58.676 --> 00:09:14.474
What, in your view, do you think has created this confusion and misapplying, if you like, the law in things like employment policies or decisions that employers have made with regards to staff who identify differently to their biological sex?
00:09:15.235 --> 00:09:19.679
I think that there are several factors that have caused this.
00:09:20.039 --> 00:09:24.826
I mean, the overriding factor is that a load of nonsense has been spoken for a very long time.
00:09:25.057 --> 00:09:37.263
There's a lot of policies that have been put about and templates and organizations that are fed into policies who have simply and straightforwardly misled the law, but they've done so from an apparent position of authority.
00:09:37.283 --> 00:09:53.797
So, you know, your average HR director, or HR business partner is not going to necessarily know the ins and outs and detail of various regulations and the backgrounds of the Equality Act and where pregnancy discrimination comes from and jurisprudence and all of these issues.
00:09:54.778 --> 00:10:00.504
They're going to look for a reasonably authoritative source to advise them to put in place policies.
00:10:01.245 --> 00:10:31.255
And where, for example, you've got organisations like Stonewall who used to be an extremely reputable organization who have previously achieved incredible things and who are very well connected in politics and in business they are a plausible authoritative or they were a plausible and authoritative source of information when they go around and say you know don't look at sex look at gender don't look at biology, look at identity, people will and did take them seriously.
00:10:31.296 --> 00:10:34.200
And it's perfectly rational and you can see why people would.
00:10:35.280 --> 00:10:58.192
When you have things like the Workplace Equality Index, which is effectively a league table of businesses
and organisations who have put in place pro-LGBTQ plus policies, You go down that league table and you look at the names on it and you're talking about government departments, you're talking about the biggest law firms in the country, you're talking about the biggest industry players in the country.
00:10:58.212 --> 00:11:06.562
So you can look at that list and say, well, look, if these people are doing this, we're going to do it because clearly they're not going to be putting in place unlawful.
00:11:06.702 --> 00:11:11.668
And there have been some lawyers who've been saying for quite some time, what are you doing?
00:11:11.707 --> 00:11:15.312
This is utterly bonkers, but haven't been listened to.
00:11:16.013 --> 00:11:16.474
And I think...
00:11:17.153 --> 00:11:23.782
what the Supreme Court has effectively said is that, as has been said a few times now, Stonewall law is not the law.
00:11:24.482 --> 00:11:28.067
So I think that's where it's come from and that's what's happened from it.
00:11:28.107 --> 00:11:36.398
There's an additional element to it as well, which is that we all want society to be better.
00:11:36.437 --> 00:11:39.903
We don't just go to work to earn a salary.
00:11:39.923 --> 00:11:42.546
We want to leave the world in a better place in which we find it.
00:11:43.106 --> 00:11:53.179
And I think there's been incredibly effective lobbying across the piece globally on this idea that the next big civil rights movement is trans equality.
00:11:54.322 --> 00:12:11.682
And the problem with that is that there is a conflict of rights, and there are rights that women hold in particular, and that lesbians hold, which are impinged by a sequence of policies which removes the relevance of biology to human sex.
00:12:12.663 --> 00:12:21.183
And I think that while it would be possible to look at the effort of the Four Moons Scotland Judgment and think, well, how does this impact our workplace policies?
00:12:22.498 --> 00:12:37.639
What will be slightly harder will be to get into a mindset where we have to actually confront and look at this conflict of rights while ensuring that we don't go too far back the other way and that trans people's rights also aren't undermined.
00:12:37.759 --> 00:12:44.188
Because again, the Four Women Scotland judgment makes it very clear that there are real substantive protections in law for trans people.
00:12:45.591 --> 00:12:49.015
And if you just explain what those protections are under the Equality
00:12:49.115 --> 00:12:49.297
Act.
00:12:49.397 --> 00:12:49.716
Sure.
00:12:49.797 --> 00:12:56.914
There's a protect the characteristic of gender reassignment, which is Section 7 of the Act, and that to protect a characteristic in the same way that sex is.
00:12:57.817 --> 00:13:09.693
And it's for anybody who has undergone, is proposing to undergo, or is undergoing a process of changing the physiological or other characteristics related to their sex.
00:13:10.315 --> 00:13:13.418
The key thing is proposing
to undergoing or has undergone.
00:13:13.438 --> 00:13:30.494
And with any other protected characteristic under the Act, people with that protected characteristic of gender reassignment, regardless of whether or not they've got a gender recognition certificate, are protected from direct and indirect discrimination, victimisation and harassment.
00:13:31.522 --> 00:13:32.363
So we've got the judgment.
00:13:32.403 --> 00:13:39.952
There's been lots of talk, and obviously social media is a wonderful echo chamber, whichever side of the debate that you're on.
00:13:40.013 --> 00:13:50.225
But let's create some sort of practical common sense discussion here around what practical things can employers do, taking into consideration this judgment.
00:13:50.466 --> 00:13:52.048
You've got to go back through your policies.
00:13:52.307 --> 00:13:56.472
You've got to work out who wrote them and based on what sources.
00:13:57.153 --> 00:13:58.716
So I'm sure we'll come on to it.
00:13:58.775 --> 00:14:00.158
Toilets is a particular thing.
00:14:00.610 --> 00:14:06.820
But this also impacts on things like maternity policy.
00:14:06.860 --> 00:14:10.225
It impacts on changing rooms, not just toilets.
00:14:10.566 --> 00:14:17.658
If you can think of any situation or scenario in which a person's sex is relevant, there will be a policy for it.
00:14:18.458 --> 00:14:25.104
And if you're not careful, you may well have taken on board just wrong advice and have put that in place.
00:14:26.725 --> 00:14:28.107
So the first thing to do is to read your policies.
00:14:28.368 --> 00:14:31.572
Yeah, and really look at the language that's been used within those policies.
00:14:31.652 --> 00:14:43.527
So if we're referring to gender as a protected character, which it isn't under the Equality Act, so that's obviously one of the kind of the red flags that employers should be looking at.
00:14:43.687 --> 00:14:46.090
What should employers be doing about bathrooms?
00:14:46.389 --> 00:14:52.677
Well, I think toilets are only, they're not actually dealt with in great detail in formal in Scotland in the judgment.
00:14:53.090 --> 00:14:57.076
But in practical terms, it's probably where it bites most in the employment sphere.
00:14:57.096 --> 00:15:07.576
I mean, the straightforward and simple answer is you have to have segregated toilets by sex, and that has to be by biological sex.
00:15:08.297 --> 00:15:10.902
It doesn't matter what gender identity a person has.
00:15:10.922 --> 00:15:14.128
It doesn't matter what gender recognition certificate a person has.
00:15:14.908 --> 00:15:15.630
So that's easy.
00:15:17.052 --> 00:15:30.711
But We don't have workplaces or offices or whatever it may be where we can always completely reconfigure the physical layout of the building at a moment's notice.
00:15:31.774 --> 00:15:34.238
The wrong policies have been in place for quite some time.
00:15:34.258 --> 00:15:37.182
And so some businesses are going to say, hang on a minute.
00:15:37.783 --> 00:15:38.405
Okay, fine.
00:15:38.426 --> 00:15:45.107
I understand biological sex is the determinant, but actually the lose policy on the second floor of our building.
00:15:45.148 --> 00:15:46.769
They are what they are.
00:15:46.809 --> 00:15:48.451
We can't change them around.
00:15:48.852 --> 00:15:49.754
This causes a problem.
00:15:50.754 --> 00:15:56.361
So this is a long way round of saying it's going to be case by case.
00:15:57.683 --> 00:15:58.585
Case by case, actually.
00:15:58.644 --> 00:16:00.687
If you've got that in your policy, that's also a problem.
00:16:00.727 --> 00:16:02.409
But I'll come back to that.
00:16:02.951 --> 00:16:08.597
You're just going to have to look at the practical implications on the floor, literally, of the layout of your building.
00:16:08.994 --> 00:16:10.135
and work out what to do next.
00:16:10.756 --> 00:16:18.230
And we've had some interim guidance, haven't we, from the Equality and Human Rights Commission, and they've been very clear on that point as well.
00:16:18.370 --> 00:16:21.195
It is compulsory too, is the language that they've used.
00:16:21.495 --> 00:16:24.860
And their guidance is quite interesting, isn't it, Peter, because it's not really guidance.
00:16:25.000 --> 00:16:26.123
It's not guidance, no.
00:16:26.224 --> 00:16:28.888
And the word guidance has been attached to it.
00:16:29.048 --> 00:16:31.924
It's been picked up by the press and run as interim guidance.
00:16:32.205 --> 00:16:32.986
It's not guidance.
00:16:33.167 --> 00:16:33.847
It's an update.
00:16:34.269 --> 00:16:42.221
Guidance is usually issued by the EHRC to give examples of things that you might do or could do.
00:16:42.241 --> 00:16:48.111
This is a very short, very straightforward statement of the law.
00:16:48.131 --> 00:16:49.433
It's not optional.
00:16:50.049 --> 00:16:50.931
But yes, you're right.
00:16:51.072 --> 00:16:54.096
It's been extremely clear and extremely helpful.
00:16:54.176 --> 00:17:05.593
It's interesting that one of the reactions of all women in Scotland, which is, I suppose, in one way, a rational reaction to being told that you got the law wrong for a very long time, is for a lot of people to say, well, I don't understand.
00:17:05.633 --> 00:17:06.954
That's not clear at all.
00:17:07.756 --> 00:17:08.696
The judgment's very clear.
00:17:08.738 --> 00:17:11.300
And so the reaction was, well, we need to see some guidance.
00:17:11.320 --> 00:17:12.363
We need some explanation.
00:17:13.805 --> 00:17:14.306
But you don't.
00:17:14.526 --> 00:17:15.386
What more do you need?
00:17:15.446 --> 00:17:15.788
88
00:17:15.847 --> 00:17:18.592
pages from the Supreme Court.
00:17:19.212 --> 00:17:19.933
You know, what more...
00:17:20.034 --> 00:17:23.140
guidance, affirmation do you need as to what you need to do?
00:17:23.160 --> 00:17:24.262
This is precisely right.
00:17:24.482 --> 00:17:35.766
But if you did need more, then you've got this interim update from the Equality
and Human Rights Commission, which is admirably clear and to the point, and I don't think leaves any room for misunderstanding.
00:17:36.287 --> 00:17:38.330
So what happens now with that update?
00:17:38.411 --> 00:17:40.435
Because obviously it is only interim.
00:17:40.496 --> 00:17:45.499
What do you think might you know when might we see some sort of formal changes being made
00:17:45.818 --> 00:18:15.363
well there's a code of practice which i think is is for service providers rather than employers so the uh and that code of practice is i think due before the summer and it's important to realize that the the the requirements under the equality act for single sex spaces are come in different sections of the act whether or not you're talking about employment and workplaces Or if you're talking about services, so shops, theatres, swimming pools, that kind of thing.
00:18:16.684 --> 00:18:26.219
And the legislative regime is slightly different for those two things, but it doesn't really matter that it's still a question of biological sex.
00:18:27.440 --> 00:18:39.044
The regime under workplaces, which I think is what we're talking about, It is contained in legislation, secondary legislation, which is the Workplace Health, Safety and Welfare Regulations 1992.
00:18:40.685 --> 00:18:52.020
And they require that for sanitary facilities, which is legislation speak for toilets and changing rooms and washing facilities, separate facilities have to be given for men and for women.
00:18:52.761 --> 00:18:56.047
In the case of toilets, they have to be separate sex.
00:18:56.287 --> 00:19:14.993
But if you've got a single floor to ceiling lockable room, which can only be used by one person at a time and isn't a cubicle, is a separate room and has a sink and a loo behind the door, which we'll call unisex loos, that is acceptable.
00:19:15.746 --> 00:19:22.011
And many businesses do have those, and increasingly you see in new builds, like that's the norm in any event.
00:19:22.873 --> 00:19:34.002
Unisex loos is a term which can sometimes be confused between, I mean, I've seen some reference to unisex loos, meaning men or women can use them at the same time, but that's not correct.
00:19:34.263 --> 00:19:40.650
You have to picture yourself, a way of thinking about it is your average loo on a plane is a unisex loo.
00:19:41.170 --> 00:19:45.013
Only one person uses it at a time, but it could be a male or it could be a female.
00:19:46.082 --> 00:19:47.624
And that's fine.
00:19:47.703 --> 00:19:49.506
So you've got those, you're home and host.
00:19:50.106 --> 00:20:00.660
I think the other difficulty is that there might be some employers thinking, oh, well, that's fine because the female leaves in the office, they are separate lockable cubicles.
00:20:00.700 --> 00:20:02.821
They have everything that they need to in there.
00:20:03.462 --> 00:20:08.328
Let's use that as our unisex toilet, for want of a better phrase.
00:20:08.990 --> 00:20:19.575
But of course, that's not the solution because you're effectively reducing the amount of female-only work facilities, but keeping the male facilities as it is.
00:20:19.634 --> 00:20:22.438
Is that something that employers should be wary
00:20:22.458 --> 00:20:22.597
of?
00:20:22.638 --> 00:20:24.119
Yeah, you do need to be careful of that.
00:20:24.161 --> 00:20:28.747
I mean, what we're getting into is the realms of indirect sex discrimination.
00:20:28.866 --> 00:20:36.396
So if you're causing a substantial disadvantage to women because of their sex, you've got an indirect sex discrimination claim.
00:20:36.636 --> 00:20:43.144
Now, there is a statutory defence to indirect sex discrimination, which is that it's a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
00:20:43.746 --> 00:20:58.969
But you're on fairly thin ice in a scenario in which the majority of your staff are women and you are then reducing the availability of female-only loos in order to accommodate males.
00:20:59.851 --> 00:21:04.278
Stressing again, for the purposes of the Equality Act, trans women are males.
00:21:05.318 --> 00:21:09.605
Then what you're doing is you're disadvantaging women on the basis of their sex and you are...
00:21:10.018 --> 00:21:12.942
perpetrating an act of indirect sex discrimination.
00:21:12.981 --> 00:21:24.938
So this is why I say the key thing for any employer in this situation is to just bear in mind that there won't be a one size fits all for every employer in every workplace.
00:21:25.739 --> 00:21:32.708
You have to look at the principles behind For Women Scotland and you have to look at the floor plan of your workplace and work out what are we going to do?
00:21:32.847 --> 00:21:33.568
Do we need to do anything?
00:21:33.630 --> 00:21:34.230
We might be fine.
00:21:34.530 --> 00:21:38.115
But if we do, what are we going to do that fits here and with our workforce?
00:21:38.876 --> 00:21:42.953
For Women Scotland, defines the meanings of the words man, woman and sex.
00:21:43.914 --> 00:21:49.462
But the 1992 Workplace Health Safety and Welfare Regulations are not the Equality Act.
00:21:49.784 --> 00:21:57.955
And when they talk about men and women, how do we know that the same approach that the Supreme Court's applied to the Equality Act actually plays through here?
00:21:57.976 --> 00:22:00.940
And there's a number of answers to that point.
00:22:00.960 --> 00:22:07.859
I mean, primarily, the 1992 regulations come from an EEC directive in 1989.
00:22:08.661 --> 00:22:12.984
That directive has been retained post-Brexit, so it's law that we have to follow.
00:22:13.025 --> 00:22:16.749
Secondly, the 1992 regulations are regulations.
00:22:17.288 --> 00:22:20.491
There's no right of action under those regulations.
00:22:21.492 --> 00:22:37.748
If you want to challenge, or if an employee or a worker says, hang on a minute, I've got a right to sex-segregated washing facilities under the regulations, I'm not being provided it, their remedy is litigation under the Equality Act.
00:22:38.568 --> 00:22:49.842
So if you're in a hypothetical example where a workplace has got one single communal lose for men and for women, and they all use them together, what does a woman do?
00:22:50.082 --> 00:22:55.848
Or for that matter, what does a man do to enforce the right that they've got under the 1992 regs?
00:22:56.028 --> 00:23:01.174
The answer is they go to the employment tribunal and they bring a claim for sex discrimination under the Act.
00:23:01.875 --> 00:23:08.028
And at that point, you're using the for Women's Scotland Supreme Court biological definition of man, dog and sex.
00:23:09.009 --> 00:23:11.535
And you're also gonna look at the purpose of the legislation in the first place.
00:23:11.955 --> 00:23:15.721
Why do we have separate sex facilities?
00:23:15.962 --> 00:23:17.464
Why are the regulations required?
00:23:17.525 --> 00:23:19.008
Why was the EU law required?
00:23:19.028 --> 00:23:31.402
I mean, you're talking about an EU, directive from 1989, you know, which is what, seven years before Jupiter Butler even wrote Gender Troubles and before a lot of these issues came to the fore.
00:23:31.823 --> 00:23:38.973
So I think it would be something of a challenge to say that the EEC, as it then was, was applying a A
00:23:39.074 --> 00:23:39.955
gender
00:23:40.516 --> 00:23:42.700
identity theory definition of man and woman.
00:23:43.140 --> 00:23:47.566
And again, why do we have separate sex facilities and spaces anywhere?
00:23:47.605 --> 00:23:58.622
It's because we recognise that there are different requirements, privacy, dignity, safety for women than there are for men, which is independent of identity or trans status.
00:23:59.282 --> 00:24:06.752
So I don't think there's any real kind of basis to say that the same definition is applied by the Supreme Court.
00:24:07.394 --> 00:24:11.065
to the Equality Act don't equally apply to the 1992 regulations.
00:24:11.907 --> 00:24:12.529
Thank you, Peter.
00:24:12.569 --> 00:24:14.074
That was incredibly helpful.
00:24:14.174 --> 00:24:15.337
Thank you much for joining me today.
00:24:15.759 --> 00:24:16.481
Pleasure to be here.
00:24:16.993 --> 00:24:26.614
If you'd like to find out more about how Dora Clayton can help you with reviewing your policies or looking at your procedures in general, then please do contact us via our website.
00:24:27.134 --> 00:24:31.183
And also, don't forget to like and subscribe to this podcast.
00:24:31.625 --> 00:24:38.378
Many thanks for listening.