TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: Do you ever wake up in the middle of the night and you think you hear something. Well, in Port Arthur, Texas, that bump in the night was real. A dad asleep in his own home when suddenly there's that bump in the night, and now he's looking at murder charges. Take a listen to this breaking overnight out of Port Arthur. Two armed robbers are on the run. One person is dead now. Port Arthur police are investigating a robbery that happened on Eighteenth Street near to Queen Street just before nine pm last night. Police say three men forcibly entered the home as a female resident was arriving and held the family at gunpoint. Police say children were inside the home at the time. So everybody's sleep, the dad, the man in the home. Here's something. It's armed intruders in the home. With me and I'll start panel to break it down and put it back together again. Should daddy be charged with murder? First of all, Ken Belkan with me, new York criminal defense attorney knows his way around the courtroom. You can find him at belcan Law dot com or now. A psychologists joining us out of Manhattan is Karen start with a c at Karen Stark dot com, former police chief in John's Creek, twenty five years with the police force. Now he is at Chris Buyer's Investigations and polygraph dot com. Joining me out of Austin, Texas Deputy Medical Examiner Travis County. That's Austin doctor Kendall Krouse. But first to Ray Kimputo, lead news anchor at w d BO. Ray, tell me about Port Arthur. What is that. It's a it's a sleepy little city. It's right there on the co O Golf coast, Nancy, not far from Beaumont. I mean, he couldn't get any closer to the Gulf than where it's at. And uh, it's it's not far from Houston. But long story short is it's you know, it's got some some industry, but a lot of rural communities, little little neighborhoods like where this happen. You know, you're reminding me of Ray Kimpeter. You're reminding me of when I first went to the scene of Lacy Peterson's murder. And people think they hear California and they think La or Sacramento or San Diego or San Francisco, a big city Modesto was nothing like that. I remember I drove down the end of Lacy Peterson's Street and there was a I guess it was an olive farm. It was full of farming country, beautiful beautiful farm country, all sorts of trees, groves, you name it. And when most people think of Texas, a lot of them, not me, but a lot of people think of Dallas or Houston. But it's not all like that at all. Go ahead, yeah, well put Port Arthur. You know, I know you're gonna get on me, but it's not you know, a place where a lot of folks, you know, see this sort of thing, or see high crying budget out. But wait a minute, right, you know you knew I was gonna jump on that. Right, it doesn't happen here. How many times have you heard that? Chief fires? It just doesn't happen in our neighborhood. Oh absolutely. You know I've spent during my twenty five year career, I worked all sides of Metro Atlanta,
Load full transcript
and I've worked in the high crime areas. And then I finished out my last thirteen years in what was named the safest city in Georgia for six or seven years straight. Number like fourteen in the country, and we had every one of the crimes that I dealt with when I worked in South Atlanta, maybe not as frequently, but every one of those happened right here in John's Creek. So people have that false sense of security when they live in what they deem a safe area. Yeah, I will never forget prosecuting in Inner City Atlanta. I had tons. That's the height of the drug trade at that time. Atlanta one of the murder capitals of the world because of the drug trade. Lots and lots and lots of murderers in Inner City and South Atlanta as you head toward the airport. But I'll never forget when I went into a wealthy enclave off of North Russell Road, the Long Island Drive area, Nope, And I pulled in and went to the scene. And when I got back out into my car, when I left several hours later, people were in their front yards just looking. They could not believe that a crime had occurred there. And I guess that's what you're telling me, Rykafudo, Nancy, it's not. It's not without its crime. But you if you ask residents, you know a lot of them are you know they don't see. You know, you don't see violent crime like that. But you know what, then again, if you look at crime statistics for any city, not a lot of people expect murders and rapes and robberies to happen on a daily base, especially in your home. I mean, Ken Belkin, h veteran criminal defense attorney on New York at Belkin law dot com. You know, in law school we studied every theory of criminal law about mentreya and tent, malignant heart, wild, abandonment, you name it. But I think a jury can normally assume when an intruder comes into your home, you sheet him dead. It's not your fault. I'm sure you're going to disagree. Hit me. I'm ready, Ken Belkin. I mean, I would want to defend this guy because he's got a supercastle doctrine defense. He was defending these children in his home and these three people came in as a home invasion, and he took one of them out, and quite frankly, I think he was within his rights to do so. And I'd love to have that case of Hey Belkin, for once you and I agree, I mean, Karen, start to think about it. You live in the heart of Manhattan, not too far from where David and the twins and I are. And imagine all safe and snug and tugged in, and then somebody is in your home. It's not like you're walking down the street. It's some hateful person mugs you didn't see on the end, steals your pocket. But you're at home, minding your own business when someone intrudes that's the worst nightmare scenario. Well, I think, Nancy, I think you're correct in saying that you'd be very happy if you had some kind of a weapon in a situation like that. I guess, I guess it depends if you're allowed to have that gun, if it's legal that you have it. How did you get on gun control when I asked you about the
psychology of feeling safe in your own home? You know, don't start me up on Second Amendment, okay, because you know how I hate guns, hate hate hate guns. I'm a victim of gun violence myself, But I don't think that that right should be taken away from us and just white out of in the constitution. Now, can we get back on the psychology of feeling safe in your own home? But you're not well and that's that's the part of this incident that's most frightening I think is that anybody would be glad if they had something that they could protect themselves, especially when it comes to children. People are fierce about their families and their children. I can understand completely. I think that most people in that circumstance would you be to jack same thing. And you know, Karen Starr, you and I've covered so many cases where child goes missing from the home, where child is hurt in the home. With all the cases we've covered and that I've prosecuted up all during the night and just go peek on the twins. I just look at them, make sure they're in their bed, make sure they're still breathing, and then try to go back to sleep. You know, that was actually the scenario here. So Port Arthur Low crime, rural area, some business. So what happened in this case Crime Stories with Nancy Grace, we are talking about a shooting in a residential area, in someone's own home. Everybody in the home at night, mining their own business. When three arm intruders bust in Ray Kimputer lead news anchor WDBO. I understand they had their faces covered yeah, Nancy, like you, like a lot of robbers do. But what they what happened was they had followed the mother who had just got home into the house. Now inside was the dad. There was a couple of kids, one of them was young faces Tell me that again, because that's that's Jackie. Do you remember the case doctor pettit up in New England and his wife and daughter, I think is the way it went. Had been to the store, and two or three evildoers followed them home, made the mom go in withdraw money from the bank. They targeted that home. They waited, They hit mister doctor Ellis I think it was in the head, made him, tied him all up he was immobile, then raped and killed the daughters and the mother. This set the house on fire from following her home. Following her home, so Ray Kimpeter, that's how the whole thing started. They followed the mom home. I don't know if they followed her home, but they certainly were lying in wait, Nancy. They could have been outside, They could have followed at her home. They may have seen that she went to an at I'm a certain store. But they were ready is because right after she got home, it wasn't long after that these massive intruders with their guns busted up in that home. That tells me a lot right there. Ken Belkin at Belkin Law dot com, New York criminal defense attorney. They did you hear what Raykabuto said, the words they were ready? There's no way around premeditation. How often do you go visit someone's home, Belkin, with your face mask and your gun with you? Well, given the fact that I live in New York, you know we can't really even have guns in the city, But in any event, I always have my mask on du to COVID. Long story short, guys, What I'm trying to call car pull out of Belkin is that when you go, let's just say, to a bank and you want to get twenty dollars out of the ATM, do you care your gun at a face covering a mask to do that? No, and if you do, you're robbing the bank. Bam. There. So, when you go to a place with ill intent that is under our law premeditation. Premeditation can be formed just like that in the twinkling of a moment, the blink of an eye, the time it takes you to raise the gun and pull the trigger. And when you travel to a location let's just say, with a Molotov cocktail or a gun or a face mask, and then you commit a crime with it, it shows you planned it and that sets you up for malice murder. So in this case, Ray Computer w DBO, they see the mom come in, and then what happens. They come in, guns a drawn, and they hold the mom and she has two young kids in this home, Nancy, one of them again five years old. They hold all of this entire family hostage three I think, one five year old and one three year old? Go ahead, Oh could you imagine? Now? I can't. So Mom's got her handsful. Mom's hysterical, you know, worried about these children. These people are pointing guns at her, and dad is sleeping in the other room. Guys, take a listen. Earlier you heard Tracy Kennett kb MT. Take a listen to Jordan Williams at twelve years One suspect is dad. Two others on the run after Port Arthur police say they tried to rob a family in their home. Investigators say three men broken the home on Eighteenth Street around eight thirty Sunday night. Once inside, they held a family at gunpoint while demanding their belongings. The homeowner was in another room and he heard everything. The man grabbed his gun and fired several shots, hitting and killing twenty seven year old Terrence Ellis. The two other suspects ran from the scene. Port Arthur police tonight are still looking for those two men. So dad pulls a gun and unloads two Doctor Kendall Crowns, Deputy Medical Examiner, Chavis County, Texas. That's Austin, doctor Crowns. As you heard Ray Komputer say, the three perps came in the home, guns drawn, following mom into the home. There's a three year old and a five year old there. Very often when I've spoken to crime victims, they are very They feel like adrenaline is pumping through their body at the time of the attack. So the man, the dad, grabs the gun and fires at them as they are holding the children at gunpoint. What is that chemical reaction in your body? You know, you've heard those stories about moms being able to lift a car off their child, stories of typically unimaginable behavior, but they do it in that moment. What is that? What it is is when you get into a frightful situation, it's called fighter flight, and your body dumps a
chemical which is called epinefrin into your bloodstream and then that thusans you to be able to react more quickly, have more strength. And so from that fight or flight response from the epinefrin, you can see people have these sudden massive strength or be able to jump further, etc. Etc. So when the dump happens, a lot a lot of things can change suddenly and you can see a lot of quick reactions. You know, Chris Buyer's former police chief John's Creek now at Chris Buyer's Investigation and polygraph dot Com Chief Buyers. I've seen so many homicides happen in the heat of the moment. But in this case, this is not out of passion. This is out of defense of a third party. What do you make this case as we know it now and what I've heard everything on this case, he was completely justified in what he did. Did the exact same thing that I did or I would do again. I'm a card killing and r A member, so I am. You know, I'm very much for having guns to take care of yourself. You know. One of the things that I used to tell people all the time, especially in the community I was a chief at when seconds count, we the police will be there in minutes, So you've got to do something to take care of yourself and protect yourself within those seconds until we can get there. And people have that false sense of that the police are going to get there and take care of it. But these things unfold within seconds, just like this. So everything he did, everything right as far as I'm concerned, and now the possibility of a murder charge looming on him put out the police id the dead suspectus Terence Ellis, the owner of the home, fatally guns him down after he barges into the home with two other suspects, all with their faces covered. The three suspects barge in when a woman who lives there, the mom, comes home. The homeowner is said to be a twenty nine year old dad who was armed with a rifle. The other two suspects flee the sea, leaving their buddy behind bleeding out on the floor. But it's not over yet. Take a listen to our friends at kb EMPT twelve. Now to our breaking news out of Port Arthur. This morning. A house fire just before midnight at the same home where three people broke in and held a family at gunpoint on Sunday night. The homeowner there shot and killed one of the suspects involved, and I witness tells twelve News and neighbors saw smoke and flames coming from that home and dial nine one. Nobody was at home when the fire started, and the cause is still unknown. And we're learning this morning that hours before the fire broke out, Port Arthur police were called back to the twenty five hundred block of Eighteenth Street to investigate a different shooting. This time nobody was injured. Does it never end? For this family Crime Stories with Nancy Grace, We are talking about intruders, masked intruders entering a residence and a sleepy area Port Arthur, Texas. Mom has just come in a three year old and a five year old. A three year old had a gun held to his face that
may affect the way that child grows up the rest of his life. So after daddy guns down one of the perps, the other two perps leave and at the same residence, there's a what we think as a drive by shooting after what was that in retaliation? And then after the family leaves, they set the home on fire as what I get back. I mean, see, Grace, this is crime Stories. I'm gonna thank you again for being with us here at Fox Nation in series x M one eleven. I mean, Ray Kaputo WDPO. What did they come back and retaliation to set the home on fire, Nancy, within like thirty hours, you got someone shot in this home, you got a drive by shooting, and then the home gets lit on fire. I mean, this poor family that went through a lot of events and just you know, a little over twenty four hours, little over one day. So you're correct on that, and it seems I guess you can't look at it any other way. They were targeting this family, Yeah, I know, but you could say that about any crivict that they were targeted. Take a listen to Jordan Williams Kelsey Johnson KBMT twelve. A deadly home invasion, a drive by shooting, and that fire all at the same house in Port Arthur, all in roughly thirty hours. Tonight, people who live near eighteenth and the Queen are in disbelief and police are trying to find out if the three things are related. Towels Reporter Kelsey Johnson joins us with new information that she uncovered. The motive in this case is unclear. Port Arthur police say that the homeowner is being cooperative. But right now, the answer to why this family was targeted lies with the two suspects who got away. You know, there you go. Another issue, Ken Belkan, a sticky legal issue is that the other two perhaps that got away, could actually be charged with their buddies murder. Explain the theory A felony murder. That's the good old Veaston felony murder. Now taking me back the first year of law school, Nancy. So look, if a murder is if someone loses their life in the commission of a felony, the people who were committing that felony can be charged for murder, even if they were not directly responsible for the loss of life. So here where mister Ellis was shot and killed by the father you know these he was engaged with two other people in a home invasion, which is a felony, and he was killed as a result of it. So his two co felons can be charged for felony murder because of his death. Darn right. An easy example I always gave you juries is that let's just say Jackie and I decide to rob a bank, and you know, I say, Okay, nobody's going to get hurt Jackie. This is strictly about the money. She agrees. As soon as she gets in there, she goes, why I'll start shooting kills a teller. You know what I'm in for it too. I'm responsible for felony murder because I was part of a felony and a death occurred. Let's see another example. Let's say we're leaving the bank and I'm the getaway driver. I go up on a curb in my haste and hit a gas station. The tank blows up, the cashier on the inside of the gas station dies. Felony murder. I'm in commission of a felony, and what otherwise may have been an accident is now a felony murder. Did I intend to kill the gas store owner? Note? But it was part of a felony and therefore felony murder, And in most jurisdictions, felony murder carries the same penalty as malice or murder one, so we're looking at murder charges all around. Least likely is on the dad, But believe it or not, it happens. The murder charges against the dad have been thrown around. Take a listen now to Kelsey Johnson KB empty. If houses could talk, this home on the corner of eighteenth Street into Queen Boulevard in Port Arthur would have a story to tell. This wasn't a random act. We believe that the house was specifically targeted. On Sunday night, a home invasion turned deadly. Three suspects forced their way into a home and only two made it out alive. One of these suspects was shot and killed by the homeowner himself, defending his family. That family included a woman and two young children. Hours later, a drive by shooting at the same address. No one was in the house of time. But this home story is not over yet. Last night the house went up in flames. You know, revenge, revenge Chief Chris Buyers, former police chief John's Creek, Georgia at Chris Buyers investigations and polygraph dot Com. Chief Buyers. Revenge is not a defense under the law. How often have you seen death the car because of revenge? Oh? Absolutely happens all the time. That mental trigger goes and you're set on that revenge and just rage comes from it, Oh what happens? Gosh, hundreds of times during my twenty five years, I've seen those different types of crimes, maybe not to this extent where somebody was killed, but yes, revenge is a motive for a lot of things that go on in the criminal world. Yeah, I'm thinking about the one bleeding out before cops could get there and question him, and the other two perps to get away to Doctor Kendall Crowns, Deputy Medical Examiner, Travis County. That's Austin, Texas, Doctor Crowns. How much blood is in our body and how long does it take you to bleed out? You have about three leaders of blood in your body, so about three large bottles of pop or soda. Didn't you ever call it a super bottle? A super bottle? So we called it growing up. I mean, you've got a regular coke and then you've got a super bottle, which is I guess a leader? No, just me, Jackie says, she called it a super bottle too, Okay, go ahead. That must be a regional thing anyway. So you have about three leaders in your system that any given time, and depending on what gets hit, if your a order gets hit, you can bleed out in seconds. If it's a smaller vessel, you can take several minutes to bleed out. So it just depends on what organ gets hit, what vessel gets hit. So if it's a smaller vessel, it still only takes minutes. Well, if you get to the smaller vessel, that can take minutes, being thirty minutes, forty minutes, etc. And you know, if it's
just periphery in your capillarias, if you just put pressure on it, you won't die at all. Another issue, how much blood do you have to lose? Doctor Kennel crowns out of three super bottles, how much blood you have to lose to actually die? So once you lose about a leader, you're going to go into shock and then that's going to cause you to go into organ failure. So I think if you lose at least one super bottle, as you say, you're going to be in trouble. So what really went down in this home? And too you are the other two perhaps the ones that get away? Take a listen to our friends at Channel twelve. Early this morning, police pulled over a vehicle on Jimmy Johnson Boulevard. Officers searched it and found three loaded semi automatic handguns and an ar style rifle. They also recovered ski masks. The suspects face a long list of charges. Now what's unclear is whether the suspects could be connected to those three crimes earlier this week at a house on Eighteenth Street and a queen Remember the deadly home invasion, the shooting, the fire, all in roughly a day and a half. Detective Mike Keebert telling twelve News tonight that the Port Earth Police departments Criminal Investigation Divisions detectives are looking into any possible connection between the traffic stop and what happened on Eighteenth Street. You know, it's always amazing to me how a simple traffic stop can catch a killer. Crime stories with Nancy Grace, guys were talking about a family minding their own business. Mom is followed in. She got three year old and five year old child with her mask. Intruders wearing ski masks come in, guns loaded. Dad grabs a rifle and let's sit rip, killing one of the purpose. The other two take off and go on the run. They stay gone nearly a week before because of a traffic stop, they're pulled over. I mean Wow, that's quite a coincidence, Ken, Belcon. They get pulled over and the idiots still have three ski masks, have ski masks in the car and weapons. Well look, you know, as a mentor of mine once called me the fifth pillar of the criminal justice systy. Yes, you know, they're not always the brightest. They're not always thinking we're planning ahead, or they wouldn't be in situation you cut out on me. But what I think you said, Belcon, is that most criminals are idiots. Yes, more or lesson That's what I'm saying. You know what, I think you're probably right, but they're so it's a huge majority of criminals that get away. We think we're getting fifty percent, sixty percent. In a way, we're not even We're scratching the surface of criminals that are apprehended. But for the most part, I agree with you, Ken Belkin. Not that smart. It's not liking an air Kuel Poirot movie where they're so smart that they get away with murder. They're still driving around with a ski mask and the guns in the car. It'll take one ballistics comparison to figure out that the bullets were fired from one of those guns. Here. What it's what I think is the real travesty. The real travesty, in addition to what the victims went through, is that there is a possibility Dad is going to be facing murder charges. It's happened before. We take a Listen to our friends over at court TV. Dousett, a karate instructor, had abducted eleven year old Jodie Plochet several weeks earlier and taken him to California. When Jody was rescued and returned to his family, his father Gary was coping with reports that Dussette had sexually assaulted his son. We didn't know what to do. You just feel helpless. Ten days later, when the police flew Ducette back to face trial, Gary Cloche was waiting with a gun. As a suspect came through the airport. I ready my camera, raced it up to get a close up shot at him. As I got a close up shot, and as he got parallel to me, Garry Cloche shoots. That's right, Dad guns down the man he suspected I'm molesting his son. Listen, Cloche shoots and kills him. Gary Why? Gary? Why? And to this day it stands out in my mind, the shooter. Gary Ploche says, if it had been your child, you would have done the same thing too. Today, Abram McGaugh is an assistant US attorney and views that tape through the eyes of a federal prosecutor. I would have to say the video take was the most ideal witness in this case and actually see him take the gun out of his boot, pull it up to the shoulder lever of Jeff du Sat and pull the trigger and shoot him. Yet Clochet, after pleading no contest to manslaughter, got off with only five years probation. Would you have done the same thing? A lot of parents say yes, He's not the only one to take a Listen to our friends at Fox ten. For Aaron Latowski, his sole responsibility is protecting his wife, three kids, and their nanny. Don't forget the family dog, Sadie, who Latowski says alerted him late last night to a break in. And so I came inside and I saw that one of our side doors was open, and she was barking in the hall towards my kid's bedrooms. Right away, Latowski says, he grabbed his shotgun. Meanwhile, the rest of the family was asleep we never would have known. We would have continued to sleep and sleep through it. So I'm just so thankful. Letowski went into his daughter's room, where he says the suspect came out with a large piece of wood, his face mask and his body naked. A face mask and completely naked. And your little girl's room. Take a listen to Justin Lamb. Letowski went into his daughter's room, where he says the suspect came out with a large piece of wood, his face masked and his body naked. He basically was lunging at me, so it was very quick. He had his hands in the air. I could see something dark or black coming at me, and again it was very very close, so I fired almost immediately. Two shots killed the suspect, police believed to be an eighteen to nineteen year old man. The Latowski said this was the first break in at their home, but they have always been prepared. God bless America and the Second Amendment. I'm glad we're I was able to protect my family. God bless the police for coming so quick to take care of us. It's amazing to me that anyone could even consider putting these cases to a grand jury. But it happens. Listen to our friends at ABC News. A frantic father called nine one after finding a farm hand. He sues Flores allegedly sexually assaulting his little girl. The Lavaca County District Attorney's office released the dramatic call. Okay, the nine one on the audio is just part of the evidence presented to a Lavaca County grand jury who chose not to indict the father. District Attorney Heather mcmihn tells us why and under the law in the state of Texas, deadly fourth force is authorized and justify in order to stop and aggravated sexual assault or a sexual assault. All the evidence that was presented by the Sheriff's department and by the Texas Rangers indicated that that was in fact what was occurring when the victim's father arrived at the scene. Did you hear that this father finds a man raping his five year old little girl, beats him to death, and then the father's case is sent to a grand jury. Luckily, the grand jury had enough sense not to indict. But listen to this for neighbor Michael Vay to the decision not to indict, It wasn't surprising. He grew up with a young man who went to school with my kids. Great guy, I mean, calls me mister Weiss, yes or no, Sarah will manor kid. Prosecutors say, you can hear the young father trying to say Flora as in the nine one one audio. I don't know the man, dival man, I'm a tomb. They hopes his neighbor's family can now recover my man actually lost his life. It's sad, but I think justice was served that day that grand jury did not indict. But that is not true for every dad that takes action. Take a listen to NBC fifteen mobile. A defense lawyer says authorities are overreacting with a murder charge against a Coleman County man charging killing his daughter's sexual abuser. Forty one year old Jay Mayner is charged with the shooting death of fifty nine year old Raymond Earld Brooks. The family says that Brooks was sexually abusing Maynard's daughter, who is now speaking out about the incident. I was so so young. I don't remember when it started, but when I finally told someone I was eight, for the first time in my life. I do not feel scared. For the first time in my life. I do not wake up feeling fear. Coleman County investigators couldn't confirm whether the two thousand and two sex abuse case had any connection to the shooting, but Brooks was a registered sex offender. The Coleman County Sheriff's Office reports Jay Mayner will be charged with first degree murder, attempted murder, and shooting into an occupied dwelling. We can only hope that the father in this case that we are covering today out of Port Arthur, Texas, is not charged. The phrase vigilante dad is being thrown around recklessly, but this father should be applauded for protecting his family. We wait as justice unfolds. Nancy Grace crime story signing off Goodbye friend.