TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:10.819 --> 00:00:16.370
Hello, and welcome to Conversations with Great Historians, the podcast brought
00:00:16.370 --> 00:00:19.132
to you from the Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History.
00:00:19.596 --> 00:00:23.110
I'm Jim Basker, President and CEO of the Gilder Lehrman Institute,
00:00:23.110 --> 00:00:25.193
and I'm delighted to have you join us.
00:00:25.816 --> 00:00:29.860
For years, our program, Book Breaks, has brought together thousands of history
00:00:29.860 --> 00:00:34.380
lovers, teachers, students, and lifelong learners for conversations with leading
00:00:34.380 --> 00:00:35.615
historians and writers.
00:00:36.195 --> 00:00:40.860
Each week, we explore important books that deepen our understanding of the people,
00:00:40.860 --> 00:00:43.846
events, and ideas that have shaped our past.
00:00:44.458 --> 00:00:49.085
Now we're bringing those conversations directly to you in podcast form.
00:00:49.661 --> 00:00:53.920
In each episode, you'll hear an engaging conversation with an author about their
00:00:53.920 --> 00:00:57.561
latest work, followed by thoughtful questions from our audience.
00:00:58.142 --> 00:01:03.030
We hope these conversations inform and inspire you, and most of all,
00:01:03.030 --> 00:01:05.386
spark your curiosity about history.
00:01:06.023 --> 00:01:10.661
Thank you for listening, and welcome again to Conversations with Great Historians.
00:01:11.582 --> 00:01:15.508
Hello, and welcome to Book Breaks. We are so thrilled today to welcome Saif,
00:01:15.508 --> 00:01:18.967
she's chef, and her book, The Revolutionary San Adams.
00:01:19.310 --> 00:01:22.498
As always, if you'd like to ask a question, you can use the Q&A feature,
00:01:22.498 --> 00:01:26.195
and we'll be asking questions submitted by the audience in the second half of the program.
00:01:26.785 --> 00:01:31.248
And we'd always like to thank Citizens Travelers, the nonpartisan civic engagement
00:01:31.248 --> 00:01:34.371
initiative of the Travelers Company for its support of Book Breaks.
00:01:34.900 --> 00:01:37.998
And I'm your host, Gina Oppenheim, and I'm joined by my friend,
00:01:37.998 --> 00:01:40.357
Ryan Sullivan. There's Ryan, hi.
00:01:40.978 --> 00:01:44.606
And without further ado, we are so thrilled today to welcome Stacey Schiff,
00:01:44.839 --> 00:01:48.618
who's written such acclaimed books as Vera, Portrait of a Marriage,
00:01:48.960 --> 00:01:52.748
winner of the Pulitzer Prize, A Great Improvisation, Franklin,
00:01:52.748 --> 00:01:57.058
France, and the Birth of America, winner of the Washington Prize, and many others.
00:01:57.058 --> 00:01:59.287
Stacey, thanks so much for joining us today.
00:01:59.681 --> 00:02:01.510
I'm delighted to join you both. Thanks, Gina.
00:02:02.090 --> 00:02:06.058
Yes, so just to start off, could you give us an overview of this book and what
00:02:06.058 --> 00:02:08.729
was your impetus to write it? Yeah, overview.
00:02:09.630 --> 00:02:13.678
I went back. I was
Load full transcript
working with some 18th century materials I had used for a
00:02:13.678 --> 00:02:16.265
book I had written years ago about Benjamin Franklin.
00:02:16.654 --> 00:02:20.218
And I was struck by the fact that Samuel Adams makes kind of a walk-on appearance
00:02:20.218 --> 00:02:23.318
in my own book, and I knew so little about him. So that kind of sent me back
00:02:23.318 --> 00:02:26.975
into the archives to read what his contemporaries had said about him.
00:02:27.270 --> 00:02:30.198
And I was floored, to be honest with you. I mean, it just hit me that there
00:02:30.198 --> 00:02:34.138
is this person standing at the center of the revolution to whose eminence his
00:02:34.138 --> 00:02:36.884
contemporaries attest and about whom we know next to nothing.
00:02:37.273 --> 00:02:41.108
And moreover, that the image that they leave us of him, especially in the words
00:02:41.108 --> 00:02:45.468
of John Adams, who talks about how tireless but patient he was,
00:02:45.468 --> 00:02:47.082
how decorous, how affable,
00:02:47.420 --> 00:02:51.598
how serene, how little that tallied with our sort of, I think,
00:02:51.598 --> 00:02:54.681
classroom cartoon of that firebrand Samuel Adams.
00:02:54.942 --> 00:02:58.078
So I just kind of went down the rabbit hole and started reading his papers.
00:02:58.078 --> 00:03:03.544
And to do that is really to read the thought, the thinking behind,
00:03:03.829 --> 00:03:06.718
as John Adams put the revolution that actually preceded the revolution,
00:03:06.718 --> 00:03:08.060
the revolution in thinking.
00:03:08.321 --> 00:03:10.908
And that's something for which Samuel Adams is largely responsible.
00:03:10.908 --> 00:03:12.855
So that's, in short, the origin of the book.
00:03:14.102 --> 00:03:18.468
And you opened with the quote, emissions are not accidents. And unlike Alexander
00:03:18.468 --> 00:03:22.653
Hamilton, Adam somewhat wrote himself out of history. Why was that?
00:03:23.249 --> 00:03:27.028
There are a lot of reasons, and I think one of them more interesting the next
00:03:27.028 --> 00:03:28.351
as to why he goes missing.
00:03:28.705 --> 00:03:31.378
I mean, the biggest reason, just to build on what I just said,
00:03:31.378 --> 00:03:35.678
is that this is the part of the revolution that I think we were most eager to
00:03:35.678 --> 00:03:39.018
kind of sweep off the table post-revolution. These were the anarchic years,
00:03:39.018 --> 00:03:41.018
the provocative years, the messy years.
00:03:41.557 --> 00:03:45.808
And it was much easier afterward to sort of appeal to the high-minded writings
00:03:45.808 --> 00:03:48.898
of Thomas Jefferson than it was to talk about street protest in Boston.
00:03:48.898 --> 00:03:53.228
So this was really the part you want to turn the Boston destruction of the tea
00:03:53.228 --> 00:03:56.508
into the Boston Tea Party. And in doing that, you need to kind of get rid of
00:03:56.508 --> 00:03:58.397
a provocateur like Samuel Adams.
00:03:58.668 --> 00:04:00.736
So that's a large piece of it.
00:04:01.235 --> 00:04:05.118
To some extent, he's very uncooperative from a historical point of view.
00:04:05.698 --> 00:04:10.298
He partly destroys his papers. John Adams leaves us this terrifying scene of
00:04:10.298 --> 00:04:14.448
the two of them in Philadelphia at the Continental Congress watching as Samuel
00:04:14.448 --> 00:04:16.515
Adams feeds his papers to the fire.
00:04:16.962 --> 00:04:19.738
And that's because this is the no fingerprints school, right?
00:04:19.738 --> 00:04:22.883
He's committing sedition. He knows he's committing what could be called treason.
00:04:23.040 --> 00:04:27.063
And he's trying to cover up the trail of his confederates as well as his own.
00:04:27.295 --> 00:04:30.588
So there's a certain destruction of the papers involved. He never collects his
00:04:30.588 --> 00:04:33.251
papers despite people urging him to do so.
00:04:33.449 --> 00:04:38.248
He never writes a memoir. He's a very diffident fellow. He prefers to be out
00:04:38.248 --> 00:04:41.773
of the spotlight. He's very comfortable there, unlike John Adams, for example.
00:04:42.111 --> 00:04:44.729
So he really takes to the wings in many ways.
00:04:45.142 --> 00:04:49.768
And the waters are poisoned against him in Massachusetts, in Boston in particular,
00:04:49.768 --> 00:04:53.600
after the revolution by John Hancock, with whom he has a very complicated relationship.
00:04:53.821 --> 00:04:57.878
So a lot of these things working together conspire against him so that really
00:04:57.878 --> 00:05:01.290
by two generations after his death, he's gone from the scene.
00:05:01.435 --> 00:05:04.428
Although in his lifetime, he and Washington were considered the sort of two
00:05:04.428 --> 00:05:05.632
pillars of the revolution.
00:05:06.116 --> 00:05:09.534
Yeah, and something you wrote about, too, that just really affected me and I
00:05:09.534 --> 00:05:12.634
think would really be great to bring into the classroom is you write that he
00:05:12.634 --> 00:05:16.354
was the patron saint of late bloomers. Can you expand on that?
00:05:16.734 --> 00:05:20.554
I don't know why I find this so tremendously appealing. I mean, maybe as teachers.
00:05:23.134 --> 00:05:28.894
There is no sign, there is no clue to his later genius in his early years.
00:05:28.894 --> 00:05:34.114
He is a feckless man who can't seem to find a profession, who manages to squander
00:05:34.114 --> 00:05:38.274
a fortune, who kind of loses one business after the next, never really kind
00:05:38.274 --> 00:05:42.784
of finds his foothold because he's largely a man of ideas.
00:05:42.784 --> 00:05:44.802
And it takes, in a funny way, it takes
00:05:45.238 --> 00:05:49.887
politics to align where he is intellectually with his moment in time.
00:05:50.067 --> 00:05:53.600
So for the first really 40 years of his life, he is downwardly mobile,
00:05:53.821 --> 00:05:55.388
has no visible profession.
00:05:55.713 --> 00:05:58.724
I
mean, it's kind of just sort of loitering his way toward his future.
00:05:58.724 --> 00:06:03.078
And I don't know why, but I just find the fact that he isn't a miniature version of his later self.
00:06:03.534 --> 00:06:06.444
From a biographical point of view, I find that fascinating. And from a personal
00:06:06.444 --> 00:06:09.971
point of view, I find it kind of deeply reaffirming. That you could be... Inspiring.
00:06:10.285 --> 00:06:13.924
Yeah, that you could just blaze suddenly into full splendor in middle age,
00:06:13.924 --> 00:06:14.958
right? There's still hope.
00:06:15.260 --> 00:06:19.774
I love that. Yeah. And just going back a little bit, just talk about his childhood
00:06:19.774 --> 00:06:23.683
or what we know and how that shaped his later years. Sure.
00:06:24.134 --> 00:06:29.114
You would think he would be born to this kind of future because he's born to
00:06:29.114 --> 00:06:31.038
a very prosperous Boston family.
00:06:31.363 --> 00:06:36.190
He gets the best education in colonial America, really, at the time. He goes to Boston Latin.
00:06:36.556 --> 00:06:40.654
He goes to Harvard for his undergraduate degree and then returns there for a graduate degree.
00:06:40.968 --> 00:06:44.674
This was the grounding of the New England elite. These were the best courses
00:06:44.674 --> 00:06:46.216
in the best schools at the time.
00:06:47.339 --> 00:06:51.079
And he grows up in a very wealthy household, sort of overlooking Boston Harbor
00:06:51.363 --> 00:06:52.642
and with every advantage.
00:06:52.909 --> 00:06:58.719
That is all, interestingly, forgotten later by his enemies, who will write him
00:06:58.719 --> 00:07:02.749
off as a sort of penniless desperado and a man who had nothing to lose.
00:07:02.749 --> 00:07:05.439
So, of course, why not foment revolution? Because you have nothing,
00:07:05.439 --> 00:07:08.989
you know, you have no property, you have no estate, and it's likely to be compromised
00:07:08.989 --> 00:07:10.214
in the sake of that revolution.
00:07:10.959 --> 00:07:15.729
But a born wealthy man who becomes poor by his own inattention is very different
00:07:15.729 --> 00:07:17.589
from a man who is not born to privilege.
00:07:17.589 --> 00:07:21.619
So the privilege thing is really interesting because it gives him too a great
00:07:21.619 --> 00:07:26.689
power in Boston in that he can unite. He knows the people in the street and
00:07:26.689 --> 00:07:30.352
he knows the Boston ministers. He knows the merchant elite and he knows the dock workers.
00:07:30.700 --> 00:07:34.641
Like none of the other founders, he is able to connect these two populaces.
00:07:34.984 --> 00:07:38.429
And that gives him a tremendous amount of traction when it comes to really trying
00:07:38.429 --> 00:07:43.179
to solidify the town and to solidify people around a common cause.
00:07:43.962 --> 00:07:47.705
And I know for your research, you went through some Harvard theses from the time.
00:07:48.042 --> 00:07:50.909
That's my favorite question. Oh, bless you for asking that. Yes,
00:07:50.909 --> 00:07:54.990
of course. Well, I loved that. So if you could tell us about some of your findings from that research.
00:07:55.147 --> 00:07:57.881
Well, you know, part of the problem with someone like Adams,
00:07:58.422 --> 00:08:01.789
who isn't born to greatness, is that no one's keeping track of his early years.
00:08:01.789 --> 00:08:05.179
So we have almost nothing of his childhood. We have hints here and there.
00:08:05.179 --> 00:08:09.754
We know his mother wanted him to become, not to become a lawyer, and so he obeys her.
00:08:09.974 --> 00:08:13.498
We know that he did not want to become a minister. I mean, we have little hints and glimmers.
00:08:14.212 --> 00:08:18.409
So I needed something that would fill out the picture intellectually,
00:08:18.409 --> 00:08:23.139
both for what he's consuming during his years at Harvard and for where the colony is.
00:08:23.139 --> 00:08:28.059
What is the Massachusetts Bay Colony preoccupied by? What are its soon-to-be
00:08:28.059 --> 00:08:31.360
leaders thinking about and studying about when they're undergraduates?
00:08:31.882 --> 00:08:34.869
And so the Harvard theses for these years, these are the theses,
00:08:34.869 --> 00:08:37.397
this is the thesis you wrote for your master's degree.
00:08:37.873 --> 00:08:40.915
And the assignment was essentially to answer a question, yea or nay,
00:08:41.443 --> 00:08:47.164
in Latin, seemed to me an incredibly interesting sort of gauge by which to judge,
00:08:47.762 --> 00:08:49.639
essentially colonial preoccupations.
00:08:49.639 --> 00:08:53.309
And the questions are fascinating because they're questions that we still ask
00:08:53.309 --> 00:08:56.510
today, but people answer the question, you know, did the ends justify the means?
00:08:56.818 --> 00:09:00.498
Can capital punishment be justified? Will you meet your friends in heaven?
00:09:00.997 --> 00:09:04.789
And then some of the questions are so kind of crazy sounding,
00:09:04.789 --> 00:09:06.535
like do vegetables breathe?
00:09:06.721 --> 00:09:11.335
Is the Pope the Antichrist? That was a big seller, that question that gets asked over and over again.
00:09:12.158 --> 00:09:17.429
Very few of the questions in the 1740s when Adams was studying for his masters
00:09:17.429 --> 00:09:20.128
were overtly political. Most of them were religious.
00:09:21.335 --> 00:09:25.573
But as his question, for probably familial reasons,
00:09:26.066 --> 00:09:29.686
he poses a question that he takes out of a textbook that had not been asked
00:09:29.686 --> 00:09:34.247
previously and would not be asked again for many years, which was essentially,
00:09:34.369 --> 00:09:38.891
is resistance to the king justified if the republic stands in jeopardy?
00:09:39.152 --> 00:09:43.156
And it was a very, it sounds like a very cheeky question because we see it through
00:09:43.156 --> 00:09:45.890
the lens of the 1760s and 1770s.
00:09:46.616 --> 00:09:49.456
But in the 1740s, there was really not much to that question because nobody
00:09:49.456 --> 00:09:50.970
was thinking about defying a king.
00:09:51.411 --> 00:09:54.806
But it's an interesting point of departure for him. And, you know,
00:09:54.806 --> 00:09:58.946
if you really want it to be reductive, you could say that the whole life falls
00:09:58.946 --> 00:10:01.606
out of that Harvard thesis question because, of course, he answers it in the
00:10:01.606 --> 00:10:02.746
affirmative. Yes, it's OK.
00:10:04.426 --> 00:10:07.890
Acts of disobedience are acceptable if the republic is in danger.
00:10:08.429 --> 00:10:12.115
Wow. Yeah. So fascinating, the research, what they can uncover.
00:10:12.456 --> 00:10:16.766
So I know another question that comes up a lot about Samuel Adams is his relationship
00:10:16.766 --> 00:10:19.456
with his second cousin, John. Can you tell us about that?
00:10:20.344 --> 00:10:24.226
So I think in retrospect, John has so much sort of subsumed Samuel that I think
00:10:24.226 --> 00:10:29.506
we assume that John was the more urbane cousin and the older cousin,
00:10:29.506 --> 00:10:31.702
when in fact he's 13 years younger than Samuel.
00:10:32.137 --> 00:10:36.736
One of Samuel Adams' great contributions to the revolution is that he's a recruiting
00:10:36.736 --> 00:10:37.993
agent, really, for the cause.
00:10:38.399 --> 00:10:42.022
And John Adams, John Hancock, Josiah Quincy, these were all his recruits.
00:10:42.926 --> 00:10:46.416
The word on the street of the day was that if you gave the best commencement
00:10:46.416 --> 00:10:49.936
address that anyone had heard at Harvard that year, Samuel Adams would be on
00:10:49.936 --> 00:10:51.393
your doorstep the next morning.
00:10:51.707 --> 00:10:54.505
So John's an early recruit. They're second cousins.
00:10:54.987 --> 00:10:58.522
It seems that they didn't meet until the early 1760s.
00:10:59.143 --> 00:11:02.678
And when they do meet, John Adams tells us, they are immediately.
00:11:03.386 --> 00:11:08.495
In sync on one particular subject, and that subject is their antipathy to the
00:11:08.495 --> 00:11:10.463
then-Lieutenant Governor Thomas Hutchinson.
00:11:10.962 --> 00:11:14.715
And their antipathy seems to be born from a very similar vein,
00:11:14.715 --> 00:11:19.195
which is that they both deeply resent the hold that Thomas Hutchinson and his
00:11:19.195 --> 00:11:21.309
family have on Massachusetts politics.
00:11:21.675 --> 00:11:24.645
This is a moment where you have a few elite families who are really pulling
00:11:24.645 --> 00:11:25.970
all the levers of government.
00:11:26.487 --> 00:11:30.446
And Thomas Hutchinson, who is a lovely, decorous, dutiful public servant,
00:11:30.707 --> 00:11:34.718
has amassed a tremendous number of titles to himself. So at various points,
00:11:35.211 --> 00:11:39.024
as Samuel Adams points out, he occupies all three branches of government.
00:11:39.367 --> 00:11:42.193
So the two Adams cousins come together over this antipathy.
00:11:42.634 --> 00:11:47.815
And thenceforth, John, they work hand in glove. John very much trailing Samuel
00:11:47.815 --> 00:11:52.595
around as a sort of junior associate, very starry-eyed. He's clearly starstruck
00:11:52.595 --> 00:11:56.036
by his cousin Samuel, very willing to do Samuel's bidding.
00:11:56.386 --> 00:12:01.244
It is probably at Samuel's suggestion that John defends the soldiers of the Boston Massacre.
00:12:01.673 --> 00:12:06.135
And only much later, after the years in Congress, will John begin to eclipse
00:12:06.135 --> 00:12:09.645
Samuel because John assumes a federal role, something that his cousin,
00:12:09.645 --> 00:12:11.043
his older cousin, never does.
00:12:11.564 --> 00:12:15.265
But when John Adams finally goes to France before the end of the war to help
00:12:15.265 --> 00:12:18.905
Ben Franklin, he's assumed to be Samuel Adams because everyone at that moment
00:12:18.905 --> 00:12:21.135
has heard of Samuel Adams, but no one has heard of John.
00:12:21.135 --> 00:12:24.825
And so poor John Adams has to say to the French, I'm not the man you think,
00:12:24.825 --> 00:12:26.943
I'm not really Mr. Adams you think I am.
00:12:27.326 --> 00:12:30.013
So that's a different Mr. Adams, and of course, nobody believes him.
00:12:30.477 --> 00:12:33.635
Well, you have a great moment with Thomas Jefferson, who asked that as well,
00:12:33.635 --> 00:12:35.065
right? Are you the famous Adams?
00:12:35.944 --> 00:12:39.125
It's very hard for John Adams, I think, to, you know, who has a certain sense
00:12:39.125 --> 00:12:43.072
of vanity that his cousin did not share, to have to sort of say, no, no, that was not I.
00:12:43.675 --> 00:12:47.925
Yeah. So then in that light, why did the crown view Adams as he write the greatest
00:12:47.925 --> 00:12:50.148
incendiary in the king's dominion?
00:12:50.821 --> 00:12:54.965
At a certain point, for better or worse, he begins to get credit.
00:12:54.965 --> 00:13:00.238
And this is after the Sugar and Stamp Act, so by the 1767, 1768,
00:13:00.714 --> 00:13:06.465
Adams begins to get credit for pretty much any piece of really smart inflammatory
00:13:06.465 --> 00:13:07.936
prose that appears in the papers.
00:13:08.631 --> 00:13:11.774
Now, in many cases, this makes sense because he is writing column inch after
00:13:11.774 --> 00:13:15.928
column inch under this pseudonym and that pseudonym over and over again in these years.
00:13:16.381 --> 00:13:20.833
But he's not the only one writing these papers. He simply has made himself the most obnoxious.
00:13:21.768 --> 00:13:27.196
He's extremely good, especially good at figuring out just how far he can push things.
00:13:27.567 --> 00:13:31.004
And this is true on any number of things. This is true in terms of street protests.
00:13:31.004 --> 00:13:35.224
This is true in terms of inflammatory pieces for the paper. this is true in
00:13:35.224 --> 00:13:39.325
terms
of setting up a gallery in the Massachusetts House of Representatives
00:13:39.645 --> 00:13:42.594
so that as he sees that the people can look down on their elected officials
00:13:42.594 --> 00:13:44.075
and there can be some accountability.
00:13:44.544 --> 00:13:48.204
And these were all gestures, of course, which were very little appreciated by
00:13:48.204 --> 00:13:52.934
the crown officers in Boston who have been writing by the 1760s letter after
00:13:52.934 --> 00:13:57.851
letter back to London saying, you know, could you maybe just do something about this, you know,
00:13:58.275 --> 00:14:04.056
gadfly Samuel Adams, because if you did, you could nip this whole opposition thing in the bud.
00:14:04.585 --> 00:14:09.594
And in a funny way, his being underestimated, I think, is a great boon to the
00:14:09.594 --> 00:14:13.414
cause of liberty, because it's that inability on the part of London to see that
00:14:13.414 --> 00:14:16.114
it's anything but a few bad eggs.
00:14:16.114 --> 00:14:18.488
You know, if you could just get rid of John Hancock and Samuel Adams,
00:14:18.673 --> 00:14:22.528
London thinks this will all, this unpleasantness will all just evaporate.
00:14:22.748 --> 00:14:27.576
And no one sees how contagious these ideas have been how far-reaching is the discontent.
00:14:28.156 --> 00:14:31.703
What was the Journal of Occurrences? Because that was fascinating too.
00:14:32.156 --> 00:14:37.392
So that too is an Adams invention that leaves poor Thomas Hutchinson tearing his hair out.
00:14:38.584 --> 00:14:42.274
Boston sees troops for the first time in 1768, which is something I think we
00:14:42.274 --> 00:14:45.706
tend to forget because I think we all think Boston Massacre 1770,
00:14:46.182 --> 00:14:48.736
but there had been troops there since the fall of 1768.
00:14:49.350 --> 00:14:52.859
And when they arrive, and there's some discussion over whether Boston should
00:14:52.859 --> 00:14:55.939
rise up in opposition when the troops arrive, how should they be greeted?
00:14:55.939 --> 00:14:58.498
Should they be greeted? Should they be housed?
00:14:59.999 --> 00:15:03.219
Was the town responsible for quartering them? But what Samuel Adams,
00:15:03.719 --> 00:15:08.349
really figures out early on is that it's essential for the other colonies to
00:15:08.349 --> 00:15:13.329
see, essentially, Boston being martyred at the hands of these troops,
00:15:13.329 --> 00:15:16.767
who in fact are relatively well-behaved as far as troops go.
00:15:17.330 --> 00:15:21.269
But Adams and as Confederates begin a sort of news syndicate called the Journal
00:15:21.269 --> 00:15:24.555
of Occurrences, where they start to deliver,
00:15:25.123 --> 00:15:31.179
these incredibly colorful accounts of assaults by soldiers in the town of Boston
00:15:31.179 --> 00:15:34.499
on men, women, and children, you know, women in their beds, old women in their
00:15:34.499 --> 00:15:39.456
shops, young boys in the streets, you know, pistols in
the face, muskets in the back.
00:15:39.984 --> 00:15:45.523
And they distribute these little snippets, all of them extremely colorful, to the New York papers.
00:15:45.837 --> 00:15:51.219
And then from New York, those snippets are sent on to Philadelphia where they are published again.
00:15:51.219 --> 00:15:55.889
So they're basically trying to just disseminate as much essentially disfavor
00:15:55.889 --> 00:16:00.359
as they can for the Boston troops in order to sort of bring the other colonies
00:16:00.359 --> 00:16:01.911
into Massachusetts' orbit.
00:16:03.039 --> 00:16:05.394
What were Adams' views on enslavement?
00:16:06.560 --> 00:16:10.882
He's very clear about slavery really early on, and I wish I could account,
00:16:10.882 --> 00:16:14.312
other than the fact that he truly believes that all men are created equal.
00:16:14.312 --> 00:16:15.453
I wish I could account for this.
00:16:16.637 --> 00:16:21.262
On his second marriage, he and his new wife are given a household slave,
00:16:21.262 --> 00:16:26.168
which was apparently a very common wedding gift at the time among upper-crust Bostonians.
00:16:26.673 --> 00:16:30.572
And Adams makes a big point of it. Adams basically says she cannot come and
00:16:30.572 --> 00:16:32.350
live in our house unless she is freed.
00:16:32.815 --> 00:16:37.292
And it is, in fact, on those terms that Surrey does come to live with the family
00:16:37.292 --> 00:16:39.374
and stays there for decades, in fact.
00:16:39.891 --> 00:16:43.920
And he'll later make several attempts in the Massachusetts House with other
00:16:44.059 --> 00:16:48.452
Confederates to try to write up some kind of legislation abolishing the slave
00:16:48.452 --> 00:16:50.439
trade. Obviously, he doesn't succeed.
00:16:50.938 --> 00:16:55.312
And ultimately, this will be something that trips him up when it comes to ratifying
00:16:55.312 --> 00:16:56.402
the Constitution as well.
00:16:56.402 --> 00:16:59.982
He feels there needs to be a clause for the abolition of the slave trade.
00:16:59.982 --> 00:17:06.040
And he's struck by the fact that it isn't there and therefore the document seems to him incomplete.
00:17:06.794 --> 00:17:11.293
Now, you mentioned his second wife. Can you tell us about his two marriages and his two children?
00:17:11.965 --> 00:17:16.396
So he marries two women named Betsy, which is very inconvenient from a Bible.
00:17:17.772 --> 00:17:23.152
The first wife is not thoroughly from an unexpected corner. She's the daughter of his minister.
00:17:23.268 --> 00:17:25.973
So it's someone he probably had known all his life.
00:17:26.455 --> 00:17:31.016
We know relatively little about the first Mrs. Adams for the happy reason that
00:17:31.016 --> 00:17:32.579
the two of them are almost never apart.
00:17:32.875 --> 00:17:35.706
And obviously, when people are together, they're not writing each other letters,
00:17:35.706 --> 00:17:37.496
so we have relatively little to go on.
00:17:38.019 --> 00:17:41.101
She does bear two children, and then she dies in childbirth.
00:17:41.562 --> 00:17:46.766
And what's curious about Adams is that he will then spend seven years as a bachelor.
00:17:46.766 --> 00:17:51.482
He's a single father for seven years, which is really out of keeping with most
00:17:51.801 --> 00:17:55.661
Bostonians. There were plenty of women in Boston. There were a lot of widows in Boston.
00:17:56.097 --> 00:18:00.116
Paul Revere went five months between marriages. It was very unusual to spend
00:18:00.116 --> 00:18:01.524
that long as a single father.
00:18:01.913 --> 00:18:06.166
And he ultimately remarries the daughter of a distiller who had gone bankrupt
00:18:06.166 --> 00:18:08.887
in these years, in fact, so he clearly didn't marry for money,
00:18:09.322 --> 00:18:13.003
who is charmingly his intellectual equal,
00:18:13.462 --> 00:18:16.636
and whom Abigail Adams writes about with tremendous fondness,
00:18:16.636 --> 00:18:19.406
telling us that the two of them made for a lovely couple.
00:18:20.066 --> 00:18:23.346
It's clearly a relationship in which they tease each other a great deal.
00:18:23.346 --> 00:18:26.236
He writes someone about the fact that she's always sort of looking over his
00:18:26.236 --> 00:18:27.597
shoulder as he writes letters.
00:18:28.080 --> 00:18:32.877
And who turns out to be very much of the Abigail Adams school,
00:18:32.877 --> 00:18:38.838
really very resourceful, dauntless, unfazed by the fact that there's cannon fire in the distance,
00:18:39.297 --> 00:18:43.877
very much eager to share his political views and his political grudges,
00:18:44.243 --> 00:18:47.427
and very eager to talk to him, in fact, about what's happening politically.
00:18:47.427 --> 00:18:50.013
At one point, he'll be made fun of in the papers.
00:18:50.402 --> 00:18:53.917
He'll be mocked for the fact that he actually has written his wife about politics,
00:18:53.917 --> 00:18:56.107
which was considered something one didn't do at the time.
00:18:56.403 --> 00:19:00.617
But it's clearly a very blessed marriage and one where she, in fact,
00:19:00.617 --> 00:19:05.527
while he's in Congress, supports the family because he is still in these years
00:19:05.527 --> 00:19:08.907
without profession and has, on his last trip home from Philadelphia,
00:19:08.907 --> 00:19:10.567
evidently forgotten to give her any money.
00:19:10.567 --> 00:19:14.388
So she turns out to some kind of manual labor, we don't know what kind,
00:19:14.563 --> 00:19:15.549
to support the household.
00:19:16.066 --> 00:19:20.047
Yes, and you mentioned earlier about his complicated relationship with Hancock.
00:19:20.047 --> 00:19:21.511
Can you tell us more about that?
00:19:22.254 --> 00:19:26.407
So Hancock is one of the early recruits. He's also significantly younger than
00:19:26.407 --> 00:19:28.005
Adams. I think he's 15 years younger.
00:19:29.327 --> 00:19:32.858
And he's in possession. John Hancock has inherited a tremendous fortune from his
uncle.
00:19:33.148 --> 00:19:38.727
So Adams makes the fairly interesting, fairly obvious calculation that the fortune
00:19:38.727 --> 00:19:42.787
will be of tremendous use to the cause, and that John Hancock,
00:19:42.787 --> 00:19:47.866
who's very given to attention, will appreciate all the adulation that comes with it.
00:19:48.092 --> 00:19:52.376
And that's exactly what happens. I mean, he really does, he nails that one completely.
00:19:52.736 --> 00:19:57.477
What he doesn't count on is how much Hancock will occasionally be frustrated
00:19:57.477 --> 00:20:00.537
by the fact that he's seen to be the dupe of Adams and that he's seen to be
00:20:00.537 --> 00:20:03.429
sort of trailing Samuel Adams around town.
00:20:03.922 --> 00:20:10.437
So that there are, at various points, real kind of rocky patches in their relationship at one point.
00:20:10.878 --> 00:20:14.347
John Hancock will do everything he can to see that Adams is not voted back into
00:20:14.347 --> 00:20:15.528
the Massachusetts house.
00:20:16.271 --> 00:20:20.903
Shortly after the Boston Massacre, Hancock will tell Thomas Hutchinson he's
00:20:20.903 --> 00:20:25.132
never going to speak to Samuel Adams again and hopes never to in his entire lifetime.
00:20:25.578 --> 00:20:28.815
And friends have to intervene to sort of make peace between the two friends.
00:20:29.239 --> 00:20:33.383
They're together on the night that Paul Revere gallops off to warn them that
00:20:33.383 --> 00:20:35.331
the British are coming out to arrest them.
00:20:35.569 --> 00:20:38.872
And even that night, under severe distress and in great danger,
00:20:39.006 --> 00:20:42.113
they manage to have a fight over whether they should actually go out with their
00:20:42.113 --> 00:20:44.451
muskets or hide themselves as statesmen.
00:20:44.817 --> 00:20:49.193
And it takes Revere twice, two calls on the parsonage in Lexington to get them
00:20:49.193 --> 00:20:52.898
finally to agree on what the proper course of action should be.
00:20:53.397 --> 00:20:58.037
And then Hancock will find that the other Massachusetts delegates in Congress,
00:20:58.525 --> 00:21:01.127
he'll find that they are extremely scornful of him.
00:21:01.359 --> 00:21:05.433
And he's not wrong. I mean, they do tend to treat him as a lesser intellectual.
00:21:05.433 --> 00:21:07.244
He's not a man of great ideas.
00:21:07.773 --> 00:21:12.773
And they see him as a sort of a flimsy person who's a little bit of a whirligig
00:21:12.773 --> 00:21:15.973
in terms of where his head is going, and who's much more given to
00:21:16.313 --> 00:21:19.163
naming opportunities in the town of Boston, with which he's very generous,
00:21:19.163 --> 00:21:23.843
in fact, and to outfitting his coach and to traveling in splendid livery than
00:21:23.843 --> 00:21:27.099
as someone who's really upholding the cause of the new nation.
00:21:27.741 --> 00:21:31.834
You mentioned those Harvard theses, but I was wondering about your other favorite
00:21:31.834 --> 00:21:34.707
or most surprising discoveries you made in your research.
00:21:34.980 --> 00:21:38.904
I'll tell you what was not—I'll tell you a surprising, unhappy discovery.
00:21:39.487 --> 00:21:44.054
You asked about Samuel Adams' domestic life, and I had always assumed I would
00:21:44.054 --> 00:21:48.903
work from the memoir that his daughter, Hannah, had written about him,
00:21:49.100 --> 00:21:53.843
because the few little anecdotes we have from that are really wonderful and extremely telling.
00:21:54.278 --> 00:21:58.774
And that memoir, which is, I think, 65 pages, is meant to be with the papers
00:21:58.774 --> 00:22:01.138
of Samuel Adams, but it is no longer there.
00:22:01.400 --> 00:22:04.884
So that was one of those unhappy surprises where you think, I mean,
00:22:04.884 --> 00:22:07.854
I just kept sort of working my way toward it, and then when I went to look for
00:22:07.854 --> 00:22:10.003
it, lo and behold, it's missing.
00:22:10.310 --> 00:22:15.014
So the domestic life really is cobbled together from the remaining letters between
00:22:15.014 --> 00:22:19.291
the second Mrs. Adams and Samuel with some anecdotes of the daughter.
00:22:19.619 --> 00:22:23.564
I think that there's a lot of Adams in those Journal of Occurrence pieces.
00:22:24.952 --> 00:22:28.084
There's a great deal of, you know, the marauding soldiers did this and can you
00:22:28.084 --> 00:22:29.451
believe they attacked this woman?
00:22:29.753 --> 00:22:35.344
But threaded through that are these real anthems to America's future and to
00:22:35.344 --> 00:22:38.501
what the rights and privileges of the colonies should consist of.
00:22:38.954 --> 00:22:42.094
And it's very rousing material. And I think that was, you know,
00:22:42.094 --> 00:22:46.624
that to me was the really sustaining part of the research, was to see how intent
00:22:46.624 --> 00:22:49.281
he was on these ideas, how expert he was,
00:22:49.989 --> 00:22:55.507
at articulating them, and how much the grammar and the vocabulary that he really
00:22:55.507 --> 00:22:59.909
is early on attaching himself to begins to filter into the groundwater.
00:23:00.431 --> 00:23:04.287
Well, and perhaps that 65 pages is in someone's attic in New England right now.
00:23:04.287 --> 00:23:07.177
That's why I'm mentioning it now, in case someone on this call happens to have
00:23:07.177 --> 00:23:10.257
those 65 pages. And they have to surface, right? It's just not...
00:23:10.257 --> 00:23:13.967
Right, that would be an amazing book breaks discovery, so you all heard it here first.
00:23:15.007 --> 00:23:18.252
So now we have a number of teachers and students on the call.
00:23:18.479 --> 00:23:22.258
I was wondering if you could let us know how you think this book could be utilized in classrooms.
00:23:22.842 --> 00:23:25.327
Oh, that's such a great question. Well, first of all, let me just start by saying
00:23:25.327 --> 00:23:29.797
that the easiest page of this book to write was the dedication page because
00:23:29.797 --> 00:23:31.927
it is dedicated to my 11th grade history teacher.
00:23:32.165 --> 00:23:36.316
So, U.S. history teacher. So, you know, be careful, this could happen to you.
00:23:37.431 --> 00:23:42.437
To some extent, what happens with Adams' life is really an amazing advertisement
00:23:42.437 --> 00:23:45.482
for what one individual can achieve.
00:23:46.028 --> 00:23:50.177
And, you know, he's so out in front. He's so out of pace with everyone else.
00:23:50.177 --> 00:23:53.069
He's so tenacious at times when everyone else has fallen away.
00:23:53.499 --> 00:23:56.859
He's such an advertisement, really, for the single-minded idealist.
00:23:57.167 --> 00:23:59.610
And I think that's a, you know, a very rousing lesson.
00:24:00.121 --> 00:24:03.598
I think, too, he's fighting for rights and privileges that,
00:24:04.381 --> 00:24:09.925
to this day, I think we're looking to sustain and extend. And this sort of early articulation of them.
00:24:11.039 --> 00:24:14.390
Is vital, first of all, for us to understand, and second of all,
00:24:14.390 --> 00:24:20.829
for us to insist upon at times when those things seem to be corroding or evaporating at the edges.
00:24:21.044 --> 00:24:24.580
I could go on and on with these lessons, but I guess the other essential one
00:24:24.580 --> 00:24:26.274
is this is a protest movement.
00:24:26.524 --> 00:24:30.999
And I think when I say Adams, this piece of this is washed away to some extent.
00:24:31.615 --> 00:24:36.800
If you look at it through the prism of what we today consider real civil resistance
00:24:36.800 --> 00:24:40.870
theory, Adams hits every one of the major points instinctively.
00:24:40.870 --> 00:24:43.920
He obviously isn't appealing to 21st century civil resistance theory,
00:24:43.920 --> 00:24:49.110
but his ability to achieve solidarity, to fold men, women, and children into
00:24:49.110 --> 00:24:51.930
what he's doing, to, as I say, change,
00:24:52.630 --> 00:24:56.760
the very vocabulary with which people are speaking is extraordinary.
00:24:57.184 --> 00:25:02.304
And that is the kind of protest, I think, that we keep reaching for today and
00:25:02.629 --> 00:25:05.370
wondering how to achieve. And I just think it's interesting to look back and
00:25:05.370 --> 00:25:09.070
see, you know, how protest worked then and what we're doing with it today.
00:25:10.130 --> 00:25:13.670
There's a real resonance, I think, between the two times. Another question I
00:25:13.670 --> 00:25:16.272
have to ask, did he ever work as a brewer?
00:25:17.409 --> 00:25:19.319
He didn't drink. Isn't that terrifying?
00:25:20.470 --> 00:25:24.291
His family had made their fortune as malsters, which is to say,
00:25:24.547 --> 00:25:28.970
for several generations, they had been the ones to prepare the barley for the
00:25:28.970 --> 00:25:33.450
brewing of beer, which was a very different operation in an age of some specialization
00:25:33.450 -->
00:25:35.112
than was the actual brewing.
00:25:35.437 --> 00:25:39.570
But if you wanted to brew beer, you stopped at Samuel Adams Sr.'s malt shop
00:25:39.570 --> 00:25:42.740
and you bought your bags of malt.
00:25:43.158 --> 00:25:46.290
And that was how his father had made the fortune. And that is the business that
00:25:46.290 --> 00:25:51.050
Adams inherits in some part and manages to squander over the next years.
00:25:51.172 --> 00:25:53.273
So no, alas, he never works as a brewer.
00:25:53.564 --> 00:25:59.320
But I think Jim Cook, who named Sam Adams beer, also picked the name because
00:25:59.320 --> 00:26:02.140
of a history, because of a U.S. history teacher. So I just want to say there's
00:26:02.140 --> 00:26:04.587
like a, you know, there's a double whammy there.
00:26:04.994 --> 00:26:07.983
Yeah. How do you think he would feel about having a beer named after him?
00:26:09.113 --> 00:26:12.583
I think he would—you know, it's a really hard one. Since he's not a drinker,
00:26:12.583 --> 00:26:16.059
I just think he'd be so happy that he would remember it, right? Yes.
00:26:16.713 --> 00:26:22.172
And how well known was he during his lifetime? Did he receive a lot of notoriety?
00:26:22.721 --> 00:26:27.783
At the time, there was a—if you were the greatest incendiary in your colony,
00:26:27.783 --> 00:26:32.223
if you were the greatest pain to the British authorities, you were known as
00:26:32.223 --> 00:26:36.915
the Samuel Adams of Georgia or the Samuel Adams of North Carolina or the Samuel Adams of Rhode Island.
00:26:37.286 --> 00:26:43.337
So well enough known that other people were obviously given the same nickname as you.
00:26:43.854 --> 00:26:47.133
The Crown knows him because the Crown officers have been writing back about
00:26:47.133 --> 00:26:49.330
him with such indignation for years.
00:26:49.754 --> 00:26:54.653
By the time Thomas Hutchinson finally goes back to London after the destruction
00:26:54.653 --> 00:26:58.103
of the T in the harbor and meets with the King, he's asked, you know,
00:26:58.103 --> 00:26:59.630
who were the leading men of the party?
00:27:00.239 --> 00:27:06.062
And the King is already slightly acquainted with this reputation of this malefactor Samuel Adams.
00:27:06.933 --> 00:27:10.653
And Hutchinson at that meeting, in fact, will say that Adams was the first person,
00:27:11.605 --> 00:27:14.763
to advocate for independence of the colonies, which I'm not sure is actually
00:27:14.763 --> 00:27:17.328
true, but it was certainly how Thomas Hutchinson saw the situation.
00:27:17.642 --> 00:27:22.703
So it meant well enough known that another Samuel Adams, this one living on
00:27:22.703 --> 00:27:26.473
Cape Cod, would write to him at one point and say, it's a glorious thing to
00:27:26.473 --> 00:27:30.814
share your name. I'm very proud to do so, but it does expose one to a certain amount of danger.
00:27:32.555 --> 00:27:35.841
Now, what do you hope readers take away upon finishing this
book?
00:27:36.643 --> 00:27:41.493
I think the sense that the Revolution didn't happen in a preordained way.
00:27:41.853 --> 00:27:44.695
I don't know how you all are teaching history, but in my faint memory,
00:27:45.351 --> 00:27:49.033
there's sort of the Stamp Act, and then maybe you stop at the T in the harbor,
00:27:49.033 --> 00:27:50.733
and then suddenly it's Lexington and Concord.
00:27:51.452 --> 00:27:54.826
And what happens over those 12 or 14, however you're counting, years,
00:27:55.714 --> 00:28:01.224
is very back and forth and very helter-skelter. It's anything but preordained.
00:28:01.844 --> 00:28:05.974
Things come to a shuddering halt at various times. They pick up largely because
00:28:05.974 --> 00:28:08.402
of Britishness, because of missteps from the Crown.
00:28:08.928 --> 00:28:11.874
There are moments where you think, especially after the Boston Massacre,
00:28:11.874 --> 00:28:15.274
where everyone really just wants to go back to life as normal and forget about
00:28:15.274 --> 00:28:16.585
all this opposition stuff.
00:28:17.071 --> 00:28:22.479
So I think there's something about the fact that it is an incredibly improbable result,
00:28:22.955 --> 00:28:28.564
but it is also born of these very momentously variegated years where there is
00:28:28.564 --> 00:28:33.950
no linear, you can't really draw a linear line between the Sugar Act and 1776.
00:28:34.420 --> 00:28:39.529
What you can draw, though, is a sense of how much the thinking changes there.
00:28:40.434 --> 00:28:44.416
And that, to me, is the astonishment, is that you could have such a complete reversal in thought.
00:28:44.886 --> 00:28:48.454
To have been loyal, to have been a patriot in 1750 meant you were loyal to the
00:28:48.454 --> 00:28:51.867
crown. To be a patriot in 1770 meant you were loyal to the colonies.
00:28:52.844 --> 00:28:56.465
It's an extraordinary and sort of dizzying, really, change in thought.
00:28:57.179 --> 00:29:00.914
Yeah. Now you've written about everyone from Cleopatra to Ben Franklin.
00:29:00.914 --> 00:29:02.949
Can you share with us what might be next?
00:29:03.800 --> 00:29:07.724
I would love to, but I think I will not this week, if that's all right.
00:29:07.724 --> 00:29:11.564
Of course, yes. I think it's 18th century. I'm sort of hesitating between two
00:29:11.564 --> 00:29:15.744
ideas, and I haven't entirely touched down. And the thing about having two ideas,
00:29:15.744 --> 00:29:17.947
it's like having two fiancées, you never have to get married.
00:29:18.964 --> 00:29:22.084
So as long as I can prolong, I'm not sure if it's this or that.
00:29:22.564 --> 00:29:26.374
I don't have to really do anything. No. Well, when you make the choice,
00:29:26.374 --> 00:29:29.882
we hope you and your intended will join us again on Boat Breaks.
00:29:31.444 --> 00:29:34.838
I'm going to pass you over to Ryan to start with our student question of the week.
00:29:35.245 --> 00:29:38.854
Thanks, Gina. Yeah, thank you so
much, Gina, for that wonderful back and forth.
00:29:38.854 --> 00:29:40.359
It was really awesome to listen to.
00:29:40.696 --> 00:29:43.904
And for our loyal listeners, they know that we always begin this part of the
00:29:43.904 --> 00:29:46.914
program with our History Scholar Question of the Week.
00:29:46.914 --> 00:29:51.194
And just as a reminder, the History Scholar of the Week is a weekly competition
00:29:51.194 --> 00:29:54.824
in which students have a chance to ask our great guests, like Stacey Shipp,
00:29:54.824 --> 00:29:57.868
a question for a chance for themselves and their teacher to win
00:29:58.204 --> 00:30:02.198
the $50 gift card to the Gilded Allurement Institute of American History gift shop.
00:30:02.854 --> 00:30:07.264
And this week, our question's coming from very far away. It's Marinus High School
00:30:07.264 --> 00:30:10.322
in, again, complete the other side of the world.
00:30:10.616 --> 00:30:14.107
And the winning winner is Kelly, who's in Miss Algiers' class.
00:30:14.728 --> 00:30:20.104
And Kelly asks, how did your perception or understanding of Samuel Adams evolve,
00:30:20.104 --> 00:30:22.636
if it did, throughout your research and writing process?
00:30:23.012 --> 00:30:27.874
That is such a great question, Kelly, I think every biographer goes into a project
00:30:27.874 --> 00:30:31.854
thinking she has some sense of her subject. I mean, obviously,
00:30:31.854 --> 00:30:32.804
there's an attraction of some
00:30:32.804 --> 00:30:35.789
kind, so you're following something that you find appealing in some way.
00:30:36.433 --> 00:30:41.797
And to me, anyway, the beauty of the enterprise is that your ideas change as you research.
00:30:42.238 --> 00:30:45.484
And I mean, I'm thinking about this in particular when I did a book on Cleopatra,
00:30:45.484 --> 00:30:52.794
where I hadn't really understood at the outset how ceaselessly shrewd she was.
00:30:52.794 --> 00:30:55.784
I mean, she's an incredibly strategic thinker. And I had to kind of go back
00:30:55.784 --> 00:31:00.794
into the first chapters and thread in more of her kind of ruthlessness in a
00:31:00.794 --> 00:31:02.852
funny way than I had understood when I started.
00:31:03.283 --> 00:31:07.954
In this case, I think that the real revelation was listening to what his contemporaries
00:31:07.954 --> 00:31:15.371
had to say and leaving aside what we today use as his legacy or think of as his legacy so that.
00:31:16.172 --> 00:31:19.875
Really the Tory point of view, the Thomas Hutchinson comments about,
00:31:19.875 --> 00:31:24.744
you know, him having been incredibly rude and incredibly obstreperous and a firebrand,
00:31:25.342 --> 00:31:28.505
those are really the way the South would have seen him early on at the First
00:31:28.505 --> 00:31:31.917
Continental Congress or the way the Crown officers would have seen him.
00:31:32.359 --> 00:31:35.423
They're certainly not the Samuel Adams that his contemporaries saw.
00:31:35.690 --> 00:31:37.687
So, leaving—beginning to sort of,
00:31:38.307 --> 00:31:43.132
to peel that away from the story and to look at what his friends in Boston,
00:31:43.132 --> 00:31:45.267
what his colleagues had to say about him.
00:31:45.592 --> 00:31:50.482
And as I hinted earlier, the real takeaway there is that he's this tremendously.
00:31:51.182 --> 00:31:57.662
Serene, formal character, very comfortable with his faith, very much convinced
00:31:57.662 --> 00:32:00.199
from day one that he's on the side of the angels.
00:32:00.575 --> 00:32:04.000
And though he is unrelenting, he's a very patient man.
00:32:04.267 --> 00:32:08.162
And there's none of this, I mean, with the South fears that the First Continental
00:32:08.162 --> 00:32:12.052
Congress is really that the Northern states are going to overtake the Southern
00:32:12.052 --> 00:32:15.462
states. They're not even as worried about London as they are about these hot-headed
00:32:15.462 --> 00:32:17.039
fanatics from New England.
00:32:17.334 --> 00:32:22.344
And Adams is not of that make at all. John Adams may have been, Samuel Adams was not.
00:32:22.687 --> 00:32:25.436
And that took me a while as well to get my mind around.
00:32:26.039 --> 00:32:29.332
Fascinating. Thank you so much for that question, Kelly. It was a great one.
00:32:29.332 --> 00:32:30.624
And for the answer, of course.
00:32:30.979 --> 00:32:35.502
Sam asks what I think is an interesting question. Since Adams was so well-known
00:32:35.502 --> 00:32:39.592
as an agitator against English authority in Massachusetts, it's surprising that
00:32:39.592 --> 00:32:42.905
he didn't face more repercussions by the likes of Hutchinson.
00:32:43.224 --> 00:32:46.902
Is there any evidence that the English authorities were afraid of popular reaction
00:32:46.902 --> 00:32:49.354
if they acted, you know, harshly against Adams?
00:32:49.905 --> 00:32:54.992
Immensely astute. There are numerous junctures at which Francis Bernard,
00:32:54.992 --> 00:32:58.212
who's the royal governor before Thomas Hutchinson and Thomas Hutchinson,
00:32:58.694 --> 00:33:03.442
will write back to London and say, you know, here's what appeared in the paper.
00:33:03.442 --> 00:33:06.032
Surely this is sedition. Can we please arrest this man?
00:33:06.572 --> 00:33:12.472
And at several junctures, you see a conversation in London about what laws actually
00:33:12.472 --> 00:33:15.773
apply. And it's complicated because what you're doing is you're having to try,
00:33:16.307 --> 00:33:18.692
bring someone back from the colonies to try them.
00:33:19.210 --> 00:33:23.582
Is that even legal? It hadn't been used. That statute dates from something like
00:33:23.582 --> 00:33:27.160
Henry VIII. They weren't sure if they could really dust it off without repercussion.
00:33:27.787 --> 00:33:33.568
And there are large discussions in London about whether the rule of law is on their side or not.
00:33:34.079 --> 00:33:37.521
And this will come up again just after
the destruction of the tea in Boston
00:33:37.521 --> 00:33:42.521
in 1773, when the king is furious that this has happened. No one can believe
00:33:42.521 --> 00:33:46.422
these Bostonians have actually destroyed tea. It's private property.
00:33:46.846 --> 00:33:50.911
And the king will ask his solicitor general and his attorney general together
00:33:50.911 --> 00:33:54.247
to put together a case to have the perpetrators punished.
00:33:54.711 --> 00:33:58.151
And Adams is at the top of that list because he's understood to have been one
00:33:58.151 --> 00:33:59.808
of the prime movers behind the destruction.
00:34:00.214 --> 00:34:04.751
And they first put together what they consider to be a fairly good case.
00:34:04.751 --> 00:34:07.651
And then one of them, I think it's the Solicitor General, basically says,
00:34:07.651 --> 00:34:10.286
this isn't going to hold up. We just don't have the right to do this.
00:34:10.489 --> 00:34:12.684
And instead, the Intolerable Acts are passed.
00:34:13.038 --> 00:34:17.661
But so the short answer here is, yes, there were numerous attempts made to figure
00:34:17.661 --> 00:34:22.351
out a way to extract him from the colonies. He does fear arrest at certain points.
00:34:22.351 --> 00:34:24.581
He's told at one point he's likely to be assassinated.
00:34:25.132 --> 00:34:28.928
By the time General Gage comes to America after the destruction of the T,
00:34:29.410 --> 00:34:33.271
his first order of business is meant to be to arrest Samuel Adams.
00:34:33.724 --> 00:34:39.021
And very quickly after arrival, he realizes that to do that is to detonate a
00:34:39.021 --> 00:34:43.975
revolt of some kind. And he just, he realizes he's just missed his moment and he can't do that.
00:34:44.301 --> 00:34:50.821
But as late as January of 1774, when Gage marches out to Concord,
00:34:51.187 --> 00:34:54.741
his orders, in fact, were not to collect munitions in Concord.
00:34:54.741 --> 00:34:58.194
His orders were to arrest Samuel Adams and John Hancock.
00:34:58.827 --> 00:35:02.989
Wow. Fascinating. Thank you so much for that great question, Sam, and answer.
00:35:03.601 --> 00:35:07.301
Adam, I think, raises an interesting point. He says, I was struck in the book
00:35:07.301 --> 00:35:13.661
by the amount of disinformation, misinformation, and selective quotation and such put forth by Adams.
00:35:13.661 --> 00:35:16.261
If you could maybe comment on the use of, you know, this is,
00:35:16.261 --> 00:35:20.667
we think maybe this is a 21st century creation, but it certainly is not, right?
00:35:21.125 --> 00:35:23.871
Yeah. And I think that's, you know, to the many teachable moments,
00:35:23.871 --> 00:35:27.951
I think that's one of them is that misinformation is so deeply,
00:35:27.951 --> 00:35:30.841
profoundly threaded through this effort as well.
00:35:31.201 --> 00:35:34.915
It wasn't invented in the 21st century. It has been there since time immemorial.
00:35:35.245 --> 00:35:40.651
I will say, just
to put a larger context here, there was no such thing as an
00:35:40.651 --> 00:35:43.420
objective press at the time. That doesn't happen until the 20th century.
00:35:43.716 --> 00:35:47.020
And nowhere in the world in the 18th century was there an objective newspaper.
00:35:47.240 --> 00:35:49.533
So this was not all that unusual.
00:35:49.921 --> 00:35:53.748
Adams certainly, as I said, pushes the limits of this in all ways.
00:35:56.141 --> 00:36:00.121
Basically, what happens after the Boston massacre is perhaps the best illustration
00:36:00.121 --> 00:36:02.276
of how far he's willing to push this.
00:36:02.676 --> 00:36:06.531
Because of John Adams' brilliant work, most of the soldiers have been exonerated
00:36:06.531 --> 00:36:09.386
from after the massacre, except for two.
00:36:10.210 --> 00:36:16.144
That said, Samuel Adams does not hesitate for several months in 1771 from relitigating
00:36:16.272 --> 00:36:17.890
the entire case in the press,
00:36:18.668 --> 00:36:23.291
essentially cherry-picking the information and publishing what he feels is likely
00:36:23.291 --> 00:36:26.470
to sound more damning as opposed to what John had used in the courtroom.
00:36:27.206 --> 00:36:30.791
That was exactly how he made this work. I think you could say,
00:36:30.791 --> 00:36:32.501
wow, this is really out of line.
00:36:32.501 --> 00:36:35.511
On the other hand, it was extremely effective for what he meant to do.
00:36:35.871 --> 00:36:40.001
And that kind of misinformation is there throughout the war years and for many
00:36:40.001 --> 00:36:45.492
years afterward. He hardly invents it. He is an immensely agile practitioner of it.
00:36:46.253 --> 00:36:51.021
Fascinating. Thank you so much for that. Jim asks, if you were able to describe
00:36:51.021 --> 00:36:55.731
the relationship between Samuel Adams and James Otis, the relationship seems very special
00:36:56.111 --> 00:36:59.121
with respect to the beginning of the revolution, and it doesn't seem like this
00:36:59.121 --> 00:37:02.363
relationship gets the scholarship that it really deserves.
00:37:03.025 --> 00:37:06.771
I don't think that Otis gets the attention he deserves generally,
00:37:07.131 --> 00:37:10.866
and I assume that's because the archive is fairly sparse for Otis.
00:37:11.476 --> 00:37:15.280
Otis, in fact, although younger than Adams, is his political mentor.
00:37:15.734 --> 00:37:20.250
And insofar as Adams is brought to the public's attention in these early years,
00:37:20.685 --> 00:37:22.392
it is because Otis has put him there.
00:37:22.746 --> 00:37:27.351
Otis is an absolutely brilliant lawyer. He can speak extemporaneously and apparently
00:37:27.351 --> 00:37:30.240
very quotably for hours on end. He's a fiery orator.
00:37:30.706 --> 00:37:34.287
And it's he who really takes Adams under his wing.
00:37:34.891 --> 00:37:40.321
The Sugar on the Stamp Act protests are really largely done with the two of
00:37:40.321 --> 00:37:41.432
them working hand in glove.
00:37:41.885 --> 00:37:46.231
And then over the course of the next few years in 1760s, Otis will begin to
00:37:46.231 --> 00:37:50.461
suffer from whatever mental illness it is that will ultimately do him in.
00:37:50.461 --> 00:37:53.224
We don't know what it is. It sounds like it was some kind of schizophrenia.
00:37:53.839 --> 00:37:59.121
And he becomes very erratic in his actions. On one day, he might shoot pistols
00:37:59.121 --> 00:38:02.941
from his window. On another, he might break all the windows in the townhouse.
00:38:02.941 --> 00:38:06.981
He will alternately swear that the Great Britain should be drowned.
00:38:06.981 --> 00:38:08.601
He never says the king because that would be treason.
00:38:08.955 --> 00:38:11.831
And he will go to Thomas Hutchinson's house and land on his doorstep and say
00:38:11.831 --> 00:38:17.131
that he regrets all of his actions against Hutchinson. So he's immensely erratic.
00:38:17.131 --> 00:38:18.396
He's clearly very troubled.
00:38:19.018 --> 00:38:20.463
Adams will be left.
00:38:21.249 --> 00:38:26.016
On the one hand, immensely loyal to him, cleaning up after him,
00:38:26.016 --> 00:38:32.086
really, writing to their colleagues and saying, I know this is difficult,
00:38:32.086 --> 00:38:34.706
but we really need to keep Otis in.
00:38:35.586 --> 00:38:38.476
We need to fold him into what we're doing. We need to add him to our committees.
00:38:38.476 --> 00:38:42.576
We need to be really careful, basically bonding, making sure that there's a
00:38:42.576 --> 00:38:46.387
band around him to protect Otis from himself to a large extent.
00:38:46.689 --> 00:38:50.793
And Otis will ultimately be carted off, in fact, and straitjacketed by his family.
00:38:51.130 --> 00:38:54.717
But insofar as Adams was able to protect him, he did try to do so.
00:38:55.158 --> 00:38:59.196
And by the time Adams will form his committees of correspondence in 1773,
00:38:59.196 --> 00:39:01.877
he will put Otis front and center on one of those committees.
00:39:02.429 --> 00:39:06.246
It's unclear how active Otis actually was at that point, or at least it's unclear
00:39:06.246 --> 00:39:11.236
to me, but this is, again, Adams protecting his old mentor insofar as he was
00:39:11.236 --> 00:39:13.421
capable in keeping him at the center of the action.
00:39:14.626 --> 00:39:18.806
Thank you so much for that. Although the event has been mythicized in American
00:39:18.806 --> 00:39:21.635
culture and American history, several in our audience are asking if you could
00:39:21.890 --> 00:39:26.397
just talk a little bit more about how instrumental Adams was in the Boston Tea Party.
00:39:27.566 --> 00:39:31.064
And how significant that was for accelerating the revolution.
00:39:31.430 --> 00:39:35.839
Yeah, and I think that's another one where we sort of glide past that event a little bit.
00:39:36.906 --> 00:39:41.789
I think he's hugely instrumental. I think this is really his masterpiece. And I say that,
00:39:42.753 --> 00:39:46.247
I say that because I'm sort of combining disparate things, not because I have,
00:39:47.262 --> 00:39:48.577
one sort of scene to point to.
00:39:49.222 --> 00:39:54.202
Early on, and most importantly, it's Adams and his friends who have helped to
00:39:54.202 --> 00:40:00.476
forge this equation between British overreach and the consumption of tea.
00:40:00.836 --> 00:40:06.014
So that what London misreads when they send the East India Tea Company to America,
00:40:06.624 --> 00:40:10.772
is this sense that already America is on edge about tea. Already the consumption
00:40:10.772 --> 00:40:12.475
of tea is considered to be noxious.
00:40:12.986 --> 00:40:16.132
And that is something that is largely the work of Adams.
00:40:16.132 --> 00:40:22.472
So the overreach and the clumsiness on the part of Great Britain comes right
00:40:22.472 --> 00:40:28.178
up against what Adams' earlier work has accomplished, just in the dispatch of the tea.
00:40:28.613 --> 00:40:32.822
It doesn't help, I should add, that the tea, which is meant to be sold in America
00:40:32.822 --> 00:40:37.892
without middlemen, which is part of the Tea Act, is consigned to six individuals,
00:40:37.892 --> 00:40:41.092
two of whom are Thomas Hutchinson's sons, two of them his friends,
00:40:41.092 --> 00:40:42.922
and two of them his relatives.
00:40:43.160 --> 00:40:47.912
So again, it proves what Adams and his friends have been saying so long about
00:40:47.912 --> 00:40:51.022
this stranglehold of a few families on power in New England.
00:40:51.022 --> 00:40:54.552
So in a funny way, I guess what I'm saying is the British in passing the Tea
00:40:54.552 --> 00:40:57.612
Act have played into his hands to some extent because they've proved what he's
00:40:57.612 --> 00:40:59.931
been saying essentially now for years.
00:41:00.582 --> 00:41:04.912
The tea is dispatched. There's some communication among Philadelphia,
00:41:04.912 --> 00:41:08.485
Boston, New York, what are we going to do about this tea?
00:41:09.106 --> 00:41:12.757
Philadelphia is sort of egging Boston on a little bit, not for the first time.
00:41:13.362 --> 00:41:17.622
And it's unclear what's really going to happen. Adams writes his closest London
00:41:17.622 --> 00:41:21.512
associate, saying, if something really unusual doesn't take place,
00:41:21.512 --> 00:41:25.551
I'm going to be writing you about a non-trifling event fairly soon.
00:41:25.882 --> 00:41:29.802
And that non-trifling event would seem to indicate the destruction of a T,
00:41:29.802 --> 00:41:31.263
although obviously he doesn't say so.
00:41:31.965 --> 00:41:37.218
The T, as you remember, has 20 days to be either dispatched back to London or
00:41:37.218 --> 00:41:38.618
it will be uncrated and sold.
00:41:39.060 --> 00:41:42.978
And so the clock is ticking over those 20 days from the arrival of the Dartmouth on.
00:41:43.588 --> 00:41:48.268
And in the town meetings that take place as that clock is ticking to figure
00:41:48.268 --> 00:41:52.729
out the fate of the T, we know from later reports that Adams plays a leading role.
00:41:52.955 --> 00:41:58.588
And we know that because afterwards 12 sailors are deposed in London,
00:41:58.588 --> 00:42:02.198
this is several months afterward, and all of them in their accounts will say
00:42:02.198 --> 00:42:05.415
that he basically was the chief agitator at those meetings.
00:42:05.745 --> 00:42:10.248
And we have some actually verbatim quotations from those meetings that.
00:42:11.514 --> 00:42:15.364
Basically, the first attempt that he will make is to treat the situation the
00:42:15.364 --> 00:42:17.934
same way the Stamp Act had been treated, which is to say if they could only
00:42:17.934 --> 00:42:21.315
get the commissioners to resign, if they could get the tea consignees to resign,
00:42:21.588 --> 00:42:24.223
this wouldn't be an issue. And they fail in that respect.
00:42:24.432 --> 00:42:26.307
But Adams is behind that effort as well.
00:42:26.853 --> 00:42:29.714
And of course, as late as the last night, as late as the night when the tea
00:42:29.714 --> 00:42:33.104
is finally destroyed, he and John Hancock and Dr.
00:42:33.104 --> 00:42:37.044
Young and Dr. Warren are holding the meeting down, giving speech after speech
00:42:37.044 --> 00:42:41.304
after speech to try to run down the clock, trying to get Thomas Hutchinson to
00:42:41.304 --> 00:42:44.714
agree to let them send the tea back to Great Britain because they refuse to
00:42:44.714 --> 00:42:46.571
have it unloaded in America.
00:42:47.129 --> 00:42:50.864
With the understanding that if it is unloaded in America, that is to,
00:42:50.864 --> 00:42:54.674
as John Adams puts it, basically say the last 10 years of effort we're worthless
00:42:54.674 --> 00:43:00.351
because we've just accepted parliamentary sovereignty, despite all of our efforts otherwise.
00:43:00.851 --> 00:43:03.725
Anyway, so it's Adams in the forefront of that movement and Adams,
00:43:03.840 --> 00:43:08.014
who is very conspicuously not on the wharf in the next hour,
00:43:08.335 --> 00:43:10.274
along with most of the rest of Boston.
00:43:10.274 --> 00:43:13.233
So thousands of people will decamp from that meeting that night,
00:43:13.628 --> 00:43:16.682
along with the perpetrators of the destruction.
00:43:17.204 --> 00:43:21.344
But we know that Adams and John Hancock and a few others very conspicuously
00:43:21.344 --> 00:43:22.603
kept themselves behind.
00:43:23.015 --> 00:43:26.194
I would say that that too is pretty much an indication of how central he was,
00:43:26.194 --> 00:43:29.999
that it was very important for him not to be seen directing anything on the wharf.
00:43:30.503 --> 00:43:35.146
The next day, Thomas Hutchinson will say that Adams was in his greatest glory,
00:43:35.297 --> 00:43:38.964
which I also would consider not exactly a mark of distinction,
00:43:38.964 --> 00:43:42.595
but certainly an indication that he was a
presiding genius behind the event.
00:43:43.088 --> 00:43:45.016
Yeah, sounds so to me.
00:43:45.741 --> 00:43:49.362
Austin asked, I think, an interesting question. He asked if you could tell us
00:43:49.362 --> 00:43:53.892
a little bit about if there's any other biographies that you relied on or that
00:43:53.892 --> 00:43:58.382
you could recommend or that you used of Adams.
00:43:59.002 --> 00:44:03.032
He's mentioned the Irving biography, the Ira Stoll biography,
00:44:03.032 --> 00:44:07.502
or what they've written about Adams, and if there's any differences between
00:44:07.502 --> 00:44:11.272
what other scholars have said about Adams, what your book says about Adams.
00:44:12.762 --> 00:44:16.622
I haven't looked at the earlier biographies since It's probably been seven years
00:44:16.622 --> 00:44:18.215
now before I started writing the book.
00:44:19.802 --> 00:44:23.282
He's been ill-treated by some people. I think there's a wonderful biography
00:44:23.282 --> 00:44:26.987
by, I want to say, a Stanford professor whose name I want to say is Miller,
00:44:27.457 --> 00:44:30.542
which basically turns him into a master of propaganda. It basically makes him
00:44:30.542 --> 00:44:34.746
this very wily and untrustworthy man of the press.
00:44:35.256 --> 00:44:39.132
And, you know, it's extremely good in the sense that it reveals a lot of column
00:44:39.132 --> 00:44:42.902
inches that I think we wouldn't otherwise know, but it does paint him in a fairly
00:44:42.902 --> 00:44:44.137
one-dimensional light.
00:44:44.897 --> 00:44:49.320
And of the others, I have less of a sense because either I didn't look at them or it's been so long.
00:44:50.582 --> 00:44:54.522
He's very much been lost, even in the John Adams biographies.
00:44:54.522 --> 00:44:57.435
If you look at David McCullough's brilliant biography of John Adams,
00:44:57.888 --> 00:45:00.136
you get very little sense of Samuel Adams.
00:45:00.432 --> 00:45:05.642
So I think he, for the most part, has gone missing, both in the books about
00:45:05.642 --> 00:45:08.162
him and in the books about his closest Confederates.
00:45:08.482 --> 00:45:10.752
He doesn't always come off well when he does come off.
00:45:11.788 --> 00:45:16.123
Fascinating. Thank you so much. Patricia and others in the chat are asking if
00:45:16.123 --> 00:45:20.773
you could talk a little bit about the post-revolutionary life of Adams and specifically
00:45:20.773 --> 00:45:24.033
how he might have felt about some international,
00:45:24.533 --> 00:45:28.713
conflicts, you know, Shays' Rebellion, things like that, kind of the early learning bumps,
00:45:29.573 --> 00:45:31.713
of learning curves of the early nation,
00:45:32.253 --> 00:45:35.109
but more specifically or more generally his post-revolutionary life.
00:45:35.410 --> 00:45:39.933
Yeah, you know, as I said that the early years gave no sense of the grandeur
00:45:40.253 --> 00:45:45.393
or the ambition that it was going to manifest later, so the later years gave
00:45:45.393 --> 00:45:47.713
no indication of the ambition that he had manifested.
00:45:47.713 --> 00:45:51.275
It's a really somewhat disappointing third act of the life.
00:45:52.288 --> 00:45:55.695
He's in Philadelphia for many years at Congress. I think he's there for nearly eight years.
00:45:56.183 --> 00:46:00.243
And during that time, a French envoy will say of him that he was someone who
00:46:00.243 --> 00:46:02.685
needed—he always needed to oppose something.
00:46:03.082 --> 00:46:06.508
I mean, he thrived in that kind of opposition. And then once there was no opposition,
00:46:06.891 --> 00:46:10.763
said this envoy, Adams was basically going to be reduced to insignificance.
00:46:11.082 --> 00:46:12.963
And that was not untrue, in fact.
00:46:13.703 --> 00:46:17.367
Once the nation begins to put itself together, he's not a federalist.
00:46:17.517 --> 00:46:21.094
He's not particularly keen on institutions generally.
00:46:21.494 --> 00:46:25.023
There's a really brilliant exchange of letters between John and Samuel,
00:46:25.583 --> 00:46:31.227
early 19th century, in which John makes the case that institutions are necessary to a republic.
00:46:31.674 --> 00:46:37.133
And Samuel basically puts all of his faith in individual liberties and believes
00:46:37.133 --> 00:46:40.813
that a moral populace will make the right decisions and doesn't need the apparatus
00:46:40.813 --> 00:46:43.168
of state as much as John seems to think it does.
00:46:43.528 --> 00:46:46.140
So there's a real division there politically between the two men,
00:46:46.791 --> 00:46:50.959
who I think also slightly fall off each other's radars late in life.
00:46:51.417 --> 00:46:56.863
For example, there's no trace that I can find in John Adams' papers of the death of Samuel.
00:46:56.863 --> 00:47:00.533
He does talk about how at the end of his life, Samuel's very reduced,
00:47:00.533 --> 00:47:05.268
very feeble, slightly senile. He hopes John Adams never ends that way,
00:47:05.697 --> 00:47:09.703
but there's no expression of regret at the end of Samuel Adams' life.
00:47:10.074 --> 00:47:15.703
So very little sense that Adams is engaged in international matters or even
00:47:15.703 --> 00:47:17.617
sometimes in federal matters.
00:47:17.989 --> 00:47:23.073
Shea's Rebellion is an exception and I think a really important one because
00:47:23.073 --> 00:47:26.737
this is a moment where you would think the person who had advocated for
00:47:27.091 --> 00:47:32.743
unrest and popular revolt at all times would rally to the sides of the Massachusetts
00:47:32.743 --> 00:47:35.563
farmers who basically are protesting taxes.
00:47:35.563 --> 00:47:38.295
This is Samuel Adams' theme song all over again.
00:47:39.119 --> 00:47:42.385
And in fact, here he proves something which I think is also really important
00:47:42.385 --> 00:47:46.815
to remember, which is that when you are protesting a foreign power,
00:47:47.255 --> 00:47:50.339
a
power in which you have no role and play and have no voice,
00:47:50.670 --> 00:47:51.615
you are within your rights.
00:47:51.615 --> 00:47:55.894
But when you are protesting a legitimately elected government in which you participate,
00:47:56.109 --> 00:47:58.838
you have a legal means of recourse, and that is the voting booth.
00:47:59.070 --> 00:48:00.887
And that is where your protest belongs.
00:48:01.154 --> 00:48:06.085
So he looks scant at the Massachusetts farmers and at one point even suggests
00:48:06.085 --> 00:48:09.345
that they be hanged, which just does not happen. And I think John Hancock,
00:48:09.345 --> 00:48:11.472
in fact, pardons them all.
00:48:11.681 --> 00:48:15.106
So there's a real difference of opinion even between Adams and Hancock at that juncture.
00:48:15.725 --> 00:48:20.045
Fascinating. Thank you. Lauren asked if you could tell us what,
00:48:20.045 --> 00:48:24.168
in your opinion or in Adams' own opinion, was his best way of communicating
00:48:24.451 --> 00:48:26.275
or getting across his ideas.
00:48:26.275 --> 00:48:31.435
Was he the best at kind of verbal speaking or was he a man of written word?
00:48:31.435 --> 00:48:34.578
How did he get across his ideas and moments he had his strongest? lift.
00:48:35.228 --> 00:48:40.024
So we have a certain number of speeches, or I should say snippets of speeches,
00:48:40.431 --> 00:48:43.895
in particular from the Boston Tea Meetings, but of other town meetings.
00:48:43.895 --> 00:48:45.810
And I should just go back a half a step and say that,
00:48:46.535 --> 00:48:49.890
the whole idea of a town meeting is Adams' invention.
00:48:50.239 --> 00:48:53.373
And I mean, it existed in New England, obviously, but the way he uses these
00:48:53.373 --> 00:48:59.263
town meetings to essentially usurp power is very crafty and is very much like
00:48:59.263 --> 00:49:02.096
the signature move of Samuel Adams.
00:49:02.358 --> 00:49:04.893
And in fact, the Continental Congress itself is that same kind of thing.
00:49:05.733 --> 00:49:09.649
It's basically an extra legal meeting at a time when that should not have happened.
00:49:09.921 --> 00:49:16.313
So he's very strong in those assemblies, but he's not necessarily always the
00:49:16.313 --> 00:49:21.393
speaker. And he seems to me very clearly to be someone far more comfortable
00:49:21.393 --> 00:49:24.437
on the page than standing in front of a group of men.
00:49:24.646 --> 00:49:27.032
There's nothing retiring about him in a group of men.
00:49:27.296 --> 00:49:32.133
We have, for example, an extremely toxic address that he, the toxic set of remarks
00:49:32.133 --> 00:49:35.426
he makes about Thomas Hutchinson at one juncture. He's no shrinking violet.
00:49:35.849 --> 00:49:40.173
But in terms of the sort of sheer expression of ideas, and I think the ease
00:49:40.173 --> 00:49:44.586
with which he does it, I would say that the words on the page are his forte.
00:49:44.923 --> 00:49:49.047
And there's a wonderful
description by one Bostonian who says that every time
00:49:49.338 --> 00:49:53.423
he walked past Samuel Adams' window at midnight, he could still see the candle
00:49:53.423 --> 00:49:56.993
in the window, and he knew that there was Adams writing against the Tories.
00:49:56.993 --> 00:50:00.622
And he does seem to have done this until late into the night,
00:50:00.785 --> 00:50:04.863
early into the morning, and then been there in the composing room at the Boston
00:50:04.863 --> 00:50:07.861
Gazette setting the type on Sunday evenings.
00:50:08.256 --> 00:50:11.353
Wow, fascinating. And keeping an eye on time, I think we have time for maybe
00:50:11.353 --> 00:50:12.499
one or two more questions.
00:50:12.754 --> 00:50:18.298
And, you know, several in our audience are wondering, in your research, if you came across any
00:50:18.571 --> 00:50:22.533
letters or correspondence or anything that might indicate how Adams felt about
00:50:22.533 --> 00:50:25.811
Washington or if they ever had any type of relationship with correspondence
00:50:26.009 --> 00:50:27.924
or if Adams had any views on Washington.
00:50:28.133 --> 00:50:32.153
There's very little on paper between the two of them. It's a warm relationship.
00:50:32.153 --> 00:50:36.566
Adams is, in Congress, Adams, I think, sits on almost every committee note to man.
00:50:36.909 --> 00:50:40.433
And several times he is on the committee that basically deals with the correspondence
00:50:40.433 --> 00:50:43.943
with General Washington. So this is all going through him. So there's clearly
00:50:43.943 --> 00:50:46.011
a sense of rapport between the two men.
00:50:46.691 --> 00:50:52.427
Washington will visit Boston at one point post-Revolution, and it's actually
00:50:52.427 --> 00:50:54.032
an interesting visit because he's there.
00:50:55.037 --> 00:50:58.557
He's meant to see John Hancock, but John Hancock stands on ceremony and thinks
00:50:58.557 --> 00:51:01.557
that Washington should call on him, and Washington thinks John Hancock should
00:51:01.557 --> 00:51:03.267
call on him so the two of them never meet.
00:51:03.714 --> 00:51:06.967
And instead, Washington tours the town with both of the two Adams men at his
00:51:06.967 --> 00:51:08.986
sides, both the Adams cousins.
00:51:09.224 --> 00:51:11.942
So there's a certain familiarity and a certain rapport.
00:51:12.186 --> 00:51:15.817
There's almost nothing in the papers of George Washington, but that's not all
00:51:15.817 --> 00:51:20.539
that unusual because there are a lot of absences in the papers of George Washington.
00:51:21.604 --> 00:51:25.978
Adams will be in the really unenviable position at the end of his life—he lives
00:51:25.978 --> 00:51:30.118
for a very long time—of reading the first histories of the Revolution.
00:51:30.118 --> 00:51:34.671
So he's reading what got written about what had happened a generation earlier.
00:51:35.124 --> 00:51:40.993
And to his enormous chagrin, he discovers that probably because of
John Hancock,
00:51:41.318 --> 00:51:45.168
he is implicated in the Conway Cabal to oust George Washington in the first
00:51:45.168 --> 00:51:48.578
history that's written of the war, something that he had not been involved in.
00:51:48.578 --> 00:51:52.632
So there are people who are trying to stir up bad blood between him and Washington,
00:51:53.015 --> 00:51:55.546
but there was none in reality.
00:51:56.376 --> 00:52:00.758
Fascinating. What was the link between the Bill of Rights and Adams,
00:52:00.758 --> 00:52:03.750
if there was any, in the push and the writing of the Bill of Rights?
00:52:04.307 --> 00:52:07.975
You know, by this point, it's really hard to say where he is in the picture.
00:52:08.663 --> 00:52:13.088
Marc Thiessen That's it. And lastly, I suppose, as a big accumulating question,
00:52:13.088 --> 00:52:17.702
just Adams' biggest contribution to American history, to the revolution,
00:52:17.947 --> 00:52:20.938
what do you remember him for? What do you think is one or two of the most important
00:52:20.938 --> 00:52:22.328
contributions that Adams made? Dr.
00:52:22.978 --> 00:52:30.058
Well, I think in the sense that he is able to move a population from one set of thoughts to another.
00:52:30.058 --> 00:52:33.508
And I don't even, you know, I can't even begin to understand how that can be
00:52:33.508 --> 00:52:37.108
done. We all know how set people are in their convictions, how difficult it
00:52:37.108 --> 00:52:39.511
is for them to be tolerant, much less open-minded.
00:52:40.039 --> 00:52:44.818
Somehow he manages, despite rather considerable odds and rather considerably
00:52:44.818 --> 00:52:50.948
short arms on his part, to affect this incredible change in thought and to,
00:52:51.528 --> 00:52:56.328
as I said, infuse these ideas, which obviously he alone did not advocate.
00:52:56.328 --> 00:53:00.638
Many people were of the same school, but he has somehow managed to get these
00:53:00.638 --> 00:53:02.900
ideas to really settle into the drinking water.
00:53:03.467 --> 00:53:05.104
I think it's an extraordinary contribution.
00:53:06.092 --> 00:53:07.290
Secondly, I would say the fact.
00:53:09.470 --> 00:53:14.806
That he manages to use the frustration, I guess, with the Massachusetts oligarchy,
00:53:15.305 --> 00:53:20.690
to stand in for a sense of a greater compromise.
00:53:21.030 --> 00:53:23.940
This feeling that if the Thomas Hutchinsons of the world were controlling things
00:53:23.940 --> 00:53:26.526
at home and that set people's teeth on edge.
00:53:28.610 --> 00:53:31.430
Imagine how he was able to extrapolate out from that to the crown.
00:53:31.430 --> 00:53:36.121
It was easier for him to make that case using the ammunition he had at hand,
00:53:36.336 --> 00:53:38.089
thanks to Thomas Hutchinson and company.
00:53:38.351 --> 00:53:44.899
So there's a sort of imaginative leap there that particularly in Massachusetts he manages to make.
00:53:45.415 --> 00:53:49.240
And then I guess the other greatest and the accompanying greatest thing is that
00:53:49.240 --> 00:53:51.534
he manages to step back from these things,
00:53:51.998 --> 00:53:56.740
and let other people take over and make good on those promises and make good
00:53:56.740 --> 00:54:00.796
on those ideas so that by the time that the first Congress meets,
00:54:01.255 --> 00:54:04.560
he's willing to let the Virginians take the leading role because he realizes
00:54:04.560 --> 00:54:09.840
that the Massachusetts men are seen to be these fanatics, and they can't be
00:54:09.840 --> 00:54:11.250
the ones to advocate these ideas.
00:54:11.250 --> 00:54:15.440
And he's just deferential enough and just nimble enough to realize that he needs
00:54:15.440 --> 00:54:18.419
to hand off that responsibility to a different team.
00:54:19.190 --> 00:54:22.240
And that's not something that I think comes naturally to most people who are
00:54:22.240 --> 00:54:26.564
smart about politics. He's very willing to dismiss himself from center stage.
00:54:27.210 --> 00:54:30.059
Fascinating. Thank you so much. On that note, I'm going to throw it back to
00:54:30.059 --> 00:54:31.384
Gina for some final thoughts.
00:54:31.628 --> 00:54:34.729
We had so many more questions than we had time for, and I'm sorry if you did
00:54:34.729 --> 00:54:38.159
not get your question asked, but a great solution to that is buying this great
00:54:38.159 --> 00:54:41.179
book, which all your answers can be found there, and there's links in the chat
00:54:41.179 --> 00:54:44.957
to do so. So we hope we highly encourage everyone to do that. Gina, back to you.
00:54:45.421 --> 00:54:47.809
Yes, absolutely makes a great stalking stuffer.
00:54:49.032 --> 00:54:52.729
And next week, we're really thrilled to welcome the author of Black Ball,
00:54:52.729 --> 00:54:56.789
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Spencer Haywood, and The Generation That Saved the Soul
00:54:56.789 --> 00:54:58.777
of the NBA. So please join us for that.
00:54:59.044 --> 00:55:02.809
And you can always watch our archive of more than 150 scholar presentations
00:55:02.809 --> 00:55:06.452
on Book Breaks at gilderlerman.org slash bookbreaks.
00:55:06.661 --> 00:55:10.259
And you can also visit our website for documents, essays, digital exhibitions,
00:55:10.259 --> 00:55:14.379
the Hamilton Education program, and so much more. Stacey, thank you so much
00:55:14.379 --> 00:55:17.382
for joining us. This was a fantastic discussion today.
00:55:17.858 --> 00:55:22.083
Related to join you. Thank you so much for having me. Have a great day, everyone. Bye.
00:55:23.100 --> 00:55:26.439
Thank you for listening to Conversations with Great Historians,
00:55:26.439 --> 00:55:30.101
the podcast from the Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History.
00:55:30.752 --> 00:55:34.449
We hope today's conversation gave you a new perspective on the history of our
00:55:34.449 --> 00:55:39.122
country and sparked some ideas you can take with you, whether into the classroom,
00:55:39.360 --> 00:55:43.012
into your family conversations, or into the life of your community.
00:55:43.635 --> 00:55:47.009
To explore more conversations with leading historians, authors,
00:55:47.009 --> 00:55:52.086
and scholars, visit the Gilder Lehrman Institute at gilderlehrman.org.
00:55:52.812 --> 00:55:57.734
And be sure to subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts so you never miss a new episode.
00:55:58.332 --> 00:56:03.743
Thanks again for joining us, and we'll see you next time on Conversations with Great Historians.