TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.320 --> 00:00:04.480
This week on Conservative Crossroads, Should employers be required to
2
00:00:04.599 --> 00:00:08.160
verify the legal status of their workers before offering them
3
00:00:08.279 --> 00:00:13.119
a job? Employer verification of legal status of their workers
4
00:00:13.320 --> 00:00:21.640
coming up on Conservative Crossroads now. Welcome back to Conservative Crossroads,
5
00:00:21.760 --> 00:00:25.800
the podcast where conservatives lean into their differences rather than
6
00:00:25.879 --> 00:00:29.280
deny them. I'm Henry Olson, Senior fellow at the Ethics
7
00:00:29.320 --> 00:00:32.960
and Public Policy Center and your host for this program.
8
00:00:34.000 --> 00:00:39.479
Should employers have to verify or confirm the legal status
9
00:00:39.520 --> 00:00:45.000
of their workers before offering them a job. That's a
10
00:00:45.039 --> 00:00:47.840
contentious issue and the question of immigration, and we have
11
00:00:47.960 --> 00:00:51.479
many views within the conservative movement on it. Tonight, I'm
12
00:00:51.560 --> 00:00:57.039
joined by two estimable scholars, Daniel Keshi he is the
13
00:00:57.119 --> 00:01:00.240
senior policy analyst at American Compass, who will are you
14
00:01:00.359 --> 00:01:05.920
in favor of mandatory employer legal status verification? And David Beer,
15
00:01:06.079 --> 00:01:09.680
director of Immigration Studies at the Cato Institute, who will
16
00:01:09.760 --> 00:01:13.799
argue against it. As is our pattern, we will each
17
00:01:13.840 --> 00:01:18.719
have five minute opening statements by our discussants. Daniel will
18
00:01:18.760 --> 00:01:21.159
go first. We will then have forty minutes or so
19
00:01:21.359 --> 00:01:25.480
of mutual questioning and conclude with each person having a
20
00:01:25.519 --> 00:01:29.680
two minute closing statement. Going in reverse, order of the introductions.
21
00:01:30.280 --> 00:01:34.799
Daniel, you're up great, well, Thank you, Henry, thank you
22
00:01:34.879 --> 00:01:38.920
for hosting this conversation. You know, I think I'll probably
23
00:01:38.959 --> 00:01:44.359
just begin by stating two principles or two premises. The first,
24
00:01:44.959 --> 00:01:49.079
only individuals who are authorized be in the United States
25
00:01:49.519 --> 00:01:53.280
should be here, and only individuals who are authorized to
26
00:01:53.560 --> 00:01:56.439
work in the US labor market should work in it.
27
00:01:57.400 --> 00:02:00.879
You know, these are not radical claims, not radical premises.
28
00:02:01.040 --> 00:02:03.799
They are in fact the law of the land, and
29
00:02:03.840 --> 00:02:06.159
I think they are the law of the land for
30
00:02:06.239 --> 00:02:10.319
good reason. There are you know, many harms associated with
31
00:02:11.400 --> 00:02:16.560
illegal immigrants in the American workforce. The first is that
32
00:02:16.599 --> 00:02:22.000
it harms American workers, American citizens, workers who are otherwise
33
00:02:22.120 --> 00:02:26.960
authorized to be here, especially those with you know, lower education,
34
00:02:27.360 --> 00:02:31.240
lower skills, who often are forced to compete with the
35
00:02:31.439 --> 00:02:36.400
illegal immigrants. It pushes downward pressure on wages and conditions.
36
00:02:37.439 --> 00:02:41.120
Second is that it harms law body and firms. You know,
37
00:02:41.599 --> 00:02:46.360
employers that abide by our immigration law that verify the
38
00:02:46.360 --> 00:02:53.159
employment of their warforce face a you know, competitive disadvantage
39
00:02:53.240 --> 00:02:57.719
relative to employers that are competing against who hire illicitly
40
00:02:58.240 --> 00:03:02.400
and are able to employ their work workers with substandard wages.
41
00:03:02.520 --> 00:03:09.680
In substandard conditions. And thirdly, it corrupts entire sectors of
42
00:03:09.719 --> 00:03:14.879
our economy, entire industries. If we allow for businesses within
43
00:03:14.919 --> 00:03:19.800
these industries to develop business models that are you know,
44
00:03:19.919 --> 00:03:27.520
predicated on access to cheap, oftentimes exploitable labor, it prevents
45
00:03:27.560 --> 00:03:33.639
them from making the necessary investments to increase productivity, increase output,
46
00:03:33.840 --> 00:03:40.000
increase or train the skills of their workers, and increase
47
00:03:40.080 --> 00:03:43.280
wages as a result. You know, I think it's probably
48
00:03:43.319 --> 00:03:46.159
worth establishing sort of the scale of the problem. I
49
00:03:46.159 --> 00:03:50.879
think estimates suggest that anywhere from eight to ten igle
50
00:03:50.919 --> 00:03:55.080
immigrants are in the US labor market. Perhaps those numbers
51
00:03:55.159 --> 00:03:58.800
have declined under the enforcement actions of the Trump administration.
52
00:04:00.000 --> 00:04:05.159
Important understand why rather the incentives that draw elleo immigrants
53
00:04:05.199 --> 00:04:09.159
to our country. You know, Ell, immigrants don't come here
54
00:04:09.439 --> 00:04:11.680
just for the sake of breaking the law. They don't
55
00:04:11.719 --> 00:04:15.639
overstay their visa just for the sake of overstaying their visa. Uh.
56
00:04:15.680 --> 00:04:19.319
You know, they come here for a job. Jobs are
57
00:04:19.519 --> 00:04:24.680
an incredibly powerful magnet that attract illegal immigrants into the
58
00:04:24.800 --> 00:04:29.399
United States, and it's important to you know, ensure that we,
59
00:04:29.600 --> 00:04:32.319
to the best of our ability, are able to turn
60
00:04:32.360 --> 00:04:37.920
that magnet off. The current system or the current sort
61
00:04:37.959 --> 00:04:46.800
of uh you know regime for employer side verification is
62
00:04:47.199 --> 00:04:49.519
you know, in many ways a dead letter. U. They
63
00:04:49.680 --> 00:04:52.959
employers have to fill out an I nine form. Uh.
64
00:04:53.040 --> 00:04:56.360
They do not have
Load full transcript
to verify the information against a
65
00:04:56.399 --> 00:05:02.120
government database. Uh, you know, Everify. The system for which
66
00:05:02.639 --> 00:05:09.839
this information is verified against is completely voluntary. Only about
67
00:05:09.879 --> 00:05:15.040
I think one in six employers voluntary voluntarily use the
68
00:05:15.120 --> 00:05:20.160
Everify system, which I think is a statistic that surprises
69
00:05:21.199 --> 00:05:24.879
you know, many Americans. And in addition to sort of
70
00:05:25.519 --> 00:05:31.519
insufficient verification protocols, uh, sort of the penalties associated with
71
00:05:31.600 --> 00:05:36.600
illicit hiring are you know, quite weak. There are civil penalties.
72
00:05:36.920 --> 00:05:39.759
The civil penalties are often written off at the cost
73
00:05:39.839 --> 00:05:43.639
of doing business, and they are very rarely any you know,
74
00:05:43.759 --> 00:05:48.240
criminal prosecutions in any any given year. And so I
75
00:05:48.279 --> 00:05:51.600
think that if we sort of agree with the first
76
00:05:51.600 --> 00:05:55.079
two premises that I stated, and for the reasons that
77
00:05:55.720 --> 00:05:58.879
they are in fact the law, the question becomes sort
78
00:05:58.920 --> 00:06:03.639
of what we do about I think border enforcement is
79
00:06:03.680 --> 00:06:07.959
a key part of the solution, but I think that
80
00:06:08.399 --> 00:06:13.079
a mandatory e verify system in which the verification status,
81
00:06:13.160 --> 00:06:16.839
authorization status of workers are checked at the hiring desk
82
00:06:17.079 --> 00:06:21.839
against a government database ensures that workers in the US
83
00:06:21.920 --> 00:06:26.360
labor market are authorized to be here, and that we
84
00:06:26.439 --> 00:06:29.519
turn off the magnet that attracts ELI immigrants to the
85
00:06:29.600 --> 00:06:31.199
United States in the first place.
86
00:06:33.800 --> 00:06:36.160
Thank you, Daniel, David, it's your turn.
87
00:06:37.120 --> 00:06:41.879
Thank you Henry. Thank you Daniel for your presentation. Let
88
00:06:41.920 --> 00:06:45.399
me be clear, I don't want illegal immigration. People should
89
00:06:45.439 --> 00:06:49.720
come if they come at all legally, but this debate
90
00:06:49.920 --> 00:06:53.839
has nothing to do with enforcing the law. The whole
91
00:06:53.879 --> 00:06:57.240
point here is what the law should be. You Verify
92
00:06:58.199 --> 00:07:04.399
isn't law enforcement. It's a fake shortcut to enforcement. But
93
00:07:04.519 --> 00:07:07.480
my main reasons for opposing everify I have little to
94
00:07:07.560 --> 00:07:15.639
do with immigration policy. First, Everify is a national identification
95
00:07:15.839 --> 00:07:20.279
system that conservatives since Ronald Reagan have traditionally opposed, and
96
00:07:20.399 --> 00:07:25.319
he verified mandate would be the largest in scope government
97
00:07:25.480 --> 00:07:30.279
mandate on US employers, US workers, and American families in
98
00:07:30.439 --> 00:07:34.680
US history. My basic view here is that it is
99
00:07:34.759 --> 00:07:40.040
inconsistent with a free society with limited government for the
100
00:07:40.120 --> 00:07:45.720
state to conscript private people into carrying out its goals.
101
00:07:46.279 --> 00:07:50.079
The Left has for decades tried to eliminate the difference
102
00:07:50.160 --> 00:07:53.759
between public and private actors. So we end up with
103
00:07:54.319 --> 00:07:59.680
woke mandates on businesses to micro manage their demographics, divest
104
00:07:59.720 --> 00:08:04.839
from non woke industries, mandate healthcare or vaccines, and on
105
00:08:04.920 --> 00:08:09.279
and on. If the government wants to engineer society, it
106
00:08:09.319 --> 00:08:13.279
should have to do so without conscripting US pre people
107
00:08:13.720 --> 00:08:20.959
in its efforts. Targeting Americans isn't immigration enforcement, It's not
108
00:08:22.560 --> 00:08:27.439
the second. I'm particularly concerned about Everify because it creates
109
00:08:27.519 --> 00:08:33.639
a new dystopian power, effectively a DC on off switch
110
00:08:34.000 --> 00:08:38.600
for all employment in America. Again, just imagine this power
111
00:08:39.080 --> 00:08:43.440
in the hands of your worst enemy, Lois Leerner or
112
00:08:43.440 --> 00:08:48.039
Anthony Fauci or Barack Obama or whoever. We already know
113
00:08:48.559 --> 00:08:53.399
how Obama mistreated conservative nonprofits and deep bank disfavored industries
114
00:08:53.480 --> 00:08:59.279
like gun dealers. Unlike the I nine form, Everify infiltrates
115
00:08:59.360 --> 00:09:04.279
businesses in a direct way and can remotely and immediately
116
00:09:04.360 --> 00:09:09.840
regulate them. It's a reinvention of government overreach. And moreover,
117
00:09:09.960 --> 00:09:14.879
the logic of everify right making life difficult for illegal immigrants,
118
00:09:15.399 --> 00:09:18.919
certainly doesn't stop with jobs, so it will be used
119
00:09:19.120 --> 00:09:22.399
for transit and guns, and banking and apartments and entry
120
00:09:22.480 --> 00:09:28.480
to government properties. If nothing else, Everified will create a
121
00:09:28.679 --> 00:09:32.639
permanent record of your life. It is mass surveillance, but
122
00:09:32.879 --> 00:09:37.679
unlike passive data collection, it comes with a massive opportunity
123
00:09:38.000 --> 00:09:43.679
to regulate full participation in society for anyone. And we
124
00:09:43.799 --> 00:09:47.480
know it won't stop with jobs because we know everify
125
00:09:47.799 --> 00:09:51.960
doesn't actually work, which has already led to calls for
126
00:09:52.000 --> 00:09:56.679
its use elsewhere. But in fact everify has failed everywhere.
127
00:09:56.919 --> 00:09:59.720
There are two point nine million illegal immigrants living in
128
00:09:59.720 --> 00:10:03.240
the night nine states where Everify was mandatory for
private
129
00:10:03.279 --> 00:10:08.200
employers in twenty twenty five, an increase of one million
130
00:10:08.399 --> 00:10:12.039
over twenty twelve when these mandates really started getting going.
131
00:10:13.039 --> 00:10:17.519
Everified doesn't work, but more importantly, it can never work
132
00:10:17.879 --> 00:10:22.440
because people can just borrow identification or work under the table.
133
00:10:22.960 --> 00:10:25.759
It's just like gun control. The only people who follow
134
00:10:25.799 --> 00:10:30.000
it are the rule followers. What actually happens is that
135
00:10:30.120 --> 00:10:35.120
more illegal immigrant men end up working for unscrupulous employers
136
00:10:35.159 --> 00:10:41.240
and staffing agencies at lower wages, the opposite of everifi's goal. Meanwhile,
137
00:10:41.480 --> 00:10:44.840
more women enter the labor force to make up for
138
00:10:44.919 --> 00:10:47.120
the lower wages of the men, so we end up
139
00:10:47.159 --> 00:10:52.279
with more total illegal workers. Don't take it from me, though,
140
00:10:52.840 --> 00:10:56.399
DHS itself last year called hiring someone after a clean
141
00:10:56.480 --> 00:11:03.639
Everified check reckless reliance. Also last year, ICE rated and
142
00:11:03.720 --> 00:11:08.399
shut down operations at an Everified compliant employer in Nebraska.
143
00:11:09.360 --> 00:11:15.480
The raid was real immigration enforcement. Everified, however, was fake
144
00:11:16.360 --> 00:11:20.559
immigration enforcement. So while it doesn't actually work to stop
145
00:11:20.559 --> 00:11:25.679
illegal workers, Everified does cause problems for legal workers. Despite
146
00:11:25.720 --> 00:11:30.120
the low error rate, there's been nearly one million legal
147
00:11:30.159 --> 00:11:34.799
workers this is, according to DHS statistics, who were blocked
148
00:11:34.840 --> 00:11:39.759
either temporarily or permanently because so many people are being
149
00:11:39.799 --> 00:11:43.320
fed through the system, so that low error rate doesn't
150
00:11:43.320 --> 00:11:47.919
mean lots of people are not still negatively affected by
151
00:11:48.080 --> 00:11:51.679
the flawled system. So on its own terms, you verify
152
00:11:51.759 --> 00:11:56.080
fans doesn't help legal workers. It tracks and harasses them.
153
00:11:56.720 --> 00:12:01.000
It does help DC bureaucrats to conscript b businessmen into
154
00:12:01.080 --> 00:12:05.759
micromanaging our society in whatever way they want. It's not
155
00:12:05.919 --> 00:12:12.799
about immigration enforcement, it's about government power. Conservatives should reject it.
156
00:12:13.840 --> 00:12:16.279
Thank you, and I look forward to the discussion.
157
00:12:17.360 --> 00:12:20.480
Well, thank you very much, David, and you obviously have
158
00:12:20.919 --> 00:12:25.279
strongly divergent views. Who wants to kick off the discussion
159
00:12:25.279 --> 00:12:26.000
with the question.
160
00:12:28.159 --> 00:12:32.159
Well,
I'm happy to start. I mean the thing, that's
161
00:12:32.320 --> 00:12:36.559
what I was trying to listen for was when Daniel
162
00:12:37.159 --> 00:12:39.399
you were presenting. The thing that stood out to me
163
00:12:39.480 --> 00:12:43.159
on the economic kind of argument here that you're making
164
00:12:44.440 --> 00:12:50.960
isn't that isn't really uniquely concerned with illegal immigration. Your
165
00:12:51.240 --> 00:12:55.080
sort of basic point was, if we reduce the number
166
00:12:55.080 --> 00:13:00.000
of workers in these industries, then businesses will invest more
167
00:13:00.039 --> 00:13:04.000
were in capital and you know this is going to
168
00:13:04.559 --> 00:13:08.200
lead to more productivity or higher wages or something along
169
00:13:08.240 --> 00:13:11.080
those lines. And so I just wanted to confirm what
170
00:13:11.080 --> 00:13:14.120
you're basically saying is that the government should also be
171
00:13:15.039 --> 00:13:18.799
trying to reduce the legal workers in these industries as
172
00:13:18.840 --> 00:13:23.399
well to stimulate more I don't know, investment or something
173
00:13:23.440 --> 00:13:26.759
along those lines. A change. You mentioned the business model
174
00:13:26.840 --> 00:13:30.639
of these, uh, these industries, So I just wanted to
175
00:13:30.679 --> 00:13:33.679
confirm you're also you know, you would apply the same
176
00:13:33.759 --> 00:13:38.840
logic to legal immigration and legal workers and not just
177
00:13:39.159 --> 00:13:40.639
you know, illegal immigration.
178
00:13:42.120 --> 00:13:42.360
Yeah.
179
00:13:42.440 --> 00:13:45.799
Well, you know, I think in the first instance, I
180
00:13:45.799 --> 00:13:51.840
think the analysis applies to you know, the illegal immigrant population.
181
00:13:52.279 --> 00:13:55.399
I think that they are, you know, even more so
182
00:13:55.879 --> 00:14:01.200
than like temporary visa programs, uniquely cheap and an expensive
183
00:14:01.840 --> 00:14:07.879
and uniquely exploitable. I think that if you know, it
184
00:14:08.120 --> 00:14:11.399
was the case where we say we're to you know,
185
00:14:11.960 --> 00:14:18.960
over a graduated series or you know, you know, time period,
186
00:14:19.320 --> 00:14:26.240
reduce the illeuo immigrant population. I think we would necessarily
187
00:14:26.320 --> 00:14:32.360
have conditions of greater labor scarcity, which would require businesses
188
00:14:32.919 --> 00:14:37.679
to increase the wage that they pay their their workers.
189
00:14:38.399 --> 00:14:41.799
And also then though, could force them to make those
190
00:14:41.919 --> 00:14:47.600
investment decisions in the capitol hall expenditures to to be
191
00:14:47.720 --> 00:14:51.720
more productive and to get more out of fewer workers
192
00:14:52.080 --> 00:14:55.679
or more expensive workers. I think that you you know,
193
00:14:56.000 --> 00:15:00.720
mentioned or maybe I imagined you ment sing sort of
194
00:15:00.720
--> 00:15:05.360
the agricultural sector specifically, and I think that there are
195
00:15:05.679 --> 00:15:11.039
you know, anecdotes throughout history and in recent history of
196
00:15:12.000 --> 00:15:17.720
examples when farmers, growers, uh you know, lose access to
197
00:15:18.360 --> 00:15:23.120
uh you know, uh an immigrant labor pool and they
198
00:15:23.279 --> 00:15:29.039
make the decision to uh, you know, make capital expenditures,
199
00:15:29.200 --> 00:15:30.480
do capital substitution.
200
00:15:31.279 --> 00:15:31.519
Uh.
201
00:15:31.559 --> 00:15:35.360
The canonical example here is, of course, the Persero program
202
00:15:36.360 --> 00:15:42.639
termination and uh you know tomato uh processed tomato growing
203
00:15:42.799 --> 00:15:47.679
in the state of California, where you know, the technology exists,
204
00:15:48.759 --> 00:15:54.919
the mechanization systems existed, but it was you know, uneconomic
205
00:15:55.039 --> 00:15:58.879
for those growers to to to purchase the equipment UH
206
00:15:58.960 --> 00:16:03.360
to do this productively until the point at which they
207
00:16:03.399 --> 00:16:06.240
did not have access UH, you know, to to to
208
00:16:06.279 --> 00:16:09.759
the cheap labor. And so you know, I think, in
209
00:16:09.799 --> 00:16:14.840
the first instance, just answer your question, the ill immigrant
210
00:16:14.919 --> 00:16:19.000
population is the line share of the problem. But I
211
00:16:19.039 --> 00:16:22.080
think the analysis could then be applied to temporary use
212
00:16:22.120 --> 00:16:24.960
of programs such as the h U A H two
213
00:16:24.960 --> 00:16:30.159
B to the extent that employers have access to low
214
00:16:30.200 --> 00:16:35.799
cost foreign labor that will keep wages down or lower
215
00:16:35.799 --> 00:16:40.000
than they would otherwise be for domestic citizen workers. UH
216
00:16:40.080 --> 00:16:46.240
and and forestall the investments necessary UH too drastically increase
217
00:16:46.399 --> 00:16:50.320
the productivity of a sector that has seen rather stagnant
218
00:16:50.360 --> 00:16:51.279
productivity rates.
219
00:16:53.000 --> 00:16:55.919
Well on the economic analysis point, you know, I just
220
00:16:56.039 --> 00:16:59.039
don't buy the the I don't just I just don't
221
00:16:59.120 --> 00:17:03.000
understand the art. I mean, you're basically saying, we want
222
00:17:03.039 --> 00:17:10.240
farmers to replace all these jobs with robots, and that's
223
00:17:10.359 --> 00:17:13.440
going to be good for US workers to have those
224
00:17:13.559 --> 00:17:18.319
jobs being done by robots, but it's not good for
225
00:17:18.799 --> 00:17:23.680
American workers when those jobs are done by immigrants. I
226
00:17:23.680 --> 00:17:26.759
don't understand that point, but it really it's not really
227
00:17:26.880 --> 00:17:30.359
my main point here. My main point is this is
228
00:17:30.400 --> 00:17:33.559
what I'm concerned about is that we have
someone in
229
00:17:33.759 --> 00:17:39.319
Washington or wherever saying, we know what the right business
230
00:17:39.319 --> 00:17:43.400
model is for businesses, and we're going to use this system,
231
00:17:43.640 --> 00:17:49.839
this regulatory apparatus, to impose our will on every business
232
00:17:49.839 --> 00:17:52.400
in the country. And if that means reducing the number
233
00:17:52.400 --> 00:17:55.799
of legal immigrant workers in that industry, if that means
234
00:17:55.839 --> 00:17:58.799
reducing the number of US citizen workers in that industry,
235
00:17:59.160 --> 00:18:03.359
to produce the result that we think is best for
236
00:18:03.759 --> 00:18:08.079
the economy. That's the type of grand vision that Thomas
237
00:18:08.079 --> 00:18:11.400
Soul would have called the vision of the anointed. I mean, people,
238
00:18:12.039 --> 00:18:15.279
it's easy to cite anecdotes or whatever, but look, over
239
00:18:15.319 --> 00:18:20.680
the last decade, we've seen two hundred thousand US farms disappear,
240
00:18:20.799 --> 00:18:24.079
go out of business, and so you know, you can
241
00:18:24.079 --> 00:18:26.680
always find that, well, this is an example or that example.
242
00:18:27.000 --> 00:18:30.880
The trends here aren't good. And the question that I
243
00:18:31.039 --> 00:18:34.759
have is does DC do the people in DC should
244
00:18:34.839 --> 00:18:40.039
they have the power to regulate the entire economy with
245
00:18:40.119 --> 00:18:45.960
a flip of a switch and decide for every business,
246
00:18:46.000 --> 00:18:50.079
for every consumer, for every person in the country, what
247
00:18:50.160 --> 00:18:54.440
the right amount of capital versus labor is. And look,
248
00:18:54.599 --> 00:18:56.759
this isn't again, it has nothing for me. It has
249
00:18:56.799 --> 00:19:00.920
nothing to do with illegal immigration. It doesn't. I don't
250
00:19:00.960 --> 00:19:04.319
think it works for illegal immigration, But it really has
251
00:19:04.359 --> 00:19:06.319
to do with the power that we're going to create.
252
00:19:06.400 --> 00:19:10.400
Its actually would work for legal workers. It's obviously because
253
00:19:10.599 --> 00:19:14.119
it's only the legal workers who follow the law. It's
254
00:19:14.119 --> 00:19:17.240
the illegal workers who don't follow the law. So the
255
00:19:17.240 --> 00:19:21.079
only people that this could in theory work for are
256
00:19:21.119 --> 00:19:25.079
the people who actually follow the law. And if you think, like, well,
257
00:19:25.160 --> 00:19:28.759
you know what is everified, I mean it's essentially a
258
00:19:29.599 --> 00:19:33.960
way of regulating licensing for jobs. I mean, it's essentially
259
00:19:35.839 --> 00:19:41.359
enforcing a license to work for immigrants right now. But
260
00:19:41.720 --> 00:19:44.920
the same principle could be applied to any type of
261
00:19:45.079 --> 00:19:49.160
license in the in the entire economy, And so my
262
00:19:49.319 --> 00:19:52.920
concern I don't think you really haven't lessened my concern
263
00:19:53.799 --> 00:19:56.640
on that front, that you know, this system isn't going
264
00:19:56.720 --> 00:19:59.920
to be used inappropriately down the line for really techn
265
00:20:00.000 --> 00:20:04.559
democratic goals that had nothing to do with immigration. It's
266
00:20:04.640 --> 00:20:08.680
kind of enhances my concern on that point. But I
267
00:20:08.720 --> 00:20:13.160
did want to ask you about the just the efficacy
268
00:20:13.440 --> 00:20:15.480
of the system. I mean, why do you think you
269
00:20:15.599 --> 00:20:19.400
verify is going to drive illegal workers who are already
270
00:20:19.799 --> 00:20:23.279
violating the law out of the country. When gun control
271
00:20:23.359 --> 00:20:27.079
doesn't stop illegal gun sales, when I nine didn't stop
272
00:20:27.200 --> 00:20:30.519
illegal workers. So what what is it about you verify
273
00:20:30.599 --> 00:20:34.680
that you think is even going to produce some you
274
00:20:34.720 --> 00:20:38.119
know way in which it's going to reduce illegal immigration.
275
00:20:40.000 --> 00:20:44.400
Yeah, I mean I think that as it currently stands,
276
00:20:44.480 --> 00:20:50.359
you know, the I nine form, you know perspective, employees
277
00:20:50.400 --> 00:20:55.160
provide information and employers you know, more or less do
278
00:20:55.640 --> 00:21:00.519
sort of an eye check does this look valid? Does
279
00:21:00.559 --> 00:21:04.440
this look correct? And you know, in theory that is
280
00:21:04.599 --> 00:21:10.039
like effectively the only verification under under the current system,
281
00:21:10.839 --> 00:21:14.759
and so long as the employers sort of satisfy what
282
00:21:14.960 --> 00:21:19.480
is a very low bar, uh, they completely you know,
283
00:21:19.599 --> 00:21:26.720
inoculate themselves from any civil or criminal penalty. I think
284
00:21:26.759 --> 00:21:33.039
the verification system is you know, more or less instantaneous.
285
00:21:33.279 --> 00:21:40.279
I think results after putting in the identification information, uh,
286
00:21:40.359 --> 00:21:45.400
the vast majority the line share render a you know,
287
00:21:45.720 --> 00:21:49.440
result in a couple of minutes, to the extent that
288
00:21:49.519 --> 00:21:55.839
there is sort of a you know, the system does
289
00:21:55.880 --> 00:22:00.920
not uh you know, come back with a verification. And
290
00:22:01.160 --> 00:22:03.440
I think it's called you know, the t n C.
291
00:22:04.720 --> 00:22:07.720
The workers themselves have, uh you know, I think it's
292
00:22:07.720 --> 00:22:13.920
six to eight days to update the system and ensure
293
00:22:13.960 --> 00:22:17.519
that they are in fact, uh, you know, indeed authorized
294
00:22:17.559 --> 00:22:22.839
to work in this country. So I think it's it's
295
00:22:22.920 --> 00:22:25.680
quite obvious to me that if those are sort of
296
00:22:25.720 --> 00:22:28.200
the two standards, one is sort of an eye check,
297
00:22:28.880 --> 00:22:33.119
where you know, employers hold on file these records for
298
00:22:33.279 --> 00:22:39.400
three years and unless you know, Immigration Enforcement comes knocking
299
00:22:39.480 --> 00:22:43.960
and performs an I nine audit more or less. Uh,
300
00:22:44.000 --> 00:22:50.160
it's it's the employer's word against against nobody really versus
301
00:22:50.240 --> 00:22:55.000
a system that uh, in real time or close to
302
00:22:55.160 --> 00:23:01.039
real time, ensures that these workers are are authorized to
303
00:23:01.079 --> 00:23:04.680
work in the US labor market. Question for you, if
304
00:23:04.680 --> 00:23:09.200
I if I may, I mean I think that you know,
305
00:23:09.799 --> 00:23:13.880
uh suggest that this would be sort of a tool
306
00:23:14.079 --> 00:23:21.319
of some draconian uh administration uh to sort of impose
307
00:23:21.519 --> 00:23:26.640
their political pet projects on the American people American businesses.
308
00:23:28.680 --> 00:23:33.440
I you know, fail to see how that is.
309
00:23:33.599 --> 00:23:36.079
Uh how how how that is possible?
310
00:23:36.200 --> 00:23:41.079
The sort of pilot program before you verify the one
311
00:23:41.119 --> 00:23:45.880
that employers can currently voluntarily participate in, as well as
312
00:23:45.880 --> 00:23:49.960
the legislative proposals that uh you know, have obviously been
313
00:23:50.039 --> 00:23:53.759
floating around for Congress for quite some time. Uh, you know,
314
00:23:53.880 --> 00:23:58.359
only allow for uh, sort of the up or down,
315
00:23:58.720 --> 00:24:02.920
green or red based off of sort of the personal
316
00:24:02.920 --> 00:24:08.680
information that can confirm lawful status, whether a citizen or
317
00:24:08.720 --> 00:24:13.680
through other forms of authorization. So the idea that sort
318
00:24:13.680 --> 00:24:19.359
of a overreaching bureaucracy in DC will begin to then
319
00:24:19.519 --> 00:24:23.559
sort of make judgments or determinations on who can work
320
00:24:24.079 --> 00:24:31.559
at any given business seems to me sort of implausible
321
00:24:32.039 --> 00:24:35.640
based off how you verify has worked since the pilot
322
00:24:35.640 --> 00:24:38.559
program was sted up in the nineties, and how the
323
00:24:38.680 --> 00:24:42.200
legislation would prescribe this program becoming mandatory if it were
324
00:24:42.200 --> 00:24:42.839
to become a law.
325
00:24:44.200 --> 00:24:47.359
Yeah, I mean when Social Security came out, I mean
326
00:24:47.359 --> 00:24:50.599
the Social Security number was just you know, for the
327
00:24:50.640 --> 00:24:56.000
Social Security benefit system. Now it's used absolutely everywhere for
328
00:24:56.119 --> 00:24:59.519
things that have absolutely nothing to do with Social Security.
329
00:24:59.559 --> 00:25:03.680
So the the fact that the initial use of this
330
00:25:03.799 --> 00:25:11.720
program is you know, for targeting illegal immigrants really has
331
00:25:11.759 --> 00:25:14.279
no bearing on the point. The point is we're creating
332
00:25:14.319 --> 00:25:18.160
a power here that's really, like I said, totally distinct
333
00:25:18.200 --> 00:25:21.160
from anything that we've seen before. I mean, this is
334
00:25:22.759 --> 00:25:25.759
really an on off switch in DC where you can
335
00:25:25.799 --> 00:25:31.599
immediately see a regime that really wants to adjust the
336
00:25:31.720 --> 00:25:35.400
levers of the economy in some way, resorting to that
337
00:25:35.480 --> 00:25:38.519
and say, well, right now, it's just on off if
338
00:25:38.559 --> 00:25:41.680
you're authorized to be employed in the United States. But
339
00:25:41.759 --> 00:25:46.039
we could change it to whether the whether the employer
340
00:25:46.119 --> 00:25:49.599
is authorized to employ someone in the United States. And
341
00:25:49.640 --> 00:25:52.680
there's one hundred thousand different reason. I mean, you listen
342
00:25:53.119 --> 00:25:57.079
to the left and what they say about businesses, and
343
00:25:57.160 --> 00:26:01.240
certainly businesses in certain sectors that they think have bad
344
00:26:01.359 --> 00:26:07.039
environmental impacts or bad social impacts. There's so many different
345
00:26:07.119 --> 00:26:11.400
reasons why a government would say, no, we're not going
346
00:26:11.440 --> 00:26:14.559
to allow more hiring in this area, we want to
347
00:26:14.599 --> 00:26:18.759
direct workers to this area. That's the type of micromanaging
348
00:26:18.920 --> 00:26:22.640
that I'm afraid of. And unfortunately, I mean, your economic
349
00:26:22.799 --> 00:26:27.640
analysis and argument leads me to believe that people who
350
00:26:27.680 --> 00:26:32.720
accept your arguments on the economic benefits here could reach
351
00:26:32.759 --> 00:26:37.200
free verify to keep out US citizen workers or legal
352
00:26:37.240 --> 00:26:42.640
workers out of industries that they want to see more
353
00:26:42.720 --> 00:26:47.400
capital investment in or more technology being used in those industries.
354
00:26:47.480 --> 00:26:51.240
Because I mean, look, we know the left thinks that
355
00:26:51.279 --> 00:26:54.720
there shouldn't be any low wage jobs in America. I
356
00:26:54.759 --> 00:26:59.160
mean they shouldn't exist. We should have a mandatory minimum
357
00:26:59.200 --> 00:27:03.880
wage of you know, twenty dollars an hour. Whatever they're
358
00:27:03.960 --> 00:27:08.880
up to now, I mean they The idea that this
359
00:27:08.920 --> 00:27:12.839
will not be used for reasons that have nothing to
360
00:27:12.880 --> 00:27:17.039
do with immigration enforcement seems incredibly naive when you look
361
00:27:17.079 --> 00:27:21.319
at the history of the left on virtually every issue,
362
00:27:21.799 --> 00:27:25.160
and the history of the Social Security number. Now it's
363
00:27:25.200 --> 00:27:29.160
being used for something again, for immigration enforcement purposes that
364
00:27:29.240 --> 00:27:31.720
have nothing to do with social security. So I can
365
00:27:31.759 --> 00:27:35.359
give you countless examples and ideas, but the point is
366
00:27:35.720 --> 00:27:38.960
there shouldn't be this power. And that's the thing that
367
00:27:39.000 --> 00:27:43.079
concerns me is like, this is really a principled argument
368
00:27:43.119 --> 00:27:45.680
to some extent. I don't think the government should be
369
00:27:45.839 --> 00:27:50.160
allowed to conscript private citizens in this effort. And so
370
00:27:50.240 --> 00:27:54.279
my question for you is why limit it to jobs?
371
00:27:54.319 --> 00:27:58.599
Why aren't we doing any verified checks for every household,
372
00:27:58.720 --> 00:28:02.000
guest in, your nanny and your friends and your bridesmaids
373
00:28:02.039 --> 00:28:06.359
at your wedding, And why is it limited to just jobs? Why?
374
00:28:06.720 --> 00:28:09.079
You know, wouldn't it be more effective just have a
375
00:28:09.160 --> 00:28:14.839
society wide mandate here Obviously, you verify hasn't worked already,
376
00:28:14.640 --> 00:28:20.200
so why not apply it to everyday interactions that you have.
377
00:28:21.799 --> 00:28:25.079
Yeah, I mean I think that is probably sort of
378
00:28:25.440 --> 00:28:29.640
certainly scapegoating the position. I mean, I think that there
379
00:28:29.720 --> 00:28:34.440
is sort of a spectrum that we find ourselves on,
380
00:28:34.559 --> 00:28:38.039
which is one being sort of the status quo. I
381
00:28:38.200 --> 00:28:44.720
nine forms very infrequent nine audits sort of you know,
382
00:28:45.960 --> 00:28:49.160
you know, scouts honor from employers that they have done
383
00:28:49.200 --> 00:28:52.400
their due diligence and ensuring that these workers are are
384
00:28:52.440 --> 00:28:56.119
here legally, and sort of what you have sort of
385
00:28:56.160 --> 00:28:59.720
put this up against and proposed is sort of a
386
00:29:00.160 --> 00:29:06.920
vision of totalitarianism for which simply manted an everify far
387
00:29:07.000 --> 00:29:12.400
closer to the status quo than sort of policing every
388
00:29:12.440 --> 00:29:18.160
engagement we might have in in the course of our lives.
389
00:29:20.200 --> 00:29:21.640
I think that, uh, why not?
390
00:29:23.960 --> 00:29:27.240
I mean, what wouldn't that drive out illegal workers and
391
00:29:28.240 --> 00:29:29.039
illegal people?
392
00:29:29.119 --> 00:29:29.880
Isn't that the point?
393
00:29:30.079 --> 00:29:34.680
So my whole point here is like what's the principle
394
00:29:34.880 --> 00:29:37.359
Like what print do you have a limiting principle here?
395
00:29:37.519 --> 00:29:42.440
Like what is enforcement of our immigration law which Congress
396
00:29:42.440 --> 00:29:46.079
passed in nineteen eighty six. They created sort of sort
397
00:29:46.119 --> 00:29:51.440
of you know, standards that it is illegal for employers
398
00:29:51.440 --> 00:29:54.920
to hire illegal immigrants. The question is like what system
399
00:29:55.200 --> 00:30:01.000
optimizes for enforcement of that law, of the law passed
400
00:30:01.000 --> 00:30:03.880
by Congress. You have the I nine system, which again
401
00:30:04.599 --> 00:30:11.799
is insufficiently sort of robust to you know, protect the
402
00:30:11.920 --> 00:30:17.960
US labor market from illicit workers, and you have any
403
00:30:18.079 --> 00:30:23.400
Verify system that ensures and verifies at the hiring desk
404
00:30:23.559 --> 00:30:27.680
whether those workers workers should be here. I do have
405
00:30:27.720 --> 00:30:31.599
a question for you. You know, you at least at
406
00:30:31.680 --> 00:30:35.440
least if my memory serves, sort of conceded the argument
407
00:30:35.559 --> 00:30:38.720
that you also do not want any legal immigrants here
408
00:30:40.039 --> 00:30:42.640
in the US labor market, and you also sort of
409
00:30:43.599 --> 00:30:50.279
sort of positioned everify as sort of fake enforcement against
410
00:30:50.799 --> 00:30:55.440
the workplace rates or the work site enforcement as the
411
00:30:55.519 --> 00:31:01.839
real enforcement. Now, you know, I in my mind, I say,
412
00:31:02.000 --> 00:31:04.440
you know, why not both? I don't think those are certainly,
413
00:31:04.519 --> 00:31:08.160
you know, mutually exclusive. But I guess if you are
414
00:31:08.240 --> 00:31:12.440
committed to the sort of protection of the US labor
415
00:31:12.480 --> 00:31:17.519
market from you know, illegal immigrants, and you sort of
416
00:31:17.640 --> 00:31:22.519
are concerned with Everify in the slippery slope of some
417
00:31:22.640 --> 00:31:28.039
totalitarian regime that will sort of regulate every interaction that
418
00:31:28.319 --> 00:31:33.839
American citizens have with one another, do you what would
419
00:31:33.880 --> 00:31:40.799
you like to see significant investments in internal enforcement agencies,
420
00:31:40.960 --> 00:31:46.079
would you like to see significant increases of I nine
421
00:31:46.079 --> 00:31:53.519
audits where you're not necessarily you know, you know, rating
422
00:31:53.559 --> 00:31:57.440
a work site and you know, arresting workers on site,
423
00:31:57.519 --> 00:32:02.200
but you are doing thorough verification and examination and an
424
00:32:02.240 --> 00:32:04.319
audit of the papers and then assessing the civil and
425
00:32:04.359 --> 00:32:08.880
criminal penalties that current law allows for. And likewise, would
426
00:32:08.880 --> 00:32:12.359
you be supportive of increasing those civil and criminal penalties
427
00:32:12.440 --> 00:32:17.480
even under the current regime so as to further disincentivize
428
00:32:18.000 --> 00:32:20.720
as a way to prevent, you know, the construction of
429
00:32:20.839 --> 00:32:25.759
this uh totalitarian infrastructure that you suggest he verifies.
430
00:32:26.960 --> 00:32:29.119
Well, look, I mean you can do all those things
431
00:32:29.200 --> 00:32:32.519
without you verify, So I mean it doesn't he verify
432
00:32:32.559 --> 00:32:34.799
has nothing to do with the amount of money we
433
00:32:34.839 --> 00:32:37.119
spend on interior enforcement, and that has nothing to do
434
00:32:37.200 --> 00:32:42.119
with how much we spend on whatever. I mean, look,
435
00:32:42.200 --> 00:32:47.039
ie audits, you know they don't work either. We had
436
00:32:47.079 --> 00:32:51.720
we had the highest number ever under Obama and they
437
00:32:51.720 --> 00:32:55.000
were totally ineffectual. I mean, it's just shifting people around
438
00:32:55.119 --> 00:32:58.319
from one job to the other, and there they had
439
00:32:58.359 --> 00:33:01.599
the exact same effect as verify. When it comes to
440
00:33:03.119 --> 00:33:06.839
what happens to illegal workers, Yes, they get pushed into
441
00:33:06.960 --> 00:33:11.240
two more unscrupulous employers and move from state to state,
442
00:33:11.319 --> 00:33:14.559
or location to location, or from job to job, and
443
00:33:14.640 --> 00:33:17.119
they end up with the lower wages than they would
444
00:33:17.119 --> 00:33:22.319
have before. They don't actually stop the underlying problem. And
445
00:33:22.440 --> 00:33:25.559
so you know, it's all about opportunity.
446
00:33:26.079 --> 00:33:30.079
If you verify, is unacceptable if the status quo system
447
00:33:30.519 --> 00:33:35.119
doesn't work, But you nonetheless would like, at least as
448
00:33:35.160 --> 00:33:40.400
you suggest, to reduce as practical the sort of presence
449
00:33:40.400 --> 00:33:43.880
of illegal immigrants in the US labor market. What remedies
450
00:33:43.920 --> 00:33:45.680
do you have on the are you putting on the
451
00:33:45.680 --> 00:33:49.279
table to actually address that or is it simply an
452
00:33:49.319 --> 00:33:54.119
impossible problem to solve the FAA complete there just will
453
00:33:54.160 --> 00:33:58.720
always be millions and millions and millions of illegal immigrants
454
00:33:58.759 --> 00:34:01.359
in the ascendant sort of associated with that.
455
00:34:02.599 --> 00:34:05.279
Well, look, I mean, we don't have you verify now,
456
00:34:05.640 --> 00:34:08.559
and there's hardly anyone crossing the border, So that proves
457
00:34:09.079 --> 00:34:14.280
that we can have a system where you know, very
458
00:34:14.280 --> 00:34:18.880
few people enter the country illegally without imposing this new
459
00:34:18.920 --> 00:34:24.760
mandate on businesses and on workers with all the attendant
460
00:34:24.800 --> 00:34:30.719
farms and risks associated with that system. And so you know,
461
00:34:30.760 --> 00:34:35.079
I just I don't see why you verify doesn't add
462
00:34:35.119 --> 00:34:39.440
anything to that, It doesn't doesn't produce any better results,
463
00:34:39.519 --> 00:34:45.159
it produces worse results and doesn't actually stop the problem.
464
00:34:45.280 --> 00:34:49.679
You actually have to do real immigration enforcement to reduce
465
00:34:49.719 --> 00:34:53.960
the number of illegal immigrants in the country. And look,
466
00:34:54.039 --> 00:34:58.239
I mean, do I support mass deportation, No, I don't want.
467
00:34:58.760 --> 00:35:01.880
You know, I think people should have a process by
468
00:35:01.880 --> 00:35:05.679
which they can come legally to the United States. That's
469
00:35:05.760 --> 00:35:12.119
the best way to reduce illegal immigration cheaply. But you know,
470
00:35:12.480 --> 00:35:16.039
this Congress, they've gone another way. They're spending two hundred
471
00:35:16.039 --> 00:35:21.280
and forty billion dollars to enforce kind of a mass
472
00:35:21.320 --> 00:35:24.920
deportation agenda. But that's the real alternative, the two hundred
473
00:35:24.920 --> 00:35:29.119
and fifty billion dollars in spending. That is the real
474
00:35:29.199 --> 00:35:33.320
immigration enforcement. That is actually what you have to do
475
00:35:33.599 --> 00:35:39.159
if you want to reduce illegal immigration, not everify which
476
00:35:39.239 --> 00:35:42.559
doesn't add anything to that, It doesn't reduce the cost
477
00:35:42.639 --> 00:35:47.400
of that. It's it's just a total government power play
478
00:35:48.320 --> 00:35:51.400
with no upside. And so if you want to spend
479
00:35:51.440 --> 00:35:54.880
the two hundred forty billion dollars, which I think is
480
00:35:54.920 --> 00:35:59.760
a waste of money as well, versus having legal immigration
481
00:35:59.840 --> 00:36:04.679
so networks, I mean, those are different options. But at
482
00:36:04.719 --> 00:36:06.760
the end of the day, there's no evidence that you
483
00:36:06.840 --> 00:36:13.119
verify adds anything to either one of those situations. And
484
00:36:13.480 --> 00:36:16.119
I mean, look when you say, I mean it's not
485
00:36:16.199 --> 00:36:19.639
my main argument, but you know the idea that this
486
00:36:19.760 --> 00:36:23.960
is just a simple thing, and then anytime any employer
487
00:36:24.159 --> 00:36:29.760
violates it, we should just destroy the employer. I mean basically,
488
00:36:29.800 --> 00:36:33.079
that's what you know when you're talking about making these
489
00:36:33.159 --> 00:36:38.480
fines enormous and criminalizing it and all of this stuff.
490
00:36:39.079 --> 00:36:42.800
I mean, you have to understand that it's actually a
491
00:36:42.920 --> 00:36:47.920
very complicated thing. There's an entire body of law around
492
00:36:48.000 --> 00:36:54.079
you verify I nine compliance. So just to give you example,
493
00:36:54.159 --> 00:36:58.199
here's a totally common situation. You're a builder. You have
494
00:36:58.280 --> 00:37:01.039
a crew, you move from job to job. You don't
495
00:37:01.079 --> 00:37:04.239
need broofers or plumbers or whoever on one job, but
496
00:37:04.280 --> 00:37:06.960
then you need them on the
next. Do you know
497
00:37:08.400 --> 00:37:12.000
if you have to everify them each time that you
498
00:37:12.039 --> 00:37:12.800
bring them back.
499
00:37:13.800 --> 00:37:14.559
I mean, just.
500
00:37:16.239 --> 00:37:17.480
Do you know the answer to that.
501
00:37:18.320 --> 00:37:25.280
I mean, undercurrent law, no builders required to verify anybody
502
00:37:25.840 --> 00:37:30.159
because it's voluntary.
503
00:37:30.800 --> 00:37:34.800
I mean, if you voluntarily participate in it, then you
504
00:37:34.960 --> 00:37:37.480
have to follow the rules of it, and it's not
505
00:37:37.719 --> 00:37:41.800
voluntary in Arizona, in South Carolina and Florida and several
506
00:37:41.840 --> 00:37:45.079
other states. I mean the answer is it depends on
507
00:37:45.119 --> 00:37:47.440
the length of time, and the length of time isn't
508
00:37:47.480 --> 00:37:50.800
even set out in regulation, and the required amount of
509
00:37:50.800 --> 00:37:55.400
time that you have to that you're allowed to essentially
510
00:37:55.440 --> 00:37:59.119
not use them or not pay them before you have
511
00:37:59.199 --> 00:38:02.559
to then do the verified check actually conflicts with the
512
00:38:02.559 --> 00:38:06.679
amount of time that you're allowed to recycle the I
513
00:38:06.840 --> 00:38:11.719
nine form that that they originally filled out. So it's
514
00:38:11.800 --> 00:38:16.880
not easy. These are just one example, is just another
515
00:38:17.079 --> 00:38:20.599
example of this. Do you know whether for the I
516
00:38:20.719 --> 00:38:25.559
nine ICE uses the I R S or DLL definition
517
00:38:25.719 --> 00:38:30.480
of who is an employee? I mean, I mean it
518
00:38:30.800 --> 00:38:32.400
versus an independent contractor?
519
00:38:32.519 --> 00:38:32.719
Right?
520
00:38:33.639 --> 00:38:34.599
I mean, these are.
521
00:38:34.639 --> 00:38:38.800
Complicated issues that employers have to wade through when they're
522
00:38:38.840 --> 00:38:44.079
doing this. South Carolina most aggressive state on enforcing you verify.
523
00:38:44.159 --> 00:38:46.760
They do tons of audits, far more than any other state.
524
00:38:47.440 --> 00:38:51.760
They've only ever done they've only ever found paperwork violations,
525
00:38:51.800 --> 00:38:54.280
meaning they didn't fill out the form when they were
526
00:38:54.320 --> 00:38:57.400
supposed to fill out the form. And so the idea
527
00:38:57.440 --> 00:38:59.679
that we're going to go around bankrupting all of these
528
00:38:59.719 --> 00:39:05.840
business is and causing enormous problems for their American employees
529
00:39:06.400 --> 00:39:10.639
and these American entrepreneurs is just crazy. I mean, it
530
00:39:11.440 --> 00:39:14.199
doesn't make any sense, especially when the system doesn't work.
531
00:39:14.679 --> 00:39:17.159
I think the question I would like to ask is
532
00:39:17.840 --> 00:39:21.519
what should be done about illegal labor? Should labor be
533
00:39:21.639 --> 00:39:25.559
illegal at all? That if we have eight to ten
534
00:39:25.639 --> 00:39:29.280
million people who currently are not legally able to work
535
00:39:29.280 --> 00:39:32.639
in the United States who are working, is that a problem?
536
00:39:33.199 --> 00:39:36.480
I think Daniel says yes. I'm David. Do you think
537
00:39:36.639 --> 00:39:40.360
that's an issue that is a real problem or is
538
00:39:40.760 --> 00:39:44.760
the cost of actually trying to enforce the current law,
539
00:39:44.800 --> 00:39:47.719
which is that they can't legally work far out weigh
540
00:39:47.840 --> 00:39:50.719
any of the possible benefits from dealing with the existing
541
00:39:51.159 --> 00:39:54.000
number of illegal workers already in the labor force.
542
00:39:54.760 --> 00:39:57.320
Well, I think black markets are a problem. I mean,
543
00:39:57.320 --> 00:40:01.800
it caused all sorts of issues for eployers. I agree
544
00:40:01.880 --> 00:40:04.920
with Daniel that it's unfair to the you know, very
545
00:40:05.199 --> 00:40:09.639
highly scrupulous employers, and even unfair to the ones who
546
00:40:09.960 --> 00:40:12.239
you know, they use Everify and then they still get
547
00:40:12.519 --> 00:40:15.320
you know, audited, and then you know, the audit turns
548
00:40:15.400 --> 00:40:18.440
up well, actually these workers were using fake id's or
549
00:40:18.480 --> 00:40:22.400
someone's identity or whatever, and so the black market is
550
00:40:22.480 --> 00:40:25.159
the problem. The question is how do you deal with
551
00:40:25.199 --> 00:40:27.559
a black market? I mean, what's the best way to
552
00:40:27.599 --> 00:40:31.599
address it. I mean, if we had licenses on the
553
00:40:31.679 --> 00:40:37.199
number of construction workers in the economy and it was
554
00:40:37.199 --> 00:40:42.320
set in nineteen ninety and never adjusted, then you'd end
555
00:40:42.400 --> 00:40:46.119
up with lots of illegal construction workers who are US citizens,
556
00:40:46.159 --> 00:40:49.079
who you know, couldn't get licenses because there's a cap
557
00:40:49.119 --> 00:40:51.920
on the number of licenses, and that would be a
558
00:40:51.920 --> 00:40:56.119
real problem for the for the country. The best response
559
00:40:56.199 --> 00:40:59.360
to that is the free market one, which is have
560
00:40:59.679 --> 00:41:03.960
a more liberal licensing regime that lets people legally work
561
00:41:04.000 --> 00:41:07.840
in these industries. And I think from what I heard
562
00:41:07.840 --> 00:41:11.880
from Daniels, basically that whole idea of a legal immigration
563
00:41:12.079 --> 00:41:15.559
system that's you know, based on markets and based on
564
00:41:15.639 --> 00:41:19.320
demand should be off the table for reform. And I
565
00:41:19.360 --> 00:41:22.559
think once you say that, then you're committing yourself not
566
00:41:22.679 --> 00:41:26.480
to verify which doesn't work. But to the two hundred
567
00:41:26.480 --> 00:41:29.719
and fifty billion dollars mass deportation campaign and all the
568
00:41:29.760 --> 00:41:34.639
stuff that Trump has done since he's come back into office.
569
00:41:35.880 --> 00:41:38.039
It just sounds if I don't want to put words
570
00:41:38.039 --> 00:41:40.280
into your mouth, but it sounds something like your approach
571
00:41:40.320 --> 00:41:45.000
would be deregulatory, which is to say, legalize their status
572
00:41:45.039 --> 00:41:47.360
and the problem is solved because the fact that they're
573
00:41:47.360 --> 00:41:53.679
here already represents anow the fact that employers demand labor
574
00:41:53.679 --> 00:41:56.679
at a lower price than the American citizen is willing
575
00:41:56.719 --> 00:41:57.320
to provide.
576
00:41:59.320 --> 00:42:02.760
Yeah, I think having a system that works going forward,
577
00:42:03.239 --> 00:42:07.199
it's self correcting. I mean, it's like tax law or
578
00:42:07.199 --> 00:42:09.639
anything else. You want to have an opportunity. If someone
579
00:42:09.719 --> 00:42:13.760
does violate the tax rules, it shouldn't immediately then they
580
00:42:13.800 --> 00:42:15.360
go to prison for the rest of their life. There
581
00:42:15.360 --> 00:42:18.480
should be an opportunity for them to file late and
582
00:42:18.760 --> 00:42:22.440
pay a penalty and you know, get on the right
583
00:42:22.480 --> 00:42:25.119
side of the law. The same thing goes here. We
584
00:42:25.119 --> 00:42:27.800
should have a legal immigration system that works. If there's
585
00:42:28.119 --> 00:42:30.800
a problem someone you know, violates a rule or something,
586
00:42:30.840 --> 00:42:33.039
there should be a reasonable way for them to get
587
00:42:33.360 --> 00:42:36.719
back on the right side of the law, because otherwise then, yeah,
588
00:42:36.760 --> 00:42:41.400
they'll just continue to be this black market that festers forever.
589
00:42:42.800 --> 00:42:45.159
So let me ask you a question, Danielle, and that's
590
00:42:45.159 --> 00:42:48.960
with respect to the principle behind the verify you know,
591
00:42:49.000 --> 00:42:53.400
which is that the way to I guess self deport
592
00:42:54.079 --> 00:42:58.000
people is to dry up their source of income. Would
593
00:42:58.079 --> 00:43:03.199
you be favorable to extending an everify principle to things
594
00:43:03.679 --> 00:43:08.400
services that are under the off either publicly financed like
595
00:43:08.480 --> 00:43:13.159
health care or education, or are directly under public control
596
00:43:13.239 --> 00:43:16.400
like licenses. You know, would you require somebody who wants
597
00:43:16.480 --> 00:43:19.079
to get a driver's license to have to demonstrate legal
598
00:43:19.119 --> 00:43:22.400
status in the country, or someone who wants to access
599
00:43:22.480 --> 00:43:26.840
a hospital that receives Medicare or Medicaid funding to have
600
00:43:26.920 --> 00:43:29.760
to demonstrate legal status
in order to receive care.
601
00:43:32.639 --> 00:43:39.280
I mean, I think that in terms of benefiting from
602
00:43:39.320 --> 00:43:44.079
public benefits, I think it is perfectly reasonable and consistent
603
00:43:44.320 --> 00:43:49.159
with sort of social welfare principles to ensure that, you know,
604
00:43:49.239 --> 00:43:54.239
those that benefit from these programs are you know, citizens
605
00:43:54.320 --> 00:43:58.480
or otherwise authorized to be here now, you know, whether
606
00:43:58.519 --> 00:44:01.000
that be Medicaid or Medicare or any other sort of
607
00:44:01.000 --> 00:44:06.400
public health programs, would probably allow for you know, hospitals
608
00:44:06.920 --> 00:44:11.519
or emergency services to be rendered to whoever comes in
609
00:44:11.559 --> 00:44:14.400
the door and and sort of needs you know, life
610
00:44:14.480 --> 00:44:18.400
saving care. I think it should that, you know, very
611
00:44:18.519 --> 00:44:24.079
clearly to me, be applied to sort of driver driver's license,
612
00:44:24.320 --> 00:44:29.440
especially commercial driver's license. I think that this is actually
613
00:44:29.480 --> 00:44:35.639
one of the most uh, you know, under the radar
614
00:44:35.760 --> 00:44:39.440
but important enforcement actions that the Trump administration has taken,
615
00:44:39.559 --> 00:44:44.400
which is to sort of really crack down on sort
616
00:44:44.440 --> 00:44:46.239
of the the number of.
617
00:44:47.880 --> 00:44:49.159
You know, non.
618
00:44:49.039 --> 00:44:52.840
Citizens, non residents, illegal workers that have been handed commercial
619
00:44:52.920 --> 00:44:58.960
driver's license by state departments of motor vehicles. I think
620
00:44:59.039 --> 00:45:02.840
that you know, we see this not just as like
621
00:45:02.920 --> 00:45:05.519
a public safety concern where there are sort of news
622
00:45:05.559 --> 00:45:10.519
reports of drivers getting in car accidents and you know,
623
00:45:10.599 --> 00:45:15.000
lo and behold the driver cannot read or speak English,
624
00:45:15.119 --> 00:45:18.480
which you would think would be sort of a baseline
625
00:45:18.519 --> 00:45:23.360
requisite to drive on American roads. But it again sort
626
00:45:23.400 --> 00:45:28.239
of is a perfect microcosm of the sort of illicit
627
00:45:28.280 --> 00:45:33.119
employment problem at large, which is that, you know, the
628
00:45:33.159 --> 00:45:37.360
influx of illegal workers that have been handed these commercial
629
00:45:37.440 --> 00:45:40.840
driver's license pushed down the wages and the rates for
630
00:45:41.119 --> 00:45:46.639
American citizen truck drivers, and it creates that competitive disadvantage
631
00:45:46.679 --> 00:45:50.519
for the truck companies, trucking companies that employ American workers.
632
00:45:51.840 --> 00:45:58.000
The trucking companies that you know willfully violate our immigration
633
00:45:58.119 --> 00:46:02.880
laws are also far more likely to willfully violate other
634
00:46:03.199 --> 00:46:08.480
service safety regulations in terms of sort of maximum hours
635
00:46:09.400 --> 00:46:12.599
that can be driven on any given day, and so
636
00:46:12.960 --> 00:46:18.039
I think the principle is broadly applicable not just to
637
00:46:18.199 --> 00:46:25.000
labor markets, which but to you know, social welfare programs
638
00:46:25.159 --> 00:46:29.559
in general, for which the American people pay into and
639
00:46:29.719 --> 00:46:34.840
expect that these programs pay out to the American citizens
640
00:46:34.920 --> 00:46:37.320
or people that should benefit from them.
641
00:46:37.960 --> 00:46:39.400
I got a few minutes left, so let me just
642
00:46:39.480 --> 00:46:41.960
ask a question that either of that it's applicable to
643
00:46:42.000 --> 00:46:45.280
either of you. A number of economists argue in a
644
00:46:45.320 --> 00:46:50.079
whole series of areas that regulation is inefficient, but that
645
00:46:50.440 --> 00:46:55.519
there are things that people do that affect larger populations
646
00:46:55.599 --> 00:46:58.679
for which the actors do not bear the cost. The
647
00:46:58.719 --> 00:47:02.480
technical term is extraalities. It's kind of a geeky term.
648
00:47:02.519 --> 00:47:05.639
I think both of you are familiar of it. And
649
00:47:05.679 --> 00:47:08.400
they argue that the argument there is some sort of
650
00:47:08.679 --> 00:47:14.199
cost allocation taxation, often called a Pagovian tax. Would either
651
00:47:14.280 --> 00:47:17.920
of you favor as an alternative to the regulatory approach
652
00:47:17.960 --> 00:47:23.119
of everify some sort of Pagovian tax on people who
653
00:47:23.159 --> 00:47:26.079
employ non legal labor that yeah, you can employ non
654
00:47:26.199 --> 00:47:29.639
legal labor, but that causes a decline, or we estimate
655
00:47:29.639 --> 00:47:34.800
that that has a negative social effect. Either of x
656
00:47:34.960 --> 00:47:37.280
amount and you'll have to pay a twenty percent tax
657
00:47:37.320 --> 00:47:40.000
on your compensation that you play to that person. Do
658
00:47:40.039 --> 00:47:43.559
you think that a Pagovian tax would be a market
659
00:47:43.679 --> 00:47:49.280
oriented but still regulatory enforcement minded way to address the
660
00:47:49.400 --> 00:47:53.280
question of illegal migration without engaging in the sort of
661
00:47:53.599 --> 00:47:58.920
regulatory and enforcement overreach that David is concerned about.
662
00:48:01.199 --> 00:48:03.079
Well, I guess I think I can go first.
663
00:48:03.119 --> 00:48:03.400
Maybe.
664
00:48:04.719 --> 00:48:08.840
I mean, I think that's probably better than nothing, But
665
00:48:08.920 --> 00:48:10.880
of course it depends on what the tax is. Said
666
00:48:10.920 --> 00:48:13.599
out of it's too high, then you don't have any
667
00:48:13.840 --> 00:48:18.639
improvement at all. It's obviously going to be completely arbitrary
668
00:48:18.679 -->
00:48:23.239
whatever you end up setting it at, And so I
669
00:48:23.239 --> 00:48:25.800
wouldn't trust the government to come up with the right
670
00:48:27.760 --> 00:48:30.280
tax there. And of course if they did decide to
671
00:48:30.320 --> 00:48:35.239
tax it, it wouldn't be illegal labor anymore legal labor. So
672
00:48:35.840 --> 00:48:40.800
you know, it's sort of a interesting idea, but you know,
673
00:48:40.840 --> 00:48:43.079
I'm not really confident that they'll come up with it
674
00:48:43.360 --> 00:48:45.079
at the end of the day. I mean, it's not
675
00:48:45.159 --> 00:48:49.679
really that different than immigrants paying a penalty or a
676
00:48:49.719 --> 00:48:53.760
fee to be able to access the legal immigration system. Again,
677
00:48:54.920 --> 00:48:57.960
right now, of course, they're here illegally because they can't
678
00:48:58.000 --> 00:49:03.679
access the legal immigrant system, and so you know, a
679
00:49:03.800 --> 00:49:06.639
tax on you know, that employer's pay would just be
680
00:49:06.719 --> 00:49:09.360
passed on to workers in terms of lower wages and
681
00:49:09.480 --> 00:49:14.360
less compensation in other ways. And so I don't really
682
00:49:14.360 --> 00:49:17.280
see it as distinct from all the ideas that you know,
683
00:49:17.599 --> 00:49:20.719
already kind of dominate the space, which, as you know,
684
00:49:20.760 --> 00:49:24.079
the best and easiest way, most enforceable way to deal
685
00:49:24.159 --> 00:49:27.119
with this problem is just let people pay a fee
686
00:49:27.199 --> 00:49:31.039
or penalty in order to access the legal immigration system,
687
00:49:31.079 --> 00:49:33.599
and if they qualify, then they can go on their
688
00:49:33.639 --> 00:49:37.000
way and and you know, we don't have to deal
689
00:49:37.079 --> 00:49:41.599
with the illegal immigration problem.
690
00:49:41.760 --> 00:49:44.599
Yeah, I mean, I guess I suppose it could you know,
691
00:49:44.760 --> 00:49:50.119
neutralize some of the competitive advantages or disadvantages between firms
692
00:49:50.119 --> 00:49:54.480
that follow along those that choose not to. You know,
693
00:49:54.519 --> 00:50:00.639
it doesn't I think, really implicate the workers, whether you know,
694
00:50:01.000 --> 00:50:04.440
citizens or authorized or illegal one way or the other.
695
00:50:05.159 --> 00:50:08.280
And I think that like the the market principle, or
696
00:50:08.320 --> 00:50:12.239
rather the pro market reform to my mind, is in fact,
697
00:50:13.239 --> 00:50:17.880
you know, border enforcement and verify policing the boundaries of
698
00:50:17.960 --> 00:50:22.719
the labor market, ensuring labor market participants are allowed and
699
00:50:22.760 --> 00:50:26.199
authorized to be within it. Uh, then you can allow
700
00:50:26.559 --> 00:50:31.320
the market principles to to to take effect and see
701
00:50:31.360 --> 00:50:35.199
what the you know, market clearing wage rates for this
702
00:50:35.360 --> 00:50:39.920
job and that industry truly are under sort of the
703
00:50:39.960 --> 00:50:44.840
conditions of of of a properly policed labor market.
704
00:50:46.360 --> 00:50:49.119
Well, that brings us to the end of our mutual discussion.
705
00:50:49.119 --> 00:50:53.360
We're turning now to the closing statements segment of our program.
706
00:50:53.760 --> 00:50:56.159
David Europe two minutes.
707
00:50:57.599 --> 00:50:59.440
Yeah, I think when I, you know, laid out at
708
00:50:59.440 --> 00:51:03.000
the beginning, the concern about this being used for other purposes,
709
00:51:04.199 --> 00:51:09.480
for really empowering the government to micromanage the economy, I
710
00:51:09.480 --> 00:51:13.079
think what we heard from Daniel is really not responsive
711
00:51:13.119 --> 00:51:17.480
to that concern. It really sounds to me like he
712
00:51:17.639 --> 00:51:21.760
would try to set up a system that would reduce
713
00:51:21.760 --> 00:51:25.920
the number of legal workers that you know, really doesn't
714
00:51:25.960 --> 00:51:31.000
have the guardrails necessary to prevent this type of misbehavior
715
00:51:32.400 --> 00:51:36.880
by the government. And so I think when you're thinking about,
716
00:51:37.000 --> 00:51:40.519
you know, whether to support you verify or not, you
717
00:51:40.639 --> 00:51:43.679
have to think about what are the consequences of giving
718
00:51:43.960 --> 00:51:51.320
government the power to regulate the entire society in this way.
719
00:51:51.880 --> 00:51:56.599
And really, I mean e verify. You know, maybe it
720
00:51:56.679 --> 00:52:00.440
sounds good for illegal immigration, but it's not going to
721
00:52:00.519 --> 00:52:03.239
sound so good when it's being used for guns. And
722
00:52:03.280 --> 00:52:05.920
now we have a gun registry of every single gun
723
00:52:05.960 --> 00:52:09.000
owner in America and every single gun purchase in America,
724
00:52:09.840 --> 00:52:12.920
empowering people who want to regulate guns and prevent them
725
00:52:13.079 --> 00:52:17.599
from not just falling into the hands of illegal immigrants,
726
00:52:17.719 --> 00:52:20.400
but falling into the hands of US citizens who want
727
00:52:20.400 --> 00:52:23.239
to use them for self defense and other purposes. So
728
00:52:23.519 --> 00:52:27.440
I think that's sort of my main point. The second
729
00:52:27.440 --> 00:52:29.639
point is that you Verify doesn't work, and so what
730
00:52:29.679 --> 00:52:34.239
you're really signing up for is empowering the government to
731
00:52:34.559 --> 00:52:38.679
regulate the entire economy in this way and not actually
732
00:52:38.679 --> 00:52:42.320
achieve the goals set out by the system. In fact,
733
00:52:43.199 --> 00:52:47.639
it actually creates more problems for legal workers as a
734
00:52:47.639 --> 00:52:51.480
result of e verify errors, but also it actually results
735
00:52:51.519 --> 00:52:55.039
in lower wages for illegal workers
than they otherwise would
736
00:52:55.039 --> 00:52:57.239
have had. So it doesn't drive them out, it drives
737
00:52:57.239 --> 00:53:03.400
them the worse employment opportunities, and so it's ineffective. It's
738
00:53:03.679 --> 00:53:06.559
going to empower the government ways that we can't even
739
00:53:06.559 --> 00:53:11.199
comprehend at this time. And I think if you at
740
00:53:11.199 --> 00:53:14.679
a minimum, you just think about whether this system will
741
00:53:14.719 --> 00:53:19.239
actually accomplish the goals that the proponents say it will.
742
00:53:19.559 --> 00:53:23.599
It's proven the opposite everywhere, it's been tried. Everywhere it's
743
00:53:23.639 --> 00:53:26.920
been tried, and so I think you have to reject
744
00:53:27.000 --> 00:53:29.360
the proposition on those reasons alone.
745
00:53:29.519 --> 00:53:32.960
Thank you, Daniel. The last word is with.
746
00:53:32.880 --> 00:53:37.719
You sure you know all? Maybe begin by just rearticulating
747
00:53:37.760 --> 00:53:41.079
the principles I stated at the beginning, which is that
748
00:53:41.199 --> 00:53:44.119
I think, you know, only individuals authorized to be the
749
00:53:44.199 --> 00:53:47.280
United States should be here, and only individuals authorized to
750
00:53:47.400 --> 00:53:50.639
work in the US labor market should work within it.
751
00:53:52.320 --> 00:53:57.719
Employment opportunities jobs are you know, the single largest magnet
752
00:53:57.920 --> 00:54:02.679
for illegal immigration into the United States, and I think
753
00:54:02.760 --> 00:54:06.159
that if we want as a country to be serious
754
00:54:06.239 --> 00:54:11.480
about enforcing laws that are already on the books, we
755
00:54:11.599 --> 00:54:15.519
have to sort of think seriously about what a more
756
00:54:15.559 --> 00:54:22.639
optimal enforcement system might look like. Everify verification at the
757
00:54:22.719 --> 00:54:27.199
hiring desk to ensure that such workers that apply for
758
00:54:27.280 --> 00:54:30.880
a job are authorized to work here. If they are
759
00:54:30.920 --> 00:54:34.000
not authorized to work for here, they will be rejected.
760
00:54:34.840 --> 00:54:37.320
That is one way we can turn off the magnet.
761
00:54:38.360 --> 00:54:42.559
Everify is not, of course, a silver bullet. Border enforcement
762
00:54:43.199 --> 00:54:50.440
is important, As David suggested, work site enforcement via sort
763
00:54:50.440 --> 00:54:56.320
of you know, audits is important imposing penalties both civil
764
00:54:56.360 --> 00:55:02.000
and criminal, not in some attempt to bankrupt businesses, but
765
00:55:02.119 --> 00:55:07.960
to ensure that there is sufficient deterrent, sufficient incentives for
766
00:55:08.400 --> 00:55:12.920
abiding buyer. Immigration law all part of the toolkit necessary
767
00:55:13.280 --> 00:55:17.599
to ensure that the two principles of ensuring that individuals
768
00:55:17.599 --> 00:55:19.440
that are authorized to be in our country and work
769
00:55:19.440 --> 00:55:25.639
on our labor market are able to do so.
770
00:55:25.679 --> 00:55:29.039
Thank you Daniel, thank you David, and thank you listeners.
771
00:55:29.400 --> 00:55:32.360
Please join me Henry Olsen again in two weeks for
772
00:55:32.440 --> 00:55:38.360
another episode of Conservative Crossroads, the topic should government regulate
773
00:55:38.679 --> 00:55:42.519
the development of artificial intelligence? Take care