TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Bryan Loomis: Alright. Didn't coming through alright. Seems to be. Alright. This is Cinema Field Guide, a podcast that surveys the breadth and depth of film history, one movement or microgenre at a time. We're currently looking at New German cinema. I am Bryan Loomis, joined by Felicia Moroni. How are you doing today, Felicia?
Felicia Maroni: I'm great. ⁓ it's cooled down. But we were having a wee bit of a weather chatter just before we hopped on to record. ⁓ it's cooled down but we're we're heading into the humid season here in Toronto, which I'm sure you obviously can relate to. But it's been good.
Bryan Loomis: Mm. Mm-hmm. Yes. Absolutely. It's a Monday here, so just starting the week, but I'm doing some travel towards the end of the week here. So it's like squeezing all of my normal stuff into Monday and Tuesday and then traveling Wednesday through Friday for work stuff. So gonna be long days, but I enjoy traveling. I like, you know, the flights I usually can't do any work. So I'll like download a couple of movies and watch ⁓ and Yeah, so it's good.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. Yeah. I was gonna ask.
Bryan Loomis: It's good movie watching time. ⁓ uninterrupted movie watching time and yeah. So I do enjoy that part of it.
Felicia Maroni: Nice. Yeah. I always get in any time I'm on a longer flight, ⁓ watching movies that I just normally wouldn't put on. So I'll be like, Well, I guess I'll watch, you know, whatever seventeenth Marvel movie has been come has been out with zero context. I'm like, Well, I have time and this movie's like two and a half hours long. So
Bryan Loomis: Mm. Yeah. Ha Yeah. Do it while you have time. Do you use the seatback screen if you have it available? Yeah, you're using the seatback screen.
Felicia Maroni: ⁓ yeah. Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: A lot of my flights for whatever reason don't have the seatback screen. And even if they do, like we ⁓ Hannah and I have a lot of screening streaming services anyway, so I might have access to something. The only who the only time I would use it is if I can watch something earlier that's not yet on streaming. Maybe it's like twenty dollars to rent and I'm not gonna pay twenty dollars. But if I can get it early, then I will watch it on the seatback. But that rarely happens where there's something that I'm interested in enough to ⁓ co-opt my whatever I have downloaded from Criterion on my phone. So.
Felicia Maroni: I know. Exactly. I mean, I feel that. We Air Canada, the airline, here the entertainment system has a criterion channel. It doesn't have the whole criterion channel but it'll have like a f a few select movies, so I'll go through that first to see. And sometimes it's like, Okay, finally I I get to watch something I haven't 'cause I saw on a flight
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Mm.
Felicia Maroni: Black girl for the first time 'cause it been on my list and I like, Hey, here's the time and then I went. I was like, Okay, well I have six more hours, so I guess I'll watch Avengers Seven. Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: ⁓ yeah. Mm-hmm. Watch whatever. Yeah. Yeah, Black Girl is ⁓ is pretty snappy. That's a shorter runtime. So you got time for the longer ⁓ Marvel thing. No ⁓ you know, 30-minute set piece battle scenes in in Black Girl to bloat out that runtime. So I I I should share my horrific airline customer service story from this week.
Felicia Maroni: Yes. Yeah. No, no. ⁓ gosh, okay.
Bryan Loomis: So originally I was going to fly into Memphis. on Thursday and back out on Friday. Then I got another request. So I have to be in Louisiana on Wednesday, then drive it's like a five hour drive Louisiana up to Memphis and just fly back. So I needed to cancel the flight there but not the flight back. And I'd booked it as a round trip. I always for work book with trip insurance because stuff happens and going
Felicia Maroni: Mm. Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: For like permitting hearings, basically, and and the hearings get canceled or moved around or whatever. So I had trip insurance, and the trip insurance just told me you have to cancel and we'll refund you, which doesn't do me any good because I need this Friday flight back, and there aren't as good options, and they're all very expensive, being a week out. So I called Delta, and they said basically the same thing of in order to we can't. We can't just cancel one leg of the flight. We've got to cancel the whole thing and rebook you on Friday. To rebook you on Friday, it's going to be $250 more expensive just for that than it was for the round trip. I was like, you're not understanding. I already have these tickets. I am already on this flight.
Felicia Maroni: ⁓ huh. Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: And you're telling me that I need to pay more than I originally spent. I understand that the prices are more expensive now, but I already have the tickets and I had trip insurance and they wouldn't help me, so Ooh, yeah, made yeah.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. ⁓ my god. I just feel like did you just not cancel the first one then?
Bryan Loomis: I ended up doing it. I mean, it's it's for work and so
Felicia Maroni: Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: That's it's not my money. So I and I needed needed to be able to fly back on Friday. So they did knock a hundred dollars off of it. There was some like seat upgrade because the only seats that were available were like Economy Plus. So they were like, Well, we'll knock off the upgrade to Economy Plus that we were gonna make you pay for. It's like, okay, thanks. I guess so.
Felicia Maroni: ⁓ yeah. ⁓ thanks. Cool. That's fun.
Bryan Loomis: finalized. I've got all of my ⁓ all of my stuff set, so I think ⁓ I am ⁓ all to go the rest of the week. But we are here, ⁓ and we're gonna be about Young Törless today, which ⁓ is directed by Volker ⁓ so ⁓ you want hit up with a synopsis for this, Felicia?
Felicia Maroni: gonna pause for one second. ⁓ it ⁓ did it cut out on my side? Did I freeze for you second?
Bryan Loomis: Yeah. I did not notice you freezing. Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: Okay. It you frozen for you, but you obviously
Load full transcript
asked me for the synopsis of the film. I assume. It kinda cut right back in. Okay.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah. Okay. Yeah, I don't I think it it does like flag it for you if you if it like dropped the recording or whatever. So yeah, I think we're good.
Felicia Maroni: Cool. yeah. So Young Törless directed by Volker Schlöndorff ⁓ and it's film about an Austrian boy's boarding school in the early nineteen hundreds. Shy, intelligent Törless observes the sadistic behavior of his fellow students doing nothing to help a victimized classmate until the torture ⁓ goes too Which sounds ⁓ quite intense. actually the movie is intense, but
Bryan Loomis: Yeah, that's not a joke. Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: ⁓ maybe a little bit more intense d yeah. It's a little it's well, we'll get into it. Actually.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. So ⁓ we'll with a little bit of background on the film, director, how it came to be, ⁓ etcetera. Volker Schlöndorff ⁓ very important director ⁓ of German cinema. Were you familiar much with his work before we started this project?
Felicia Maroni: Not his name, but some of the films I definitely was familiar with but hadn't seen, so 'Cause quite a few of them, including this one, are Criterion releases, including Coup de Grace and ⁓ The Tin Drum which should be is probably most known ⁓ And the Tin Drum had just been of ⁓ murmuring in the background of films that I should probably watch. ⁓ and and I for ⁓ this series. ⁓ it's an interesting film. I definitely prefer personally this but ⁓ I think doing research him ⁓ It was interesting because I feel like at some point I eventually would have come around to his work. ⁓ he's just kind of like a little bit on the sidelines. ⁓ a little bit kind of like Alexander Kluge from last week, where once you start expanding post ⁓ or past the big three, then you eventually he's the next step. ⁓ but w had you seen any of his work prior to this?
Bryan Loomis: I had not I think I was vaguely familiar with the Tin Drum, but really hadn't explored a lot beyond the big three in New German cinema. ⁓ he would be though In terms of especially at the time, he would be thought of sort of among those big directors of Wenders, Herzog and Fassbinder, especially because of the Tin Drum, which got a lot of contemporaneous recognition, maybe the most recognition of any new German cinema film. It won the Palme D'Or.
Felicia Maroni: Mm.
Bryan Loomis: Shared it with Apocalypse Now. And it also won the Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film in that year. So very recognized at the time. I don't know that it or his other films like this or ⁓ The lost honor of Katarina Blum, are as seen, I mean of cour by letterbox logs, you know, you'd have to get past a good like fifteen Fassbinder films to find, you know, the films that are ⁓ logged about as much as those ones. So I think it's getting to that point where like because Fassbinder has the name recognition, people are more willing to check out his stuff, even though at the time like the Schlöndorff
Films that were recognized, those really the the biggest three would be this one: Katarina Blum and The Tin Drum. Like those were among the biggest and most important films from New German cinema at the time. Just not maybe historically recognized as much because he doesn't have the rain name recognition that those three do now.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. It's always interesting how that happens. And there might be a a a ⁓ circle, you know, might come full circle again where people start revisiting his work. He's still he's still around. He's still working and we'll we'll get into that later of ⁓ where he's at n now and what he did a little bit post the New Jersey cinema era, but Again, not to sound dark, but sometimes when a a director passes, people then start revising his work. Criterion's definitely a big help with that. And the fact that they've released quite a few of his films, I'm sure they might do like a retrospective ⁓ it's always nice if they can do one while the person's still around. But ⁓ you there's a lot of people to get around to, so who knows? ⁓ he might get a revision
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm.
Felicia Maroni: And people start discovering his work. And I hope you know I I hope that if you've are listening to this, you've watched the film, but if not, ⁓ hopefully we inspire you as we carry on with the episode.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Absolutely. Well, can you tell us a little bit about his background before he made this film, which was his very first feature film at least?
Felicia Maroni: Mhm. So it was interesting to find out that he as a teen his family moved him a and them to France. So he spent a good part of his teens and early twenties there, going to school and then he apprenticed apprenticed, sorry, in the sixties there and worked with like a lot of really big name, French director, Louis Malle, Alain Resnais Jean Pierre Melville, ⁓ working as, you know, assistant directors on some really big films of theirs. ⁓ and you can see the influence on ⁓ of French cinema, especially French New Wave cinema, on his work, but especially this film and To me, that's definitely why I gravitated towards it because of my love of French New Wave, but it feels very French with a German essence, which describes who he is. So to find that out made so much sense. He later on in his career was the chief ⁓ my gosh, chief executive for five years at one of the world's old oldest film studios, which is really interesting to find out. So it was called Studio Babelsburg. And from what I know from reading him talk about it, the studio was in basically about to shut down. And he's like, We can't let this happen. This is like a studio that released a lot of like Fritz Lang's earliest work and a lot of like early German cinema and it was like really important. So he kind of heralded like a campaign to make sure it's it survived. So that's that's fantastic. He was also married to fellow filmmaker and collaborator Margarethe von Trotta And I feel like hopefully I'll get better as we when we eventually do one of her films ⁓ pronouncing her name. But she will return, ⁓ in this series. ⁓ like I said, and like you've mentioned, he's definitely a name in with within the New German cinema era. And when you see the work that he did and all the work that he did alongside other directors to push the new German cinema, ⁓ it's
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm.
Felicia Maroni: I think to me a little unfortunate that he's kind of a lost name, but i a lot of his stuff is readily available a little bit more than some of the other directors were covering, I will say. So there is that.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah. The the availability on Criterion does ⁓ especially for these there aren't a lot of other channels where their work would get featured or recognized in the same way. Now some work has gotten physical release and such, but there's there's not a lot of you know, labels that are releasing a ton of new German cinema stuff, which is a shame other than sort of the big big stuff, big directors. But hold on a second. Max, what are you doing out of bed?
Felicia Maroni: Mm.
Bryan Loomis: Max, go to bed. Bah ba. You can look for your water bottle, Bub, but if you don't find it, go back to bed, please.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: just wandering around there like walking into the room and watching me. so thankfully I wasn't talking while I was doing that, but that's all right. okay. ⁓ okay, let's see here.
Felicia Maroni: It's okay.
Bryan Loomis: I think the thing working with those French directors, the three that he worked with, Louis Malle, Alain Resnais, and Jean-Pierre Melville, they're among the best craftspeople I'd say of the French New Wave. You've got other directors who have a lot of
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: you know, energy or innovation or such, but they in particular really know their craft and their film history. And you can see that immediately in Schlöndorff's stuff that he has learned cinematic language and technique and how to use that effectively. Watching after something like Yesterday Girl, which is good and is using craft in interesting ways, but just the deep understanding of Okay, you do this shot and then this shot and then this shot to communicate the certain type of of thing. There's such a clear understanding of how to do that in Schlöndorff's work that I really like. ⁓ so that that definitely stood out on first watch and in in his other work, like how much of a craftsman he is and how much he knows how to communicate things via film.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm. Yeah, it really feels like a more seasoned director making this, so the fact that this is his first feature directing on his own is kind of wild and even watching like you said, his other films, there's a very like astute attention to detail and the imagery and the way a a frame is crafted. And like you said, if you're looking at a Resnais film, that's that's what he is. It's all of his films are like down to every detail
perfectly placed and you can feel that in this in this film and I I mean, when I watched it definitely didn't realise that it was his first, so to come to find out I was like, Wow, that's a great way to kick off your career
Bryan Loomis: Yes. Absolutely. And so this is ⁓ right at the outset of the new German cinema movement, it's released pretty much exactly around the same time as Yesterday Girl, maybe even slightly earlier. I saw some places that said 1965, some that said 1966. Yesterday Girl would be 1966. So it's unclear to me if this received Kuratorium money. Yesterday Girl seems to be the first film that that received. That and if this was coming a little earlier, probably not, but he did get it funded and very much is in line. He's not one of the signatories of the Oberhausen Manifesto or really involved in that group of short film directors. He's more just coming from France and his experience there. But that connection with the French New Wave and what he is trying to do artistically is very similar to. What the Oberhausen folks were trying to do as well. So I think he's very much in line with that and then does end up working with Kluge later in Germany in autumn. And so definitely is is aligned with the movement as a whole, just comes from sort of a different strand at first, I think.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: ⁓ this film is based on a novel. It is from Robert Moose's nineteen ⁓ six novel, The Confusions of Young Törless. ⁓ from our wonderful Thomas Elsa Esser book that we ⁓ we both read to get background on New German cinema. I pulled a quote from it. ⁓ Schlöndorff's first film, Young Törless, was taken from Robert Musil's story, written in 1906, and shows the literary influence of Joyce and Proust. Schlöndorff and his script writer Herbert Esmodi simplified the complex temporal structure of the story and externalized the stream of conscious narrative into action scenes and scenes.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: set pieces. So there is definitely this is a novel adaptation and you can sort of feel that in the complexity of the story that's being dealt with here, but it really is a movie first. They made quite a bit of changes to the source material from what I saw to make this work as a movie that's much more based on dialogue and doesn't rely really heavily on narration or other things where the book is very focused on Törless's inner life and thoughts. This externalizes a lot of that and is really trying to be a proper movie that uses the building blocks of what film can do versus the building blocks of what a novel can do.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. And I know he's known for doing a lot of novel adaptations, but I think what he does with this, as someone who hasn't read the the novel but knows that there were a lot of updates, he definitely modernizes it and we'll talk about it but brings where Germany was at at that point and where th those kids would be add in their their lives and modernizes it quite a bit so it feels ⁓ fresh and it doesn't feel necessarily like something from nineteen ⁓ six. So it feels good.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. It is it is so interesting because he was dealing a lot with ⁓ we'll get into that later. I wanna cut that. Well wait to get into it until the proper time. so I'll just go into the next part I guess.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: Okay, well it's time to talk about the film itself now. We're gonna highlight some traits or aspects that we think are unique or noteworthy. I wanted to just start, Felicia, by talking through each of these lead characters. So if you haven't seen this or it's been a while, essentially you have two young boys Beineberg and Reiting who are Essentially torturing, raping this other young boy, Basini who they've caught stealing, and they're threatening to turn him in and essentially make him their slave. And Törless is our main character, and he is more of a Somewhat passive observer. He doesn't partake in the torture, but he is around, he has knowledge of it, he speaks with Basini at times, but ultimately does not intervene throughout the vast majority of the film in what's happening here. So it that's sort of the basic. So it and there's so much psychologically going on. Here that I sort of want to entangle some of that. So first of all, Beineberg and Reiting are a little more I think they're the they're the easiest to wrestle. And I honestly like wrestle a little bit with the actions of each of these characters and how we're supposed to feel and why they do the things that they do. And so I find that aspect of the film really fascinating and and thorny. But Beineberg and Reiting, you know, why are they? Behaving this really heinous way in the film, I think. Does do you get the sense for why they're doing this to Basini?
Felicia Maroni: I I think I agree with you that they're the easiest not necessarily the easiest to understand, but because they're so outright evil in quotes it's easier to be like, okay, I know they're the clear villains. as opposed to the other two characters who are a little bit more nuanced, especially Torless which we'll get into. But these two watching it and watching even just a lot of teen movies of maybe the time or novels that are dealing with a gathering of boys o and we might get into the fact that it's sets like an at I don't know, a boys boarding school, but these are two people who get off on power and they will take whatever they can however they can and they seem to have zero empathy. and they're just clear as sadist and there's really nothing redeeming about them at all. And it's interesting that the film really doesn't try and make you empathize for them. Like right off the bat they're shown off as being quite sadistic and it's hard to watch children be that awful, especially to one another. And to the extent that they're they're
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm.
Felicia Maroni: being violent, it's very difficult to see that if they're able to do this at this age, ⁓ how
are they gonna move on from this? Because they are justifying to themselves every action that they're putting out there and they are not sorry for it. So I you just feel ⁓ a level of frustration
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm.
Felicia Maroni: I feel even more frustrated by another character, but ⁓ I think these two you can just kind of like you know they're not gonna there's no there's no redemption arc for these characters. At least to me I never thought that the film was gonna try and turn it around and be like, ⁓ they're you know, they're gonna apologize for their actions. These are two characters who are not sorry. At least that's how I read it.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Mm-mm. Yeah. Another I think important aspect is that they're very much coming from a place of privilege. Beineberg is talking about what his plans are after graduating from this boarding school and it's such a privilege, ⁓ well, maybe I'll do this for a year and maybe I'll just go like live and not work for a year and all of this stuff of clearly coming from a place of wealth and privilege. I think that plays into like being so young.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: And never having any needs that weren't immediately met. Just seeing others who do have needs, if Basini is running out of money, if Beineberg ran out of money, he'd have that money in a second, probably. So seeing people who are needy, there's so little empathy there of I'm in a place of privilege and power, and I can do whatever I want. And there's this sort of
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: Of learned quality of that through their youth and upbringing that I find really interesting as well. But yeah, very ⁓ pretty straightforward sadistic evil characters in this film that are just ⁓ upping the ante and making the torture worse because they are getting bored, which is really hard to watch, of just like, yeah, I'm I'm sort of bored with this. Bassini's getting used to this way of torture, so let's take it further and further and further. so pretty heartbreaking there.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: How do you feel about Basini as well? Because he I think at first they they do show you how he gets into this situation of lying about stealing money, being caught, not wanting to get turned in and essentially expelled from the school. But then as time goes on, and Törless even asks him at some point, like, why are you still putting up to the like where where is the line where you'd say it is better to get excel expelled than to experience this anymore? So how how do you feel about that portrayal? I don't see it as like a a victim blaming sort of thing. I think it's more insightful about the psychology of someone who's experiencing something like this than I'd call it that, but wondering how you feel about it.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah, he side note he he reminded me a little bit ⁓ ⁓ from Lord of the ⁓ Just the way the the boys go about him. ⁓ I think the fact that he's having to ⁓ ⁓ because he's running out of ⁓ ⁓ enough to tell ⁓ ⁓ he's putting up with ⁓ and why he doesn't want to be expelled, my ⁓ is that maybe home ⁓ is even ⁓
Bryan Loomis: I can see that.
Felicia Maroni: than this and he needs to stay at school. That's how I viewed it because a as you're watching this film, especially for the first time, you're like, Man Being kicked out of school cannot be worse than what you're going through because these kids the next step is to kill you, probably. Cause they're never gonna be satisfied with ⁓ just torturing you. And the fact that he just wouldn't give himself up made me feel like there's something worse at home and there's gotta be a reason why he doesn't wanna go there. And it can't just be embarrassment of being expelled from school. I think there's something worse And maybe he's used to this and that makes it really that makes it really hard to watch, ⁓ just knowing that he's able to sustain so much and not that it doesn't faze him, but not as much it mu as it might of another kid and I I just there's a darkness an added layer of darkness to that for me. because I just feel like there's no way you would put up with that.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: You know. I don't know. It's really sad.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah, it is sad. There also might be a little bit of like a sunk cost thing going on of I've already experienced this much and if I go tell people and get expelled, then it will have been for nothing. So I just need to, you know, put up with it until we could graduate and then I can free myself from it. So I th and I think he says something somewhat to that extent when Törless confronts him.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: About not going to the authorities. But then he also at times asks Törless for help. And I imagine that Törless is the one that you find the most frustrating here. So how do you and and I think that's the crux of the film: is why is Törless not doing anything about this? And what on earth is going on in this kid's mind?
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: So how do you feel about it?
Felicia Maroni: Yeah, h he's frustrating for sure, and part of me has part of me feels bad also because I feel like there's a a small amount of fear of stepping in for someone and putting yourself on the line. But I think he knows that he's in better standing with Beineberg and Reiting that He wouldn't be in the same position as Basini. So that's what makes it feels like frustrating because he could go to someone for help. And we see in this movie the adults aren't much help, but he could have gone to someone for it. But I just feel like standing by and actively watching something, even though you're not participating physically, to me, that's still a little participating in violent behavior and we'll talk about the the themes that it it ⁓ this film has that fall in line with the new German cinema ⁓ microgenre, but I think it says a lot about the p passive nature that was happening amongst a lot of Germans as the war was beginning and
you can see what Schlöndorff was trying to say with this character and how it's easy for us as viewers to be like, Well, why wouldn't you do something about this? But also if you step into those that person's shoes and be like, Well, would you do something about it? And maybe yes you would, but would you do something about it right away? Or how long would it take you to do something about it? 'Cause he does eventually. But by then it's too late when he does it. So I think it's it's a fantastic way of saying things without explicitly saying things. I think Törless is a fascinating character, incredibly frustrating, but that's the point. And if you're not frustrated by this character, I I would encourage you to re watch it ⁓ with maybe fresher eyes because there's a lot being said with this character, I think.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah, absolutely. It's a exploration of passivity as complicity, essentially. So looking at this boy who is Really, he's coming of age. He's trying to figure out how the world works, and I think very frustratingly sees this as an opportunity to learn how the world works, and his fascination with imaginary numbers and that there might be something beyond what you can comprehend, but it still is useful, sort of plays into this as well of like, I don't understand. Exactly what's going on in this situation or why these people are doing this, but I want to observe and learn from it. And that is the exact wrong way to approach this situation, to just observe and learn from it. He's like journaling about this and considering it as an ethical quandary without doing anything about it, which is. completely an antithetical to anything ethical, right? So ⁓ yeah it's it's very frustrating and I think it's something that we we see in Nazi Germany is something that we see today and it's important to understand why people don't act when there is evil being done in the world that they could make a difference towards and so it's a very difficult film but I think it's it's not an easy film to watch. It's maybe the least easy film to watch of the ones that that we chose for this series, but I think it is such an important topic to understand and explore for that reason of understanding why somebody would see something so heinous and not do it. And the film doesn't
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: very cleanly answer that question. You know, the novel has more of Törless's inner life and his thoughts, the
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: film is a little more elliptical about what he's thinking, but I think if you watch it carefully and you can I think the craft is strong enough that you can sort of feel it in in your gut and your bones, even if intellectually you don't quite understand what it's going for or why Törless is acting the way he does. We know that people do act like this and we don't need to to understand this, we don't need an essay on why exactly people behave like this. We need to just see it and feel it and know that we we
can do something we can choose to do something different essentially.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. I think again it's it's not necessarily written out for you in this film, but to me it feels a little bit more effective this way because I think watching something like this that feels very realistic, like nothing about this doesn't feel like it couldn't happen. You would absolutely hope that it doesn't, but we know that violence happens within schools. It continues to happen within schools. And I think something like this has more of an effect than like at the end of a film having, you know, Reiting come across the screen to be like, Hey, you shouldn't do this or speak up if you see evils. Like that's not gonna work. ⁓ to talk down
Bryan Loomis: Yes.
Felicia Maroni: to people. I think something like this that throws you in there and forces you to watch this unfiltered makes you think a lot harder about your own actions, let alone the actions of the past, as we wonder why people might have taken too long to speak up. Even in today's world of people ⁓ taking too long or not wanting to speak up just yet. So unfortunately this film continues to be really relevant.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Yeah. It's getting at something in human nature that I think is somewhat universal and unfortunately is is not going away. ⁓ because of it's just how humans are and operate in society, but very important to understand so that we can make different choices. So it's at a boarding school. How do you feel that the setting how and the and the use of the characters helps tell this story where you could tell a morality play like this in many different ways, but w w w what does the setting contribute to this?
Felicia Maroni: For me it typically sets up that there is a higher economic status for a lot of these kids for sure to be in a boarding school and an all boys boarding school so likely most of these people's parents are some one of you know Big status or they have money and or they have money. And we mentioned some of the characters talking about how they're pretty much set after they graduate. They just have to graduate and everything is gonna be handed to them. But then we do see that there's characters who are struggling a bit. But I think the close knit nature of a boarding school where they're stuck there essentially for a certain amount of time. They're not around their parents. They're around adults but most of the time they're around each other like basically twenty-four seven, which is not something that most of us have to deal with. You know, we go to school and then you come home and then you don't see people on the weekends unless that they're your friends. And then you're not with them twenty-four seven. So this constant ⁓ proximity of having a bunch of boys of this age together has to be very intense. And ⁓ my partner, he didn't go to boarding school, but in Ireland they
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm.
Felicia Maroni: back in the day it was still gendered, ⁓ all boys, all girls. So he went to an all boys school and some of the horror stories I hear from that are enough to kinda scare you off of anything like that. So I think being stuck in such close proximity and having people like ⁓ Beineberg ⁓ Reiting who are already people who ⁓
Bryan Loomis: Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: This is not I don't think this developed as they were at school. I think it ⁓ was nurtured by being able to be like, I have earned my status here and I can now exert power because I don't I think they're they're you know, they're in their graduating year. So, ⁓ Boarding school films not all of them, but I find a lot of them are very intense and typically horror stories. I think a lot of boarding school movies make a lot of great horror films, but It makes sense to be told in this. I think you could still tell the story if they had just gone to regular school, but it's a lot more effective with them being able to be like, There's nowhere for a Basini to run other than to ⁓ an adult. So he's stuck there.
Bryan Loomis: But the adults, ⁓ know, ⁓ adults around them are also ⁓ unhelpful ⁓ best, and at worst are very authoritarian. ⁓ ⁓ see Törless get punished very early on and ⁓ the ⁓
Felicia Maroni: Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: Teachers are either doling out punishments or giving long-winded explanations around why kids just don't understand and just nothing about the adults in this film feels like they are any more mature than the students, though they certainly think of themselves as better.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: And that that final scene as well with the panel of teachers and adults who are interviewing Törless and trying, in theory, trying to figure out why he's run away after Basini has been publicly humiliated and tortured by
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: the whole class, essentially. That scene, it it's so clear to me that they are not really that they're not really interested in getting to the bottom of what Turlis experienced or knew, and they're just getting very frustrated with him by not for not being able to communicate clearly. And they're honestly grandstanding. It's They're trying to look good in front of each other in the way that they're asking these questions and communicating these things and setting themselves over as the authorities over these boys and trying to find out who needs the punishment essentially from this whole situation. And that's not the right way to go about it. There's no real empathy or understanding there. Just as there's no real un empathy or understanding in the boys.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. It also feels like they're looking to blame anyone but themselves for not catching on to the fact that a boy was being t tortured under their supervision. And, you know, i if it was a different time in a more modern times, parents would be in there. immediately asking how has d this happened and none of you saw this happening. ⁓ it's not up to children to, you know, be making sure that ⁓ other children are safe.
So ⁓ it just shows that's like you said, there's zero empathy from them and they would much rather be like, Well, now who do we need to punish in order to to make to rectify this and just exert more violence instead of actually fixing the situation.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah, absolutely. Well, I wanted to talk about the score in this. I usually don't ⁓ don't think about scores so much in films, but I came across a really interesting article about this film as an adaptation and how the score is doing a lot of work in communicating the things that the novel does. Just examining Törless's imagination, inner turmoil, confusion, et cetera. And it basically was making the argument that the score is the film's equivalent of making those arguments. Did the score stand out at all to you and and did it seem like it was communicating effectively how Törless was feeling throughout the film?
Felicia Maroni: You know what? It wasn't until I saw your notes on this that it made sense. I don't think I n I personally noticed it too much. I think because I'm just so horrified by the imagery that I'm watching that I didn't fully tune into the score, but I him saying this, ⁓ really makes sense. And it's kind of at least to me, good that it didn't overpower the scenes and try and sway you in any other way. ⁓
Bryan Loomis: Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: I think definitely on a another watch I'll probably be able to tune into it a bit more, but ⁓ I think you know, I am curious to hear what's to why why you ⁓ tune into the to the score on this watch.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, it was mostly when I was doing the research. I think I did notice it and as I was reading about it, I could sort of hear the score. And if I'm remembering correctly, it's it's often at sort of transitional moments. So there's not a lot behind the dialogue. There's a lot of silence, which
Felicia Maroni: Mm.
Bryan Loomis: of course can can work really well for a film film like this when there's sort of action and dialogue going on, you just sort of use the score to transition between one or the other. I do think the It's an atonal score, which makes it sound uncomfortable and unsettling. Schlöndorff said he wanted the score to set an atmosphere of vastness and forsakenness. And I do feel that in the film. And I think even if Folks don't notice the score while they're watching. It still does make you feel a certain way that contributes to how you feel about the film as a whole. And so it's working on scores often work on the unconscious. I think a good score often does not draw attention to itself and just adds to the mood of the movie. And this is a very moody movie, I think, in in parts because of the score. It in ⁓
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: Henze, the ⁓ composer of this score, chose to use earlier period instruments like the hurdy gurdy and the lute that don't do a lot of like vibrato or refined sounds. So very sort of crude, you might say, instruments, like early instruments to represent the boys unrefined nature, how they haven't matured into adults. They're not fully formed people yet. So that was sort of his idea behind it. But then it is a very modern in terms of being atonal, so it's not, you know, Renaissance music or or whatever. It does feel very modern in terms of the musical background that it's using.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm. That's interesting. I w when I saw your notes about the lute, I like, Okay, wow, I totally missed that. ⁓ I have to go back.
Bryan Loomis: a hurdy-gurdy and a lute in in the the score either, but ⁓ I did come across that in the and thought it was interesting as well. So. Mm-hmm. How about and and I think this is a film that is trying to ⁓ make viewers feel things ⁓ unconsciously in lot of ways, rather ⁓
Felicia Maroni: Ha ha ha. No, that is. That's cool. Yep.
Bryan Loomis: The Kluger, the the Kluger film yesterday, girl, it's just such an interesting contrast because they came out roughly around the same time. Kluge wants you to know like what's wrong with the ⁓ economic miracle in Germany Germany and walk away with some talking points. I think Schlöndorff sort of wants you to walk away from this being like What the heck is going on there and why are these people he wants to like get you thinking about it more. And so I think there are a lot of these things in the film that are implied or communicated in less clear ways or more evoked than explicitly laid out. And I think that that works well for the type of film that this is. One of those things is there are beyond, you know, clearly the the the rape of Basini, ⁓ there are other homoerotic elements in the film, I would say, around Törless and his desire perhaps for his classmates. Those are, from what I understand, much more clearly communicated in the novel.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: But I would say still present here. D do you feel that much while watching or was it more in the research that you came across this stuff?
Felicia Maroni: I felt ⁓ definitely a little bit of it and I'm I g actually a little fascinated to hear that the novel explored it more explicitly than the film. And my guess is because I didn't come across ⁓ any interviews with Schlöndorff talking about that theme at all. Maybe he just decided to minimize it because there's already a lot going on in this film and that's just like an added layer. But I definitely felt it in the fact that Törless is definitely a voyeur and he's someone who he's still young and not fully developed mentally, physically, and he He's probably a little confused as to why he's feeling these th feelings. And I think that's where the voyeurism comes in, along with the him just being passive and not wanting to interject. But he the way the camera frames him watching Basini I was like, I don't think it's just in the performance. I think it's something they must have discussed. ⁓ ⁓ I think it was implied. I don't think it was by accident that we're reading reading into it like after the fact and
putting our own reading onto it. I think it's there. and I I think it would be a little bit more of a different film if it had been explicit. I think it's probably better off if it's the way it is now because I think that just adds too much to the film and ⁓ opens up a lot more questions and I don't know that Schlöndorff is well equipped to answer those questions to be honest. maybe is, but I'm not sure. ⁓ but I definitely felt that there was a presence of that of someone who is questioning his sexuality and probably doesn't even know really what
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm.
Felicia Maroni: his sexuality could possibly be at this point, but is in such a impressionable age where he is curious about it and it's unfortunate what he is seeing is a very violent way of assault And that's what he's he's watching. So it's it's very dark but I I it's to me it was there. I don't know if you saw it as you were watching it or y it came about more in the the research.
Bryan Loomis: was a little bit more in the research. I don't think it surprised me so much in the research. It was like a ⁓ yeah, I can see how that element is there. Essentially, so I actually have a a passage from the book. But in the book, it is it's pretty clear during the period when Törless and Basini are alone at the boarding school over a break without the other two boys, that they do have sex. Basically, Basini climbs naked into bed with Törless and proclaims his love for him. So the passage then at that point says, Then Törless stopped searching for words, the sensuality which had been gradually seeping into him.
Felicia Maroni: Mm.
Bryan Loomis: From his isolated moments of despair had now reached its full extent. It lay naked beside him and covered his head with its soft black mantle, ⁓ it murmured sweet words of resignation onto his ear, ⁓ with its warm fingers it pushed away all questions and obligations as vain. And it whispered, In solitude everything is permitted. So that's not like implied, you know, ⁓ not implied homoeroticism there. That's very explicit. ⁓
Felicia Maroni: No, yeah. No.
Bryan Loomis: So ⁓ and there is a little bit of like the way, like you said, Törless looks at Basini. I don't think Schlöndorff is trying to remove that as a plot line here. I think his interest thematically lies a little bit elsewhere, particularly because this was a
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: novel that was written before the Nazis came to power, but he is a lot more interested in Törless's passivity because of basically grappling with Nazism. And so those are the themes of the book that he's really wanting to explore. But I wouldn't say he removes the homo erotic elements from the storyline. I think if you're watching carefully you can sort of see that the desire is there. But the desire is so confusing and would be so confusing for Turlis, because Bissinian Reiting
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: Raping Bassini is not really about desire. It's much more about power and control. And so then having this actual desire for Basini would be so confusing. And so that definitely like comes through and it's really complex.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I think if you're putting this on blind and you think it's just about boys being boys in a boarding school, you're gonna be fairly shocked about how how deep it goes. ⁓ Yeah. I think it's it's very gripping. As har as difficult as it is to to watch, it's a very gripping film.
Bryan Loomis: Mm. It is. and there are more difficult films to watch. This is pretty clear about what's what's happening in a lot of ways, but ⁓ many times things are talked about or shown off screen. I think it's very respectful of these young actors and wants you to feel uncomfortable but i isn't trying to
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: It isn't trying to be unwatchable for the sake of being unwatchable. It is trying to communicate something about this situation, first and foremost. So it has to be very clear about the situation in that way. But it's it's relatively generous towards the audience because it doesn't it doesn't hate its audience, I would say, where a lot of the films that might be dealing with similar subjects.
Felicia Maroni: No.
Bryan Loomis: subject matter might be doing so because they sort of hate their audience and want to put them through it. It's not really trying to do that necessarily. It has a r a reason why it's using this sort of material to to make its point.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah, it's ⁓ it's not a Gaspar Noe way film, that's for sure.
Bryan Loomis: No. No. He's one of the ones that yeah I would say is sorta hates his audience and is is trying to just just trying to make them feel bad as as an exercise. And they're they're, you know, if he's got a ton of fans who are sorta into that and it's the same thing with horror movies of if you like being scared then you might like being made uncomfortable and we should I think be open to films allowing us to have all sorts of diff
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. Bull that. Yeah. Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: different experiences other than just being entertained. But I personally don't really respond to films that are just like putting you through it just for the sake of it. ⁓ but other people do and that's okay. Yeah. Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm. Neither do I. Yeah. I'm in the same boat.
Bryan Loomis: Okay. Well, let's get into this film's importance to the New German cinema movement itself in terms of Hallmarks, how it pushes the movement forward at this very young stage for the movement. And this What we're just talking about of covering uncomfortable subjects, this wasn't the only film that worked in that regard in New German cinema. Do you feel its influence in some of the other stuff that that we watched?
Felicia Maroni: Yeah, for sure. I think you know, I I see we have Germany Pale Mother ⁓ listed there. I think most of her films, to be honest, are have to be influenced by this film. Or at least she's seen it and yes.
Bryan
Loomis: Yep. That's ⁓ Helma Sanders Brahms is the director
Felicia Maroni: I I have to imagine just even the way something I didn't mention ⁓ above but as you were talking about how ⁓ he makes films, especially this one where the message is very clear but it's not trying to make you it's not trying to make the audience too uncomfortable. I think there's a dreaminess to the way the the film is shot. ⁓ again, very influenced by the French New Wave. But even something like Germany Pale Mother, there's a dreaminess to it which makes that the the images and the storyline feel even more ⁓ effective because you're kind of pulled in to this dream like state of being, you know, immersed in a world that feels so real and dark. But we see this even in a lot of Fassbinder's work. I wouldn't say all of it, but his stuff that is a lot more clearly messaged he Fassbinder can have a a mean streak. ⁓ My favorite one, even though it's an incredibly difficult to watch film, but Martha is has to be, again, influenced by this film. ⁓ I can't imagine Fassbinder not having seen this and taking a a little bit of influence from the way he got the message across of how people uh's passivity can affect ⁓ others near them and in certain instances like millions of other people. again, ⁓ even though this film isn't as spoken about today, I think it definitely at the time had a a huge influence, especially being one of the first in the the movement to come to come out.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah. Yeah, they're there are definitely a series of films in New German cinema that are actively in this mode of covering really uncomfortable subjects, ⁓ difficult for the viewer to watch, and really making you confront evil and a lot of that stems from these being sort of the generation after the Nazis in Germany and really wanting to recommend with what it meant for their parents' generation. You know, these these are the the artistic people who are wanting to confront this this previous generation's actions and understand what it means for their nation. And so this I think is really The first stab at that in New German cinema, and it will get more explicit about grappling with Nazism and less metaphorical, particularly in the back half of New German cinema. But even the one we've already talked about, Aguirre the Wrath of God, also grappling with that Nazism and confronting evil head on, the I I've I've another film I saw, Hunting Scenes from Bavaria, is not not quite as well known. It's also from the late sixties, but very much in the same mode of showing a lot of human cruelty, really making the viewers sit through it and watch all of these horrific things happen. There's a scene in the slaughterhouse that is just horrifying. So if animal cruelty is a thing for people, like that's one of the that's one of the roughest things I've sat through in terms of animal cruelty. ⁓ so yeah it was it was pretty rough.
Felicia Maroni: Mm. I guess
Bryan Loomis: But yeah, there's there's definitely like this kicks off a strand of movies who are dealing with the this stuff. So I think it's it's an important part of the movement as a whole.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. And I do think it's like it is ⁓ you know, as you mentioned and we'll probably continue to mention through the series, the new German cinema movement coming about as a criticism of those postwar heimat films, and I think this feels like a direct criticism ⁓ those films that were just really not wanting to talk about ⁓ ⁓ happened in their country ⁓ this takes it head on and as we mentioned is just a little bit more direct about how he's feeling and I think the fact that he also spent time outside of Germany and in France allowed him to have a bit more introspection on maybe the people around him, his family and the culture that he was immersed in. Once you're away from it, you can look back on it and you know, be more direct in confronting your emotions, even if he didn't personally live through this, but it's still very much a part of the culture at that time. Even today. But I think that distance allowed him to tackle it the way he did in this film. That's how I read it.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Yeah. The the other aspect here of the grappling with Nazism and and the Holocaust would be the depiction of Törless as this passive, complicit figure, and the relationship of that with the essentially the banality of evil, the famous Hannah Arendt, ⁓ description of ⁓ sort of the Nazi regime of just following orders, we're just going along and don't really see themselves as evil, just going along with what was happening even if they didn't they weren't actively cruel or participants, they went along with things that were horrific. So did you feel that in this film?
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm. Very much. kind of what we've been saying that it's even if the film doesn't explicitly mention those words, those that part of the the German culture, it's difficult for you to not read that, you know, as you're watching it. And i it's not even necessarily just about German ⁓ history 'cause if there's many people many countries and ⁓ parts of history that have dealt with similar horrific know, experiences where a lot of members of the communities were just being like, If it's not affecting me, I'm not gonna do put my neck out on the line ⁓ until I need to and there's a pretty good quote that I found from Schlöndorff where he says as he's talking about the film, ⁓ he says, All this is reminiscent of the Nazi regime the practices of the takeover, Himmler's speeches and the attitude of the enlightened bourgeoisie that only watched the primitive Nazis until it was too late. And I feel like that pretty much sums up the film without again it being explicitly about, you know, Nazis, or that that era of German history. ⁓ If you know anything about this era of film, most of those directors were wanting to tackle it in one way or another. So it's it's again, I think common theme throughout the series will be the way the
different directors tackle it because they all have their own ways of doing it. I definitely gravitated towards his way of tackling these this themes.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah, I think it's a really strong one. and I think part of the strength of it as well comes from the fact that it's an adaptation of a From All Indications really great novel. Neither of us have have read it, but
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: You know, German novels, unlike like we've been talking about German films at this time, were not very well thought of. They weren't important thought of as important internationally, contemporaneously until new German cinema come up came along. So I think the The adaptation of novels becomes very important to new German cinema in terms of establishing its respectability because there are many German novels at at the time and in the first half of the twentieth century are among the most c critically acclaimed. you've got Thomas Mann, Heinrich Boll, Gunter Grass, and Musil Who wrote this film? Most of those authors are adapted by new German cinema directors. And then not in Germany, but in German language, you've also got Franz Kafka, who I'm sure people would be familiar with as well. So German is like a language where a lot of great literature is being written. And so the ability to sort of take that art form that is more established and is doing some of the things that
Felicia Maroni: Uh-huh.
Bryan Loomis: that the new German cinema directors want to be doing with their medium i i is a good way to launch their their movement essentially to say we're more aligned with these novels than the films that have come in the decade prior.
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. I think it also it definitely helps having a built in audience, as you said, who would be even if they haven't read it, maybe they're at least familiar with the title, what the films ⁓ sorry, what the novel is about. And those those novels being translated to other languages too and being read outside of Germany helps as well. because even when the research that I was doing
Bryan Loomis: ⁓ yeah.
Felicia Maroni: The s the book seems to be still widely read because there was a lot of literature about this book that came I came across as I was doing research. And this is a book I personally had never heard about before, but obviously has still, you know, presence amongst, you know, literaries. So I am interested to to read it at some point.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Yeah. I saw a lot of the contemporary criticism around this film was that it was not a very faithful novel adaptation, which really drives me crazy as a criticism of the movie ⁓ of a movie. It might be fair in this case, having not read the novel, like maybe the novel's doing things that are really, really excellent. But I think this is a very strong film and I don't think that a film needs to be faithful to its source material. It doesn't owe the source material anything. It should be the best film that it can be and you are working
in a different medium and so you To be able to do different things. And from what I've read about this book, being a lot about Törless's imagination, his inner thought life, really exploring the way he is thinking and processing things. Like there's just not You know, you can't you could make a movie that was a lot more heavy on narration. And I think that movie would probably be worse than what we have here, which I think is a very strong film. A lot of the action's been externalized. We're dealing with maybe a shift in thematic emphasis versus what the novel was doing. doing, but there's no reason you can't do that. You can take the bones of a story and apply it to something else. So I I don't have a problem with like a lack of faithfulness, even if it is like a classic novel necessarily. Though though I do, you know, the novel sounds really compelling as well and is also something I'd be interested like you in in reading. So
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. I don't think a film should ever aim to put page to, you know, celluloid directly. That's that's never gonna make for a good film. And I think the best part about it is the film is that we d don't have that much insight into Torles's mind. ⁓
Bryan Loomis: No. Mm-hmm.
Felicia Maroni: 'Cause if you know too much, if if he's telling you this is why I'm thinking this and that, ⁓ it's less effective and ⁓ it doesn't allow for the audience to try and decipher why someone might do ⁓ something like this or not do anything at all. So I think this is the better way about going about it.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah. Absolutely. The the not knowing why he is behaving the way he is behaving sort of makes you just dwell on it and it makes it sits with you for a you know after you've finished watching the film and for the purpose of this film is really trying to grapple with passive observation of evil and why people don't take action to stop evil happening. Like that is the perfect thing for the viewer to be sitting with, not as important perhaps to the novel, but very important to what the film's doing.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm. I agree.
Bryan Loomis: Cool. Okay, well we talked about Schlöndorff a little bit and I think mentioned many of the the films that people might be familiar with. He's made ⁓ a lot of films, only really a handful that I was compelled to check out. There seemed to be some some duds in there, but some seemed somewhat interesting as well. So how do you think this fits into his broader filmography and are there other any others that you would recommend?
Felicia Maroni: ⁓
Bryan Loomis: Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: I think this is definitely the place to start. 'cause I think it really exemplifies w who he is as a director, both thematically but visually, and you get the the direct influence of the French New Wave on this that still continues throughout his at least German career. ⁓ He later goes to America, has a little brief stint, as a lot of European directors do. The only one out of the major three 'cause he did a film called Swan and Love. He did one c ⁓ Death of a Salesman, which I'm sure a lot of people have seen, Dustin Hoff and John Malkovich one, which I I haven't seen, but I know a lot of people have. And The Handmaid's Tale, the first film adaptation, which I watched in high school. Obviously had no idea that he directed this.
Bryan Loomis: Mm.
Felicia Maroni: But the imagery from that film has stuck with me for a very long time and doing research of watching his films and research on him, I can see a lot of his work on there. But I personally would recommend sticking with his German work. I'd say this one Tindrum, just because I think people should watch it and it's interesting. ⁓ The Lost Honor of Katarina Blum, I think it's a fascinating film and more politically overt than this one is for sure and then Coup de Gras is visually similar to this one. I liked it a lot. and I think that film specifically influenced the White Ribbon. It had to have influenced influence the white ribbon. So if you're a fan of that film, not that that's a feel good movie at all, but if you're in the mood to watch something similar. and as we mentioned, he's still he's still making work. He his latest film just premiered at Cannes and it'll be coming out for people to watch in October twenty twenty six. It's called ⁓ the English title is called Visitation. I saw a lot of interviews with him talking about it, even recent ones when he was at the film fest.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: and all of the images. It looks it looks very interesting, so I'd be interested to to watch it when it comes out for people. If it comes out out o out here, we'll see, but I don't know.
Bryan Loomis: Yeah. I love that he and Herzog and Wenders are still working, you know, have released films this decade. That's really fantastic to still have those active voices from this movement even as we're ⁓ recording this series, you know, sixty years after the fact of this this movie being released. So which is sort of crazy. So yeah. yeah, the
Felicia Maroni: I know. ⁓ gosh. Wow.
Bryan Loomis: I think for me the the highlight I've only seen ⁓ Lost Honor of Katarina Blum and Tin Drum of his others. Lost Honor of Katarina Blum is is fantastic and certainly worth checking out. Very different, but really ⁓ really great. The Tin Drum is a little controversial because of some sex scenes with of an adolescent boy involved. And so there's a little bit of ickiness. involved in that and it also just felt like a real it felt like a real like this is what you can see at an international art house festival every year sort of thing to me. Like ⁓ you know, if there's there're some moments that have like a distinct voice, but when you watch enough art house films, ⁓ you get the sense for like, ⁓ this is doing that sort of thing. And you can see why it was recognized, why it did well at festivals and the Oscars and such, but in terms of how
Felicia Maroni: Yeah. Yeah.
Bryan Loomis: Having a
distinctive voice, I didn't enjoy it as much as the other ⁓ two that I've seen. So
Felicia Maroni: That's fair. And I was just laughing 'cause it it it feels very much like that one, you know, European art house film that makes it out. ⁓ and sometimes a director's most popular film is not their best. So, ⁓ I think we're both in agreement. Again, an interesting enough film to check out, but I think that this one is a lot better.
Bryan Loomis: Mm-hmm. Yeah, absolutely. All right, well, we've done enough talking about new German cinema. It is time for a double feature with this film that is not from the movement. What do you have for us today, Felicia?
Felicia Maroni: Yep. Kind of like last week I went a little bit more on the on the nose and a little more obvious, but I think that this reminded me so much of the four hundred blows, the Truffaut film from nineteen fifty nine. ⁓ as you've been mentioning throughout this episode, the influence on the French New Wave on Schlöndorff's career and this film I think you you pairing it with a New Wave, French New Wave film, is definitely gonna elevate the imagery, especially if you're in the mood to watch two black and white films and we can see the different ways the two cultures tackle troubled boys. Four hundred Blows is a s sad enough film, but it's nowhere near as dark as this film is. So ⁓ I would say watch it second. so that you have something a little bit nicer to watch after ⁓ Young Torless unless you want to end on a darker note, but I feel like I I mean the film doesn't end happy, n not to spoil four hundred blows, but ⁓ there's a lot more humor, I think, in the four hundred blows than there is in this one. And I'll recommend any Truffaut It's not my favourite, but
Bryan Loomis: Mm. Mm.
Felicia Maroni: I think thematically they deal with similar things. I just don't think that Truffaut has like a a nasty bone in his body. He would not be able to make a movie this dark, I don't think.
Bryan Loomis: Probably not, but that's okay. We love him anyway. Yeah. ⁓ so I had gone after the movement for my first two double features, and so I wanted to go a little bit earlier for this one, but was having trouble in
Felicia Maroni: That's okay. We do. What do you got?
Bryan Loomis: really finding a good match because this is so dark and explicit. Earlier films don't necessarily are aren't necessarily as as frank as a whole about, you know Sex, torture, all of the stuff that's featured here, and so the darker tone was was a hard hard thing to find a good fit for. But then of course I thought of our our friend Luis Buñuel who made many, many dark films over the course of his career. But the one I thought of was Los Olvidados or The Young and the Damned from 1950. An excellent, excellent film, one of his most known, most respected, ⁓ made in in Mexico. And I think the key difference here is that Los Olvidados is dealing with essentially kids in poverty versus kids from privilege, but similarly dealing with some of that Cruelty, violence begets violence, ⁓ the impossibility of exiting, you know, from these sorts of situations, and how has a similarly bleak ending to this film and and a lot of like turning the other way or not really wanting to confront evil or the way world the world works and such. So it's a great film. And that was my ⁓ double feature for this week. So only Buñuel could provide something that was ⁓ mean spirited enough earlier than this film to to be a good match.
Felicia Maroni: Nice. Yeah. Ha ha ha. that I like, you know that makes sense. He is ⁓ he has a great balance in his films but he does ⁓ definitely have a mean streak, ⁓ within reason. I think he hates his audience, yeah.
Bryan Loomis: ⁓ I really like yeah. I really like Buñuel and I do like we were talking about with Fassbinder of like the big three. He's the one because he's the meanest, he is sort of the one that I generally respond to the films the most. So I definitely think that that that style really works for me in general. So yeah, love love Buñuel. And continues to do great work, you know, through the sixties, through the seventies. So he's active around around the time of this film, but Lost will be that.
Felicia Maroni: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nice. Mm-hmm.
Bryan Loomis: Well, this has been Cinema Field Guide. Felicia, where can people ⁓ find us?
Felicia Maroni: On most social main social platforms we've got our Instagram, ⁓ which is under the name Cinema Field Guide. We have our YouTube, Blue Sky and Twitter, both under our Cinema Field Guide and ⁓ our website also. Cinema Field Guide. Do a quick Google, I'm sure hopefully all those will come up fairly easily. Also create a link tree so everything will be out there
Bryan Loomis: ⁓ very nice.
Felicia Maroni: for you to just click one link and have all the links available for you. ⁓ and then we also have an email, cinemafieldguide at gmail dot com. ⁓ send us emails about anything, either the episodes, the movies you cover, movie movies we didn't cover, if you want to recommend us some movies, or just general movie chatter, I'm sure we'd be happy to talk about anything. ⁓ within within reason. But
Bryan Loomis: Yeah. Between the two of us we've probably seen the movie that you want to talk about, but not necessarily. There there's some movie there's always more movies to see. There's always more to see. Yeah.
Felicia Maroni: Yes. I know. You might try this. Always. There's always that's the best that's the beautiful part of life. It's never ending. So yeah, please ⁓ send us a follow.
Bryan Loomis: Mm. You never run out yeah, never run out of movies to watch, and never run out you never run out of interesting and even great movies to watch. There's a never-ending stream if if you're open to it. So that's ⁓ that's what we're all about here at Cinema Field Guide. Thanks for listening to the podcast, and we'll see you next week on Cinema Field Guide.
Felicia Maroni: Exactly.
Bryan Loomis: I think I like ending on the