TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:04
Speaker 1: Hey, guys, thanks for listening to Breaking Points with Crystal and Sager. We're gonna be totally upfront with you. We took a big risk going independent to make this work. We need your support to beat the corporate media CNN, Fox, MSNBC. They are ripping this country apart. They are making millions of dollars doing it. To help support our mission of making all of us hate each other, less hate the corrupt ruling class more support the show. Become a Breaking Points Premium Member today, where you get to watch and listen to the entire show ad free and uncut, an hour early before everyone else. You get to hear our reactions to each other's monologues. You get to participate and weekly ask me any things, and you don't need to hear our annoying voices pitching you like I am right now, So what are you waiting for? Go to Breakingpoints dot com become a Premium member today, which is available in the show notes. Enjoy the show, guys, Good morning, everybody, Happy Tuesday. We have an amazing show for everybody today. What do we have, Crystal, Indeed we do. We've got a bunch of really fascinating stories this morning. So Amazon was caught destroying out one warehouse over one hundred and thirty thousand items per week. We're going to dig into that, some really fascinating rulings from the Supreme Court, including on the NCAA, and then I'm also focused on my monologue on one regarding Goldman Sachs. Everybody coming together to let them off the hook. Good old fashioned bipartisanship. Gotta love that Sager's taking a look at the rise of barstool conservatives. Today is New York City's mayoral race primary, and like the worst political contest of all time. Ross Barkana is going to dig into all of the dynamics there and what to expect. But we wanted to start with American Airlines canceling a whole bunch of flights and basically blaming their workers. This is a huge story that actually ABC News, mainstream media actually does a decent job enough at least in order to sum up the situation. Let's take a listen, we'll dissect it on the other side. This morning, the cancelation of hundreds of flights is being partially blamed on a staffing crunch, as a record number of travelers returned to the skies. American Airlines canceling one hundred and twenty three flights on Saturday, one hundred and seventy eight on Sunday, and today more than one hundred flights are canceled already, the airline blaming significant staffing shortages and maintenance issues. American says it will continue to cancel at least fifty to sixty flights a day for the rest of June and fifty to eighty flights per day in July. So there's a lot going on here, Chris. We'll obviously people look at that and say, hey, what's going on here? Do we have a labor shortage? All of that? Well, you know, it just turns out though that if you dig a little bit deeper, you might remember about a year and a half ago, whenever we designed a custom bailout for the airline industry, which I was
Load full transcript
fine with. We had Sarah Nelson on the show who was talking about how vital it was in order to make sure flight attendants got paid, and because the airline industry itself like if you let it bottom out, you're completely screwed. Part of the thing, though, is if you're going to bail them out, you would say, oh, maybe we're gonna put some restrictions on that money. Well, let's take a trip down memory lane. Shall we put it up there on the screen. In terms of how exactly we designed this thing ten point six million dollars in compensation the CEO received last year and still forced thousands of workers into leave early retirement and furloughs. Now blaming labor shortages. Go ahead and throw the next one up there. In terms of how we exactly designed this bailout, five point eight billion dollars in pandemic assistance from the Department of Treasury. Four point one billion of that was a grant. It wasn't even alone. Only one point seven billion of that was actually the loan. And yet today they are canceling now one percent of their total flights. And it's not me saying boohoo for you know, commercial airline passengers. There are freight concerns, but really what it is is that these companies took literally billions of dollars in pandemic bailout, and now they spent that time furloughing people, firing people, reducing their labor, and now they can't keep up with the demand and they're trying to create some artificial story about, oh, we have the labor shortage or whatever. We gave you literally billions and billions and billions of dollars, and now you're crippling the US economy once again, and you're making it seem as if this entire thing was a total joke in the first place. It really is terrible what they've done here, and I do feel bad for people who maybe this is like their first vacation, their first venture out after business pandemic. For those people like the regular families who've saved up their money to go somewhere after the pandemic and it's like their first time. I do feel really bad for these people where it turns into a total might marry, your entire trip might be ruined. And I love that they don't give any context for oh, it's a labor shortage. Well, why do you have a labor shortage. We bailed you out with the express provision in the original bailout package that this money should go to keeping your workforce. So what happened They took the money, They kept those workers until the date that we said okay, after September thirty. If I think was the last day. Then you can do whatever you want after those bailout provisions expire and they want ahead and laid off, furloughed or forced down thirty thousand of their workers. So it's not like just oh, boo hooo, we have a labor shortage and there's nothing we can do about it. You're the one that created that labor shortage, and somehow that context is wildly missing for most of the mainstream coverage. I took a look at I was actually perusing CNBC yesterday. I need to watch them more often because it is incredible the type of content they put on. I jumped right from a segment. The headline of the segment was Jim Kramer weighs in on like American airlines layoffs, but it was even worse than He didn't even say anything about. It was just him complaining about like lazy millennials not wanting to come to the office. And then the next one up with some dude who was like trashing redditors for not respecting the fundamentals anyway, this is how CNBC covered the American airline situation, just framing it as a labor shortage, just coming dropping out of the sky with absolutely zero context. Let's take a listen. CBC dot com airline reporter Leslie Josephs is covering the story for US. She joins us, Now, Leslie, why is it American in particular that can't seem to get workers? So what American is dealing with now they have packed their schedule a little bit fuller than some of their competitors or closest competitors like Delta and United. And what they're finding is there are a shortage of workers during the middle of training pilots that might have been idled during the pandemic. I mean, remember, think back to a year ago, we were retiring planes. Airlines were telling employees to please, please please take an early retirement or a bio package. So their focus has switched entirely. So that's why they're seeing a little bit of this strain. Add to that a little bit of seasonal weather, and this is the recipe for what we're seeing right now. It's amazing. Nothing about nothing about the bailout provisions, nothing about how they laid off thirty thousand workers. Just like well, you know, they're ramping up a little different than everybody. They got to get these pilots back online. Ridiculous. No, it's terrible. And this is actually this maybe is a little bit of a corollary to I've talked about how in many ways I think the labor shortage is just revenge for Americans bad policy, which is that at the beginning of the pandemic, we made the choice to force people onto unemployment. What we should have done is actually what we did for the airline industry in the very first place, which was say, hey, we're going to pay you billions and billions of dollars fine, and in exchange, you have to use that money in order to keep people on your workflaw on your in workplace, because the airline industry is critical to the way we function freight and all that. Actually, I think every industry should have been declared critical, and that's how we should have done everything. But what did I forget, which is that in the United States, what they did is they wrote in these ridiculous provisions making it so oh until September thirtieth. I actually remember covering it at Rising. It was maybe David Dane or somebody else there who's like, listen, guys, like come September or not September thirty. First, what August or whatever comes back October? Okay, there we go October. Come October first. He's like, everyone's going to get fired, everyone's going to get
furloughed. And I was like, oh my god, he's totally right, and that is exactly what happened. And now here we are, sixteen seventeen months now into the pandemic. These people have been laid off. Travel demand is actually surged. A lot of people have savings, like you were saying, people who bought flights that want to take their first vacation, and now there's a fake labor shortage in terms of American airlines. We actually did everything that we were supposed to do in terms of designing that program. We just wrote it so that they get billions. Then they didn't actually have that much restrictions on the way that they were going to spend the money, and then made it so that they created their own fake labor shortage. And what also grinds my gears is if you were a small business in your paycheck production program and you got alone like this, you did not have the ability to fire people at all. You had to use all that money to keep people on payroll again a provision I support. So if you were a small business, you had all these restrictions on how you got your money. You did get some custom bailout from the Fed. You didn't get some post bailout from Congress. You had to apply to the bank. And even then the bank like put you in whatever order they want. Limited pool airline gets a specially cut and tailor designed bailout and they get all this money, and then in the end, at the end of the day, what's going on. They didn't even use it in the way that we told them to. It's fundamentally unfair the way that we did this entirety. So this whole episode with the airlines, and as I was thinking about this yesterday, has actually kind of changed my mindset over what we should have done at the beginning of the pandemic. I'll tell you why in just a second. So I was reading Andrew ross Orkin when these bailout programs were being contemplated a while back, wrote a piece about does the airline industry really need this bailout? And what he wrote is no other industry affected by the pandemic received more from the government. There was no special program for hotels, for restaurants, for travel agencies. Companies in those industries had to line up for the Small Business Focus paycheck protection program and prey the largest loan in the program could make was ten million dollars, as opposed to the five billion that the airline industry received. And so what I realized here is that you're right. We actually sort of held this up and we talked to Sarah Nelson as the model of what they should have done for other industries. Well, you know what, it turns out, actually the most effective part of the program, of all the different relief programs that we had in place, was just given people cash, just straight giving people cash. The addition of the child tax credit, the unemployments insurance system, Yeah it was clunky, but that also just putting cash straight in people's pockets, if that worked more effectively, those were the pieces that lowered poverty. And actually
now are giving workers a tiny bit of cushion so that they can say, like, screw you, I'm not going back to work on the frontlines for seven to twenty five. Screw y, I'm not working for tips at whatever what is it, two dollars and whatever. So I actually think we have so much of a mindset in this country that like, oh, we have to be skeptical every time we're handing out cash directly to people. Maybe they're going to be lazy, maybe they're not going to spend it in the right way, maybe they're going to be irresponsible for this money. But the reality is actually the individual human beings use the money in far more efficient and productive ways than these giant companies. So even this program, which again was kind of the best of the best in terms of it required that you kept the employees on. Of course, the minute that they can lay them off, the minute those provisions expire, they go ahead and do that. They give their CEO ten million dollar pay compensation so that he can apparently like completely fail on the other side kind of the pandemic. So even in the best case scenario, we were better off just straight giving cash to people. And oh, by the way, that's something our federal government, which is capacity has been stripped down over years and years and decades and decades, something that they were able to do very efficiently and very effectively. Yeah, actually it's more of a matter of timeline. I agree with you. Look, at the end of the day, I want people to have the money. I think at the time the reason I was arguing for it was because people's bank account information already existed with their employers and we didn't. We had some initial implementation problems around the stimulus checks. I want to say, I think we own that. Just didn't think it was likely that the American political system would be like, instead, let's just hand out large amounts of cash. Yes, this was more like a pree Overton window. I was like, look like, we got to give people money we need as soon as humanly possible. And the way I was thinking about it was that, look, people are already attached their payroll. And also, if you think about it from a business concerned perspective, like the businesses are like we can't find anyone, etc. I actually understand that. I sympathize, especially if you're one of the smallest businesses or one of those people who truly can't compete, or you didn't get a PPP loan or any of these things. The problem that we had, again is that Washington basically kicked people off onto unemployment then left them to dry and screwed around with the plus ups. Did we not have any plus up in terms of like extra cash for months on end while Congress was getting its act together, and then people because of these like crazy lockdown procedures, some people were on unemployment, went off unemployment back on, but that takes months, so that those systems were total are totally regular. We're a total disaster. I've heard from many of you actually telling me
about how often how difficult it was in order to get your unemployment, and so I was saying, like, look, the easiest way thing to do this is the payroll. But all the retconning of like what we should have done, et cetera. It's just so disgusting to watch this company who got billions of dollars and to come out and now say they have some labor shortage. It was like, what was the point? Why did we bail you out? It gave you billillions and billions to make sure your industry remained robust. And again fair airlines are we need airlines. The country needs it in order to move freight passengers. Is critical, even at the height of the pandemic. We had it all for a reason. But it really pisses me off watching them come out and make these fake excuses, and it just makes you think, like, can we do anything fairly in this country anymore? Yeah, what are you supposed to think if you can't catch a flight because of this? And you see how much money that these people got in the pandemic. So this is also for Andrew Ross Sorkin again about like how we could have used the money in a better fashion. So the money that we gave the airlines likely saved about seventy five thousand jobs, really significant, right, critical for those people at a cost of three hundred thousand dollars per job. Wow, those people are not making three hundred thousand dollars by the way. I mean, you know, some of the pilot's flight attendants, like these are good middle class jobs or flight attendants, but they're not making three hundred k a year. So we spent that much money. It's just wildly inefficient, right give it. I really have come to believe that individual human beings can be trusted with direct cash infusions to a far greater extent than any of these businesses that are always, always, always looking for every way to cheat suck up that money for themselves, like buy back their stock all of that stuff. And that's the other piece of this if we even go back before the pandemic, why were the airlines so close to the wall that the minute there was a drop in their revenue and their passengers who were flying they were totally screwed. Well, it's because they spent all that the corporate tax cut money from Trump. They spent that on stock buybacks so that they could enrich themselves and enrich their shareholders, rather than investing in their business and making sure that they had that resiliency if there was a downturn. So again, as I look at this kind of my big takeaway is we should just trust people and working Americans way way way before we trust these idiots who find every way they possibly can to fail and then just expect that they're going to be bailed out no matter how uncomfortable they're Actually, this is the thing. These people don't get people. I don't know, how often do you think you can get away with this, like in terms, we had it on two thousand and eight Wall Street bailout, give everybody bonuses AIG. I mean, that was probably as close to the biggest popular outrage
that we saw on something economically in a long time. Obviously that faded, but then you see this American Airlines story next time around, How are you, like, do you think you're going to get bailed out? Do you really think so? Maybe? Now, maybe you will because the government did all that congressional system is there, but like this all has to break at some point. And so look, I've I mean American Airlines yesterday it was like trending. It was one of the biggest stories in the country. And coincidentally, I didn't see very much coverage of it, Like yes, you know, CNBC goes and covers it for about thirty seconds with some thirty seconds or the American Airlines pr tells us and they're like, and now let's happen to you. You're on to explain why he can't get any workers and didn't misspend five billion dollars. Same thing though, I mean, I saw it trending all across the country in terms of the Internet outrage. People were contacting us about it and more, but the actual mainstream coverage of it wasn't there. So it just seems to me like one of those mainstream backlashes again sorry, a backlash against the mainstream and very popular outrage around this type of story because people understood and saw that while they were waiting for a check, while they were waiting for extra unemployment, while they wanted the lockdowns to end, while they wanted some proper information that these people were getting bailed out to the tune of billions. And we remember some of the initial bailout outrage whenever people understood I think it was David Dayan talking about the trillions of dollars a federal reserve and all that were shooting, which would have been fine if you had reciprocal programs for people who were working, and that just faded off as time went. Now we're at this strange time, like people do have money in the bank, two hundred million Americans or so or not. I mean, they're not like a you know, they're like still a paycheck away from bankruptcy. But you know, that's a little bit better apparently than where things were before. And yet the memory has not faded around how people remember this type of stuff. And I suspect that the next time around that it made things be different. Although you know, maybe I should be more cynical. Our political class doesn't respond to popular will. I mean, that's just the reality and so, and especially when you have a situation like maybe you're in Atlanta or what's is it Houston that's the big hub in Texas where there's a lot of jobs at stake and the airlines kind of oh, well, your economy is going to crash if you don't get the bailout. It's very compelling case. You know, your point about media, I think is really important, really interesting because why does this not get coverage because there's not a Trump angle and there's not a Biden angle, So because you can't fit it neatly into this like Democrats are bad or Republican are bad. Narrative, they're just like, eh, we don't really care, even though it, you know,
is something that says so much, not just about this current moment, but there's so many lessons to be taken from it about how we approach this entire situation to start with. And if you don't think that we're going to find ourselves in another downturn, pandemic, collapse, crash where we're faced with these kinds of questions again, you're fooling yourself. And actually to that point, and it's not just Democrats bad, Republicans bad. Everybody was complicit in this. The White House at all parties, I mean a past ninety nine. Oh, if I recall through the US Senate, this is what happens, you know, when you have total and complete bipartisanship. And I think it's an important lesson to remember exactly how these things play out. Speaking of corporate mouthfeasans, we get another good one for you from Amazon. Yeah, okay, this is probably one of the craziest things I've ever seen. So ITV news out of the UK has caught Amazon destroying millions of dollars worth of merchandise for no discernible reason. And I'll explain why they say that they do so, but let's watch this video first because it's totally nuts. Let's take a listen. So from a Friday to a Friday, our target was approximately one hundred and thirty thousand items a week. The target to destroy from one center was one hundred and thirty thousand items. Yes, okay, So let me explain this to you, which is that what they caught there with the guy who was on camera, was that Amazon is destroying millions of items of unsold stock in just one of its UK warehouses every single year, and that this is indicative of a company wide policy. So what they found is that they are destroying one hundred and thirty thousand items a week, and we're talking about brand new stuff, dice and fans, hoover vacuums, the occasional MacBook and iPad. The other day, twenty thousand face masks still in their wrappers. Here's what he said. Overall, fifty percent of all items are unopened, still in their shrink wrap. The other half are returns and in good condition. Staff have become numb in terms of what they are asking to do. So you might ask why exactly is all of this happening, Well, what's happening is that because of their business model, they have it such that they store with stuff inside of their warehouse. It's called fulfilled by Amazon. It's actually one of the most profitable parts of their business, which is that you're a third party seller. But in order to take advantage of Amazon's distribution, you can. Amazon will list your goods on its website obviously, and then when I buy it, Amazon will fulfill the order because they have the third party goods inside of their warehouse. But then the question arises, like what exactly do you do whenever you have extra stuff, and it turns out that the actual physical policy at least look at least in the UK in terms of what's happening, is that they are destroying it. They're not even going in trying to donate it to anybody, They're not making any efforts. They're literally incinerating and destroying hundreds of millions of dollars worth of goods. And this is so insane it's actually royaling UK politics. Even Boris Johnson weighed in on this, but I thought this was important enough, Christel, because are they doing the same stuff here? We should ask a lot of questions because if they are, I think there's a lot of people out there who could view some of this stuff and it's just totally unopened and they're just destroying it. It's insane. It is completely nuts. And your question is the right one because just to emphasize again, one hundred and thirty thousand items from one warehouse every single week. Yeah, like think about that. Well, you think their policies are different here. Do you see Amazon giving out goods to the needy across America? No, we don't, So what's happening to those goods? It's an excellent question and could us them for doing the reporting here they got basically a whistleblower inside the warehouse. They were able to film undercover footage revealing how this was taking place. They even had footage of them like taking these electronics to essentially the dump for them to be destroyed. You know, I got to give it to and Boris Johnson actually made a pretty good josh about it. He said, this is an indictment of a consumerist society, so as much of it as it's an indictment of Amazon and their practices, and how gross it is that I mean, basically, the bottom line is why would they do this. It's because they have to keep the prices for all these goods high. So they can't just be given stuff away because then people won't want to buy stuff as much, right, so it would depress demand for the other stuff that they're trying to sell. So rather than giving it to people who need these goods, who can't afford these goods, they rather just destroy it in order to protect their profit margins. So certainly an indictment of Amazon and their practices. And also, by the way, there are a lot of questions over whether they've been lying about exactly what they do, because apparently they've been asked before, like how much of your goods are destroyed? And they're like almost nothing, next to nothing, very very little is your definition of very very little? One hundred and thirty thousand items at one warehouse every single week. I don't think that would be a reasonable person's definition of very little. So Amazon totally culpable. But it does just show, you know, how gross it is the fact that we've all had drilled into us in American society, Western society ri at large, like this religion around consumerism, Like we're always sold this bill of goods that like the next item, the next purchase, the next whatever, is going to make us happy, it's going to make us popular, it's going to make us beautiful, it's going to make us fulfilled, when the reality is anything but. And at the same time, it's just it's such an incredibly wasteful it's like grotesquely wasteful. So while we're at the same time, at the individual
level, like trying in different ways to be responsible, let me see if I can recycle a little more. Let me see if I can you know, use a little bit more of the food run and throwing it out. These giant corporations are just incredibly abusive with the resources of the world. Just you know, all of these manufactured goods that create tremendous pollution and tremendous waste then just being tossed aside into a landfill to compose over hundreds and hundreds of years. It really is a sort of like grotesque picture of exactly what we're doing here as a society. Yeah, and what's crazy to me too, is it just shows how full of it they are and how much they've bought the political system. Because yes, while Boris Johnson may have said that, yeah, I love this and it's just good to see that all Western societies are the same. The business secretary told ITV news this is in the UK. M hm. It was very surprise about the findings of our investigation and said he wanted to get to the bottom. But he adds, I know Amazon is committed to net zero. They've committed huge amounts of investment to the rainforest to keep the rainforest going. I'm surprised. I haven't read the report, so I'll have to take a look at the response is But what's funny is if you read Amazon's statement, they basically use the same They use the same language. We are working towards a goal of zero product disposal. Our priority is to resale, donate to charitable organizations, or recycle unsold products. No items are sent to the landfall in the UK. As a last resort, we will send items to energy recovery. But we are working hard to drive the number of times as happens down to zero. So it's like we're a little harder guy. The same language that Amazon uses baking like, we're working hard to get zero. And you know they talk about net zero climate and all this stuff is the same stuff that comes out of the mouth of the I think it's the equivalent of our commerce secretary in the UK. Amazing even Amazon runs stuff over in the UK. I didn't even know, of course, And this is the amazing thing. If they're throwing away millions of things in the UK, which has a population I think like one sixth or like one seventh the size of the US, what the hell is going on over here in terms of what's going on in our warehouses and what exactly is being done, because not just in terms of the way they treat their workforce, but the physical goods inside of these inside of these warehouses that could be used for so many better purposes. I think it just reveals again and it's true, which is that we were talking yesterday about widget brain around housing, where people are like, oh, look, when you're a widget, you're just better off if you know renting and you know, disregarding any of the social benefits of housing. This is the same thing. They're like, look, we need thirty percent more warehouse space. The fastest way to get of that warehouse space is just a junket. I mean, in one of these pictures is a Samsung q LED TV. It's like a three thousand dollars TV. It's complex's nuts in terms of what who could imagine like a nursing home or like, I don't know, a kid's home. There are so many people out there UK too. They're not actually that rich of a country in terms of what some of the people over there could use it. So I just think it's a really gross indictment of everything. I am very glad that ITV did this investigation. Yeah, and you're right to say, like, let's not give Boris Johnson too much credit here. You made a nice comment, but you know, you have power to do a lot more than make a nice comment. And it is also interesting that his focus is not he says this is an indictment of a consumer society, rather than like, this is an indictment of Amazon, and we're going to get to the bottom of what have in here? Right, So, yeah, that's a good point. That's one point there. Hey, So remember how we told you how awesome premium membership was. Well, here we are again to remind you that becoming a premium member means you don't have to listen to our constant please for you to subscribe. So what are you waiting for? Become a premium member today by going to Breakingpoints dot com, which you can click on in the show notes. Okay, we have an update for you on the bipartisan instructure negotiations that have been ongoing. I mean, the bottom line here is this whole attempt at a bipartisan package is pretty much a hot mess. One good thing did happen. Biden came out. Remember one of the pay fors that they've been floating with. This is a guest to x, which is absurd, absurd that you're going to make the working class of this country long suffering and with the least ability to pay that you're going to put the infrastructure price tag on their back. So Biden did come out and rule that out, and they're framing it, and I mean he is on these sorts of things. He has pretty good political instincts, I think, and he also sees it as would be breaking his pledge not to raise taxes on anyone making less than four hundred thousand dollars a year, which I think is true. We could throw this tweet up on the screen showing what Biden had to say there. So this was Jensaki to CBS this morning said Biden is a hard no on the gas tax. An idea that's been floating around that certainly the President would not support is a gas tax which would raise taxes on people making less than four hundred k a year. We're not going to stand for that. So very clear language, very unequivocal. At least someone has half a brain over there, because a gas tax is like the dumbest idea that is ever. It's politically dumb, and it's also the wrong thing to do, just like on every level, it would be a bad direction to go in. Okay, So that's off the table. So what are the other payfors that are being proposed in this bipartisan infrastructure deal. Well, David dan who always always follow what this guy is doing, he's one of the few that really digs into the details and gets down to the nitty gritty of what's actually
being proposed. And it turns out, remember when Trump was proposing his infrastructure deal time and time again, and a lot of liberals and a lot of progressives were rightfully very exercised that this was like basically, it was a privatization of infrastructures, give away to the private sector, and the payfors there were very uncomfortable. Well, a lot of those same mechanisms are being included in this bipartisan deals. So let's throw David Dayan's tear sheet up here on the screen. He says, Bipartisan Senate Infrastructure Plan is a stocking horse for privatization. The scheme would fund new infrastructure by selling off old infrastructure. And by the way, Trump proposed the same thing. So here's some of the details. Let me just read you a little bit from the piece. He says, the really scary piece in terms of the pay force is labeled public private partnerships, private activity bonds, and asset recycling. Okay, in the name of building world class infrastructure, these lawmakers will sell it off in fire sales to private financiers. We have lots of experience with infrastructure privatization that strongly suggest it should be avoided. Those first two things. Public private partnerships, you can imagine what that is. That's basically like toll roads, that sort of thing where you're like, hey, private company, why don't you build our infrastructure, and then you can charge user fees, again largely to work in class people to pay for it. You have private activity bonds that's just like debt by another name, an asset recycling, which is one of these terms that you'd read and you're like, oh, recycling, that sounds good, right, Like, what's going that sounds crazy? What's going on there? What they mean is we're going to take our existing port or whatever, sell it off and then use that money to build some other thing. This has been tried here, It was tried, he points out. It was tried notably in Australia, total failure, total disaster. Oftentimes, the projects that they sell off were actually good public works. Projects that the public was benefiting from the government was receiving tax revenue from, like a port is a good example of that. And then the things that they build, the asset that they're I guess recycling this into turned out to be sort of like hair brained and useless and not particularly well done. The other bottom line piece here is we talked about this a little bit yesterday. There's always this assumption that's like baked into the American economic political ethos that, oh, the privatesctor must be more efficient, they must do a better job, they must do it in lower costs and all of that and a shorter timeframe. But it's really not the case because, I mean, for a very obvious reason, the private sector has to build in profit margins into whatever it is they're doing. So we've seen time after time that you should not assume that relying more on the private sector is going to get you into a better place. But it's just it's interesting
because a lot of the criticism of the infrastructure package, the bipartisan infrastructure package this far, has been around it's not enough money, something we've talked about here also from the left, like this isn't dealing with climate change whatsoever, both totally in my view, legitimate criticisms. But this piece has gotten it has been ignored until David Day and pointed out. And it's also really super important. It's super important. And also he just shows how many Democrats are full of it. I mean, I love this line. There was a time when Democrats oppose such schemes. It was during the Trumps, it was any years talks exactly about how Democrats rightfully and loudly objected to giving up public access to investors because the biggest money makers would be forward, it would be favored. But so why would he I love this, Why would Democrats entertain going down the exact same road under Biden until despite the fact that they rebuffed it under Trump. And I think that we all know what the answer to this is. And it actually is a decent example of like uniparty whenever it comes to the economic proposals that we put forward. And I agree, this is a terrible, absolutely terrible idea. And the Australia part I actually didn't know. I looked a little bit into it, and he's totally right, which is that we borrowed this from a previous scheme and in that case of what happened in Australia, there was actually a lot of outrage over some of the things that were auctioned off that were actually quite not profitable but net positive or whatever in terms of Jack's revenue. And I've said this a million times instead of faking all these pay fors. If there is one thing on Earth that you deficit spend, it's called infrastructure, because we all know that the social and economic benefits explode whenever you have infrastructure. It can open up new areas of commerce, it can open up new business lines, it can open up all sorts of different things, and that you will more than recoup it in terms of tax revenue, benefit to the community and more. Infrastructure is by definition, the type of thing that you're supposed to deficit spend for. And instead we're playing all these like kabuki theater games in DC around auctioning things off that we already have, around raising the private bonds or whatever. Reading like why is any of this necessary? Go out and ask people do you care about how the infrastructure package is paid for? In the most intuitive thing, even people who have businesses and more understand that the type of things that you deficit spend for are investments which are going to pay out ten x longer in the long run, so you put the money down. Well, when you're a government, this is one of the few times that the business whatever example actually does apply. You should do the exact same thing. And so I think the politics around this are just so farcical generally, and that the David Dayan piece reveals how in a way people use deficit politics and pay force in order to just cover up for a lot of corporate giveaways. Yeah, that's what social mightyological agenda. That's right. And actually I think I think if you ask people, and we've seen some of the polling on this, how they want it to be paid for, they do have a preference. They want rich people in corporate right to be taxed. That's what they want. I mean, we saw in some of the polling that just the infrastructure package on its own, like oh, we're going to invest in roads and bridges, et cetera, et cetera pretty popular. You add to that like oh, and we're going to pay for it by taxing rich people, and they're like, oh, hell yeah, I'm in The polling numbers actually jump up, so it says everything. Just I think that's really important to keep in mind as you're watching these negotiations play out, because oftentimes the way that they're portrayed in mainstream media is like, oh, the bipartisan deal. They have to make these trade offs to make it politically palatable for frontline Democrats in the midterms, et cetera, et cetera. No, No, you're actually proposing a plan that is less popular because you're trying to pair it initially with a gas tax, which is ridiculous, but now with these various privatization schemes which are also unpopular, versus what is a clearly extremely popular position of paying for it with increased taxes on people who got tremendously wealthy during the pandemic, whether it's wealthy individuals or corporations. That is what the American people actually want. And so the fact that the political class is so nervous and unsure and basically putting off the table any of that tells you something. This isn't about them wanting the good politics of it. It's about them protecting their donors and protecting their friends in their social circle. And that's exactly how you end up with these hair brain schemes of like let's sell off a port in order to build a new bridge. Watching this thing become Obamacare two point zero has been really sad to show that Biden and them actually just learned nothing. Obama'scare ended up becoming a corporate nightmare mess. It became the political albatross that hung around his neck. Now it's June twenty second. Remember that they've already said they cannot hit the September deadline. Okay, I think the exact same thing is going to happen. Republicans are going to filbuster. It's going to go all the way up until like Thanksgiving or Christmas Day or whatever. And at the end of the day, it's going to be a BS bill which actually doesn't even do very much, probably like a trillion dollars or whatever in new spending. It won't be forcefully felt in many different communities, and there'll be some like Windmill Package, which will become the bane of every single Democrat running in the mid terms because of a bunch of attack ads. And what do we get from all of this? I think maybe what a modest tax increase on people who are wealthy. Maybe even then, I don't actually think that's going to pass at all. So yeah,
actually the only thing that might pass is some sort of fake gas tax. So he may have ruled it out now, but I won't hold my breath understanding how these things are moving through Congress. It's a huge political failure for the Biden administration in my opinion. Yeah, and again a totally unnecessary one. Totally unnecessary, and I just think I'll say it again, I think it says everything about the sort of failed state nature of this country that just the least controversial thing you could possibly do, like fixing a damn bridge, you can't even get your act together to do that. The basics of providing not just an investment for you know, jobs and business community, et cetera. But part of why these privatization schemes are such a problem is there's a lot of basic infrastructure that provides for safe quality of life water systems, wastewater treatment plans. As I covered yesterday in large parts of West Virginia, other rural communities across the country, they don't even have clean drinking water Like that's never going to turn a profit for a company, of course, so we can't be in the business of only doing projects that are you're going to be able to, like charge enough toll fees to turn a profit on or charge enough user fees to turn a profit. You're not going to make money building a wastewater treatment plan or a new water system in McDowell County, West Virginia. So what and that's basically what's happened is anything that hasn't been profitable for the private sector hasn't gotten done. And so you've got parts of the country that are reverting back to like pre New Deal era conditions, reverting back to like developing world conditions because we don't put any sort of a priority on people having the basic standards for like the basic level quality of living. Everything is about profit profit profit, and apparently that ethos has thoroughly pervaded this new bipartisan infrastructure efforts. Really sad to see, very sad story. But I think we have some good news. Slightly sorry, it's yeah, good news. I would temper my enthusiasm for this a little bit more than what some of the media coverage has been. So we got a couple of Supreme Court notable court decisions yesterday. I'm covering one of them in my monologue, which is everybody coming together to give away the store to Golden Sex and make sure they can't be held accountable for any of their crimes. So the during the financial crisis will get into that one in a second. They did do something modestly good here, though, in a case involving the nc DOUBLEA. So I'm sure a lot of you have been following the sort of back and forth of n CUBLEA is basically like a racket and a monopoly that completely abuses their workers, which are the players, right, especially in lucrative sports like basketball and football, NCUBLEA breaking in billions and viewership fees to the television networks. And meanwhile, you know they're very adamant about, oh, we have to protect the purity integrity of the sport and amateur competition, as if this is some virtuous thing that they're doing, even though they themselves can't really even define what it means to be an amateur. They've changed the definition over the years. So I'm going to read here a little bit from Vox. Yesterday. The Supreme Court handed down a caveat in victory for elite college athletes on Monday. The immediate impact of the Court's unanimous decision nine to nothing in NCAA versus Alston is that many elite student athletes will receive additional education related compensations, such as additional scholarship money. But the case could have broader implications and could eventually lead to these athletes being paid salary. So let me break down for you what that means. The question in this case that they decided to rule on was not whether these athletes could be compensated for playing their sport. The question was this one that they made very narrow around this question of additional educational scholarship limited benefits. Right, So this was again, this isn't about receiving payment. This was about sort of like scholarships and educational scholarships essentially. And this is one of the hallmarks of the Roberts Court in this era is he has really tried to sort of cabin these decisions to be as narrow as possible because I think what a lot of court watchers feel is that he recognizes the credibility of the Supreme Court and the structure of the Supreme Court as it stands is very much at risk right now. So he's trying not to make a lot of waves and he's trying to have as many decisions as possible where it's not just the conservatives overwriting the liberals. So that's how you get a decision like this where they very narrowly rule on this very specific question about education scholarships, but it's unanimous. And what's giving people hope that this could lead to more dramatic changes is in the opinion as it was written, I think by Gorsicch. Actually he essentially said, look, we're not ruling on the larger compensation piece because you didn't specifically ask us to, but maybe you should try again and see what happens. Actually, So what's other also interesting here was Justice Kavanaugh. Here's what he wrote. Quote Nowhere else in America can businesses get away with agreeing not to pay their workers a fair market rate on the theory that the product is defined by not paying their workers a fair market rate. Adding quote and under ordinary principles of antitrust law, it is not evident why college sports should be any different. The NCAA is not above the law, and so just to recoup, remember what they have said is that the students who play sports as amateurs should not be getting paid because they should not should not be getting paid because the amateur nature of the sport, which would corrupt it and make it so that these rules, you know, are cross subsidized, and it would make it unfair, et cetera. Now, maybe there was something to that in like nineteen sixty, but right now it's totally
ridiculous. Just to give you guys insight, Like, I'm from College Station, Texas, where Texas A and M IS. Football is the lifeblood of that town. Whenever they moved to the SEC, I think over a billion dollars of new revenue came in to College Station, and I remember Johnny football and Johnny selling all that. The guy single handedly, I think, brought in hundreds of millions of dollars into the town itself, and he wasn't making in time. Many of the stars that I've seen come through Collegs Station in my entire lifetime were not compensated until at least some of them went to the NFL. Some of them, like Johnny, didn't end up doing so well even when they got there. But the point is that their time and the amount of economic and social benefit that they were bringing to the towns was immense, and they were being profited off of by the NCAA and by many of these schools who can sell merchandise and who can see huge additions to their endowments, to their bottom lines if they invest in the stadiums and like all this other stuff, but which the students don't get any of. And it's just a fundamental question of fairness. So we've seen in like the video games industry in terms of how their likenesses are used in terms of how much they're profited off of. It is just totally unfair. And I think the fact that Justice Kavanaugh and Justice Gorsich both put in like little caveats there inviting it. That's kind of the more interesting part here. I think what a lot of the court watchers saw, and this was the lead in the New York Times story as well, is that it underscored that the band it basically invited a new case. Right, So it may take a couple of years, but at least in the current composition of the court, I would say that things are looking pretty good for college athletes, and I think that's the way that it should be. It's not fair to let these schools make billions of dollars on the backs of these kids and they don't get to make a dime again, I would. I'll believe it when I see it. Yeah right. I mean, we've had all these big decisions over the years that people thought, we're definitely going to go this way, We're definitely going to go that way, and oh, you know ACB is definitely going to rule against Obamacare because she said this or that in the past, or you know, I mean, how long have people who really care a lot about abortion rights on either side of that debate or they're pro or against, how long have they thought this is going to be the one and we're reading the tea leaves and it doesn't come to fruition Roberts. The hallmark of Robert has been to be extremely, extremely cautious and not to make any big sweeping decisions with massive ramifications, which is what we're talking about here, but to talk about like the morality of it and the actual you know, situation that college athletes are facing. They not only they should they be compensated, they should also be able to unionize because this is this is the other thing. And I mean I was a college
athlete as I was a swimmer, though wasn't like one of these sports where there's actually lucrative and money money involved. So, but I did have a firsthand experience of just how much control they have over your life, right, I mean, you're there supposedly as a student first, but your sport really controls every aspect of your day. They have entire control over like you know, even what times you're studying and whether you're required to go to study hall. You have these like academic counselors, but obviously your schedule in terms of when you're at the gym and what your training regimen looks like and all of those things even when you can have classes and when you can't have classes. Much more control over your life when you're an NC double a athlete than I would say almost any other certainly like profession, because they truly have rules that govern every single aspect of your life. So to me, it's not just about the compensation. It's also like players should be able to have a say and what those rules are and what the limitations are, and how their days and their schedules are governed, because again, you know, if you're trying to balance a rigorous academic schedule with your sport, sometimes that's made nearly impossible by the requirements that they that they put on top of you. So I think that pieces also needs to not be overlooked the fact that it's not just about players should be profiting off of their skills and their talents, that the NC double A is exploiting for massive, massive profits, but they also should have a say in what their employment looks like, essentially from on a day to day basis. Actually, this reminds me there's actually currently a bill in Congress which was introduced by Bernie and by Chris Murphy. I remember reading about this at the time, which would actually allow college athletes to form unions and become employees. Coincidentally, of course, the NC DOUBLEA has been lobbying hard against it. And this is actually something which how they have tried to push through several times, and college football players, I know a last year in particular, were really beginning to talk a little bit about this, and there's at least a little bit of momentum behind it. But of course the NC double A is throwing everything they possibly can against this. They really are a cartel. I mean, whenever the way Justice Kavanaugh was writing about it, It's true, it's like yeah, you can't define your industry as one which makes money by not paying his employees. It's bs and yeah, it's basically what it is. Right, let's boil it down. Imagine Amazon being they just for the love of the warehouse work, they're getting trained. This is apprenticeship. It's like slate, you know, literally, that's it's like modern modern forms of obviously not the same thing as chattel slavery. Okay, so don't anybody go and quote that. But indentured servitude and all of that had its own very ugly parts in early American history and in Europe. And I think that there's a lot to be said about what you have. And by the way, like we always focus on the stars who then go on to the NBA, go on to the NFL, the overwhelming majority of these athletes are not going to be making it to the next level. This is it for them. I think it's like three percent. Yeah, this is it for them in terms of their career. Are their athletic career and they deserve to be paid commensurate with the profits that are being made off of them for their skills in their labor. Wow, you guys must really like listening to our voices. Well, I know this is annoying, instead of making you listen to a Viagric commercial. When you're done, check out the other podcast I do with Marshall Kassoff called The Realignment. We talk a lot about the deeper issues that are changing, realigning in American society. You always need more Crystal and soag in your daily lives. Take care guys. All right, Crystal, what are your breaking points today? Well, right now, the Trump administration and Senate Republicans are urging the Supreme Court to strike down the entire Affordable Care Act and all of its patient protections. Republicans are scrambling to confirm this nominee as fast as possible because they need one more Trump judge on the bench before November tenth to win and strike down the entire Affordable Care Act. This is not hyperbole, This is not a hypothetical on This is happening. That was then Senator Kamala Harris during confirmation hearings for Amy Cony Barrett, asserting that Barrett's edition to the Court would almost certainly be the end of the Affordable Care Act. This is not hyperbole, she said, this is happening. Of course, Senator Harris and every other Democrat confidently predicting the demise of Obamacare turned out to be wrong. Last week, the majority ruled that plaintiffs in the case did not have standing, leaving the ACA ultimately unscathed. AC joined the majority in protecting that law. Now, this outcome was predictable, and in fact, we've predicted it at the time. That's not to say, though, that from a left perspective, this court poses no threat to galitarian values or the quality of life of ordinary Americans. On the contrary, the problem is when it comes to Supreme Court, the media seems to only know how to cover culture things like LGBTQ rights, abortion, guns, and I would submit Obamacare's achieved full culture war status. Now, I'm not saying these issues are not important, but covering them and obsessing over them exclusively can create a false impression of the Court and can also mask the profound way that the Court has transformed the nation into a corporatocracy. It also makes it easy for Chief Justice John Roberts and the other conservative justices to confuse the public into thinking the Court isn't really so regressive. Throw a bone to the liberals on Obamacare, and everyone immediately goes, golly gee, maybe we're wrong about ACB and Kavanaugh, Gorsich. Maybe the Court isn't so bad after all. On the other hand, you're
much like likely to hear about this opinion, which came down yesterday. The US Supreme Court on Monday handed a victory to Goldman's Sachs in its bid to avoid an investor class action lawsuit accusing the bank of hiding conflicts of interest when creating risky subprime securities before the two thousand and eight financial crisis. So, in a decision that was authored by Amy Cony Barrett, the court threw on a decision by the Second US Circuit Court of Appeals that would have allowed that class action lawsuit to move forward. Essentially, what happened is this rewind back to the two thousand and eight financial crisis. One of the things we learned about Goldman's outrageously criminal behavior was at the very same time they were selling certain securities to their clients, they were also betting against those same securities with full knowledge that they were total and complete garbage. So, just to restate, Goldman knew they were selling crap, they were betting against that crap, and they stood to benefit by having their own clients bid up the price of the crop so that their gains in the inevitable crash would be more spectacular. David Serrot, I want to give him credit here. He flagged the story for me and reminded me of this memorable exchange between a Goldman executive and Senator Carl Levin of Michigan about the shitty deals. His words, Goldman was pushing on their clients. Look what your sales team was saying about Timberwolf, boy, That Timberwolf was one shitty deal. They sold that, mister Naman. This email was from the head of the division, not the salesforce. Whatever it was it was. It's an internal It's an internal Goldman document. This was an email to me in late June. Right, and you sold Timberwolf action. No, No, you sold Timberwolf after as well. We did trades after that, yeah, okay, and the trades after some contexts, Yeah, might be helpful. The context. Let me tell you, the context is mighty clear. June twenty two is the date of this email. Boy, that Timberwolf was one shitty deal. How much of that shitty deal did you sell to your clients after June twenty two, two thousand and seven. The answer to the Cenator's question was, hundreds of millions of dollars of that shitty deal was sold after that email was sent. And by the way, it's not just some nameless, faceless ridge ghule that's getting hurt by this type of fraud. Obviously, the entire economy was rocked by the cumulative weight of Wall Street's crimes, but in this specific instance with Golden Sacks, some of the institutional investors fleeced in these schemes are rather important to working class Americans. For example, the Arkansas Teacher Retirement System, relying on Goldman's lives about how they always put the client first, they were hurt greatly by their investments in Goldman Sacks. In fact, the Arkansas Teacher Retirement System, they were part of this class action lawsuit that led ultimately to this ruling by the Supreme Court. With this decision for Goldman, ACB is
doing what she was really put on the court to do, which was to protect the American plutocracy. She's not alone, though. Her majority opinion handing a win to Goldman Sacks wasn't just the work of Trump's evil justices, liberals Kagan and Bryer. They both signed on to the opinion agreeing that Goldman Sachs should be protected from accountability. Don't you just love to see that by partisanship in action, guys. In this way, the Supreme Court is kind of like every other institution in this country. They play to the crowd and whatever their perceived interests are on culture war issues, allowing them to quietly hand more and more power to corporations and away from workers without anyone really even noticing. The media typically plays along, creating a conversation and perception of the Court that is a funhouse mirror distortion of its true intent. Chief Justice Roberts He's a savvy operator. He knows the credibility and makeup of the Court is in serious peril. So, unlike Republican politicians, whose incentives are to be ever more radical on the right wing culture war, Roberts sees his interest in mollifying liberals, not rocking the boat too much, so that efforts to reform the Court into a more representative and frankly less awful institution don't pick up too much steam. New York Times is out with a pretty interesting piece on how the Court appears to be very intentionally issuing opinions that can keep it from facing full liberal iyre and backlash on culture war issues. Roberts has been pushing extremely narrow rulings on the most hot button cultural issues, things like gay rights and Obamacare, getting majorities, including some liberals, to agree on these small and very technical opinions that have very little in the way of broader implications. In other words, they know that while there would be hell to pay for a major ruling on gay rights, they can give a store away to Goldman Sachson barely anyone will even notice. As Saga and Rachel Beauvart have as well have long pointed out, this is also part of a shell game of manipulation of the religious right. The federalist society, bankrolled by wealthy business interests, turns out nominee after nominee pledging to be a true believing social conservative, But what those business interests are really paying for is to make sure the nominees are not going to give workers power or hold business or Wall Street to account. Ever so, in the same way democrats lie to their voters about the threat to Obamacare in order to gin up votes, Republicans routinely lie to their voters about nominating justices who will roll back abortion rights and protect wedding cake bakers or whatever the issue du jour is. Meanwhile, in court after court, the big money interests rack up win after win after win. Just another front in the class war that America's plutocrats are relentlessly pursuing, even as they aggressively pretend it does not exist. And Sager, we talked about the NCUA. One more thing, I promise. Just wanted to make sure you knew about my podcast with Kyle Kolinski. It's called Crystal, Kyle and Friends, where we do long form interviews with people like Noam Chomsky, Cornell West, and Glenn Greenwald. You can listen on any podcast platform, or you can subscribe over on substack to get the video a day early. We're going to stop bugging you now. Enjoy all right, Zacer, what are you looking at? Well? I mean, one of my favorite things to do is I say I told you so. It's a natural human inclination. I'm not above it. I love being right, or at very least one of the first to popularize an idea. Some of you may have noticed, but Chrystial and I were recently on Joe Rogan's podcast. Joe asked me an interesting question about social conservatism, how it applies to both my views and to the right generally. I turned the tables. I actually explained to Joe I thought the new social issues of our time have nothing to do with many of the fights of the past, And in my explanation I named Dave Portnoy as the current largest conservative icon in the country. Let's review for those who missed it. I think Social Conservatism today is actually one of the best pieces I read on this shout out to Matthew Walther is called Rise of the Barstool Conservatives. So if you were to ask me who I think like the most the biggest right wing social icon in America right now twenty five years ago, I would have said, like Franklin Graham or something like that, I think it's Dave Portnoy. I really think it is somebody like Portnoy who is anti PC. The current social conservatism, or at least the way that I think things are moving forward, is anti woke, anti PC, and that is where I think the emerging fights are. I didn't invent the thesis. As I said, I stole it from Matthew Walter, who is a columnist over at the Week. But interestingly enough, someone else appears to have taken notice and added to the discourse, with Politico Magazine writing a new piece titled quote, how Republicans became the barstool Party. Now this might confuse some casual observers of politics because the question even arises, is Dave Portnoyd conservative by his account? Not really if you're thinking in terms of old ways of doing business. Dave is pro choice, He's had multiple sex tapes released, which he's proud of. He's pro gay marriage. So what conservative thing is about him? Well, look, he's conservative in the way that Trump kind of was. He just refuses to bow to the liberal intelligentsia, and he likes to drive them crazy. Portnoy refuses to apologize for past jokes. He basically holds up a middle finger up to the elite. He was one of the most prominent people against lockdowns and look to his eternal credit, he raised tens of millions of dollars for small businesses. Every time he tells the liberal media fu he gets richer and more popular. Walter describes of Trump and of Portinoy, describing the phenomenon this way, quote Trump recognized there are millions of Americans who do not oppose or even care about
abortion or same sex marriage, much less stem cell research or any of the other causes that had animated traditional conservatives. He adds quote Instead, he correctly intuited the new culture war would be fought over very different and very more nebulous issues. Vague concerns about political correctness, sjw's opposition to the popularization of critical race theory, sentimentality about the American flag and the military, the rights of mail undergraduates to engage in fornication while in intoxicated without fear of the title ten mafia. That's basically it right there. That's port NOI's appeal and the direction of the new American right. The fights of the past are in the past. The fights of the future are How do we teach our kid's history? Is it okay to be outspokenly patriotic in popular culture and in elite circles? Do we say Merry Christmas? Again? Can we say quote unquote problematic words? Can we roll our eyes at people's pronouns and their email signatures without being called homophobic. Now, look, I know none of these seem that important, but let's be real. This is what gets people going in America, whether you like it or not. This is how Trump won ten million more votes in twenty twenty, and I suspect if the GOP ever wins a popular vote margin in the future again, it's gonna look like Dave Portnoy's fan base. Pretty diverse, pretty male, a huge base of support outside of its traditional voting space. I call it grill dad conservatism. I actually think it's the future. And look already in the twenty twenty data, you can see signs of this everywhere. Hispanic males voted for Trump at a higher rate than anyone else compared to twenty sixteen, and cited Trump's opposition to woke shibbaltz like defund the police and lockdowns as a number one reason they voted for him. You see the same thing in the modest but soill noticeable increase in black men voted for Trump, and ironically, the only group who voted for him at a lower rate was white men, which I will find eternally funny. But look, I don't want to fully sing the praises of barstool conservatism, because if I have one great worry, it's this. The barstoolification of the GOP can easily win, but economically things aren't going to be too great. As Walter writes, quote, where will barstool conservatism leave what remains of the old conservative movement? In the case of free market dogmatists, I believe there's almost zero daylight between them. The policy papers on why blockchain enabled future markets in organ donation, brought to you by Manscape, will revitalized Dayton, Ohio is going to rite itself. Part of Portnoy's core ethos is an economic libertarianism, and look I mean and served him quite well. It's obviously evident in his stand for retail investors during GameStop and more. But when you translate that to public policy, you actually get a lot of the same old Paul Ryan stuff with a new flare on it. Barstool and Conservatism could easily end up being the new cover album for the tax
cut GOP of old. All of this, I guess is to say, is if you want to keep on your eye on where things are headed, look to our culture. For people who are anti PC and anti woke. That's where the new conservative movement is and what it actually probably could win and who will likely be in charge a decade from now. It's interesting, Crystal, there's a lot of debate. Joining us now to talk about the mess that is the New York City mayor roal race this year is Ross Barkin. He is a contributor to the Nation, wrote a fantastic piece there we're going to talk about. He's also author of a brand new book out today, The Prince Andrew Cuomo, Coronavirus and the Fall of New York timely stuff. Congrats on the book, Roscard, to see you, Yes, thank you, and thank you for having me a very crazy day in New York City and also the release of my books for you that perfect day to make sure I dropped on a low key day where you could really focus on it. So good job there. I want to ask you about the book actually, but first just break down for us for people who haven't been immersed in the details of this mayor's race, which has like completely gone off the rails. Who are the main players, what's the state of the race, who's the front runner, what have the contours been like? Sure, so right now, there are four Democrats who all have some shot at winning. The front runner in the pools last month has been the Brooklyn Burger president Eric Adams, and he's been followed by different candidates at different times. Originally Andrew Gang the celebrity for presidential candidate, then he no longer is. You have Maya Wiley, who's the Plasio's former council an MSNBC pundit, and you have Kathlin Garcia, who is the Blasio's former sanitation commissioner. And there was a fifth candidate who was once one of the top contenders, Scott Stringer, but he was accused of sexual assault. The allegation was never substantiated, but that really deroulds his campaign. So there's really four contenders. Adams is the favorite. Three of them are running explicitly I would define them as moderates, and one Wiley, is kind of occupying this left liberal lane. But certainly most of the candidates are talking about issues like crime, public safety, are pro charter school, and have come out explicitly against the funding of Please. So very interesting race coming off of what happened in twenty twenty. Yeah, and so Ross, you wrote this piece let's put it up there on the screen in the Nation, which I saw get some play. We were talking a little bit about how Eric Adams in particular, who has been really kind of a strange figure who uses identity politics in order to cover for some of these corporate things that he's doing. Could you just explain that a bit. Yeah, So Eric Adams, he is fascinating political history. He was a police captain for a long time. He was in the transit police and the NYPD. He's elected to the state Senate and then to the relatively powerless perchaur president. He would be the bur of the city's second black mayor. And he is someone who is both very anti woke, I would say, in terms of he talks a lot about, you know, public safety and crime and being tough on crime. He said he carried gun on him if he was elected mayor because he can legally do that. He has a history of making very incendiary statements. He once told the people who are from out of the town, so called gentrifiers, to go back to Iowa. At the same time, welc identity politics. So I don't know if if that's like the little look side of him or it's more just kind of a classic cynical ploy but repeatedly throughout this campaign and throughout his political career, his youth race as a way to deflect whether talking about tenant protections as an attack on black wealth even though real estate developers and landlords are almost exclusively very wealthy white people, or these kind of large corporate firms, and also you know, saying he can, you know, illegally use these parking PLACU cards because the last former president got to do it and he was white, So you can't have corruption for the white guy, not the black guy. So he's a very handy and incendiary figure, a little bit like Rudy Giuliani, maybe more left wing Rudy, and even tiny shades of Trump. I don't like to liken anyone to Trump, but he's definitely someone who makes a lot of outrageous statements and it can be very hard to keep track of all of them. I mean, he's really weaponized race and what is a disgraceful manner in this campaign, and it's been called out by you know, Maya Wiley, and certainly some of his attacks have been on Yang and Catherine Garcina, who kind of teamed up together, the campaigned together, including on June teenth, Eric Adams tried to pretend like that was some racial affront and they were trying to disenfranchise black voters. He likened it to horrific legacy, the Jim Crow South and poll taxes. I mean, that's how aggressive he's been in essentially using these identity politics terms and the very real scourge of racism to cover for what is essentially a like corporate police state agenda. You have this paragraph in your piece that I think is really important because it takes it out of the context of just the New York City mayor's race and poses a larger question for the left. You say, for a long time, many on the left have favored in identitarian politics over one that aligns class with race. If identity is elevated above class and critiques of capitalism no longer matter, politicians like Adams will be in. As a black man, he's been able to effectively denounce calls for greater tenant protections on the grounds they would adversely affect minority landlords, while rebuking all criticism criticism of himself as a racist as racist. So he's basically saying like, if you're critiquing May, then you must be racist, no matter how legitimate the critique is. His supporters have attacked rank choice voting itself erroneously, claiming that it weakens the power of non white voters. So
again, this is a guy who is basically cynically exploiting some of the well intentioned proclivities of a lot of people on the left to position himself as a progressive, while his ideals and what he stands for is anything but Yes. So I think Adams supposes a unique danger to the left if he wins, and it looks like he may very well win because he has a lot of the populist rhetoric, and he's someone who'd come in with a real populist coalition working class blacks and Latinos labor union. Is he's kind of dying out of borough political machines, and he could say, on one hand, incredibly I was elected by the people. But unlike sort of you know, left populist type politicians, there will be no large redistributive agenda. Right. Eric Adams is backed by like Andrew Yang is supported by you know, billionaire charter school supporters, billionaire real estate developers. The city's power elite are very excited about Eric at they might be a bit weary because he is unpredictable in the scendiary. They prefer someone like Michael Bloomberg, who you know very much fit in a box. Whereas Adams used to be a Republican now is a Democrat. He's all over the place, but fundamentally he's not a challenge to capital. He's not a challenge to the power elite. At the same time, he's very a depth at invoking race and making it seem like he himself is some kind of underdog or some kind of populist, like a lot of candy politicians. So challenging him, organizing against him will be difficult in my eyes, because he has a strong coalition and he's very good at using these weapons of identity against the left. That's why I'm always warning my friends in the left, you really have to pair the class critique with race, otherwise you get this kind of woke capitalism, which is what Eric Adams ultimately represents. So ross have New York City progressive is how are they going to square that working class blacks are likely to elect a black mayor who wants more cops and doesn't want to defund the police. I just feel like this has to be one of the biggest reckonings for what's happening with left politics in New York City right now. I'm curious for your thoughts on that. Yeah, I mean, I would like to see that reckoning. So after the twenty twenty election, you know, I and some other people on left were saying, look, you know New York City, Trump threw his vote share in working class Latino neighborhoods and then to a lesser extent in working class Black neighborhoods. He did not really grow a share in white neighborhoods. And this was true nationally. This really followed national trends that waiting for like the professional left reckoning with that, and it just never came. I think unfortunately a lot of these kind of NGO type groups, you know, they really have incentive to ignore what's going on. So you have you have these weird scenarios where you know, a nonprofit NGO organization will say we speak for the working class. Meanwhile the working class is booting a certain way. I think
there are smarter, cannier groups like the ESA, but still there is this disconnect and the reckoning has not come. Yeah, and even the like left candidate in the race now Maya whiley the only marginally progressive person who has a shot. I mean, she was like on MSNBC every day opposed to Bernie Sanders. So and Scott Stringer, who was the other one, was also like, you know, a Hillary Clinton type progressive I guess. So the left really didn't have much of a showing in this race or anyone to root for whatsoever. Look, we don't what's going to happen, and ranked choice makes this very dicey in order in order to effectively predict what's going to happen in this race first time having ranked choice voting in New York City mayor oal primary. But Andrew Yang was once solidly at the top of this field and has really fallen off to where you know, I think if he were to win at this point, it would be a tremendous comeback. He's a large underdog at this point. What happened that caused him to fall off in the polls to that significant amount? So my theory is Andrew Yang really lost educated liberal voters. Unlike the national Democratic electorate, the left liberal PMC. Part of the Democratic electorate in New York City is a lot bigger. So, you know, Elizabeth Warren flopped on the national stage right, I think an Elizabeth Warren type candidate could do a lot better in New York City just because this kind of you know, wealthyre, affluent type democrat who consumes a lot of news and has as a graduate degree matters. Right, You really can't win the mayoralty being entirely shut out by them. And my theory so far is that despite their revulsion towards Eric Adams, they're more accepting of Eric Adams because he's been an elected official, his gaps take on a different quality. Andrew Yang really came in with a lot of energy and excitement. He just has shown a real knowledge gap around certain issues. He's gotten a lot of media scrup me. Eric Adams did not really get any media scrutiny until I would say around May of twenty twenty one, and it's almost entirely absent from the media. It's very strange to even see this. Whereas Andrew Yang wall to wall coverage, I think ultimately that hurt him. I think if Eric Adams got the level to scrutin me Yang did, he would not be so high in the pools. That being said, I think Andrew Yang did a really poor job of mitigating the fears of progressives and also at least trying to assuage some of this kind of educated liberal voter base, which does matter Lasio one with educated liberals, one with working class black voters. Eric Adams will not do well educated liberals, But my own sense is he's probably better positioned in ranking choice voting to show up on their ballots more than Ye'll get to listen to those Yang listen to those consultant, those Bloomberg consultants a little too much, I think. Tell us about the book, congrats on it coming out today again. It's called The Prince Andrew Cuomo Coronavirus in the Fall of New York. We've certainly been talking to you about these topics for a while. What is it that you wanted to dig into in this book and expose about Andrew Cuomo and his reign as governor there? So I really see this book as a rejoinder to the propaganda memoir he put out last year the focus of late mayor's race. But Andrew Cuomo is still the King of New York. He has not resigned. He's inordantly powerful. He wants to run for fourth term. So this is a book about the horrible year of COVID in New York State. It's about how Andrew Culomo failed in New York, how he downplayed COVID, compared it to the flu like Donald Trump did, was late to respond, mismanaged nursing homes, courted scandal and controversy. And it's also about its political history. So if an interest in kind of how Clomo came to be who he is, how he betrayed the left Oprah and over again, and really a work to foil the ambitions of democrats, this is definitely a book for you. It's pretty, it's very readable, it's fairly short, and if you really you know, you read the memoir last year or ignored the memoir last year, and you want to really find out what happened with Andrew Clomo, what happened with COVID, Who is this guy? Why is he so powerful? I really think this is a book you will enjoy and you should go buy it from four Books. Today, I'm going to go ahead and a say in our audience did not read the Andrew Cuomo memoir. However, they should read your book because you have been the most astute observer, one of the most street observers, certainly of Cuomo and his failures. From the very beginning. You weren't buying into the media hype. You've had already a lot of journalistic revelations that have been important, and you're incredible writer. Everybody. We're going to put the information for the book down in the description so you can find it. Definitely check it out again. Ross, great to have you, Thanks for joining us on this spectacularly busy day for you. Thank you, Ross, Thank you for having me. Of course, thanks everybody for watching, guys, we really appreciate it. As a reminder, if you want to watch the full show, completely uncut, you can become a Premium member today. You get to listen to it as a full audio show as well, and you get to help support our work here. We're one hundred percent powered by Supercast. We love them. It's an awesome partnership and we will see you all on Thursday. Have a great day, guys, We'll see you back here on Thursday. Enjoy. Thanks for listening to the show. Guys, we really appreciate it. To help other people find the show, Go ahead and leave us a five star rating on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. Really helps other people find the show as always special thank you to Supercast for powering our premium membership. If you want to find out more, go to Crystalansager dot com