TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Lisa Abel: Welcome to Bemaadizijig Ganoonindwaa. This podcast is produced by the Communications Department at the Anishinabek Nation. We will be focusing on the issues and initiatives in Anishinabek Nation territory. I’m your host, Lisa Abel.
Lisa Abel: In early January 1990, shock waves rippled through both First Nations and non-First Nation communities of Manitoulin Island. The Ministry of Natural Resources (the MNR) and the Ontario Provincial Police (the OPP), delivered summons to dozens of people, the majority from local First Nations, charged with violations related to hunting and the sale of game and fish. In a news conference at the MNR’s Toronto offices, a provincial enforcement specialist revealed that in 1988-1989, over 30 MNR Conservation Officers from across Ontario, with assistance from the OPP, had conducted an undercover investigation on Manitoulin Island into what they suspected was “an extensive underground market for deer meat and fish.”
It’s said that the officers were given written instructions that began with the phrase “Welcome to Adventures in Rainbow Country,” a reference to a classic TV series, and the name of the tourism marketing area in the Sudbury, Manitoulin, and North Shore areas. The entire saga became known as “Operation Rainbow.” Over 30 people were charged, including 23 First Nations citizens from Sheshegwaning, Aundeck Omni Kaning, M’Chigeeng, and Wiikwemkoong Unceded Territory, and 11 non-First Nations people from Whitefish Falls, Nairn Centre, and Sudbury, and as far south as Toronto, Niagara Falls, and Windsor. One retail butcher shop was charged as well.
The names of all the people charged were published in the media. The charges included infractions under the Game and Fish Act, including buying and selling wild-harvested venison, other game meats and fish; hunting at night; hunting from a vehicle; driving with a loaded gun in a vehicle; and discharging firearms across or on roads, as well as two charges under the federal Fisheries Act, charges under the Trespass to Property Act, and four charges under the Criminal Code for careless use of firearms. Three vehicles and hunting equipment were seized in a series of search warrants conducted at homes on the Island.
02:59 The MNR said the investigation was triggered by “an increasing number of complaints from people on Manitoulin, including hunters, tourist operators, and farmers,” of increased night hunting, and occurrences of carcasses found in fields. During the investigation, undercover officers purchased a reported 1,800 kilograms of wild game, which amounted to approximately 41 whitetail deer , which the MNR claimed were illegally hunted, as well as meat from illegally hunted moose and bear, and almost 100 kilograms of commercial and game fish, including lake trout taken out of season.
A district manager from the MNR told the Manitoulin Expositor in 1990 that “the prospect of laying charges under the Game and Fish Act on an Indian Reserve is a delicate matter requiring the permission of the Deputy Minister. A few years ago, conservation officers were issued a directive not to bother except under very special circumstances. The Deputy Minister was fully informed of the action ahead of time and had given his permission.” Both the United Chiefs and Councils of Manitoulin tribal council and Wiikwemkoong Unceded Territory moved to secure legal representation for their affected members.
Operation Rainbow impacted the relationships between First Nations and non-First Nation communities on Manitoulin in ways that continue to reverberate today. For this podcast series, I read through many news articles related to Operation Rainbow, as well as reports describing the historic relationship between First Nations and the Crown and how it impacted our Anishinabek ability to exercise our Aboriginal and Treaty rights to hunt and fish in our traditional territories. Yet, the memory of Operation Rainbow is still alive in many Anishinabek Nation citizens and leaders who experienced these events. From our perspective, MNR enforcement wasn’t uniquely about uncovering a poaching ring, disrupting an underground economy, addressing unsafe hunting practices, or acting against the depletion of wildlife.
Operation Rainbow reflects a long history—going back to the 1850s—of outside governments interfering with Anishinabek control over natural resources. At its core, it highlights a fundamental conflict in how treaty rights are understood. Provincial policies imposed harvesting regulations that failed to recognize Anishinabek cultural practices, traditional economies, and community needs. These actions weren’t just regulatory—they created pressure and intimidation, discouraging people from exercising their inherent rights to hunt and fish.
05:53 Ultimately, Operation Rainbow reveals a larger issue: Ontario’s refusal to “acknowledge that First Nations, by virtue of their rights and treaties, must be recognized as partners in the management of natural resources.” The 1980s had ushered in significant gains, with the inclusion of Section 35 in the Canadian Constitution, which recognizes and affirms the existing Aboriginal and Treaty rights of the Aboriginal peoples of Canada. But the implementation of our rights on the ground was a complicated process that was met with resistance.
To begin to understand our Anishinabek perspective of Operation Rainbow, I spoke with Glen Hare, who served as the Deputy Chief and Chief of M’Chigeeng First Nation in the early 1990s; and Patrick Madahbee, who was the Chief of Aundeck Omni Kaning First Nation at the time. Over the past thirty years, both have continued to serve in leadership roles within the Anishinabek Nation and at the regional and provincial levels. Glen Hare has recently been re-elected Chief of M’Chigeeng, and Patrick Madahbee is the Anishinabek Nation Commissioner on Governance, in addition to many other roles.
Lisa Abel: I've been trying to piece what happened,
Load full transcript
together, based on what was printed in the media at the time. I think we need to get your perspectives, because you both were in political leadership at that time.
Patrick Madahbee: Yeah, we were both Chiefs here on Manitoulin at the same time. You want to go first there, Glen? Just to kind of give an overview.
Glen Hare: Yeah. Okay. Well, from my interests of all this activity that happened, it starts long before the sting operation itself. You know, when I was growing up, 10,10 years plus, when I moved in with my grandmother. My grandfather drowned then. And he drowned in ‘67. And then my younger brother drowned in 1982, with his friend, Floyd. Do you remember Pat, Floyd Ace?
Patrick Madahbee: He was a defense player when I played hockey for M’Chigeeng.
Glen Hare: Yeah, yeah. So them two episodes there: they were setting the net at night. And both of them accidents happened early in the morning. They were retrieving their nets before daylight. That was because MNR was on watch with all Nishnaabeg. They claimed that that was not our right, to set nets at night. So, in 1985, that's when I first got elected to council in M’Chigeeng. And the activity of MNR to our First Nations was still very rampant. It was very high. But I was still working away from home. And then in 1989, I still ran for council. But I got the highest vote, so I was the Deputy Chief, and so that got me in there, and our Chief at the time was Joe Hare. And he said, “You should come home and work. We'll hire you as a full-time Deputy/Administration.” That's when we built our community centre.
09:29 Lo and behold, I guess maybe Pat can give a little bit light on this. We didn't know, I didn't know, anyway. 1989, I guess, maybe ‘88, there was some activity from the MNR, doing a sting, already had started on our communities. One of the things that that really hurt them was night hunting. And I guess some stories got out that our members were night hunting and selling the deer. Now, night hunting’s still a right for us. Just as much as spear hunting is and setting the nets. That was way back our right, and it still is. So when the sting operation came to light, it hit everybody like a ton of bricks, leadership, members. And in our community, they targeted two or three of them from our community. So, things really escalated from there. Our relationship with them, when all this opened up, our relationship with MNR was… that was it. That was the end of that. Really, pretty much to this day.
Patrick Madahbee: Like Glen has outlined, this harassment goes back a long time, on many fronts. They were after us for things that were well within our rights, like spearing of fish, night hunting, deer hunting, moose hunting. And moose hunting is still a problem. Incidental cabins. And, ironically, after all of the court proceedings and everything, nothing really came out of this. In terms of, anything diminishing our rights, or MNR winning anything. We have a situation here where we had the old guard Conservation Officers. They knew our people, they even came into our communities. You know, I recall, one of the conservation officers having a few beers with some of the local guys, and they were invited in for meals. But that era of Conservation Officers, they had developed relationships with the communities, but they also knew the history of the treaties, they knew the history of Nishnaabe around here. The new Conservation Officers were minted out of a training program down at MNR. They had no orientation about First Nations issues of any significance, when they started this sting, basically, entrapment of our people.
You know, here's the ironic part. It’s said that they take eight to ten thousand deer out of Manitoulin, in terms of the non-Native hunt, every year. That doesn't factor in the hunt on Manitoulin of regular hunters, or farmers that sometimes hang three or four deer up in their barns. You don't see those numbers anywhere. And yet there was this false narrative out there that First Nations had a poaching operation of such a significant magnitude, that they had to call in undercover officers and people from all over to come into our communities.
Lisa Abel: The undercover operation took place in 1988-1989, and charges were laid in 1990. Several non-First Nations people went to court and plead guilty. In September 1994, after a few delays and appeals, the trial of the remaining defendants, mostly First Nations citizens, began in Gore Bay, the government and judicial seat of Manitoulin Island. Due to the expected length of the trial, and the large number of defendants, legal counsel, and witnesses, the proceedings were held in a makeshift courtroom at the local curling club. There was widespread interest, and the trial was attended by both First Nations people, local citizens, and a contingent from the Ministry of Natural Resources.
The trial began by hearing the Crown’s evidence and witnesses for all 22 defendants . The court heard that before the undercover operation even got started, Conservation Officers in charge of the project checked in with the Crown Attorney for the Sudbury and Manitoulin area. They wanted to know, how far could they go in breaking the law – such as game, fish, migratory bird or liquor laws - to stay undercover? The Crown Attorney told them he was prepared not to prosecute if they had to break certain wildlife laws, like the Game and Fish Act or the Migratory Birds Convention Act, to maintain their cover. But he drew the line at impaired driving. Starting in March of 1989, a Conservation Officer from another district drove around the North Shore and Manitoulin in a van packed with sporting gear, posing as a travelling salesman for a fake sporting goods company, striking up friendly relationships with the suspects to establish rapport so he could later connect them with the investigation teams. By October 1989, the operation ramped up in a big way. Thirty-five Conservation Officers from across
Ontario were brought into Manitoulin. They were told they’d be going undercover as hunters looking for guides. In court, a couple of those Conservation Officers said they were given short lists of people to approach, along with photos, home addresses, and maps. Most of their targets lived on First Nations reserves. They were supplied with cash for expenses, things like buying game or beer, and given hunting gear, including bows and rifles. Some Conservation Officers even kept empty beer cans in their vehicles and offered drinks as part of the “social side” of hunting, all to make their undercover roles more believable. The court heard just how closely these undercover officers embedded themselves. They visited people in their homes, met their families, shared meals, and had many conversations about hunting. Some First Nations hunters guided them on expeditions both on and off-reserve, during the day and at night. And in at least one case, it went even further: a Conservation Officer supplied the gun and ammunition for a night hunt, while another Conservation Officer held the spotlight. When the hunts didn’t pan out, several Conservation Officers asked to purchase deer, and did so, even though some declined to sell deer when the subject was first broached. The court later heard that at least one of the accused understood the payment to be for their guiding services.Conservation Officers took photos, videos, and audio recordings of their suspects without their knowledge, sometimes from a surveillance van. Other officers were wired with recording devices. The court also heard about a Conservation Officer who used a racial slur, which was caught on the surveillance tape. Conservation Officers had pursued their investigations on reserve land, even though normal protocol required the MNR to notify and seek permission from Chief and Council. The prosecution’s case ended with a special Crown witness: the man who had served as Deputy Minister of the MNR between 1987 to 1993. A special exemption clause in the Regulations allowed the Deputy Minister to authorize going on reserves without notification. He told the court that back in 1988, he’d been confidentially briefed on MNR concerns about illegal hunting on Manitoulin Island, including night hunting and other activity. He was told it involved both First Nations and non-First Nations people. After that meeting, he gave the investigation the go-ahead , with clear instructions: enforce the law fairly and go after anyone breaking it, regardless of who they were. He also acknowledged that undercover officers might cross legal lines but stressed that any of that should be kept to a minimum. The Crown rested its case and part one of the trial adjourned in November 1994. It was scheduled to resume in April 1995, with three weeks set aside for the defence to present its case. What our First Nations citizens and leadership heard in court in 1994 was that Operation Rainbow was an immense betrayal of trust.
Glen
Hare: For them to attack our people the way they did, they broke every law in the book. They supplied the vehicles. They supplied the booze, they supplied the rifles, the ammunition, you name it. They drove, drinking and driving. You name it, they did it. They broke every law in the book.
Patrick Madahbee: They befriended a lot of our people. And as Glen was saying, they used every dirty trick in the book. They supplied booze. Got a lot of our people intoxicated. They supplied the ammunition, the guns, the lights, the transportation out there to go hunting and, everything like that. And this thing went on for quite some time and they did target all of our communities, and they did go after specific people that were very prominent to them. And what a farce, for a false scenario that they created there. They went so far as to say it was truckloads of deer going out of here. And that was not the case at all.
See, part of this business, what you mentioned, like people were complaining, I mean, that's there all the time because there's a real, absolutely stupid myth out there, that First Nations people are hunting every day of the week, all seasons of the year. What they don't understand is Nishnaabe work with nature and the deer in particular, or all game that people harvest. They hunted at certain periods of the time because, during the winter months, they're not eating well, they're eating different types of diet and, it doesn't taste the same. And then, of course, in the Spring, they're having fawns and stuff like that. And then, during the summer, they're starting to build up their fat reserves again, and so the best time to hunt them is in the cooler weather, from September, in the Fall season. But they think we hunt out there every day of the week.
And it's the same thing with other species. Like, you know, the best time to go getting fish is in the Spring and in the Fall. Moose, same thing. And there's lots of other game that's available in those other months, whether it's partridge or rabbits in the Winter and other things like that. And that's how the Nishnaabe lived. I mean, you also have to remember, First Nations more than maybe the non-Native on the Island, back in that era, still ate a lot of the game that they caught, whether it's rabbits, partridge, ducks, you name it, whatever. Deer and moose and also the stuff they harvested like different types of berries and whatever. And so it's a whole different scenario. We relied on that as our food source more so than the non-Native here, so that was a way of life. It was not the myth that we’re out there, shooting and spearing and hunting everything down in sight every day of the week. Now, I will say, in every society, there are people that abuse, and we have this term, I know Glen and I have used it lots in our political careers, “That with rights come responsibilities.” And that's what our Elders and our uncles and everyone that taught us to hunt always said, “Only take what you need.
Don't waste anything. Use as much of the animal as you can.” All these teachings were part of the fabric for our hunting. It wasn't just, go out there and shoot everything in sight. Now there's some stories, I don't know whether we should tell 'em now or we got some time to tell them, but there's been a few incidents that happened, during the entrapment period. I don't know if you want me to comment on them now or after. But I recall a couple of them, that were very comical in a way, in terms of the amateurish way to a certain extent, how these officers were operating. But anyway, if you want me, I can, just a couple of quick stories.
Glen Hare: I guess maybe Pat, I think you were referring to… when you say some of these off-the-cuff stories. Like one of them, in Sheshegwaning, when they were driving down the road, the gun went off in the cabin, hit the side of the motor. And the other one they hit the bicycle reflector that was outside the house. Those kind of things. And there was many, there was quite a few of those kind of, ah, funny things to them, I would think, that when they occurred…
Patrick Madahbee: Yeah, that was actually my uncle, that fired off that gun at a bicycle reflector.
Glen Hare: Uh-huh.
Patrick Madahbee: He was [word in Anishinaabemowin], you know, he was really… I mean, he told me this himself. They were shining the light around and he saw, what he thought was the eyes of a deer. He was pretty heavily intoxicated by that time, 'cause this guy was supplying him booze.
Glen Hare: Yep.
Patrick Madahbee: Intoxicated to the point where he didn't even get outta the truck. He fired right across, in front of the MNR officer's chest and shot. And it kind of deafened the guy for a while, with the shot in an enclosed area –
Glen Hare: And power.
Patrick Madahbee: - with quite loud, with a high-powered rifle. And when they investigated, it was a bicycle reflector. So lots of different things like that happened, crazy things… and I don't think I attended all of the court sessions myself. Again, the rooms were packed, eh, it was hard to get in. But, sometimes, as what happens in courts, people will say something that is quite comical, in a serious situation. It's just the way things unfold. It's like a comedy of errors, of these folks that hunted and with these guys supplying the booze. I mean, what a… what a… what a recipe for craziness and disaster, to get people all drunked up, and then take them out at night, and that type of thing. That’s the unfortunate part of this thing. As I said, in the old guard conservation officer, they knew our people and our communities, and there was a little bit of an understanding, rapport. They knew, how we were out there hunting and everything, and they respected that, those treaty rights. These new guys, they came in there, and you know, that Operation Rainbow has tarnished any relationship. I don't think that was ever rebuilt. Ever, even to this day. It's created continued mistrust. And
I've seen some of the orientation things they put out there for MNR officers about First Nation issues, and it's, it's very inadequate. It's their own people trying to come up with what they think is the best way to deal with Nishnaabe people. And MNR, spending millions of dollars on this sting operation that amounted to nothing, with no result, was a giant waste of everyone's time. Especially being in the courts for about seven years. But you know, there's a couple things that, as I said, come out of it, is that seven years of litigation and high costs to our communities, not just in money, but the human factor. A number of our people died during that seven, eight years, with the harassment and just the depression of being targeted like this. It was an unhealthy situation all around.
Lisa Abel: Throughout the 1990s, Anishinabek leadership continued to advocate for fair enforcement of our Aboriginal harvesting rights, including the right to build incidental cabins on Crown land; the cultural tradition of night hunting; and fur harvesting issues. In 1994, M’Chigeeng asserted its jurisdiction by prohibiting MNR Conservation Officers from entering its territory. Patrick also points out that many Ministers of Natural Resources are urban based with little understanding of what it’s really like in the bush. And are the Ministry’s priorities really about conservation or the revenues generated by the sports hunting industry?
Patrick Madahbee: Now some of these issues that we've talked about, a number of political leaders, including Glen and myself, have fought these issues. You know, like Glen was very prominent, for example, on the incidental cabin issue, where we are allowed to have cabins anywhere in the territory for hunting and trapping and everything, and they used to harass our people about that. And I know there's still tidbits of harassment here and there, but for the most part, they leave our people alone as a result of the efforts that Glen did with meeting with the Minister on that. And this business about night hunting and spearing, I know that we advocated, and I even went on behalf of the Anishinabek Nation to Geneva and spoke to the United Nations about the fur harvest, and I talked about this entrapment situation, over there.
Glen Hare: One of the things that, we really stressed, I stressed anyway for M’Chigeeng, was they [the MNR] are not allowed into M’Chigeeng anymore. They're not, I said that right court back in the day. They're not allowed to come, unless they go through the leadership, through the Chief, first. If they want to do business of any kind in the community. They’re not to bring any sidearms with them. None of their fancy chrome shiny trucks, nothing like that. You just come in, just a regular person and all that, otherwise you're not allowed. The only time they come through our First Nation is because of the Trans-Canada highway comes through it. Otherwise, the rest of the property is ours.
When Pat talks about the incidental cabins, yes, and that's still an issue. They kind of recognize our position on incidental cabins today, but it's so sad that in the Superior region, they still attack the communities up there though. And I wish, I wish some that someday soon someone would get up and stand up to these MNR bullies up there because it is, again, one of our rights. And you know what I came to learn here, when they attacked us on incidental cabins, everybody fought back and they fought back because they were fighting them. And I said, “Listen, leave us alone. Leave us alone. If John, Dick, and Harry and whoever wants to build a cabin, let them build it. It is their right. But if you fight them, you’re going to get 20 more, 50 more of them individuals. They will go and build.” Today, I think us here, I think I'm pretty close. There's probably only about four, maybe five incidental cabins on Crown land up north of 17, north of Massey. So, see? I think if they kept on fighting though, we probably would've seen 40 of them still fighting yet today.
Patrick Madahbee: We have probably a half a dozen cabins up there. But at one point, they tried dig a big ditch to stop access on the road.
Glen Hare: Yep.
Patrick Madahbee: I sent heavy equipment up there and we dug into the side of the bank and fixed that ditch to allow the access. So then what they did then was they put a gate up there with a lock, a big padlock on it. And the guys asked me what to do. I said, “Shoot the lock off.” And after several locks, they finally gave our guys a key. Because they were trying to… it wasn't just Nishnaabe up there going through, there was non-Native people, going into the territory, hunting illegally. You know, at least we were hunting within our rights, but they, they weren't. So they were trying to stop everybody. But for us, they finally gave our guys a key. And it took several locks that got shot off the gate before they realized they weren't gonna stop us.
Glen Hare: So Pat, do, you remember the Minister at Queen’s Park back in there… I forget her name.
Patrick Madahbee: Yeah, I do, too. And here's the ironic part, Lisa. They've had a couple of, pretty well most of those ministers that are there, they're urban people that have probably never hunted a day in their life. And we were dealing with ministers that really had no experience in the bush. They had no experience of the reality of what it is, with a hunting issue. They were just relying on their conservation officers to tell them. And we've went through so many different ministers. Even in that Ministry of Natural Resources, the turnover has been significant. So it is hard to remember a particular individual minister's name. But I do remember, Glen, we went down there and you were championing the cause there for some M’Chigeeng band members on that incidental cabin. And that's when that policy got changed.
Glen Hare: And that's where this happened. I'd already advocated for them before for their cabin, because
the roads were kept being taken out, the driveways. And so at one point, our members here went up there and they were confronted by the Ministry guys. … And long story short, I was on my way to have a meeting with the Minister of Natural Resources that day when my members called me. I was in Toronto; I was walking to the meeting. And they said, “Glen, can you get the… help us again? This is what happened.”
Patrick Madahbee: That matter was dealt with, like really quick. I think within the next day, the word got out. But there was some aspects of that, we could tell, when we talked to those folks there, being a minister from an urban population, how do they really know, not being out in the bush themselves? The one minister we talked to said, “Well, I have a cabin up in the Muskokas,” you know, thinking that there's an affinity to being in the north, the Great White North, because she has a, probably a cabin that's fancier than a lot of our own houses, sitting up there in a high, rich, tourist area. And that's her saying, “Well, I'm an outdoors person.” I'm gonna comment back on what I said earlier about hunting as a sport, you know, they take 8 to 10,000 deer annually off Manitoulin Island. Plus, not factoring in what's shot on Manitoulin by the non-Natives, and I think there's lots of these non-Native hunters are hunting year-round on the Island. They're hiding them in their barns, big farmlands properties. Who is going to monitor anybody hunting on a big acreage? But here's the thing, Ministry of Natural Resources, has a “Conservation Officer.” Those words are not reflective of what this is actually about. Think about this: a hunting license bought by thousands of hunters, big revenue for the province of Ontario. Go over to Bass Pro Shop there in Highway 7 and Vaughn area. Millions of dollars of sporting equipment, guns, the camouflage gear, the vests, the hats, ammunition, fishing tackle, boats, ATVs, you name it. I mean, it's a multimillion-dollar business. And they even bring in the American hunters up here, and charge them even more. So what the hell, if there was truly concern about conservation, then they wouldn't be allowing all these licenses and hunters to descend on Manitoulin Island and shoot up that amount of deer - or anywhere in the province, or anywhere in Canada for that matter. That’s the hypocrisy of this whole situation. This is a big money thing, sports hunting, sports fishing. I mean, there's television programs about it. Big advertisers come into play, it's a multimillion-dollar business. But they want to pick on the subsistence harvesters here in our communities. That's the irony of this and the stupidity of this Operation Rainbow. It just… the amount of deer taken by Anishinabe, you know, I'll give you an example. We've got a population now probably close to 1,200 maybe, but back in the day when this happened, we were about 800. While they think 800 people are hunting. We only have about nine active hunters that go up,
go moose hunting or actively hunt.
Lisa Abel: You're talking about the population of Aundeck Omni Kaning?
Patrick Madahbee: Yes. Yes.
Lisa Abel: Yeah, thank you.
Patrick Madahbee: And we only have about nine active hunters. And, if the truth be told, you know, there's probably even among those nine, maybe four or five of them that are really hunters. The rest like to go up there and have a few pops in the old cabin and just look around and a lot of them don't get anything. It's almost, seems to be the same guys getting the animal each year, and they share it around. Like, I haven't hunted in probably 30-plus, maybe even 40 years now. I used to hunt with my uncles. We did fishing and hunting guiding for parties from West Virginia, Southern Ontario, Michigan, Ohio, different places. And we went moose hunting, bear hunting, deer hunting, and we only shot, again, enough for that particular tourist to take home some game. Again, we weren't out there shooting everything in sight, and those folks were all licensed properly, and it was done properly. And same thing with, even back in our days of guiding fishing, we had a standing rule amongst us guides. Back in the day, the fish were quite good-sized fish. It was nothing unusual to bring in a 36-pound northern pike, a 40-pound muskie. You know, 20, 30, 40 pounds was the average size. But we had a standing rule, anything under 10 pounds went back. A release. Because again, we wanted them to generate more fish. And again, we only took as many as we needed. We didn't fish and say, “Oh, we can brag, we brought 20 fish home.” If we needed six or eight, we brought six or eight. We didn't bring 20 or 30. And that's just the way, even today, I'm still an active fisherman. I'm a sports fisherman. I'll bring home two or three pike or whatever it is. And most of the time, I'm giving it away to some of the Elders that don't get fresh fish around here. That's my idea of sports fishing. I just like being out there. And sometimes I'll eat a little bit of it. Most of the time I'm giving it away, to the Elders and people that don't get fresh fish.
Lisa Abel: So you're saying that amongst the Anishinabe population, that there was actually a very small number of hunters, and if they were skilled in hunting, that they were taking what they needed, and part of their role was to share that with community.
Patrick Madahbee: Yes. Look, I'm not a super fisherman, like Glen. (Laughs).
Glen Hare: (Laughs). That's for another day.
Patrick Madahbee: And there's a whole story behind that commentary. Lisa.
Lisa Abel: I'll have to get out on a boat with you in M’Chigeeng, Glen. (Laughs).
Patrick Madahbee: Get life insurance first. (Laughs).
Glen Hare: Yeah!
Lisa Abel: As mentioned, Operation Rainbow was a breach of protocol. Anishinabek have their own community standards for hunting and fishing, and both Glen and Patrick said it was important for the MNR to respect community leadership to deal with inappropriate behaviour in
our established ways.
Glen Hare: So you know, even to this day, and even back then, if somebody around here, and it happened, there was a half a moose was found at our landfill site, at the dump. And MNR, he was going to try to investigate that matter. When I got wind of it, I got a hold of them, and him. And I said, “This is not your matter. Because even the people within M’Chigeeng, yes, they were upset when they heard that too. It's not as if anyone looked the other way and you know, just, that’s nothing. Well, we dealt with it, and I know how we dealt with it was more severe than the Gore Bay courthouse would have done.
Patrick Madahbee: Lots of examples of that. In every society, there's always people that abuse things, and that's what I said earlier about, “With rights comes responsibility.” I had a cousin of mine, unfortunately his… all he was doing, was doing that to sell the deer, you know, for his habits. And, MNR called me as the Chief and said, “Should we charge him?” I said, “We will not protect somebody that is abusing our rights.” And so they did charge him. I could have said, “Oh, we'll deal with it.” But in that particular incident, it was severe enough that he deserved to be charged to teach him a lesson. And he hasn't done that since. But there's lots of these, and much like Glen says, we've had that experience here where, sometimes a moose was found in the landfill site, but sometimes there's even reasons for that. And again, it goes to this aerial spraying and stuff that's going on. We're finding parasites or finding lesions and cancerous growths on animals, whether it's deer or moose, even in the fish, and being caused primarily by aerial spraying, pesticide use by farming communities, all these types of things. And so sometimes, there's a rationale why a carcass will be found in a landfill site. But then there's also these individuals that are, they don't take the responsible approach, and they're in every society. You can't say we're 100 per cent immune from somebody that will abuse rights. It does happen, I won't sit here and say that a hundred per cent of Nishnaabe follow all the rules. But I think it's a darn good number, compared to the non-Native society, of who abuses these rights out there because you see people breaking the law all the time. So what Glen says is right. When we hear of something that happens, abuse of our communities, our people make sure that person knows well about it. And it's frowned upon. And we had even another incident, which is another thing. We've been using our islands surrounding our community extensively. And one guy was leaving his garbage, kind of making a mess over there. And MNR took pictures of it and everything, and of course, we told them, “We'll look after it.” So we made them clean that whole area up, and that's how we would've dealt with it. They would've just went to court and charged them. And what would've come out of that? The place would've probably been left with all that garbage over there, and they would've got a fine. And, to fine these people who were poor in the first place, doesn't really help them, anything. But Glen's right. Our people will generally deal with it in the proper manner.
Glen Hare: So we don’t know, I don't think anyone has ever told the public how much the government actually spent in money to do what they tried to do. I bet you it was in the millions.
Patrick Madahbee: Oh, for sure. And I'm sure it's in the… maybe if somebody went to the access to information, they could find out, but you're right, Glen. To come there with undercover officers, the overtime, vehicles, ammunition, lights, booze, you know, even. It is significant because that just didn’t end then. Over a seven- or eight-year period -
Glen Hare: Yeah, yeah.
Patrick Madahbee: You know, the court costs. I mean, you go into that court, they had reams of lawyers in there. It was, you’re absolutely, debwe Glen, you're talking millions of dollars. I wouldn't hesitate to say that's probably, and I'm being just making an estimated guess, I would say probably in excess of 20 million dollars.
Glen Hare: Yep, for sure.
Patrick Madahbee: If not more.
Glen Hare: And one thing about it, as we go into the end of our stories here, I can say in front of anyone, I can do it anytime. I can still… we all still walk with our heads high. We did nothing wrong. To this day. In regards to that whole, I'll say, 10-year episode with the government. To this day, you know, I wanna really believe MNR, to M’Chigeeng, and to all the communities, I hope we still have a great deal of respect with each other because of what happened. Because if something still ever came up, even after today, I would go to fight. Because again, our rights will not be taken away through the court system, by any stupid activities as such. That was so wrong, what they did to our communities, to our people. That was so wrong. I know, some of our Elders that did pass away, probably would've enjoyed a few more, if not years, then certainly months. But this took a toll on them. It took a toll on them right to the end. So yeah, that's how that came to be to the end of it, somewhat.
Patrick Madahbee: So Lisa, you can see in Glen's voice, and I share that same sentiment. You know, here we are, 30-plus years later, and there is still a bitterness, in my mind anyway, of this entrapment, and a total unnecessary farce that this turned out to be, in terms of a sting operation, and the tactics that were used. And I think it's been irreparable. That relationship that we had with the old guard MNR has been destroyed. I don't think they'll ever rebuild that trust, again, and that was the sad part of it. Like I said, Glen pointed it out. We lost a number of our people, with the trauma. Enduring seven years of court. And a lot of these people were poor people that they targeted as well. Some of the people that had their issues with alcoholism and various things like that. Like, pick on
the weakest. That to me is, it just leaves a bad taste, in the whole scenario here, of seek out these people that have addictions, people that are poor. You know, offer them money. Offer them booze. And take them out there on the land. And then charge them. It is just… I don't even have the right words for it. It's so stupid, you know, and unnecessary. And so I'm saying, here we are and the fact that you've brought this up for Glen and I has probably triggered us again, we'll be in trauma now for the next few days. (Laughs.)
Lisa Abel: Yeah, definitely, it must have really long-term impact on relationships between people, especially on Manitoulin, right? It's a small population. Everybody knows each other.
Glen Hare: Yep. You know, when things really got rolling, the fight started, we had all our Elders, leadership, members from all the First Nations on the island, including Birch Island. We got into the fight. We were all on the same page. There's a number of us now, I don't know who's left from Pat and I being the Chiefs at the time, but all of them are gone now. But we all stood firm. We all voiced everything. We participated, right from the get-go, right to the courts. Our Elders who were targeted also, they attended the courts. Even though they couldn’t even, they weren’t capable to get into the courtroom because the Gore Bay courthouse had stairways all the way up to the top. When one of the times when it came push, came to shove, we wanted our Elders to speak for us, because they wanted to speak. So… I guess the other thing too, for me anyway, and I think for all of us, and I still to this day, I owe former National Chief Ovide Mercredi for his support because every time I called him, we called him, he showed up, in person. It wasn't not by telephone, “I support First Nations on the island.” No, he was here in person. We did community sessions with him. And, so I do, I give him a lot of credit for that, to this day.
Patrick Madahbee: You know, we got lots of support, as Glen said, from our National Chief of the day. And I think, that was a classic example of one of the times that the First Nations in this area worked so collectively, and strong together. And it shows what can happen when we work together.
Lisa Abel: More than three decades later, the legacy of Operation Rainbow still lingers. What began as a wildlife enforcement investigation became something much deeper—a flashpoint in the ongoing struggle over Aboriginal rights, jurisdiction, and respect. For many Anishinabek people, it wasn’t just about charges or courtrooms. It was about trust broken, relationships damaged, and an Anishinabek way of life called into question. This story also challenges the narratives that shaped that moment in time. It reminds us that First Nations harvesting practices are rooted in responsibility, sustainability, and community—not exploitation. And it raises difficult questions about whose laws are enforced, whose knowledge is respected, and who gets to decide how the lands and resources are used. Operation Rainbow didn’t resolve those tensions. In many ways, it exposed them. As we continue this series, we’ll hear about the next stage of the Operation Rainbow trial, which still had a few years to go. We’ll hear about how the defence tried to persuade the MNR to drop the outstanding charges and start negotiations with Manitoulin’s First Nations leadership about our hunting and fishing rights; and how they faced significant barriers due to a lack of financial resources; and how they did their very best to defend our citizens with arguments based on Aboriginal and Treaty rights. We’ll also learn from Glen Hare, Patrick Madahbee, and Fred Bellefeuille, Director of the Anishinabek Nation Legal Department, about how the relationship between First Nations and the Ministry of Natural Resources has changed over the years, with significant progress made in the development of First-Nation led management of natural resources in several of our communities, and the potential of our Anishinabek Nation Governance Agreement to support self-determination in our hunting and fishing rights. Chi Miigwech to Glen Hare and Patrick Madahbee for taking part in the podcast, and to the Anishinabek Nation Lands and Resources Department for supporting this episode. To download a transcript, find the link in the podcast description! This episode includes the tracks “Minou Pimatiswen” by Nigel Irwin and Bryden Gwiss Kiwenzie, and “Down in the Valley” by Graeme Jonez, provided by Nagamo Publishing. And, "Leaving Home" by Kevin MacLeod. Chi Miigwech for listening to Bemaadizijig Ganoonindwaa. Until next time, Baamaa pii.