TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.400 --> 00:00:05.040
If you had solar panels put on your roof a few years ago, you did not pay what they cost.
00:00:05.200 --> 00:00:08.960
You paid a discounted price, and the discount came from a certificate.
00:00:09.119 --> 00:00:20.800
Back in 2020, when a rooftop system was installed, the owner became entitled to create a set of small-scale technology certificates based on how much power that system was expected to generate over its life.
00:00:21.039 --> 00:00:22.559
Most people never saw them.
00:00:22.719 --> 00:00:28.399
The entitlement was signed over to the installer or to an agent and came off the invoice as a discount.
00:00:28.559 --> 00:00:43.600
The agent then sold those certificates on because electricity retailers were required by law to buy and surrender them in proportion to the power they sold, which meant the discount on that roof was paid for, in very small pieces, on everybody else's power bill.
00:00:43.840 --> 00:00:47.119
One system, one address, one set of certificates.
00:00:47.280 --> 00:00:48.399
That was the machine.
00:00:48.640 --> 00:00:50.880
And the number of certificates was not counted.
00:00:51.039 --> 00:00:55.359
It was calculated from the size of the system and where in the country it was.
00:00:55.520 --> 00:00:58.479
Nobody weighed anything, nobody meted anything.
00:00:58.719 --> 00:01:01.520
The figures went in and an entitlement came out.
00:01:01.679 --> 00:01:04.560
Here is the structural detail the whole thing rested on.
00:01:04.799 --> 00:01:08.319
The certificates were not created by an inspector who visited the roof.
00:01:08.560 --> 00:01:11.760
They were created from the paperwork that said the roof was done.
00:01:11.920 --> 00:01:22.400
In October 2020, an accredited solar installer in Victoria named Gavin Brady, the director of a company called Shine Tech Solar, began filing that paperwork.
00:01:22.640 --> 00:01:32.159
Eleven sets of forms, over six months, assignment forms, transferring the right to create certificates, and with each one a certificate of electrical safety.
00:01:32.319 --> 00:01:38.159
The document and electrician signs to say an installation has been done properly and is safe to energize.
00:01:38.319 --> 00:01:43.760
The forms went to a renewable energy certificate agent who did what the system was built to do.
00:01:44.000 --> 00:01:46.879
Read the paperwork, accept it, act on it.
00:01:47.120 --> 00:01:50.719
The agent created 1,390 certificates.
00:01:50.879 --> 00:01:56.959
Then the agent paid Brady fifty thousand dollars for the right to create them, and on paper there was nothing to query.
00:01:57.120 --> 00:02:01.200
An accredited installer, an accreditation is a thing anybody can check.
00:02:01.359 --> 00:02:09.199
A company, eleven addresses, a safety certificate with each one, signed, every document the process asked for, present.
00:02:09.360 --> 00:02:12.960
There were no solar systems, not one of the eleven had been installed.
00:02:13.120 --> 00:02:21.439
The roofs were bare, the safety certificates certified the safety of installations that did not exist, and look at the economy of it professionally speaking.
00:02:21.680 --> 00:02:29.280
No panels to buy, no inverter, no racking, no crew, no scaffold, no traffic management, no trip to site.
00:02:29.520 --> 00:02:30.639
Eleven envelopes.
00:02:30.879 --> 00:02:33.120
The Clean Energy Regulator investigated.
00:02:33.360 --> 00:02:45.919
On the first of february 2023, at the Moo Rabin Justice Center, Gavin Brady, the director of Shine Tech Solar, pleaded guilty to five dishonesty offences under the Commonwealth Criminal Code.
00:02:46.080 --> 00:02:56.240
The magistrate said the sentence had to strongly emphasize general deterrence and took into account the early plea, the record of interview, and the fact that Brady had made full admissions.
00:02:56.479 --> 00:03:04.639
Brady was convicted, placed on a community correction order for two years, and ordered to complete 300 hours of unpaid community work.
00:03:04.800 --> 00:03:09.919
He was ordered to pay forty eight thousand five hundred and twenty-eight dollars in reparation.
00:03:10.159 --> 00:03:19.759
At the time his accreditation as a solar installer was suspended, so the scheme does have a regulator, and the regulator does have investigators, and they did find him.
00:03:20.000 --> 00:03:29.439
Afterwards, eleven roofs, fifty thousand dollars, one thousand three hundred and ninety certificates, bought and surrendered by people who will never know they paid for them.
00:03:29.759 --> 00:03:33.599
Two years and three hundred hours for a job that was eleven envelopes.
00:03:33.759 --> 00:03:38.879
Nobody climbed a ladder, nobody drove to an address, nobody stood in a front yard and looked up.
00:03:39.039 --> 00:03:40.240
The file said so.
00:03:40.400 --> 00:03:43.599
The paperwork trick is not rare, and it is not clever.
00:03:43.840 --> 00:03:50.400
It works in any system where money is released by a document rather than by a person who has seen the thing the document describes.
00:03:50.560 --> 00:03:53.039
It works better the further the money has to travel.
00:03:53.280 --> 00:03:56.080
A roof is one address and fifty thousand dollars.
00:03:56.240 --> 00:04:13.520
Now put it inside a program with a budget of more than a billion a year that pays by the hour, which brings us to two schools in Melbourne, one in Reservoir and one in Footscray, and to a state government that in the same period had budgeted around$1.2 billion a year for training and paid it out one reported hour at a time.
00:04:13.680 --> 00:04:20.319
Two private colleges report lessons that were never taught, and Victoria pays for every hour of them, on this episode of Audit This.
00:04:20.639 --> 00:04:23.040
In July 2008, a company called St.
00:04:23.199 --> 00:04:27.920
Stephen Institute of Technology was registered with a director named Bal Jit Singh.
00:04:28.079 --> 00:04:31.839
Its
Load full transcript
premises were on High Street in Reservoir, in Melbourne's North.
00:04:32.000 --> 00:04:33.839
In October 2010, St.
00:04:34.000 --> 00:04:38.879
Stephen was added to the Commonwealth Register of Institutions and Courses for Overseas Studies.
00:04:39.120 --> 00:04:42.399
That registration is the one that matters, so hold on to it.
00:04:42.560 --> 00:05:04.000
It gave the school the authority to market to overseas students and to create their enrolments, and a certificate of enrolment was what an overseas student needed to apply for a visa to come and study in Australia, which means a private company, on a register, was issuing the document an Australian government department relied on to decide who came into the country, not the decision, the document the decision was made on.
00:05:04.160 --> 00:05:08.639
In November 2010, Rakesh Kumar acquired a 25% stake in St.
00:05:08.800 --> 00:05:12.639
Stephen, having helped Singh obtain the training registration in the first place.
00:05:12.879 --> 00:05:18.240
Both men had access to the Commonwealth database through which those certificates of enrolment are produced.
00:05:18.399 --> 00:05:21.040
Across town in Footscray there was a second school.
00:05:21.279 --> 00:05:27.519
Symbiosis Institute of Technical Education registered as a training organization in July 2010.
00:05:27.759 --> 00:05:32.800
Mukesh Sharma bought into it in February 2014 and held about 10%.
00:05:33.360 --> 00:05:42.399
Symbiosis was approved to deliver diplomas in business, advanced diplomas in management, certificates in accounting, and certificates in printing and graphic arts.
00:05:42.639 --> 00:05:44.560
Courses of 6 to 18 months.
00:05:44.720 --> 00:05:51.519
Both schools were also registered with the Victorian Department of Education to deliver vocational courses to domestic students.
00:05:51.680 --> 00:05:58.079
The judgment calls that funding the Skills Victoria Grants program in one place and the Victorian Training Guarantee in another.
00:05:58.319 --> 00:05:59.040
Same money.
00:05:59.199 --> 00:06:01.920
It is the second name that the rest of this episode uses.
00:06:02.160 --> 00:06:07.839
So there were two kinds of customer, and the difference between them is the difference the rest of this episode turns on.
00:06:08.079 --> 00:06:10.000
Overseas students paid their own money.
00:06:10.160 --> 00:06:11.600
The judgment is specific.
00:06:11.759 --> 00:06:17.439
They were full fee paying, self-funded, and received no subsidy from the Commonwealth or Victorian governments.
00:06:17.600 --> 00:06:22.160
They were buying training, a qualification, and the visa that let them stay while they studied.
00:06:22.399 --> 00:06:24.079
Domestic students paid nothing.
00:06:24.319 --> 00:06:30.079
For them, the government paid through a subsidy for every hour of training the school reported having delivered.
00:06:30.240 --> 00:06:34.720
One group paid at the counter, the other was paid for by everybody afterwards.
00:06:34.879 --> 00:06:36.560
So what did these schools look like?
00:06:36.800 --> 00:06:37.600
From outside.
00:06:37.839 --> 00:06:52.480
They had rented premises, occupied, staff, policy and procedure documents, teaching and assessment guides, websites, rooms, computers and printers, timetables listing class times and subjects, everything a school has.
00:06:52.720 --> 00:06:56.399
At the sentencing hearing the Crown set out what all of that actually was.
00:06:56.639 --> 00:07:16.720
Maintaining and occupying rented premises, employing a minimum number of staff, creating and maintaining generic policy and procedure documentation, creating and maintaining generic teaching and assessment guides that were never genuinely utilized or implemented, publishing websites with limited functionality and content that appeared to comply with the course requirements.
00:07:16.959 --> 00:07:24.800
And in the same list, failing to provide any genuine teaching and assessment in accordance with the guidelines and standards set by the relevant authorities.
00:07:25.040 --> 00:07:30.560
The court summary of the two schools together runs to four words a single fraudulent enterprise.
00:07:30.800 --> 00:07:32.399
Here is the thing about that list.
00:07:32.560 --> 00:07:34.959
Every item on it is a thing a school would have.
00:07:35.199 --> 00:07:40.639
The premises were real premises, the computers were real computers, the websites were up.
00:07:40.800 --> 00:07:44.000
Somebody paid that rent every month on time for years.
00:07:44.240 --> 00:07:45.759
None of it was a disguise.
00:07:45.920 --> 00:07:50.879
It was infrastructure and it had one purpose, which was to be seen by the people who check.
00:07:51.120 --> 00:07:52.879
They were not hiding from the system.
00:07:53.040 --> 00:07:54.079
They were built for it.
00:07:54.319 --> 00:07:59.519
In 2008, Victoria published a policy called Securing Jobs for Your Future.
00:07:59.680 --> 00:08:01.199
It created an entitlement.
00:08:01.360 --> 00:08:08.560
If you were eligible, you were entitled to a government subsidized training place and you could take that entitlement to any approved provider.
00:08:08.720 --> 00:08:15.680
By 2011 it covered every vocational qualification in the state under the name the Victorian Training Guarantee.
00:08:15.839 --> 00:08:19.040
Around$1.2 billion a year was budgeted for it.
00:08:19.199 --> 00:08:22.480
It was demand driven, which is a phrase worth slowing down on.
00:08:22.639 --> 00:08:25.600
It means the budget did not decide how much training happened.
00:08:25.759 --> 00:08:28.399
The training decided how much the budget spent.
00:08:28.639 --> 00:08:35.200
In 2010 there were about 426,000 government subsidized course enrollments in Victoria.
00:08:35.360 --> 00:08:38.879
Two years later there were about six hundred and sixty nine thousand.
00:08:39.039 --> 00:08:43.919
In 2010, private providers accounted for 26% of subsidized students.
00:08:44.159 --> 00:08:46.399
By 2014, 57.
00:08:46.799 --> 00:08:48.559
Now how a provider got paid.
00:08:48.720 --> 00:08:51.519
A provider signed a funding contract with the department.
00:08:51.759 --> 00:09:01.759
Under it, the provider had to submit accurate student statistical reports through a departmental system called the Skills Victoria Training System, no less than once every calendar month.
00:09:01.919 --> 00:09:22.720
Those reports stated how many scheduled hours of training and assessment had been delivered, in which subject, to which student, sit on the unit for a second because the unit is the whole story, not a student, not a course, not a qualification finished, and a person who can now do something they could not do before an hour in a subject against a name.
00:09:22.879 --> 00:09:29.360
That is what the state was buying, and that is what it counted, and an hour is the easiest thing in the world to write down.
00:09:29.600 --> 00:09:42.639
The contract then says this the department will pay the provider contact hour funds for scheduled hours of training and assessment reported under this Schedule I as having been delivered to eligible individuals.
00:09:42.879 --> 00:09:55.759
In other words, the department paid for hours the provider said it had delivered, not hours anybody watched, not hours anybody verified, hours reported monthly, through a portal, by the organization being paid for them.
00:09:56.000 --> 00:10:00.639
Run it forwards with a student who exists, a person enroll in a diploma.
00:10:00.799 --> 00:10:13.600
The school schedules the hours, the school delivers the classes, the school reports those hours, the department pays, the student finishes with a qualification, and the state has bought a skill it wanted in the workforce.
00:10:13.759 --> 00:10:19.120
That is the system working, and for most providers, most of the time, that is what happened.
00:10:19.279 --> 00:10:22.080
Now run it backwards with a student who does not.
00:10:22.240 --> 00:10:29.360
A name goes on an enrollment, hours are scheduled against it, no class is held, the hours are reported anyway.
00:10:29.519 --> 00:10:33.600
The department pays because the report says the hours were delivered.
00:10:33.759 --> 00:10:38.799
The only difference between those two, on the department side of the screen, is nothing.
00:10:38.960 --> 00:10:47.679
So the form did not just decide how much training had happened, it decided who it had happened to and which subject, and therefore what it was worth.
00:10:47.840 --> 00:10:48.960
There was a deadline.
00:10:49.200 --> 00:11:20.639
The department was only obliged to pay for a unit of training, where the provider created the claim within ninety days of the enrollment activity start date, ninety days to lodge the claim, nothing, anywhere about proving the training occurred, and to be fair to the contract, it did require things a documented process for checking eligibility, evidence cited before training started, a review of the student before training began, and it gave the department the power to withhold, to deduct, to audit, and to recover.
00:11:20.879 --> 00:11:40.799
Every one of those was a check the provider performed on itself, the eligibility test, run by the college, the evidence cited by the college, the review done by the college, the report written by the college, the claim made by the college, and then the money paid by the department on the strength of the file.
00:11:40.960 --> 00:11:46.320
There was no step in the payment process where anybody outside the college had to confirm a class had happened.
00:11:46.559 --> 00:11:47.679
There was a regulator.
00:11:47.840 --> 00:11:54.639
On the first of july twenty eleven, the Australian Skills Quality Authority took over the regulation of vocational training.
00:11:54.799 --> 00:12:00.559
It could audit any registered provider, it could suspend a registration, and it could cancel one.
00:12:00.720 --> 00:12:21.840
The conspiracy these four people were later convicted of is charged as beginning on the first of july twenty eleven, the same day, and an audit in practice is a request for documents, student files, enrollment forms, assessments, marked, completed assignments, records showing that a person was taught, then tested, then found competent.
00:12:22.080 --> 00:12:31.279
The regulator asks the provider to produce evidence about itself, and the provider produces it, which is the same sentence as the prelude, wearing a different uniform.
00:12:31.519 --> 00:12:36.480
Nobody sat in the back of the room, nobody counted the chairs, the file said so.
00:12:36.639 --> 00:12:42.720
The first of the two charges the jury convicted on in the judge's description was concerned with a standing plan.
00:12:42.879 --> 00:12:49.440
A standing plan to present whatever documents were required to make it look like the schools were complying with the required standards.
00:12:49.679 --> 00:12:51.440
Whatever documents were required.
00:12:51.679 --> 00:12:59.919
Not a document, not a forgery, singular, done once under pressure, a standing plan, running for years, for a category of problem.
00:13:00.159 --> 00:13:02.480
The judgment puts the result in one line.
00:13:02.639 --> 00:13:16.799
In fraudulently satisfying any compliance checks if audited by the regulator, both schools were able to retain their status as RTOs, which enabled them to continue to operate, to charge fees, and to remain eligible to apply for government funding.
00:13:17.039 --> 00:13:24.960
On the front of that judgment, in the catchwords a court writes for other lawyers, is the phrase wholesale fabrication of documents to deceive regulator.
00:13:25.120 --> 00:13:27.440
Not a forged signature, wholesale.
00:13:27.679 --> 00:13:30.240
If the files survived audits, the files were good.
00:13:30.399 --> 00:13:34.799
In 2019, the ABC obtained material from the investigation.
00:13:34.960 --> 00:13:44.080
Across assessments from both colleges, the same answers
appear in different students' work, not similar answers, the same ones, including the same mistake.
00:13:44.240 --> 00:13:52.960
The word chef, spelled C H I E F, repeatedly across different students at different colleges.
00:13:53.200 --> 00:13:58.000
Somebody had written one set of answers and everybody had been assessed as competent against it.
00:13:58.240 --> 00:14:01.200
The judgment describes what those files were covering for.
00:14:01.360 --> 00:14:18.000
Students were not genuinely assessed as to their competency in accordance with course progress policy, nor did they receive genuine teaching and assessment, as outlined in teaching and assessment guides, including structured classes, individual and group assessment, and simulated workplace environments.
00:14:18.240 --> 00:14:21.759
They maintained false timetables for class times and subjects.
00:14:21.919 --> 00:14:28.240
Students did not attend for structured subject-based classes at all, and then the line that changes who this is happening to.
00:14:28.480 --> 00:14:44.159
Students were enrolled, sometimes falsely and without their knowledge, and were kept on record with the creation of the superficial student files, fake student assessments, and completed assignments and other false documents and records as required, sometimes falsely and without their knowledge.
00:14:44.320 --> 00:14:51.679
Which means somewhere in a Victorian government system there was a list of people who had done training, names on it, courses, hours.
00:14:51.919 --> 00:14:54.240
The government paid for every hour on that list.
00:14:54.399 --> 00:14:59.039
Some of the people on it had never walked into the building, some of them did not know they were on it.
00:14:59.200 --> 00:15:03.039
According to the ABC, more than forty students gave evidence at the trial.
00:15:03.279 --> 00:15:05.279
The overseas students were the other kind.
00:15:05.440 --> 00:15:06.159
They paid.
00:15:06.320 --> 00:15:10.399
They had come on student visas against enrollments the school itself created.
00:15:10.559 --> 00:15:17.679
They were full fee paying and self-funded, in the judgment's words and received no subsidy from the Commonwealth or Victorian governments.
00:15:17.840 --> 00:15:19.360
Whatever they got they bought.
00:15:19.519 --> 00:15:28.240
What the Australian Federal Police told the ABC is that they were told they did not need to attend, that they could pay, and the certificate would be issued anyway.
00:15:28.480 --> 00:15:36.720
Detective Superintendent Danielle Woodward's description of the qualifications those students now hold runs to two words, basically fake.
00:15:36.960 --> 00:15:39.759
And remember what the school could do from Act I.
00:15:40.080 --> 00:15:41.519
It created the enrollment.
00:15:41.679 --> 00:15:51.679
The enrollment was the document behind the visa, so the same organization that decided whether a person was studying was the organization that produced the document their visa was decided on.
00:15:51.919 --> 00:15:56.159
The court's finding is about the teaching, and it is narrow, and it is brutal.
00:15:56.320 --> 00:15:59.759
Students did not attend for structured subject-based classes at all.
00:16:00.000 --> 00:16:06.240
False timetables, no genuine assessment, the paper held, everything the paper described did not.
00:16:06.480 --> 00:16:08.559
So think about what that certificate is.
00:16:08.720 --> 00:16:11.840
It is not a piece of paper that is worth less than they thought.
00:16:12.000 --> 00:16:20.159
It is a piece of paper that says a person can do something, held by a person who was never taught to do it, issued by a college that is now gone.
00:16:20.320 --> 00:16:22.720
You cannot hand that back and get the years off.
00:16:22.879 --> 00:16:26.240
A covert camera in the lobby of a college should record a college.
00:16:26.480 --> 00:16:28.960
The Australian Federal Police installed one at St.
00:16:29.120 --> 00:16:29.679
Stephen.
00:16:29.840 --> 00:16:35.120
According to the ABC's account of that material, the device recorded twenty three days.
00:16:35.279 --> 00:16:38.159
On twenty of those days no student was visible at all.
00:16:38.320 --> 00:16:39.840
Students appeared on three.
00:16:40.080 --> 00:16:44.159
On those three days, not one of them stayed for the length of a timetable class.
00:16:44.399 --> 00:16:49.039
On the fifth of july twenty fifteen, the timetable listed six classes.
00:16:49.200 --> 00:16:52.320
The footage from that day shows one person entering the building.
00:16:52.559 --> 00:16:53.759
He was there to clean it.
00:16:53.919 --> 00:16:59.840
In December 2014, the Australian Federal Police and the regulator began a joint investigation.
00:17:00.080 --> 00:17:02.799
It had a name, Operation Aristotle.
00:17:02.960 --> 00:17:09.359
The regulator's own account of its part is a single sentence from its chief commissioner at the time, Chris Robinson.
00:17:09.680 --> 00:17:20.640
ASQA has been assisting the AFP with its investigation, Operation Aristotle, into individuals who either own or are high managerial agents with these RTOs.
00:17:20.799 --> 00:17:22.319
For months they watched.
00:17:22.559 --> 00:17:29.119
Then, on the first of july twenty fifteen, the regulator rang Baljit Singh to let him know that an audit visit was coming.
00:17:29.359 --> 00:17:34.559
A routine call, the regulator announcing itself, exactly as the process required.
00:17:34.799 --> 00:17:36.319
The police were listening to it.
00:17:36.480 --> 00:17:40.480
According to the ABC, the call ran four minutes and thirty eight seconds.
00:17:40.640 --> 00:17:43.680
What happened after it, the ABC also reported.
00:17:43.839 --> 00:17:47.920
Computers were carried into the building, paperwork was carried into the building.
00:17:48.079 --> 00:17:51.519
The computers were not networked, they were not connected to anything.
00:17:51.680 --> 00:17:53.359
Five weeks later it stopped.
00:17:53.519 -->
00:17:58.880
On the fifth of August 2015, police executed search warrants across Melbourne.
00:17:59.119 --> 00:18:00.160
Charges were laid.
00:18:00.400 --> 00:18:10.480
The regulator suspended both colleges the same day, and from that morning neither of them could train anybody, enroll anybody, advertise anything, or issue a single piece of paper.
00:18:10.720 --> 00:18:13.920
Eight months of an investigation and it ended in a morning.
00:18:14.079 --> 00:18:19.680
The trial ran through the first half of 2018 and the jury convicted all four on both charges.
00:18:19.920 --> 00:18:38.799
At the sentencing, the judge recorded what the prosecutor had put to that jury in his closing address, that these schools were a sham, where a facade of legitimacy was used to fraudulently obtain thousands of dollars from international students and thousands from the Victorian government in subsidies for domestic students, and then the judge's own sentence about it.
00:18:38.960 --> 00:18:42.079
The jury's verdicts reflect their acceptance of that submission.
00:18:42.240 --> 00:18:44.640
Here is how the judge described the mechanism.
00:18:44.880 --> 00:18:56.400
Students were enrolled, sometimes falsely and without their knowledge, and were kept on record with the bare minimum being done so that the schools could receive government funding, so that the schools could receive government funding.
00:18:56.640 --> 00:18:59.839
That was the purpose of the classrooms, not a consequence of them.
00:19:00.000 --> 00:19:03.839
It would be easy to finish this as a story about four people in two buildings.
00:19:04.079 --> 00:19:05.039
It is not one.
00:19:05.200 --> 00:19:09.680
By 2015 the state had worked out that something was wrong with its training market.
00:19:09.920 --> 00:19:11.279
It commissioned a review.
00:19:11.519 --> 00:19:18.640
The review found an entitlement that was effectively unlimited, covering every course through a growing number of providers with no cap.
00:19:19.039 --> 00:19:21.440
Its verdict on what that had done is one line.
00:19:21.599 --> 00:19:28.720
In past years this has led to significant budget overruns, resulting in the manipulation of subsidies to address spikes in demand.
00:19:28.960 --> 00:19:30.240
Spikes in demand.
00:19:30.480 --> 00:19:34.880
When the demand is a monthly report, a spike in demand is a spike in reporting.
00:19:35.119 --> 00:19:39.839
The review also found a proliferation of training providers without any assurance of quality.
00:19:40.000 --> 00:19:43.039
The government's response came in December of the same year.
00:19:43.279 --> 00:19:46.079
The department launched what it called a quality blitz.
00:19:46.319 --> 00:20:02.240
Between July 2015 and the end of 2016, 62 training organizations were investigated, 21 funding contracts were terminated, and$48 million was identified for recovery, identified, not recovered, located.
00:20:02.480 --> 00:20:17.359
Looking back at those years, the department's own
market report said government funded training activity in Victoria had declined every year since the record highs of 2012, demonstrating clearly, in its words, that training activity in previous years was overinflated.
00:20:17.599 --> 00:20:21.279
Overinflated is a department's word for a number that was never real.
00:20:21.440 --> 00:20:25.200
And the reason the number was never real is the reason this episode exists.
00:20:25.440 --> 00:20:32.480
The number was a sum of monthly reports, and a monthly report is a claim about the past written by the person being paid for it.
00:20:32.640 --> 00:20:34.799
Now put our two colleges back into that.
00:20:35.039 --> 00:20:39.680
Two million dollars out of a program budgeted at about 1.2 billion a year.
00:20:39.920 --> 00:20:46.720
Across sixteen months from two colleges in a state of just under six million people, it is thirty-four cents each.
00:20:46.880 --> 00:20:48.960
Nobody feels thirty-four cents.
00:20:49.119 --> 00:20:50.799
There is no line on any bill.
00:20:50.960 --> 00:20:57.039
There is no rate payer who looks at a number and thinks that is wrong, and that is the condition the whole thing runs in.
00:20:57.200 --> 00:21:04.160
Not a heist anybody notices, a rate of loss below the threshold at which anybody is required to look.
00:21:04.400 --> 00:21:09.920
The crown made a related point at the sentencing, and it is the most useful sentence in the judgment.
00:21:10.240 --> 00:21:26.079
Offenses of this kind, it said, are generally difficult to detect, investigate, and prosecute successfully, difficult to detect, not difficult to prove, once you know, difficult to see at all, and these two were not detected by the system that was paying them.
00:21:26.240 --> 00:21:36.640
According to the ABC, the investigation began with a tip off, which leaves one question the published record cannot answer, and it is the question this episode is actually about.
00:21:36.799 --> 00:21:42.799
Forty eight million dollars was identified for recovery in eighteen months from 62 investigations.
00:21:43.039 --> 00:21:46.880
That is what looking found in the period after somebody started looking.
00:21:47.039 --> 00:21:55.599
Nobody has published a figure for the years before that, when the reports came in monthly and were paid, and when the only way in was a phone call from somebody who knew.
00:21:55.839 --> 00:21:58.079
There is no number for what nobody looked for.
00:21:58.240 --> 00:21:58.880
There cannot be.
00:21:59.039 --> 00:21:59.680
That is what the design.
00:22:00.160 --> 00:22:00.960
Design means.
00:22:01.119 --> 00:22:07.519
In December 2023, a Victorian court sentenced two more people over training that did not happen.
00:22:07.680 --> 00:22:13.759
About$2 million, taken from two public TAFEs, claimed for training that was not delivered.
00:22:14.000 --> 00:22:17.680
Both pleaded guilty to obtaining financial advantage by deception.
00:22:17.839 --> 00:22:23.519
The judge described the work as filling in forms and spreadsheets with false information to get the payout.
00:22:23.759 --> 00:22:27.759
In a text message, one of them asked the other how the sausages were going.
00:22:28.000 --> 00:22:33.440
Different people, different colleges, public institutions this time, not private ones.
00:22:33.680 --> 00:22:35.680
Eight years after the raids in Melbourne.
00:22:35.920 --> 00:22:36.880
Same forms.
00:22:38.400 --> 00:22:40.079
Quick one before the ledger.
00:22:40.319 --> 00:22:42.720
If this has been worth your time, follow order.
00:22:43.279 --> 00:22:45.759
This wherever you're listening and give it five stars.
00:22:46.079 --> 00:22:48.000
Nobody in this story counted anything.
00:22:48.160 --> 00:22:52.160
A rating counts and it decides whether the next person ever finds this.
00:22:52.480 --> 00:22:54.000
New story every week.
00:22:55.200 --> 00:23:04.720
On the 5th of August 2015, the day the charges were laid, the regulator suspended both colleges under the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act.
00:23:04.960 --> 00:23:05.119
St.
00:23:05.279 --> 00:23:10.720
Stephen Institute of Technology, Registered Training Organization 22336.
00:23:16.079 --> 00:23:26.720
In the regulator's own terms, that meant this: no training and no assessment, no new students, no advertising and no promotion of courses, no qualifications and no statements of attainment.
00:23:26.960 --> 00:23:28.960
SIMBIOSIS never returned.
00:23:29.119 --> 00:23:32.880
Its registration expired in 2016 and was not renewed.
00:23:33.119 --> 00:23:33.279
St.
00:23:33.440 --> 00:23:37.119
Stephen's registration was cancelled in November 2017.
00:23:37.279 --> 00:23:46.319
A jury found four people guilty of both charges, conspiring to dishonestly influence a Commonwealth public official, conspiring to deal in the proceeds of crime.
00:23:46.559 --> 00:23:49.759
Sentenced the 21st of September 2018.
00:23:49.920 --> 00:23:54.079
Baljit Singh, six years, non-parole three years and nine months.
00:23:54.240 --> 00:23:58.079
Rakesh Kumar, five years, non-parole three years.
00:23:58.319 --> 00:24:02.400
Mukesh Sharma, five years, non-parole three years.
00:24:02.640 --> 00:24:03.519
Raka A.
00:24:03.680 --> 00:24:05.039
Rora three years.
00:24:05.279 --> 00:24:08.480
Released immediately on a$5,000 recognizance.
00:24:08.720 --> 00:24:21.920
Public money obtained from the Victorian Training System, March 2014 to July 2015,$2,000.75, including goods and services tax.
00:24:22.240 --> 00:24:26.240
The judge's explanation of why it was paid runs to one sentence.
00:24:26.400 --> 00:24:31.279
These subsidies were fraudulently claimed because the students were not being properly taught, if at all.
00:24:31.440 --> 00:24:32.640
There was one more case.
00:24:32.880 --> 00:24:39.200
In November 2019, the same court dealt with a second matter about a loan obtained on false documents.
00:24:39.440 --> 00:24:49.599
Singh pleaded guilty to that, and to one other thing, attempting to pervert the course of justice by having an invoice reissued and then pressing a builder to tell police a version of events that was not true.
00:24:49.839 --> 00:24:51.440
The builder is not named here.
00:24:51.599 --> 00:24:52.559
He was a witness.
00:24:52.720 --> 00:24:58.640
The sentence for that second matter was ordered to be served at the same time as the first, so it added nothing to the years.
00:24:58.880 --> 00:25:05.920
A document that said the wrong thing, fixed by having a new document issued, and a person asked to say the new document was right.
00:25:06.160 --> 00:25:09.680
When the convictions came through, the National Regulator put out a statement.
00:25:09.839 --> 00:25:24.559
Its Chief Commissioner Mark Patterson said there is no place in Australia's VET sector for companies and individuals who are not genuinely committed to providing high quality training and assessment that arms learners with the skills and experience that employers need and want.
00:25:24.799 --> 00:25:29.279
Forty eight million dollars was identified for recovery in 18 months of looking.
00:25:29.440 --> 00:25:32.880
Nobody has published a figure for how much was never identified.
00:25:33.119 --> 00:25:42.559
$2,000 and seventy-five cents left the Victorian budget, and we could find no public record of what came back.
00:25:42.720 --> 00:25:44.640
Nobody sat in the back of the room.
00:25:44.799 --> 00:25:46.319
Nobody counted the chairs.
00:25:46.480 --> 00:25:48.000
The file said so.