TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.640 --> 00:00:09.679
The information and ideas expressed in the allegedly golden podcast are legal explanation and legal analysis, not legal advice.
00:00:09.919 --> 00:00:12.880
While I am a lawyer, I am not your lawyer.
00:00:13.119 --> 00:00:17.440
If you need legal advice, please contact a licensed legal professional in your area.
00:00:17.600 --> 00:00:19.359
My opinions are my own.
00:00:19.679 --> 00:00:21.760
For better or for worse.
00:00:30.399 --> 00:00:33.119
Welcome to Allegedly Golden.
00:00:33.679 --> 00:00:38.320
I'm a little under the weather today, but I sound worse than I feel.
00:00:38.640 --> 00:00:44.799
So last week we had construction banging away, and this week we have sniffles and coughs.
00:00:44.960 --> 00:00:53.840
I will try to edit the sniffles and coughs out, but I make no promises as to what I sound like because my postnasal drip is pretty bad.
00:00:54.000 --> 00:00:56.799
Nonetheless, all the usual conditions are happening.
00:00:56.880 --> 00:00:58.640
I got my die coke.
00:01:02.640 --> 00:01:04.400
Truly mother's milk.
00:01:04.719 --> 00:01:07.599
Frank is here with me, but he is in another room.
00:01:07.840 --> 00:01:14.000
He's upset with me because it is raining outside, and so he cannot go on a walk.
00:01:14.560 --> 00:01:18.560
And so he hates me because, you know, French Bulldog things.
00:01:18.719 --> 00:01:42.159
I want to rant a little bit because the thing that is on my mind this week about the internet and being an online person is these lunatics who have lost the plot and have started making themselves into some kind of like true crime truthers or something.
00:01:42.319 --> 00:01:51.680
I'm talking about the people who insist that Patrick Clancy really did it, and I'm talking about the people who insist that Brian Koberger didn't do it.
00:01:52.799 --> 00:02:02.000
They're a small group, but it's hard not to know that they're out there if you cover either one of those cases or anything related to them because they're very loud.
00:02:02.239 --> 00:02:07.680
Um and I've been trying to like understand the psychology of it, right?
00:02:07.840 --> 00:02:20.000
So there's a group of people who, of course, are absolutely convinced that Patrick Clancy actually killed the children and that he told Lindsay that she's the one who did it.
00:02:20.080 --> 00:02:21.919
So she believes that she did it.
00:02:22.479 --> 00:02:37.199
And there's now a similar group of people, I don't know if there's any crossover, honestly, I didn't look, who believe that Brian Coberger did not actually kill the Idaho four, but that I think there's different flavors of it.
00:02:37.360 --> 00:02:46.240
One is that like the Goncalvez family, Gonzalvez family, um is somehow involved in the murders.
00:02:46.960 --> 00:02:55.680
Um that they were like trafficking their children somehow, something, something, Brian Coberger didn't do it.
00:02:57.280 --> 00:03:03.439
And, you know, I'm trying to understand like why people are drawn to this kind of thing.
00:03:03.599 --> 00:03:21.120
And I'm obviously not a psychologist, but you know, I think my own channel is a testament to the fact that we like to keep up with and sometimes get a little bit too invested in real-life legal dramas that are going on in the world, right?
00:03:21.840 --> 00:03:27.840
Now, civil, I think, is a little bit different than criminal most of the time because the stakes are a lot lower.
00:03:28.159 --> 00:03:35.840
But it's not like a new concept that humans get invested in true crime and want to be part of it.
00:03:36.080 --> 00:03:40.479
There are people out there who, you know, are like, I think I might be able to solve this.
00:03:40.560 --> 00:03:43.280
I think I might be able to figure some stuff out.
00:03:43.439 --> 00:03:46.639
And I think that's mostly pretty fucking cool, actually.
00:03:46.800 --> 00:03:50.159
Like, there are people out there who have discovered information.
00:03:50.400 --> 00:03:58.879
A lot of these people who have podcasts that they, you know, serial was the first one, and then there were others that came after that where they like solved crimes.
00:03:59.439 --> 00:04:01.280
I think that's really, really cool.
00:04:01.439 --> 00:04:08.719
I don't think there's anything wrong with a human being saying, you know, my life is not fulfilling me.
00:04:08.800 --> 00:04:12.719
Like I need meaning in something, and I think I might be able to get some meaning here.
00:04:12.800 --> 00:04:15.039
Like that as a concept doesn't really bother me.
00:04:15.199 --> 00:04:22.240
I know a lot of people criticize the way that true crime media is delivered to us, that it's delivered too much like entertainment.
00:04:22.319 --> 00:04:23.920
And so sometimes people forget that it's real.
00:04:24.079 --> 00:04:26.160
And I think that's probably true also.
00:04:26.480 --> 00:04:30.720
Um, but generally speaking, like it fills some void, right?
00:04:31.199 --> 00:04:32.319
I like it too.
00:04:32.480 --> 00:04:34.000
I like watching these things.
00:04:34.240 --> 00:04:36.720
I like, you know, sort of the cadence of it.
00:04:36.879 --> 00:04:41.680
You've got a question, there's a puzzle to be solved, and then you put the pieces of the puzzle together.
00:04:41.920 --> 00:04:48.240
So I don't want to like shit on general true crime investment because I'm guilty of it as much as anybody else.
00:04:49.279 --> 00:05:04.079
But there is this new like subtype of true crime invested person who they see true crime as like a reality show and they want to be on the cast.
00:05:05.040 --> 00:05:09.680
Like they want to insert themselves into the case.
00:05:09.759 --> 00:05:12.879
And I know they would probably say, Oh, I don't want to insert myself.
00:05:13.040 --> 00:05:17.839
It's just that I came across this information or I figured this thing out and I have to share it.
00:05:17.920 --> 00:05:19.439
And that's bullshit.
00:05:20.000 --> 00:05:32.160
There are
Load full transcript
all kinds of things that occur to me in the middle of the night, in the shower, when I'm driving about active cases, but I do not get on the internet and share them because I do not want to make myself the story.
00:05:32.399 --> 00:05:40.079
When somebody comes out there and is like, hey, everybody, this is what I found, they are purposely inserting themselves in the story.
00:05:40.319 --> 00:05:44.720
But they really want to be cast in this reality show, right?
00:05:44.800 --> 00:05:46.879
Like, hey, everybody, look at me.
00:05:48.319 --> 00:05:59.519
And I guess there's some benefit to be derived from that, particularly if you feel in other parts of your life that you are in relative obscurity, right?
00:05:59.680 --> 00:06:04.560
You've never had the praise and adulation that all of us crave.
00:06:04.800 --> 00:06:08.800
I could see how that could be rewarding, right?
00:06:09.199 --> 00:06:11.360
Um, people saying, oh my God, you figured it out.
00:06:11.519 --> 00:06:12.560
Oh my God, you're the smartest.
00:06:12.639 --> 00:06:17.680
I mean, sometimes I'll look in the comment sections of these people and I don't know how many of the comments are real.
00:06:18.240 --> 00:06:21.680
But there's a lot of like, you're so smart, what would we do without you?
00:06:21.920 --> 00:06:24.959
And that can be really intoxicating to folks.
00:06:25.199 --> 00:06:35.920
You know, I think one of the only things that keeps me from getting bound up in stuff like that is that I've been lucky enough to be doing high-stakes work for a long enough time that I've had praise.
00:06:36.079 --> 00:06:36.800
I've been the hero.
00:06:36.959 --> 00:06:39.199
I've been, you know, at the top of the heap.
00:06:39.279 --> 00:06:41.920
So like it doesn't, it doesn't fill me up.
00:06:42.000 --> 00:06:44.879
Like I've had my moments of glory, right?
00:06:45.279 --> 00:06:49.040
Um, but for some people, I realize these are the only moments of glory that they get.
00:06:49.199 --> 00:06:54.800
And so that can be addictive, I guess.
00:06:56.079 --> 00:07:00.000
They want to be special really, really badly.
00:07:00.399 --> 00:07:08.879
They want to be special, they want to be the one, they want to in many ways be contrary.
00:07:08.959 --> 00:07:12.160
Like, I think a lot of what these people are is contrarians.
00:07:12.399 --> 00:07:18.879
And if you've been on the internet for five minutes, you know how many contrarians there are the the but actually people, right?
00:07:20.240 --> 00:07:22.240
Well, actually, it's this.
00:07:22.399 --> 00:07:24.480
And it's like, no, no, it's not.
00:07:24.639 --> 00:07:34.800
And I, you know, I do think a lot of them just fall flat into this category of, you know, everything looks like a conspiracy when you don't know how anything works.
00:07:35.279 --> 00:07:37.600
But they they dig in.
00:07:37.920 --> 00:07:39.439
The thing is that they don't stop.
00:07:39.600 --> 00:07:41.759
Nobody does it and then is like, oh, you know
what?
00:07:41.839 --> 00:07:42.800
I think I was wrong.
00:07:43.279 --> 00:07:46.000
When faced with new information, I think I was wrong.
00:07:46.160 --> 00:07:47.360
They don't back down.
00:07:47.759 --> 00:07:48.879
They dig in.
00:07:49.279 --> 00:07:54.160
And that's the curious part to me is why do they keep digging in?
00:07:54.319 --> 00:08:03.439
Because if you keep digging in, it is inevitable that you are going to start getting the feedback that what you are doing is affecting real life people.
00:08:04.399 --> 00:08:11.600
That what you're saying about Patrick Clancy is affecting his day-to-day life, his wife, right?
00:08:11.759 --> 00:08:12.959
His family members.
00:08:13.680 --> 00:08:19.199
If you are saying this about the parents of the Idaho Four, these people are hearing this.
00:08:19.680 --> 00:08:21.519
That they trafficked their children.
00:08:22.079 --> 00:08:24.160
One of whom is still alive, by the way.
00:08:25.360 --> 00:08:34.480
So you you have to turn a blind eye to or find some way to discount the fact that you're actively hurting people.
00:08:34.720 --> 00:08:37.759
And I think these people tell themselves, oh, well, I'm telling the truth.
00:08:37.840 --> 00:08:38.720
I'm a truth teller.
00:08:39.039 --> 00:08:42.720
I'm a truth teller, so I, you know, I absolutely have to.
00:08:45.440 --> 00:08:46.960
But call me a cynic.
00:08:47.919 --> 00:08:49.519
But I think there's more to it.
00:08:51.440 --> 00:09:03.279
I think it starts as a way to get attention, as a way to get positive reinforcement, as a way to feel special, right?
00:09:03.519 --> 00:09:06.480
As a way to be part of something.
00:09:07.360 --> 00:09:17.919
But for the people who dig in and the people who just continue on, ultimately, the ones who just will not stop, it's a grift.
00:09:18.639 --> 00:09:20.399
It becomes a grift.
00:09:20.879 --> 00:09:23.279
Because it becomes about views.
00:09:25.360 --> 00:09:28.799
You know, the more crazy you are, the more views you'll get.
00:09:29.039 --> 00:09:31.120
Because people are like, they said, what now?
00:09:31.279 --> 00:09:37.120
And you know, I I try really hard not to go and look, but sometimes it's like people are saying, what now?
00:09:38.480 --> 00:09:52.399
They realize if they didn't already know that the crazier stuff gets more views, that you now have like a carved-out community that will watch anything that you do because you've decided that you're a truth teller and you're the one they can trust.
00:09:52.639 --> 00:09:57.840
Go look at the comments on videos of these kind of people and see how many people say you're the only one I trust on this.
00:09:58.080 --> 00:09:59.120
It's scary.
00:10:01.600 --> 00:10:08.720
But inevitably, inevitably, there's a call for donation.
00:10:10.399 --> 00:10:15.600
There's a go fund me, there's a buy my product, there's something.
00:10:15.919 --> 00:10:19.759
It's always in the end a grift if they keep going.
00:10:20.240 --> 00:10:27.600
And once it gets to that point, then I know for sure that they know exactly what they are doing.
00:10:28.720 --> 00:10:33.519
And it doesn't mean that you can't ask people for money and have a righteous cause.
00:10:34.399 --> 00:11:01.679
But when your cause, and I'm making air quotes if you're listening to this, is to run completely contrary to what all of the professionals, lawyers, law enforcement, judges, witnesses, everyone, contrary to what all those people say, because you have a theory that you figured out while you are sitting on the toilet in your infinite wisdom.
00:11:04.240 --> 00:11:13.279
You and you continue to do it, even though you are constantly being um bombarded with information that disproves your theory, and you just keep going and keep going.
00:11:13.440 --> 00:11:17.039
Either you're a grifter or mentally you are unwell.
00:11:17.200 --> 00:11:18.080
Or both.
00:11:19.519 --> 00:11:21.120
That is my opinion.
00:11:22.240 --> 00:11:24.799
Now the question becomes: what do we do with these people?
00:11:25.039 --> 00:11:25.279
Right?
00:11:25.360 --> 00:11:26.480
What do we do about this problem?
00:11:26.639 --> 00:11:32.639
And what some people are doing is threatening to sue people for defamation.
00:11:33.200 --> 00:11:33.600
Right?
00:11:33.840 --> 00:11:37.600
Because it really is one of the only tools you've got.
00:11:37.679 --> 00:11:53.039
It might be the only real tool, legally speaking, that people have, because this is America, and we have incredibly broad free speech rights, and you're allowed to say crazy shit unless it meets very defined exceptions.
00:11:53.200 --> 00:11:59.840
One of which is that it's false and that saying it causes that person harm.
00:12:00.159 --> 00:12:13.519
And so you see C-synthesis letters going out from Patrick Clancy to certain creators, and you see C synthesis letters going out from uh content creators firm to people talking about the Idaho 4.
00:12:13.679 --> 00:12:23.600
And I think that those people are trying to do what they can to say, listen, you've crossed over the line.
00:12:24.720 --> 00:12:28.159
You've crossed over the line of legality, right?
00:12:28.320 --> 00:12:31.200
Because defamation has nothing to do with decency.
00:12:32.000 --> 00:12:36.720
Defamation doesn't litigate who's a good person or a bad person.
00:12:37.039 --> 00:12:41.360
Defamation litigates things that are true versus things that are false.
00:12:41.600 --> 00:12:44.559
And opinions cannot be defamatory.
00:12:45.360 --> 00:12:48.799
So they're telling people you have stepped over the legal line.
00:12:48.960 --> 00:12:52.799
So, legally speaking, you know, this is one of those areas that I think a lot about.
00:12:52.960 --> 00:12:53.759
Could we do it better?
00:12:53.919 --> 00:12:54.799
Should we do it better?
00:12:54.960 --> 00:12:58.960
What can we do in a society based on free speech, right?
00:12:59.120 --> 00:13:04.559
But I think that all of those things that are
going out are well intended.
00:13:05.600 --> 00:13:07.919
I think the question is, do they work?
00:13:09.360 --> 00:13:22.240
You know, a lot of these content creators, because they're so far down the rabbit hole, they're just going to make content out of it because it's a grift and or they're unwell.
00:13:23.759 --> 00:13:31.679
So a lot of the time they're going to say, great, I'll use this to make content, because they're just looking for reasons to keep their audience engaged.
00:13:31.840 --> 00:13:34.720
So it might be doing two things at once.
00:13:34.960 --> 00:13:43.279
It might be giving them a genuine legal threat, like you've crossed over the line here in terms of what the law allows, but also giving them fodder for content.
00:13:43.360 --> 00:13:44.879
And that's a really rough decision to make.
00:13:45.120 --> 00:13:47.840
I wouldn't want to be somebody who has to make that decision.
00:13:48.000 --> 00:13:52.320
I want to send them this letter because I want them to be scared enough to stop.
00:13:52.639 --> 00:13:56.559
But on the other hand, am I just giving them more content?
00:13:57.120 --> 00:13:59.840
It seems to be a really difficult decision.
00:14:00.720 --> 00:14:10.720
Um, you know, the the primary example of this, the most recent one, has been this call to Patrick Clancy's dad, which is bonkers.
00:14:11.600 --> 00:14:21.120
Um in legalese, at the end of this episode, I'm gonna talk about uh wiretapping laws and how they work, because there's been a lot of questions about them with this.
00:14:21.360 --> 00:14:31.840
But the idea that a woman in Florida called Patrick Clancy's father in Massachusetts.
00:14:32.080 --> 00:14:38.480
Take out this lunatic part where they say that he thought he hung up but he didn't, and then he confessed and knows that Patrick did it.
00:14:38.559 --> 00:14:43.600
And anyone with half a working ear can listen to it and know that's not what he said at all.
00:14:43.759 --> 00:14:46.399
Just the fact that she called him in the first place.
00:14:48.080 --> 00:14:50.000
What is that about?
00:14:50.159 --> 00:14:52.480
It feels like mental illness to me.
00:14:52.960 --> 00:14:56.799
That you think that you're entitled to do that.
00:14:57.840 --> 00:14:58.480
Right?
00:15:00.000 --> 00:15:08.240
And then, of course, the people in that community are going to be like, oh my God, oh my God, you know, that you're you're again, it's like this circle jerk, right?
00:15:08.399 --> 00:15:17.200
You've got your people who believe everything you say and they only trust you, and you just keep feeding them, you feed that monster, and the monster keeps eating and keeps eating and keeps eating.
00:15:17.919 --> 00:15:24.000
But I think for the rest of us, there's this question of what do we do with that?
00:15:25.360 --> 00:15:26.639
Do we comment on it?
00:15:26.799 --> 00:15:28.240
Do we tell them they're disgusting?
00:15:28.480 --> 00:15:31.519
Do we threaten to sue them if we're the kind of person who can?
00:15:33.279 --> 00:15:37.759
And conceptually, I feel like shame is the answer.
00:15:39.519 --> 00:15:42.799
I want to shame them and ignore them.
00:15:44.559 --> 00:15:45.200
Right?
00:15:45.519 --> 00:15:48.320
Because I don't want to step on anybody's rights to free speech.
00:15:48.399 --> 00:15:58.000
And yes, I have seen where there are some places that I think people are going over the line, and there's no legal violation in calling someone that you have no business calling, right?
00:15:58.080 --> 00:16:00.320
Like that doesn't violate a law in and of itself.
00:16:00.559 --> 00:16:11.519
It's shitty ass behavior, but it doesn't violate the law, but it does violate like a civility code that I would like to think many human beings live by.
00:16:13.120 --> 00:16:21.600
And I don't want to give people who do that any incentive to keep doing it.
00:16:21.759 --> 00:16:26.720
So I don't want to watch it, I don't want to listen to it, I don't want to comment on it.
00:16:27.840 --> 00:16:33.919
You know, ignoring them, putting them in the dark is probably the best way to stop it.
00:16:34.240 --> 00:16:36.559
How do you do that is the question.
00:16:37.840 --> 00:16:40.480
Do you, you know, do we all go around?
00:16:40.639 --> 00:16:44.639
Do we have like a group of, and this is a hypothetical question?
00:16:45.679 --> 00:16:55.919
Do we all like, you know, do I go on my channel with my 62,000 people and say every single person who's watching this video should block these people?
00:16:57.120 --> 00:17:04.319
So their videos are blocked from a huge swath, and then those people don't see them, so they don't forward them to like, is that what we do?
00:17:05.119 --> 00:17:11.200
Because I'm not sure the defamation threats are really working, and I'm not sure that they're all gonna ultimately be successful.
00:17:11.440 --> 00:17:19.440
And when you threaten litigation and then it doesn't work out, sometimes that emboldens the people that you've threatened.
00:17:19.680 --> 00:17:31.680
So put me down for uh those people suck, and I don't want to give them views, and I see what they're doing, and I know what their real motivations are, and it's not what they say they are.
00:17:32.000 --> 00:17:50.319
But as we see, you know, defamation cases like that, and then defamation cases regarding these really big celebrities, some of which I'm getting ready to talk about, they all kind of fall under the same issue, which is in 2026, what are we doing?
00:17:50.640 --> 00:18:01.599
What can we do with people who say inappropriate shit, especially when that inappropriate shit is online?
00:18:02.079 --> 00:18:04.559
And I think that is a very open question.
00:18:05.680 --> 00:18:18.000
And I think that if it gets litigated, this lawsuit that has been filed by Hassan Piker might be the case that helps us answer some of those, and I will tell you.
00:18:18.319 --> 00:18:21.759
But first, let's just get into general civil disorder.
00:18:22.000 --> 00:18:30.559
Brad and Angelina have a new judge, which is crazy because this case has been going on for ever.
00:18:31.200 --> 00:18:41.279
So a couple of weeks ago, there was a questionnaire that was put on the docket for the parties to fill out called the Complex Case Questionnaire.
00:18:41.680 --> 00:18:49.200
And it appears that LA's Superior Court has like a complex designation that certain cases can get.
00:18:49.279 --> 00:18:52.640
And I've seen this in a lot of other civil courts.
00:18:52.880 --> 00:18:57.839
Um, sometimes it's called business court, sometimes it's called complex matters, right?
00:18:57.920 --> 00:18:59.839
It can be called lots of different things.
00:19:00.079 --> 00:19:12.559
And it is a way for state courts to split up cases that are more complicated legally from a lot of your sort of standard civil cases.
00:19:12.720 --> 00:19:24.000
Most cases that are filed in state courts, most civil cases are like car accidents, foreclosures, slip and falls, you know, that kind of stuff.
00:19:24.160 --> 00:19:28.160
They're not all these big complicated business issues.
00:19:28.799 --> 00:19:43.200
And I think what happened with Brad and Angelina's case, which remember is actually between the companies that own the portions of Chateau Miraval, Brad's company and Angelina's company.
00:19:44.240 --> 00:19:47.279
And eventually, or originally it was just between the two of them.
00:19:47.440 --> 00:19:57.599
It has over time become more complex because Angelina counterclaimed, basically just saying, like, I want to be able to take Discovery myself, too, that what you said is not true.
00:19:57.759 --> 00:20:00.559
It's sort of the my cousin Vinny opening statement, right?
00:20:01.039 --> 00:20:05.200
Her whole, her whole counterclaim is everything that guy said is bullshit, right?
00:20:05.680 --> 00:20:14.799
Um, but then Brad wanted to start bringing in some of the Russians that she sold her portion of Miraval to.
00:20:15.440 --> 00:20:28.640
Some of these French companies were brought in that were sort of third-party players, and there were cross claims and claims between defendants, and it has now gotten complex enough that I think they had to pull it and put it in complex court.
00:20:28.880 --> 00:20:31.839
I don't think that means a whole lot substantively.
00:20:32.000 --> 00:20:46.079
I did talk to a little girl attorney in addition to reading up on this, and she said it usually just means that like you get your single judge, and this judge is like their job is to make the case more efficient, to move it through the system faster.
00:20:46.240 --> 00:20:58.400
Um, what I saw on LA's website is that they put a lot of class actions in there, like big asbestos cases, you know, where you've got, you know, 30,000 plaintiffs or whatever.
00:20:58.559 --> 00:21:01.920
There's a there's a need for there to constantly be hearings.
00:21:02.079 --> 00:21:05.519
Instead of waiting and trying to set a hearing
and see when the judge is available.
00:21:05.680 --> 00:21:09.519
If you can get into a specialty court like this, sometimes it's like, okay, you can move things along.
00:21:09.599 --> 00:21:14.880
It's like we're gonna meet every two weeks, and every two weeks we're gonna say, what's going on with this and what's going on with that, and are we ready for this?
00:21:14.960 --> 00:21:15.440
And right.
00:21:15.599 --> 00:21:34.240
So it sounds like it might get that treatment, which will be very interesting considering that this case is technically on a trial docket for 2027, but the five-year mark of the case being filed happens in February of 2027.
00:21:35.119 --> 00:21:43.200
And as of February at five years, Angelina Jolie has the right to just make a motion with the court to say, this case has been pending for five years.
00:21:43.279 --> 00:21:47.440
He clearly doesn't want to go to trial, just drop the whole thing and kick the case out and dismiss it.
00:21:47.759 --> 00:21:49.359
She can ask for that.
00:21:50.400 --> 00:21:58.640
She has said thus far that she won't as long as they continue on the discovery and summary judgment plan that they have laid out.
00:21:58.720 --> 00:21:59.759
But if he blinks at all.
00:22:00.720 --> 00:22:02.319
She's going to exercise that right.
00:22:02.480 --> 00:22:05.119
So it seems like the pressure's kind of on here.
00:22:05.279 --> 00:22:06.480
Maybe on both sides.
00:22:06.640 --> 00:22:16.799
If they're going to get into this court, they've got this deadline looming in 2027, and now they're going to get in front of a judge who's going to be available and pushing them all the time to get this fucking case moving.
00:22:16.880 --> 00:22:21.119
It sounds like this case is going to have to do a do or die here pretty soon.
00:22:21.359 --> 00:22:23.599
So I will keep my eye on it.
00:22:24.079 --> 00:22:41.759
As for Miss Amy Griffin, the case about the woman who wrote her supposed memoir where she recovered memories of sexual abuse when she was in middle school, and then someone has now sued her saying those weren't Amy's memories, they were mine.
00:22:42.079 --> 00:22:43.440
There are now two cases, right?
00:22:43.519 --> 00:22:45.839
There's the one in Los Angeles, the original case.
00:22:45.920 --> 00:22:52.480
There's another one in Nevada where Amy countersued this woman for defamation.
00:22:52.960 --> 00:22:56.240
Um, we're kind of in a holding pattern with both.
00:22:56.880 --> 00:23:15.200
But I wanted to do a mental exercise because I think that this case is a lot like the lively Baldone case, where, at least for me, where early on I'm looking at the facts and I'm looking at the allegations and I'm looking at the legal arguments, and I'm like, okay, this is kind of 50-50 for me, right?
00:23:15.279 --> 00:23:21.839
Like I can see like what if there's evidence of this, or what if there's evidence of that, and okay, I want to hear what this person has to say about this.
00:23:23.039 -->
00:23:50.559
But what started to change my mind about the strength of Lively's case was how her lawyers were litigating it, what they were doing, the choices they were making, the things that they were willing to do and say, opened my eyes to whether this was actually as strong a case as they wanted you to believe, or whether the strength was a cover for something.
00:23:52.400 --> 00:23:59.440
And I will admit I get very judgmental about lawyers taking ethical leaps that I myself wouldn't take.
00:23:59.599 --> 00:24:07.440
And so Van Zan was a big eye-opener for me there, and the creator subpoenas were a big eye-opener for me there.
00:24:07.759 --> 00:24:16.000
And I've paid a lot of attention with the Amy Griffin case, particularly the original one, with how her lawyers were litigating it.
00:24:16.160 --> 00:24:24.319
And from the beginning, right, it's been full force, super aggressive, balls to the wall, like that's who she hired.
00:24:24.480 --> 00:24:35.039
Um, Alex Weingarten, this guy she uh hired from Wilkie for the LA case, you know, represented Jamie Spears and David Miscavige, like you, you know, she got that guy on purpose.
00:24:35.200 --> 00:24:38.960
Find me the guy who will rip everybody's head off, which she has tried to do.
00:24:39.279 --> 00:24:48.559
But it got me just thinking about the thought experiment of what if what if Amy had responded differently from the beginning?
00:24:48.880 --> 00:24:58.160
Would it change my mind in terms of whether I it's almost like um in criminal law, you know, you have consciousness of guilt, right?
00:24:58.240 --> 00:25:03.279
Where you can show evidence of how somebody behaved afterwards to show consciousness of their guilt.
00:25:03.359 --> 00:25:15.279
I mean, we're not dealing with guilt and innocence here, but the way that she uh litigates things to me is so unbelievably telling, the things that she fights and the things that she doesn't fight and the things that she turns over and doesn't turn over.
00:25:15.519 --> 00:25:20.960
So I thought that I would do a little thought experiment in this episode and you guys let me know what you think.
00:25:21.039 --> 00:25:25.440
But sort of like, what if it had happened this way instead?
00:25:25.759 --> 00:25:33.920
So clear your mind if you can and try to take yourself back to the New York Times.
00:25:34.240 --> 00:25:37.119
Guess I know we weren't all following it then, but just go with me.
00:25:37.279 --> 00:25:39.680
Um, the book comes out, it's a raving success.
00:25:39.839 --> 00:25:47.200
The New York Times starts digging into this and finds out that there was some undisclosed information about the MDMA and maybe some other things.
00:25:47.359 --> 00:25:47.680
Okay.
00:25:47.839 --> 00:25:49.359
So go back with me to that.
00:25:49.680 --> 00:25:50.000
Okay.
00:25:50.559 --> 00:26:16.480
So in the New York Times article, The Billionaire of the Psychedelics in the Best Selling Moment, what if Thomas Clare, who was representing
Amy Griffin at the time in this matter, would have said to the New York Times, it'd been quoted in the New York Times as saying, it sounds like more than one woman was the victim of this predator or of this school.
00:26:17.119 --> 00:26:35.599
We'd be really interested in speaking to Jane Doe to see if we can pool our resources to find out if there are any facts that she can share that might assist Miss Griffin in helping bring this person or people involved to justice?
00:26:36.000 --> 00:26:44.640
He had said that instead of saying the Times has been duped by a fabulist, she's a lying sack of shit.
00:26:44.799 --> 00:26:48.160
What if instead he had said something like that?
00:26:49.119 --> 00:26:57.200
What if after that Amy had actually then made some record of, or have her lawyer do it?
00:26:57.359 --> 00:27:23.039
Have Thomas Clare make a record and call Jane Doe or email her or call whoever and say, hey, Miss Griffin would like to offer you for free the use of her investigators that she's been paying for low these many years, um, to try to investigate your assault to see if we can put together uh some sort of common facts here.
00:27:23.200 --> 00:27:24.480
We'd love to talk to you.
00:27:24.640 --> 00:27:38.559
Now keep in mind, if they did that, they would have been able to talk to Jane Doe and find out what her story was going to be in the litigation, if there were any.
00:27:39.200 --> 00:27:46.160
Whereas when they said the Times was duped by a fabulist and she was a liar and a grifter, she was never gonna talk to them.
00:27:46.319 --> 00:27:50.000
What if they had said, how about we send somebody to talk to you?
00:27:52.640 --> 00:27:56.720
What if when Jane Doe did sue?
00:27:56.880 --> 00:28:01.440
Um, let's just say that Amy Griffin said, I do want to do some discovery.
00:28:01.519 --> 00:28:11.599
I think it's appropriate here, not the way that they did it, but you know, Your Honor, I think that it's appropriate that we do some discovery before this anti-slap thing because we want to make sure that we have all the information here.
00:28:11.920 --> 00:28:18.400
And what if in response to the discovery that Jane Doe sent, Amy had given her the postcard?
00:28:18.640 --> 00:28:21.119
Even if she hadn't given her Claudia's name.
00:28:21.359 --> 00:28:26.880
Even if she said, I'm really reluctant to involve this third-party person and I'm not really sure that that's the right thing to do here.
00:28:26.960 --> 00:28:28.640
But here's the postcard, you can have it.
00:28:28.880 --> 00:28:30.960
What's the worst that would have happened?
00:28:31.279 --> 00:28:35.440
Jane Doe would have said, I didn't send that postcard, that's not my handwriting.
00:28:35.839 --> 00:28:37.599
She's gonna say that.
00:28:37.920 --> 00:28:39.519
What's the difference?
00:28:40.079 --> 00:28:42.000
Why hide it from her?
00:28:42.319 --> 00:28:54.720
What if other people in Amarillo, Texas, had actually gone to the like listening center that Amy Griffin had set up?
00:28:54.960 --> 00:29:06.079
You know, she she paid, she made a big donation to uh, I guess the police department ultimately, the sort of a community center to create this space where women can go and tell their stories in this official way.
00:29:06.160 --> 00:29:09.279
So they only have to tell the story of their abuse once.
00:29:09.519 --> 00:29:16.480
And as of the time the New York Times article was written in late 2025, literally not a single person had ever used it.
00:29:16.799 --> 00:29:28.960
What if Amy Griffin paid some people to go over there and tell stories and say, yeah, this happened to me, but I don't remember who, and I don't remember nothing that could be investigated.
00:29:29.519 --> 00:29:36.000
Now, I'm not encouraging hiring people to do lying to the police.
00:29:36.400 --> 00:29:53.440
But the point I'm trying to make is I think there's a way that Amy Griffin could have handled this, could have gotten the result that she wanted, or, you know, could have certainly not done any worse than she's done without looking like a bully.
00:29:53.759 --> 00:29:55.920
Because that's what she looks like.
00:29:56.480 --> 00:30:11.200
And I think what really drew me back to this was I went back and was reading the article that was in the cut about what if there were two different men who abused two different women at the same middle school at the same time.
00:30:11.440 --> 00:30:13.440
Which is unlikely but plausible, right?
00:30:13.519 --> 00:30:14.240
Like it could happen.
00:30:14.319 --> 00:30:21.759
And I was reading the comments, and I was reading the comments of all the people who, you know, don't know much about the case.
00:30:21.920 --> 00:30:30.480
They're reading it blind, and I think they came to the conclusion that the the piece hoped they would come to, which is it seems kind of crazy, but I guess it's possible, right?
00:30:30.880 --> 00:30:32.000
Which it is.
00:30:32.480 --> 00:30:46.960
But here's the thing we know from the way that Amy handled the New York Times article, what happened after it, and discovery that she was asked to turn over in the case.
00:30:47.200 --> 00:31:01.359
We know that this whole idea that there were two assailants is something that either didn't occur to her until recently, or she didn't fucking care.
00:31:01.920 --> 00:31:09.440
Because if that were a possibility, why not act as if that were a possibility at the very fucking beginning?
00:31:09.759 --> 00:31:14.720
Now, maybe she got bad PR advice, maybe she got bad legal advice.
00:31:14.880 --> 00:31:23.519
I am starting to believe that she is one of those folks, again, this is kind of a corollary, it seems, to Reynolds and Lively, that they don't listen to the people around them.
00:31:23.839 --> 00:31:31.599
But why not come out with this whole I guess it happened to both of us thing in October of 2025 to the New York Times?
00:31:31.759 --> 00:31:33.920
She had a couple of different choices there.
00:31:34.319 --> 00:31:40.240
And she chose the one of this bitch is a lying grifter.
00:31:41.200 --> 00:31:42.559
That's the one she chose.
00:31:43.759 --> 00:31:45.599
And now she can't take it back.
00:31:46.559 --> 00:31:49.839
And she's continued to push that narrative ever since.
00:31:50.079 --> 00:31:51.759
And now she can't really change it.
00:31:52.160 --> 00:32:06.319
You know, most recently, remember how at the beginning of the case Jane Doe filed a motion to be anonymous, but then like it expired because her lawyers didn't get it, you know, set up for hearing.
00:32:06.400 --> 00:32:13.839
And literally the day it expired, Amy Griffin's lawyers are like, here's her name, here's who she is, here's where she lives.
00:32:14.640 --> 00:32:20.160
Well, she had Jane Doe has now refiled that motion to say, hey, I I want to do it this time.
00:32:20.240 --> 00:32:22.000
For the rest of this case, I just don't want.
00:32:22.960 --> 00:32:24.319
My name being used.
00:32:24.559 --> 00:32:29.839
And Amy Griffin's people, after all of this, are fighting that motion.
00:32:30.319 --> 00:32:36.240
Their tactics, this is where the law and PR really intersect.
00:32:36.400 --> 00:32:39.920
This is where like this gets really interesting to me.
00:32:40.400 --> 00:32:59.440
As I feel like there's nobody who is looking at this situation and being like, okay, you can take this legal position, but you can't act as if a legal position isn't ultimately also going to be a PR position because people can read this shit.
00:32:59.680 --> 00:33:10.480
And you are going to come off as if you are attacking this woman with all of your money and all of your resources and all of your fortune and all of your famous friends.
00:33:10.720 --> 00:33:16.240
And even if that is a good legal position for you to take, that has PR consequences.
00:33:16.480 --> 00:33:18.079
How can we deliver this?
00:33:18.319 --> 00:33:22.559
Either no one's telling her that or she's not listening to the people that are.
00:33:23.599 --> 00:33:34.480
Because I don't know about you, but if this had started, if I had picked up the complaint in whenever it was, somebody sent me a DM and was like, hey, you should check out this case.
00:33:34.559 --> 00:33:37.119
And I was like, oh, whatever, because people do that to me all the time.
00:33:37.279 --> 00:33:40.000
And I opened it up and my mouth was a gape.
00:33:40.079 --> 00:33:44.640
I remember sitting on my couch being like, This is the fucking craziest shit I've ever seen in my life, this case.
00:33:45.039 --> 00:33:49.519
So then I went back and started reading, and I went back and read that New York Times article.
00:33:50.000 --> 00:33:55.119
And if that article had said in it, wow, this is crazy.
00:33:55.279 --> 00:33:56.720
We think there might be two.
00:33:57.359 --> 00:34:03.119
Or if her response to the complaint indicated, hey, there might be two.
00:34:04.559 --> 00:34:19.280
Or anything she did or said, or her reps did
or said at any point between October of 2025 and when that cut article came out in what was it, September, said there might be two.
00:34:19.440 --> 00:34:24.719
I might believe that she thought there might be two, but it's too fucking late for me.
00:34:25.360 --> 00:34:37.599
Because I saw her label this woman a grifter and a liar, and I saw her refuse to turn over information that she herself placed at issue in the case.
00:34:40.000 --> 00:34:51.599
And I saw her not even think of the fact that, hey, maybe this woman knows something that could help me.
00:34:51.840 --> 00:34:58.079
But the only reason that wouldn't occur to her is because if she already knows everything about Jane Doe's story.
00:34:59.840 --> 00:35:00.239
Right?
00:35:00.639 --> 00:35:02.400
I don't know what can be done about it now.
00:35:02.880 --> 00:35:05.440
And I still don't know how the case is gonna turn out.
00:35:05.920 --> 00:35:08.639
I don't know whether Jane Doe can prove these things.
00:35:08.719 --> 00:35:09.599
I truly don't.
00:35:10.239 --> 00:35:11.360
It's a hard one.
00:35:12.239 --> 00:35:34.480
Um and I'm I'm still not on a side per se, but I gotta tell you, as I say all the time, there is nothing that Amy Griffin has done that has made me feel as if she is a person who has been just completely misunderstood and that some crazy person that she went to middle school with is out to get her.
00:35:34.639 --> 00:35:37.519
That is not how she is reacting.
00:35:37.760 --> 00:35:46.320
And how she is reacting absolutely goes into the credibility of her story because this whole case comes down to who do you believe?
00:35:46.559 --> 00:35:53.679
You know, if she thought it would go away if she told the New York Times, ah, this is all fake.
00:35:53.840 --> 00:35:55.119
This woman's crazy.
00:35:55.360 --> 00:36:04.559
I mean, the the wording that Thomas Clare used, duped by a fabulist, is very old school for someone as young as he is.
00:36:05.280 --> 00:36:08.320
But maybe they thought, you know, let's let's nip this shit in the bud.
00:36:08.480 --> 00:36:09.679
And it didn't work.
00:36:10.880 --> 00:36:12.559
It didn't work at all.
00:36:13.119 --> 00:36:33.760
So here we are waiting to find out what's gonna happen with the claims in California, whether they're gonna get moved to Nevada, and we're gonna find out what happens with the anti-slap motion that Jane Doe has filed in Nevada to have that defamation case thrown out.
00:36:33.920 --> 00:36:36.079
I think she has a pretty good argument, right?
00:36:36.320 --> 00:36:41.039
Talking to the news media is definitely protected speech.
00:36:41.599 --> 00:36:54.559
So the only real question is did Jane Doe, is there evidence that Jane Doe stated provable falsities to the New York Times about her own life, by the way?
00:36:54.719 --> 00:36:55.840
It's a hard rota hoe.
00:36:56.000 --> 00:36:57.039
It's not possible, but it's hard.
00:36:57.360 --> 00:37:03.840
I want to talk briefly about a filing that
was made in the Jones versus Abel case that I find fascinating.
00:37:04.000 --> 00:37:06.000
I've been following that case like loosely.
00:37:06.159 --> 00:37:21.679
I know that in the last week or so there was this hearing on the sanctions motion with regard to Melissa Nathan as to whether you know Jones and Jones works and her new lawyers are trying to say that Melissa Nathan committed perjury and she should be sanctioned for that and whatever.
00:37:21.920 --> 00:37:32.320
Um and, you know, I believe on YouTube um Bocci and Carol had a conversation about that, and Clark, who went to the hearing, was there.
00:37:32.400 --> 00:37:36.079
So I still need to go and listen to everything that Clark had to say.
00:37:36.559 --> 00:37:39.760
But what happened after the hearing, I think, is also really interesting.
00:37:39.920 --> 00:37:48.000
So apparently, you know, as is very common during hearings, someone will bring something up and the judge will go, you know what, provide supplemental briefing on that.
00:37:48.159 --> 00:37:51.920
Or, hey, can you, you know, send that case over to my office when you're done?
00:37:52.000 --> 00:37:53.519
Or I'm not sure I'm aware of that document.
00:37:53.599 --> 00:37:58.400
Can you make sure you get it to my chambers that you follow up with the judge after a hearing?
00:37:58.559 --> 00:38:12.400
And the judge had asked Jones Works to follow up with something, and they kind of like overdid it, and they followed up and made all this argument about all of these different issues that had arisen in the sanctions motion.
00:38:12.639 --> 00:38:21.440
And so Nathan and uh that side of the case was like, well, I guess we have to respond to it because now we have new argument that's out there.
00:38:21.599 --> 00:38:26.320
So they filed their own response and we're like, here's all our counterarguments to their arguments.
00:38:26.400 --> 00:38:32.880
But then they attached a document that if I've seen it before, I don't remember it, that I find fascinating.
00:38:33.119 --> 00:38:40.480
Because remember that the whole issue with this Melissa Nathan lied thing, right, is about these websites.
00:38:40.719 --> 00:38:51.920
And Katie Case apparently testified that Melissa Nathan would have her right copy and that that copy would show up on these websites about Stephanie Jones.
00:38:52.719 --> 00:38:57.840
And Melissa Nathan denies this and says that Katie Case is lying or misunderstands or something, right?
00:38:57.920 --> 00:39:01.760
So we have this whole factual dispute about what happened.
00:39:02.639 --> 00:39:13.760
But what was filed after the hearing was a set of messages between Stephanie Jones and Tara Hanks.
00:39:15.360 --> 00:39:23.920
Tara Hanks being the president of Wayfarer Studios, um, in July of 2024.
00:39:24.400 --> 00:39:37.599
And in July of 2024, Tara Hanks messages Stephanie Jones, and it's just the two of them, and says, Hey, we've decided to hire Melissa Nathan as our crisis person.
00:39:38.000 --> 00:39:41.599
They call it scenario planning, but we know what that means.
00:39:42.719 --> 00:39:44.639
We worked with her at CAA.
00:39:45.199 --> 00:39:46.159
We like her.
00:39:46.480 --> 00:39:48.559
We're signing an NDA.
00:39:49.039 --> 00:39:53.440
Um, Jamie and I talked to her just wanted to let you know that that's what we decided to do.
00:39:53.599 --> 00:40:02.000
So here's Tara Hanks at Wayfair saying, Jamie and I've decided to hire Melissa to do, you know, to have somebody ready in case we need some crisis PR, right?
00:40:02.079 --> 00:40:03.440
And she's telling Stephanie.
00:40:03.599 --> 00:40:10.239
And Stephanie's response is Jen Abel recommended her, I'm sure, right?
00:40:11.119 --> 00:40:16.400
Immediately goes to Jen, because remember, this is the time when Jen is leaving, and then says, that's disappointing.
00:40:16.639 --> 00:40:22.239
And basically, Stephanie's response to this, you know, sort of one message after the other is you shouldn't do this.
00:40:22.480 --> 00:40:24.159
Melissa Nathan's a terrible person.
00:40:24.320 --> 00:40:25.679
Jen shouldn't have talked you into this.
00:40:25.840 --> 00:40:26.960
This is all Jen's fault.
00:40:27.119 --> 00:40:30.480
You didn't include Jen on this because she knows already, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
00:40:30.800 --> 00:40:32.239
But here's the interesting part.
00:40:32.480 --> 00:40:42.159
So you get down to where Stephanie's giving more detail about why she doesn't like Melissa Nathan.
00:40:42.239 --> 00:40:45.119
And she tells Tara Hanks, we've had a lot of issues with her.
00:40:45.280 --> 00:40:52.880
And then the next message is my cybersecurity guys found her behind the site.
00:40:53.679 --> 00:40:55.760
It's a long story.
00:40:56.239 --> 00:41:21.119
So what this was filed for, the the note that was given in the response by uh Melissa Nathan and Abel and Wayfarer in this case is Stephanie Jones, Your Honor, is up here trying to get you to sanction Melissa Nathan for not giving all the information about who was behind the websites.
00:41:21.360 --> 00:41:28.079
The problem is that Stephanie Jones said in July 2024 that she knew exactly who was behind the websites.
00:41:28.239 --> 00:41:31.440
So why was Stephanie Jones even doing Discovery on this?
00:41:31.599 --> 00:41:34.559
Why was she suing Jane Doe's one through 10?
00:41:34.880 --> 00:41:40.719
She was telling Tara Hanks in July of 2024 that she knew Melissa did it.
00:41:41.039 --> 00:41:42.320
How did she know?
00:41:42.559 --> 00:41:43.920
Where's that evidence?
00:41:44.079 --> 00:41:47.440
This is all a red herring, none of this shit matters.
00:41:48.239 --> 00:41:53.920
And what is so interesting to me about this is I wonder if she really did know.
00:41:54.400 --> 00:41:56.400
Or I wonder if she lied to Tara.
00:41:56.800 --> 00:42:01.760
Did Stephanie Jones really know in July of 2024?
00:42:02.320 --> 00:42:13.840
Long before she sued, long before she brought
claims saying, I'm going to send subpoenas to find out who is behind these sites because these have ruined my reputation and I need to know.
00:42:14.000 --> 00:42:15.599
Did she actually know?
00:42:15.840 --> 00:42:17.440
Or did she just think?
00:42:17.840 --> 00:42:19.519
Was she pretty sure?
00:42:19.760 --> 00:42:24.480
And so she told Tara, oh, I know it was her, when actually it wasn't.
00:42:25.920 --> 00:42:27.199
Or maybe wasn't.
00:42:27.280 --> 00:42:29.519
She did at least didn't know for sure.
00:42:30.719 --> 00:42:51.360
And of course that's important because if Stephanie Jones is a big fat liar, and Stephanie Jones was telling big fat lies, or at best, gross exaggerations to the people at Wayfair, then she certainly wasn't acting as their PR agent anymore, was she?
00:42:51.599 --> 00:43:02.079
She certainly can't be suing them, suing them for violating their duty of loyalty and client behavior to her.
00:43:02.559 --> 00:43:04.639
So that I find very interesting.
00:43:04.719 --> 00:43:06.239
I wonder what Tara has to say about.
00:43:07.119 --> 00:43:21.920
In the field of defamation, because pretty soon I'm just gonna have to turn this into the defamation podcast, um, there's, you know, all these cases flying around because this is what, again, this is really the only avenue that people have when somebody says something shitty about you online.
00:43:22.079 --> 00:43:31.039
And I did that whole video on the Hassan Piker case, and I've actually been digging more into the recent case law on like video manipulation and deep fakes.
00:43:31.199 --> 00:43:39.760
And it's so interesting that I'm going to do a full-scale, like long-form YouTube video about it this week because I think the issues are absolutely fascinating.
00:43:40.719 --> 00:43:56.400
But I was also checking on the Tyra Banks case, where Tyra Banks is suing Netflix for what she claims is defamation for the way that she was edited in the America's Next Top Model Victor documentary.
00:43:56.559 --> 00:43:59.760
She claims she was edited to look as if she knew that someone had been sexually assaulted.
00:44:00.159 --> 00:44:00.880
And did not care.
00:44:01.039 --> 00:44:06.400
And I think it's really helpful to put those two cases up against each other as a compare and contrast situation, right?
00:44:06.639 --> 00:44:18.079
Because you've got Tyra claiming that the editing was manipulated to make her look as if she was insensitive to something.
00:44:18.320 --> 00:44:31.199
And then you've got Hassan saying he was edited to make it look as if something that he was saying to mock someone was actually his real beliefs.
00:44:31.360 --> 00:44:40.800
And, you know, the problem with both of those arguments, with both of their cases, is where's the false statement effect?
00:44:41.199 --> 00:44:44.880
Because defamation has to be a statement of fact.
00:44:45.119 --> 00:44:50.800
And I think Hassan probably has a better case because he's got the faulty headline, right?
00:44:51.039 --> 00:45:09.440
Hassan has that not only does he claim that this video clip was manipulated to take things out and make him look like he was in favor of lynchings, but that there's a headline on it that attributes to him a quote in quotation marks that is not something that he ever actually says.
00:45:09.679 --> 00:45:12.960
So that is probably better for false statement of fact.
00:45:13.199 --> 00:45:20.559
But both of these cases suffer from the same problem, which is that, yes, there is such a thing as defamation by implication, right?
00:45:21.119 --> 00:45:24.960
By saying what you're saying, you're implying something about someone.
00:45:25.199 --> 00:45:33.519
But it seems to me that they they both kind of highlight this issue of like, what do you do about a bad edit?
00:45:33.840 --> 00:45:45.760
What do you do when someone, you know, you've given someone the right to utilize your interview, your voice, your words, right?
00:45:45.840 --> 00:45:49.440
Like Tyler, Tyra signed up for that documentary and said, yep.
00:45:49.599 --> 00:45:53.519
And she, you know, said, you guys have final editing power.
00:45:53.840 --> 00:45:59.920
Hassan Piker gets on Twitch, says these things, he's put them out there into the public sphere for people to do with what they want.
00:46:00.159 --> 00:46:17.679
Where's the how do you tie false statements of fact to something like that when the person isn't really, when the person who's publishing the modified material isn't really trying to speak in facts, right?
00:46:18.239 --> 00:46:24.719
I think what we're gonna see from Scott Jennings in the Hassan Piker case is number one, uh, somebody on my staff did that.
00:46:24.800 --> 00:46:25.920
I had no idea that they did that.
00:46:26.079 --> 00:46:28.480
And number two, uh, this is how I see him.
00:46:28.559 --> 00:46:29.199
This is my opinion.
00:46:29.440 --> 00:46:30.960
I don't know whether that'll fly.
00:46:31.119 --> 00:46:34.559
But there's definitely this huge hole in the law, right?
00:46:35.119 --> 00:46:46.079
Where false statements of fact, that is a definition for defamation, might not be enough in our day and age.
00:46:46.320 --> 00:46:48.079
And I don't know how we solve that problem.
00:46:48.159 --> 00:46:49.519
I'm thinking a lot about it these days.
00:46:49.599 --> 00:46:51.840
If anybody has any ideas, let me know.
00:46:52.159 --> 00:46:59.679
But, you know, I don't think that Tyra's gonna be successful because it's an edit.
00:46:59.920 --> 00:47:03.920
Like, you know, it's the same way that everybody gets edited on reality television.
00:47:04.079 --> 00:47:05.840
They're like, I'm not the villain, that's my edit.
00:47:06.079 --> 00:47:06.400
Okay.
00:47:06.960 --> 00:47:16.800
But should there be an avenue to say, all right, maybe you didn't make a false statement of fact, but the way you portrayed me is not accurate.
00:47:16.960 --> 00:47:19.440
That's what false light is supposed to be.
00:47:19.599 -->
00:47:22.079
That's only available in a couple of states.
00:47:22.880 --> 00:47:25.920
And most of them plead that as an alternative to defamation.
00:47:26.079 --> 00:47:32.159
But maybe false light law needs to be beefed up a little bit because that's really what this is.
00:47:32.400 --> 00:47:38.400
It's not necessarily that you made a statement of fact that isn't true, it's that you made me look in a way that I'm not.
00:47:38.559 --> 00:47:47.119
And if you can prove that they did that, and that that then caused you harm and that you've suffered damages, that should be a civil claim.
00:47:47.440 --> 00:47:47.920
Right?
00:47:48.320 --> 00:47:48.800
I don't know.
00:47:48.880 --> 00:47:49.360
Think about that.
00:47:49.440 --> 00:47:50.480
Tell me what you guys think.
00:47:50.719 --> 00:47:56.320
On Miss Candace Owens, um, listen, Candace gonna Candace, okay?
00:47:57.440 --> 00:48:01.840
She is who she is, and she's gonna do what she do.
00:48:02.159 --> 00:48:15.760
Um, what's interesting to me is this defamation case is still very much live against her companies, which, as I said in my standalone video on this, I think that was always gonna be the case.
00:48:15.840 --> 00:48:19.360
I don't think Candace is the individual who's ever gonna be liable for this stuff.
00:48:19.599 --> 00:48:25.840
Um, but in her public statement, she says this was never about the gender identity allegations.
00:48:25.920 --> 00:48:29.599
This was about the whatever she calls it, the people who talk about this die, right?
00:48:29.679 --> 00:48:32.559
Because some French journalists talked about this and then wound up dead.
00:48:32.800 --> 00:48:45.840
She needs to do that because the way that the judge framed the one remaining issue forces her to try to say this isn't an issue of gender identity.
00:48:46.159 --> 00:49:03.119
Because whether the statute, the French statute of limitations, can be extended to allow the Macrones to properly and timely file this claim, is entirely dependent on whether the judge finds it to be defamation based on gender identity.
00:49:03.840 --> 00:49:11.360
And so after all this time and all these comments and all this they'll never stop me, and all this I'll never back down Candace stuff.
00:49:11.679 --> 00:49:15.760
Now she's saying, Oh, this was never about the gender identity stuff, which just isn't true.
00:49:15.920 --> 00:49:20.960
And I have said in my videos, here's the part of the complaint where they say a statement about Mrs.
00:49:21.119 --> 00:49:25.119
McCron being born a man, and that that is one of the statements that they are suing over.
00:49:25.280 --> 00:49:26.800
But she's trying to flip the script.
00:49:27.039 --> 00:49:32.880
And I think what's so interesting about this for me is that she thinks she's being slick, Candace.
00:49:33.840 --> 00:49:41.920
Um, you know, I understand her brand is to be afraid of nothing and to say the thing and do the thing, no matter how embarrassing it is.
00:49:42.000
--> 00:49:43.840
You know, she's a shock jock, right?
00:49:43.920 --> 00:49:44.880
I get it.
00:49:45.840 --> 00:49:54.079
But she must be pretty scared for her to actually tweet out, I was never being sued over the gender stuff.
00:49:54.239 --> 00:50:01.519
Because isn't that her whole thing that like that is absolute fact, and I will stand on that until the day I die.
00:50:01.679 --> 00:50:03.199
That is absolutely true.
00:50:03.440 --> 00:50:06.239
Come at me, I will fucking prove it to you.
00:50:06.480 --> 00:50:07.920
Isn't that her whole bag?
00:50:08.000 --> 00:50:12.000
And now she's like, well, it was never about gender because she doesn't want to be sued over it.
00:50:12.159 --> 00:50:13.599
She wants the case to go away.
00:50:13.840 --> 00:50:15.360
So she's not fooling me.
00:50:15.519 --> 00:50:16.960
Hopefully, now she's not fooling you either.
00:50:17.119 --> 00:50:20.559
So for legalese, let's talk about wiretapping laws.
00:50:20.719 --> 00:50:27.760
Because a lot is being said about wiretapping laws after some idiot called Patrick Clancy's father.
00:50:28.400 --> 00:50:30.079
And a lot of it is wrong.
00:50:30.320 --> 00:50:42.159
I think the best way to understand wiretapping laws is that you kind of have to reverse understand what they were actually for versus what we think about them for.
00:50:42.400 --> 00:50:47.440
So wiretapping laws originally were an evidence problem.
00:50:47.599 --> 00:51:03.039
They were solving an evidence problem because people were being recorded with or without their knowledge, and that was then being used against them as evidence in mostly criminal cases, but also some civil cases.
00:51:03.280 --> 00:51:22.079
And so it is a part of the evidence code of most state jurisdictions, and I believe the federal evidence code, I haven't looked in a while at that issue, that if a recording is not properly obtained under whatever the applicable law is, you cannot use it as evidence.
00:51:22.159 --> 00:51:24.719
It's an admissibility thing, right?
00:51:24.960 --> 00:51:34.880
Because it's not reliable, because the person didn't know, it violates their rights if the proper consent wasn't given, depending on what state's laws apply.
00:51:35.519 --> 00:51:52.079
So if I confess to you that yes, I did commit this murder and you record me surreptitiously in a two-party consent state, that recording shouldn't be allowed to be used against me in my murder trial.
00:51:52.559 --> 00:51:52.880
Right?
00:51:53.039 --> 00:51:56.639
Because it violates my rights, because I had no idea you were recording it when I said it.
00:51:56.800 --> 00:51:59.360
Now, can you get up there and testify that I said it?
00:51:59.679 --> 00:52:00.079
Sure.
00:52:00.639 --> 00:52:08.480
It's hearsay, but that would get in because it's a statement uh against interest and it's a statement of a party opponent.
00:52:08.880 --> 00:52:13.440
But the recording itself was an admissibility problem to start with.
00:52:13.840 --> 00:52:20.159
You then work backwards to the illegality of taking the recording in the first place, right?
00:52:20.400 --> 00:52:23.760
So there's there's two pieces to every wiretapping law.
00:52:23.920 --> 00:52:29.360
It usually makes it illegal to record it, but then it also makes it illegal to use it.
00:52:29.679 --> 00:52:38.159
And it's actually pretty rare for there to be any like criminal charge just for doing the recording.
00:52:38.400 --> 00:52:41.760
Because the harm comes when you use it, right?
00:52:41.840 --> 00:52:44.079
The harm comes when you share it with everybody.
00:52:44.320 --> 00:52:54.880
Just because you've recorded it, if it just sits in your closet all day and no one ever hears it, it's hard to argue that that's really, you know, worth the DA's office charging somebody over it.
00:52:55.679 --> 00:52:58.719
But I do believe that is what has happened in this Patrick Clancy case.
00:52:58.800 --> 00:53:02.639
If you read the statutes and you read what has been charged.
00:53:02.800 --> 00:53:10.559
Now, everybody talks about different parties' consent, one party, two-party, you know, there are some states that you there's no such thing.
00:53:10.639 --> 00:53:13.440
You can just record anybody and everybody all of the time.
00:53:13.840 --> 00:53:20.960
You know, I'll have people say to me all the time, um, well, this is a two-party consent state.
00:53:21.039 --> 00:53:22.079
You know, you can't record that.
00:53:22.159 --> 00:53:24.320
And it's like, what are you gonna do about it?
00:53:24.800 --> 00:53:31.199
You know, there are situations where I definitely tell folks, yeah, I know you might live in a two-party consent state, but record it anyway.
00:53:31.360 --> 00:53:34.400
You're not gonna get charged with a crime, right?
00:53:34.559 --> 00:53:40.719
Like, no one's gonna charge you with a crime for secretly recording the fight you have with your sister-in-law.
00:53:40.960 --> 00:53:41.360
Really?
00:53:41.519 --> 00:53:42.960
It's not that big of a deal.
00:53:43.280 --> 00:53:49.039
Um so, yes, technically it can be illegal in a two-party consent state.
00:53:49.199 --> 00:53:55.760
Also remember that when you do this across state lines, it gets real complicated real fast about which state's laws apply.
00:53:56.000 --> 00:53:59.280
The state of the talker or the state of the recorder.
00:53:59.519 --> 00:54:06.079
One other thing I think people don't always understand is that there is a difference in wiretapping.
00:54:06.239 --> 00:54:12.239
Most wiretapping laws are oral communications, it's about the sound.
00:54:12.639 --> 00:54:24.000
So if you have, for example, security camera or just footage that does not have audio in it, sometimes that's not wiretapping, even if the person doesn't know.
00:54:24.239 --> 00:54:29.760
Because wiretapping is about intercepting communications, right?
00:54:30.000 --> 00:54:37.039
Most of them define what can be wiretapped as oral or other communications.
00:54:37.360 --> 00:54:39.840
Walking around is not a communication.
00:54:40.239 --> 00:54:42.880
It's just it's an observation.
00:54:42.960 --> 00:54:46.639
It's like somebody would have with their own eyes.
00:54:46.960 --> 00:54:56.719
So don't assume that if something is being video recorded, if there's no sound and there's no consent, that that's wiretapping, because there's a pretty good chance that it's not.
00:54:57.039 --> 00:55:06.159
You also have to remember that these kinds of laws only apply in places where there is an expectation of privacy.
00:55:06.480 --> 00:55:16.960
If the communication occurs in a place where you know that other people can hear you, then you don't have an expectation of privacy there.
00:55:17.599 --> 00:55:30.079
So if you go stand in the middle of campus and scream at the top of your lungs and somebody records it, that's not wiretapping.
00:55:30.480 --> 00:55:36.880
No matter what your state law says about two-party consent, because you had no expectation of privacy.
00:55:37.119 --> 00:55:50.159
It can get real tricky in places like restaurants, bars, um, because it's like, well, you're in public, but are you trying to have a public conversation or a private conversation?
00:55:50.400 --> 00:55:53.440
It's really fact-dependent on the conversation itself.
00:55:53.679 --> 00:55:56.880
I love to write hypotheticals for students on issues like this.
00:55:57.039 --> 00:56:04.239
Like, okay, well, what if this couple is having this argument and one of them's recording it, and the other table is like really close?
00:56:04.320 --> 00:56:07.440
It's one of those restaurants where like the tables are right up against each other, right?
00:56:07.599 --> 00:56:14.000
Or what if there's a booth and so you can't hear, you know, it really does turn on what the circumstances are.
00:56:14.239 --> 00:56:28.719
Now it can get interesting in places like a classroom where people will try to record a teacher or an instructor's lecture without the instructor's consent.
00:56:29.440 --> 00:56:37.280
That can get really interesting because you may have no expectation, the instructor may have no expectation of privacy, but the other students do.
00:56:37.599 --> 00:56:43.760
Or the instructor may have an expectation of privacy because people have paid to be in that room.
00:56:44.079 --> 00:56:47.760
So, yes, you can record it, but again, then the use becomes a problem.
00:56:48.239 --> 00:56:59.119
Or it could be that maybe there isn't an expectation of privacy, but the use of that recording is prohibited by other things, like that lecture is the professor's intellectual property.
00:56:59.360 --> 00:57:05.920
But I think what you have to take away is that it's one of those things that looks like it's simple, but of course it isn't.
00:57:06.079 --> 00:57:16.400
There are plenty of circumstances in which you can record someone without their knowledge, even in a two-party consent state, and not commit a crime.
00:57:16.719 --> 00:57:19.519
Or commit the crime of taking.
00:57:20.159 --> 00:57:24.159
But if you never commit the crime of using, how will anybody know?
00:57:24.480 --> 00:57:24.800
Right?
00:57:24.960 --> 00:57:34.480
There's this thing I call the asterisk of the law, which you have all these requirements about, like, well, you should do this and you should do this.
00:57:34.639 --> 00:57:39.760
But there's also always this asterisk on everything, which is, are you going to get busted?
00:57:40.400 --> 00:57:50.239
If you take a surreptitious recording of somebody in a state where you're not supposed to do that, and you just listen to it in your bedroom at night, who cares?
00:57:50.800 --> 00:57:58.639
But if you start showing it to people and putting it on the internet and telling everybody you've got it, then you're gonna fucking get caught.
00:57:58.880 --> 00:58:04.719
Like, don't be a dumbass is always really solid legal advice.
00:58:05.440 --> 00:58:06.559
So I hope that makes sense.
00:58:06.719 --> 00:58:09.840
Drop in the comments any other questions that you may have.
00:58:10.000 --> 00:58:21.039
Me and my mucus are gonna go take some more Sudafed, and I'm going to edit out of this podcast episode all the snorting and coughing I've been doing, so that you won't have to hear it.
00:58:21.199 --> 00:58:24.400
But thank you for joining me again, and I will be right back here next week.
00:58:24.480 --> 00:58:28.400
Um, cough or not, because good lord the drama never stops.
00:58:28.559 --> 00:58:30.800
And someone's gotta make it make sense.