TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Parter with the Clone: Corey, there's been a Game Makers Toolkit video that came out from Mark Brown talking about how he was reached out by another developer and had his game potentially being cloned by this this developer. And he put out the video to kind of go over his thoughts and feelings. And ultimately at the end, he has a poll out for his community to kind of vote on what he should do in this situation. Option one is he says to the developer, Hey, it's fine, you can put out the game. Option two is he says, I'm not comfortable with this. And the developers are actually giving them a chance to respond, which is which is pretty cool. So what I thought we could do is maybe go through the main points and thoughts that he was feeling and maybe share some th our own perspective on the situation and and look at it maybe as if we were in his s situation, how might we feel? Or game des a whole, how how can we think about this? So what do you think? I think there's option three. It's not even realized. Option three is anybody who's seen this could now just take whatever the clone game is and clone that clone and just release it. And then he gets no say. So I guess we're gonna talk about this and this might be an interesting conversation. Well we'll we'll hold we'll hold that thought of what you started with. So option one or or sorry, thought one is he says, This could lose me money. And the thought process is, you reacting to this feeling of If this game exists, it means that there will be fewer sales for my game, because other people are gonna buy this other one, get confused, whatever it might be. This directly hurts my bottom line. So what are your initial thoughts to again, again, you have this game that's cloned or potentially gonna come out on the market? This is the dumbest shit I've ever heard, Connor. Because look look, I'm gonna get tons of hate, but like okay, listen to this. He says in a video that it's like four hundred dollars a month is what he gets with the sales and all this and it's all passive. But okay, if you want to talk business, let's talk business. All he has to do is set up a ref share agreement with the new game launch, make a bundle, and announce it, and a new game will have a launch spike and it probably a lot of his audience who already owns this game will go buy that new game if it has new features and he'll make more than the four hundred dollars a month. to sit there and be like, I'm gonna lose this passive income. It's still passive. We're talking about literally maybe four hundred dollars on a lawyer to draft something up, if that, to then sign and say, Okay, Deb, sure, we agree. I'll give you the IP. I won't come after you if you one to one clone my game, but it's gonna operate this way. The route chair's X. We're going to bundle the game. I'm gonna do an announcement. He's gonna make a video about the game too. That's gonna drive a bunch of people to support it. It's way more than what are four thousand, five thousand a year he's making on the passive income of the game. this is Look, if if you didn't say anything about money, I wouldn't bring it up. But it's just shrew business sense to bring it up and just be like, well, actually you're leaving money on the table if you just do it this way. Like Yeah. Well, and and another situation that did this would be Jonas Tyroller, and I I I forget their their studio name, so I apologize. But I think they for both Islanders and Thronefall, right? They they sold the IP to another company who picked it up and was able to do something with it, do expansions. and so it seems like, especially if you're someone like Mark Brown or someone who has a good following, that is something that might be available to you. Or if you're a smaller developer and someone is approaching you like that, it also could be an opportunity if you weren't going to do anything with the game as well. So maybe maybe there is something there. But it does sound like it's not always gonna be an option that you like even someone like me might have that access to, right? Of course. But then also that goes into my third point here, which wasn't an option, is like You're at the whim of whatever the market wants to do. Someone can go see your game, say, hey, it looks like it's doing all right. It's doing five thousand passively just off of the the seasonal sales. I'm going to go make that same game better. And I'm going to kill your sales likely because people eventually realize mine's better. And that's it. Yeah. So here he's got brand and reputation that he could leverage and make a partnership. A lot of people aren't. So they're just at the mercy of other people saying, I'm just gonna make a game similar to your game. And so I don't think I would ever vote for option two, which is like to tell them no, because saying no to them, especially having made the video, is just clearly going to be someone who just doesn't like Mark Brown and says, Okay, well, I'm gonna go do it. Interesting. Just because you s you don't want other people to do it. You've made it clear. If you made no video, this would never be brought up. Sure. yeah, yeah, yeah. You're almost you're almost I don't want to say you're asking for it, making the video, but I could definitely see the incentive for people who maybe not like this person, given he has a big following, who makes a video saying, you shouldn't do that. Don't do that, other devs and it's like, okay, someone who doesn't like you is literally gonna take that as an imitation of I just want to make you not like me. Yeah. And I don't like you. Especially now because it got the attention and everything too. So it's it kind of inviting that is true. And I guess so my feeling is I I mean, definitely think it's a anybody would feel this of like the immediate thought is, is this gonna make me lose money? Is this com competition? Some of it I think it is if you're ready for it, like in the mindset of when you release a game on
Load full transcript
Steam, it's like you don't have competitive control over a genre or specific specific type of game, right? look at Vampire Survivors and what came after that. It's like some of it I I do feel like it it should be expected that it's part of the competition of selling games. Now I think it is very different between someone like actually steals your game versus takes the idea, elevates it, does a bunch of things, maybe uses a look and feel because it's like if you have an action bar and a RPG, it's like how many times has that been done over? It it if you make it look similar what people are used to, there's some things that are just part of the genre. And some things that are maybe your specific aesthetic that, it's it's not always clear cut. But in this situation, it it seems like there are other ways that you could take that and continue to either make adjustments to your game, maybe you could do an update because maybe this is proving that there's an audience. Maybe there's a way again, like you said, work with the dev, maybe do a bundle or collaborate. So the immediate feeling of this could lose me money, valid, but if like the second thought is, okay, well then what do we do instead? are there other ways to continue to make up for that or make an opportunity out of it? Yeah. And and again, if he says no because it's it's gonna lose me money here, it's like, well, what about the person who makes a game that isn't like a one for one clone? Yeah. Was heavily inspired by your game. Now you're gonna make Zippo. Yeah. there's nothing you can do. You don't own the genre. You don't own this type of game. So for me it's like almost laughable to even ask option one or two, it's like Just pick option one and move on. Like unless it's an ethics moral debate of like yeah, I don't feel comfortable with someone who cloned the game in the first place. But then it's like if the if this individual or these people weren't like they're purely up for themselves. They wouldn't have even emailed. Right. Right. Yeah. Well, so th that leads us into thought two is well, games are built on top of other games. And the idea is that, you know, we're all adopting ideas from each other. remixing them, getting inspired. in our in one of our last episodes or future upcoming episode, we talk about this a little bit more too, that we're we're remixing these things and that no one really has an original idea that isn't inspired from somewhere else. Right. And so I think this kind of aligns with that as well of this is just kind of how creative creativity works in a way, right? And I yes, but and I didn't maybe get enough of the video to understand like exactly what they did. it's easy to say the game was cloned, but if you provide it in screenshots of the game and you have an entirely different implementation of the game, then yes, it's cloned of that game. It's like a reskin asset flip of your game. But actually, you don't own the code. So you you're not actually responsible for
anything unless it's literally ripped the art. But if it's generated an art dissimilar based off of concept images, you're good to go. I don't say I agree with that. I'm just saying There's a difference of that in hey, I literally got Claude to decompile a game and take everything out of the game and the functions of the debug and all the de all the console stuff behind the scenes exactly one for one. Yeah. It's like that is theft. Yes. That yeah. And in that scenario, you 100% better be sending the email and hoping they say yes because you can't do shit. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And well, and then and I think in the video he asked them or he clarified that he asked them to send them the ChatGPT logs and they sent it. And the first one or one of the early ones was something along the lines of, Hey, I'd like to create a game that is in this style similar to the the the game. And then having either the screenshot that was attached with it and then I think you said twelve seconds or twelve minutes later, I can't remember. It was some short amount of time, like less than thirty minutes. That it actually came back and had the first playable version, the first playable version of your game that is inspired by this game by Mark Brown. And then that was that was what they had. So not extracting it from the actual executable, but from Personally, I don't have an issue with that because that's exactly what humans do. Mm-hmm. It's just the the computer's able to do it at such efficient speed that people don't feel like, that's deserved. Yeah. that's stealing. That's that's theft. It's like actually, no, that's exactly what you're doing. If I sat you down and said make a similar game to this, would I say, Connor, you stole it if you wrote everything yourself and drew everything yourself? No, you were inspired. You took inspiration. Now, if you were like, yeah, I decompiled the thing and literally ripped all the functions, I'd be Yeah, you literally stole that code. If you copied out the images and traced over them, yeah, then again, same thing. But in this case, I'm just like, They did exactly what a human would do. It's just the computer's super efficient at doing it. Yeah. And and I think a screenshot and ask for a game similar of X. Yeah. But it's I think that's a challenge. It's the pace at at which things are moving. That's what's so different. And I think again, elicits many of us to feel these reactions and like, well, what do we think of it? Because before you had to learn a bunch of other skills or there was a like more time delay. So it was like it took more skill or whatever it might be now. It's like that. barrier has been removed so it feels more accessible. But going on to number three, I think it it he brought that up of clones are inevitable. He cited the game threes, which then 2048 came out and and he kind of said, you probably know the game 2048 or played that. And the developers of threes kind of said, well yeah, they they made the game that was
maybe more simple or or streamlined, but people didn't play the game threes long enough to see the depth and the mechanics of what they had added in that game. And so it's just this example that again isn't going on. He cited Space Invaders as well, and other companies, bigger companies doing this. So maybe this is just something that has always been happening. And again, AI just makes this even more quick. Yeah, it's also maybe cynical to say, but how much can I feel for somebody who's also like it's a passive game and is still earning me money and I'm not doing shit. It's like y y you've moved on. Be different, maybe I'd feel different if he was sitting there like, I was really looking forward to building a sequel of the game and I had plans for expansions, but it I mean the video starts with, Hey I don't do game dev. I'm glad I got out game dev when I did the two games and now I do YouTube and a being a dad. So well then come on, you weren't going to be on the the high ground here saying like this was your dream game and you want to expand it and move it further. Yeah. Corey, you're giving big left guy energy today. That's all I could say. Well we'll keep we'll keep going through some of the other ones I think that are relevant to what you just said is AI U, that's just what that thought was of, you know, not not really liking how AI is being used, the way it was trained, it like the the ethics behind it, again, many of the other concepts that are in the conversation. In addition to is the game too simple? That was a later thought, that number six. looking at saying, Hey, if you're gonna make a game that might be easy to copy or isn't that mechanically deep or you're not doing anything, you know, kind of again what you were talking about, those two things might go together a little bit that we've kind covered. So it sounds like your thought process is this is whether or not how you feel about the tooling and stuff, this is just kind of the direction that technology is going and the way that other people are choosing. So you like us as game developers still exist in this ecosystem in this environment. And so some of it you can't you really can't escape because everything around you is moving in the direction too. Yeah, and I'm not some like moral compass here of this is the way it should be because there's going to be a line that moves and it's gonna be different for everyone. Cause I there's things I don't agree with of like, hey, if they just simply decompile the game and just st strictly have one to one matching and they're just like, let's build this game. Yeah. No, I don't agree with that. but I I think it's fair to have provided a link to something that said, like, I'm trying to make a game like this and the model simply exactly what a human would do is be inspired by that and try and build something else. Yeah. and I'm definitely not in the camp with the more extreme version, which is they could have emailed him and said, Look, if you don't agree to this, we are going to make the game and release it. This was a whole thing maybe a week or two ago about game devs getting essentially, I guess, blackmailed into hey, if you don't give us money, we're going to clone your game and just simply siphon off the sales and and not even care. And obviously that's way more experiment like very, very different thing. But the law's gonna take a while to catch up on some of this and we'll see what happens. I mean you got Anthropic banning direct clones. word was that it's pressure from Nintendo. I mean they have a great incentive to protect their IP and their games. though I'm sure all of us retro nerds would love to have made Super Mario and played something similar or different versions of that. But again, it's like There, the arts protected. Yes. Right. The the thing the reason why any of us even care about s something like Mario is because of the brand itself. If it's any other character in that game, none of us would recognize the game really. we would because we played the the core mechanics and things like that. And we'd say, it's Mario but a different c Super Mario but a different character. But the reason why we all know that is because we played that game and because they built up a brand. Yeah. Well, honestly, if Mario games, like especially 2D Mario games, where like it didn't matter who the character was. pla 2D platformers would not be one of the worst performing meme genres to try to pick breaking into Steam. So it very much matters so like what the setting is, what who the character is and things like that as well. So does go a long way. And and that exact case of Claude and Anthropic adding in that that clause to say, hey, don't copy existing games one for one. It seems like That was one of the seven thoughts of maybe this is all over anyway because now these checks are in place and maybe to some degree it's catching up a little bit to try to stave off or pres prevent this. But I don't know to your point, it like if someone phrases it in a way or has screenshots and you know, like how much does it really help if you just like explain this is the idea of what I'm going for and it you know, like how much is that actually gonna help? Do do you think this is gonna become the Wild West back in Napster days for the for the for you young people who don't know what it is. Like you used to steal music. You know, download it. there wasn't Spotify, you couldn't pay a monthly subscription. because I'm sitting here thinking, are we gonna live in an era like that where you go to the dark web of steam and you can play whatever game you want because they've since simply been cloned and the expansions of these games that people have made because you're playing on a platform that isn't regulated by typical law. Like think about it from this way what is the what is the things that prevent this? Okay, mostly it's the financial system. The reason why someone like Steam is going to comply is
because US law is going to enforce it. And even if the US law doesn't enforce it, the US law is going to simply enforce it from a financial aspect. Right. Which is like we will block you from accepting Visa and MasterCard. And guess what? That that's their player base goes bye bye then. Yeah. this happened in the adult industry too. It's like if you want to attack industries that are maybe deemed less worthy than others. You don't go for the laws to regulate that. You go for the laws on the payment side to regulate it. You force Visa or MasterCard to take action. Yeah. so I'm thinking maybe in the future we end up in the dark web of like We're we're already there. It's called Roblox. You just take the game and put it on Roblox. no, because even further. Because right now we're in this middle ground of the law hasn't catched up. It hasn't caught up. Mm-hmm. Right. But if you go back in time, even when the law caught up, you still had BitTorrent get around it. Yeah. And I'm like, so do we end up with a fully decentralized game world with a fully decentralized Bitcoin purchasing? And then you can just say, Well, yeah, maybe it's breaking the law, but it really depends on what the consumer is willing to put up with. Like if they're willing to do the sketchy thing to buy the game and People are doing that. People will go make the clones. The you can't police it at the model level. The problem with Anthropic is everyone wants to shift to open weight models, which is I can download the model, run it myself locally, and now what? Yeah. Well and I I was just thinking as you were talking, it's like let's say that someone wasn't gonna sell a game and they just wanted the game, they could make their own bootleg copy of it by vibe coding their own game. It's like man. That's funny. And Alex. When you used to when you used to download music, it wasn't because you wanted to become some redistribution and sell the music. Yeah, you just for personal use. Yeah. So I I almost feel like in this conversation, we kind of are full circling back to the past. Which is really weird. Yeah. where it's like, wait, we've already technically gone through a little bit of this. Yeah. Maybe not at this acceleration of the pace. of like the ramifications because it's not just games, it's like all software. but the music industry went through something very similar, which is overnight, essentially protected IP became not so protected. And it took forever for the law to catch up and the model changed. Yeah. Right. The model changed. Yeah, that's true. And adapted as part of like ad looking at how do you sustain a business in an environment where this is happening or again, streaming platforms making it accessible. If it's like showing consumer behavior, how do you adapt to that? Which again, jokes aside, Roblox is like that. And and when I was growing up, I had Warcraft 3 custom games, right? It's like how many Naruto and Pokemon and pick your whatever game was on there, in addition
to something like Dota, which then became its own IP, which then I believe what happened was Blizzard said, Hey, any games that are made within our custom tools, I don't know if they reversed this, but they said that you we own that IP of that game. So that way there could not be a situation where Dota takes off and then they go and spawn that off and make their own, game from that with their own IP. obviously they had to change all the characters and stuff, but they were able to take that and say, No, this was ours because we created it, 'cause we made it within the tool. So I think even still some of this is evolving. There is one last thought that I I want to cover this one. It's wait, is this game better than mine? So that was thought number five. And just reconciling with the fact that someone has looked at your game, made something inspirational from it, and improved it so much that you go, dang, but this one actually is they're kinda cooking here. So I think I wanted to like more. Well, if it is, great, because like I said, then he should do what I explained as the ideal option, which is just strike a deal with them. Yeah. If it's not, then you wouldn't be worried really about your sales being hindered because you have the superior game in the first place. Yeah. So what they cloned it. There's clones of a bajillion games on Steam. There's slop all the time happening. People aren't necessarily buying it. But if it's not a slop game, it's simply a better game, then you're faced with the reality that, if you if you don't say yes and somebody else continues forward, maybe not this individual. Yeah. Then yeah, you're at the risk of your money going from four hundred dollars a month down to zero. Yeah. And you run the business numbers. It's like either you accept that someone's going to beat you, or you reinvest, or you sign. It's like any major company does. You have product lines, and if you stop maintaining it and you're coasting, a competitor can come in and take the whole thing. So either you keep investing, which would mean improving his game, or somebody else can come in. And become like the type of game for this and you lose. Yeah. for example, if there was a a series that was on the PlayStation One, Nintendo sixty four, fans thought that the series was going in the wrong direction, someone made a pixel art version of a cozy farming game that ended up selling very, very well. For example, right? Do you even know what I'm talking about? No. The exact story of Stardew Valley. okay. Like This is this is what happens, right? they they didn't go. I I can't remember what the company is. I don't think it's Konami or Natsume, but I think like what are they gonna do? Like go to Eric Barone and say, hey, you can't put out Stardew Valley. It's like he he did exactly it. They weren't making updates. He saw a need, he saw a player base, he loved the game and was like, I'm just gonna go and make this. And and I think the big difference though is that
took him however many years to make versus now if you were to go do that. How long would it take to go from nothing to make in Stardew Valley given? Well, yeah, exactly. People people reward the time. Yeah. Wow, he sacrificed everything for seven years. He put everything online, he spent all this time. Now if I told you he did it for in one month. Would that be slop? So that's that's a good question. Would that then be slop? If it if it was the exact version of Stardew Valley, but it only took a month to do because you were using agentic tools, but Recreated again, Star Trek Alley doesn't exist. There's this is the first time we're seeing it. Do you think people would call that slow? No. Because it's a well polished, crafted game. I I think people can fuse the time with the quality. Something could take five minutes and still be a great quality. Yeah. Right? it's very hard to do. It's very but if you watch somebody who's very, very specialized in a particular skill. That they have honed and honed and honed. And they are able to do something in five minutes of that skill, even an hour of that skill. And you're like, holy sh wow, this is impressive. And then you take a novice and it could take them two weeks to achieve even one tenth of that. It's like, okay, the two weeks has slopped, even though it took two weeks. Yeah. The the one hour one or the one day one, whatever it is, is not slop. It's just repetitiveness and skillfulness. And that's all what the models do is just it's just closing that gap. Yeah. And I think people get caught up with the identity and and thinking it's not fair. And I spent all this time and they spent X very little. And it's like, so what? That's been life all the time. There's people who've spent twenty years and and struggled paying the bills and had a a decent working job. You have some people who go in a different profession and make the same amount in four years because they pick a profession that pays way more. Yeah. Didn't didn't mean the person who spent four years is less hardworking. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Some some of it is just a hard pill to swallow. Cause if you're like, if you spent so much time, we'll we'll call eight years, learning a craft, a profession, and then you go in and it's no longer there, not needed, it's like it can feel very hard, but some of it is like it can happen and and now what do you do? how do you adapt to it? The other thing that I I think I would say is I think I would disagree with the sentiment that people would not would not call it slop if Stardew Valley came out today and they knew that it took a month and used AI tools. I think people would look at it and say, This this is AI slop. I don't want this, this is AI slop. It doesn't look good. look at these look at these pixel art. it doesn't even look good. It looks like AI garbage, right? I See true. Okay. I wasn't thinking from the mindset of saying it's AI. I was just thinking if you had used AI produced this, would people say it's AI slot? Yeah. See see, I think that's why it's a loaded word. I honestly think once you say you've used AI, people change the bar immediately. Right. Exactly. the quality has to be way higher. It's like self driving self-driving cars. It it's literally the same. It's like even though they'll statistically be way less likely to get an accident. Because they're not flawless and it's a machine, they're held to an entirely different standard than a human. It's like, no no. Those even the current self driving models are way more superior than humans. But because sometimes the model might miss a scenario that looks obviously human and did not look obvious to this, even though it's driving like a million miles and this is the one spot where it's like, yeah, but the kid was at the corner. Anyone would see that as a human. You go, it's garbage. It's like, but it drove a million miles with no other incidents. Yeah. statistically speaking as a human, if you drive a million model miles, I think you're I think it's every three hundred thousand miles, the average person should be almost always in an accident. Dang. I don't want to think about that. That's too much of a statistic for me. I'm like, I I drive too much. This is why you don't drive, okay? So you you're you're not looking at my wife has a hundred percent track record of no accidents. That's good. And I tell her all the time that she is statistically really against it. Yeah, yeah. It's it it's gonna come any moment. Well, I hope not. I really hope not. But but but I I think that's to me again, that's like it's so hard to even have the conversation about this because if you take examples and say, if AI generated it, like the fact that it was generated by AI, how does that change the conversation how people value this? And and I do think that right now it's more that people don't value the work that is generated by it, even if it would result in the same exact product. Like the means the means by how it came about matters. so much to people in this current moment. I don't know if that'll change over time because even something like I'm sure mass production in factories and stuff like that, right? I'm sure that there was or the printing presses, right? I'm sure technology goes through this. We're in the current moment where it is new. We're discovering it. There's a lot of discussion around it. There's a lot of feelings. There's a lot of ethics that haven't been caught like we talked about the law and all these different situations that come up. Mark is put in the situation where he has to sort through it because there's not precedent And now he has to make this choice as a as a game developer and say, what do I do with this? Right. And so some of it is I don't know. It's it's it's interesting. Twenty twenty six, end of twenty twenty six, we we really don't know where we're gonna be in the future, but Listen, Mark, take the deal, partner, take the road share, bundle, make the announcement, make the YouTube video now announcing the trailer, and yeah, you'll make a lot more than four hundred dollars a month off of it. Yeah. And if you go to office for royalties. Yeah. What even ask for royalties. You what? The royalty you give to me, just give to charity. I'm I'm all for I'm all for it. Yeah, yeah. And and and if you feel otherwise, cu come on the podcast, we'll talk to you. We we have a we'll continue the conversation, right? I thought you were gonna say if you feel otherwise, just send Connor the money. No, no, no, I don't want I don't want this money. Send it to Corey. Send it to Corey, he'll take it. Well, any other closing thoughts for us? it sounds like it is a tough situation. I if it were me, I think I would be inside one too, of just I don't know. some of it is if they if they're gonna make the game, why why are we s not letting people make games? just let's let's just all make games. Make games however you want to. And then figure it out. If someone came to me with a better black hole and said, Look, I cloned it and I could get them on a rev share deal, I would s there's what effort is there? There there's paperwork in agreement. How angry can I be? the most anger I can have is on myself to say, damn it, I should have did it myself. And then they wouldn't be involved at all. Yeah. But if you're in a spot where you've given up and you're hands off anyways, Yeah. Well, and if anything, I think people have talked about this. This is where IP and all these different things start to matter more because it is protected. You can start to do things, license it out. And so it could be that especially artists, that's the way that they go is say, Hey, I'm looking for a game dev to make a game about my game. Hey, I'll license it out and give me however much and you can, do what you want with it. Maybe that's the way that things end up going too. It's Really hard to say, but at the end of the day, we I guess y'all still gotta adapt. Any again, any final, final thoughts before we wrap it? Adapt. Adapt. It's a good one. Adapt, make games. Those two things. Well, thanks so much, Corey, for walking through this. if you have any thoughts, if you think that we haven't represented all the ideas or maybe just want to continue the conversation, let us know in the comments. and make sure that you subscribe so that way you can get notified whenever we have a new video out. But thanks so much and we'll talk to you again soon.