TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
00:00:08
Speaker 1: On September the 30th, 2026, the state of Tennessee attempted to execute a 50-year-old death row inmate, Krista Pike, by lethal injection. They were using the barbiturate, pentobarbital, and it failed to kill her.
00:00:30
Speaker 2: So tonight, Dr.
00:00:32
Speaker 1: Priya is with us, and we are going to walk through How did this failure happen? Dr.
00:00:39
Speaker 2: Priya, welcome back to Zone 7.
00:00:41
Speaker 3: Thank you, as always. And I just want to start off by saying it was an epic fail.
00:00:48
Speaker 2: Epic fail. And listen, I want to be real clear.
00:00:51
Speaker 1: We ain't debating about the death penalty. We're not saying whether or not she deserved it. What I need to know from a medical professional, a MD, a forensic pathologist, I mean, I thought it was kind of not fail-proof because I reckon nothing is.
00:01:11
Speaker 2: There's always human error. But I thought once.
00:01:15
Speaker 1: That process got started, it's like this cocktail and it, you know, goes into the IV and you just drift off to sleep and it kills you.
00:01:23
Speaker 3: Well, that's a loaded statement right there because I can dissect that and tell you why it didn't work.
00:01:31
Speaker 2: Talk to me, honey.
00:01:32
Speaker 3: Yes, so state of Tennessee where this... this procedure was supposed to take place, and she had been on death row for many years, was scheduled, sanctioned by the state law. Now, that's really important. So Tennessee state law that I've learned after this was that pentobarbital is the only drug they use. So it's not a cocktail in Tennessee like I understood it to be generally as well.
00:02:03
Speaker 2: So I was, you know, I learned that it was.
00:02:06
Speaker 3: A single agent or single medication.
00:02:08
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:02:08
Speaker 3: Now pentobarbital is a medicine. Okay. It is in the barbiturate family and that can be used as anesthesia for headaches. It does have medical reasons. Okay. But it's a controlled substance. For whatever reason, Tennessee law dictates that needs to be the only substance medicine used.
00:02:31
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:02:31
Speaker 3: So not a cocktail, there's no premedication or anything to sort of make her sleepy and then stop the heart. So the interesting part about this medicine is it acts on the brain.
00:02:44
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:02:45
Speaker 3: So normally in the cocktail, it sort of you know, puts you to sleep and then stops the heart, if you will, okay? Now, the process with penobarbital, even though it is a prescribed medicine, the thought was you give so much, you overdose her, okay? Now, the second part of your statement, I mean, it was like the perfect lead-in, you know? We didn't set it up this way, but this is magical, is that it was given what was thought to be intravenous, so IV, okay? IV stands for intravenous. Now, that, again, is calculated based on all of the medicine getting into her body. Now, if you looked at, or I read some of the not the
Load full transcript
transcript, but just the takeaways from the process, she said, you know, in paraphrasing, my arm is about to explode.
00:03:37
Speaker 2: It's burning.
00:03:38
Speaker 3: It's about to explode. So what that tells me is that the IV was probably improperly placed, meaning medicine does burn, you know, when it goes in, but it shouldn't be this excruciating pain, okay? It makes you think that either the IV... didn't make it into the vein or went through the vein where the tip wasn't in the channel, if you will, in the canal, but through the wall veins are, are thin blood vessels, right? Just like when we give our, like our arms to get blood drawn, it's the same place that you would place an IV. There's other places like the back of the hand, but they're going to try to get a big juicy vein, right? Hoping that that's the effective way to give the medicine. Now, I don't know who placed the IV and even if it was a physician, it wasn't properly placed. So all in all, what I think happened, and this is just speculation because no one's going to measure the drugs in her system. It's that the IV was placed, but I think what's happening is it's going, the end of it, the tip, the delivery of the medicine happened within the tissues of the arm. If it goes through the wall of... The vein, it's no longer getting into the bloodstream, but it's getting into the surroundings or partially into the bloodstream, partially leaking out, okay? So I think it was a twofold failure, if you will. First of all, it's a single agent, a single medication. And then whatever they thought was the two doses or the total dose, you know, two rounds, if you will, of medicine didn't all make it into her system. So it was like a multi-step sort of, you know, set of errors. And so if you notice, she does become very sleepy, sort of, they can't arouse her. She's seeing sort of, you know, very shallow breathing. And then the issue becomes sort of, and this is, again, sort of beyond my reach, but I will just say that people were surprised that EMS came and she was taken to the hospital. Now, you know, I think that gets into the do no harm or like the legal legalities of it is like, if someone doesn't pass from this, I mean, this is unprecedented, right? Like, I hate to say it, you know, other states since this have executed people. And thankfully or not, it hasn't gone awry like this process, you know? And so, you know, everybody's mentally prepared medically, you know, you think thinking to be prepared. So when she doesn't die because of it, she has to be legally taken to the hospital. Okay.
00:06:26
Speaker 1: Right.
00:06:26
Speaker 2: So the Hippocratic oath kicks in.
00:06:29
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:06:29
Speaker 3: And I think, you know, this is still someone who is in your care as, as, in custody, prisoner, right? It's in police custody. So if something goes wrong with an unanticipated consequence, like she doesn't pass away from this, I think the matter of fact is you can't let her suffer per se. You have to take her to the hospital. Now, it is unreal to me. I mean, I had spoken about this online. I really did think that because she was so unresponsive, I thought she was gonna have irreversible brain damage from the lack of oxygen. Let me just back up. So pentobarbital, the way it works on the brain is it makes you sleepy, but also tells your body that like resting breathing that we do. Like we're not thinking, hey, one, two, take a breath, three, four, take a breath, right? We're just automatically living. That is like innate in our brain. And so it'll shut off those centers, you know, and the body won't breathe and ultimately your brain will shut down from a lack of oxygen. Okay, now I thought she wouldn't, I thought she would had enough brain damage from the medication, but I think the lack of the full dose plus the rapidity of the, you know, medical intervention, Really, like, it's a miracle. I mean, I hate to say it, you know, whether you believe in the death penalty or not, I'm just saying that someone surviving this is sort of a medical miracle. I thought she would be a vegetable or paralyzed or something because of the injury to her brain from not breathing. But she recovered, you know, and now it goes way beyond medicine. It's a legal battle now, right? As to whether they can do this again. And this has come into play where... How much say do the doctors have? The doctors really don't have say in that it's a state law what medication is used. And if you know, then you know that state to state, the laws are different. We all thought it was a cocktail, but it's not in Tennessee. And I don't know the origins of that law, how long it's been in place. I'd love to hear from audience or other people who are more knowledgeable about But that all in all is my thought process on why it didn't work. There's definitely medical reasons. And then there's just, you know, luck, I think too, that she got the medical care and her body in some way wasn't as sensitive to the dose that was given to have irreversible brain damage. And that's why she could walk out of the hospital.
00:09:12
Speaker 1: Well, in preparation for tonight, you know, I looked at some other There was another lethal injection where the needle was put in backwards. So it went toward the fingers, not the heart. I see.
00:09:26
Speaker 3: So it didn't get into the circulation.
00:09:28
Speaker 2: Correct. So that failed as well.
00:09:31
Speaker 1: And I did not even remember this, but even John Wayne Gacy had a snag with his.
00:09:37
Speaker 3: Oh, I didn't know that.
00:09:39
Speaker 1: I didn't either until I did my little research today to be sure I had something to talk to you about where I wasn't just blind.
00:09:46
Speaker 2: Because the medical part, I mean, again, I don't know all this. And, you know, it blew.
00:09:52
Speaker 1: My mind that she woke up because when she was unconscious for several days, I thought, well, this is it.
00:09:58
Speaker 3:
And that's what I thought. I thought they were going to have to pull the plug in the hospital. Like I thought she would be medically much worse from the effects, you know, and then we would deal with that issue.
00:10:09
Speaker 1: Well, with Gacy, what they said was the chemicals somehow solidified and clogged the IV. I see.
00:10:17
Speaker 3: So it wasn't even like able to get through.
00:10:19
Speaker 1: Right. So they kind of had to stop it, close the curtains, redo everything. And it took about 18 minutes before they were able to get back on track. And one of the doctors that was there basically said it's IV 101.
00:10:34
Speaker 2: It was just a human error.
00:10:36
Speaker 1: And I think if we look at what's happened in other failed, you know, cases, you know, the human error or equipment failure is, I mean, that's what you're going to see. But I have never, I mean, listen, y'all. I remember there was an execution by electric chair. It was in Florida in 1990. Jesse Taffaro, flames like a foot high, shot off the headpiece when he was in the electric chair. And ironically, tragically, It happened again in Florida in 1997 with Pedro Bedina. It was horrible. And again, we're not getting into the Eighth Amendment. We're not getting into cruel and unusual. We're not getting into is this what is deserving. All I want to know again, how do we safeguard that this doesn't occur again? So, Doc, let me ask you this because I don't know. I mean, are they going to have a medical doctor or is it going to be an EMT or a nurse's aide?
00:11:46
Speaker 2: Like who's putting the IV in?
00:11:48
Speaker 3: You know, I don't know. But as far as I'm aware, that do no harm, you know, oath really overarches our practice. And as far as I know, there's no physician doing the procedure. I don't know how it's staffed. Again, I know there was a lot of repercussions, if you will, from this failed operation. procedure, right? The, I think the prison chief quit. There was other, you know, all there's a staff executions for the rest of the year. So I don't know exactly, they didn't get into the staffing part of it, but I know in my, you know, doctor group, there was absolutely like no one saying that they're going to do it because, and I mean, that's not an 100% survey, but there was a lot of like dismay. How could this have failed? Just from a purely medical perspective, you know, whether you agree with it or not, it's like, you know, this is a procedure. It's administering medicine. Like, why did we go wrong here? You know, there was a lot of discussion again, because it's, I mean, executions are rare practices. Period. Right. Like we may hear about them, one in this state, one in that state. But again, think about it. It's not a day to day event.
00:13:03
Speaker 1: Right.
00:13:04
Speaker 3: So I feel like every time the prison systems are going through it, it's maybe reinventing the wheel a little bit. And if they're far enough apart, maybe the staff that was involved in one is not there for the other one.
00:13:15
Speaker 1: Correct. And then.
00:13:18
Speaker 3: You know, physicians aren't allowed to guide to be present or guide the process. So again, it does make you wonder who wrote this law.
00:13:25
Speaker 2: It does. It does.
00:13:27
Speaker 1: Right.
00:13:27
Speaker 3: Why is only this one rare agent allowed? I do know there was some talk about like pharmaceutical companies may not want to be suppliers for agents, you know, used in this process. So there's a lot of sort of ethical and, and you know, professional beliefs, if you will, that play into this. And it always is curious, how old is the pentobarbital law? I mean, it is an older medicine. Do you know what I mean? It's not new and snazzy. It's one of the classics. So, I mean, why is that one chosen? You know, whether it's access, expense, you know, and then, you know, who administers it there? I'm sure we're not going to get a clear answer, even if we look now, because there's so much controversy. I think they're going to hold everything close to the vest. Because they're analyzing everything from a liability perspective.
00:14:16
Speaker 1: Sure they are. And when you start thinking about, okay, there's a twist or a little catch in the IV line, it's put in backwards, they don't give her enough. I mean, this doesn't sound like they're dealing with medical people. It does sound like somebody that maybe is the low rung on the totem pole, so to speak. Because they even say that specialty boards like the American Board of Anesthesiologists can pull your certification if you participate. Right.
00:14:49
Speaker 3: So it seemed very unethical, if you will, right?
00:14:52
Speaker 1: Yeah. So they're not going to have somebody qualified to start that IV line. We've pretty much figured.
00:14:58
Speaker 2: That out our own. Got it.
00:14:59
Speaker 1: Right.
00:15:00
Speaker 2: So let me ask you one more question.
00:15:03
Speaker 1: I did not realize the lethal injection could be different state to state to state. I thought everybody had agreed. I thought the first injection was to calm them down. The second injection was to make them go to sleep. And the third stopped their heart.
00:15:19
Speaker 2: That's what I thought.
00:15:21
Speaker 1: I had no idea they were just ODing somebody and hoping that was going to do it.
00:15:27
Speaker 3: Well, at least in this model or this circumstance, that's what it is, you know? And I think, right, we have a lot of.
00:15:38
Speaker 3: Variability throughout the country, right? Meaning some states have lethal injections, the death penalty, some states don't. Like I'm in Rhode Island, we do not have it. So life without parole is the maximum penalty or double life, if you will. They get that kind of sentence stacked. Regardless, you know, it's not always as well structured as you would think, you know, and whether a doctor was even involved in forming that law is questionable, right? And our doc,
because I mean, if we're, if we, meaning physicians are stopped, MD or DO stopped from being in the process, I imagine that, you know, formulating a law is also part of the process.
00:16:22
Speaker 2: Absolutely.
00:16:24
Speaker 1: But again, I know there's electric chair, there's a firing squad, there's lethal injection. But I thought the lethal injection was the same across the board. I didn't know people state to state could change that method.
00:16:37
Speaker 3: Right. I mean, it's all dictated by laws. Right. And what's interesting, you bring that up is I forgot about this until you said it, that her attorney had actually petitioned the court to say. they wanted an alternate method because they were afraid it was going to fail. You know, they wanted firing squad or electric chair, and then the judge had ruled no. You know, the court said no. So it's almost like, I hate to say it, a self-fulfilling prophecy. You know, it's like, dang, they were afraid of this. They went through the efforts to file a motion and, you know, do all this. And it sort of came to light. And I don't know if they see, you know, got guidance, right. Or like outside of court, like, Hey, a single agent isn't ideal. But it was very interesting. Cause you know, I learned a lot about this after the fact, because then I'm like, does she, you know, if she dies in the hospital, which she didn't, but I was like, Oh, does she get an autopsy? Like, you know, that sort of chain of events. Cause she's technically an in custody death, you know? And I think that would depend state to state, but I mean, she survived. So now she's back in the prison system.
00:17:43
Speaker 2: You know, things can be faulty. But I will say this.
00:17:47
Speaker 1: We've had the death penalty 120 years. Over 8,000 prisoners have been put to death. And only 276 have failed. That's less than 3%. But 3% is too many.
00:18:01
Speaker 3: That seems like a lot. Yeah, I mean, this was shocking to me. And maybe I was more keyed in professionally, you know, during my time there. Now, I would say, you know, in my practice and I do hear about cases, you know, this man was executed, this woman was executed. But I don't think I necessarily pay attention to their protocols.
00:18:22
Speaker 1: Right.
00:18:22
Speaker 3: When it's when it goes through the way it was planned. I don't I don't like the word successful in this way, but when it was effective.
00:18:29
Speaker 1: Right.
00:18:30
Speaker 3: But I think this one I read about more or more details were released as well in the media because. the outcome was so different and so unexpected.
00:18:42
Speaker 1: Understood. And I think that's the reason this is an important conversation from a medical standpoint only. Because I think that's where we start. We've got to make that correction first. This cannot happen because at the end of the day, you are talking about a human being and we are not supposed to have horrible treatment. I mean, we're not supposed to cause more harm.
00:19:09
Speaker 2: Exactly.
00:19:11
Speaker 3: And then the other, I mean, I don't want anybody else to be forgotten, meaning the victims, families who have mentally prepared for years about this. And then, you know, again, the, you know, everybody's someone's child or sister or brother or cousin. I mean, even, you know, was it Krista Pike? I mean, She has family. I don't know if there's a living or not, but, you know, it's emotional any way you look at it.
00:19:36
Speaker 1: Right.
00:19:37
Speaker 3: And so it's not to be taken lightly. And so the core of this process is is medical, at least with the injection part. Right. I mean, a firing squad or. electric chair are different. But when medicines are being introduced, you have to make sure it's an effective process. agent or combination of agents. And I think we've seen that phenobarbital by itself, along with this other, you know, probable human error, right, of the IV placement. And it sounds like it's happened before. It is not appropriate.
00:20:12
Speaker 2: So doc, here's the other reality.
00:20:14
Speaker 1: When things go wrong and there's a failure during the death penalty, that could also be traumatic for the victims that are invited to To watch.
00:20:25
Speaker 3: Oh, I think there's a psychological component to this for everybody involved, whether you're talking about victim surviving families or, you know, the person who's being put to death and their relatives or anybody who's watching or involved.
00:20:41
Speaker 1: You know.
00:20:42
Speaker 3: I think it's such a serious process to take a life that if it's going to be used, it needs to be done correctly.
00:20:52
Speaker 1: Absolutely.
00:20:53
Speaker 2: Absolutely. Well, doctor, thank you, thank you, thank you.
00:20:57
Speaker 1: You answered so many questions that I did not know, and I appreciate you as always.
00:21:02
Speaker 3: Oh, thank you.
00:21:04
Speaker 1: Y'all, I'm going to end Zone 7 the way that I always do, with a quote. When you sit around at dinner talking about the death penalty, it's hard to find relevance in the color shoes will be next season.
00:21:18
Speaker 2: Kenneth Cole. I'm Cheryl McCollum, and this is Zone 7.