TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.283 --> 00:00:04.731
Slowing down, holding your thoughts
and the thoughts of others can
00:00:04.731 --> 00:00:07.037
dramatically improve your communication.
00:00:07.462 --> 00:00:10.440
My name's Matt Abrahams, and I
teach Strategic Communication at
00:00:10.443 --> 00:00:12.165
Stanford Graduate School of Business.
00:00:12.386 --> 00:00:16.183
Welcome to Think Fast,
Talk Smart, the podcast.
00:00:20.965 --> 00:00:23.031
Today I'm excited to
chat with Frish Brandt.
00:00:23.482 --> 00:00:28.123
Frish is a professional letter midwife and
the author of Unfinished Business: Writing
00:00:28.127 --> 00:00:29.756
the Five Essential Letters of Your Life.
00:00:30.288 --> 00:00:34.269
For over a decade, Frish has guided
people in finding the most important
00:00:34.298 --> 00:00:38.405
words to write for critical personal
messages, including letters of
00:00:38.405 --> 00:00:41.155
gratitude, apology, and goodbye.
00:00:41.609 --> 00:00:45.030
Drawing on her 40-year background in
the arts, she now lives in San Francisco
00:00:45.030 --> 00:00:48.715
and Santa Cruz, teaching essential
letter writing and deep listening at
00:00:48.715 --> 00:00:50.603
Stanford University School of Medicine.
00:00:51.585 --> 00:00:52.750
Well, welcome, Frish.
00:00:52.800 --> 00:00:56.077
I am so thrilled to have you here,
and ever since we met, I've been
00:00:56.077 --> 00:00:57.944
excited to have you on the show.
00:00:57.984 --> 00:00:58.943
Uh, thanks for being here.
00:00:59.339 --> 00:01:00.699
I am delighted to be here.
00:01:00.782 --> 00:01:01.508
Excellent.
00:01:01.520 --> 00:01:02.363
Shall we get started?
00:01:02.504 --> 00:01:02.966
Let's go.
00:01:03.017 --> 00:01:03.583
Okay.
00:01:03.993 --> 00:01:06.711
You call yourself a letter midwife.
00:01:07.323 --> 00:01:10.032
What does this mean, and
what is it that you do?
00:01:10.916 --> 00:01:13.026
I help people find their words.
00:01:13.657 --> 00:01:18.126
A lot of people have letters that they're
afraid to write, that they don't know
00:01:18.126 --> 00:01:23.271
where to begin, they don't know how to
navigate, and my job is to encourage
00:01:23.271 --> 00:01:25.491
them to do that and to find their words.
00:01:26.038 --> 00:01:32.256
And what is it specifically about
letter writing versus typing a
00:01:32.258 --> 00:01:34.395
Substack or writing an email?
00:01:34.675 --> 00:01:38.199
The thing about a letter, whether
it's handwritten or typed, and even
00:01:38.199 --> 00:01:42.916
whether it's sent electronically,
though I prefer on paper in any form.
00:01:44.786 --> 00:01:49.157
So much of our lives are digital, and
so much of it is ephemeral, and we
00:01:49.158 --> 00:01:50.921
can't distinguish one from the other.
00:01:52.603 --> 00:01:56.926
For the listeners who have a letter,
they know the difference, and the
00:01:56.947 --> 00:02:00.220
other listeners who wish they had
one, they know the difference, too.
00:02:00.383 --> 00:02:01.550
I hosted a, a party.
00:02:01.551 --> 00:02:04.312
You came, and you wrote such
a lovely thank you note.
00:02:04.357 --> 00:02:08.795
And what was cool is it was a
handwritten note, uh, that came on
00:02:08.810 --> 00:02:13.364
nice stationery, and it was just lovely
to get a, a handwritten note that
00:02:13.364 --> 00:02:15.269
came with care and thought, you know.
00:02:15.271 --> 00:02:15.867
So thank you.
00:02:16.562 --> 00:02:22.001
Your book subtitle is The Five
Essential Letters of Your Life.
00:02:22.627 --> 00:02:24.958
What are those five letters,
and what makes them essential?
00:02:25.575 --> 00:02:28.202
Well, there's a few caveats.
00:02:28.233 --> 00:02:28.674
Okay.
00:02:28.749 --> 00:02:33.690
But we'll start with the answer would
seem to be thank you, I'm sorry,
00:02:33.998 --> 00:02:36.303
I miss you, I love you, goodbye.
00:02:37.103 --> 00:02:38.843
And then there's two for extra credit.
00:02:39.071 --> 00:02:39.583
Of course.
00:02:40.112 --> 00:02:43.840
And the two for extra credit might in
fact be the solar plexus of the book.
00:02:44.601 --> 00:02:49.517
I think the title is useful and it,
hopefully inviting and enticing,
00:02:50.164 --> 00:02:51.553
but it's not the whole story.
00:02:52.457 --> 00:02:54.422
And there's a few things to know.
00:02:54.460 --> 00:02:57.077
One, you could start with
any one of those letters.
00:02:57.077 --> 00:02:59.199
Write, I have an apology I want to write.
00:02:59.425 --> 00:03:00.589
I have an I miss you.
00:03:01.308 --> 00:03:05.242
But it will morph into one of the other
letters, maybe two of the other letters.
00:03:06.019 --> 00:03:09.942
And at the heart of it, every letter
is really a love letter because
00:03:09.947 --> 00:03:11.295
that's really what brings it.
00:03:11.317 --> 00:03:16.247
Even if it's a you piss me off
letter, we care enough to say it.
00:03:16.724 --> 00:03:18.605
So, and we're trying to resolve something.
00:03:19.230 --> 00:03:23.810
I have one of each type of letter
that you just delineated in mind that
00:03:23.812 --> 00:03:27.904
needs to be written or I would benefit
and perhaps the other would as well.
00:03:29.380 --> 00:03:32.914
The letters that you, uh, help
people write, who are they for?
00:03:33.037 --> 00:03:37.344
Are they for the recipient, or are
they for the writer of the letter?
00:03:37.566 --> 00:03:42.721
The truth is, when I started this
practice 11 or 12 years ago, I thought
00:03:42.760 --> 00:03:44.802
for certain it was for the recipient.
00:03:45.283 --> 00:03:50.618
But I learned really early on, actually
with a woman with ALS, and it was
00:03:50.619 --> 00:03:53.160
advancing quickly after seven years.
00:03:53.171 --> 00:03:54.218
And that's a neurological disease.
00:03:54.226 --> 00:03:54.587
Yes.
00:03:54.595 --> 00:03:54.788
Yeah.
00:03:55.087 --> 00:03:58.914
I realized very early that it was
really for the letter writer first.
00:03:59.202 --> 00:04:05.517
Load full transcript
So to your question, it's for both, but
the letter writer is served by it first.
00:04:06.055 --> 00:04:08.556
We're gonna get to this in a moment,
but I'm gonna be very curious about
00:04:08.557 --> 00:04:10.691
the process you take people through.
00:04:10.830 --> 00:04:12.980
Uh, but I wanna quote
something that you write.
00:04:13.190 --> 00:04:17.753
You write that, "Letter writing is to
communication what slow cooking is to fast
00:04:17.763 --> 00:04:23.265
food. The slow pace is fundamental to the
end result." Can you unpack that analogy?
00:04:23.265 --> 00:04:25.392
I'm a sucker for a good
analogy, and I like that one.
00:04:25.633 --> 00:04:28.676
How does slowing down help
us communicate better?
00:04:29.229 --> 00:04:32.732
Again, I think that we are
in such a fast-paced world.
00:04:33.356 --> 00:04:37.151
I'm as haunted by the fact that a
quick text, suddenly I look and I go,
00:04:37.426 --> 00:04:39.225
"What does it, what did I just type?"
00:04:39.295 --> 00:04:39.565
Right.
00:04:39.776 --> 00:04:40.125
You know?
00:04:40.366 --> 00:04:43.640
So I think so much communication
happens so quickly.
00:04:43.903 --> 00:04:50.780
Sitting down with a piece of paper or
one's keyboard to think out a letter.
00:04:50.797 --> 00:04:55.913
Science is in that thinking and writing
are deeply connected, and if we give
00:04:55.915 --> 00:04:59.327
up the writing, our thinking suffers.
00:05:00.612 --> 00:05:05.054
And we know the correspondence that we
tap out really quickly and the one that
00:05:05.054 --> 00:05:11.120
we sit quietly with has a different
tenor, the same way that a, a dinner
00:05:11.140 --> 00:05:15.555
made from frozen food or a dinner
cooked slowly has a different tenor.
00:05:15.911 --> 00:05:19.832
Yeah, the, the, the feeling and the
emotion, you know, are really different.
00:05:20.093 --> 00:05:24.283
Just like cooking is also for the
cook, I think that that's the writing.
00:05:24.320 --> 00:05:28.469
That's why the letter also serves the
letter writer first, because they're
00:05:28.649 --> 00:05:30.758
generating something from deep within.
00:05:31.218 --> 00:05:32.487
Right, and it takes time to do that.
00:05:32.578 --> 00:05:33.387
And it takes time.
00:05:33.555 --> 00:05:36.550
So walk me through the process you
would walk somebody through, like
00:05:36.550 --> 00:05:39.596
myself, in, in needing to write or
wanting to write one of those letters.
00:05:39.702 --> 00:05:40.085
Okay.
00:05:40.206 --> 00:05:43.028
You said you have a few letters
you know you need to write.
00:05:43.058 --> 00:05:43.178
Yes.
00:05:43.180 --> 00:05:47.198
I'm not gonna make you reveal anything,
but when I do this with people, and
00:05:47.198 --> 00:05:52.788
certainly when I do it in workshop,
everyone needs to focus on the letter or
00:05:52.790 --> 00:05:54.384
letters that they think they wanna write.
00:05:54.552 --> 00:05:56.182
So focus on one of those letters.
00:05:56.194 --> 00:05:57.516
I'm, uh, I'll, I'll be very candid.
00:05:57.531 --> 00:05:59.021
I'm gonna think about a gratitude letter.
00:05:59.021 --> 00:06:02.685
I wanna say thank you to some
people who I, I hope know that I'm
00:06:02.686 --> 00:06:05.712
grateful, but I'd like to actually
put a, an exclamation point on that.
00:06:06.204 --> 00:06:09.071
My question really would then
be, what are you waiting for?
00:06:09.408 --> 00:06:12.947
I mean, I'm busy, and it's easy to put it
on the back burner, to use your cooking
00:06:12.947 --> 00:06:14.628
analogy, but, uh, there's nothing.
00:06:15.083 --> 00:06:18.768
And wouldn't you feel good if
by the end of the day, or the
00:06:18.768 --> 00:06:21.605
beginning of tomorrow, you had
actually written the first sentence?
00:06:21.626 --> 00:06:23.916
100%, I would feel very good about that.
00:06:24.095 --> 00:06:25.994
Do you think I can have
your buy-in on that?
00:06:26.976 --> 00:06:28.630
I'm being led down a path here, Frish.
00:06:28.671 --> 00:06:28.936
Yes.
00:06:28.936 --> 00:06:30.727
Well, you asked me to
lead you down a path.
00:06:30.727 --> 00:06:31.325
Absolutely.
00:06:31.325 --> 00:06:32.716
I'm fully, uh, on, on board.
00:06:32.822 --> 00:06:36.911
And I hope that your listeners too are
thinking, "Ah, right, I do have that
00:06:36.911 --> 00:06:41.355
thank you letter." Thank you is such
a great place to begin because a thank
00:06:41.355 --> 00:06:43.671
you is always welcomed, no pun intended.
00:06:44.623 --> 00:06:46.683
And it feels good.
00:06:46.774 --> 00:06:50.595
You know, where there's so many things
that are divisive, it's so constructive,
00:06:51.151 --> 00:06:53.081
and it never comes at the wrong time.
00:06:53.424 --> 00:06:54.869
It's kind of like money, you know?
00:06:55.698 --> 00:06:58.351
I agree, and we have had several
academics on the show who've talked
00:06:58.355 --> 00:06:59.584
about the power of gratitude.
00:06:59.866 --> 00:07:04.710
Uh, Sonja Lyubomirsky, uh, studies this
and has studied it, and really powerfully,
00:07:05.217 --> 00:07:08.663
uh, affects not just you, but the person
that you're expressing gratitude to.
00:07:08.663 --> 00:07:11.409
So happy to learn how to
do this and to initiate.
00:07:11.761 --> 00:07:12.466
So how do we do it?
00:07:13.211 --> 00:07:13.745
How do we do it?
00:07:13.782 --> 00:07:14.662
What's the process?
00:07:15.542 --> 00:07:19.873
When I'm doing it with someone, I drill
down with other questions so that it's
00:07:19.875 --> 00:07:23.796
not just, "Thanks for the beautiful
vase," you know, or, "Thanks for dinner."
00:07:24.243 --> 00:07:26.887
It's, "I met so many interesting people.
00:07:27.061 --> 00:07:31.210
In fact, I think I met my new best
friend," or, "It reminded me of a party
00:07:31.211 --> 00:07:35.727
I went to when I was a kid," or, "My
parents used to tell me about parties like
00:07:35.728 --> 00:07:38.923
this." So it's a matter of going further.
00:07:38.959 --> 00:07:40.132
How can I go further?
00:07:40.782 --> 00:07:44.183
What might I wish someone
noticed about the party I threw?
00:07:44.602 --> 00:07:47.310
I'm not saying that my thank you
note to you covered all that ground.
00:07:47.332 --> 00:07:51.677
It did a great job, and you did, you,
you definitely revealed how, how the
00:07:51.677 --> 00:07:54.038
gathering we had had impact on you.
00:07:54.409 --> 00:07:57.962
So it wasn't just expressing
gratitude for hosting.
00:07:57.985 --> 00:07:59.762
It was gratitude for the impact.
00:07:59.768 --> 00:07:59.788
Yeah.
00:07:59.793 --> 00:08:02.548
So the point is, how can you,
one go a little bit deeper?
00:08:02.552 --> 00:08:08.759
How can one look from a slightly different
angle at that thing, you know, whether
00:08:08.760 --> 00:08:13.584
it is a vase or whether it's a dinner
or whether it's a walk in the woods?
00:08:13.877 --> 00:08:18.747
I really like that it's about reflecting
and reflecting about the impact.
00:08:18.820 --> 00:08:22.224
And it's not just for letter-writing,
in any communication, if you think about
00:08:22.239 --> 00:08:23.875
your audience and think about the impact.
00:08:24.361 --> 00:08:28.693
And it, and it leads to, if not
a full-blown story, it leads
00:08:28.696 --> 00:08:31.369
to some elements of a story,
and we connect through story.
00:08:31.433 --> 00:08:32.343
I appreciate that.
00:08:32.899 --> 00:08:34.501
I've been reflecting as
you've been speaking.
00:08:34.503 --> 00:08:38.284
Part of why I haven't done this
or written this letter is I
00:08:38.286 --> 00:08:40.019
really don't know how to start.
00:08:40.088 --> 00:08:40.969
I know how to end.
00:08:40.980 --> 00:08:44.824
I really wanna say I appreciate it,
and I want us to continue developing,
00:08:44.872 --> 00:08:46.237
uh, our relationship, et cetera.
00:08:46.834 --> 00:08:50.932
How do we get from the
blank page to, to something?
00:08:50.977 --> 00:08:52.209
You could start anywhere.
00:08:52.396 --> 00:08:54.879
And if you know where you're
ending, then just put that down,
00:08:55.281 --> 00:08:56.939
and it may end up being the launch.
00:08:57.064 --> 00:09:00.057
And then you could say, "I didn't
even know where to begin this note,
00:09:00.866 --> 00:09:02.631
but I wanted to be sure to say this.
00:09:02.698 --> 00:09:04.630
And I didn't want any more time to go by,
00:09:04.630 --> 00:09:05.386
Oh, that's interesting.
00:09:05.386 --> 00:09:07.254
Without having said these things.
00:09:07.689 --> 00:09:12.853
I, I know that if something
happens, I wanna be sure you know
00:09:12.854 --> 00:09:14.209
how important this was to me."
00:09:15.110 --> 00:09:18.883
I really like that idea of disclosing, "I,
I'm struggling with how to start this."
00:09:18.884 --> 00:09:19.153
Yeah.
00:09:19.329 --> 00:09:22.659
And that vulnerability, I
actually think, can be endearing.
00:09:22.664 --> 00:09:22.932
Yeah.
00:09:23.815 --> 00:09:28.117
Many a good letter starts with, "This
is awkward," and whether it says that
00:09:28.127 --> 00:09:31.129
or it's just that feeling, so owning it.
00:09:31.780 --> 00:09:36.202
In thinking about the conversation we
would be having, I thought you do so
00:09:36.203 --> 00:09:42.125
much of your work with people in terms of
their speaking, and here a letter lasts.
00:09:42.247 --> 00:09:46.011
We know that the connection that we
make with someone can be resonant,
00:09:46.516 --> 00:09:48.846
but a letter lingers, you know?
00:09:48.880 --> 00:09:51.507
It, we change, but the letter doesn't.
00:09:52.008 --> 00:09:55.439
I love that language, "A, a letter
lingers," and, and it really does.
00:09:55.439 --> 00:09:57.103
I mean, I, I'm a pack rat.
00:09:57.104 --> 00:09:58.343
I, I keep lots of stuff.
00:09:58.377 --> 00:10:01.483
I have notes that we used to pass
in elementary school from the girl
00:10:01.484 --> 00:10:04.019
I liked or, you know, when we were
saying something about the teacher.
00:10:04.331 --> 00:10:05.271
but they really do last.
00:10:05.363 --> 00:10:09.018
And, and what's interesting is when
I read them, uh, besides being amazed
00:10:09.018 --> 00:10:12.757
at my handwriting, uh, I, instantly
I have an emotional response.
00:10:12.993 --> 00:10:14.324
There's an emotional connection.
00:10:14.324 --> 00:10:16.873
It opens up a door and, and
there's a power in that.
00:10:17.223 --> 00:10:19.641
And we can harness that power in
all of our communication, but I
00:10:19.652 --> 00:10:21.291
think letters do that in particular.
00:10:21.571 --> 00:10:23.645
I wanna talk about a
specific type of letter.
00:10:23.646 --> 00:10:27.896
You, you advocate for writing
cathartic letters, highly charged,
00:10:27.920 --> 00:10:31.984
angry, raw letters that you explicitly
instruct the writers never to
00:10:31.986 --> 00:10:34.416
send and to immediately destroy.
00:10:34.933 --> 00:10:38.439
Uh, you call this both an
exercise and an exorcism, and of
00:10:38.439 --> 00:10:39.689
course, I love the play on words.
00:10:39.998 --> 00:10:44.882
Why is writing something that we intend
to destroy so useful and helpful for us?
00:10:45.477 --> 00:10:47.156
We're carrying it around with us.
00:10:47.262 --> 00:10:48.681
It's taking up space.
00:10:49.271 --> 00:10:54.498
It's kinda nipping at our heels,
you know, biting us in the neck.
00:10:55.868 --> 00:10:57.930
I don't think any of us
really wanna carry that.
00:10:57.930 --> 00:11:03.534
That's taking up the space that gratitude,
for instance, or regard can take.
00:11:04.020 --> 00:11:09.471
So I advocate for writing it to just
get it out, and it is possible that in
00:11:09.472 --> 00:11:14.030
the process of getting it out, that one
will get to a place where, "Oh, I think
00:11:14.031 --> 00:11:18.603
I could tell this one, this person,
this thing, this part," because if we
00:11:18.604 --> 00:11:23.068
want, this is where the love comes
in,
if I don't wanna give up that friendship
00:11:23.228 --> 00:11:29.257
or that collegiality, how do I just
say, "You stepped on my toes that day.
00:11:29.609 --> 00:11:31.055
I've had bad days, too"?
00:11:32.105 --> 00:11:35.749
I think it, it, it brings out our
own empathy, both for ourselves
00:11:35.749 --> 00:11:36.898
and for the other person.
00:11:37.261 --> 00:11:41.638
Yeah, I like that idea of self-empathy
that can come through the catharsis
00:11:41.642 --> 00:11:43.236
of just getting things done.
00:11:43.629 --> 00:11:46.583
There's some research, uh, that I'm
familiar with in the, in the literature
00:11:46.583 --> 00:11:52.196
on anxiety around communication,
that writing down the fear, literally
00:11:52.196 --> 00:11:55.497
getting it out of your head and
somewhere else can be helpful.
00:11:55.790 --> 00:11:58.248
And somebody took that even to an
extreme and said, "Okay, once you
00:11:58.248 --> 00:12:02.391
write it, take the paper, crumple
it, and throw it away," and just the,
00:12:02.400 --> 00:12:07.025
the thought that you have that sense
of agency to do that is empowering.
00:12:07.035 --> 00:12:10.669
And so I, I really can see how
writing down an emotionally charged
00:12:10.720 --> 00:12:12.116
letter could, could be helpful.
00:12:12.128 --> 00:12:12.373
Right.
00:12:12.670 --> 00:12:18.860
And conversely, I think writing down
the, the warm letter has a similar impact
00:12:19.006 --> 00:12:21.110
on the positive spectrum of emotions.
00:12:21.330 --> 00:12:22.241
Ah, interesting.
00:12:22.367 --> 00:12:26.007
Uh, your work often involves helping
people say high-stakes words like, "I'm
00:12:26.010 --> 00:12:31.712
sorry," "Forgive me," "I forgive you."
These are incredibly difficult messages.
00:12:32.149 --> 00:12:37.001
What communication advice do you have
for structuring an apology or request for
00:12:37.001 --> 00:12:42.011
forgiveness so that it lands authentically
and avoids triggering defensiveness?
00:12:42.041 --> 00:12:45.236
Because you risk that when you bring
up these types of communication.
00:12:45.557 --> 00:12:48.025
I recently had an experience like this.
00:12:48.059 --> 00:12:50.218
I don't wanna go into
too much detail here.
00:12:50.499 --> 00:12:52.329
But one takes the path.
00:12:52.469 --> 00:12:59.327
I think the reason why writing is a,
is a gerund is because it's an act.
00:12:59.504 --> 00:13:00.885
It's not generated.
00:13:01.164 --> 00:13:03.122
I think that it is difficult.
00:13:03.244 --> 00:13:05.013
Apologizing is difficult.
00:13:05.649 --> 00:13:10.036
One of the beautiful things about doing
it in writing is that one has the time to
00:13:10.037 --> 00:13:14.447
gather their thoughts, and the recipient
has time to receive those thoughts.
00:13:15.402 --> 00:13:20.581
I think one still has to exercise some
of those basic tools of mirroring and
00:13:20.581 --> 00:13:24.890
empathy and validation, and you can do
that in speaking or in
writing or both.
00:13:24.944 --> 00:13:28.751
It's difficult, but the beauty
of a written apology is you
00:13:28.752 --> 00:13:30.844
don't have to respond right away.
00:13:30.905 --> 00:13:36.466
You can look at it, look at it again,
look at it again, rethink your words.
00:13:37.171 --> 00:13:39.096
Maybe have a friend read them back to you.
00:13:39.247 --> 00:13:40.082
Oh, interesting, yeah.
00:13:40.291 --> 00:13:45.019
I like the, the thoughtfulness
that a letter of apology or asking
00:13:45.020 --> 00:13:47.066
for forgiveness, uh, brings.
00:13:47.528 --> 00:13:48.029
Thank you.
00:13:48.480 --> 00:13:52.381
AI obviously is helping people
write a lot of things these days.
00:13:52.422 --> 00:13:56.238
AI can be a very useful tool in
helping us with our communication.
00:13:56.965 --> 00:14:00.755
I'd be curious to get your thoughts
on where AI fits in this process.
00:14:00.779 --> 00:14:02.362
It can be a good partner.
00:14:02.669 --> 00:14:04.190
We're just the pioneers right now.
00:14:04.193 --> 00:14:06.743
We're just at the edge
of the, of the territory.
00:14:07.540 --> 00:14:11.915
But if I understand correctly,
or, and how I use it and how the
00:14:11.915 --> 00:14:16.206
people I know use it, the catch is
that it is a great thought partner.
00:14:17.157 --> 00:14:20.666
But writing is a verb,
and you have to do it.
00:14:20.667 --> 00:14:23.089
It's not, computers process.
00:14:23.587 --> 00:14:25.078
We write.
00:14:25.715 --> 00:14:29.344
We might do some processing in
our heads, but we're not talking
00:14:29.355 --> 00:14:30.814
about just generating a letter.
00:14:30.838 --> 00:14:34.870
We're talking about, not to play on
the midwifery, but we're really talking
00:14:34.870 --> 00:14:40.726
about birthing it or at least bringing
it into existence, and that is an act.
00:14:40.881 --> 00:14:42.565
It's not a noun.
00:14:43.071 --> 00:14:47.333
And so I think AIs are, can
be very helpful, especially to
00:14:47.334 --> 00:14:50.801
the earlier questions about,
how the heck do I get started?
00:14:50.999 --> 00:14:54.693
I think there's nothing wrong with
using as that, but really recognizing.
00:14:55.022 --> 00:14:59.372
You know, I have a friend through
Stanford who's at the forefront of AI
00:14:59.390 --> 00:15:04.090
and virtual reality, and I'd seen on his
screen when we were having a Zoom that
00:15:04.091 --> 00:15:08.722
he had written a toast to his mother
and a letter to his oldest son on it.
00:15:08.734 --> 00:15:14.379
And I said, "How did that go?" And he
said, "Well, ultimately, it didn't work.
00:15:14.936 --> 00:15:20.234
I found I had to dig deep inside myself
to write the letter." Otherwise, the
00:15:20.235 --> 00:15:21.986
writer doesn't have the experience.
00:15:21.987 --> 00:15:23.818
You don't get to process.
00:15:24.115 --> 00:15:28.469
I talk a lot about empathy atrophy
that can happen with AI if you
00:15:28.470 --> 00:15:29.703
don't do that deep thinking.
00:15:30.037 --> 00:15:33.806
Uh, a friend of mine said, you know,
when you're, whatever LLM tool you use,
00:15:33.806 --> 00:15:37.223
when it says it's thinking and it'll put
thinking dot dot dot, that's actually
00:15:37.223 --> 00:15:40.073
a cue to you to start thinking, right?
00:15:40.342 --> 00:15:41.648
You know, so it's not the machine.
00:15:41.648 --> 00:15:43.793
It's, it's like, "Hey, you need
to be thinking about this as
00:15:43.794 --> 00:15:44.863
well," and I like that a lot.
00:15:45.997 --> 00:15:50.531
You co-teach a class called Lasting
Letters and the Art of Deep Listening
00:15:50.532 --> 00:15:52.484
at Stanford School of Medicine.
00:15:52.990 --> 00:15:56.402
In communication, we spend a lot of
time teaching people how to speak,
00:15:56.425 --> 00:16:00.703
generate messages, but very little
time teaching them how to listen.
00:16:01.141 --> 00:16:05.248
Uh, what does deep listening look
like in practice, and how can we
00:16:05.249 --> 00:16:07.855
train ourselves to be deep listeners?
00:16:08.484 --> 00:16:09.989
Well, it looks pretty much like this.
00:16:12.393 --> 00:16:16.361
For those of you who are listening
and not watching, Frish tilted her
00:16:16.362 --> 00:16:18.896
head, smiled, and widened her eyes.
00:16:18.931 --> 00:16:22.207
Okay, what's going on in the,
in your head as you do that?
00:16:22.304 --> 00:16:28.044
Um, I think listening is silencing
my, the chatter that's going on.
00:16:28.406 --> 00:16:30.581
I'm not thinking about
what I'm going to say next.
00:16:30.727 --> 00:16:32.140
I'm holding what you're saying.
00:16:32.845 --> 00:16:35.665
You know, when I think about good
communicators, one person that I thought
00:16:35.665 --> 00:16:41.376
of was Frank Ostaseski, the Buddhist
teacher who spends a lot of time bedside,
00:16:41.458 --> 00:16:45.825
and much of my work is, is, the foundation
is in hospice and palliative care.
00:16:46.776 --> 00:16:50.406
Being present is really at
the center of listening.
00:16:50.897 --> 00:16:53.619
Nothing really happens
unless we're present.
00:16:54.092 --> 00:16:57.194
I like that definition of listening, of
being present, and the thing that really
00:16:57.194 --> 00:17:01.175
struck me is, I have not thought of
this before, but this idea of holding.
00:17:01.342 --> 00:17:04.945
In communication, you're holding
the other person present.
00:17:04.962 --> 00:17:06.905
You're holding the moment present.
00:17:07.357 --> 00:17:10.773
You're holding back your thoughts
and judgment and evaluation.
00:17:10.892 --> 00:17:13.430
Let me give you a somatic exercise.
00:17:13.473 --> 00:17:13.771
Please.
00:17:13.781 --> 00:17:18.254
Sometimes when something's coming
at me across the table, for
00:17:18.254 --> 00:17:20.446
instance, I'll hold my hands open.
00:17:20.718 --> 00:17:21.628
Oh, interesting.
00:17:21.705 --> 00:17:23.535
It just slows me down.
00:17:23.537 --> 00:17:27.217
It keeps me present so
that
I can receive what's coming.
00:17:27.838 --> 00:17:33.011
I'm a big fan of, uh, embodiment
of our thoughts and, uh, a lot of
00:17:33.021 --> 00:17:37.008
people, if you watch, I, I coach
a lot of, uh, executives on tough
00:17:37.042 --> 00:17:39.220
Q&A, question and answer situations.
00:17:39.598 --> 00:17:42.784
And instinctively, when something
is asked that they don't like or
00:17:42.785 --> 00:17:47.030
they're concerned with, hands come up,
looks very defensive, uh, and that's
00:17:47.031 --> 00:17:49.016
a response, a physical response.
00:17:49.017 --> 00:17:52.046
And I like what you're doing is
you're cuing yourself, "I need to
00:17:52.057 --> 00:17:55.542
be open here and hold something
by, by opening." Uh, I like that.
00:17:55.617 --> 00:17:56.867
I think there's a lot of power in that.
00:17:56.869 --> 00:17:57.679
Thank you for sharing.
00:17:58.549 --> 00:18:00.029
Thank you for sharing
everything you've done.
00:18:00.045 --> 00:18:03.000
Uh, you know, before we end, I,
I love to ask three questions.
00:18:03.001 --> 00:18:05.853
One I'm gonna make up just for you, and
two I've asked everybody for a long time.
00:18:05.854 --> 00:18:06.483
Are you up for that?
00:18:06.777 --> 00:18:07.473
I'm up for that.
00:18:07.969 --> 00:18:10.943
When we started, you said that
there are two bonus letters.
00:18:11.383 --> 00:18:12.434
What are those letters?
00:18:12.732 --> 00:18:18.006
They are legacy letters, which could
easily be to our, to our children
00:18:18.052 --> 00:18:21.880
or our children's children, but it
could also be to our niece, or it
00:18:21.880 --> 00:18:26.911
could be to the young boy around the
corner, or it could be to a sibling.
00:18:27.697 --> 00:18:28.834
It may be to a parent.
00:18:29.206 --> 00:18:31.205
I would say legacy letters of that kind.
00:18:31.602 --> 00:18:33.947
Um, sometimes they're
considered ethical wills.
00:18:34.312 --> 00:18:36.826
In the Jewish tradition, there's
such a thing as ethical wills.
00:18:36.826 --> 00:18:39.406
It's, it's as good a
model as any for this.
00:18:40.151 --> 00:18:45.836
And the other one is writing to or from
our future selves because it's a trick.
00:18:46.469 --> 00:18:53.661
We think sometimes we're stuck, but
if we just pretend that my 90-year-old
00:18:53.667 --> 00:19:00.422
self is sending me a letter, I get some
wisdoms that just pop up and vice versa.
00:19:00.432 --> 00:19:03.669
If my younger self says, "Hey,
you're doing a good job," or,
00:19:03.846 --> 00:19:06.726
"You could lighten up a little
bit on this part of your life."
00:19:07.296 --> 00:19:10.364
We did a whole episode on, on
communicating with your future self
00:19:10.364 --> 00:19:11.428
and the value that it can bring.
00:19:11.430 --> 00:19:15.885
Uh, I love that it's, it's legacy
and the time-traveling, uh, letter.
00:19:16.473 --> 00:19:19.889
Question number two: Who is a
communicator that you admire and why?
00:19:20.310 --> 00:19:25.438
Well, besides Frank Ostaseski
for his presence, I was thinking
00:19:25.438 --> 00:19:29.823
about the conversation between
Krista Tippett and John O'Donohue,
00:19:30.568 --> 00:19:35.120
which is so exquisitely beautiful,
and John died just months later.
00:19:35.732 --> 00:19:37.540
But he said some things in it.
00:19:37.778 --> 00:19:43.460
First off, she was a, she is a
very gifted interviewer because she
00:19:43.460 --> 00:19:49.898
listens, and it is a, though I'm not
a rock climber per se, I think a good
00:19:49.898 --> 00:19:51.693
conversation is like rock climbing.
00:19:51.701 --> 00:19:56.782
You pass each other on the way and you're,
you're helping each other find your way.
00:19:57.017 --> 00:20:02.279
In John's quote, which I have here, um,
he says, "When was the last time you
00:20:02.283 --> 00:20:06.909
had a great conversation? You know, a
conversation that took you someplace that
00:20:06.910 --> 00:20:11.360
you didn't know, that you heard yourself
saying things that you had never really
00:20:11.364 --> 00:20:16.290
thought before, a conversation that
stayed with you for days. And that doesn't
00:20:16.291 --> 00:20:17.950
happen just by doing all the talking."
00:20:18.656 --> 00:20:19.459
No, not at all.
00:20:19.475 --> 00:20:21.361
It, it's, it's the
listening and the presence.
00:20:21.940 --> 00:20:26.518
I appreciate that, and I appreciate
that the communicator you picked was
00:20:27.014 --> 00:20:28.889
a conversation between two people.
00:20:29.056 --> 00:20:29.457
Thank you.
00:20:30.181 --> 00:20:34.818
What are the first three ingredients that
go into a successful communication recipe?
00:20:35.565 --> 00:20:38.426
Well, I think I've touched on all of them.
00:20:39.149 --> 00:20:44.427
And in either equal proportions and
in no particular order, well, there's
00:20:44.428 --> 00:20:49.926
listening, needless to say, and
there's empathy, and there's humility.
00:20:50.177 --> 00:20:51.377
Tell me about the humility.
00:20:51.485 --> 00:20:53.370
We've definitely talked
about empathy and listening.
00:20:53.370 --> 00:20:53.380
Yeah.
00:20:53.760 --> 00:20:59.399
I think that We need to enter
conversations knowing that we don't
00:20:59.405 --> 00:21:04.167
know, and not even knowing what we don't
know, just knowing that we don't know.
00:21:04.497 --> 00:21:06.053
I think it's kind of like fly fishing.
00:21:06.271 --> 00:21:09.649
You, you choose your fly not
exactly knowing, you can't see
00:21:09.649 --> 00:21:13.245
everything you're doing, but you
are just, you're reading the signs.
00:21:13.572 --> 00:21:17.361
And I think we, I was talking with
Gordon before about musicians.
00:21:17.411 --> 00:21:22.927
I think musicians that play
together, whether it's rock or
00:21:23.022 --> 00:21:28.119
classical or jazz, that they're a
fabulous example of communication
00:21:28.119 --> 00:21:29.949
because so much of it is unspoken.
00:21:30.414 --> 00:21:35.371
But I once sat in on a quartet
practicing, and I was brought to
00:21:35.371 --> 00:21:40.898
tears by the communication that
took place when nobody was speaking.
00:21:41.378 --> 00:21:43.564
There is something magical in music.
00:21:44.376 --> 00:21:47.067
Humility is absolutely, I
think, an essential ingredient.
00:21:47.071 --> 00:21:47.559
Thank you.
00:21:47.899 --> 00:21:49.674
And thank you for introducing
everybody to Gordon.
00:21:49.674 --> 00:21:50.999
Gordon helps us record these shows.
00:21:51.212 --> 00:21:51.839
Thank you, Gordon.
00:21:51.839 --> 00:21:53.317
And we, we don't talk
about him often enough.
00:21:53.370 --> 00:21:58.222
Uh, great conversation, really helpful
insight into how to communicate
00:21:58.223 --> 00:22:01.323
in a different modality than many
of us do, and the impact that
00:22:01.323 --> 00:22:02.841
it can have on us and on others.
00:22:02.844 --> 00:22:04.253
I appreciate your time and insight.
00:22:04.697 --> 00:22:05.201
Thank you.
00:22:05.216 --> 00:22:06.463
Thank you for having me here.
00:22:06.495 --> 00:22:10.764
I hope your listeners pull out a piece
of paper and start writing a letter.
00:22:11.099 --> 00:22:13.125
Thank you for joining us
for another episode of Think
00:22:13.125 --> 00:22:14.928
Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
00:22:15.078 --> 00:22:17.018
I so enjoyed talking to Frish.
00:22:17.308 --> 00:22:20.956
Among her many ideas that she shared
that stuck with me, the one that really
00:22:20.957 --> 00:22:26.427
stands out is holding somebody's thoughts
in mind when you listen and holding
00:22:26.446 --> 00:22:28.719
back your own thoughts when you listen.
00:22:29.415 --> 00:22:32.265
To learn more about listening
and silence, please listen to
00:22:32.266 --> 00:22:34.583
episode 114 with Julian Treasure.
00:22:35.114 --> 00:22:38.826
This episode was produced by
Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, Alex
00:22:38.831 --> 00:22:41.040
McCarthy, and me, Matt Abrahams.
00:22:41.379 --> 00:22:45.620
Our music is from Floyd Wonder, with
special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
00:22:46.329 --> 00:22:48.715
Have you ever wished you could
get communication coaching
00:22:48.732 --> 00:22:50.068
exactly when you need it?
00:22:50.376 --> 00:22:55.186
Well, you can with Coach Matt, an AI coach
trained on my work, spoken in my voice.
00:22:55.501 --> 00:22:58.885
Go to fastersmarter.io and
click on the Coach Matt popup to
00:22:58.887 --> 00:23:00.677
get 10 minutes of free advice.
00:23:00.887 --> 00:23:03.971
It's super easy and
hopefully super useful.