TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:15.680
[upbeat music] This week's episode is brought to you by Beehiiv. I wanna tell you about something I think a lot of you will find useful.
2
00:00:15.760 --> 00:00:28.720
When you're running a media business, email is often, if not always, the backbone, and getting it right is unfortunately usually harder than it should be. And that is why I've been impressed and have been using Beehiiv.
3
00:00:29.160 --> 00:00:38.660
This is a platform that was built by people who scaled Morning Brew to millions of readers, and they created a platform they wish they had when they were in your shoes as a publisher.
4
00:00:38.940 --> 00:00:45.280
And so it is no surprise that companies like TechCrunch, Time, and the Texas Tribune are already running their newsletters on Beehiiv.
5
00:00:45.620 --> 00:00:57.520
It is designed for serious media operators, not marketers bolting on a newsletter as an afterthought. And here's the thing, if you're running a publication with more than 100,000 subscribers, Beehiiv is built for you.
6
00:00:57.680 --> 00:01:06.160
Their team has scaled newsletters at places like The Information, Park, and of course, Morning Brew, and they understand the challenges big publishers face.
7
00:01:06.460 --> 00:01:15.340
From seamless migration to enterprise-grade deliverability and monetization, Beehiiv makes it easy to grow, retain, and engage audiences at serious scale.
8
00:01:15.880 --> 00:01:32.540
If you wanna see what your next stage of growth can look like, go to beehiiv.com/trb. That is B-E-E-H-I-I-V.com/trb, and meet with their team of growth and newsletter experts today. Thank you so much, Beehiiv.
9
00:01:33.180 --> 00:01:44.340
Welcome to the Rebooting show. I am Brian Morrissey. I am joined today by Josh Kaplan. Josh is co-founder and CEO of Smooth Media. Welcome, Josh. Thank you so much for having me.
10
00:01:45.140 --> 00:01:57.160
I remember us talking about this in 2021 and what you were building with Smooth. And I was a believer. I did believe in, in, in the sector because I saw the... It wasn't like it was [laughs] you know, some big discovery.
11
00:01:57.620 --> 00:02:14.900
But the, the media ecosystem was rapidly decentralizing, and as someone who spent his career in B2B, I always thought, like, the most, the most potent combination is someone with direct experience in the area who is also good at the content stuff.
12
00:02:15.060 --> 00:02:26.840
I mean, it's a hard, it's, it's, it's a hard mix, but now we have examples out there. You know, there's the sort of canonical example of, like, a Lenny Rachitsky or whatnot. So let, let's just start.
13
00:02:26.900 --> 00:02:39.840
What was the original Smooth thesis? The original Smooth thesis is the same as, as when we met back in 2021 as it is today, is that creators are
14
00:02:40.760 --> 00:02:47.360
the most talented at captivating an audience on the internet today. I think they are definitely the future of media.
15
00:02:48.020 --> 00:03:01.660
And B2B media, business and technology media, you know, the media that we consume to complement the jobs that we spend so much time every day doing and trying to level up in, has been neglected for, for many years from my perspective.
16
00:03:01.680 --> 00:03:12.500
And that really was an eye-opening experience at Morning Brew, where I spent three years prior to starting Smooth with Jenny and Kinsey. And so seeing the intersection of the two, what is the future of creator?
17
00:03:12.940 --> 00:03:22.440
What is the future of business and tech media? What is gonna be that convergence? That thesis has been the same. We've been trying to pursue that for many, many years now.
18
00:03:22.880 --> 00:03:39.900
But where we first started by offering newsletter services, consulting services, a couple other things that, you know, seemed smart but weren't really it, has now led us to where we are now as a talent management company for knowledge creators, where we're able to help drive significant revenue for the creators that we partner with.
19
00:03:39.980 --> 00:03:52.560
So thesis-wise, very, very similar and very excited about how that's grown over the past five years. Okay, so w- a- along that, like, sort of journey, what were some, like, missteps? Or what were some...
20
00:03:52.900 --> 00:03:59.660
You know, I used to do these, like, Hash House Harriers, like, runs, where you would try to find, like, a path, and then it wouldn't actually be the path.
21
00:03:59.700 --> 00:04:09.140
You have to double back, and that's just part of, part of most journeys. But I'm just wondering, because I think the thesis has, like, completely held up, but, like, what were some of the areas that...
22
00:04:09.220 --> 00:04:16.720
'Cause you just test out hypotheses with these businesses and then see which ones work. Go, keep going down that. And if it doesn't work- [laughs]... you double back and go find a different path.
23
00:04:17.040 --> 00:04:28.060
So what were a couple, like, sort of false paths? The, the false path, the, the, the summary of the false paths is that we were going to charge creators money who were- Oh, yeah... creating value but weren't capturing...
24
00:04:28.640 --> 00:04:35.100
Well, we were charging creators. We were looking for a retainer. We were looking for some- Yeah, you might as well rob the library there, Josh. I could tell you. [laughs] Yeah, exact- And, and so we, we... No.
25
00:04:35.340 --> 00:04:38.060
You, you should've told me that in 2021 when we had a bunch of decisions, and I was like, "No, we're gonna-" Yeah, yeah. Come on, Willie Sutton.
26
00:04:38.140 --> 00:04:45.160
I would always say, anytime anyone was like, "Oh, we're gonna sell to publishers," I'm like, "Ah, that's like Willie Sutton saying, 'Forget the bank. I'm gonna go rob the library.'" Yeah.
27
00:04:45.560 --> 00:04:55.380
And, and, you know, somebody who's been on the show a lot, who, you know, Jenny and Colin on my team
Load full transcript
both worked for in the past, Sean Griffey, gave us very good advice that we should own the relationship with the money.
28
00:04:55.660 --> 00:05:05.400
And so then we started building a brand partnerships team, and we were able to say, "We can just bring in revenue." And that really unlocked our ability to say, "We take responsibility for that."
29
00:05:05.960 --> 00:05:16.880
Yes, the creator already has audience, already has momentum, but if we can bring the sponsors and we can help deliver for the sponsors, together we can have alignment and start to- Yeah...
30
00:05:16.980 --> 00:05:20.600
actually make this into a real business. That was the real turning point about two and a half, three years ago.
31
00:05:21.540 --> 00:05:33.120
So explain for people, like, when we talk about knowledge creators, like, I think of, I think of people who have one foot in the world of the, like, doing, like, versus being a,
32
00:05:34.120 --> 00:05:47.060
you know, capital J Journalist necessarily. I mean, sometimes that, that can exist, but rarely. I think usually the person has a little bit different background to it. Or, or, like, how do you define it?
33
00:05:47.060 --> 00:06:01.940
Is it just an individual who focuses not on Instagram selfies or food or anything like that, but on, you know, knowledge areas, getting smarter about something? Like, but, like, w- what is a knowledge creator?
34
00:06:02.856 --> 00:06:09.796
In the broadest sense, we think that it's a creator who is educating and engaging their audience at the same time.
35
00:06:09.916 --> 00:06:17.716
That it's not a trade-off being able to tell them about a particular industry or be interviewing professionals in a certain space. That's the broadest level.
36
00:06:17.796 --> 00:06:29.116
For what we're doing today, we're really looking to partner with knowledge creators who have professional audiences, and that might be a journalist that's gone independent, like Joanna Stern.
37
00:06:29.256 --> 00:06:37.816
It might be an industry professional who worked in HR for 25 years and then started their own TikTok channel that's turned into YouTube, podcast, newsletter, et cetera.
38
00:06:38.196 --> 00:06:45.136
There's also a lot of really great n- digitally native people who are just obsessed with AI, and they're the best tinkerers and tutorial people.
39
00:06:45.176 --> 00:06:54.016
They're moving at a faster clip than any other curriculum, and so they're gaining a lot of attention and trust for teaching people how to use the latest and greatest tools.
40
00:06:54.216 --> 00:07:00.036
All of that is in our purview right now, and, you know, we're continuing to see what kind of extensions we can pull into that.
41
00:07:00.076 --> 00:07:07.236
But there's so many industries that now have amazing creators, cybersecurity, UX design, all sorts of little...
42
00:07:07.616 --> 00:07:14.936
Not even little, all sorts of categories within the business world that we believe we can partner with and help them build much bigger businesses. Yeah.
43
00:07:15.336 --> 00:07:25.496
I mean, is it about that sort of, like, Lenny Rachitsky lane, or is that just one of several different lanes? And that, I mean, like, you know, I mean, Lenny Rachitsky is, like, you know, he was in product at Airbnb.
44
00:07:25.516 --> 00:07:34.396
He's one of, like, hundreds of product guys, honestly, there, and girls at, at, at Airbnb. But he was r- he was also really good at, at creating content. He can package it really well.
45
00:07:34.836 --> 00:07:44.036
And he's, you know, he got on Substack early, and that helped. Are you- I think that's a, that's a great archetype... focused on specific fields? Like... Okay, go on. So, like, what are, what are- Yeah...
46
00:07:44.056 --> 00:07:47.576
what are the, like, what are examples of, like, knowledge creators?
47
00:07:48.356 --> 00:08:00.656
Yeah, examples are Jack and Gino from Breaking and Entering, who worked in the industry for a little bit but are still, you know, early into breaking and entering in their careers, have an amazing audience for the marketing and advertising community.
48
00:08:01.256 --> 00:08:09.516
I think about Megan Tan, who's an incredible creative, teaching people- Mm-hmm... how to be a filmmaker, and so she's really for professional creatives.
49
00:08:09.536 --> 00:08:16.556
The same way Colin and Samir, who we work with on the Published Press side of the business, are appealing to a professional class of creator.
50
00:08:17.096 --> 00:08:25.156
Then there's, like, the whole technology category now we're very strong in, where you think about ChatGPT, Matt Wolfe, Nate Perk, and they are...
51
00:08:25.216 --> 00:08:35.016
Yes, they have industry experience, but they really are wrapping their hands around something that's brand new and chronicling the rise of AI. All of that- Okay, so they're m-... is in our purview, right. Right, right.
52
00:08:35.096 --> 00:08:41.176
So they're, they're away from- It's a couple different, there's a couple different archetypes. Yeah, yeah. So they're, but they're away from, like, news, like, mostly.
53
00:08:41.196 --> 00:08:51.276
Yeah, some, but Matt Wolfe has a Friday YouTube episode- Yeah... that gets 100,000 views every week. That's a news episode. Joanna Stern is a journalist, like, you know, just interviewed Mark Zuckerberg.
54
00:08:51.336 --> 00:08:55.756
So we are able to support, but I think the things that are in common is that they're all video first.
55
00:08:55.776 --> 00:09:06.096
They're very personality-led, and if they're able to succeed on those platforms, we can help them build up their teams, think through their strategy, monetize with var- brand partnerships.
56
00:09:06.516 --> 00:09:18.936
It's, it's the same playbook to a couple different archetypes of knowledge creator that we can support. Yeah. And you're very focused on YouTube, not on the, you know, Beehiiv or Substack writers necessarily.
57
00:09:18.996 -->
00:09:26.576
It doesn't mean that they don't have it, but I just feel like you have to have a home base, right? I mean, mine is kind of moving. I feel like, I don't know.
58
00:09:26.756 --> 00:09:34.096
Like, I don't know if I'm a writer or a podcaster or an events guy. I don't know at this point.
59
00:09:34.096 --> 00:09:42.356
[laughs] But, like, I, I always thought of the newsletter as central, and then it was, like, a hub and spoke, and different things were off the spoke.
60
00:09:42.396 --> 00:09:49.676
Like, it was like, okay, podcasts will be off the spoke, gatherings, and then events will be a spoke. But the, the hub was always the newsletter.
61
00:09:50.196 --> 00:10:02.656
And it feels a lot more complicated now, and everyone starts in one place, and then you end up having... Y- y- you become multimodal. I don't, I don't really believe in y- in the most part for newsletter-only businesses.
62
00:10:03.176 --> 00:10:16.356
But h- how do you... Like, it seems like YouTube was where y- you guys zeroed in on as, as a big opportunity, versus newsletter, because, and I, I say that because you were growing this during the newsletter boom.
63
00:10:17.256 --> 00:10:27.456
And we, again, we got the experience of Morning Brew, which was so paramount- Yeah... within the newsletter bur- boom, and, you know, we love Beehiiv, and we love newsletters and, and everything that goes along with it.
64
00:10:27.496 --> 00:10:41.016
But- I do, too. This episode is sponsored by Beehiiv. [laughs] Which we love, but part of our broader observation and thesis is that people follow people. Video is a stronger medium.
65
00:10:41.056 --> 00:10:49.216
The algorithm of YouTube is truly fantastic. We're also very heavy in short-form content on Instagram and YouTube Shorts and TikTok.
66
00:10:49.256 --> 00:10:58.236
So video, I mean, again, just my experience going from newsletter and then getting my eyes opened to how powerful YouTube... YouTube had already been around. Again, I felt like I discovered YouTube.
67
00:10:58.256 --> 00:11:18.956
But having those two different experiences and seeing growth rates, seeing the type of comments, seeing the type of inbound emails and opportunities you get when you have a successful YouTube channel really opened our eyes in those beginning years of the business that have convinced us that this is where there is the most momentum within the, the media space right now.
68
00:11:19.036 --> 00:11:27.836
You know, we can't say enough things about YouTube and the ways that it allows audience to, to collect, but you still wanna have that newsletter. You still wanna have these different parts of your business.
69
00:11:28.476 --> 00:11:46.136
Ultimately, I think you, and you're questioning, you know, newsletter writer or whatever, event host, you just need to be able to have consistent attention, and if you have that, then you can go and manifest in all these different ways, which doesn't make it easier for any one individual, but there are a ton of people that are succeeding in really beautiful ways on these platforms.
70
00:11:46.836 --> 00:11:50.276
So you see across these different platforms, and tell me if it...
71
00:11:50.316 --> 00:12:02.336
Like, I feel like a- attention is leaking out of the newsletter space, and I think this is somewhat inevitable, and it is a, a bit of a victim of its success.
72
00:12:02.912 --> 00:12:15.472
There are a lot of newsletters out there, you know, and I, I'm not going to be yet another person who prematurely declares the death of email. I don't think email is dead. I will not be an accomplice on that. No.
73
00:12:15.532 --> 00:12:23.412
I refuse. Absolutely not. We don't want Tyler texting us about this. [laughs] But I, but it's, I don't even know. I think these things have always been greed. Email's alive and well. It's not- Of course... it's not true.
74
00:12:23.612 --> 00:12:39.292
Email is- So leave that aside. At the same time, I think it's kinda dangerous to be email only right now. The, the text content overall, it certainly feels challenged, and it doesn't feel like this is an overreaction.
75
00:12:39.672 --> 00:12:48.532
I think we all feel kind of overwhelmed right now by media. Media feels overwhelming, and there's a lot of it out there.
76
00:12:48.952 --> 00:13:01.092
And because of shortened attention spans and all the algorithmic media and all the doom scrolling and all the other stuff, sending, sending off, you know, 1,000, sometimes 1,300 words, let's be honest- Yeah...
77
00:13:01.152 --> 00:13:16.652
to people a couple times a week feels almost rude. [laughs] I don't know. Are you seeing, like, that, that, that shift away from, from text content? I- I'm definitely a believer that we are in a video renaissance.
78
00:13:16.732 --> 00:13:26.852
And I think it's, it's all as part of this has been maturing. The barrier to entry got, was lowered first for- Yeah... writing an email, right? It's so easy to po- pop open your Behrouz sub stack and start sending. Yeah.
79
00:13:26.852 --> 00:13:38.352
It was always easy to create a YouTube channel, but now there's so much more opportunity there as well. And the, the growth rate, yes, on video I think is faster, and that is why we are focused there.
80
00:13:38.832 --> 00:13:46.692
But I, I think the world and the internet is so big that thinking of how competitive or thinking of one is better than the other- Yeah...
81
00:13:46.792 --> 00:13:52.592
is a little reductive to the idea that just, like, you can find your niche, you can find your audience. I- I was...
82
00:13:53.132 --> 00:14:06.032
got a message from a person who I met two-plus years ago who is focusing on construction technology, and I'm just, like, obsessed with how many worlds there are within this digital media bucket.
83
00:14:06.452 --> 00:14:18.392
And whether it's a newsletter, whether it's a podcast, whether it's YouTube, I think as long as you can be really captivating and informative, again,
if we're talking about the knowledge creator sphere, you can find success.
84
00:14:18.452 --> 00:14:28.752
It's not like there's only one roadmap. But again, we are betting heavily, and we have been finding a lot of success in that video-first world because that does seem like the macro shift that's happening.
85
00:14:28.812 --> 00:14:42.892
So yeah, I mean, yeah, long story short, it, it seems very obvious. Yeah. There's, there's a f- there's a few out there trying to solve this issue of we have a decentralized media ecosystem.
86
00:14:43.352 --> 00:14:54.132
A lot of the energy is, is toward the individual, not to the institution. Like, we all know that very well. The sort of leverage is definitely on the individual side, right?
87
00:14:54.932 --> 00:15:01.752
And then the other thing on top of that is making money in media these days requires doing a bunch of different things.
88
00:15:01.952 --> 00:15:15.632
I think one of the things with, with newsletters was it abstracted the publishing function to, like... It, it, it stripped it down to its studs. You know? [laughs] It was like, "We're gonna give you a basic CMS.
89
00:15:16.112 --> 00:15:24.292
You're gonna, like, publish content. We're gonna hook it up to Stripe, and you're gonna say, 'Buy our stuff.' And then, like, that's what we're gonna do."
90
00:15:24.492 --> 00:15:34.432
And, and that was kinda remarkable in, in that it, it, it worked, but that never, at least for me, it never felt l- like long term.
91
00:15:34.952 --> 00:15:46.352
Only because, like, I had the experience of, of, in B2B, like, it, that wasn't where the money was. The money was always matching up a buy and a sell side. I mean, we didn't call it advertising. We called it sponsorship.
92
00:15:46.392 --> 00:16:01.992
We called it lead generation. We, we, we used different terms, but that's... We used events [laughs] for most part. But it was not in subscriptions and certainly not subscriptions as 100% of, of the model. So how...
93
00:16:02.072 --> 00:16:16.612
Explain to me what you see on the monetization side, because I think newsletter advertising itself w- was kind of, you know, there, there was a lot of excitement around that. But it seems pretty clear to me that as,
94
00:16:17.592 --> 00:16:29.852
as these knowledge creators or creators of, of any stripe become more like regular media companies, they're gonna have to monetize in a variety of different ways, or they're gonna have the opportunity to monetize in a, in a variety of different ways.
95
00:16:30.972 --> 00:16:42.072
There's a lot of ways to monetize, of course, but I, I actually don't think that creators need to have that many different revenue streams. I think it's a lot about matching your audience to the business model.
96
00:16:42.452 --> 00:16:53.612
I think some categories, Missic sells a fantastic example. We don't work with her, but she's always an example I love talking about, who is perfect for selling courses. D2C, enterprise, that's
fantastic.
97
00:16:54.532 --> 00:17:01.672
Some are gonna be great with subscription. I think that's great for the political world. You see a lot of political creators, newsletter and/or video- Right...
98
00:17:01.712 --> 00:17:12.772
making a lot of money directly from their audience because I think that there is a relationship between your political news source and trust and which sponsors wanna get involved in political media.
99
00:17:13.192 --> 00:17:25.752
When you come to the zone that Smooth Media works in, which is predominantly B2B, tons of sponsors wanna sell business product, and they have great value on that, and we call it marketing services.
100
00:17:25.772 --> 00:17:34.952
And we think that a creator can impact up and down the funnel, whether that's brand awareness, whether that's lead gen, whether that's events. Creators can enable that. It's not easy.
101
00:17:35.012 --> 00:17:37.232
That's why we're building the competencies that we have.
102
00:17:37.572 --> 00:17:49.712
But I don't think a creator that we work with who's making hundreds of thousands of dollars or millions of dollars a year off of marketing services implicitly needs a paid newsletter or implicitly needs a course on top of that.
103
00:17:50.072 --> 00:17:58.452
I want them to have a diversified brand partnerships business where they have small, medium, large partners. They have some short-term deals, some long-term deals, different categories of partners.
104
00:17:58.852 --> 00:18:10.512
I think diversification within that is extremely smart as you build a business for the long term. But I, I don't think you, you inherently need all of those different pieces just to be successful all of a sudden.
105
00:18:11.972 --> 00:18:22.112
Quick break to encourage you to join our TRB Pro membership program. We are building it around What's Working case studies we've been doing at our salons and events this year.
106
00:18:22.552 --> 00:18:35.592
I found that media is at its heart an execution business. Now, on this podcast, I speak to leaders of media organizations about their business strategies, but those strategies live and die on execution.
107
00:18:36.232 --> 00:18:49.612
We are featuring a series of What's Working case studies on therebooting.com to highlight initiatives that are gaining traction and to unpack why they're working through the lens of the practitioners leading these initiatives.
108
00:18:50.132 --> 00:19:01.052
Our first batch of What's Working case studies, available exclusively to TRB Pro members, are from organizations like People Inc, USA Today, The Daily Beast, Outside, and more.
109
00:19:01.412 --> 00:19:09.372
TRB Pro members also get invitations to our mixers and discounted entrance to TRB events, like our recently completed TRB Audience Summit.
110
00:19:09.912 --> 00:19:22.612
We will also do a series of conversational case studies where you get to discuss the initiatives with those who are leading them, and you get access to our private social network devoted to highlighting and unpacking what's working in the market.
111
00:19:23.092 --> 00:19:35.872
The goal of TRB Pro is to make you better at your job and to enable practitioners to lead the way in creating a sustainable media industry. So please join today. Go to therebooting.com/upgrade.
112
00:19:36.312 --> 00:19:47.352
A subscription is $200 a year, or if you wanna try it out, a mere $20 a month. I think that's a good deal. So go to therebooting.com/upgrade.
113
00:19:48.732 --> 00:19:57.152
I probably said this to you when we first talked about, about Smooth, but if I didn't, I should've. Uh, 'cause I always go back to Federated Media, like...
114
00:19:57.192 --> 00:20:09.832
And Federated Media sprung up in the blog era, and they said, "We're gonna take the publishing function off your hands. You guys are bloggers. You're, you're, you're posting 90 times a day. You don't have time.
115
00:20:10.172 --> 00:20:19.652
Trust me, you don't wanna handle this. It's a pain in the ass running a bi- running a, a business, and it's more than just selling ads. You gotta do a lot of different things a- a- as part of the publisher function."
116
00:20:20.172 --> 00:20:23.132
And I thought that was a really smart idea. Jon Battelle started that company.
117
00:20:23.352 --> 00:20:34.172
But it didn't work, and, and it didn't work because they, they had Mashable, they had Gigom, TechCrunch, and they used them until they were like, "Oh, we're just gonna keep 100% of the revenue.
118
00:20:34.192 --> 00:20:45.552
We're gonna, you know, get, get this off the ground, and, and then we're going to hire our own team to do marketing services, brand partnerships, sponsorships, event sales," whatever it is.
119
00:20:45.832 --> 00:20:58.872
Like, so explain the model from that standpoint and how, how you align incentives on both sides. Like, you know, the incentives for the creators, but also the incentives for you.
120
00:20:59.732 --> 00:21:09.712
We try and put ourselves in the shoes of the creator and try and build for what's best for them. And some creators that we meet are extremely capable business people.
121
00:21:09.752 --> 00:21:19.532
They have the fortune of having been a co-founder, and they can go ahead and build their own independent media company, and that might mean building out your own brand partnerships department.
122
00:21:19.572 --> 00:21:27.772
But I think as we know in media, you gotta do everything really, really well in order to succeed over the long term. You gotta be a really great creative. You gotta have really great partnerships.
123
00:21:27.832 --> 00:21:39.012
You gotta know how to run the business model and hire and manage a team. And so I think we offer an agency option, which is saying, "Hey, you're still the principal. You still own 100% of your business.
124
00:21:39.072 --> 00:21:40.432
You are still in the driver's seat.
125
00:21:40.872 --> 00:22:04.272
But if you bring us on, we'll help be an
extension of your team on the management side," which is, again, I hate the word management, and we can talk about that, but where we are able to help with hiring, content strategy, resourcing the business, thinking about planning cycles, setting different goals, and you get the brand partnerships team, where we're able to say, "We're really great sellers.
126
00:22:04.432 --> 00:22:12.672
We train like crazy. We're really thoughtful about the proposals we're putting together, who we're selling to, how we're pricing these things.
127
00:22:12.992 --> 00:22:23.932
We get knowledge across all of the different deals that we're getting to do on a, on a given basis." And so you're getting to partner with that institutional knowledge instead of having to build it from scratch.
128
00:22:24.492 --> 00:22:39.392
And so for a lot of creators where running a successful YouTube channel is already hard enough, we get to plug in and partner and be off on the, you know, go and, go and crush it, which we've been able to do with a lot of great creators, and it saves them a lot of time.
129
00:22:39.912 --> 00:22:50.332
So that's from the creator perspective. And from us, we're a commission business. Every time we make a deal, we make money, and there's no retainer, and there's no upfront cost. There's nothing like that.
130
00:22:50.352 --> 00:23:00.532
And so the alignment is, if we continue to build together, if we continue to close bigger deals, we both win. Okay, so there's no long-term commitment. It's just, it's, it's just straight commission. No. No. Yeah.
131
00:23:00.532 --> 00:23:10.452
You gonna tell me how much? And I'll tell you how much. 20% commission. And the idea is if you don't wanna be represented by us, I don't wanna represent you. I don't wanna hold anybody hostage. Great.
132
00:23:10.452 --> 00:23:14.612
[laughs] There's no ownership. There's nothing like that. It's, it's g- you know, go, go and find what's best for you.
133
00:23:14.672 --> 00:23:20.292
But everybody we've done well for has stayed because I think it's a very aligned model, and, and there's the way we work.
134
00:23:20.332 --> 00:23:31.112
We try and be more like an extension of the team, be very aligned, be very transparent, and we work very collaboratively, so it's not like some black box of what is your representation doing. Yeah.
135
00:23:31.152 --> 00:23:37.872
It's, it's trying to really be, you know, be a team together. Yeah. I mean, I love that in theory. There, there's a but coming, right?
136
00:23:37.992 --> 00:23:47.112
Like, which is Ben Thompson says something very smart where he said, "Risk never goes away. It just moves." Just, you, you just move risk. You don't eliminate risk, right?
137
00:23:47.152 --> 00:23:56.452
And so the question is always where, where risk... And, and everyone wants the upside with no risk, right? [laughs] Like in my, in my experience, people are like, "I want the upside, but I want the guarantee."
138
00:23:56.512 --> 00:24:05.872
It's like, "Oh, really? Okay, great. Me too." How do you, how do you think about that? Because it isn't... You know, like you're,
139
00:24:07.112 --> 00:24:18.220
you're trying to align with, with the creator, and the creator's saying, "Look, I want, I want 100% control I don't wanna be locked into anything. You make money when I make money.
140
00:24:18.460 --> 00:24:32.660
I eat first, and all these kind of things, and I can like, you know, swap you out at any time. Like that, I mean, as someone, as you know, like, I mean, I think running an agency business like that is, is difficult.
141
00:24:33.160 --> 00:24:42.780
So how do you end up aligning the, the, not just the incentives, but also, like, the risk in these relationships? Well, I, I guess I, I don't know if I really...
142
00:24:42.840 --> 00:24:54.480
The risk that we're taking on, or that a creator/partner is taking on is, is a partnership like any other partnership, where you're hiring a team, and the team can work out or the team might not work out.
143
00:24:54.540 --> 00:25:03.700
And we have to be very selective these days as we've grown to partner with the right creators. Yeah. It's awesome when a creator comes to us, and we might not be the right fit.
144
00:25:03.740 --> 00:25:11.720
And we might really like them, but if we're not in the right fit, we're not gonna try and partner with them, 'cause our risk is our time and our, and my team's time. And so they- Yeah...
145
00:25:11.760 --> 00:25:19.760
we have to be very thoughtful about where we think we can s- succeed based on our competencies, based on the brands that are in our, our book of business.
146
00:25:20.180 --> 00:25:31.080
And for a creator, a lot of the times they come to us and they say, "I'm getting these opportunities. I don't know how to service them all. I wanna make sure I can keep up with the momentum again on my channel.
147
00:25:31.540 --> 00:25:40.020
Can you come help me and take, work off of my plate and help me generate some revenue?" And as time goes on, we find more ways to- Mm-hmm...
148
00:25:40.140 --> 00:25:50.180
support that creator, and that, I think, creates more partnership and more lock-in, and that's why we launched an event department to say, "Hey, you can help your audience convene.
149
00:25:50.220 --> 00:25:59.740
You can bring those same brand partners that we help service as sponsors for that summit or live show or whatever it might be." And so as we continue to grow and offer more
150
00:26:00.820 --> 00:26:06.160
to the creator, I believe that that just, you know, continues to increase the partnership and the alignment.
151
00:26:06.220 --> 00:26:12.520
So the, the risk is inherent in any business anywhere, but we're, you know, if we do good work, there's a chesty balance. Yeah.
152
00:26:12.880 --> 00:26:21.460
So I remember early on with, with Colin and Samir, I mean, you extended, I mean, they're a YouTube show. I mean, it's about YouTube. YouTube show about
YouTube, I mean, you gotta do that.
153
00:26:21.460 --> 00:26:33.300
[laughs] But you extended them into, into newsletters, and that was gonna be, like, a joint venture. Have you moved away from that model? Yes. We have moved away from that model. Publishers been awesome.
154
00:26:33.340 --> 00:26:41.380
We have marquee events. We have the newsletter. We've got the job where it's a really great team. Yeah. But what we realized is, you know, Colin and Samir are really special as creators.
155
00:26:41.420 --> 00:26:45.260
They're very special within their industry, and, you know, we're also a bootstrap company.
156
00:26:45.300 --> 00:26:54.220
And so we've, we partnered with something at an equity level, and [laughs] we realized that we need a business model that also makes, you know, cash on a regular basis to, to continue to function.
157
00:26:54.280 --> 00:27:02.780
So, you know, we set out, I think, again, when we met five years ago, I wanted to build businesses with creators. I wanted equity. But equity doesn't mean cash in the beginning.
158
00:27:02.820 --> 00:27:14.940
So that, that was one of our big learnings. Yeah. And so we moved away from that to say, first, let's build this incredible agency that can service these creators, that can help create real media businesses with them.
159
00:27:15.320 --> 00:27:32.420
Yes, we don't own them, but as time goes on, and, you know, we're not here today in 2026, but the ability to invest in certain ones or be a part of different ventures that they're able to go start, that is very exciting, and that vantage point is becoming more apparent each year.
160
00:27:32.680 --> 00:27:40.620
But we're still laser-focused on just making sure we do that basic talent management service that, you know, better than anybody else in the industry. Yeah.
161
00:27:40.680 --> 00:27:51.360
So recently, one of your top talent became an equity holder in Smooth itself, so it's kinda gone- Yeah... gone the opposite way. And I al- I've always thought, like, there is a case for
162
00:27:52.340 --> 00:28:01.000
creators to own, I guess, at least in part, the sort of centralized service. Because to me, all of these,
163
00:28:02.060 --> 00:28:12.880
all of these models are it's about getting the economics and the incentives and then the risk profile right across all sides. And it's, it's hard to do.
164
00:28:13.020 --> 00:28:21.900
Like, it's not like a, it's not a technical innovation, I don't think, that is needed [laughs] in this area. It's a, it's almost like a business model innovation.
165
00:28:22.420 --> 00:28:33.020
But I, I wouldn't even call it that innovative, 'cause talent management, you go to Hollywood and you look at representation and all these things, they, it, it's been a long-lasting institution that's really worked for talent- Yeah...
166
00:28:33.060 --> 00:28:38.800
that didn't wanna build their own full service business top to bottom. A- and so we've borrowed a lot from that.
167
00:28:38.900 --> 00:28:53.520
We've borrowed a lot from the media experiences that we've had, and we've tried to mold them into something that, that really feels new but rests on a lot of those learnings, and it's being applied to this knowledge creator set that just didn't really exist- Yeah...
168
00:28:53.580 --> 00:28:59.620
until very recent. Okay. So but walk me through this one, because, I mean, she's one of your top- Yes...
169
00:28:59.700 --> 00:29:07.420
creators, my understanding, and I would guess that every single other sort of creator, [laughs] knowledge creator that you're working with is like, "Where's our equity?"
170
00:29:07.440 --> 00:29:15.020
[laughs] And then next thing you know, you're gonna be handing out equity to everyone. Yeah. For, for a long time, Jenny and I, and Kenzie and I thought, "Hey, it'd be really great to have...
171
00:29:15.960 --> 00:29:19.360
Who could be the best people to have on our cap table?" Yeah. And
172
00:29:20.280 --> 00:29:30.100
for a while we were like, "Yeah, it's gonna probably be our best creator partners who can give the best feedback, who can make Smooth better, who can grow the Smooth brand.
173
00:29:30.200 --> 00:29:42.120
That's gonna be the X factor that would be worth bringing somebody onto the cap table." And Cat, Cat GPT is her, her, @CatGPT is her handle on most platforms, and we signed her about a year and a half ago.
174
00:29:42.660 --> 00:29:51.760
She is truly incredible both as a, a friend and a, a business partner now, and she's always been very overwhelming with feedback, connections.
175
00:29:51.820 --> 00:29:59.160
As she's gotten more popular, she's been very positive selling about bringing that opportunity to Smooth. And so a couple of months ago, we, we were having a conversation.
176
00:29:59.220 --> 00:30:06.840
We just, we re-extended it to her, and she got very excited. She, i- in her trajectory is way beyond just being a quote-unquote creator. She wants to be an entrepreneur.
177
00:30:06.880 --> 00:30:15.600
She wants to be ma- many amazing things, and this fit with her goals, and it fit with our goals to where we're super glad that she came on- Yeah... to, to agree to do this with us.
178
00:30:15.640 --> 00:30:23.820
But it, it, yeah, and again, it just, you know, I ask myself, "What are the ways to grow the business?" Yeah. That builds long-term, like, alignment and, and, but, like, at, like, a heavy cost, right?
179
00:30:23.900 --> 00:30:26.360
Because I remember, I, you know, I've done a few podcasts with...
180
00:30:26.480 --> 00:30:35.772
And it was right around the same time, and I think of you guys as, as kind of- Approaching a similar area, just differently, which is like Adam Rian with Workweek.
181
00:30:35.992 --> 00:30:42.312
And, you know, Adam's, Adam's thesis has changed a few times, I feel like, over the, over the last several years.
182
00:30:42.432 --> 00:30:59.592
But, you know, but like the, the idea there was that, you know, they were going to
figure out a way to incentivize the creators and the centralized service. And I mean, I think y- your model is more decentralized.
183
00:30:59.652 --> 00:31:04.992
I feel like their model is more centralized. How do you see the differences between what you guys are doing?
184
00:31:05.772 --> 00:31:12.712
Well, I listened to that last episode over the summer where I think you had him on, and, and I think what he's doing is really interesting, and is very different from what we're doing.
185
00:31:13.252 --> 00:31:20.952
And I think the easiest way to differentiate, and I'd be curious to get his input, and, and maybe we'll both come on one day and we'll chat about how we're- We'll patch him in. Yeah [laughs]...
186
00:31:20.952 --> 00:31:22.772
working with knowledge creators. That'd be fun.
187
00:31:22.812 --> 00:31:36.152
But he, he talks about working with creators who have not created before, but have ton of institutional knowledge about their profession, and that they can share this and, and monetize it that way, and I think that's wonderful for that cohort of creator.
188
00:31:36.512 --> 00:31:48.092
The cohort of creator that we are looking at, that we are looking to partner with, already has a material amount of traction. They're a career creator. They're making- Yeah... again, a significant amount.
189
00:31:48.112 --> 00:31:57.792
They already have opportunity, but they need this team to come in and help make it sustainable and help grow it. And so it's a different part of the creative market- Right...
190
00:31:57.832 --> 00:32:08.632
despite the fact that our creators and Workweek creators are very likely talking about similar topics. They're, they're not the same profile of creator unit. Yeah, and I think it's the emphasis, too.
191
00:32:08.672 --> 00:32:15.592
Like, I mean, like, you know, knowledge creator, I mean knowledge, you know, is modifying creator like there because like you...
192
00:32:16.092 --> 00:32:25.232
I know a lot of times, and obviously I'm biased as someone who makes stuff, s- I guess I'm a creator. I have no idea. [laughs] But look, I mean, like anyone, like I think that there's, there's skill.
193
00:32:25.272 --> 00:32:34.892
Not everyone can do it. [laughs] Like everything looks easier to the outside. I'm not saying that it's, it's literally rocket science, but you know, it does take, it does take reps and whatnot.
194
00:32:34.992 --> 00:32:46.092
And like I've always said, like Lenny Rachitsky is not, as far as my understanding [laughs], he's not the best product person who ever stepped foot on, on, on the planet, you know.
195
00:32:46.152 --> 00:32:56.892
I mean, maybe he's in the top 5%, let's say. But what makes him different is that he's a great creator a- and he, he has the knowledge, but he's a great creator.
196
00:32:56.932 --> 00:33:05.852
Like if, if he had all the knowledge and was a shitty creator, we wouldn't be talking about him. Doesn't work. Does not work. No. [laughs] He would not have
come up- No, not, not, not at all. Not at all.
197
00:33:05.892 --> 00:33:11.092
But, but he didn't. I, and I, I go back to the Morning Brew days where Neil Fryman said, you know, we were trying- Yeah...
198
00:33:11.152 --> 00:33:19.632
I tried to get him to hire so many writers and editors, and he said, "They're not this, they're not this. I need them to be funny and I need them to be smart." And you can't only be one or the other.
199
00:33:19.672 --> 00:33:30.292
It's not always funny, and it's not always raw intelligence, but you have to be informative or educational, and you have to be engaging if you're gonna play this sport. You cannot... It is not one or the other.
200
00:33:30.772 --> 00:33:42.132
And a lot of smart people try and start YouTube channels, but they can't tell a story to save their life, or they can't engage a, a guest to save their lives, and you, you have to have both, and that's a really difficult thing to do.
201
00:33:42.192 --> 00:33:52.252
But if you are able to do it, you have an incredible opportunity in 2026, and for the, you know, this generation immediately. Yeah. I have to ask about the trade publication 'cause I remember you gu- Yes...
202
00:33:52.312 --> 00:34:03.052
you guys bought- Let's do it... like a trade publication, and I was like, "Josh, what the hell are you doing?" [laughs] I love it. [laughs] There's an, there's opportunity in so many places in, in the media world.
203
00:34:03.192 --> 00:34:11.012
I know there is. I'm very excited to be in it. I, I love it, and, and you know, to, to catch people up, about two, two plus years ago, we bought a company called Energy Central.
204
00:34:11.472 --> 00:34:20.952
A wonderful couple had run it for 30 years, and you know, they, they like to joke that they started it like before the internet, or right as the internet was coming on, as I was, you know, being brought into this world myself.
205
00:34:21.472 --> 00:34:31.692
And they, they were looking for stewards to carry the brand into the next generation. And again, I, I launched Retail Brew and Marketing Brew. Jenny grew these publications. Kinsey edited these publications. Yeah, yeah.
206
00:34:31.692 --> 00:34:40.112
And we really had a good understanding. We said, "Oh, we, we can go in and bring this into the next generation." And it's been another wonderful business where we know how to sell marketing services.
207
00:34:40.172 --> 00:34:49.591
We know how to resheet media, and, and we love business media. Like for whatever reason, we got the bug. Like we really like putting out newsy newsletters.
208
00:34:49.651 --> 00:34:57.632
We love a good interview show where you capture the, the cool startup CEO within the energy sector. So it, it's a really wonderful business. It's got its own- Yeah, yeah... dedicated team.
209
00:34:57.672 --> 00:35:04.752
It operates independently from Smooth Media. I, I think we're very excited about both right now, so we don't really have like the- It just felt like a different business... we, we don't... Yeah.
210
00:35:04.772 --> 00:35:07.832
Like are you planning on like buying- It... And two degree, there's, there's separate businesses...
211
00:35:07.852 --> 00:35:16.812
there's a lot of, there's a lot of B2B trade publication who have like older owners who are, you know, their, their, their children are not going to inherit it.
212
00:35:16.872 --> 00:35:24.152
Maybe they, they sell it to someone else and like, you know, many of these businesses, not all, I don't know Energy Central necessarily was the case.
213
00:35:24.292 --> 00:35:33.852
But you know, many of them there's some basic, you know, modernizations to, to take place. I mean, we're not talking about like AI chatbots with some of these. Like we're talking about- No, no...
214
00:35:33.852 --> 00:35:40.132
just like a formatted email. We're talking about- Like I mean- Exactly... some pretty low hanging- Exactly... fruit, but it seems like a different business.
215
00:35:40.192 --> 00:35:51.792
I mean, this was like, this seemed to me like more adjacent to the like, hey, did you know like you could buy a car wash? The Cody Sanchez world. [laughs] Like, you know, there's a lot of, a lot of folks out there. Yeah.
216
00:35:51.812 --> 00:36:00.012
Internet entrepreneurs. I don't know what to call them. I, I appreciate them. [laughs] I don't have their h- their hustle, but like I, I learn from. But that's still part of the mix.
217
00:36:00.192 --> 00:36:03.752
Do, but do you plan on like doing more of that? Life is long.
218
00:36:03.792 --> 00:36:08.952
Right now we're not looking at anything 'cause we feel like we've got our hands full with Smooth Media and Energy Central right now and publish and, and you know- Yeah...
219
00:36:09.052 --> 00:36:18.792
again, it's just where we're trying to make sure that we're scaling things to be truly material and large businesses rather than having 15 small things. We wanna have fewer really big things.
220
00:36:18.852 --> 00:36:21.412
And for the, for the current moment, we're not looking at it.
221
00:36:21.432 --> 00:36:29.492
But again, if somebody came across and said, "I've got a, a great, you know, older B2B media publication that could use some renovation," I, I would probably take a look at it.
222
00:36:29.512 --> 00:36:38.232
But for right now we're, we're just really focused on growing what we have- Yeah... so that again, the, these reach material scale. But, but thesis-wise, I'm very happy with what we do.
223
00:36:38.780 --> 00:36:49.320
Opportunity-wise, I, I continue to see it just getting better and better. Again, if, if you can captivate an audience of energy professionals and sell marketing services, it's a great business to be in. Right.
224
00:36:49.420 --> 00:37:01.120
So there's marketing services. I mean, Sean with Industry Dive knocked the cover off the ball there. Events have always been the lifeblood of B2B businesses, right?
225
00:37:01.340 --> 00:37:10.860
And I think
creators doing their own events, this isn't, you know, totally new, but I think we're gonna be, we're gonna be seeing a lot more of that, right?
226
00:37:10.940 --> 00:37:22.160
So this is, this seems to me, at least judging from your website, a big focus of yours. So what is the opportunity you see with creator-led events? You know, to, to your point, a lot of people are talking about it.
227
00:37:22.200 --> 00:37:27.840
It's been a, a component of business media companies for a long time, so we won't claim anything brand new.
228
00:37:27.880 --> 00:37:32.560
It's not like a, you know, millennial guy gets on a podcast and reinvents, you know, a thing that's been around for a long time.
229
00:37:32.580 --> 00:37:40.860
We, we recognize that it's been around, but we believe- No, selling products, selling products is, is much sexier. We can get to that later. But like events- Yeah. Fine, fine... events- But, but events...
230
00:37:40.900 --> 00:37:52.040
do business events. Business events do like 65%, 70% contribution margin. Like, they can be really good, good- It's great... on the monetization side- And, and if we can make it-...
231
00:37:52.040 --> 00:38:01.900
and they're good for the community, et cetera... and if we can make it easy for our creators to turn that on, we believe it is an amazing unlock for them. They have the audience. They have the brand partners.
232
00:38:01.960 --> 00:38:09.500
They have their own brand. If we can help bring it to life... You know from the, from the events that you've done, events are difficult. There's a lot of details.
233
00:38:09.940 --> 00:38:18.100
There are plenty of experts, but you have to partner with somebody trusted who can look at it and say, "This is the time of the year you should do it. This is the right type of venue.
234
00:38:18.160 --> 00:38:25.280
This is how we should build the media kit around it. This is how we should think about the programming." And so the creator still fills it with everything that makes them unique. And- Folks...
235
00:38:25.300 --> 00:38:32.600
you know, one of the guidelines- Yeah... we have is that the events that our creators throw should be events that only that creator could throw. We don't wanna just throw a random dinner.
236
00:38:32.660 --> 00:38:41.680
We don't wanna just throw a random thing. But, you know, for example, Breaking and Entering, again, Jack and Gino are hosting a live version of their 100th show at this event.
237
00:38:42.140 --> 00:38:51.400
They host a show on LinkedIn and YouTube three times a week. 100th version is coming up. They've got David Droga and Gary Vee, and they got a comedian coming on and a shirtless guitar player.
238
00:38:51.440 --> 00:38:53.740
There's a lot of cool stuff that's coming in, but it's so them.
239
00:38:54.140 --> 00:39:01.560
Like, the way they are coming up with this is, is going to be incredibly them, but one of their long-term brand partners just came on to be one of the, the title sponsors.
240
00:39:02.120 --> 00:39:04.820
And so that is where we're like, we have the pieces.
241
00:39:05.360 --> 00:39:23.260
We wanna be the best at coming in and being able to put those pieces together and make it happen, and I think that's one of our best differentiators is that, like DNA-wise, us as a team wanna make things happen with these creators who otherwise might be too busy or too under-resourced to make it happen, yet they have that opportunity.
242
00:39:23.700 --> 00:39:29.260
We want them to find their full potential. Yeah. Well, when it comes with events, I wonder how are you dealing with...
243
00:39:29.300 --> 00:39:37.200
This is a little bit in, in the weeds, but I mean, events come with a, a lot of hard costs, and this is where I mean risk doesn't go away, like it just moves around.
244
00:39:37.340 --> 00:39:49.980
And like, yeah, when I say, "Oh, events can do 65, 70% like contribution margin," and people are like, "Yeah, sign me up." I'd be like, "Okay, you also have to put at risk 100 and to $150,000."
245
00:39:50.260 --> 00:39:57.920
They'd be like, "Excuse me? No, no, no. I want the- [laughs]... I want the margins. I don't want the, the, the- But, but why- I don't want this risk [laughs]... is that a risk? This is, this is business. We...
246
00:39:58.040 --> 00:40:06.920
A lot of these creators are entrepreneurs. We're familiar with risk, and you de-risk it by saying, "You talk to your audience. Do you wanna come to this thing? Have you thrown a smaller event?
247
00:40:06.980 --> 00:40:15.700
Can we scale them up over time?" We know the audience is real. Brand partner, "Hey, you worked with me in digital formats for 12 months. Do you wanna come to this?" You de-risk it.
248
00:40:15.780 --> 00:40:23.120
Like, again, we've closed most of the sponsors prior to spending most of that money. Like I, I... There is an advantage.
249
00:40:23.160 --> 00:40:34.120
It does not eliminate the risk, but you can de-risk it by having this existing digital business that you transition. Like you doing your, your summit I don't think is a huge risk.
250
00:40:34.560 --> 00:40:45.680
Yeah, if you're selling a digital-only product, right, like there's no, there's no hard cost really, I mean, like in delivering that, and I'm just wondering, like how do you deal with, you know, those croissants are all paid for.
251
00:40:45.840 --> 00:40:57.080
Every single cocktail is paid for. The person who, who made the cocktail is paid for. The, like insurance in case the guy who made the cocktail like stabs someone is paid for. [laughs] You know? Like- You build a model.
252
00:40:57.160 --> 00:41:04.460
It's, it's a... You... To your point, it's, it's not easy- No, no, but who-... but it's possible... well, who, who carries the cost? [laughs] Who carries the, the creator.
253
00:41:04.600 --> 00:41:13.400
If, if you hire an event production company, you have to- Okay... afford the budget for the event So you're, so you're like- So- You're, you're a production... the creators are making money Okay. So it's less...
254
00:41:13.900 --> 00:41:18.980
That's what I was trying to get at 'cause- 'Cause creators are... If you're, if you're not making money as a creator and you're doing an event, it's maybe not the right time for you to do it.
255
00:41:19.020 --> 00:41:25.340
But some of the creators that we're working with are profiting a good amount of money, and this is a way to- Oh, yeah... you know, reinvest.
256
00:41:25.380 --> 00:41:33.680
It's a short-term reinvestment, but you can say, "Hey, I'm, I'm willing to attribute that." And again, as Mood gets bigger, I can play bank as we... You can help finance some of these things.
257
00:41:33.720 --> 00:41:39.180
And again, you're moving risk around, but you can get paid for risk. So we have all these ideas around it as they get bigger.
258
00:41:39.220 --> 00:41:45.220
If we're putting on a three-day conference with 10,000 people, that's a, a very different risk profile than a, a 90-seater. Yeah, yeah.
259
00:41:45.260 --> 00:41:52.960
But, but that's part of us iteratively growing this business and learning through each, each way and figuring out the right model and way to, to work with a creator.
260
00:41:53.840 --> 00:42:04.220
Are, are you exploring any ways that you have like, that you align like long-term incentives together, whether it's taking a stake in their businesses? I mean, that's why I was surprised for the Catch BT.
261
00:42:04.360 --> 00:42:16.140
Usually, the, the, the expectation is the centralized service would take, would have a, an equity interest in the creator's businesses, but this was a little bit of the reverse. So I'm just wondering, like how do you...
262
00:42:16.420 --> 00:42:24.700
Do you see that, that working both ways? Right now, we're very happy with the transaction model where we don't have equity. That's very comfortable.
263
00:42:24.780 --> 00:42:37.060
Again, we're, we're happy to continue to, to bring cash in and, and make cash alongside the creator. I think when you start talking about equity, you have to open up a can of worms of what is the exit potential.
264
00:42:37.080 --> 00:42:40.592
You know- Yeah... how are we defining profits at the end of the year? All sorts of things that-...
265
00:42:40.612 --> 00:42:53.112
you know, are, are exciting and intellectually stimulating, but we wanna stay laser focused on what we're doing now, which is really perfecting this agency format that, that is commission-oriented. Yeah.
266
00:42:53.392 --> 00:43:03.852
Do you, do you see yourself coming in, in competition increasingly with, like, the traditional talent management agencies? Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
267
00:43:03.892 --> 00:43:12.751
There's a lot of really amazing knowledge creators that are at, you know, three-letter big agencies, and we'd love to appeal to them. We'd love to, you know, figure out ways that we, we could
268
00:43:13.712 --> 00:43:20.232
get the next generation of a Cleo Abram or a
Johnny Harris or somebody like that. But there's really amazing talent there.
269
00:43:20.332 --> 00:43:25.892
A lot of them are taking our category more seriously, which is very exciting for us 'cause it means everybody will take it more seriously.
270
00:43:26.412 --> 00:43:37.032
And we're also competing against, you know, Lenny Rachitsky building his own team out, who he has a wonderful team that helps him operate, or an Eric Newcomer who's building an incredible business and an incredible team at the same time.
271
00:43:37.512 --> 00:43:45.292
So where we're competing, there's a couple other boutique agencies that I admire that I think are doing a great job, so, you know, we're, we're not alone in this space. Yeah.
272
00:43:45.331 --> 00:43:54.172
Which again, is just, it's just part of any of these things maturing. So what do you say to, to creators? 'Cause I have similar conversations, honestly, with people all the time 'cause I, I'm deciding...
273
00:43:54.232 --> 00:44:03.532
I'm, I'm making a lot of these- Right... decisions, like, myself, right? Which is what do you, what do you build yourself? What do you rely on for partners?
274
00:44:03.932 --> 00:44:13.412
You talk with enough people, they, you know, sometimes they start to, like, slow down, like, wherein they start to talk about things involving money and I'm like, "No, you can talk normally. Like, I'm, I'm [laughs] okay.
275
00:44:13.512 --> 00:44:27.012
Like, I, my, my IQ is in three digits." Uh-huh. "I can, I can figure this, this out. I know what DM and CPM means and whatnot." [laughs] But, like, how do you end up, like, 'cause, you know, a lot of people are creators.
276
00:44:27.072 --> 00:44:40.592
You know, they want th- they wanna be independent. There is, like, there's an autonomy there, right? And I think that there is probably a tendency to take on too much among creators.
277
00:44:40.632 --> 00:44:51.452
I mean, there's a lot of different types of creators, right? But, you know, I think that there... I think it can go into, like, almost like having, like, some sort of control freak tendencies in, in ways.
278
00:44:51.612 --> 00:45:01.992
But you have to make the, the, the key decision about, like, where you're going to spend your time and what, how you're going to also... You end up having to make, I don't know, make compromises.
279
00:45:02.192 --> 00:45:15.832
I don't know, what is your sort of pitch to them about, like, how they should think about whether they bring on, like, a partner like Smooth or someone else, or whether they build it themselves, or whether they b- bring on a partner until they can build themselves?
280
00:45:16.552 --> 00:45:25.112
Well, when we're talking to a creator, first it's about understanding where are they today, what are their goals, and how ambitious are they. How much... Do they wanna make a ton of money?
281
00:45:25.172 --> 00:45:34.812
Do they wanna build their own team? Some people like traveling around the world and they don't wanna have a stat to manage, or they didn't get into this to have to be somebody's boss. And so you, you see- Yeah...
282
00:45:34.932 --> 00:45:42.312
if our puzzle piece fits their puzzle piece. And like I said, we're not the right fit for a lot of creators, and it, we're very comfortable with that.
283
00:45:42.372 --> 00:45:52.492
We, we try stay, to stay very disciplined and to only partner with people that we think have the right alignment and have the right trajectory. And we then start slow.
284
00:45:52.772 --> 00:46:02.752
You don't see us, like, try and activate everything all at once. Let's do one deal together. Now let's start to build out all that. We have a really thoughtful onboarding process. And so- Yeah...
285
00:46:03.352 --> 00:46:15.492
I do see a lot of creators that, rightfully so, wanna have a lot of control, and they wanna be able to see a lot of what's going on, and I understand that. The creative process, they should be very protective of.
286
00:46:15.852 --> 00:46:24.212
If we give them the wrong sponsor, or if we do something wrong, it can lose all the trust from their audience. There is risk to who you partner with and who you let- Mm-hmm...
287
00:46:24.272 --> 00:46:29.812
impact your business, so we wanna be thoughtful about that. But you, you can build that trust up over time.
288
00:46:30.312 --> 00:46:40.332
And so now, as years are compounding, we're seeing, oh, we are on autopilot with a partner for our, the basic YouTube and newsletter brand partnerships, and we have a good planning cycle.
289
00:46:40.732 --> 00:46:44.332
Now we can introduce the idea- Yeah... of doing a big event in 2027.
290
00:46:44.412 --> 00:46:53.852
So we, we totally, and we actually prefer to work in that iterative way because I think a lot of media, you do, you go to other examples where people raise a ton of money and try and do it all at once.
291
00:46:54.212 --> 00:47:04.332
We just don't think that works. You, you can only do so many things really well at once in this current media era, so I'd much rather do one thing perfectly and then move on to the next thing.
292
00:47:04.412 --> 00:47:11.892
And so again, even that mode and that speed of working needs to agree with the creator who's gonna buy into that.
293
00:47:11.972 --> 00:47:19.132
And so some people really like it, and again, we're finding tons and tons of success, and others are not, and I'm glad that they go find in the scenario that works for them. Yeah.
294
00:47:19.452 --> 00:47:29.052
Now, are the, are the clients Smooth clients, or are they the creator's clients? The brand clients? The, the brand partners? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, are the, are the- Well, that's clients. It's clienting, yeah...
295
00:47:29.092 --> 00:47:41.972
are, yeah, are the brand partners doing business with Smooth and Smooth is then like, you know, running it through a bunch of different, like, creators? Or is it Smooth is representing the creator?
296
00:47:42.372 -->
00:47:43.552
You know, there, there's a difference.
297
00:47:44.452 --> 00:48:03.152
There, there is a difference, but Smooth represents the creator, and as we engage brands, we're specific with each creator and we make them each an account in their own way to say, all right, you know, sometimes they just wanna work with Mav, or they just wanna work with Kat, and that's great, so we're able to build a long-term partnership around that.
298
00:48:03.232 --> 00:48:10.152
Or somebody comes in and says, "Hey, Smooth, you represent a bunch of knowledge creators. I've got a big thing coming out in November. Can you help me- Yeah...
299
00:48:10.192 --> 00:48:12.992
market the crap out of this new feature that we're launching?"
300
00:48:13.072 --> 00:48:30.812
So we're, we're able to do that in many ways, but, you know, we, we are representing the creator, and the benefit of us being the contracting party is that we can also do the invoicing, we can take on a lot of that administrative work so that, again, it is less cumbersome for the creator now to remember to have to follow up on an invoice or see if something got signed the right way.
301
00:48:31.712 --> 00:48:34.252
Yeah. That's, that's a good reminder. Thank you, Josh.
302
00:48:34.272 --> 00:48:53.932
[laughs] So the talent management question, and we were talking before, before we, we, we hit record about this because I kinda feel like this area, it's- It, it's somewhere in between, like what's needed or like it's not ad sales, it's kinda talent management, it's not...
303
00:48:53.972 --> 00:49:02.092
Like, the, it's, it's a, it's a strange mix in some ways. I, I agree. It's a little bit of a strange mix, which is why it's exciting to be building in the space.
304
00:49:02.132 --> 00:49:11.112
And for one, like I, I didn't come from a management background and, and some of the terminology feels like a little bit too like paternalistic within that world. [laughs] I'm like, these are smart...
305
00:49:11.132 --> 00:49:18.232
You know, again, you talk about your ideal. Yeah. [laughs] We, we got smart, like there are smart- Yeah, yeah... We, we are very lucky to be in a space where our partners are very intelligent.
306
00:49:18.272 --> 00:49:29.272
They don't need somebody to come in and like tell them how to tie their shoes. And so I prefer the image of them being the proprietor of their own media business and needing to build out a team.
307
00:49:29.812 --> 00:49:41.312
And so the management, you know, quote-unquote management 'cause it's easier to communicate, is more like the strategy and operations player who can help them extend themselves and help architect the operations of their business.
308
00:49:41.812 --> 00:49:53.232
And then our representation, our, our brand partnerships team is a brand partnerships department that they get to tap into, which looks like a modern brand partnerships department at a, at more so the media company.
309
00:49:53.271 --> 00:49:58.332
We think about inventory, we think about rates, we think about media kits. And so you're- Right...
310
00:49:58.372 --> 00:50:08.772
you're getting functions of a business that I'm very proud of, but we're using terminology to resonate with the fact that, you know, most of this creator economy- Yeah... is still using words like talent and agent.
311
00:50:09.752 --> 00:50:21.872
So w- you don't have exclusivity with, with everyone, or do you? We do. We are the exclusive rep for these partners. Okay. But there's no other way to do business with them except for th- through you?
312
00:50:21.932 --> 00:50:28.852
Or if like someone comes to them and is like, "Hey, I wanna buy ads," like do they kick them to, to Smooth? Yeah. Ta- talk to my rep. Okay.
313
00:50:28.872 --> 00:50:38.072
And we're, we're a combined team, and they're incentivized 'cause we're good at expanding an account. We're better at- Yeah... building out that proposal, and it's... Yeah, you, you, you don't wanna take on that work.
314
00:50:38.332 --> 00:50:47.832
Yeah. Just 'cause somebody can cut a deal doesn't mean that's what they should spend their limited time doing. I gotcha. Awesome. Cool. So. Josh, thanks. I'm glad we finally did this. Thank you. Thanks for having me.
315
00:50:47.892 --> 00:50:58.392
I really appreciate it. It was a great time. [outro music]