TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.080 --> 00:00:07.599
Before we get into this episode, just a little reminder that we are hosting the State of Sustainability Summit in London on October the 14th.
00:00:07.919 --> 00:00:12.160
We host the summit three times a year now in London, Chicago, and Amsterdam.
00:00:12.320 --> 00:00:32.320
It is the best place for you to meet a group of your peers, sustainability professionals in Food and Bev, FMCG, CPG packaging companies, sharing thoughts, learnings, problems on topics such as PCFs, topics such as the future of Regen Ag, all the kind of stuff that we cover on this podcast.
00:00:32.399 --> 00:00:35.280
So if you're interested in attending, check out the website.
00:00:35.359 --> 00:00:39.600
It'll be in the show notes, or drop me an email at sef at ultruistic.com.
00:00:39.679 --> 00:00:40.479
We would love to have you.
00:00:40.560 --> 00:00:42.000
I'd love to meet you in person.
00:00:48.159 --> 00:00:51.520
Welcome back to another episode of the State of Sustainability.
00:00:51.679 --> 00:00:55.280
I'm your host, Sef Hamid, founder and CEO of Ultruistic.
00:00:55.520 --> 00:01:07.680
Today's episode, we are going to revisit an old familiar staple of the State of Sustainability podcast, which is the PCF, the product carbon footprint.
00:01:07.920 --> 00:01:15.439
I haven't talked about PCFs on this show for I think actually at least a year, maybe even two years.
00:01:15.599 --> 00:01:15.920
I don't know.
00:01:16.000 --> 00:01:17.200
It's been a while.
00:01:17.519 --> 00:01:25.680
And the reason is that I got kind of bored of talking about it a couple of years ago and switched over to other more interesting fair for me.
00:01:25.920 --> 00:01:29.040
But I think it is about time to revisit that and a few reasons.
00:01:29.200 --> 00:01:33.120
One is that not everyone will have heard my previous monologues on PCFs.
00:01:33.439 --> 00:01:38.959
Another is that I think the PCF has actually come quite a long way uh since I first started talking about it.
00:01:39.120 --> 00:02:04.000
So today we are going to uh give a little bit of a primer on PCFs for those of you who are new to the game, and also a little bit of a like the story so far, the status now and where this is heading, which I hope will be interesting for you if you're if you're deep in the weeds on PCFs and trying to actually now figure out what the trends are in this in this fascinating little space.
00:02:04.239 --> 00:02:05.840
So, what is a PCF?
00:02:05.920 --> 00:02:07.760
What is a product carbon footprint?
00:02:08.159 --> 00:02:18.639
I think the best way to think about this, there are these like two academic arcane disciplines within carbon accounting.
00:02:18.960 --> 00:02:26.319
And historically, the twain have not met any place nice, and they've kind of um been their own separate little fiefdoms.
00:02:26.479 --> 00:02:39.599
One has been corporate carbon footprinting uh and all the greenhouse gas protocol stuff, and the other has been LCA's life cycle analyses or lifecycle assessments and all the stuff that goes into that vein.
00:02:40.000 --> 00:02:43.280
And they have both kind of come out of different places.
00:02:43.439 --> 00:03:02.879
I'm not going to give the whole origin story of these two things, but in brief, greenhouse gas protocol-based corporate carbon footprinting came out of like Kyoto Protocol style, carbon budgeting at the country level, and then taking that and saying, okay, well, if countries have carbon budgets, what does that look like for industries?
00:03:03.199 --> 00:03:06.560
If industries have carbon budgets, what could that look like for a company?
00:03:06.719 --> 00:03:15.520
And sort of very top-down, how do you come down and make sense of a global greenhouse gas goal and what that needs to look like at a company level?
00:03:15.680 --> 00:03:19.919
And that sort of led us to the corporate carbon footprint that we all know and hate.
00:03:20.159 --> 00:03:40.719
The LCA came from a different place, which is more from environmental science, more from academia, uh, which is if you kind of look uh at a product, and if you look at the full life cycle of the product, which means the creation, the use, the end state, you know, potentially reuse, et cetera, of the product, what is that journey?
00:03:40.879 --> 00:03:42.319
What is that life cycle?
00:03:42.479 --> 00:03:47.439
And what is the whole host of impacts that that life cycle creates?
00:03:47.759 --> 00:03:59.280
And within LC analyses, you would have carbon, but also water, you know, potentially many other different factors as well, toxicity, social impacts often also get looked at as part of this analysis.
00:03:59.360 --> 00:04:02.000
And so you kind of take this full life cycle view of a product.
00:04:02.240 --> 00:04:09.280
And typically that was not very cost effective to do for many different products, and was not really a corporate exercise.
00:04:09.360 --> 00:04:16.160
It was usually done as an academic exercise where you say, you know, I, as a researcher, I'm looking into the impact of mayonnaise.
00:04:16.399 --> 00:04:21.360
And so I take like a sample mayonnaise and I say, okay, well, what does mayonnaise in general look like?
00:04:21.519 --> 00:04:28.399
And maybe to some extent I'm saying, well, if this mayonnaise were buying edible oil from country A versus country B, it might look a little bit different.
00:04:28.560 --> 00:04:41.920
I wasn't really expecting that any company is gonna ask me to come and do 50 of these, much less that a company is gonna look to like hire me and have me do 50 of these every year across different variations of my products.
00:04:42.079 --> 00:04:44.480
It seems a bit crazy now that you say it out loud.
00:04:44.639 --> 00:04:54.959
And because these two were quite different, obviously some little overlaps, right, in like how you treat carbon, but because these were quite different, they didn't really come together very neatly and they didn't
Load full transcript
really reconcile.
00:04:55.120 --> 00:05:04.240
So if you were a big corporate and you had done your corporate carbon footprint and you had also done one, two, ten, fifteen LCAs on different products.
00:05:04.399 --> 00:05:17.439
Like I know, for example, Nestle had historically been doing many different LCAs on different products to understand for their own product development purposes what the environmental and potentially even social impacts of their products were.
00:05:17.600 --> 00:05:27.439
You would kind of have these as two separate things, and you wouldn't expect that all your LCAs might add up to a subset of your corporate carbon footprint.
00:05:27.680 --> 00:05:33.920
Now, if you're a layperson coming to this, like you know, my producer Ben, you'd say, well, why not?
00:05:34.079 --> 00:05:42.480
Like you're selling mayonnaise, you've got LCAs of what mayonnaise looks like, you've got the corporate footprint of your business, your business is selling mayonnaise.
00:05:42.720 --> 00:05:45.839
Surely these two things should should jive somehow.
00:05:46.000 --> 00:05:47.040
And you would be wrong.
00:05:47.199 --> 00:05:48.240
They don't jive.
00:05:48.399 --> 00:05:50.160
Well, they maybe they should, but they don't really jive.
00:05:50.480 --> 00:05:51.839
Until now, until recently.
00:05:51.920 --> 00:05:54.720
And the recency element is the PCF.
00:05:54.959 --> 00:06:00.639
What I mean by that is a PCF is a slice of an LCA.
00:06:00.800 --> 00:06:02.959
It is the carbon element of the LCA.
00:06:03.040 --> 00:06:07.680
Remember that the LCA includes many different things, you know, water, potentially various other impacts.
00:06:07.839 --> 00:06:10.399
The PCF is just the carbon bit for that product.
00:06:10.560 --> 00:06:20.560
It is what that product looks like across its life cycle, and we can talk about what, where we draw the cutoffs, but across its life cycle, what that product looks like in carbon terms.
00:06:20.800 --> 00:06:30.000
Which means that in theory, you should be able to just add those up across all your products and get a subset of your corporate carbon footprint that can somehow reconcile.
00:06:30.240 --> 00:06:45.439
The next step was if I'm getting these PCFs together, am I actually using the same PCF in my corporate carbon footprint as a component of it, or am I using at least the same emissions factors that go into generating my product carbon footprint?
00:06:45.600 --> 00:06:48.160
Am I using those also in my corporate carbon footprint?
00:06:48.319 --> 00:07:04.639
And this is the whole reconciliation exercise that uh many of the companies that are using PCFs are now going through, which is how do we get our PCFs to feed into our corporate carbon footprint, or vice versa, or at least how do we get them to reconcile by using the same emissions factors underneath them?
00:07:05.279 --> 00:07:10.959
And this sort of race for the PCF kicked off maybe about three years ago.
00:07:11.279 --> 00:07:29.360
And a lot of the I think innovation around this was led by PACT, which is an initiative spun out of the WBCSD, the World Business Council for Sustainable Development, uh, which includes most of the big corporations, certainly in the FMCG space, but also various others that you might think of.
00:07:29.600 --> 00:07:38.879
And this sort of effort, this Pact coalition or group, or I hate the word coalition, always makes me think of like 10 people on a stage holding hands and raising them up triumphantly.
00:07:38.959 --> 00:07:43.199
Uh, whereas actually this is more like 10 people in a room bickering over standards.
00:07:43.360 --> 00:07:47.519
No offense to PACT, uh, all views are expressed are mine and mine alone.
00:07:47.680 --> 00:07:53.920
But basically, the the effort behind PACT was focused on two problems.
00:07:54.319 --> 00:08:10.240
One is how do we make sure that if people are making PCFs, people being software companies, consultants, corporates, if they're all making their own PCFs for products, how do we ensure that all those PCFs speak to each other and are of the same standard and are comparable?
00:08:10.480 --> 00:08:21.759
So if I am a Unilever and you're a supplier to me and I ask you for a PCF, the PCF you give me is a PCF that I can reconcile with PCFs that I might be creating.
00:08:22.000 --> 00:08:25.839
It's a Lego block that I can put onto my stack of Lego blocks.
00:08:25.920 --> 00:08:28.079
Uh I'm asking you for a packaging PCF.
00:08:28.240 --> 00:08:31.839
I'm asking Jack for a soap noodle PCF.
00:08:32.000 --> 00:08:45.279
I'm asking so-and-so for a artificial scent PCF, all the different things that go into soap, let's say, and I'm stacking all these PCFs onto one onto the other to make a PCF for my finished product, which is, let's say, Dove soap.
00:08:45.759 --> 00:08:46.720
True story.
00:08:47.039 --> 00:08:54.639
So that stack should all be comparable in that the Lego blocks should stack onto each other nicely by having the same standard.
00:08:54.879 --> 00:08:57.519
That was problem A, which is get the standards to align.
00:08:57.759 --> 00:09:15.519
Problem B was okay, if we're going to have a lot of people asking each other for PCFs because you're a retailer retailing DoveSap, or you're the packaging company supplying the packaging for DoveSoap or whatever, uh, how do we make sure that these requests are all easy with minimal burden on all participants?
00:09:15.679 --> 00:09:27.039
Which means we need to have an API, an automated programming interface of some sort, a piece of code that allows you to have the exchange of data flow seamlessly all over the place.
00:09:27.279 --> 00:09:34.080
And so that kind of API creation was the second piece of the puzzle that Pact really needed to solve in a standardized way.
00:09:34.240 --> 00:09:39.200
Standardized methodology, standardized API, both of which could be used across the industry.
00:09:39.519 --> 00:09:47.360
Many years later, or at least like I think three, four, five years later, Pact sort of emerged with usable versions of both of these.
00:09:47.679 --> 00:09:55.039
And uh, and those then started to proliferate or at least get out into the ecosystem of the corporate world a few years ago.
00:09:55.200 --> 00:10:16.320
And by that I mean that I'm gonna get my years wrong maybe, but about three years ago, I would say there were probably like low hundreds of PCFs being created in general against the PAC standard across the corporate world, uh, and probably even fewer changing hands or moving across the sort of the network really through the API.
00:10:16.559 --> 00:10:23.600
Those numbers have all trended significantly up over the last few years, both in terms of PCFs created and in terms of PCFs exchanged.
00:10:23.759 --> 00:10:30.879
Uh, one of the reasons that I know this is because Ultruistic is one of the platforms being used for creating PCFs and also for sharing PCFs.
00:10:31.039 --> 00:10:35.440
And for us, the PCF numbers in the thousands on any given year.
00:10:35.759 --> 00:10:39.600
So that is kind of the story so far on the PCF.
00:10:39.679 --> 00:10:44.159
Now let's talk a little bit about why PCFs have caught on.
00:10:44.240 --> 00:10:50.720
We've talked about what PACT was trying to do and standardization, but why is a PCF interesting or useful for a corporation?
00:10:50.879 --> 00:10:53.279
Now, there are a couple of reasons why it's useful.
00:10:53.600 --> 00:10:59.440
One is the theoretical reason, and the other is what I've actually observed in practice.
00:10:59.679 --> 00:11:13.279
The theoretical reason is that a PCF is a better way than the corporate carbon footprinting way of understanding how to actually improve the environmental quality of your business.
00:11:13.440 --> 00:11:25.679
What I mean by that is if you take your corporate carbon footprint, it's not really very useful for driving much change once you get past all the electrification and decarbonization of energy stuff.
00:11:25.840 --> 00:11:34.240
And that's because most of your impact sits within scope three, scope three cat one, for example, you know, it's in the purchases that you buy and the stuff that you buy.
00:11:34.480 --> 00:11:42.159
And it's really hard to use these massive lump sum numbers to actually get specificity in what you need to change.
00:11:42.320 --> 00:11:50.000
Uh, you know, you know the footprint of everything that you're buying, great, but actually that rests on all these emissions factors that are somewhat generic.
00:11:50.159 --> 00:12:04.000
And so it's a little hard to see, okay, well, if I want to change this specific thing that I buy, what is the conversation I have with the supplier that can be very specific on a particular activity, a particular thing that they're doing, a particular type of change that I want them to make?
00:12:04.240 --> 00:12:07.360
I need data cut in a slightly different way.
00:12:07.679 --> 00:12:14.240
By contrast, a PCF gives you
a view on the product that takes into account all the activities that went into making this product.
00:12:14.399 --> 00:12:18.960
So you can kind of say, well, you know, I think you guys should be using different materials in your sourcing.
00:12:19.120 --> 00:12:21.440
I think you guys should be using decarbonized energy.
00:12:21.679 --> 00:12:25.519
You can have like a more nuanced conversation around the nature of the product that you're buying.
00:12:25.759 --> 00:12:39.279
The other thing is that if you kind of stack up those Lego blocks and you now build your Dove soap and you can see all the blocks in, your internal conversations are also more robust because you're able to say internally, hey guys, we are in the business of making Dove soap.
00:12:39.360 --> 00:12:41.519
This is the carbon impact of Dove soap.
00:12:41.679 --> 00:12:42.879
These are the different blocks.
00:12:43.039 --> 00:12:51.120
We internally, and as an RD team or otherwise, we need to think about how we bring the blocks all down and reduce the carbon footprint of this dove soap.
00:12:51.200 --> 00:12:57.679
And if we do that well, we can be reasonably confident that because we sell a lot of dove soap, we'll drive reductions across our full footprint.
00:12:57.919 --> 00:13:04.720
It's a more logical conversation because most people in the business will already be used to having conversations at the level of dove soap.
00:13:04.799 --> 00:13:07.200
This is the cost of dove soap, this is how much it costs us to make.
00:13:07.360 --> 00:13:17.279
You know, this is how much soap noodle goes into dove soap, this is how much of these different ingredients go into dove soap, this is how much carbon dove soap generates, and this is how much we would need to reduce it by to meet our targets.
00:13:17.440 --> 00:13:32.559
You know, these conversations can all flow in the same rhythm rather than trying to educate everyone on an arcane greenhouse gas protocol methodology that no one really still understands, uh, except for five people sitting in five separate rooms alone on Zoom.
00:13:32.960 --> 00:13:39.200
Uh coming back, so this was the theoretical reason for why PCFs uh are useful.
00:13:39.440 --> 00:13:50.720
Uh the actual practical reasons that I'm seeing in use is mostly about making scope three more specific, more accurate, more defensible, more robust, etc.
00:13:50.960 --> 00:14:03.039
Which is most corporations have now realized that most of the emissions factors they're using are very generic, very high-level, kind of like aggregated food and bev factors or global average factors or whatever.
00:14:03.360 --> 00:14:15.600
And they want to now try and find a way to replace the generic with the specific, the generic uh mayonnaise emissions factor with a specific supplier-specific mayonnaise PCF, for example.
00:14:15.919 --> 00:14:21.440
And that is one of the things that is driving, I would say, the push towards getting more PCFs.
00:14:21.600 --> 00:14:30.720
The first big leap was can we move from spend-based scope three calculations towards weights and regional specificity and all this?
00:14:30.799 --> 00:14:34.320
Uh, and the next is now can we get supplier-specific PCFs?
00:14:34.559 --> 00:14:39.279
So that I think is what's driving a lot of the big uh push in this direction now.
00:14:39.519 --> 00:14:43.200
What I think is interesting is a few different areas, right?
00:14:43.360 --> 00:14:54.879
One is I think that this push for more PCFs, like I'm all for it, not just because I'm in the PCF business, uh, but also because I think PCFs do generally help with getting more scope three specificity.
00:14:54.960 --> 00:14:59.120
I think once you have them, you do also give a common language for action internally.
00:14:59.360 --> 00:15:05.919
You do also give a common language for buyers and procurement professionals to have conversations with suppliers where they can drive action.
00:15:06.240 --> 00:15:10.799
I think that, however, there are some challenges with PCFs as well.
00:15:11.120 --> 00:15:19.360
One is, as with carbon accounting, PCFs give the impression of precision.
00:15:19.679 --> 00:15:34.639
Anyone who has had to present a corporate carbon footprint to their finance team knows what I'm talking about when I say that your colleagues will expect that this has some type of rigor that you might expect from financial data.
00:15:34.799 --> 00:15:35.759
And they would be wrong.
00:15:35.840 --> 00:15:37.840
It has no such type of rigor at all.
00:15:38.080 --> 00:15:53.679
In fact, you cannot even say in most businesses whether your scope three is within a margin of error of 10% or within a margin of error of 20% or 30% or 40%, because this is inherently somewhat subjective.
00:15:54.080 --> 00:16:01.279
True, full 100% accuracy is a complete pipe dream in carbon accounting.
00:16:01.440 --> 00:16:08.799
And anyone who tries to convince you or tell you that it is otherwise is absolutely lying.
00:16:09.279 --> 00:16:14.879
And by that I mean that it is not really possible, and I've kind of learned this the hard way as well.
00:16:15.440 --> 00:16:26.240
It is not only is it not possible to say that a given corporate carbon footprint is 100% accurate, for the same reason, it is not possible to say that this is accurate to within 10%.
00:16:26.799 --> 00:16:31.279
Because no one will ever know what 100% looks like, because it is purely subjective.
00:16:31.600 --> 00:16:40.879
And the reason for that is that corporate footprints are ultimately composed of so many different environmental impact proxies, so many emissions factor proxies.
00:16:41.120 --> 00:16:45.360
PCF still being built on emissions factors is also composed of proxies.
00:16:45.519 --> 00:16:53.200
If you do get a mayonnaise PCF from a supplier, that mayonnaise PCF is itself created with emissions factors underlying it.
00:16:53.360 --> 00:17:08.880
Those emissions factors will just be emissions factors for edible oil and
eggs and all the other stuff that goes into mayonnaise, you're no longer using a generic mayonnaise emissions factor, but whoever is supplying you is using generic edible oil emissions factors to create the PCF that they're giving you for mayonnaise.
00:17:09.200 --> 00:17:42.160
And until the entire world has people going out there with sensors on fields and sticking things in the ground and measuring flatulence of cows and all these other sorts of things, capturing methane emissions from landfills, literally, unless until this is all physically captured, which it will never be because it will never be cost effective, you can never get any true sense of the environmental impact of most activities, certainly within the consumer goods, food, personal care sort of space, which means that we're all back to proxies.
00:17:42.319 --> 00:17:50.799
So this false precision problem is still going to be going to sort of hound the PCF world much as it hounds the corporate carbon footprint world.
00:17:51.200 --> 00:18:05.519
To make it kind of even more entertaining, if you ask three different solution providers to create PCFs for the same product, three different consultancies, three different software players, you will get different PCFs.
00:18:06.160 --> 00:18:12.079
And they may be within 10% of each other, they may be within 20%, they may be within 30%, who knows?
00:18:12.319 --> 00:18:20.000
And one of the reasons is that each of those different consultants or solution providers will probably be using slightly different emissions factors.
00:18:20.400 --> 00:18:34.240
Now, if everyone is following a packed-aligned methodology, they're following the same approach, the same practice, but they might still be using different packed-aligned emissions factors underlying those calculations, different inputs, which means they'll get a different output.
00:18:34.559 --> 00:18:38.240
And the variation on those outputs is unpredictable.
00:18:38.400 --> 00:18:50.079
And that I think is unfortunately just a problem of this space, which means you need to kind of figure out your own baseline for your own PCF and track against that baseline using a consistent approach internally.
00:18:50.720 --> 00:20:01.629
And I think not worry so much or fret so much or get too fixated on I hate saying this, but I'm gonna say it, on lots of comparability across different players because it's a little bit of a pipe dream.
00:20:01.709 --> 00:20:06.349
You measure against your own baseline, you don't try and measure against what everyone else has.
00:20:06.909 --> 00:20:11.709
Second problem with PCFs is it sort of shifts a bit of the problem upstream to your suppliers.
00:20:11.869 --> 00:20:14.589
Your suppliers now need to figure out how they get PCFs.
00:20:14.829 --> 00:20:28.669
As long as solutions, whether it's software or consultancy, is expensive or charges for this, that you know, basically until the stuff becomes free, that is imposing a cost on your suppliers.
00:20:28.829 --> 00:20:44.429
Whether that's a cost of service provision to calculate PCFs or whether it's a cost of time and energy that they put into creating PCFs, you know, there are some variations where you could say there are free solutions out there, but the more that you want rigor, ultimately rigor will come at a price.
00:20:44.909 --> 00:20:56.109
There's generally a trade-off between how rigorous, how robust, how accurate, how auditable, how usable is what I'm getting, and whether I'm paying something for it or someone is paying something for it.
00:20:56.189 --> 00:20:59.789
You typically get what you pay for, is what I mean, in shorter words.
00:21:00.349 --> 00:21:06.269
Another problem with the PCF is that you only really get the carbon view for now.
00:21:06.509 --> 00:21:09.389
Now, you know, in our case, for example, we're also looking at water.
00:21:09.549 --> 00:21:14.109
There will be other factors, you know, as you kind of get flag PCFs, we will have flag breakdowns as well.
00:21:14.189 --> 00:21:17.309
So there'll be land use change and land management, and these things will be represented.
00:21:17.469 --> 00:21:21.789
But ultimately, this is still a slice of what you might want to view at the product level.
00:21:21.869 --> 00:21:28.909
And an LCA would have given you many other cuts on this potentially that you won't have with a simple PCF, depending on what you're using.
00:21:29.069 --> 00:21:39.149
So I think there's this element where it's a little bit of a, we used to call this like this sort of blinders or blinkers problem a few years ago when people were like, well, we should be caring about all the other metrics.
00:21:39.309 --> 00:21:46.829
Now people don't raise this because now everyone's like, well, forget the other metrics, let's just figure out carbon because we don't have budgets, we don't have capacity, we don't have a team.
00:21:47.069 --> 00:21:48.429
So now it's less of a problem.
00:21:48.509 --> 00:21:53.309
But at some point, people will again start looking at, well, what about all the other things that we're supposed to be measuring?
00:21:53.549 --> 00:22:04.109
Already, what I find is quite interesting is we work with, I would say, most of the large PACT-conformant PCF requesters in the world.
00:22:04.269 --> 00:22:12.669
And what I find there is that the biggest, most ambitious companies have other stuff that they want that is beyond Pact.
00:22:13.389 --> 00:22:18.750
And that's solving for this problem where they don't just want to look at just some aspects of carbon.
00:22:18.909 --> 00:22:23.549
They want to look at a broader picture and look at other elements of data that are important for them for their strategy.
00:22:23.709 --> 00:22:38.509
At the same time, the more that they do that, the more they either force Pact to raise the bar on what's in the standard, which makes it expensive and prohibitive for everyone else, or they go against the grain of standardization because
they're the largest requesters of this sort of data.
00:22:38.589 --> 00:22:45.069
And if they're not going with the standardization approach, what's the value for everyone else in being in this in this methodology club?
00:22:45.230 --> 00:22:49.309
So I think there's this like inherent tension here as well that you end up getting.
00:22:49.629 --> 00:22:56.269
The other thing that I find is a challenge with PCFs is that mostly these are going into the procurement function.
00:22:56.429 --> 00:22:58.109
For requesters, at least, mostly it's ending.
00:22:58.429 --> 00:22:59.949
Up in the procurement function.
00:23:00.269 --> 00:23:05.789
And not everyone in the procurement function really usually gets what a PCF is, why is it important?
00:23:05.949 --> 00:23:07.709
It's again this arcane thing.
00:23:07.789 --> 00:23:13.389
And the ability to bring it back into something that makes sense for procurement professionals requires a lot of education.
00:23:13.549 --> 00:23:21.309
So right now, I find that a sophisticated procurement professional who is charged with figuring out carbon, let's say, figuring out carbon.
00:23:21.389 --> 00:23:25.069
If you can't see the video, I'm doing the little squiggly bunny ears with my hand.
00:23:25.389 --> 00:23:36.669
Understands, like generally speaking, what a carbon footprint means, generally, and that you need to have projects to reduce things like energy use on the supplier side.
00:23:36.829 --> 00:23:39.230
And those projects are a good thing to do.
00:23:39.469 --> 00:23:52.750
So, for example, if you're a consumer goods business, you're buying packaging materials, I think that a good procurement professional will understand that going into this conversation with a glass maker, I want to understand: are they moving to hybrid furnaces?
00:23:52.909 --> 00:23:54.909
Are they electrifying their furnaces progressively?
00:23:55.069 --> 00:23:56.589
Are they using recycled content?
00:23:56.750 --> 00:24:06.429
These are all projects that as someone who has been buying glass for years and years, I can get my head around and understand because they overlap often with cost initiatives as well.
00:24:06.509 --> 00:24:09.230
And they're so intrinsic to the business that I'm buying from.
00:24:09.469 --> 00:24:20.109
But then kind of getting a sense of like not just energy intensity, but also like PCFs, which include a lot of these other things, like where are you buying the sand from or whatever else goes into your glass and so on, right?
00:24:20.189 --> 00:24:24.269
Like how the glass gets trucked, like it's a little bit of a more complicated topic.
00:24:24.429 --> 00:24:33.309
And so I think there's a big educational burden with PCFs because it's something new in general for us to solve with procurement professionals, given that they're the front line for this stuff.
00:24:33.709 --> 00:24:38.029
So we've talked a little bit about the origins of PCFs.
00:24:38.109 --> 00:24:41.309
I said this wouldn't be like an origin story podcast, but it kind of is.
00:24:41.469 --> 00:24:46.829
So we've talked a little bit about where PCFs came from, how PCFs have developed, how they're being used today.
00:24:46.990 --> 00:24:49.789
We've talked a little bit also about the challenges.
00:24:49.869 --> 00:24:53.469
Uh, I want to give maybe a few more highlights of like what we see in programs.
00:24:53.709 --> 00:25:06.029
Some of our customers or partners or clients or whatever you want to call them, I would say are really ambitious requesters of PCFs, and others are really ambitious creators of PCFs.
00:25:06.189 --> 00:25:19.949
They are suppliers into FMCG CPG, and they want to really nail the business of generating PCFs that provide them with the most robust way to build strategic collaborations with their customers.
00:25:20.429 --> 00:25:24.509
Let's talk a little bit about what we learned from both because I think it's quite helpful.
00:25:24.990 --> 00:25:37.869
On the ambitious requester side, what I find is that the most ambitious requesters set a target, which is what share of their scope three emissions do they want to have underpinned by supplier-specific emissions factors or PCFs?
00:25:38.109 --> 00:25:45.389
They then robustly manage that program in terms of getting responses, figuring out who they send requests to, how they get those PCFs back.
00:25:45.549 --> 00:25:53.149
There's a robust approach that they need to take to quality and how those PCFs all get like reviewed, assessed, evaluated as good enough.
00:25:53.230 --> 00:26:04.189
There's a bar that needs to be set on what a good enough PCF means, not just at the level of the PAC standard, but also for the business in particular to feel confident and comfortable that it meets their own internal bar.
00:26:04.750 --> 00:26:11.869
Challenges that they tend to face is that participation is often late, uneven, inconsistent.
00:26:12.029 --> 00:26:20.669
I've noticed that, for example, you know, a company like Coca-Cola will generally get, in my, from my vantage point, like a really good response rate.
00:26:20.829 --> 00:26:24.909
They'll get rapid engagement by suppliers, deep collaboration.
00:26:25.069 --> 00:26:42.429
You know, often it it will be better than what I might see at, let's say, a mid-size FMCG that doesn't have, may still be a multi-billion dollar revenue business, but doesn't have the same like anchor brand cachet with suppliers, for want of a better word, that a Coca-Cola might have or a Unilever might have.
00:26:42.669 --> 00:26:44.669
And so I think there's this like slight unevenness.
00:26:44.750 --> 00:26:50.269
You'll also find that certain materials and certain geographies tend to be more proactive and more responsive.
00:26:50.509 --> 00:26:57.789
I think that a better predictor is the industry of the supplier than the geography of the supplier, actually.
00:26:57.949 --> 00:27:06.189
So, for example, I noticed that packaging and food ingredients get a lot of
pressure from requesters, understandably given the nature of the materials.
00:27:06.349 --> 00:27:16.750
I find packaging uh tends to have quite a high engagement rate from what I've seen versus some other types of material, despite the fact that packaging companies may be in many different sorts of locations.
00:27:17.069 --> 00:27:20.829
Um, often suppliers will have capability gaps and skill gaps.
00:27:20.990 --> 00:27:27.230
That's not the same as uh so high engagement doesn't necessarily mean high capabilities and PCFs ready to go.
00:27:27.309 --> 00:27:30.349
It just means that you get responses, you get questions, you get involvement.
00:27:30.429 --> 00:27:34.509
Uh, but you'll find that actually the capability set across the supply chain is very patchy.
00:27:34.669 --> 00:27:51.709
So you want to get an understanding when you're kind of setting up these programs of where are if you have a goal of a certain percentage of coverage across your scope three, what is most likely going to get you to that goal based on supplier types that are going to engage with you and are gonna have PCFs that you can acquire?
00:27:51.869 --> 00:27:54.029
And those two are kind of complementary.
00:27:54.109 --> 00:28:04.349
Either they have PCFs that you're gonna acquire, in which case it doesn't matter if they're super high engagement, maybe they engage with you late, maybe they engage with you sporadically, but they have the stuff so they can give it to you.
00:28:04.589 --> 00:28:11.389
If they don't have the PCFs, then you do want high engagement because you're gonna need them to build those PCFs for you and get and then get them to you.
00:28:11.549 --> 00:28:14.189
So I think you kind of want some combination of these things.
00:28:14.429 --> 00:28:20.669
On the requester side, I think that there's a big premium in two types of education.
00:28:20.909 --> 00:28:31.469
One is education of suppliers, a lot of hand holding, a lot of support, you know, combination of people responding to emails, webinars, educational materials.
00:28:31.869 --> 00:28:39.869
I think there's definitely, like I noticed this in both DiAgio and Unilever, where the programs were spearheaded by the chief procurement officers.
00:28:40.029 --> 00:28:48.909
I think that's a really good thing for every company to be doing as well, where the CPO establishes that this is important, why this is important, and that it's strategic.
00:28:49.069 --> 00:28:51.309
Uh, I think there's really very little substitute for that.
00:28:51.469 --> 00:28:53.869
Suppliers need to know that this is something you're going to take seriously.
00:28:54.029 --> 00:29:05.549
You have such little of a stick and such little of a carrot with these things, given where everyone's budgets for this stuff land, that you at least want to use soft power quite assertively.
00:29:05.709 --> 00:29:21.149
The other educational component is you really want to make sure that as a requester, you have your own procurement team aligned on what this is, why it's important, how to run it, how to escalate things if they go wrong, what good looks like, what bad looks like, how to support all this stuff.
00:29:21.309 --> 00:29:23.309
And frankly, it is a little bit of a lift.
00:29:23.549 --> 00:29:31.709
I see a model where some organizations have particular category managers maybe tasked with thinking specifically about sustainability.
00:29:31.789 --> 00:29:34.349
And so they spend most of their time on these topics.
00:29:34.509 --> 00:29:42.909
And I see others where the general purpose procurement professional or buyer is expected to be upskilled onto this and to lead the charge, and there's obviously hybrids.
00:29:43.389 --> 00:29:56.429
The final and most annoying element of education that a requester needs to get right is having their sustainability professionals and their procurement professionals aligned on what good enough looks like.
00:29:56.750 --> 00:30:01.949
The most irritating problem, and this is not just for me, this is actually for the businesses that we work with.
00:30:02.109 --> 00:30:08.429
The most irritating problem is that you get good alignment on the procurement side on what you're going to be requesting.
00:30:08.589 --> 00:30:24.429
You get PCFs back that meet that bar, but then the sustainability professionals believe that this bar is not sufficiently good to meet the rigor and robustness that we need for our own corporate carbon footprinting, for example, or for our own external reporting.
00:30:24.669 --> 00:30:27.469
You know, that's not a fault of one side or another.
00:30:27.709 --> 00:30:30.429
Both of them are solving for the right things.
00:30:30.589 --> 00:30:39.149
Procurement professionals are solving for getting something done and getting something done to an agreed standard, and trying to do this with as little pain and friction with suppliers as possible.
00:30:39.230 --> 00:30:40.829
And that's a good thing to aim for.
00:30:41.069 --> 00:30:52.589
On the other hand, the sustainability professionals are trying to solve for not watering down quality, maintaining rigor, and you know, not getting in the soup, basically, on sharing something externally that is not up to scratch.
00:30:52.750 --> 00:30:54.990
And both of these are like, you know, noble pursuits.
00:30:55.149 --> 00:31:02.589
We just need to make sure that they're well aligned at the starts of these programs rather than at the ends of these programs when it's much more painful to pick up the pieces.
00:31:02.750 --> 00:31:04.349
That's on the requester side.
00:31:04.509 --> 00:31:23.949
On the supplier side, let's say, or the person generating and sharing PCFs, I think that I'm trying to, I think I used a really uh framing that I found quite fun a few years ago, which is I think you sort of have these three camps of um of suppliers.
00:31:24.109 --> 00:31:38.189
I think you have suppliers that really get that PCFs can be useful for them, and
let's talk about how, and are quick to move and assertive and really try and establish what good looks like and try and set the bar.
00:31:38.750 --> 00:31:46.909
I think you then have another tier of suppliers that see what these suppliers, these other players are doing and figure, oh, we should get on this bandwagon.
00:31:47.149 --> 00:31:52.269
Let us try and build capabilities, maybe pick our battles, but actually kind of move in this direction as well.
00:31:52.429 --> 00:31:56.829
And we're not going to be leaders and change makers, but we're going to be fast followers.
00:31:56.990 --> 00:32:12.429
And so maybe that means that we're not seen as the strategic partner, but we're actually seen as a potential good option to, you know, as part of a suite of initiatives we're doing to build a strategic partner relationship with our customer, we are seen as proactive.
00:32:12.589 --> 00:32:25.709
You know, as a as a supplier, you want to be seen as a supplier that manages quality well, that is coachable by the buyer, that is proactive, that owns the outcomes that your customer wants to hit.
00:32:26.109 --> 00:32:32.669
And often the combination of these can be more valuable than simply being the rock bottom cheapest supplier.
00:32:32.829 --> 00:32:48.029
And the combination of these can therefore help you get market share, given that every big buyer, right now that I've seen at least is part is following a mandate to try and consolidate purchasing activity in fewer suppliers and give more market share or more share of wallet to fewer suppliers.
00:32:48.189 --> 00:32:54.349
You want to play into that narrative as a fast follower or as camp one, which was the sort of the trailblazer.
00:32:54.829 --> 00:32:56.589
I think the trailblazers are very few.
00:32:56.750 --> 00:32:59.230
I've only seen a handful of them, frankly.
00:32:59.389 --> 00:33:02.109
I think I've seen actually a few of them in each category.
00:33:02.189 --> 00:33:07.309
I see a few of them in food ingredients, I see a few of them in packaging, uh, you know, maybe a few of them in logistics.
00:33:07.469 --> 00:33:09.549
The fast followers, I think, are more interesting.
00:33:09.629 --> 00:33:12.750
You see quite a disparate spread, often across geographies as well.
00:33:12.829 --> 00:33:20.429
You'll see, you know, maybe a dozen different packaging companies that are exploring this and innovating and experimenting, but they're not taking the full plunge yet.
00:33:20.589 --> 00:33:24.829
Similarly, with food ingredients, you might see a few dozen or more there as well.
00:33:25.069 --> 00:33:34.509
And then you have the larger camp, which is the vast majority of suppliers, where I think that if this stuff catches on, many of them will find themselves just expected to comply at some point.
00:33:34.589 --> 00:33:38.909
It'll be a bit like QA requirements and you know other stuff that you're just expected to go through.
00:33:39.069 --> 00:33:43.469
They'll incur the cost,
but they won't really capture any particular advantage of it.
00:33:43.549 --> 00:34:03.069
Like, you know, if you think about quality assurance, for example, and in that space, imagine if you were the first tier of suppliers shaping quality assurance standards with your customers and actually helping define what good quality ingredients and raw materials and feedstock look like, and saying with your customers, this should be the standard, really.
00:34:03.149 --> 00:34:04.429
You know, this is how we do it.
00:34:04.589 --> 00:34:07.549
Here are some areas we don't do yet, but we think should be part of the standard.
00:34:07.709 --> 00:34:10.110
You know, imagine like helping really define that.
00:34:10.349 --> 00:34:18.750
And then ISO and all the industry standards kind of pick up off the back of what is normal industry practice and really shape around what you had already built out.
00:34:18.909 --> 00:34:20.990
What a massive strategic advantage that is.
00:34:21.070 --> 00:34:22.510
Everyone else is playing catch-up.
00:34:22.670 --> 00:34:31.789
Even if you're the fast follower on that, imagine being one of the first few suppliers in your category to be compliant with modern quality assurance standards, everyone else is playing catch-up, right?
00:34:31.869 --> 00:34:39.150
There's big advantages to doing that in an area where the cost is going to come your way anyway, and you're then going to just have to play catch-up.
00:34:39.789 --> 00:34:56.349
So, you know, in terms of kind of what we see from the requester side in that first category, I think that we tend to see companies wanting to understand the PCF already on their side for all their products, not just like one or two product categories, not just a handful of SKUs, but really everything.
00:34:56.510 --> 00:35:00.829
And then try and understand what are the projects that would drive these PCFs down over time.
00:35:00.990 --> 00:35:05.789
And how do we go to our customers and pitch those projects and pitch those roadmaps?
00:35:06.030 --> 00:35:11.789
It's not just a spot sale of a product today, it is a transition plan to a lower carbon product.
00:35:11.949 --> 00:35:13.549
It's going to take several years.
00:35:13.710 --> 00:35:28.429
It's one of a number of other collaborative initiatives that we might do together, which will ultimately make us a better partner for you, help you deliver better products, whether it's just quality and cost and all that stuff, or whether it's also about carbon and environmental impact.
00:35:28.589 --> 00:35:41.389
And I find that they use this as a really proactive strategic lever, which means that at the front line, if this is commercial teams, they heavily coach and upskill commercial teams in going and having these conversations as well.
00:35:41.630 --> 00:35:45.789
One of the best examples I've seen of this is actually Carrie Foods.
00:35:46.029 --> 00:35:58.829
There are other great examples as well, but like Carry Foods is one of the
best examples I've seen of this, where if you kind of look at the Carrie Foods presence at major events like New York Climate Week, for example, London Climate Week, like it is just impressive.
00:35:58.989 --> 00:36:05.789
Like, you know, they bring out core uh leaders from the full exec team, chief procurement officers, chief commercial officers, right?
00:36:05.949 --> 00:36:12.670
Full C-suite is out there pitching the narrative of why sustainability makes sense for them as business, why it makes sense for their customers.
00:36:12.829 --> 00:36:33.069
They go deep, they go specific, you know, and they really pitch this as programmatic strategy with key accounts, which is exactly the way that you move from being a supplier of commodities, like just milk and dairy stuff, towards higher value, more complex food ingredients with longer-term build-out programs, shared RD.
00:36:33.230 --> 00:36:35.230
You know, this doesn't exist in a silo.
00:36:35.630 --> 00:36:40.429
Generating a PCF and showing what the carbon impact looks like doesn't exist in a silo on its own.
00:36:40.589 --> 00:36:44.190
You're not gonna get any benefit from just checking a PCF over the wall.
00:36:44.349 --> 00:36:51.549
It exists as part of a programmatic strategy to build share of wallet, build longer-term tenure relationships with customers.
00:36:51.789 --> 00:36:58.110
I have waxed far more lyrical, or at least far longer, maybe not so lyrical, than I had expected.
00:36:58.269 --> 00:37:00.349
So I'm gonna kind of tie this up now.
00:37:00.509 --> 00:37:05.309
Hopefully, if you were looking for a general primer on what a PCF is, this has been useful.
00:37:05.469 --> 00:37:09.469
If you were looking to understand as a requester, uh, what should you think about?
00:37:09.789 --> 00:37:13.869
How should you learn from the successes and errors of others?
00:37:13.949 --> 00:37:15.710
Uh, this has given you some food for thought.
00:37:15.869 --> 00:37:24.829
If you're getting asked for PCFs, it maybe gives you a frame of reference for how to think about this and how to also like pitch this upwards in the organization.
00:37:25.069 --> 00:37:29.710
If you have any questions on PCFs, you know, drop me an email, seth at ultruistic.com.
00:37:29.789 --> 00:37:31.069
It'll be in the show notes.
00:37:31.150 --> 00:37:39.549
Uh, very happy to either uh get on a call and talk PCFs and you know help talk through some of the details of what we've covered here.
00:37:39.710 --> 00:37:46.509
Uh if you have thoughts on what would be interesting to talk about on a next episode or follow-up, please, you know, again, drop drop me a note.
00:37:46.750 --> 00:37:50.670
Very happy to hear about your learnings and experiences with PCFs as well.
00:37:50.829 --> 00:37:55.389
And if you want to meet me uh in person, then please join us at the State of Sustainability Summit.
00:37:55.469 --> 00:37:58.509
We're hosting the next one on 14th October in London.
00:37:58.589 --> 00:38:02.349
We do these three times a year now: London, Chicago, and Amsterdam.
00:38:02.429 --> 00:38:16.909
Uh, it is the best place for you to meet your peers uh in the FMCG, CPG, food and beverage space who are focused on similar problems, including PCFs, and we have a fun panel discussion on the future of the PCF as well, which you might enjoy.
00:38:17.150 --> 00:38:19.230
Drop me a note or just register on the website.
00:38:19.309 --> 00:38:22.190
We'll put that in the show notes as well, whatever is easier.
00:38:22.989 --> 00:38:27.069
Thanks very much for listening to this edition of the State of Sustainability Podcast.
00:38:27.230 --> 00:38:31.549
Please hit follow or subscribe so you get notified as soon as our next episode drops.