TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.330 --> 00:00:03.189
I've not been the same since we had lunch. You
2
00:00:03.229 --> 00:00:06.650
explained to me, and I've said it here, the fabric
3
00:00:07.169 --> 00:00:13.279
of space-time might be woven by wormholes that connect the
4
00:00:13.380 --> 00:00:16.800
virtual particle pairs that come in and out of existence.
5
00:00:17.230 --> 00:00:20.510
So it's like a little quantum net holding the whole
6
00:00:20.530 --> 00:00:21.170
universe together.
7
00:00:21.190 --> 00:00:24.980
Yes, exactly right. We find mathematically if we cut the
8
00:00:25.079 --> 00:00:30.140
threads of quantum entanglement, space falls apart. It discretizes into
9
00:00:30.179 --> 00:00:32.439
little tiny pieces and then just disappears.
10
00:00:33.600 --> 00:00:41.759
I gotta go. I gotta go. This is StarTalk. Neil
11
00:00:41.780 --> 00:00:45.149
deGrasse Tyson, you're a personal astrophysicist. I got Chuck Nice
12
00:00:45.170 --> 00:00:48.590
with me. Chuck, baby. What's up, Neil? All right, all right.
13
00:00:48.609 --> 00:00:50.030
You know what you're going to talk about today? I
14
00:00:50.070 --> 00:00:53.429
do not. The only way to talk about physics is
15
00:00:53.450 --> 00:00:56.000
to talk about physics with Brian Greene in the house.
16
00:00:56.060 --> 00:00:57.960
That is true, that is true. Thank you. You gotta,
17
00:00:58.039 --> 00:01:01.000
you know, you can't, it's empty unless you have Brian
18
00:01:01.020 --> 00:01:04.219
Greene in the conversation. Absolutely. And he's just up the street,
19
00:01:04.599 --> 00:01:08.079
up at Columbia. You're a dual professor, professor of physics
20
00:01:08.260 --> 00:01:11.340
and professor of mathematics. That's right. Wow. You get paid
21
00:01:11.379 --> 00:01:12.140
twice for that.
22
00:01:12.879 --> 00:01:15.239
But I go to no faculty meeting. I'm always saying
23
00:01:15.299 --> 00:01:16.480
I'm in the other department.
24
00:01:17.879 --> 00:01:21.859
That's pretty cool. I'm sorry. I can't. I'm math today.
25
00:01:21.879 --> 00:01:26.689
So you're... author of several books, Until the End of Time.
26
00:01:26.870 --> 00:01:27.739
Was that your more recent one?
27
00:01:27.750 --> 00:01:28.439
That's my most recent, yes.
28
00:01:28.450 --> 00:01:29.469
And that came out how long ago?
29
00:01:29.469 --> 00:01:32.349
2020, right at the pandemic. What a moment to have
30
00:01:32.370 --> 00:01:34.750
a book called Until the End of Time, right?
31
00:01:35.250 --> 00:01:37.269
And the one I think most people know, if they
32
00:01:37.310 --> 00:01:40.000
know you at all, The Elegant Universe. There's another one,
33
00:01:40.019 --> 00:01:41.299
The Fabric of the Cosmos?
34
00:01:41.540 --> 00:01:41.640
Yeah.
35
00:01:42.200 --> 00:01:42.549
Absolutely.
36
00:01:42.560 --> 00:01:43.430
That was an excellent one.
37
00:01:43.469 --> 00:01:44.250
Hidden reality.
38
00:01:44.349 --> 00:01:46.010
Yeah, that was about multiple universes.
39
00:01:46.090 --> 00:01:46.269
Right.
40
00:01:46.370 --> 00:01:48.489
Man, so he's all up in it. I believe the
41
00:01:48.530 --> 00:01:53.069
fabric of the universe is a tweed. A tweed. A
42
00:01:53.109 --> 00:01:57.629
satin weave. A satin weave. So welcome back to the show.
43
00:01:57.689 --> 00:02:00.370
Thank you. You're more than a three-peat, I think, at
44
00:02:00.390 --> 00:02:03.329
this point. Yeah. Oh, God. And you're involved in a
45
00:02:03.349 --> 00:02:05.049
lot of things. You're writing the book. Other than being
46
00:02:05.069 --> 00:02:08.250
a professor, you're writing the books. And are we in
47
00:02:08.289 --> 00:02:11.849
the 15th year of your... You're a World Science Festival?
48
00:02:11.889 --> 00:02:13.210
How many years have you been doing this?
49
00:02:13.229 --> 00:02:16.069
That's right, we started 2008. So if you just subtract,
50
00:02:16.129 --> 00:02:18.169
it's even a little bit more, but the pandemic changed
51
00:02:18.189 --> 00:02:18.770
things a little bit.
52
00:02:18.810 --> 00:02:19.530
Pandemic, yeah, okay.
53
00:02:19.770 --> 00:02:22.509
Yeah, but yeah, we're coming up to probably the 15th
54
00:02:22.569 --> 00:02:22.990
live event.
55
00:02:23.110 --> 00:02:24.009
Congratulations on that.
56
00:02:24.030 --> 00:02:24.240
Thank you.
57
00:02:24.330 --> 00:02:26.409
Although it's a little audacious to hold it in New
58
00:02:26.449 --> 00:02:28.689
York and call it the World Science Festival.
59
00:02:28.710 --> 00:02:30.550
But we don't only have it in New York. We
60
00:02:30.590 --> 00:02:34.590
also have it in Australia, and we've had events in Amsterdam.
61
00:02:35.159 --> 00:02:39.189
in Moscow, in Italy, in Spain.
62
00:02:39.229 --> 00:02:39.710
I know.
63
00:02:39.889 --> 00:02:42.370
I try to. And by the way, New York is
64
00:02:42.430 --> 00:02:45.449
the world. Let's be honest. I mean, for anybody out
65
00:02:45.469 --> 00:02:48.439
there listening, I'm sorry. You go to Paris, you find Parisians.
66
00:02:48.479 --> 00:02:52.680
You go to England, you find the Brits. But you
67
00:02:52.740 --> 00:02:54.199
come to New York, you find everybody.
68
00:02:54.520 --> 00:02:59.189
Audacious would have been like the... Cosmic science festival. Yeah,
69
00:02:59.210 --> 00:03:02.849
you know, then you would have had a point. Well,
70
00:03:02.870 --> 00:03:05.250
congratulations on bringing it to the world. Thank you.
71
00:03:06.090 --> 00:03:09.490
Or taking it to the world. And what I enjoyed
72
00:03:09.550 --> 00:03:13.689
most about the several that I've attended is the effort
73
00:03:14.629 --> 00:03:19.810
to bring the arts into it in a meaningful way. There's,
74
00:03:20.120 --> 00:03:22.439
you know, there are many artists who I would later
75
00:03:22.520 --> 00:03:27.219
learn are not rare, who are inspired by science and
76
00:03:27.240 --> 00:03:31.360
the universe and discoveries and they will compose dance and
77
00:03:31.439 --> 00:03:35.560
music and you have, a mixture of these sessions.
78
Load full transcript
00:03:35.620 --> 00:03:37.699
We do, we do. I mean, the goal is to
79
00:03:37.860 --> 00:03:42.379
have science feel connected to everything that matters to us.
80
00:03:42.439 --> 00:03:44.060
And of course, culture is a big part of it.
81
00:03:44.060 --> 00:03:45.159
Culture and arts matter to everybody.
82
00:03:45.180 --> 00:03:47.680
In fact, now with AI, we're doing a program on
83
00:03:47.719 --> 00:03:50.620
the arts in the age of artificial intelligence. So how
84
00:03:50.639 --> 00:03:53.819
is AI changing how artists approach their work and how
85
00:03:53.919 --> 00:03:54.909
scientists think about art?
86
00:03:54.930 --> 00:03:57.009
There'll be more unemployed artists. Yeah, well.
87
00:03:57.629 --> 00:03:58.370
But it's a funny thing.
88
00:03:58.389 --> 00:04:01.030
People say that. Just not paid. They won't be unemployed.
89
00:04:01.069 --> 00:04:01.770
They just won't be paid.
90
00:04:01.789 --> 00:04:04.550
Yeah, but whenever new technology comes along, like the camera,
91
00:04:04.689 --> 00:04:06.879
people are like, okay, now you don't need artists anymore
92
00:04:06.900 --> 00:04:09.479
because anyone can just click. But there are artists who
93
00:04:09.580 --> 00:04:12.280
use the camera to create things that mere mortals can't.
94
00:04:12.319 --> 00:04:14.879
And there are painters who actually take a picture.
95
00:04:14.659 --> 00:04:17.079
And then they actually paint the picture as opposed to
96
00:04:17.490 --> 00:04:19.209
having someone sit for a portrait.
97
00:04:19.250 --> 00:04:22.639
But that wasn't the biggest issue, the biggest thing. the
98
00:04:22.660 --> 00:04:25.459
biggest force operating was you no longer needed the artist
99
00:04:25.860 --> 00:04:28.500
to portray reality, because of course the camera captured that.
100
00:04:28.860 --> 00:04:35.019
So that freed the artist to portray impressionistic reality.
101
00:04:35.560 --> 00:04:37.970
It's not what the scene looks like, it's what the
102
00:04:37.990 --> 00:04:41.089
scene feels like. That matters.
103
00:04:41.329 --> 00:04:43.769
It's huge. I mean, that's what is the magic in
104
00:04:43.829 --> 00:04:47.129
so much expression. It's what we do with it as
105
00:04:47.209 --> 00:04:50.699
opposed to just literally depicting what's out there. So There
106
00:04:50.730 --> 00:04:53.350
are many people who project that AI is going to
107
00:04:53.389 --> 00:04:57.189
create a new kind of art just the way the
108
00:04:57.209 --> 00:04:57.569
camera does.
109
00:04:57.589 --> 00:05:00.250
Just the way the camera does. It has to shake out.
110
00:05:00.509 --> 00:05:05.149
I think AI just accelerates creativity. It doesn't replace it
111
00:05:05.230 --> 00:05:09.509
because what happens is you have associations that are being
112
00:05:09.569 --> 00:05:11.579
made at a level that you as a human being
113
00:05:12.160 --> 00:05:15.120
would maybe eventually, over a course of years, you might
114
00:05:15.180 --> 00:05:19.860
make those associations, but the computer can do it almost instantaneously.
115
00:05:20.139 --> 00:05:22.639
And then you take that and you say, hmm, what
116
00:05:22.670 --> 00:05:25.129
does that mean to me? Okay, so it pushes you along.
117
00:05:25.290 --> 00:05:25.730
Pushes you along.
118
00:05:25.750 --> 00:05:27.050
Yeah, but the flip side of that is if you
119
00:05:27.069 --> 00:05:29.230
have a computer creating so much, there's a lot of
120
00:05:29.790 --> 00:05:33.600
chaff that you have to separate out. That's so true.
121
00:05:33.649 --> 00:05:38.019
There's chaff even when people do it. You were born
122
00:05:38.040 --> 00:05:39.079
and raised in New York City.
123
00:05:39.160 --> 00:05:41.019
Yeah, right across the street from where we are sitting
124
00:05:41.060 --> 00:05:41.399
right now.
125
00:05:41.420 --> 00:05:44.420
You went to Stuyvesant High School, which is a selective
126
00:05:44.519 --> 00:05:47.660
high school that specialized in science in the way the
127
00:05:47.680 --> 00:05:50.220
Bronx High School of Science, especially, in fact, they're rivals.
128
00:05:50.379 --> 00:05:51.899
They're like intellectual rivals.
129
00:05:51.920 --> 00:05:54.100
Why do you think that we've wrestled each other now
130
00:05:54.500 --> 00:05:55.759
and then? I always lose, though.
131
00:05:56.120 --> 00:05:58.540
You would not like a book if it didn't have
132
00:05:58.560 --> 00:06:00.800
equations in it. It's true, it's true. This is weird.
133
00:06:00.860 --> 00:06:03.959
Yeah, that has changed, I should say. So you've read
134
00:06:03.980 --> 00:06:04.379
a novel.
135
00:06:04.420 --> 00:06:07.480
That's right, now and then. That meant you thought more
136
00:06:07.579 --> 00:06:09.459
deeply about math than you thought about words.
137
00:06:09.500 --> 00:06:12.680
Yeah, but the one change I would make to that
138
00:06:12.720 --> 00:06:15.529
statement was, It was when it came to books for
139
00:06:15.589 --> 00:06:19.629
a science class. If the book was chock full of words,
140
00:06:20.029 --> 00:06:22.329
I'd feel like, oh no, there's a lot of interpretation
141
00:06:22.370 --> 00:06:24.819
that's going to go into this particular science class. But
142
00:06:24.839 --> 00:06:27.060
if it was chock full of equations, I was like, nah,
143
00:06:27.279 --> 00:06:30.220
this is rigorous. This is going to be specific. And
144
00:06:30.279 --> 00:06:32.180
it's going to be something that I can nail because
145
00:06:32.540 --> 00:06:36.139
I don't have to interpret. I can just really engage
146
00:06:36.160 --> 00:06:36.939
with the equation.
147
00:06:37.000 --> 00:06:37.259
Wow.
148
00:06:37.430 --> 00:06:41.269
So in a history class or a literature class, you
149
00:06:41.829 --> 00:06:44.959
were- you would have been in tears for.
150
00:06:44.920 --> 00:06:48.240
The task required of you. It was mostly just for science.
151
00:06:48.300 --> 00:06:51.040
But you're absolutely right. There is a different mindset
that
152
00:06:51.060 --> 00:06:53.000
you bring to a history class or an English class,
153
00:06:53.040 --> 00:06:55.920
which I did not have a full appreciation for when
154
00:06:55.939 --> 00:06:58.180
I was younger. That's absolutely true. And as I got older,
155
00:06:58.220 --> 00:07:01.500
and especially there's a moment when I graduated college and
156
00:07:01.519 --> 00:07:04.519
I said to myself, I think I just got a
157
00:07:04.600 --> 00:07:08.319
technical education as opposed to learning about the world and
158
00:07:08.420 --> 00:07:11.180
life and humanity. And I went into kind of a
159
00:07:11.300 --> 00:07:13.279
tailspin for a little while because I was like, what
160
00:07:13.300 --> 00:07:16.129
did I do? And that really then changed it all
161
00:07:16.170 --> 00:07:19.360
for me and words changed. have become vital to the
162
00:07:19.399 --> 00:07:20.519
way I engage with the world.
163
00:07:20.620 --> 00:07:24.160
You think? I mean, given his four bestselling books, words matter.
164
00:07:24.180 --> 00:07:25.699
That'll do it. If you want to talk to other
165
00:07:25.740 --> 00:07:26.920
people who are not physicists.
166
00:07:27.199 --> 00:07:29.480
And if you want to really get the essence of
167
00:07:29.519 --> 00:07:32.800
what someone's about as opposed to quantifying some quality of
168
00:07:33.180 --> 00:07:35.019
abstract or objective reality.
169
00:07:35.220 --> 00:07:35.300
Okay.
170
00:07:35.339 --> 00:07:40.120
Yeah. All right. I think that's an enlightened posture. Yeah.
171
00:07:40.360 --> 00:07:43.279
I've gotten there. It took me a while.
172
00:07:44.779 --> 00:07:46.699
So what I want to do is follow up. There
173
00:07:46.730 --> 00:07:51.870
was a question to our our cosmic queries, that I
174
00:07:51.910 --> 00:07:52.689
didn't have an answer to.
175
00:07:52.769 --> 00:07:53.709
Oh no, here we go.
176
00:07:53.870 --> 00:07:56.529
Okay. And I said, you know, I don't know, I gotta...
177
00:07:56.589 --> 00:07:57.769
We're gonna have to get Brian Greene in here. We
178
00:07:57.790 --> 00:07:59.850
gotta get the big guns in here, all right? If
179
00:07:59.889 --> 00:08:04.410
I remember the question, it was, what happens if a
180
00:08:04.610 --> 00:08:09.029
quark falls into a black hole? You have a quark pair. Yes.
181
00:08:09.089 --> 00:08:11.329
And we've only ever found them in quark pairs. Okay.
182
00:08:11.910 --> 00:08:14.509
And in a normal lab, if you take them and
183
00:08:14.610 --> 00:08:16.990
pull them apart, the force that wants to bring them
184
00:08:17.110 --> 00:08:21.000
together grows. which sounds weird when you're used to gravity
185
00:08:21.019 --> 00:08:23.199
and other things where distance makes something weaker.
186
00:08:23.339 --> 00:08:27.939
But they're like really creepy identical twins. Like you ever
187
00:08:27.980 --> 00:08:30.399
meet identical twins that are like super creepy.
188
00:08:30.540 --> 00:08:31.879
Where they sort of talk together.
Where they kind of
189
00:08:31.899 --> 00:08:36.419
talk together. They walk together. They got their own language. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Okay. Right. So,
190
00:08:36.899 --> 00:08:39.039
but it's kind of like a rubber band. Because you've
191
00:08:39.070 --> 00:08:40.629
stretched the rhombus band, the force is greater.
192
00:08:40.769 --> 00:08:42.429
Yeah, the gluonic force between them.
193
00:08:42.450 --> 00:08:45.230
The gluonic force, because it's held together by gluons. Okay,
194
00:08:45.250 --> 00:08:47.450
so now, as I pull it apart, there will be
195
00:08:47.509 --> 00:08:52.610
a point where it snaps. As I understand my nuclear physics,
196
00:08:52.769 --> 00:08:56.539
it snaps with the exact amount of energy you put in,
197
00:08:57.200 --> 00:08:59.820
so that out of that energy creates two other quarks.
198
00:09:00.179 --> 00:09:01.080
So now I have four quarks.
199
00:09:01.100 --> 00:09:02.419
Quark-antic quark pairs.
200
00:09:02.519 --> 00:09:05.559
Pairs, thank you. Okay, pairs. Okay, so now.
201
00:09:06.049 --> 00:09:07.470
So you want to see what happens.
202
00:09:07.629 --> 00:09:09.730
Now you send a pair of quarks down the black hole.
203
00:09:10.669 --> 00:09:15.029
It gets split. We make two other quarks. Yeah. Thank you.
204
00:09:15.409 --> 00:09:19.639
That was very good. And you keep doing this and they,
205
00:09:19.820 --> 00:09:25.419
so wouldn't the quarks eat the entire gravitational field of
206
00:09:25.440 --> 00:09:27.419
the black hole. And that you wouldn't have a black
207
00:09:27.440 --> 00:09:29.159
hole left, you just have a ball of quarks.
208
00:09:29.350 --> 00:09:31.730
You have to realize, number one, that we still don't
209
00:09:31.750 --> 00:09:34.629
know the under, the physics of the singularity of black
210
00:09:34.669 --> 00:09:35.570
hole well enough.
211
00:09:35.590 --> 00:09:37.610
Why else did I invite you into this office now?
212
00:09:37.629 --> 00:09:40.750
So, well, I wish, one day, one day I pray
213
00:09:40.769 --> 00:09:42.929
that I'll sit here and tell you what happens at
214
00:09:42.950 --> 00:09:43.950
the singularity of a black hole.
215
00:09:43.970 --> 00:09:45.230
Bring the person who knows next time.
216
00:09:45.289 --> 00:09:47.470
But here's the thing, there is nobody on planet Earth
217
00:09:47.509 --> 00:09:50.370
who knows the answer, unfortunately, yet. Okay. When we follow
218
00:09:50.389 --> 00:09:53.090
the mathematics to the actual singularity of a black.
219
00:09:52.850 --> 00:09:55.120
Hole, using Einstein general relativity.
220
00:09:55.210 --> 00:09:58.870
Using Einstein general relativity and even some of the modifications
221
00:09:58.909 --> 00:10:01.649
that have come from more recent thinking, we're still not
222
00:10:01.860 --> 00:10:04.559
there yet to truly understand what happens. But I should
223
00:10:04.600 --> 00:10:07.120
say there are ideas. There are ideas of things, I
224
00:10:07.120 --> 00:10:09.409
don't know
if you've heard of them, called fuzzballs. where
225
00:10:09.429 --> 00:10:11.769
there isn't actually a singularity and the black hole is
226
00:10:11.870 --> 00:10:15.970
actually a more fuzzy collection of matter. So there are
227
00:10:16.049 --> 00:10:16.950
ideas that people put forward.
228
00:10:16.970 --> 00:10:18.289
That makes your math come out okay.
229
00:10:18.309 --> 00:10:19.950
Makes the math come out okay, but we're not sure
230
00:10:19.970 --> 00:10:20.370
if it's right.
231
00:10:20.490 --> 00:10:23.429
When they say the singularity at the center of a
232
00:10:23.429 --> 00:10:25.120
black hole is where God is dividing by zero.
233
00:10:25.129 --> 00:10:27.279
Yeah, that's a Stephen Hawking quip or something.
234
00:10:27.299 --> 00:10:27.679
Did he say that?
235
00:10:27.700 --> 00:10:28.220
I think it is.
236
00:10:28.259 --> 00:10:30.559
So you remember why if you divide by zero, it
237
00:10:30.580 --> 00:10:32.299
blows up. Well, it's not going to work out. Right.
238
00:10:33.220 --> 00:10:35.700
And it's actually, in a sense, it's literal because if
239
00:10:35.720 --> 00:10:38.519
you calculate what's known as a scalar curvature, which is
240
00:10:38.539 --> 00:10:43.539
a number that characterizes how warped a region of space is,
241
00:10:44.179 --> 00:10:47.519
it does go to infinity as you go to the
242
00:10:47.620 --> 00:10:49.360
center of a black hole, just like when you divide
243
00:10:49.399 --> 00:10:51.240
by zero, it goes to infinity. In fact, it goes
244
00:10:51.279 --> 00:10:54.100
to infinity as the sixth power of your distance. So
245
00:10:54.139 --> 00:10:57.860
we know very well how badly behaved the center of
246
00:10:57.899 --> 00:10:58.840
a black hole is.
247
00:10:58.919 --> 00:11:00.360
So it goes to infinity fast.
248
00:11:00.379 --> 00:11:01.500
It goes to infinity fast.
249
00:11:01.519 --> 00:11:02.519
That's crazy. Yeah.
250
00:11:02.919 --> 00:11:06.080
And so if you ask what really happens if something
251
00:11:06.159 --> 00:11:09.440
is just being crushed at the center, We can't really
252
00:11:09.559 --> 00:11:12.440
answer yet. So is it possible that as a quark-antiquark
253
00:11:12.480 --> 00:11:17.350
pair goes, that the tidal forces will create additional quark-antiquark pairs?
254
00:11:17.490 --> 00:11:19.690
Sure. And then you'd have the proliferation of quarks. Making
255
00:11:19.710 --> 00:11:21.669
me some sounds.
256
00:11:22.590 --> 00:11:24.389
So there may be a cloud, and there may be
257
00:11:24.429 --> 00:11:27.710
some sort of cloud that forms just before it hits. Ultimately,
258
00:11:27.769 --> 00:11:31.570
we believe it hits the singularity, whatever that means, because
259
00:11:31.629 --> 00:11:33.789
we don't really know what the singularity is yet.
260
00:11:33.820 --> 00:11:36.789
If it's a fuzzball, you can have a fuzzball or quarks. Possibly.
261
00:11:37.000 --> 00:11:39.639
Or the fuzzball may have a slightly different impact on
262
00:11:39.659 --> 00:11:43.759
the quark-anti-quark pair. Maybe before... Influence. Influence on it.
263
00:11:43.779 --> 00:11:44.720
Yeah, yeah. Impact.
264
00:11:45.019 --> 00:11:45.539
Yeah, that's right.
265
00:11:45.600 --> 00:11:45.980
Exactly.
266
00:11:46.399 --> 00:11:48.580
So it's a really good question, but it will have
267
00:11:48.620 --> 00:11:52.039
to fully await a full understanding of what truly.
268
00:11:51.779 --> 00:11:52.820
Happened at the center. Okay, so me not being able
269
00:11:52.840 --> 00:11:56.059
to answer it wasn't just my personal ignorance. It's a
270
00:11:56.080 --> 00:11:57.730
total ignorance of all humans on Earth.
271
00:11:57.779 --> 00:11:58.259
Yeah, and there are.
272
00:11:58.259 --> 00:11:58.889
So I don't feel so bad.
273
00:11:58.909 --> 00:12:01.870
And I should say there are many, many questions like
274
00:12:01.909 --> 00:12:04.990
that that we're still struggling with. Like, We believe that
275
00:12:05.049 --> 00:12:08.370
when any information falls into a black hole, we believe
276
00:12:08.409 --> 00:12:11.889
that information does not get destroyed. But for a while,
277
00:12:11.929 --> 00:12:16.460
Stephen Hawking thought, no, any information ultimately hits the singularity
278
00:12:16.629 --> 00:12:20.639
and leaves our universe. He changed his mind later in life,
279
00:12:20.940 --> 00:12:21.440
which just.
280
00:12:21.299 --> 00:12:23.779
Goes to show- Was that his famous bet with Kip Thorne?
281
00:12:23.799 --> 00:12:26.799
Yes, that's right. So they bet, I think, an encyclopedia,
282
00:12:26.840 --> 00:12:30.860
the source of information that we humans have created. So
283
00:12:30.879 --> 00:12:31.539
there- Kip.
284
00:12:31.419 --> 00:12:35.450
Thorne was a- one of the executive producers on Interstellar.
285
00:12:35.909 --> 00:12:39.009
And he sort of spearheaded the effort among others, but
286
00:12:39.090 --> 00:12:45.580
he was the exponent. to build the laser interferometry gravitational
287
00:12:45.620 --> 00:12:48.820
wave observatory, LIGO, that detected colliding black holes, and he
288
00:12:48.840 --> 00:12:51.879
won the Nobel Prize for that. So he's significant in
289
00:12:51.940 --> 00:12:53.899
our field, and I have at least a few books
290
00:12:53.940 --> 00:12:56.659
by him on my shelves. Yeah. And he was clearly
291
00:12:56.860 --> 00:13:00.980
on a level of geekdom where he bets encyclopedias. Yeah.
292
00:13:01.259 --> 00:13:05.299
But in terms of his book, he wrote an encyclopedic
293
00:13:05.370 --> 00:13:10.029
book on gravity and black holes, which is, About, you know, 1,200
294
00:13:10.029 --> 00:13:13.309
pages just filled with equations. Therefore, I loved it when
295
00:13:13.350 --> 00:13:13.830
I was a kid.
296
00:13:13.970 --> 00:13:17.309
The Misner-Thorne-Wheeler. Yes. I have two copies of that in
297
00:13:17.330 --> 00:13:17.750
my office.
298
00:13:18.230 --> 00:13:18.850
Two copies?
299
00:13:18.870 --> 00:13:19.009
Yes.
300
00:13:19.029 --> 00:13:21.809
Do you want to cross-reference or something?
301
00:13:21.870 --> 00:13:23.470
One of those is mine, and the other one belonged
302
00:13:23.490 --> 00:13:26.740
to my wife, who has a PhD in mathematical physics.
303
00:13:26.750 --> 00:13:27.379
Wow, that's so cool.
304
00:13:27.789 --> 00:13:30.860
We met in relativity class. Really? Taught by John Wheeler.
305
00:13:31.519 --> 00:13:31.860
Really?
306
00:13:31.899 --> 00:13:32.299
Yes!
307
00:13:32.559 --> 00:13:34.460
You took it? Relativity from Wheeler?
308
00:13:34.480 --> 00:13:35.179
Yes, I did.
309
00:13:35.399 --> 00:13:36.980
That is amazing. Wow.
310
00:13:37.000 --> 00:13:37.120
Yeah.
311
00:13:37.460 --> 00:13:39.379
Nice. Yeah. So John Wheeler is one of the authors
312
00:13:39.440 --> 00:13:43.049
of this Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler. Yeah. And Misner taught
313
00:13:43.110 --> 00:13:45.730
physics at University of Maryland.
314
00:13:46.009 --> 00:13:46.610
Charles Misner.
315
00:13:46.649 --> 00:13:50.769
Charles Misner. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So I want to think
316
00:13:50.789 --> 00:13:53.190
of it as a quark catastrophe that would happen in
317
00:13:53.210 --> 00:13:54.850
the center of the black hole. The trouble with quarks.
318
00:13:55.100 --> 00:13:57.899
They're like triples. By the way, there's a previous, if
319
00:13:58.700 --> 00:14:01.320
we're physics geeking out here. Right. There's a previous time,
320
00:14:01.340 --> 00:14:04.490
was it 100 years, 110? 10 years ago, with something
321
00:14:04.500 --> 00:14:07.090
called the ultraviolet catastrophe. Do you remember that?
322
00:14:07.269 --> 00:14:10.610
I remember it. Well, I wasn't there, but I've learned
323
00:14:10.629 --> 00:14:13.070
about it. Yeah, this is the start of quantum physics.
324
00:14:13.090 --> 00:14:18.990
Yeah, it had to predate 1900. It predated Planck, Max Planck. Oh, okay.
325
00:14:19.049 --> 00:14:21.830
Because there was an equation that would show how much
326
00:14:22.009 --> 00:14:23.889
energy would come from glowing objects.
327
00:14:24.149 --> 00:14:24.450
Okay.
328
00:14:24.690 --> 00:14:28.169
And how much energy of a certain wavelength of light
329
00:14:28.409 --> 00:14:31.549
and then another wavelength. And so there'd be the spectrum
330
00:14:31.750 --> 00:14:34.070
of what it gives you. Okay. And if you follow
331
00:14:34.110 --> 00:14:39.320
that equation to higher and higher energies, it blows up.
332
00:14:40.659 --> 00:14:43.639
And it's called the ultraviolet catastrophe. Nice. Now, we knew
333
00:14:43.700 --> 00:14:46.159
that's not happening in the actual universe. Right. But we
334
00:14:46.200 --> 00:14:50.519
had no theoretical understanding of why the actual universe was
335
00:14:50.580 --> 00:14:53.659
not doing what our equation said. So we knew something
336
00:14:53.700 --> 00:14:57.740
was missing. Okay. And Max Planck comes along, finished the story.
337
00:14:57.759 --> 00:15:00.769
Yes, and Max Planck comes along and he... suggests an
338
00:15:00.870 --> 00:15:03.870
idea that he never fully believed. This is interesting. He
339
00:15:03.929 --> 00:15:07.990
suggests that maybe the energy only comes in packets of
340
00:15:08.110 --> 00:15:13.269
certain quantized sizes, and therefore your calculation of the amount
341
00:15:13.309 --> 00:15:16.470
of energy was biased by assuming that energy could come
342
00:15:16.509 --> 00:15:20.370
in arbitrarily large or small amounts. If you assume it
343
00:15:20.409 --> 00:15:23.450
only comes in packets of a minimum size, then the
344
00:15:23.509 --> 00:15:25.509
total energy inside that cavity is finite.
345
00:15:25.529 --> 00:15:27.389
It actually converges and drops off.
346
00:15:27.529 --> 00:15:28.820
And it agrees with experiments.
347
00:15:29.139 --> 00:15:29.279
Right.
348
00:15:29.299 --> 00:15:30.259
But the weird thing is.
349
00:15:30.519 --> 00:15:33.740
And he got an equation. The equation is like, holy shit,
350
00:15:34.419 --> 00:15:37.049
this would come out of someone's head to make this happen.
351
00:15:37.389 --> 00:15:40.580
It's got an exponential. And an exponential has interesting properties
352
00:15:40.940 --> 00:15:42.500
where it goes up and then it comes down again
353
00:15:42.659 --> 00:15:45.139
if it's a negative exponent. I mean, there's a fun
354
00:15:45.500 --> 00:15:48.620
math in there. And was it just a fitting function
355
00:15:48.980 --> 00:15:51.299
or did he actually have deep physics insight?
356
00:15:51.360 --> 00:15:55.159
He had a model in mind. He really quantized the energy.
357
00:15:55.179 --> 00:15:58.750
He broke it up into little bits and redid the calculation.
358
00:15:58.789 --> 00:16:01.690
And that's what came out. But then later on, he
359
00:16:01.750 --> 00:16:05.529
never fully believed that energy in light, in photons, as
360
00:16:05.590 --> 00:16:10.179
we now call it, did come in little packets. He said, sure,
361
00:16:10.240 --> 00:16:13.980
the math seems to describe it, but I'm not willing
362
00:16:14.019 --> 00:16:17.139
to go to that next step of ascribing a full
363
00:16:17.179 --> 00:16:19.899
reality to it. And so it's really Einstein who came
364
00:16:19.980 --> 00:16:23.070
along and came up with the idea of photons more
365
00:16:23.250 --> 00:16:26.929
particularly with the photoelectric effect. And that's how he wins
366
00:16:26.950 --> 00:16:29.269
the Nobel Prize. Many people think he won the prize
367
00:16:29.309 --> 00:16:31.490
for special relativity or general relativity.
368
00:16:31.529 --> 00:16:33.789
No. My boy could have had eight Nobel Prizes. His
369
00:16:33.830 --> 00:16:38.409
Nobel Prizes are for what he's least famous for. Right. Yeah.
370
00:16:38.429 --> 00:16:42.029
That just means you're gangster. That's straight up. But in
371
00:16:42.049 --> 00:16:45.049
terms of impact. Right, exactly. There are people winning Nobel
372
00:16:45.090 --> 00:16:49.169
Prizes for discovering things that he
predicted. Right. So if
373
00:16:49.210 --> 00:16:52.009
you add everything he predicted to the Nobel Prize count,
374
00:16:52.090 --> 00:16:54.379
plus what everything, if they gave out Nobel Prizes for
375
00:16:54.429 --> 00:16:57.049
everything you did, I give him eight Nobel Prizes, what
376
00:16:57.080 --> 00:16:57.490
would you give him?
377
00:16:58.019 --> 00:17:02.389
Well, certainly gravitational waves, although again, he didn't fully believe it,
378
00:17:02.419 --> 00:17:04.559
but it comes right out of his 1916 and 1918 paper.
379
00:17:04.740 --> 00:17:06.839
I'm saying if you give him a Nobel Prize for
380
00:17:06.940 --> 00:17:09.650
everything people discovered based on his stuff.
381
00:17:09.730 --> 00:17:11.269
Well then, it's kind of everything.
382
00:17:11.309 --> 00:17:16.890
Your person's on the Nobel Prize receiving right, and nope,
383
00:17:16.910 --> 00:17:17.930
you're taken. Right.
384
00:17:18.539 --> 00:17:21.160
It's like that Bugs Bunny, first base, Bugs Bunny, second base,
385
00:17:21.180 --> 00:17:24.579
Bugs Bunny, third base, Bugs, yeah, every Nobel Prize is
386
00:17:24.680 --> 00:17:25.079
Albert Einstein.
387
00:17:25.099 --> 00:17:28.619
That's the answer right there. And so of course, since
388
00:17:28.960 --> 00:17:34.380
if energy is quantized, thus is born the branch of
389
00:17:34.440 --> 00:17:36.049
physics called Quantum mechanics.
390
00:17:36.069 --> 00:17:36.690
Quantum physics.
391
00:17:36.849 --> 00:17:37.549
Quantum mechanics.
392
00:17:37.650 --> 00:17:37.970
Wow.
393
00:17:38.390 --> 00:17:41.380
And that probably has had the greatest impact on life
394
00:17:41.430 --> 00:17:42.019
as we know it.
395
00:17:42.039 --> 00:17:43.420
And that was the year 1900. Yeah.
396
00:17:43.440 --> 00:17:47.680
Well, 1905 is when Einstein writes his paper on the
397
00:17:48.000 --> 00:17:50.599
idea of photons. But Max Planck, you're right, was 1900.
398
00:17:50.579 --> 00:17:53.319
Max Planck was clean 1900, starting a new century. Yeah.
399
00:17:53.779 --> 00:17:56.880
Before they even had calculators. Oh, was that?
400
00:17:57.160 --> 00:17:57.440
Really?
401
00:17:57.480 --> 00:17:59.819
Was it that far back?
402
00:18:00.279 --> 00:18:03.039
As you may know, we recently posted a video in
403
00:18:03.079 --> 00:18:06.690
response to Terence Howard's appearance on Joe Rogan's podcast where
404
00:18:06.730 --> 00:18:10.049
he discussed his interpretation of maths. And key points to
405
00:18:10.089 --> 00:18:13.650
take away from that are, one, we should critically analyse
406
00:18:14.049 --> 00:18:17.750
all the information we come across, and two, be open
407
00:18:17.829 --> 00:18:21.029
to our views being challenged. Like this new study on
408
00:18:21.069 --> 00:18:25.470
dark matter being debunked, for example. It suggests the universe's
409
00:18:25.569 --> 00:18:29.490
expansion is not driven by dark energy, but by weakening
410
00:18:29.549 --> 00:18:32.630
forces of nature.
Now, when it comes to new theories
411
00:18:32.650 --> 00:18:36.500
that challenge our accepted understanding of space, it's important to
412
00:18:36.539 --> 00:18:40.319
see how different scientific sources are interpreting these new findings
413
00:18:40.359 --> 00:18:44.740
to fully understand it. Luckily, ground news makes this much
414
00:18:44.980 --> 00:18:47.759
easier to do. With the Vantage Plan, you get access
415
00:18:47.799 --> 00:18:51.809
to original research, plus every article covering it and even
416
00:18:51.950 --> 00:18:56.490
insight on each news publication's political bias and credibility, context,
417
00:18:56.509 --> 00:19:00.369
and that could influence their reporting. Their founder and former
418
00:19:00.450 --> 00:19:04.319
NASA engineer also designed their Blind Spot feed, which uses
419
00:19:04.460 --> 00:19:07.680
patented technology to help us easily step out of our
420
00:19:07.759 --> 00:19:11.509
echo chambers and see important news stories we might have
421
00:19:11.549 --> 00:19:15.950
otherwise missed. Exposing yourself to diverse perspectives helps ensure that
422
00:19:15.970 --> 00:19:18.450
you don't just know enough about an issue to think
423
00:19:18.490 --> 00:19:22.190
you're right, but you actually know enough to recognize when
424
00:19:22.210 --> 00:19:26.470
you might be wrong. So avoid the Dunning-Kruger effect, get
425
00:19:26.549 --> 00:19:31.490
ground news and critically analyze the information you consume. All
426
00:19:31.549 --> 00:19:34.269
for $ 5 a month if you use our link or
427
00:19:34.390 --> 00:19:38.960
scan the QR code. You're saving 40% on the same
428
00:19:39.180 --> 00:19:41.000
unlimited access Vantage plan.
429
00:19:40.819 --> 00:19:41.519
You use regularly.
430
00:19:41.819 --> 00:19:45.700
With the discount. We really can't recommend Ground News and
431
00:19:45.740 --> 00:19:51.599
their commitment to rigorous analysis and combating misinformation enough. Having
432
00:19:51.660 --> 00:19:54.079
said all of that, let's get straight back to the show.
433
00:19:55.119 --> 00:19:58.339
We're old enough to remember when the United States lost
434
00:19:59.619 --> 00:20:04.799
the most powerful collider in the world, the superconducting supercollider.
435
00:20:05.440 --> 00:20:08.000
which they already, there was money allocated. They started digging
436
00:20:08.039 --> 00:20:11.579
a hole. It was a 200-mile circumference. There was some huge,
437
00:20:11.920 --> 00:20:15.900
and superconducting, it was going to use superconducting magnets, which
438
00:20:15.940 --> 00:20:20.220
had very powerful magnetic fields. And because that was coming
439
00:20:20.259 --> 00:20:22.240
of age at the time, it was going to push
440
00:20:22.279 --> 00:20:26.289
the frontier. My analysis, if you read the report, well,
441
00:20:26.309 --> 00:20:29.269
there were cost overruns, and we have too many other
442
00:20:29.289 --> 00:20:33.690
priorities here. So we're going to zero
the budget for
443
00:20:33.710 --> 00:20:36.640
this superconducting supercollider. And you read the report and say, well,
444
00:20:36.660 --> 00:20:38.359
we have other priorities. Plus, this was going to be
445
00:20:38.380 --> 00:20:40.720
built in Texas. And if we're going to build the
446
00:20:40.740 --> 00:20:44.109
space station, which is based in Houston, Texas was already
447
00:20:44.150 --> 00:20:46.329
getting a chunk of change. You know when all this happened?
448
00:20:46.390 --> 00:20:51.769
Like between 1989 and 1992, when the debates and then
449
00:20:51.789 --> 00:20:55.529
they zeroed the budget. What else was happening over those years?
450
00:20:55.789 --> 00:20:59.829
Let me think. Oh, my gosh. Peace broke out in Europe.
451
00:21:00.549 --> 00:21:03.930
No longer do we need the physicists to protect us
452
00:21:04.789 --> 00:21:09.950
from the evil, godless communists. That's what I think was
453
00:21:09.990 --> 00:21:15.029
the subtext of that story. Because no other particle accelerator
454
00:21:15.190 --> 00:21:18.619
was ever canceled for any reason that was designed, conceived,
455
00:21:18.650 --> 00:21:21.140
and built in the 20th century. So if you grant
456
00:21:21.160 --> 00:21:23.460
me one conspiracy theory, grant me that.
457
00:21:23.599 --> 00:21:26.559
But then you think they kept the space station because
458
00:21:26.779 --> 00:21:29.660
that was the place where the new battles might be waged?
459
00:21:29.799 --> 00:21:33.019
Possibly. So what we're looking at right now when you
460
00:21:33.059 --> 00:21:35.220
think about it? Yeah, with the Space Force and everything else.
461
00:21:35.240 --> 00:21:38.539
So that's where I am on that. But I say
462
00:21:38.579 --> 00:21:43.539
this only to note that once that got canceled, the
463
00:21:43.619 --> 00:21:47.319
center of mass of particle physics went across the pond
464
00:21:48.099 --> 00:21:53.650
to Europe. And then CERN The.
465
00:21:52.950 --> 00:21:58.009
European Center for Nuclear Research? Somewhere in there, yes.
466
00:21:59.589 --> 00:22:02.720
It's a French acronym when the words are in the
467
00:22:02.779 --> 00:22:06.539
French order or something. That's it. It goes there. And
468
00:22:06.559 --> 00:22:12.990
I think our lawmakers don't really understand that if we
469
00:22:13.009 --> 00:22:16.119
don't do the physics, someone else can and will. We
470
00:22:16.160 --> 00:22:19.559
don't own all access to future discoveries of science. And
471
00:22:19.579 --> 00:22:21.569
so now Europe does it. And so they went ahead,
472
00:22:22.069 --> 00:22:28.430
built a large hadron collider, and they successfully found the
473
00:22:28.509 --> 00:22:30.710
Higgs boson, the big holy grail.
474
00:22:30.950 --> 00:22:32.630
July 4th, 2012.
475
00:22:32.630 --> 00:22:34.509
Look at that. Was it July 4th? That's sticking it
476
00:22:34.549 --> 00:22:34.839
to us.
477
00:22:34.910 --> 00:22:35.150
Wow.
478
00:22:35.170 --> 00:22:36.230
That really was.
479
00:22:36.349 --> 00:22:38.289
And you know, they really found it on like June 28th.
480
00:22:38.329 --> 00:22:41.450
You know, they found it on June 28th and they
481
00:22:41.470 --> 00:22:44.109
were like, guys, we're going to sit on this for
482
00:22:44.150 --> 00:22:44.869
a few days.
483
00:22:45.529 --> 00:22:45.910
Yeah.
484
00:22:46.990 --> 00:22:49.849
But, but there are a lot of Americans involved in
485
00:22:49.869 --> 00:22:50.589
the large- Yes, of course.
486
00:22:50.609 --> 00:22:50.829
That's true.
487
00:22:50.849 --> 00:22:52.789
But just to say, but yes, exactly right.
488
00:22:52.930 --> 00:22:55.190
Yeah. Even Peter Higgs, is he American?
489
00:22:55.589 --> 00:22:58.880
Peter Higgs was Scottish, I would think you know i
490
00:22:58.880 --> 00:23:00.980
think it's from edinburgh although i think he was at
491
00:23:01.000 --> 00:23:02.559
edinburgh but i don't think he was guys maybe he
492
00:23:02.599 --> 00:23:05.839
was english you know i i don't know but uh
493
00:23:05.880 --> 00:23:10.119
but yeah you know he he uh predicted its existence
494
00:23:10.200 --> 00:23:13.700
and then it was discovered and at the announcement saw
495
00:23:13.819 --> 00:23:16.480
tears welling in this man's eyes who'd been waiting decades
496
00:23:16.519 --> 00:23:20.420
for this idea that at first nobody believed right ultimately
497
00:23:20.500 --> 00:23:23.980
was accepted theoretically but it was proven experimentally finally.
498
00:23:23.680 --> 00:23:26.740
And what is that what is the hicks boson Exactly.
499
00:23:27.140 --> 00:23:31.160
Of the particle categories, one of them is bosons. Right. Okay.
500
00:23:31.640 --> 00:23:38.420
And bosons are force mitigating particles. Okay. Okay. So, and
501
00:23:38.440 --> 00:23:41.039
when we think of a force action at a distance,
502
00:23:41.079 --> 00:23:43.299
there's a way to think about that in terms of
503
00:23:43.819 --> 00:23:46.460
the particle that in the category of particles is a boson.
504
00:23:46.940 --> 00:23:49.490
One of the bosons is this Higgs boson, which has
505
00:23:49.529 --> 00:23:50.109
what properties?
506
00:23:50.559 --> 00:23:53.200
Was I right? Yes, very good. Thank you.
507
00:23:53.220 --> 00:23:58.650
We said I was very good. Can I answer?
508
00:23:58.710 --> 00:24:00.730
Thank you, Brian.
509
00:24:00.789 --> 00:24:01.970
Thank you, Brian. Please.
510
00:24:02.130 --> 00:24:06.069
It's what endows other particles, even itself actually, with mass.
511
00:24:07.119 --> 00:24:07.880
Interesting.
512
00:24:07.920 --> 00:24:10.180
Now, where does that come from? Well, just to take
513
00:24:10.400 --> 00:24:12.450
Neil's idea, it starts with the idea of a field.
514
00:24:12.509 --> 00:24:14.289
That's how you get rid of this idea of action
515
00:24:14.349 --> 00:24:17.170
at a distance. You imagine that space is filled with stuff.
516
00:24:17.190 --> 00:24:17.970
You don't invent the fields?
517
00:24:19.549 -->
00:24:20.390
I really don't.
518
00:24:20.430 --> 00:24:20.990
Michael Faraday.
519
00:24:21.450 --> 00:24:21.890
Oh, really?
520
00:24:22.049 --> 00:24:25.630
Well, that makes sense. He was the first. And think
521
00:24:25.670 --> 00:24:27.150
what a leap that is. Yeah, that is.
522
00:24:27.170 --> 00:24:29.079
It's an insane leap.
523
00:24:29.119 --> 00:24:30.220
You take it for granted.
524
00:24:30.240 --> 00:24:33.299
There's nothing there. You're looking at nothing. You're And yet
525
00:24:33.319 --> 00:24:36.319
you're positing that there is something there. And that's an
526
00:24:36.359 --> 00:24:39.539
amazing thing. But he was talking electric and magnetic fields.
527
00:24:39.599 --> 00:24:42.119
What Higgs is talking about is a new field called
528
00:24:42.420 --> 00:24:45.670
the Higgs field, which he didn't call it that, but
529
00:24:45.710 --> 00:24:47.869
that's what we call it. So it's this field that
530
00:24:47.950 --> 00:24:51.589
fills space. And as particles that otherwise would be massless,
531
00:24:52.150 --> 00:24:53.809
as they try to go through space, they have to
532
00:24:53.950 --> 00:24:56.450
burrow through the Higgs field. And that creates a kind
533
00:24:56.490 --> 00:25:00.359
of drag force on them. which is what imparts the
534
00:25:00.420 --> 00:25:03.779
mass that they have. And that's the field. Now what's
535
00:25:03.819 --> 00:25:06.400
the particle? Well, if you have this field in principle,
536
00:25:06.799 --> 00:25:09.089
if you hit it hard enough, like hitting the surface
537
00:25:09.109 --> 00:25:12.309
of water, you can cause little particles of the field
538
00:25:12.349 --> 00:25:15.269
to spray out. And that's what the Large Hadron Collider did.
539
00:25:15.589 --> 00:25:19.470
It slammed proton against proton, and that way jostled the
540
00:25:19.509 --> 00:25:22.809
Higgs field and caused a little droplet of it to
541
00:25:22.890 --> 00:25:24.470
break free, and that's the Higgs particle.
542
00:25:24.490 --> 00:25:25.710
And then we got the, oh my God, so you're
543
00:25:25.730 --> 00:25:29.119
seeing an actual piece of the field. Yes. Oh my God. Wait,
544
00:25:29.140 --> 00:25:32.990
so the Higgs field- generated via E equals MC squared,
545
00:25:33.470 --> 00:25:36.990
its own particle of its own DNA.
546
00:25:37.230 --> 00:25:39.170
Or you can say it's a quanta, to go back
547
00:25:39.190 --> 00:25:41.329
to the other language, it's a quanta of the Higgs field,
548
00:25:41.630 --> 00:25:44.730
like the photon is the quanta of the electromagnetic field.
549
00:25:45.089 --> 00:25:49.980
All right, that's amazing. That's some stuff. Okay, now I
550
00:25:50.000 --> 00:25:51.480
get it. So it's not the particle.
551
00:25:51.839 --> 00:25:55.119
That you're actually seeing it's not the particle that is
552
00:25:55.200 --> 00:25:59.859
imbued with mass itself it is the thing on which
553
00:25:59.920 --> 00:26:04.359
the particle is traveling the field the medium itself boom
554
00:26:04.420 --> 00:26:07.000
it kind of splashes apart for a quick second and
555
00:26:07.039 --> 00:26:12.140
then that itself becomes a particle and has mass holy.
556
00:26:14.769 --> 00:26:20.390
That's amazing! That is amazing! Chuck just blew a gas can.
557
00:26:20.529 --> 00:26:22.480
Oh my God, that's crazy!
558
00:26:22.500 --> 00:26:25.740
Dude, that is insane! Call the doctors. This is the
559
00:26:25.799 --> 00:26:29.680
first time I've actually really understood. Call the doctors. Because,
560
00:26:30.299 --> 00:26:34.890
oh my God, that's so freaking crazy! Oh my God!
561
00:26:35.410 --> 00:26:39.650
A week later, he's there in bed still. Eyes this big.
562
00:26:39.950 --> 00:26:44.150
That is fantastic. So my favorite analog to this is
563
00:26:44.190 --> 00:26:46.490
when I explain the Higgs field to people, I say
564
00:26:47.130 --> 00:26:53.589
it's like a Hollywood party. So there are people in
565
00:26:53.630 --> 00:26:57.819
the party. And the bar is at the back of
566
00:26:57.859 --> 00:27:03.299
the wall. And If no one knows you and you
567
00:27:03.339 --> 00:27:06.339
walk into this party. Okay, that's my experience. You have
568
00:27:07.079 --> 00:27:13.279
near zero resistance to movement through that party. True. So
569
00:27:13.319 --> 00:27:18.299
you have a very low, if not zero, party mass. Exactly. Okay?
570
00:27:18.759 --> 00:27:21.500
Because you have no- You get into the bar right away.
571
00:27:21.880 --> 00:27:24.059
You get in the bar right away. Right. So your inertia,
572
00:27:25.380 --> 00:27:29.710
it knows no resistance there. Exactly. Whereas- Beyonce walks in,
573
00:27:30.609 --> 00:27:33.910
everybody will crowd around here. She can only make very
574
00:27:34.029 --> 00:27:36.930
small steps towards the bar. She has a very high,
575
00:27:37.640 --> 00:27:40.700
hearty mass. Is that fair? That's awesome.
576
00:27:40.759 --> 00:27:41.759
That's the party field.
577
00:27:41.779 --> 00:27:42.500
The party field.
578
00:27:42.519 --> 00:27:45.299
And then if you slap all those party goers, you
579
00:27:45.319 --> 00:27:48.119
can slap off one of them. That's the party particle.
580
00:27:48.140 --> 00:27:49.299
Somebody from the beehive.
581
00:27:49.319 --> 00:27:52.660
Somebody from the beehive pops out. Oh, my God, look
582
00:27:53.289 --> 00:27:57.740
at Beyonce. Oh, there it is. All right, so I
583
00:27:57.789 --> 00:28:00.569
have learned, not from you, and I'm disappointed because I
584
00:28:00.589 --> 00:28:02.289
thought you would have told me the whole story. Yes.
585
00:28:02.789 --> 00:28:07.529
I come to you for these frontier conversations that, The
586
00:28:07.630 --> 00:28:11.990
Higgs mass that a particle would have is only for
587
00:28:12.109 --> 00:28:16.930
free particles. If a particle is in an atom, it's
588
00:28:16.970 --> 00:28:18.289
not getting its mass from the Higgs field.
589
00:28:18.309 --> 00:28:20.529
I have told you this in the past,
though. I
590
00:28:20.650 --> 00:28:24.089
absolutely have. But you're absolutely right. Absolutely right.
591
00:28:24.430 --> 00:28:29.940
So if I'm a fat proton in a nucleus, I'm
592
00:28:29.960 --> 00:28:31.200
not getting my mass from the Higgs field.
593
00:28:31.259 --> 00:28:34.160
No, and that's why it's a really misleading notion that
594
00:28:34.200 --> 00:28:38.269
many people have. They think that all mass comes from
595
00:28:38.309 --> 00:28:41.509
the Higgs field. It is just the fundamental particles. And
596
00:28:41.549 --> 00:28:43.410
here's the thing. If you were to go up into
597
00:28:43.430 --> 00:28:45.359
your particle data book, which I know you have a
598
00:28:45.410 --> 00:28:47.579
few copies lying around in here.
599
00:28:47.650 --> 00:28:48.299
It's very good.
600
00:28:48.490 --> 00:28:50.599
If you look up the masses of the quarks, the
601
00:28:50.759 --> 00:28:53.680
up quark and the down quark that make up a proton, up, up,
602
00:28:53.720 --> 00:28:55.319
and a down, add up their masses.
603
00:28:55.500 --> 00:28:58.000
He said that quickly. Up, up, and a down. The
604
00:28:58.539 --> 00:29:03.079
nucleons have three quarks in them all bound together. making
605
00:29:03.140 --> 00:29:06.059
up the proton and the neutron, but they're different combinations
606
00:29:06.200 --> 00:29:09.799
of three quarks. This is good. Tell them. So quarks
607
00:29:09.839 --> 00:29:13.539
have charges, fractional charges. So watch, watch this, watch this.
608
00:29:13.680 --> 00:29:17.009
So proton has a charge of plus one. How do
609
00:29:17.029 --> 00:29:18.380
you get that from three quarks?
610
00:29:18.509 --> 00:29:19.430
Yeah, how do you do that?
611
00:29:19.509 --> 00:29:20.650
So give it to me.
612
00:29:20.690 --> 00:29:22.289
You gotta have a two-thirds and a two-thirds and a
613
00:29:22.309 --> 00:29:23.069
minus one-third.
614
00:29:23.509 --> 00:29:26.269
Two-thirds, two-thirds, minus one-third. So two-thirds plus two-thirds is one
615
00:29:26.309 --> 00:29:28.470
and a third, and then a minus charge to bring
616
00:29:28.509 --> 00:29:32.680
it down to one. Now, neutrons... have charged quarks inside
617
00:29:32.700 --> 00:29:34.799
of them, but they don't have any charge. So how
618
00:29:34.849 --> 00:29:35.329
do you get them?
619
00:29:35.440 --> 00:29:37.420
How do you get them? Let's hear it.
620
00:29:37.420 --> 00:29:43.160
Oh, it must be up two-thirds, down one-third, down one-third.
621
00:29:43.180 --> 00:29:45.599
Yeah, so if you have an up and then a down,
622
00:29:45.740 --> 00:29:48.559
and a down-down, then you got a two-thirds, minus one-third,
623
00:29:48.579 --> 00:29:49.079
minus one-third.
624
00:29:49.099 --> 00:29:51.329
Minus one-third. Now- Cancelling out, and so it's a neutral thing.
625
00:29:51.369 --> 00:29:53.150
Even though what's inside of it has charges.
626
00:29:53.309 --> 00:29:55.089
Right, but here's the thing. The point I want to make, though,
627
00:29:55.109 --> 00:29:57.349
is if you add up the masses of those quarks,
628
00:29:57.369 --> 00:30:00.160
they're Much less than the mass of the proton. So
629
00:30:00.180 --> 00:30:02.619
what's going on here? They make up the proton and
630
00:30:02.660 --> 00:30:04.720
yet the proton is much heavier than its ingredients.
631
00:30:05.119 --> 00:30:05.380
Right.
632
00:30:05.640 --> 00:30:08.529
Answer is there's another contribution to the mass, which has
633
00:30:08.589 --> 00:30:12.220
nothing to do with the Higgs field. which is the
634
00:30:12.240 --> 00:30:14.460
thing we were talking about before, the energy in the
635
00:30:14.500 --> 00:30:17.019
glue holding the quarks together.
636
00:30:17.460 --> 00:30:18.460
Oh, the gluonic force.
637
00:30:18.480 --> 00:30:21.940
There's energy holding them together equals MC squared. There's mass
638
00:30:21.980 --> 00:30:24.619
associated with that energy, and most of the mass of
639
00:30:24.660 --> 00:30:27.230
the proton is coming from the glue that's holding the
640
00:30:27.289 --> 00:30:28.170
quarks together.
641
00:30:28.490 --> 00:30:31.130
That's insane. So let's take a neutron, which has a
642
00:30:31.170 --> 00:30:35.130
half-life in minutes, like 15 minutes, if memory serves. And
643
00:30:35.630 --> 00:30:38.450
after that amount of time, half the neutrons will have
644
00:30:38.490 --> 00:30:42.200
decayed into a proton- and let's say if it's a
645
00:30:42.220 --> 00:30:43.240
regular proton and.
646
00:30:43.200 --> 00:30:44.380
Then an- Electron.
647
00:30:44.420 --> 00:30:45.019
An electron.
648
00:30:45.059 --> 00:30:46.049
And an anti-neutrino.
649
00:30:46.450 --> 00:30:48.789
And an anti-neutrino. If you add up the masses of those,
650
00:30:49.150 --> 00:30:51.130
don't you recover the mass of the proton?
651
00:30:51.170 --> 00:30:53.950
As long as you're taking kinetic energy into account and
652
00:30:53.970 --> 00:30:54.609
all this too.
653
00:30:54.650 --> 00:30:55.190
Because they fly away.
654
00:30:55.210 --> 00:30:57.230
They fly away. But yes, but yes.
655
00:30:57.299 --> 00:30:58.819
So the energy budget is all there.
656
00:30:58.839 --> 00:30:59.319
It's all there.
657
00:31:00.140 --> 00:31:03.539
Okay. Look at that. So everything is conserved. All the time.
658
00:31:03.720 --> 00:31:07.619
And in fact, the way the neutrino was predicted- was
659
00:31:07.660 --> 00:31:10.200
from looking at these particle decays and finding that the
660
00:31:10.339 --> 00:31:14.039
energy budget was not adding up. And so the idea
661
00:31:14.079 --> 00:31:16.950
was maybe there's an invisible particle that's carrying away some
662
00:31:16.990 --> 00:31:17.730
additional energy.
663
00:31:17.750 --> 00:31:18.470
Was this Enrico Fermi?
664
00:31:18.490 --> 00:31:19.109
Yes.
665
00:31:19.349 --> 00:31:22.049
So what I like about this is he's like, look folks,
666
00:31:22.490 --> 00:31:24.259
I can't explain this, let's make some shit up.
667
00:31:24.430 -->
00:31:28.190
Yes, but geniuses make up shit that's right.
668
00:31:30.000 --> 00:31:33.089
That is a quote. That's a quote. That's a bumper
669
00:31:33.150 --> 00:31:36.890
sticker right there. That's it. I'm getting a T-shirt. I'm
670
00:31:37.069 --> 00:31:44.490
getting a T-shirt. That's awesome. That's great. That's what Carl
671
00:31:44.529 --> 00:31:47.450
Sagan was famous for saying. They laughed at Einstein. They
672
00:31:47.509 --> 00:31:50.930
laughed at, you know, all these people with these great ideas.
673
00:31:50.990 --> 00:31:54.119
And he said, they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.
674
00:31:54.160 --> 00:31:58.539
Just because people laugh doesn't mean they're going to be wrong.
675
00:31:58.799 --> 00:32:01.400
He makes it up. And then everyone starts looking for it.
676
00:32:01.809 --> 00:32:05.869
And it's this highly elusive particle that has no charge,
677
00:32:06.289 --> 00:32:09.490
because we knew all the charges had already balanced in
678
00:32:09.509 --> 00:32:11.750
the lab. It's got no charge, but it's carrying away
679
00:32:11.829 --> 00:32:16.029
energy and no one has detected it. And he was Italian, right?
680
00:32:16.170 --> 00:32:18.789
So neutrino is like little neutral.
681
00:32:18.809 --> 00:32:19.210
Little neutron.
682
00:32:19.230 --> 00:32:21.369
Little neutron. Little neutral one, I think is technically.
683
00:32:21.390 --> 00:32:22.509
Oh, that may be right, little neutron.
684
00:32:22.529 --> 00:32:26.089
Little neutral one. Yeah, right. And so that's the only
685
00:32:26.190 --> 00:32:31.650
thing that allows me to, okay, I'm not gonna get
686
00:32:31.670 --> 00:32:34.910
in your way. When people saying dark matter, it's some
687
00:32:34.950 --> 00:32:38.440
elusive particle that we can't detect. That's accounting for the
688
00:32:38.519 --> 00:32:40.880
extra gravity. And it's just a particle, we haven't found
689
00:32:40.900 --> 00:32:44.460
the particle yet. And I'm thinking that's intellectually lazy, but
690
00:32:44.480 --> 00:32:48.519
it's no different than the neutrino. So that's why I
691
00:32:48.559 --> 00:32:50.819
cut it some slack, more slack than I otherwise would.
692
00:32:51.119 --> 00:32:52.990
We still need to find it.
693
00:32:53.420 --> 00:32:56.420
If it's a particle we haven't found it. So are
694
00:32:56.440 --> 00:32:57.950
you a betting man? Is it a particle or is
695
00:32:57.990 --> 00:32:58.490
it something else?
696
00:32:59.269 --> 00:33:02.599
Uh, look, I'm relatively conservative when it comes to these things,
697
00:33:02.660 --> 00:33:06.079
so I think that it's likely to be a particle, but.
698
00:33:06.079 --> 00:33:07.430
Look- Just because we've been down that road before.
699
00:33:07.450 --> 00:33:09.430
We've been down that road before. It fits in so
700
00:33:09.450 --> 00:33:11.289
well to our theoretical framework.
701
00:33:11.329 --> 00:33:13.410
It doesn't require- You have a slot for a dark
702
00:33:13.450 --> 00:33:14.410
matter- Particle?
703
00:33:14.519 --> 00:33:16.880
Well, the amazing thing is, and here's where you're going
704
00:33:16.900 --> 00:33:18.859
to come back at me and say this should undercut
705
00:33:18.900 --> 00:33:22.039
my confidence. When you look at a theory called supersymmetry
706
00:33:22.180 --> 00:33:24.250
that I've spent a long time working on.
707
00:33:24.359 --> 00:33:24.700
Okay.
708
00:33:24.920 --> 00:33:27.720
Within this theory, which goes beyond what we know about
709
00:33:27.799 --> 00:33:30.519
particle physics for reasons that are well motivated.
710
00:33:30.539 --> 00:33:31.759
Because that's ordinary symmetry.
711
00:33:32.059 --> 00:33:34.599
That's right. It takes the symmetries that we have and
712
00:33:34.640 --> 00:33:37.119
it takes them one step further and it's the only
713
00:33:37.200 --> 00:33:39.890
step further that you could possibly go. So of course
714
00:33:39.990 --> 00:33:43.769
nature must make use of this final symmetry principle. Why
715
00:33:43.809 --> 00:33:46.309
else would it exist? That's the thinking that we've had.
716
00:33:46.329 --> 00:33:48.789
Wait, just let me back up for a minute. So
717
00:33:49.009 --> 00:33:52.369
as I was learning particle physics, I was intrigued to
718
00:33:52.450 --> 00:33:56.309
recognize that you have your electron, you have your photon,
719
00:33:56.819 --> 00:33:59.779
you have your neutrino, and these other sort of basic particles.
720
00:34:00.349 --> 00:34:05.009
and they exist in our world that we live, we experience, okay?
721
00:34:05.589 --> 00:34:10.989
If you up the energy knob, other particles manifest. There's
722
00:34:11.030 --> 00:34:15.000
a version of the electron that manifests only in these
723
00:34:15.059 --> 00:34:17.139
higher energy levels, and it's called the muon.
724
00:34:17.159 --> 00:34:17.820
Okay?
725
00:34:19.670 --> 00:34:23.550
So there's a whole layer of particles sitting above the
726
00:34:23.690 --> 00:34:26.090
ones that are in our world. So there's three of
727
00:34:26.150 --> 00:34:28.469
these layers. And tell me the three electrons.
728
00:34:29.050 --> 00:34:31.170
You got the electron, the muon, and the tau.
729
00:34:31.469 --> 00:34:35.289
The tau. Yeah. Okay. And there's an electron neutrino. There's
730
00:34:35.309 --> 00:34:37.489
a muon neutrino. There's a tau neutrino. So now I
731
00:34:37.530 --> 00:34:40.030
have three layers here and you have access to them
732
00:34:40.340 --> 00:34:42.460
in your particle accelerators because it takes a lot of
733
00:34:42.500 --> 00:34:44.300
energy and you can get there. Yeah. Okay. Now what
734
00:34:44.320 --> 00:34:45.599
does supersymmetry do with this package?
735
00:34:45.619 --> 00:34:49.610
Supersymmetry says that- This package is- Beautiful and confirmed.
736
00:34:49.829 --> 00:34:53.739
And tell me the three force carriers. We have a photon.
737
00:34:53.880 --> 00:34:55.719
You got the photon, then you got the gluons, you
738
00:34:55.739 -->
00:34:58.480
need the W and Z bosons, or the weak nuclear force.
739
00:34:58.659 --> 00:34:59.000
Okay.
740
00:34:59.119 --> 00:35:00.519
And those are the three forces.
741
00:35:00.539 --> 00:35:05.079
Discovered by Bozo. Right, Bozo. Actually, Bose. Bose is an
742
00:35:05.139 --> 00:35:07.030
Indian physicist. Yes, absolutely.
743
00:35:07.070 --> 00:35:08.650
And then for the quarks, you got the up and
744
00:35:08.670 --> 00:35:10.610
the down that we spoke about. You got the charm,
745
00:35:10.630 --> 00:35:13.110
the strange, you got the top and the bottom. So again,
746
00:35:13.130 --> 00:35:14.929
they come in three pairs of two.
747
00:35:15.289 --> 00:35:15.829
Okay.
748
00:35:16.030 --> 00:35:19.170
Super symmetry says take all of those particles, And double them.
749
00:35:20.369 --> 00:35:23.809
Another shadow version of all of those particles.
750
00:35:23.829 --> 00:35:24.610
It's a shadow governed.
751
00:35:24.630 --> 00:35:25.820
For the electron.
752
00:35:28.420 --> 00:35:30.840
We are the puppets. This is the deep state. This
753
00:35:30.920 --> 00:35:34.260
is the deep state. They are the puppet masters. Quantum
754
00:35:34.300 --> 00:35:37.099
deep state. Wait, wait, wait. So I didn't know this.
755
00:35:37.139 --> 00:35:42.030
The entire set of particles would have a counterpart in
756
00:35:42.050 --> 00:35:44.110
this supersymmetric place.
757
00:35:44.289 --> 00:35:48.550
So for the electron, you have the supersymmetric electron. For
758
00:35:48.650 --> 00:35:53.679
the quarks, you have squarks. For neutrinos, you have neutrinos.
759
00:35:53.699 --> 00:35:54.739
People just making shit up.
760
00:35:54.780 --> 00:35:57.800
You do run out of names after a while. But
761
00:35:57.820 --> 00:36:01.639
here's the thing. This is all mathematically motivated by a
762
00:36:01.800 --> 00:36:05.630
completely compelling rationale. So this is not pulled out of
763
00:36:05.650 --> 00:36:06.949
thin air.
764
00:36:07.170 --> 00:36:11.150
We have our universe three ways, a three-layer cake. And
765
00:36:11.170 --> 00:36:13.409
there's a whole other cake. Where does that live?
766
00:36:13.989 --> 00:36:17.059
With us, but we believe they're more massive, which is
767
00:36:17.119 --> 00:36:20.280
why we wanted to build the superconducting super collider to
768
00:36:20.300 --> 00:36:21.989
try to find them. Now we've looked for these at
769
00:36:22.030 --> 00:36:22.630
the Large Hadron.
770
00:36:22.650 --> 00:36:26.150
If they're massive, why aren't they right here in front
771
00:36:26.170 --> 00:36:26.690
of our faces?
772
00:36:26.789 --> 00:36:31.099
They typically have short lifetimes, so they'll decay into lighter particles.
773
00:36:31.610 --> 00:36:35.630
but the lightest of the supersymmetric particles would not decay,
774
00:36:36.030 --> 00:36:38.320
and therefore it should be all around us.
775
00:36:38.329 --> 00:36:40.110
Tell them why the lightest one would not decay.
776
00:36:40.269 --> 00:36:42.670
If it's the lightest one, when it decays, the decay
777
00:36:42.769 --> 00:36:44.369
products have to be lighter than it.
778
00:36:45.050 --> 00:36:45.210
Okay.
779
00:36:45.269 --> 00:36:47.989
And so if it's the lightest one, subject to a
780
00:36:48.030 --> 00:36:49.650
certain conservation law.
781
00:36:49.690 --> 00:36:50.679
It's no place for it to go.
782
00:36:50.690 --> 00:36:52.869
It's no place for it to go.
783
00:36:53.110 --> 00:36:55.570
It's the same reason why you can have an energy
784
00:36:55.769 --> 00:36:59.969
field of any kind, and you will not make particles
785
00:37:00.170 --> 00:37:05.079
out of that. Right. Unless the energy available is higher
786
00:37:05.880 --> 00:37:10.179
than the E equals MC squared of two electrons. Right.
787
00:37:10.579 --> 00:37:12.579
Because it has to make them in pairs. Okay.
788
00:37:12.659 --> 00:37:14.019
To keep the charge conservative.
789
00:37:14.039 --> 00:37:15.949
Yeah, because it's plus and a minus. Right. And so
790
00:37:15.969 --> 00:37:19.269
an electron is the lightest. physical particle, that's right. So
791
00:37:19.469 --> 00:37:22.340
nothing's happening. That's why it's not happening around us right now.
792
00:37:22.360 --> 00:37:24.760
Yeah, it's the lightest charged particle. So it has to
793
00:37:24.800 --> 00:37:26.099
talk to the electromagnetic field.
794
00:37:26.179 --> 00:37:29.119
There it is. That's why light coming from lights is
795
00:37:29.159 --> 00:37:32.139
not just making particles. It doesn't have enough energy. But
796
00:37:32.780 --> 00:37:37.010
if X-rays start to come out of there, high energy X-rays,
797
00:37:37.260 --> 00:37:40.829
you can pop electrons into existence Because they're stepping down,
798
00:37:40.949 --> 00:37:41.949
so they leave something.
799
00:37:42.309 --> 00:37:44.829
The energy of the field is big enough to create
800
00:37:44.889 --> 00:37:48.670
the electron and anti-electron, and so it will pair produce them.
801
00:37:48.769 --> 00:37:54.400
In fact- That's so wild. Electron microscopes are enabled by
802
00:37:54.780 --> 00:37:59.980
X-rays creating them, and the wavelength of X-rays is so
803
00:38:00.039 --> 00:38:05.320
tiny- that you can see tiny detail. It's tinier than
804
00:38:05.360 --> 00:38:09.119
the detail, you can't have resolution higher than the wavelength
805
00:38:09.219 --> 00:38:10.719
of light that you're using to see it.
806
00:38:11.900 --> 00:38:14.670
Now, back to dark matter, just to finish this point.
807
00:38:14.690 --> 00:38:17.010
This is a whole massive other layer cake, and you're
808
00:38:17.030 --> 00:38:19.730
telling me that is the mass of the dark matter.
809
00:38:19.789 --> 00:38:23.789
Well, the lightest supersymmetric particle would be stable, should be
810
00:38:23.849 --> 00:38:27.789
around us. So maybe it's filling space. And here's the
811
00:38:27.809 --> 00:38:30.300
beautiful thing. This will blow your mind. This will blow
812
00:38:30.320 --> 00:38:30.860
your mind.
813
00:38:30.969 --> 00:38:32.639
This will blow your mind.
814
00:38:32.909 --> 00:38:35.860
When you do the calculation of how much of this
815
00:38:36.300 --> 00:38:38.800
light is supersymmetric particle should be left over since the
816
00:38:38.840 --> 00:38:42.880
Big Bang, it exactly matches what you need to be
817
00:38:42.960 --> 00:38:46.840
the dark matter. It comes in the right abundance. And
818
00:38:46.880 --> 00:38:48.619
yet we've not found it. And it may be the
819
00:38:48.659 --> 00:38:51.639
wrong answer. So sometimes things that just seem so deeply
820
00:38:51.679 --> 00:38:54.250
compelling are wrong, but we don't know yet.
821
00:38:54.849 --> 00:38:57.250
Wow. So do you know enough in the theory of
822
00:38:57.289 --> 00:39:00.500
these particles to predict how you should detect it?
823
00:39:00.969 --> 00:39:04.369
Yes, now they can vary which is the lightest supersymmetric
824
00:39:04.409 --> 00:39:07.849
particle on the flavor of the supersymmetric theory you're looking at.
825
00:39:08.329 --> 00:39:11.469
But in any given version, yes, you know exactly how
826
00:39:11.510 --> 00:39:12.610
the particle interacts.
827
00:39:12.690 --> 00:39:15.550
Okay, so now you have everybody's favorite flavor, the theorists,
828
00:39:15.829 --> 00:39:18.380
come out with their competing models, but still, they gotta
829
00:39:18.389 --> 00:39:22.179
have one of these particles. Okay, so now I'm a experimentalist,
830
00:39:22.489 --> 00:39:23.920
And it's, let me test for this one. I don't
831
00:39:23.940 --> 00:39:25.559
find it. Let me test for that one. I don't
832
00:39:25.579 --> 00:39:27.139
find it. So it's not looking good.
833
00:39:27.280 --> 00:39:27.909
Yeah, I agree.
834
00:39:28.369 --> 00:39:28.570
Okay.
835
00:39:28.650 --> 00:39:29.949
I agree. Okay. Wow. I agree.
836
00:39:30.539 --> 00:39:33.210
But yeah, when I was a student... It was almost
837
00:39:33.230 --> 00:39:36.320
a foregone conclusion that you just had to look for it.
838
00:39:36.340 --> 00:39:39.400
You'd find it. This is the dark matter. Because supersymmetry
839
00:39:39.500 --> 00:39:42.840
also solves other problems, the so-called hierarchy problem. It solved
840
00:39:42.860 --> 00:39:46.090
the dark matter problem. It's a beautiful idea that seems
841
00:39:46.230 --> 00:39:48.489
perhaps not to be right now. It's not fully ruled
842
00:39:48.570 --> 00:39:50.170
out yet, but that may be where we're going.
843
00:39:50.190 --> 00:39:53.750
Who's the one that said the great tragedy in science,
844
00:39:54.369 --> 00:40:01.230
the beautiful theory? A slain by some facts. Somebody said
845
00:40:01.269 --> 00:40:02.010
I forgot that.
846
00:40:02.030 --> 00:40:03.210
I think that's exactly what it may be.
847
00:40:03.230 --> 00:40:05.909
Hey, StarTalk fans. I don't know if you know this,
848
00:40:06.070 --> 00:40:10.909
but the audio version of the podcast actually posts a
849
00:40:11.050 --> 00:40:14.570
week
in advance of the video version. And you can
850
00:40:14.639 --> 00:40:20.440
get that in Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and most other podcast
851
00:40:20.539 --> 00:40:24.940
outlets that are out there. Multiple ways to ingest all
852
00:40:24.960 --> 00:40:28.090
that is cosmic on StarTalk. I have not been the
853
00:40:28.150 --> 00:40:33.590
same since we had lunch months ago. And you explained
854
00:40:33.630 --> 00:40:37.949
to me, and I've said it here, that there are
855
00:40:38.070 --> 00:40:47.070
ideas percolating that the fabric of space-time might be woven
856
00:40:48.219 --> 00:40:54.980
by wormholes that connect the virtual particle pairs that come
857
00:40:55.119 --> 00:40:57.840
in and out of existence. And that if they're connected
858
00:40:57.880 --> 00:41:03.510
by wormholes, rather than just some field, then the wormhole
859
00:41:03.730 --> 00:41:09.929
is an actual structural texture of the universe. Yeah. In fact,
860
00:41:09.969 --> 00:41:12.139
the other way- I'm sorry. What?
861
00:41:12.219 --> 00:41:16.599
First of all, I need some weed to even.
862
00:41:16.480 --> 00:41:17.099
Deal with this.
863
00:41:17.960 --> 00:41:20.599
Because if I'm trying to figure out what you just said,
864
00:41:20.619 --> 00:41:23.360
because it's so freaking, I mean, it really is just crazy.
865
00:41:23.380 --> 00:41:26.280
Well, let's back up. The vacuum of space is not
866
00:41:26.300 --> 00:41:28.780
a vacuum because quantum physics requires what?
867
00:41:29.000 --> 00:41:31.840
There's all sorts of uncertainty, and that uncertainty means that
868
00:41:31.860 --> 00:41:36.489
there's fluctuations, and therefore there are particle-antiparticle pairs. There's energy fluctuations.
869
00:41:36.510 --> 00:41:40.210
There's field fluctuations. It's a roiling mess out there.
870
00:41:40.030 --> 00:41:42.550
In energy space. So there's no nothing. There is no
871
00:41:42.570 --> 00:41:43.309
such thing as nothing.
872
00:41:43.510 --> 00:41:45.510
That violates uncertainty if there's truly nothing.
873
00:41:45.530 --> 00:41:48.010
Right, if there's truly nothing. We couldn't have uncertainty.
874
00:41:48.289 --> 00:41:52.079
So the uncertainty is, you know, gives us the fact
875
00:41:52.119 --> 00:41:55.239
that we do have virtual particles. We know that they
876
00:41:55.260 --> 00:41:57.539
popped in and out of existence. What you're trying to
877
00:41:57.579 --> 00:41:59.880
tell me. I think it's not that we know they're there.
878
00:41:59.940 --> 00:42:03.550
No one denies it because it's completely consistent.
879
00:42:04.449 --> 00:42:07.570
Well, the Casimir force where you actually put two metal
880
00:42:07.630 --> 00:42:10.789
plates in otherwise empty space, they should simply sit there.
881
00:42:11.179 --> 00:42:14.380
They're drawn together, and our best explanation is it's the
882
00:42:14.460 --> 00:42:17.440
virtual pairs of particles. It's a fluctuating film.
883
00:42:17.460 --> 00:42:21.110
I feel like I
have fallen into a Star Trek nightmare.
884
00:42:21.130 --> 00:42:26.730
So you take two exactly parallel plates. Okay. Okay, and
885
00:42:26.750 --> 00:42:30.010
evacuate what's in between. In between them. That makes sense.
886
00:42:30.030 --> 00:42:33.300
The best vacuum you can muster. Right. Then you slowly
887
00:42:33.400 --> 00:42:36.840
move them together. Right. There is a point within which
888
00:42:37.519 --> 00:42:38.719
a whole other force kicks in.
889
00:42:38.780 --> 00:42:42.420
That's right. And it's not the gravitational force. It's not
890
00:42:42.440 --> 00:42:45.760
electromagnetic force. Rather, it's a force that comes from the
891
00:42:45.909 --> 00:42:49.050
Casimir field, which is basically- That got a Nobel prize,
892
00:42:49.090 --> 00:42:52.489
the Casimir? Well, 1948 is when it was discovered.
893
00:42:52.650 --> 00:42:53.909
It got one in my book.
894
00:42:53.949 --> 00:42:54.829
But it should have.
895
00:42:54.849 --> 00:42:56.010
You just gave it one. I just gave it one.
896
00:42:56.030 --> 00:42:57.110
Yeah, it definitely deserved one.
897
00:42:57.150 --> 00:42:57.750
That's insane.
898
00:42:57.789 --> 00:43:02.130
But it's an imbalance between the fluctuations of uncertainty within
899
00:43:02.150 --> 00:43:04.590
the place and the fluctuations of uncertainty.
900
00:43:04.329 --> 00:43:05.389
Outside of the place.
901
00:43:05.650 --> 00:43:07.250
And it's that imbalance.
902
00:43:07.980 --> 00:43:11.699
Creates a force and puts them together. Okay, okay, so
903
00:43:11.800 --> 00:43:14.840
that's how we get the particles in the vacuum of space. Okay,
904
00:43:14.880 --> 00:43:19.519
so now, so now, why a, what compels you to
905
00:43:19.800 --> 00:43:22.219
say wormhole rather than just a field?
906
00:43:22.340 --> 00:43:25.750
Well, because it really comes from the idea of quantum entanglement.
907
00:43:26.210 --> 00:43:30.530
What we find is that, entanglement, which normally we think
908
00:43:30.570 --> 00:43:32.960
of as particle pairs, but now we're finding that the
909
00:43:33.039 --> 00:43:36.639
vacuum of space may be stitched together by the threads
910
00:43:36.659 --> 00:43:42.000
of quantum entanglement itself. So deep down within the substrate
911
00:43:42.059 --> 00:43:45.659
of reality, it may all be stitched together by quantum entanglement.
912
00:43:45.699 --> 00:43:49.269
And then other work shows us that quantum entanglement connecting
913
00:43:49.309 --> 00:43:52.710
two particles is just like a wormhole going from one
914
00:43:52.750 --> 00:43:53.309
to the other.
915
00:43:53.329 --> 00:43:55.449
Because what happens in one happens to the other instantly.
916
00:43:55.489 --> 00:43:55.869
Yes.
917
00:43:55.989 --> 00:43:57.809
And that means they're touching each other in that instant.
918
00:43:57.829 --> 00:44:02.570
They're connected in some weird way. And entanglement is one language,
919
00:44:02.820 --> 00:44:06.380
but we believe wormholes may be the general relativistic version
920
00:44:06.420 --> 00:44:07.559
of that quantum language.
921
00:44:07.739 --> 00:44:11.039
So it's like a little quantum net holding the whole
922
00:44:11.059 --> 00:44:11.719
universe together.
923
00:44:11.739 --> 00:44:18.360
Yes, exactly right. Because we find mathematically, if we cut
924
00:44:18.699 --> 00:44:21.800
the threads of quantum entanglement, which we can do mathematically,
925
00:44:22.300 --> 00:44:27.039
space falls apart. It discretizes into little tiny pieces and
926
00:44:27.059 --> 00:44:28.099
then just disappears.
927
00:44:29.269 --> 00:44:32.230
I gotta go. I gotta go. I gotta go. I
928
00:44:32.369 --> 00:44:34.550
need you to the end of this. Jack, don't leave me.
929
00:44:34.829 --> 00:44:39.150
Don't leave me, Jack. Oh my God. Oh my God. Dude,
930
00:44:39.170 --> 00:44:42.739
that's insane. It's not just that there's a field there.
931
00:44:43.030 --> 00:44:45.800
It's the fact that they were quantum entangled that makes
932
00:44:45.840 --> 00:44:49.820
the wormhole model compelling.
933
00:44:49.960 --> 00:44:51.460
Yeah, but I would say you don't even need the
934
00:44:51.539 --> 00:44:55.960
particle pairs. It's as if the entanglement is entangling regions
935
00:44:56.000 --> 00:45:01.769
of space. So space itself has a fundamental substrate woven
936
00:45:01.969 --> 00:45:07.400
by these threads of quantum connection. Now look, it's mathematical,
937
00:45:07.460 --> 00:45:10.019
but it comes out of our cutting edge ideas. It
938
00:45:10.079 --> 00:45:10.840
all makes sense.
939
00:45:10.860 --> 00:45:12.179
It just makes sense. He's saying he's not pulling it
940
00:45:12.199 --> 00:45:13.719
out of his ass. Right. He's saying the math gave
941
00:45:13.739 --> 00:45:15.820
it to him. The math works. And he started out saying,
942
00:45:15.860 --> 00:45:19.000
the man, my boy loves the math. So now, last thing. Yeah.
943
00:45:19.400 --> 00:45:26.190
Explain why you need more than four dimensions for your
944
00:45:26.329 --> 00:45:27.909
string theory universe?
945
00:45:28.130 --> 00:45:32.280
Well, it's a very concrete explanation. When we look at
946
00:45:32.320 --> 00:45:36.300
the equations of string theory, there's a consistency equation where
947
00:45:36.360 --> 00:45:39.519
something must equal zero or the math doesn't work. That
948
00:45:39.579 --> 00:45:42.679
something is a product of two things. One term is
949
00:45:42.719 --> 00:45:45.389
really complicated. It's never zero. The other term is the
950
00:45:45.429 --> 00:45:49.570
number of dimensions minus 10. The only way to get
951
00:45:49.610 --> 00:45:50.989
it to be equal to zero is for D to
952
00:45:51.030 --> 00:45:52.869
be equal to 10.
953
00:45:52.869 --> 00:45:53.389
That's it.
954
00:45:53.489 --> 00:45:56.389
I am not joking. This is where the constraint of
955
00:45:56.570 --> 00:45:58.460
extra dimensions comes from in string theory.
956
00:45:58.699 --> 00:45:59.920
The math is
forcing our hands.
957
00:45:59.980 --> 00:46:02.380
Forces your hand. And then you say, well, let me
958
00:46:02.429 --> 00:46:04.559
take this mass here. One thing you could say is, well,
959
00:46:04.820 --> 00:46:07.380
if it's not D equals four, three space in one time,
960
00:46:07.420 --> 00:46:10.500
throw the theory away. Others of us will say, hey,
961
00:46:10.539 --> 00:46:12.300
let's consider the possibility.
962
00:46:12.320 --> 00:46:13.219
Don't sell the universe short.
963
00:46:13.260 --> 00:46:16.260
Yeah, exactly. So why should these three dimensions of space
964
00:46:16.320 --> 00:46:17.179
be the only ones?
965
00:46:17.280 --> 00:46:17.480
Right.
966
00:46:17.699 --> 00:46:19.699
We only are aware of them because they're big enough
967
00:46:19.760 --> 00:46:21.659
that we can be directly aware of them with these
968
00:46:22.119 --> 00:46:24.570
really faulty sensors that we have.
969
00:46:24.610 --> 00:46:27.210
Right. If it's only your senses that limit that awareness,
970
00:46:28.289 --> 00:46:31.079
why not, in principle, can we build something that can
971
00:46:31.099 --> 00:46:32.800
gain access to these higher dimensions. Yeah.
972
00:46:32.840 --> 00:46:35.880
So there are experiments on the table. Some have been
973
00:46:35.920 --> 00:46:38.699
carried out, but more precise ones may be done where
974
00:46:39.139 --> 00:46:42.360
you study Newton's law of gravity. Why is Newton's law
975
00:46:42.400 --> 00:46:44.389
go like one over R squared? Why do we teach
976
00:46:44.449 --> 00:46:46.170
our kids GMM over R squared?
977
00:46:46.190 --> 00:46:46.809
It's a geometric.
978
00:46:46.829 --> 00:46:50.570
Geometric sphere in three dimensions of space.
979
00:46:50.630 --> 00:46:50.869
Yes.
980
00:46:51.090 --> 00:46:53.650
Look at that sphere in four or five or six dimensions.
981
00:46:53.789 --> 00:46:56.469
And the two in Newton's law won't be a two.
982
00:46:56.670 --> 00:46:56.849
No.
983
00:46:56.989 --> 00:46:59.429
It'll be a bigger number. The fall off will be differently.
984
00:46:59.449 --> 00:46:59.570
Right.
985
00:47:00.320 --> 00:47:03.820
And so look at the gravitational force on very small distances.
986
00:47:04.340 --> 00:47:06.619
Look for a deviation from the one over R squared
987
00:47:06.639 --> 00:47:08.940
that Isaac Newton told us about in the late 16th century.
988
00:47:08.960 --> 00:47:13.590
Okay, because that's only in our dimensional measurement of it. Yes. Okay,
989
00:47:13.610 --> 00:47:15.949
because I'd asked you, again, over that same lunch. Yeah.
990
00:47:16.469 --> 00:47:17.570
Why did we have lunch? I forgot.
991
00:47:17.590 --> 00:47:19.659
We were just catching up.
992
00:47:19.969 --> 00:47:23.150
We were just catching up. You know, it's my annual fix,
993
00:47:23.610 --> 00:47:30.190
my annual Brian Greene infusion. It was, could dark matter be...
994
00:47:30.840 --> 00:47:36.469
ordinary matter with ordinary gravity in a parallel universe. Because
995
00:47:36.650 --> 00:47:39.710
for reasons I don't understand the math of, the field
996
00:47:39.869 --> 00:47:44.480
theory equations of, you were telling me that electromagnetic energy
997
00:47:44.599 --> 00:47:48.420
cannot escape our space time, but gravity can.
998
00:47:48.880 --> 00:47:53.920
In a certain model called the brain universe, where our universe, B-R-A-N-E,
999
00:47:54.579 --> 00:47:56.699
It comes out as a membrane. Yeah, it's a membrane.
1000
00:47:56.719 --> 00:47:59.829
So our universe is like a four-dimensional membrane floating in
1001
00:47:59.849 --> 00:48:02.969
a higher-dimensional universe that might have other membranes.
1002
00:48:03.530 --> 00:48:04.389
Higher-dimensional membranes.
1003
00:48:04.429 --> 00:48:07.199
Yes, and those other membranes are parallel to us, like
1004
00:48:07.239 --> 00:48:09.820
two slices of bread and a big loaf of bread.
1005
00:48:09.840 --> 00:48:11.860
I like it. So one slice of bread is some
1006
00:48:11.940 --> 00:48:15.449
other membranal universe. Ours is this one, but it's one...
1007
00:48:16.070 --> 00:48:17.670
It's one multi-grain.
1008
00:48:17.710 --> 00:48:17.969
Yeah.
1009
00:48:18.170 --> 00:48:20.590
Okay. And so gravity could leak out of one into
1010
00:48:20.610 --> 00:48:20.909
the other.
1011
00:48:21.070 --> 00:48:22.590
Or it could just be the, yeah, that's right. So
1012
00:48:22.610 --> 00:48:23.650
the gravitational pull, yeah.
1013
00:48:23.670 --> 00:48:26.239
That's what I'm getting. So if the other universe has
1014
00:48:26.469 --> 00:48:29.730
six times, nobody, see, this is where you corrected me.
1015
00:48:29.739 --> 00:48:32.340
Because I was thinking, because we have six times as
1016
00:48:32.380 --> 00:48:35.059
much force of gravity operating in the universe as matter
1017
00:48:35.079 --> 00:48:36.199
and energy can account for it.
1018
00:48:36.500 --> 00:48:36.679
Okay.
1019
00:48:36.719 --> 00:48:38.679
It's a factor of six. Right. So I was saying,
1020
00:48:38.739 --> 00:48:41.340
why isn't it just a parallel universe that has six
1021
00:48:41.409 --> 00:48:45.239
times the mass and And it's leakage into our universe.
1022
00:48:45.519 --> 00:48:47.659
And we're trying to feel the elephant, trying to figure
1023
00:48:47.679 --> 00:48:50.289
out what it is. But it's just regular matter in
1024
00:48:50.329 --> 00:48:53.510
another universe whose gravity leaked. But then you said, if
1025
00:48:53.550 --> 00:48:56.210
it's in another membrane, it's going to be dropping off
1026
00:48:56.469 --> 00:48:59.039
faster than 1 over r squared. Yeah. Like 1 over
1027
00:48:59.199 --> 00:49:00.659
r cubed or some higher dimension.
1028
00:49:00.739 --> 00:49:00.840
Yeah.
1029
00:49:01.389 --> 00:49:03.170
And if that's the case, it has to be way
1030
00:49:03.230 --> 00:49:04.170
more than six times.
1031
00:49:04.469 --> 00:49:06.590
But you could imagine rigging it so that it would
1032
00:49:06.650 --> 00:49:07.760
have the right amount.
1033
00:49:07.880 --> 00:49:08.099
Yes.
1034
00:49:08.159 --> 00:49:10.539
And people have studied this, and it's hard to make
1035
00:49:10.599 --> 00:49:12.480
these theories work in detail.
1036
00:49:12.699 --> 00:49:13.519
And be all self-consistent.
1037
00:49:13.539 --> 00:49:16.530
But in principle, it's an idea that's absolutely worthy of
1038
00:49:16.630 --> 00:49:19.860
investigating because that's one way to make it invisible. Just
1039
00:49:19.940 --> 00:49:20.880
put it in another membrane.
1040
00:49:20.920 --> 00:49:21.840
Yeah, just stick it somewhere else.
1041
00:49:21.860 --> 00:49:22.380
Yeah, exactly.
1042
00:49:22.880 --> 00:49:25.320
And then we can still calculate with it. It's not
1043
00:49:25.340 --> 00:49:30.539
a problem. Right. Yeah. That's crazy. Oh, man. All right.
1044
00:49:31.280 --> 00:49:34.280
I don't know what to believe about anything.
1045
00:49:35.469 --> 00:49:41.969
Nothing is real. Nothing is real, man. Dark energy. I'm
1046
00:49:42.050 --> 00:49:48.909
curious about this because it was a natural arithmetic element
1047
00:49:49.489 --> 00:49:53.590
of Einstein's equations. It's like an integration constant, as I
1048
00:49:53.610 --> 00:49:54.130
understood it.
1049
00:49:54.250 --> 00:49:55.989
You're talking about the cosmological constant?
1050
00:49:56.340 --> 00:50:01.559
The cosmological constant in his equations. Yes. that enabled Lemaitre
1051
00:50:02.019 --> 00:50:06.679
to calculate that the universe is either expanding or, well,
1052
00:50:06.699 --> 00:50:08.960
the universe is not static. And so there's a term there.
1053
00:50:10.840 --> 00:50:13.480
And if you've had calculus, you might remember there's a
1054
00:50:13.539 --> 00:50:16.420
constant of integration, often it's just zero and you can
1055
00:50:16.440 --> 00:50:20.079
ignore it. But when we were in graduate school, I'm
1056
00:50:20.099 --> 00:50:22.469
a little older than you. When we were in graduate school,
1057
00:50:23.030 --> 00:50:27.230
we always recognized, we paid homage to that constant, but said,
1058
00:50:27.590 --> 00:50:30.409
let's assume it's zero. If this term existed, it would
1059
00:50:30.449 --> 00:50:33.329
mean there was a force operating in the universe opposite
1060
00:50:33.369 --> 00:50:34.050
that of gravity.
1061
00:50:34.190 --> 00:50:36.840
Depending on the sign of the cosmological constant, but yes.
1062
00:50:37.510 --> 00:50:38.750
Because it could have either sign.
1063
00:50:38.929 --> 00:50:40.869
Okay, it would either work with gravity or against it.
1064
00:50:41.090 --> 00:50:41.429
Exactly.
1065
00:50:41.449 --> 00:50:43.030
But if we had a static universe, it would be
1066
00:50:43.070 --> 00:50:45.260
something just holding up the universe against.
1067
00:50:44.980 --> 00:50:47.519
The collapse of gravity. Which is why Einstein thought of it.
1068
00:50:47.639 --> 00:50:50.940
And we didn't have any reason to think it. So
1069
00:50:50.980 --> 00:50:53.519
it could be zero.
But we always had to go
1070
00:50:53.599 --> 00:50:56.010
through that portal. We say, here it is. We set
1071
00:50:56.050 --> 00:50:59.110
it to zero and move on. Then it gets discovered.
1072
00:51:00.170 --> 00:51:03.670
Dark energy gets discovered in 1998. It gets the Nobel Prize.
1073
00:51:04.090 --> 00:51:07.269
Using quantum physics... which has done so well by us,
1074
00:51:08.050 --> 00:51:13.619
perhaps the most successful theory ever about anything fails in
1075
00:51:13.659 --> 00:51:16.809
its attempt to predict the amount of dark energy in
1076
00:51:16.829 --> 00:51:23.019
the universe. And it fails. Badly. By a factor- What's
1077
00:51:23.059 --> 00:51:24.639
up with that, Brian? Of a Google.
1078
00:51:25.539 --> 00:51:27.929
Wow, by a factor of- Bigger than a Google. 10
1079
00:51:27.929 --> 00:51:30.929
to like, it's like 10 to 123. Google is 10
1080
00:51:30.929 --> 00:51:31.769
to the 100th?
1081
00:51:32.090 --> 00:51:35.710
Yeah. It gets the wrong answer by the biggest amount
1082
00:51:36.050 --> 00:51:39.230
ever in a mismatch between theory and observation. Yeah. Where
1083
00:51:39.289 --> 00:51:41.429
are we with the dark energy theorists?
1084
00:51:41.449 --> 00:51:44.159
Well, look, what this is showing us is that quantum
1085
00:51:44.179 --> 00:51:47.760
mechanics is incredibly successful when you apply it to the
1086
00:51:47.820 --> 00:51:51.139
electromagnetic force, to the weak nuclear force, to the strong
1087
00:51:51.179 --> 00:51:53.469
nuclear force. But we've long known that when you apply
1088
00:51:53.489 --> 00:51:57.110
it to gravity, something goes wrong. Something changes. This is
1089
00:51:57.130 --> 00:51:59.969
the motivation for string theory. And this is the motivation
1090
00:51:59.989 --> 00:52:03.989
for trying to go beyond conventional approaches. And so you're
1091
00:52:04.210 --> 00:52:08.570
absolutely right. This is the clearest signal that something is wrong. Now, here's,
1092
00:52:08.590 --> 00:52:09.090
I think our best guess.
1093
00:52:09.110 --> 00:52:10.989
But that's not something's wrong. That's actually a good thing.
1094
00:52:11.260 --> 00:52:12.300
Well, it's an opportunity.
1095
00:52:12.380 --> 00:52:12.860
Opportunity.
1096
00:52:12.889 --> 00:52:14.460
Yeah, it's a huge opportunity.
1097
00:52:14.500 --> 00:52:17.699
The press always says, oh, scientists are angry or this. No,
1098
00:52:17.719 --> 00:52:20.460
we're delighted. If something breaks, oh my gosh, it's a
1099
00:52:20.480 --> 00:52:21.880
new thing. Exactly. That's right.
1100
00:52:22.219 --> 00:52:25.699
And so I would say my guess where we're going is,
1101
00:52:25.800 --> 00:52:30.010
and many of my colleagues agree with me, that you
1102
00:52:30.070 --> 00:52:34.289
can't quantize gravity. the way you had to quantize Faraday
1103
00:52:34.309 --> 00:52:37.909
and Maxwell's electromagnetism, or the way you had to quantize
1104
00:52:37.949 --> 00:52:40.570
the weak or strong nuclear forces. It may be that
1105
00:52:40.690 --> 00:52:45.880
gravity and quantum mechanics are already so intimately connected that
1106
00:52:45.929 --> 00:52:49.920
it's a completely different mindset when you approach them. You
1107
00:52:49.960 --> 00:52:52.239
don't take the rules of quantum mechanics and slap them
1108
00:52:52.480 --> 00:52:55.460
onto gravity. That gets you the wrong answer. That's the
1109
00:52:55.579 --> 00:52:59.119
wrong approach. In fact, this idea of entanglement and wormholes
1110
00:52:59.139 --> 00:53:00.900
suggests that gravity.
1111
00:53:00.519 --> 00:53:02.739
And quantum mechanics, they're already in there.
1112
00:53:02.760 --> 00:53:03.679
They're already there.
1113
00:53:03.699 --> 00:53:06.960
That makes sense. They already have the shotgun wedding.
1114
00:53:07.019 --> 00:53:10.489
Exactly. So you just need to understand that melding better.
1115
00:53:10.690 --> 00:53:12.769
And when you do, perhaps you'll be able to do
1116
00:53:12.809 --> 00:53:16.849
a calculation of the cosmological constant and get the right answer. Right.
1117
00:53:16.889 --> 00:53:17.050
Yeah.
1118
00:53:17.289 --> 00:53:20.630
Now, another answer might be maybe the cosmological constant is
1119
00:53:20.670 --> 00:53:21.429
not a constant.
1120
00:53:22.010 --> 00:53:22.219
Right?
1121
00:53:22.260 --> 00:53:23.119
There's recent data.
1122
00:53:23.139 --> 00:53:24.079
They're working on that now.
1123
00:53:24.139 --> 00:53:28.139
Yeah. Maybe it's changing over time. And so you don't
1124
00:53:28.199 --> 00:53:30.599
actually calculate the number. You just need to understand the
1125
00:53:30.659 --> 00:53:32.119
dynamical process.
1126
00:53:32.280 --> 00:53:38.260
However, doesn't the math in general relativity... require that it
1127
00:53:38.280 --> 00:53:40.699
be constant. That's how it came out of the integral.
1128
00:53:40.800 --> 00:53:44.000
There can be a constant, but it doesn't have to
1129
00:53:44.059 --> 00:53:47.280
be the only contribution that looks like that constant. And
1130
00:53:47.300 --> 00:53:49.099
the other contribution can change over time.
1131
00:53:49.280 --> 00:53:51.500
What do you say there? It can be a constant,
1132
00:53:51.639 --> 00:53:54.420
but it doesn't have to look like, and then.
1133
00:53:54.739 --> 00:53:57.239
No, it's not the only contribution to that term. So
1134
00:53:57.679 --> 00:54:01.369
you can have a field. that slowly varies over time,
1135
00:54:01.909 --> 00:54:04.880
and that field may dominate its conservation.
1136
00:54:04.889 --> 00:54:07.599
So that field is meta to that equation. Yes. Look
1137
00:54:07.639 --> 00:54:07.860
at that.
1138
00:54:07.880 --> 00:54:09.179
It is meta to that equation.
1139
00:54:09.199 --> 00:54:09.900
Oh, my gosh. Absolutely.
1140
00:54:09.920 --> 00:54:11.639
So Einstein did not talk about that field.
1141
00:54:11.679 --> 00:54:12.980
No, he didn't. No, he wasn't there yet. And you're right.
1142
00:54:13.159 --> 00:54:15.239
And he did talk about the constant, because you're right.
1143
00:54:15.280 --> 00:54:16.820
It's just an integration constant.
1144
00:54:16.840 --> 00:54:18.320
It's an integration constant. It's right there. It's a constant.
1145
00:54:18.340 --> 00:54:18.860
It's a constant.
1146
00:54:18.900 --> 00:54:19.159
Right.
1147
00:54:19.440 --> 00:54:23.400
So if, in fact, it needs to modify, because that's
1148
00:54:23.420 --> 00:54:26.619
how they reconcile this tension in the age of the universe. Yes.
1149
00:54:26.739 --> 00:54:29.269
Because the age of the universe, there's In my day,
1150
00:54:29.309 --> 00:54:32.269
we didn't know it by a factor of two. Now
1151
00:54:32.349 --> 00:54:36.579
people are, there's a 10% difference. So it's more than 6,000 years.
1152
00:54:38.099 --> 00:54:41.679
Is what you're saying. Yes, that's exactly what I'm saying. Yes, yes, yes.
1153
00:54:41.900 --> 00:54:46.019
When Noah's flood took place. So to relieve the tension,
1154
00:54:46.340 --> 00:54:49.440
as we describe it, this was a 10%, some single
1155
00:54:49.480 --> 00:54:52.849
digit percent. Uncertainty of the age of the universe. Actually,
1156
00:54:52.869 --> 00:54:57.579
not uncertainty. These two methods have very small, tight, uncertainties
1157
00:54:57.780 --> 00:55:00.239
that do not overlap. That's why everyone is freaking out.
1158
00:55:00.559 --> 00:55:04.030
And as I learned recently, you can resolve that by
1159
00:55:04.159 --> 00:55:08.110
allowing the cosmological constant to vary in some way, but
1160
00:55:08.150 --> 00:55:11.269
that's a meta variation on top of Einstein.
1161
00:55:11.289 --> 00:55:13.969
Yes, this Hubble tension that people are struggling with today
1162
00:55:14.010 --> 00:55:17.750
is exactly something that also may point toward a dynamical value.
1163
00:55:17.809 --> 00:55:21.630
So we'll see. But yes, the true test of a
1164
00:55:22.130 --> 00:55:25.000
version of gravity that you fully understand with quantum mechanics
1165
00:55:25.039 --> 00:55:28.889
included would be a calculation. of the cosmological constant and
1166
00:55:29.090 --> 00:55:29.710
get a number.
1167
00:55:29.730 --> 00:55:31.489
Are you and your people smart enough to get this
1168
00:55:31.530 --> 00:55:31.880
figured out?
1169
00:55:32.010 --> 00:55:32.719
I don't think so.
1170
00:55:34.260 --> 00:55:40.500
And that's social? Good answer. Because you know I've dragged
1171
00:55:40.519 --> 00:55:43.000
you over the cold about that. We have come full circle.
1172
00:55:43.659 --> 00:55:47.099
Because I told him, I said, look, you know, Einstein
1173
00:55:47.119 --> 00:55:50.400
came up with general relativity in 10 years by himself.
1174
00:55:51.079 --> 00:55:53.820
You strength theorists, dozens of you have been working on
1175
00:55:53.860 --> 00:55:58.710
this for decades. Either... You're all wrong, or you're all
1176
00:55:58.750 --> 00:56:00.130
just too stupid to figure it out.
1177
00:56:00.829 --> 00:56:03.570
And it's probably a combination.
1178
00:56:04.590 --> 00:56:07.030
Love you, man. Brian, thanks for coming back to StarTalk.
1179
00:56:07.309 --> 00:56:09.369
Always good, Chuck. So great. Chuck, we'll find you in
1180
00:56:09.389 --> 00:56:14.320
the hospital. Bless you. I'm completely fried right now. I'm fried.
1181
00:56:14.530 --> 00:56:16.440
Just to take us out, let me remind us all,
1182
00:56:16.480 --> 00:56:19.119
we are in my office at the Hayden Planetarium of
1183
00:56:19.139 --> 00:56:22.760
the American Museum of Natural History. The Cosmic Crib. The
1184
00:56:22.780 --> 00:56:27.050
Cosmic Crib. And after this conversation we just had, I
1185
00:56:27.110 --> 00:56:32.630
delight in realizing and celebrating the fact that just a
1186
00:56:32.969 --> 00:56:38.460
few pounds of organic matter inside of our heads can
1187
00:56:38.940 --> 00:56:44.659
not only contemplate, but figure out how the universe works.
1188
00:56:46.599 --> 00:56:49.739
And yes, we still have a long way to go,
1189
00:56:50.219 --> 00:56:52.800
and we don't even know how long a way to
1190
00:56:52.820 --> 00:56:58.570
go remains in front of us. The distance we've come
1191
00:56:58.679 --> 00:57:04.369
thus far gives us everything that we call civilization. And
1192
00:57:04.789 --> 00:57:09.130
it's the power of mind over the mysteries of the universe.
1193
00:57:09.369 --> 00:57:14.510
And that is a product of the eternal curiosity expressed
1194
00:57:14.550 --> 00:57:21.429
by our species. Beginning in childhood, continuing for some into adulthood.
1195
00:57:22.150 --> 00:57:26.690
We call them scientists. Those who never lost that childhood curiosity.
1196
00:57:27.119 --> 00:57:32.400
Brian Greene, of course, among them. So I'd like to
1197
00:57:32.460 --> 00:57:37.389
just give a shout out to our species for all
1198
00:57:37.429 --> 00:57:40.150
that has wondered as we looked up at night, all
1199
00:57:40.190 --> 00:57:43.070
that we have discovered, and all that we have yet
1200
00:57:43.969 --> 00:57:49.239
to figure out. That is a cosmic perspective. I'm Neil
1201
00:57:49.280 --> 00:57:52.840
deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. Keep looking up.
1202
00:58:03.210 --> 00:58:03.289
So,