TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
Paolo Longo: All right, hey everybody, welcome back to Shielded. Today we're gonna do something a little bit different. Most of our episodes to date have been sort of single topic, sort of deep dives into individual issues that we see with our first responder clients. Today we're gonna have a little fun and do something a little bit different. I don't know that we got a good name for this, but other than something like a mailbag episode where. you know, fortunately we've been getting lots of calls and lots of emails and lots of questions. And one thing we've noticed is that over the past couple of months that we've been doing these podcasts is that we're getting some of the same questions. So folks are paying attention, folks are studying, but, and they're asking the same question. So what we're going to do today is just go through a bunch of those questions that our listeners have been asking. ⁓ just provide some more information. Today with me obviously is not Jeff Bickler. You can tell by the hair and the glasses, ⁓ this is one of our other partners, Christine Calleghi. Christine, welcome.
Kristine Callagy: Thank you. Pleasure to be here.
Paolo Longo: Christine is a pit bull. Don't let the smile fool you. When she's on your case, you're gonna get, ⁓ you know, it's pedal to the metal with Christine, always and forever. ⁓ And so we've asked her to come on, because she gets a lot of these questions too. And we'll tell some stories and answer some questions and hopefully provide you guys some more information. So with that, let's get into it. Question number one, ⁓ that we actually get a lot of, this one specifically, Broward County firefighter asks, how long do I have to file a claim? ⁓ And he asked sort of three questions, was a regular kind of orthopedic claim, how long do I have to file a heart claim, and how long do I have to file my PTSD claim? So where do you want to start?
Kristine Callagy: Let's start with the hard cases. I think that's probably what most people are looking to hear about most anyway, you know, ⁓ the information dive. ⁓ So with hard cases, you've got 90 days from the date of the accident to report your injury. ⁓ And as usual with lawyers, there's always a it depends that follows that. So well, yeah, everything I know I learned from Palo Longo.
Paolo Longo: You sound just like a lawyer. I trained you well. Yes. That's a warning.
Kristine Callagy: It's a fact, it is a fact. Maybe, maybe a little bit. So yeah, 90 days from the date of accident, but there's also that it depends, like we said, right? So for example. had this case that went to trial a couple of years ago and this this individual was a firefighter and he had a heart attack. ⁓ he thought because it didn't happen on duty that he couldn't get coverage through the heart bill. He knew the heart bill existed, just didn't really know the ins and outs of it. ⁓ said anything, never filed a claim, came to us for a different reason and we kind of did a deep dive and found that he had this issue. So we ended up filing a claim for him ⁓ we were able to be successful on that claim because he didn't know his rights and obligations at the time. that the accident happened, he only learned from us and teaching him and kind of getting him involved in another case. And we were able to kind of have that it depends exception because he did not know what his rights and responsibilities were back then.
Paolo Longo: Right, so but when you say date of accident, mean, what does date of accident mean?
Kristine Callagy: It's a fancy term for the date that your issue happens. It's not necessarily an accident where you're in a vehicle and you get in a collision or you fall tripping with your fire hose or a suspect is fighting you and you break your finger. Those technically are all dates of accident, but it's just a fancy term of art that we use. It's a lawyer term. It's really just, when did your issue happen? That's the date of the problem.
Paolo Longo: Right, so if it's a heart attack claim, right, it's the date of your heart attack. If it's a hypertension thing or something like that, a blood pressure problem, it's the date that you're missing work or the doctor diagnoses you, things like that. So 90 days from that date or 90 days from when you figure it out that you should be filing a claim.
Kristine Callagy: Right. Right. Right, that your issue is related to your job, 90 days from that period. And in the example that we were just talking about, his 90 days started to run from the day that he and I had that conversation about, this should have been a claim three years ago when you had your heart attack. That was the starting point for his 90 day clock to run.
Paolo Longo: Right, And insurance companies love to fight us over this 90 days thing, because they're like, well, no, you had a certain amount of time to report it, and it was a late reporting, your accident happened, your heart attack was three years ago, and you never said anything. But if my client didn't know, I had a case similar to the one you had, it was up in the panhandle where... One of my clients was shopping at Walmart and ran into one of his buddies. ⁓ When they were comparing ⁓ bypass scars, they both had bypass surgeries. And the one guy's like, yeah, I'm getting my workers' comp and my doctors and my medicine and everything's being provided. And his buddy was like, what the hell are you talking about? And he's like, yeah, well.
Kristine Callagy: Mm-hmm.
Paolo Longo: you know, I had a heart attack and workers compass covering the guys like, well, I had a bypass too, but you know, mine was, you know, I was at home and the guy's like, no, you need to, you know, call these guys. So when I talked to him, you know, ultimately it was several years after his bypass, but he didn't know that he could file a claim. And, know, so we were ultimately successful in getting that claim accepted and getting him coverage and all that stuff. His 90 days didn't begin until that
Load full transcript
conversation in a Walmart, but you, you, you raise another issue.
Kristine Callagy: Thank
Paolo Longo: which is a question I had down the list, but you kind of already brought it up and is it, is, ⁓ hold on, where's that question? Who sent it to me? This was actually another guy I've been panhandling as a law enforcement officer. What happens ⁓ if my issue doesn't happen on duty? Like what happens if I have my heart attack, you know, or my cardiac issue and I'm not actually, you know, working?
Kristine Callagy: Yeah, you still can get coverage. The example I always give to people when we're out and about and having these educational events and just chatting with people out and about, you know, first responders, you know, when I'm out walking my dog and the police down the street. ⁓ I always tell them, you do not have to be on duty when it happens. I have a client who was on vacation in Columbia, so he wasn't even in the country and he had a heart attack. And luckily he had enough sense about him while he was there to get those records. were all in Spanish, of course, but he was able to get the medical records and we were able to get that case picked up because even though he wasn't here in country or on duty, he still suffered a temporary disability because of his heart, because of a cardiac issue. Wait, well, we ended up using an expert that speaks Spanish. was Dr. Costello. Yeah.
Paolo Longo: Right, and thanks to ChatGPT, we can translate those records pretty quick now. ⁓ well, there you go. I mean, perfect. Knowing a doctor that speaks Spanish and can translate the medical records. There you go. Yeah, I had one a long time ago where a guy was on a scuba diving trip and he was like 50 or 60 feet underwater, you know, with his tanks on and had a heart attack underwater while he was diving. And thank God, you know, they got him up into the hospital and stuff too. And, you know, I don't, I'm going to remember how he, how he,
Kristine Callagy: There we go. Mm
Paolo Longo: found us, but you know, like, yeah, it's fine. You don't have to be on duty, you know? So the answer to the question is, does my cardiac issue have to happen on duty to be covered, is a flat out no. I mean, you can be on vacation, you can be scuba diving, you can be in another country. It doesn't matter because after that event, you're unable to work regardless of where you are, right? So.
Kristine Callagy: Yes. It's the incapacity that triggers the protections of the heart, not the fact that it happens on duty. I had another client who had an arrhythmia issue when he was on a cruise ship in the middle of the Caribbean or by the Bahamas, wherever he was, I don't remember. And they ended up medevacking him out of the cruise ship to the hospital. He was able to get the records from the cruise ship and we were able to get that case picked up as well, even though he was in the middle of the ocean.
Paolo Longo: Great. Right. Didn't you have an Apple Watch 1, 2, where a guy was, you know, like on doing something or running or jogging in the Apple Watch and he wasn't on work?
Kristine Callagy: I've got a couple of cases like that. I have one where he was at home. He had just gotten off of shift, kind of like a midday shift where it kind of put him into, you know, like a two o'clock in the morning dismissal. He was at home trying to calm down and just felt, you know, the rapid heartbeat and ran an EKG on his Apple Watch. And we were able to get that case picked up after some fighting as well. But that EKG was really the key piece of evidence, a smoking gun, if you will.
Paolo Longo: Right, right. No, that's great. And so, you know, the important thing here is it doesn't have to, you don't have to be on shift, right? You don't have to be in a firehouse. You don't have to be in a police car. I mean, it doesn't matter. It doesn't matter. ⁓ So next question, this is actually from a central Florida law enforcement officer, Red Run in our neighborhood. ⁓ My employer says that I have to miss more than seven days of work to be covered. Is that true?
Kristine Callagy: No, that's not true. You have to miss more than seven days of work to get paid from workers' comp, but you don't have to miss more than seven days from work to get coverage under the harmful absolutely not. That's someone spreading misinformation so that people don't fly flames right there.
Paolo Longo: Right, well that's the insurance company taking some truth, right, where you have to be out seven days or more to actually get paid by workers comp, and then just including, well, if you don't get paid by comp, then you're not covered. So, you know, that is a complete misrepresentation of the law, right? You can miss seven seconds and be covered, okay? I mean, doesn't matter, right? You know, the seven day thing is, you know, if you...
Kristine Callagy: Okay. Right. Right.
Paolo Longo: have a heart attack and you're gonna miss a month of work. You have to be out seven consecutive days before workers comp starts paying your lost wages. But getting your wages paid is not different than having a covered compensable claim. You don't have to miss seven days to have a claim. You can miss seven minutes and have a claim. You don't even have to miss any work to have a claim. You can go from full duty to light duty and never miss one minute of work and still have a claim.
Kristine Callagy: Yeah. Yep.
Paolo Longo: So the whole, and I get this call a lot. mean, I don't know. I mean, I get a lot of these, these calls where like, they told me that if I didn't miss more than a week, I didn't have a case. And I'm like, Oh my God, you know, like, no, that is not, I just want to take out billboards and run them across I-10 and, know, up and down 95. You know, you don't have to, you don't have to be, you don't have to be out seven days, right? So I think that's an important, that's an important distinction.
Kristine Callagy: Everywhere,
Paolo Longo: Well, and that kind of ties us up into
another sort of ancillary topic is, if I'm out of work more than seven days, how am I getting paid? How am I getting paid? Who's paying me? That's a question we get. That's almost a daily, certainly weekly, but everyday question. How am I going to get paid?
Kristine Callagy: And that's another one that has that it depends caveat because it really depends on your agency. There are a lot of agencies that have the collective bargaining agreements that allow them to get full pay 100 % no matter what they're doing, no matter what the issue is, whether it's a heart bill or some other sort of injury, as long as they're out for workers come, you get 100 % pay, no interruption.
Paolo Longo: But that's only a certain time, right? I mean, that may be eight weeks or 10 weeks or 16 weeks. That's not indefinite though, right?
Kristine Callagy: Right. Yeah. And that's very dependent on what the CBA says as well. Some of them have 180 day limits, some of them have a two year limit. It really depends on how good your agency is negotiating the CBA, the union reps. And the follow up to that is when you don't have a CBA that says that, typically you would receive checks from Workers' Comm every two weeks. It's a 14 day scale, biweekly payments.
Paolo Longo: Right.
Kristine Callagy: and you would receive 66 and two thirds of your pre-injury earnings. And then if you want to get to 100 % pay, typically HR will supplement that with your leave time that you have in your bank so that you're not going without your mortgage and paying for your groceries or things for your kids, that sort of stuff, and also paying for your health insurance. That is another important distinction that we get a question a lot about on the leave time that people are using when they're out. Part of that is just to pay your portion of ⁓
Paolo Longo: Right, so essentially, regardless of a CBA, the comp is gonna pay two thirds and if you've got leave time or sick time or PTO time, you can use that to supplement the one third, so at least you're getting a full check. Some agencies have full pay status for 30 days, 60 days, 90 days, 180, however time it is, but assuming that's, even if you don't have that or if it runs out, comp's gonna pay
Kristine Callagy: Thank Correct.
Paolo Longo: two thirds, you know, and ⁓ you know, you're gonna supplement your own, you know, you don't have to use your sick time. I mean, I've got some guys that they don't have any sick time. So they're just getting, they're just getting the two thirds part, you know, and that'll motivate somebody to get back to work. But you know, sometimes if you have a surgery, can't, you can't, you gotta take the time off. ⁓ But, but we get that a lot, you know, how am I gonna get paid? Now there are some, you know, it's never gonna be a full, ⁓ you know, it's not always gonna be a full paycheck because comp pays, you know,
Kristine Callagy: All right, can't go back.
Paolo Longo: Most folks make more than the max comp rate. know, sort of there are some caps and there are some limits. Everybody's case is a little bit different. But in general, know, if you're gonna, you know, the seven day thing is only to get paid, not if you have a case. You don't have to miss seven days to have a case.
Kristine Callagy: Yeah, and then after you miss more than 21 days, they're supposed to go back and pay those first seven days anyway, but you've got to wait for those 21 days to pass before they do it. A lot of wonky rules and regulations we have in our system, that's for sure.
Paolo Longo: Right, right, right. Yep, 100%. Next question. ⁓ South Florida police officer, how do I actually report a claim? Is there any difference between reporting a claim for a heart case, an orthopedic case, a hearing loss case, or etc? That's a pretty good thought.
Kristine Callagy: it. No, I mean, yeah, that's a great question, but theoretically, they're all the same. So the way that you would do that is either through your supervisor or HR asking them to file what's called a notice of injury. And that's the official first form that goes up to the workers' comp carrier to let them know that you filed the claim. They open their file and start the process. Now, sometimes you'll get a supervisor that doesn't want to do it or doesn't know how to do it. And that's OK. I always tell people, tell them, hey, thanks. you know, I'll call you back and then we can do it. It's a very easy form to fill out. And some of them have, some agencies have a supervisor's report that will come along with that where you kind of got to fill out more detail about what happened. But the notice of injury is just kind of a bare bones, hey, on this date at this time, I was in the hospital for AFib or I had a heart attack. The language doesn't really matter too, too much as long as you're identifying what happened and what the issue is.
Paolo Longo: Right, right. But a lot of times, you know, I get this a lot, especially from, you know, central Florida and north, right? They don't want to fill out the forms, you know. So if you've got a supervisor, a boss, a chief, ⁓ you know, whatever you want to call it, that's not, you know, hip to the law. ⁓
Kristine Callagy: the
Paolo Longo: then what do you do? How do you report a claim? mean, are there magic words that you have to fill out? I mean, if somebody's not gonna do the form, and the person can't locate the specific worker's comp form, what's enough?
Kristine Callagy: Well, asking them to file it would be enough for notice like we were talking about before the timeframe to report it. Asking them to file it and putting them on notice verbally would be sufficient within your 90-day window or your 30-day window, whatever it may be for your type of injury. But actually doing the paperwork, if they refuse, then you're going to have to get somebody who is qualified to do that. So giving us a call, we can easily, I can do that for them in my sleep, you can do that for them in your sleep. It's a one page
PDF. We type on it and we can just send it in very easily. So if someone is getting pushed back, it's a very simple thing for us to do. Yeah.
Paolo Longo: Yeah, and I've done that. Yeah, we- Yeah, we've done that a hundred times. We fill out the form, we give it to the guy and have him go turn it into HR. Here you go. ⁓ Also, just sort of a side note, if you can get a copy of the injury report, get a copy of that ⁓ because I've seen those things ⁓ disappear, ⁓ jump into shredders.
Kristine Callagy: No. lit on fire.
Paolo Longo: I've heard every story. My client goes and reports the injury, they fill out the form, and then all of sudden the insurance company is like, well, the guy never reported it. We don't have a notice. like, well, my guy's got a copy. Here it is. ⁓ So you want to keep copies of that stuff ⁓ because also you want to make sure you want a copy to make sure that it's accurate. ⁓ They put the wrong dates. They put the wrong body part. put... something and then they try and use it against you that you're committing fraud by putting some other thing on there. ⁓ You know, any piece of paper that HR is gonna generate, you want a copy of, right, period. ⁓
Kristine Callagy: Yep. And double check your personal information too. I had a case years ago where the HR person transposed my client's social security number and two numbers in the social security and it wasn't in his file and they made that argument, ⁓ well he never reported it because it was in someone else's file.
Paolo Longo: Or I mean I could see them saying, know, try to throw a fraud defense out, know, by giving a, you know, a false or misleading, you know, information or something like that, you know. ⁓ Yeah, that's good point. never, never, I you can have my social security number, take my identity. ⁓ But that goes, so it's, you know, the question was, you know, heart or the period, hearing loss, any injury, it's the same, right? Does it matter what kind of injury it is?
Kristine Callagy: Right. Yeah. you No, it's all the same form, whether it's a heart case, whether it's hearing loss, whether it's a broken, peaking finger, it's all the same notice of injury form. It all goes on the same piece of paper.
Paolo Longo: Got it, got it, got it. This is a pretty simple one, but we get it a lot. In workers' comp, can I pick my own doctor?
Kristine Callagy: No, unfortunately, the answer to that is a big fat no. We wish that we could. It would be a lot easier. But the adjuster has control of the doctor that you see. And she also has control if you don't like your doctor and you exercise your one time change, the adjuster still gets to choose your doctor. No matter what the specialty is, they get to choose the doctor that you're seeing.
Paolo Longo: Right, right. mean, the short answer is no, you don't get to pick your doctor, right? I mean, there are some things you can do. I mean, if you... the reason is who pays picks, right? I mean, that's like, you know, that's like what you tell
your kids when you're going out for dinner, right? I'm buying, I'm picking the restaurant, right? mean, so if they're paying, you know, then they're picking. ⁓ You know, you do get it if you don't like the doctor.
Kristine Callagy: Thank
Paolo Longo: ⁓ You know, you do get to exercise your right to a one-time change. You know, you get a new pick, but again, you're not doing the picking and sometimes you can go from the frying pan into the fire with the new doctors. ⁓ You know, the one doctor that you can pick is an expert, right? I mean, if you go to one doctor and you don't like what their opinion or you disagree or they're recommending some course of treatment or something like that, ⁓ you have the right to select an independent medical examiner, right? Which is basically our own expert. we do get the right to pick that doctor because they are. Unfortunately, they're not in it for the long haul for treatment, ⁓ we do get to get their opinion ⁓ to, this surgery necessary or is this therapy necessary or is this treatment related or ⁓ it be better to do something else? So we do get some ⁓ back, ⁓ but the short answer is, do you get to pick your own doctors? No. ⁓ We did try, know, Jeff and I spent a lot of time in Tallahassee every year, and we've been pushing for ⁓ right to choose ⁓ on these, these heart bill claims. ⁓ You know, we haven't got a bill passed ⁓ yet, but we've got, we've been talking to some legislators who are willing to ⁓ sponsor this legislation for. ⁓ least on heart bill claims, know, on the presumption claims under 112.18 that to say, look, you know, these first responders are serious claims. They need to be able to choose their own doctors. There's not a lot of cardiologists around the state that will accept workers comp. So it gets to be difficult sometimes. mean, orthopedics, you you can, you can, you know, swing a branch anywhere and hit an orthopedic, you know, an E or a shoulder or a back guy, but you know, you're not. You're not going to see a lot of folks, you know, in the cardiology area that are, that are workers comp doctors, right? So, you know, a lot of times the carriers end up having to authorize, you know, our clients doctor anyway, because there's no one else to send them to. So we're working on some legislation, but you know, unfortunately the law as it sits right now, as of this, you know, podcast is you don't get to pick your own doctor, but that's a good question. And we get a lot of that. ⁓ And so there's no dumb question. Ask them.
Kristine Callagy: Exactly. There's never a dumb question when it comes to legal stuff. Yeah, that's true. Yep. 100%.
Paolo Longo: on. Yeah, there's only dumb answers, but no dumb quips. Yeah, yeah. Kind of related to this, ⁓ we get this question a lot too. Can I get gas money ⁓ for, you know, going to the doctor and medical related travel?
Kristine Callagy: answer to that is a little bit. ⁓ don't call it gas money. ⁓ call it mileage reimbursement. And so what you do is you fill
out a form and ⁓ a hundred different versions of the form. It doesn't really matter which form you use, but you track your starting location and your end location and then your end location back to your starting location for a round trip, total mileage amount for your trip to the doctor, your trip to physical therapy, your trip to the pharmacy.
Paolo Longo: Yeah
Kristine Callagy: Anywhere you're going for your workers' comp claim and you're using your own personal vehicle, you can get reimbursed at 44 and a half cents a mile, which is buttons compared to gas prices and the IRS rate, but that's what we're stuck with. In our statute, like Paula said, there's only stupid answers, no stupid questions. And you can get your tolls if you have a toll going to and from your doctor or your pharmacy and parking, some dark. Doctors, especially down in Miami, some of them have parking fees for the big office buildings or wherever they may be located. So as long as you've got receipts for all that, we can submit it all at one time and then they've got 45 days to pay you back.
Paolo Longo: Yeah, so I mean it's not really technically gas money. I mean they call it, you know medical mileage, but essentially it is gas money, right? I mean if you're going to a doctor's appointment a physical therapy appointment a medical test blood work even if you go to the pharmacy Right if you're driving back and forth to the pharmacy you get you know 45 cents a mile And and I always encourage my clients to do this, right? I mean look if all you're entitled to
Kristine Callagy: it.
Paolo Longo: under comp is a cup of coffee, let's get a full cup, right? So just do it. And sometimes, especially for my folks up in the panhandle, it may be 40 or 50 miles one way to the doctor, right? So mean, if you're driving an hour there and an hour back, 45, 50 cents a mile adds up. You might get 70 or 80 bucks for that trip. mean, at least that's gonna, I guess, cover your gas.
Kristine Callagy: Mm-hmm.
Paolo Longo: Now it is, you who knows, but you know, it does help. And so I always try to encourage my clients, you know, we'll send you the forms, you know, I mean, we got, we have them, you know, well, I used to have before, you know, PDFs, right? We just had stacks of them, you know, we just mail them to you. ⁓ But, but now, you know, we just email them and print them out all you want. You know, the one thing I will tell you is, you know, make sure if you're going to fill out a mileage form, you know, go to, you know, Waze or Google maps and put the exact 26.28 miles from your house to the doctor in back. Don't ballpark it, don't round up because you signed that form and you're misrepresenting, then you got problems with your claim. Don't round, just get a calculator and add the 28.26 miles times two there in back. Put the exact percentage point miles. And then, you know, send in the form and do it. And so, I mean, we've had some cases too, or I mean, we're talking about like thousands of dollars. We go back like a year, you know, somebody going to physical therapy three times a week for two years and they're like, oh, I could get mileage. And I'm like, here's a $4,000 mileage check, you know.
Kristine Callagy: Yeah, yeah, I had a guy who had a really, really old date of accident who came on with us as a new client and I was talking to him about mileage and tolls and he sent me his son passed report. It was like four years of tolls and I think probably like $4,000 just in tolls that we got him not including the mileage. He had no idea that he could even make a claim for that.
Paolo Longo: Yeah. And you know, that's going to piss an adjuster off. You know what I mean? And so and that's the totally that's like the icing on the cake. I mean, it's not even the 50 bucks for gas mileage. It's just making them, you know, write the check. You know, it's like, look, you know, you're dragging this guy, you know, 30 miles to a doctor and he probably passed 10 on the way to his doctor. Then, you know, you're going to you're going to pay him mileage. Now, kind of related to mileage is transportation. Right. So if if you and that wasn't really a technical
Kristine Callagy: ⁓ yeah, ⁓ yeah, and that's the best part. except
Paolo Longo: technically a question, I mean, it's kind of related. you know, lots of folks may not be able to drive after an injury. Okay. ⁓ So you can get transportation, right? If you need to go to physical therapy, if you need to go to a doctor's appointment, they will come and pick you up, ⁓ take you to the doctor, take you to therapy, do whatever you need to do, and then, and then, and then come home, you know, like I had like lots of ⁓ definitely after a bypass, you know, you're not driving, you know, for like six weeks, right? Because you've got that, you've got that big scar.
Kristine Callagy: Thank
Paolo Longo: and they don't want the seatbelt and all that stuff, you're not driving anywhere. And if your wife or spouse is working or they're gonna pick up kids and you can't get to an appointment, then the transportation will come and pick you up. mean, I've had cases where even... You know some pretty significant cases where guys had to do like aqua therapy water aerobic therapy, you know, because they couldn't really do walk yet. They had to do stuff in the water, you know, in a shuttle coming to pick them up every single day and take them to the pool and therapy and then take them home and do all that stuff back and forth. So not really in the same vein as mileage, but you know, it's also important to note in that in that area. ⁓
Kristine Callagy: There's specialty transportation too. I had a client who had a really bad back injury and neck injury and he wasn't able to drive, but he also wasn't able to sit up all the way. So we had to track down a very special mode of transportation, a very special company that could transport him laying down safely so that he wasn't stressing his neck and wasn't stressing his back. It
took a bit of time to find it, but the adjuster was able to do it. We got him there. We got him home safely and we were able to do that for the few months that he was on those restrictions.
Paolo Longo: Yeah, that's great. mean, so there are some benefits. mean, yeah, you get medical mileage. Yeah, you get transportation. ⁓ You know, those things are available. you know, unless you unless you know, you know, you're giving up a lot of stuff potentially, you know. ⁓ And then the last question I had for today, ⁓ this is a firefighter up in the Jacksonville area. ⁓ Does Workers' Comp really get access to all of my medical history?
Kristine Callagy: Right? And another, it depends. it, I don't know, they gave me this bar card and this degree. So I kind of have to, you know, pick up all the lingo, but the, depends. It's a caveat for mental health, right? So when you see those requests and the subpoenas come in from opposing counsel, where they're asking for people's medical records, unless your case is a mental health case, they are not allowed to access your mental health records.
Paolo Longo: He sounded like a lawyer, Christine. mean, this is really, it's...
Kristine Callagy: I will always object on that. The judges will always back us up on that. But if you've got a knee injury, they're going to go and get all of the medical records back to when you were born at the hospital if they can, right? They want to get everything in their ability to argue that your injury isn't work-related and use all of your history against you. And the statute says that workers' comp can do that. They can access your medical history once you make a claim. You kind of put that into fruition by making that.
Paolo Longo: Right. Yeah, but there are some limits, right? Like I'm not gonna, I'm gonna object to like dental records, right? You know, I mean, you're not getting my pediatrician records, you know. I've got a lot of, you know, female clients, right? Who, you know, may have a shoulder surgery or, you know, a knee injury. There's no need for, you know, gynecological records or, you know, birth stuff. I mean, that's not relevant. You know, so we're gonna fight. We're gonna fight that stuff. You know, unfortunately though, if you, for example, are making a PTSD claim, okay, or a mental health claim or anxiety, something like that, you know, then those records obviously are going to be relevant. So, you know, the answer to that question is they may not get everything, but if you're making a claim for a mental nervous injury like PTSD, then, you know, you were seeing a counselor for 10 years, then, you know, those records are going to be relevant and the judge is going to make us turn those over, right? Because in the neighborhood of the claim, right? mean, they're only gonna, ⁓ general rule is they're gonna have access to things that you're making a claim about, right? ⁓ mean, if you're making a shoulder case, ⁓ records are not gonna be relevant. ⁓ if you're making a knee claim, ⁓ health records are not ⁓ right? Dental records are not relevant. ⁓ We're gonna put up that stuff, but ⁓ gonna fight ⁓ those issues. But if you do make a claim for a specific injury, any relevant treatment that you've had is gonna have to, we're gonna have to turn those records over.
Kristine Callagy: Yeah, and with the mental health claims, typically the providers are going to require a supplemental release, even when the defense attorney sends a subpoena to the therapist or the psychiatrist, that provider is going to require a special release. And when I get those in, I look at them and I limit the timeframe because they'll have no end date in sight on that release. And I always make them edit it down to six months or three months, depending on what the issue is so that it's not. unfettered access to this person's mental health record forever and ever.
Paolo Longo: Right, right. No, that's a good point. That's a good point. So I think that's going to do it for us today. ⁓ If you found this episode to be of any help, please like, share, follow. You can reach us at ⁓ bicklerlaw.com on our website. can ⁓ email us at info at bicklerlaw.com. You can follow us on socials at Bickler Law. ⁓ We appreciate your listening and ⁓ as always, we thank you for what we do. Thank you, Christine, for... ⁓ for coming on today. You got it.
Kristine Callagy: Thanks for having me.