TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to Plan On It.
[0:07] Hello, everyone, and welcome to Plan On It
[0:10] with Attorney Christopher E. Botti Board Certified Specialists
[0:13] in a state planning, trust and probate law.
[0:16] Chris has more than 30 years of experience
[0:19] helping individuals and families plan for long-term care
[0:22] and protect what they've built.
[0:24] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today, Chris and I are talking
[0:27] about a planning strategy known as stack gifting
[0:32] and how it may fit into long-term care medical planning.
[0:36] Hi, Chris.
[0:37] Hey, Sean.
[0:38] Great to see you.
[0:38] Thank you for having me.
[0:39] Good to see you too.
[0:42] We were recently talking about medical and dealing
[0:46] with the sort of ins and outs of qualifying
[0:49] and managing your assets.
[0:50] And now, stack gifting, it sounds
[0:53] like it's something that can work in concert with that.
[0:57] Why don't you first just explain
[0:59] like what stack gifting is and why
[1:03] is it sort of come into prominence
[1:06] around planning strategy in California?
[1:10] OK.
[1:10] So stack gifting is truly a unique California experience, OK?
[1:15] No other state can you do what I'm about to explain.
[1:18] You can't do it, OK?
[1:19] So California is unique.
[1:21] And people, other elder law attorneys
[1:24] and other parts of the country think they're crazy out there
[1:27] because they can get away with something like this.
[1:29] And my attitude is, look, if there's
[1:30] a legally available strategy that can help protect my clients,
[1:34] I have an ethical application to deploy it.
[1:36] So what is stack gifting?
[1:37] Well, basically, it's the idea of making multiple transfers
[1:41] in such a way as to not cause or trigger what they call
[1:45] the lookback rules, which is the idea
[1:47] if you transfer assets out of your name.
[1:50] And properly, the state of California
[1:52] can say, look, you are doing that in contemplation
[1:55] of applying for medical.
[1:56] Therefore, we're going to penalize you
[1:58] because you made an improper gift.
[2:00] And so the whole idea with the stack gifting strategy
[2:03] is taking advantage of the rules of this.
[2:06] They currently exist, and they do.
[2:08] And they could change.
[2:10] But right now, they currently exist.
[2:11] And so we are going to continue to deploy this technique
[2:14] to allow transfers to occur.
[2:16] It kind of accelerates the process of getting rid of what
[2:19] I call excess resources.
[2:21] And by excess resources, I mean,
[2:23] resource above me on the eligibility criteria
[2:26] where you would fail the medical asset test
[2:28] because you have too many assets.
[2:30] This technique allows you to move assets quicker
[2:33] than otherwise could be done in other states.
[2:37] Well, and you and I spoke in a previous episode
[2:40] about sort of strategy behind the spend down.
[2:42] So this is clearly part of that conversation.
[2:47] Absolutely, right?
[2:49]
Load full transcript
Oh, yeah.
[2:49] It is definitely part of the spend down analysis.
[2:52] Yeah.
[2:53] And so how does, and you may have just answered this,
[2:57] hold on, how does stack gifting fit into the medical lookback
[3:01] and transfer rules?
[3:03] So basically, the way California assesses a penalty period
[3:07] is they say, OK, if you've given away more than what
[3:09] they call the average private pay rate at the nursing home
[3:13] in California, if you give over that amount and a given day,
[3:18] we're going to penalize you for that transfer.
[3:21] And we're going to take that gift and divide it,
[3:24] divide it by the average private pay rate.
[3:27] And we're going to come up with a number that equals how many
[3:29] months you're in eligible for medical.
[3:31] So the current average private pay rate in California
[3:35] is $14,440, right?
[3:38] So if you were to give someone $15,000,
[3:40] write them a check for $15,000, you would lose one month's
[3:44] of eligibility for medical.
[3:46] If you gave them $30,000, you would lose two months
[3:50] and so on and so on.
[3:51] So that's how the math works out.
[3:53] So with stack gifting, if you come in below the average private
[3:57] pay rate with a gift, then it does not trigger any penalty
[4:02] whatsoever because it's below the average private pay
[4:04] rate.
[4:04] So theoretically, you can give away each day $14,400
[4:11] without triggering any lookback penalty whatsoever.
[4:14] And so by stack gifting, we say we can consecutively
[4:16] make these gifts gifts every single day
[4:18] to the tune of $14,000.
[4:21] Well, we can round it down to $14,000 because we don't
[4:24] want to go over that.
[4:25] So we're going to give away $14,000 each day
[4:28] until we get our excess resources below the threshold
[4:32] so we can qualify for medical.
[4:34] And that's basically how stack gifting works.
[4:36] Is there an annual cap on that kind of a thing?
[4:39] No.
[4:40] There is no one.
[4:41] No cap.
[4:41] So if you've got, let me just say a bottomless pot of cash,
[4:47] you can just give $14,000 away every day,
[4:50] and it won't sound any alarms.
[4:53] No, because the question is, should you do it?
[4:57] That's a whole other issue.
[4:58] If you have enough resources to private pay for care
[5:01] and get the best facilities, you're going to have to do it.
[5:04] Exactly.
[5:05] Yeah, but I have a bottomless barrel of cash.
[5:10] I'm not dealing with this at all.
[5:12] I'm just paying probably, and it's all good.
[5:15] Yeah.
[5:16] And so most people, when I explain the concept to them,
[5:19] they think somehow we're like, this is something
[5:22] that we're not going to disclose to the state of California.
[5:24] And somehow we're doing this on the DL, so to speak.
[5:27] And we're not going to, you know,
[5:29] we're trying to get around some rules.
[5:31] And the answer is absolutely not.
[5:32] When we do this, we disclose everything we do to the state
[5:37] and
say, look, these are the rules.
[5:38] You allow for this kind of planning.
[5:41] We are doing this kind of planning.
[5:42] We're going to document everything
[5:43] we've done to the state of California.
[5:44] We're going to disclose the stack gifting
[5:46] that we've completed in our application.
[5:49] And there's nothing they can do about it.
[5:51] So it's full transparency here.
[5:53] And so that's the beautiful thing about this.
[5:56] And so is that, you know, is that 14K
[6:01] that I've gifted to, you know, my daughter?
[6:06] Is that taxable on her end?
[6:08] Like we're reporting everything, right?
[6:10] Is that now income for her?
[6:12] That's a great question, actually.
[6:14] And so there's a limit.
[6:17] It's called your annual exclusion amount.
[6:19] This is the amount the IRS says,
[6:20] you can give away per year tax 40 without having to report it.
[6:23] And that number is $19,000.
[6:26] Now, yeah, you can give away during your lifetime
[6:30] currently $15 million.
[6:32] And if you have a $15 million state,
[6:34] you're not doing medical planning, I'm sorry.
[6:36] I mean, you just don't need to.
[6:38] It's ridiculous, right?
[6:39] You can probably pay.
[6:40] So yeah, if you went over that, like if you, you know,
[6:43] using the stack gifting approach, for example,
[6:45] and the aggregate value of all the gifts you've made
[6:47] exceed that $19,000 a number, okay?
[6:51] If you just gave it to them outright,
[6:53] then that would be something you'd have to report
[6:55] to the IRS using Form 709, which is a federal gift tax return.
[6:59] However, okay, this is where the medical asset protection
[7:03] trust comes in the plate.
[7:04] If you would have transferred that money,
[7:06] instead of outright to someone
[7:08] to the medical asset protection trust,
[7:11] that's called a, and this is a tax planning
[7:13] term of our potentially defective grant or trust,
[7:15] which means the IRS considers it's still your asset
[7:19] for ownership purposes.
[7:20] So it's not a reportable gift.
[7:23] Yet, the state of California does not consider a resource
[7:26] for eligibility purposes.
[7:28] So those types of trust, and I know that's a whole separate
[7:30] pocket, we can go into the weeds on this.
[7:33] But like the bottom line is the medical asset protection
[7:35] trust, transferring using the stack gifting technique
[7:39] to that type of trust would avoid the need to report
[7:41] to the IRS.
[7:44] Okay.
[7:44] Why isn't stack gifting simply the same as just giving assets
[7:48] a way to family members, right?
[7:49] Like that distinction is in what you just said, isn't it?
[7:55] It's the amount, it's the amount.
[7:56] So it comes down to, how much are you giving away?
[7:57] How much are you transferring?
[7:59] If you do it below the average private pay rate,
[8:02] which round down to $14,000 for some pleasantly stake,
[8:06] you're fine.
[8:08] But if you go over that, then you're creating a
spirit
[8:10] of an eligibility and a lot of potential benefits.
[8:13] And so that's the idea.
[8:15] And so we call it stack gifting
[8:16] because you literally are consecutively making gifts
[8:19] on a daily basis.
[8:20] And the rule is, if you write a check,
[8:23] that check must clear.
[8:24] And the next check can't clear on the same day.
[8:26] It has to clear on a different day.
[8:28] If it clears on the same day, you've got a problem.
[8:30] You can fix it, but you've got a problem.
[8:32] Yeah, I hear you.
[8:33] I hear you.
[8:34] And so we're kind of talking about cash here in a way.
[8:36] I mean, does stack gifting apply to all assets
[8:39] or certain types of property?
[8:41] How does that work?
[8:43] Well, in theory, it could apply to real estate.
[8:45] But with real estate, you would have
[8:46] to do fractional deeds.
[8:47] And that raises, that's a very difficult thing
[8:50] to do logistically.
[8:52] We prefer using cash assets for this technique,
[8:54] but you can theoretically do it with real estate.
[8:56] But every time you prepare a deed,
[8:58] a fractional ownership interest needs,
[9:01] it's going to trigger recording fees
[9:02] in a reassessment for a tensile property tax purposes.
[9:05] So it's not attractive to use things like real estate,
[9:09] but you can't.
[9:10] But if it's desert land not worth much,
[9:14] yeah, that's easy to do.
[9:15] But if it's something substantial, that's
[9:17] a more problematic.
[9:17] But it really lends itself to cash or security.
[9:21] So with securities, we're not going
[9:23] to trigger a liquidating event, which
[9:26] would cause capital gains tax as potential to be owed.
[9:28] It's what you're going to do as an in-kind transfer.
[9:31] So you're not going to sell.
[9:32] You're going to transfer a fractional ownership interest
[9:35] in a security through this technique.
[9:37] And it doesn't trigger any capital gains tax.
[9:40] OK.
[9:40] All right.
[9:41] And why do you recommend using the irrevocable, irrevocable
[9:46] medical asset preservation trust instead
[9:50] of making outright gifts to the kids?
[9:52] Yeah.
[9:53] There's three main reasons.
[9:55] And the first is control.
[9:57] If you just deflate out would just gift assets to your children,
[10:00] you've now lost control.
[10:02] It's theirs.
[10:02] Now they may honor your wishes
[10:04] and do what you say to do with the money.
[10:06] But theoretically, they can do anything they want with it.
[10:09] And if they get into trouble financially,
[10:11] they get sued if they get through a divorce,
[10:12] so their creditors can kind of have that money.
[10:14] So with the medical asset protection trust,
[10:16] you maintain two really critically important elements
[10:19] of control.
[10:20] One is the power to change trustee.
[10:22] So you can change who's in charge of the trust.
[10:25] And so if your trustee's not doing a good job,
[10:27] you can theoretically fire them in the point
[10:29] to a whole new set of trustees.
[10:31] And the other thing you're maintaining control over
[10:33] is the ability to say where it goes when you die.
[10:36] You can modify those provisions,
[10:38] even though the trust is irrevocable,
[10:40] it's irrevocable which strengths.
[10:42] And so you're maintaining control over who's in charge,
[10:46] and you're maintaining control over who gets what part.
[10:48] And those assets don't transfer until you're no longer with us.
[10:51] So it doesn't occur until you pass on.
[10:54] That's the biggest reason.
[10:55] And there's other secondary reasons too.
[10:58] Okay.
[10:59] I mean, stack gifting is, I mean,
[11:01] it sounds partially a little bit of it.
[11:04] It's got some silver bullet qualities to it.
[11:06] But are there other situations
[11:08] where you wouldn't recommend it?
[11:10] Well, again, it comes down to,
[11:13] well, let's take a step back.
[11:14] When you do this kind of planning,
[11:15] it's pretty aggressive planning, right?
[11:17] And so if you're relying upon a power of attorney
[11:20] to do this kind of planning
[11:21] because someone's already incapacitated,
[11:23] then if you don't have expressed language in that paperwork,
[11:26] the power of attorney that allows this kind of gifting
[11:28] to occur,
[11:29] you can't do it.
[11:30] It's illegal essentially.
[11:31] So like, I wouldn't recommend,
[11:33] I wouldn't do it in a situation
[11:35] where you can have the authority to do so.
[11:36] So if you're doing it for yourself, that's easy.
[11:38] You could interview the client and say,
[11:40] okay, do you understand the consequences
[11:41] of what you're doing?
[11:42] You're making all these transfers.
[11:44] We're doing it for this reason.
[11:45] And they're like, yes, I want to do that.
[11:46] That's easy.
[11:47] But when you get into a situation where you're relying upon
[11:50] powers of attorney to do this kind of gifting,
[11:52] which you can, that's what powers of attorney are for,
[11:55] you have to have baked into the documents,
[11:57] expressed language to allow this planning to occur.
[12:00] And that's what I call my e-book,
[12:02] long-term care compliant documents.
[12:04] You can't do this without the power to do so.
[12:07] These are self-dealing powers.
[12:10] These are, and so without expressed language,
[12:12] you're dead in the water.
[12:13] And so, and then sometimes it's not suitable.
[12:16] They family, they don't, for whatever reason,
[12:18] it's just they don't want to go through this process.
[12:20] I get that.
[12:21] And so they don't do it.
[12:23] But for most people, once they understand it,
[12:26] they see the value.
[12:27] And if they're a suitable candidate for medical planning,
[12:30] then we move forward with this technique.
[12:32] OK, let's inevitably, right?
[12:34] We got to talk about some downsides, mistakes, right?
[12:37] Are there mistakes that can jeopardize a stack gifting
[12:42]
strategy or even create problems with eligibility?
[12:47] Well, yeah, the biggest mistake people make
[12:49] is they don't apply the rules correctly,
[12:51] and they give too much at once, right?
[12:53] And then you've got a situation where
[12:55] you've got a penalty period being imposed,
[12:57] and now you've got to wait in order to that penalty period
[13:00] to run before you can tap into the program.
[13:02] That's probably the biggest mistake.
[13:04] And that would only happen if you try to do it yourself,
[13:06] and it realized the consequences of doing that.
[13:09] So quick question.
[13:11] Yeah.
[13:12] Quick question on that.
[13:13] OK, we made a mistake, we shifted too much money,
[13:16] and there's a, based on the amount,
[13:18] it was a two month penalty.
[13:20] I mean, essentially, the ramifications there
[13:22] are I'm going to be paying out a pocket for two months.
[13:26] Right.
[13:27] If I want to avail myself of whatever services
[13:30] I'm hoping that Medi-Cal will cover.
[13:33] Correct.
[13:34] OK, that's a $30,000 mistake.
[13:36] Yeah, OK, that's a pretty big mistake.
[13:38] And that's a little, I mean, in the grand speed,
[13:41] it's a lot of money.
[13:42] Don't get me wrong, but I've had people come to me,
[13:44] and it just happened recently, where someone gave their son
[13:48] money to purchase a home, and they wrote a big fat check.
[13:52] And they got to me and say, hey, look,
[13:54] I'm interested in Medi-Cal planning.
[13:55] I go, do you make any transfers for the last 30 months?
[13:57] Because that's the basically lookback period 30 months back.
[14:01] Stay could look back for a few months.
[14:03] And they said, yes, just recently, we wrote our check,
[14:06] a check for our son in excess of $200,000.
[14:09] I'm like, wow, that's a big mistake.
[14:11] That's a big flag, a big flag.
[14:14] We can fix it, OK?
[14:15] And so what we had to do is have the son transfer the money back
[14:18] to the parent, and basically, so it landed back into their account.
[14:22] And then, using the stack gifting technique,
[14:24] you can transfer the money back to the child the correct way.
[14:28] And so mistakes can be fixed, but you don't want to make them
[14:33] if you can avoid them.
[14:34] Yeah, you got to pay to unravel it, too.
[14:38] In that story, I mean, really no one's the wise
[14:44] that that $200K went and came back, right?
[14:49] And because, or is it like, no, yeah, we made a mistake.
[14:52] We meant to do a stack gift.
[14:54] Well, exactly, again, full transparency, full disclosure,
[14:57] everything we do, when you go through the process
[15:00] of submitting an application, there's a verification process.
[15:03] And so the counties are going to want to look back and say,
[15:06] OK, they have a right to go back 30 months.
[15:08] What transfers occurred during this 31th period?
[15:10] And you must disclose that to them.
[15:12] So we're going to disclose, yes, there was
an improper transfer.
[15:14] However, it landed back into the account.
[15:16] Here's proof.
[15:17] OK, so you see the donor now?
[15:19] Here's the paper trail.
[15:20] And then from there, we're deploying stack
[15:23] gifting to transfer it back out correctly.
[15:26] And you disclose this to the state of California.
[15:28] And it's not a problem.
[15:31] All right, I like that.
[15:33] And we've just got a couple of minutes left.
[15:35] And I don't know if I missed this in our back and forth here.
[15:38] But why is it so important to explore the stack gifting option
[15:43] before there's an immediate need, say, for long term care
[15:47] or some other issue?
[15:48] Well, again, it comes down like I like to use the analogy
[15:51] of landing strip, right?
[15:52] The longer the landing strip, the less
[15:54] hectic the environment is when deploying these techniques,
[15:57] particularly when it comes to like securities, right?
[15:59] Like the transfer securities in kind
[16:01] without churning capital gains is a coordinated effort.
[16:04] And like when you have an immediate need,
[16:06] like an urgent situation where there's a crisis, right?
[16:09] You got to move quick, right?
[16:10] And it's quickly humanly possible.
[16:13] But it's better to like look at it
[16:15] down like with a long term approach, OK?
[16:17] And say, OK, we don't need it now.
[16:20] But in a year, I have a diagnosis of Alzheimer's, for example.
[16:23] And I know where we know where this is ultimately going.
[16:26] It's really sad, but you know where it's going to end up going.
[16:29] So you can start displaying process a lot sooner
[16:31] in a more methodical, measured way, less stressful.
[16:35] And get to the point where deploying that technique,
[16:38] you can get someone qualified.
[16:39] You may not even need to do it.
[16:41] You only, again, we only deploy this technique
[16:43] when you have excess resources.
[16:44] There are plenty of people who come to me
[16:47] and they just need help getting qualified from medical.
[16:49] And they don't know the rules.
[16:50] They don't know how difficult it is to navigate that.
[16:53] And they don't need to do this.
[16:54] It's the ones who have excess resources.
[16:57] And it's one of the many options you have.
[16:59] You can also take those excess resources.
[17:01] Instead of stack gifting, you can, I said, pay off the mortgage, right?
[17:04] Yeah, you've been a part of your use.
[17:06] There's other things you can do.
[17:08] It is not the first and first go to all the time.
[17:11] You know, it's an analysis, right?
[17:13] What's in the best interest of this family?
[17:15] Is it better to pay down debt, to fix the bathrooms?
[17:19] So there's, you know, they,
[17:20] while they're still at home, they have, you know,
[17:22] easier access for use of the home facilities.
[17:25] And so it's not just rush me to stack gifting.
[17:28] I want to make sure that everybody understands that.
[17:29] That is not like, okay, we're going,
[17:31] that's not the starting point.
[17:32] That's just one of many different techniques we deploy, right?
[17:35] It's just a very unique to California.
[17:38] That's why I wanted to highlight this in the podcast
[17:40] is because another state, can you do this?
[17:42] And so it needs to be explained.
[17:45] And it is just a tool in the arsenal.
[17:48] It's not the only tool.
[17:50] Got it, loud and clear.
[17:51] Yeah, I love that.
[17:54] Yeah, especially, you know, just like in the example
[17:58] you've got a diagnosis, you know,
[18:00] you're probably going to deteriorate
[18:01] over a certain amount of months or years
[18:04] and that idea of like, hey, well, let's get the ramp built.
[18:08] Let's do the AD, all that sort of home improvement stuff.
[18:11] And you know, that's, that's got to bring some peace of mind.
[18:15] Awesome.
[18:16] Chris, great conversation.
[18:17] Thanks for sharing the, the nuances of this.
[18:20] I get, I get it, that's complicated,
[18:22] but you made it understandable.
[18:24] And I appreciate that.
[18:26] I'll talk to you soon.
[18:28] Take care.
[18:29] Thank you so much.
[18:30] You bet.
[18:30] That's it for today's episode of Plan On It
[18:33] with Attorney Christopher Bonnie.
[18:35] If you want to access more resources, including Chris's
[18:38] 2026 medical ebook and upcoming estate planning workshops,
[18:43] visit his website, bottilaw.com.
[18:46] Thanks for listening.
[18:48] And it's helpful for others to find us.
[18:51] If you leave us a review, subscribe, share a link.
[18:55] The algorithms love that and we appreciate it.
[18:58] I'm Sean O'Connor.
[18:59] Have a great day.
[19:05] If you're enjoying Plan On It, be sure to subscribe.
[19:08] Leave us a five-star review and like the post.
[19:11] Share or tag friends and family who could benefit
[19:13] from clear, practical estate planning guidance.