TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
1
00:00:02,986 --> 00:00:05,546
Carla: So I could feel the presence of all the people.
2
00:00:06,361 --> 00:00:07,921
Everybody on the earth.
3
00:00:07,921 --> 00:00:11,860
It was so weird, and what was crazy was all of a sudden, like,
4
00:00:11,860 --> 00:00:20,748
my eyes open and I was just like basking in this insane love for everyone, for the whole experience on this planet.
5
00:00:21,759 --> 00:00:26,229
But so what, that's my big question all the time.
6
00:00:26,229 --> 00:00:27,011
So what.
7
00:00:27,011 --> 00:00:31,169
So I had like the explosive love experience, you know, so what.
8
00:00:32,584 --> 00:00:34,354
How does that change somebody's life?
9
00:00:34,864 --> 00:00:40,236
Oshan: Throughout this series, I've described pivot points as someone's first transformative meditation experience.
10
00:00:41,029 --> 00:00:48,055
But something that almost everyone reported is that whatever happens during these experiences, it always comes to an end.
11
00:00:48,633 --> 00:00:50,061
And usually pretty quickly.
12
00:00:50,971 --> 00:00:57,152
No matter how explosive the love or bliss, no matter how deeply your awareness unhooks from its habits,
13
00:00:57,625 --> 00:01:00,917
everyone winds up back on the doorstep of their familiar selves.
14
00:01:02,301 --> 00:01:05,658
So what's actually transformative about a pivot point?
15
00:01:06,413 --> 00:01:08,467
What, if anything, actually changes?
16
00:01:09,207 --> 00:01:14,112
Are they just flashes of experience that disappear without a trace, or do they leave a mark?
17
00:01:16,204 --> 00:01:20,140
I'm Oshan Jarow, and this is the final episode of Pivot Points.
18
00:01:29,746 --> 00:01:37,426
Remember the journalist Claudia, who had that experience of the little person sitting behind her eyeballs, anchoring her first-person perspective,
19
00:01:37,426 --> 00:01:43,354
getting knocked loose and sinking back to join what she described as the cavernous blackness of the rest of her being?
20
00:01:44,349 --> 00:01:46,546
For a few days afterwards, she felt incredible.
21
00:01:47,206 --> 00:01:53,905
Claudia: I would just be like walking around in my house and like looking at trees and just felt like this incredible sense of oneness,
22
00:01:53,905 --> 00:01:56,826
which sounds like cringe and dumb, but that's how it felt.
23
00:01:57,696 --> 00:02:00,606
And yeah, I said this afterglow that lasted days.
24
00:02:01,048 --> 00:02:03,667
Oshan: The afterglow faded, but something did stick around.
25
00:02:04,294 --> 00:02:08,359
Claudia: I would describe it as a shift that anchored a permanent change.
26
00:02:08,503 --> 00:02:14,233
I didn't remain in that kind of like, very enhanced state of just crying with joy.
27
00:02:14,233 --> 00:02:18,673
Like I don't wake up on a Monday morning crying tears of joy, maybe one day.
28
00:02:19,123 --> 00:02:26,335
But having that felt embodied experience of it gave me this permanent shift where I've ever since just.
29
00:02:26,995 --> 00:02:31,375
Just kind of held the sense of like self just a lot more lightly.
30
00:02:31,715 --> 00:02:37,175
I just feel that sense of like my identity as a separate person.
31
00:02:37,235 --> 00:02:38,855
I just feel it's a bit lighter.
32
00:02:38,885 --> 00:02:45,605
I feel I can take it a bit less seriously and I feel I can take the world a bit less personally.
33
00:02:46,301 --> 00:02:52,403
Oshan: A similar thing happened to Max, who we met in episode two when he stumbled into the tingling pleasure of the first jhana while driving.
34
00:02:53,179 --> 00:02:58,434
Subsequently, he went on a meditation retreat, and he described this same kind of afterglow.
35
00:02:59,222 --> 00:03:05,111
Max: You get like this floating on cloud nine kind of quality, where suddenly you are at work and it's super stressful,
36
00:03:05,111 --> 00:03:07,231
but you're not buffered by it at all.
37
00:03:07,261 --> 00:03:13,041
You're just floating through the world and seeing the birds up in the trees and it's just very nice.
38
00:03:13,371 --> 00:03:17,297
Like for the first, I think day and a half or so after retreat,
39
00:03:17,297 --> 00:03:22,939
I had a very hard time To not chatting up random strangers at the airport and stuff like that.
40
00:03:23,369 --> 00:03:25,109
That was a bit of a harsh come down.
41
00:03:25,609 --> 00:03:34,787
But I still felt like traces of that openness of that like just extreme ease, just suffusing my day-to-day life.
42
00:03:34,817 --> 00:03:40,443
I was suddenly, worry-free and happy in a way that I hadn't been really before.
43
00:03:42,140 --> 00:03:45,687
Oshan: Cloud nine didn't last forever, but something subtle had changed.
44
00:03:46,068 --> 00:03:53,659
Max: There's a definite difference between before and after in the sense that,
45
00:03:53,659 --> 00:04:03,548
at least for my feeling of what normalcy meant in terms of psychological health and,
46
00:04:03,548 --> 00:04:07,208
how easy life can feel and how happy one can be on average.
47
00:04:07,568 --> 00:04:10,118
Like that kind of changed.
48
00:04:10,978 --> 00:04:13,316
Oshan: I heard this same pattern over and over again.
49
00:04:13,968 --> 00:04:18,996
The most intense features of someone's pivot point, that part of the experience always came to an end.
50
00:04:19,622 --> 00:04:25,471
No one's pivot point just permanently locked them into a perpetual state of bliss or non-dual selfless awareness.
51
00:04:25,971 --> 00:04:32,862
But there were often subtler lasting changes, like the sense of levity or ease that Claudia and Max described.
52
00:04:34,225 --> 00:04:36,950
That said, there were interesting exceptions.
53
00:04:37,597 --> 00:04:40,459
My favorite example was from the engineering professor, Sean.
54
00:04:40,996 --> 00:04:45,128
He had that experience of losing a sense of self while walking along the Charles River.
55
00:04:45,874 --> 00:04:55,209
Sean: It was an extremely positive element in the sense that I really just love
Load full transcript
understanding how the world or the universe or life works.
56
00:04:55,389 --> 00:04:58,299
And this was a huge clicking of like, ah, there.
57
00:04:58,974 --> 00:05:04,584
But to be frank about it in terms of practical utility to my life, almost zero.
58
00:05:04,684 --> 00:05:06,064
It's like this fun party trick.
59
00:05:06,514 --> 00:05:09,724
He said it's one that I can't even show someone else 'cause it's purely subjective.
60
00:05:09,724 --> 00:05:11,614
So it's a fun party trick that no one else can even see.
61
00:05:11,714 --> 00:05:13,514
It's really interesting.
62
00:05:13,724 --> 00:05:19,869
It's deeply satisfying because it starts to connect some dots that I've had my whole life
63
00:05:19,869 --> 00:05:26,924
that I haven't been able to figure out how to connect, but hasn't actually changed much of anything about my lived experience.
64
00:05:28,038 --> 00:05:31,192
Oshan: Except one thing did change, and pretty significantly.
65
00:05:31,944 --> 00:05:34,155
He started meditating a lot more.
66
00:05:35,047 --> 00:05:39,615
So much so that he started putting fake meetings on his calendar just to make sure he got the time to meditate.
67
00:05:40,240 --> 00:05:44,697
And this motivation spike is one of the most common effects I heard across all the different stories.
68
00:05:45,260 --> 00:05:48,402
After a pivot point, people get really excited to meditate.
69
00:05:49,113 --> 00:05:51,268
There's this breathless sense of discovery.
70
00:05:52,031 --> 00:05:55,851
Something is happening in their meditation practice that they really want to explore.
71
00:05:56,211 --> 00:06:03,106
Emily: That like really kickstarted me to just do more as much, much more meditation as I could.
72
00:06:03,816 --> 00:06:10,696
Santtu: Without that experience, I probably would not have taken up two hours per day of sitting afterwards and would not have stuck with it.
73
00:06:11,137 --> 00:06:13,347
Colin: And it sort of gets a snowball effect, right?
74
00:06:13,407 --> 00:06:13,957
Quite quickly.
75
00:06:13,957 --> 00:06:20,937
Like, it's interesting, and then you wanna do more, and it gets, more interesting, and you wanna do more, and it gets sort of self-reinforcing.
76
00:06:22,257 --> 00:06:27,197
Oshan: There was something really interesting about the flavor of motivation that spiked after a pivot point.
77
00:06:27,717 --> 00:06:32,271
It wasn't just more willpower for people to discipline themselves into meditating more.
78
00:06:32,944 --> 00:06:38,712
The motivation came from a shift in how they thought about their practice, the kind of thing that their practice was.
79
00:06:39,514 --> 00:06:42,689
It was like meditation went from a chore to an adventure.
80
00:06:43,357 --> 00:06:47,523
People who started with an abstract idea that they should or ought to meditate
81
00:06:47,551 --> 00:06:53,755
because they've been told it's good for them came out with a curiosity that made them genuinely excited to meditate.
82
00:06:54,939 --> 00:06:58,323
And this is where I started to see what I mentioned at the end of last episode,
83
00:06:58,323 --> 00:07:09,715
pivot points as the beginnings of what meditators call a path Meditators have described practice as a path for millennia.
84
00:07:10,344 --> 00:07:15,579
The Buddha himself taught meditation as one part of the Eightfold Path towards enlightenment.
85
00:07:16,068 --> 00:07:25,347
And that tells us something about why Buddhists caution against these flashy and potentially distracting experiences like pivot points Distractions from what?
86
00:07:26,143 --> 00:07:26,678
The path.
87
00:07:27,398 --> 00:07:32,527
You're supposed to keep moving towards enlightenment, not go off on some side quest of blissful altered states.
88
00:07:33,540 --> 00:07:38,476
This is the way that Matt, the Midwestern lawyer we've heard from, learned after studying with Buddhist teachers.
89
00:07:39,109 --> 00:07:42,199
Matt: These big experiences are both important and unimportant.
90
00:07:42,469 --> 00:07:46,249
It's important because you can see it, you know, the proof of the pudding is in the eating.
91
00:07:46,649 --> 00:07:47,519
And you've tasted it.
92
00:07:47,867 --> 00:07:55,348
I think it's good because it shows you the possibility of what experience can be.
93
00:07:56,024 --> 00:07:58,244
I've heard them explained as, they're like signposts.
94
00:07:58,244 --> 00:08:04,730
You're, you're driving somewhere and you see a sign and you go into Albuquerque and the sign says, Albuquerque, 50 miles this way.
95
00:08:05,201 --> 00:08:06,482
So, that's good.
96
00:08:06,482 --> 00:08:07,849
You're getting closer to Albuquerque.
97
00:08:07,849 --> 00:08:09,709
And then Albuquerque, 25 miles away.
98
00:08:09,739 --> 00:08:16,639
You don't get out of the car and then grab the sign and then try to try to hold onto it in perpetuity.
99
00:08:16,639 --> 00:08:19,969
It's just saying, you know, if they arise, you're going the right way.
100
00:08:20,359 --> 00:08:23,919
So I think that it's important and it's incredibly motivating.
101
00:08:24,319 --> 00:08:28,119
But it's also can be just another thing to clinging onto.
102
00:08:28,799 --> 00:08:31,391
Oshan: The majority of people I interviewed were not Buddhists,
103
00:08:31,736 --> 00:08:37,337
and they didn't go into having their pivot points already thinking of meditation in terms of being a path.
104
00:08:38,399 --> 00:08:43,090
And yet, the experiences they had still tended to point beyond themselves.
105
00:08:43,920 --> 00:08:51,666
Sometimes people do get fixated on having the same experience, the same pivot point again and again, though usually that burns itself out.
106
00:08:52,282 --> 00:08:59,620
But more often, pivot points created an interest in what more experience could become, what else meditation could do.
107
00:09:00,418 --> 00:09:06,688
People came out of Pivot Points with a sense of wanting to go explore, with a sense that there is a path to go explore.
108
00:09:07,409 --> 00:09:12,599
Alejandro: It's almost like you were in a beautiful cave, like surrounded with, you know, treasure and all this stuff,
109
00:09:12,599 --> 00:09:17,206
but you were only got to be there for a couple minutes, you know, you wanna go in there and see what else is there.
110
00:09:17,961 --> 00:09:20,315
Oshan: That was a Kansas-based DJ named Alejandro.
111
00:09:20,940 --> 00:09:25,699
And notice that the thing he's picking out is not the treasure he found in the experience he had.
112
00:09:26,223 --> 00:09:29,109
It was his curiosity as to what else is in the cave.
113
00:09:30,403 --> 00:09:35,505
Claudia discussed her experience with a teacher at a local zendo and came away with a similar feeling.
114
00:09:36,042 --> 00:09:41,442
Claudia: He was like, imagine there's this massive, massive, massive pane of glass that's all fogged up.
115
00:09:41,802 --> 00:09:45,642
You've just rubbed a little corner in this foggy pane of glass and now that's clear.
116
00:09:45,642 --> 00:09:49,832
And he was like, now your job is to rub more of the pane of glass and more of the pane of glass
117
00:09:49,832 --> 00:09:50,852
and more of the pane of glass.
118
00:09:51,932 --> 00:09:54,422
And I found that super helpful because I was like, okay, cool.
119
00:09:54,422 --> 00:10:00,153
Like I had been fortunate enough to kind of like stumble into this amazing experience
120
00:10:00,153 --> 00:10:03,317
and now my job is to just keep trying with it.
121
00:10:03,906 --> 00:10:08,100
Oshan: She picked up that same open-ended interest and told me that from there on,
122
00:10:08,100 --> 00:10:11,574
she started sitting for 30 minutes a day just to see what happens.
123
00:10:12,235 --> 00:10:15,532
And again, with Tobin, the exterminator living out in British Columbia.
124
00:10:16,054 --> 00:10:18,479
Tobin: After that it was, curiosity took me.
125
00:10:18,730 --> 00:10:21,190
I was wanting to learn everything I could.
126
00:10:21,710 --> 00:10:26,570
I'd realized that I've learned something that I assumed I already knew.
127
00:10:26,810 --> 00:10:34,400
I assumed I was completely aware of how my body was and how my, my mind worked and where my, what my experience was like.
128
00:10:34,400 --> 00:10:40,130
So I realizing that there was another way of approaching my experience,
129
00:10:40,130 --> 00:10:44,810
I got very fascinated and I needed to I needed to explore it as much as I could.
130
00:10:45,409 --> 00:10:48,489
Oshan: These experiences didn't create mild curiosities.
131
00:10:49,063 --> 00:10:56,790
The sense of a path and a more exploratory relationship to meditation also has this quality of depth and importance.
132
00:10:57,142 --> 00:10:58,552
It feels significant.
133
00:10:59,065 --> 00:11:01,006
Here's Stuart, the UK-based filmmaker.
134
00:11:01,633 --> 00:11:05,923
Stuart: It felt to me as though what I had experienced was very authentic and very sincere.
135
00:11:06,323 --> 00:11:12,613
I really would
say that it was as though from that point onwards, I thought this.
136
00:11:12,613 --> 00:11:16,633
Will inevitably be a sort of facet of my existence.
137
00:11:16,753 --> 00:11:23,963
A component of my main interest will be exploring why this was the way it was and so I just launched into the practice.
138
00:11:24,383 --> 00:11:28,913
And yeah, and then it's led me down this path over the last sort of six years.
139
00:11:31,569 --> 00:11:33,115
Oshan: If I had another five episodes,
140
00:11:33,115 --> 00:11:39,102
we could look at where these paths seem to go and what other treasures people do find out in those beautiful caves.
141
00:11:39,556 --> 00:11:44,177
But in terms of pivot points, what matters is that they're inaugural experiences.
142
00:11:44,876 --> 00:11:52,245
They recast the whole project of meditation as doing something or going somewhere that just wasn't on your map of the mind beforehand.
143
00:11:58,062 --> 00:12:03,544
If you have a pivot point that launches you into the world of deep meditation, the whole thing seems to open up.
144
00:12:04,218 --> 00:12:07,692
Motivation swells, intrigue abounds, a path appears.
145
00:12:08,483 --> 00:12:14,166
But tens of millions of Americans try meditation every year, and far more across the Western world,
146
00:12:14,753 --> 00:12:18,280
and we do not have millions of meditators experiencing pivot points.
147
00:12:19,344 --> 00:12:24,105
Instead, the terrain of beginner's meditation, as we've heard, can feel like a boring or difficult chore.
148
00:12:25,266 --> 00:12:29,481
Sometimes people have pivot points pretty quickly, and sometimes it could take years.
149
00:12:29,943 --> 00:12:37,113
Matt: But I would say at least for the first five years, meditation was difficult, it was boring, it was not fun.
150
00:12:37,573 --> 00:12:42,843
Going through those beginner stages was really difficult and I really salute anybody who can do that.
151
00:12:43,023 --> 00:12:44,193
'cause it's very hard.
152
00:12:44,553 --> 00:12:46,783
Richard: For some people, it can take decades.
153
00:12:47,053 --> 00:12:48,396
Then you need patience.
154
00:12:48,706 --> 00:12:50,026
You need to keep showing up.
155
00:12:50,489 --> 00:12:55,657
Oshan: Which means that one of the most common outcomes among people who pick up a meditation practice is
156
00:12:55,657 --> 00:12:59,097
that they give it up before anything really compelling or profound happens.
157
00:12:59,852 --> 00:13:02,836
And this isn't a new or uniquely Western situation.
158
00:13:03,706 --> 00:13:09,893
Probably for as long as humans have been meditating, the majority of people's experiences have not penetrated into the deep end.
159
00:13:10,558 --> 00:13:15,433
Michael: We know historically this is just not for everyone.
160
00:13:15,483 --> 00:13:22,409
The media kind of makes it sound like everyone needs some mindfulness and sure a little bit of mindfulness, that could help.
161
00:13:22,725 --> 00:13:28,526
But I would
say that people who are gonna go to that second thing and say, huh, there's something interesting here.
162
00:13:30,021 --> 00:13:31,371
Beyond just stress reduction.
163
00:13:31,761 --> 00:13:33,861
That's like one or 2% maybe.
164
00:13:34,581 --> 00:13:36,231
That's what we see over and over again.
165
00:13:36,231 --> 00:13:42,681
It's a very, very tiny sliver of humanity that is going to give a fuck about this.
166
00:13:43,365 --> 00:13:50,790
Oshan: Which is why I think it's actually a really interesting thing that the West has begun to ask a quintessentially Western question of meditation.
167
00:13:51,932 --> 00:13:56,606
Can we make the benefits of deep meditation more accessible by speeding the whole thing up?
168
00:13:57,691 --> 00:14:01,525
Can we use technology to accelerate the road to a pivot point?
169
00:14:04,888 --> 00:14:12,651
There have been media headlines in the past about using technology to, quote, "hack enlightenment," to speed run the entire path of Buddhist meditation,
170
00:14:13,358 --> 00:14:16,466
and that hasn't panned out so far, and I'm skeptical it ever will.
171
00:14:17,010 --> 00:14:24,019
But what does seem possible, and what is actually being worked on by a number of organizations and researchers right now,
172
00:14:24,019 --> 00:14:33,106
is using technology to get people from never having meditated into their first taste of the deep end or their first pivot point quicker.
173
00:14:33,976 --> 00:14:35,296
Kati: I've been talking about this for years.
174
00:14:35,296 --> 00:14:38,069
Like this is one of the dreams of my life is to,
175
00:14:38,069 --> 00:14:43,126
is to have something that I've been calling with the super catchy name of a practice matcher.
176
00:14:43,487 --> 00:14:47,664
Oshan: Here's Kati Devaney, the neuroscientist and research director at the Consciousness Foundation.
177
00:14:48,264 --> 00:14:53,154
Kati: What I would love to have is just a giant database of all these different paths up the mountain.
178
00:14:53,334 --> 00:15:02,112
And then when someone new, comes to practice for whatever their reason is, either I'm suffering, I'm curious, I wanna get enlightened,
179
00:15:02,112 --> 00:15:04,214
I just wanna feel better in my family.
180
00:15:04,604 --> 00:15:11,838
There could be a say an initial sort of scan and then a result that says, oh,
181
00:15:11,838 --> 00:15:20,889
you have the type of psychobiological system that other people like you have benefited from doing a lot of ecstatic dance
182
00:15:20,889 --> 00:15:24,780
and then a sitting practice or other people like you have benefited from,
183
00:15:24,780 --> 00:15:31,154
starting with psychedelics and then moving into a movement practice and you should not do a sitting still practice for a while.
184
00:15:31,274 --> 00:15:36,404
And being able to have that kind of, almost like a sorting hat for practitioners.
185
00:15:36,972 --> 00:15:39,801
Oshan: This kind of pluralism in meditation practice,
186
00:15:39,801 --> 00:15:47,485
the idea that you can choose from among a variety of practices depending on your own context and goals to best suit your needs,
187
00:15:47,485 --> 00:15:49,947
Kati explained that this is a pretty new thing.
188
00:15:50,727 --> 00:15:55,062
This is something that's relatively unique and exciting about the Western culture of meditation.
189
00:15:55,657 --> 00:15:59,882
Kati: And that was the great thing about being in this historical moment that we're in, is that,
190
00:15:59,882 --> 00:16:03,596
all of us have access to all of these things that were typically,
191
00:16:03,596 --> 00:16:06,847
what you had access to was just what the people around you were doing.
192
00:16:06,847 --> 00:16:09,637
There was the practice of your culture and that was it.
193
00:16:10,777 --> 00:16:17,467
In some ways that practice was pre-matched to you because it was developed in the culture that you were situated in.
194
00:16:17,767 --> 00:16:19,957
And we've lost that.
195
00:16:20,317 --> 00:16:25,327
But what we've gained is the ability to have something that's incredibly personalized.
196
00:16:25,753 --> 00:16:28,303
But it could be so much better than it is now.
197
00:16:28,904 --> 00:16:34,257
Oshan: Remember that we've already heard stories of people starting out with styles of meditation that just did not work for them.
198
00:16:34,895 --> 00:16:35,972
For example, Sean.
199
00:16:36,477 --> 00:16:40,845
Sean: I tried meditation many times before that because I knew that, okay, this is the way to study your mind.
200
00:16:40,845 --> 00:16:44,715
But it was always the watch the breath for an hour.
201
00:16:44,775 --> 00:16:54,987
And I just bounced off of that I think it was mostly sold as there's a way to improve focus to, have better emotional regulation,
202
00:16:54,987 --> 00:16:59,397
all good things, but not what I was trying to get out of it.
203
00:17:00,342 --> 00:17:06,925
And so for it to feel like it wasn't directly getting at what I wanted and also for the actual exercise to just feel,
204
00:17:06,925 --> 00:17:17,820
to be blunt, really boring and frustrating, and there to be no apparent feedback loop of this is doing something, I couldn't stick with it.
205
00:17:18,361 --> 00:17:26,477
Oshan: Kati's idea is basically a massive database that would let us find correlations between types of people and types of practices,
206
00:17:26,477 --> 00:17:34,684
so that maybe when Sean first started meditation, he could have been told that based on past experiences of people with his disposition and goals,
207
00:17:34,684 --> 00:17:41,422
and maybe even patterns of brain activity, meditating on the breath for an hour probably won't be a super effective practice.
208
00:17:42,103 --> 00:17:48,857
That perhaps inquiry-based practices, like what he eventually picked up through the Waking Up app, would be more effective for someone like him.
209
00:17:50,079 --> 00:17:55,051
I heard something similar from Lars
Sandved-Smith, the neuroscientist we met back in the third episode.
210
00:17:55,570 --> 00:17:59,827
Lars: What you're talking about, is, I think one of the, one of the great promises of this work.
211
00:18:00,177 --> 00:18:04,523
Oshan: Lars thinks we might be able to get more precise than just a database of correlations.
212
00:18:05,078 --> 00:18:12,239
He and his colleagues are developing mathematical models of the mind based on those theories of predictive processing and active inference we heard about.
213
00:18:13,055 --> 00:18:19,611
Which basically means they have a bunch of equations that describe what the mind does at a general level.
214
00:18:20,356 --> 00:18:22,604
The equations provide a model of the mind.
215
00:18:23,008 --> 00:18:31,822
Lars: So what we can do is take one of these models and fit an individual's data to the model,
216
00:18:31,822 --> 00:18:35,046
and then that model is gonna tell us something about…
217
00:18:35,046 --> 00:18:37,598
How does this person account for uncertainty?
218
00:18:37,598 --> 00:18:39,698
How does this person allocate their attention?
219
00:18:40,028 --> 00:18:41,108
And given that.
220
00:18:41,903 --> 00:18:49,234
Now taking that fitted model and running the simulation towards awakening gives you a kind of intervention for that individual.
221
00:18:49,264 --> 00:18:51,572
And maybe it looks like meditation, maybe it looks like something else.
222
00:18:52,072 --> 00:18:55,521
Oshan: Once you've plugged in someone's psychological details,
223
00:18:55,521 --> 00:19:02,810
you could basically run the numbers on those equations to get a recommendation for the most effective kind of practice for that individual.
224
00:19:03,344 --> 00:19:08,990
Lars: I think that's a really, beautiful thing that might come of this is that for so many of us,
225
00:19:08,990 --> 00:19:16,032
if you find yourself in a community doing a style of practice that just doesn't work for you,
226
00:19:16,032 --> 00:19:20,740
you can spend decades just digging wells that never hit water,
227
00:19:20,740 --> 00:19:24,204
and all it would take is just finding the style of practice that works for you.
228
00:19:24,204 --> 00:19:30,564
And it could just be right around the corner and you could, you could break through in, in, in very little time.
229
00:19:30,934 --> 00:19:36,324
And a deeper understanding of the mechanisms behind all of that would, facilitate that whole process.
230
00:19:38,034 --> 00:19:40,812
Oshan: So all this gave me another way to think about pivot points.
231
00:19:41,834 --> 00:19:47,103
Pivot points are moments where the practice you're doing clicks into place with your psychology.
232
00:19:47,784 --> 00:19:52,595
It's a burst of feedback that tells you the well you're digging with your practice has struck something.
233
00:19:55,919 --> 00:20:02,244
When I started researching the acceleration part of this project, I assumed I'd wind up focusing on brain stimulation.
234
00:20:03,129 -->
00:20:11,809
People have been building different kinds of brain stimulation technologies focused on meditation or just spiritual experiences in general, for decades now,
235
00:20:12,574 --> 00:20:18,071
and there have been a few flashes of interesting results, but nothing all that exciting has made it through the hype.
236
00:20:18,973 --> 00:20:22,471
When I asked Lars about the brain stimulation stuff, he kind of sighed.
237
00:20:23,019 --> 00:20:27,805
Lars: You know, it's funny, I've been in this space for long enough to meet, some of the more senior,
238
00:20:28,475 --> 00:20:31,895
contemplative neuroscience researchers at different conferences and things.
239
00:20:32,645 --> 00:20:38,495
And there's this arc that, a lot of researchers seem to go through in this space from.
240
00:20:39,590 --> 00:20:40,010
Oh my God.
241
00:20:40,010 --> 00:20:42,170
We're right around the corner to a science of awakening.
242
00:20:42,170 --> 00:20:47,450
And this is gonna give rise to a technology that will allow awakening at scale like we have never seen before.
243
00:20:47,450 --> 00:20:52,902
And we are just going to understand how it works and why it works, engineer it, and boom,
244
00:20:52,902 --> 00:20:57,080
everybody just come into the awakening booth and walk out a bodhisattva.
245
00:20:57,110 --> 00:21:00,080
Like the future is bright.
246
00:21:00,630 --> 00:21:04,521
And then things sort of dry up and the problem seems harder than expected.
247
00:21:04,611 --> 00:21:09,141
And then the researchers end up just kind of, actually I'm not meeting them at conferences anymore.
248
00:21:09,141 --> 00:21:12,651
I'm meeting them at retreat centers and they're, they're not really trying to build technology anymore.
249
00:21:12,651 --> 00:21:15,965
They're just sort of going back to the source and sitting with great teachers.
250
00:21:15,994 --> 00:21:18,062
And have kind of given up on that project.
251
00:21:18,405 --> 00:21:19,905
And there's like two ways you could interpret that.
252
00:21:19,905 --> 00:21:28,055
One way is to say, there's something deeply misguided or flawed in the notion of engineering, awakening tech.
253
00:21:28,505 --> 00:21:30,527
The other thing you could say is, well, they're just too early.
254
00:21:30,707 --> 00:21:33,557
And, actually it's a harder problem than originally thought.
255
00:21:33,557 --> 00:21:35,247
And I think it's somewhere in between.
256
00:21:35,637 --> 00:21:40,837
I am optimistic about the potential for technology to facilitate awakening.
257
00:21:41,427 --> 00:21:46,693
But I definitely see it more like playing the role of having good nutrition when you go into the gym, you know,
258
00:21:46,693 --> 00:21:50,962
you still gotta go to the gym and do the work, but, you know, eating well helps.
259
00:21:51,609 --> 00:21:59,209
Oshan: I think we're still very early in our understanding of how technology can play a healthy role in supporting or deepening a meditation practice.
260
00:21:59,834 --> 00:22:06,240
And at the moment, there's still a growing variety of potential avenues, potential technologies that could prove helpful.
261
00:22:06,812 --> 00:22:14,707
For example, one that I'm really interested in is being very slowly and patiently researched at the University of Arizona's SEMA Lab
262
00:22:14,707 --> 00:22:17,156
or Science Enhanced Mindful Awareness Lab.
263
00:22:17,711 --> 00:22:21,084
They're working on targeted ultrasound brain stimulation,
264
00:22:21,084 --> 00:22:29,960
where they basically pulse ultrasound waves at a hub of the brain's default mode network in an effort to get people into deeper states of meditation more quickly.
265
00:22:30,551 --> 00:22:34,933
And their first paper reporting on those results just came out last year and looked pretty good.
266
00:22:35,581 --> 00:22:45,025
The ultrasound did seem to help novice meditators get from the early stages of drowning in incessant thoughts to a more calm state of equanimity quicker.
267
00:22:46,495 --> 00:22:49,654
When I asked Lars, he was actually excited by a different technology.
268
00:22:50,224 --> 00:22:50,944
Lars: I've tried them all.
269
00:22:50,944 --> 00:22:53,971
I've tried the ultrasound, I've tried the biofeedback, I've tried tDCS,
270
00:22:53,971 --> 00:23:00,694
the one bit I'm actually quite curious about and kind of cautiously exploring is, photobiomodulation.
271
00:23:01,754 --> 00:23:08,344
I recently purchased a Vielight headset, and have been practicing with that and been finding that really powerful actually.
272
00:23:08,590 --> 00:23:10,761
Oshan: Is that infrared, does that actually look like in practice?
273
00:23:11,161 --> 00:23:18,301
Lars: It looks like a headset, with infrared LEDs, that are shining, a frequency of light that you're getting when you walk outside in the sun.
274
00:23:18,301 --> 00:23:20,471
I mean, it's, as far as I understand, it's very, very safe.
275
00:23:20,891 --> 00:23:25,069
And that just phenomenologically, what I find when I practice with that is like,
276
00:23:25,069 --> 00:23:31,990
it's as if I'm at the end of a retreat quite quickly in terms of just like the energy
277
00:23:31,990 --> 00:23:36,549
and the kind of ability to let go of tensions that I hadn't even noticed before kind of thing.
278
00:23:36,549 --> 00:23:42,389
So I think it's quite interesting and I, and I kind of think it's also there's like a plausible, mechanism of action there.
279
00:23:42,389 --> 00:23:43,966
And it seems to kind of work.
280
00:23:44,222 --> 00:23:47,125
And I also think it might have potential for giving people an experience.
281
00:23:47,129 --> 00:23:50,460
We've been talking about, you galvanizing this faith, like kind of giving people a sense.
282
00:23:50,820 --> 00:23:58,073
And it was interesting actually, just anecdotally, my wife, first time she tried it, what she said afterwards was, you know,
283
00:23:58,073 --> 00:24:06,645
I haven't experienced a quiet like that since
we were, in India since, because we were like really practicing and really going forward there.
284
00:24:06,645 --> 00:24:10,343
And like, it's just, you know, you'd forgotten what that could be like.
285
00:24:10,663 --> 00:24:16,597
And not even being aware of the places that one can reach with meditation that like, you know, you say to people like, you know,
286
00:24:16,597 --> 00:24:19,653
meditate because you know it's gonna, you know, make you feel better and calmer and stuff.
287
00:24:19,743 --> 00:24:21,093
Like, well, I feel better, I'm pretty calm.
288
00:24:21,093 --> 00:24:27,213
Like, you don't even have a sense of how calm it's possible to be, or how open or how lucid or how peaceful, how joyful,
289
00:24:27,213 --> 00:24:28,278
how loving, like it's not even there.
290
00:24:28,278 --> 00:24:30,393
And so something that just gives you a taste could be really powerful.
291
00:24:30,393 --> 00:24:34,373
And for her it's really, you know rekindled her desire to, to sit.
292
00:24:35,148 --> 00:24:42,023
Oshan: It kind of seems to me like we've moved from the old idea of a full-on awakening helmet to more just a helmet
293
00:24:42,023 --> 00:24:45,258
that can kind of help out a little bit and mostly at first?
294
00:24:45,548 --> 00:24:46,683
Lars: Yeah, exactly.
295
00:24:46,783 --> 00:24:53,226
It feels a bit like training wheels in a bit, like kinda like I'm being pulled subtly in the direction and I'm,
296
00:24:53,226 --> 00:24:56,529
I've still had to figure out how to let go into it and that's kind of always been the case,
297
00:24:56,529 --> 00:24:58,178
but it just a little bit of, a little bit of help.
298
00:24:58,697 --> 00:24:59,177
So who knows?
299
00:25:00,903 --> 00:25:08,140
Oshan: At this point, we just don't know if using infrared light helmets or ultrasound brain stimulation will wind up proving helpful
300
00:25:08,214 --> 00:25:10,180
and safe for meditation at scale.
301
00:25:10,968 --> 00:25:16,236
Maybe 50 years from now, in the same way that today we might think of monasteries and robes
302
00:25:16,236 --> 00:25:19,494
and singing bowls as the paraphernalia of deep meditation,
303
00:25:19,494 --> 00:25:27,017
future generations will think of practice-matching algorithms and ultrasound headsets and maybe even psychedelics in similar ways.
304
00:25:27,971 --> 00:25:30,340
But say that does all happen.
305
00:25:31,194 --> 00:25:38,033
Say we get really good at speeding meditators from complete beginners into the deeper terrain that pivot points open up.
306
00:25:39,438 --> 00:25:44,170
Then whatever risks come along with deep meditation, those will be amplified, too.
307
00:25:45,694 --> 00:25:49,675
Kati, who's also a meditation teacher, mentioned something interesting.
308
00:25:50,572 --> 00:26:00,554
She's noticed a relationship between how deep of a meditation experience someone has and how psychologically prepared they are to handle and integrate that experience.
309
00:26:00,969 --> 00:26:03,639
Kati: This is something I notice in a lot of my students also.
310
00:26:03,699 --> 00:26:14,939
There's a deeper wisdom that's often online in practice, which is about what's the level of insight that's safe to have right now?
311
00:26:15,339 --> 00:26:21,669
Like what can the container hold and the container of your own mind and then the container of the retreat you're on
312
00:26:21,669 --> 00:26:24,519
and all the psychological stuff you're bringing to it.
313
00:26:24,989 --> 00:26:27,445
Oshan: The teacher Richard Shankman describes something similar.
314
00:26:27,897 --> 00:26:33,409
He works a lot with concentration practices where people report those big blissful experiences.
315
00:26:33,989 --> 00:26:36,719
Richard: A lot of people think, oh, that's what I would want.
316
00:26:36,719 --> 00:26:43,229
That sounds great, but it's got its downside because the concentration can get ahead of,
317
00:26:43,229 --> 00:26:49,460
how much they've unwound their own psychology and somatic in the body and everything.
318
00:26:49,460 --> 00:26:51,320
And that can lead to certain challenges.
319
00:26:51,320 --> 00:26:53,150
It can be too much overwhelming.
320
00:26:53,370 --> 00:27:01,112
So things can start to blow open in a way, that you may not have built up the resources to work with,
321
00:27:01,112 --> 00:27:05,965
or you might not have worked it out in gradual steps to get to the deeper states.
322
00:27:06,441 --> 00:27:12,652
Oshan: All of which is to say, it's not necessarily a good thing to just blast a beginner into a pivot point right off the bat.
323
00:27:13,381 --> 00:27:17,894
The better we get at zipping and zapping people into these transformative experiences,
324
00:27:17,894 --> 00:27:26,039
the better we ought to be at recognizing when that's actually going to be safe and beneficial, and supporting the people who inevitably have difficulties.
325
00:27:27,604 --> 00:27:30,243
Now, again, let's say that all happens.
326
00:27:30,795 --> 00:27:36,331
We develop all kinds of accelerating technology and all sorts of know-how around how to use it safely.
327
00:27:37,511 --> 00:27:44,201
Remember that every teacher we heard from last episode recommended that as we focus more on pivot points,
328
00:27:44,201 --> 00:27:46,908
we shouldn't get caught up in the desire to have them.
329
00:27:47,558 --> 00:27:49,520
When we actually sit and meditate,
330
00:27:49,520 --> 00:27:54,745
we need to be able to give up any hope of having an experience other than what's already actually happening.
331
00:27:54,749 --> 00:27:57,903
As meditation teacher Tina Rasmussen put it…
332
00:27:58,479 --> 00:28:01,659
Tina: Cause the minute we're trying to get somewhere, we're not in the present moment.
333
00:28:02,515 --> 00:28:04,705
All the good stuff is in the present moment.
334
00:28:05,121 --> 00:28:14,912
Oshan: The mentality of trying to accelerate and optimize meditation practice to have pivot points faster can be in
direct conflict with actually deepening your practice.
335
00:28:15,638 --> 00:28:21,807
If we get too caught up in searching for ways to have different experiences than what we're already having,
336
00:28:21,807 --> 00:28:25,326
it can be difficult to let that go when you sit down on the meditation cushion.
337
00:28:25,882 --> 00:28:31,346
Which is why I really liked how meditation teacher Charlie Awbery described this whole project of acceleration.
338
00:28:32,085 --> 00:28:33,945
Charlie: Yeah, it's so ironic, isn't it?
339
00:28:34,485 --> 00:28:43,134
I mean, one of the results is felt sense of not rushing anymore.
340
00:28:43,559 --> 00:28:54,769
Of not being forward, end gaining, like trying to get to the thing, but a sense of contented, open, presence.
341
00:28:55,631 --> 00:29:00,535
And that is not necessarily, speedy.
342
00:29:01,242 --> 00:29:08,873
You know, it strikes me that speed and effectiveness are not all the same thing.
343
00:29:09,608 --> 00:29:14,677
You can be highly pragmatic in your practice.
344
00:29:14,677 --> 00:29:21,650
You can optimize that process, or at least, get close to having a very fast feedback loop.
345
00:29:21,966 --> 00:29:30,250
That is not the same necessarily as looking to see what is most effective in the long run.
346
00:29:30,637 --> 00:29:34,747
Maybe we have a tendency to overemphasize the speed aspect.
347
00:29:34,987 --> 00:29:40,337
Like, let's get through this stage quickly, let's get into that next experience.
348
00:29:40,337 --> 00:29:43,517
And have that experience next, and have that experience next.
349
00:29:43,517 --> 00:29:56,379
But when you relate the experience itself to long-term contexts that provides a richer, more, giving?
350
00:29:56,619 --> 00:30:04,654
Giving in the sense of like receptive, relaxed, understanding of what this is about and why.
351
00:30:05,504 --> 00:30:09,697
I'm smiling because there's Dzogchen Yogis are always the lazy ones.
352
00:30:10,327 --> 00:30:11,527
I'm very definitely a fit.
353
00:30:11,947 --> 00:30:12,997
I'm a lazy yogi.
354
00:30:13,894 --> 00:30:17,310
Oshan: If you remember, we heard Charlie's pivot point at the beginning of last episode.
355
00:30:18,002 --> 00:30:23,756
At 22 years old, Charlie goes on a retreat in India just to see what this whole meditation thing is about,
356
00:30:23,756 --> 00:30:28,387
and right away on that retreat, they have this completely explosive meditation experience.
357
00:30:29,411 --> 00:30:36,429
And from an acceleration perspective, we might say if you can have a pivot point in your first attempt at meditating, that's a good thing.
358
00:30:37,051 --> 00:30:39,147
You're just jumping right into the good stuff.
359
00:30:40,027 --> 00:30:45,010
But Charlie subsequently spent months exhausted and depressed and going to see doctors.
360
00:30:45,635 --> 00:30:51,877
Eventually, they came back around to meditating and felt that the experience was positive, but it took a long time to get to that place.
361
00:30:52,688 --> 00:31:00,868
Ultimately, it's probably easier for someone to embrace a lazy meditation practice when, like Charlie, they had their first pivot point right off the bat.
362
00:31:01,398 --> 00:31:09,116
They didn't go through years of boring and dull practice without any suggestion or occasion to believe that something deeper might be available to them.
363
00:31:10,531 --> 00:31:16,061
But this gives us a sense of the tightrope we'll have to walk between the risks and the potential benefits of acceleration.
364
00:31:17,002 --> 00:31:18,863
Go too fast and people can get hurt.
365
00:31:19,767 --> 00:31:21,703
Go too slow, people get bored.
366
00:31:23,061 --> 00:31:30,551
The idea isn't that technology can or should replace meditation altogether, especially because when talking to advanced meditators,
367
00:31:30,551 --> 00:31:35,703
they're not looking for ways to get out of doing the practice or to spend less time meditating.
368
00:31:36,165 --> 00:31:40,069
Meditation is something that becomes deeply important and meaningful to them.
369
00:31:41,038 --> 00:31:48,064
But often it takes some time for that to happen, and that's where, at their best, I think these acceleration approaches can help.
370
00:31:48,685 --> 00:31:56,768
Not as replacements for meditation and not as shortcuts for gaining the benefits of deep meditation without putting in the effort of keeping a regular practice.
371
00:31:57,196 --> 00:32:02,389
Although I wouldn't be surprised if we do wind up developing technological shortcuts to some of the benefits.
372
00:32:03,028 --> 00:32:04,820
But at least in my mind,
373
00:32:04,820 --> 00:32:12,733
the most interesting and exciting prospect of acceleration is reducing the time it takes for someone to learn how to enjoy and appreciate their practice.
374
00:32:13,359 --> 00:32:15,181
To put that a little differently,
375
00:32:15,181 --> 00:32:22,204
I think that acceleration technologies could be helpful in reducing the time it takes for meditators to lose interest in acceleration altogether.
376
00:32:23,112 --> 00:32:28,656
Acceleration is like a ladder that we want to climb up to the point that we're happy to just kick it aside
377
00:32:28,684 --> 00:32:32,047
and enjoy whatever our practice and experience already has to offer.
378
00:32:32,726 --> 00:32:40,436
Matt: I would say it's more about going from goal oriented and I would say to some extent an ego-driven practice, right?
379
00:32:40,466 --> 00:32:54,101
Like, I want, I want, to being less goal-oriented, more allowing the practice to unfold spontaneously in the way that it's going to unfold.
380
00:32:54,953 --> 00:33:02,035
I mean, you can try to fight against it, but you know, you're fighting against the combined universe, I suppose.
381
00:33:04,562 --> 00:33:09,867
Oshan: Back in the first episode, I mentioned that I was interested in pivot points as occasions to believe,
382
00:33:10,843 --> 00:33:15,201
as experiences
that generate a belief in the value of deep meditation practice.
383
00:33:15,638 --> 00:33:17,383
Beyond the beginner's mindfulness stuff.
384
00:33:18,399 --> 00:33:23,122
And you can see that start to happen with that sense of a path emerging out of these experiences.
385
00:33:23,811 --> 00:33:28,820
There's a sense of something more to be found than just repeating the same experiences over and over.
386
00:33:29,346 --> 00:33:32,806
Henry: It's like you've knocked a hole through a wall now
387
00:33:32,806 --> 00:33:39,666
and you can no longer sort of deny that there's something on the other side of the wall that you didn't know about before.
388
00:33:40,248 --> 00:33:43,850
Oshan: But I also mentioned the role my own doubts have played in the project.
389
00:33:44,705 --> 00:33:48,983
I know what the fireworks of access concentration or the first jhana feel like.
390
00:33:49,372 --> 00:33:53,735
I know what unhooking from thoughts and certain aspects of the sense of self feel like.
391
00:33:54,381 --> 00:33:59,294
What I don't know is what it feels like to come out of these experiences with certainty
392
00:33:59,294 --> 00:34:03,606
or even confidence in the value of continuing down the path they suggest.
393
00:34:04,458 --> 00:34:11,546
After a meditation experience, I'm usually still left with some version of Carla's "so what" question still nagging at me.
394
00:34:13,343 --> 00:34:22,628
So after spending so much time thinking about pivot points, I wanted to go back to one of the oldest acceleration technologies, a meditation retreat,
395
00:34:22,628 --> 00:34:27,643
to see if I could revisit them from one more perspective, my own experience.
396
00:34:29,752 --> 00:34:33,637
And so in the late spring, after wrapping up all my interviews,
397
00:34:33,637 --> 00:34:42,399
I traveled to a meditation center outside of Santa Cruz and joined Michael Taft for a seven-day meditation retreat As is common
398
00:34:42,399 --> 00:34:46,505
when I go on retreat, I spent the first day or two mostly just sitting there and thinking.
399
00:34:47,436 --> 00:34:49,544
By the third day, my legs started to hurt.
400
00:34:49,845 --> 00:34:51,284
And I mean really hurt.
401
00:34:51,361 --> 00:34:52,762
I was dreading every session.
402
00:34:53,440 --> 00:34:56,576
So I tried focusing on the pain like we heard so many others do.
403
00:34:57,309 --> 00:34:59,738
Maybe I'd find a way to transform the pain into pleasure.
404
00:35:00,907 --> 00:35:02,568
Unfortunately, I had no such luck.
405
00:35:02,589 --> 00:35:05,150
I was just really aware of the pain in my legs.
406
00:35:05,739 --> 00:35:08,410
But by around the fifth day, the worst of it had passed.
407
00:35:08,552 --> 00:35:13,666
I think my body gave up on trying to get me to move, and I also started mixing in a few different postures.
408
00:35:14,146 --> 00:35:18,868
And I found that all that focusing on the pain had helped to bring me into a pretty concentrated state.
409
00:35:20,477 --> 00:35:28,965
And what usually happens when I'm in a nice groove of concentration is that I have this feeling of melting into a really spacious expanse.
410
00:35:29,686 --> 00:35:33,136
It's like a big void with no boundaries and nothing inside of it.
411
00:35:33,730 --> 00:35:37,360
It's nothing revolutionary, but it is pleasant and it is relaxing.
412
00:35:38,349 --> 00:35:43,944
And I've often thought of this empty void as what meditation teachers mean when they talk about awareness.
413
00:35:44,853 --> 00:35:51,500
Michael's whole meditation instruction is basically about recognizing awareness and then just resting in that recognition.
414
00:35:52,447 --> 00:35:59,541
So on the afternoon sit of the fifth day, I'm settling into my spacious expanse, and this thought popped up.
415
00:36:01,732 --> 00:36:05,605
Whatever this comfortable void is, it's not awareness.
416
00:36:06,038 --> 00:36:07,511
Because I could literally see it.
417
00:36:07,511 --> 00:36:09,901
It looked like the night sky without any stars.
418
00:36:10,872 --> 00:36:17,841
But non-dual teachers are always confusingly pointing out that awareness is not something you can see or touch or feel.
419
00:36:18,857 --> 00:36:25,874
So when that thought arose, it was as if it just popped the balloon, and the whole field collapsed.
420
00:36:26,776 --> 00:36:34,116
My sense of there being space or time or a self at the center of it all, everything evaporated in an instant.
421
00:36:34,850 --> 00:36:36,072
I didn't go unconscious.
422
00:36:37,090 --> 00:36:43,910
There was a complete absence of everything that usually structures my experience, but there was something present.
423
00:36:44,897 --> 00:36:47,140
It wasn't something that I could see or feel.
424
00:36:47,146 --> 00:36:48,201
I just kind of knew it.
425
00:36:48,921 --> 00:36:55,042
It was like this very primitive or fundamental sense of liveliness or awakeness.
426
00:36:56,178 --> 00:36:58,618
There was nothing, but nothing was awake.
427
00:37:00,224 --> 00:37:03,986
And I wasn't having a bunch of insights in the form of words in my head.
428
00:37:04,547 --> 00:37:13,070
I just knew immediately that this quality is always there and is something like the raw material out of which my usual experience is built.
429
00:37:13,724 --> 00:37:16,371
And while saying that still sounds strange to me,
430
00:37:16,371 --> 00:37:21,818
it was interesting to think how similar it was to something that Thomas had mentioned about his experience.
431
00:37:22,867 --> 00:37:32,617
Thomas: And everything, the forest and the baby stroller and the foot and the thought was made of the same essential substance.
432
00:37:35,297 --> 00:37:39,670
Oshan: As I came out of it, experience returned to its three-dimensional shape.
433
00:37:40,089 --> 00:37:41,680
I remembered I was sitting in a room.
434
00:37:42,175 --> 00:37:45,119
Sounds and sights and all the works came back online.
435
00:37:45,913 --> 00:37:50,637
But
all of my usual experiences now had this new strangeness to them.
436
00:37:51,525 --> 00:38:00,942
I was noticing that same awake, primitive quality everywhere, and it had the effect of making everything appear just a little more miraculous,
437
00:38:00,961 --> 00:38:02,872
for lack of a less embarrassing word.
438
00:38:03,768 --> 00:38:08,684
And I understood why meditators leave a retreat and can just look down at a blade of grass
439
00:38:08,684 --> 00:38:11,134
or a stone and be in complete awe.
440
00:38:11,813 --> 00:38:18,084
Because it doesn't matter what you're looking at, it's the material of perception itself that feels like it's imbued with this quality.
441
00:38:19,001 --> 00:38:25,117
I spent that evening mostly just walking around the grounds, wondering what had happened, kind of confused about what I was seeing.
442
00:38:25,934 --> 00:38:31,047
That night, I'm sitting at this little circular table in my room trying to write notes about the experience.
443
00:38:31,656 --> 00:38:34,458
After a few failed attempts, I remembered something
444
00:38:34,458 --> 00:38:41,035
that the neuroscientist Ruben Laukkonen told me about what to do after the roots of your mind are yanked out of place.
445
00:38:41,956 --> 00:38:52,886
Ruben: When you have a explosive experience, there's a whole process that the mind body system engages in to put everything in its new place.
446
00:38:53,656 --> 00:38:58,506
And a lot of this happens naturally in the mind and brain if we allow it to.
447
00:38:59,206 --> 00:39:07,976
The brain, even when we're resting, taking shower, sleeping is engaging in model optimization processes.
448
00:39:07,976 --> 00:39:11,429
So you can imagine that you've got a set of bowling pins,
449
00:39:11,429 --> 00:39:17,066
and this experience has been this kind of bowling ball that's just come through and, knocked over a bunch of pins.
450
00:39:17,606 --> 00:39:21,351
But those pins now have to find their place back in a kind of, order.
451
00:39:21,561 --> 00:39:24,621
And the brain has really beautiful mechanisms for doing this.
452
00:39:24,621 --> 00:39:27,956
Things like synaptic pruning and then model optimization and so on.
453
00:39:28,429 --> 00:39:30,199
And so this takes time.
454
00:39:30,469 --> 00:39:31,459
This takes rest.
455
00:39:31,459 --> 00:39:32,569
This takes humility.
456
00:39:32,569 --> 00:39:40,318
This takes openness because the biggest risk I think, with integration is not so much that integration won't happen.
457
00:39:40,318 --> 00:39:45,171
I think it's a very natural process, but that we get in the way of the integration process.
458
00:39:45,504 --> 00:39:51,457
Somehow the self models get kind of graspy with the experience that's happened and build a new story,
459
00:39:51,457 --> 00:39:53,244
a new narrative to get locked up in.
460
00:39:53,859 --> 00:39:56,834
And so my sense with the integration is more
461
00:39:56,834 --> 00:40:07,791
that how can we kind of get out the way to
allow the integration to take place without jumping to conclusions about our experience without coming up with a new story about who we now think we are
462
00:40:07,791 --> 00:40:09,639
or our specialness or so on?
463
00:40:10,009 --> 00:40:15,689
And knowing that our brain and body is a vehicle for that, it's tuned for that.
464
00:40:15,689 --> 00:40:21,769
It's tuned to adapt to find a new way of seeing, and all of the kind of confusion will find its place.
465
00:40:22,500 --> 00:40:27,353
Oshan: I was basically doing the opposite, and not just with my own experience.
466
00:40:27,685 --> 00:40:29,792
The whole time I was on the retreat,
467
00:40:29,792 --> 00:40:32,929
I'd been thinking about all the stories of pivot points I'd heard
468
00:40:32,929 --> 00:40:37,876
and wondering what kind of story corralling them all into one space could tell about meditation.
469
00:40:39,161 --> 00:40:45,228
What should we make of the fact that somebody can concentrate on tingling sensations in their body to the point
470
00:40:45,228 --> 00:40:47,409
where a volcano of bliss erupts through their heads?
471
00:40:48,543 --> 00:40:56,029
Or that you can unhook awareness from thoughts, from the body, from the self, and slip into these startlingly rich,
472
00:40:56,029 --> 00:40:59,483
meaningful, and expansive configurations of consciousness.
473
00:41:00,612 --> 00:41:05,715
If mindfulness told the story of stress reduction, what story do these experiences tell?
474
00:41:07,011 --> 00:41:16,208
To Ruben's point, it's starting to seem to me that whatever stories we can tell about these experiences are among their least interesting consequences.
475
00:41:17,517 --> 00:41:20,802
One of the functions of a story is to freeze experience.
476
00:41:21,472 --> 00:41:27,480
The moment you have a new story to tell about your experience, you've removed the uncertainty that it brought into your world,
477
00:41:27,480 --> 00:41:29,949
and that's what the predictive mind evolved to do.
478
00:41:30,022 --> 00:41:33,056
It comes up with stories that explain away uncertainty.
479
00:41:33,963 --> 00:41:38,642
A pivot point is not actually a moment where your understanding of the world changes.
480
00:41:39,231 --> 00:41:40,841
It's just prior to that.
481
00:41:41,785 --> 00:41:45,143
It's a moment where your understanding of the world is suspended.
482
00:41:46,056 --> 00:41:56,350
Your entire story-making apparatus is temporarily broken by an experience that doesn't fit, and it's that space before a new story takes over,
483
00:41:56,350 --> 00:42:02,539
that space in between stories where uncertainty floods in, where we don't know what's happening.
484
00:42:03,246 --> 00:42:05,624
That's the critical moment of a pivot point.
485
00:42:06,407 --> 00:42:12,874
And that's why people so often describe the value of pivot points with terms like not knowing, as in the case of Kim.
486
00:42:14,232 --> 00:42:16,692
Kim: A softening into, I don't know.
487
00:42:17,221
--> 00:42:21,001
There was just this delightful falling into not knowing.
488
00:42:21,402 --> 00:42:24,305
Oshan: Or as some kind of mystery in the case of Jay.
489
00:42:24,766 --> 00:42:31,741
Jay: I know it has something to do with tapping into, something primordial, right?
490
00:42:31,741 --> 00:42:36,541
Something that defines the very fundamental essence of who we are.
491
00:42:37,051 --> 00:42:38,971
And you can use a lot of words to describe that.
492
00:42:38,971 --> 00:42:47,427
And the words are always inadequate and certain form of teacher or practitioner might use the word pure awareness or tapping into awareness.
493
00:42:47,727 --> 00:42:52,557
But then you could also use the word magic, like tapping into magic or mystery.
494
00:42:53,097 --> 00:43:00,807
Oshan: There's something to that direct feeling of uncertainty or not knowing or mystery that, as Jay said, feels primordial.
495
00:43:00,810 --> 00:43:01,937
It feels fundamental.
496
00:43:02,859 --> 00:43:05,827
That's exactly how a psychologist named Nick Bowles described it.
497
00:43:06,420 --> 00:43:13,170
Nicholas: More and more I think about meditation it's connecting into something very fundamental about what it is to be alive.
498
00:43:13,220 --> 00:43:16,430
It opens up a lot more questions than it provides answers to.
499
00:43:16,430 --> 00:43:22,738
So sitting in with the ambiguity of the unknown nature of what it is to be alive
500
00:43:22,738 --> 00:43:25,455
and to be in the circumstance we find ourselves in.
501
00:43:25,705 --> 00:43:28,015
It's really difficult because, yeah.
502
00:43:28,015 --> 00:43:32,035
How do you articulate the, this kind of opening up into the unknown?
503
00:43:32,035 --> 00:43:42,214
And being comfortable with the messiness and just developing a different relationship to the chaotic and, existential challenges that we face, going through this world.
504
00:43:43,363 --> 00:43:49,963
Oshan: One way to think about that sense of a path that emerges out of these experiences is learning to grow more comfortable in
505
00:43:49,963 --> 00:43:54,931
that sense of not knowing, to let it unfold rather than trying to shut it down.
506
00:43:55,935 --> 00:44:00,737
And it seems like the more comfortable we can become in that feeling, the more it opens up.
507
00:44:01,218 --> 00:44:08,658
Tina: I mean, there is a mystery that has unfolded you and me and everyone listening to this your entire life.
508
00:44:09,329 --> 00:44:10,497
Oshan: Again, Tina Rasmussen.
509
00:44:10,762 --> 00:44:14,737
Tina: And that mystery is trustworthy you know,
510
00:44:14,737 --> 00:44:21,433
there's the potential that we can know something about the mystery of existence that the Buddha was pointing to.
511
00:44:21,433 --> 00:44:23,413
We can know that for ourselves.
512
00:44:23,713 --> 00:44:26,503
Every human being has the potential to know that.
513
00:44:26,864 --> 00:44:28,754
And we're opening to the mystery.
514
00:44:29,336 --> 00:44:31,231
Oshan: And opening is the right word here.
515
00:44:31,537 --> 00:44:34,375
There's no single template for what that process feels like.
516
00:44:34,983 --> 00:44:40,141
Suspending our usual habits and stories expands the range of what we might experience.
517
00:44:41,008 --> 00:44:45,350
So it makes sense that we've heard a pretty wide range of how pivot points actually play out.
518
00:44:46,313 --> 00:44:48,010
Maybe you find a sense of healing.
519
00:44:50,027 --> 00:44:53,081
Matt: There is no better medicine that I have found,
520
00:44:53,636 --> 00:44:54,832
Oshan: Or a feeling of love.
521
00:44:55,158 --> 00:44:59,568
Claudia: My heart space was just like cracking wide open.
522
00:44:59,688 --> 00:45:02,718
All I wanted to do was like grab the other people on retreat and be like, I love you.
523
00:45:03,492 --> 00:45:05,386
Oshan: Maybe you find yourself terrified.
524
00:45:05,932 --> 00:45:11,212
Thomas: Things like condensed and started to feel heavy and I got so scared.
525
00:45:11,731 --> 00:45:12,601
This is lights out.
526
00:45:12,661 --> 00:45:13,891
What if I never come back?
527
00:45:14,158 --> 00:45:15,749
Oshan: Maybe you find catharsis.
528
00:45:16,160 --> 00:45:19,826
Mark: I remember one day leaving the meditation hall and going out to the jungle and just like,
529
00:45:19,826 --> 00:45:23,330
it's pouring rain and I'm just on the ground sobbing.
530
00:45:23,477 --> 00:45:26,687
And when it passed and the rain passed.
531
00:45:26,927 --> 00:45:31,964
Feeling, feeling like feeling the transformative power of that.
532
00:45:32,614 --> 00:45:36,871
Oshan: Or maybe like me, you still can't say all that much about what actually happened.
533
00:45:37,471 --> 00:45:44,346
Aviva: I was thrown into this total different realm where I can just say what I didn't have.
534
00:45:44,346 --> 00:45:48,726
I didn't have a body, I didn't have a identity.
535
00:45:49,176 --> 00:45:51,486
There was no time, there was no space.
536
00:45:52,065 --> 00:45:54,795
There was no thought, there was even no emotion.
537
00:45:55,485 --> 00:45:58,575
Somehow it was very, very full.
538
00:45:59,265 --> 00:46:03,285
Full of meaning and, and beauty.
539
00:46:04,510 --> 00:46:08,512
Oshan: The experience I had on retreat didn't settle the question of "so what?"
540
00:46:08,512 --> 00:46:08,900
For me.
541
00:46:09,799 --> 00:46:11,708
I've still got doubts that come and go.
542
00:46:12,891 --> 00:46:17,337
But since my retreat, the way I think about why I'm meditating has been changing.
543
00:46:18,364 --> 00:46:21,120
I'm not worrying about what I'll get out of it in the long run.
544
00:46:21,705 --> 00:46:29,314
I'm meditating because I found something extremely strange in my own direct experience, and I want to explore that.
545
00:46:30,117 --> 00:46:38,298
Every time I sit down, I just let my mind go slack, and that quality I mentioned comes into varying degrees of focus.
546
00:46:38,990 --> 00:46:42,868
I have no idea where that might lead, but that doesn't really matter.
547
00:46:44,064 --> 00:46:46,785
And that's how I'm starting to think about pivot points in general.
548
00:46:47,750 --> 00:46:51,140
They seem to offer many things, but answers are not one of them.
549
00:46:52,173 --> 00:46:55,472
Clarity about the world of deep meditation is not one of them.
550
00:46:56,933 --> 00:47:03,442
When I started working on this project, I thought of the obscurity that surrounds the world of deep meditation as a problem.
551
00:47:04,778 --> 00:47:07,585
I thought of mystery as the end of inquiry.
552
00:47:09,020 --> 00:47:11,895
And instead, I think I'm realizing
553
00:47:11,935 --> 00:47:19,202
that pivot points have a way of turning a felt sense of mystery into the beginning of a path of practice.
554
00:47:20,575 --> 00:47:27,654
And the value of that path, the value of deep meditation, is going to remain somewhat obscure,
555
00:47:27,654 --> 00:47:35,167
because what seems to matter most about these experiences is precisely what cannot be said.
556
00:47:41,060 --> 00:47:50,437
As always, if you wanna learn more about the series, read transcripts, find guest information, discover bonus episodes, you can head over to pivotpoints.xyz.
557
00:47:51,447 --> 00:47:55,161
If you enjoyed the series and wanna stay in the loop on similar projects in the future,
558
00:47:55,161 --> 00:47:59,277
you can sign up for my newsletter at heretodisappear.org.
559
00:48:00,400 --> 00:48:02,726
And if you'd like to support more projects like this,
560
00:48:02,726 --> 00:48:06,275
you can either become a paid subscriber of that newsletter
561
00:48:06,275 --> 00:48:09,366
or just share this series with a friend who you think might get a kick out of it.
562
00:48:10,999 --> 00:48:14,588
Pivot Points was made possible by an incredible cast of supporters.
563
00:48:15,337 --> 00:48:24,384
The team at the Waking Up meditation app, editing by Amy Standen, original theme music by Marcus Bagala, cover art by Valero Doval,
564
00:48:24,384 --> 00:48:33,637
audio engineering by Lucas Del Calvo, and the generous meditators, scientists, and teachers who took the time to share their stories and insights.
565
00:48:34,572 --> 00:48:35,105
Thank you all.