TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
00:00:12
Speaker 1: I'm Manny.
00:00:12
Speaker 2: I'm Noah. This is Devin.
00:00:14
Speaker 3: And this is No Such Thing, the show where we settle our dumb arguments and yours by actually doing the research. This week, do lie detector tests actually detect lies?
00:00:27
Speaker 1: There's no such thing.
00:00:28
Speaker 2: No such thing.
00:00:30
Speaker 4: No such thing.
00:00:34
Speaker 2: No such thing.
00:00:36
Speaker 4: No such thing.
00:00:43
Speaker 3: I've got a question, and I need you guys to answer honestly. Are you guys good liars?
00:00:51
Speaker 1: Mia is currently watching The Traitors. And she says I would be bad at that Oh yeah you would be horrible at trading I think I'd sacrifice myself.
00:00:58
Speaker 5: Your issue in traders though would be like You look like you're lying sometimes when you're telling the truth I think you have the opposite problem Of like you'll laugh or something And I'm like I.
00:01:07
Speaker 1: Know he's not lying I get nervous or something Like.
00:01:11
Speaker 5: Your reaction to nerves Makes you seem like you're lying.
00:01:14
Speaker 1: I think I'd want people to believe me so bad Even though I am telling the truth Yeah That it would feel like a lie.
00:01:21
Speaker 2: Yeah, it would feel like you're... How do you think you'd do?
00:01:23
Speaker 3: I think you'd be the best of us three on traitors.
00:01:26
Speaker 5: I don't think I'm a great liar by, like, if someone asks me something straight up.
00:01:32
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:01:32
Speaker 2: I think I'm a good liar by omission.
00:01:34
Speaker 3: Yeah, so you could, you know, hide a little bit.
00:01:37
Speaker 2: Yes, I think I could talk around things.
00:01:39
Speaker 3: But if you're getting grilled, it's... Yeah, if you're.
00:01:42
Speaker 5: Asking me something straight up, it's hard because I'm bad at, like, thinking of what the lie would be ahead of time.
00:01:49
Speaker 2: Yeah. Which I think good liars do, you know?
00:01:52
Speaker 1: The premeditated is crazy.
00:01:54
Speaker 2: You can't show up and lie. I can't lie on the spot. That's the issue. Yeah.
00:01:57
Speaker 3: I'll say this.
00:01:58
Speaker 1: I don't think I could do the premeditated story and.
00:02:02
Speaker 2: Stick to it. Some people are really good at that.
00:02:04
Speaker 1: But I think I could get out of a situation by lying, probably. Something was sprung up on me.
00:02:08
Speaker 2: I thought, you know, you'd probably actually be a good liar.
00:02:12
Speaker 3: I think it depends. I don't think, again, under kind of interrogation, no. I think if it's simple, hey- Do you do this thing?
00:02:20
Speaker 6: No.
00:02:21
Speaker 3: I think I could get through that first round, but I can't do the two-factor sort of thing.
00:02:26
Speaker 2: No follow-ups.
00:02:28
Speaker 3: Exactly. Then I have to leave, which is then more suspicious. So anyway, I was thinking about a recent headline from a few weeks ago. Manny, why don't you read this aloud?
00:02:36
Speaker 1: In Major League Hunt, Pentagon gives polygraph tests to joint staff members.
00:02:43
Speaker 2: Okay.
00:02:44
Speaker 3: So a polygraph is well-known as a lie detector test.
00:02:47
Speaker 7: Mm-hmm.
00:02:48
Speaker 3: What do we know about polygraphs?
00:02:50
Speaker 2: Go.
00:02:51
Speaker 5: Well, my introduction to the polygraph, I think with a lot of millennials, was thanks to Maury, the daytime TV show gods.
00:03:00
Speaker 1: Maury Povich.
00:03:01
Speaker 5: Where they would give lie detector tests to cheating husbands, mostly, or spouses.
00:03:07
Speaker 8: Yeah.
00:03:08
Speaker 5: And that was riveting as a child, seeing people being caught, quote unquote, And a lie.
00:03:15
Speaker 9: During your relationship with Elizabeth, how many times have you had sexual intercourse with another woman she does not know about? You said none. The lie detector test determined that was a lie more than five times. We asked you, did you have sexual intercourse with a woman you.
00:03:36
Speaker 3: Admitted to showering with?
00:03:37
Speaker 9: You said no. The lie detector test determined that was a lie.
00:03:40
Speaker 4: Oh!
00:03:45
Speaker 1: Yeah, and what was funny about the Maury lie detector test is, to the best of my recollection, I don't think they rarely ever showed the test being administered.
00:03:54
Speaker 2: No, just like B-roll. Right.
00:03:55
Speaker 1: Yeah, and then you'd just get the results. But in pop culture movies and TV shows, the image I'm thinking of is you connect someone's finger to the wire. the test itself, it's like a machine that is, that has ink in it.
00:04:11
Speaker 3: And it's like.
00:04:12
Speaker 1: Drawing these kind of heartbeat looking lines on a piece of paper. And I think when the needle, so to speak, goes crazy, that's supposed to indicate that the person is lying.
00:04:23
Speaker 3: So yeah. What do you think it's actually measuring?
00:04:26
Speaker 1: Maybe like your heart rate or something. I imagine your heart rate increases when you're telling a lie. It can't just be that because you wouldn't, you could, measure that without all that equipment so i actually don't know.
00:04:39
Speaker 5: But think about the stuff that you're talking about the images are older maybe the newer ones don't have that but i think about the was it meet the parents yeah yeah yeah where they where they do the lie detector and it's a similar setup now.
00:04:51
Speaker 4: These aren't 100 accurate right there well you'd be surprised how accurate they are.
00:04:56
Speaker 5: I would imagine it's a change in heart rate everyone has their baseline and then If you're lying, I'm imagining in anticipation of the lie, your body would maybe do something different.
00:05:09
Speaker 2: But as a kid, you're like, the lie detector is... Foolproof. Yes.
00:05:12
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:05:13
Speaker 1: It's like the Wonder Woman lasso of truth.
00:05:14
Speaker 7: Yes.
00:05:15
Speaker 2: You cannot lie
Load full transcript
once they get the lie detector.
00:05:18
Speaker 4: Yes.
00:05:18
Speaker 2: As an adult, I feel like that's not true. Yeah.
00:05:20
Speaker 3: So how reliable do you think they are?
00:05:23
Speaker 1: Similar to what Devin's saying, as we've gotten older, I've learned that they're not so reliable. Not that they... couldn't catch someone in a lie, but that, you know, that's just not a fair piece of equipment to really pin everything on someone in like a court case, for example. I used to watch on Netflix the confession tapes, and you get people lying on there all the time, supposedly, and then it turns out, no, the evidence dictates that they could not have been the place that they were. And so it's like, well, damn, that lie detector test What is it actually measuring?
00:06:01
Speaker 3: Yeah, the examiner should be taking a damn test.
00:06:05
Speaker 2: Is it a nerve detector test?
00:06:07
Speaker 4: Yes.
00:06:07
Speaker 2: Yeah. Great question.
00:06:11
Speaker 3: So this week, we're going to learn the history of the polygraph, find out how reliable it is or isn't, and finally, test one out ourselves. After the break, we take a visit to the early days of lie detection.
00:06:37
Speaker 10: My name is Amit Katwala. I'm a science and technology journalist and the author of Tremors in the Blood, Murder, Obsession and the Birth of the Lie Detector.
00:06:45
Speaker 3: Before the polygraph was invented, what were the methods used for lie detection or what were the kind of the theories going around before we got to the point of anyone actually trying to build this machine?
00:06:56
Speaker 10: There had been folk theories for thousands of years, you know, in like ancient China, people would say that if you got someone you thought was lying to chew rice, it would sort of turn sticky in their mouth if they were lying because of the adrenaline. And there was like all these sort of like folk ideas of what liars would do. And the book title Tremors in the Blood comes from this quote from Daniel Defoe, who was writing about how there is a tremor in the blood of a thief, this idea that you can kind of tell when someone's lying because they'll be tense, their heart will be racing and things like that. But it didn't really get formalised until much, much later, until the 1910s, 1920s. And it was actually this guy called William Marston who came up with this first insight that, oh, hey, maybe blood pressure, heart rate is linked to lying. He did a bunch of experiments on his peers at Harvard and at other colleges and basically got them to tell made up stories while measuring their blood pressure, and this was the first sort of insight that maybe there was a link between telling lies and what the body was doing. William Marston, incidentally, then went on to create Wonder Woman, the comic book character who had a lasso of truth, so there was like a weird link there too.
00:08:12
Speaker 1: The thing about how in ancient China they would give people rice.
00:08:16
Speaker 1: How many people have been fucked over by the most bullshit tests? That guy probably spent the rest of his life in jail.
00:08:24
Speaker 2: Oh, worse.
00:08:26
Speaker 1: Because he's like, this is good.
00:08:27
Speaker 2: Yeah. Certainly too much.
00:08:31
Speaker 1: Oops.
00:08:32
Speaker 3: So here's how we got to the invention of the polygraph device.
00:08:37
Speaker 10: In the 1910s, policing was quite a brutal affair. So if the police wanted to find information out from the suspect, they would generally... beat out of them with sticks and policing was quite a corrupt profession often staffed by sort of you know fairly uneducated people often run in this sort of like mafia-esque kind of like it's who you know and that kind of thing and in Berkeley in the 1910s and 1920s there was this police chief called August Vollmer who was the sort of visionary guy and he wanted to really like professionalize policing.
00:09:09
Speaker 3: Vollmer had read about William Marston's theory about a potential link between blood pressure and lies. So he asked one of his rookie cops, a guy named John Larson, who had studied physiology at Berkeley, to make a machine to measure this.
00:09:20
Speaker 10: Larson went away and he built this machine that basically connected a blood pressure cuff and some pneumatic tubes to measure how someone was breathing to this pen that would scratch up and down on a roll of paper as someone breathed in and out and as the blood pressure went up and down. And that really was the basis of the first polygraph machine.
00:09:40
Speaker 3: So like we described earlier, it's that cuff, it's measuring blood pressure, and it's attached to a pen on the paper that's making the lines, you know, corresponding to that.
00:09:49
Speaker 10: The polygraph is basically measuring three things. So your blood pressure and heart rate, your breathing, and then neuro devices also measure your galvanic skin response, which is basically how much you're sweating, and taken together polygraph examiners will say that this is giving you like a sense of like someone's overall physiological arousal how stressed they are basically and the idea is that if you're lying and more likely more stressed your blood pressure might be different to how it is if you're telling the truth and that's what polygraph examiners look for when they're conducting a test.
00:10:25
Speaker 3: Can you walk us through what a polygraph exam looks like?
00:10:28
Speaker 10: A polygraph exam doesn't really look like the way they portray it in the movies and on TV. It's much slower and much more boring than that. So basically, if you're doing a polygraph test properly, what you want to do is you want to collect a lot of baseline data about how someone's body reacts when they're telling the truth. So you might start by asking them questions like, is your name Noah? Or is your birthday in June? And questions to which you know the answer is yes, or that you know they're
going to be telling the truth. And then you use that data as a baseline. And then when you drop in target questions like, did you do the crime or did you steal the car? The idea is that you can then look for a difference between that baseline question and the target question. And if there's a difference, it means that they're likely to be lying. And you repeat this several times over the course of several hours. And eventually you end up with a sort of body of evidence that suggests that, hey, this person's blood pressure did this thing when they were saying they didn't steal the car. So That suggests maybe they were lying on that question, whereas it didn't do that thing when they were telling me that their name was Noah.
00:11:31
Speaker 1: I didn't quite realize that they were testing against the control answers. I thought the authorities were saying, in a vacuum, we can tell what a lie is, not necessarily that they're testing against some preset questions.
00:11:45
Speaker 3: So the polygraph machine was first used in a theft case at a dorm in Berkeley in 1922. And from then on, it started being used in murder trials and big cases. The media really kind of led the hype around it at the time. Newspapers would commission John Larson to run tests for them so they could report exclusive results about potential murder suspects. So it wasn't in the court system, but it was just in the press and media hype around it.
00:12:09
Speaker 2: Right.
00:12:09
Speaker 3: Which I feel like, you know, downstream of that is where we get kind of the Maury style thing where, yeah, that's not a legal proceeding, but we're kind of taking it as fact regardless of kind of the.
00:12:22
Speaker 3: The setting, to say the least. Can you talk about the issues with the accuracy of these tests?
00:12:28
Speaker 10: Polygraph tests have been shown to be fairly inaccurate, basically, ever since they were invented. There are a bunch of stats and reports on this, but I think the rough level of accuracy is about 60% to 70%, basically, whereas the average person can guess when someone's lying about 54% of the time. So they're not much better than just someone off the street.
00:12:51
Speaker 4: And.
00:12:51
Speaker 10: A lot of the supposed effectiveness of the polygraph comes from its use as like a psychological prop. If you've been told that the machine in front of you can tell if you're lying or not, and the person who's operating the machine is a skilled investigator, then you are more likely to blurt out the truth or confess to something than if that machine didn't exist. There's like a famous story from David Simon who wrote The Wire about cops in Baltimore using like a Xerox machine pretending it was a lie detector and getting a suspect to put their hand on it and then it would get spit out bits of paper with he's lying written on it and they used that to trick someone into confessing and.
00:13:32
Speaker 1: Did you and Mon-El shoot your boy Pookie down on Cary Street
just like Mon-El said you did nah no.
00:13:45
Speaker 2: Lie machine is never wrong son.
00:13:48
Speaker 10: And the polygraph has often been used in that sort of setting as essentially like a prop. And that's not to say that it hasn't gotten murderers to confess or put dangerous people behind bars, because it obviously has, but it's also been used to coerce people into giving false confessions. And I think one thing that's not appreciated very much is that the polygraph is not admissible as evidence in federal court, and it never has been.
00:14:12
Speaker 3: I asked him to explain why isn't it admissible in court, because that was news to me that it was never allowed.
00:14:17
Speaker 10: So it's never been used in court because of this standard called the Frye standard. And the Frye standard basically says that you can only admit a new technology or a new piece of scientific evidence in court if a majority of experts in that field believe that it's effective in doing what it says it does. So things like DNA testing, fingerprinting clear that bar. Other things maybe don't. So the polygraph doesn't clear that bar. Things like blood spatter analysis are sort of in the kind of grey area where some people accept them, some people don't, but there are some problems with evidence types like that. If you watch any Netflix true crime series, you'll come across a lot of these technologies and they are of varying levels of effectiveness, but the polygraph never cleared that standard and never has, basically. So where it ends up being used is a lot of it is pre-trial or in the sort of investigative phase of crimes when police are looking into stuff or they want to rule people in or out, they'll use it as a means of applying pressure to suspects that they think are lying, or they'll use it to essentially screen a lot of people in a short space of time in the hope, I think, that the pressure of the exam will force someone to blurt something out that they didn't mean to or something like that. So it's used a lot in the pre-trial investigative phase of crimes.
00:15:38
Speaker 5: It's fine that you can't use it in court, but I think the issue with it is that If the police department is using it and then they zero in on, okay, we gave Manny a lie detector test.
00:15:48
Speaker 2: He failed it. Okay.
00:15:51
Speaker 5: We have all these other suspects. Let's stop looking into them. And now let's just start collecting evidence that points to Manny doing the crime. So at the end of the day, that test may not be.
00:16:00
Speaker 2: Used in court.
00:16:01
Speaker 5: But it has directed the police in a way to ignore other suspects or ignore evidence that doesn't fit this narrative that has come from the lie detector.
00:16:10
Speaker 3: Yeah, and that person wouldn't seem so guilty if we are just seeing it as a prop wasn't in the room.
00:16:14
Speaker 2: Yep.
00:16:15
Speaker 1: So you're saying it shouldn't be allowed in court and the police shouldn't even be allowed to use it.
00:16:19
Speaker 2: No, I don't think that, yeah.
00:16:20
Speaker 9: Yeah.
00:16:21
Speaker 5: Because I think a lot of the, you know, we could say whatever about the accuracy of it, but I think... When it's used by police departments, they're not saying, well, you know, there's a 30 or 40% chance that this could be inaccurate.
00:16:33
Speaker 2: They're saying, well, this is the truth.
00:16:35
Speaker 3: It's like a PED for, you know, getting a conviction, basically.
00:16:41
Speaker 2: It's not fair.
00:16:43
Speaker 1: It's true. There are so many instances where police just zero in on someone and forget about everyone else. I've seen this happen in many episodes of True Crime TV. They let the criminal go for 25, 30 years. Then they're like, oh, it was that guy?
00:17:01
Speaker 2: Yeah, the guy who was, it was obvious if we just looked at the accident.
00:17:04
Speaker 1: We wrote him off immediately because he was nice to us.
00:17:07
Speaker 3: Yeah, to me, the biggest thing that jumped out was, you know, when Amit said that the rough level of accuracy is maybe 70%. And, you know, the average person can guess a liar around 54%. And that's an average person, not an investigator who I should hope could get a little higher.
00:17:26
Speaker 1: But what do you guys think about the average person, 54%, is so high to me. I thought it would be way lower.
00:17:33
Speaker 3: Yeah, but it's a coin toss.
00:17:35
Speaker 4: True, yeah.
00:17:36
Speaker 1: The answer is a showing coin.
00:17:37
Speaker 3: So all you need is one little thing.
00:17:40
Speaker 2: I mean, I don't know.
00:17:42
Speaker 3: Like how often do people lie? 46% of the time.
00:17:47
Speaker 1: That's a great question.
00:17:50
Speaker 5: I think it makes sense. It's like we all know what these tells are, even if it's like kids learn how to lie from adults, right? So like there's patterns that we don't discuss maybe openly of like when someone is lying, they do X, Y, and Z, but.
00:18:06
Speaker 3: We all pick up on. Yeah, because think of some of the things.
00:18:09
Speaker 1: They don't look you in the eye.
00:18:10
Speaker 3: Fidgeting.
00:18:11
Speaker 1: Yeah, fidgeting.
00:18:12
Speaker 2: Stuttering.
00:18:12
Speaker 3: Yeah, adding– like talking a lot more than they need to. I think that's where I would fall.
00:18:17
Speaker 1: If you know the person well, kind of like the lie detector test, you have the base standard and you know if they're deviating from that behavior.
00:18:24
Speaker 3: It's like, man, he's acting weird.
00:18:26
Speaker 8: Yeah, exactly.
00:18:26
Speaker 6: Why?
00:18:27
Speaker 3: So that's a bit of background on the history of the polygraph. And the big takeaway is it's not admissible in court because of that Frye standard, which it does not pass, meaning a majority of experts in the field don't back it up. But the story doesn't end there. Next up, we're going to hear more about how the polygraph is being used at high
levels in our country. When we're back, we'll hear from someone who has been passionately advocating against the polygraph for over 30 years.
00:18:52
Speaker 4: Wow.
00:19:04
Speaker 2: We're back. I'm Manny. I'm Noah.
00:19:06
Speaker 8: Devin.
00:19:07
Speaker 3: So we're talking polygraphs. We heard about the history of the polygraph machine. Now I'm going to introduce you guys to a fellow I met named George. Here's his story.
00:19:18
Speaker 6: My name is George Mashke, and I'm a co-founder of antipolygraph.org, a nonprofit public interest website dedicated to exposing and ending waste, fraud, and abuse associated with a polygraph and other purported lie detectors.
00:19:34
Speaker 3: George, a former Army Reserve intelligence officer, told me he worked with the FBI on a few sensitive investigations.
00:19:39
Speaker 6: So my interest in polygraphy really became keen in 1995 when I applied for a job with the FBI. They had just then started requiring applicants to take polygraph.
00:19:50
Speaker 1: Tests.
00:19:51
Speaker 6: This was after Ulrich Ames was arrested, who ironically had beaten the polygraph twice while spying for the Russians.
00:19:59
Speaker 7: Justice Department officials today charged Aldrich Ames and his wife Rosario with spying on America for the Russians. Ames was arrested on his way to his job at the CIA, where he has worked for 31 years.
00:20:12
Speaker 6: But the FBI got it in their head that using polygraph screening for their applicants would somehow be a good idea. So I was among the first FBI special agent applicants to be polygraphed, and my polygrapher basically decided decided that I'm a spy. He accused me of deception when I denied having unauthorized contacts with a representative of a foreign government, when I denied having released classified information to unauthorized persons. So I didn't have any unauthorized contacts with foreign nationals. I hadn't divulged any classified information to anyone. So this made me very curious. How could I have told the truth yet fail the polygraph? And of course, if you fail an FBI polygraph, it results in your being blacklisted for life from FBI employment. There's no appeal. And the results of your polygraph will be shared with other federal agencies. So it's really quite damaging to one's career prospects, at least in government employment, if you fail an FBI polygraph.
00:21:11
Speaker 3: One thing I can't confirm... is whether or not George is a spy. I asked, he said no, so your guess is as good as mine.
00:21:21
Speaker 2: A lie detector test.
00:21:23
Speaker 1: How terrifying of a situation where you're being grilled about whether you're doing espionage.
00:21:29
Speaker 6: A few years later, as the World Wide Web grew, I discovered a website set up by another polygraph victim, and I found that the failure rate for the polygraph was actually 20% then for the FBI. And It was hard for me to imagine that that many applicants who made it that far in the process were lying about espionage matters or undisclosed criminal activity. I felt the need to speak publicly about my experience and to share what I had learned about the unreliability of polygraphs.
00:22:04
Speaker 1: Well, assuming what he's saying is true, it's so insane that the FBI looked at their data, saw that 20% of the people who were doing the tests were spies and they just didn't second guess. They're like, oh damn, I guess 20%.
00:22:20
Speaker 3: Good thing we got them.
00:22:21
Speaker 1: It's so crazy that no one was like, this doesn't seem right.
00:22:27
Speaker 3: So George failed the FBI polygraph, but we know that the polygraph doesn't pass the Fry standard, which allows it to be admissible in court evidence. So I asked kind of what gives, how does that work? Would you be able to explain the, what the EPPA of 1988 is?
00:22:45
Speaker 2: Yes.
00:22:45
Speaker 6: So that's the Employee Polygraph Protection Act. And it was a law that was passed with bipartisan support, signed by then-President Ronald Reagan, that prohibits most private employers from requiring applicants or employees to submit to lie detector tests. They can only request that they submit to them under very specific circumstances when there's, for example, a suspected loss caused by employee misconduct and the employee they want to polygraph could possibly have committed the crime. In practice, the law is so restrictive that employment-related polygraphs are seldom done in the private sector. But the government carved out a large exception for itself. federal, state, and local government agencies are all excluded from this act, and they can polygraph whoever they like for whatever reason without any legal restrictions.
00:23:44
Speaker 3: And do you have a sense of what the kind of justification for that carve-out was?
00:23:48
Speaker 6: The CIA lobbied for it. The CIA has, and had been then for decades, been a heavy user of polygraphs. And they valued the admissions that they sometimes got from applicants. So they used their influence with Congress to to get this exemption added. There's a few instances where applicants have made admissions to serious crimes. And so admissions of that nature tend to sway policymakers thinking, well, you know, if we hadn't used the polygraph, maybe we would have hired that person. But of course they are hiring people who have committed serious crimes anyway. They're just the ones who are clever enough to fool the lie detector.
00:24:28
Speaker 3: George's website has tons of reference materials and other things. including tips on how to beat the lie detector, which has gotten people like him in some trouble. George told me the cases of two men, Chad Dixon, an Indiana electrician who shared a polygraph passing course as a side hustle, and Doug Williams, a former police polygrapher from Oklahoma who published a manual called How to Sting the Polygraph.
00:24:53
Speaker 6: What the government did was sent undercover agents to them who
purported to be applicants for... government employment or government employees who said they needed to lie on the polygraph. In Doug Williams' case, he initially declined to train the undercover agent, but the undercover agent wouldn't take no for an answer. He kept saying, please, I need your help. I think he appealed to Doug's religion as a Christian to help him. And so eventually both men trained people who said they were either seeking federal employment or a federal employee under investigation. the legal theory on which these cases were based was not that teaching countermeasures is itself illegal, but that it was part of a conspiracy to defraud the government by helping these people gain employment to which they were not entitled.
00:25:48
Speaker 3: The main gist of it there is that last bit of, you know, it's kind of a way of looking at it where these people aren't entitled to have these jobs. So if you're helping them, do that that's illegal and it's it's fraud in some sense if.
00:26:01
Speaker 1: You're helping them defraud yeah knowing that they know they came saying basically hey i've done stuff that i can't do to get this job.
00:26:10
Speaker 3: Yeah help me i need to beat this help me.
00:26:12
Speaker 5: Beat this test which is gonna question me about these things should i can't get the job versus them just coming and saying hey, I just want to know how to beat this test and you don't know anything about me.
00:26:24
Speaker 3: Right, yeah, just offering the class or sharing the book is not illegal and you can find this pretty easily. But if I went and said, I'm a criminal and I need to be in the CIA next week, help me. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's a different sort of situation.
00:26:42
Speaker 6: What I believe the motivation truly was is to silence these people. Criminal investigations were launched against them in the absence of any evidence at all that they had committed any crime. The government set about to manufacture crimes for which to prosecute them. The only crimes to which they pled guilty were the crimes that the government had conceived and orchestrated itself. They didn't involve any actual persons that these people had trained in how to pass a polygraph test.
00:27:13
Speaker 1: Do you remember the... The Gretchen Whitmer case where the guys were like going to kidnap Gretchen Whitmer.
00:27:20
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:27:21
Speaker 1: And, you know, it was such an insane news at the time. And then you read the art, this kind of like expose came out, I think it was in the Times, about just how much the FBI egged them on to do it. They were like, we really don't want to do this.
00:27:36
Speaker 2: Are you sure, bro?
00:27:36
Speaker 3: And it just kept going. Yeah.
00:27:39
Speaker 1: They're like, fine, after like three years.
00:27:42
Speaker 2: Of doing it.
00:27:43
Speaker 3: Yeah, it's like, I'll do anything too. Just leave me alone.
00:27:46
Speaker 1: But I'll say one more thing about making teaching the countermeasures illegal, even though it's pretty narrowly about helping people beat the system, not really beat the test. There's probably, I think, no greater indictment about these tests in general than the idea that, hey, we got to make sure that people don't teach people how to beat them.
00:28:09
Speaker 2: Right.
00:28:09
Speaker 6: Right.
00:28:10
Speaker 1: Because if we could just say lie or not, then what do you have to worry about?
00:28:14
Speaker 3: Especially your high-level examiner. It's not like you're someone off the street just doing a test.
00:28:20
Speaker 1: If your device is so foolproof, you should encourage people to try to beat it if you feel that strongly about it.
00:28:26
Speaker 2: Yep. Clearly you don't. Good point, Manny.
00:28:31
Speaker 3: That's a great point. Anyways, like and subscribe. Yeah, well, we go on a break now. On that note, we have learned about the history of the polygraph. We've seen the controversies surrounding the device and its use. So lastly, let's strap ourselves up to one of these things after the break.
00:29:04
Speaker 1: I'm Manny.
00:29:05
Speaker 2: Noah. Devin.
00:29:07
Speaker 3: And we are back. So, boys, we took a little field trip, a rare field trip, to the city of brotherly love.
00:29:14
Speaker 2: Yes, we did.
00:29:14
Speaker 3: We were visiting our new friend, Nate Gordon.
00:29:17
Speaker 8: My name is Nathan Gordon, and I'm director of the Academy for Scientific and Investigative Training, which is the American Polygraph Association and International Society of Polygraph Examiner Accredited School since 1980.
00:29:31
Speaker 3: Nate's Academy has trained thousands of law enforcement, intelligence, and private security officers all around the world. His office also administers tests themselves, like examining applicants for the Philly Police Department, as well as private sector uses. So he was kind enough to show us how the polygraph works, and Manny, you got strapped in and kind.
00:29:48
Speaker 2: Of put to the test.
00:29:49
Speaker 8: Yeah.
00:29:50
Speaker 2: Immediately.
00:29:50
Speaker 8: Arms up in the air like it's a holdup.
00:29:56
Speaker 2: I can already tell by this handle here.
00:29:59
Speaker 6: Some perspiration is happening.
00:30:03
Speaker 1: They strapped me to a chair by my torso.
00:30:07
Speaker 8: The top thing on his chest and the silver thing on his stomach is picking up body movements, which actually equates to respiration.
00:30:14
Speaker 1: Then they put these devices on my fingers.
00:30:18
Speaker 8: On his right hand, on his index finger and his ring finger. He's picking up electroderma activity, which is basically sweating of the fingertips. The one on his middle finger is a plethysmograph, which is picking up blood volume changes.
00:30:31
Speaker 1: The chair is recording my movement. And then the final thing was one of those cuffs that go on your arm when they're testing your blood pressure at the doctor, for example. So, like, I was
really just kind of, I felt almost like RoboCop or something.
00:30:47
Speaker 3: Now, can you walk us through the actual demo?
00:30:49
Speaker 1: So, Nate showed me three index cards.
00:30:52
Speaker 8: And all three cards, regardless of the color, you'll say yes.
00:30:55
Speaker 1: And so he showed me the first card.
00:30:57
Speaker 2: It was yellow.
00:30:58
Speaker 1: He said, is this yellow?
00:30:59
Speaker 2: I said yes.
00:31:00
Speaker 1: He showed me the second card. It wasn't yellow, but I said yes, it was yellow. Then he showed me the third card, and it was yellow with a little red dot on it. And I said yes, it is yellow. Basically, he was asking me to lie about what I was seeing on the card.
00:31:18
Speaker 3: Yeah, he was trying to get a baseline... For you telling a truth and then you telling a lie. Yeah.
00:31:23
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:31:23
Speaker 3: And Devon and I were able to watch kind of from the other side and we saw the wavelengths coming in and we could see you were, you were pretty shook. And, you know, Nate would be kind of pointing out as you did things and you could actually really see the difference between the control and then the lies. Can you describe what it was like to be set up as a demo subject for the polygraph?
00:31:43
Speaker 1: Yeah, it was extremely nerve wracking. even though we were in a demo environment. And so if I was nervous just sitting there to see how it worked, imagine how nervous people are who are being accused of crimes or leaking information to the press or whatever the case may be. So yeah, man, I was like immediately sweating bullets. Like I could feel myself sweating.
00:32:10
Speaker 2: I think my.
00:32:11
Speaker 1: Knee was kind of jumping a little bit. And I just felt like a shortness of breath almost. Like I was like, whew. Got to lock in for this.
00:32:18
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:32:19
Speaker 2: It was kind of nuts.
00:32:20
Speaker 8: Generally, the biggest question we have from people is, how does nervousness affect the test? So I say, taking a polygraph test is like we're in a strange city late at night. I say, get out of my car and meet two blocks from here. So you get out of the car. You have no idea where you are. It's not well lit. But you can sense it's not a real safe neighborhood to be walking in, but you have to walk. As you're walking down the street, you're going to be a little bit nervous and anxious. Even if you're nervous walking down the street, you walk by an alleyway. Someone comes out of the shadows.
00:32:46
Speaker 2: Hey, you!
00:32:47
Speaker 8: Now, adrenaline starts to flow, your heart really starts to pound fast, hands sweat, air in your back, and that goes up. So even though you're nervous, there's a dramatic change that takes place. Now, any time there's a change, stress, any emotional change, is going to cause physiological change. And that's what we're looking at, physiological change.
00:33:11
Speaker 3: Obviously, you're strapped into this thing. You're probably, in most cases, not taking a polygraph.
00:33:16
Speaker 2: For a good reason. You're on the Maury show.
00:33:19
Speaker 3: Yeah, you're on Maury. So you're going to be, you're in an unnatural kind of environment. Now that we're adding more variables, it doesn't necessarily make me trust the reliability of the results anymore. And necessarily if I'm trying to look at it totally evenly.
00:33:34
Speaker 1: What struck me when he showed me that third card that was yellow with a little red dot was the split second of thinking I had to do. Even though I was supposed to say yes, no matter what.
00:33:46
Speaker 3: Yep.
00:33:46
Speaker 1: That red dot popped up. I had a split second of like, what's going on here? And that registered as a lie. Of course he was asking me to lie, but like, I think in that moment, the thinking that I had to do is what was being registered. Not necessarily that I was lying. So I wonder if in some cases, you know, you get in some real life situations, someone gets a question wrong. They have to think about, they might be telling the truth, but if they had to be like, wait a second, blah, blah, blah. Was it like this? Was it like that?
00:34:20
Speaker 3: Listen, Pete Higgs asked you that? Your ass is out of here. Out of the Pentagon.
00:34:24
Speaker 5: Well, I think, yeah, I think the counter argument would be, you only need to think about something if you are lying, because if it's the truth, then you wouldn't have to consider, you know, but I agree.
00:34:36
Speaker 2: I don't, there's sometimes where you're like, you know, memory's not perfect.
00:34:39
Speaker 5: You may be like, oh, I don't know if I'll, you know, if that happened or if I was exactly there or what time I was at this thing. So there may be, when things aren't so black and white, I could see it registering. But it was interesting that with the three cards.
00:34:53
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:34:54
Speaker 5: It was sort of like a gradient. Your lie had the biggest reaction. Your straight lie had the biggest reaction when the card was just red. And when it was yellow with the red dot, it was a smaller reaction than the big lie, but it was more than the truth.
00:35:07
Speaker 3: Yeah, it was like right between them, which is interesting.
00:35:09
Speaker 2: So it was like kind of like a gradient based on how much you were lying.
00:35:13
Speaker 3: Manny, you actually had brushed up on some of the countermeasures prior to our trip to Philadelphia.
00:35:18
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:35:19
Speaker 3: When you were strapped in there, did you try to use any of them?
00:35:23
Speaker 1: Yes, I did.
00:35:24
Speaker 2: And you failed.
00:35:28
Speaker 1: When I was strapped up and he was asking me to lie about whether the card was yellow, I was trying to make the test appear as if I was telling the truth. But one thing I was thinking was just like being on a beach, like being in a really calm environment. something that's kind of serene, but I just
couldn't do it. Like I tried and he asks you a question. At some point it's, you know, it's socially awkward to not be saying anything. So I'm like, I can't even picture the damn beach before it's time for me to respond. And so all that to say is just like these countermeasure, like people who try to teach you how to beat a lie detector test or polygraph test, God, I feel like it's got to be so much harder than they're making it out to be.
00:36:20
Speaker 8: It depends on the sophistication. It depends on what a person knows. So, for example, if you know nothing about polygraph, countermeasures are usually very obvious. If I was testing a polygraph examiner who knows everything about polygraph, they're not going to be as obvious. So there's other things you would do. There's countermeasure tests that look at the mental aspect of countermeasures and try to identify it that way. Obviously, there's physiological things you could look for. You want to see what countermeasures look like? We can pass them again.
00:36:48
Speaker 2: Yeah, we'd love to. Let's get them back in there.
00:36:52
Speaker 3: Then Nate walked us through some of the more common countermeasures. Manny, care to share what those were?
00:36:57
Speaker 1: The first countermeasure I can remember is clenching my butt.
00:37:02
Speaker 8: Tighten your butt muscle.
00:37:03
Speaker 1: Which was much harder to sustain than I thought it was going to be. It's actually a physical activity that can tire you out.
00:37:14
Speaker 2: You did ask at one point, it's like, can I stop now? Can I stop now?
00:37:19
Speaker 6: Sniff.
00:37:21
Speaker 8: Flex your muscle on the other side. Press down on your toes. Bite your tongue. On your right hand, press down on those things. Press on your toes.
00:37:32
Speaker 2: Swallow.
00:37:34
Speaker 8: Swallow.
00:37:36
Speaker 3: Yeah, and then as he did those, he was pointing out to us on the chart the differences of seeing how this affects it. And those are the things that he looks for if he suspects someone is trying to use these countermeasures.
00:37:48
Speaker 8: We have processes to identify what normal baselines should look like. And we record what normal baselines should look like. And I could have five minutes of normal physiology. And now I say we're about to begin the test, and now I see this gross change. Then I know that's deliberate. So I would probably first give you a warning that some people try to control things in their body because they want to help me. They're telling the truth and they want to help me find that. Some people do it because they're trying to beat me because they're guilty. I can't tell if a person's doing it to help me or beat me, but I can tell you I'm good at what I do, so I don't need your help. If you continue to do what you're doing, you're going to fail the test. That would be my first warning.
00:38:30
Speaker 3: So, of course, we had to ask, how reliable are the polygraph tests, according to Nate?
00:38:35
Speaker 8: So first of all, it depends on what kind of test you're doing. So we have different kinds of tests.
00:38:42
Speaker 3: Nate broke down three types of tests. Single issue, multifaceted, and multi-issue. The first, single issue, looks at one question asked in different ways.
00:38:51
Speaker 8: Did you shoot John? Regarding John, did you shoot him? Were you the person who shot John?
00:38:55
Speaker 3: And for each test, he'll ask the same questions in different order to gather more data.
00:38:59
Speaker 8: So now I run three charts of that, and I'm making an evaluation based on nine views. I've seen it nine times. So a single issue is going to give you the most accurate test. That's the only test that will give you above 90% accuracy.
00:39:13
Speaker 3: Type 2 is multifaceted. Multifaceted tests look at different aspects of the same crime.
00:39:18
Speaker 8: Did you plan with anyone to shoot John? Did you shoot John? Do you know for sure who shot John? Well, now if I run three tries, I'm only getting to see each relevant question three times. Multifaceted. maybe mid-80s.
00:39:32
Speaker 3: And lastly, a mixed-issue test is like a screening test, asking about a bunch of unrelated things.
00:39:38
Speaker 8: Drugs, theft, undetected crime, physical altercations.
00:39:44
Speaker 3: Overall, according to Nate, it's really dependent on the examiner knowing what they're looking at.
00:39:49
Speaker 8: When you look at polygraph, we say it's an art based on the sciences of psychology and physiology, psychophysiology. But the art is the examiner. So it's like anything else. You have to plug that into the formula. How good is the examiner? When I was growing up, I used to believe that there was an 80-20 rule in life. 80% of any profession was fair to poor, and 20% was good to excellent. As I grew older, I realized that's probably not true. It's probably like 90-10.
00:40:21
Speaker 3: And, of course, this led to the big question about why polygraphs aren't admissible in court. And Nate brought up our old friend Fry of the Fry Standard.
00:40:31
Speaker 8: So in 1923, a very prominent doctor gets murdered in Washington, D.C. They offer a reward. Someone comes forward and tells the police he knows the shooter. His name is Alfonso Fry. Police arrest Fry. They interrogate, and he confesses. He hires a defense attorney. and they hire a doctor by the name of William Marston. And all he would do is he would put a cuff on a person, have their arm through a curtain while someone interviewed them, and every now and then he'd put air on the cuff and take a systolic blood pressure reading. And based on that, he reported 90-something percent accuracy, determining deception. So they hire Marston, and he does a discontinuous blood pressure test and says, in fact, Fry was telling the truth when he said he didn't shoot him. Unfortunately, two years before that, 1921, Berkeley, California Police Department came out with the first polygraph, which monitored
constant changes in cardio, vascular activity, as well as respiration. And the prosecutors showed that discontinuous blood pressure was not state of the art. So the Supreme Court rolled against it. That 1923 decision of a discontinuous blood pressure test is what keeps polygraph out of most courts in the United States.
00:41:48
Speaker 3: So in Nate's view, it's not fair that the Frye standard is based on the discontinuous blood pressure reading and not the more comprehensive data from the polygraph. And while there have been some cases arguing for its use, the device is still largely not allowed in federal court. But state courts tell a slightly different story. While most states have a strict polygraph ban, some others do allow their use by stipulation, which means both the prosecution and the defense have to agree on admitting the polygraph as evidence. And New Mexico is the only state that allows polygraph results without the need for both sides to agree. So be careful if you're ever over there. Let's talk about our overall thoughts on this.
00:42:32
Speaker 1: What I came away with was that these polygraphs are incredibly good at testing the specific things that they're trying to test. And that, you know, originally I thought, You could just appear to be so calm throughout the entire interview process that, you know, they would never detect any lying. But yes, as we learned, you've got the control questions first. If you're super calm during the control questions, you know, that's what they're going to use as their baseline. Or if you're super erratic during the control questions, that's what they're going to use during the baseline. And they're detecting a change, not just the behaviors by themselves.
00:43:14
Speaker 3: That said.
00:43:19
Speaker 1: I still feel like I can't necessarily say it's testing whether you're lying.
00:43:26
Speaker 2: Well, yeah.
00:43:26
Speaker 3: So this is the thing. And Nate said as much where talking about how reliable it is, he says something like it's very dependent on the examiner. So you have an expert examiner. They're going to be maybe better at sussing this out. It ultimately comes down to a judgment call of someone who is used to doing these things and looking for certain things. The machine itself is only going to give you so much data. It's additive to something, but ultimately it is just measuring one thing. If there actually was a tool that could 100% or 99% say, this is a lie, it would be a world-changing event. And we wouldn't be having this debate about if it should be allowed in court or something. It would change the entire universe. as we know it. I mean, it really would.
00:44:18
Speaker 1: Nate was careful to refer to these as polygraph tests, not what we call them in regular society, lie detector tests. And he was clear that that's not what it's detecting. It's detecting changes in your behavior. And like you said, it ends up just being a judgment call based on who the examiner is. But, you know, to that point, I guess it's kind of always been a judgment call to determine whether someone's lying or not.
00:44:45
Speaker 3: Do you think there's... a good case for this to be admissible in court.
00:44:49
Speaker 1: The big problem for me is even though I think a polygraph could tell, can tell when I'm lying, I think I'm dead to rights.
00:44:57
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:44:59
Speaker 1: If one guy in the world can beat a lie detector test, then you got to throw the whole shit away in terms of like sentencing someone else or like convicting someone else based on that.
00:45:09
Speaker 5: And there's clearly people failing it who are telling the truth. So it's like, there's something going on with it. And it's like, yeah, you know, I'm not saying, I'm not going to say it's like a broken clock. I think it's, you know, I think it's probably, it's my read of it. It's, it's probably more accurate than I was anticipating.
00:45:26
Speaker 8: Yeah.
00:45:26
Speaker 2: After seeing it in action. More useful. Yeah.
00:45:29
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:45:29
Speaker 5: But I, I don't think like any, it seems like a thing, you know, like it should stick to like Maury, you know, it's like, like, I don't know that we should be using this in any sort of high stakes situation. It should be like a, oh, we're going to go out and have a good time with my work group and we're going to get lie detectors. That's the level.
00:45:51
Speaker 2: Party trick. Exactly.
00:45:53
Speaker 5: It shouldn't be something that's determining whether somebody's going to jail or whether or not somebody's getting a job.
00:45:59
Speaker 2: It just feels like, what are we doing here?
00:46:03
Speaker 5: And I think we went to one of the best people to do this test, too. That's another thing, right? It's like all things. There are people who are much better With the same title at something than people who have the exact same title who are much worse.
00:46:18
Speaker 2: So it's like we went to the best guy. Man, he's not that great at lying. He caught him lying about a card. He's a perfect storm. But to put someone in jail over this is crazy.
00:46:28
Speaker 7: Yeah.
00:46:29
Speaker 3: No, I totally agree. It's how I feel about the death penalty or something like that where it's like I would rather take the risk that a guilty man walk free than– The chance that someone's locked up for life or loses their job and career or et cetera, et cetera.
00:46:44
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:46:45
Speaker 3: Based on something that we can't really prove.
00:46:48
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:46:48
Speaker 3: Based on just this tool.
00:46:50
Speaker 8: Yeah.
00:46:50
Speaker 1: Look at this highly decorated general that just got fired by Pete Hegseth for failing, allegedly failing three separate polygraph tests. Just kind of crazy that that is what the standard of evidence is that got him fired. I do wonder, the Maury guys, how many of them must have gone to their wives after being caught cheating, being like, babe, these are unreliable. You've got to do some research on them.
00:47:20
Speaker 3: Listen to No Such Thing. No Such Thing is a production of Kaleidoscope Content. Our executive producer is Mangesh Hatikadur. The show is created by Manny Fidel, Noah Friedman, and Devin Joseph. Theme and credits music by Manny. Mixing is by Steve Bone. Our guests this week were Amit Katwala, George Mashki, and Nathan Gordon. Thank you all for your time. If you have feedback for us or a question, our email is mandynoahdevin at gmail.com. Or you can leave us a voicemail by calling the number in our show notes. Our website is nosuchthing.show. And we'll be back next week with a new episode.
00:47:56
Speaker 2: Bye.
00:47:57
Speaker 9: No such thing.