TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to lessons from the Sensei, law, business, and life.
[0:08] Welcome to lessons from the Sensei, law, business, and life with Dennis Quintana, veteran
[0:13] Orlando defense attorney.
[0:15] I'm Shmika Rhymes, and today we're talking about what happens when you're facing criminal
[0:19] charges for the first time.
[0:20] A lot of people assume that because they've never been arrested before, the court will
[0:25] automatically go easy on them.
[0:27] Sometimes a clean record can help, but it doesn't erase the charge or guarantee a particular
[0:32] outcome.
[0:33] So let's talk about what actually changes for first time offenders and what doesn't.
[0:39] Welcome back, Dennis.
[0:41] It's great to be back.
[0:42] It's great to see you.
[0:44] Well, Dennis, does being a first time offender change your case as much as people think it does?
[0:50] Well, you know, the classic legal answer is, it depends, right?
[0:55] So we can agree that if you have a long record that that's not going to help your case, right?
[1:05] So the idea of a no record, a first time offense, it depends on the level of the offense.
[1:13] So for example, if it's a first time offense and you're the Pope, you've got an exemplary record
[1:20] and you've done all sorts of public service and you've got a great character, right?
[1:25] But the first offense is murder.
[1:27] You know, that's a serious offense, right?
[1:30] So yeah, it's your first offense, but man, it's a big one and it's a bad one.
[1:35] So probably not going to matter very much.
[1:40] Now, as you get to more common routine,
[1:45] I don't want to say popular, let's say more ubiquitous things like, for example, a DUI,
[1:57] a DUI in Florida is driving under the influence of alcohol.
[2:01] And it is one of those offenses that if you have priors, it gets worse, right?
[2:07] So the second one and the third one and the fourth one, I mean, they can become felonies.
[2:12] So in several jurisdictions now throughout the state,
[2:17] a first time DUI is eligible for some jurisdictions call it a diversion program,
[2:25] others call it a pretrial intervention program.
[2:29] What it is is because you've never been arrested before.
[2:34] And there have to be some other qualifiers, right?
[2:37] They can't have been an accident, can't be any injuries.
[2:42] And so a first time offense is eligible, and this DUI is not the only charge.
[2:48] But diversion programs and pretrial intervention programs,
[2:52] or programs where they take first time offenders for certain circumstances,
[2:56] and they allow them to bypass the criminal system.
[3:01] So when they say diversion, they mean divert it.
[3:04] So out of the normal criminal routine,
[3:08] and most of them, you substantially complete the same kind of rehabilitative penalties,
[3:14] which would include things like driving school and a DUI,
[3:18] or if it's a theft class like, you know, petty theft could be an impulse control class.
[3:24] There may be community service.
[3:26] But the net effect of it is, is they take you out of the criminal system.
[3:30] And then you do some rehabilitative things, and then they dismiss the charge.
[3:35] And so that's a big benefit.
[3:39] There are other things that a first time offender may be eligible for.
[3:44] So even though something happened, and there's evidence of it,
[3:48] when the judge goes to enter a sentence,
[3:51] the judge isn't required to convict you.
[3:58] There are some cases that have a mandatory adjudication conviction.
[4:03] DUI is one of them.
[4:05] If you're being sentenced, DUI domestic violence is another one.
[4:09] The judge is not allowed to not convict you.
[4:12] But on something like a petty theft, they're allowed to withhold adjudication.
[4:18] So to adjudicate means to judge.
[4:21] And that translates into convict.
[4:24] Right to withhold to not impose an adjudgment and adjudication means you're not convicted.
[4:32] So it's analogous to driving offenses.
[4:35] Sometimes when you get a speeding ticket, if you pay the ticket,
[4:38] you might get points on your license.
[4:40] And if you get a lot of points, your license gets convicted.
[4:43] So the points are your license gets suspended.
[4:46] And so the points are considered a conviction.
[4:49] And in many jurisdictions, like Florida, if you elect to take a driving school instead of just pay in the ticket,
[4:57] then they will withhold the points.
[4:59] You won't get the points accumulated on your license.
[5:02] And in criminal cases, for first time offenders,
[5:05] these diversion programs or pretrial intervention programs are really a good avenue,
[5:12] because it's one way of guaranteeing,
[5:15] you know, so long as you complete whatever they're asking you to do,
[5:19] because it puts you in the driver's seat, right?
[5:21] They say, hey, Shamika, you know, I know you went to this, you know, great New Year's Eve party.
[5:25] And everybody loved you so much.
[5:27] They were buying you all these drinks.
[5:29] And you really wanted to get home and you shouldn't have driven.
[5:32] So, but apparently now that the, you know, legal requirements for alcohol are so low,
[5:38] you blew over the legal limit.
[5:40] However, we're not going to, you know, convict you,
[5:44] we're going to allow you to do a diversion program.
[5:47] And so long as you learn from the diversion program,
[5:50] case gets dismissed.
[5:51] So that's, that's the concept.
[5:53] There's one other issue with when it comes to first time offenders.
[5:57] So if you're in, in Florida, there's a thing called youthful offender.
[6:03] And so if you're not a juvenile, if you're over 18,
[6:07] but you're not over 22, so between 18 and 22,
[6:12] there is a statute that's called a youthful offender sentencing statute.
[6:17] And even if you are convicted of a more serious offense,
[6:22] it limits or it mitigates what the court could do in terms of a normal sentence
[6:29] to a
Load full transcript
maximum of six years.
[6:31] And a maximum of six years can be divided in multiple different ways.
[6:35] It can start out with some period of incarceration.
[6:38] It can have some period of community control or what's called house arrest,
[6:43] followed by some period of probation.
[6:46] And so youthful offender is something where let's say somebody young,
[6:50] you know, a 20 year old is doing stupid stuff with the wrong crowd.
[6:55] And they get arrested for armed robbery.
[6:58] You know, armed robbery is a serious offense.
[7:01] And so some people can go to prison for many, many years on that.
[7:05] And armed robbery is a first degree felony where the judge has up to 30 years
[7:09] to, you know, to supervise you.
[7:11] But if you qualify for youthful offender, then it capsid at six years.
[7:16] And so it might be two years of prison followed by two years of community control
[7:20] or it might be six years of probation.
[7:23] But that's something that's not necessarily first time offense,
[7:27] but when you're thinking about young people, hopefully it is the first time offense.
[7:30] Right.
[7:32] So yeah, it can, it can definitely help.
[7:35] Remember, right, we're not supposed to break the law.
[7:38] That's just basic stuff.
[7:40] Right.
[7:41] They're giving us credit if we don't.
[7:43] So I'm an old fart. Right.
[7:45] I'm 60 years old.
[7:46] If I show up in court and have never been convicted of anything,
[7:49] they're going to go, wow, you know,
[7:51] either you've been lucky and you haven't gotten caught or maybe for most of your life,
[7:55] you know, you did, you did what we're all supposed to do.
[7:58] The basic stuff.
[7:59] And so maybe, you know, this one circumstance,
[8:03] the Miami Hurricanes lost a national championship and you punched the Indiana fan.
[8:08] I would never do that.
[8:09] Indiana is a great team.
[8:10] But, you know, what I'm saying is they're like, they're like,
[8:13] look, man, you know, you did something that's out of character.
[8:15] We're going to, we're going to give you some consideration for that.
[8:18] Well, Dennis, first of all, you don't look 60.
[8:20] So I think you're, I think you're making things up today.
[8:25] No, no, no, no, if I were lying, it would be about my weight.
[8:28] Because I'm, you know, I'm going to get as a bikini figure.
[8:32] It might be a big bikini, but I'm getting there someday.
[8:35] Well, where does having a clean record actually really make the biggest difference?
[8:42] I know we were talking about, well, you know,
[8:44] the first, your first charge is murder.
[8:46] That's a huge one.
[8:46] Even if you've got a clean record.
[8:48] But say, what if your first charge is, you know,
[8:52] you're, you're caught selling drugs or, you know, like,
[8:56] I'm trying to think of something else.
[8:58] Great question.
[8:58] So, so other, other, there are, there are different ways.
[9:04] Different kinds or categories of diversion.
[9:08] So one
of them in Florida is called drug court.
[9:10] And so drug court is a program that is designed for somebody who is possessing drugs.
[9:18] And somebody who may use drugs.
[9:20] It's not designed for somebody who's selling drugs.
[9:24] So I'm arrested for possession with intent to sell, right?
[9:28] Possession with intent to sell would say they found me with whatever narcotic cocaine in a bunch of little baggies.
[9:36] And so it looks like it was packaged for me to distribute.
[9:40] They're going to say that's possession with intent to sell your sale and delivery.
[9:44] We don't, we don't like drug dealers, right?
[9:48] But if I have a little bit of cocaine or if I have one pill of ecstasy.
[9:54] And if I have one pill of ecstasy, like it's for my personal use,
[9:56] then they're going to say, OK, that's possession.
[10:00] And, and if you have a possession offense and you don't have a record, a long record,
[10:04] you can participate in drug court.
[10:06] Drug court is, again, it's counseling.
[10:10] It's outpatient group counseling.
[10:12] It's supposed to be remedial to help you not come back.
[10:16] And it's designed for people who use drugs and shouldn't be using drugs.
[10:20] But the carrot is that if you complete it all, then at the end of it, they dismiss it.
[10:26] And that's very important because possession of cocaine or possession of ecstasy or, or Xanax, right?
[10:34] Some people have anxiety issues.
[10:36] And a friend says, oh, try my Xanax, right?
[10:38] Take my value.
[10:40] And so it's, they're trying to help a friend.
[10:42] Friends got an anxiety.
[10:44] They're going to take a flight.
[10:44] They're scared of flying or whatever the issue is.
[10:46] But that pill isn't prescribed to them.
[10:50] And so they're not lawfully supposed to have it, right?
[10:52] So they get arrested for possession.
[10:56] OK, well, the, the charge of possession of a substance like that, that's a felony.
[11:02] If you get convicted of a felony, you're going to lose, you're going to lose your right to vote.
[11:06] You're going to lose your right to bear arms.
[11:08] You're going to lose your right to have, you know, some professional licenses.
[11:12] So in Florida, a real estate license is governed by the department of professional regulation and the Florida real estate commission.
[11:20] So felony convictions keep you from not only professional licenses like, like real estate, but stockbroker or, or having a, if you're a bodega owner, right?
[11:32] And you want to sell alcohol, you can't get a liquor license or you can't sell lottery tickets.
[11:38] So if I'm, if I'm arrested and convicted of possession of a drug while I'm driving, it'll also suspend my license.
[11:46] So it has these ancillary consequences in addition to the stigma, because now I'm a convicted felon.
[11:54] Right.
[11:54] And I'm a convicted felon for possession of drugs.
[11:56] So, you know, a potential employer or a future business partner.
[12:02] And they're going to go, dude, Dennis is a, is a rapid, you know, drug user.
[12:08] We don't want to hire him.
[12:10] We don't want to invest with him.
[12:12] So, you know, people draw all these assumptions.
[12:14] You may have gotten a Xanax pill from a friend because you were going to fly.
[12:18] When you got to the airport, they searched your bag and they found a Xanax pill in your purse.
[12:24] And then you got arrested.
[12:24] And you're not, you're not a horrible painless person.
[12:28] But now you have this scarlet letter around your neck because of the drug conviction.
[12:34] And so drug court is designed to help people in that circumstance.
[12:40] And that's where, you know, lack of a record helps.
[12:44] Okay.
[12:44] So I'm curious though, if they do get caught at the airport and they say, oh, it's, it's my friend gave it to me.
[12:50] Does the friend get in trouble too?
[12:52] No.
[12:52] Okay.
[12:54] Well, because, I mean, if, first of all, I, you know, I can say, oh, that ain't mine.
[12:58] I don't know how I got there.
[12:58] Right.
[13:00] But, but if it's in my possession, I'm, I'm presumed to have knowledge of it.
[13:04] I mean, especially if it's in my purse.
[13:06] Right.
[13:06] A purse is something that is personal.
[13:10] Or if it's in my pocket.
[13:12] Right.
[13:12] But, you know, I get a lot of kids that get arrested and they have them in a book bag.
[13:18] And the book bag is in the back of a car.
[13:20] And there's four people in the car.
[13:22] Right.
[13:24] So who's is it?
[13:24] Right.
[13:26] So when, when something like that happens, then it opens up the idea of, well, how do you know who's it is?
[13:30] So many people had access to this.
[13:32] And so that becomes a defense is called constructive possession.
[13:36] You're not actually holding it.
[13:38] It's not in your, on your person.
[13:40] But it's somewhere where they're going to try to prove that either you have knowledge or you have control, dominion or control.
[13:46] But I may not have knowledge.
[13:48] I'll give you a quick story.
[13:50] I remember when I was in law school, they had the William Kennedy Smith trials.
[13:56] So one of the Kennedys was accused of, of sexual assault on a young lady and Palm Beach.
[14:02] One of the witnesses was Senator, then Senator Ted Kennedy.
[14:06] And Ted Kennedy was talking about, he was being asked, where were you that night?
[14:10] And he was saying, well, I had gone to this particular restaurant.
[14:14] And he had rented a car.
[14:16] It was notable to me because, first of all, you know, in Kennedy, in the 90s, the Kennedys, you know, in Palm Beach, they have the Kennedy compound.
[14:27] You know, I figured, oh, the guy's got a Bugatti or a Rolls Royce or so.
[14:31] And no, he just rented a, like, a Dodge, you know, regular car.
[14:35] Okay.
[14:36] And then when he gets to the restaurant, he intentionally never valets.
[14:42] And I thought, dude, this guy's like,
you know, this guy's got money.
[14:46] Like, maybe I don't valets. I don't want to spend money on the ballet.
[14:49] Right. Exactly.
[14:50] This guy's got great.
[14:52] And he's like, he's like, look, I don't, I don't valet because, because I'm a Kennedy, right.
[14:57] I don't want anybody not only getting in and out of a car, but leaving something in a car that I may not have knowledge about.
[15:04] And then later on, I get arrested and the paparazzi are there.
[15:08] And, you know, here's all sorts of heinous things.
[15:11] So I, I try to be discreet.
[15:14] I rent regular average cars.
[15:17] I park it myself.
[15:18] I don't care if people call me cheap.
[15:20] I don't have anything to prove, right.
[15:22] Wow.
[15:23] And I thought, oh, that's interesting.
[15:24] But the point is is, you may be helping somebody out, giving them a ride.
[15:28] You may be going home for school.
[15:29] They might leave something in your car.
[15:31] You don't know.
[15:32] Later on, you get pulled over for speeding and they search your car.
[15:35] They find something in the back.
[15:36] They're going to go, hey, Jamaica, you're alone at your car.
[15:38] This is yours.
[15:39] You're going to go, oh, no clue.
[15:41] So many people have been in and out of my car to be anybody.
[15:44] So that's just a tangent on constructive possession and the idea that people, you know,
[15:51] the prosecutors have to prove knowledge.
[15:53] But why would you not have knowledge or something in your car?
[15:56] Because you have other people in your car.
[15:58] Could be you took it to the car wash and somebody dropped a pill in it from the car wash.
[16:02] You don't know.
[16:03] Right.
[16:04] That's very true.
[16:05] Well, as we wrap up, if someone is facing criminal charges for the first time,
[16:10] would advice, would you want them to remember throughout the process?
[16:13] Always consider all the alternatives and to get some, some, you know, get some help.
[16:19] Get, get, get an attorney.
[16:21] Because you, you may think, man, I really screwed up.
[16:24] This is that of character.
[16:25] You've, you've never been arrested before.
[16:27] And you think, look, I'm just going to go in and I'm an accept responsibility.
[16:30] And I'm going to beg for forgiveness without realizing, hey, maybe,
[16:34] there's these alternatives and maybe somebody could get you into a diversion program.
[16:39] And, and, and, and just quickly, you know, the diversion programs are not just for drugs or for DUI.
[16:44] But they also have things called veterans court and they also have something called mental health court.
[16:49] And so if you're a veteran, you know, you, you may get some special consideration because of the special service on the circumstances.
[16:56] That, that may have, you know, ultimately led to whatever it is you're doing now.
[17:00] And so if you're just not aware of these things and you commit to sentence and a conviction, you, you may not be taking advantage of all of the things available to you.
[17:10] And that's, that's why an attorney can help, right?
[17:12] Because the biggest obstacle to good decision making is not considering all the alternatives.
[17:17] And our job is to educate you, defend you, protect you and give you as many options so that you can continue your life as before.
[17:25] Hopefully in a good meaningful, productive and happy manner.
[17:28] Thank you, Dennis. This has been an informative, as always, in a great conversation.
[17:32] Thanks. You should make it your very kind.
[17:34] Well, that is it for today's episode of Lessons from the Sensei Law Business and Life.
[17:39] If you'd like to learn more or speak with Dennis Quintana, contact Sensei Legal at 407-694-5403.
[17:48] Thanks for listening and don't forget to subscribe, share, and leave a review if you found this episode helpful.
[17:54] Thanks for watching. Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments.