TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
1
00:00:05,727 --> 00:00:08,811
Hello, you're listening to Inking Neon.
2
00:00:08,811 --> 00:00:10,536
I'm Cullen McHael
3
00:00:11,896 --> 00:00:18,630
and I'm Stuart Tanner, here to talk about this week's subject, is plot.
4
00:00:19,463 --> 00:00:20,793
or no plot.
5
00:00:21,454 --> 00:00:27,355
There's a long time running debate among authors, or maybe it's just a favorite question
to ask each other.
6
00:00:27,355 --> 00:00:29,596
Are you a plotter or a pantser?
7
00:00:30,336 --> 00:00:41,789
Where a plotter is someone who carefully constructs their stories in advance ah with
something that looks like the murder board in a murder mystery, ah putting together all
8
00:00:41,789 --> 00:00:48,243
the characters and ideas and carefully sketching out the twists and turns of the story in
advance.
9
00:00:48,243 --> 00:00:53,154
like an architect with a blueprint, and then executing on that blueprint.
10
00:00:53,154 --> 00:00:54,255
That would be a plotter.
11
00:00:54,255 --> 00:01:03,677
ah By contrast, there are Pantsers or so the story goes, people who just make it up as
they go along.
12
00:01:04,058 --> 00:01:12,780
And then once you get to the end, you usually take a step back, figure out where you
arrived, and make it look like you meant to get there all along.
13
00:01:13,740 --> 00:01:16,601
So that's the plotter versus pancer debate.
14
00:01:18,355 --> 00:01:19,225
Which are you, Stuart?
15
00:01:19,225 --> 00:01:20,868
Are you a plotter or a pantser?
16
00:01:21,174 --> 00:01:25,597
I am definitely a plotter and I'm going to advocate for plotting.
17
00:01:25,597 --> 00:01:39,604
Particularly if you're playing in the arena of speculative fiction, writing science
fiction or fantasy or related genre, then yes, I'm going to be big advocate for plotting.
18
00:01:39,604 --> 00:01:43,986
And there is a fundamental reason why.
19
00:01:45,983 --> 00:01:50,062
Well, that's perfect because I'm a bit more of a pantser myself.
20
00:01:50,062 --> 00:01:53,510
So we'll lay out the arguments on either side.
21
00:01:53,510 --> 00:01:55,553
See, that's a phrase I'm never gonna say.
22
00:01:55,553 --> 00:01:56,877
Not a panther
23
00:01:56,938 --> 00:02:02,087
I'm definitely not going to ever say, no, I'm more of a pantser myself.
24
00:02:02,087 --> 00:02:02,948
Yeah.
25
00:02:03,404 --> 00:02:09,525
Yes, well, there are a lot of things that a pantser might be, and I am almost a none of
them.
26
00:02:09,525 --> 00:02:14,885
But in the case of the pantser versus plotter debate, I will accept the title.
27
00:02:17,287 --> 00:02:32,412
Okay, I guess we'll layout our cases and um I mean the the big idea behind, you know, me
saying that I'm definitely an advocate for plotting, particularly in speculative fiction,
28
00:02:32,412 --> 00:02:38,994
is because of, you know, one maybe or like two reasons.
29
00:02:38,994 --> 00:02:40,535
Let's start with two reasons.
30
00:02:40,535 --> 00:02:42,585
We can definitely add more.
31
00:02:42,695 --> 00:02:48,256
But number one reason is time.
32
00:02:49,077 --> 00:02:51,318
Time is so precious.
33
00:02:51,318 --> 00:02:53,038
It's hard enough as it is.
34
00:02:53,038 --> 00:02:55,555
You're living a life and you've got to earn coin.
35
00:02:55,555 --> 00:02:56,779
You've got to do everything else.
36
00:02:56,779 --> 00:03:01,781
You want to be a writer and you haven't inherited a family fortune.
37
00:03:01,781 --> 00:03:05,302
So use of time is a really important thing.
38
00:03:05,302 --> 00:03:10,573
Finding the time to write and then using the time wisely and all the rest of it.
39
00:03:10,879 --> 00:03:23,761
And um one of the things that plot plotting helps you with is basically making sure that
as you progress through the novel, you don't get fascinated by a little glorious little
40
00:03:23,761 --> 00:03:35,031
den off on the left and go down that route and start writing something that is not belong
to that novel, but belongs to a different idea in a different novel.
41
00:03:35,031 --> 00:03:37,223
And it's a very good idea and it would
42
00:03:37,223 --> 00:03:43,386
be great in that other novel, but it doesn't belong in this one that you've already
written a third of.
43
00:03:43,526 --> 00:03:54,612
And you really don't want to discover that after you've spent another few chapters writing
about that glorious tale and its story, and then realizing that you've gone way off from
44
00:03:54,612 --> 00:03:57,293
your main story and you have to cut it all back.
45
00:03:57,774 --> 00:03:59,115
You can do it that way.
46
00:03:59,115 --> 00:04:03,777
uh you know, maybe there's a pantser argument for that.
47
00:04:03,917 --> 00:04:06,361
But uh I don't think it's a good idea.
48
00:04:06,361 --> 00:04:07,315
I think it's
49
00:04:07,315 --> 00:04:16,255
very good idea to plot and from my experience I would say most writers are around about 70
percent.
50
00:04:16,255 --> 00:04:17,495
What does that mean?
51
00:04:17,495 --> 00:04:25,595
It means that there's a little bit of room for the pantser in there, So you know,
discovery writing.
52
00:04:26,455 --> 00:04:36,307
Everybody has the experience of when you're working on a story, even if you've written a
plot, that your character kind of like does something funky or
53
00:04:36,307 --> 00:04:44,346
takes a different direction than you expected or you have a fresh idea and it can be a
really compelling idea and a correct idea.
54
00:04:44,346 --> 00:04:56,667
So you need some room for adjustment, for discovery, those magical moments when those
things break through into your consciousness and you think, oh yeah, yeah, that is
55
00:04:56,667 --> 00:04:58,287
absolutely it.
56
00:04:58,287 --> 00:04:59,747
That makes sense.
57
00:04:59,767 --> 00:05:05,811
So I wouldn't advocate being 100 % totally, you know,
58
00:05:05,811 --> 00:05:09,614
uh architecturally complete 100 percent.
59
00:05:09,614 --> 00:05:17,190
um I think
Load full transcript
it is good to have some room for discovery and so that's good thing but but
60
00:05:17,190 --> 00:05:20,484
making all my arguments for me, but yeah.
61
00:05:20,484 --> 00:05:29,537
as long as I think, you like if you hit, if you strike in around 60 or 70 percent, then
I'm happy for you and for me.
62
00:05:30,190 --> 00:05:43,402
I would, first of all, I think you're absolutely correct that the pantser argument, the
like kind of thesis behind winging it when you're writing a novel or preparing a
63
00:05:43,402 --> 00:05:49,767
screenplay uh is the joy of discovery in a word, the joy of discovery.
64
00:05:49,848 --> 00:05:57,344
That exploration of the idea when it happens organically can be extremely enjoyable.
65
00:05:57,762 --> 00:06:06,435
and just getting pulled along by the whimsy or the surprise of your own story is a huge
part of it.
66
00:06:06,435 --> 00:06:12,476
You would think that a writer would know what was going to happen, but oftentimes we
really don't any more than anyone else.
67
00:06:12,476 --> 00:06:15,907
That's what makes it exciting to write the book.
68
00:06:16,087 --> 00:06:18,268
So that joy of discovery is really important.
69
00:06:18,268 --> 00:06:25,642
And I think it's important because writing a book or a screenplay is an immense amount of
work because you're not going to get
70
00:06:25,642 --> 00:06:34,367
much in the way of positive feedback from anyone beside yourself for months or years when
you set out to write a novel or to write a screenplay.
71
00:06:34,367 --> 00:06:42,430
uh It's not like posting on social media where you get immediate dopamine hits every time
somebody likes it.
72
00:06:43,012 --> 00:06:51,036
You can be slaving away on a novel for years and not get a single iota of social credit
or...
73
00:06:51,237 --> 00:06:54,028
So really, you've got to love what you're doing.
74
00:06:54,138 --> 00:07:00,838
And that joy of discovery can be an important bit of catnip to keep you pulled along.
75
00:07:00,878 --> 00:07:04,718
Wanting to find out what's going to happen can keep you going through the story.
76
00:07:04,718 --> 00:07:11,118
But that said, I'm not even going to argue with your point, your allegation that plotting
is more efficient.
77
00:07:11,958 --> 00:07:12,798
I'm not.
78
00:07:12,798 --> 00:07:13,818
You are correct.
79
00:07:13,818 --> 00:07:17,898
If you have a plot and you can execute on that plot, that's going to be a lot faster.
80
00:07:17,898 --> 00:07:21,018
That is how people like Terry Pratchett could do three books a year.
81
00:07:22,147 --> 00:07:32,750
Yeah, and I think that, know, um if you go through the plotting process, then ah you know,
you have every right as the writer to throw away your plot.
82
00:07:32,750 --> 00:07:40,472
uh Or I doubt whether you will entirely, but you might do partially due to the
discoveries.
83
00:07:40,572 --> 00:07:50,865
But I think, you know, if you stride forth along the path, you know, you don't
even know
which mountain you've chosen to climb yet.
84
00:07:50,963 --> 00:07:55,789
um then you certainly can get lost along the way.
85
00:07:55,789 --> 00:07:57,912
I mean it can be fun to get lost.
86
00:07:57,912 --> 00:08:05,781
You could end up in the Trolls Cave for all you know and it could have a very interesting
time there.
87
00:08:06,783 --> 00:08:08,906
I'm sure we've all done that occasionally.
88
00:08:08,906 --> 00:08:09,757
oh
89
00:08:09,757 --> 00:08:15,370
will actually produce a product that people want to buy uh is another question.
90
00:08:16,271 --> 00:08:22,736
To make one of Stuart's arguments for him, there is a huge advantage to plotting in that.
91
00:08:24,678 --> 00:08:32,963
When you're plotting a book, you can see its wholeness and you can know in advance whether
it is a thing that is worth doing.
92
00:08:33,925 --> 00:08:36,306
There is a real risk in
93
00:08:36,448 --> 00:08:46,843
in exploration writing and at the end of the way, you've got a product that is compelling
to you, but that no one is going to pay you for, right?
94
00:08:46,843 --> 00:08:49,464
That might be impossible to market.
95
00:08:50,085 --> 00:08:52,546
And marketing is important actually.
96
00:08:52,827 --> 00:08:54,248
Yeah, right.
97
00:08:54,248 --> 00:08:59,242
You know, and you know, you know from experience, you know, I mean, how many manuscripts
have you read?
98
00:08:59,242 --> 00:09:08,893
How many sort of, you know, we both do, uh you know, have done and do creative writing,
teaching and workshops and speak to writers a lot and everything.
99
00:09:08,893 --> 00:09:19,288
I mean, how many times have you come across, you know, the biggest challenge for most
writers earlier on in their career is not getting ideas.
100
00:09:19,288 --> 00:09:21,290
It's not about creativity.
101
00:09:21,290 --> 00:09:22,991
That's never the problem.
102
00:09:23,035 --> 00:09:38,994
in my experience, it's usually more about being overly complex, overly ambitious, trying
to do too much, trying to cover too much ground, um and not knowing what your principal
103
00:09:38,994 --> 00:09:41,605
themes are and all the rest of it.
104
00:09:41,605 --> 00:09:52,931
And so, you know, one big thing is like the plot is for the writer, it's not for the
reader.
105
00:09:53,167 --> 00:09:55,579
It's for you, the writer.
106
00:09:57,978 --> 00:10:05,906
It's a tool that you are going to put together to help guide you as you are producing a
book or a screenplay.
107
00:10:06,028 --> 00:10:06,398
yeah.
108
00:10:06,398 --> 00:10:11,591
When you walk out into that wilderness, right, you have a map with you.
109
00:10:11,591 --> 00:10:16,213
Now, if you decide to go off the trail because it looks more interesting, you can do that.
110
00:10:16,234 --> 00:10:26,999
But at least on your map, you have like your map and it's telling you your plan for the
day or for the two years that it takes to write a novel or whatever, if you're lucky.
111
00:10:27,820 --> 00:10:33,923
That, you know, there's a little mountain you're gonna climb and then a slightly larger
one and then a really big one.
112
00:10:34,035 --> 00:10:41,261
And this is the root and it has a name and an end product.
113
00:10:42,463 --> 00:10:45,445
You may meander a bit, that's fine.
114
00:10:45,445 --> 00:10:49,128
And you're still going to discover quite a few things along the way.
115
00:10:49,128 --> 00:10:52,781
But at least you're striding out into that wilderness with a map.
116
00:10:54,789 --> 00:10:56,718
or a GPS of its science fiction.
117
00:10:56,718 --> 00:11:06,798
the theme, you touched on something there that I want to echo, which is the utility of
knowing your themes in advance.
118
00:11:07,178 --> 00:11:15,438
Because the themes that you're exploring come out in every metaphor you use, and you can
use metaphors in every paragraph of your writing.
119
00:11:15,478 --> 00:11:24,850
And if you're doing it right, there will be metaphors not just in the literal syntax of
your writing, there will be metaphors in the scenes and in the
120
00:11:24,856 --> 00:11:29,711
and the composition of scenes, metaphors that come out in the subtext.
121
00:11:29,711 --> 00:11:36,166
And all of that can only really happen if you have some sense of what you're trying to
say.
122
00:11:36,166 --> 00:11:40,100
It's just very practical to know what themes you're working with.
123
00:11:40,100 --> 00:11:44,745
m It doesn't have, it's not something like Stuart is saying.
124
00:11:44,745 --> 00:11:47,947
It's not something that you prescribe to yourself.
125
00:11:48,006 --> 00:11:51,180
And it's not a run of medications where you have to.
126
00:11:51,310 --> 00:11:54,352
do X, Y, Z at exactly these times.
127
00:11:54,352 --> 00:12:03,939
It's something that you prepare for yourself and then you digest it and it becomes part of
your consciousness as you're working and it comes out naturally.
128
00:12:03,939 --> 00:12:06,440
You shouldn't be having to do it consciously.
129
00:12:06,440 --> 00:12:09,054
uh Working with themes, I mean.
130
00:12:09,054 --> 00:12:12,683
there's a simple test you can do for yourself.
131
00:12:12,683 --> 00:12:20,289
If you ask yourself, you you want to write the book or you're writing a book and
everything and someone asks you, what is it about?
132
00:12:21,590 --> 00:12:28,323
Okay, and if you start giving an answer that's basically telling them the story, then
that's not the answer to that question.
133
00:12:28,323 --> 00:12:29,933
Okay.
134
00:12:30,714 --> 00:12:33,835
So if you ask the question, what is Star Wars about?
135
00:12:35,473 --> 00:12:43,105
then you could say, know, well, you know, there's this guy, he's just lived on a farm and
da-da-da-da-da, and start describing the story.
136
00:12:43,165 --> 00:12:44,606
But there's another answer to that.
137
00:12:44,606 --> 00:13:05,031
What it's about is that guy, Skywalker, ultimately
learning that there's this force in the
universe and that he is going to align with the benign side of it and learn to trust it.
138
00:13:05,669 --> 00:13:07,783
That's what Star Wars is about.
139
00:13:09,934 --> 00:13:23,556
I think very practically speaking that um knowing what your book is about in terms of a
log line of a pitch, in terms of how you would answer if you're sitting at a book fair and
140
00:13:23,556 --> 00:13:26,749
a book buyer approaches you and says, what's your book about?
141
00:13:26,749 --> 00:13:37,688
Knowing the answer in advance makes it easier to write your book, easier to market your
book, easier to finish your book and move on to the next.
142
00:13:37,688 --> 00:13:44,004
Those three things are not necessarily every writer's highest priority, but they are
working writers' highest priorities.
143
00:13:45,286 --> 00:13:53,474
So if you want to be doing this for work, you need to know the answer to that question and
it's very helpful to know the answer to that question in advance.
144
00:13:53,873 --> 00:13:57,059
Yeah, you know, there's something really, really sort of like...
145
00:13:57,059 --> 00:13:57,774
um
146
00:13:57,774 --> 00:14:11,284
really essential about this and it's a beautiful thing as David Lynch would say, uh is
that you when you work in science fiction you work in fantasy right you create these
147
00:14:11,284 --> 00:14:25,974
complex worlds, political systems, religions, know empires and know rebels and you know
corporate enterprises and you know some metaphysical stuff going on and all the rest of
148
00:14:25,974 --> 00:14:26,584
it.
149
00:14:26,800 --> 00:14:29,042
So there's all this stuff like...
150
00:14:29,042 --> 00:14:31,145
into your story.
151
00:14:31,454 --> 00:14:36,774
Yeah, yeah, this is a world, this is a complex, living thing and all the rest of it.
152
00:14:36,774 --> 00:14:39,414
It's the big stage that you're creating.
153
00:14:40,274 --> 00:14:47,374
So that's fine, that's where all that complexity and everything exists.
154
00:14:47,434 --> 00:14:59,752
But the through line for, you know, in terms of the plot is that, like you're saying about
Luke Skywalker, is actually there's something that's actually...
155
00:14:59,752 --> 00:15:06,124
quite often if you look at the core of a story, it's not as complex as you think.
156
00:15:06,124 --> 00:15:11,526
It's actually, you know, fairly simple in a way.
157
00:15:11,906 --> 00:15:15,867
And, you know, there's a great virtue to that simplicity.
158
00:15:15,867 --> 00:15:17,408
There really is.
159
00:15:17,828 --> 00:15:24,350
And we'll talk more about that as we get into maybe some specific examples.
160
00:15:24,943 --> 00:15:41,813
So that, to take it back to plotting, uh one of the goals of doing a plot, of taking the
time to produce a plot document in advance of doing a draft is to be able to succinctly
161
00:15:41,813 --> 00:15:43,984
describe what your book is about.
162
00:15:44,684 --> 00:15:53,269
One of the deliverables in a plotting process is a two sentence pitch that can...
163
00:15:53,527 --> 00:16:01,261
say to anyone what makes the story interesting and why they would want to watch it or read
it or buy it.
164
00:16:01,882 --> 00:16:15,719
And that is an immensely useful thing to have, not just because ah we want to sell our
stories, but also because during the writing process, knowing what you're making, it's
165
00:16:15,719 --> 00:16:19,471
like a carpenter making a table, right?
166
00:16:19,471 --> 00:16:20,432
Like, what are you making?
167
00:16:20,432 --> 00:16:22,373
It's a table, right?
168
00:16:22,913 --> 00:16:30,637
Knowing that what you're building is a table uh is an important thing to have in mind when
you are putting together, when you are a carpenter, right?
169
00:16:32,218 --> 00:16:39,862
You may do things that a less skilled carpenter might not recognize as being pieces of a
table.
170
00:16:39,862 --> 00:16:46,406
You might be doing some creative version of a table that would surprise someone who
doesn't know what you're doing.
171
00:16:46,406 --> 00:16:52,471
But you know it's a table and you know where you're going and that at the end of the day,
you're gonna be selling a table, right?
172
00:16:52,471 --> 00:16:55,341
That is an important deliverable for the plotting process.
173
00:16:55,341 --> 00:16:57,755
And here I'm making Stuart's arguments for him.
174
00:16:57,755 --> 00:16:58,136
right.
175
00:16:58,136 --> 00:16:59,156
It's so important.
176
00:16:59,156 --> 00:17:13,516
mean, you know, I do a workshop on, you know, called story and bound and that's where I
start usually with the idea that, you know, um form is your friend and form is a very
177
00:17:13,516 --> 00:17:14,926
important thing.
178
00:17:15,007 --> 00:17:22,552
The shape that you give something and, you know, in its broadest sense, the form is not
your enemy.
179
00:17:22,552 --> 00:17:24,093
Plot is not your enemy.
180
00:17:24,093 --> 00:17:25,960
The logos of plot.
181
00:17:25,960 --> 00:17:27,630
figuring out the logic.
182
00:17:27,851 --> 00:17:36,533
And the logic works on a number of different levels, again, something we can go into
later, but um is not the enemy of creativity.
183
00:17:36,533 --> 00:17:39,374
It's not a restriction on your creativity.
184
00:17:39,374 --> 00:17:42,194
It is not working to a formula.
185
00:17:42,455 --> 00:17:54,162
These are sometimes the sort of like rejections that, um you know, sometimes people have
is like, oh, don't know what paint by numbers work to a formula or.
186
00:17:54,162 --> 00:17:57,963
you know this is a kind of restriction putting it being put inside a box.
187
00:17:57,963 --> 00:17:58,903
No.
188
00:18:01,024 --> 00:18:14,868
Yeah, but it but it but actually that the form releases all the goodness of everything all
the ingredients that you're putting in all the nuts all the fruit all the special spices
189
00:18:14,868 --> 00:18:16,288
that are in there.
190
00:18:16,788 --> 00:18:24,310
They come together and they work because of the form and it's the plot that gives you that
form and so.
191
00:18:24,380 --> 00:18:31,172
You that's why I think you've been working on writing quite a bit.
192
00:18:31,190 --> 00:18:33,693
Yeah, I know you have, I know I have.
193
00:18:33,693 --> 00:18:38,134
Then you realize, oh shit, yes, form is important.
194
00:18:38,134 --> 00:18:39,574
Form is my friend.
195
00:18:39,574 --> 00:18:40,704
Plot is my friend.
196
00:18:40,704 --> 00:18:42,755
It's not a restriction really.
197
00:18:43,255 --> 00:18:49,477
And if I feel that it is, I can make adjustments, but it's a great benefactor.
198
00:18:49,477 --> 00:18:54,038
It's a great God, which needs to be.
199
00:18:54,615 --> 00:18:58,943
Paid homage to and we pay our homage to the great dollar plot
200
00:18:58,943 --> 00:19:12,637
Yes, addressing the argument I think that is common in certain literary circles that ah
the narrative is the term that they use, they use the term narrative as pejorative ah to
201
00:19:12,637 --> 00:19:21,303
say that it is that any kind of formulaic structure is a detriment to writing.
202
00:19:21,303 --> 00:19:27,391
I definitely am on the same page here as Stuart as oh to say that I think that that is
203
00:19:27,573 --> 00:19:30,804
just fundamentally misunderstanding craft.
204
00:19:30,985 --> 00:19:36,407
And if you have a writing teacher who tells you that plot is not useful, then get a
different writing teacher.
205
00:19:37,227 --> 00:19:39,929
Plot is the same as learning.
206
00:19:39,929 --> 00:19:44,850
It's like an artist learning to draw shapes, learning what perspective is.
207
00:19:45,531 --> 00:19:54,775
It's like uh there are structural things you need to learn in order to transcend them.
208
00:19:54,919 --> 00:19:58,802
And one of those is how to plot a story.
209
00:19:58,803 --> 00:20:11,883
Now, there are a lot of ways to plot a story and some of them, here I'm thinking of Save
the Cat, a very famous plot outlining book, um have the tendency to result in highly
210
00:20:11,883 --> 00:20:20,140
formulaic stories in the same way that a cookie cutter is going to produce the same shape
over and over again.
211
00:20:20,140 --> 00:20:23,953
An artist might learn to trace a cookie cutter, but they wouldn't like
212
00:20:23,953 --> 00:20:28,104
use the cookie cutter necessarily over and over again.
213
00:20:28,104 --> 00:20:31,725
Like, it's a tool in their tool chest.
214
00:20:32,545 --> 00:20:36,106
It's not a prescription for how art should look, right?
215
00:20:36,346 --> 00:20:40,027
The same is true for any kind of plotting device that you tend to use.
216
00:20:40,021 --> 00:20:45,143
uh I have a question for Stuart, because I tend to be more of a pantser.
217
00:20:45,143 --> 00:20:49,044
So we've been kind of extolling the virtues of plots.
218
00:20:49,664 --> 00:20:53,809
When I write, what tends to happen is I create a plot.
219
00:20:53,809 --> 00:20:57,449
And with a great first, I'll have some very creative idea.
220
00:20:57,449 --> 00:21:02,509
I'll just, wherever it comes from, whether it's a dream or whatever, and I'll just get
started on that.
221
00:21:02,509 --> 00:21:09,929
And as soon as that initial wave of inspiration starts to crest, I'll take a step back and
to make a plot outline.
222
00:21:10,909 --> 00:21:18,629
Once I've got a plot outline, I get back to work and within a, I don't know, 10 to 15
minutes, the plot outlines out the window.
223
00:21:19,809 --> 00:21:22,129
My maps never last me very long.
224
00:21:22,161 --> 00:21:27,461
And I usually have to then take a step back and do some more plotting to try to figure out
where I'm going now.
225
00:21:27,461 --> 00:21:32,321
It's more like orienteering than the navigating with the map.
226
00:21:33,361 --> 00:21:43,001
So what would you I mean, how do you avoid the problem of throwing away your plot every 10
steps?
227
00:21:44,695 --> 00:21:53,922
well, I, I, I never have to do that, Cullen No, I'm joshing with you.
228
00:21:53,922 --> 00:21:57,755
And that there might be the difference between a plotter and a panther.
229
00:21:59,988 --> 00:22:01,069
Yeah, that could be it.
230
00:22:01,069 --> 00:22:02,722
uh
231
00:22:03,692 --> 00:22:04,512
You
232
00:22:08,010 --> 00:22:08,370
Uh, #$@%.
233
00:22:08,370 --> 00:22:13,790
Oh well, it's not entirely true.
234
00:22:15,810 --> 00:22:23,090
One does experience occasionally sort of quite a turn in the plot which you didn't
necessarily see.
235
00:22:23,150 --> 00:22:37,634
You know, it's an interesting thing because I think that I would say that I'm, you know,
if you have plotted to a fair degree, and I stick around the 60 to 70 percent.
236
00:22:37,834 --> 00:22:42,177
um It actually makes it easier to adjust the plot than not.
237
00:22:42,177 --> 00:22:48,821
um Because it's like you've got terrain to work with already.
238
00:22:48,821 --> 00:22:59,148
um I think that because of that, you have a certain level of confidence in the story that
you've mapped out.
239
00:22:59,148 --> 00:23:00,369
And you can see how...
240
00:23:00,369 --> 00:23:07,774
eh I don't like uh writing a story where I don't know what happens in the third act.
241
00:23:09,730 --> 00:23:21,250
or the fifth act sometimes people say you know not all have a fifth or five acts I can see
the logic of that but you know that final section you know if I don't know what happens in
242
00:23:21,250 --> 00:23:34,390
that final section and that makes me queasy you know and so how do know what happens in
the final section if you don't know what happens before it in a way well you know it's
243
00:23:34,390 --> 00:23:36,870
interesting I mean you kind of have gaps
244
00:23:37,672 --> 00:23:40,784
but you certainly need the broad strokes.
245
00:23:40,784 --> 00:23:43,646
I think if
you've got the broad strokes, you're okay.
246
00:23:43,687 --> 00:23:47,329
You don't need every detail.
247
00:23:48,590 --> 00:23:57,857
you know, my plotting actually goes to another level because I don't just write the plot,
I write the exposition of the plot.
248
00:23:58,138 --> 00:24:04,262
So, you know, when you write a plot, it's like, it's the logic of all the story for you as
the writer.
249
00:24:04,580 --> 00:24:08,793
the exposition is how it comes out in sequence on the page.
250
00:24:09,414 --> 00:24:14,999
And so then I break down all the scenes in the book.
251
00:24:14,999 --> 00:24:20,643
um And then I write notes on every single scene.
252
00:24:21,444 --> 00:24:31,583
And the logic for that is because I think that if you think about what you're trying to do
when you write a novel, you're trying to play different characters and it's all you
253
00:24:31,583 --> 00:24:33,514
playing those different characters.
254
00:24:33,514 --> 00:24:40,937
You're trying to do the scenery, do the action, create the dialogue, uh make sure it fits
with the story.
255
00:24:40,937 --> 00:24:43,476
ah Each scene needs a purpose.
256
00:24:43,476 --> 00:24:45,479
It needs to lead to something else.
257
00:24:45,479 --> 00:24:50,441
It progresses the story, reverses the story, escalates the story, whatever.
258
00:24:50,601 --> 00:24:55,163
Are you going to ask your brain to do all of that in one go?
259
00:24:55,163 --> 00:24:58,364
um My answer is no, don't do that.
260
00:24:58,364 --> 00:25:03,120
Actually, the purpose of doing all this other work is that so...
261
00:25:03,120 --> 00:25:15,889
When you're in the act of writing, you've preloaded the software in your brain of a lot of
these things so that you can have more readily a kind of immersive experience whilst
262
00:25:15,889 --> 00:25:16,979
you're writing.
263
00:25:17,060 --> 00:25:31,350
So my advocacy for plot is also to free up maybe the most creative, uh higher function
part of the brain that we use when we write creative fiction.
264
00:25:31,786 --> 00:25:41,466
And I can tell that if this part of my brain is tired, this frontal lobe here, I can't
write creatively very well.
265
00:25:41,466 --> 00:25:44,286
It's got to be fresh, it's got to be lively.
266
00:25:44,406 --> 00:25:52,946
So anything I can do to give it the maximum capability to perform is a good thing.
267
00:25:53,086 --> 00:26:00,446
So that's another sideways argument for the virtue of plotting in a way.
268
00:26:02,211 --> 00:26:03,000
you
269
00:26:04,269 --> 00:26:12,289
You offered a few different examples of kinds of plots, uh just as we've gone along.
270
00:26:12,289 --> 00:26:13,872
A three act, a five act.
271
00:26:13,872 --> 00:26:21,454
uh Would you like to lay out for those who don't know what you're talking about, what you
mean by plot structures?
272
00:26:21,454 --> 00:26:23,474
Let's like give them a couple of examples.
273
00:26:23,474 --> 00:26:28,216
Obviously, there's no one plot structure.
274
00:26:28,216 --> 00:26:33,537
uh Joseph Campbell's hero with a thousand faces uh is very wrong.
275
00:26:33,787 --> 00:26:36,640
That is, he was just so wrong.
276
00:26:36,640 --> 00:26:39,023
There are lots of different plot structures.
277
00:26:39,023 --> 00:26:40,444
There is not just one.
278
00:26:40,444 --> 00:26:44,328
He was only able to claim that there was just one by ignoring a lot of others.
279
00:26:44,328 --> 00:26:49,133
uh There have been many efforts to enumerate them all.
280
00:26:49,133 --> 00:26:54,778
uh different tools are useful under different circumstances.
281
00:26:54,999 --> 00:26:57,101
it might be worth laying out a few.
282
00:26:57,512 --> 00:27:00,944
Well, I think that's a really useful exercise.
283
00:27:00,944 --> 00:27:17,576
would say, maybe that would be an entire kind of um other podcast session where we could
do that with examples of each one, because um there are many different varieties and some
284
00:27:17,576 --> 00:27:27,454
allow for um the world transforming more than the main character and the main character
being a kind of...
285
00:27:27,454 --> 00:27:31,396
catalyst for the change in the world more than the other way around.
286
00:27:31,736 --> 00:27:39,040
So there's all sorts of things like that that you can do with story that is quite
interesting.
287
00:27:39,160 --> 00:27:54,969
And this forms a plot which, if you take a David Lynch film or a film like The Green
Knight, which more follow a kind of um intuitive plotting, we sometimes call it, or
288
00:27:54,969 --> 00:27:57,404
follows more like a mythic loric.
289
00:27:57,404 --> 00:28:08,661
a mythic folkloric fairy tale kind of logic, know, um sometimes dream logic is called or
surrealist, whatever.
290
00:28:08,661 --> 00:28:12,223
So there's those types of films and plotting.
291
00:28:12,223 --> 00:28:15,144
And so there's lots of different varieties.
292
00:28:15,144 --> 00:28:19,457
So, um you know, that's that's something we can explore further.
293
00:28:19,457 --> 00:28:25,258
You know, but one of the things I wanted to
294
00:28:25,258 --> 00:28:36,447
kind of do is give a couple of examples of from films where the essence, that simple
essence that's at the heart of a plot really shines through.
295
00:28:36,447 --> 00:28:39,214
So I thought we could do a couple of those.
296
00:28:41,008 --> 00:28:44,943
Yeah, you've set us up for a couple of good examples here.
297
00:28:44,943 --> 00:28:46,755
uh I'd be interested.
298
00:28:46,755 --> 00:28:48,928
Let's go ahead and dive into them.
299
00:28:48,928 --> 00:28:50,570
Which one do you want to do first?
300
00:28:50,943 --> 00:28:52,304
Let's the Lord of the Rings.
301
00:28:52,304 --> 00:28:56,548
So this is a scene from the Lord of the Rings that Stuart has queued up.
302
00:28:56,548 --> 00:29:11,490
Obviously, I have seen this movie, but we'll be reacting to it and then discussing it in
terms
of the execution of the plotting ah and the importance of the scene to the plot
303
00:29:11,490 --> 00:29:11,960
overall.
304
00:31:09,272 --> 00:31:11,712
It's funny they put these two scenes together.
305
00:31:45,144 --> 00:31:47,335
Classic, legendary.
306
00:31:48,216 --> 00:31:49,767
My memory is a little fuzzy.
307
00:31:49,767 --> 00:31:52,408
I've read The Lord of the Rings until it fell apart.
308
00:31:52,408 --> 00:32:05,515
It was my first great love in literature, but I think that's actually two scenes in the
book ah where Gandalf is talking about Sméagol and where Frodo says, want, I wish it had
309
00:32:05,515 --> 00:32:06,746
not happened in my time.
310
00:32:06,746 --> 00:32:14,070
Those are both bits of dialogue that are more or less directly from the books, but I think
they're in two different places.
311
00:32:14,119 --> 00:32:14,975
Mm-hmm.
312
00:32:15,212 --> 00:32:17,675
I could be wrong about that, but I'm pretty sure.
313
00:32:18,331 --> 00:32:25,073
Well, I mean, these are rare scenes in a way, they're very pivotal.
314
00:32:25,073 --> 00:32:38,477
And um particularly in the case of that scene in Lord of the Rings, the film version, um
it's actually something that doesn't always happen where the film is directly addressing
315
00:32:38,477 --> 00:32:40,277
its main theme.
316
00:32:41,117 --> 00:32:45,939
And so as is often the case with uh fantasy in the world of fantasy.
317
00:32:45,939 --> 00:32:47,679
m
318
00:32:48,243 --> 00:32:53,665
the moral order is a little bit less complex than in science fiction quite often.
319
00:32:53,905 --> 00:32:58,986
So you have light and dark really in a more clear sense.
320
00:32:58,986 --> 00:33:04,788
um Sometimes in science fiction fantasy that's true also as in know Star Wars.
321
00:33:04,788 --> 00:33:15,801
um And so you know it's a beautiful scene because that point at which Frodo says you know
322
00:33:16,237 --> 00:33:18,968
I'd wish he'd killed him when he had the chance.
323
00:33:19,168 --> 00:33:20,509
Pity you didn't kill him.
324
00:33:20,509 --> 00:33:23,130
And then Godloft says pity.
325
00:33:23,147 --> 00:33:26,771
was pity that stayed Bilbo's hand.
326
00:33:28,072 --> 00:33:44,739
If the whole of the Lord of the Rings, the entire story and the ending would have been a
failure without that central point of the compassion of Bilbo Baggins.
327
00:33:45,563 --> 00:33:51,708
the mercy that he showed and the understanding and the humanity that he showed.
328
00:33:51,708 --> 00:33:56,872
Because if you think about it, why is it that the hobbits are chosen?
329
00:33:57,233 --> 00:34:02,877
Why is it that Frodo can get the ring all the way to Mount Doom?
330
00:34:03,978 --> 00:34:14,947
And it's because of the quintessential quality of goodness, which is the least corruptible
form of goodness.
331
00:34:14,947 --> 00:34:21,012
in the entire Middle Earth, in contrast to humans as well.
332
00:34:21,012 --> 00:34:40,527
It's no uh man or woman who could have carried out that task because the hobbits were
uniquely, you know, in a sense, uh innocent, pure, but not in, you know, in a way that was
333
00:34:41,048 --> 00:34:42,890
so important for the story.
334
00:34:42,890 --> 00:34:44,421
And there is your
335
00:34:44,421 --> 00:34:52,917
there is your central, simple premise of the plot, the central point, the central essence
of it.
336
00:34:53,137 --> 00:34:59,142
And also Gollum, of course, helps him get to Mount Doom.
337
00:34:59,142 --> 00:35:02,274
And in the end, actually Frodo fails, right?
338
00:35:02,274 --> 00:35:06,446
Because he succumbs to the power of the ring.
339
00:35:07,288 --> 00:35:08,008
Oh, shoot.
340
00:35:08,008 --> 00:35:10,311
I think I just saw that.
341
00:35:10,470 --> 00:35:11,850
I think we're okay.
342
00:35:11,850 --> 00:35:19,593
If you haven't seen the Lord of the Rings yet, it's not going to be us that spoil it for
you.
343
00:35:19,593 --> 00:35:20,713
Yeah.
344
00:35:20,753 --> 00:35:23,484
But no, think you're right.
345
00:35:23,484 --> 00:35:39,018
And what I hear you're reaching for in describing the essential importance of this scene
is the statement of the Theme, the statements of the overall message that...
346
00:35:40,638 --> 00:35:43,779
beyond just a catchphrase.
347
00:35:43,819 --> 00:36:01,524
I mean, as catchy as those lines are, it also deeply captures what makes the whole debate
of the story, the debate ah between a willingness to let others live and a willingness to
348
00:36:01,624 --> 00:36:03,094
enforce your will on them.
349
00:36:03,094 --> 00:36:09,108
Like Frodo says, if only we just killed him, but Gandalf...
350
00:36:09,108 --> 00:36:12,999
immediately says, No, no, that is not what will save us.
351
00:36:12,999 --> 00:36:19,081
Yes, of course, we need to fight the orcs or or Sauron, but what will save us is not the
fighting.
352
00:36:19,081 --> 00:36:36,245
um It is the it is the forgiving, which is an kind of an interesting and complicated
message in a book that is largely about armed military conflict.
353
00:36:36,898 --> 00:36:40,759
or at least features quite a lot of armed military conflict, right?
354
00:36:40,940 --> 00:36:55,064
That the message of all of this, the message Tolkien presumably found in the trenches in
Guam was that what saves us at the end of the day is um not the guns ah or the charging
355
00:36:55,064 --> 00:36:56,145
cavalry.
356
00:36:56,625 --> 00:36:59,906
It's the care and the companions.
357
00:37:00,603 --> 00:37:01,944
Yeah, absolutely.
358
00:37:01,944 --> 00:37:11,147
And obviously it's, you know, it's had the particular uh time and experiences of the
history of that time.
359
00:37:11,748 --> 00:37:16,189
The recent wars and all the rest of it, which is the context behind Lord of the Rings.
360
00:37:16,250 --> 00:37:29,775
And that scene sets up, it foreshadows the story's resolution, defines the moral law, a
world of Lord of
the Rings, and it sets up the transformational journey.
361
00:37:29,827 --> 00:37:30,708
of Frodo.
362
00:37:30,708 --> 00:37:44,187
It does a lot of work, there's a lot in that pack, but it also is uh giving you the theme,
which doesn't always happen, um but occasionally it does.
363
00:37:44,187 --> 00:37:47,920
A scene will give you, explicitly sort of give you the theme.
364
00:37:47,920 --> 00:37:52,074
um And then, um you know,
365
00:37:52,074 --> 00:37:57,396
Save the Cat would try to tell you that you have to say the theme.
366
00:37:57,396 --> 00:38:02,678
But I tend to think that Save the Cat isn't really right about that.
367
00:38:02,678 --> 00:38:12,412
But it is definitely a school of thinking, the Disney School of Thinking in Hollywood,
that you have to explicitly state your theme and that that explicit statement of the theme
368
00:38:12,412 --> 00:38:17,825
comes immediately after the dark tea time of the soul when the character is at their most
vulnerable.
369
00:38:17,825 --> 00:38:21,826
uh There is a value to those kinds of tools.
370
00:38:21,950 --> 00:38:28,412
I just think that prescribing them is very risky at the risk of becoming quite formulaic.
371
00:38:28,412 --> 00:38:39,515
Notably, this scene didn't happen immediately after Frodo had faced some shattering defeat
or was in the deepest dark of his teatime of the soul, right?
372
00:38:39,515 --> 00:38:41,575
He just had that thought.
373
00:38:41,575 --> 00:38:43,916
I they are in Moria, they're deep underground.
374
00:38:43,916 --> 00:38:47,157
I guess that's kind of a dark teatime of the soul.
375
00:38:47,457 --> 00:38:50,498
That's not quite, I think, what Campbell would have identified.
376
00:38:50,498 --> 00:38:51,718
um
377
00:38:52,012 --> 00:38:58,401
But Stuart, I'm curious, if you're setting out to plot a book, are you writing the scene
first?
378
00:38:59,295 --> 00:39:01,417
well, yeah, you know, that's a really interesting thing.
379
00:39:01,417 --> 00:39:13,527
mean, this is where, um you know, there's a balance here between how creativity works for
most of us.
380
00:39:13,527 --> 00:39:21,193
Maybe not all of us, we're all different, but how I can speak to how it works for me and
how I've certainly seen it work for other people.
381
00:39:21,473 --> 00:39:28,799
When one talks about having a plot and, you know, the logos of it, the logic of it, which
has to be on a number of different levels.
382
00:39:28,871 --> 00:39:41,716
um then it doesn't mean that you're not also working by a kind of visionary process as
well.
383
00:39:41,777 --> 00:39:45,378
So, no, definitely not.
384
00:39:45,378 --> 00:39:48,880
One's not necessarily starting with that quintessential scene.
385
00:39:48,880 --> 00:39:54,042
um I think a book can start anywhere.
386
00:39:54,042 --> 00:39:56,729
It might start in the beginning for the writer.
387
00:39:56,729 --> 00:39:59,562
it might start at the end, it might start in the middle.
388
00:39:59,562 --> 00:40:13,748
um know, I mean David Lynch used to say that, like, I get my ideas, like, you know, I'm
standing in a room and someone's throwing cards, playing cards through, you know, through
389
00:40:13,748 --> 00:40:14,649
the door.
390
00:40:16,219 --> 00:40:18,680
and he's just picking them up.
391
00:40:19,201 --> 00:40:22,182
And they're not in any particular order.
392
00:40:22,803 --> 00:40:29,216
And then, you know, it's kind of like putting them in the order that David Lynch thinks
they work.
393
00:40:31,448 --> 00:40:36,892
Stuart got disconnected there, but we're back from our temporary disconnect and you won't
even know the difference.
394
00:40:36,892 --> 00:40:39,023
We'll cut out all that madness.
395
00:40:39,564 --> 00:40:41,395
But we have forgotten what we were talking about.
396
00:40:41,395 --> 00:40:52,693
Let's see, I think we were just talking about David Lynch and his often used metaphor of
uh getting ideas like someone's throwing playing cards at me through a closed door.
397
00:40:55,035 --> 00:40:58,778
We reference David Lynch a lot because we both at various times have worked for him.
398
00:40:58,778 --> 00:40:59,718
uh
399
00:41:00,142 --> 00:41:06,502
a phenomenal person, David, always a pleasure to get to work with David.
400
00:41:06,502 --> 00:41:16,946
I would say probably sits at the extreme far end of the pantser end of the plotter versus
pantser debate.
401
00:41:17,247 --> 00:41:21,589
He never had anything even remotely like a plot in mind in advance.
402
00:41:21,589 --> 00:41:24,910
uh And often.
403
00:41:26,476 --> 00:41:35,857
I've heard some great stories about him effectively lying to studio execs about having a
plan for what he was planning to do.
404
00:41:35,857 --> 00:41:38,900
But speaking of David Lynch, we're not going to...
405
00:41:39,522 --> 00:41:45,589
Stuart's next example is from Dune, the Denis Villeneuve version of Dune, not the David
Lynch version of Dune.
406
00:41:45,589 --> 00:41:46,474
uh
407
00:41:46,474 --> 00:41:51,247
the David Lynch version, although there is a little comment to make about that afterwards.
408
00:41:51,476 --> 00:42:05,333
Yeah, I would argue based on my uh everything David said over the years, he would probably
be relieved ah that we're not going to be referencing the dune that bears his name, but
409
00:42:05,333 --> 00:42:07,574
none of his ah decisions.
410
00:42:07,574 --> 00:42:15,768
ah OK, so we shall play the scene from the Denis Villeneuve ah interpretation of Dune.
411
00:45:32,894 --> 00:45:35,354
stirring stuff, stirring stuff.
412
00:45:35,354 --> 00:45:40,174
Again, a scene that gives you the very essence of the story.
413
00:45:41,254 --> 00:45:49,493
A theme scene in that respect again, but a very different world, you know.
414
00:45:49,493 --> 00:45:51,516
different uh message.
415
00:45:51,516 --> 00:45:53,147
and very different message.
416
00:45:53,147 --> 00:45:54,167
Yes.
417
00:45:55,828 --> 00:45:59,680
It's, wow, it's fascinating stuff, right?
418
00:45:59,680 --> 00:46:16,860
Because this is the turning point again, from just moving from passive and survival to
active, which is a very, always a very key transition point for a principal character.
419
00:46:17,600 --> 00:46:21,062
They often are in the passive position quite a lot.
420
00:46:21,703 --> 00:46:26,524
begin with, not always, and then shift, they have to shift at some point to the active.
421
00:46:26,524 --> 00:46:43,328
In this scene, of course, it's Paul Atreides becoming the Lisanne Al-Ghaib is consciously
m going to exploit the religious myth and use its power to lead the Fremen.
422
00:46:43,328 --> 00:46:51,684
And that speaks to the purpose of revenge for House Atreides, um the rise
423
00:46:51,684 --> 00:46:58,036
of the Fremen embracing what has been seeded centuries ago.
424
00:46:59,157 --> 00:47:02,978
So, you know, the analytical machinations are there.
425
00:47:03,359 --> 00:47:06,840
And it's not for mercy.
426
00:47:06,840 --> 00:47:09,301
It's for revenge.
427
00:47:09,301 --> 00:47:11,322
It's for victory.
428
00:47:11,322 --> 00:47:13,563
It's for power.
429
00:47:13,703 --> 00:47:21,746
So it stands in contrast to Lords of the Rings, manipulating belief for power, gain
pragmatic control.
430
00:47:22,248 --> 00:47:36,060
So it's a different moral compass and it wasn't a decision that, you know, he came to
easily, came to easily really, because obviously this is the, I mean, an interesting thing
431
00:47:36,060 --> 00:47:49,482
about, you know, Dune being sci-fi fantasy is you can see it all in terms of the political
machinations of the Bene Gesserit and...
432
00:47:49,726 --> 00:47:56,728
planting prophecies and controlling the fate of the uh universe and so on.
433
00:47:56,728 --> 00:48:12,652
But then there is also the fantasy element in the sense that there is, through the spice,
real sort of uh otherworldly or prophecy powers or special powers that emerge from that.
434
00:48:12,792 --> 00:48:14,973
So it is something of a blend of the two.
435
00:48:14,973 --> 00:48:19,684
And of course, that symbolic moment that puts on the ring at the same time.
436
00:48:19,731 --> 00:48:22,768
as becoming the Lisan al-Ghaib.
437
00:48:22,768 --> 00:48:27,659
It speaks to the unification of purpose between those two things.
438
00:48:27,659 --> 00:48:30,434
So again, a real powerful scene.
439
00:48:31,009 --> 00:48:42,060
I suspect that Tolkien ah would have been very tickled by Paul Atreides putting on the
ring of power.
440
00:48:42,060 --> 00:48:49,998
ah Because that is, I don't know if Frank Herbert ah did that intentionally.
441
00:48:49,998 --> 00:48:54,873
I think they're both drawing on the same sort of underlying symbols.
442
00:48:55,655 --> 00:49:05,349
But it is definitely my take on this scene, or at least this version of this scene, that
that Ducal Signet might as well be the one ring.
443
00:49:05,349 --> 00:49:13,252
This scene is a scene in which a character who had hitherto been a hero becomes a villain.
444
00:49:13,432 --> 00:49:18,394
It uh is a plot arc, that's a tragedy.
445
00:49:18,414 --> 00:49:25,317
On the outward face of it, the second act after this scene shows Paul Atreides,
446
00:49:25,359 --> 00:49:28,532
Ascending to power getting everything he ever wanted.
447
00:49:28,532 --> 00:49:32,335
But in fact His power bathes the universe in blood.
448
00:49:32,335 --> 00:49:43,554
uh No one is happy including himself Right that this is not a good thing to have done and
I think that one one kind of Trick that I think Denis Villeneuve played in putting this
449
00:49:43,554 --> 00:49:47,248
scene together is having uh Chani?
450
00:49:47,248 --> 00:49:53,791
the Chani there and having her react to it in in a negative way
451
00:49:53,791 --> 00:49:54,451
Yeah.
452
00:49:54,451 --> 00:50:08,453
the audience an avenue or at least a perspective on what the actual takeaway of this scene
is, which is that this is an unredeemable act of evil by Paul Atreides, that he has set
453
00:50:08,453 --> 00:50:12,957
himself on a road of annihilation from which there's really no return.
454
00:50:12,957 --> 00:50:21,443
And the only thing about it that is even remotely forgivable is that the people he's going
to be destroying are also pretty bad.
455
00:50:21,919 --> 00:50:23,679
They are pretty bad.
456
00:50:23,919 --> 00:50:27,359
I wouldn't characterize it as an evil decision myself.
457
00:50:27,359 --> 00:50:31,999
think it's, you know, it's falling into the...
458
00:50:31,999 --> 00:50:34,579
I mean, he is driven by revenge, right?
459
00:50:34,579 --> 00:50:39,079
And that's part of the moral compass there, is that a house...
460
00:50:39,079 --> 00:50:50,354
And they are of their kind, even though they're portrayed benignly in a way, they are the
most benign, really, compared to the portrayal of the Harkonnen in a way.
461
00:50:50,354 --> 00:50:58,759
Nonetheless, it's a rivalry between houses that's centuries long and each side has had
dark dealings and stuff.
462
00:50:58,900 --> 00:51:08,646
really, this road that Paul has decided to travel, of course, leads to horrendous war and
loss of life.
463
00:51:08,646 --> 00:51:13,309
And so, is the revenge in the end worth it?
464
00:51:13,309 --> 00:51:19,193
um So it sets a very different moral compass to Lord of the Rings.
465
00:51:19,193 --> 00:51:20,286
uh
466
00:51:20,286 --> 00:51:33,146
I mean, for me, one of the key things that you can unpack from these scenes is it gives
you the pathos, the ethos, and the logic, logos, of any given plot.
467
00:51:33,406 --> 00:51:39,126
And I think that's a whole other conversation, what is meant by that.
468
00:51:39,126 --> 00:51:44,466
But if you unpack these two scenes, you will get all of that.
469
00:51:44,586 --> 00:51:48,634
And for me, if you synthesize those,
470
00:51:48,634 --> 00:51:57,397
in
the story, the essence of your main character or the plot or the main characters, you
you're ah doing well.
471
00:51:57,397 --> 00:51:59,018
You're probably on to a winner.
472
00:51:59,018 --> 00:52:06,101
You really are sort of having a beautiful clarity in the form of what you're doing.
473
00:52:06,101 --> 00:52:09,222
And it's not that complex like we were saying.
474
00:52:09,222 --> 00:52:10,522
It's just not.
475
00:52:11,589 --> 00:52:20,718
Yeah, sometimes the best guide is the simplest.
476
00:52:21,360 --> 00:52:24,643
The best outline to try to follow is the simplest of ideas.
477
00:52:24,643 --> 00:52:27,146
um
478
00:52:27,146 --> 00:52:31,691
You point to pathos logos and ethos.
479
00:52:31,691 --> 00:52:34,013
I'm kind of curious what you meant by that.
480
00:52:34,866 --> 00:52:36,737
Well, it's another level of plot actually.
481
00:52:36,737 --> 00:52:48,800
if you if you if you I mean, I do think that this is sort of part of the the work this is
this is the sort of boiler room of the plot.
482
00:52:48,800 --> 00:52:58,593
This is where you do your blood sweat and tears on plot blotting, I think, is to
understand that those three levels of any plot need to work.
483
00:52:58,793 --> 00:53:03,314
Logos is the is basically the the logic of the action.
484
00:53:03,314 --> 00:53:09,820
the motivations of your main character and all characters in your book.
485
00:53:09,861 --> 00:53:11,041
Pathos.
486
00:53:13,344 --> 00:53:15,013
Yeah, right.
487
00:53:15,013 --> 00:53:25,574
design decisions you've made in building your world, the physical consequences of things
need to all have a basic physics and logic.
488
00:53:25,575 --> 00:53:31,272
things need to follow from each other, at least according to the rules that you've set
out.
489
00:53:31,272 --> 00:53:42,045
cause and effect in the world that you have created and understanding the logic of the
powers that you've created, how they work, how far they go, how far they don't go, what
490
00:53:42,045 --> 00:53:44,186
consequences they have.
491
00:53:44,186 --> 00:53:49,507
All this is the of like the boiler room work for plotting.
492
00:53:49,747 --> 00:53:51,948
Pathos is the emotional logic.
493
00:53:51,948 --> 00:54:00,870
It's to do with motivation, it's to do with those key sort of decisions, relationships and
so on that need to make sense also.
494
00:54:00,955 --> 00:54:06,278
And um one that we've talked about before, which is really, really important.
495
00:54:06,278 --> 00:54:22,506
And it's one of my pet things, Peeves, is when the ethos hasn't been thought through or
the ethos is kind of damaged or overthrown or just disposed with in a very, you know,
496
00:54:22,926 --> 00:54:24,527
unsatisfactory way.
497
00:54:24,527 --> 00:54:29,389
An ethos is broadly speaking, the moral compass of your main character.
498
00:54:29,490 --> 00:54:30,694
It's the needle.
499
00:54:30,694 --> 00:54:38,717
It doesn't matter where it starts, but it does matter how it gets shifted, how it gets
moved and where it moves to.
500
00:54:39,238 --> 00:54:44,220
And that's the ethos part of the equation.
501
00:54:44,220 --> 00:54:46,360
And that also needs to make sense.
502
00:54:46,360 --> 00:54:53,223
So all those three, the logos, the pathos and the ethos, all need to make sense.
503
00:54:53,383 --> 00:55:00,568
as I said, if you really have, you and I'm not saying you've
504
00:55:00,568 --> 00:55:02,621
one has figured all these things out.
505
00:55:02,621 --> 00:55:06,125
I know I haven't right at the start when you're writing.
506
00:55:06,286 --> 00:55:19,282
But I think if you get them in alignment and they make sense, you will produce something
that's deeply meaningful and satisfying for your audience.
507
00:55:21,405 --> 00:55:33,811
So when you're talking about putting together a plot, doing the boiler room work of
plotting a story, whether it's a screenplay or a novel, or a whole series of novels, um
508
00:55:33,811 --> 00:55:45,417
you would think of it in terms of the logos, the pathos and the ethos of the, as all
being.
509
00:55:45,897 --> 00:55:48,340
ways to look at am I fulfilling these things?
510
00:55:48,340 --> 00:55:49,751
Are these things making sense?
511
00:55:49,751 --> 00:55:51,383
Are they following from each other?
512
00:55:51,383 --> 00:55:53,064
Are they reasonable?
513
00:55:53,414 --> 00:55:57,335
yeah, because let's look at Paul Atreides, right?
514
00:55:58,556 --> 00:56:12,420
Why does he make that decision to use what he knows is the planting of the Bene Gesserit
and their work to manipulate the Fremen for their own designs, which are very dark and
515
00:56:12,420 --> 00:56:14,400
about control and power?
516
00:56:15,521 --> 00:56:20,622
You know, when essentially, you know, he starts off with this sort of this, this,
517
00:56:21,011 --> 00:56:29,638
this boy coming into manhood and so on and the father is sort of like benign and all the
rest of it sort of quite benign influences around him and all the rest of it.
518
00:56:29,638 --> 00:56:33,961
It's a huge decision with massive consequences for the universe.
519
00:56:34,282 --> 00:56:36,363
So it can't come out of nowhere.
520
00:56:36,744 --> 00:56:37,905
And of course it doesn't.
521
00:56:37,905 --> 00:56:48,714
The foundation for that shift in that needle is very well laid out and I think very
effectively laid out for
522
00:56:48,786 --> 00:56:57,013
that a momentous decision to be made and to feel as though it's legit and it feels
authentic.
523
00:56:57,013 --> 00:57:06,862
uh And it's not a nasty surprise or like way out of character or, you know, where did that
come from sort of thing.
524
00:57:08,278 --> 00:57:16,882
So Stuart, I think this is a really interesting uh toolkit that you're kind of laying out
for how to look at plotting.
525
00:57:17,577 --> 00:57:24,086
And we're coming to the end of our hour, so it might be time to make our kind of
summary
statements.
526
00:57:24,206 --> 00:57:29,128
Stuart has been arguing largely in favor of doing plotting work and I've been...
527
00:57:29,128 --> 00:57:30,869
uh
528
00:57:31,101 --> 00:57:37,969
I've been arguing, sort of, in favor of uh discovery, maybe not super effectively.
529
00:57:38,170 --> 00:57:42,735
But I would like to make a closing argument in favor of discovery, which is.
530
00:57:42,735 --> 00:57:44,597
uh
531
00:57:45,717 --> 00:57:59,101
We've talked about, so Stuart is talking about logos, ethos and pathos as sort of
bandwidths by which you can measure and restore integrity to a story.
532
00:57:59,281 --> 00:58:10,224
And I think that these are really useful tools, but in my process, I would tend to find
them to be useful in revision rather than in the initial plotting.
533
00:58:10,384 --> 00:58:13,285
So once I've got a whole story draft,
534
00:58:13,285 --> 00:58:16,628
and I start looking at it and going, something is not right here.
535
00:58:16,628 --> 00:58:27,878
That's where I would start reaching for tools like what you've just laid out, checking
whether the character's integrity is correct throughout, whether this surprise is really
536
00:58:27,878 --> 00:58:34,984
properly set up earlier and using uh prescriptions like looking at ethos, logos and
pathos.
537
00:58:35,773 --> 00:58:43,793
I can imagine a mind capable of doing all the plotting first and then applying all these
things and then just writing it and letting it all fall out.
538
00:58:43,793 --> 00:58:45,593
That is not my mind.
539
00:58:46,153 --> 00:58:52,853
When I start writing, I very often don't know the outcome of a fight scene when I start
writing it.
540
00:58:52,853 --> 00:58:56,633
And that's what makes it kind of exciting to me and I hope exciting to my audience.
541
00:58:56,633 --> 00:59:02,961
And if I don't know the outcome of the fight scene, then I certainly don't know what's
going to happen in the scene following it when people have their lives on the line.
542
00:59:02,961 --> 00:59:03,321
Right?
543
00:59:03,321 --> 00:59:16,260
So for me, the process of discovery draws me through the narrative through the first draft
and then tools like Save the Cat or a Hero with a Thousand Faces, both of which I think
544
00:59:16,260 --> 00:59:27,217
are very wrong, might still supply some language for asking the question, what does the
audience expect and how am I using their expectations?
545
00:59:27,623 --> 00:59:29,654
How am I playing with their expectations?
546
00:59:29,654 --> 00:59:41,957
And those sorts of questions, those plot outlines, the whatever, Christopher Booker's
seven basic plots, uh the different ideas of like a monster hunt or rags to riches or a
547
00:59:41,957 --> 00:59:45,208
quest or a tragedy or a comedy, right?
548
00:59:45,208 --> 00:59:49,379
Like all these different plot ideas are expectations the audience might have.
549
00:59:49,379 --> 00:59:54,020
And I find those tend to be more useful in the revision phase.
550
00:59:54,020 --> 00:59:56,321
But when I set out to write,
551
00:59:56,783 --> 01:00:09,466
a rough draft starting from a blank page, I consistently found myself overusing them and
then spending too much time on plots that I ended up throwing away anyway.
552
01:00:09,466 --> 01:00:19,797
uh So what I have found for myself a tool, which I'd love to share, which is, uh it comes
from...
553
01:00:19,797 --> 01:00:20,597
uh
554
01:00:21,184 --> 01:00:23,225
Aaron Sorkin.
555
01:00:23,986 --> 01:00:25,116
It comes from Aaron Sorkin.
556
01:00:25,116 --> 01:00:30,629
He said in a master class, uh all you need is a character and a problem.
557
01:00:31,190 --> 01:00:35,111
You have a character who has a problem, you've got a story.
558
01:00:35,852 --> 01:00:42,475
I think this is a pretty good prescription, but I would add to it that it is very helpful
to also have a setting.
559
01:00:45,208 --> 01:00:53,948
If you don't have the setting in mind, then you can't do any of that game design work,
which is so important in the preloading for science fiction and fantasy, in designing the
560
01:00:53,948 --> 01:00:56,048
world that they're gonna be operating in and so on.
561
01:00:56,048 --> 01:01:05,008
So a character, a character who has a problem and therefore is motivated to go on a
journey and therefore there's gonna be a story, whether they succeed or fail, that will
562
01:01:05,008 --> 01:01:07,528
get you through there, but you also need a setting.
563
01:01:07,528 --> 01:01:13,976
And as we have so often said, you also really, really, it's very helpful to have a theme,
to have an idea.
564
01:01:13,976 --> 01:01:17,958
of what your overall motion and emotion is driving toward.
565
01:01:17,958 --> 01:01:21,819
And those four things will get you there, at least in my experience.
566
01:01:22,160 --> 01:01:29,543
And if I've got those four things, then the rough draft will fall out of me wherever it
will.
567
01:01:30,263 --> 01:01:39,247
And then at some point I will start applying some more plotty related tools to recover
from the terrible mistakes I've made.
568
01:01:41,303 --> 01:01:43,095
Yeah, well, I agree.
569
01:01:43,095 --> 01:01:54,083
I don't actually myself use uh pathos ethos, um logos, you know, sort of tool in the the
point of writing a plot.
570
01:01:54,083 --> 01:01:56,245
um So yeah, that's true.
571
01:01:56,245 --> 01:02:03,591
It's more like something you can apply later and appreciate and understand um that maybe
it can help you out.
572
01:02:03,591 --> 01:02:06,473
um So I don't necessarily I don't do that.
573
01:02:06,616 --> 01:02:16,364
Myself I as somewhere in the back of my mind, but I'm not really conscious thinking about
that at all I do also think that when you know, it's great when you if you immerse in your
574
01:02:16,364 --> 01:02:30,426
character You're especially important with the principal character All characters then you
know, they
do they do come to life in such a way that You really know you really know
575
01:02:30,426 --> 01:02:33,959
you've immersed in a character when the character surprises you right?
576
01:02:33,987 --> 01:02:44,141
when they come up with something or you see that maybe you had an idea for them, but they
say, no, no, I'm not gonna do that.
577
01:02:44,141 --> 01:02:46,362
I'm gonna do this, right?
578
01:02:47,243 --> 01:02:59,327
And so um you do need to leave room for that because it is, uh like you said, part of the
joy of the writing um to have that.
579
01:02:59,928 --> 01:03:01,969
If I write a fight scene, I don't always know.
580
01:03:01,969 --> 01:03:03,095
uh
581
01:03:03,095 --> 01:03:04,905
where it's going to land either.
582
01:03:04,986 --> 01:03:15,788
I like that process of, you know, giving my, you know, you're always dropping your
characters into tough situations.
583
01:03:15,909 --> 01:03:21,430
I mean, you know, part of the advocacy for plotting is because we're talking about
speculative fiction.
584
01:03:21,430 --> 01:03:29,672
And so you do tend to have pretty complex landscapes and settings and lots of different
factors at work within them.
585
01:03:29,712 --> 01:03:31,153
So, yeah.
586
01:03:31,559 --> 01:03:40,014
if you've done your plotting properly, and you really do have some idea of where the story
is going, you're much less likely to write yourself into a situation you don't know how to
587
01:03:40,014 --> 01:03:40,621
get out of.
588
01:03:40,621 --> 01:03:42,402
Yeah, yeah, I think so.
589
01:03:42,402 --> 01:03:57,926
So um it is, I think, you know, to bring in uh the wholeness of the message here is that
probably for most of us, plotting is a good idea, but it doesn't entirely, and it
590
01:03:57,926 --> 01:04:10,189
shouldn't, get in the way of also processes of discovery and freshness and letting your
characters sometimes tell you where they want to go and what they want to do.
591
01:04:10,429 --> 01:04:17,011
And uh you know, that is, you don't want to crush the joy of the writing process at all.
592
01:04:17,011 --> 01:04:21,592
So um where the balance is for all of us is for us to find.
593
01:04:21,592 --> 01:04:26,113
But yeah, both are good.
594
01:04:27,034 --> 01:04:30,114
Speculative fiction is a particular thing.
595
01:04:30,435 --> 01:04:36,896
And you know, it does tend to involve a lot of world building with unique aspects to it.
596
01:04:36,896 --> 01:04:39,189
So yeah, that's another thing.
597
01:04:39,189 --> 01:04:44,473
of speculative fiction is that it is premised on world building of some kind.
598
01:04:44,954 --> 01:04:45,374
All right.
599
01:04:45,374 --> 01:04:47,556
Well, everybody, you let us know in the comments.
600
01:04:47,556 --> 01:04:49,498
Are you more of a pantser or a plotter?
601
01:04:49,498 --> 01:04:50,448
Did we convince you?
602
01:04:50,448 --> 01:04:52,920
Are you with Stuart or are you with Cullen?
603
01:04:52,980 --> 01:04:59,045
Let us know in the comments and we will be back next time with more hard-earned insights.
604
01:04:59,045 --> 01:05:02,768
uh Thank you for joining us and thanks for your company.
605
01:05:02,935 --> 01:05:05,980
Yeah, thanks for joining us and yeah, that was great fun.
606
01:05:05,980 --> 01:05:07,564
Until next time.