TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:08.080 --> 00:00:10.640
Tonight's lecture I'm really excited about.
00:00:10.720 --> 00:00:14.960
It's the first in a series that's going to run through the Gresham Year called What is Precious to Us.
00:00:15.119 --> 00:00:21.440
And so it makes sense to me at least that we're starting with museums and with one of the world's experts on the study of museums.
00:00:22.079 --> 00:00:32.320
Our lecturer tonight is Professor Kate Hill, Professor of History at the University of Lincoln, where she teaches modern British history and heritage, and she's a Fellow of the Royal Historical Society.
00:00:32.719 --> 00:00:45.119
She's got many books, including Women in Museums 1815-1914, Modernity and the Gendering of Knowledge, and more recently, Museums, Modernity and Conflict Museums and Collections in and of War.
00:00:45.439 --> 00:01:01.600
She led the project Making Museum Professionals 1850 to the Present, all of which, plus chairing the Museum and Galleries History Group and co-editing the Museum History Journal, make her eminently suited to talk to us tonight about rather trivial things, finding the precious in an alternative museum history.
00:01:01.759 --> 00:01:03.119
Kate, over to you.
00:01:09.439 --> 00:01:10.000
Thank you.
00:01:10.319 --> 00:01:16.319
I'm delighted to be here and to get a chance to talk to you about some of my favourite museums.
00:01:18.799 --> 00:01:23.760
Museums are in many ways value engines.
00:01:24.079 --> 00:01:36.719
They play a significant role in telling us what has value and in naturalising that value, despite or because of the fact that they remove objects from the marketplace.
00:01:36.959 --> 00:01:47.840
They often form spectacular settings, such as the British Museum here, to reinforce the point that the collections within are inherently valuable and precious.
00:01:48.400 --> 00:02:03.680
And we can see this in some interesting ways, particularly clearly with the VA, known until 1899 as the South Kensington Museum, which started out with a very frank and open attitude to the question of value.
00:02:03.840 --> 00:02:10.719
I don't know if you can see in this catalogue, but it displays the price of all the objects.
00:02:10.800 --> 00:02:23.520
And at the same time, it also had uh this this was uh immediately after the great exhibition, the very beginnings of the South Kensington Museum, its labels also had the price of every single object on it.
00:02:23.840 --> 00:02:27.199
Um, and that feels kind of wrong for museums, doesn't it?
00:02:27.280 --> 00:02:37.280
Um it feels sort of transgressive, and it's a mark, I think, of how important museums, especially national museums, are in a system of value.
00:02:37.599 --> 00:02:48.080
Their avoidance, their separateness from the market and from commercial systems of value actually works to support and maintain that very system of value.
00:02:49.039 --> 00:03:01.520
Equally, of course, they're part of an international network of rivalry, whereby the point of a national museum is to display the wealth and prestige of that nation.
00:03:02.479 --> 00:03:13.840
Objects are evidently precious because they're in the National Museum, and the nation is uh powerful because it has national uh precious objects in its museums.
00:03:14.479 --> 00:03:30.319
Uh, again, this is something you can see so clearly in the 19th century, where initially Britain and France, and then increasingly Germany and the US, among others, competed militarily and diplomatically for antiquities, classical and Egyptian antiquities.
00:03:30.400 --> 00:03:36.560
And this was very much about winners and losers defined by might and dominance.
00:03:36.719 --> 00:03:48.080
So the history of the Rosetta Stone is that the French found it and then the British beat them at the uh Battle of Alexandria in 1801 and they took the Rosetta Stone off them.
00:03:48.240 --> 00:04:00.479
And the side of the Rosetta Stone has um inscriptions captured in Egypt by the British Army in 1801, presented by King George III.
00:04:01.280 --> 00:04:10.879
So, yeah, putting putting the kind of the value in the museum is something that nations did from the 19th century onwards.
00:04:11.919 --> 00:04:21.920
But we might call this the top-down vision of what has value and is precious, and it's only one part of the story.
00:04:22.240 --> 00:04:31.600
There's another view from smaller and more obscure museums, which tells quite a different story.
00:04:32.319 --> 00:04:45.279
So if national museums act to underwrite the value of the nation's possessions, smaller museums are more able to reflect a different sense of value, which we might call bottom-up.
00:04:45.680 --> 00:04:51.439
So their history tells us about a greater range of museum creators beyond the national.
00:04:51.759 --> 00:05:02.480
So museums like the VA and the British Museum had, by UK museum standards, quite large resources, but they also had a lot of oversight from parliament and all the way down.
00:05:02.800 --> 00:05:14.720
Whereas if you look at um museums run by local councils, by individuals, by charities, they have a lot less money, but they also have a lot less oversight.
00:05:14.879 --> 00:05:19.759
They can do things without people noticing so much, people at the top.
00:05:20.240 --> 00:05:25.040
I think these smaller museums also tell us much more about audiences.
00:05:25.279 --> 00:05:34.000
So I would argue in smaller museums the visitors have a more immediate relationship with the museum curators and the museum staff.
00:05:34.319 --> 00:05:37.920
It's more obvious what the audience like and dislike.
00:05:38.240 --> 00:05:41.680
They're also very dependent on donations of all sorts.
00:05:41.839 --> 00:05:45.519
So again, they've got that very close relationship with their audience.
00:05:46.879 --> 00:06:00.720
So I think that smaller and less prestigious museums reflect back more popular, multifaceted ideas about value and preciousness, more of a kind of people's
Load full transcript
vision of value, if you like.
00:06:00.879 --> 00:06:07.600
Now, of course, this division between sort of bottom down, top, bottom up, top down, uh doesn't fully work in practice.
00:06:07.680 --> 00:06:10.720
You know, both elements exist in all museums.
00:06:10.879 --> 00:06:17.279
But I think because smaller museums are um, you can see the workings more clearly in small museums, right?
00:06:17.439 --> 00:06:23.680
Um, you can see the kind of dialogue or negotiation over what has value and what doesn't.
00:06:24.160 --> 00:06:38.240
So I'm gonna try and illustrate this by looking at some of the lesser-known museums of the UK between about 1860 and 1960, roughly, um, to show some different aspects of that.
00:06:38.319 --> 00:06:49.040
I've got three roughly chronological case studies showing quite different ways in which ostensibly worthless things were used to create different sorts of value.
00:06:49.360 --> 00:07:03.199
It's not strictly chronological, um, it's more like the examination of some innovations which which waxed and waned across the UK and beyond, but I'm I'm gonna stick to the UK just to keep it manageable.
00:07:04.079 --> 00:07:10.319
So, nothing of intrinsic value, the East End of London's Bethnal Green Museum.
00:07:11.600 --> 00:07:19.759
So in 1872, a new museum opened in the East End of London, Bethnyl Green Museum, now Young VA.
00:07:20.079 --> 00:07:35.279
It was opened by the Prince of Wales in a blaze of publicity as a branch of uh the South Kensington Museum, the VA, and promised to bring all the same benefits of the main museum to the east end of London rather than the west.
00:07:35.839 --> 00:07:46.000
But right from the start, there was a sense that, in fact, a different sort of museum was appropriate for this location and audience.
00:07:46.160 --> 00:07:59.199
So it's actually built out of leftovers, these leftovers, the old Brompton boilers, as they were called, prefabricated structures that had been used at the VA before the permanent buildings were uh erected.
00:07:59.439 --> 00:08:03.040
Now, by this point in the 1870s, they weren't uh uh needed anymore.
00:08:03.199 --> 00:08:11.120
I think they did quite a nice job of hiding the fact that this is basically what's what's inside.
00:08:11.680 --> 00:08:17.199
And it was actually filled with leftovers as well, or collections that had no current home.
00:08:17.439 --> 00:08:24.639
So the Wallace collection and the Pitt Rivers collection were both displayed here before finding permanent homes.
00:08:24.959 --> 00:08:35.200
The permanent collections of the Bethnal Green Museum uh consisted of displays moved from South Kensington because they were no longer wanted or valued there.
00:08:35.759 --> 00:08:54.399
Um, so this is the ground floor of the original uh uh plan of the Bethnal Green Museum, and I think you can see, I hope you can see they've got the food collection and the animal products collection, um, both of which were definitely uh they're described as sweepings from the uh VA.
00:08:54.559 --> 00:08:58.000
Um, and best of all, waste products.
00:08:59.039 --> 00:09:00.399
Oh, waste products.
00:09:00.559 --> 00:09:04.000
Um, I'm afraid this slide is going to stay up for quite a long time.
00:09:04.159 --> 00:09:15.360
This is a panel that was up in the Bethnal Green Museum illustrating the value of a dead horse, uh all the different bits of it uh and and what they were worth per pound and what you would use them for.
00:09:16.320 --> 00:09:19.519
Heart and tongue are described as a mystery.
00:09:21.679 --> 00:09:30.000
Um, so these are quite unappealing displays, um, maybe less so in a 19th-century uh context.
00:09:30.399 --> 00:09:38.799
Um, but this is where we see the the phrases from my title and my subtitle, trivial things of no intrinsic value.
00:09:38.879 --> 00:09:43.519
This is what the VA described as the things that they sent to Bethnel Green.
00:09:43.759 --> 00:09:46.240
Um so there's a clear opposition there.
00:09:46.320 --> 00:09:54.159
So by implication, the South Kensington parent holds objects that it believes to be of intrinsic and universal high value.
00:09:54.320 --> 00:10:05.440
By the end of the 19th century, it was increasingly caught up in international bidding wars and rapidly rising prices for globally sought-after objects of art and design.
00:10:06.080 --> 00:10:15.519
Whereas the objects and collections that went to Bethnal Green were seen as good enough for an audience of working men and not for the nation as a whole.
00:10:15.759 --> 00:10:19.200
So there's a lot of judgments about uh social groups going on there.
00:10:19.440 --> 00:10:24.399
All in all, the Bethnal Green Museum was demonstrably low value.
00:10:25.039 --> 00:10:30.799
And yet, there is another way to look at the Bethnal Green Museum and its apparently valueless things.
00:10:31.039 --> 00:10:44.799
The main VA Museum made very few concessions at this time to what any audience wanted or needed, but this East End Museum had a particular audience in mind and specific goals that it wanted to achieve.
00:10:45.039 --> 00:10:47.840
It wanted to provide educational resources.
00:10:48.080 --> 00:11:03.200
It was assumed that working men would educate themselves with the material to offer an alternative leisure venue to the pub and to be useful, to offer exhibits and displays that directly related to people's working lives and industry.
00:11:03.679 --> 00:11:09.919
These are actually much less patronizing aims than many Victorian cultural initiatives.
00:11:10.159 --> 00:11:23.919
They might still be a bit patronizing, but actually, you know, pubs are they're not a driver of poverty to the extent that the Victorians thought they were, but it's certainly true that working class people had very few uh leisure uh venues.
00:11:24.080 --> 00:11:31.039
Um, and it is also certainly true that the working class were expert and avid self-educators given the resources.
00:11:31.919 -->
00:11:42.000
Whatever precisely the reason, the Bethnal Green Museum was massively popular, featuring huge crowds.
00:11:42.240 --> 00:11:52.320
So in 1888, 900,000 people visited it, which was a lot higher than the number that visited the main museum in South Kensington.
00:11:53.120 --> 00:12:00.240
So if you measure by numbers, the Bethnel Green Museum certainly had as much value as its South Kensington parent.
00:12:02.320 --> 00:12:03.840
So why was this?
00:12:04.639 --> 00:12:10.399
I think, as I suggested before, curators here could could experiment a little bit.
00:12:10.480 --> 00:12:26.320
They didn't have as much oversight, um, and they could therefore respond to their audiences in a way, as long as they didn't spend any money, because they didn't have any money to spend, but if they could find cheap ways of working with their audience, um they could do that, which which was much less the case at the main museum.
00:12:26.639 --> 00:12:33.679
So, firstly, its content was more varied than this waste product displays suggest.
00:12:33.840 --> 00:12:40.720
They had rapidly changing loan collections on very varied topics and collections of particular local interest.
00:12:40.799 --> 00:12:48.879
So in the year 1913 to 14, they had loan displays of furniture, Chinese enamels, lepidoptera, fine art, and more.
00:12:49.360 --> 00:13:00.480
By 1923, it had a loan collection of drawings and paintings from the art section of the Men's Evening Institute, and the curator said it was entering into the life of Bethnal Green.
00:13:02.480 --> 00:13:06.240
The local focus became more pronounced as well.
00:13:06.399 --> 00:13:13.519
In the same year, 1923, it acquired part of the Gardiner collection of prints, drawings, and ephemera relating to East London.
00:13:13.679 --> 00:13:21.120
You can see here a rather lovely uh map of uh Bethnal Green from the beginning of the 18th century.
00:13:21.440 --> 00:13:31.600
Again, though, the VA curators thought it was low quality but of local interest, so they were happy to relegate it to Bethnal Green.
00:13:33.200 --> 00:13:49.519
It also quickly came to contain the germs of what became the uh Museum of Childhood collection in 1974, despite again the main museum's lack of interest in and disdain for toys and games and dolls.
00:13:49.759 --> 00:13:55.360
Curators said they couldn't see any value in toys and games and dolls except to send them to Bethnal Green.
00:13:55.519 --> 00:14:02.879
So a number of donors, mostly women, as we can see with with this uh uh this doll acquired in the in 1925.
00:14:04.559 --> 00:14:12.240
The most important donor was Queen Mary, which really helped, I think, to establish uh this this collection.
00:14:12.399 --> 00:14:17.919
Um the uh the the gabled doll's house is is one that she gave as a whole.
00:14:18.080 --> 00:14:26.960
The other one, the furnishings are her collection, and she had someone, a handyman at Buckingham Palace, knock up the house for her.
00:14:27.600 --> 00:14:39.039
Um so donors, women donors started giving miniature and toy objects, and the Bethnal Green curator encouraged it despite uh a lack of enthusiasm from the VA.
00:14:39.120 --> 00:14:46.399
And by 1974, when it became the Museum of Childhood, it had the largest collection of childhood-related items in the UK.
00:14:47.279 --> 00:14:50.720
Secondly, it knew its audience and it catered to it.
00:14:50.879 --> 00:15:01.360
It was open every day except Christmas Day and Good Friday, and it stayed open till 10 pm, three days a week, and more in summer.
00:15:03.279 --> 00:15:10.080
It had a huge number of unaccompanied child visitors in the interwar period.
00:15:10.240 --> 00:15:18.720
Uh, one observer in um 1921 suggested that 90% of all its visitors were unaccompanied child uh visitors.
00:15:18.799 --> 00:15:29.200
Uh, someone else said it was 70%, so I think we can probably cast some doubt on the 90% figure, but certainly there were a lot of unaccompanied uh children uh visiting there.
00:15:29.360 --> 00:15:34.639
And it did quite a lot in a low-key kind of way to engage this group.
00:15:34.879 --> 00:15:51.519
So obviously the Toys and Dolls collection uh are part of this, uh, but the museum also provided activities in the holidays and at weekends, it resolved to tell a story with uh the technical displays and provide enhanced facilities for school groups and teachers.
00:15:51.679 --> 00:16:11.200
I like this quote from The Times from 1928, uh, where it talks about the curator um uh seeing the children as raw material that he could kind of impose the museum habit on, but we don't need to worry about them being um too highbrow because they like dolls' houses, models of ships, railway engines, and birds in that order.
00:16:11.519 --> 00:16:12.159
Great.
00:16:12.799 --> 00:16:33.840
So, despite originating as a collection of low-value and trivial cast-offs, the Bethnal Green Museum provided value to its audience, who valued indoor space as a minimum, and exhibits of interest to children, opening times that worked with their lives, and varied collections focusing on the area they lived in.
00:16:35.519 --> 00:16:43.039
The value of the local and ordinary and of museums as part of daily life comes through the Bethnal Green Museum really strongly.
00:16:43.200 --> 00:16:52.960
Now, in these days of physical and virtual travel and of restricted child independence, much of the value of a museum on your doorstep might have disappeared.
00:16:53.279 --> 00:17:01.679
But the idea of responsiveness to your audience has very much not disappeared but has become a key part of museum work.
00:17:04.640 --> 00:17:07.119
So, living nature in museums.
00:17:07.359 --> 00:17:15.119
I'm going to stay in the east end of London here and I'm going to introduce you to Tom the Borough Toad.
00:17:15.440 --> 00:17:17.359
He's a marvellous creature.
00:17:17.599 --> 00:17:27.839
And he lived at the nature study branch of Stepney Borough Museum in the
first decade of the 20th century as a living specimen.
00:17:27.920 --> 00:17:31.039
He was alive, he lived in a sort of tank type thing there.
00:17:31.200 --> 00:17:44.559
He lived alongside Sally the Borough Newt, who I do not have a picture of, and a host of other live creatures, in contrast to the usual museum habit of displaying dead ones.
00:17:45.519 --> 00:18:00.240
A few museums today continue this practice, including notably Manchester Museum, whose vivarium contains some magnificent creatures, but it's not a very widespread habit these days compared to the first half of the 20th century.
00:18:01.440 --> 00:18:06.079
The Nature Study Museum was located in the disused mortuary chapel of St.
00:18:06.160 --> 00:18:10.559
George and East Church in Chadwell, East London, off Cable Street.
00:18:10.720 --> 00:18:13.599
It's long got well, it's long gone as a museum.
00:18:13.680 --> 00:18:21.759
The building is still there in a bit of a state, and you can just see Nature Study Museum on that plaque above the door.
00:18:22.720 --> 00:18:26.559
And it went all in on living creatures as exhibits.
00:18:26.640 --> 00:18:44.400
It had a bad-tempered monkey, it had a hedgehog, it had a beehive, it had an anthill, it was almost entirely kind of living creatures, but mostly very local creatures, unlike these kind of exotic uh things that you get uh elsewhere.
00:18:44.480 --> 00:18:48.640
These were things that you could literally find in your garden, like the hedgehog.
00:18:48.799 --> 00:18:52.240
Um, even the monkey came from a ship in the nearby London docks.
00:18:52.480 --> 00:18:54.799
So, again, it's a very cheap collection.
00:18:54.880 --> 00:18:57.359
Um, most of it is basically free.
00:18:58.000 --> 00:19:04.319
And yet, it had an enormous impact, being described as a fairy house at the time.
00:19:04.480 --> 00:19:07.200
And I love the quote, the toad makes a snap at us.
00:19:07.359 --> 00:19:12.799
That's from an essay that some child had to write when they went back to school after the school visit to the museum.
00:19:12.880 --> 00:19:15.119
And I think many of us can relate to that.
00:19:15.200 --> 00:19:20.319
Uh, and I love the picture of the the school kids in the museum about 1910.
00:19:20.640 --> 00:19:25.839
Um and even more alive things here.
00:19:25.920 --> 00:19:30.319
Uh, you can see the beehive, you can see uh tanks with local pond life.
00:19:30.400 --> 00:19:35.599
Again, local pond life only is what we've got there in that um in those tanks there.
00:19:36.720 --> 00:19:46.240
Now, one of the reasons I'm so interested in these living specimens is because they really challenge the idea of the museum object, which is supposed to be permanent.
00:19:46.319 --> 00:19:48.799
That's one of the things you want from a museum object.
00:19:48.880 --> 00:19:51.519
You put it in a museum and it stays there and it stays the same.
00:19:51.680 --> 00:19:55.279
And that, of course, is partly where its value comes from.
00:19:55.519 --> 00:20:00.720
Once an object's in the collection, it's preserved, it's taken out of time, and it's supposed to stay the same.
00:20:01.039 --> 00:20:07.279
But you can't keep living things alive forever or even for very long in some cases.
00:20:07.519 --> 00:20:11.839
And that means there's real challenges in treating them as museum objects.
00:20:12.160 --> 00:20:13.680
Can you catalogue them?
00:20:13.920 --> 00:20:15.359
Can you label them?
00:20:15.599 --> 00:20:19.200
Obviously, the tanks are labelled, but that's not quite the same, is it?
00:20:19.440 --> 00:20:24.960
Tom has a name, we know he was called Tom, but did he have a museum number?
00:20:25.200 --> 00:20:28.240
Um, the Manchester Vivarium creatures do.
00:20:28.400 --> 00:20:34.799
They all have um reference numbers that you can find them in the in the catalogue, but I don't believe Tom did uh at all.
00:20:34.960 --> 00:20:36.960
Certainly the bees and ants didn't.
00:20:37.039 --> 00:20:39.599
Uh so you know you've got to draw the line somewhere.
00:20:39.839 --> 00:20:50.799
And as the idea of living displays spread around other small museums in the period, this issue of ephemerality of highly temporary exhibits became even more acute.
00:20:51.599 --> 00:20:58.240
Um, this is Horsville Art Museum in Manchester, um, which is uh no longer extant.
00:20:58.319 --> 00:21:03.920
Um, it's the birdroom, and you can see it has a large aviary right in the middle.
00:21:04.079 --> 00:21:06.559
There's very few images of it, I'm afraid.
00:21:06.799 --> 00:21:13.119
It also has plants down the side, possibly a nature table in the in the middle of the wall there.
00:21:13.200 --> 00:21:17.279
Um, and I the plants look to be both planted and cut.
00:21:17.920 --> 00:21:34.799
Tollcross House Museum in Glasgow, another museum which is no longer in existence, had again aquaria, vivaria, aviaries, all with local animals such as sticklebacks rather than anything more expensive.
00:21:35.599 --> 00:21:46.000
And these museums and more increasingly contained wildflower displays, which are the most impermanent of them all.
00:21:46.319 --> 00:21:49.200
These are cut wildflowers.
00:21:49.279 --> 00:21:51.920
I know they're technically actually not alive.
00:21:52.000 --> 00:21:54.240
Uh they're dying, I would say, cut flowers.
00:21:54.319 --> 00:21:54.640
That's the thing.
00:21:54.720 --> 00:21:56.079
They're dying, but they're not dead.
00:21:56.319 --> 00:21:59.279
And they are very, very impermanent collections.
00:21:59.440 --> 00:22:06.400
Um Huge displays like this one at Hazelmere need replacing weekly.
00:22:06.960 --> 00:22:10.000
And you can see that this is a fairly sizable display.
00:22:10.720 --> 00:22:17.680
There's a lot of labour involved in replacing all of these cut flowers every single week throughout the summer.
00:22:17.839 --> 00:22:23.680
Some museums did March to October, so that's a real commitment in terms of labour.
00:22:24.799 --> 00:22:31.599
Now
the wildflower displays are really hard to find in the records because they're not catalogued, they're very ephemeral.
00:22:32.720 --> 00:22:36.720
But newspapers occasionally refer to them if you search through those.
00:22:36.799 --> 00:22:56.720
And I think from these kind of hints and traces, we can say that many, if not most, local and municipal museums had some wildflower displays at some point between 1880 and 1960, including quite large museum services such as Glasgow's, here pictured in 1949.
00:22:58.240 --> 00:23:00.880
They are, as I say, very, very labour intensive.
00:23:01.119 --> 00:23:04.640
So what happened was that they were generally crowdsourced.
00:23:05.839 --> 00:23:11.759
There might be a volunteer committee whose job it was to collect wildflowers every week.
00:23:11.920 --> 00:23:16.559
They might draw on the local botanical society to supply them.
00:23:16.720 --> 00:23:20.160
They might get schoolchildren to do it, which is the best solution of all, isn't it?
00:23:20.640 --> 00:23:21.519
Lots of them.
00:23:21.839 --> 00:23:26.559
I fear they must have impacted quite badly on local flora, actually.
00:23:26.720 --> 00:23:30.000
You know, there's this just all the flowers being picked all the time.
00:23:30.160 --> 00:23:33.200
We'll never be able to know for sure, but but they are there.
00:23:33.440 --> 00:23:43.279
Now, if you think of earlier Victorian museums, they look like this, full of dead things, dead nature.
00:23:43.839 --> 00:23:47.119
Most museums in the 19th century focused on natural history.
00:23:47.279 --> 00:23:54.799
Most of their curators came from a natural science background and were often skilled and sometimes professional taxidermists themselves.
00:23:55.920 --> 00:24:05.920
But as we get into the 20th century, people are much less keen on looking at case after case of more or less competent taxidermy.
00:24:06.079 --> 00:24:15.359
And it's at this point that you start to get characterizations of museums as dead and dusty in cultural forms, like novels and things like that.
00:24:15.599 --> 00:24:34.079
Newspapers have loads of references in the first half of the 20th century to the awfulness of dusty museums filled with poor little butterflies stuck in a glass case with pins, dusty bones, the comparing of anything that was really felt to be dead and worthless to a museum specimen.
00:24:35.119 --> 00:24:44.640
So increasingly commentators argued that nature should be appreciated in the wild with full colour and movement.
00:24:45.839 --> 00:24:51.039
And in this context, the interest in living things, I think, becomes much more comprehensible.
00:24:51.440 --> 00:25:00.480
However, much their collection and display might have been equally destructive as the shooting game approach to the museum.
00:25:01.039 --> 00:25:08.319
Aliveness became a much more precious quality in the 20th century, and deadness fell in value.
00:25:08.480 --> 00:25:14.640
And again, this is driven by visitors, often against opposition from curators.
00:25:15.119 --> 00:25:26.960
Curators who were, as I've said, good at taxidermy felt that you just need more taxidermy, you need more dust-free cases, you need more systematic displays, this kind of thing.
00:25:27.279 --> 00:25:37.279
The president of the Museums Association said in 1890, this is one of my favourite quotes by a museum worker of all time.
00:25:37.599 --> 00:25:41.920
If museums appeal to idle curiosity, they are failures.
00:25:43.535 --> 00:25:46.494
You should you should learn to deal with boredom.
00:25:47.519 --> 00:25:49.759
Curators didn't win, though, on that point.
00:25:49.920 --> 00:25:56.400
Visitors weren't going to come to study natural history, which was exclusively about classification and dead animals.
00:25:57.200 --> 00:26:10.559
Now, this particularly this section where my case study museums have all vanished, and you don't really get much in the way of displays of wildflowers in museums in the 21st century.
00:26:11.039 --> 00:26:14.000
So, in a way, you might say, well, did this have any effect?
00:26:14.319 --> 00:26:23.519
And I do think that dusty cases, dusty specimens of taxidermy have retreated in museums.
00:26:23.839 --> 00:26:30.880
Natural history display in museums is much more varied, more interesting, and more alive, dare we say it, than before.
00:26:31.119 --> 00:26:36.400
Now, this is not to sort of diss the museum that looks like this.
00:26:36.559 --> 00:26:53.119
I am partial to a case of Victorian taxidermy, but there is no doubt that a whole museum entirely full of such displays with an exclusive focus on classification, they're very hard work and they do seem to sell the natural world short.
00:26:53.200 --> 00:26:55.519
They don't feel like actual nature.
00:26:55.759 --> 00:27:09.680
Whereas dioramas and theme displays, museum storytelling, all offer the kind of liveliness over the sense of deadness, which not only is not valued but can repel the visitor.
00:27:13.359 --> 00:27:18.319
Now we are going to leave the east end of London and we're going to go somewhere completely different.
00:27:20.240 --> 00:27:25.440
In 1938, two small new museums opened.
00:27:25.839 --> 00:27:35.519
The Highland Folk Museum, originally sited on Iona off the west coast of Scotland, and Craig Neish Open Air Museum on the Isle of Man.
00:27:36.400 --> 00:27:52.160
So both in what might be considered, depending on your perspective, quite remote corners of the British Isles, containing objects of little to no commercial value, which had in some cases actively been salvaged from derelict houses and rubbish heaps.
00:27:52.400 --> 00:27:57.440
They also pioneered a new way to display reconstruction.
00:27:58.000 --> 00:28:09.440
Now, reconstruction had been used before in room settings, initially for decorative art objects and increasingly for what we might start to call social history.
00:28:09.680 --> 00:28:14.720
So this is a precursor on the Isle of Man to Craig
Neche.
00:28:14.880 --> 00:28:21.039
This is in the main museum in Douglas, which is a very kind of generic late Victorian museum.
00:28:21.200 --> 00:28:33.680
But what they did is they built a cottage interior inside it about 1930, in what they called then the Lower Folk Gallery.
00:28:35.200 --> 00:28:39.200
But these two new museums went much further than that.
00:28:40.480 --> 00:28:57.440
The Craig Neesch Museum, which is the bottom white one here with a boat outside it, was initially just that one building, which is Harry Kelly's Cottage, a single cottage which was given to the Museum Trust in Douglas by Harry Kelly's heirs after his death.
00:28:57.519 --> 00:29:03.680
And they remodeled the inside to give it a more traditional look before opening it to the public.
00:29:05.279 --> 00:29:20.160
Over the next couple of decades, interrupted by the Second World War, during which period the South of Man was the site of a very large internment camp, which actually cut the museum off from Douglas for part of the time.
00:29:20.960 --> 00:29:27.839
They started to acquire other cottages and buildings in the village of Craigniche.
00:29:28.000 --> 00:29:34.880
So they ended up by about the middle of the 1950s with a museum that looks like this.
00:29:35.920 --> 00:29:44.640
As you can see, that some of the buildings are labelled and those are museum buildings, but some of the buildings are not labelled, and those are just an ordinary private residences.
00:29:44.720 --> 00:29:50.880
So it's a kind of patchwork of bits of museum in amongst an ordinary village.
00:29:52.240 --> 00:29:59.680
The Highland Folk Museum, which has staffed out in that beautiful, beautiful building on Iona, which is a disused chapel.
00:29:59.759 --> 00:30:14.079
I think that's the most beautiful setting for a museum ever, quickly left uh uh Iona, and again, uh Iona wasn't fully accessible during the Second World War, so it was just as well that they got away from that.
00:30:14.240 --> 00:30:30.720
Um, and on the mainland, it turned not just to using existing old buildings as at Craigniche, but to constructing buildings in a traditional way with traditional craftsmen, traditional materials and techniques.
00:30:30.960 --> 00:30:48.160
So, in this postcard uh for the Highland Folk Museum from I think the 1950s, we can see the Lewis Cottage and the Invernessia Cottage, which, as I say, they're not buildings in situ, they're not buildings that were actually moved uh from Lewis uh or Invernesscia.
00:30:48.400 --> 00:31:00.960
They are built from scratch by craftsmen from those areas with the uh materials from those areas, and you can see they've got um uh traditionally reconstructed interiors as well.
00:31:02.000 --> 00:31:06.640
Now, this is very popular and it's spread around the country.
00:31:06.880 --> 00:31:11.680
Um places couldn't always do open-air museums.
00:31:11.759 --> 00:31:27.200
Uh, so Cambridge and County Folk Museum, which opened in the same year as the
other two, is in an old inn building, but it has um again created a um uh a hearthside setting within the building there.
00:31:27.599 --> 00:31:39.839
Um so it's it's very popular amongst museums that have uh rural folk collections, um, but it's also popular um with other museums with more urban collections.
00:31:40.000 --> 00:31:42.319
We start to get uh museum displays like this.
00:31:42.400 --> 00:31:54.319
This is Lark Hill Place, uh, which is a kind of um a street setting from Salford Museum, um, which uh goes in in the 1940s, I believe.
00:31:55.279 --> 00:32:03.440
So the collections and the display methods of these museums are quite different from what has gone before.
00:32:03.599 --> 00:32:11.279
And what they represent, I think, is a revolution maybe in what is valued in museums.
00:32:11.920 --> 00:32:18.799
Because the value here comes from memory, memory of the everyday domestic past.
00:32:19.839 --> 00:32:34.480
Now, memory is sensory and embodied, um, sensory traces relating to home, even if not our own, can act as extremely powerful prompts for emotional responses.
00:32:34.720 --> 00:32:44.720
These are museums where people have feelings and memories, and this is very um different from uh existing museums.
00:32:45.039 --> 00:32:52.720
So there are a number of ways in which these new museums um feel different.
00:32:53.599 --> 00:33:00.240
But first of all, you have to go inside what is quite a small space, as we can see here.
00:33:00.319 --> 00:33:01.839
That's a really low doorway.
00:33:02.079 --> 00:33:05.920
That's a really low doorway, and the ceiling's pretty low inside as well.
00:33:09.440 --> 00:33:14.880
They're often well, they're lit differently from from normal museums, from normal museums.
00:33:15.039 --> 00:33:21.599
Obviously, the aim in normal museums is to have clarity, to have clear, bright, consistent lighting.
00:33:21.759 --> 00:33:32.799
Whereas these museums have very inconsistent lighting, they're quite dim inside, and where they have light, it's daylight, and it's quite um quite directional, as you can see from these photographs.
00:33:32.880 --> 00:33:41.279
I think the way light and shadow, I mean it's been photographed for the like light and shadow, but you don't have to try too hard to get these lighting effects in these museums.
00:33:41.519 --> 00:33:47.039
Some of them, of course, had fires burning in the half place where it was a real one.
00:33:47.200 --> 00:33:58.559
So you've also got a very distinctive temperature environment in these buildings compared to uh a glass case museum.
00:34:00.079 --> 00:34:03.119
And they're only open in the summer.
00:34:03.279 --> 00:34:08.559
I I can't help thinking this one, Harry Kelly's Cottage, it was probably horrible in the winter.
00:34:08.719 --> 00:34:11.599
It's it's right on the south of the man, it's very exposed.
00:34:11.760 --> 00:34:17.679
Um, they tried to get the caretaker to live in a neighbouring cottage, and he wouldn't because it
was just too damp.
00:34:18.000 --> 00:34:18.960
Very, very damp.
00:34:19.119 --> 00:34:23.360
But if it's only open from May to October, you don't really have too much of that problem.
00:34:23.679 --> 00:34:29.360
Um, and you just get the kind of the nice bits of having an open fire and no other heating.
00:34:29.840 --> 00:34:38.719
The surfaces of the old things assembled clearly indicated their oldness, the sort of loving way in which the table there is photographed.
00:34:38.880 --> 00:34:46.239
Um, I think really sort of highlights the kind of old surface, invites you to touch, and you definitely could touch.
00:34:46.400 --> 00:34:48.719
So we've got a real valuing of that.
00:34:49.039 --> 00:34:55.599
There's also um a very distinctive soundscape at these museums.
00:34:55.760 --> 00:35:03.920
Again, if you think of a glass case museum, they're quite hushed, there isn't too much sound, just the sort of murmur of people thinking great thoughts.
00:35:04.000 --> 00:35:07.360
Um, but these ones had animals.
00:35:07.840 --> 00:35:12.079
Um, so they also had distinct smells, but I I won't talk too much about that.
00:35:12.239 --> 00:35:14.639
Um, but also the craft demonstrations.
00:35:14.800 --> 00:35:18.880
So there's a lot of clacking uh from uh endless spinning wheels.
00:35:18.960 --> 00:35:25.920
They all have spinning wheels, quite a lot of them have looms as well, and quite a lot of them have um have animals.
00:35:26.079 --> 00:35:33.039
These are these are baby goats, but the um fully sized goats were quite again quite quite quite aggressive, apparently.
00:35:33.360 --> 00:35:37.519
And you've also got animals and craft together.
00:35:37.760 --> 00:35:50.559
So the blacksmith um at Craigniche, um again, they demonstrated uh uh uh smithy crafts and shoeing horses and things like that, which is very noisy, very hot.
00:35:50.880 --> 00:35:57.280
Um, you've also got the sound and the smell of the horses themselves, so it's all a you know, there's a sensory overload here, really.
00:35:57.519 --> 00:36:20.400
And this hit in really powerful ways when museums had, as I've suggested, hitherto tried to suppress visitors' emotions and visitors' sensory experiences in favour of in favor of a detached and rational form of looking where you don't engage the other senses and you're not distracted by different shadowy corners and things like that.
00:36:21.360 --> 00:36:25.920
And people found it a really different experience.
00:36:26.480 --> 00:36:28.880
Um, some of these quotes I think are amazing.
00:36:28.960 --> 00:36:41.440
The fact that it was a personal and intimate atmosphere at this these museums, you know, the British Museum does not have a personal and intimate atmosphere, um, which isn't, you know, it's a different type of experience.
00:36:41.679 --> 00:36:56.320
But um, you know, the the spinning wheel is like a friend, um and the memories are really dwelt on here, even if the actual sensory cues are not quite right.
00:36:56.800 --> 00:37:10.320
So just looking at the hearth area will get people smelling the smell of a turf fire, even if there isn't one burning there, and they will be sort of tasting the sup of steaming broth, which isn't there either.
00:37:11.840 --> 00:37:22.000
So again and again we find descriptions of the experience of visiting museums like this as being magical, spiritual, transporting people.
00:37:22.239 --> 00:37:25.280
It's it's kind of a spiritual revelation for some people.
00:37:25.440 --> 00:37:31.119
Someone describes it as like um uh being on the road to Damascus and having a kind of uh revelation.
00:37:32.960 --> 00:37:44.960
So, what this tells us is that in the 20th century, people valued an intimate and enchanting experience at a museum highly.
00:37:45.199 --> 00:37:55.039
We've already seen that orderly specimens with rows and rows of properly arranged specimens were starting to leave people a little bit cold and they're starting to vote with their feet.
00:37:55.360 --> 00:38:01.840
Curators didn't really know how to respond to this, um, apart from to maybe put a kitchen in.
00:38:02.000 --> 00:38:03.519
Everybody put a kitchen in.
00:38:03.760 --> 00:38:15.840
Um, but there are some signs that uh cultural elites felt that this was kind of too popular a trend.
00:38:17.920 --> 00:38:23.760
So the very popularity of these um types of living history museums was held against them.
00:38:24.000 --> 00:38:27.039
Elite cultural commentators think they're fake and tacky.
00:38:27.119 --> 00:38:29.440
This is a rather marvellous charter for Ramblers by C.
00:38:29.599 --> 00:38:29.679
E.
00:38:29.760 --> 00:38:29.840
M.
00:38:29.920 --> 00:38:32.239
Jode, which has this frontis piece.
00:38:32.480 --> 00:38:44.239
Um really um quite a biting satire against the kind of ye oldy cottage with a thatch with the lady spinning outside it.
00:38:44.320 --> 00:38:56.239
Um he talks about yeah, the thatch cottage, the old lady spinning, grandfather clocks, kitchen dressers, these kind of things add up to him to an extremely fake Ursatz kind of experience.
00:38:56.320 --> 00:39:01.519
And also, quite prominently in the illustration, right in the top corner, you can see the car park.
00:39:01.679 --> 00:39:08.320
And I think that's one of the things, you know, these are these are kind of trippers, day trippers, and um, everybody hated day trippers.
00:39:08.480 --> 00:39:11.119
Everybody who was anybody hated day trippers.
00:39:11.599 --> 00:39:23.039
But I think it is it's just popularity in some ways, and this is also shown by this amazing photograph of the opening day of York Castle Museum in 1938.
00:39:23.360 --> 00:39:38.159
York Castle Museum, if you don't know it, despite being in the old castle at York, it is a social history museum which featured from the start cottage rooms and street reconstructions, urban street reconstructions like Lark Hill Place.
00:39:38.320 --> 00:39:41.440
And on its opening day, as you can see,
there was a huge cue.
00:39:41.920 --> 00:39:52.639
Um, and it was actually singled out at the time and since for not being scholarly or systematic enough in its collecting.
00:39:52.719 --> 00:40:02.079
And you can't help thinking actually, this is this is just because it was about the most popular museum outside London in the country at the time.
00:40:03.440 --> 00:40:11.440
Now, the 20th century uh was the century of cinema, and I think we can maybe um make some links here.
00:40:11.679 --> 00:40:21.760
Audiences at films had swiftly found they could experience magical transportation to any number of alternative places, periods, uh, and milieu.
00:40:22.320 --> 00:40:32.000
Film is very realistic, uh, it's intimate, what can be intimate, and it accustoms the viewer to a sort of visual spectacle.
00:40:32.480 --> 00:40:39.679
Film is the medium of 20th century modernity, but from the start it dwelt on the past as much as the future.
00:40:39.760 --> 00:40:53.360
You know, for every sci-fi there was a historical uh drama, and actually, the technological developments of modernity, particularly the motor car, this is Isabel Grant of the Highland Folk Museum.
00:40:53.440 --> 00:41:04.800
She had a car from quite early in the 1920s and she drove around Scotland collecting stuff, and there are unidentifiable objects in her car that she has been collecting there.
00:41:04.960 --> 00:41:11.440
Um, the motor car went alongside and fed the desire to be transported into the world of the everyday past.
00:41:11.599 --> 00:41:18.000
So many of these folk and social history museum collectors were early adopters of the car and loved the car.
00:41:20.000 --> 00:41:29.440
So, um, to conclude, it is true still that we value museums in different ways and in changing ways.
00:41:30.079 --> 00:41:36.000
So, most of the things I've been talking about today have at the very least dropped in value.
00:41:36.480 --> 00:41:40.880
And you've picked up that many of my case studies are museums which have closed.
00:41:41.119 --> 00:41:43.920
Those that are still extant have changed significantly.
00:41:44.000 --> 00:41:54.239
So the Bethnal Green Museum, now a young VA, it draws on those early donations of toys and dolls, but it focuses now on the creativity of young people.
00:41:54.559 --> 00:41:57.840
The Highland Folk Museum still exists, it's great.
00:41:58.480 --> 00:41:59.360
Go and visit it.
00:41:59.440 --> 00:42:09.519
Um, it still has reconstructions of ordinary people's homes, but it displays much less of the 18th and 19th century social history which it started with.
00:42:09.840 --> 00:42:15.440
Quite a lot of the original collection collected by this woman is in storage.
00:42:16.400 --> 00:42:18.559
But that's absolutely fine.
00:42:19.039 --> 00:42:28.000
Despite their assertions of permanence and of eternally valued objects and collections, museums are products of their time and always have been.
00:42:28.159 --> 00:42:33.360
They change constantly, even the ones that seem literally set in stone.
00:42:33.599 --> 00:42:36.880
And they need to, because their visitors change.
00:42:37.440 --> 00:42:50.159
Ultimately, what museum history tells us is that visitors and what's precious to them determines museums rather than museums determining what is valuable and precious.
00:42:50.480 --> 00:42:53.840
Now, for sure, not all visitors are equal.
00:42:54.239 --> 00:43:09.039
Um, 19th century museums with their collections of dead animals, those come largely from a civic elite, 19th century civic elite who treated their museums as a giant display case for their own bird collections or whatever.
00:43:09.760 --> 00:43:16.719
But even then, a much wider selection of the public than we might think helped to shape museums.
00:43:17.280 --> 00:43:20.480
It's particularly clear to see, I think, at small museums.
00:43:20.639 --> 00:43:27.440
You can see how indivisible they are from their visitors and how clearly they reveal the cultural histories of their period.
00:43:27.599 --> 00:43:41.440
They tell us about the popularity of the local, of living nature, of imagining time travel in the 20th century through the way those concepts were imprinted into museums.
00:43:41.679 --> 00:43:50.079
Museums look after the things that we value, and so they remind us that things are only precious because people think they are.
00:43:50.400 --> 00:43:51.360
Thank you.