TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Hello and welcome to Future Projection.
00:00:02
Speaker 2: This is episode 210 of the show. I am Carlos Clauso, joined by Ben Badler.
00:00:08
Speaker 1: What's up, Ben? Happy postseason. How are you doing?
00:00:11
Speaker 3: Good, good. I'm feeling pretty good. About half of my Dodgers over Mariners preseason World Series pick still, so I have that going, but yeah.
00:00:21
Speaker 2: Well, that's one more team you can be excited about than I can for my preseason picks because.
00:00:27
Speaker 1: I.
00:00:27
Speaker 3: Knew you shouldn't have picked the Rockies, Carlos. I don't know what you were thinking on that one, but I warned you.
00:00:35
Speaker 2: Yeah, I had Blue Jays for best offseason and as my World Series winner over the Mets, and neither of those teams are in the postseason. We talked about that a little bit on last week's episode, if you missed that. But we are doing a mailbag episode today. I don't know if we have anything specific to the postseason, but because... This is coming out when the postseason kicks off. I would hate to not let you throw any comments out about the postseason that you might have before we get into that. I'm mostly just excited to watch playoff baseball. It's always fun. We've got four games on deck Tuesday, so that'll be great. What are you most excited for?
00:01:14
Speaker 1: Let me think here.
00:01:18
Speaker 3: I'd like to see.
00:01:24
Speaker 1: I guess.
00:01:26
Speaker 3: The White Sox are not in the draft lottery anymore, right? So they can't win the World Series.
00:01:33
Speaker 1: They cannot, correct, yeah.
00:01:35
Speaker 2: Although, we had the draft lottery odds, and I guess there are some questions about what is even going to happen with the draft lottery, both is it going to take place during the lockout?
00:01:45
Speaker 1: That would be a little bit of a surprise. And also, will we.
00:01:49
Speaker 2: Be seeing a new variant of the draft lottery, both the players and the owners have submitted specific proposals about tweaking the lottery. So it feels like both sides seem happy with a lottery system of some capacity. It's just about like what the details might be. Um, maybe we go to eight teams, maybe we go to four teams for the actual lottery, but, uh, it seems like everyone's pretty happy with it. I think it's a fine solution to prevent like consistent tanking measures. Um, and I think it adds a little bit of a intrigue, but, But they could.
00:02:24
Speaker 3: Like I phrased it poorly, but what I meant is they can't win the lottery this year, obviously, but they could win the World Series and the draft lottery all within the same 12-month span, right?
00:02:34
Speaker 1: Correct.
00:02:35
Speaker 2: Yeah, within the same calendar year, that would be something.
00:02:38
Speaker 3: Number one overall pick and World Series trophy. I don't know which one's, which one. Which one's bigger?
00:02:46
Speaker 1: I mean, the World Series trophy is just a hunk of metal.
00:02:48
Speaker 2: And then picking number one includes a ton of fun throughout the entire spring. Exactly. Rock Choloski is forever. But no, I'm mostly just excited to see the action. Again, every postseason we have delivers. Hopefully this will be the same. But let's hop into our mailbag questions this week. And again, if you guys want to send us any questions at any point, you can email us at futureprojection.baseballamerica.com. We've got a really exciting... For me, email today to talk through. You can also reach us on socials. Ben is at Ben Badler. I'm at Carlos A.
00:03:19
Speaker 1: Collazo.
00:03:20
Speaker 2: All of that info is in the show notes of every episode. So if you ever want to reach out with a question you might have on a prospect, on a team, on general scouting philosophies or anything about our process, we're excited to answer any of those. But let's hop in with our first question from Brad on Twitter who asks, could you list the five or ten guys that with the most exciting measurables in the 2027 draft class. I'm not sure that we'll have or that I have immediate like 10 names that come to mind, but we can certainly list a handful of exciting players. And I'm also curious, Ben, where your mind goes when you hear the term measurables. Because I feel like you could go in any number of different directions. I tend to think of like quantifiable athletic testing or like some sort of like physical... numbers that people are putting up that you can, you can actually slap a number on. Do you, do you go to anything in particular? Because I do feel like measurables is a fairly vague term generally when we're talking about baseball prospects.
00:04:22
Speaker 3: Yeah. I think it's something either athletically or tools wise that you can measure or quantify in a simple way. Right. So that, I mean, that could be force plate, jump mat type testing, It could just be something as simple too as, okay, your 60-yard dash time or your 30-yard dash time, whatever you want to run, or your outfield velo. Infield velo is more like, I don't know, it's a little bit dicier sometimes where, oh, I threw, this guy threw 96 from the infield. Yeah, we took like seven crow hops across the.
00:04:56
Speaker 2: Never forget Blaze Alexander's PG National infield.
00:04:59
Speaker 1: Throw at shortstop. Still lingers in my memory.
00:05:03
Speaker 3: It's easier for me to put more faith in the outfield VLO numbers. Cause okay. All right. Everybody's running to get their start there or catcher, especially because with very few exceptions, it's harder to, it's harder to cheat the catching, uh, the catcher VLO throw, but obviously, you know, you can take off the gear, all that, whatever. But, um, you know, that kind of stuff, bat speed metrics, um, exit velocities especially top ends exit velocities yeah that kind of stuff where you can quantify the tools that way.
00:05:39
Speaker 2: Yeah i guess let's go into some of the players then um i mean the first
Load full transcript
one that jumps to mind for me because he was a member of our summer showcase all-star team and part of the reason that he made the final roster at least for me was because his athletic testing was so tremendous really across the board i feel like he's got a chance to be one of the better athletes overall in this class.
00:06:03
Speaker 1: And that is a.
00:06:04
Speaker 2: Charlotte Catholic high outfielder, John Hucko. He had just tremendous, um, athletic testing at East coast pro. He ran a 6.47, 60 yard dash. His broad jump was an elite figure.
00:06:18
Speaker 1: He had a broad jump that was more than 11 feet.
00:06:21
Speaker 2: And I was just trying to sort of contextualize that specific, uh, athletic test result. And it would have been among the most elite broad jumps for the NFL combine. And I just think across the board as well, and most of the athletic tests they were doing at that event in particular, he was a standout. And it sounds like on a number of teams models, he grades up tremendously well for just like athletic testing power speed that he's able to produce.
00:06:50
Speaker 1: As a baseball player.
00:06:51
Speaker 2: So I think in terms of all around, he's one of the first names to that I go to in next year's class.
00:06:56
Speaker 1: How about you?
00:06:58
Speaker 3: I would have Dylan Seward. I mean, he's just a blazing fast runner. 80 runner, quick burst, twitch, acceleration is tremendous. Then you look at the bat speed, really fast hands, fast barrel through the zone. Part of why he's the number one player in the class, but then the other stuff that he does, all of the actions, the instincts, the internal clock, the ability to translate it. in games is why he is the number one player and do it all at a premium position at shortstop. So, um, there's a lot of things to love with Dylan Seward, but he does a lot of the, uh, you know, he just hits a lot of the explosiveness checkpoints. And obviously with the eight grade speed is he's, he's the fastest guy out there.
00:07:44
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:07:44
Speaker 2: A year ago as an underclassman, I think he was like 0.01 seconds off of Eric Booth jr. At a 60 yard dash, uh, PBRs, all America game this year, he set the record for that individual event, um, for their 60 very clear top of the scale runner. I think that just the Twitch that he has in every aspect of his game really amplifies what he can do, um, in the power offensively that he shows. If you just look at him, walk into the batter's box, you might think that power is not a part of his game. Now, maybe you would think that it's like not ever going to be a huge part of his game, but he's able to generate such Twitch, uh, with his hands and get the bat head through the zone, um, with so much speed that, um, like the power he's able to show is, is pretty remarkable for the frame. So yeah, he would definitely be up there. Another player I want to mention for just like pure athletic testing is Jacob Seaman, another North Carolina outfield prospect a year ago when he was, when he was an underclassman, I took basically like all of the athletic testing events. um, that I had access to from the East coast pro and made like a, a little model that tried to weight those and rank players. And he, he scored at least in my amateurish model, um, as the, the best athletic tester a year ago when he would have been probably 16 years old at that event.
00:09:06
Speaker 3: Um, he probably was, he probably was 15 there cause he's for the class. He like, he just turned 16 in August.
00:09:15
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:09:15
Speaker 2: But, like his, his combination of size, power, speed. Um, I know load and scores are very popular when people are looking at like overall athletic ability, I would be stunned to hear that he didn't have an elite load and score because of that combination of his size, speed, power. Unfortunately, we haven't had a chance to see him a ton, but he would definitely be up there in terms of just pure physical athletic measurables. Um, another player who kind of stands out to me as Nico more, it's Toledo. Um, He's one of the fastest players in the class. Outfielder out of PDG Baseball Academy in Virginia. I believe committed to Virginia Tech. So that's another one on the high school side. I'm sure there's some college names. we could mention here, but the high school players are just like kind of closer to mind for me.
00:10:06
Speaker 1: Um, any other names you want to point out?
00:10:09
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:10:09
Speaker 3: Yeah. I got a bunch on the high school side. I mean, among the high profile guys, Brady Cunningham sticks out to me. He's a third baseman from Illinois and, some Caleb Bonhamer type similarities there just in the way he's built the explosiveness, the power that he has, like it's six, three, 225 pounds. Um, looks like he should be like cracking skulls on the football field, but it's just huge power. And he hit, it was like 17 home runs and 38 games this year or this spring, uh, in high school. And, um, did it on the summer circuit to, um, really athletic, really powerful, explosive, above average runner, strong arm. So, um, just a lot of exciting traits there to like with Brady Cunningham. Uh, Jake Turner would be another one in like a different type of bucket, maybe than some of these guys that we're talking about where, you know, he's not like the burner runner that more it's Toledo or Seward or some of these other guys that we've talked about are, but, um, In terms of just raw bat speed, raw power, raw arm strength, there are many guys that can match him, and he's probably 6'3, 6'4, 200-something pounds. There's a lot going on in the swing, so probably going to be power over hit type guy with him with some adjustments he's going to have to make against better pitching, but it's just vicious play. vicious bat speed, huge power, uh, up to, I think 96 on the mound. Looks like there's probably even more if he keeps going with pitching. Um, but
I, my, excuse me, my, my inclination is he ends up being, uh, a hitter with huge, huge power.
00:12:06
Speaker 1: Right.
00:12:07
Speaker 2: I'll just mention a few other college players that we have pretty loud quantifiable X velocity data from their 2026 spring seasons. I mean, A lot of these players would be unsurprising to hear them mentioned. Brendan Lawson, tremendous power that he's bringing to the table. He had one of the better 90th percentile exit velocities a year ago.
00:12:29
Speaker 1: Jimmy Janicki is another one.
00:12:30
Speaker 2: Nate Savoy and Tate Davis, probably none of those names are massively surprising to hear about in the power department. I'm not sure if you view pure pitching stuff As a measurable here, but I probably would be inclined to think of it in that bucket. And I would throw out Jackson Barbary and Ethan Lund as two of the more exciting, just like pure stuff arms in the class. Barbary is a guy who averaged more than 97 miles per hour with his fastball last spring.
00:13:01
Speaker 1: And then Lund has.
00:13:03
Speaker 2: This dynamic mix of velocity and high spin breaking balls, multiple shapes. Both those guys, hopefully you can harness it a little bit more.
00:13:12
Speaker 1: And find the zone.
00:13:13
Speaker 2: Um, but in terms of pure stuff, they're probably up there with anyone in this, in this class.
00:13:19
Speaker 1: So those are a few other names.
00:13:21
Speaker 3: Yeah. And then I think on the high school side, you got a bunch of like toolsy outfielders with, uh, maybe not in like the top tier of guys, but are definitely players who are of interest and of varying degrees of, uh, baseball skill and like present hitting ability. Somebody like Noah Gottke, uh, Power, speed, strong arm, Tyler Fryman, who's a great, great athlete, big-time runner, football recruit to Jordan Griffin, who is short. I mean, he's probably 5'8 or so, but extremely strong with a great runner and a tremendous amount of bat speed. He hits the ball way harder and way farther than a lot of guys who are significantly stronger bigger than him. You know, he's going to have to, you know, manage some of the swing and miss there, but it's big time tools, big time athlete, Lash Henderson, who, I mean, he looks like he's built in a lab, like six foot four, lean, ultra athletic, great bat speed, can run, throw a ton of tools, still on the raw side. Um, so I imagine he's somebody who probably ends up getting to college and see where it develops from there. But, you know, we'll see what the sign ability obviously is. Cause there's a lot of teams that would love to have just that type of raw physicality athleticism set. That's probably, I mean, just in terms of that matches up as well, like in the very top of the class. but still refining a lot of things still him and like JJ Utash to another physical outfielder with, with power, with speed. These guys are not in that top, top tier of high school player on our draft board, but definitely buyers who are of interest. And if they make adjustments could very well move up just based on the raw tools that they have.
00:15:33
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:15:34
Speaker 2: And I feel like Lash Henderson has got to get some extra points for just A tremendously fun name.
00:15:39
Speaker 1: Lash is a great name for a hitter with his tool set.
00:15:42
Speaker 2: Okay, well, we actually kind of did get towards that 5-10 player bucket in terms of names, so hopefully that gives you more insight on the class, Brad.
00:15:50
Speaker 1: Thank you for the question.
00:15:51
Speaker 2: Let's go to one from Benny on Twitter who asks, how much have Rangers prospects Dylan Dreiling and Rafe Parrish done to impress you guys this season? Yeah, I think two of the better performers in the Rangers system This year, Dylan Dreiling won the Rangers Minor League Player of the Year Award, and then Rafe Parrish certainly had a solid argument for that as well. Did they turn your heads or impress you in any particular ways, Ben?
00:16:17
Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, certainly with the performance they did. You look at what Dylan Dreiling did his first year, first year and change in the Rangers farm system. I don't think Dylan Dreiling probably was too happy with what he did. But then you look at what he did this season, it was 312, 380, 516 in AA.
00:16:48
Speaker 1: I still get a.
00:16:49
Speaker 3: Little bit of 4A type vibes from both those guys. I think you have to be happy with the seasons that they had, but I do still have questions about how... How does this all translate above the minor league level? Right.
00:17:10
Speaker 2: I mean, both, they're not the youngest players in the world. Rafe Parrish is 24. I think Dylan Dreiling is 23. I do think it's worth mentioning Rafe's season here just for people who are maybe non-Rangers fans and haven't been paying as much attention to what he's been doing because it wasn't the same sort of prospect pedigree coming out of college. He was the seventh round pick, signed for just $ 175, 000.
00:17:30
Speaker 1: He was 22 years old.
00:17:33
Speaker 2: At the draft out of Lehigh. We had him as like a fringe top 300 type player in the class. Um, but his production and performance throughout college was always really impressive. Um, there were some questions about like, okay, has he handled the sort of velocity that you're going to be seeing in pro ball at that high level? How is that going to translate? How's the power going to translate? But so far he's, he's looked excellent. I mean, his 2026 season, he had 27 home runs. He slashed three 15, four Oh one five 86, uh, between high A and double A with a majority of that playing time coming in double A. And you look at just the under the hood, bad at ball metrics. He makes a lot of contact. He stays within the zone. Seems to have a pretty good understanding of what to swing at, what not to swing at.
00:18:18
Speaker 1: He hits the ball hard.
00:18:20
Speaker 2: Like his
underlying power numbers are quite a bit more impressive to me than what Dreiling showed this year. But I guess for you, is it just more skepticism of them performing at even higher levels or just like what they can bring to the table beyond the bat. I think Dreiling has a chance to be able to play pretty solid outfield, less familiar with Rafe Parrish's defensive work this year, but it's certainly an impressive offensive season for him.
00:18:46
Speaker 3: Yeah, I think of the two, I'm probably more optimistic about Parrish. I do think it's a more complete offensive profile where with Dreiling, You know, there's some power there. Pretty good feel for the barrel. There's a tendency to struggle to recognize breaking balls to expand the strike zone more than he should. Parrish, yeah, he's older. Kind of just seems like maybe a bit more of a late bloomer if you want to be optimistic about him. It's only his second full season, right? Out of college. So, okay, he is older. It does seem like he took a huge leap forward this year, especially in terms of the power. And it doesn't seem like there's a ton of air in those numbers with the caveat of what we saw just overall this year, especially in teams like in that league and just in general. with the baseball flying in the minor leagues, but the exit velocities are there. There's plenty of contact. It seems like a more mature approach and understanding of the strike zone for him. So if I had to bet on one, he'd be the guy I would bet on.
00:20:05
Speaker 1: Yeah, I think I'd probably be with you. on that one. Um, okay. That's the Rangers prospects, Dylan dryling, Rafe parish.
00:20:13
Speaker 2: We've got another question here from Ben on Twitter who asks, what kind of role could you see with Alexander Alberto in a major league bullpen? He has unique release traits and stuff. The command seems to have taken a step forward. I believe he's going to be a free agent. I'm not sure if he'll fit in the raise post-season bullpen. Uh, so yeah, Alexander Alberto, number 18 prospect in the race system currently, uh, On our board, he was signed by the Rays in November 2019. He's kind of bounced around a little bit. The White Sox selected him in the Rule 5 draft in the offseason, but he got back to the Rays, pitched in AA and AAA. And as Ben said on Twitter here, he did make some strides with the walk rate, particularly in his stint in AA, where he.
00:20:56
Speaker 1: Walked 8% of batters.
00:20:59
Speaker 2: He is historically a very erratic strike thrower, and I think there are probably still some struggles with the control here, but it's a big kind of cut fastball and a sweeper slider. It seems like he's got a chance to pitch as a high leverage reliever of some capacity. If he's able to maintain these control and command strides. But I'm not sure that you could go much like into the 55 sort of tier for our, our reliever grades. If you're looking at BA grades, kind of how we're evaluating relievers, sort of that 45, 50 BA grade bucket.
00:21:31
Speaker 1: Is, is how I would view him. right now.
00:21:34
Speaker 2: Um, it does seem like he's gotten some positive feedback about the ability to pitch in a big league bullpen right now. Um, whether or not that means post-season this year, uh, I guess is open for, for debate. What are your thoughts on Alberto here, Ben?
00:21:49
Speaker 3: Uh, I'd probably go a tick lower in terms of the ultimate role for him. Probably more of like a moderate leverage type reliever. I don't see him being like a high end, uh, high leverage back of the bullpen type guy, but I do like, I mean, I like, it's obviously like that cut fastball, the sweeper he throws it's, it's good stuff. I just don't know that it's like elite, like high leverage type reliever type outcome for him.
00:22:19
Speaker 2: So you'd probably just be comfortable with the sort of 45 mild grade we've got on them right now. Um, for those maybe unfamiliar with our BA grading system for relievers, Um, if we're putting a 60, we basically think you're going to be the best reliever in baseball, very few, and maybe no relievers in any given year. We'll get that sort of grade. 55 is like an elite reliever. One of the, one of the lockdown players that you would want to come in like the most clutch situations. And then 50, 45, 40, it goes high leverage, middle reliever, low leverage. Um, so it seems like 45 is what you're kind of describing there. Yeah.
00:22:54
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:22:54
Speaker 3: I think that's, that's a good fit for, for him.
00:22:58
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:23:00
Speaker 2: Hopefully that kind of answers your question on at least how we're viewing Alberto right now, Ben.
00:23:04
Speaker 1: Thank you for the question.
00:23:05
Speaker 2: All right, let's get into our final question today that I'm excited to talk to you about, Ben, and hear your opinions on. This is an email from Phil who notes that he's been a subscriber for longer than I've been alive and also maybe longer than you've been alive, Ben. So we really appreciate your longstanding support of Baseball America. Phil, it's crazy to hear that you've been subscribing to this company longer than I've been alive. Um, but there are definitely other people like you out there. So it is very cool and very much appreciated. But, uh, Phil is asking about whether or not right-handed hitting prospects are undervalued, uh, maybe because left-handed hitting prospects themselves are overvalued. There's been a lot of talk this year about teams looking for right-handed hitters and right-handed hitting outfielders, um, in particular, um, Phil notes that the bar for being a right-handed hitting outfielder in first baseman is really high, and that teams maybe are looking for left-handed hitters at those positions, essentially asking us, are teams undervaluing right-handed hitters, and has that led to maybe a less exciting batch of major league right-handed hitters in pro ball? I'm kind of curious about this
platoon conversation, why left-handed hitters generally get get an edge, all other things being equal, the benefits of being left-handed, kind of the balance you're looking for in lineups. I know Matt Eddy has thought and talked a lot about this, so I picked his brain for it. I've got some thoughts from him I can share. But yeah, why are left-handed hitters more valued generally?
00:24:40
Speaker 3: I think they are a little bit overvalued. I think I would generally agree with what sounds like is the premise of the question. I just try to evaluate the players based on their talent level. There's something to handedness. I think there's maybe an aesthetic value that gets left-handed hitters to be overvalued relative to right-handed hitters sometimes. We certainly see some teams that heavily gravitate toward left-handed hitters, whether it's in the draft or internationally. But I just, I look up and down big league rosters right now. And like just who the best players in the game are. I don't see a slant. I don't see, it's not like left-handed hitters are dominating.
00:25:33
Speaker 1: That is.
00:25:34
Speaker 3: I mean, if you look at the top 25 hitters in war this year, which is basically all the five win or better players, you've got 13 right-handed hitters and left-handed hitters. And then you got a couple of switch hitters. You get Caminero, Bobby Wood Jr. I mean, Aaron Judge is not there right now, but Wilson Contreras, Rosarena, obviously, Trout, Alonzo, Tatis, Bregman, Turner, Jackson, Churrio, Miguel Vargas, some of the biggest stars in the game. I mean, you look at the active war. leaders, six of the top seven, I mean, just among position players, plus Joey Otani, too. Six of the top seven are right-handed. Twelve of the top 20 are right-handed, plus there's two switch hitters in there. So, you know, it's like Mookie Betts and Paul Goldschmidt, Machado, Arenado, you know, Altuve, Simeon, McCutcheon, Carlos Correa, Stan, like I Yeah, and I like left-handed hitters too, but I do think they have a tendency, especially at the amateur level, to, at least when they're being discussed a lot of times, they hear, oh, well, this guy's left-handed as if it's like some big, big boost for the player when I don't necessarily think that's deserved. Or, yeah, I would agree that, oh, he's a right-handed corner guy.
00:27:12
Speaker 1: I don't know.
00:27:13
Speaker 3: I'm fine with Junior Caminero. I'm fine with Paul Goldschmidt. I'll take them on my team.
00:27:18
Speaker 2: I think I'll disagree slightly, and I think that where I'll agree, I guess I'll start there, is at the extremes, I'm indifferent to whether you hit right or left-handed. I think if you're an elite hitter, if you're a right-handed hitter and you're elite, or if you're a left-handed hitter and you're elite, I.
00:27:35
Speaker 1: Kind of don't care.
00:27:36
Speaker 2: I think in general, though, there are a few just baked-in advantages to being left-handed. The first and most obvious is that you're almost always coming up with the platoon advantage. Um, even though there were more innings thrown from left-handed pitchers this year, I think going back to like 2000, there are between 10,000 and 13,000 innings each season thrown from left-handed pitchers. If you look at how many innings are thrown by righties, it's in the 30,000 to 33,000 innings bucket. So you're just seeing more right-handed pitchers in general. If you can have the platoon advantage, um, I think that is generally good for you. I think additionally, it is more beneficial to hit behind runners than in front of them, all things being equal, and it's more natural for players to pull the ball. When you're talking about situational hitting, to the extent that that exists in the major leagues these days, it's just easier for a left-handed hitter to maybe come across a batted ball that is more beneficial for runners on first or second base because it's harder to throw to third base from right field than it is left field. Now that maybe is marginal, but I think that's an advantage. I also think just standing closer to first base as a left-handed hitter is an advantage. You're going to get to first base quicker if you're the same speed as someone who is starting in the right-handed batter's box. And if you just look at the overall production of left-handed hitters in the major leagues compared to right-handed hitters, they are more productive. In the last five years, Let me see where I have my numbers here. Yeah, right-handed hitters have a WRC Plus between 98 and 97 from 2023 to 2026. If you're a left-handed hitter or left-handed hitters league-wide, I should say are all in the 104 to 105 WRC Plus bucket. And I think that probably has a lot to do with just platoon advantage, being closer to first base. I think maybe like on the margins, the fact that more... sliders, like sliders in general are becoming more popular, that tends to be a pitch that is better right on right and left on left. And again, if you're a left-handed hitter, you're facing more sliders from righties. I feel like that is an easier adjustment for left-handed hitters most of the time. Although Phil notes that like if you're a right-handed hitter, You are accustomed to facing right-handed pitchers throughout your whole life, and I do think the extreme platoon splits are more obvious for left-handed hitters. But I do think there is something to balance in a lineup. I wouldn't want to be too right-handed heavy or left-handed heavy in my lineup if I had the choice because it just makes it harder to manage against you, and it makes it harder to bring in specialist relievers who really dominate versus one one side or the other. And so that can be beneficial. So I think in general, I understand why teams really value left-handed hitters. And I also think there's just the element of, Hey, if you're a left-handed hitter or a right-handed hitter, you're, you're more likely to throw with that same hand.
And so there are just fewer places for left-handed throwers to find spots on the field. And so that maybe adds to the, the already rare nature of left-handed hitters, but those are just kind of some of my thoughts. I don't necessarily think I would think... I don't think being left-handed is overvalued, though.
00:31:03
Speaker 1: I don't know if it.
00:31:05
Speaker 2: It doesn't seem to me like there's a reason to believe they are.
00:31:09
Speaker 3: The numbers you're talking about with the advantages for left-handed hitters overall in terms of what they hit, is that... I'd be curious to break that out by position, too. Because there's probably just more left-handed hitters. Like you said, there's only certain positions they can play. Like if you're left-handed... I mean, we can maybe debate another time whether they should be allowed to play other positions, but you're not going to have as many, you know, you're not going to have them catching or playing shortstop or second base. You can always have a left-handed hitter there, but it's, you know, all those guys are going to throw right-handed, whereas if you're a left-handed thrower, you're probably a left-left guy and you're going to play first base or outfielder or DH, right?
00:31:58
Speaker 1: Yeah. There's definitely going to be some like confirm.
00:32:00
Speaker 2: I don't know if it's confirmation bias, but yeah, the fact that you are playing a position where inherently the bar to clear offensively is much higher than, than a premium position.
00:32:07
Speaker 1: That's definitely true. That has to be factored into that. Yeah.
00:32:11
Speaker 3: So I don't know. You'd have to go through it to me. I, to me it's more, yeah, I can't say, um, you know, systemically our left-handed hitters overrated without looking more at a comprehensive data set. So it's more going off of just my, uh, I guess instinct, if you want to call it, from the way players are discussed by clubs when they're talking about players. My sense is, okay, yeah, I like left-handed hitters too, but not to the extreme that certain clubs or maybe generally the sense that I get is when teams are talking about how they evaluate left-handed hitters versus righties.
00:32:55
Speaker 1: If it was a case where you're taking a.
00:32:59
Speaker 2: Player that you view in a different tier, if you're taking a left-handed hitter who's maybe not in that tier over a right-handed hitter, I would think it's problematic. But if it's similar to how I think most teams view age, or at least the teams that I appreciate, how they use age in a model where it's like, hey, if you've got a couple players in the exact same tier that are hard for you to separate, sure, go with the younger player.
00:33:20
Speaker 1: I view it in the same way.
00:33:20
Speaker 2: Like, yeah, if you have two players, difficult to separate, similar value, similar ideas about their offensive ability. I think being a left-handed hitter is a useful tiebreaker and a reasonable tiebreaker for me just because of those baked-in advantages that you have in the game as a left-handed hitter. I guess I would want to be more convinced that the league has over-indexed on left-handed hitters to the extent that right-handed hitters are Because I think I would circle back to your main point. A lot of our stars in the game are right-handed. Those players aren't going to surface regardless. But I just don't know that I've seen enough evidence to say, oh, teams are forgetting about these right-handed studs who are being slept on because they hit right-handed.
00:34:07
Speaker 1: I don't know if that's the case.
00:34:09
Speaker 3: Yeah, that could be true. It didn't stop Rock Cholowski and Von Lackey and Zane Rose and Drew Burrus from being top eight overall picks this year.
00:34:20
Speaker 2: Yeah, fun conversation though. So I guess we'll see if more comes from this next year or if the numbers start to change. It is interesting to me how consistent just the innings and plate appearances seem to be for right-handed hitters, left-handed hitters, right-handed pitchers, left-handed pitchers in general in the league. And ultimately it is a supply issue. You can't just create people who throw or hit left-handed kind of is just how it how it works, how people are born, how they naturally come to hitting. I think developing as a switch hitter is already hard. And then we almost never see it for switch pitchers.
00:34:57
Speaker 1: So, okay. Hopefully that was a satisfying answer, Phil.
00:35:01
Speaker 2: And again, we appreciate you supporting BA for the length of time that you have. So really thank you for that. And thanks to everyone who's listening to the podcast. Thank you to everyone who submitted questions. They're a lot of fun. We love these mailbags. And again, Postseason is getting started today if you're listening to this podcast as it releases. So hopefully you enjoy. We'll be back to talk about the postseason and all sorts of offseason prospect stuff on the feed moving forward as regularly scheduled. For Ben, I'm Carlos.
00:35:31
Speaker 1: So long, everybody.