TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
National Anthems: Only One per Nation
February 2023
According to the Classic FM, the oldest national anthem belongs to the Netherlands and is called the Wilhelmus. It was written between 1568 and 1572 during the Dutch Revolt against Habsburg, Spain. However, it did not become the official anthem until 1932.
A national anthem is generally a patriotic musical composition that evokes and eulogizes the history and traditions of a country and its people and is recognized either by a nation's government as the official national song or by convention through use by the people.
National anthems rose to prominence in Europe during the 19th century, but some originated much earlier. Most national anthems are either marches or hymns in style. They are usually in the country's national or most common language, although states with more than one national language may offer several versions of their anthem. For example, the Swiss Psalm, the national anthem of Switzerland, has different lyrics for each of the country's four official languages (French, German, Italian, and Romansh). Meanwhile, the current national anthem of South Africa is unique in that five of the country's eleven official languages are used in the same anthem (the first stanza is divided between two languages, with each of the remaining three stanzas in a different language).
Very few countries have a national anthem written by a world-renowned composer. Exceptions include Germany, whose anthem, Das Lied der Deutschen, uses a melody written by Joseph Haydn, and Austria, whose national anthem, Land der Berge, Land am Strome, is sometimes credited to Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart.
"La Marseillaise” is the national anthem of France. The song was written in 1792 by Claude Joseph Rouget de Lisle in Strasbourg after the declaration of war by France against Austria and was originally titled "War Song for the Army of the Rhine." The French National Convention adopted it as the Republic's anthem in 1795. The song acquired its nickname after being sung in Paris by volunteers from Marseille marching to the capital. The song is the first example of the "European march" anthemic style. The anthem's evocative melody and lyrics have led to its widespread use as a song of revolution and incorporation into many pieces of classical and popular music. You have probably heard this yet did not know of it, given the popularity of Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture, where the Marseillaise is intermingled with the composer's most famous music. Here it is.
Right now, Russia is a horrible actor on the world stage. I think the invasion of Ukraine is heinous, and I applaud Zelensky’s efforts in freeing his nation from this subjugation. But the Russian National Anthem is that kind of stirring tribute that gets the blood moving. Russian Anthem.
As for our American national anthem, on September 14, 1814, while detained aboard a British ship during the bombardment of Ft. McHenry, Francis Scott Key witnessed at dawn the failure of the British attempt to take Baltimore. Based on this experience, he wrote a poem that asks, "Oh, say does that Star-Spangled Banner yet wave?" Almost immediately, Key's poem was published and wedded to the tune of the "Anacreontic Song." Long before the Civil War, "The Star-Spangled Banner" became the musical and lyrical embodiment of the American flag.
On July 26, 1889, the Secretary of the Navy designated "The Star-Spangled Banner" as the official tune to be played at the raising of the flag. And during Woodrow Wilson's presidency, it was chosen by the White House to be played wherever a national anthem was appropriate, probably the only thing of solid value from the Wilson years. Well, that and child labor laws.
Still, the song was criticized as violent in tone, challenging to sing, and, by prohibitionists, as a drinking song. But on its side, "The Star-Spangled Banner" had a strong supporter in John Philip Sousa, who, in 1931, opined that besides Key's "soul-stirring" words, "it is the spirit of the music that inspires." That same year, on March 3, President Herbert C. Hoover signed the Act establishing Key's poem and John Stafford Smith’s music as the official anthem of the United States.
As noted above, the Star-Spangled Banner was not universally beloved, so America the Beautiful's replacement crept up. Writing in the American Conservative, Michael Warren Davis makes his case: “I think we’re long overdue for an anthem overhaul. Frankly, there’s not much to recommend “The Star-Spangled Banner.” Mr. Key’s poem is alright, but John Stafford Smith’s musical setting is dreadful. For one thing, it’s notoriously difficult to sing. The great virtue of “America the Beautiful” is that it’s actually about a place: namely, America. It celebrates the land that we’re rightly proud to call home, with its purple mountains, fruited plains, and shining seas. It has a history: the pilgrims, who beat “a thoroughfare of freedom” across the wilderness, and those brave men “proved in liberating strife”—who loved their country more than self “and mercy more than life.” It’s these things we share, our common home and history, which “crowns our good in brotherhood.”
I will elucidate why I like the Star-Spangled Banner, aside from the history, later in the podcast. Still, I will say that America the Beautiful is considered to be a replacement for the current National Anthem, not as a separate anthem for some Americans, but not for others.
Actually, for about four years, an alternative American anthem operated at the same time as the Star Spangled Banner and was intended for a separate group of Americans. The song was called Dixie and was celebrated by the slaveholders of the South. "Dixie," also known as "Dixie's Land," "I Wish I Was in Dixie," and other titles is a song about the Southern United States first made in 1859. It is one of the most distinctively Southern musical products of the 19th century. "Dixie" originated in the minstrel
Load full transcript
shows of the 1850s and quickly became popular throughout the United States. During the American Civil War, it was adopted as a de facto national anthem of the Confederacy, along with "The Bonnie Blue Flag" and "God Save the South ."New versions appeared at this time that more explicitly tied the song to the events of the Civil War.
And that brings us to the so-called, mischaracterized Lift Every Voice and Sing, often referred (way too often) as "The Black National Anthem," Lift Every Voice and Sing was a hymn written as a poem by NAACP leader James Weldon Johnson in 1900. His brother, John Rosamond Johnson, composed the music for the lyrics. A choir of 500 schoolchildren at the segregated Stanton School, where James Weldon Johnson was principal, first performed the song publicly in Jacksonville, Florida, to celebrate President Abraham Lincoln's birthday.
It does not seem totally odd for the NAACP, an organization founded in part by WEB Du Bois and Ida B Wells, to try to create an alternative anthem to the
In 2018, NPR noted "Lift Every Voice and Sing" is a song many African Americans know from school or church. But if you didn't hear it there, you may know it from one of a few landmark performances.
Motown's Kim Weston sang it to nearly 100,000 people at the historic Wattstax concert in 1972. In 1990, singer Melba Moore released an all-star version that included Anita Baker, Stevie Wonder, and Dionne Warwick. Gladys Knight and Bebe Winans added their rendition in 2012. And this April, Beyoncé sang it at Coachella, highlighting black culture to a largely white audience.” Okay, so it is a popular song. I even like it though it, but NPR, being NPR, or the cultural left, could not leave it that; they never seem to be able to simply leave anything at that, “So what is it about "Lift Every Voice and Sing" that speaks to a people, so much that it's become known as the "black national anthem"?
Shana Redmond, a professor at UCLA who studies music, race, and politics and author of the book Anthem: Social Movements and the Sound of Solidarity in the African Diaspora, says it's a song about transcending difficulties — and those difficulties have never fully receded. "Black communities across the globe continue to be vulnerable in very unique and unsettling ways," Redmond says. "To sing this song is to revive that past — but also to recognize, as the lyrics of the song reveal, that there is a hopeful future that might come of it."
I have zero issues with anything Redmond is saying here. Well aside from the issue of how many national anthems a nation needs, Redmond talks about a “national” anthem and then speaks of global communities. Either the song is transcendent, or it is American. And the concept of a black national anthem is gaining further purchase. In writing about the 2023 Super Bowl a few weeks ago, Entertainment Weekly noted that Emmy winner Sheryl Lee Ralph kicked off Super Bowl 2023, singing the Black national anthem "Lift Every Voice and Sing." In writing of the same event, Britain’s Daily Mail at least put quotation marks around it, “The 'black national anthem' was performed before the Super Bowl for the third time in a row, causing outrage on social media.”
So why would I belabor this point? As a democracy of competing interests, we will always be at odds over this or that. At the founding, it was the power of the government vs. that of the states. In the early 1800s, there were intense debates about spending on infrastructure, whether we needed a national bank and the still-burning question of state vs. federal power. The Civil War speaks for itself. In the late 1800s, everything from tariffs to immigration to whether we had a gold or silver standard would tear us asunder. In the early 1900s, the progressives, the Great Depression, and late in the century, the Civil Rights Movement, and the Viet Nam War. Some issues, such as sound vs. soft money or states' rights, are over. Others, such as Jim Crow and black equality, and the size and scope of the federal government, are very much with us today.
Those who call for grand unification are often those who only believe in unification under their terms, with them yielding the power. We do not have Kings or Emperors.
But there must be moments, however fleeting when we are an indivisible nation. Where if not everyone, almost everyone can agree on a standard set of cultural touchstones. A National Anthem is one of those: a single Independence Day and a single founding. That, too, is under dire threat but the likes of the 1619 Project. Though in a fit of revisionism to their revisionism, the editors took away the “Founding” statement, they did so with a wink and a nod.
Writer Caroline Downey makes this additional point, “American actress and singer Vanessa Williams will perform the song “Lift Every Voice and Sing,” which has become known as the “black national anthem,” at the annual A Capitol Fourth televised celebration. Williams told the Associated Press she would be honoring the nation’s Independence Day and Juneteenth, which recognizes the anniversary of the liberation of the last slaves in the United States, at the show.
No real distinction here. Except to say that if Life Every Voice and Sing is the black national anthem, then is the Star-Spangled Banner the white one? What is the end game? Do Latinos get their national anthem and make Cinco De Mayo equivalent to the 4th of July? That will not work because we would need Cuban, Mexican, and many central and southern American immigration songs and days. We will need an Asian one, well two, China and India, well three, Pakistan is big too. And the Japanese. Do we need one for Jewish people? Maybe for Arab cultures? Roosevelt famously used a divide-and-conquer tradition to build his New Deal coalition, but it is hard to imagine Roosevelt wanting to separate everything.
Let me place a word here that, rightly, has an odium in American history, segregation: the
action or state of setting someone or something apart from others. What is a separate national anthem but a new version of that? Writing for the National Review, I think Rich Lowry captures this threat, “A nation is to a large extent defined by its symbols and associations, the holidays, rituals, heroes, and history — the mystic chords of memory — that constitute its collective self-understanding. This is how a nation tells itself what it is and what its priorities should be.
Lowry Adds, “In discussing the roots of identity, Huntington notes that people inevitably define their identities in opposition to an “other.” The “other” in the case of our new national identity isn’t foreign powers or alien practices, but American traditions themselves; everything that doesn’t fit into a new “anti-racist” narrative of the country must be denigrated and cast aside. New ceremonies, catchphrases, and heroes will replace the allegedly inadequate, sinful ones of yore. Unfortunately, the NFL, which not too long ago represented a consensus American patriotism, is now part of the vanguard of this hostile redefinition of what America is and should be.
So, what exactly does the Star Bangled Banner say in about 80 words? It evinces another of our totems that is also under siege, our own flag. One cannot know our anthem without knowing our flag.
Oh, say, can you see by the dawn's early light,
What so proudly we hailed at the twilight's last gleaming?
Whose broad stripes and bright stars, thru the perilous fight,
O'er the ramparts we watched were so gallantly streaming.
And the rocket's red glare,
the bombs bursting in air,
Gave proof through the night that our flag was still there.
Oh, say does that star-spangled Banner yet wave,
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave?
For me, the key passage is that our flag was still there. Our nation experiences torment, depressions, and war, but we are resilient, free, and brave.
Compare the American National Anthem to Russia’s:
Be glorified, our free Fatherland,
The age-old union of fraternal peoples,
Ancestor-given wisdom of the people!
Be glorified, country! We are proud of you!
From the southern seas to the polar edge
Our forests and fields are spread out.
You are the only one in the world! You are the only one -
the native land so kept by God!
The Russian national anthem is about the nation and very much about the land, not necessarily the attributes of their people. And what is not evidence, and is in ours, is the ideals of freedom.
This does not expurgate the wrongs of our history; it does not even mention them. What our National Anthem does is exude the best qualities of us as Americans, as one people.
The elevation of other American national anthems is not a direct repudiation of this ethos, for it is almost impossible to repudiate this even for the descendants of slaves, as “the land of the free” provides that repudiation of slavery. Instead, determining alternatives to our national mood provides those who do the determining with power. There are those who glory and prosper in division and divisiveness, and if our national fabric frays or comes apart, they do not care as long as they get theirs.
Lincoln famously noted a house divided against itself cannot stand. Again, multiple anthems and culture without common cultural touchstones will prove Lincoln right.