TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
James Hurman 0:00
How markets work at any point in time. You've got a small group of people that are in the market ready to buy, and you've got a much larger group who aren't in the market. They're not ready to buy yet, but they will definitely come into the market at some point in the future. And so we've got two jobs. One is to convert the people who are in the market, but there's only a certain amount of them at any given point in time, so if we overspend doing that, that's what pushes up our cost of acquisition. That's why we see this performance plateau happening, and this other group building the the future customers, who for whom it's no use to try to persuade them to buy a product now. They're not going to. They're not in the market, and so we've got to do something different, which is fundamentally what brand building is about making our brand familiar to and emotionally kind of you know likeable by those people, so that as they come into market, these biases, the familiarity bias and the affect heuristic, which is fancy way of saying we tend to place value in things that we like, those those biases we carry those into the market and those gravitators towards the brand that's being advertised.
Ben Walker 1:22
Hello, everybody, and welcome to the CIM Marketing Podcast. And you know, one of the all-time evergreen questions in our industry is how do we balance investment in creating future demand, aka brand building, versus getting current sales, getting current demand, and it's as I say, it is an evergreen, immortal, eternal question in marketing. And there's no better man to answer this eternal question than mr. James Herman, who's joining us today, actually from Vancouver, Canada. Although, as you will doubt to tell from his accent, is a New Zealander. James is author of Future Demand. He is a New Zealand-based entrepreneur, an investor, and an advertising effectiveness expert. He grew up in the advertising industry as a strategic planner, and during his career has won over 50 advertising effectiveness awards, and was named the world's number one strategic planning director. James, how are you doing?
James Hurman 2:24
I'm great, Ben. Great to be with you.
Ben Walker 2:26
One of my favourite questions: What's the biggest misconception about marketing that you run into during your work?
James Hurman 2:34
I think the biggest misconception is just the idea that advertising works by persuading people to buy things, and and and it's sort of it's natural to believe that. I mean, it seems pretty logical that that's why we advertise. You know, you put an advertisement up for something, you make a case for the product, or you know why it's better than the others, and and hopefully if you've made a persuasive enough case, then people see the ad and run out and buy the thing, and and so like I say, it's kind of it sort of seems to make logical sense that that's how advertising works, but it's not how advertising works at all. And
Load full transcript
now we've got you know just so much evidence and data of of how markets really work and how humans really make decisions, and you know, markets are are these things that people naturally move in in and out of. You know, the when when we go to the supermarket and do our shop, that's driven by a load of normal life forces that have nothing to do with advertising. How we make decisions is basically you know fundamentally influenced by a series of biases that shape how those decisions are made, and and so effectively, you know, as people come into a market, very naturally, what advertising does is kind of directs them toward the thing that they're already somewhat biassed towards. Should that advertiser have advertised in the past to make us feel more familiar with and more emotionally positive about their brand, and so so advertising works in that way. It's kind of by by creating a bias in people's heads, and then and then sort of delivering on that bias as those people naturally come into market. So I think that's one thing that you know means that we spend a lot of time making advertising that doesn't work very well because we expect it to work in a way that it doesn't.
Ben Walker 4:29
How many advertisers get that? Do you think? Do you think it's a common misconception that by creating advertising, you're creating sales?
James Hurman 4:37
Yeah, it's a very common misconception, and it actually goes back to the early 1900s. So, so back in I think it was about 1902. There was an American guy called Frank Dukesmith who who came up with what we in marketing know as Ada. So the the the sort of creation of awareness and then interest and then. And then action, and that was adopted by the advertising marketing industry as a kind of mental model of how advertising worked. That's what a good ad did. It sort of generated awareness and turned that into interest, and then desire, and then sort of call to action at the end of that, at the end of the ad, and and and that was actually that that kind of discovery or that mental model was not produced by an advertising or marketing person. Frank Dukesmith was a salesman. He was describing how sales work. He was not describing how advertising or marketing work. And advertising is not sales over media, right? That's that's the misconception. Sales, you know, sales are completely different things. Sales is something you do with warm leads who are already interested in what you've got to sell, and and it's the process of converting that that interest into into a sale. And advertising doesn't work like that at all. When we advertise, we advertise mostly to people who aren't in the market and have no interest in buying what we've got to sell, or what our category has to sell. So when we think of Ada and we think of advertising as a persuasion mechanism, we're actually thinking of sales, and it's a completely different discipline. In
Ben Walker 6:10
terms of building that awareness, building that emotional connection, or creating that sort of positive bias, what's the most memorable campaign you've worked on?
James Hurman 6:20
Oh boy! Well, I haven't worked in advertising now for about 13 years. I've worked on advertising effectively, so that's continued to be a passion. But but yeah, the last advertising campaigns that I did were were a long time ago. But if I sort of think back back to those, I mean, it was probably, you know, there was a campaign that we did for a beer brand in New Zealand called DB Export. And if anyone out there is sort of closely follows Can Lions and the companies that win awards, you'll be familiar with DB Export as a brand that's won lots of them. But but we we made this amazing ad back in probably 2010 or something like that, that told the story of this brand that that no one had heard before, right? So this brand, this brand of beer was actually invented in the 1950s by a guy called Morton Coots, and he invented it because he wanted to create the best beer in the world from New Zealand, and no one had ever done that before, and the reason was the government had introduced something called the black budget, which was a sort of punitive tax regime where they taxed the importation of lots of goods, including beer. And back in the back in those days, if you you know the beer that was made in New Zealand was just ordinary, average, not particularly good beer, and if you wanted to drink the best, the good stuff, you drunk the imported stuff. And this tax regime basically put it out of the reach of kind of your common New Zealand working man. And so Morton Coots had this idea: if I can make the best beer in the world in New Zealand, they can't tax it, and New Zealand men can still afford to drink the best beer in the world. So it was this amazing sort of, you know, conception story, and it went on to sure enough be the first beer in New Zealand to win best beer in the world, and and it was this this like wonderful story that had this villain in the government and this hero in Morton Coates who started the brewery and you know made this beer, and and no one had heard the story because it had just been lost to history, and everyone thought this this beer had actually been invented by the marketing department in the 1980s, and had absolutely no sort of you know brewing credentials or history or any of that that stuff to it. And and simply by kind of digging out the story, discovering the story that not even the CEO of the company knew at the at the time in the in 2010, we managed to sort of really make people think a whole lot better of that of that brand, and subsequently took it back up to the market share level it was at during the 90s when it was at its absolute sort of peak, and and so that was a that was you know that was one of my favourite things you know proper storytelling. I think you know some brands have the have you know genuine and surprising you know genuinely interesting stories, and some don't, and and you
know so you've got to find other ways of making them interesting, frankly. But when a brand does have a really a really good story and one that people are surprised to hear and enjoy when they hear it, then it can be, you know, one of the best brand building mechanisms. You know, just telling the truth.
Ben Walker 9:29
Fantastic way of brand building, but brand building itself is under a bit of threat, isn't it? You know, this is part of your part of your book. You know, that more and more we, you know, there's this old adage that you should spend 60% of your marketing time and budget, if you like, on on building your brand, and 40% on conversions, on on creating immediate immediate demand, immediate sales, as it were. And over time, that's been whittled away. And we're now, if we look at it these days, particularly. In the UK, we're near near a 50-50. You're worried about that, aren't you? You you you say in you say in the book, you know, there's the feeling where we're sort of hitting a ceiling, you know, where all of a sudden we're putting more and more money into the performance machine, the performance marketing, you know, the second bit, the short term, and all we're doing is actually increasing the cost of acquisition, you know, rather than escalating any sales, you know, is that brand building under threat?
James Hurman 10:27
Yeah, I mean, I'll I'll sort of correct you slightly on the questions. Brand building right now is actually in an ascendance, I think. Ah, so it has been absolutely, you know, diminished for the past 15 years due to the rise of the platforms and performance marketing, and and and you know the likes of Meta addicting addicting marketers to performance marketing. But they so it has it's had a really tough time, and and yes, Les and Peter sort of came up with 6040 back in 2013. That's what the IPA data said the optimal split was. I mean, now most companies around the world would be closer to 80% performance and 20% brand. So it's back to about half and half. And and and in the IPA data, Liz and Peter rightly found the optimal split was 6040. When we look at the other studies that have been done into that same thing, you know, can we look at the split of brand and performance, and then can we look at the overall ROI of marketing of all of those things combined? There were actually three studies done just last year: one by Google, one by Analytic Partners, one by BCG, and they all found that the splits are more like about half and half in their data. And and if you go back to you know back way before Liz and Peter, a guy called Peter Kim in New York did a really similar study using the the PIMS database in America, and back then we called it advertising and promotion. It wasn't brand and performance; it was advertising and promotion. And and he found that the optimal split there was about half and half. And so the companies that were spending 70% on promotion, only 30% on advertising, we're doing nearly as well as
the companies that were spending half and half. So it's a pretty good now over you know many many years and in different parts of the world, there's a pretty good case for spending about half and half on on each, and and that has you know the the reason that that you know my point of view on the reason for this is how markets work. At any point in time, you've got a small group of people that are in the market ready to buy, and you've got a much larger group who aren't in the market. They're not ready to buy yet, but they will definitely come into the market at some point in the future. And so we've got two jobs. One is to convert the people who are in the market, but there's only a certain amount of them at any given point in time. So if we overspend doing that, that's what pushes up our cost of acquisition. That's why we see this performance plateau happening, and this other group building the the future customers, who for whom it's no use to try to persuade them to buy a product now. They're not going to. They're not in the market, and so we've got to do something different, which is fundamentally what brand building is about: making our brand familiar to and emotionally kind of you know likeable by those people, so that as they come into market, these biases, the familiarity bias and the affect heuristic, which is fancy way of saying we tend to place value in things that we like those those biases we carry those into the market and those gravitators towards the brand that's being advertised both those jobs are equally important and that's why the split is you know roughly 5050 whenever we look at it
Ben Walker 13:56
so so just to clarify then what you're saying is yes we reached an idea where we were piling all on far too much of our investment into into performance marketing, you know, the internet stuff, the click for sale, the click the lead, all that sort of stuff. But now the industry sort of reached the bottom of the hockey stick, and a renaissance is identifiable where we are going back towards where we should be, which is actually investing in brand building.
James Hurman 14:21
Yes, and it's a long road back, and we're by no means are we at the end of that road yet, because we've sort of, you know, we we went far so far off that track. It's a long road back, but we are, I think, at least in the general marketing community, we are starting to understand why that balance needs to be 50-50, and starting to have some of the tools. Hopefully, my book is one that help us articulate that reality to the people around us, the non-marketing stakeholders around us, and that's, I think, the number one sort of. You know, problem or challenge in marketing at the moment is non-marketing stakeholders, not because you know there's there's anything wrong with them, but just because they they have a bunch of beliefs about marketing that are not informed by the evidence on how marketing really works. And so, communicating to them, convincing them
to let us do the things that the evidence says is the right thing to do. You know that's the real challenge at the moment.
Ben Walker 15:26
How do you do that? I mean, briefly, you. I love this interview you did with Campaign Asia at the beginning of this year. You described your business. Businesses are farms. You said your business is a farm. Performance marketing is the harvest. It's the last stage, brand building is planting seeds and watering the soil. How do you get that lovely sort of long-term view embedded in the non-marketing stakeholders? Even if your colleagues in your marketing department in your agency understand that, how do you get that long-term farming view, if you like to people who aren't in our industry,
James Hurman 16:04
yeah, it's education basically, right? So we've got to educate them. I was speaking to Dara Tresido, who's great, great American marketer. At the time, she was CMO of Palatine, and and she said to me, you know, marketing has not done a very good job of marketing marketing. That's a you know pithy statement, but absolutely right. You know we've often done a fantastic job of marketing the brands and the products in our care, but a pretty terrible job of communicating and educating on what how marketing really works to those non-marketing stakeholders, be that our C-suite or our board or you know whoever it might be, and we need to get much better at that, right? And so it's and it's not a one and done thing. You can't explain all of this, and suddenly the light bulb goes on, and everyone gets it. It's something which, like anything, requires kind of consistent communication, repetition, helping them understand from their point of view in human terms, not marketing terms, how this stuff works. So that's, I mean, part of the mission of Future Demand is about that education. So, so the book itself was written in a way that you know you don't, you don't. It's it's not a bunch of marketing or academic jargon. It's you know it's plain language that any anyone can understand, and just the concept of future demand. I mean, when we, you know, if you say to any non-marketing stakeholder, should we do? Do you want? Do you want to build brand? They sort of say, I don't. I'm not. I'm not quite sure. Maybe. If you say, do you want future demand? They tend to say yes. And not only do I want it, we absolutely need it as a business, and so it's framing the language in slightly more kind of, I don't know, commercial or engineering-like terminology, rather than sort of talking about the the the stuff that we talk about in marketing. We tend to use words in marketing that are ultimately, you know, we understand them as marketers, but they're bloody difficult to describe to others. If you try and if you ask any marketer to define what an insight is, you know they'll tie themselves in knots trying to do that. Right? It's very very difficult to define what an insight is. If you ask them to define creativity, it's really hard to define it. Yes, we know it when we look, when we see it. It's really hard to define when you ask them to define what brand is. It's really hard to do that, right? So we we have all of this terminology that's very well understood to us intuitively as marketers, but is actually very difficult to communicate outward. And so I think part of you know my role is is sort of as a marketing science communicator in the way that you know, great science communicators like Brian Cox, you know, will explain physics to you in a way that makes sense to you as a layman. You know, it's the same for marketing. We've got to get better at communicating marketing and the evidence on how it works, so that people can understand it without having to, you know, first be marketers.
Ben Walker 18:59
It's interesting. You're creating almost creating a new lexicon for marketers, aren't you? You're the title of the book, as you say, is a classic example. Don't say brand building; say creating future demand. You know that you know that's what brand building essentially is. But if you say brand building to someone who's a non-marketer, you're then either stuck with having to make a very long-winded explanation of what that is, or hoping they've got some marketing experience, which they which they may not have. Do people outside of the marketing industry understand the true role of advertising? Do you think I looked at a piece of research that you cited in the book, which is from WPP actually, in Oxford University's Saeed Business School, and it's called "How Humans Decide." If you want to have a look at this research and you're in the audience, we'll include a link in the description for that paper. Now, this paper found that this isn't this number of. Astounded me. I must admit that 84%, 84% of purchases are effectively decided before shopping even begins. People might then reasonably ask, "What's the role of advertising at
James Hurman 20:14
all?" Well, it's to cause that to happen. So, I mean, yes, it's a really excellent piece of research, actually, because you know, I I say a lot. Marketing is fundamentally about how how markets work and how humans make decisions. If you really understand how markets work and how humans make decisions, then the rest of it becomes pretty simple to kind of get your head round. So, how markets work is there's a small group of people in them at any one time, and there's a much larger group of people who aren't in them right now, but will definitely come into them at some point in future. And I do this thing at conferences where I say to the audience, "I want you to put your hand up if you're currently in the market for a new mobile phone. So you're you're shopping for one, you're about you'll buy one in the next couple of weeks, and one or two hands go up, and I say, "Okay, now put your hand up if you think you'll buy a new mobile phone in the next two years, sometime." And almost everyone's hand goes up, and that's a
demonstration of the reality that in any market there are these two types of demand. How humans make decisions is as they come into market, they gravitate towards brands that they are biassed towards, that they feel more familiar with, and that they feel more emotionally positive toward. What the WPP study showed, they they looked at 1.2 million purchase journeys. Right, so people not being in the market, coming into the market, making a purchase, then leaving the market again. So it's a really excellent way of sort of proving this point, and they found that as you said, 84% of people chose a brand that they were already predisposed towards. You know, was on their consideration set before they came into the market, and what this tells us is that you know we've got a slim chance of actually persuading people once they're in a market to buy our brand. It's the brand that already did the job when they were out of market. When they were one of the people that put their hands up and said, "I'm going to buy a new mobile phone in the next two years," they were advertising to those people and making the brand more familiar to those people and more kind of emotionally resonant with those people, so that when they came into market, the sale went to them. And so, I think that's a really instructive study because it it really shows this reality that we really do operate on biases that were formed before we came into market when we were in market making decisions.
Ben Walker 22:34
So when you're creating future demand, you're creating those biases.
James Hurman 22:38
That's right.
Ben Walker 22:38
Now, so they will have an impact on sales in the future.
James Hurman 22:44
Yeah, yeah, that's right. And now, many decades of behavioural economics and neuroscience has sort of shown that these biases are very real. They happen completely unconsciously, so we don't know that we're being influenced by these biases, and we can't report them when we're asked. But they absolutely do shape our decisions, and and so if we want to make more sales, it's about triggering the familiarity bias and by making ourselves more familiar to more people. If we want to sell at a higher price, it's about triggering the affect heuristic, our bias towards paying more for things that we like more, when we feel emotionally positive or we have what's called positive affect towards a brand, we see the price is a little bit smaller than it really is. Which means we'll pay a bit more for that brand. We'll buy it when it's not on discount. We'll still buy it if they put their price up a little bit. That margin is what drives profit. That's how advertising creates profit, and so we can do that kind of advertising. We should be doing it all year, right? Doing the stuff which is not about trying to make the sale, but is the creator of emotional, broadly targeted advertising that that makes sure that we are we are influencing those biases in people,
Ben Walker 24:00
doing the farming, planting the seed, you know, watering the soil as you. So yeah, that's
James Hurman 24:06
right. And the farming analogy is a good one. I actually didn't come up with that. It was actually a guy called John Denny in in in New York who who'd read some of my early work on future demand, and he came up with that. But it's he's really right. You know, you can if if you're a farmer, you need to plant and you need to harvest. And if you do one of those things too much, you end up with less money. So if you harvest more than you plant, you just end up harvesting a plant over and over again and get less and less out of it. You end up with less money. If you plant more than you harvest, you leave a bunch of money on the table because you're not harvesting all that you've planted. So the only way to maximise the revenue and profit of a of a farm is to harvest exactly the amount you planted, right? Yeah, and that's why there's this 5050 split. It's the same thing, right? We need to be converting. Exactly as much demand as we create for the whole thing to work at its optimal level, and that's why we see the highest overall ROI when brands are spending about half and half on those two different forms of advertising.
Ben Walker 25:13
I think the tools that we've got for performance marketing, the harvesting, if you like, you know, they're well known, possibly too well known, because as you say, in the in the fairly recent past, we've we've we've overused them, sacrificing the future demand side as we went. Um, what tools can we use as marketers to boost that farming side? You know, the the the planting, the future demand side. Yeah.
James Hurman 25:39
So there's a really simple recipe for converting current demand and creating future demand, and they're basically the inverse of one another. And so when we're converting the current demand in the market, we're actually better to use pretty rational, pretty informative approaches. So you know, if we look at the data, it tells us that creative award-winning advertising is less likely to drive immediate sales than advertising that's not particularly creative, and advertising that's rational is more likely to drive immediate sales than advertising that's emotional. And advertising that's really well targeted at people that are in the market, be that using retail media or algorithms or contextual media placements or those sorts of things much better than using but big broad advertising that reaches lots of people, and the reason for that is if you're in the market for something, you're actually very likely to pick up the information and read it. If I show you a side by side of the Samsung Galaxy and the Apple iPhone, if you're in the market for a mobile phone, you're pretty likely to stop and read all that information about the pros and cons and features and benefits and how much it costs and where can I get it and all that kind of stuff. If you're not in the market for a mobile phone, unless
you're weirdly interested in mobile phones, there's chance that you're going to stop and read that information. You you won't even notice that information. Now that's not to say that you can't be engaged by a mobile phone brand. It just needs to happen on completely different terms. So if you're not in the market, in order to build future demand, what brands need is creativity, emotion, and very broad targeting. And the reason for that is creativity essentially earns the interest. It earns the attention of people who aren't yet in market and therefore don't care about your category. You know you're not in the market for a commercial truck, but you definitely watch Jean Claude Van Damme do the splits over two river voyaging Volvo's, where then you're playing in the background, right? The reason that you watch that, even though it's of no rational value to you whatsoever to do that, is that it was creative. So creativity earns the attention of people that aren't in the market. Emotion, we remember feelings for far longer than we remember facts, and this has been proven out by by Robert Heath, who did a bunch of work at Bath University studying how our memory, where we store memories. Our facts are stored in one part of our brain. Our feelings are stored in another part. And facts, memory for facts decays very fast, so we forget those facts very quickly. Memory for feelings lasts a really long time, and that's why you know the Maya Angelou quote. I've learned that people will forget what you said, they'll forget what you did, but they'll never forget the way you made them feel. That's actually based in in in neuroscience. We remember feelings for far longer than facts. So, if we want someone to remember our brand when they come into the market in eight months' time, if we give them a bunch of facts, they'll they will definitely have forgotten those facts. If we make them feel something, they'll carry that feeling into market, and it will, you know, it will predispose them towards viewing us positively. And so, creativity and emotion really critical, and broad targeting using television and outdoor and all of the you know these now are sort of seen as very old school media, but actually they're the best way of reaching those broad audiences of people who will come into the market later. That sort of 7580, 90% of the category that's not in the market right now. Reaching them and reaching them very publicly and in a way that actually translates into them recalling the brand when they come into market. And so, so you've got these two recipes. They're basically the inverse of each other, and they're really easy ones to follow. And we just need to spend half of our time following one of them, and the other half of the time following the other, and that's how you that's how you do
Ben Walker 29:24
it. Yeah, broad markets are a bit of an understatement, isn't it? You've just alluded to it there. You've got this in the book. You highlight what you call the 95-five rule, different to the 60-40 rule, different to the 50-50 rule, where you've got it. And this rule is that Actually, 95%, more than nine in 10 buyers are not in today's market. They're not your current. They're not your current customer. So you're you're trying to, as a marketer, you're trying to pitch for investment in the future demand. That the 95. If you like, of people who are not current customers who are not currently in the market, how do you make that case?
James Hurman 30:07
Yeah, I mean 95 five is actually actually it was John Dawes at Ehrenberg Institute who proposed that, and he was talking about business to business B 2b advertising, and that 95% of B 2b buyers were not on not in market in any given quarter, and and that that split it it varies entirely dependent on category and purchase cycle and and what you consider in the market is it this week or is it the next two weeks or the next month or the next quarter or whatever you might be, but the the the the principle remains very true, and so I've measured this across all sorts of categories now, and and however it varies, there's always a much larger group who aren't going to buy from you right now and are definitely going to buy from you in future. So so whether it's 95-five or it's 2575 doesn't really matter. The point is that there's this big group that you need to communicate with much more creative, emotional, broadly targeted advertising if you want to bias them toward your brand, such that they're more likely to choose you when they do come into market.
Ben Walker 31:18
Is it is it is it is it is it something that you can tell a difference between B to B and B to C, or is it broadly you know across the board that always you know you're going to be in the in the high 80s at least of people that are future customers or potential future demand versus current?
James Hurman 31:37
Yeah, I mean it's in any category; it doesn't matter. B to B and B to C. It's interesting because you know we. I think we tend to believe that B to B marketing is a completely different beast to B to C marketing, and of course it is sort of at at a at a kind of tactical level, it is. But at a fundamental level, it's really not. And the B to B Institute, the LinkedIn think tank that sort of studies this. They've now worked with all of us who've been effective, who you know are effectiveness researchers, from the Aaron Bass folk to Liz and Peter and the IPA to myself and you know a bunch of others who do this sort of work, and and they sort of tasked us all with can we repeat our research for B 2b with B 2b data and see if it's any different? And and resoundingly, the evidence is that B 2b advertising and marketing are no different whatsoever in terms of the fundamentals. So in terms of how markets work, just the same. In terms of how humans make decisions, just the same, and and so you know if you're working in B 2b marketing, you can absolutely you know apply all of all of what
I'm saying and all of the other evidence that has largely come from the B 2c world. It really does work in B 2b, and you can get all of that research for free if you just go and search for B 2b Institute. It's all there and it's all very good. And so there's been a bit of a misnomer. I think that B 2b is completely different. Like I say, it is at a tactical level. You know, marketing has more of a sales enablement function in B 2b than it does in B 2c. But when it comes back to the fundamentals, it's it's it's just the same.
Ben Walker 33:19
It's interesting, mind blowing. I would say, for some people, because there is a sort of you're you're going to tell me an incorrect understanding that, you know, people at home maybe are more emotional beasts. You know, they'll buy things on a whim through sort of for so-called irrational or emotional reasons as consumers. When they come to the office. They become these rational actors, who are you know much more scientific in the way they make their purchases. And you're telling me that's not the case.
James Hurman 33:50
No, and they've studied this. There's there's a piece of research that that B 2b Institute actually commissioned, which looked into purchase journeys in B 2b. So similar to the WPP one, right? They looked at lots of purchase B 2b purchase journeys, where the WPP one was B 2c, and and what they found was that it was in their case, 81% of the time the sale went to someone that everyone on the buying team in the business, a brand that they'd all heard of before the process started, right? So simple brand awareness, simple familiarity, largely predicts what gets bought in B 2b. And what they found was that in most B 2b buying decisions, there's no it's not one person who's a sort of technical expert in the field who's making the decision. It's generally a group of people. There's a technical expert. There's a whole bunch of other people from around the business making the decision on sort of which vendor to choose, and and most of those people are making a risk mitigation choice. They're trying to buy the thing that's going to pose the least least risk to the business, and and and doing. That we again default to the familiarity bias. Things which are already familiar to us appear less risky than things which are unfamiliar to us. And so, when we go through that process, you know what that tends to mean is that the brand that was most familiar to the most people in the organisation is the one that gets bought. No one ever got fired for buying IBM, right? What that meant was you were safe to buy IBM because your boss had heard of it, and your boss's boss had heard of it, and their boss had heard of it too. So you weren't going to be accused as the renegade that went out on a limb and chose some sort of you know some brand that no one had ever heard of if anything went wrong. And so this is really how B 2b purchasing works. It's absolutely driven by these biases. That's not to say it's completely irrational. It's not irrational at all. But it's still influenced heavily by the biases that we have in our brains. It's interesting if you're
Ben Walker 35:58
keeping that in mind that you know you're you're building future demand, you're drawing on emotions, you're creating positive biases, so people will come and shop from you in the future. It is harder for marketers to make that case, I think, internally or if they're agencies with their clients, than being able to show direct, immediate sales.
James Hurman 36:23
Yes.
Ben Walker 36:24
So, what are the what indicators or proxy metrics should they use to say, look, we're not this this this campaign or this this this project is not here to create current demand. It is to create future demand, and here are the ways I can prove that we have created that future demand.
James Hurman 36:46
Yeah, so there's basically you've got kind of a stack of of metrics or instruments that you can use. So at the bottom of the stack is basically you know performance dashboards and brand dashboards. So, you know, performance dashboards and performance metrics, you know, cost of acquisition, conversion rate, these sorts of things. They are the perfect metrics to use to know how efficiently you're converting the current demand in your market. They are perfect. Use those. When it comes to creating future demand, they're absolutely useless because none of those people are in market, so they're not going to show up in your sales data at the moment. So you need to rely on brand brand health metrics. You know, are we growing awareness? Are we going growing consideration? Are we growing preference? Are we making people people associate the right things with our brand? Those sorts of things tell us, and so that's the place to start. Make sure you're measuring the creation of future demand by by tracking your brand and being able to report on that. But that's often still, you know, it's it's it's not as good as doing incrementality testing or you know holdout studies or these sorts of things. So I'll give you an example. A friend of mine was CMO at Telstra, Australia's biggest telecommunications company, for about four years recently. And when he started, they were spending 80% on performance or trading, as they call it in the in the telco category, and 20% on brand. He wanted to take that to 5050, but rather than do that all at once, he did a holdout study in Adelaide, which is you know a relatively small city in Australia. He changed the mix in Adelaide to 5050, and then he ran that for about four months. And at the end of the four months, Adelaide's Adelaide sales were up 14% compared to the rest of the business. Okay, and so what he managed to prove in that holdout study was that if you got the balance right, you would achieve better overall outcomes. And then he took that to a CFO and said, "Would you like to be 14% up everywhere, or would you not like to be?" And that's a pretty easy question
to answer, right? If you're running the business, and so so incrementality testing, holdout tests, those sorts of things, really useful to kind of prove what happens when we when we get the balance right. And then the third the third layer up top is is using a good MMM or econometric study. So econometrics can help us isolate out the effects of different forms of marketing and show that, in fact, yes, most of those sales that you're attributing to performance marketing at the moment were actually created in the past by the brand building work that you did, and and just sort of collected by the performance marketing as people came into market. And so you know nowadays MMMs are vastly less expensive and more accessible than they have been in the past. And you know if you're a business of any you know decent size, you ought to be using one to so that the rest of the business is informed about what's really driving what.
Ben Walker 39:57
Interesting. In the book, you've talked you've read. Extensively about this concept of pricing power when brand building.
James Hurman 40:05
Yeah, so pricing power is essentially just the ability for a brand to charge a little bit more, or discount a bit less, or you know put its prices up a little bit and still remain, you know, have customers remain. So you know, price elasticity is basically, you know, to what extent do consumers sort of pull you back to a certain price and only buy you when you're that price or cheaper? And brands with very low price elasticity can put their prices up more easily, or they can charge a bit more than their competitors would charge, and that is what drives profit, basically. Because a small change, you know, if you're a company that I don't know, if you make a 5% overall net profit margin, if you put your prices up 1%, that will have that will give you a 20% increase in profit, right? So that and that's leverage, right? And so, and so, pricing power. Even if it's only a small amount, like we can only put our prices up 1%, that will often make a really big difference to the bottom line because all of that extra 1% goes directly to the bottom line. Whereas when we sell more stuff, when we increase our volume sales, only some of that goes to the bottom line because we've got to pay all of our cost of goods and all of the other costs of servicing that customer. So pricing power is a really important thing. We should be measuring it. We should understand how much, like what our price elasticity is, how much pricing power we've got as a brand, and we should try to grow that pricing power because that's how we drive real kind of sustainable, profitable growth, and pricing power is very much linked back to the thing I explained before: the affect heuristic. When we emotionally positive towards something, we see we tend to minimise its risks and its costs and maximise its benefits in our minds. Unconsciously, again, you know, we don't know that we're doing that, but we are, and that's why brands that communicate emotionally and create good emotional sort of connection can afford to try to charge a little bit more.
Ben Walker 42:12
CFOs are still going to come to you and demand, you know, short-term proof of ROI. They may not. They may understand. They may understand that you're there to build future demand, but they're still going to probably want something now, you know, some pound of flesh now, if you like, to prove that you're, you know, you're you're the marketer that you say you are, and this is going to work long term. How do you bridge that?
James Hurman 42:36
I tend to go back to, you know, the reality that CFOs are already balancing across short and long terms, right? They're already doing this in their day-to-day kind of existence through operating expense and capital expense. So opex is basically what we spend today to kind of keep the lights on, and we expect the returns from our operational expense to be immediate, right? When we pay our staff, we're paying them for work that they have that they have just done, right? When we pay our rent, we're paying to be there for that, you know, for that point in time. We see the benefit immediately. On the capex side of the budget, we're investing in research and development. We're investing in new plant equipment, we're investing in IT infrastructure. We're investing in things that we know will not pay back to the business immediately, but will do so over many years. And we're comfortable with that as CFOs. We're comfortable with the uncertainty of exactly how much that'll pay back, but we know that it will pay back over time, and probably more than we've invested in it, so the ROI will be strong. And we have kind of financial mechanisms for doing that, right? We know our weighted average cost of capital, so we know the hurdle rate that that capital needs to meet for it to be justified to to spend or to invest, and we apply a discount rate to those future future cash flows that are more uncertain. We apply that discount rate in case anything sort of doesn't quite go right. So you've got to meet the the the hurdle at the discount rate, and we can calculate that back. We can do a DCF, or we can calculate net present value of that future income on the balance sheet, and so we've already got as CFOs the mechanisms to do these calculations and to understand the stuff. So I tend to kind of take all of that and go, well, marketing is just the same. Marketing has some opex-like effects in that the performance side of marketing does generate, you know, it generates immediate returns, and we can see those, and they're very easy to measure and very visible. And it creates some capex-like returns, which are returns that show up in the future. Those returns tend to be much bigger than the opex-like returns, but they take a while more to more to come in, and they're not immediately visible and measurable. CFOs are. Really comfortable with this idea, right? So we've just
got to actually frame up marketing, give them the evidence that marketing too works in these two types of ways, and we need to think of it like that, as opposed to expecting all of it to work in an opex-like way.
Ben Walker 45:14
So going back to the use the lexicon, use the language that non-marketers understand, and you'll have much greatest chance of success.
James Hurman 45:23
Yeah, and I think like yeah, it's um, it's we we I've got a study coming out with um with Google, which I shouldn't say too much about, but it's essentially a study that we've we've we've got brewing with the Financial Times, and we've done a massive survey of about 700 CFOs, and we can look at how they we can look at how they approach marketing, the sort of mindset that they're they're in when they invest in marketing, and we can look at the revenue and profit performance of their companies, and we can see a very tight correlation between the the CFOs that approach brand and marketing as more of a capital asset than a cost centre, those capital asset mindset CFOs are the ones that are driving the best revenue and profit outcomes for their companies, and so and so yes, sort of being able to actually you know show an interest in those non-marketing functions, learn their language a little bit, understand how they think about things, and then sort of relate what we do to them in terms that they understand is a really useful thing to be able to do. In saying that, it should also come the come in the opposite direction. You know, a CFO is is actually has a fiduciary duty to understand how marketing works and not mess it up, right? So, so it does need to be a partnership. It's not all on the marketer, but it helps to be literate in other areas of business.
Ben Walker 46:52
You're absolutely right. It is a two-way process, and our friends in the finance department also need to learn a little bit about how marketing works, as you say, as well as as learning their language. Adolf said we're here mainly to give guidance to people in marketing, you know, from junior levels all the way up to CMOs. But let's talk about the top before we go. We do have lots of CMOs listen to this show. If they could make just one operational change, you know, next week to start capturing future demand better, what would it be? What should it be?
James Hurman 47:33
I'd say probably three things. One, be aware that all of the evidence, all of it, says spend about half and half on performance and brand. Yeah, like be aware of that. There's not one research study anywhere that shows that spending all of your money on performance or most of it on performance is a good way to go. Nor is there a study anywhere that shows spending all of your money or most of your money on brand is the right way to go. It's about all of the evidence is that learn it and be fluent in it. Number two is embrace on the on the creation of future demand side, on the brand side, embrace creativity and emotion. Right? If you're not already doing that, if you're if you're a bit sort of suspicious of it, or you know you're you don't you lack sort of creative confidence or the ability to sort of judge emotional work, you know, get over that and and you know and make yourself better at creating very creative, very emotional advertising. It is in your interest you to do so, and you have a duty to be good at that side of things. And then the third thing is education. You need to have a plan to educate the business around you on these principles that have now been proven out in two decades of effectiveness and marketing science research, which you know we now have a very high fidelity understanding of how marketing and advertising work to create commercial outcomes. It's all available. It's all in my book. It's you know lots of it's in other people's books and all the rest of it, and you ought to know all of it. It's really important that you do because it's really settled science at this point. You know, there's no argument, and so and it's not people's opinions. It's not my opinions on how things work. It's what the data says, and tonnes and tonnes now of data.
Ben Walker 49:19
It's the proven reality, so act upon it. And if you do want to act upon it, then one of the great places to start or act upon it better is James's book, Future Demand. And you can also find a lot of his work on Future demand.com. Thanks, James, for an amazing show. I hope you'll come back sometime. I wish you luck with the book. I'm sure you'll have it. If you're listening at home, remind you to subscribe to the show and fill out the listener survey. We always do read the listener survey, so we're responding to them every day, and we look and find what you want to come on the show, and we do read them and we do respond to it. So that's your. Chance to shape the future show, and of course, make sure you tune in for the next episode. But before then, I just want to thank James for his time and his amazing insights today, and hope change the way we look at marketing for the better. James, thank you very much indeed.
James Hurman 50:14
Thanks for having me, Ben. It's been great.
Ben Walker 50:17
And here on the CIM Marketing Podcast, we are back every fortnight with a new edition. So keep tuning in every two weeks to find a new episode of the podcast with great guests from across the industry. Finally, thanks for listening. I hope you enjoyed the episode, and we'll see you in a couple of weeks for the next episode of the CIM Marketing Podcast.