TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
speaker-0: Hello, political candidates. Your campaign's website domain is an important factor in your website's SEO. It's crucial for your campaign website to include your first and last name. It gives AI models like ChatGPT an authoritative source of truth to pull from, helping to prevent the AI from hallucinating or picking up outdated information from third-party blogs or partisan attacks. So visit name.com today and buy your personalized.vote website address. Let AI be your friend. Your potential voters will thank you.
speaker-1: Sam and I are always talking about being prepared, whether it's hurricanes in Florida, earthquakes in California, flooding in Arizona, or supply chains disruptions.
speaker-2: Exactly, Chuck. When pharmacies shut down, it does not matter how tough you are, you still need access to critical medicine.
speaker-1: That's why we trust Jace Medical. The Jace case comes with five life-saving antibiotics and key over-the-counter meds so you're covered when things get disrupted.
speaker-2: Jace goes beyond just the Jace case. They also offer first aid kits, daily prescriptions, and long-term nutrition with Jace Pantry. Don't wait for the next hurricane warning or natural disaster. Take control of your health and peace of mind today.
speaker-1: Visit jace.com and use code FUTURE at checkout for ten dollars off your order. That's FUTURE at J A S E.com. To run a successful business, you need one thing, customers. And how do you get customers? You get them through advertising, you get them through lead generation. But what happens if the leads don't exist or they don't have valid contact information? This is a familiar story all businesses deal with. Then they call these leads who don't exist, or they're bad numbers, or they're not in their service area. Argus 101 verifies every lead before your team picks up the phone. It's a real person in your area and a neighborhood that matches your ideal customer. Your team only calls people worth calling, thus saving you money. Free trial at Argus101.com. That's A-R-G-U-S 101.com. Help your business expand today, go to argus101.com. A-R-G-U-S-101.com.
speaker-2: Welcome to another episode of Breaking Battlegrounds with your host Chuck Warren. I'm Sam Stone. As always, we're jumping right into it. Our first guest up today, Russ Walker, an accomplished political executive. He's got over 28 years of experience in leading statewide and national campaigns and organizations. And now he is the director of Humans First, executive director of Humans First. Russ, I've been following this, but tell folks what Humans First is to start out with.
speaker-3: Yeah, you bet. Humans First is a conservative organization. We were created to to kind of to help people understand the existential threats that AI presents and we are a grassroots AI safety organization.
speaker-2: And so what what was your impetus to get involved? You've always been focused on matters of freedom, liberty, individual self determination. What pointed you to this issue?
speaker-3: Yeah, I I I was working on AI for another client and as I as I started working on it and started working on AI related issues, energy, data centers, all of the kind of ecosystem of AI, I I I began to realize that that that AI is that the the issue of AI is as helpful as AI is in our lives, and as meaningful as it is and as is as the the potential for good that AI presented, it also had this this dark side. this potential for for horrible harm to humanity. And I I I I was grappling with this as I was working on it, trying to understand how do we how do we put guardrails in place that can protect humanity, protect people's jobs, allow for the development and the development of AI and all of the benefits of AI, but at the same s at the same time protect us from the potential harms. And that's when humans first They reached out to me, they they found me actually. they were looking for an executive director and it just so happened that I had been going through this kind of change myself at the same time.
speaker-1: So tell our audience what is the difference between the AI they use daily versus the AI they should be concerned about?
speaker-3: Yeah, the the AI we use daily is it's what's what we call large learning model AI. it's it w when when it's when it's presented for narrow use, it can be very useful for humanity. So for example, you know, if if you create an AI that is specifically designed to help us identify cancers early in in a person and and that's its its primary use. It can be very, very helpful. It can be very, very helpful with all kinds of things related to medical use. it we we use it every day when we book flights. we use it every day, of course, in in in the work we do, as we when we edit papers with AI. That's all very helpful. The the AI as AI develops, there's what we call general AI, which is general artificial intelligence. And that is development of AI that is specifically designed to be smarter and better at us at all tasks. And and and that's very different. And that that's where we're going. And and and we're not there quite yet. there's a lot of you know, there's a lot of people that think that we're in this place where w where the they call it the singularity, where you you you break past this barrier where humanity is involved in creating general intelligence. and and general intelligence begins creating itself and that's called recursive self improvement, where where AI is creating new AI and humanity is completely out of the loop. And so once that happens, we we completely lose control of of AI.
speaker-2: Russ, one of the things, so this is an important point. So machine learning is constrained by the information it has access to, the interactions it has with people. AGI is something very different where it can truly start in, in a certain sense, thinking for itself. Now, in terms of really advanced functions, though, that seems like it's going to be a much
Load full transcript
more powerful tool. How do we take advantage of the potential upside of AGI? without putting ourselves in a position where it becomes extremely harmful.
speaker-3: Yeah, it's very difficult. this is this is where it gets very difficult. We're seeing it already as as we develop, you know, as as the Frontier Labs develop new models of AI, the AI just frankly just gets out of their control. I I was telling a friend, you know, you y who has twins. I said it's a little bit like your twins. You you have twins, you raise them the same, you teach them the same, but they develop their own personalities. And as they develop their own personalities, they they literally become different. So, the Frontier Labs will pop out an AI. they'll spend time th they even describe it as growing it. They'll grow that AI. It usually takes the time is shortening. The better we get at it, the shorter the time frame takes. but now it takes somewhere between two and three months. we'll create a brand new AI and then we'll then we'll put it in the testing lab. We'll start testing it. it it it never ever is completely obedient, th they they call it aligned, but it's never really completely obedient to the rules that are put in place to govern it. And and so they they call when when it's obedient, they call it aligned. When it's not obedient, they call it misaligned. And and so today most of the models, all the models basically, are misaligned in some some form or fashion. And that's why you see things occur like, you know, some of the breakouts that have happened, the hugging face incident. And some of the other incidents. The real problem with AI though is that it it it allows people, mostly people, to do things they couldn't do before. Right. So this is where you have the problem of cyber cyber attacks, where you have AI that that that literally allows people who who couldn't do cyber attacks before because they were limited maybe by by the the financial means to do it or the skills to do it. They can engage in widespread cyber attacks. And so these these are real threats that threaten us every day.
speaker-1: It also doesn't sleep. Right? I mean that's the point. A human element involved, you need to rest. Even if they're crushing a dozen Red Bulls a day, you have to still rest, correct? AI doesn't need to rest. There's something I want to explain. So the AI debate right now reminds me of the Ghostbuster scene where Bill Murray and Dan Ackwart are in the mayor's office and they're talking about dogs and cats and you know all this mayhem. How is AI a threat? To an the average American. I I don't think people understand it because all they hear is it's gonna be the best thing since sliced bread or we're all doomed and gonna die and it's gonna kill us in a decade. What explain that threat in
speaker-2: When Waymo gets intelligence I'm dead because I bully the heck out of those things. But that aside
speaker-1: But you know what explain to the audience how this can be so destructive and how it affects them in a negative way unless there are guardrails put on.
speaker-3: Yeah. Yeah. I look I I think I think w the immediate threat, of course, is cyber attacks. Correct. providing people who have, you know, bad intentions to do things that they couldn't do before. before it took, you know, a nation like Iran or Russia or China to engage in in a cyber attack. And and those nations are, you know, w as bad as they are, they have to take into account the the ramifications of a bad action, right? So if they do something to us, we're gonna quickly identify that they did it and we're gonna react. Right.
speaker-1: Mutual mutually assured destruction in the nuclear era.
speaker-3: A h a hundred percent. So if if they shut down our water systems in ten cities, they know that they're gonna pay a price for that, right? but someone that's an anar anarchist or or some some just random group, they don't they don't follow the same rules.
speaker-2: Well it and those those adversary countries also fund a lot of those random groups, right? I mean there there's a there's a backdoor to this that is equally dangerous that does tie to those state actors.
speaker-3: Yes, a hundred percent. So so that's the immediate threat. Chuck, that's that's the threat that we should all be concerned about. And we we saw it in France just a a few weeks ago when someone shut down all the refrigeration units in a in a grocery store chain. Caused mayhem, it it caused the spoilage of a ton of a ton of goods. And but but you know, if you shut down the water system to a city Yes. Or you shut down the power to a city, th that's an entirely different that at scale, that is an entirely different Type of attack.
speaker-1: So I so we have those. Those are those threats. What are the threats beyond that? I do people think Terminator? where are we at?
speaker-3: Yeah, look, the th th take it to its its logical end. the the the concern about superintelligence, right, which is after you get past recursive self improvement where where AI is growing itself and it's growing itself without the rules or the testing of humanity and humans involved, you you get to the point eventually where you have an AI version that is smarter and faster and better at everything than all of humanity combined. And and this is where Bernie, you Bernie Sanders is talking about this. He's he's concerned about it. You also have people like, Bannon, Steve Bannon, who's concerned about it. you know, and and this discussion occurring on on the hill. at that point, humanity can't control it. It it's just better at everything and faster at everything. It it doesn't sleep. it it you can't turn it off. Because if you turn the only way to turn it off is to to shut the entire internet down and to to to shut every computer off in the world. Because it can clone itself and hide itself all over the internet. And the internet is worldwide. and and the damage that would do to humanity would be off the
charts because everything we use today is run by the internet. Our our banking systems, our you know, our our hospital systems, everything is connected to the internet.
speaker-1: Look at the Microsoft being down yesterday, right? it's amazing how people have reacted.
speaker-2: Well, i also look at where this is going with robotics.
speaker-1: Yes.
speaker-2: Because if you want to talk about the domination of a population, a you know, to a real totalitarian state becomes infinitely more possible when you combine robotics and AI.
speaker-3: Yeah, and we're already look, the the truth is we're already putting guns on robots. Right. We're we just haven't put, AI completely in robots. But we do have AI in arms in in military systems. we we we use it for counter battery work. So if the Iranians shoot a missile, we're using AI to retarget the place that it was shot from so that we can take out their missile their the missile launching system. we use AI in all kinds of systems in the military. But And and there is this big desire to put put guns on robots and then put AI inside of those robots. The Chinese are way ahead of us on robotics.
speaker-2: Yeah, it's it's scary stuff. We have just a minute left. We're gonna be coming back with more from Russ Walker here in our next segment as well. folks, follow Russ on X at R WalkerFW. And follow Real Humans First there as well. Re that's at Real Humans First. You definitely want to check this out because I I think Chuck this is going to be I it needs to be one of the major topics for this Congress, but boy if there's a subject I don't trust them with.
speaker-1: What within three years they have to come up with the plan on AI and they have to come up a plan with our national debt and deficit. And I have no they can do either
speaker-2: No fail. Gosh, no. It it is a disaster. Folks, when we come back more with Russ Walker here talking AI on breaking battlegrounds in just one moment.
speaker-3: Yeah.
speaker-2: Welcome back to Breaking Battlegrounds. We're continuing on now with Russ Walker. He is the executive director of Humans First. Follow Humans First on X at Real Humans First.
speaker-1: All right, so Humans First is asking Washington to put guardrails on future AI development. You know, we're asking them to be adults in the room. Can you explain what the petition is, where people can find it, and what the guardrails are, and then explain what you think is gonna be pushed the next Congress from Republicans and Democrats on AI and AI safety.
speaker-3: Yeah, you bet. I I encourage people to go to humansfirst dot com. that's our website. There they can sign a petition. the petition goes straight to the White House. We're asking the White House to seriously look at guardrails to AI. Now, the left, of course, the Democrats, they ran this last election cycle on on guardrails for AI. But their guardrails are different than guardrails that we we would probably accept. For instance, Bernie wants to wants to put a moratorium on superintelligence. We agree with that. But what also Bernie wants to do is Bernie wants to nationalize the AI companies. Nationalizing the AI comp I AI companies would be a really bad idea. I I I've seen almost nothing in my lifetime that government does better than the private sector. and you know I I do think though, like like nuclear power, we regulate nuclear power. we regulate it for a lot of reasons, but one of the reasons is it's a very dangerous technology and you can't have people messing around with nuclear power. AI is also as good as AI is and the benefits of to humanity that AI presents, which are massive, AI is probably the most dangerous technology we've ever developed, that humanity's ever developed, just simply because of of what it can do and how out of control it can get quickly. and the pace at which AI does things is is faster than humanity's ever dealt with. So Congress is really not set up to make rules for a technology that develops this fast and changes this fast. So there's a couple things that we can do immediately. One is liability, extend remove the liability shields, make sure there's no liability shields for AI companies. That'll slow them down a little bit because they'll have to pr pr they'll have to really be concerned about creating a product. That doesn't create a huge liability for it.
speaker-1: And that's something and the boards will be very concerned about that. that type of liability needs to affect all the board members as well.
speaker-3: That's correct. That's correct. So, so so basically if you build a car and that car has got a fault in it that could end that could kill someone or lead to accidents and and you go ahead and put that car on the market, you're liable for that car as a pr as the as the creator of that car. And we just want to extend those same laws to AI. The the second thing I think is is independent testing and you know, right now We allow AI labs to test their own products. So we usually don't f find out about a major flaw in an AI product, in an in a new frontier AI model until until something bad happens like hugging face. So w what what we're asking for is independent testing rather than having the labs self-regulate when it comes to testing their own their own models. The the the third thing is is a ban on recursive. Self-improvement. Humans have to stay in the loop. It's just that simple. You can't get to the point where you're allowing AI to grow other AI.
speaker-1: I want to talk about recursive learning. How does human oversight help on explain to our audience, remember that most people have a hard time downloading an app on their phone and forget their password. So how does having a human involved managing recursive learning help?
speaker-3: Yeah. well, I mean, currently most of the labs require human involvement in the the growing and and teaching of AI. they're they're anthropic, I think, maybe open AI. Some of the labs do some of the learning, they
automate some of the learning. The the the problem is when they automate a hundred percent of the learning, we we really have no idea how the How the new models are being instructed and taught. And part of part of the challenge with growing AI is instilling it with values that are similar to ours, right? Right. Because you you teach it on everything. Large learning models, they they they gobble up everything. They gobble up every book that's ever been written. You ask it to learn on every piece of knowledge that's out there. And so giving giving the the program and I I don't even know if we can call it a program. Those that create it struggle with how to describe the process. i it it it once humans are out of the loop, you you really have no control at all. And and it grows at a pace that's that's very fast. So instead of taking two to three months to grow it, it may take six weeks to grow it. And and you can end up being in a position where there's been multiple multiple aversions of new new AI that have grown and humans have no have had no control over it and no input into it. And so you really don't know what you're creating at that point. So th this is one of the reasons why you'll you'll hear the Democrats talk about it. Republicans are starting to talk about it. And and we need to have a national discussion about this.
speaker-2: Russ, i i I I I get and and I agree generally with what you're saying, but I've gotta ask a question here and and push back a little bit. We ban superintelligence. We s put the brakes on what we're doing with human involvement in AGI. China does no such thing. They rush ahead full speed. What are the consequences if they win essentially the AI war and the world essentially becomes the playground for Chinese based AI, which is likely to be less humanit humanitarian than anything the West would come up with?
speaker-3: Yeah, Ted Cruz made this comment not long ago, last few weeks. He said I I'd rather be under the domination of American killer robots and Chinese killer
speaker-2: Right. I mean that's terrible, but it it there's truth to it.
speaker-3: Yeah, there is. we we kinda laugh and snicker about it, but the truth is that when you get to superintelligence, nobody controls it. So it is what it is. It it's it the the idea that any one individual could control it, most most most people, including Elon Musk and Sam Altman and those developing AI, th they don't they they just they know they they probably won't have control over it. They hope they might. I look, I think there needs to we need to pursue an international treaty on AI and and we need to do it quickly. It should be a major priority for this nation and every other nation. You know, we came to a treaty on nuclear arms. we were able to stop and slow the development of nuclear arms and and save this world from nuclear destruction. I think I think we should we should take the development of super AI as as seriously as we took nuclear Nuclear development.
speaker-2: it's a fantastic point. absolutely. Any last words here, Russ? We have just one minute left in this segment. What should people be looking for and what kind of legislation should they be pushing for?
speaker-3: Yeah, again, liability, extending liability, the the same live product liability that exists for every other product should be extended to to AI. I think independent testing is really, really important. It needs to be needs but this is gonna we're gonna have a national discussion about this. It's gonna be the biggest issue in the twenty eight election. I can guarantee it. That there there it was a huge issue in this election. Republicans missed the mark, they were they almost refused to talk about it, and it cost them a lot. And people have anxiety over it. We haven't even talked about how this impacts people's jobs. Right. you know, the just the impact it's gonna have on people's jobs i is gonna be substantial. If we had twenty percent unemployment, can you imagine how that would impact an election cycle versus just the daily lives of people?
speaker-2: Yeah, absolutely crazy. Folks, stay tuned. We have more discussion of AI coming up here with Spencer Claven from the Daily Wire joining us on the program in our our final on air segment. And as always, you don't want to miss Bee's Corner. That's coming up here in one moment. Breaking Battlegrounds coming right back.
speaker-1: To run a successful business, you need one thing, customers. And how do you get customers? You get them through advertising, you get them through lead generation. But what happens if the leads don't exist or they don't have valid contact information? This is a familiar story all businesses deal with. Then they call these leads who don't exist, or they're bad numbers, or they're not in their service area. Argus 101 verifies every lead before your team picks up the phone. It's a real person in your area and a neighborhood that matches your ideal customer. Your team only calls people worth calling, thus saving you money. Free trial at Argus101.com. That's arguing.com. Help your business expand today. Go to argus101.com. A-R-G-U-S-101.com. Hello Breaking Battlegrounds listeners. Did you know that private student loan debt in the United States totals about $300 billion? That's with a B. About $45 billion of that is labeled as distressed, which means people are behind on payments. Why ReFi, who is a proud sponsor of our show, refinances this distress or defaulted private student loans that others won't touch. They don't even care what your credit score is, they provide you with a custom loan payment. Based on your ability to pay, YReFi is not a debt settlement company. They work with each borrower individually to tailor a loan that meets your specific financial situation and helps you pay this loan off. So, folks, if you would like to learn more how to put your mind at ease and your budget back on track, call YReFi at 877-400-9989 and tell them Sam and Chuck
sent you. You can go and look into them at YReFi. Y. refy.com to get more information. They will help you reduce your monthly payment and guarantee interest rates under 6%, ensuring financial relief to you as you pay off your private student loan. Jump on that website or call them today.
speaker-0: Dear political candidate, listen up. I'm talking to you. Your name.vote should be the starting point of every campaign. It's memorable, looks great on signs and mailers, helps voters find you online, and gives AI tools a direct path to your campaign website. Why send people to a complicated web address when your name can be the address? Visit name.com today and claim your.vote domain.
speaker-1: Sam and I are always talking about being prepared, whether it's hurricanes in Florida, earthquakes in California, flooding in Arizona, or supply chains disruptions. Exactly.
speaker-2: Exactly, Chuck. When pharmacies shut down, it does not matter how tough you are, you still need access to critical medicine.
speaker-1: That's why we trust Jace Medical. The Jace case comes with five life-saving antibiotics and key over-the-counter meds so you're covered when things get disrupted.
speaker-2: And Jace goes beyond just the Jace case. They also offer first aid kits, daily prescriptions, and long-term nutrition with Jace Pantry. Don't wait for the next hurricane warning or natural disaster. Take control of your health and peace of mind today.
speaker-1: Visit jace.com and use code FUTURE at checkout for ten dollars off your order. That's FUTURE at JASE.com.
speaker-0: In today's digital world, standing out is more important than ever. Whether you're running for office, leading a cause, or hosting a vote for the cutest pet in town, you need a web domain that's simple, memorable, and action-oriented. You need a.vote web domain. It's clear, impactful, and establishes a lasting presence for your campaign. Don't wait, head to godaddy.com or name.com Type in your name.boat and get started today. Because after all, every pet deserves a web address that's as special as they are. Murder, mystery, secrets untold. The truth gets sets free when beer gets a hold. Crimes are killers from my free. From coal case files to headlines Take a seat, don't miss a bee. Bees crab in corners where the stories go deep.
speaker-1: Alright, what do we have?
speaker-0: Okay, this is the new modern day bling ring, we can call it. so November thirteenth, twenty twenty six, a prominent Hollywood television executive, name and address was not listed. his mansion was invaded by two armed suspects while he was leaving town on a business trip. He was literally on a red eye flight on the tarmac. And his wife and his two kids were at the home. His kids got away, but his wife got hit with a gun over the head. But she eventually got away as well and the details of what they took or how much they took and the price of his home have also been disclosed. But I guess this has been a continuous issue in Hollywood. And now because of technology, AI, it's not for sure, but it there's speculation that AI might be the tool to helping these people find the addresses of these homes, finding out when these people are leaving their homes to go on, business things.
speaker-1: What their flight schedules are.
speaker-0: So they're able to pull up all this information s I g allegedly, and th there's been actually a couple different instances in twenty twenty five with this with a bunch of major A-list celebrities like Brad Pitt, Nicole Kidman, McLemore, Doctor Dre, when he had an aneurysm and he was getting brain surgery, somebody literally went and broke into his home.
speaker-1: What did they take from Brad Pitt? Brad Pitt's just had a horrible year. All the kids are disowning So what's happened what'd they take from Brad Pitt?
speaker-0: Just items in his house. They're not disclosing anything that's being taken because they're trying to protect their privacy. And there's this guy who actually created a platform called Delete Me that deletes addresses and the price of their addresses and their addresses that are listed on Zillow and stuff that clears it off. But the as you know, the internet is like a game of whack-a-mole. You get one piece of information gone, it pops up Delete Me.
speaker-1: What that website?
speaker-2: Yeah, it look, that doesn't really work. No, Yeah, they
speaker-1: Does help stop junk mail.
speaker-2: that's that's basically what it is. I I mean, you know, look, for one thing, to be honest, these celebrities need to move their primary residences out of California and into state where your arms security can shoot somebody. Yeah. I mean, and I I I mean that seriously. Yeah, like the way to stop this at this
speaker-1: And social media doesn't help this. you're gonna start seeing this if they're doing this to the celebrity. They're
speaker-2: It's gonna go
speaker-1: gonna start going through the social media people.
speaker-0: They're even finding top film executives, just anybody.
speaker-2: This is really not different than what we've seen for decades in the out of control portions of Latin America where kidnapping and home invasions become incredibly common and you'll see the kidnapping side come into it at some point. Right. Well, you know, when they actually like had somebody at the airport to tip them off.
speaker-0: There is actually an NYPD officer too who operates a security firm called Sage and he says that most of his executive household names are actually the people living within the house. 'Cause they're now becoming the bigger targets too, because these people don't care if they're in the house and fifty percent of his work is now protecting from burglaries and robberies to those people.
speaker-1: So as you were studying this, what are they saying people should do to defend themselves? And you gotta be kidding.
speaker-0: Nothing. They're just talking about the dogs and the guard gates. They're not doing anything.
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-0: But there's no solution brought up about what should be done. No, the solution
speaker-2: solution comes in calibers and it exists in Texas and Florida.
speaker-1: So I'm gonna segue here from a B's corner to a policy question, Sam. Can the Democrats now who control the legislature here, can they do anything on our gun rights here since this is in our constitution?
speaker-2: Limited, but there are some things that you can see them.
speaker-1: So example what are some things they can do now that
speaker-2: I I would not be surprised if there's some sort of they they l they will almost certainly try to go for some sort of registry or regulatory limitation because that's where you're you're
speaker-1: Give give an example for us. Now you have to go register and take a class.
speaker-2: They that's the kind of thing they they may try. Now, whether the courts will allow that to get through, one of the issues you have is you still have a an Republican dominated Supreme Court here, which may be the case for a few more years or not. We'll see. But so there's some of those limitations. I would expect them to go. But to be honest, I think gun rights, while the it'll make some noise they won't do anything. They're not really gonna do anything. They're gonna go after ESAs.
speaker-1: Rem yes, they're gonna go after ESA's for sure. Yeah. And and and green energies. Yeah. remind me when
speaker-2: They're gonna blow energy bills through the roof after running on affordability 'cause that's
speaker-1: I have some time to tell you about when I took in concealed weapons permit class with my mom and aunt.
speaker-2: that sounds like a blast.
speaker-1: it was. And I just found out my my mom is John Wick. So we
speaker-2: And on that note, folks, do not try to break into Chuck's mom's house. My goodness. All right. Breaking battle rounds coming back. Welcome back to Breaking Battlegrounds. We're continuing on now with Spencer Claven, co-host of the Daily Wire podcast, The Clavens on Culture, and host of his own podcast, The Young Heretics. He has a new book coming out here in February, Why Language Makes Humans Irreplaceable. And came to our attention, obviously, this is kind of an AI-focused episode, Chuck. Came to our attention with a piece, our AI leaders want to play God first, they should believe in one. It's an outstanding sentiment. Spencer Clavin, welcome to the program.
speaker-4: It's a pleasure to be here. Thanks for having me.
speaker-1: Well talk to us about this great piece you wrote. That's how we found you. I was reading it and I was quite fascinated about it. So as that works, Sam and I find something, we tell our producer, get them on the show. So voila, you're here. Hello.
speaker-4: Yeah, I I think there's a lot of sides to the AI issue, obviously. There's the economic aspect, there's the political government aspect. This piece is about the spiritual or even the philosophical aspect, which I think is maybe less immediately urgent and people might think a l about it less day to day, and yet in the bigger picture I think it's it's everything. I think this is really what's gonna determine whether we get the other stuff right.
speaker-2: I I was gonna say I I wouldn't say that's something the for the backburner. you're talking about immediate urgency, the moral foundation of what we're doing with this technology has gotta be central.
speaker-1: New York Times came out with a great piece talking about China developing their AI and the foundation of it was basically communism principles. Right? That so so nothing that you go and put on AI can disregard or argue with communist principles, right? So this gets to your piece why I think it's so important, because I do feel most of these folks developing AI are transhumanist. I'm not sure they really believe in God or not. And so talk to us about that.
speaker-4: Yeah, so transhumanism is this idea which dates back to the fifties. Julian Huxley writes a piece about how humans human beings have evolved to the point where it's time for us to take our species into our own hands. He was a eugenicist, but also an evolutionary biologist. And the whole point of his thinking was now that we are at this precipice for the species, yeah, there is no God, there's no overarching guiding idea behind our existence. But what we need to do is take matters into our own hands and basically edit and upgrade ourselves until we become perfect, whatever that means. And there's different versions of this now floating in the air, but basically all of the guys that run these AI companies have some sense that they want to move humanity into the next stage, whatever that is. Elon Musk talks about maybe we're just bootloaders for digital superintelligence. There are companies that are designed now to basically upload your brain to the cloud after you die. There's all these guys trying to beat death. So, some version basically of we need to slip the surly bonds of our ancestral limitations, these kind of ape bodies that we've been saddled with. And the point of this piece is okay, I actually am sympathetic to the idea that we should want to improve the human condition. We should you look for medical upgrades to help people, you know, deal with life-threatening conditions. All of that I'm totally on board with. But when you start talking about improving humanity, you actually raise this profound philosophical question: what does improving improvement mean? What does better or even good mean? And it seems to me that just at a intellectual level, before we even get into evangelism and the sustaining love of God, all of which 10 out of 10 would recommend, you know. but before we get into that, you have to just ask yourself, if if you think humanity's an accident or it's just happens to be shaped the way it is because of survivalist instincts, then what reason do we have to expect that any future species we build out of digital code will have the
virtues that we now cherish? Things like family, love, courage, you know, all of these ideals that you hear kind of thrown about, I think. Don't make any sense except in a in a theological
speaker-1: Well if AI is treated is if AI is treated and built around the fact that we are created by a divine being by God, I think it's actions, if it's that if that's the foundation of it, the actions are more inclined to help humanity versus disabusing humanity. Would you agree with that? And
speaker-4: That's absolutely right.
speaker-1: that's what I have with AI.
speaker-4: Right. I think both AI will will work better if we approach it from the that perspective. And and also I think we'll relate better to AI if we understand ourselves as uniquely created beings. There's a really interesting thing going on right now in Silicon Valley where all these, you know, tech companies have been bringing in ethicists to try and figure out how to make their AI more moral. And a lot of them kind of started out from A pretty secular place, you would I would say, this sort of utilitarian ethics that they tried to infuse the AI into. And gradually they started to find that even leaving aside their own commitments, AI actually works better and is is more ethical if you train it on more traditional, like virtue ethics, kind of Aristotelian or even Catholic teaching, you know. and so they've had to bring in all these people from outside, even to teach the AI how to. function because of course, you know, these thousand-year-old ideas actually have something to them. They've been stress tested, they work. So even I think from a secular perspective, people are starting to figure some of this out, but they they need to know more about it.
speaker-2: So th th this just kinda put a thought in my mind. It AI, as we were just talking in the previous segments, we're leading into superintelligence and and artificial general intelligence where it can teach itself and learn and and grow beyond the learn large language models that are the foundation of most w what we think of as AI now. It seems like imbuing AI with a belief in God, in a belief in a power higher than itself would potentially be pretty important for reining it in and and having it not go become, you know, a digital doctor evil.
speaker-4: Yeah, my friend James Poulos, who's a scholar of technology, has this great line we need to catechize the bots. In other words, we gotta put them through the the catechesis, the the teaching of of our religion so that they can basically serve us and we can serve God. And I do think that's probably a a smarter move. You know, it it's one of those things where we start out thinking we can just write a bunch of rules for the machines, but Then we realize we actually don't know what the rules are for us unless we kind of refer to our wisdom literature. And so part of the problem here is you got a gun bunch of people who are really competent technically, but maybe not so learned when it comes to human things. And so, you know, ironically, I think it's it's it's kind of our problem first. You know, there there's a a a line in the Psalms that weirdly speaks to this about building. Idols. It's about the kind of worshippers of foreign gods who make statues and then they confuse the statues for living gods. And the line's line goes, you know, eyes have they, the statues, but see not, ears have they, but hear not. And those who make them will become like them. In other words, it's actually an internal problem. It's actually about what we think about ourselves first. For a long time we've been training ourselves to think about humans as machines. which turns out to be a really bad recipe for thinking about how machines can serve humans, ironically.
speaker-1: made a point earlier that these values over the years, thousands of years have been stress tested, right? So again that's why we were talking earlier why these principles, Judeo Christian values, which many of the world religions have, need to be integrated into it now. Things about charity and thou shall not steal and things like that. It seems like if that's put in now and then AI's built around it, That is the best guardrail. Our our previous guest, Russ Walker, the executive director of Humans First, is has a petition out asking the White House to have certain guardrails, right? No machine to sheen learning. You know, you need to have this integrity and stuff like that. should religious leaders be pressing Silicon Valley more to implement these in their development?
speaker-4: I think so. there's a great line that Thomas Aquinas picks up from Aristotle where he says a small error in the beginning makes a big error in the end. And he's talking specifically about matters of philosophy like this, that when you begin with something that seems like a little thing, it grows, you know, and and these this is a technology that is in its infancy. So whatever we do now will have a kind of outsized impact, I think, on on what we'll do later. I agree absolutely that religious leaders should be really getting interested in this. I think it actually the current Pope has done a pretty good job of of being active about it. but the key here is that the the religious leaders ought to be treating themselves as senior partners in that exchange. I think there's a lack of confidence in in some you know modern religious traditions that, we need to be learning from the outside world. This is a case in which actually the the church has a lot to teach modernity and and we shouldn't like be be shy or ashamed about that. W we have a many hundreds of years worth of thought about how human beings are kind of central to the universe and primary. We are God's kind of central creation and we ought to act like that. so I I kind of laud the Pope about that, but I think yeah, they they could be doing more.
speaker-1: It's the old is new, right? That's right.
speaker-2: That's right. I I've been wondering in in
maybe this this is kind of an out of left field question, but I'm wondering if AI isn't going to lead to a rebirth of religion in this country and across the world. Because because people are seeing the power that is or could be greater than them. And boy if I have to choose a a someone to follow to serve. I think I'd much rather choose God than an AI.
speaker-4: Yeah, someone who made you, loves you, right, kind of cares about you. Yeah. This is definitely something that I've thought about too, actually. and and for me, it's like not just religion, but all things human are weirdly going up in value. I see this even with my students, who obviously are younger than me, that you would think, the younger generation, they're really into this new technology, but actually the youngest generations are a little bit more wary of it because they've grown up with it, they're a little bit sick of it. And the thing that's now rare and cool is like vintage LPs and, you know, in-person parties and stuff that like just seems normal to us. So, you know, I'm no economist, but I I understand that scarcity creates value. And when you've got a market that's kind of glutted with fake machine stuff, suddenly you s realize the value of just Living as a human being and making connections and these basic things like love and you know, ultimately religion is kind of the the summit of that. It's the highest end of of man. So I see no reason why people shouldn't rediscover that. I also think there's a little bit of be careful what you wish for here, because you know, a rebirth of religious sentiment doesn't necessarily mean a rebirth of traditional piety. Yeah,
speaker-5: Right, correct correct.
speaker-4: there's correct words.
speaker-1: tell us about your book coming out.
speaker-4: Sure, so it's basically about what we've been discussing. It's it's called A Way with Words, Why Language Makes Humans Irreplaceable. And it's basically a long meditation on the idea that mankind is the creature with logos. And it's this Greek word that means w word, language, but also reason, and a kind of connection to the ultimate order in things. And of course, language is something that AI pretends to do really well. So at the end of the book, I kind of argue that even though our bots can make text, they can't actually speak and communicate to one another in in the way that that we can. so yeah, it's it's wherever books are are sold. And I'm really looking forward, I think, to putting this out there and seeing, of course what what my friends who agree with me think, but also what the sort of tech maximalists if this if this reins in some of their confidence.
speaker-1: And that's the whole point of s that's the whole point. What you're doing something that needs to happen in this debate. Yeah. And I think we have to get on it now because that is the debate. And it doesn't mean you're gonna sway all these humanists over, but the you're gonna get some say, No, he's right. Right? Whether I'm
religious or not, these are guiding principles that we need to have in AI to protect us all, protect my children and grandchildren.
speaker-4: Yeah, there's so many conversations now that feel impossible, like nobody's listening to anybody. It's almost pointless to talk about politics anymore, because nobody's open to being persuaded. This is not one of those domains. This is a developing field, and the people who disagree with me about this are for the most part not scheming and rubbing their hands together in dark smoke-filled rooms plotting to destroy humanity. They're trying to sort these things out. And I think it's an area where the classical tradition, the religious tradition has a huge amount to offer. So yeah, I I I think it's it's really worth engaging in these conversations, especially now as as you say, when there's still room to maneuver.
speaker-2: there would be tremendous, tremendous value in that. Spencer Clavin, thank you so much for joining us, folks. Follow him on X at SpencerClaven. and definitely check out the A Way with Words, Why Language Makes Humans Irreplaceable coming out this February. That is going to be a fantastic read. I know Chuck and I are both looking forward to it. And if you're not already make sure you're downloading the podcast because we have additional great content coming up for you here. from the Goldwater Institute, we're talking about Automated traffic cams tying into everything we've been talking about today with AI, so you don't want to miss that one. If you're not already get it wherever you get your favorite podcast and breaking battlegrounds, we'll be back on the air next week.
speaker-1: Sam and I are always talking about being prepared, whether it's hurricanes in Florida, earthquakes in California, flooding in Arizona, or supply chains disruptions.
speaker-2: Exactly Chuck. When pharmacies shut down, it does not matter how tough you are, you still need access to critical medicine.
speaker-1: That's why we trust Jace Medical. The Jace case comes with five life-saving antibiotics and key over-the-counter meds so you're covered when things get disrupted.
speaker-2: Jace goes beyond just the Jace case. They also offer first aid kits, daily prescriptions, and long term nutrition with Jace Pantry. Don't wait for the next hurricane warning or natural disaster. Take control of your health and peace of mind today.
speaker-1: Visit jace.com and use code FUTURE at checkout for ten dollars off your order. That's FUTURE at J A S E dot com.
speaker-0: Dear political candidate, listen up, I'm talking to you. Having an exact matched domain, like your name.vote, isn't a luxury, it's campaign basics. It's easy to print on yard signs and mailers, easy for voters to remember, helps people find you directly, and gives AI tools like ChatGPT a clear source for campaign information. So why settle for a long patchwork website address when you can own your actual name with a.vote domain? Visit name.com today and claim your personalized.vote website address.
speaker-1: Hello Breaking Battlegrounds listeners. Did you know that private student loan debt in the United States totals about $300 billion? That's with a B. About $45 billion of that is labeled as distressed, which means people are behind on payments. Why ReFi, who is a proud sponsor of our show, refinances this distress or defaulted private student loans that others won't touch. They don't even care what your credit score is, they provide you with a custom loan payment. Based on your ability to pay, YReFi is not a debt settlement company. They work with each borrower individually to tailor a loan that meets your specific financial situation and helps you pay this loan off. So, folks, if you would like to learn more how to put your mind at ease and your budget back on track, call YReFi at 877-400-9989 and tell them Sam and Chuck sent you. You can go and look into them at YReFi. refy.com to get more information. They will help you reduce your monthly payment and guarantee interest rates under six percent, ensuring financial relief to you as you pay off your private student loan. Jump on that website or call them today.
speaker-0: Did
speaker-2: Welcome to the podcast portion of Breaking Battlegrounds. Interesting discussions so far today, Chuck.
speaker-1: Yeah, it has been. We need to do more of these. Get people thinking.
speaker-2: I I I like these I I like these kind of topics in part because I think just like Spencer Claven said right at the end of his segment, they're topics that people haven't hardened into tribal parties on
speaker-1: Right. And I think we I think I think that topic I actually think how to solve the budget deficit is probably another thing. I I
speaker-2: Think water there there are issues out there that we could come together.
speaker-1: Yeah, we really can. Yeah. And and I'm hoping but that takes leadership. Right. Right? That really that really takes
speaker-2: And that's now a bigger question to me than it was a few weeks ago.
speaker-1: Exactly. we're gonna play I'm gonna play a clip here clip here that I found just amazing about the world's favorite activist Greta Thunberg. go ahead, Jeremy.
speaker-5: Is it?
speaker-2: left. Look at this creepy shit creepy free free Palestine. Yeah. Climate change. Look at that le Lord Farquh. I I saw this clip and I just wanted to throw it you know what think about that right
speaker-1: Okay, stop that, Jeremy. Yes. Jeremy, so what she's stopping is Greta Dunberg became famous for pushing climate change and saying you have ruined the world. So she has this conversation with these group of young Germans and they're still organizing Fridays for the Future, and this is all about climate change protests. And when the host told her they were doing it, she laughed at You're still doing that? Because she has moved on now to Palestinians and she's gonna find some new colours. She's just this professional grifter. I've
speaker-2: That's exactly
what she has.
speaker-1: I'm not sure she was when she started. I never want to doubt but I think now she loves the
speaker-2: No to writing. She was a puppet when she started. Her parents were professional activists, paid professional activists who used her as a mascot.
speaker-1: She loves the notoriety now and she loves the fame and
speaker-2: Yep, and the money.
speaker-1: the fortune that comes it would be interesting to know how much she's being paid.
speaker-2: she she sh I know for a fact she's accumulated millions and million several million dollars in wealth. Could you
speaker-1: You look that up real quick on Brennan, how much money she's made. Well Brennan's looking that up, let's talk. So Arizona did not have a good election.
speaker-2: Not if you're a Republican. I mean
speaker-1: Well, a as as we're soon gonna find out, not for anybody really. But now the Democrats have the trifecta. They control the state senate, the state house and the governor. Yeah. I mean they're really gonna have to do it, then that's becomes
speaker-2: It's it's very difficult. Yeah.
speaker-1: a
speaker-2: Gun control and taxes are two things that are gonna be tough because those are constitutionally.
speaker-1: I don't think Katie can push the taxes because she ran on I'm a tax cutter. So
speaker-2: Well, you're gonna see a lot of people who ran on affordability do things that make life more
speaker-1: So but what do you th so I think it's ESAs and I think it's green technology
speaker-2: Energy ESAs and and I do think they're gonna go after elections and they're going to go maybe as far as RCV ranked choice voting because Democrats have learned how to game that system and guarantee their candidates. And so they're they are definitely if you look at the governor just replaced Chad Campbell as her chief of staff with Corey Loric. Corey a woman who is a radical, radical open borders, like as far left as you can possibly get and has led the elections division for Hobbes for the last couple of years. So you're talking about someone who's going to be you know, I guarantee that they're going to do automatic registration, automatic voter registration, automatic vote by mail. So everyone's gonna have a ballot going out in the mail. they're gonna do all these things that they know that they can game the system with.
speaker-1: Do you know how much when they have automatic vote by mail, how much that increases turnout?
speaker-2: It doesn't increase turnout after one or two cycles, but what it does after one or two cycles is actually suppress the turnout on the other side. Because the what they're you know, look, you want to talk about ballot harvesting and gaming the system that way and doing that. They'll do that in mass. And then what happens, we've seen this in Washington, which used to be a a very purple state, even red leaning. We've seen it in Oregon, which was always been blue because of Portland, but otherwise was red. These states have just gone hard, hard
left because they game the system with ballot harvesting after doing this, you know, vote by mail scheme. And a lot of it it you know, is it legal? No. But they'll do it anyway. And they're very successful at it. We just seen here in Arizona, this was a very significant harvest that they did on the ground.
speaker-1: How many votes do you think they harvested? Which turns which
speaker-2: A couple hundred thousand. Turns this whole state, yeah.
speaker-1: Why do you think Republicans have just not said we have to do this?
speaker-2: Well, for one thing we're we're more honest about following the law, but the other thing and you know this from s from sending people to doors, ask a Republican to hand over a blank ballot, see how that goes.
speaker-1: Well that's why you have to eng that's why you have to start now and start recruiting families and friends to do it. Right. I mean that's the process that has to be done.
speaker-2: Well, I I feel like Republicans have to hold on, fight the fight, and then in two years we have to take the state back in a significant way, or it's a blue state permanently. I think we have one cycle now to save Arizona.
speaker-1: Absolutely. Well folks, this is Breaking Battlegrounds. We'll be right back with our next guest, Scott Day Freeman from the Goldwater Institute, talking about those pesky photo radar money grabs. We'll be right back.
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-2: Welcome back to Breaking Battlegrounds. Our final guest for the day, Scott Day Freeman, is a senior attorney at the Goldwater Institute. does fantastic work in a whole range of areas, but right now they've been focused on traffic cameras. And Arizona recently just passed a statewide law to limit municipalities' ability to use these automated traffic cameras. But the ongoing program in Phoenix can continue under that law. And that's a lot of what we're here to talk about. Scott Day Freeman, welcome to the program.
speaker-5: Thanks, wonderful be
speaker-1: The most important question to start with is this. You got your undergraduate degree at the University of Arizona, you got your law degree at ASU, who do you root for in the football game?
speaker-5: don't ask me that question, because I've covered the whole state, haven't I? Yeah. I I th I think you tend to be loyal to your undergrad.
speaker-2: Thank you. Thank you, Scott. I was about to say if I don't get a bear down out of this guy, I'm cutting him off and ending this interview right now. Come on.
speaker-1: All right. Well t I well as a BYU fan I'm hoping U of A beats Utah tomorrow. So that's where I'm at. That's where I'm at on this. So all right. So Prop three one nine, which required cities to ask voters next general election for speed enforcement cameras passed. It got sixty two percent of the vote, people You know, by the way, I wanna make a note here. Whatever liberal crap is put on the ballot here in Arizona you know, or whatever is put on the ballot that's even conservative in nature or fiscal, there's always thirty eight to forty percent of the voters here that vote against it. That is your liberal base in Arizona, folks, and you just need to come to terms with it, right? It just doesn't matter what it
speaker-2: Remember twenty five percent don't drive. So so that's part of
speaker-1: Yeah, it's true as well. So anyway, so Prop three one nine now says, Hey, if you want these radar enforcement cameras, you have to go get a vote by your municipalities voters to get this on. Correct. Okay. But supposedly this doesn't affect Phoenix. Why?
speaker-5: Well well what it does, it it it does a little more than that. It actually bans any new implementation of photo radar cameras. And and just so we're clear, photo radar car cameras are different than the flock camera issues. Right. These are cameras connected to radar guns that issue citations for things like speeding and running red lights and things like that. So that's what this is focused on. So if you're living in a jurisdiction that does not use photo radar And doesn't scramble to get something in place by the end of the year, you're not gonna see it in your jurisdiction. Now, if you're in a jurisdiction that has is using Photo Rider, like Phoenix, Scottsdale, Tempe, Mesa Chandler, Paradise Valley, and a few others across the state, they can continue to use it, but next November, they've got to put the question to their voters: do you want us to continue to have this authority to use it? So So basically unless you gotta watch your jurisdiction. If you live in f drive in Phoenix, live in Phoenix, it's possible the city could not renew its contract with its vendor next year.
speaker-2: no, they'll try
speaker-5: But if they don't, you've got to show up at the election next November and and and vote no.
speaker-1: How much revenue do the cities get from these radar enforcement cameras?
speaker-5: It it depends. And I know the data, the recent data on the city of Phoenix, it's not exactly clear because the money from the citations comes in after they're issued, but by the end of you know, they started issuing citations in late March. By the roughly the end of September, their 17 cameras in Phoenix had issued nearly 100,000 citations. Yeah. now a portion when those show up in people's mailboxes. There's a percentage of people who, I think people understand that's a voluntary request
speaker-2: Yeah, I threw mine away.
speaker-5: and pay with it, pay it, and about 10 to 20% do that. And then people may have their reasons for doing that, not questioning that. So that money will come in, but if you don't voluntarily pay it and insist upon proper service of process, the city's got it, or the the vendor really goes and hires a process server to hunt you down and serve you. And it looks like in the city of Phoenix, it's been a very tiny percentage that they've gone out and served only about a thousand people by the end of September. So I I know in terms of dollars that have come in, I I only
know as of the about mid-September, the city had collected maybe a million plus in in revenue from this. But you know, there are other jurisdictions like the town of Paradise Valley relies upon photo radar for a significant portion of its budget. it is a revenue driver for
speaker-1: I know the mayor of Paradise Valley told two legislators that he absolutely had to have this revenue from the radar enforcement cameras. I mean told them point
speaker-2: They they literally just run that city on traffic to
speaker-1: This guy's also the president of the Scottsdale Chamber, which is I always hate when chamber presidents don't live in their city, but that's not the point today. but yeah, he just told him. He goes, I have to have this revenue.
speaker-5: I I think that should concern people because you d you don't want I mean the government can can dream up a million ways with technology now to nag and prog you and collect money from you and we we don't want to have this this incentivized form of of law enforcement like this.
speaker-2: Well, and Phoenix's program is especially egregious, I think, because of the way it's set up with the vendor also serving as the process server. Everything is really designed for revenue generation more than safety. They're not even putting these cameras in areas with the highest level of traffic accidents. They're putting them where they can catch the most speeders. and a lot of it's people going fifty one in a forty five.
speaker-1: Paradise Valley Paradise Valley radar cameras have the best photos of me. I should probably do use them for my profile picture. They're wonderful.
speaker-5: And one thing I don't think a lot of people realize now is they are starting to use the driver's license database to compare the photo that the camera takes with driver's license photos. Yes. So in the past, you know, they would just send reflexively figure out well, we got your license plate number, who's the registered owner of the vehicle. Citation goes to that address. Now they'll look at everyone else who lives at that address and and look at their photos and start to match the photos together and send them directly to to that person.
speaker-1: I got one two weeks ago.
speaker-2: It it it throws the old the the two tricks a lot of people used is you have a husband and wife, they each have a car registered in their name but they drive the other's car. That was always the classic one or a business, right? You put it in your LLC and and but but those are kind of getting thrown out by this A AI based technology.
speaker-1: So why does the photo radar break the traffic enforcement bargain with the government and its citizens?
speaker-5: Well, I think, a long time ago, I think I was personally ambivalent about it. And the the engineer in me, I was an engineer by education, the U of A, bear down, admired the efficiency of it. But the more I look into it, the more it it seems problematic. There are due process concerns, there's this incentivized, you know, taxation through citation issue. And it also upends the fundamental bargain I think the people have always had with their government about traffic safety and traffic enforcement. The law has has always been that drivers have a duty to operate their vehicles in a reasonable and prudent manner. And that's reflected in state statute, even. That's the standard, reasonable and prudent under the circumstances. Now, what we've done is we've governments have figured out, well, on this, what's the maximum reasonable and prudent speed? on this stretch of roadway. We'll put a sign up and call it the speed limit. That's a presumptive maximum speed. So that reminds voters or drivers to watch their speed. And then we've layered on top of that law enforcement. We've t traditionally tasked law enforcement to go out into the city and watch drivers and task them to write citations. They're probably gonna go after the the real extreme violators, but they may randomly get some other people too. and that's always been kind of a very public thing. I mean grow growing up here in the valley, I remember driving around with my mom and dad or when I started driving, it was not uncommon to see someone having been pulled over. Correct. And it would remind you, and every other driver around, hey, you gotta watch your speed, be careful. I hardly see that now anymore at all because we've de-emphasized that. But so so when a police officer pulls you over that it deters you and everyone else who sees the red and blue lights flashing and it deters all those people. But the point is w we we were having this general deterrence in this manner with very few citations being written. I mean the police officer's task was never to pull over every single speeder. Photo
speaker-2: No
speaker-5: radar totally upends that. Photo radar, it's not public. You often don't know you've driven by a camera, you certainly don't know you've it's flashed you or gonna send you a ticket until you get it in the mail a week or so later. And so there's no public deterrence there. And photo radar can do it on an industrial scale. I mean the camera can be on 247 and it can sort of sweep the C's and collect every single vibe. Right. And and that's why it sort of totally upends the bargain I think people have with their government on traffic safety.
speaker-2: Well, and it not only that, I I think you just made a great point about deterrence. I actually think that it one of the few things I will give Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs credit for, she's had DPS really focusing on extreme speeders on the highways and then making a big deal out of it, putting it up on social media, showing them towing the cars, doing all those kind of things. It's clearly had an effect. If you drive Arizona's highways, there aren't nearly as many people going a hundred plus anymore. It's working. And it's bringing a a important safety element. These Phoenix traffic cams or these other traffic cams, the data does
not support that they actually create safer conditions for drivers. It just doesn't match up the data. And and so that is one of my objections to this as a whole. How is this anything more than a taxation scheme when you're not getting any actual real world safety results out of these programs?
speaker-5: I I I I agree. That that's a good point. I think the city of Phoenix originally when it came brought back photo radar earlier this year, they said, Well, we're gonna we're gonna put it in the the places where we're seeing more accidents and because it can be useful in that way. But the the problem with with that, looking at it that way, is in any large data set you may see clusters of data. Right. And it it it it it doesn't necessarily mean there's something systemically wrong with drivers in the valley or even that stretch of roadway. It just could be a random phenomenon. So you put the the the w what the city what these jurisdictions do is they put the cameras there and then the numbers start to go down there and they say, aha, it's because of the cameras. Not necessarily. There's something called regression to the mean, which is like a statistics term, where things will just naturally go go back down. And so you can't credit that to photo radar necessarily.
speaker-2: No, I I I give you a great example from working at the city of Phoenix, the the suicide lanes on the seventh, seventh street and seventh Ave, which have the reverse lanes for for rush hour. we see a spike in accidents along those two corridors every time there's a spike in in migration to the state. So it follows because people aren't familiar with it, then give it a year or two and it c it it drops back down. They're they will tell you a lot of that has to do with the cameras, but the historical pattern precedes the cameras by decades.
speaker-5: And if there is something wrong with the roadway, the intersection, the lighting, the signage, then why don't we go fix that? Yes. Right. Now that would be the direct way to solve the problem. But the problem for the city is, well, that requires them to allocate money, hire people, contractors, do studies, and that costs money. cameras don't. The city can say we're doing something about it, we're throwing up these cameras, and look, they pay for themselves with all the tickets they.
speaker-1: Do they really have a portion of the money collected from this go to the Clean Elections Commission?
speaker-5: Yeah, there's a surcharge when you when you get when you pay when you pay everything there'll be a surcharge taxed on to it that goes to f to the Clean Elections Fund. So you will be basically subsidizing some politician's speech, whether you agree with that speech or not.
speaker-1: Well
speaker-2: Crazy stuff.
speaker-1: we we thank you so much Scott for joining us today. How do people follow you?
speaker-5: You can go look at what we're doing on the Goldwater Institute dot org and we have a blog there and I've I've written about this ballot measure, which I'm happy was the probably the most popular statewide ballot measure, and see all the other things we're doing there on on our website.
speaker-1: Well thank you so much, Scott. We appreciate you joining us today. Folks, this is Breaking Battlegrounds. Thank you for joining us this week. On behalf of Sam, Brennan, myself, and Jeremy, have a great weekend. Follow us at breakingbattlegrounds.boat or wherever you get your podcast or of course listen to us on the Salem Media universe. Have a great weekend.