TRANSKRYPCJA 🔗
00:00:00
S1: Hi friend. Thank you so much for downloading this podcast of In the Market with Janet Parshall. And as always, I truly hope you hear something that Edifies equip energizes Edifies and gets you out there in the marketplace of ideas. But before you listen and before you go, let me take a moment of your time, if I may, and tell you about this month's truth tool. It's called God's Book An Honest Look at the Bible Seven Toughest Topics, and it's written by Doctor Andrew Ollerton. He's a theologian, a best selling author, a pastor, and he's from the UK. Absolutely brilliant in the way in which he communicates. And so he wants to answer questions. When people challenge us about some of those tough topics we find in Scripture, tough topics like science and evolution versus creation, slavery and Old Testament laws, warfare and violence, suffering. The list goes on. Andrew does an absolutely brilliant job of breaking it down so that you and I never have to be ashamed of the integrity of the Bible. It'll help you contend for the faith, and it'll answer some questions you yourself might have, or friend who's been asking you about one of these tough topics. So it's yours for a gift of any amount because we are listener supported radio. If you'd like a copy of God's book, just call. 877 Janet 58 that's 877 Janet 58 and ask for a copy of God's book. You can do the same thing by going online to in the market with Janet parshall.org. Scroll to the bottom of the page. There's the cover of the book. Click on make your Donation, and we'll send it to you again as a way of saying thank you. You might also want to become a partial partner. Those are people who give every single month at a level of their own choosing as my way of saying thank you. I make sure that you get every single month's truth tool, as long as you're a partial partner. And in addition, you will be getting a weekly newsletter that contains my writing that only my partial partner see, and an audio piece only prepared for my partial partners. So prayerfully consider what you might do to support in the market with Janet. Partial. Now please enjoy the broadcast.
00:01:44
S2: Here are some of the news headlines we're watching.
00:01:46
S3: The conference was over. The president won a pledge.
00:01:48
S4: Americans worshiping government over God.
00:01:51
S5: Extremely rare safety.
00:01:52
S1: Move by a.
00:01:53
S6: 17 years. The Palestinians and Israelis negotiated. Every idea.
00:02:11
S1: Hi friends. Welcome to in the market with Janet. Partial. So please, we're going to spend the hour together and we're going to do some critical and biblical thinking this hour about artificial intelligence. It is no longer the future, is it? It's right here. It is the present. And we if we're going to live like ambassadors for Christ, if we're going to grow up in him, if we're very concerned about our ongoing sanctification, then we can't be cavalier about this technology because it is technology like no other. It is not. Let me make this declarative statement value neutral. In fact, it's anything but. It's designed to change who we are. And I think we need to use that as a starting point in our conversation. You know, I read a lot of books on this topic, and I have to tell you, I think one of the preeminent voices in warning the church. Capital C universal on this topic is Doug Smith. Yes, that Doug Smith, which is the name of this website. I love the way he singles out himself that way because that's a great thing to do. This is a man who understands software development. He understands what goes on behind the tech curtain. He understands all of the ones and zeros and programs that have to be done. But far more importantly, he loves the Lord Jesus Christ and he loves His Word, and he loves to go on mission trips. And he loves to tell people about Jesus. And he loves to talk about screen time. And he loves to be able to say to the church, wait a minute, let's hit the pause button here and stop and think. Now I will tell you right out of the gate that that means my friend Doug doesn't always win the Miss Popularity Award by any stretch of the imagination. Because unfortunately, in our human condition, which is sin sick and fallen, we do get attracted quite easily and very readily to new shiny objects, of which AI is certainly one. But more importantly, we fail to understand what's going on behind the curtain. what the creator's worldview is not the creator capital C, but the creators in Silicon Valley. What is it they want to do with these advanced models the cloud, the open AI, the chat bots, the LMS, the idea that it isn't just going to be good intelligence, it's going to be super intelligent someday. And what about drafting constitutional rights for machines? And the list goes on and on and on that raise a panoply of questions that discerning saints, being good brains, must take the time to answer. And Doug is helping the church in that area because he's causing us. He's forcing us, if you will, to think critically and biblically about this topic. So I have been waiting anxiously for this interview because this is the day we're going to talk about Doug's brand new book. It's called An Intelligence, and that UN is bracketed on the title and in every chapter. And it's really a wonderful way of saying it's not. I'll start with that. The subtitle is The Lies Behind Today's AI and the Truths You Need to Thrive. Let me tell you officially who Doug is. He's an international speaker and expert on the intersection of technology and discipleship. He has filled diverse stages from university seminars to international conferences. His insights are forged by decades of software engineering experience and, more importantly, a lifetime of Bible study. He's authored the award winning book, unintentional. We've talked about that book frequently here. How screened secretly shape your desires and how you can break free. Doug is gratefully married to an award
Load full transcript
winning author who helped him do some work on this book, edited and was his constant companion, and is blessed with four wonderful grown up daughters that I'm going to guess. Just a stretch here, Doug are called Meg, Jo, Amy, and Beth. And if you don't know who Louisa May Alcott is, that falls flat on its face. So welcome, Doug. I'm sure you didn't name your daughters after Little Women, but I just thought I'd throw that out there anyway.
00:05:44
S7: I love that, Janet. No, we didn't, but. But that's a great idea for a family. We didn't, you know, obviously didn't know we're going to have four girls. But you know, it's the greatest blessing in my life. I love them.
00:05:54
S1: All. I'm so glad. I'm so glad.
00:05:56
S7: But thank you so much for the wonderful invitation and the opportunity to talk about this with you today. Janet. It's such a blessing.
00:06:01
S1: Oh, it's exactly right back at you, Doug, because I really want to honor Christ in all things. And I know the people in our listening audience want to do the same thing. And this you can't compartmentalize your faith. You can't say, well, my, my computer screen time, my AI usage, it's over here and my walk with Christ is over here. If your identity is in him, if you take Galatians 220 very seriously, if you believe that you've been crucified in Christ and you no longer live, but Christ lives in you, then everything we do should bring honor and glory to him. And I think it's important for us to stop and do some deep, critical thinking about this technology. And I, I have to take the adjective future away because it's not it's very much present and it's going to rapidly escalate. And we are going to be left behind if we're not being good Bereans on this topic. But you wrote about it in the book, so I do not feel like I'm violating your privacy. I want my friends first before we get into this book. And by the way, Doug, fair warning. I'm going very slow in this interview because I expect to have multiple interviews on this book. Every chapter is worth an hour's discussion from my vantage point, and they're not the kind that you skim over quickly. I stop, I read, I pause, I ruminate on what you've just said. And so I'm not going to conduct a lickety split interview. So if we don't go over the entire book today, just know there are multiple more should the Lord tarry and he doesn't call either one of his home? We're going to spread this out because I want to talk about this entire book, but I want to talk about you personally. Tell me about your background. What drew you as an interest in technology, this particular kind of technology. And then I want to talk about the fact that you didn't just talk the talk, but you walked the walk, and sometimes that means paying a price. So just tell me about how you're hard wired and what draws you to this technology. Because do you love science? Do you love math? It is a combination of both. What was it?
00:07:44
S7: Yeah. Thank you Janet. Yeah, absolutely. I've been a tech nerd, like as long as it could be. It started out as an electronics engineering student and learned computers along the way, learned software engineering along the way. And so yeah, I've always been fascinated by how things work. I love science fiction. I, I have been fascinated by all of that. And so I, and I've had a good career in that. Um, until it ended abruptly. And we'll, I'll mention, we'll talk about that. But, but just in terms of like the background of this, as I was, as I was working in the technology industry, I was also like all of us. We, we all have, um, observed how big technology has the big technology companies, especially in Silicon Valley, have learned how to create products that change our behaviors, that actually shape our desires. That was the content of my, what ended up being my first book. I just, I, as I was watching people, you know, the, the classic thing where you go in the restaurant and all four people are on a phone where the kids have an iPad and nobody's talking to each other. I was back in 2014, 2015. I was like, what is going on? So I did I did deep dive research, not just on the technology, but on what turned out to be behavioral psychology, neuroscience, other and then theology, of course, and learned that there is a whole practice of shaping us with software. And I brought that lens. That's the lens I look through when I when ChatGPT and large language models came on the scene about four years ago.
00:09:18
S3: Wow.
00:09:18
S1: Now there's more to the story. So let me just hit the pause button there and we're going to come back and continue. So it's a big day, at least for me, because today is my first opportunity to talk with Doug about his brand new book called UN Intelligence The Lies Behind Today's AI and the Truths You Need to Thrive. So this is an anti-technology. It's about being a good Berean. We're going to take a break back after this. Does the Bible condone warfare? Does it support slavery? Is there a literal heaven in hell? That's why I've chosen God's Book by Andrew Ollerton as this month's truth tool. Get clear, concise answers to seven of the Bible's toughest topics. Ask for your copy of God's book. When you give a gift of any amount in the market, call 877. Janet 58. That's 877 Janet 58. Or go to in the market with janet.org. We're talking with Doug Smith and he's got a brand new book out today. We've been waiting for it for some time. He speaks and writes on this intersection of technology and discipleship and does it with powerful eloquence. His brand new book is out now. It's called Unintelligence The Lies Behind Today's AI and the Truths You Need to Thrive. So I appreciate so much lingering a bit with your story, Doug, because I want it to set the stage. Not only that, but, um, if I were a trial attorney and you were my expert witness. I want to put your credentials on the record for the jury to hear that. Why you have the ethos and the pathos and the
gravitas to be able to talk about this, that this wasn't you just sitting around one day and thinking, oh, I think I'll write about this. So you were trained in this area. This was your area of expertise. But you're a believing follower of Christ who has a quickened spirit in you that started picking up. There were some things here that were red flags. So you began to see the kind of manipulation that was being done in the industry. And eventually that, of course, leads to the first book. Um, unintelligible. And you say the title of it unintentional, unintentional. There you go. And it was really about holding us on our screens. But tell me some more, because it's one thing to say, oh, I feel a little uncomfortable about this, but the uncomfort grew to a point where you had to really make a decision, and I want to talk about that.
00:11:34
S7: Yeah. So definitely I, I don't write, I write out of calling, not out of like some writers just feel like they have to write. And I write because of the burden that I see, and I feel like I have a case I have to make that requires a book, a book length treatment. And in the case of Unintelligence 275 footnotes. Because when you're making the case that I'm making, you know, you have to you have to back it up. Uh, but yeah, in terms of my story, so when I was, when I, well, as I was saying, when ChatGPT came out about four years ago, I was already looking at big tech products through the lens that they intentionally make their products habit forming and even addicting. And so I was looking for those, um, those signs of that and, and the way that it works. And I was, as I did the research, I started seeing exactly that even more in spades, more than I expected to find. So I had been a skeptic and I've been writing and speaking. I have a whole series on my website of these should we articles? Should we use it for research? Should we use it for creativity? And all these things that I had to dig into. Um, so, but anyway, as I think, as you're alluding to, Janet, as I talk about in the introduction, I, um, as a software engineer, which was my day job, uh, that that whole field has had a significant interest in using AI because the industry has been targeting it as a platform for making money. They, as an industry, the generative AI industry really has a hard time becoming profitable. But software engineering, that was one area where they thought they could make some money. And so they have made tooling and things around it to try to attract software engineers. And I, I was a skeptic, and inside the company that I worked for a company I loved, I had a I worked there for seven years. I'd planned to work there ten more years because I'm not ready to retire and definitely needed the money, needed a good paycheck and needed the needed the work. But, um, but anyway, so up until, uh, about May of this last year of this year, may of this year, um, they had made it optional to use AI for work. Um, but they, but unfortunately, they changed their policy very quickly and decided to mandate it and require us to use AI for software engineering. And after all of my research and I had to search my soul and really dig deep. Like, how much do I really believe this stuff? It turns out I believe it wholeheartedly, even enough to just to trust God for the next step. And so, uh, so I, I left that company. I still love that company. I left, I left them, um, and, and kind of like Abraham didn't exactly know where we're going, but one of the blessings of that conviction and all the research I'd already been doing for the past couple of years was that I had full time to finish this book as fast as possible. So by the grace of God, it was able to be finished much faster than I could have otherwise. And now we're offering it to the Lord and just seeing what he will do.
00:14:23
S1: Amen. I put that out there, friends, as a prayer request, so that you would pray that the needs of the Doug Smith household are met financially and that he would provide, you know, we trust God in all things. And this is a perfect example. And by the way, I see his hand. You know, his thoughts are way above our thoughts. But I have to tell you that having read this book and knowing how many footnotes and research and cross-references and books you refer to throughout the writing, this would be very tough to do. After a 9 to 5 job, you'd be exhausted to be able to do it. It's that kind of deep thinking in this book that really requires sole focus. And so I don't know what the future holds, but boy, I can see a blessing in it happening right now because the book is just absolutely superb. So if I were going to do and I hate the sort of colloquial aspect of this, but I'll ask the question anyway. If I'm going down an elevator and I got 30s to say, so why'd you leave your job? What would you say were the primary concerns that you had that made you say, I can't do this because I have such deep concerns and convictions about AI now that it's not an option. It's a it's a mandate. I can't stay here. Someone would say, well, give me some bullet points and why you have some concerns and you can't stay here and do this.
00:15:34
S7: Yeah. Thank you for asking that, Janet. I it's it was something that I wrestled with a lot. And as you know, I do tend to back up everything with a lot of research. But for this particular decision, I had to write it from my heart, from my like, what are my reasons? So on my website, I have a document that I wrote to myself, really, of the reasons why I could not use, why I will not use software or I will not use generative AI, specifically big tech generative AI for software engineering and the the class of reasons. The primary reason I had was that, um, and the biggest kind of claim in the book is that we are changed by our adoption of any technology. We are, we are formed and in generative AI and especially in software engineering. And there's studies that document this, we
actually lose the skills we offload into the, into the technology. And for me, my everything I love to do, I do it as a craft. I do it as like I was. I was always known as the guy who was always looking for the best quality, always trying to bring excellence. And so I've worked really hard to craft these skills, and I wasn't about to lose them and offload them to this technology. So along with that, I also, um, realized that this was kind of a trap of dependency forming trap. So by embracing this technology, I would not only lose my skills, but I would have a, I would have this dependent relationship on a technology which I had found was fundamentally untrustworthy. And I would be changed by that as well. So those two are the main things that I really that really grounded my decision. And I have about ten more in my article as well.
00:17:15
S8: Yeah. Wow.
00:17:16
S1: Well, I, I'm so thankful that you're openly transparent about this because I want a friend to understand that it's one thing to write a book. It's another thing to give speeches. It's another to say, now I have to walk the walk, not just talk the talk. Trusting the Lord here. But these are how deep my convictions are on this. More with Doug Smith and his brand new book on intelligence right after this. Doug Smith is with us. He's got a brand new book out now. It's called UN Intelligence The Lies Behind Today's AI and the Truths You Need to Thrive. It follows on the heels of his first book, unintentional, which really and truly was about how you and I are being manipulated. And I think that's the appropriate word to spend longer and longer and longer time on our screens, because Silicon Valley wants you there, so they're changing you, as Doug said. Now, he also said if you were listening astutely, that he's got about ten other reasons, he could tell you why he decided to say to the core of my convictions, I can't stay with this company that I love, that I've been at for seven years, would like to be here for another decade. Um, those reasons, by the way, are beautifully articulated as he lays them out in his book on intelligence. Now, if you're paying attention unintentional unintelligence. And then every chapter begins with an UN and it's brilliant. By the way, if I can say that, Doug, but you say that it's your way of pushing back against the intentionality imbalance. I love that word. So talk to me about what you mean about intentionally imbalance.
00:18:51
S7: Yeah. Thank you. So my, my first book, that's what it that's what the UN, this, this kind of crafting of these chapters and the titles is the idea that we approach technology unintentionally. But what we want to do is drop that un and become more intentional. The the intentionality imbalance is that most of us approach technology unintentionally. But the industry, big technology companies are extremely intentional. They spend billions of dollars, millions of hours, incredibly complex suite of experiments that are really performed. I call us the petri dish generation. We're experimented on from thousands and thousands of experiments. Every time you're on any big tech product, they're figuring out what works on you. In particular, out of all the 8 billion people on the planet, they know how to target you with what will keep you hooked. And they do that because they're extremely intentional with how we spend our time. And so that's where unintentional was about flipping the intentionality imbalance. And that's what so we want to drop the UN's. We want to become more intentional than than big tech with Unintelligence. I carried that further, and I'm calling it an intelligence exchange that they want that big tech wants us to make. They want us to be less intelligent. So so-called, than the machines they're creating that they believe will be super intelligent. They won't be. And that's the kind of a spoiler. Spoiler alert in chapter one, they will never be able to do that. But they're but they're claiming to do that. And in so doing, the thing that I found again is the forming power. If we offload our intelligence, it does actually degrade. We do actually lose God given abilities by trusting in machines. So again, I want people to flip the intelligence exchange and become more care more about their God given intelligence than the companies who would rob you from it.
00:20:44
S1: This is why I find this conversation so delicious. Doug, every time we have a conversation, I always think that because whether you like it or not, you're forcing us to do some deep thinking here. And I'm going to give an example of that in just a moment. But I so appreciated what you said before, which is I think we're so caught up in, can I get AI to draw me a picture of a cat that we forget that there is an exchange going on that you can't see, but is very much transactional is taking place, and you are becoming an unwilling or unwilling partner in what's going on right now. But you can't afford that. You cannot plead ignorance in this area. As a discerning Berean, you have to understand how this works and understand the choices that you're making and what you are acquiescing to the machines. And that's one of the things I appreciate. So how dare you make us think? You ask us very early on in the introduction that really and truly and these are deep questions and I don't know, in our busy lives as Christians, when we're running hither and yon, whether or not we take the time to do some deep thinking, we should be. I don't know how you can be in Scripture without doing deep thinking, but this is one of those questions that you should be pondering as you're driving around in the car. You're standing at the sink doing the dishes. Questions like, who are we really? What does it mean to be a human made in the image of God? And can that image be tainted or even desecrated? Now, let me leave those three big transcendent questions out there for a minute, because the first thing I want to do is I
want to slay the dragons of complacency. A lot of people hearing me articulate those three questions that you wrote, Doug, in the book might say, well, I don't care. I mean, what does it mean to be human? What it means I get up, I, I take care of my wife and kids. I put food on the table and I make sure that I live a good, clean, moral life. That's what it means to be human. Why are these questions for the believers relevant and important?
00:22:31
S7: Oh, they're they're vitally important, Janet. It's the thing is, is that as as I talked about with the the exchanges that we have put before us, if we will not ask these questions of ourselves, big technology has proven that they're willing to answer them for us if we won't think deeply. And that's why there's always an easy button. It's always really easy. That's why chatbots are everywhere. Generative AI opportunities are everywhere because they just want it to be the low hanging fruit, the the easy button we're all looking for. Because, yeah, we're exhausted. We've got kids, we've got diapers, we've got all of our problems. We all have life so full. And they're, they're optimizing, they're maximizing our vulnerability. They're robbing us of these, of these essential questions that if we don't answer them again, they will answer them. And their answers are not biblical. Their answers are not. You're a human made in the image of God. The answer, ah is you are an accident of evolution, and you need artificial intelligence to overcome all of your limitations. Like that's what that's for. So, so yeah, it's vital for us to take the time even when it's uncomfortable, even if we don't feel like we have the time to really ask these deep questions and trust God to answer them through the biblical lens that he wants us all to have. And we all have time. The the reason, the unintentional part, um, people are unintentionally spending like eight hours a day on their screens on social media, video games, and, um, streaming video platforms. Average. So if people cut off that time, you could then take the time to answer some of these big questions and not like big tech rob you of that.
00:24:11
S1: Oh, that's such a great point. Wow. Okay, as I said before, and I'm going to repeat myself, I love this book. It's deep and it's rich theologically. It also helps you understand the tech world. I love his cross-reference to other thinkers that are out there that make his point. It's brilliant. It's called Unintelligence. The lies behind today's AI, the truths you need to thrive. When we come back, we're going to look at that first one, and it's a very important one. And like I said, we're going to go through this book slowly because there's so much good stuff there back after this. With so many stations, channels, websites and newspapers to choose from, sometimes it's hard to uncover the truth in today's world. So many voices clamoring for our attention on in the market. We bring biblical truth into the marketplace of
ideas, equipping you to become a bold voice of truth in this confused and chaotic culture. Become a partial partner today. Call 877 Janet, 58, or go online to In the market with Janet parshall.org. If you're just joining us, Doug Smith is our guest. You're going to want to download the first half of this conversation. Just go to wherever you find your favorite podcast and download today's date. Doug Smith in the market with Janet Partial. Doug is an international speaker and expert on the intersection of technology and discipleship. He has filled diverse stages from universities to international conferences, and audiences always appreciate his biblical approach and his understanding of the technology as well. So his first book was called unintentional, and it was fabulous. It was about how you were manipulated by screen time. Now, his new book, Just Out, is called Unintelligence The Lies Behind Today's AI and the Truths You Need to Thrive. So I want to start with the very first one, which I think is very crucial, particularly because, um, I think we're falling so readily into the delusion that somehow there's creative thinking going on in part of these machines, that they really are intelligent. And quite honestly, if you're paying attention, that's not by happenstance. When you look at the people behind anthropic, for example, and they're drafting constitutions for their machines, and they're putting out warnings that you better not treat the machines poorly. You're doing all these superimpositions of anthropomorphic qualities, and they're machines. They're ones and zeros and diodes and motherboards, and they are not people, and they are not made in the image of God. Which is why those three questions that you asked in the introduction are paramount. Because here's the first question that comes up against your question, which is, are these machines able to have intelligence? And you do a superb job of breaking this down. And you tell the story of Alan Turing. And for a lot of people, if you saw the movie with Benedict Cumberbatch, you saw the it was called The Imitation Game. It was really about how America and the world got computers used to decode the Nazis. But that was a launching board for everything we're talking about today. Tell me more about that, Doug.
00:27:08
S7: Right. It's really important, I think, to understand that there's a lot of history this I didn't just pop out four years ago. It's been really in. From the birth of modern computing with Alan Turing. And he was fascinated by this idea of intelligence. And he thought because he did, I mean, obviously he did a huge thing. And he and his team, by learning how to break Nazi codes, uh, it won the war for the allies, arguably, because they were able to decode things using his machine. But what's interesting is that he then was he, he was trying to figure out how would he know if a machine was intelligent. And he came up with this, what the movie is that movie title, The Imitation
Game. It was also known as the Turing Test, which is this idea that if a computer can fool a human into thinking that the computer is human. So. So a human using a computer doesn't know it's a computer. They end up thinking it's actually human. If the human is fooled, then it has passed the Turing test by imitation. So the. So the fundamental part of the of the Imitation Game is that humans are deceived. We're tricked into thinking that it's intelligent and that the vital thing, and why I call this the dehumanizing lie underneath AI, underneath today's AI, it's a dehumanizing lie because the only way they get to this definition of intelligence is by reducing it far, far below to, to the actual intelligence that all humans have been given as made in the image of God. And so no machine will ever be intelligent. And I and I'll demonstrate that in my book and why I want to try to really push against this notion and show that it not only is untrue, but it really matters.
00:28:47
S1: This is why I don't want to rush through our conversations, Doug, because every one of these is it's really worth some deep thinking. So I ask these questions just as the common man, and I use that in the Chaucer version. I don't have a problem with gender specificity here. Okay, so as the common man, when I'm looking at a machine, the first thing that comes to my mind is I love John Bunyan tremendously, both Pilgrim's Progress and many other things that he wrote. But he said, once doth thou see the Spirit of God in that man? Someday he and I shall together walk in glory. So, in other words, we're able to recognize the image of God in a fellow human being. And I'm going to separate the believers from the unbelievers at this point. So for the believers in particular, I understand the world. The world lives in darkness. I understand why they can't see. But for the believer, this is where my questions raise. So we are capable. Theoretically, I think we're hardwired, no pun intended, to be able to see the image of God in another human being, which then, um, portends a whole series of ways in which we interact with fellow human beings simply because we know that they're made in the image of God. Are we truly blind in that we are incapable of looking at a screen or a machine? Um, and thinking there's no way in the world that this represents who I am. Made in the image of God. The only part of creation is you and me that is made in his image. Are we utterly as believers, incapable of recognizing the fact because intelligence could only be subscribed, it seems to me, to human beings. And before you answer that question, we have to back up a little bit and say, and you do this in the first chapter. How does one define the word intelligence? Because if I were talking to Sam Altman, I bet he'd give me a different definition than you would. So how should we as believers define intelligence?
00:30:28
S7: Yeah, I love that question, Janet. And before I answer the definition, I want to
I do want to respond to what you were saying there at the beginning. Like, are we able to be deceived? And I think you're exactly right. I think ultimately we do know that other humans are made in the image of God and have and share the gift of intelligence with us. And we're the only creatures that can have that. And there's no way we can make a machine to do that. However, what we have to understand is that the biggest companies, the most powerful companies have discovered how to fake us out so much that even Christians are truly being deceived. They. Unfortunately. Because before um, especially before chatbots. The only thing we chatted with, the only things we chatted with were other people. You know, we texted mom to ask her for that recipe. We texted our, our siblings and our friends. We, we had interactive, um, chats with our, with our coworkers at work. And so what they've done is they've faked us out. They've, they've passed the Turing test so decisively that when that you can like it's this unfair arms race. It's, you know, if somebody else is willing to spend $1 trillion to, to build a scheme that can deceive the world if they're willing to spend trillions of dollars and then do it, well, those of us, you know, the rank and file common men like you would say we, we have little chance to overcoming that. I mean, we can know it and we can understand it. And that's one of my goals with my book is to help people understand it. No matter how it feels, it will never be intelligent. But man, the feeling is really powerful. It's kind of like getting, you know, doing drugs. Like we would not want the drug to cause us to have a hallucination or some kind of delusion. But but we're weak. And if you take a drug that has a hallucinogenic property, you're going to be have hallucinations. And the machines are designed with very similar and even maybe more, arguably more powerful traits. So so what is the true definition of intelligence? Well, there's a lot of definitions, but I've always been a fan of the intelligent design think tank, the Discovery Institute. And so I subscribe to a lot of their, um, their materials. And so they're, they're looking at what's, you know, how do we have signs in the material world that, that an intelligence, a designing intelligence has created things. And so their definition of intelligence is, is a very mature. But the bottom line, the one of the really tight definitions is the ability to choose for a purpose, the ability to make a choice based on an end goal or teleology is the big word that you would say there. So the, the that requires first person experience. It requires consciousness. It requires the ability to make a choice. Because we have purposes, machines don't and never will have purposes. They run code, they run algorithms, and those aren't purposes. So so yeah, that would be my tight definition is the ability to choose for a purpose is a, is a good working definition of intelligence.
00:33:22
S1: I love
that. So let me linger here again. Words are important. So intelligence is not to be confused just with knowledge. And you may. I've never forgotten it, Doug, because it was such a great word picture. And one of our conversations, you talked about the fact that if you were to say to AI, give me a picture of a cat, it doesn't ex nihilo create the cat. What it does is it breakneck speed, it searches whatever programs have been put in for pictures of cats and then comes up with one of those pictures. So there isn't it's not original thinking here. It is replication. It is imitation. Let's go back to Turing again. It's imitation of what's been programmed in. But but it it doesn't necessarily mean that you are making creative choices or moral choices, which I think has to be a part of intelligence. Um, you can have the intelligence to know how to make a nuclear warhead, but you better have the moral decision making about whether or not it's right or wrong to use it. So do you relegate that to a machine? I mean, how does that tie into the conversation of intelligence? But let me go back to the cat picture that you painted before. So these machines spit out, they don't create. And I think there's a distinction there. Talk to me about that.
00:34:31
S7: Absolutely. I think we are gifted by our creator with the ability to actually have genuine ideas. We, I mean, we only God creates ex nihilo, of course, but he has gifted us with the ability to have epiphanies, to have genuine ideas. And unfortunately, the machines are really pushing back even against those by claiming that they are also creative. But as you as you reminded us, they are not. They only are pattern matching running algorithms based on being pulling in all of the data that they could possibly find. Every digitized word, every digitized picture, every digitized video all become part of what's called training data to run these machines, and then they just create them in new permutations. But that isn't what we do. What we do is genuine creativity, genuine, um, intelligence. And sometimes that means, um, that we have a spark of genius, which to me, I believe comes as a gift from God. And only in my personal experience as I'm leaning into God more. Those are when my best ideas come. And, uh, and as I even even in editing the book, as I look back through it, I can, I can look back and say, wow, that was actually better than me. Because, uh, one thing I'll point out, which is probably a no brainer, is that not one word in this book, not one word was even inspired or touched or edited or written or any other way touched by artificial intelligence. So yeah, it's only God and me and my, my, my wonderful editors that helped it become what it is.
00:36:05
S1: I'm so glad you brought that up because believe it or not, I'm beginning to see more and more of this in the books that I'm reading and vetting and reviewing on a regular basis. You've got a stamp that literally says human authored on the book. And
I have to tell you, at first it made me smile, and now I'm thinking I'd better be seeing that more and more in books, because books that don't tell me that they're human authored. I'm not interested in reading some imitations spit out from an AI writer. I want to know the spark of creativity in a writer who's wrestled with this issue, and then has told me what they've learned in the process. So wow. Human authored. I'm not done with this chapter at all. There's still much more and more with Doug Smith after this. By the way, I should tell you that Doug is a wonderful writer. When he's not writing books, he's also writing blogs. So I've linked to his website on our information page that Doug smith.com. Brilliant don't you think? That Doug smith.com. And by the way, the new book is now out. Unintelligence the Lies Behind Today's AI and the Truths You Need to Thrive. And we're going through this book. It's just now hot off the presses. And so I really encourage you to get it. But I'm not going to rush through these conversations because there's such richness. And again, one of our goals is to grow up in him, right? To get off that diet of milk, to move to a diet of meat and to get some spiritual heft on our bones. And so if you want to think great thoughts, you read great books. And the best book is the Word of God. And then when you have wonderful, wonderful apologists like Doug, who can help us to think deeply about tech and AI, I think that that's a blessing for the times in which God has called us to live. You quote John Lennox in the book, and I'm so glad you did. That's one of the blessings of your books, is you cross-reference brilliant people. So of course, John, the brilliant Oxford mathematician. And if you're counting the uncle of Kristyn Getty of Keith and Kristyn Getty Music, by the way. But he responded to Turing's. And I just want to read a part of this quote because it's brilliant. He said for a machine to win the game. Responding to Turing, it must be able to converse with human with humans, without the human's knowledge. It is a machine. Such a machine could then be said to be intelligent, even though its intelligence was not the same as human intelligence. So in other words, it's that idea again of spitting back and not creating, but simply spitting back again. You introduced me to a new person, a brilliant Hungarian British Christian chemist philosopher whose name I don't know how to pronounce. First name Michael, tell me who this man was and what his response was to Turing.
00:38:35
S7: Yeah. Michael Polanyi, he is a wonderful philosopher, chemist. Like you said, he's a he's a believer. And he, um, he, what the fascinating thing is that he was a contemporary of Alan Turing in the, at the University of Manchester in the UK. And so he actually wrote an article that pushed back against The Imitation Game. Bright, contemporary with touring. So touring had pushed back right as his ideas were being formed by people who were looking at
it through a much broader lens. And I'm really deeply indebted to Doctor Esther Meek, who was a is a world renowned philosopher scholar of Polanyi, kind of in Polanyi is super deep. So he needs a lot of interpretation, at least for me, because I'm not a I'm not a PhD philosopher. So Doctor Meek makes his work very approachable. Um, but the main thing that we get from Polanyi is this idea that it's a logical contradiction. It's not just a, a feeling or I'm uncomfortable. It's no, it's logically impossible to create a machine that can actually know anything because of this, this idea of epistemology, which is how we come to know what we know. That's what Polanyi is famous for, is this, this idea of that, the way we come to know is a gift from God that is almost hard to explain. Most of the things that we know. It's an intimate connection with reality as God has made us. And so like, um, we know much more than we can even say in words. The words we choose are chosen because we have something to say, because we know what we want to say deeply inside. And the words just simply reflect the knowledge that we're that we're expressing. And so yeah, I'm hugely grateful for the work of Michael Polanyi and Esther Meek, so that I could have a very solid, logical pushback against the idea that any machine could ever become intelligent. And the thing that I'm super grateful for is that gives us this confidence to stand when we are withered away by, as you mentioned, you know, by Dario Amodei. And the idea that the cloud is becoming intelligent or may already be or will, you know, be a superintelligence. Like it's, it's just simply never going to happen. And we can have certain confidence based on these, the research that I've done.
00:40:43
S1: And, and he co-opts religious leaders, according to the New York Times. Right. And we've talked about this and asks for their input as he's drafting and crafting the morality of a machine. It's it's well, it's an idol. And it goes back to something you and I have talked before about AI, and that's exactly what this is. You you write this. Polanyi remembers what Turing forgot the essential human element in the operation and interpretation of any machine, especially computing machines. Again, the the this is fascinating to me because this is not only this is exactly your your strong point. It's technology and discipleship, the intersection between the two. And that's what this is. It's really technology and theology looking at each other. So Turing was willing to acquiesce and immediately talk about the fact that there's some greater power in the machines. Now Polanyi pushes back and says, no, there's a human being who programs a machine. And remember, you just pointed out to us that they were contemporaries. So right out of the gate, there were two distinctly and starkly different worldviews on this machinery. And now we've just developed to the nth degree different iterations, but it's the same core issue of can a machine create is an intelligent or is it not? You break down some of the words that Polanyi uses and let me just look at one. I want to talk about his approach towards semantic operations, because words are powerful here. What did he mean by that?
00:42:04
S7: Yeah. The semantics has to do with meaning that again, when we pick words when we're choosing, you and I are having this conversation right now, what the words we pick, we choose for a purpose. It's that definition of intelligence. Again, we're choosing words for a purpose and we do that. Semantics is the is the study of the meaning of words and connecting with context and the real world. And no machine will ever have context, even though they claim that they do, that no machine will ever know the meaning. Again, that's where Turing didn't recognize the reason he was able to break the Nazi codes or or solve chess playing or whatever is because he interpreted the output of an algorithm, the algorithm itself, no matter how fancy, no matter how many data centers, no matter how many you know, GPUs or whatever are running it, it's still an algorithm that has no idea of the meaning of a single word it generates, no matter how it feels. Yet we do. And that's the essential difference that Polanyi really brought to light that we have this, we have this, such a connection with with purpose and with reality that we express meaning. And I really, again, call that a gift from God. He has made his world brimming with meaning and we are able to discern it, detect it, and express it with our hearts. And, and that's a beautiful thing that I don't want us to lose to a machine.
00:43:23
S8: Yeah.
00:43:24
S1: Let me read from your book, Doctor Meek, who you referenced earlier, quotes Polanyi again, to deliver the decisive blow against Turing's Imitation Game, Polanyi explicitly descends from Turing's conclusion that a machine that deceives us into thinking that it is, that it thinks is actually thinking neither a machine nor a neurological model, nor Or an equivalent robot can be said to think, feel, imagine, desire, mean, believe, or judge something. They may conceivably simulate those propensities to such an extent as to deceive us altogether. But a deception, however compelling, does not qualify thereby as truth. And you brilliantly note that last sentence should be put to memory. I'll say it again. But a deception, however compelling, does not qualify thereby as truth. I'm glad we're going to take our time on this book, Doug, because we didn't even get through the first chapter. It's so good and so rich. You get a copy, you read it, you can follow along the next time we have a conversation. It is a wonderful, insightful, biblical challenge to the church to remember whose we are and how we should live again. Unintelligence the lies behind today's AI and the truths you need to thrive. Get a copy right away. See you next time, friends. Thank you Doug. See you next time.