TRANSCRIPTIE 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.920 --> 00:00:18.000
Calpuder got calm in the shadows of the snow capped Alps,
2
00:00:18.679 --> 00:00:22.160
in a stone jail whose walls frowned down upon the
3
00:00:22.199 --> 00:00:27.359
most peaceful scene in Italy. Porter Charlton, a young American
4
00:00:27.440 --> 00:00:30.160
who ten years ago was still at his studies at
5
00:00:30.199 --> 00:00:34.799
Saint Luke's School, Wayne, Pennsylvania, is awaiting the day he
6
00:00:34.880 --> 00:00:38.240
will be brought before the Court of Criminal Assizes at Como,
7
00:00:38.560 --> 00:00:42.719
to answer for his self confessed crime, the murder more
8
00:00:42.799 --> 00:00:46.119
than five years ago of the woman with whom he
9
00:00:46.280 --> 00:00:50.880
was on his honeymoon. Five years of delay, three of
10
00:00:50.880 --> 00:00:53.679
them on Charlton's part and two on the part of
11
00:00:53.719 --> 00:00:58.479
the Italian system of jurisprudence. Five years during which every
12
00:00:58.560 --> 00:01:02.560
artifice of the law, every subterfuge that could beget delay,
13
00:01:03.039 --> 00:01:06.480
every plea that might move to sympathy either the United
14
00:01:06.480 --> 00:01:11.280
States or the Italian government, have been invoked. Five years
15
00:01:11.359 --> 00:01:14.200
during which, if there is any ground for the belief
16
00:01:14.280 --> 00:01:18.560
in human resource, the soul of Porter or Charlton, must
17
00:01:18.599 --> 00:01:21.680
have been harrowed by the memory of his desperate act
18
00:01:23.319 --> 00:01:30.159
Lake Como. What wonderful recollections the name inspires. The noble
19
00:01:30.280 --> 00:01:35.319
Villa d'Este, with its magnificent fountains and terraces. The beautiful
20
00:01:35.400 --> 00:01:39.920
Villa Carlada, where the masterpieces of Canova and Thorwaldsen are
21
00:01:39.959 --> 00:01:46.200
tenderly shrined, amidst acres of gorgeous gardens. The Laggio, jutting
22
00:01:46.200 --> 00:01:49.200
out on a promontory into the sky blue waters of
23
00:01:49.239 --> 00:01:52.000
the lake, and thought by many to be the most
24
00:01:52.040 --> 00:01:57.840
picturesque village in all Europe. Menaggio, with its silk looms
25
00:01:57.879 --> 00:02:03.120
and curio shops. To the north, the towering peaks of
26
00:02:03.200 --> 00:02:07.079
the first of the Swiss Alps, rising heavenward to kiss
27
00:02:07.120 --> 00:02:41.639
the clouds, and a pure embrace. True crime historian presents
28
00:02:41.759 --> 00:02:46.439
pulp nonfiction a celebration of the pioneers of true crime.
29
00:02:47.840 --> 00:02:51.639
Episode two hundred and forty six explores two more European
30
00:02:51.680 --> 00:02:55.719
trunk murders, told this time by two pioneers of true
31
00:02:55.759 --> 00:03:00.199
crime reporters, Ro Scollon of the New York World and
32
00:03:00.280 --> 00:03:06.319
Peter Levins of the New York Daily News. First up,
33
00:03:06.759 --> 00:03:10.840
Levin's The Brighton Trunk Murders tells how an American trunk
34
00:03:10.960 --> 00:03:13.840
murder led to the discovery of three other trunk murders
35
00:03:13.879 --> 00:03:17.840
in Britain. Levin's report of the string of trunk murders
36
00:03:18.039 --> 00:03:21.319
was written just before the trial of one of the perpetrators,
37
00:03:22.280 --> 00:03:25.080
and will be followed by a guardian's report on that trial,
38
00:03:25.280 --> 00:03:30.280
including a statement by the accused. But first, when an
39
00:03:30.280 --> 00:03:33.520
American newlywed woman's body turns up in a trunk in
40
00:03:33.599 --> 00:03:37.560
an Italian lake, police expect to find the groom's body
41
00:03:37.560 --> 00:03:42.479
floating nearby. But alas not a double murder, but a
42
00:03:42.520 --> 00:03:48.919
honeymoon squabble gone too far. I'm true crime historian Richard O. Jones,
43
00:03:48.960 --> 00:03:53.680
and I give you the Lake Como Honeymoon Trunk Murder
44
00:03:53.800 --> 00:04:18.759
by ro Scallon the notorious late Como Honeymoon Murder. The
45
00:04:18.839 --> 00:04:24.480
true story of Porter Charlton, slayer of wife, will face
46
00:04:24.600 --> 00:04:30.040
jury in Italy soon. Writer who heard story from Charlton's
47
00:04:30.040 --> 00:04:35.240
lips relates circumstances leading up to tragic termination of honeymoon
48
00:04:36.399 --> 00:04:45.240
slain woman had a checkered career by R. O. Scallon,
49
00:04:48.560 --> 00:04:52.560
Porter Charlton and Mary Scott to use only her maiden name.
50
00:04:52.839 --> 00:04:57.040
Had spent a month rambling through this exquisite country. They
51
00:04:57.040 --> 00:05:01.000
had gazed upon the supposed birthplaces of the elder younger Pliny.
52
00:05:01.759 --> 00:05:04.959
They had read together the rhapsodies of Virgil, who knew
53
00:05:05.000 --> 00:05:08.720
it as the beautiful Lake Larius. They had pondered over
54
00:05:08.759 --> 00:05:14.279
the romantic tragedy of Mansoni's I Promisi Sposa The Betrothed,
55
00:05:14.800 --> 00:05:17.319
which tells of the fortunes of a peasant girl and
56
00:05:17.399 --> 00:05:21.279
a youth native to Como during the dark days of
57
00:05:21.319 --> 00:05:25.279
the Hispanic oppression three centuries ago, and they had boded
58
00:05:25.319 --> 00:05:28.759
and tramped to the scores of lovely spots that line
59
00:05:28.839 --> 00:05:32.680
the shores of the Upper and the Lower Lakes. Though
60
00:05:32.720 --> 00:05:35.879
planning to move on to the more imposing scenes along
61
00:05:35.920 --> 00:05:39.399
the Rhine, they had been overcome, as every lover of
62
00:05:39.519 --> 00:05:44.240
nature is, by the simple beauty of Como, simple yet
63
00:05:44.279 --> 00:05:49.160
gorgeous and inspiring. So they rented a small villa that
64
00:05:49.199 --> 00:05:52.600
they might enjoy the surrounding unhampered by the necessities of
65
00:05:52.639 --> 00:05:57.240
hotel life. And therefore, in the little villa by the lakeside,
66
00:05:57.360 --> 00:05:59.879
in the twilight of a sunset such as one
Load full transcript
must
67
00:05:59.879 --> 00:06:03.879
go there to see Porter Charlton club Mary Scott to
68
00:06:03.959 --> 00:06:07.439
death with a mallet, jammed her palpitating body into a
69
00:06:07.480 --> 00:06:12.319
trunk and hurled it all into the darkening waters. And
70
00:06:12.399 --> 00:06:19.040
this was her honeymoon. A black picture in truth, But
71
00:06:19.160 --> 00:06:21.560
let us lift an edge of the pall that fell
72
00:06:21.680 --> 00:06:25.720
so suddenly that night of June eighth, nineteen ten, over
73
00:06:25.759 --> 00:06:30.120
the Villa Legnazzi, for then once the Villa Charlton, in
74
00:06:30.160 --> 00:06:35.199
the little town of Multrassio. Porter Charlton slept after his crime,
75
00:06:36.199 --> 00:06:39.680
slept the sleep that oftentimes comes to the prisoner about
76
00:06:39.759 --> 00:06:44.120
to be executed. Perhaps in his dreams, he reviewed the
77
00:06:44.160 --> 00:06:47.680
story of his short, tragic intimacy with the woman he
78
00:06:47.720 --> 00:06:56.120
had just murdered. He had seen her in Peacock Alley,
79
00:06:56.639 --> 00:07:00.560
that strolling place of the Waldorf Astoria Hotel, New York.
80
00:07:01.360 --> 00:07:04.720
He was a clerk in the National City Bank, placed
81
00:07:04.720 --> 00:07:08.759
there through the influence of his father, Paul Charlton of Washington.
82
00:07:09.360 --> 00:07:12.560
The elder Charleton had been a classmate of President taft
83
00:07:12.600 --> 00:07:15.399
At Yale and had obtained a position in the courts
84
00:07:15.439 --> 00:07:18.959
of Puerto Rico, which entitled him to the rank of judge.
85
00:07:19.439 --> 00:07:22.600
When Porter Charleton wanted to go to New York, his
86
00:07:22.720 --> 00:07:26.319
father placed him in the largest bank of the United States, and,
87
00:07:26.439 --> 00:07:30.160
through his influence, the stripling he was not yet twenty,
88
00:07:30.600 --> 00:07:35.399
had an excellent opportunity for advancement. Young Charleton was threatened
89
00:07:35.399 --> 00:07:38.439
with consumption, and was warned not to work too hard
90
00:07:38.480 --> 00:07:43.199
and to avoid all dissipations and indulgences. For a while,
91
00:07:43.279 --> 00:07:45.800
he was so steady that he was looked upon at
92
00:07:45.800 --> 00:07:49.240
the bank as a model clerk, but the glamour of
93
00:07:49.319 --> 00:07:52.959
New York was too much for him. Missus Castle, as
94
00:07:53.000 --> 00:07:57.279
the woman was then known, fascinated him. She was the
95
00:07:57.360 --> 00:08:02.000
grass widow of Neville Castle, san Francisco lawyer who had
96
00:08:02.040 --> 00:08:07.560
gone to Alaska to retrieve his shattered fortunes. As Mary Scott,
97
00:08:07.839 --> 00:08:10.720
she had been a belle of San Francisco twenty years
98
00:08:10.759 --> 00:08:14.240
before she met Charlton, and as Missus Castle, she led
99
00:08:14.240 --> 00:08:18.560
the Pacific Coast lawyer along a spendthrift life. A short
100
00:08:18.639 --> 00:08:22.720
career
on the stage led to her downfall. She played
101
00:08:22.759 --> 00:08:26.160
in Tim Frawley's Stock Company in the California Theater in
102
00:08:26.279 --> 00:08:29.920
San Francisco in nineteen hundred and made a hit as
103
00:08:30.040 --> 00:08:34.840
fay Zulaine in The Princess and the Butterfly. As the
104
00:08:34.919 --> 00:08:39.000
daughter of Henry Harrison Scott of San Francisco, she claimed
105
00:08:39.039 --> 00:08:43.320
a distant cousinship with former President Benjamin Harrison, and her brother,
106
00:08:43.759 --> 00:08:47.159
named after his father, was an officer in the United
107
00:08:47.200 --> 00:08:56.039
States Army. Between nineteen hundred and nineteen oh nine, she
108
00:08:56.159 --> 00:08:59.279
drifted to New York and there formed the acquaintance of
109
00:08:59.320 --> 00:09:03.639
a broker, William B. Craig. She was seen with him
110
00:09:03.720 --> 00:09:08.279
a good deal and entertained a lively jealousy of his wife.
111
00:09:08.360 --> 00:09:12.679
They quarreled, for the woman was of an intensely emotional disposition,
112
00:09:13.440 --> 00:09:16.759
and on August third, nineteen o nine, she attempted to
113
00:09:16.759 --> 00:09:20.240
shoot him as he passed her in Peacock Alley. A
114
00:09:20.320 --> 00:09:24.159
tiny twenty two caliber revolver was her weapon, and with
115
00:09:24.279 --> 00:09:27.360
much theatricalism, she rushed up to him in a crowded
116
00:09:27.360 --> 00:09:32.399
hotel corridor and pulled the trigger. The small bullet struck
117
00:09:32.399 --> 00:09:36.159
a fountain pen in Craig's vest pocket, and was deflected
118
00:09:36.240 --> 00:09:41.159
and spent without inflicting any injury. Missus Castle was arrested
119
00:09:41.200 --> 00:09:44.399
and held in three thousand dollars bail for the grand jury.
120
00:09:45.320 --> 00:09:49.039
She pleaded earnestly with the broker not to press the complaint,
121
00:09:49.600 --> 00:09:54.480
but he was obdurate. Her brother, Captain Harrison Scott, went
122
00:09:54.559 --> 00:10:00.240
on from Fort Wright Fisher's Island, New York, and obtained
123
00:10:00.240 --> 00:10:05.159
her release on bail. When the time came, however, to
124
00:10:05.200 --> 00:10:09.279
press the charge before the grand jury. Broker Craig relented
125
00:10:09.440 --> 00:10:13.600
and the case was dropped. Captain Scott then begged his
126
00:10:13.720 --> 00:10:23.200
sister to settle down and avoid the temptations of Broadway.
127
00:10:23.360 --> 00:10:26.960
Her case had aroused the interest of young Charlton, and
128
00:10:27.039 --> 00:10:30.240
when he met her accidentally, he was fascinated by the woman.
129
00:10:31.000 --> 00:10:33.600
She was pleased at the attentions the good looking young
130
00:10:33.639 --> 00:10:36.440
bank clerk paid to her, and although old enough to
131
00:10:36.480 --> 00:10:39.159
be his mother, she led him on to believe that
132
00:10:39.200 --> 00:10:45.600
she loved him. Meanwhile, lawyer Neville, turned prospector in Alaska,
133
00:10:46.039 --> 00:10:49.159
obtained a decree of divorce against her, and once more
134
00:10:49.320 --> 00:10:52.960
she was free playing her charms upon the youth. She
135
00:10:53.039 --> 00:10:56.120
led him into marriage, and on May twelfth, nineteen ten,
136
00:10:56.639 --> 00:11:00.600
they were married secretly at Wilmington, Delaware, by Reverend Doctor Clay,
137
00:11:00.960 --> 00:11:04.919
then of Philadelphia, but since gone to Seattle. She gave
138
00:11:04.919 --> 00:11:07.919
her age then as twenty seven, he is twenty five,
139
00:11:08.519 --> 00:11:12.000
both of them misstatements, since he was barely twenty one
140
00:11:12.399 --> 00:11:16.879
and she was almost forty. Charlton's parents knew nothing of
141
00:11:16.919 --> 00:11:19.879
the marriage till it had been accomplished, and they were
142
00:11:19.919 --> 00:11:24.240
surprised and chagrined. Captain Scott did not hear of the
143
00:11:24.279 --> 00:11:28.120
marriage for some time afterward. The marriage of the bank
144
00:11:28.159 --> 00:11:31.039
clerk to a woman who had achieved such an unenviable
145
00:11:31.080 --> 00:11:35.240
reputation was hardly pleasing to the officials of the National
146
00:11:35.279 --> 00:11:38.879
City Bank, and they were relieved when young Charlton announced
147
00:11:38.879 --> 00:11:41.399
that he was going to Europe on a long leave
148
00:11:41.480 --> 00:11:45.639
of absence. Missus Charlton told her friends that her boy
149
00:11:45.759 --> 00:11:49.919
husband was going to make influential banking connections in Hamburg, Germany,
150
00:11:50.759 --> 00:11:52.679
but that they would first spend a year or so
151
00:11:52.759 --> 00:12:02.240
honeymooning through the Italian Lakes, the Alps and the Rhymee.
152
00:12:02.279 --> 00:12:04.559
Where the funds for such a trip were to come
153
00:12:04.600 --> 00:12:08.840
from has always remained a mystery. Whether Missus Charlton believed
154
00:12:08.840 --> 00:12:11.639
her husband was wealthy, or whether she assured him that
155
00:12:11.720 --> 00:12:15.440
she had plenty of funds herself. As not known. She
156
00:12:15.519 --> 00:12:19.840
had some jewelry valuable presents from several admirers, and wore
157
00:12:19.879 --> 00:12:24.080
it conspicuously enough while parading through the Waldorf and other hotels.
158
00:12:24.960 --> 00:12:27.960
It is certain that young Charlton had little money, hardly
159
00:12:28.000 --> 00:12:30.519
more than would pay for the steamship fares to Europe
160
00:12:30.559 --> 00:12:33.840
and back, and his friends have maintained that he believed
161
00:12:33.840 --> 00:12:37.720
Missus Charlton had a large bank account. She was known
162
00:12:37.759 --> 00:12:43.120
to speak in glowing terms of her fortune occasionally. From
163
00:12:43.200 --> 00:12:46.200
London to Paris, to the Riviera, then up to Como
164
00:12:46.480 --> 00:12:49.279
was their route. Those who have made such a trip,
165
00:12:49.759 --> 00:12:54.080
traveling in the luxurious comfort generally associated with a honeymoon trip,
166
00:12:54.720 --> 00:12:57.440
will realize that by the time they had reached Como
167
00:12:57.600 --> 00:13:01.120
and taken rooms there at a hotel, even an ample
168
00:13:01.200 --> 00:13:06.679
pocketbook would have been seriously depleted. During those few weeks
169
00:13:06.679 --> 00:13:10.919
of intimacy, Porter Charlton learned many things about Missus Charlton
170
00:13:11.039 --> 00:13:15.000
that he had not known about Missus Neville. He found
171
00:13:15.000 --> 00:13:18.440
her addicted to the use of drugs, subject to fits
172
00:13:18.440 --> 00:13:22.559
of depression and violent outbursts of passion, and as he
173
00:13:22.600 --> 00:13:26.000
has set himself, he discovered other things about her that
174
00:13:26.159 --> 00:13:30.639
shocked his youthful moral sins. But under her glamour he
175
00:13:30.720 --> 00:13:34.240
succumbed to it all, and soon he was himself as
176
00:13:34.320 --> 00:13:38.639
much inclined to drugs as she, and therefore developed in
177
00:13:38.799 --> 00:13:44.360
him the same moral delinquencies, the same abnormal tastes, the
178
00:13:44.399 --> 00:13:49.039
same tendencies to fits of remorse, of passion, and of
179
00:13:49.159 --> 00:13:59.679
bitter jealousy. They quarreled violently, sometimes over the wine, and
180
00:13:59.720 --> 00:14:04.799
some times apparently without any cause at all. So strenuous
181
00:14:04.840 --> 00:14:08.120
did their relations become that the hotel keeper at Como
182
00:14:08.240 --> 00:14:12.200
informed Charlton that he must ask that they find other quarters.
183
00:14:13.039 --> 00:14:16.639
It was then they rented the villa Liignazi at Moltracio
184
00:14:17.080 --> 00:14:20.919
from a countess Spalatov. But they did not quarrel all
185
00:14:20.960 --> 00:14:25.399
the time. They roamed about the lake, enjoying its beauties,
186
00:14:25.919 --> 00:14:29.039
and they were noted among the neighbors as a curious couple,
187
00:14:29.559 --> 00:14:33.279
sentimental but fiercely passionate, as though they had been imbued
188
00:14:33.320 --> 00:14:36.840
with the spirit of southern Italy instead of the quiet
189
00:14:36.919 --> 00:14:42.039
calm of the north its Palotov was their guest occasionally,
190
00:14:42.399 --> 00:14:46.039
and they had parties, which sometimes turned as the neighbors
191
00:14:46.080 --> 00:14:51.240
declared to something approaching orgies. There can be no question
192
00:14:51.360 --> 00:14:55.639
that the matter of funds was seriously agitating them. One
193
00:14:55.759 --> 00:15:00.080
by one, the woman's jewels disappeared, and so short was
194
00:15:00.159 --> 00:15:03.120
Charleton of cash that he was unable, on one of
195
00:15:03.159 --> 00:15:08.080
their boat rides to pay the boatman his eight cent charge.
196
00:15:08.279 --> 00:15:11.679
Those who supplied the villa with fruit, vegetable milk, and
197
00:15:11.759 --> 00:15:14.960
so forth found that their bills were allowed to run,
198
00:15:15.360 --> 00:15:21.320
and they were constantly put off with excuses. Quarrels became
199
00:15:21.399 --> 00:15:25.240
more frequent, and at night, fishermen whose boats neared the
200
00:15:25.360 --> 00:15:30.240
villa Ignazi heard high pitched voices and sounds of struggles.
201
00:15:32.399 --> 00:15:36.639
Then came that day of June eighth. It had been
202
00:15:36.679 --> 00:15:40.679
a remarkable day even for that country, and the Charltons
203
00:15:40.720 --> 00:15:45.080
had enjoyed a walk to the village and back that evening.
204
00:15:45.639 --> 00:15:49.519
The woman complained of being tired, and from that her
205
00:15:49.559 --> 00:15:54.639
complaints turned to other things. Money, or the lack of it.
206
00:15:54.759 --> 00:16:00.279
Was won porter's youth and innocence. She often taunted him
207
00:16:00.279 --> 00:16:05.559
with it, he has said, was another her own worldly wisdom,
208
00:16:05.919 --> 00:16:10.039
her disappointment in him from all the standpoints of a husband.
209
00:16:10.840 --> 00:16:14.440
All these she flung at him, and he replied in kind.
210
00:16:15.600 --> 00:16:20.360
He told her that she had ruined him. The woman,
211
00:16:21.039 --> 00:16:24.120
trained from her stage days to crack her tongue and
212
00:16:24.320 --> 00:16:28.080
taunts like the snap of a whip, sneered at him,
213
00:16:28.279 --> 00:16:33.039
reviled him, spurned him. The hidden devil in the body
214
00:16:33.159 --> 00:16:36.919
rose to the surface, and, seizing the wooden mallet with
215
00:16:36.960 --> 00:16:40.000
which he had been working on a broken chair, he
216
00:16:40.159 --> 00:16:41.600
hurled himself upon her.
217
00:16:48.279 --> 00:16:50.799
You can pay more if you want, but rent is
218
00:16:50.879 --> 00:16:52.480
just a buck a week at the safe house for
219
00:16:52.559 --> 00:16:55.919
all the horror and indignation you can stand. With full
220
00:16:56.000 --> 00:17:00.159
access to over four hundred commercial free episodes exploring the scandals,
221
00:17:00.240 --> 00:17:04.400
scoundrels and scourges of the past, plus direct access to
222
00:17:04.440 --> 00:17:08.640
the Boss and whatever personal services you require. Register at
223
00:17:08.799 --> 00:17:14.079
www dot patreon dot com. Slash true crime Historian The
224
00:17:14.119 --> 00:17:15.119
past is present.
225
00:17:16.480 --> 00:17:19.799
Exhausted by the struggles in the labor of hurling the
226
00:17:19.839 --> 00:17:22.440
trunk in which he had flung her body down the
227
00:17:22.480 --> 00:17:27.200
stairs and into the lake, Porter Charlton lay down to sleep.
228
00:17:28.559 --> 00:17:32.079
It was daylight when he woke, and the scene around
229
00:17:32.160 --> 00:17:36.880
and brought him quickly to his shattered senses. A statuette
230
00:17:36.920 --> 00:17:40.799
of love lay in fragments on the floor around him.
231
00:17:40.799 -->
00:17:46.920
Everywhere were the evidences of his crime. Dazed, he pondered
232
00:17:46.960 --> 00:17:50.319
what to do, giving the latter a list of the
233
00:17:50.319 --> 00:17:53.720
people missus Charlton wished announcements of their marriage sent to
234
00:17:54.880 --> 00:17:57.640
the pen and paper were still at hand, and with
235
00:17:57.720 --> 00:18:02.240
trembling fingers, he wrote two identical notes, addressed to Ispalatov,
236
00:18:02.359 --> 00:18:06.240
his landlord, saying that owing to a sudden cable message
237
00:18:06.440 --> 00:18:09.799
mister and Missus Charlton have been obliged to leave quickly.
238
00:18:11.160 --> 00:18:14.119
One message he left on the table should his Palatov
239
00:18:14.200 --> 00:18:17.279
come to the villa. The other he sealed and later
240
00:18:17.400 --> 00:18:22.839
dropped unstamped in a mailbox. Then he straightened out the
241
00:18:22.920 --> 00:18:26.920
room to some extent, and packing a suitcase, hurriedly set
242
00:18:26.960 --> 00:18:31.160
out for Como. There he entered a shop where he
243
00:18:31.279 --> 00:18:35.599
was not known, and made inquiries concerning the boats for America.
244
00:18:36.839 --> 00:18:40.440
That was the first step that led to its capture.
245
00:18:46.160 --> 00:18:51.519
Charlton vanished. All was peaceful for two days till fishermen
246
00:18:51.640 --> 00:18:55.599
got their lines tangled in the trunk. They dragged it
247
00:18:55.640 --> 00:18:58.400
to the surface at the foot of the villa Ignazi dock,
248
00:18:58.880 --> 00:19:03.359
and stood horrified when they found its contents. The crushed
249
00:19:03.400 --> 00:19:07.079
body was soon identified as that of Missus Charlton, and
250
00:19:07.200 --> 00:19:10.279
quiet late Como had a sensation from which it has
251
00:19:10.359 --> 00:19:15.519
not yet recovered, though five years have elapsed. A search
252
00:19:15.559 --> 00:19:19.720
of the villa produced the note to a Spalatov. The Russian,
253
00:19:19.880 --> 00:19:23.279
who was not regarded in a friendly way, fell under
254
00:19:23.279 --> 00:19:27.839
suspicion at once among the villagers. Charlton's absence led to
255
00:19:27.880 --> 00:19:30.960
the belief that he had been murdered also, and there
256
00:19:31.039 --> 00:19:34.400
sprang up a theory that is Palatov's attentions to Missus
257
00:19:34.519 --> 00:19:38.240
Charlton had led to a quarrel in which Charlton had
258
00:19:38.319 --> 00:19:41.519
lost his life, and that the Russian had then killed
259
00:19:41.559 --> 00:19:47.359
the woman to conceal his crime. This Palatov smiled, shrugged
260
00:19:47.359 --> 00:19:51.440
his shoulders, denied any knowledge of the crime, and notified
261
00:19:51.480 --> 00:19:56.480
the Russian ambassador of his predicament. The cables to New
262
00:19:56.599 --> 00:20:00.559
York burned with the news, and ex Judge Charlton requested
263
00:20:00.559 --> 00:20:04.319
that Ambassador Leischman be urged to make a personal investigation.
264
00:20:05.559 --> 00:20:08.559
The lake was dragged for another trunk in which it
265
00:20:08.599 --> 00:20:11.559
was feared the body of Charleton would be found, and
266
00:20:11.720 --> 00:20:16.079
divers examined all the waters around the villa's dock. The
267
00:20:16.079 --> 00:20:19.880
Italian police formed the idea that Charlton was not dead,
268
00:20:20.559 --> 00:20:23.279
but was fleeing from the scene of his own crime.
269
00:20:24.400 --> 00:20:27.519
The quarrels of the couple were recalled, and their financial
270
00:20:27.559 --> 00:20:32.599
condition was soon public property. None of Missus Charlton's jewels
271
00:20:32.640 --> 00:20:34.880
were to be found in the villa, and it was
272
00:20:34.920 --> 00:20:39.799
concluded that Charlton had taken them with him. Detectives in London,
273
00:20:39.920 --> 00:20:43.160
Paris and All seaports were asked to look out for him,
274
00:20:43.559 --> 00:20:46.720
and a minute description of the man was flashed throughout
275
00:20:46.759 --> 00:20:50.640
the police world. For some reason, it was believed that
276
00:20:50.680 --> 00:20:53.039
he would try to make his way to America by
277
00:20:53.119 --> 00:21:03.160
way of Paris, in Southampton or Liverpool. All this time,
278
00:21:03.400 --> 00:21:07.359
Charlton was rapidly making his way to Genoa. There he
279
00:21:07.480 --> 00:21:10.599
learned that the Princess Irene, bound for New York, was
280
00:21:10.640 --> 00:21:13.240
in port, and he picked up an acquaintance with a
281
00:21:13.279 --> 00:21:17.640
second cabin steward named Rhinehold. He wanted Reinhold to smuggle
282
00:21:17.680 --> 00:21:21.680
him aboard, but the steward refused. Porter Charlton had then
283
00:21:21.839 --> 00:21:25.319
become Jack Coleman, and he explained to Rhinehold that he
284
00:21:25.359 --> 00:21:28.160
had got into a little financial trouble and wanted to
285
00:21:28.160 --> 00:21:30.519
make his way back to New York, where he could
286
00:21:30.559 --> 00:21:35.519
get money from his family. Charlton then pledged the last
287
00:21:35.559 --> 00:21:38.880
of his wife's jewelry and purchased a second cabin ticket
288
00:21:39.119 --> 00:21:43.440
with which, to Reinhold's astonishment, he appeared at the boat's
289
00:21:43.519 --> 00:21:46.759
side just as the Princess Irene was about to depart.
290
00:21:47.880 --> 00:21:51.680
On the way over, Jack Coleman kept very much to himself,
291
00:21:52.119 --> 00:21:56.759
but cultivated the acquaintance of Rhinehold and Schwab. A deck steward,
292
00:21:57.680 --> 00:22:01.480
he expressed fear of a woman passing who he thought
293
00:22:01.599 --> 00:22:04.880
might be a detective, and was relieved when she got
294
00:22:04.920 --> 00:22:08.839
off at Gibraltar. At Palermo and other points where the
295
00:22:08.839 --> 00:22:12.839
ship stopped in the Mediterranean, detectives were presumably on the
296
00:22:12.880 --> 00:22:16.640
lookout for Porter Charlton, but
they did not recognize him
297
00:22:16.680 --> 00:22:28.759
as Jack Coleman. Captain Scott, at Fisher's Island, horrified at
298
00:22:28.799 --> 00:22:32.279
the news of his sister's murder, determined to do all
299
00:22:32.319 --> 00:22:36.279
he could to find Charlton, who he was firmly convinced
300
00:22:36.440 --> 00:22:40.160
was guilty of the crime. The day before, the Hamburg
301
00:22:40.279 --> 00:22:45.160
American liner Deutschland was duet Hoboken. Captain Scott obtained leave
302
00:22:45.200 --> 00:22:48.799
of absence, and, having first visited the National City Bank
303
00:22:48.839 --> 00:22:52.279
to get a photograph and accurate description of Charlton, he
304
00:22:52.359 --> 00:22:56.279
decided to meet the deutsch Land, convinced for some reason
305
00:22:56.559 --> 00:23:00.240
he would find the young man aboarder. Taking the two
306
00:23:00.279 --> 00:23:03.480
detectives with him, he went to Hoboken. They got there
307
00:23:03.519 --> 00:23:06.599
too early for the deutsch Land's landing to pass. The
308
00:23:06.640 --> 00:23:09.799
time away, Captain Scott went over to the adjacent North
309
00:23:09.839 --> 00:23:13.119
German Lloyd Docks to watch the landing of the Princess
310
00:23:13.160 --> 00:23:17.079
Irene's passengers. There was not the slightest idea in the
311
00:23:17.200 --> 00:23:21.839
Army Captain's mind that he would meet Charlton there. What
312
00:23:22.160 --> 00:23:25.799
to his astonishment on approaching the dock to perceive in
313
00:23:25.880 --> 00:23:28.960
a young man standing alone at the sea section, closing
314
00:23:29.039 --> 00:23:32.880
up his suitcase and about to leave, a striking resemblance
315
00:23:32.960 --> 00:23:36.440
to Porter Charlton, whom the Captain had never seen, but
316
00:23:36.519 --> 00:23:41.680
whose photograph was indelibly impressed upon his memory. Stepping up
317
00:23:41.720 --> 00:23:45.279
to him, Scott inquired his name. The answer came back
318
00:23:45.720 --> 00:23:51.039
Jack Coleman. Not satisfied, Captain Scott summoned the two detectives,
319
00:23:51.200 --> 00:23:55.039
who hurriedly glanced through Jack Coleman's clothing in a suitcase
320
00:23:55.400 --> 00:23:59.240
and found the name Porter Charlton on some of the underclothes.
321
00:24:00.200 --> 00:24:03.720
Without a word of explanation, Charlton was hurried to the
322
00:24:03.799 --> 00:24:11.680
nearby police station. He had been caught by the merest accident,
323
00:24:12.160 --> 00:24:16.160
and in another five minutes would have been away absolutely
324
00:24:16.200 --> 00:24:19.079
without funds. He had borrowed five dollars from the deck
325
00:24:19.160 --> 00:24:22.599
Steward Swab. With this he had paid up a small
326
00:24:22.640 --> 00:24:25.839
wine bill. He had incurred and left the ship. He
327
00:24:25.920 --> 00:24:27.759
tried to get hold of Rhinehold to let him off
328
00:24:27.839 --> 00:24:31.160
by some secret way, saying he feared detectives might be
329
00:24:31.240 --> 00:24:34.559
watching for him, and he was the first down the gangplank.
330
00:24:34.599 --> 00:24:38.240
After the vessel had been tied up and boarded in
331
00:24:38.319 --> 00:24:42.000
the police station, Charlton, after a brief attempt to maintain
332
00:24:42.079 --> 00:24:45.359
he was Jack Coleman, broke down and confessed that in
333
00:24:45.440 --> 00:24:49.279
truth he was Porter Charlton, and with that he blurted
334
00:24:49.319 --> 00:24:53.119
into tears and declared that he had murdered quote my
335
00:24:53.359 --> 00:24:59.480
poor Mary unquote under the skillful guidance of Police Captain Hayes.
336
00:24:59.599 --> 00:25:02.680
He then rode out in his own hand a confession
337
00:25:02.759 --> 00:25:06.079
of the crime. He said that he had been driven
338
00:25:06.119 --> 00:25:09.160
to it by her ungovernable temper, which had led her
339
00:25:09.160 --> 00:25:11.799
to use language to him that he could not stand.
340
00:25:12.640 --> 00:25:15.799
In a fit of fury, he said he had killed her.
341
00:25:17.279 --> 00:25:21.480
Once he had confessed, Charlton seemed relieved, and later he
342
00:25:21.559 --> 00:25:24.680
gave to the writer of this article a long story
343
00:25:24.720 --> 00:25:27.519
of the events that led up to the crime and
344
00:25:27.599 --> 00:25:30.480
what had happened that night, much of which has been
345
00:25:30.519 --> 00:25:33.960
set down here, but some of which could never be printed.
346
00:25:34.880 --> 00:25:38.720
Recorder McGovern held Charlton pending a formal complaint by the
347
00:25:38.759 --> 00:25:42.680
Italian authorities, and he was taken to the Hudson County Jail,
348
00:25:42.920 --> 00:25:46.759
Jersey City, there to remain, as it turned out, for
349
00:25:46.799 --> 00:25:51.359
three years, until August fourteenth, nineteen thirteen, when he was
350
00:25:51.440 --> 00:25:54.319
finally taken back to Italy and in the custody of
351
00:25:54.400 --> 00:25:58.640
two carabineers and an Italian Medical Army officer sent over
352
00:25:58.759 --> 00:26:05.839
to observe him for signs of insanity on the voyage.
353
00:26:06.200 --> 00:26:09.599
As soon as Judge Charlton could reach the boy, preparations
354
00:26:09.640 --> 00:26:13.720
for his defense began. Several lawyers were retained in a
355
00:26:13.799 --> 00:26:17.119
number of alienists, all to plead that Charlton was insane
356
00:26:17.200 --> 00:26:21.279
and therefore not accountable for his crime. Lawyers learned and
357
00:26:21.440 --> 00:26:25.160
extradition law were also employed, and they presently set up
358
00:26:25.200 --> 00:26:28.119
a vigorous claim that under the Treaty of eighteen sixty
359
00:26:28.160 --> 00:26:31.720
eight between Italy and the United States, extradition of Porter
360
00:26:31.880 --> 00:26:35.960
Charlton could and should be refused. It was pointed out
361
00:26:36.000 --> 00:26:39.480
that Italy had consistently refused to deliver up to this
362
00:26:39.640
--> 00:26:42.559
country at her own subjects who had fled to Italy
363
00:26:42.640 --> 00:26:46.440
after committing a crime. Here the Black Hand cases were
364
00:26:46.519 --> 00:26:50.440
specially quoted on this head, and it was urged that
365
00:26:50.480 --> 00:26:53.240
the United States could elect to declare that Italy had
366
00:26:53.279 --> 00:26:57.079
abrogated the treaty by these refusals, and that therefore the
367
00:26:57.160 --> 00:27:01.319
Italian government should not be given custody of Charlton. And
368
00:27:01.359 --> 00:27:05.279
it was pleaded that the boy, whose health was rapidly failing,
369
00:27:05.519 --> 00:27:08.440
should be sent to an asylum, not to a prison.
370
00:27:09.480 --> 00:27:13.119
After some months, during which elaborate arguments were prepared by
371
00:27:13.119 --> 00:27:16.680
the Council, and many observations of Charlton were made by
372
00:27:16.680 --> 00:27:20.680
the alienists, the case came up before Judge Blair, sitting
373
00:27:20.720 --> 00:27:25.359
as a federal magistrate. The representatives of the Italian government
374
00:27:25.400 --> 00:27:28.960
were on hand with the formal application for extradition papers,
375
00:27:29.279 --> 00:27:33.200
and the State Department at Washington, despite great influences, sought
376
00:27:33.240 --> 00:27:36.400
to be brought to bear upon it, indicated its intention
377
00:27:36.519 --> 00:27:40.720
of standing by the treaty with Italy and not refusing extradition.
378
00:27:41.680 --> 00:27:45.759
There remained therefore only the question of determining whether Porter
379
00:27:45.960 --> 00:27:50.359
Charlton was, in truth the person demanded by Italy, whether
380
00:27:50.400 --> 00:27:54.119
there was sufficient cause for his apprehension, and whether the
381
00:27:54.200 --> 00:27:58.680
papers were in due form. Judge Blair was asked to
382
00:27:58.720 --> 00:28:02.039
hear testimony as to the insanity of Charlton, and the
383
00:28:02.079 --> 00:28:06.039
experts were on hand to testify, but he held that
384
00:28:06.039 --> 00:28:08.480
that had no bearing on the matter at hand, as
385
00:28:08.599 --> 00:28:11.839
insanity could be pleaded at the trial in Italy if
386
00:28:11.920 --> 00:28:15.839
Charlton were taken there. Then he ruled that the papers
387
00:28:15.839 --> 00:28:19.039
were in order and directed Charlton be turned over to
388
00:28:19.119 --> 00:28:27.920
the Italian government for extradition. Judge Charlton's lawyers obtained to
389
00:28:27.960 --> 00:28:31.720
stay pending appeal, and the matter was argued before the
390
00:28:31.759 --> 00:28:35.880
Circuit Court of Appeals. After some months, the decision of
391
00:28:36.000 --> 00:28:40.559
Judge Blair was upheld. Many more months passed while an
392
00:28:40.599 --> 00:28:44.400
appeal was taken to the United States Supreme Court, and
393
00:28:44.440 --> 00:28:47.200
there a great argument was given on the subject of
394
00:28:47.200 --> 00:28:51.599
the treaty with Italy. It was not until June tenth,
395
00:28:51.839 --> 00:28:56.200
nineteen eighteen, that the Supreme Court handed down its decision,
396
00:28:56.759 --> 00:29:00.160
upholding all the lower courts and directed the Charlton and
397
00:29:00.240 --> 00:29:05.359
be turned over to the Italian government. Judge Lurton, writing
398
00:29:05.400 --> 00:29:09.240
the opinion, ruled that since the State Department had not
399
00:29:09.359 --> 00:29:13.200
elected to declare the treaty with Italy abrogated, because of
400
00:29:13.240 --> 00:29:17.079
Italy's refusal to deliver up criminals to the United States,
401
00:29:17.640 --> 00:29:20.440
the treaty must be held to remain in full force
402
00:29:20.480 --> 00:29:25.119
and standing. He also pointed out in Italy's favor that
403
00:29:25.240 --> 00:29:28.960
under her laws, Italian subjects who have committed crimes in
404
00:29:29.000 --> 00:29:32.319
another country can be tried for that crime in Italy
405
00:29:32.359 --> 00:29:36.119
if they flee there, whereas this country cannot try a
406
00:29:36.160 --> 00:29:39.559
person for a crime committed outside the jurisdiction of the
407
00:29:39.680 --> 00:29:44.559
United States. This has been Italy's practice and her defense
408
00:29:44.640 --> 00:29:50.200
for refusing extradition of her own subjects. The decision rendered
409
00:29:50.400 --> 00:29:54.319
two months more elapsed until the Italian government sent back
410
00:29:54.359 --> 00:29:58.680
over a proper guard to take Charlton back. He was
411
00:29:58.759 --> 00:30:02.960
landed at Naples August twenty eighth, nineteen thirteen, and taken
412
00:30:03.000 --> 00:30:06.440
immediately to Milan and from there to the prison at Como.
413
00:30:07.720 --> 00:30:10.359
Three years and two months had gone by since he
414
00:30:10.400 --> 00:30:17.480
had fled from there with murder on his hands. Italian
415
00:30:17.559 --> 00:30:23.279
legal processes are proverbially slow. Since the plea of insanity
416
00:30:23.400 --> 00:30:26.720
was to be urged, it was decided that Charlton must
417
00:30:26.759 --> 00:30:31.559
be lodged in an asylum for observation. Two doctors have
418
00:30:31.640 --> 00:30:35.039
watched him, one for the defense and one for the government.
419
00:30:36.160 --> 00:30:40.680
The latter has pronounced him absolutely sane. Other delays have
420
00:30:40.799 --> 00:30:44.079
been due to the Italian form of making an investigation,
421
00:30:44.759 --> 00:30:49.880
which is secretly conducted while the defendant awaits trial. Detectives
422
00:30:49.920 --> 00:30:52.519
and lawyers were sent to this country, and they have
423
00:30:52.599 --> 00:30:58.599
reported fully on Charlton's life history. Finally, the trial was
424
00:30:58.640 --> 00:31:02.799
set for August nineteen fourteen, but in July came the
425
00:31:02.839 --> 00:31:07.640
warlike situation which spread Europe into flames in August, and
426
00:31:07.759 --> 00:31:11.240
Italy had too much to think about to bother trying Charlton.
427
00:31:12.279 --> 00:31:14.880
While he was in the asylum and later in jail,
428
00:31:15.400 --> 00:31:19.200
Charlton had spent his time studying Italian and has also
429
00:31:19.279 --> 00:31:22.160
written in that language a detailed story of his whole
430
00:31:22.200 --> 00:31:25.640
life to date, which under the Italian law he can
431
00:31:25.720 --> 00:31:30.440
read to the jury at trial. In Italy, the defendant
432
00:31:30.519 --> 00:31:34.160
is presumed to be guilty and must prove his own innocence,
433
00:31:34.599 --> 00:31:37.839
and for that reason he has allowed the widest latitude
434
00:31:37.880 --> 00:31:42.160
in examining witnesses and addressing the jury. In fact, he
435
00:31:42.200 --> 00:31:45.079
may interrupt the trial at any time to say what
436
00:31:45.200 --> 00:31:53.279
he pleases. From August nineteen fourteen, the time of his
437
00:31:53.440 --> 00:31:57.079
trial was changed to June of this year, but Italy's
438
00:31:57.200 --> 00:32:00.960
entry into the war against Austria caused a post and
439
00:32:01.000 --> 00:32:04.319
now it has been set for October next, when Charleton's
440
00:32:04.359 --> 00:32:07.400
lawyers and his father have been definitely promised it will
441
00:32:07.440 --> 00:32:11.839
be held. The utmost punishment he can receive is twenty
442
00:32:11.880 --> 00:32:15.559
years imprisonment, because the crime was committed under circumstances not
443
00:32:15.720 --> 00:32:20.880
indicating premeditation. There is no capital punishment in Italy, but
444
00:32:21.000 --> 00:32:24.039
murderers in the first degree can be sentenced to solitary
445
00:32:24.079 --> 00:32:28.240
confinement for their natural life, which means rapid insanity and
446
00:32:28.359 --> 00:32:32.119
death in a few years. As a rule, Charleton is
447
00:32:32.160 --> 00:32:36.519
a second degree offender, will escape this awful fate, but
448
00:32:36.680 --> 00:32:39.920
it is considered likely that even if he has found guilty,
449
00:32:40.039 --> 00:32:43.400
which is doubted as such crimes of passion are looked
450
00:32:43.440 --> 00:32:49.000
upon rather indulgently by Italian juries, Charleton will escape lightly.
451
00:32:49.759 --> 00:32:52.799
The time spent in prison before the trial is always
452
00:32:52.839 --> 00:32:56.240
taken into consideration, and in his case this will take
453
00:32:56.279 --> 00:33:00.480
more than five years off of any possible sentence. Also,
454
00:33:00.640 --> 00:33:03.319
his social standing, the fact that he is an American,
455
00:33:03.400 --> 00:33:06.319
and lastly the chance that he may be considered to
456
00:33:06.319 --> 00:33:10.240
have been temporarily deranged, will all operate in his favor.
457
00:33:10.720 --> 00:33:13.599
As will too the fact that the woman whom he
458
00:33:13.720 --> 00:33:17.720
killed was so many years as senior and a woman
459
00:33:18.039 --> 00:33:25.440
of the world. In
Como, Italy, October twenty fifth, nineteen fifteen,
460
00:33:27.319 --> 00:33:31.119
Porter Charlton, the American who has been on trial here
461
00:33:31.319 --> 00:33:35.839
charged with murdering his wife in nineteen ten, was today
462
00:33:35.920 --> 00:33:40.440
condemned to six years and eight months imprisonment. The jury
463
00:33:40.519 --> 00:33:46.880
found Charlton only partially responsible and that there were extenuating circumstances.
464
00:33:47.519 --> 00:33:52.160
Owing to amnesty, Charlton will serve only twenty nine days
465
00:33:52.200 --> 00:33:57.960
in prison. Baron Schiaka, the presiding judge, before the case
466
00:33:58.000 --> 00:34:00.799
went to the jury, asked Charlton and whether he had
467
00:34:00.839 --> 00:34:05.240
anything to add to the defense. With tears in his eyes,
468
00:34:05.400 --> 00:34:10.719
Charlton exclaimed, I trust entirely to Italian justice. I can
469
00:34:10.760 --> 00:34:15.880
only say that I am a most unfortunate man. Before
470
00:34:15.920 --> 00:34:20.039
the prosecutor and the counsel for the defense made stirring pleas,
471
00:34:20.480 --> 00:34:23.639
the former for the imposition of a heavy sentence, the
472
00:34:23.760 --> 00:34:26.960
latter for acquittal on the ground that the prisoner was
473
00:34:27.039 --> 00:34:32.880
totally irresponsible when the crime was committed. His attorney, Signor Picardi,
474
00:34:33.039 --> 00:34:37.199
declared that no man in Charlton's condition could be responsible
475
00:34:37.239 --> 00:34:42.320
for his actions under any law. Charlton, under the verdict,
476
00:34:42.800 --> 00:34:46.480
benefits by the time he has been under restraint, and
477
00:34:46.519 --> 00:34:50.039
in addition, a year has taken off the sentence under
478
00:34:50.039 --> 00:34:54.519
the amnesty for all offenses committed before Italy entered the war.
479
00:34:55.920 --> 00:34:58.760
Even though he was greatly pleased over the verdict of
480
00:34:58.800 --> 00:35:03.320
the court and viewed with pleasure his approaching liberation from custody,
481
00:35:04.119 --> 00:35:09.679
Charlton maintained his usual restrained and almost passive attitude. He
482
00:35:09.800 --> 00:35:15.039
thanked all those about him for their congratulations. Charlton said
483
00:35:15.079 --> 00:35:18.159
that after his release he would return to the United
484
00:35:18.239 --> 00:35:22.920
States and join his family. Before departing, he said he
485
00:35:22.960 --> 00:35:26.840
would visit and personally thank friends and como who had,
486
00:35:26.920 --> 00:35:31.000
by their kindness, lightened the hours of his captivity, and
487
00:35:31.199 --> 00:35:35.760
especially Ambassador Thomas Nelson Page, who, as the representative of
488
00:35:35.920 --> 00:35:42.360
the American government, has seen that his legal rights were observed.
489
00:35:51.119 --> 00:35:57.119
Enjoy ad free listening at the Safehouse. Dubbadubbadubba dot Patreon
490
00:35:57.239 --> 00:36:00.079
dot com, slash true Crime, His Star.
491
00:36:11.960 --> 00:36:26.960
Will Justice, Triumph, Brighton Trunk Murders, Scotland Yards, Toughest Mystery
492
00:36:27.000 --> 00:36:36.920
in a Generation by Peter Levins, August nineteen thirty four,
493
00:36:39.039 --> 00:36:44.239
If Scotland Yard that superior detective organization might be said
494
00:36:44.239 --> 00:36:48.280
to have been flabbergasted, then it was within recent weeks.
495
00:36:49.000 --> 00:36:51.679
If ever, the people of London, who are inclined to
496
00:36:51.679 --> 00:36:55.039
be a bit supercilious when it comes to American murders
497
00:36:55.039 --> 00:36:59.280
and American detective methods, were startled out of their habitual
498
00:36:59.320 --> 00:37:03.880
hateur than they certainly were in the extraordinary case of
499
00:37:03.960 --> 00:37:09.199
the Brighton Trunk murders. Should we all live for another
500
00:37:09.199 --> 00:37:11.920
one hundred years, we shall probably not see such a
501
00:37:11.960 --> 00:37:17.079
fantastic sequence of events again. The New York Police in
502
00:37:17.199 --> 00:37:20.280
mid June had asked the Yard for help in clearing
503
00:37:20.360 --> 00:37:25.480
up the mysterious disappearance of miss Agnes C. Tuversen, prosperous
504
00:37:25.599 --> 00:37:29.800
lawyer who had married Ivan Potter Jay on December fourth,
505
00:37:30.360 --> 00:37:36.480
nineteen thirty three, and vanished sixteen days later. Potter Jay
506
00:37:36.559 --> 00:37:39.480
had been located in Vienna, where he was living with
507
00:37:39.519 --> 00:37:42.639
a woman he had married before making miss Tuverson his
508
00:37:42.719 --> 00:37:48.400
bigamous bride. Specifically, the New York authorities wanted the London
509
00:37:48.440 --> 00:37:51.639
police to hunt for a big black trunk Potter Jay
510
00:37:51.719 --> 00:37:56.360
had purchased just before the woman disappeared. They suspected that
511
00:37:56.400 --> 00:37:59.480
this trunk might contain a body or at least throw
512
00:37:59.559 --> 00:38:03.280
some luw on the mystery. Potter Jay had most of
513
00:38:03.320 --> 00:38:07.079
Miss Tuverson's effects with him in Vienna, but the trunk
514
00:38:07.559 --> 00:38:13.360
was missing. Scotland Yard hastened to comply. The people of
515
00:38:13.440 --> 00:38:17.079
London raised their eyebrows and passed remarks to the effect
516
00:38:17.320 --> 00:38:21.320
that these Americans are always disappearing or getting murdered or
517
00:38:21.360 --> 00:38:25.639
something disorderly. It was an excellent moment for the people
518
00:38:25.639 --> 00:38:28.960
of London to feel superior and make comments about the
519
00:38:28.960 --> 00:38:35.119
blundering Americans. Several officers of the London Force made routine
520
00:38:35.199 --> 00:38:40.519
inquiries at railway stations, baggage depots, travel bureaus, etc. The
521
00:38:40.639 --> 00:38:44.079
usual instructions were sent to all police stations throughout the
522
00:38:44.159 --> 00:38:47.599
country to report on any trunk left since a certain
523
00:38:47.679 --> 00:38:52.719
date and not claimed. It was not seriously expected that
524
00:38:52.760 --> 00:38:55.599
the trunk would be found in England, but after all,
525
00:38:55.639 --> 00:38:59.280
the United States authorities had asked for help, and Scotland
526
00:38:59.320 --> 00:39:03.639
Yard wanted to assist its brothers in New York. On
527
00:39:03.800 --> 00:39:07.840
June seventeenth, the detective of the Brighton Police drifted into
528
00:39:07.880 --> 00:39:11.880
the baggage room of the main station at Brighton. He
529
00:39:11.920 --> 00:39:16.159
inquired in so many words. Have you any trunks left unclaimed,
530
00:39:16.239 --> 00:39:21.119
or any trunk giving off a bad smell? Well, as
531
00:39:21.159 --> 00:39:24.079
it happened, there was one trunk which was beginning to
532
00:39:24.119 --> 00:39:28.679
offend the surrounding air. The attendant said in effect, this
533
00:39:28.880 --> 00:39:32.000
trunk had been left on June sixth, and he thought
534
00:39:32.039 --> 00:39:35.559
more than once of opening it. He showed the detective
535
00:39:35.559 --> 00:39:38.519
of the trunk. It did not fit the description of
536
00:39:38.559 --> 00:39:44.679
the Tufferson trunk, but it unquestionably smelled in the presence
537
00:39:44.679 --> 00:39:48.559
of other officers from headquarters. The trunk was open. It
538
00:39:48.599 --> 00:39:52.920
contained the torso of a woman, head legs and arms missing,
539
00:39:53.440 --> 00:39:56.440
wrapped in brown paper and tied with a nineteen foot
540
00:39:56.559 --> 00:40:00.679
length of new cord. The woman was aged about twenty
541
00:40:00.679 --> 00:40:04.199
five or thirty and had been dead about three weeks.
542
00:40:05.239 --> 00:40:08.320
The only writing to be found was the syllable ford
543
00:40:08.599 --> 00:40:12.440
on the edge of a torn portion. This apparently was
544
00:40:12.480 --> 00:40:15.760
the end of a word, possibly the name of a town.
545
00:40:16.760 --> 00:40:20.840
Wires hummed between London and New York. The people of
546
00:40:20.880 --> 00:40:24.559
Britain nodded their heads pridefully and told each other that
547
00:40:24.639 --> 00:40:29.559
Scotland Yard had solved that New York mystery. Speedy work, eh.
548
00:40:30.599 --> 00:40:34.440
But almost immediately it was definitely established that this was
549
00:40:34.559 --> 00:40:39.840
not Agnes Tooverson. Experts rushed from London to the seaside
550
00:40:39.880 --> 00:40:44.199
resort of Brighton. The finest criminal brains of Scotland yard,
551
00:40:44.320 --> 00:40:48.880
including Sir Bernard Spillsbury, the famed pathologist who has called
552
00:40:48.920 --> 00:40:54.400
the modern Sherlock Holmes, tackled the case. All police stations
553
00:40:54.440 --> 00:40:59.360
in England were informed of the gruesome discovery. A widespread
554
00:40:59.480 --> 00:41:02.480
search for the missing portions
of the body netted a
555
00:41:02.519 --> 00:41:06.760
suitcase containing the legs. It had been left at the
556
00:41:06.760 --> 00:41:09.920
cloakroom of the King's Crossing Station the day after the
557
00:41:09.960 --> 00:41:14.119
trunk had been deposited and brightened. The remains of a
558
00:41:14.199 --> 00:41:17.039
label adhered to the new case, but there was no
559
00:41:17.199 --> 00:41:21.639
riding or printing to be found. Officers noted that the
560
00:41:21.639 --> 00:41:25.239
toes of the victim had been carefully pedicured and the
561
00:41:25.360 --> 00:41:30.719
nails polished and tinted. An extensive hunt for the missing
562
00:41:30.800 --> 00:41:35.960
head and arms brought no results. The head was, of course,
563
00:41:36.400 --> 00:41:41.280
the most vital clue to the whole mystery. Presently, the
564
00:41:41.320 --> 00:41:45.400
baggage man at Brighton detected a telltale odor issuing from
565
00:41:45.400 --> 00:41:49.360
a small fish basket. As every piece of baggage had
566
00:41:49.360 --> 00:41:52.679
been opened and examined the baggage room had not been
567
00:41:52.719 --> 00:41:57.800
subjected to a further search. Excitedly, the attendant called the police,
568
00:41:58.079 --> 00:42:03.159
who hastened to the station expect to find the missing fragments. Instead,
569
00:42:03.880 --> 00:42:07.800
they found the body of a newborn baby girl. When
570
00:42:07.840 --> 00:42:11.800
the newspapers learned of the newest discovery, they decided that
571
00:42:11.840 --> 00:42:14.719
the child had belonged to the murdered woman, and she,
572
00:42:15.039 --> 00:42:19.039
having threatened the father, probably a married man with exposure,
573
00:42:19.639 --> 00:42:23.800
had promptly been silenced as well as the child. But
574
00:42:23.840 --> 00:42:26.440
this turned out to be a mistake in theory. For
575
00:42:26.519 --> 00:42:29.920
three days after the discovery of the torso, the police
576
00:42:29.960 --> 00:42:32.920
announced that the woman had been about to become a mother.
577
00:42:33.559 --> 00:42:37.920
The newspapers criticized the authorities for withholding this vital information
578
00:42:38.039 --> 00:42:41.199
from the public. The press also pointed out that the
579
00:42:41.239 --> 00:42:45.719
police might work more efficiently were somewhat official in charge.
580
00:42:45.719 --> 00:42:49.800
Captain William J. Hutchinson, chief Constable of Brighton, was being
581
00:42:49.840 --> 00:42:53.719
assisted by Chief Inspector Donaldson and Detective Sergeant Sorel of
582
00:42:53.760 --> 00:42:56.719
the Yard, but none of these was in full command.
583
00:42:58.039 --> 00:43:00.800
While a house to house canvas was being pushed with
584
00:43:00.840 --> 00:43:05.159
a small army of officers taking part. Captain Hutchinson said
585
00:43:05.199 --> 00:43:08.599
on June twentieth, quote, we are definitely of the opinion
586
00:43:08.639 --> 00:43:11.000
that the information which will lead to the discovery of
587
00:43:11.039 --> 00:43:14.159
the offenders, the identity of the victim, and the recovery
588
00:43:14.199 --> 00:43:16.320
of the head and arms which are missing, will be
589
00:43:16.360 --> 00:43:19.440
obtained from the public. To have committed a crime of
590
00:43:19.440 --> 00:43:23.000
this kind without having left some trace or aroused someone's
591
00:43:23.039 --> 00:43:29.719
suspicion is beyond belief unquote. Hundreds of false clues were traced,
592
00:43:30.159 --> 00:43:34.440
hundreds of persons were questioned. Photographs of the trunk and
593
00:43:34.559 --> 00:43:39.039
suitcase were printed in newspapers all over the land. Doctors
594
00:43:39.079 --> 00:43:42.840
and maternity nurses were asked for information concerning young women
595
00:43:43.079 --> 00:43:47.000
who had come for advice. Lists of names of missing
596
00:43:47.039 --> 00:43:51.679
girls were published. Thousands of replies poured into Scotland yard,
597
00:43:51.880 --> 00:43:56.480
but they all led nowhere. Completely baffled the police and
598
00:43:56.559 --> 00:44:02.000
their desperation consulted Miss Jene Dennis, American clairvoyant who has
599
00:44:02.039 --> 00:44:06.559
on occasion made some startling accurate conclusions in robbery and
600
00:44:06.679 --> 00:44:11.480
murder cases. Her information, which was given front space in
601
00:44:11.519 --> 00:44:15.480
the newspapers, was as follows. She said that the Brighton
602
00:44:15.559 --> 00:44:18.920
trunk murder was connected with another murder. She said the
603
00:44:19.000 --> 00:44:21.840
murder took place near the railway and near the water.
604
00:44:22.559 --> 00:44:24.960
She said that the murderer was a foreign man or
605
00:44:25.000 --> 00:44:27.960
had a foreign name beginning with a letter M or F,
606
00:44:28.480 --> 00:44:31.320
that he was about thirty three with dark curly hair.
607
00:44:32.280 --> 00:44:34.440
She said that he was either tongue tied or had
608
00:44:34.480 --> 00:44:38.639
a speech impediment. Tense excitement prevailed when a skull was
609
00:44:38.679 --> 00:44:42.360
reported having been seen on the Brighton Sands at high tide.
610
00:44:43.199 --> 00:44:46.119
Police dashed to the spot and as soon as the
611
00:44:46.199 --> 00:44:51.199
tide receded, started digging feverishly. All they recovered was a
612
00:44:51.239 --> 00:44:54.360
part of a skull which a medical student had either
613
00:44:54.440 --> 00:44:57.719
placed the spot for a joke or had thrown away.
614
00:44:58.880 --> 00:45:02.639
At one time believed they had a definite clue when
615
00:45:02.679 --> 00:45:05.159
a woman in New England said that the writing on
616
00:45:05.199 --> 00:45:08.159
the brown paper in which the torso had been wrapped
617
00:45:08.639 --> 00:45:13.760
looked like her handwriting, but this fizzled out. Also, all
618
00:45:13.800 --> 00:45:17.559
attempts to trace the trunk failed. The firm which made
619
00:45:17.599 --> 00:45:20.159
the trunk could not say who had purchased it, as
620
00:45:20.280 --> 00:45:23.000
hundreds were sent out to all parts of the country
621
00:45:23.079 --> 00:45:27.320
every week. Meanwhile, the house to house canvas of Brighton,
622
00:45:27.480 --> 00:45:32.320
Hove and other seaside resorts continued. One day in the
623
00:45:32.360 --> 00:45:36.039
first week of July, an officer called at a house
624
00:45:36.079 --> 00:45:41.159
on Kemp Street, Brighton. No one was in neighbors on
625
00:45:41.199 --> 00:45:43.960
either side of the house. Explained that the lower floor
626
00:45:44.000 --> 00:45:46.920
of the house was empty and that the owners, an
627
00:45:46.960 --> 00:45:50.880
elderly couple, were moving down from London to take possession.
628
00:45:51.840 --> 00:45:54.840
As for the upper floor, this was occupied by a
629
00:45:54.880 --> 00:45:59.119
waiter in a cafe on Brighton Esplanade. The waiter's name
630
00:45:59.599 --> 00:46:04.000
was Tone Mansini. As a result of this information, the
631
00:46:04.039 --> 00:46:08.480
police troubled no further with the house on Kemp Street. However,
632
00:46:08.559 --> 00:46:14.079
as a precaution, they later questioned Mancini. He seemed nervous
633
00:46:14.079 --> 00:46:18.320
and excitable, but the officers found nothing suspicious about his
634
00:46:18.480 --> 00:46:23.920
behavior and he was released. Four days later, the elderly
635
00:46:23.960 --> 00:46:28.079
couple moved into the lower half of the house. Deciding
636
00:46:28.119 --> 00:46:31.119
that the dwelling needed a coat of paint, they called
637
00:46:31.159 --> 00:46:34.239
in the painters, who began work at once on the
638
00:46:34.280 --> 00:46:39.119
outside of the house. The following day, the police questioned
639
00:46:39.159 --> 00:46:42.920
Mancini again, not so much as to cross examine him
640
00:46:42.960 --> 00:46:45.119
as to find out from him the address of a
641
00:46:45.159 --> 00:46:48.239
woman friend of his, who he had told the officers
642
00:46:48.280 --> 00:46:51.800
had gone to London. As she was a dancer, the
643
00:46:51.840 --> 00:46:54.920
police thought she might have been acquainted with the murdered woman.
644
00:46:55.920 --> 00:46:59.800
The carefully kept toes and nails of the victim indicated
645
00:46:59.840 --> 00:47:03.719
that she might have been a dancer herself. What man
646
00:47:03.719 --> 00:47:06.960
seen he told the police, was not made public, but
647
00:47:07.039 --> 00:47:12.480
he apparently satisfied them and was again released. The next day,
648
00:47:12.880 --> 00:47:16.719
July fifteenth, one of the painters was working near a
649
00:47:16.760 --> 00:47:19.920
window of the second floor of the house on Kemp Street.
650
00:47:20.840 --> 00:47:24.480
The window was slightly open. As he drew his brush
651
00:47:24.519 --> 00:47:26.920
down on the side of the house, the painter became
652
00:47:27.079 --> 00:47:30.960
conscious of a most offensive odor issuing from the
room.
653
00:47:32.079 --> 00:47:35.159
He informed his partner, and the two painters asked the
654
00:47:35.199 --> 00:47:40.239
elderly couple what was causing that awful stench upstairs, but
655
00:47:40.360 --> 00:47:44.039
both the old people had completely lost their sense of smell.
656
00:47:44.880 --> 00:47:48.239
The painters, knowing that all England was looking for the
657
00:47:48.280 --> 00:47:52.159
head and arms of the brightoned trunk victim, informed the police,
658
00:47:52.440 --> 00:47:55.519
who dashed to the house, broke into the room and
659
00:47:55.639 --> 00:47:59.840
found not the head and arms of the dismembered woman,
660
00:48:00.400 --> 00:48:03.719
but the complete body of a woman tightly packed in
661
00:48:03.760 --> 00:48:09.679
a large trunk under the bed. She was Mancini's dancer friend,
662
00:48:09.800 --> 00:48:15.400
violette K. She had, according to Spillsbury, been dead even
663
00:48:15.480 --> 00:48:18.400
longer than the woman whose torso had been found in
664
00:48:18.440 --> 00:48:22.880
the baggage room. Investigation showed that she had been missing
665
00:48:23.000 --> 00:48:26.159
since the middle of May. Her home had been in
666
00:48:26.239 --> 00:48:31.679
a basement flat in Park Crescent, Brighton. Violette Ky was
667
00:48:31.760 --> 00:48:36.159
well known to the theater going public. Born Violet Watts,
668
00:48:36.320 --> 00:48:39.800
one of a family of sixteen children, she had gone
669
00:48:39.840 --> 00:48:42.519
on the stage at the age of fourteen and had
670
00:48:42.559 --> 00:48:46.199
married when she was fifteen. She had danced and sung
671
00:48:46.320 --> 00:48:49.800
in reviews all over Britain and the continent. At one
672
00:48:49.840 --> 00:48:53.039
time she had earned an excellent salary, but the years
673
00:48:53.079 --> 00:48:57.000
had affected her attractiveness in her dancing. She was forty
674
00:48:57.039 --> 00:49:00.639
two when she died. The officers rushed from the house
675
00:49:00.679 --> 00:49:05.280
to the cafe, but Mancini had vanished, apparently after visiting
676
00:49:05.360 --> 00:49:09.679
the police station the previous day, he had immediately left Brighton.
677
00:49:10.440 --> 00:49:15.159
Thus were the police confronted with Brighton Trunk murder number two.
678
00:49:15.360 --> 00:49:18.360
To say that they were flabbergasted is a state only
679
00:49:18.440 --> 00:49:22.760
the truth. As for the people of London, they were stunned.
680
00:49:23.440 --> 00:49:26.760
By this time, you may be sure that Tufferson mystery
681
00:49:26.800 --> 00:49:30.800
had passed completely out of their minds. One can imagine
682
00:49:30.840 --> 00:49:34.039
that they had asked themselves just how many bodies are
683
00:49:34.119 --> 00:49:38.400
there lying around these parts. The newest discovery was a
684
00:49:38.440 --> 00:49:42.719
severe blow to Brighton. This popular resort had just started
685
00:49:42.760 --> 00:49:47.599
the busiest part of the summer season. Concessionaires saw ruins
686
00:49:47.599 --> 00:49:51.000
staring at them in the face, for with a murderer
687
00:49:51.039 --> 00:49:55.599
at large, there might be a concerted exodus from the place. Moreover,
688
00:49:55.719 --> 00:49:58.840
the local authorities had just been engaging in a scrap
689
00:49:58.880 --> 00:50:03.320
with the newspapers over a particularly daring holiday poster bearing
690
00:50:03.360 --> 00:50:06.880
the words east or West bright and his best come
691
00:50:06.920 --> 00:50:10.679
on down and see me some time. An unclad girl
692
00:50:10.880 --> 00:50:16.960
smiled the invitation from the poster. Scotland Yard broadcast a
693
00:50:17.039 --> 00:50:21.440
description of Mancini. He was twenty six five feet six
694
00:50:21.480 --> 00:50:25.679
inches in height, clean shaven, with a dark sallow complexion
695
00:50:26.079 --> 00:50:31.239
and well greased black hair. Though apparently an Italian, he
696
00:50:31.400 --> 00:50:36.239
was undoubtedly British, said police. He was very fond of dancing,
697
00:50:36.519 --> 00:50:41.719
frequenting cheap cafes and dance halls. In their desperate search
698
00:50:41.840 --> 00:50:45.920
for information, the detectives gathered some significant clues from an
699
00:50:45.960 --> 00:50:50.000
attendant at a rifle range at the Esplanade. He told
700
00:50:50.039 --> 00:50:52.800
them that a little more than a month before, that is,
701
00:50:52.840 --> 00:50:55.960
about the middle of June, a man had asked him
702
00:50:56.000 --> 00:50:59.079
to carry a trunk from Violette Cay's flat to the
703
00:50:59.119 --> 00:51:03.760
house on Kemp Street. The informant identified the trunk as
704
00:51:03.800 --> 00:51:08.159
the one he had carried there. Naturally, the newspapers checked
705
00:51:08.159 --> 00:51:12.880
Clairvoyant Dennis's conclusions with what the police had discovered, and
706
00:51:12.960 --> 00:51:16.159
it was immediately seen that she had not done so badly.
707
00:51:16.599 --> 00:51:20.280
In fact, she had just about scored a bull's eye.
708
00:51:20.360 --> 00:51:23.079
She had said that the Torso murder was connected with
709
00:51:23.159 --> 00:51:26.360
another murder, and this seemed to be the case. She
710
00:51:26.440 --> 00:51:28.679
said it had taken place near the water in the
711
00:51:28.760 --> 00:51:32.480
railway station. Kemp Street is near the sea, with a
712
00:51:32.599 --> 00:51:36.280
railway running along the rear. She had said that the
713
00:51:36.400 --> 00:51:40.360
murderer's name began with an M or n F. As
714
00:51:40.440 --> 00:51:44.840
for her description, Mancini was thirty, had dark, curly hair, and,
715
00:51:44.960 --> 00:51:51.119
most remarkable of awe, he stuttered. Thirty six hours after
716
00:51:51.159 --> 00:51:54.360
the discovery of the second body, a police squad car
717
00:51:54.559 --> 00:51:58.760
patrolling Blackheath, a suburb of London, drove up beside a
718
00:51:58.800 -->
00:52:03.199
man shambling along the road toward town. His name was
719
00:52:03.280 --> 00:52:08.800
Tony Mancini. He offered no resistance. His first request was
720
00:52:08.840 --> 00:52:13.159
for something to drink. He was tired and footsore, having
721
00:52:13.199 --> 00:52:18.519
walked many miles since leaving the seashore. Returned to Brighton,
722
00:52:18.800 --> 00:52:23.239
he was locked up and held for trial. The police
723
00:52:23.280 --> 00:52:28.079
were convinced that their prisoner killed violette K. They felt
724
00:52:28.119 --> 00:52:31.880
confident that in some manner both trunk murders tied up.
725
00:52:32.559 --> 00:52:36.559
How they could not say. It was suggested that Mancini
726
00:52:36.719 --> 00:52:39.760
got the first girl into trouble and killed her when
727
00:52:39.800 --> 00:52:43.239
she threatened to expose him to violette Ka, with whom
728
00:52:43.280 --> 00:52:47.719
he was living. Then it was argued miss Kay discovered
729
00:52:47.719 --> 00:52:51.559
the murder, began to blackmail him, and was herself killed,
730
00:52:52.840 --> 00:52:59.519
but this was pure speculation. Mancini himself would not talk. Moreover,
731
00:53:00.000 --> 00:53:03.199
this theory does not tie up with Spilsbury's opinion that
732
00:53:03.280 --> 00:53:08.280
miss Kay was slain before the other woman. Scotland Yard,
733
00:53:08.760 --> 00:53:12.440
It's prestige challenged as it has not been in a generation,
734
00:53:13.239 --> 00:53:16.440
is hopeful that some scrap of information will soon turn
735
00:53:16.519 --> 00:53:19.920
up to bring this most baffling murder case to a
736
00:53:20.000 --> 00:53:29.239
successful close. I first met this young lady, violet Ka,
737
00:53:29.800 --> 00:53:33.079
who was also known as Watson. As far as I know,
738
00:53:33.320 --> 00:53:37.719
in Sadie's Cafe, Leicester Square, I was a chef there.
739
00:53:38.159 --> 00:53:42.599
It was about the beginning of September last the cafe
740
00:53:42.719 --> 00:53:45.400
shut down. She asked me if I would like to
741
00:53:45.400 --> 00:53:48.679
come to Brighton to find another job. I gave it
742
00:53:48.719 --> 00:53:50.920
a couple of days to think over, and then I
743
00:53:51.039 --> 00:53:55.079
decided to say yes. I came down to Brighton. We
744
00:53:55.239 --> 00:54:00.000
lived there since until just recently we went to Park Crescon.
745
00:54:00.599 --> 00:54:03.360
We must have lived there for about six weeks before
746
00:54:03.400 --> 00:54:07.159
I started work. I started work a fortnight before the
747
00:54:07.199 --> 00:54:11.440
Whitson holidays at the Skylark. I was a handyman there
748
00:54:11.599 --> 00:54:14.599
practically everything. I was in the kitchen and outside and
749
00:54:14.639 --> 00:54:17.880
looked after the customers. I had been working there a week.
750
00:54:18.000 --> 00:54:20.480
I started on the Sunday and on the Saturday I
751
00:54:20.559 --> 00:54:24.280
drew my first week's wages. On my way home, I
752
00:54:24.320 --> 00:54:26.320
bought a hat and a pair of gloves in the
753
00:54:26.360 --> 00:54:30.360
London Road. I went downstairs to the flat. I always
754
00:54:30.480 --> 00:54:32.280
used to ring the bell, but I could not get
755
00:54:32.280 --> 00:54:35.159
an answer. I got in through the front room window
756
00:54:35.239 --> 00:54:37.559
and she was not in the room or in the kitchen.
757
00:54:38.719 --> 00:54:41.360
I went into the bedroom. She was lying on the
758
00:54:41.360 --> 00:54:46.280
bed with a handkerchief tied around her neck. There was
759
00:54:46.320 --> 00:54:50.679
blood all over the sheets and everywhere. Well, I got frightened.
760
00:54:51.119 --> 00:54:53.000
I knew they would blame me, and I could not
761
00:54:53.119 --> 00:54:55.679
prove I had not done it. So I just went
762
00:54:55.719 --> 00:54:58.079
out and I tried to think things over what to do.
763
00:54:58.920 --> 00:55:01.079
I do not know why, but I had not got
764
00:55:01.119 --> 00:55:03.800
the courage to go and tell the police what I found,
765
00:55:04.360 --> 00:55:07.719
so I decided to take it with me. So for
766
00:55:07.760 --> 00:55:10.679
that purposes, I bought a trunk on the following Tuesday.
767
00:55:11.920 --> 00:55:15.000
She was a prostitute. There were always men coming to
768
00:55:15.079 --> 00:55:17.719
the house all the night. You have only got to
769
00:55:17.760 --> 00:55:20.639
ask my landlord, mister Snugs, and he will tell you
770
00:55:21.079 --> 00:55:23.679
I did not kill her. As God as my judge,
771
00:55:24.719 --> 00:55:26.960
I do not know. But there is one man who
772
00:55:27.039 --> 00:55:29.840
she used to live with for five years, called Frederick's.
773
00:55:30.440 --> 00:55:33.639
He is now a fascist at Chelsea. He was the
774
00:55:33.679 --> 00:55:36.800
only lover she had besides me, and he wanted her
775
00:55:36.840 --> 00:55:39.320
to go back to him, and he was very upset
776
00:55:39.400 --> 00:55:41.920
because she would not. And this is all I know
777
00:55:42.039 --> 00:55:45.039
about it. That is the truth. But this is not.
778
00:55:45.639 --> 00:55:47.760
This is where they always hit a man when he
779
00:55:47.840 --> 00:55:51.159
is out. This is libel. I have never hit a man.
780
00:55:51.719 --> 00:55:54.039
It has got here I was a notorious man for
781
00:55:54.079 --> 00:55:56.960
a number of years. That is quite untrue. I have
782
00:55:57.039 --> 00:56:00.920
never been a notorious character. It says here. Recently I
783
00:56:01.039 --> 00:56:03.159
was involved in a scene in a cafe when a
784
00:56:03.159 --> 00:56:06.119
woman was stabbed. But that is quite untrue, which you
785
00:56:06.159 --> 00:56:09.880
can prove it is absurd. I am quite innocent, except
786
00:56:09.880 --> 00:56:12.360
for the fact that I kept the body. I should
787
00:56:12.400 --> 00:56:14.920
have told the police that I found her. I bought
788
00:56:15.000 --> 00:56:17.719
the hat
and gloves for her, as I promised her.
789
00:56:17.760 --> 00:56:30.719
Then Brighton trunk mystery murder charge fails. Mancini acquitted after
790
00:56:30.880 --> 00:56:41.800
five days trial. December fifteenth, nineteen thirty four. Jack no
791
00:56:42.079 --> 00:56:48.320
Tire alias Tony Mancini, twenty six was at the Sussex's
792
00:56:48.440 --> 00:56:52.760
Eyes at Lewis yesterday found not guilty of the murder
793
00:56:52.800 --> 00:56:58.960
of Violet Saunders or violette k forty two, a professional
794
00:56:59.079 --> 00:57:03.199
dancer whose body was found in a trunk in Kemp Street,
795
00:57:03.320 --> 00:57:09.559
Brighton in July, and was discharged. The trial had lasted
796
00:57:09.599 --> 00:57:13.920
five days. The last day's hearing opened with the evidence
797
00:57:14.000 --> 00:57:18.239
of several witnesses for the defense and council's speeches and
798
00:57:18.320 --> 00:57:22.639
the judges summing up Each lasted about an hour. The
799
00:57:22.760 --> 00:57:26.159
jury were absent considering their verdict for two and a
800
00:57:26.239 --> 00:57:30.000
quarter hours. At the beginning of the day's hearings, k
801
00:57:30.280 --> 00:57:34.480
Fredericks was recalled and said that at times Saunders appeared
802
00:57:34.480 --> 00:57:38.960
to be under the influence of drugs. Walter Blaker, a
803
00:57:39.039 --> 00:57:42.360
tailor of Kemp Street, gave evidence that a pair of
804
00:57:42.360 --> 00:57:46.119
flannel trousers was delivered to No Tire on June second.
805
00:57:47.239 --> 00:57:51.320
No Tire's mother, missus Lydia England, was also called to
806
00:57:51.360 --> 00:57:55.079
give evidence. She stated that on one occasion when Miss
807
00:57:55.199 --> 00:57:58.880
Kay stayed at her house in Brownhill Road, Catford, she
808
00:57:58.960 --> 00:58:02.880
appeared to be under the u influence of drugs. After
809
00:58:02.960 --> 00:58:05.960
two other witnesses had been heard, mister Burkett began his
810
00:58:06.079 --> 00:58:10.159
final address for the defense. Mister Burkett said that all
811
00:58:10.199 --> 00:58:12.400
the evidence before the death of the woman was that
812
00:58:12.440 --> 00:58:16.960
they were friendly, affectionate, no quarreling, no rows, no anger,
813
00:58:17.079 --> 00:58:20.119
no words of abuse, no bitterness, no malice, none of
814
00:58:20.199 --> 00:58:25.440
those things that were concomitant with brutality or injury. Counsel
815
00:58:25.559 --> 00:58:28.360
said he waited to hear as no doubt they waited
816
00:58:28.400 --> 00:58:31.719
to hear. Mister Cassell's asked the prisoner when he was
817
00:58:31.760 --> 00:58:35.119
in the box a question which he thought and which
818
00:58:35.199 --> 00:58:39.199
they might think was vital to the case. The prosecution
819
00:58:39.400 --> 00:58:41.960
was saying, you took a hammer and you killed her.
820
00:58:42.320 --> 00:58:44.679
He had been waiting to hear some suggestion to which
821
00:58:44.719 --> 00:58:48.239
the prisoner would reply, why did you do it? There
822
00:58:48.280 --> 00:58:50.960
had not been a single word. It was not open
823
00:58:51.039 --> 00:58:53.800
to the crown to say that motive was not essential.
824
00:58:54.519 --> 00:58:57.840
He submitted to them as strongly as words could put it,
825
00:58:58.239 --> 00:59:00.679
that this was a vital omission in the case for
826
00:59:00.760 --> 00:59:05.239
the Crown, which in his submission, destroyed it. The prisoner
827
00:59:05.280 --> 00:59:08.960
has said, continued mister Burkett, that a man convicted does
828
00:59:08.960 --> 00:59:11.920
not get a square deal from the police. I want
829
00:59:11.960 --> 00:59:14.960
to say, as counsel that in this case, so far
830
00:59:15.000 --> 00:59:18.079
as my knowledge and information go, he has had a
831
00:59:18.119 --> 00:59:21.719
square deal. But had the case been proved to the
832
00:59:21.800 --> 00:59:27.280
jury's reasonable satisfaction, said mister Burkett, the chill of doubt
833
00:59:27.400 --> 00:59:32.119
which comes hereafter is too late doubt. This case is
834
00:59:32.159 --> 00:59:35.639
simply riddled with it. Isn't it the most astounding thing
835
00:59:35.679 --> 00:59:38.159
in the world that the case has been opened with
836
00:59:38.360 --> 00:59:41.920
morphine in the body. It may have been a fatal dose.
837
00:59:42.679 --> 00:59:45.199
It is beyond the wit and learning of men to
838
00:59:45.280 --> 00:59:47.920
tell you. But when the prisoner was in the box,
839
00:59:48.119 --> 00:59:51.079
he was not asked a single word about it. There
840
00:59:51.159 --> 00:59:54.599
was no suggestion you gave her the morphine, no suggestion
841
00:59:54.880 --> 00:59:57.920
you drugged her. The Crown had said you killed this
842
00:59:57.960 --> 01:00:00.280
woman with a hammer. Did they not think think a
843
01:00:00.280 --> 01:00:03.320
man having killed a woman and concealed the body, would
844
01:00:03.360 --> 01:00:05.920
not at least have got rid of the hammer. He
845
01:00:05.960 --> 01:00:08.599
would almost certainly have dropped it into the depths of
846
01:00:08.639 --> 01:00:12.840
the sea. Sir Bernard Spillsbury said at the police court
847
01:00:12.960 --> 01:00:15.519
that it was more likely that the injury was caused
848
01:00:15.519 --> 01:00:17.960
by the larger end of the hammer. Here in this
849
01:00:18.119 --> 01:00:20.480
court he said it was more probably caused with the
850
01:00:20.559 --> 01:00:25.239
smaller end unquote. Mister Burkett submitted that on this main
851
01:00:25.400 --> 01:00:29.159
matter the case for the prosecution was full of uncertainty
852
01:00:29.199 --> 01:00:33.519
and doubt. Referring to the evidence of doctor roach Lynch
853
01:00:33.599 --> 01:00:36.239
on the question of the stains on the flannel trousers
854
01:00:36.239 --> 01:00:39.400
and the shirt, counsel added that he had now proved
855
01:00:39.440 --> 01:00:42.400
conclusively that the trousers
were not in the possession of
856
01:00:42.400 --> 01:00:45.760
the prisoner until June second, and the shirt not until
857
01:00:45.800 --> 01:00:48.960
a much later date. In a later reference to the
858
01:00:49.000 --> 01:00:53.400
evidence of Sir Bernard Spillsbury, and doctor Roach Lynch. Mister
859
01:00:53.440 --> 01:00:58.000
Burkett said, quote men may have names and reputations, experienced
860
01:00:58.039 --> 01:01:03.360
degrees distinctions, but high and low, famous and obscure, known
861
01:01:03.440 --> 01:01:09.599
and unknown men are all human, infallible. Unquote. Mister Burkett
862
01:01:09.599 --> 01:01:12.800
said he wanted the jury to consider seriously the theory
863
01:01:12.840 --> 01:01:16.239
that he had suggested a fall down the stairs. It
864
01:01:16.320 --> 01:01:18.800
was no part of his duty to prove such a theory,
865
01:01:18.800 --> 01:01:21.639
and he was merely suggesting to them that when people
866
01:01:21.679 --> 01:01:24.559
came into court and spoke with such certainty and said
867
01:01:24.599 --> 01:01:27.119
these things could not have happened, they should at least
868
01:01:27.159 --> 01:01:31.719
consider seriously the alternative theory. Quote. There was also the
869
01:01:31.800 --> 01:01:35.760
other theory that somebody else killed this woman. The evidence,
870
01:01:35.840 --> 01:01:39.079
though it pointed to no particular man, was evident such
871
01:01:39.079 --> 01:01:43.719
as was certainly worthy of their careful consideration. Unquote. Referring
872
01:01:43.760 --> 01:01:47.679
to Violette Kay's character, mister Burkett told the jury quote,
873
01:01:47.880 --> 01:01:52.199
they ought to consider and consider carefully the probability amounting
874
01:01:52.239 --> 01:01:56.519
almost to a certainty that in this unhappy woman's dreadful life,
875
01:01:56.719 --> 01:02:01.039
blackmail might have formed a considerable part. I submit the
876
01:02:01.079 --> 01:02:05.159
prisoner spoke the truth, he said to mister Cassell's I
877
01:02:05.239 --> 01:02:07.400
know that a man with a record never gets a
878
01:02:07.440 --> 01:02:10.840
square deal. I am not concerned for one moment whether
879
01:02:10.880 --> 01:02:13.920
that be true or not. I do not know. But
880
01:02:14.039 --> 01:02:16.719
what I am convinced is to say that the prisoner
881
01:02:16.760 --> 01:02:21.679
believed it unquote. Mister Casseles then spoke for the crown
882
01:02:21.760 --> 01:02:24.360
and said that it was not necessary for the prosecution
883
01:02:24.519 --> 01:02:28.679
to establish motive. Quote. Is not the outstanding feature the
884
01:02:28.679 --> 01:02:32.960
concealment of the body. It is not such conduct contrary
885
01:02:33.039 --> 01:02:36.639
to human instincts in human nature, unless there is for
886
01:02:36.679 --> 01:02:41.440
such conduct the overwhelming reason of the guilt unquote. The
887
01:02:41.519 --> 01:02:44.239
prisoner had said that he secreted the body because the
888
01:02:44.280 --> 01:02:47.119
man who had once been convicted never got a square deal.
889
01:02:47.559 --> 01:02:49.840
But was that the thought which went through his mind
890
01:02:49.920 --> 01:02:53.199
upon that evening? Let them consider that a quarter of
891
01:02:53.239 --> 01:02:55.760
an hour before he had just left the place where
892
01:02:55.760 --> 01:02:58.559
he had been employed, and where his employer and his
893
01:02:58.639 --> 01:03:02.159
employer's wife would know what time he had left. It
894
01:03:02.280 --> 01:03:04.679
was only a quarter of an hour's walk from the
895
01:03:04.679 --> 01:03:07.920
place where he was employed to the flat where he lived.
896
01:03:08.559 --> 01:03:11.840
The woman was then dead, according to him, but he
897
01:03:11.920 --> 01:03:15.480
called no assistance of any kind and no doctor. She
898
01:03:15.599 --> 01:03:17.800
might not have been dead at all, but she might
899
01:03:17.840 --> 01:03:20.760
have been dead so long as to establish clearly that
900
01:03:20.880 --> 01:03:23.039
he could have had nothing at all to do with it.
901
01:03:23.519 --> 01:03:27.159
But his decision was in his own words, I decided
902
01:03:27.159 --> 01:03:29.360
that the only course was to keep it a secret
903
01:03:29.480 --> 01:03:32.239
until I could find out, if I could, who had
904
01:03:32.320 --> 01:03:36.320
killed her. He spent some considerable time of the hours
905
01:03:36.360 --> 01:03:38.920
of the rest of the night and eliminating every trace
906
01:03:38.960 --> 01:03:42.039
of the crime, swabbing up the blood upon the floor,
907
01:03:42.119 --> 01:03:44.679
and hiding the body in a cupboard, And the next
908
01:03:44.719 --> 01:03:48.199
morning he took the precaution of stopping Violet Saunders assister
909
01:03:48.280 --> 01:03:52.440
from coming to the flat. Mister Cassell said that there
910
01:03:52.519 --> 01:03:56.159
was no suggestion that no tire bought or administered morphine
911
01:03:56.199 --> 01:03:58.719
to the woman, but there was a definite statement of
912
01:03:58.800 --> 01:04:02.719
Sir Bernard's spills that the woman did not die from
913
01:04:02.800 --> 01:04:08.239
morphine poisoning. Mister Justice Branson began his summing up by
914
01:04:08.239 --> 01:04:11.840
saying that the jury had to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt.
915
01:04:12.760 --> 01:04:15.440
It was common ground that the woman was supporting the
916
01:04:15.480 --> 01:04:18.880
prisoner out of her immoral earnings, but that the court
917
01:04:19.039 --> 01:04:22.320
was not a court of morals. Quote, if you are
918
01:04:22.360 --> 01:04:25.400
not satisfied that she died from the blow upon her head,
919
01:04:25.559 --> 01:04:29.639
then I think you should immediately acquit this prisoner. Supposing
920
01:04:29.679 --> 01:04:32.400
you are satisfied that she died from being struck upon
921
01:04:32.440 --> 01:04:35.039
the head, you then come to the crucial point of
922
01:04:35.039 -->
01:04:38.360
the case. The question was at the prisoner's hand that
923
01:04:38.480 --> 01:04:41.960
struck the blow. You may think it possible that it
924
01:04:42.039 --> 01:04:44.440
was the hand of the prisoner who struck the blow.
925
01:04:44.679 --> 01:04:47.760
But before you so find, you must consider and exclude
926
01:04:47.800 --> 01:04:53.719
the possibility of there being other reasonable alternatives. He suggested
927
01:04:53.760 --> 01:04:56.519
that some other man murdered the woman on the afternoon
928
01:04:56.559 --> 01:05:00.199
of that May day, and you may consider that possibility.
929
01:05:01.440 --> 01:05:04.800
We have not heard any suggestion pointing to any particular man,
930
01:05:04.960 --> 01:05:07.199
and you must consider it in relation to the rest
931
01:05:07.239 --> 01:05:10.079
of the evidence. And in that relation you must take
932
01:05:10.079 --> 01:05:14.199
into consideration the actions of the prisoner himself when he found,
933
01:05:14.280 --> 01:05:16.599
as he said he did, the body and put it
934
01:05:16.639 --> 01:05:19.000
in the cupboard. What do you think of that as
935
01:05:19.039 --> 01:05:23.199
the action of an innocent man? Ask yourself, can you
936
01:05:23.280 --> 01:05:26.519
imagine an innocent man dealing in this way with the
937
01:05:26.559 --> 01:05:30.079
woman whom he says he loves. In giving your opinion
938
01:05:30.119 --> 01:05:32.599
on that question, you will form your own view of
939
01:05:32.639 --> 01:05:35.519
the intelligence of this man, Because what somebody with a
940
01:05:35.519 --> 01:05:38.599
weak intellect might do would not necessarily be the same
941
01:05:38.639 --> 01:05:41.719
as that of a man whose intellect was alive and appreciative,
942
01:05:41.920 --> 01:05:44.840
and one who had to act rapidly. Make up your
943
01:05:44.880 --> 01:05:47.920
own minds as to his intellect, and whether reasonable people
944
01:05:47.960 --> 01:05:50.559
could credit him with the folly of hiding the body
945
01:05:51.039 --> 01:05:54.920
with all it involved, unless he himself was the person
946
01:05:54.960 --> 01:05:59.519
who killed her unquote. The judge referred to the lying
947
01:05:59.639 --> 01:06:03.639
statements the prisoner made. He said that these were consistent
948
01:06:03.719 --> 01:06:07.320
with his innocence and with his guilt. If he chose
949
01:06:07.400 --> 01:06:10.039
that plan of hiding the corpse in a trunk, he
950
01:06:10.159 --> 01:06:13.920
had to lie to explain its absence. Dealing with the
951
01:06:13.920 --> 01:06:16.519
evidence of statements alleged to have been made by no
952
01:06:16.639 --> 01:06:19.960
Tire oft Aladdin's cave, the judge asked if it was
953
01:06:20.119 --> 01:06:22.960
likely that no Tire, with the corpse and the hammer
954
01:06:23.039 --> 01:06:27.000
still there, would say to comparative strangers, I slaughtered her
955
01:06:27.039 --> 01:06:31.760
out with a hammer. The judge added, quote, my view
956
01:06:31.800 --> 01:06:34.440
of this particular part of the case is in favor
957
01:06:34.519 --> 01:06:39.159
of the prisoner unquote. After referring to the clothes produced,
958
01:06:39.199 --> 01:06:41.280
he said, it seems to me that you are left
959
01:06:41.280 --> 01:06:44.280
in the position of having no bloodstained clothes upon which
960
01:06:44.320 --> 01:06:47.840
you can safely rely as having been worn by the prisoner.
961
01:06:48.039 --> 01:06:54.039
On May tenth, the jury retired at one fifty and
962
01:06:54.119 --> 01:06:57.880
were absent two hours and fifteen minutes before they returned
963
01:06:57.920 --> 01:07:14.039
their verdict epilogue. The first body found in Brighton without
964
01:07:14.039 --> 01:07:18.320
the head and limbs, was never identified, the killer never found,
965
01:07:19.079 --> 01:07:22.360
and the body of the infant girl never identified. So
966
01:07:22.480 --> 01:07:28.360
with Mancini's acquittal, all three cases remained unsolved. As far
967
01:07:28.400 --> 01:07:32.199
as Agnes Tufferson, I've added that one to my list
968
01:07:32.280 --> 01:07:54.480
of cases to look into. That was the Brighton Trunck
969
01:07:54.599 --> 01:07:59.880
murder by Peter Levin. True Crime Historian is a creation
970
01:08:00.159 --> 01:08:04.880
of polpopular media. Opening music by Nico Vittessi, closing theme
971
01:08:04.960 --> 01:08:08.159
by Dave Sam's and Rachel Shatt, engineered by David Hish
972
01:08:08.239 --> 01:08:12.920
at Third Street Music, incidental music from Podcastmusic dot Com.
973
01:08:12.960 --> 01:08:17.039
Media management by Sean R. Jones, Production assistants by Emily
974
01:08:17.119 --> 01:08:21.039
simer Braun. And as for me, I can only say
975
01:08:21.079 --> 01:08:25.600
that I am a most unfortunate man. I'm True Crime Historian,
976
01:08:25.760 --> 01:08:40.720
Richard O. Jones, signing off for now. All