TRANSCRIPTIE 🔗
1
00:00:52,707.271 --> 00:01:00,706.271
Our one pasuk for this week, Parshas Vayira comes from Perek Yod Tes, Pasuk Yod Zayin, chapter 19, verse 17.
2
00:01:00,706.271 --> 00:01:10,696.271
And here we're in the middle of the very dramatic episode of Lot and his family being extricated from Sodom before Sodom is destroyed.
3
00:01:10,696.271 --> 00:01:13,748.271
We know that the angels come to visit Lot and his family.
4
00:01:14,128.271 --> 00:01:18,517.271
They have to basically pry him out of Sodom to save his life.
5
00:01:18,830.271 --> 00:01:26,928.271
And we are told, Vayehi kehotziam osam hachutza," that when they brought them outside, "vayomer, himaleit al nafshecha.
6
00:01:26,928.271 --> 00:01:30,256.271
Al tabit acharecha ve'al tamod bechol hakikar.
7
00:01:30,256.271 --> 00:01:32,580.271
Hahara himaleit pen tisafeh."
8
00:01:33,30.271 --> 00:01:36,149.271
When they got outside, one of the angels said, "Flee for your life.
9
00:01:36,201.271 --> 00:01:39,871.271
Do not look behind you, nor stop anywhere in the plain.
10
00:01:40,140.271 --> 00:01:43,197.271
Flee to the hills, lest you be swept away."
11
00:01:43,197.271 --> 00:01:46,639.271
So they are given this instruction, Don't look back."
12
00:01:46,944.271 --> 00:01:50,296.271
And of course, as we know Eshes Lot, Lot's wife, Mrs.
13
00:01:50,299.271 --> 00:01:54,85.271
Lot, does in fact look back, and she is turned into a pillar of salt.
14
00:01:54,113.271 --> 00:01:58,851.271
This makes my top 10 list of things that are actually in the Torah that seem like they're Midrashim.
15
00:01:58,865.271 --> 00:02:02,834.271
Like, when you grow up you know a lot of Midrashim and a lot of stories in the Torah, and sometimes we conflate the two.
16
00:02:02,834.271 --> 00:02:06,420.271
Very often, we conflate things that are Midrashim, and we think they're actually in the Torah.
17
00:02:06,619.271 --> 00:02:15,951.271
This is one of those list of things along with the, a talking donkey that feel like they should be Midrashic but are actually in the text, that Eshet Lot looks back and is turned into a pillar of salt.
18
00:02:15,966.271 --> 00:02:17,51.271
Anyway, this precedes that.
19
00:02:17,51.271 --> 00:02:29,642.00938361
This is the instruction not to look back, and to me there's something very evocative and inviting that says dorsheini, So I wanted to hear, rabbis, how are you dorash this pasuk? So first of all, this is such a great choice of a pasuk.
20
00:02:29,668.00938361 --> 00:02:34,438.00938361
I really love it because- Thank you when I choose pesukim I look for the ones with the most commentaries.
21
00:02:34,503.00938361 --> 00:02:44,536.00938361
I look for the ones that are the most familiar and even though the event of Lot's wife turning into a pillar of salt is a familiar event, I definitely would've just read past that pasuk.
22
00:02:44,538.00938361 --> 00:02:45,366.00938361
I wouldn't even thought about it.
23
00:02:45,366.00938361 --> 00:02:46,931.00938361
So I'm so glad you pointed it out.
24
00:02:47,270.00938361 --> 00:02:59,94.00938361
And yeah, by the way, If we did like a survey of people in shul of a whole bunch of stories and asked them to check off which are in the Midrash and which are not, there would be so many that people would think were not in the Midrash, but really are.
25
00:02:59,280.00938361 --> 00:02:59,576.00938361
Yeah.
26
00:02:59,639.00938361 --> 00:03:03,882.00938361
And this would be one which people think would be in the Midrash, but really is.
27
00:03:03,882.00938361 --> 00:03:04,938.00938361
Yes, yes, I think so.
28
00:03:04,938.00938361 --> 00:03:05,546.00938361
Really is in the Posuk.
29
00:03:05,573.00938361 --> 00:03:17,167.00942494
That's, that'd be a great, that'd be a great test I don't know in what context you would give it out, but- Am I sensing our, our- There, there is, there is no context, but it would be fun am I sensing our very, am I sensing our very first One Posuk Podcast poll that we- One, One Posuk Podcast poll, yeah.
30
00:03:17,181.00942494 --> 00:03:23,607.00942494
Maybe like a parent-child learning night, like at the end of Sefer Bereishit you do Yeah which of these are in the text, which are not? It's in- interesting.
31
00:03:23,622.00942494 --> 00:03:24,328.00942494
It's an interesting thing.
32
00:03:24,727.00942494 --> 00:03:30,199.12131077
Curious to hear, if we put like frogs in Pharaoh's bed, what would people say? Cause it does say in your beds, Yeah.
33
00:03:30,199.12131077 --> 00:03:30,530.12131077
All right, whatever.
34
00:03:30,530.12131077 --> 00:03:31,79.12131077
It does say that.
35
00:03:31,79.12131077 --> 00:03:31,418.12131077
Yeah.
36
00:03:31,525.12131077 --> 00:03:33,41.12131077
But not even on Paros' teddy bear.
37
00:03:33,41.12131077 --> 00:03:34,686.12131077
That one- Right that's Midrash.
38
00:03:34,712.12131077 --> 00:03:34,941.12131077
Right.
39
00:03:34,953.12131077 --> 00:03:35,434.12131077
That's right.
40
00:03:36,217.12131077 --> 00:03:36,941.12131077
Or Little Midrash.
41
00:03:37,2.12131077 --> 00:03:37,794.12131077
That's Little Midrash.
42
00:03:39,125.12131077 --> 00:03:46,462.12131077
This definitely goes on another list, which is stories that you remember from when you were a kid that really require an analysis with fresh eyes.
43
00:03:46,737.12131077 --> 00:04:07,965.45464411
And in reading this series of pesukim I was going through the Parsha, another thing struck me about this passuk as I am considering and reflecting on it, When the angels take Lot and his family out, Vayehi kehotziam osam hachutza, they take Lot and otam, means plural, kehotziam osam, he takes all of them out, but then the directive is in the singular.
44
00:04:08,361.45464411 --> 00:04:12,951.45464411
Vayomer, himeleit al nafshecha, you, in the singular.
45
00:04:13,220.45464411 --> 00:04:17,182.57380571
Now, it's not clear from the passuk who the you, the singular individual, is.
46
Load full transcript
00:04:17,438.57380571 --> 00:04:18,857.57380571
Presumably, it's referring to Lot.
47
00:04:19,34.57380571 --> 00:04:29,527.57380571
In other words, all of them are taken out, but Lot and Lot only is told, presumably, Al tabit acharecha, ve'al taamod bechol hakikar, hahara himeleit pen tizafe.
48
00:04:29,527.57380571 --> 00:04:32,610.57380571
Lot is told individually, Don't look back.
49
00:04:32,610.57380571 --> 00:04:37,554.57380571
Go straight to the mountains, otherwise you will be swept away," pen tizafe, you will be destroyed.
50
00:04:37,899.57380571 --> 00:04:46,867.57380571
So at least at first glance, only Lot was given this directive, and Lot's wife, Lot's daughters, seem nowhere to be found.
51
00:04:46,867.57380571 --> 00:04:56,626.57380571
Of course, we know that that's likely not true because Lot's wife eventually does look back, and Vatihi nitziv melach, she is punished, she is swept away, if you will.
52
00:04:56,626.57380571 --> 00:05:02,756.57380571
So apparently, ostensibly, Lot's wife was given this directive as well, which therefore brings us to the obvious question.
53
00:05:03,188.57380571 --> 00:05:31,878.57380571
If this directive applied to Lot and to Lot's wife and to Lot's daughters, why is the pasuk in the singular? And lest you say, "Well, it's just in the singular, but it applies to everybody," the beginning of the pasuk explicitly says, So there's an abrupt shift within the pasuk itself in referring to everybody, to referring specifically only to the individual.
54
00:05:32,7.57380571 --> 00:05:35,262.57380571
So I'm just left wondering, why the pasuk is phrased as it is.
55
00:05:35,286.57380571 --> 00:05:43,893.57380571
If the warning applied to everybody, why is it only in the singular? And I don't have a great answer to this question, but it occurred to me maybe as follows.
56
00:05:43,893.57380571 --> 00:05:47,538.57380571
It's very difficult to tell someone, Completely shed your past.
57
00:05:47,538.57380571 --> 00:05:48,640.57380571
Do not look back.
58
00:05:48,640.57380571 --> 00:05:50,256.57380571
Don't even pause to reflect."
59
00:05:50,297.57380571 --> 00:05:56,279.57380571
Many of the mefarshim point out that al tabeyt acharecha isn't just a literal reference, it's a figurative reference as well.
60
00:05:56,279.57380571 --> 00:06:00,95.57380571
You have to completely cut yourself off from everything that was.
61
00:06:00,95.57380571 --> 00:06:01,137.57380571
Don't look back.
62
00:06:01,137.57380571 --> 00:06:02,293.57380571
Don't consider what was.
63
00:06:02,293.57380571 --> 00:06:03,835.57380571
Don't reflect on your life in Sdom.
64
00:06:03,836.57380571 --> 00:06:06,752.57380571
It's time to totally turn the page and start anew.
65
00:06:07,153.57380571 --> 00:06:08,554.57380571
And that's a difficult thing to do.
66
00:06:08,554.57380571 --> 00:06:24,110.57380571
But maybe what the pasuk is subtly trying to teach us is there's room in your life for thinking about, reflecting on, maybe even looking at the past from which you come, the evil past from which you come, but it cannot be done as a singular individual.
67
00:06:24,274.57380571 --> 00:06:27,306.57380571
It has to be vayehi hotziam osam hachutza.
68
00:06:27,319.57380571 --> 00:06:31,793.57380571
Lot's mistake, again, this is somewhat homiletical, but I think it actually reads well into the pesukim.
69
00:06:32,77.57380571 --> 00:06:34,853.57380571
Lot's wife's mistake wasn't that she looked back.
70
00:06:34,853.57380571 --> 00:06:42,571.57380571
It was that she looked back as an individual, not in the context of her family, not in the context of her tradition, not in the context of joining Avraham and his legacy.
71
00:06:42,772.57380571 --> 00:06:46,861.57380571
Vatabeit ishto me-achara, she looked back, vatehi nitziv melach.
72
00:06:46,861.57380571 --> 00:06:53,664.57380571
All of them were taken out, but then each of them individually was told, You can't reckon with your past all by yourself."
73
00:06:53,751.57380571 --> 00:06:56,361.57380571
Al tabeyt acharecha, don't look back.
74
00:06:56,361.57380571 --> 00:06:57,587.57380571
Tabeytu achareichem.
75
00:06:57,664.57380571 --> 00:07:08,111.57380571
As a community, as a people, as a family, you can sit and reflect and process together on everything that was, but you can't reckon with and grapple with and come to grips with everything that was as an individual.
76
00:07:08,132.57380571 --> 00:07:09,371.57380571
It will just be too much.
77
00:07:09,391.57380571 --> 00:07:10,267.57380571
Pen tisafe.
78
00:07:10,489.57380571 --> 00:07:11,621.57380571
It will overtake you.
79
00:07:11,932.57380571 --> 00:07:20,12.57380571
The demons that live within you as an individual just can't- navigate the turbulent waters if you encounter them by yourself.
80
00:07:20,12.57380571 --> 00:07:27,462.57380571
So they're all brought outside together, but then as individuals, they are all told, "Al tabet acharecha," don't look behind you.
81
00:07:27,656.57380571 --> 00:07:31,54.57380571
If you want to look back, you can only look back together as a family.
82
00:07:31,213.57380571 --> 00:07:41,187.57380571
And that ultimately I think was maybe the problem with Lot's wife, is that she refused to associate with or identify with Lot and his legacy and his family, and that ultimately spelled her downfall.
83
00:07:42,105.57380571 --> 00:07:46,611.57380571
So there's a natural application to, to your idea, which I think- It's a difficult read, I know.
84
00:07:46,613.57380571 --> 00:07:48,514.57380571
I'm just like- No I was kind of thinking out loud.
85
00:07:48,588.57380571 --> 00:07:54,824.57380571
Well, first of all I like that formulation that, you said it was homiletical, but it reads well in the language, and that's very precise.
86
00:07:54,848.57380571 --> 00:08:05,167.57380571
Meaning, this isn't sha' in the Posuk necessarily, but the ideas that you wanna find in the Posuk do track
with, how the language develops, which is great.
87
00:08:05,579.57380571 --> 00:08:19,877.57380571
And the application of your idea, which is what I think you're either explicitly or implicitly hinting to, is that when we see people make significant changes in their lives and they, for instance, become more observant, more committed to Torah than they had before.
88
00:08:19,877.57380571 --> 00:08:25,28.57380571
I'm trying to not use the word, flip out, which I think is a judgmental pejorative sometimes.
89
00:08:25,432.57380571 --> 00:08:28,779.57380571
But- Or even the term baal teshuva, which is another- That's a good one yeah but right.
90
00:08:28,782.57380571 --> 00:08:50,827.57380571
So this, but the idea is that when somebody really makes a significant, obvious change in their lives, at least I find, and I think many others do, that we have more esteem, we have more admiration for people who are able to do that in an integrated way, in a way in which it doesn't seem like they reject their past, they reject the way they were raised, their upbringing.
91
00:08:50,829.57380571 --> 00:08:52,435.57380571
But rather, they embrace that.
92
00:08:52,442.57380571 --> 00:08:54,5.57380571
They embrace that as part of their journey.
93
00:08:54,9.57380571 --> 00:09:09,139.57380571
and especially when they do that in a way in which they're able to, remain really connected to the people in their lives, their family, and their friends who maybe haven't changed or are just of a different culture, and yet they're able to be integrated the way that you describe.
94
00:09:09,141.57380571 --> 00:09:12,215.57380571
And so I think that's the natural application of this beautiful idea.
95
00:09:12,231.57380571 --> 00:09:28,18.57380571
I would actually say it's because they're integrated, it's because they- Right to, to apply this idea, because they are secure in their identity as a part of the community, it's what gives them the strength, the courage to look back at their past and actually embrace it for what it is.
96
00:09:28,371.57380571 --> 00:09:30,361.57380571
That's, so that's a, that's an important ha'arah- Yeah 'cause that you're right.
97
00:09:30,361.57380571 --> 00:09:30,980.57380571
That's what you're saying.
98
00:09:30,980.57380571 --> 00:09:38,172.57380571
You're saying that, the more integrated they are, the more they're able to make those changes- that transitions in a healthy way, and I think that's true.
99
00:09:38,606.57380571 --> 00:09:44,8.57380571
I, listen, I've seen with families within our community that have children who have gone to Israel and have come back more serious.
100
00:09:44,8.57380571 --> 00:10:03,932.57380571
oftentimes, families that are able to understand their kids and embrace them are able to foster better relationships, but it's better for the young person and they're able to mature and grow into this new identity in a much more healthy way, as opposed to situations in which I've seen, where the parents have had a hard time with it.
101
00:10:03,932.57380571 --> 00:10:08,399.57380571
not only is it more difficult for the young person, but Sometimes it pushes them even more extreme.
102
00:10:08,545.57380571 --> 00:10:08,791.57380571
Yeah.
103
00:10:08,834.57380571 --> 00:10:15,735.57380571
Because they have to reassert, they have to double down on the decisions that they're making and it creates challenges for everybody involved.
104
00:10:15,748.57380571 --> 00:10:21,882.57380571
Again, this isn't a rule, this doesn't happen every single time but there's a tendency there and I think it's reflected in it's highlighted by what you're saying.
105
00:10:22,369.57380571 --> 00:10:31,335.57380571
A few weeks ago, we referenced the Ohev Yisrael, who every single time he would give a Dvar Torah, he'd always connect it to the themes of Ahavat Yisrael, of loving fellow Jews.
106
00:10:31,678.57380571 --> 00:10:41,501.57380571
So this is like a meta Rabbi Block comment here, which is that Rabbi Block is always able to connect almost any passuk to the theme of a community.
107
00:10:41,728.57380571 --> 00:10:41,834.57380571
Yeah.
108
00:10:41,842.57380571 --> 00:10:52,962.57380571
And the communal service of Hashem versus the, tailored, personal, individualized, which is, he casts aspersion on the, overemphasis on individuality and very much promotes the notion of the communal.
109
00:10:52,962.57380571 --> 00:11:01,625.57380571
And it's it was remarkable as you were darshaning this passuk in that way, and a, a message that I, you know, is, is, is not there on a, on a simple, you know, the, on the, on the surface level.
110
00:11:01,638.57380571 --> 00:11:03,194.57380571
So I just, I was marveling at that.
111
00:11:03,194.57380571 --> 00:11:03,845.57380571
I appreciate that.
112
00:11:03,861.57380571 --> 00:11:08,223.57380571
I wouldn't say versus as the, as though the, Yes.
113
00:11:08,274.57380571 --> 00:11:09,778.57380571
I didn't know, I didn't know we were going down here.
114
00:11:09,783.57380571 --> 00:11:17,428.57380571
Yeah, I do think that that is my general inclination in reading the Torah, and applying Halakha, and living as a Jew.
115
00:11:17,519.57380571 --> 00:11:18,420.57380571
That's- And building a community.
116
00:11:18,482.57380571 --> 00:11:18,759.57380571
Yeah.
117
00:11:18,865.57380571 --> 00:11:20,236.57380571
But thank you for noticing that.
118
00:11:20,624.57380571 --> 00:11:21,556.57380571
You're such an observant Jew.
119
00:11:21,987.57380571 --> 00:11:23,518.57380571
I am an observant Jew, indeed.
120
00:11:24,801.57380571 --> 00:11:50,443.57380571
When I looked at this passek, at first I wanted to just make a simple observation that when Lot's wife was told, and when they're all told not to look back, and Lot's wife does, and she apparently is punished for that the conventional understanding is that, she had to make a separation from Sodom, right? Looking back would show some, some yearning
and some desire, and it would be hard to make a break from that corrupt culture if, if you look back.
121
00:11:50,747.57380571 --> 00:11:51,929.57380571
They needed to make a clean break.
122
00:11:52,600.57380571 --> 00:11:59,530.57380571
But I wanted to make an even further simple observation, that perhaps it was about just not witnessing the destruction.
123
00:12:00,61.57380571 --> 00:12:05,480.57380571
That that imagery is something that can really have an impact on a person and their neshamah.
124
00:12:05,891.57380571 --> 00:12:15,313.57380571
And, Love that In, in removing themselves from that world Hashem wanted to make sure that, they don't expose themselves to something so terrible and so violent.
125
00:12:15,734.57380571 --> 00:12:30,622.57380571
You could say maybe that's why Noah was put in an ark while the entire world was destroyed, and I was thinking about that, of course, in light of, our experience today, which, due to technology we're exposed to so much imagery, and it's so easy to see violent imagery.
126
00:12:30,953.57380571 --> 00:12:37,590.57380571
And it really has an impact on us, and it can either desensitize or traumatize in very real ways, and we have to be careful about that.
127
00:12:38,457.57380571 --> 00:12:41,230.57380571
I was gonna make that observation, and obviously I just did.
128
00:12:41,583.57380571 --> 00:12:48,967.57380571
But then I was thinking about the fact that at Krias Yam Suf, it says specifically "Wayar'u Yisrael et Mitzrayim meis al sfat hayam."
129
00:12:49,27.57380571 --> 00:12:49,232.57380571
Hmm.
130
00:12:49,834.57380571 --> 00:12:53,682.57380571
That Bnei Yisrael saw the Egyptians dead on the shores of the Yam Suf.
131
00:12:54,23.57380571 --> 00:13:02,538.57380571
And just prior to that, they're encouraged to look, to watch, ki asher ra'item et Mitzrayim hayom lo sosifu lir'otam od olam.
132
00:13:03,40.57380571 --> 00:13:05,607.57380571
As you see Mitzrayim today, you will no longer see them.
133
00:13:05,946.57380571 --> 00:13:15,186.57380571
That really was a visual aspect to this, that they should see the destruction of Mitzrayim, they should see the death of Pharaoh's soldiers as part of their spiritual transition.
134
00:13:15,236.57380571 --> 00:13:29,920.57380571
I think the difference between Bnei Yisrael at the Yam Suf and Lot and his family departing Sdom the reason why they weren't supposed to look back but Bnei Yisrael were supposed to look is because Lot was integrated into that society.
135
00:13:30,339.57380571 --> 00:13:32,182.57380571
There was a certain identification with them.
136
00:13:32,854.57380571 --> 00:13:42,318.57380571
And because you had that identification they needed to make, a clean break, and that looking back at something that they're familiar with, something that they're naturally attracted to.
137
00:13:42,847.57380571 --> 00:13:50,833.57380571
And so that commandment to not look back represents this idea that they really do have
a deep attachment to what they were being rescued from.
138
00:13:51,455.57380571 --> 00:14:00,136.57380571
As opposed to Bnei Yisrael, who lived as slaves, who lived as a lower class in Mitzrayim, it wasn't about not identifying with Mitzrayim.
139
00:14:00,722.57380571 --> 00:14:04,861.57380571
For Bnei Yisrael, it was about how they see themselves as free people.
140
00:14:05,159.57380571 --> 00:14:22,773.57380571
And so for them to look back meant to see that their lords, their masters were gone, and that now they are completely subject to the, the King of Kings The message I see in this, of course is we should be sensitive to the things that we really immerse ourselves in the culture.
141
00:14:22,840.57380571 --> 00:14:27,751.57380571
We don't think so much about the stuff that we expose ourselves to, the stuff we expose our children to.
142
00:14:28,187.57380571 --> 00:14:38,321.57380571
As Modern Orthodox Jews we're integrated with the society around us, and we listen to its music, we watch its TV shows, its movies, but I think that creates a responsibility.
143
00:14:38,409.57380571 --> 00:15:08,553.57380571
It creates a responsibility for us to think about what we're looking at, and what we're exposing ourselves to and to what degree does it influence us? I know it sounds very moralizing but I think, one of the things we're learning as we sensitize ourselves to the impact of social media and cell phones on our young people, on our teens and us, is that we are influenced subconsciously in ways we don't even realize, and we should just be mindful of that.
144
00:15:09,5.57380571 --> 00:15:20,376.57380571
Be mindful of that as we raise our kids, as we create our homes and perhaps be more explicit about our values, knowing that our kids are being raised by Netflix at the same time.
145
00:15:20,703.57380571 --> 00:15:27,730.57380571
I think that's such a powerful and fruitful comparison to the seeing the Egyptians and not looking back at Sdom.
146
00:15:27,731.57380571 --> 00:15:28,977.57380571
I feel like there's so many...
147
00:15:29,45.57380571 --> 00:15:36,592.57380571
you developed it beautifully, but I think it's like even just holding that up for our listenership to just think about that, that's just such a compelling...
148
00:15:37,193.57380571 --> 00:15:38,510.57380571
Even just that question is such a gift.
149
00:15:38,510.57380571 --> 00:15:41,310.57380571
It's such a great point of foil thank you.
150
00:15:41,311.57380571 --> 00:15:42,124.57380571
I'll just make a footnote.
151
00:15:42,175.57380571 --> 00:15:55,400.57380571
If you look at that chapter right before the Shira the song at the sea, if you look there's several instances where it talks about seeing- Yeah and how they see Mitzrayim and how they won't see Mitzrayim.
152
00:15:55,450.57380571 --> 00:15:55,652.57380571
Yeah.
153
00:15:55,652.57380571 --> 00:16:11,436.57380571
And I've always felt, not to give another Drash, but I've always felt that
there was a very deliberate deliberate Mila Mancha like keyword here that is marking the transition out of Mitzrayim that, there the, it's a visual experience, and that visual experience is meant to to usher in a new era.
154
00:16:11,631.57380571 --> 00:16:11,879.57380571
Yeah.
155
00:16:11,880.57380571 --> 00:16:21,114.57380571
That, I guess the what makes it so complicated for me is, number one, we have these Midrash that say that, the angels say, why are you saving the Jewish people? That these guys are Ovdei Avodah Zara, and they're Ovdei Avodah Zara."
156
00:16:21,131.57380571 --> 00:16:25,943.57380571
I take your point that we were not integrated 'cause we were a substrata of society.
157
00:16:25,944.57380571 --> 00:16:26,779.57380571
We were in servitude.
158
00:16:26,779.57380571 --> 00:16:37,250.57380571
But at the same time, we were, there is this sense in which we were not that different at that time at least in our external behaviors than our Egyptian neighbors.
159
00:16:37,431.57380571 --> 00:16:43,360.5738057
And- That's an excellent question, right? We say- and then I would say, okay, so then seeing him was meant to almost instill within Benei Yisrael you're not this.
160
00:16:43,379.5738057 --> 00:16:56,735.5738057
It was almost like a breaking of the way, as it says, Kasher Isem, the way you see them today the kinship or the fear, all those aspects that you feel today Hashem wants you to see this and destroy all the illusions that you have about Egypt.
161
00:16:56,819.5738057 --> 00:17:04,595.5738057
I- But then I would say okay for Sdom maybe look at what happens to terrible people and also, make this a clean break.
162
00:17:04,595.5738057 --> 00:17:08,405.5738057
Meaning I feel like we can muddy these waters and it's, it becomes harder to to...
163
00:17:08,422.5738057 --> 00:17:16,144.5738057
The, the question is stronger than the answer, right? But those, but those are very, but those are very instructive questions, meaning, we're taking Sdom as an analogy here.
164
00:17:16,561.5738057 --> 00:17:19,345.5738057
And but you could take the analogy in different ways and ask these questions.
165
00:17:19,345.5738057 --> 00:17:32,209.5738057
In fact, I like the way you said it, but y- you could have really said, Rabbi Hupko there's a Ba'al Kasha on what you're saying that, that Bene Israel weren't integrated like Lot and his family were in Sdom, right? They were on the 49th level of Tumah.
166
00:17:32,266.5738057 --> 00:17:32,607.5738057
Right.
167
00:17:32,775.5738057 --> 00:17:34,460.5738057
Right? They had to be rescued from that.
168
00:17:34,923.907139 --> 00:17:37,806.907139
I think that's a great question and, we can talk it out for nuance.
169
00:17:38,116.907139 --> 00:17:46,146.907139
I still think that the dynamic between, master and slave creates something different than Lot and his family being neighbors with all these people but you're you're right.
170
00:17:46,152.907139 --> 00:17:48,308.907139
And I think, we could muddy things.
171
00:17:48,580.907139 --> 00:17:53,966.907139
I think those are actually very very productive questions to challenge and refine the ideas.
172
00:17:54,867.907139 --> 00:17:57,846.907139
We don't have time for all that, but it's something for people to think about.
173
00:17:57,925.907139 --> 00:17:58,245.907139
Yeah.
174
00:17:58,316.907139 --> 00:18:07,610.907139
I really do agree about holding up this contrast as a really a f- a fruitful endeavor, and it's, really something so worthwhile.
175
00:18:07,610.907139 --> 00:18:11,630.907139
But I don't mean to, to be so predictable, but I think the answer is obvious.
176
00:18:12,503.907139 --> 00:18:36,487.907139
Which is- Community Am Yisrael as a nation- Yeah VaYar Yisrael es haYaD haGdolah, VaYar Yisrael es Mitzrayim meis os vasayam» they were able to see that- Yeah and allow it to still be able to make a clean break because they weren't identifying with it as much.
177
00:18:36,490.907139 --> 00:18:40,32.907139
They were secure in their identity as a klal, as a nation, as a people.
178
00:18:40,33.907139 --> 00:18:42,300.907139
They were able to look at that and be fine.
179
00:18:42,406.907139 --> 00:18:48,317.907139
Rabbi Pupko, you mentioned Mi Lamancha as another thing that I noticed as I was reading these pesukim is there's a Mi Lamancha here too.
180
00:18:48,332.907139 --> 00:18:48,819.907139
Himaleit.
181
00:18:48,839.907139 --> 00:18:49,636.907139
Himaleit.
182
00:18:49,665.907139 --> 00:18:49,989.907139
Yeah.
183
00:18:50,43.907139 --> 00:18:51,702.907139
Over and over and over and over again.
184
00:18:51,726.907139 --> 00:18:51,770.907139
Yeah.
185
00:18:51,770.907139 --> 00:18:52,282.907139
Fascinating.
186
00:18:52,314.907139 --> 00:18:57,427.907139
Which means, it's actually really interesting 'cause it only begins to appear in this pasuk that you chose.
187
00:18:57,481.907139 --> 00:18:57,746.907139
Yeah.
188
00:18:57,849.907139 --> 00:19:01,27.907139
Before that, when he's still at home, before he goes outside, there's no himaleit.
189
00:19:01,47.907139 --> 00:19:03,519.907139
It's vayetse, hotze, vayitzu.
190
00:19:03,886.907139 --> 00:19:08,838.907139
And now all of a sudden he goes outside, and it's, "We've got to escape," right? Himaleit means escape or to run away.
191
00:19:09,193.907139 --> 00:19:14,188.907139
Lot as an individual is running away from something, and it's really he can't look back.
192
00:19:14,233.907139 --> 00:19:14,944.907139
He just can't.
193
00:19:15,4.907139 --> 00:19:15,240.907139
Yeah.
194
00:19:15,240.907139 --> 00:19:24,340.907139
There's a certain almost weakness or vulnerability that a person has as an individual, which makes it much more difficult to grapple with that kind of thing.
195
00:19:24,405.907139 --> 00:19:24,608.907139
Yeah.
196
00:19:24,618.907139 --> 00:19:33,614.907139
And this goes back to actually the kind of Rabbi Pupko's comment about
your initial comment, which, and again, in the I'm like the chaos sower today, but, if you...
197
00:19:33,677.907139 --> 00:19:53,518.907139
No I'm not chaos, but I'm just, to problematize or take the other side of things, it's almost like you could use this as a different model of growth, not as a proof to the healthy model of growth, which is organic and step-by-step, but it's almost like Hashem is saying if you wanna really fundamentally change your lives and be saved you need a firm and complete break as a..."
198
00:19:53,573.907139 --> 00:20:17,633.907139
And you could say that a model there, which is if a person always takes if a person always takes small steps in the right direction, sometimes there's just not enough escape velocity to really change your life, right? Incremental steps- You never get anywhere you never get anywhere, right? The first piece which is the only piece in the Tzizkas Hatzadik that I know from Rav Tzadok, is that growth happens befipazon, right? Going back to Egypt, right? That the Jewish people had to leave Egypt befipazon.
199
00:20:17,637.907139 --> 00:20:18,623.907139
It had to be quick.
200
00:20:18,771.907139 --> 00:20:22,485.907139
It had to be a fast departure because you need to take a quick first step.
201
00:20:22,796.907139 --> 00:20:27,96.907139
You have to do something dramatic, and then, things then happen more slowly after that.
202
00:20:27,106.907139 --> 00:20:32,655.907139
You need that escape velocity, literally could learn from physics in order to like really make a change.
203
00:20:33,37.907139 --> 00:20:34,949.907139
And I feel like this is a, a good example of that.
204
00:20:34,949.907139 --> 00:20:37,330.907139
There needed to be like a quick severing.
205
00:20:37,343.907139 --> 00:20:38,216.907139
You can't look back.
206
00:20:38,217.907139 --> 00:20:39,594.907139
This can't be a half measure.
207
00:20:39,824.907139 --> 00:20:46,990.907139
Lot, you wanna save yourself, do this 100%, and there'll be time to reflect and do all the work and, catch up to yourself in a certain way later.
208
00:20:47,309.907139 --> 00:20:55,176.907139
But it's just another way to think about it, like I feel like a lot of times we see this going back to, let's say the gap year students who like do something really dramatic.
209
00:20:55,181.907139 --> 00:21:02,735.907139
Sometimes it's like we call it unhealthy, and maybe it is unhealthy, but maybe also you need that to like really transform.
210
00:21:02,736.907139 --> 00:21:10,765.907139
This comes back, we've had discussions in the past I've made this Ara, which I'm very proud of, which is that, there's like the, the Avrahms who completely change their name altogether.
211
00:21:11,64.907139 --> 00:21:13,599.907139
Avraham completely transforms from Avraham to Avraham.
212
00:21:13,897.907139 --> 00:21:19,909.907139
Yitzchak always stays the same, and Yaakov introduces Yisrael and Yaakov next to each other, two identities.
213
00:21:20,153.907139 --> 00:21:22,751.907139
So we have three Avos, one whose name completely changed.
214
00:21:22,765.907139 --> 00:21:24,726.907139
That's like the complete flip out, so to speak.
215
00:21:24,751.907139 --> 00:21:26,328.907139
Yitzchak, who's like always been the same.
216
00:21:26,331.907139 --> 00:21:30,486.907139
I think people who knew me in high school would say I'm just exactly the same, basically the same person as I was then.
217
00:21:30,568.907139 --> 00:21:31,469.907139
Baruch Hashem, I'm not.
218
00:21:31,709.907139 --> 00:21:33,814.907139
But, I haven't, I never flipped out, quote unquote.
219
00:21:33,816.907139 --> 00:21:40,737.907139
And then there's people who put two different identities next to each other and able to synthesize, and the Torah never quite chooses whether he's Yisrael or Yaakov.
220
00:21:40,747.907139 --> 00:21:41,631.907139
It keeps going back and forth.
221
00:21:41,696.907139 --> 00:21:44,539.907139
Anyway, I'm just again I'm making trouble in a, in a positive way.
222
00:21:44,540.907139 --> 00:21:49,282.907139
I just think these are these are fruitful and- Sure and that you can say these things and see these things otherwise all right.
223
00:21:49,681.907139 --> 00:21:50,207.907139
Fantastic.
224
00:21:50,207.907139 --> 00:21:50,866.907139
Thanks everyone.
225
00:21:50,879.907139 --> 00:21:51,230.907139
Shkoll.
226
00:21:51,230.907139 --> 00:21:51,777.907139
Shkoll, listeners.