TRANSCRIPTIE 🔗
Marcy Twete: Welcome back to Table Stakes. My guest today is Professor Christopher Marquis, Signier Professor of Chinese Management at the University of Cambridge Judge School of Business, former professor at Harvard Business School and Cornell, and the author of three books I have absolutely loved, including Better Business, How the B Corp Movement is Remaking Capitalism, and his most recent The Profiteers: How Business Privatizes Profits and Socializes Costs. Chris has spent his career. Great. Okay. Hi Chris. Welcome to Table Stakes. Thank you so much for joining me.
Chris Marquis: Great. Thanks so much, Marcy. Really great to be with you.
Marcy Twete: Yes, I'm excited. It's this has been ⁓ a fun series. I reached out, you know, to all of these wonderful authors like you who have been on my sustainability book list over the years, and everybody said yes, which is so, so incredibly fun. I think we all love talking about our books and ⁓ and it's it's great to see. So and I loved, I've read two of your books. I've read Better Business and I've read The Profiteers. Asking a deceptively simple question. When business creates damage, who actually ends up paying for it? I think you're going to love this conversation. I absolutely did. Here's our conversation with Chris. Love them both. And I was just saying to you before we started, my next book is Mao and Markets. So I've got a I'm putting that on the vacation list and so excited to read it. Yeah. So you came on, I recorded your your bio and background so folks know a little bit about you, but I'd love to just kind of start with the thread of your career because you have ⁓
Chris Marquis: Thank you. Okay. Good. Well thank you thank you. I appreciate it.
Marcy Twete: been in academia for a long time, but you were at JP Morgan Chase. You're kind of a, you know, not a lot of academics come into their space and have that real heavy corporate background. So you also have kind of come up through sustainability and activism through finance, which is a sometimes weird place to do that. So I'd love to just kind of hear you riff a little bit on your career and the threads of your career. What sent you to academia in these difficult topics?
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Shh sure. Well, th thank you for that question. ⁓ brings back some some memories, I guess, and really makes me realize how old I am, to be honest. I ⁓
Marcy Twete: My birthday was yesterday and I've been like feel so old, but it's, you know, it's good. ⁓ It beats the alternative, right?
Chris Marquis: well, congratulations. It's that's that's that's good. It totally, totally beats the alternative. And you know, I it's amazing to think that it is now 30 years since I started working at JP Morgan ⁓ or I'm working in financial services. I first worked for another bank, PNC Financial, which was in Pittsburgh, which is my hometown, although pretty large bank now, but but you know, headquartered in in Pittsburgh.
Marcy Twete: Wow.
Chris Marquis: And you know, it's so interesting because, you know, a lot of what I write and what I really believe is that finance really a, you know, the way finance is organized is really a root cause problem of many of the issues in our world. It sort of really drives a lot of, you know, short term short-termism ⁓ for companies that I think probably would be doing a lot more things in sustainability, social impact, et cetera. And certainly not that. You know, sort of banking or finance were ever, know, altruistic. But there was a time when ⁓ was much more about being part of a community, financing small businesses in that community. And that was really ⁓ the that I was working in. So I mean it's JP Morgan, Chase. You know, it sounds I'm some high-flying investment banker in New York City. ⁓ You know, like in the movie Wall Street or or something, because that sort of was around the time, ⁓ a little bit later than that. But I was actually started out and was working mostly in the community-oriented banking and retail banking, which is much less prestigious. However, ⁓ I I found it to be actually have some of that social texture that really came to be important to me as I did my research. So that was sort of the what led me in that. And I think I ended up getting a PhD. ⁓ Going back to school because I was always very, very interested in in learning and teaching. ⁓ thought, you know, my sort of business and banking background combined with an academic background, I would be well suited to be maybe like a professor at a business school, which I ended up doing. So it it it all worked out, although w ⁓ mentioned a thread and I and I think for a while my parents were a bit worried that I was sort of jumping all over the place. And maybe I was doing that for a while, but Finally settled on something.
Marcy Twete: That's awesome. it's interesting. I was just having a conversation with someone in banking the other day, and we were talking about the impact of the Community Reinvestment Act, which I think was the ⁓ if I'm not mistaken, right? And I think a lot of people think that banks were doing a lot of this giving and philanthropy because they thought it was good. They were doing it because it was regulatorily required and it still is.
Chris Marquis: Yeah, seventies, eighties, yeah, yeah, yeah. Sure. Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
Marcy Twete: Right. And it's that kind of chicken and egg, right? Which came first. The the the purpose of the corporation or the regulation that pushed them toward that purpose and
Chris Marquis: Yeah, it's really interesting. ⁓ and I think, you know, the Community Reinvestment Act, I mean, I think there was a lot of really horrible things around red l redlining and ⁓ you know, sort of exclusion of different, you know, ethnic groups, particularly black borrowers from different from different neighborhoods. ⁓ but yeah, so that certainly ⁓ horrible. But there there was a lot, if you remember the movie It's a Wonderful Life, actually, the protagonist in that was a
Load full transcript
was a banker, and it was about
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Chris Marquis: This sort of home homebown bank and really its sort of role in the community. And so it is ⁓ a complicated legacy. And I think that to be honest, part of what at least I take from that is ⁓ both there are ⁓ lot of things that need reform ⁓ to be made better, but also ⁓ do think that we need to think about ways of having business be organized such that it is. ⁓ a motor of social and environmental impact because many people just wanna say, forget about it. I can understand that at some level, but also I think it's more productive to try to think away ⁓ about ways of of positive reform.
Marcy Twete: Well, you tell this story in I think both of your books or a couple of places about watching Jack Welch at a PBS taping when you were a grad student at Michigan. And he essentially said, talking about dumping PCBs into the Hudson River, that's how business is done. Get over it. And I'd love to I mean, that moment stuck with you for a long time. And I I I think we've all had that moment where we look at a corporate CEO who goes, you know, it's just how we do things here.
Chris Marquis: Yeah.
Marcy Twete: ⁓ I'm curious how that is that the seed that continues to stick with you?
Chris Marquis: It does you know, it does. I mean, I must say, you know, it definitely was something that I remembered. you know, it's sort interesting because, ⁓ know, sometimes you ⁓ you worry that maybe the things you remember weren't exactly how you thought they would be. ⁓ that actually, I mean, it's on YouTube that I mean it was a PBS show and you can sort of see it on YouTube. So as I was writing the book, really in some ways fact checking myself, I wanted to make sure that actually I was remembering things. Right. And that actually was not that was not in the the broadcast PBS broadcast because it was actually a student, if I remember correctly, that was sort of asking about the issues. And turns out actually the Michigan Daily paper, the student paper actually ran a discussion of it, but but actually didn't make the PBS broadcast. So, you know, I certainly remember that as I'm saying, but you know, it I didn't really It's it it stuck with me in some way, but in many in many cases, you know, what things become clearer much later. And I think the fact that it stuck with me really says something about some of the issues that I was wrestling with, because, you know, even just when we're talking about, you know, financial services, you know, I think a problem that we have as professionals trying to promote a more, you know, sustainable, just world is that the way the system is set up. You know, the system being many cases the way laws are, you know, motivations have meet shareholder demands, ⁓ the the of pressure investors put on ⁓ companies ends making it hard to actually do the right thing, so so to speak. I d I don't I think it's so structural issues, not necessarily that people are bad. I think that actually many many times people actually want to be doing the right thing. So so I think that ⁓ You know, it took me a while to really unravel that in my mind, like why that stuck with me. yeah. So and this I I used it to open the book, The Prophets. Yeah.
Marcy Twete: Yeah. Yeah. It's ⁓ my my ethics professor at Kellogg, Adam Waits, always says there's no such thing as no such thing as bad apples, only bad barrels, right? And it's it's kind of in the in the same space. So the central concept of the profiteers is this idea that businesses privatize profits and socialize costs. So for our listeners who may not have read the book yet.
Chris Marquis: Uh-huh. Sure, that's a good good way to put it. Yeah.
Marcy Twete: Talk about that concept and kind of how you came to that term profiteers.
Chris Marquis: Sure. So ⁓ you know, the subtitle, as you mentioned, sort of this ⁓ privatized profit and socialized cost, is a way to put the the con the economic and accounting concept of an externality. It's a bad sound sounding word, but basically it means or it's basically a concept that describes, in some ways, the social and environmental spillovers from companies or other people's actions on the broader society or the or the environment. So, you know. ⁓ pollution from a factory is a real simple example that people can people can understand. You know, you have ⁓ that is manufacturing something in a factory and produces smoke. You know, that's that smoke, if it has CO2, creates global warming, but also, ⁓ know, has health impacts of people around the factory, you know, all kinds, you know, ⁓ respiratory problems they might have or or or whatnot. And so those, you know. Climate, you know, climate change, carbon emissions, and and health impacts are the extern are are what are externalities. And so really want to focus on this for a couple reasons. So one, you know, this something that is frequently thought of as just an economic concept. And obviously, ⁓ you know, it's the concept was is from economics. Actually, I'm I'm at Cambridge. ⁓ teaching now and actually with some economists at Cambridge that actually came up with came up with this idea. So I feel like I'm in sort of their lit lineage a bit. But but I want to actually think about it in a little bit more of a political socially constructed, so to speak, way because I think a lot of the things that we think are responsible ⁓ of companies or not. It's actually the companies that are ⁓ creating in some ways that responsibility for for us. ⁓ and I you know, I can provide some examples of that, but I'll but I'll stop. I've been talked a lot. I'll stop there for a second so you can ask some more questions.
Marcy Twete: No, it's it's it's really helpful. And you know, it's interesting. I spent ⁓ a bunch of my career working for one of the largest pollu polluters emitters in the world with the the world's largest steel company, Arcelor Middle. you know, you talk about in your book, and you know, I still I think
Arcelor's doing some great things and they're doing some not so great things, right? But there's about a hundred companies in the world that really account for 70% of our global emissions, yet we feel really guilty for using straws, right? And it's that kind of
Chris Marquis: Okay. Yeah. Right, exactly.
Marcy Twete: It's that kind of friction you talk about the moral weight on individuals, right? Like what does it cost tr to strategically keep that moral weight on people instead of companies?
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Exactly. And I think that's that's where some of this political and social construction happens because, you know, the you know, company, those hundred companies, they they don't want people to realize that actually they're the biggest problem. So, you know, the business has done these various things like personal carbon footprints, which was popularized by British Petroleum. You know, the idea that, ⁓ you should be worried about your own personal carbon footprint. ⁓ you know, they had advertising campaigns about this. I mean, think about that. It's sort of really strange that a you know, oil company, fossil fuel company, is advertising about individuals' carbon footprints. I mean, it's a clear distraction technique where they don't they want people to worry about themselves. And clearly we should all think about our environmental impact. I'm not saying that we're, you know, give ha give us a free license, but the fact that we do so much, I think we need to understand that it's the it's these large companies that are really. putting that responsibility on us and we should be more conscious of putting the responsibility back on them.
Marcy Twete: Yeah, it's interesting. We are ⁓ as a small firm, climate neutral certified, and there's lots of big firms that that go through that process as well. But it's funny, you get to a point as a micro firm, you know, less than 10 people where there's only so much you can do. And at that point we're offsetting, right? And I laughed this year. Climate neutral certified put out a couple of like micro business guides, and one of them was, you know, about how to find flights that have, you know, that have less carbon emissions and all these kind of things. And I'm like, you guys, the plane's going, whether I go or not. You know, it's that you can attribute that to my small business, but the plane is flying and let's let's think about where we're at. And it it's a literal gaslighting of of sort of people on the on the bottom end. Yeah.
Chris Marquis: Sure. Yeah, right. Sure. Exactly. Right. Yeah, exa exactly. And I think, yeah. And so I I go through I have a chapter actually called corporate gaslighting where I go through these variety of examples of, you know, greenwashing and you know this, you know, there's something called astroturfing, which is, you know, astroturf people are probably familiar with from, you know, fe you know, fee artificial grass and fields, but but actually a lot of companies they they have ⁓ they they sort of make up grassroots organizations to make it seem like a variety of political pressure is coming from the people as opposed to you know as opposed to companies. And so I think this is a this is a thing we need to be much more conscious about, you know, really trying to understand like who's driving the public agenda. And I think, you know, in the United States, with Citizens and all the money in politics, I think it's a real challenge because it's very hard to really identify and understand, you the motivation of the actors that are driving the agenda and the powerful companies, powerful rich individuals have more ⁓ sort power and ability to do that today now than ever.
Marcy Twete: Yeah, and and from behind the scenes, I think, you know, we've seen I've seen more and more in even sustainability reporting of companies saying, well, we don't do a lot of giving to candidates. You're right, you don't. You do give a lot of giving to individual organizations that are also giving to candidates. So you can say, ⁓ you know, we didn't, we didn't give a lot of money to candidates, but if you're funding, you know, APAC or whoever the the answer is, it's clear.
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. I mean, I think this is the thing. All these, you know, political action committees, industry associations that are doing tremendous amounts of lobbying, you know, behind the scenes. and I think, you know, one of the examples of that is the business roundtable, you know, this organization of about 200 largest US which ⁓ in ⁓ got accolades because they put out a statement saying, you know, we believe the purpose of business is to ⁓
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm.
Chris Marquis: To serve stakeholders, you know, not just not just short-term profit and shareholders, but actually think about employees, communities, blah, blah, blah. However, you know, turns out when you say something public, people can check. unfortunately, you know, the the checking usually does not get nearly as much publicity as actually saying it in the first place. but ⁓ but you people can look around. There's been academic investigations, both The Guardian and Business Week both published pretty extensive analyses. And it turns out that actually these companies are worse. The business roundtable companies on things like carbon emissions, on things like labor standards, pay are all worse than actually the companies that are not part of the business round table. So so it's really
Marcy Twete: It's interesting. I'll I'll tell you a funny story about that. So the week after Business Roundtable published the list and the letter and all of the things, I was in a final interview for a chief sustainability officer role with one of those companies. I asked wasn't the CEO, but it was someone who was on the CEO's team who would have been my boss. Tell me about the process to sign on to this pledge and to go through this process. He had
Chris Marquis: wow.
Marcy Twete: absolutely no idea what
I was talking about. And the CEO never even saw it. It went, it was a complete communications exercise. There was no questions about signing it. Someone at and at that moment I went, I think I'm gonna stay in consulting. Like I don't think I think I'm done. Yeah.
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Yeah, exactly. I mean that it's interesting. I I had not heard that part. I did I I assumed because the CEOs are ⁓ members of that group that they had some visibility in it, but there's been yeah. Yeah.
Marcy Twete: I think some did. I think some did. It just this I won't say who it was, but this one said, ⁓ no, I don't even know what that is, you know.
Chris Marquis: You know, it's interesting. there's been some investigation as well on the boards of these companies. And yeah, the bo the boards had absolutely no sort of communication or buy in around it either, which really tells you just what a bunch of yeah, basically nothing it is.
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm. No. ⁓ goodness. You know, they're trying to do their best. And that's it's hard. We, you know, sitting, I'm in Minneapolis and they there was a statement from 60 Minneapolis CEOs around Operation Metro Surge and and the ice work here. And I do, I understand from those folks, people were very upset after the statement came out. It was kind of milk toast. It was it was nothing. But there really were 60 CEOs in a in on a call for that. And I've heard from behind the scenes.
Chris Marquis: Sure, I remember that, yeah. Sure.
Marcy Twete: And they it's really hard to get 60 CEOs to agree to sign their name on something that kind of goes against the administration, you know, says some things that maybe they're afraid of saying. And they did the best they could. So it's, you know, at least, at least on that one, they all they all actually put their name on the paper. But ⁓ it depends on on where you're at. So everything you studied, all of all of where you're at. I just ⁓ the podcast that will go up the week before yours is with Christine Bader, who wrote Evolution of a Corporate Idealist.
Chris Marquis: Okay, sure.
Marcy Twete: formerly worked for BP I asked her this question, like, are you still a corporate idealist? You know, I think your writing tends to be a little more bearish on the fate of the corporation, but I'd love to hear kind of where you are today on whether business can be a vehicle for positivity in our society.
Chris Marquis: Yeah. I mean, I d I do think I mean I I'm generally an optimistic person, and I must say I do think that business a it can be can be positive, but I it's the system, so speak, more more so that I am much more concerned about. And aga you know, the things we already talked about regarding a lot of the you know, motivations and pressures ⁓ of public companies, a lot of the political ⁓ environment how actually know there's been a retreat in recent years, recent year, year you were a year or two from a lot of the things that I thought were gaining traction around sustainability, around diversity, it's et cetera. So I think that yeah, the system is is challenge. And that's really in many ways what I'm, ⁓ you know, profiteers in particular ⁓ trying to look, we have, you know, ⁓ it It does actually, the profiteers, how business privatizes profit, socializes costs. Does sound like I'm talking about one like a particular company's, but really it's a mu it's a more critique of the broader system. that we're the current, you know, call it sh shareholder primacy, neoliberal, know, you whatever sort of phrase you want you want to use, that really ⁓ I think warp warps the action of ⁓ ⁓ of comp companies to be to not be sustainable, to not be responsible.
Marcy Twete: Yeah. It's interesting. And I I didn't prep you for the or didn't put this question in my list of questions for you. So let me throw a curveball in. you know, one of the things that I heard, well, I worked in the steel industry obviously for a long time, and and the kind of internal world in the steel industry was, well, you know, we're gonna do the best we can, but China cheats. And you a professor of of Chinese business and and in that space. So I'm curious how you've seen. ⁓
Chris Marquis: Yes.
Marcy Twete: the system, as it were, work differently an Asian market versus in in sort of a Western market? And and how how does this play there? Have you, you know, where's the intersection of of that business sector versus where we're what we're talking about now?
Chris Marquis: Yeah, really interesting question. And yeah, so in the in one of the books that I wrote was actually on in some ways the economic model of of China. and you know, I I think that the steel you know, industry folks were were right in in some in some ways. ⁓ I do think, although I do think that we can't be using that as ⁓ like get out of jail free card to be totally unsustainable, I think that's, you know, you can see that. happening a lot with the AI companies with so social media before that. It's like, ⁓ you have to give us free reign because otherwise, you know, China will ⁓ will sort of eat our lunch or become the world leader in in this certain technology or d I do think though that sort of thoughtful and appropriate policy, ⁓ and working with the government on that, at least, you know, around tech, ⁓ a little more appropriate. Like for instance, for me, you know, you think about, you know, I mean, social media is the one that I s know the best. I mean, AI is currently evolving, but but ⁓ you know, Mark Zuckerberg, who I'm no f fan of necessarily, you know, would come to Capitol Hill and complain about TikTok, you know, which was really eating Instagram's lunch, so to speak. ⁓ and I think that's a reasonable comment. know, all of the ch all all of the American social media companies, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, You name it, are banned and blocked from So I think that, you know, I mean, I don't think we should give ⁓ any breaks, but I do think we should actually be reciprocal on the Chinese
companies. so for I I'm not sure with the I'm not a fan of tariffs, or certainly how they're being applied necessarily by this administration, but something like the steel industry, I think is a is a hugely strategic industry to make sure that we're still having steel.
Marcy Twete: Sure.
Chris Marquis: you know, produced in the United States. you know, a lot of national security and other reasons. Also, ⁓ must have been, I'm from Pittsburgh, ⁓ so I have a deep sort tie to the steel industry, I guess, a bit. but I think that yeah, so so let's actually think of, you know, ⁓ not necessarily those companies to lower their environmental standards, but let's think about ways of helping productively foster ⁓ that industry the US, you know, could be. ⁓ Yeah, could be some sort of targeted tariffs, ⁓ could be other other, you know, ways of helping the industry.
Marcy Twete: Yeah, I we I was just having a discussion with someone over dinner about ethics and AI. And and what I said about Anthropic at the time was like at least there are ethicists at the table at Anthropic. It feels like there are others where there are no ethicists anywhere. And in fact, they would actually say they shouldn't have ethicists at the table because they should let the free market roll, right? just it's a hard place to be of how do you responsibly build in a industry where the train has left the station and
Chris Marquis: Sure.
Marcy Twete: It's it's rolling, but you have to have to ask them to hold themselves back.
Chris Marquis: Yeah, and I think, you know, I mean, I think anthropic, I mean, it we're sort of still in the first inning of of, you know, maybe even not even that of of the AI industry, so can't be drawing any any super strong conclusions. But I mean, if you look at anthropic over the past, you know, year or two, I mean, they are the ones that have really succeeded. And they've done this. They held their ground against the administration on a variety of of uses. They ⁓ as you said, you know, they have ethicists.
Marcy Twete: Yeah.
Chris Marquis: And philosophers consulting on the in some way soul of the model. I think ⁓ and I've and they've done well. I mean, they've actually, you know, I think part of it might be that Claude seems to be doing really well with code and a lot of companies are are adopting it. So I don't, you know, I don't know if necessarily we can draw a a really ⁓ causal arg argument, but but I feel good that they're the ones that seem to be doing well. And you know, XAI. ⁓ Although, you know, I guess SpaceX is going public, you know, today or tomorrow or as we talk, wh whenever whenever, you know, seems to be doing less ⁓ well. you know, and they've been doing a lot of pretty irresponsible things around ⁓ their data centers and certainly some of the ⁓ ways the algorithm is engineered has some questionable ethics to it.
Marcy Twete: Yeah. Yeah. Well, and I think that comes back to, you know, SpaceX and a number of these big IPOs that are coming, there's a lot in the market about are they greasing the wheels in terms of some of the ways that they're coming at this with individual investors? Again, that's a systemic approach, right? Can we fault them for working within a system that gives them the right to do what they're doing?
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Yeah, I I I I it is a challenge, yeah.
Marcy Twete: It's hard. So I'm curious, ⁓ you know, as I said, I got my my MBA at Kellogg. You know, you're teaching at Cambridge, which is fantastic. One of the things I was I was disappointed in at Kellogg, and I've I've heard people say the same about Wharton, same about you Chicago, ⁓ there's not enough ethics infused in ⁓ curriculum across these kind of prolific leading business schools. You know, I had an ethics class, we had a law class that had some ethics in it. But there really isn't a an infusion of ethics and moral responsibility across it. I'm curious how you guys are bringing that into the curriculum at Cambridge. how are you, you know, obviously you're teaching sort of the ⁓ Chinese business, but how are you bringing the profiteers and better business kind of into your classes and into the way you teach the future of business?
Chris Marquis: Yeah. So so so my title that the in some ways the professorship that I was hired, that they had this opening, ⁓ they hired me for this. But actually I was hired during COVID. China shut down and I was doing ⁓ r research on China, but also doing for a long time but doing sustainability research. So I I actually don't really do very much on China anymore, despite despite my title. I'm doing pretty much all sustainability focused research and writing and also teaching.
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm. ⁓ okay. Nice.
Chris Marquis: And you know, this is something you have to be careful in case my dean ends up getting a hold of this and then I might actually get ⁓ get fired or something because I have pretty negative ⁓ about how this has transpired at Cambridge, to be honest. I went there ⁓ ⁓ of the you know, there's many reasons that I went there, one of which was because the university and the school is actually known for having a a more sort of sustainability and ethics focused.
Marcy Twete: Ha ha ha.
Chris Marquis: ⁓ program. And I still have a lot of great colleagues that I, you know, have tremendous respect and like for the for the work they do. ⁓ within the the actual MBA program, I've I've been really disappointed, ⁓ you mentioned, these other top programs. And to me, ⁓ I've been working on trying to get more sustainability or corporate social responsibility as it used to be called a long time ago into curriculums ⁓ know my entire career basically when I was at Harvard Business School when I started out, you know, I I wasn't leading on this, but I was helping people that were leading to try to get the get the more of those topics in the curriculum of Cornell certainly. And was actually a lot of interest in this when I joined Cambridge. And we made very good
progress at having courses added, ⁓ having a variety of other sort of experiential type things added for the students.
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm.
Chris Marquis: ⁓ and that in the last year has all basically been gutted. it's really been unfortunate. And I there's two reasons for this. I mean, ⁓ to me, my analysis, and and a friend of mine who who sort of I was I was, you know, grousing about this to him, he's been at Cambridge a lot longer than me. He Yeah, this is, ⁓ know, sort of sustainability ESG was popular. It was flavor of the month. Before that, we actually introduced a lot of a lot of you know entrepreneurship. And so now it's being replaced basically with AI type of things. So to me, I think, you know, Cambridge is an amazing, incredible university. But but as an MBA program, it's not going to be able to go toe-to-toe because it's smaller, because it's, you know, less well known with some of these top US programs. So my feeling is this is an area where you would want to actually differentiate and actually create a unique specialized offering, not sort of follow.
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm.
Chris Marquis: The trends. You're never gonna actually become a leader by following know, follow follow following trends. So ⁓ I think that's that's ⁓ you know sort of one reason. I think two, a really unfortunate reason is that actually I think there there's a misperception that the that we teach sustainability topics, you know, actually the the Financial Times as part of their ranking asks ⁓ ⁓ like how much I I think they might use the term ESG or I'm not sure if it's sustainability, how much ESG you know materials in the is in the is in the curriculum. So every faculty asks how much ESG this is for our for our, you know, Financial Times you know Financial Times ranking, which gets gives you a hint that probably if you even mention some sustainability thing that that would be good to conclude that hour because I mean so so we ⁓ on the surface it looks like there's a reasonable amount, but I think that's totally not the case. it's it's really very disappointing to me, actually.
Marcy Twete: Yeah. Well, it's, you know, you're you're singing to the choir for for anybody in American business schools too. I mean, I think there's there's this interesting and I I get the question all the time, I'm sure you do, from from kids who are going into this field going, Well, do I go get a master's in sustainability? Do I go get an MBA? And neither one is doing the work that it needs to do in order to get business leaders to understand where they're going. And I think that's that's tough. And
Chris Marquis: And I and I think too, you know, the thing is, is that these are topics. If we think about like something that's very important to me, I believe in the topics are are important, but also, you know, to me, I think we have a responsibility to our students. And these topics are ones that will be incredibly important for their careers. It's not as if climate change is going to be any less impactful. So if you think you know, you look just in the last year. You know, bec you know, people are be are seeing it as a national security risk, creating a lot of issues with costs and inflation. ⁓ know, this is not just about sort of do-gooder ⁓ hugging type of stuff. This is actually a huge sort of risk ⁓ and ⁓ that people are going to be dealing with their in their careers. And ⁓ I think it's ⁓ you know, I use a sort of malpractice to be honest, that we have taken so much sustainability content out of the curriculum.
Marcy Twete: Yeah. And I think I I'm curious sort of where you land on the words. And I've been talking to everybody about this, like ESG, sustainability, CSR, ethics, morals. How do you, you know, sometimes I think it's easier to talk about ethics and morals because it it more universally understood. although compliance world has kind of taken on the taken the ethics word from us. But, you know.
Chris Marquis: Sure.
Marcy Twete: DEI and ESG have gotten attacked by this administration. There's all these things coming. I mean, is sustainability just the right term to to land on? I I don't know, but curious what you think.
Chris Marquis: Yeah. It's a it is a it is a hard question. I mean it's ⁓ yeah and I do think that I mean language is really, really important. and how we talk about things is really, really important. ⁓ I'll get to your I I'm gonna take a slight detour before actually getting to your exact ⁓ quite question. So just to let you know. ⁓ but but recently I've been talking to some entrepreneurs in the UK ⁓ that were involved in actually changing the dictionary definition of nature.
Marcy Twete: Yeah.
Chris Marquis: Now, this is really interesting because actually it turns out that the the definition of nature ⁓ ⁓ humans from it. So so within the definition, typically excludes excludes humans. And this is a product of the Enlightenment, where ⁓ know humans were set off from nature and was seen as something we should dominate and extract from. ⁓ but if you look at indigenous peoples, if you look at
Marcy Twete: Wow.
Chris Marquis: world before the enlightenment actually nature was a much more fundamental part of like like it's our you know some indigenous people it's the ancestor or part of the family and I think that you know if we thought like that we would probably not see it as just a you know a waste dump to just you know put put put our trash so ⁓ I'm ⁓ know ⁓ know thinking about writing something about this because I think that
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm.
Chris Marquis: You know, it's how we actually define and think about things is really, really important. So I so I just wanna say I think it's really important. But I
Marcy Twete: It's it's so interesting that you say that because this is I I'm originally from rural North Dakota. And the the joke I always make with people about climate change is if you go talk to most, frankly, they're they're all male, you know, male farmers in North Dakota and you try
to talk to them about climate change, they go directly to the Fox News talking points, right? If you go to a farmer in North Dakota and you try to talk to them about nature water and land. They're as blue as the sky could be in terms of political because they want, you know, they want clean water, they want clean air, they want clean land, they want their farms to be sustainable for their next generation, for their kids to leave them. And it's just in the way we taught we've we've leaned so much into these political Yeah. And it's like, how do we get back to talking about nature? And I think that's I love it. That's so cool.
Chris Marquis: Sure. Yeah. Sure. Sure. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, right. And I do and I do think that how we it talk about broadly speaking sustainability is really, really important. I think that some of the some of the words I'm not in favor of. I think that sort of ESG I I'm not hugely in favor of because it really I think frequently ends up boiling down to just a set of measures that are end up being used in ⁓ in a way. ⁓ ⁓ also, you know, CSR is a little out of faith, you know, sort of old-fashioned, although responsibility is not too bad. You know, I have not, I mean, I hear your point about sort of morals and ethics, and I do think that that is a really important way to think about behaviors, but I don't use those as much because I think I also, when teaching the MBAs in particular, I'm really trying to situate as a business. ⁓ problem also. And so, you know, sustainability is one way, although, you know, sustainability, an issue with sustainability is that, you know, the idea of sustain means keeping things the same. most sort of definitions of sustainability, it's really about mitigating damage. And I think we need to be actually thinking much more, you know, proactively about ways of improving, restoring,
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Chris Marquis: You know, I I frequently use the word regeneration, but that ends up being confusing to some people, so I don't actually use it that often. Sustainability is usually what I use.
Marcy Twete: No, I just did I just did John Fullerton's ⁓ regenerative economics course and it was fantastic. It was really amazing and and really thoughtfully done. And I just I think there's a lot in that, it does feel I for someone who might be on the sort of traditional financing, it does feel feel a little radical ⁓ to those folks to to think of it that way. but really.
Chris Marquis: ⁓ fantastic. Yeah.
Marcy Twete: Really, really interesting. And I agree with it's like sustain feels like a very low bar, you know. Sustain feels we use I mean, manufacturing industry long time has said license to operate, license to grow, right? And that was an eighties, an old, you know, barbarians at the gate kind of thing. But it's ⁓ it it's it applies as you look at it today. Yeah.
Chris Marquis: Right. Yeah, I think a licensed operators I think we need to be I mean, come we should hold be holding companies much more
accountable for their ability to legitimately exist within our society and so much of the things that people are doing are actually ⁓ violate that license.
Marcy Twete: How do you, do you feel like we hold we can hold account ⁓ companies accountable? You talked in your book about strategic hibernation and you know, we've talked about green hushing ⁓ has happened over the last couple of years. You know, it used to be companies could make a big statement, make a commitment, and then we hold them accountable to that commitment. In today's political climate, how do you know company's going in the right direction? How do you hold them accountable as a stakeholder?
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Yeah, that's it's a real challenge. And I think, you know, I mean, the business round table example, you know, they got all kinds of press for saying things, and then, you know, no one checks or or people do check, but actually the, you know, the the checking does not get nearly as much visibility as actually what they originally st originally stated. So, I mean, I do think it's I mean, as consumers we need to do this. I think this is traditionally a big role that the government and policy could take, however.
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm.
Chris Marquis: You know, back to Citizens United, I think that infrastructure has been unfortunately so co opted. So so I I do think, yeah, a lot of it is publics.
Marcy Twete: I do think, you know, I think CSRD in in the EU is moving the needle. They're moving it very slowly and they're kicking the can a lot, but but at least at least people are saying, okay, what do we need to do for CSRD? Even if it's a compliance checkbox, it's at least a step.
Chris Marquis: Totally. Yeah. I mean Totally. ⁓ I totally agree. And I think I mean I I think I had a little bit more optimism for CSRD than some of my colleagues and still do. because I think, you know, they were very thoughtful. The EU ⁓ I'm probably gotten burnt bur burnt by it ab burnt by this issue a number of times, but ⁓ been very thoughtful about constructing their regulations so that, you know, you can't like just escape the EU and you get out of it. So, ⁓ know, the this CBAM, which is ⁓ carbon border adjustment mechanism where, you know, if you trying to import steel ⁓ some other product and has not undergone some sort of carbon tax, you know, you get a a border adjustment f for for that amount. So people can't just, you know, race to the bottom, used to be called, where ⁓ just leave tough jurisdictions. And I think, you know, CSRD also, again, you know, as you mentioned, it's really been ⁓ delayed ⁓ and weakened, ⁓ it is something that applies will apply
Marcy Twete: Yes.
Chris Marquis: to company's global operations, not just what they do in the Europe. And so I am cautiously optimistic that something like that will help raise the bar global companies.
Marcy Twete: Yeah. I I think it is. It's slow, you know, slow and steady, but I I think it will. California regulations, same thing, you know, new it's it's slow, it's taking time and it's being challenged, but the even the bits that make it out of those challenges will be positive in the right direction, I hope. Yeah. Yeah.
Chris Marquis: Right, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. And I do think accountability is really important. I mean, I think that that's something that and it's one of the reasons why I've, you know, always been a fan of the B Corp movement is that, you know, they've been pushing you know, really advancing the conversation ⁓ companies' accountability. And so that's I think that's hugely important. It's it's obviously, ⁓ know, we need to do many things. I mean, some people have give me hard time and criticize me, like, ⁓ you know, you know, accountability, it's you
Marcy Twete: Mm-hmm. Yes.
Chris Marquis: there's so much more needs to be done and I and I agree with the new more needs to be done, but it's a necessary step because if you cannot actually understand and report on and be transparent about your operations, know, how how can you be held to account? You know, so I think it's a really a necessary first step.
Marcy Twete: Well, and I I've always loved the B Corp movement. ⁓ you know, I made Veerless a B Corp when I was still a one-person shop and and we've grown with it. And I love that it's a positive screen, right? And it it says, do these things and rack up the good choices, rack up the good points instead of saying, well, if you don't do everything, it's not enough, right? Just keep keep building and finding those new places to grow. And I think their new set of standards are pushing even the B Corps that have really easily made their numbers to now go back and say, Okay, we've got more work to do and let's come to the table and it's it's really lovely.
Chris Marquis: Right. Yeah, and I think that's been this I mean, I've been studying, you know, B Corp since two thousand nine. that's ⁓ of the things that I think I've really come to appreciate is that it is about continuous improvement. it's about, you know, setting the bar higher and higher, ⁓ but just doing it then ⁓ saying, ⁓ your problem, go figure it out. I mean, actually there it's a community with a lot of ⁓ tools to benchmark and to partner and to learn. So I think it's I think, you know, that community aspect and network aspect is also really, really important.
Marcy Twete: ⁓ it's it's so great. I mean, I'm I think Minneapolis is still the largest number of B Corps for any like single city in the country. It used to be. I don't know if it still is. No, we are. Yeah. Largest, largest B Corp market per per city. I think San Francisco was really close to us, but I'm pretty sure Minneapolis still is.
Chris Marquis: Get out. I didn't know that. Okay. I d I d I Okay. And I know some of the like maybe Portland is is big too. ⁓
Marcy Twete: Yeah, Portland's been big as well and and things like that. But we've had some big ones come on. Rumen Board recently, ⁓ you know, Aveda, they're all yeah, Rumen Board was
Rumen Board is was our newest. I think there there's now been another one since then. But it, you know, it's such a great community. We all we all answer each other's phone calls when we call, you know. How are you guys handling this? How can you, you know, it's such an open community. When you tell someone, fellow B Corp here, they always answer the phone.
Chris Marquis: ⁓ fantastic. ⁓ Roman Board is is in ⁓ okay. ⁓ Okay. That's ⁓ I mean I would love to yeah. It Yeah. Exactly. This is something I've really found too. That it's actually someone told me actually, ⁓ not just someone, more than one person told me that actually when they were working on some things, they actually were able to call the CEO of Patagonia, ⁓ be because because of this connection. And so, like, how can you as a small company get access to the CEO of Patagonia? That's like sort of, you know, ⁓ I mean, so it really I think is a testament. And I and I'm and I'm gonna if you have anything on the Minneapolis B Corp community, please send it to me because
Marcy Twete: ⁓ yeah. Yeah, I'll send it over to you because we're it's a great, an incredible group and very heavy. We I think there are other B Corp communities that tend to be more brand heavy. The Minneapolis community is very professional services and B2B heavy. We've got a lot of we've got l a lot less sort of big corp ⁓ consumer brands. We although there are some big ones, QBP and Peace Coffee and you know, there's some great ones here. But ⁓ yeah, we're a great, a great group, a little ragtag group, but we're we like each other.
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Got it. Okay. Yeah. you know, I mean, some of the earlier research I did on US communities, that Minneapolis has always been so well known about corporate responsibility. There, you know, there was such a longstanding commitment. There was this five percent club, which I don't know how long it goes back in the seventies or eighties, where companies, you know, target ⁓ Honeywell, I think ⁓ or Honeywell was I think in in Minneapolis, if I'm correct me if I'm wrong. ⁓ all of the all
Marcy Twete: Yes. Many years. Yep. Yep. You are correct. Honeywell, Medtronic, all those guys. Yeah. This is people could have a bingo card about my podcast and how many times I talk about Bill George, the CEO of Medtronic, because he's just the best there ever was. He just there's no there aren't CEOs like Bill anymore. But it's interesting. one of the Star Tribune writers, I'll send you the article, did an article this week about Solventum, which is the company that spun off of 3M. ⁓
Chris Marquis: Medtronic, yeah, yeah. They ⁓ sure, yeah. Sure. Okay.
Marcy Twete: A real takedown on how none of their leaders live in Minneapolis. it was really interesting. And he talked about, and Bill George has talked about this in his own writing, about the problem of CEOs not living in their cities anymore and what that does, because they don't have to go to the theater and stand next to people and and ⁓ be accountable to for the fact that they haven't funded the the orchestra or they haven't funded.
Chris Marquis: ⁓ okay. Sure. Sure. Right.
Marcy Twete: The theater and in the 80s they had to. They had to stand next to people in in line at the grocery store and they don't have to anymore. And it's just, it's really interesting. I'll send, I'll send you that. But yeah, Bill George is, I think he was one of those top five percenters and he he just yeah, started that whole movement. Yeah. Well, let me kind of wrap up with a couple of questions I've been asking everybody. So, besides your own, what are your favorite must reads if someone is looking to
Chris Marquis: Exactly. Sharply, please do. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sure.
Marcy Twete: make a dent in this business sustainability world? What what do people need to have on their bookshelves?
Chris Marquis: Yeah, I you know, actually I have not read it, but I have read a bit about it and I ordered it ordered it. I still I still like using physical books a lot and and because I can then sort of know sort of take take notes and ⁓ things I I read a lot of things electronically, but books so I just ⁓ by Eric Reese, ⁓ who ⁓ it's called Yeah.
Marcy Twete: We this is the other thing that's on my bingo card. I think I've talked about Eric's book on every podcast so far. Incorruptible. It is fantastic, Chris. You're gonna love it. Yeah.
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Incorruptible. So that good. Well, it is. I I got it I got an email ⁓ from Amazon about ⁓ an hour or two ago that it actually had arrived. ⁓ and I haven't I I haven't actually gotten and got the gotten the box yet, but ⁓ but I'm I'm gonna be I'm gonna be cracking that open.
Marcy Twete: It's great. It really is so I saw it and I thought, ⁓ I think Eric just wrote the book that I'm writing. And then I read it and I was like, ⁓ don't worry, it's okay. He wrote a different book. So but ⁓ it's really, it's really a great, a great book. And he talks about Patagonia and their model and it's it's really ten fantastic.
Chris Marquis: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And not Patagonia, you know, one of the books that I like a lot as well, just came out about a year ago, and it ties to our Jack Welch conversation, is Dirtbag Billionaire by David Gellies, who's a New York Times reporter. ⁓ and I like that because you, you as journalist, you know, he writes in a very, you know, narrative, tells the story of Patagonia, tells the challenges. You know, as an academic, I'm
Marcy Twete: So good. Yes.
Chris Marquis: Much more thinking about like, okay, what's this sort of framework, et cetera? I wish I wish I could actually write the narrative way. Maybe I'm just a little bit of envious of someone like ⁓ David Gellies. But but where I why I think that is a useful book is because Patagonia is always held up as, you know, this sort of shining star of sustainability. And you can see through the history how much tension and challenges there were around. that mission as the external
environment was changing. And so I think it's a good it's a good s story that gives a window into many of the issues that I'm I'm really interested and passionate about.
Marcy Twete: Yeah. And still ⁓ the thing that I don't think we give Patagonia enough even true credit for is they still have problems, right? Like they still they still have I mean that's the thing and they admit them, they still have employees who are not making a livable wage in some of their stores and they're working on it, but it's very hard, right? And they get they get a couple of things perfectly right and there are other things that they struggle with and they still struggle with to find their
Chris Marquis: ⁓ sure. They admit them. Yeah.
Marcy Twete: their footing and that's okay. And it's the transparency is there on it, which is is really cool. I love it. what what advice do you have? ⁓ you know, I'm I'm doing this series because I want everybody to meet you guys and read your books, but selfishly I'm also writing a book and and want your advice. So ⁓ advice do you have for a ⁓ a writer in this space? What hasn't been written, what needs to be told? ⁓ I'd love your advice for me as we close out.
Chris Marquis: ⁓ great. Yeah, sure. Yeah, good question. ⁓ and and I'm happy to talk at a longer venue if you if you want if you want more advice. I mean, I'm you know, it's been ⁓ know, I most of my career I was an ac an academic, which mostly for us ⁓ writing papers. And only, you know, in the last four to five years or five or six years have I been writing books. And so I've been learning a lot myself, ⁓ to to be honest. I I th I think a surprising
Marcy Twete: Yeah.
Chris Marquis: Surprising level, I think that that your network and platform is really what's essential. And I think that there's a cynical way to look at that. That I mean, not to get publishers mad, but publishers are lazy and they don't want to market the book. And so this way, you know, the the the the author can actually sell sell the book and they don't have to really w worry about it. And I think that's, you know, they're a business, I guess.
Marcy Twete: Ha ha.
Chris Marquis: But I think also, you know, the more that you can engage and communicate with others, I find, the better. I mean, my ideas are really not my own. They're based on being on podcasts like this and talking to you about you know, things I'm thinking about, hearing what you say, ⁓ and talking to other people. And so really, you know, knowledge construction and the best ideas are a very much social and collaborative process. And so, yeah, do I think. You know, having this podcast is a great idea for that. yeah, I w I wish you the best.
Marcy Twete: Thank you. I appreciate it. Well, thank you for coming on. It's so great to meet you. I like I said, I'm I'm a fangirl because I love your books and look forward to I might pepper you with some questions after I read Mao and Markets next week. So
Chris Marquis: Thank you, Marcy. ⁓ sure. Yeah. Great. Happy to happy to talk again. Thanks so much, Marcy, for having me on. Great.
Marcy Twete: Awesome. Thanks so much, Chris.