TRANSCRIPTIE 🔗
Audrey Rose: Welcome to Just the Tip, where I pull out the most important parts of this week's episode and give them to you in a tight little package. It's short, it's intriguing, it's just enough to leave you wanting more. But to maximize your experience, you'll want to download the full-length episode. For now, this is Just the Tip.
Audrey @dryhumorpodcast: Have you ever been the person suggesting mimosas at breakfast when everyone else just wants coffee? Or you're getting ready to go somewhere and casually suggests pregaming, only to realize that literally no one else was planning on drinking before you got to the event. Or the end of the night when all of the alcohol is gone and everyone's ready to go to bed and your mind is spinning with ways that you could work in just one more. And through each scenario, you're thinking, Wait, we're not gonna drink right now. it's funny because sometimes we assume everyone thinks about drinking the way we do. That everyone is just as excited about the next opportunity to drink. Or that everyone is looking for a reason to turn an ordinary occasion into a drinking occasion. But they're not. Not always, at least. Some people can take it or leave it. And other people seem to have an endless appetite for alcohol. So what is that? Why do some people want to drink so much more than others? Is it genetics? Is there really an alcoholic gene? Is it something happening in our brains? Or do some people just experience alcohol completely differently? Well, it turns out there's actually some pretty interesting science behind this, and today we're going to get into it. Welcome to Just the Tip, the Friday edition of Dry Humor, where we take a topic from the episode of the week and dig a little deeper. And today, yes, we are getting a little scientific. Don't worry, I am not turning this into a facts and science podcast. Y'all know me too well by now. I'd never make it. But I do think it's interesting to understand some of the science behind our relationship with alcohol, because so much of what we talk about in sobriety is emotional. We talk about our behaviors, our habits, our relationships, the things we regret, and the things we learn about ourselves. But every once in a while, I think it's worth asking what's actually happening in our brains and bodies. And this week's conversation with Bailey really got me thinking about that. First of all, I just want to thank her for coming on and sharing so vulnerably. There were some really sensitive topics in this episode, and it was heartbreaking to hear some of the things that she shared, the depths and desperation that she went to in her drinking, and just to think of being twenty again and twenty three and twenty six in these really pivotal ages that she was experiencing life in this really destructive relationship with alcohol. And I am just so grateful again. And I said it in the episode many times. I'm just so glad that she made it through and is able to share the way she
Load full transcript
does because I know it's connecting with people in her age group and and phases in life and all of these stressors and things that are going on. And just how you can get help and navigate through these really rough and dark seasons. So just a huge thank you to her for coming Yeah. But during her story, she talked about drinking before class, drinking in the mornings, and wanting to like pre game When none of her classmates and friends and peers really wanted to participate. It was how her desire to drink seemed to be different from the people around her. She was ready to go. And everyone else was essentially saying, We're going to class. And I kept thinking, why? Why did she want alcohol so badly in situations where nobody else seemed to be thinking about it? And it got me thinking about this in a few different ways. Why do some people drink so much more than others or think about drinking so much more than others? And why does alcohol seem to have such a different hold on different people? So let's jump in. I've got five points today to talk through. Number one. Does alcohol affect everyone differently? I actually have an example to share from my own drinking days about how I could tell that my drinking was different from other people. I remember planning my daughter's fourth birthday party, and since no one asked, I'll let you know. It was a Sophia the First theme. So she was literally in this like beautiful lavender princess gown was so cute. so I set the party, I scheduled the party to be from eleven to one. Not just to accommodate nap times, which was definitely a consideration, but also because it would be an acceptable time to drink. So in my head, I'm thinking, great, we can do mimosas. Because apparently nothing says happy birthday to a four-year-old like popping a bottle of champagne at 11 a.m. But that's exactly what I did. I opened that bottle, started offering everyone mimosas, and I remember people looking at the clock and politely declining. And I was surprised because in my mind, this was a perfectly reasonable and thoughtfully curated opportunity to drink. But clearly, not everyone else was approaching this party with the same priorities. I remember people being like, maybe in a little while, like kind of pushing it off, or they would say, I have so much to do this afternoon. In my head, I'm like, Yeah, so, so will I, but I'm gonna drink and do all those things too. So It was just this noticing of the way people approached alcohol differently than I did. And that's what I think makes this topic interesting. Sometimes you really don't realize how differently you do think about alcohol until you're in a situation kind of like that where everyone else seems perfectly content without it. And it does make you wonder why that desire is so much stronger for some people than others. So let's start with something that sounds obvious, but it's important to just state. Alcohol does not affect everyone the same way. And I'm not just talking
about body size or whether someone ate before they started drinking. I'm talking about how alcohol actually makes people feel. Think about the different types of drinkers you've encountered. And I have been all of these at one point or another. Some people get loud and energetic. They're suddenly everybody's best friend. Some people get affectionate. Some people get argumentative. They go from being perfectly pleasant to wanting to fight somebody over absolutely nothing. And then there are the people who get sad. Bailey actually described herself as a sad drinker. And I thought that was interesting because we often talk about alcohol in this generic way as if it creates the same experience for everybody. It doesn't. Alcohol affects brain systems involved in emotion, inhibition, judgment, and reward. and the way those effects show up can vary based on the person, the amount consumed, their expectations, and even the environment they're drinking in. So someone might feel relaxed and happy after a couple of drinks, while someone else might become anxious, emotional, or irritable. And even the same person can have different reactions on different nights. Now, here's something that I do think is particularly interesting. Researchers have found, yep, you heard it, researchers. that people can also differ in how strongly they experience alcohol stimulating and sedating effects. Some people experience a more noticeable energizing or rewarding effect, especially as their blood alcohol concentration is rising. Others experience more of the unpleasant effects, like feeling sleepy, dizzy, or physically uncomfortable. And according to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, see? Facts, guys. These differences in how people respond to alcohol can actually influence their risk of developing alcohol problems. People who experience stronger stimulating effects or relatively weak intoxicating effects May be more likely to drink heavily. Think about it. If alcohol makes you feel fantastic, energized, confident, and social, you might be more motivated to keep chasing that feeling. If two drinks make you feel exhausted and nauseated, you're probably not particularly interested in a third. Of course, that's not the whole story. People can drink heavily for many reasons, including to relieve distress. And someone's response to alcohol can change over time. But it does raise an interesting possibility. Maybe the person who's perfectly satisfied with having two drinks isn't simply demonstrating superior willpower. Maybe those two drinks are creating a different experience for them. And I think that's worth remembering when we start comparing our drinking to other people's. Number two. why does one drink make some people want another? Let's talk about something I think a lot of people will recognize. That feeling when you're having your first drink and suddenly you're already thinking about your second, and then your third, and maybe your fourth. Because I
think this is where some of us have a very different relationship with the phrase, just one drink. For some people, one drink is genuinely one drink. They have it, they enjoy it, and then they move on with their lives. Which for me is a fascinating concept and is one that I think should be deeply studied. For other people, me, one drink is basically the opening act. It's not the event, it's the warm-up. And the minute that first drink hits, you're already mentally scheduling the next one. It's almost like the first drink doesn't scratch that itch. It makes the itch worse. It's like it doesn't satisfy that desire to drink. It kind of activates it. So what's happening there? I think that's where things get interesting. Alcohol affects the brain's reward and motivation systems, including pathways involving dopamine. Now, dopamine gets talked about constantly as the pleasure chemical, but that's a pretty oversimplified description. dopamine is also involved in motivation, learning, and helping our brains recognize things that might be worth pursuing again. And again, the NIAA, NIAA, the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, which I'll reference several times throughout this episode. explains that dopamine helps our brains learn these associations with alcohol's rewarding effects. And over time, those associations can become powerful triggers for wanting more alcohol. So when it creates this rewarding experience, our brains can learn to associate drinking with that reward. And over time, those associations, the sights, sounds, people, and situations connected with drinking can become cues that trigger a powerful desire for alcohol. Think about how just walking into a restaurant or hearing someone open a bottle of wine can suddenly make you want a drink. literally, your mouth can start watering. You haven't even tasted anything yet. but your brain already recognizes the situation. And with repeated heavy drinking, these learned associations and changes in brain function can contribute to stronger cravings and more difficulty controlling consumption. Again, it is an addictive substance at the end of the day. Now, this doesn't mean everyone who wants another glass of wine has developed an addiction, but it does help to explain why the desire to continue drinking can become much stronger for some people than others. And I think this is one of the ways some of us begin noticing that our relationship with alcohol Is different. Maybe you're already thinking about the next opportunity to drink before the current one is even over. Or you're planning how much alcohol to bring to an event while everyone else is focused on what food they're making. Or you're disappointed when someone suggests an activity that doesn't involve drinking. I remember this once. It was before we had kids, but my husband and I got invited to go to an escape room for my friend's birthday. And I was so annoyed that we had to go and be locked in a room for someone's birthday
to celebrate without drinking. I was dreading it and then counting down the end to where we could go somewhere after and drink. Like she wasn't thinking that way. She was excited about going to this escape room without alcohol. So examples like that and somewhere maybe in the back of your mind you start realizing that maybe the people around you aren't thinking about alcohol nearly as much as you are. that difference in realization can be really profound. Not because wanting another drink automatically means something's wrong, but because the intensity of that desire and how difficult it feels to resist can tell us something about our relationship with alcohol. It's important information. Number three. Is there really an alcoholic gene? Okay, now let's get into one of the biggest questions. Is alcoholism genetic? Because I feel like we've all heard people say things like, alcoholism runs in my family, or I have an addictive personality, or I just don't have the alcoholic gene. So is there actually a gene that makes someone more likely to develop a problem with alcohol? The short answer is that genetics absolutely play a role, but there isn't one single alcoholic gene. and I think that's an important distinction. Alcohol use disorder, which is the medical term for a problematic pattern of alcohol use, is influenced by many different genes, along with environmental and personal factors. And there's a statistic I found pretty interesting. According to, again, the NIEEA, genetic factors account for roughly half of the variation in people's risk for developing alcohol use disorder. Now that doesn't mean that if your parent had alcohol use disorder, you have a 50% chance of developing it. And it doesn't mean that half of your personal drinking behavior is controlled by your DNA. This is where genetics get so complicated and confusing. it means that when researchers study differences and risk across groups of people, genetic factors explain a substantial portion of those differences. But genetics are only part of the picture. Your environment matters, your experiences matter, your drinking patterns matter, your mental health matters. And all of these things can interact. which brings me to something I find fascinating. Because you've probably seen families where one sibling can have a couple of beers at a cookout and forget about drinking for the rest of the afternoon. And then you have the other sibling who's shotgunning beers from the cooler and is running around blackout through the woods. How does that happen? You've got the one sibling who can drink occasionally. Maybe one had a heavy drinking period in college and eventually cuts back or grows out of it, and another develops a serious alcohol problem. Same parents, same house, same family vacations, very different relationships with alcohol. So what gives? Did one sibling inherit some magical off switch that the other one missed? Not exactly. siblings don't inherit identical combinations of genes
unless they're identical twins. And even children raised in the same household don't necessarily have the same experiences. They have different friends, different personalities, different stressors, and different exposures to alcohol, and that includes outside the home. they may even experience the same family environment differently. So a family history of alcohol problems can increase someone's vulnerability, but it doesn't determine their future. And the opposite is also true. you can develop alcohol use disorder without having any known family history of it. Which is why I think the phrase I don't have the alcoholic gene, can be misleading. There's no single genetic test that can tell you whether you're destined to develop alcohol problems or whether you're completely protected from them. It's much more complicated than that. And while that might not be the neat, simple answer we want, I think it's actually encouraging because vulnerability is not destiny. Okay, number four. Is alcoholism a disease or a choice? people have some pretty strong opinions about this one. Don't come at me. Some people look at someone who continues drinking despite serious consequences and think, well, why don't they just stop? Which sounds like a perfectly reasonable question if stopping has never been particularly difficult for you. But that's the point. If your experience of alcohol is that you can have a drink, decide you've had enough, and move on, it might be difficult to understand why someone else can't do the same thing. and here's where the science becomes important. Choosing to take a drink is a behavior. But alcohol use disorder is a recognized medical condition that can involve impaired control over drinking, cravings, continued use despite consequences and other symptoms. It's not diagnosed simply by how many drinks someone has or whether they drink more than their friends. And back to the NIEEAA. Repeated heavy drinking can change brain systems involved in reward, stress, and self-control. Those changes make it increasingly difficult to stop drinking, even when someone recognizes the consequences. Now, that doesn't mean people have no agency or that their choices don't matter, and it doesn't mean that every person with alcohol use disorder Has exactly the same experience. But it does mean that reducing addiction to a simple question of willpower misses a lot of what science has taught us. The medical and disease frameworks are widely used, although there are ongoing discussions about how best to understand addiction and the different pathways people take into and out of it. And here's what I think matters most. Whatever language someone uses to describe their experience, alcohol use disorder is treatable. People can and do change their relationships with alcohol. And understanding that biological vulnerability exists doesn't have to mean believing that change is impossible. Quite the opposite. It gives us more ways to understand what's happening and more ways to address it. Okay, last one. Number five. How does drinking change over time? This is another piece that I think is important. The way someone drinks at twenty isn't necessarily the way they'll drink at thirty or forty. And their experience with alcohol can change over time too. It's interesting how drinking can go from something you do at a party to something you do before the party. And then maybe something you do while getting ready for the party, and something you do after the party. And eventually you're finding reasons to drink when there isn't even a party. at some point, Tuesday itself has become the occasion. Hence the ideas of these drinking days of the week, like Taco Tuesday. Creating this reason, this excuse to party, to celebrate, to drink. And for many people, drinking starts out as something social. It's fun, it's exciting. It's connected to parties and celebrations and being around friends. But repeated heavy drinking can lead to tolerance, dependence, and changes in the brain's reward and stress systems. And eventually, drinking might become less about getting that initial buzz and more about avoiding how someone feels without alcohol. That can include cravings, anxiety, irritability, or physical withdrawal symptoms. and this is something the researchers at the NIAA describe when they explain how addiction can progress. Drinking can shift from seeking pleasure to seeking relief from discomfort. And I think that's a pretty significant distinction, this shift. Because it means the reason someone continues drinking might be very different from the reason they started. why they drink can become complicated. Maybe they initially drank because it made them feel confident. Maybe they continued because it became a habit. And maybe eventually they were drinking because not drinking felt physically or emotionally unbearable. the reasons can change. And sometimes multiple reasons exist at the same time. I think this is especially important when we hear stories of people drinking at times that seem completely unusual to us. drinking before class or drinking during the lunch break or waking up and immediately wanting alcohol. we can't assume we know exactly what's driving that behavior. It could involve craving, dependence, habit, emotional distress, Or several things at once. But it does remind us that for some people, alcohol can become much more than something that they occasionally choose to enjoy. And I think that's where understanding the science can help us approach these stories with a little more curiosity and a little less judgment for ourselves and for others. And of course, there's one important safety point here. For someone who has been drinking heavily for a prolonged period, suddenly stopping can cause dangerous and life-threatening withdrawals. So if that describes you or someone you love, please talk with a medical professional about stopping safely. There is no shame in asking for that kind of help. And just
back to the science piece of it, I think it really is an important layer of sobriety. So like I kind of started in the episode, we talk about kind of our behaviors and our emotions and all these feelings that we're having in our sobriety. But I've heard a lot of times People learning about the science and the brain chemistry and the dopamine and all these things, that piece of it, that arm of sobriety is really important to dip your toes into a little bit because I think it can help you make sense about your relationship with alcohol. Huberman's podcast on this is wonderful. Jill was sober powered, does an excellent job of diving into the neuroscience behind these motivators and all of the reasons chemically that we drink. So I think it's it's really sometimes it's what moves the needle for people. The more they learn about the science of alcohol, it gives you A little more understanding or a little more compassion for yourself when you find out some of these really factual and concrete things, it kind of takes a little bit of that guilt or shame or pressure off of of why you did the things that you do. It's kind of nice to have that, you know, w when I talk about behaviors and feelings and emotions, those are a little more fluid, whereas the science is factual and it's just a different way to approach sobriety. And I've heard for many that it helps you kind of work through it in more of a black and white type manner instead of the gray that can sometimes be introduced with with the feelings and emotional piece of it. So just something to think about. And again, I have facts in here and I have sources, but I am I am not the source for the factual components of sobriety. So there are a lot of amazing resources and literature out there and podcasts and all those things. So something to consider jumping into. So let's wrap it up. So why do some people drink more than others? I think the most interesting thing I learned while looking into this is that there isn't one answer. Some people may have a greater genetic vulnerability. Some may experience alcohol's rewarding effects differently. Some may develop stronger cravings through repeated drinking. And some may be dealing with circumstances, habits, or mental health changes that make alcohol especially appealing or difficult to give up. Often it's a combination. And I think that helps explain why two people can be in the same environment, surrounded by the same opportunities to drink, and have completely different relationships with alcohol. One person might be excited about having a drink, another might be consumed by the thought of when they can have one. And from the outside, those differences might not even be obvious. But I think there's something valuable about understanding that not everyone experiences alcohol the same way. Because it challenges this idea that everyone should be able to drink in moderation simply because some people can. It also challenges the idea that someone who struggles with alcohol must be weaker, less disciplined, or somehow doing something wrong. There are real biological, physiological, and environmental factors involved. And understanding those factors doesn't excuse harmful behavior or eliminate personal responsibility. but it can help us replace some of the judgment with understanding. And maybe the most important thing is recognizing that we don't have to have the same experience with alcohol as anyone else. We don't have to drink the same amount, we don't have to react the same way. And we certainly don't have to keep drinking simply because someone else seems perfectly capable of doing it. Because the question isn't really why someone else can stop at two drinks. It's what alcohol does to you And whether that's something you want to keep inviting into your life. Thank you for listening.