TRANSCRIPTIE 🔗
Speaker 1 0:00
To answer the scientific question, you have to go into a storytelling mode. That's not, and that's not even a kind of an indictment of science. It's just like, how else can you describe, you know, the history of life on Earth, or the history of the planet in the solar system, or the history of the solar system, without moving into a narrative dimension?
PJ Wehry 0:25
Hello and welcome to Chasing the Viathan. I'm your host PJ Wery, and I'm here today with Dr. Boris Shoshi Tadi Shvili, and he is an author, editor, and science studies scholar with a background in evolutionary biology, comparative literature, and classical studies. We're here today to talk about his book, *Our Planetary Mirror: Earth Science and the Reimagining of Humanity* Dr. Boris, Boris, wonderful to have you on today.
Speaker 1 0:51
Oh, great to be with you, PJ Jason Lewis.
PJ Wehry 0:55
So, Boris, tell me why this book.
Speaker 1 0:59
Yeah, I um, well, so the the origin of the book, in a way, kind of goes back to a topic that's not as explicitly treated in our plans here, mirror, and that's this interest that I've had, you know, in combining essentially some of what I was learning as a both comparative literature but also classics by training scholars. So thinking a lot about Greek myth, writing about the Iliad, and thinking specifically about epic as a genre. And at the same time, I have a bio background. And as early as undergrad, while I was juggling these two disciplines, I started, you know, being exposed to pretty major public-facing, you know, biologists like E.O. Wilson, Stephen Jay Gould, some of the debates that were going on in in bio in the 70s and 80s, and what the what what relevance does biology, the natural sciences, and specifically the sort of narrative dimension of the evolutionary story, like taken very broadly. So, if you think about the evolution of life, but also the unfolding of you know historical geology, and you know and and the different eons and then periods and epochs of the Earth and then physical cosmology, this massive story that starts to unfold. A lot of biologists were often at the forefront in underscoring how epic this is the word that they often use in their public writing how epic this story is and I got curious studying since I was kind of studying both they were so separate in my mind it was my science side I had my humanities side and and then I you know this was this unexpected point of contact between them. Like, what do the biologists mean when they talk about this epic dimension of science? Especially given what I'm learning about epic. You know, of course, the word is rooted in the Homeric epics. The word epos, you know, being itself the word for word, right, and also the word for speech, and finally the word for the poems themselves. So the kind of a long way of saying that this question of of if the natural sciences give a sort of epic according to some scientists, who is the hero of an of that
Load full transcript
epic? Another kind of what what does it mean to be a hero in an epic? Not necessarily a hero in you know the Marvel superhero sense, but in that classical sense, it's another word that goes back to Homer. And you know, over time, through twists and turns in what I was studying, I ended up writing about this concept that, and I know we'll probably get into of the noosphere and ultimately these these big planetary ideas for imagining the human, and I, and it was only after I started writing about those ideas that I realized, in some sense, this is growing out of this question of what is the mythic dimension of science, and are these actually images of what a planetary hero would be like? So if if we if we think there is a kind of a story that's emerging out of an interaction with the discoveries of the natural sciences, if it has a narrative dimension, has a poetic dimension. What does it say about who we are? And you know, and and and you know, maybe just to highlight 111 thing about this this concept of the hero that the hero is often the one who disrupts the world of the epic and shows you how it's structured. So Achilles, you know, to take right one of our archetypal epic heroes, you know, is part divine, part mortal. He is, you know, an incredible speaker. He's eloquent, but he's also a completely, a completely brutal warrior and can be like on the you know can descend into the the scariest sides of violence for the human. So he's he's kind of cutting the world into pieces in his own activity in the epic, and then revealing how that world is structured. So you know this is sort of all background to in in our plan. Mirror, you know, if we start thinking of humankind as having, to some extent, a a role in this epic, what kind of transgressive activity is there in it?
Speaker 1 5:13
What do these concepts that are actually emerging out of the earth sciences, out of out of scholars who study the earth and the planet, and you know, and then rediscover the human in that context. Like, what are the modes of tension, disruption, forms of you know violence, and connection that we get from their imagery of what the human being is inside of a story of a planet unfolding, and on the scale of the planet. That's that's a you know partly kind of genealogical personal intellectual history and and that doesn't touch yet very closely on the ideas in the book but it's just it's background that is feels both kind of important to share just because it's always interesting to think about where books come from something we don't often even realize until well after we've written the book, and and I do think it's a background that's that's valuable for framing this whole discussion of what planetary humankind is, if that's what we are becoming. I'll stop there.
PJ Wehry 6:15
Yeah, yeah, that's great. As I'm looking at this, and this I think is just a clarifying question, but it does have it has it has its sides. The people who would take up different sides when you're talking about narrative in science is is narrative something that shows us how science is formed? Like there's a there's a story that we put on it to forming science, or is science actually kind of delivering the narrative to us?
Speaker 1 6:46
I think I think in this case both, and it's that's what makes it such a tangle to you know to try to understand because you know on the one hand for what we sometimes call the historical sciences, used in the specific way of like the natural sciences that have a like a temporal dimension inside of them. So when you're talking about the evolution, the evolution of life, let's say on Earth, or when you're just talking about the kind of formation of the Earth through time, you can't run any experiment in a kind of a more synchronic mode of you know, saying okay, here's an Earth with, you know, here's an Earth where we don't have these chemicals. Here's an Earth that we do. We we can do the best we can by like looking at you know fellow planets in our solar system or imagining artificial simulations. But you can't run the kind of experiment in a lab that you could for much shorter timescales and much smaller scale things. So you're you're what you end up doing, at least this is kind of my understanding experience of the process, is all of those observations and experiments that you can run on small scales. You then connect them all. You give theoretical mechanisms. You know, let's say it's natural selection, or you know, mechanism. But then, beyond even the mechanism and the combination of all of the experiments and observations, you almost have to tell a story to even to even it's funny to answer the scientific question. You have to go into a storytelling mode. That's not and and that's not even a kind of an indictment of science. It's just like how else can you describe, you know, the history of life on Earth, or the history of the planet in the solar system, or the history of the solar system, without moving into a narrative dimension? So that's kind of there, almost I think by default. And then there's the question: once you have that story, do you treat it as the one true story? As often epics tend to think of themselves and the the rhapsodes or the or the cultural figures that are sharing that story. Do you think of it as one story among others, which is always a challenge for epic because there is this grand ambition that any any grand narrative has within it, and that's where it gets like you know. So there's these two dimensions. It's actually like part of how the science itself works, I think, and it kind of has to work. But then it's also tapping into the entire question of what do grand narratives do for us existentially, culturally? How do they share space with other narratives? How do they share space with non-narrative modes of you know explaining like systematic modes, poetic modes. You know, like if you're, I mean, one one example would be like, let's say you have, you know,
you can have you have the Hebrew Bible or you have the Tao Te Ching. One is one has a more obvious kind of narrative unfolding inside of it, and one has a very strong, you know, emphasis on a kind of a mystical poetry, and they each have like hints of the other, but that contrast can be an interesting one because there's also that's just a set like an and yet one more that narrative is not the only thing that verges into poetry, and but but yeah, so that's that's a kind of a a first pass at this, and that I think that kind of helps point to. Some of the stakes as well for this question,
PJ Wehry 10:03
and if you don't mind me digging a little deeper, one is that part of this is that science is a human endeavor, and so it has to even just come back to be human. We explain things in stories, if I understand that correctly, and I just want to see if this if this is tracking with what you're talking about if we look at this from kind of the craft of storytelling, the the argument and the tangle about is narrative speaking or forming science, or is science forming narrative is kind of goes to in in storytelling. Do your characters develop plot, or do your plots develop character? Because science does give you the the characters, it gives you the setting, and it gives you the incidents. How you choose to tell that, you know, you mentioned the Iliad, and you mentioned that that earlier to me. You mentioned that that's what you did. I think your dissertation on yeah, and I'm I'm I I'm reading it with my kids right now. That's what we're doing this year is Greek and Roman history, and we're reading the Iliad together, and they love it because there's violence and name calling because you know they're kids. There is there is a lot of that. Yeah, yes, But sorry, I got I got distracted by that because I've I've been really enjoying that part of it. Oh yeah, no, but I'm looking at what else for them to read.
Speaker 1 11:30
Yeah, no, I mean it's it's it's the highest rarefied form of the artistic expression of that side of ourselves. But it's definitely part of that agonistic mode of you know of the great, and it's fascinating. You learn a lot, also by the way, as you as you might know, you know, and and you definitely see this in translation. You see this in the Greek as well. You also learn a lot about anatomy just because of like how everything is really you know described. Everything that's kind of going on in these battles with with such excruciating detail that like I remember as a student, like reading for the first time in Greek, it's just you're suddenly like the vocabulary, especially for the Iliad. Like for the Odyssey, a lot of the vocabulary is like, you know, what are the different tools you use to build a raft? Like when Odysseus is leaving, you know, Calypso's, and you're like, oh my god, like, like you know, this is like the ads, the board, the augur, all of these like these these words, but from 3000 years ago. And for the Iliad, it's often like, what are the different? I mean, in a like, you know, it's both like a very kind of funny dimension because we have the distance from it in time, but also it's just like yeah, all the parts of the body that are, of course, you know, vulnerable in this setting of of the Trojan War that the warriors are. So anyway, that's that's that's me jumping out of your tangent, no, no, I love it. Yeah,
Speaker 1 12:43
with you.
PJ Wehry 12:43
We're reading, so we're. I'm reading with them. I chose Lombardo because the Lombardo translation is the most. I mean, it's already can be a little bit difficult for them to get through. But anytime, like you know, you can translate something as like you dog face. You know, they love that kind of thing. But and I and I, yeah. So as we as we're looking at this, one of the things I want them to choose a book of their own to read, but it has to be kind of Greek inspired. And of course, there's like so many retellings from the different viewpoints, and is that kind of the the incidents and the characters and the setting are all the same, but is that kind of is that back and forth kind of what we're getting with science and with the actual like how you you formulate those all together? For instance, I mean, as we talk about you know you're talking about the noosphere and the Anthropocene and the Gaia hypothesis. Some of this is like whose perspective are we telling the story from? Because the characters are generally the same and the incidents are the same, but it radically changes. I can't remember. I was just looking at it, and it might be a little too old for them. But there's there's a retelling of the Iliad from the story, the viewpoint of Briseis, and I was like, "That's going to be. I'm like, "I have a feeling that that's going to be a very different and very difficult story than the Achilles Patroclus fight. Yes, fighting Hector. Yeah,
Speaker 1 14:19
yeah, no, absolutely, and even like Song of Achilles, that famous novel that I think Madeline Miller wrote, telling it from Patrol's point of view. Like, yeah, and and the shift to Briseis and or Briseis. Either way, it's uh, it's also probably Brisa. Yeah, yeah. Even the way you said it is for sure, right? They're like they're like five different ways of of like trans translating Greek and picking which modern, and we we're not even completely positive about how the ancients, you know, pronounce these their own their their language. So it's a so no no we have lots of flexibility on that. But no, no. But your question to your question on perspective, which character, which perspective on a character, I think that is really helpful here because. Does you know how would I put this? Like I think one thing that I find interesting. I've I I remember one of my favorite fantasy authors that because I grew up reading a lot of high fantasy. I've got you know the Shire is hanging right in the background up there, and um but one of my favorite fantasy
authors, Robin Hobb. I don't know if you ever read her books, but she, yeah, she has. I was watching an interview with her, and she says, and her books, they're they're amazing, and they kind of pull you in, and they're such like character intensive, interiority intensive. It was unusual for high fantasy, and one of the things she said, and that like really stuck with me, is like she would be writing, you know, the story of Fitz chivalry, like one of the characters that carried through, like, and she's kind of followed his story across like nine books and most of his life, like from young childhood to, you know, to an older man. And it was interesting because she would say, you know, she's writing this book and it's already like 500 pages, and she's like, and she would say that, and I'm like I'm really ready to wrap up this story. But then Fitz would like demand something of her, like the character would sort of intrude into what she wants to do, and then she would kind of and to her credit, I think she would like kind of throw up her hands, and she's like, if he demands this, like I have to give him this, and so she would expand the story, and she's like, the last thing I want to do is write another 60 pages, both because the publisher is not going to be like amazingly thrilled, and because like I've already been writing 500, and I thought I was done. And you know, we all have this experience, I think, with our writing, even academic writing. But to bring that to like to combine that with your question, I think there is something about specifically these three ideas of the noosphere, the Anthropocene, and Gaia, and with Gaia, like maybe a subset of Gaia, of like to what extent are we inside of the superorganism, living body of the Earth, or to what extent are we kind of a child of that superorganism that has its own superorganic qualities and is differentiating? But in all of these cases, the scientists that came up with the ideas-they were studying the Earth and its dynamics. They were thinking, like to use the noosphere as an example, they were looking at you know Vladimir Venodsky and Pierre de Chardin, the two kind of co-theorists for that concept in the 1920s, you know, Vladimir Ronatsky is the one who gave us the idea of the biosphere that we have from you know before the 1920s developing idea. Like it was just a word used in one text, and then Bernatsky took it and said, "No, like we have to think of life as a an interactive, powerful sphere that shapes the planet. And it was deeply, you know, these were people thinking about the biosphere and its relationship to the atmosphere and the lithosphere and the hydrosphere, and all of it was just, you know, a planet made out of these somewhat almost concentric spheres, which itself is interesting.
Speaker 1 17:53
Brings us back to the, you know, music of the spheres and the older cosmology that was like coming in actually at this time into our vision of the planet specifically, but what's interesting is like he's studying like that's his background, and then he is thinking about the human, and he's thinking about it before we even have photographs, you know, from space of where we can now kind of see a network of technology and the night sky lit up by our electricity and all of this. Like he's writing before we even have that visualization, but is already recognizing we've kind of covered the earth with our ways of life, our technologies, just our bodies. We're we're sort of, and he says in a way, it strikes him in a way like we kind of can't think of the humans as just just one part of the biosphere, even though we're clearly that as well, because we look so different. Just like the biosphere, in a certain sense, looks so different from the lithosphere of rock and the atmosphere, air and the hydrosphere of water. It kind of weaves among all of them, and you know. So the the point I want to make is like the character in a way that they were interested in was the planet, at least Vernadsky to speak for this point, and then but then in studying the planet, it was almost like you know Fitzchivalry telling his author Robin Hobb, "You have to write me another chapter. In this case, it's like we're studying the planet, and suddenly we have to grapple with the human as this planetary layer that we don't really know how to talk about, but they start trying to find the language for, and it's not necessarily like something they wanted to or intended to. I mean, I'm sure they were perfectly interested. We're all interested in what we are on this planet, but I think that's part of the that's part of the dynamic is like almost science, which the natural sciences tend to be somewhat suspicious, with understandable reason, of you know, of focusing too much just on the human. You know, there are sciences that do focus on the human, but if you're studying planetary systems, like you know, the sun and its relationship to the Earth and photosynthesis, these are huge forces that have very little to do the human historically until you know more recently, but. Then, in spite of that desire to think about the planet and have that slight distance from focusing and and overselling the role of the human, they still get pulled into it, and the character kind of demands attention. And so suddenly, we're in this position of like now we're describing the human in a way we never have as a sphere of the Earth. What does that? What does it mean to be one of these spheres that are in and out of harmony with each other? And is it, you know, a form of like dangerous and delusional anthropocentrism to say that we are a sphere that, in some sense, is you know comparable to the biosphere, the lithosphere, or is it something we actually need to do? Because otherwise, we're closing our eyes to a reality that seems to be kind of hitting us when we just think about the planet from. So, so I think that's that's a kind of a long answer, but I think the characters are
actually kind of breaking through in a way. Yeah, and and that's just you know, I think the noosphere is just one one of the three where that's particularly evident, but I think we, yeah, well,
PJ Wehry 21:05
yeah, absolutely. And just as an aside, so all I read from Robin Hobb was the Assassin trilogy, and it left me feeling very very sad. And so I never read any of her other books. So I need to get maybe after some recommendation. But
Speaker 1 21:19
it is so you you you have been with and and and I will say like they don't change like you know so the Assassins trilogy goes up to like Fitz's like you know he's 2122 the next trilogy that she has picks up Fitz's life as like a 3637 38 year old and then the next trilogy is 50s or something like this so she she stays with Fitz but it stays sad I mean there are moments of. So I will. I will put that. I will give you at least that. Like that. That general. Like there. Depending on what your mood is, it's amazing. But yeah, you definitely feel the ache for this character. Like yes. Okay. So I. I do want to skip up the three models, but yeah, I will say. I just like
PJ Wehry 22:03
to read 1500 pages and then to be like, "Oh, that's depressing. Was just a little.
Speaker 1 22:08
Yeah, it's it's kind of it's demands demands to be written. Yeah,
PJ Wehry 22:17
he's a sad guy. Well, he ends up in sad situations. Anyways, so. So I think this is a good point to to, if you don't mind, to walk us through what are the differences
Speaker 1 22:30
between the the noosphere, the Anthropocene, and the Gaia hypothesis. Totally, and and you know this gets at like if we can think of humankind as having some kind of heroic role in the planetary story, what are the one way I started kind of putting this to myself, almost you know, in the conclusion of the book after having written the book and thinking about how do I wrap this up, is these are really kind of three faces for the planetary hero, just as you know, if you think about Joseph Campbell in *The 1000 Faces* like he's trying to say that there's some archetypal structure, and then there's variation, and these are, and and you know, even though you can find shared characteristics between you know Achilles, and you could say you know Moses, Jesus, you can pick up quite a few characters that may fit that are, but but obviously the particularity will draw you into kind of completely different worlds and stories. I think something similar is happening with the noosphere, the Anthropocene, and Gaia. All three of the all three of these give us a planetary vision of the human, and I think the move I try to make in the book that's somewhat unusual and informed by this kind of background on the literary side as well as the science is that they each build themselves on and intensify certain very very foundational metaphors, kind of root metaphors that we have. So the the noosphere that we talked about already a little bit is this language of spheres,
and going back to antiquity, going back in Pedocles and to Plato, and but then you can kind of see this to some extent in traditions outside of the you know the Greek and Roman tradition is this idea that spheres are related to harmony. They're the kind of this all-encompassing shape. They're equid, you know, the surface equidistant from the center. They have this kind of container feel, and so there's this way of thinking about that. I think we see in strongest form in that tradition of the whole universe or cosmos is made up of spheres rotating around each other and making music, and that's why the planets move in the sky. Is they each have a crystalline sheath that holds them, rubs against the crystalline sheath holding adjacent planets, creating a music altogether. I think that actually made its way into science in the late 1800s and then 1900s, and that's where. You know, when we say biosphere, and when we think about how the biosphere relates hydrosphere, atmosphere, we are immediately thinking in terms of harmony as well as a kind of part of this metaphorical model. And so, when the noosphere comes around, you know, it's it's kind of fascinating because the three, the two thinkers that I mentioned, they are thinking about what is the role of thought-that's this word noos or nous, right? The Greek word for thought and mind. You know what? What does mind do, and how does mind appear on a planetary scale? And they are drawn to this language of spheres. It manifests as its own sphere, and then they want to say, and this is really interesting because they're writing and thinking. You know, they both have certain kind. Like, well, Teilhard especially has a really intense experience of World War One. He's a stretcher bearer. Bernatsky for the you know for Imperial Russian and the early Soviet Union is gathering information about you know everything that humans can use to build the kind of technology that they need for the war. So they both have these roles in in the First World War, and then they both live long enough to see the Second World War. And that's the so they're writing about the human sphere during you know some of the most intense forms of human suffering. That's of course bless you. That's driven by technology, or or or at least you know where technology has now the power to amplify human suffering to these extents. So you would think they would be more pessimistic, but when they write about the noosphere, they almost treat it as like things can harmonize. Like the noosphere is emerging, and everything will be. So reading it in a weird way feels very prescient.
Speaker 1 26:39
Because on the one hand, because Teilhard, for example, will say, you know, computers like are emerging, the very earliest signs of computers, and we have communication systems that are connecting the world all over. These are like the foundations of a global mind. So he's already in a way got the two pieces of the internet and speaking to the. But then, in
the same breath as saying that, he says, and now we're going to live in this harmonious and like amazing, interconnected, you know, future that's going to pull us away from from history and into union with the divine. And it's a very, it's this very, you know, and and you know, one other tag is that Teilhard de Chardin is a paleontologist and a Jesuit priest, and Vernadsky is kind of a humanist mystic material, so they're they're they're they're they and and they have different optimistic aspirations for what the noosphere is becoming, kind of rooted in these the different backgrounds there. But in both cases, they're incredibly optimistic that this is gonna you know, and and so so for them, the harmony side came first. In our moment, we read them and we're like, "Oh, there's a lot of prescient stuff here. But what about all the disharmonies of how the the forming noosphere relates to the biosphere, or how it relates to, you know, our individual cognition when we join these kind of global networks? And and and so that's you know that's just one point about sphere, sphere talk, the sphere metaphor, the importance of harmony or disharmony in that metaphor. We can kind of get into all of that more, but to contrast that with the Anthropocene that a lot of listeners have heard about, this you know this idea that humans have become that we have such an impact on the planet and on its different systems. You know, climate is probably the sort of proxy issue we think about this through. But obviously, it's like like you know, our industrialized societies affect so many things all around us. You know, we move rivers. We you know we move more land than tectonic activity does at this point every year, and all you know all all of these various effects that, and we leave so many what some geologists are now calling techno fossils. Like the whole world is full of our technology. So the Anthropocene comes out of this thought of that. In you know, if you go 1000, project yourself 1000 years from now, and you're looking through the layers of the Earth, or 20,000 years from now, or however, you're going to see this radical change around these 200 years, especially around the last 75 years. You suddenly have radioactive isotopes everywhere, from nuclear testing and nuclear bombs. You suddenly have techno fossils of all kinds, like everywhere in these layers. There's there's going to be such a radical shift that it would at least mark a new epoch in geological time. Like if we saw that in like you know that's that's kind of how we think about the the separation between other epochs. Time is like looking, and so the Anthropocene is this point of like what kind of force are we? It's not so much like are we a sphere with harmony and disharmony as as part of that metaphor, but what kind of force are we inside of an ancient system? And that kind of tracking that metaphor kind of pulled me into the relationship of force and kind of cosmic coherence that goes back into a lot of traditions, you know, including kind of the Greek one that we've touched about. Like, you know, what's the relationship between the kind of force? That Zeus can affect in the world, you know, with the other gods, but sometimes like against faith. Like when he wants to save his mortal son in the Iliad, Sarpedon, he Hera tells him, "Listen, if you do this, if you exert your divine force as the most powerful of the gods, it will disrupt the whole order.
Speaker 1 30:19
Like you, you know like this like on the one hand you're forceful and you keep us all kind of in line on the other hand there's always this dangerous point where you exert too much of your force and the whole system falls apart and I actually think this poetics of how force relates to the cosmos or later on to to systems like Earth to Earth system in this case is coming back now with the anthropology. We are a force. We can do all sorts of things. We express all sorts of different ways that life, you know, like we're changing the atmosphere. We're doing at least one some part in that. But but you know, bacteria changed the atmosphere in the Great Oxygenation 2 billion years ago, so like that. But we're doing it in our this particular way. Are we disrupting the system? Are we creating a different system? Are we going against the measures that are in place? This it pulls us into a different language and different way of thinking than spheres and harmony. And you know, one of the like adjacent concepts to force and system here is tipping points. We've heard about this a lot. Like we warm the Earth enough, we're worried it'll fall over a tipping point and we'll lose a form of stability and we'll have real you know we'll enter a regime that we don't yet fully understand. That will so we're worried that we like if you even visualize it, you push the Earth enough as a force, it tips over, and you're worried. Like then it tips over, and it falls into some other basin to think abstractly. But that's what this force language kind of brings out for us: this like feeling of tipping points, of landscapes of stability and instability, of sort of our role in,
PJ Wehry 32:00
you know, our role in directing our activity, whereas the sphere is much more kind of harmonics. How do different layers? Yeah, there and so it's just they're very different ways of thinking. And we can jump to Gaia next, but I want to pause in case we want to take it in any other directions. We can always come back. You know, Gaia is the metaphor is the body as a as a preview, a collective body, and that's a loaded metaphor. And and then oh yeah, you might have you probably have have thoughts. You you know, and I'm happy to go wherever you want to take it. Yeah, well, what's actually interesting is even as you're describing how different they are, I'm hearing similarities. For instance, one we're talking about coherence, and the other one we're talking about harmony, and then, and some of this may be just point of
view, or maybe I'm misunderstanding. So I'd love to hear what you think when you talk about this tipping point, and we're scared of what's going to happen after the tipping point. But I think the harmony of the spheres idea, if I understand correctly, is that that they will, it'll come into balance eventually. Would that be kind of like? I mean, if you wanted to synthesize both of them, you could like. I, I, and what I'm thinking of here specifically is the day after tomorrow. At first, it's like, oh man, all these terrible things are happening to humans, and then the end of it is like, oh, the Earth has reset itself and it's doing fine because you know it's like oh it wasn't about us at all you know and I understand that's one perspective on it but is that one way where these kind of can meet
Speaker 1 33:32
no I like that a lot I think I think there is a sense in which like even if Hayard and Bernatsky were so you know put so much emphasis on harmony and harmony coming soon, and we can't hold on to that in the same way because we're actually living the reality. We're living the reality that they prophesied, but the experience of that reality is so different from what they envisioned it would be. It's like the weird part is like they're they were more right than they knew, and but like you know, and so even even with all of that, though, I think when we think in terms of spheres, I think you're right. I think ultimately there is this feeling; it opens up, you know, like music. Like if we're in moments of extreme disharmony, you know, those moments can still be resolved ultimately. And and there's there's a kind of an esthetics, a really strong esthetics to spier language. I think this one it draws a certain kind of person. Like people get really kind of connected to this idea of the nose here in this interesting way that I found in navigating these spaces, and and so I think you're right that there is some sense in which ultimately, you know, once you're in sphere language, the idea of reharmonization is is kind of present, even if it's distant, even if you're not as kind of sanguine or optimistic as Teyard and not the key word. But then when you get to the Anthropocene, yeah, it gives a much more intense feeling for like what are the stakes at this moment, what will. Happen if we keep pushing the way we push, but also, and I think this is you know another set of concepts I think more and more people know about, but it's kind of I think worth bringing to people's attention is like there's this idea of the of the you know whether it's a climate or just more generally Earth system tipping points. You know, if glaciers, the sea levels rise, that's one potential tipping. If you know things get hot enough on average that it, yeah, essentially like yeah, we end up in like strange El Ninos wildfires, etc. That's another kind, but it's like the set of geological tipping points. But then the same scientists that are studying the geological tipping points are then thinking, well, wait, if like there are things that we press on in the more than human world, like in you know in the world of of you know of Earth systems, and then those things can like you press and you don't know exactly when, but you press just enough and or by accident in the wrong or you know right place, but in this case the wrong place, and everything tips over. Why can't we have things like that in human society? And so there's this idea of social tipping points. Can we press enough? I mean, the argument would be like make solar energy super cheap. And if you have enough, you know, governments or people, and as I mean, this is I think one of the interesting points of optimism that are now around in climate circles, which is fascinating to see because that is tended to be gloomy. There's plenty of like cause and people that are still kind of gloomy about things, but there's also, or sometimes it's the same people who are saying, but like what we didn't expect is how cheap solar would happen would become how fast that it's now like, you know, it now really is a competitive form of energy, and that's a kind of and more of the of of the Earth system scientists who are particularly worried about and interested in tipping points in the Earth system are actually getting interested in can we actually marshal the same kinds of dynamics in the human world and push like you know our economics and technological systems and and cultural systems in the right place that big changes happen, and we find a new new forms of organization for our energy regimes, for whatever the case may be in our human world.
Speaker 1 37:09
So it's almost like using one tipping point to prevent the other tipping point, kind of like studying the Earth system and studying the biosphere, and then realizing, oh, what what if humans are a sphere of their own, and how do these react? It's the same kind of mode, but to get to your question, like the whole Anthropocene imaginary is still about like these intense. It it has a its poetics has less of this like the esthetics of music and more of the intensity of like pushing of things falling, of things kind of then getting pushed back, like stopping the fall, or like keeping it, you know. And and and and I think it brings us into a different mindset, and has just, I think they all have like dangers and values they've taken to extremes. So like the the the sphere language, I think Teyard and Renatsky are helpful because I think you see the extreme of like it's all going to be wonderful, you know. Let's hurry and throw ourselves into every aspect of you know of of of new of of the new technologies and ways that we're reshaping the earth and each other and how we talk and interact. And there's a danger in like committing to that extremely and imagining the harmonies there and coming. And there's a danger in the anthropocene side, where we're about to like fall into this horrific future, like you know, it's like you
know that can be very dispiriting. It can actually work against you know, and and and we've experienced in in a way that's maybe more familiar to us in 2026 that aspect than the than the fear aspect, which I think was more the case for the you know post war era where people like did think like computers are going to usher in, and and the early internet, the internet has brought a lot of great things, but it's an it's as as anything, it's an ambivalent thing, right? And yeah, anyway, so that's um, so that I think you're onto something. That that rings true to me. That'd be yeah. I mean
PJ Wehry 38:59
that's that's that's like reading Isaac Asimov and Foundation, and the way that it just-you know-you are like he-he. You could tell that he introduces problems, but that really he doesn't believe in that. He thinks that we're going to like mathematically solve. You know, it's like so much more. But I appreciate you bring. Yeah, I appreciate you bringing this up because it was actually not entirely new to me, but the the doom and gloom side of climate change. It's not that I disagree with with with climate change. It's that it leaves us with nowhere to go. And I had Rob Verchik. I don't know if you know that name, but he. So he he worked in the White House under Obama with the environmental like dealing with climate change, and he wrote the octopus in the parking garage, and he said, "I
Speaker 1 39:54
feel like I've heard the title of the book.
PJ Wehry 39:55
Yes, it was, and I really appreciate how he said, "We can't." There, right, like, and talking about climate resilience and starting to give power back to people and how to deal with climate change at a local level, and not just like, hey, how do we stop the whole Earth from melting? But like, how do we prepare for the sea levels rising? You know, like, you know, in Florida, very different from sea levels rising, the glaciers melting in like Montana. We'll still have effects, right? And so, anyway, I appreciate it. I think that's something that I want to constantly press on: is not denying climate change, but trying to think of how do we, how do we, okay, this is happening. How can we stop it? You know, if we can make solar energy, but then, like, how can we have? And I think this is, as you're talking about forces and falling and kind of the inevitability that sometimes come with with Anthropocene language, and that you're you're even pushing against the first level of Anthropocene poetics, if I can put that way, seems very tragic, right? It's very, it's like it's like ah, humans have this fatal flaw, and now we're gonna all just you know like we're gonna end up with our eyes gouged out. And
Speaker 1 41:17
anyways, sorry. Yeah, no, no, I like. I mean, I think actually that the identification of that genre is really good because, in a way, one if if we're going back to you know the ancient Greeks and the relationship between the genre of epic and the genre of tragedy, in some ways, the genre of tragedy kind of zeroes in on some of the most like painful, fraught, full of tension, unable to be reconciled, but needing to be addressed, aspects of you know social life, of metaphysical reality, of all of this. That that genre really like zeroes in on those things and makes it super intense. And the epic is this sort of broad canvas, a canvas that has those elements in it, but it has a lot of different things kind of floating around in it. So it's almost like this kind of relationship between you know this like this kind of vast and and like vast fabric full of different if we want to call them like moods and maybe make it like different kind of colors and weaves. And then tragedy is like you take that fabric and you like you know twist it and you're like holding up like the place where the you know this kind of weave is interacting with this kind of weave, and it's it's a kind of a jarring. And you're saying like we need to pay attention to this too, and I think so. I think there is this sort of relationship a little bit with the Anthropocene specifically, let's say, and all you know climate being like the proxy that we all are most familiar with talking about it, and this like much bigger story, and like we of course need to focus, kind of like you're saying, we need to focus on the tension. But if we are always in the tragic mood and we lose sight of that epic fabric, that it can also be stifling and you know dispiriting and and ultimately self-defeating, and I think like, and this is the like the the thing that was kind of coming to mind. I think in a way, I've come to the realization that at least at least this is one. I don't know if I want to say provocative take, but one of the things that makes it kind of that has divided tends to divide people on climate, especially, is that I think there's a bigger conversation behind climate that is a very hard and kind of scary and weird conversation to have that pulls in everything-not just climate, but geoengineering. Of like these, if we are a force that can change the Earth system, what kind of force are we? Are we like you know like if I mean the very sci-fi example of this is like if an asteroid is coming towards Earth, we're gonna deflect it, right? That's something that we will use all of the technological force, and we'll do it on behalf of ourselves, and we'll we'll also do it on behalf of like the biosphere that we've inherited and decimated to some extent too. Don't get me wrong; like we we haven't just like amazing only amazing stewards, but we'll still that'll be part of, and so it's like we're we're we're exiting a time of innocence where if we have the capability to geoengineer consciously and intentionally, and there might be good reasons not to do it, but we're gonna have to choose not to do it, and that itself is a weird place to be. Like that, we you know we could release things into the atmosphere that radically, for the first time, like we will have and
increasingly have that capacity. So I think that's the like, I think in a way when we talk about climate, we're actually also talking about that giant, complex background, that epic sweep of how what kind of impacts we can now make, and how we can structure or or you know disrupt or destroy, and all of the various combinations. So yeah, I think there is. I think that's one of the values of the Anthropocene. But I think it like we kind of need to open up that background and about you know have that conversation. As hard and weird as it is, like yeah, and it'll vary.
Speaker 1 45:03
Like you're saying, it'll vary locally, but it'll also like you know we got a is the whole ministry for the future sci-fi of Kim Stanley Robinson. What kind of institution will be built that decides whether or not we solar geoengineer? What humans will have buy-in? Since that'll affect that could affect all humans, very and all of life, and complex life at least fairly directly. So, but yeah, my own yeah, yeah. I
PJ Wehry 45:32
so how do we so we we've kind of not completely nailed down. I mean, you know, we're talking for an hour, but what? How does the Gaia hypothesis then fit in, and what does that give us that's different?
Speaker 1 45:46
Yeah, no, that's great, and it's the one that actually, in a way, I was most nervous about. Like when I structured the book, it starts with three chapters on spheres and here, like the history of that metaphor plus specifically planetary application, and then I did the Anthropocene, even though chronologically the you know Gaia hypothesis, Gaia theory, like came into play 30 years before it was formulated. Really, kind of 30 years before the Anthropocene, but I saved it till the end in a way, like both when writing and and then I actually kind of kept it in the structure, because the metaphor at the base of Gaia theory is the collective body, and that's an ancient and powerful metaphor for political community. It's also the metaphor that, in its in its extreme, you know, we talked about some of the dangers of and the downsides of the extreme forms of like spheres and harmony thought and of anthropocene force. systems thought the extreme form of collective body thought. You know, of course, is essentially fascism. It is the metaphor, the key metaphor of like. So I was like, oh my god, you know, I'm not a political theorist. Like, how do I, you know, and and but but I I can't not write it because you know the book is structured also on two chapters about the history of the metaphor, like you know, from antiquity to the present, and then the application-a third chapter in each section of the application of that metaphor and planetary thought. So you're doing the history of the collective body and its role in getting people to think about the community that they're in and the greater whole that they're a part of. You can't not ultimately like brush against what happened in the 20th century when that metaphor suddenly and this this was the interesting realization or even single realization but just the discovery in reading the literature in the 19th and 20th century of like what happened to the collective body metaphor if you think about the older forms in antiquity of that metaphor, whether it's in you know the Vedas or in how you know Saint Paul uses it or in how Plato uses it, in the older forms, the way we thought about the body was that it was you know a system made up of organs and energies or humors beyond kind of system of medicine, and and so the smallest parts of the body were were like really the organ or or or one of the four humors. You can't just like lose an entire humor without obviously disrupting. Oh, it's kind of an interesting like way of saying it. Losing losing a humor that I'm having a sense of humor, but losing a humor. But yeah, so you can't just you can't just imagine a body losing that part of itself without being heavily disrupted. So you can't be like blasé about like you know if you're seeing, let's say, even if you're saying that the the sort of laboring people that holding up a society are the feet, and there's something you know potentially denigrating, depending on how you're, or or like you're saying, we're all we all have a role to play in the bigger body. You know, you are the farmers or peasants. You guys are the feet. We're the elite. You know, we're the head. You know, obviously, very self-serving can you know keep a power structure in place, etc. But it also implicitly, at least, you can't just lose your feet, and you know, and and and it it also underscores that there's an importance to each part of the body. What's interesting is what happens when our image of the body changes once we have modern cell theory, is that suddenly the body isn't just made up of organs or humors or chi or energy? It's made up of tiny cells, many of most of which are fairly short-lived by comparison to the overarching body itself, with immense turnover, with dynamics like apoptosis, where the cells are you know kind of destroy themselves for the sake of the greater whole, and all of this, and so you suddenly have a radically different image of what the body is. You also have a radically different image of disease. Disease is no longer atmospheric conditions disrupting the humors or imbalances among them.
Speaker 1 49:55
It's actually now, you know, seen as virus. Or bacteria as other tiny cells from outside getting in, or with cancer as cells inside of the greater body that are no longer being team players and are trying to replicate themselves. And so your whole imagery of the body and disease changes scientifically. So the same, the metaphor applied for the political community or the greater system, even if it stays the same, like if suddenly you can look at a human being not as part of the feet, but rather as a cell that can get be turned over, or as a bacteria, the scariest you know version of, or as a virus, or as a parasite that
essentially disease almost becomes parasitism. It becomes like micro parasitism. So with Gaia, that is the part of the background is this vision of of bodies that are bigger than multicellular organisms, and then those can do real political work, make people feel part of a community. They can also sort of bring stability to communities, but if you start imagining the Earth system as a greater body, what are humans in that body? And you know, maybe we're the nervous system, and we have this really important role to play. That's one way Gaetherists, you know, have played around with it. Maybe we're the reproductive system, and we're going to seed other planets with not just biospheres, but with other societies, you know the sort of the you might know this as well. But like the one where Mars has its own society, and the outer, like the mining belt has its, and all of these now are humans kind of evolving slightly differently, but have to have relate like and Earth has its own dynamics. The expanse, the expanse is the show. Okay, yeah, yeah, but yeah, yeah. The expanse has this like this imaginary. But yeah, but like if you start so those okay like you know not the worst thing in the world. But then what if humans in the way that we're disrupting your system, and guy theorists have gone there too. What if we're a cancer? What if we're a disease on the earth, and you know, obviously, none of the Gaia theorists who are thinking about playing with these metaphors are consciously thinking like, "Oh, we're going to tap into the same metaphorical language that's there in the 20th century. You know, 20th century Nazi Germany or Italy, or but you know, the metaphor has its own sort of, and so that's that's sort of a long like kind of caveat of I felt I I personally kind of felt the like scary side of the metaphor very very powerfully with Gaia theory, but then the power of it is it does kind of give you this image of like the Earth really has it's not just an inert planet; it's it's a living body, and it's an so it can be an ethical, you know. Maybe we can call it an ethical agent, but we can at least call it an ethical subject. It's something that has a being that we are in relationship to, and you know, and and we intuitively have this with Mother Earth, with Pacha Mama, with Gaia with all of these traditions that see the Earth as a body that we come from. So you also can't throw away the the body with the bathwater in this in in in this case either. And so it's a very so there's a very kind of powerful form of like relating to the Earth system in a emotionally kind of rich and resonant way, the esthetics kind of do that, and they have this danger. Even more time underscoring, and then there's, and we we can jump into this, but then there's also the like a question of like, is the best way to imagine humans as a collective body, as one organ or part of Gaia, or is it as a differentiating off, becoming a body of? It's the
PJ Wehry 53:47
reproductive. Yes, yeah, the expanse. I haven't. I've seen the expanse, but have not read it. So I've seen it floating. That's something I'm gonna
Speaker 1 53:54
tell you. Oh yes, I'm also going just on. I'm gonna be upfront. Like who knows? The books might be completely different, but I doubt that part is. But like,
PJ Wehry 54:04
I was thinking the the Wayfarers by Becky Chambers, but it wasn't quite the same description. So, anyways, I was like, I was like, no, that's not
Speaker 1 54:11
it. And I know Ursula Le Guin has versions, but yeah, go on,
PJ Wehry 54:14
go on. Oh yeah, I was, I like when you first started, I was like, that could be a couple different series. But then as you were going on, I was like, okay, I haven't read that one. I um, yeah, immediately what comes to mind, and you mentioned that bacteria is the scariest one. I feel like, especially if we're talking about 20th-century cancer, it's probably the scariest one. Where it's literally like you have an an entire replicating foreign body that is harmful. I mean, yeah, if that's not fascist Germany, right there, and you do see, and I, I, you know, I'm not, I'm never fond of like, oh, it's just like Hitler, right? But I mean, I'm just talking about the metaphorical corollary. I mean, this is where you do get people talking about we need to introduce a plague intentionally to kill off a bunch of humans. Because they are a cancer, right? Like, I mean, the the the there's a there is a logic to metaphors that comes out, and obviously, if you're if you're talking about as energies or you're talking about as an ecosystem, you know, people are getting more into like the gut flora fauna idea. It's like, hey, actually, we don't exist without other cells, that kind of thing, then you end up with a totally different way of viewing it. Like it becomes more about harmony and coherence, even right, which is kind of interesting. Yeah,
Speaker 1 55:31
no, I'm totally with you. Just real quick on that, it's like you're right. Like now, with the kind of realization of how important the microbiome is, both our physiology but also development as individuals, the idea of the body is transforming again, and we no longer can look at, you know, we can't anymore look at single cell life and just say like, oh, these are bacteria invading a multicellular organism. Like actually, you know, we exist in huge, you know, communities internally, and that's that's how our bodies have always did, and so that is an interesting point about how like there was a sort of a partial truth discovered in the sciences in the 19th century, and then it was actually like the exaggerated version of that partial truth was part of at least in my reading what made the metaphorical landscape fascism kind of possible and scary. Now we're discovering a fuller truth, and you know still be partial and probably will have its you know its own limitations. But it's a fuller vision of single celled life and what it means and what
it does. It's not even just not only not only harmful. It's also not just neutral. It's also you know there's also positive. Even viruses. It's that whole idea of the human. The you know the placenta or placental mammals is probably something that you know viruses. This is the most kind of as far as I I can tell. This is fairly consensus based science, but I find this so like such a powerful idea is that you know the viruses have to right merge with a cell or get incest, so they have you know certain molecular you know protein whatever the specifics are mechanisms to merge with a cell, and then viruses over time, you know as we get infected, is sometimes they leave their their traces and capabilities inside of our genome, and that the placenta itself, the ability to have something that merges from the mother to the developing the developing embryo, is is a is a remnant of a virus that at some point, like it was the the it was with the very simplest form of single celled life, with even questions of like where on the boundary of what that may have given us that may have given us like the very like one of our more main modes of like what makes placental mammals so distinct and what's such a powerful part of our life, so I find that like that's such a different version of the single cell world than the 19th century initial discovery of that world.
PJ Wehry 58:09
Yeah, yes, and so I one thank you. I've really enjoyed this. I do want to be respectful of your time. So if I can, so if I can ask you this last question, I've really enjoyed this. Besides buying and reading your excellent book, let me turn the page here. Our planetary mirror. Got it. I remember the title, but you know, it's the subtitle gets me. Earth science and the reimagining of humanity. So, besides buying, reading our planetary mirror, what is something that you would recommend to our audience, after listening for the last hour, to either meditate on or do in response.
Speaker 1 58:47
So this is beyond even like what are three books you'd recommend? You know, this is like you're you're asking kind of this this this.
PJ Wehry 58:54
I will say many professors just say here's another three books to read that does, which
Speaker 1 59:00
is I I don't I don't judge that that is just that is a little stereotypical yeah that's the seed that's secretly the seed for like three more conversations and I yeah there you go yeah yeah no I think I think what I would would want like people to do whether it's with these and what I want to do more of myself is like whether it's with these concepts that have jumped out for me as being so vividly, esthetically, conceptually, philosophically rich. I think like I guess is almost like what are when we're looking at some of the biggest disruptions and changes and technological transformations that all of us are kind of grappling with right now-you know, the the rise and proliferation of AI, right, and of generative AI in particular, like being
one one other example that we haven't, you know, that. We haven't had time to like think about or talk about when we're looking at anything anything like this, you know. Like for me, one thing I'm interested in is like the rise of like gaming culture and how much all of us play computer and video games and how much like that. That's like such that's something that like you know, of course, games have always been around, but like now, adults and kids like we spend so many hours in worlds that are about play and made for play, but then they spill out into way beyond just the time that we play. Like the scariest version of this, you know, things like, you know, for drone warfare that pilots, drone pilots, are recruited from gaming populations often. Like that's even those. So when we're thinking about all of these, and it's that's not it's not only a negative thing. I just want to like throw that out because it is one of the. But when gaming leads to violence, sorry, you know, in middle school, in middle school, that was the argumentative paper that I had to write. I think I was on. I like does do do video games are they connected to violence or not? Like as a 12, it was the first time I was like doing research and had to an argument. And I don't remember like the full results of my 11-year-old like you know quest to try to track whatever whatever research was available at the time. So it's a funny thing. But what what I'm I guess what I want to get at is when we're thinking about these things, I think actually one thing that maybe we're right now is what are the sort of background stories? What are the images of what it, not just what it means to be human, on like a in a philosophical sense, but like what kind of myth of what it means to be human and myths plural are we engaging and how to connect the kind of contemporary disruptive elements in our disruptive moment to those myths? Whether those are myths that we're drawing from scientific traditions, whether those are myths that we're drawing from world religions, you know, and I and I don't mean myth in any dismissive sense, as you as you know from our you know conversation, but like that, I feel like we could have conversations that would be strange if more of us did that, but also, you know, I think it would actually, in a very productive way, take some of the the heat and intensity out of the way we describe the way that we grapple with these things right now together because that bigger background is actually I think like again kind of like I mentioned with kind of climate I feel like a lot of the intensity around the issue is partly fueled by the fact that we still haven't found a language for the bigger background and talking about it, and that frustration of not having that is actually fueling a lot of the kind of intensity and the sum of the kind of negative feelings. So that's what I would. That's a very strange conception, kind of prompt. But that's yeah.
PJ Wehry 1:02:55
That's a that's a great answer, pointing us towards a way to have more fruitful discussions instead of more, just let's just bang our heads against against each other some more. Like we're like, it's just it's not. I don't think that's the way forward. Boris, absolute joy having you on today. Thank you. It's it's really been a lot of fun.
Speaker 1 1:03:17
Thank you, Vijay. Thank you for the wonderful interview and one of the first interviews I've had about the book, which is you know coming out and coming out soon. Yeah, yeah, exactly. So thank you so much for kicking it off for me in such a charitable and absolutely.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai