UDSKRIFT 🔗
Megan Willome: George Orwell wrote that bad writing habits can be avoided if one is willing to take the necessary trouble. Welcome to Necessary Trouble, a pilgrimage into writing faithfully. Each season, we read a book about writing craft and critique each other's work right here in real time. As we grow in love of words, we grow in love of God and of our neighbor. Words, they're worth the trouble. All right, welcome back to Necessary Trouble. We are still in season one, and we are reading at Marilyn McIntyre's Caring for Words in a Culture of Wise. This is episode four, and the chapter title is Read Well, which is something all of us are excited to talk about because all of us as writers incorporate reading into our writing lives. So I'm Megan Willamy.
Callie: I'm Kelly Feyen.
Tresta: I'm Tresta Pain.
Megan Willome: And welcome. All right. So glad y'all are here today.
Callie: Good to see you.
Tresta: Yay.
Megan Willome: So read well. Read well. I enjoyed this chapter so much. It was very rich with all kinds of all kinds of meditations on what reading means.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: Who wants to start off with a passage that they really liked?
Callie: I can s I can start. there are so many. I will have to say the one that I that I'm not gonna share, but the one that I really also loved was this idea that reading is a physical act. And just my I I that resonated with me in my own quest into reading because I've always I've been a very slow reader. I was always in the lower reading classes. but the stories imprint themselves on me. So the act of of grappling with those words, sounding them out, trying to understand what sentences mean has always been something that's I feel it, it's been something that's very physical. But I also see that when I'm working with students, especially emerging readers or strong. Struggling readers. just the almost like rocking at times because it's
Tresta: Hm.
Callie: very difficult. And when it's authentic, there are we have to take some breaks because two things. There's there's the content of what they're trying to understand, and then there's the sounding out of the words. And and I think both are just physically draining.
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: So I really I really liked that, but she made that into a an offering and I liked the spiritual part of it that it it is like prayer. and I I I liked I liked that. but the place the the quote that I wanted to talk about was it was on my version is page seventy eight. She says, and some readers, trained readers, good readers, those who are called to teach reading, become the guides or docents in those spaces. They show people around. They help us to feel at home. They help us not to feel afraid. In that sense, good reading is a pastoral calling. And I'm like, I want that job.
Tresta: Do you do you know do you know what I wrote in the margin next to that paragraph? I wrote
Callie: What did you do? Huh.
Tresta: your name, Callie. I wrote your name.
Megan Willome: Yes. I
Load full transcript
think you do have that case.
Tresta: Yes, yes, yes.
Callie: That is what I do. Like I do this. So where do I get a job that is a a pastoral reader?
Tresta: Mm.
Callie: Anyway, I just, I just love that because I feel like in my bones, especially because I don't think of myself as somebody who, you know, can get through a text fast. I feel like, I I know this is hard. I can do this and let me show you around. Let me show you not how to do it, but you know, let's go into this story together. I can remember I was in a Starbucks once. I was in a book club when I was in Washington, DC, and we were reading Dr. Jekyll. I can't remember what it was a big black book, and it's as big as Kristen Lavrins that are just huge. shoot, what was it called? I can't remember. It was a
Megan Willome: It wasn't it wasn't Dracula, was it?
Callie: No, it wasn't Dracula. It was like something along those lines. And it had come out and everybody was love was loving it. And anyway, I had so so my book club's like, we're gonna read it. So I had index cards and journals and the book and you know, different markers
Tresta: Mm.
Callie: and stuff. And it was summer and a woman comes up to me and she says, Goodness gracious, are you doing that for a class? And I said, No, it's for fun.
Tresta: It's for fun.
Callie: She was like, You are insane. But I still have those index cards and anyway. I wish I could remember the title of it, but it was a hard text, but it was fun to like do it on my own time and and look around. So
Megan Willome: Well, and trust is right. I mean, that is a gift you give your students. And of course you talk a lot in your book when we swung from church bells about your journey with reading and about
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: and going into teaching as well. And how the struggles that you've had in being a slower reader, how that has made you a better reader in many ways, and certainly a better
Callie: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: teacher.
Callie: Yeah, I I think that there was I think especially in the last couple of years, there's been I've realized that my experience in elementary education and in high school too, I thought it was definitive and it actually wasn't. It was it was or I it was the wrong definition. You know, to say I'm a slow reader. I assumed that a bunch of stuff about myself. And actually, I'm a slow reader, but there's also, or and you know, maybe
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: that's a gift, you know, like Percy Jackson. I don't know if you guys read The Lightning Thief,
Megan Willome: for sure.
Callie: but he like in the beginning, he's diagnosed with ADHD, dyslexia. Well, you and I I think he has anger issues, something along those lines. and then you realize all three of those things are actually gifts. for for being able to like survive in this other in this other world. And so I loved that idea of like, okay, so someone has labeled you as something and it's a negative connotation. But actually what if it were a gift? So I think
in the last couple of years I've been, you know, messing around with that. But this also just feels like a service, like like an
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: offering. so anyway, that that's the big yeah.
Tresta: So when you s when you say, Callie, when you say that you're a slow reader, do you mean that it takes you a while to get through a text or do it took you a while to learn how to read proficiently? Both.
Callie: both, both for sure. You know, I I don't I don't know I don't know when I mean I know in kindergarten I was in the slower. I mean that was part of it, but part of my reasoning, even at five or six or whenever you're in kindergarten. You know, I lived right next door to a library and I would take stacks of books out of the library and bring them home and quote read on the pic based on the pictures. And then when I started to learn to read and read the stories, I was like, Well, I'm not I'm not happy with this. This is this is
Tresta: Ha ha ha.
Callie: not a story that I was telling myself. This didn't
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: happen in Cat in a Hat. You know, this didn't. And I think that It wasn't like I was being belligerent to not read, but I think the heartbreak feels like a a dramatic word, but I think the the tension of what I thought the story was and realizing what it actually was was kind of hard for me. And so there was sort of a I don't know. Maybe it was belligerence. You know, I just I it it took a long time for me to to sound out words. and it's it still does at times. like classics are very difficult for me. Shakespeare is very difficult for me. I don't just like pick those things up and you know sit on a hammock and read the afternoon waves. We're sitting at a desk. So yeah,
Megan Willome: But yet I can say Yeah. But
Tresta: Right.
Megan Willome: I will say to the world here, Callie has read more Shakespeare than me. You you have and I know you did it in a group and it was a project, but you
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: committed to that discipline. And I just I find that so admirable.
Callie: It was so fun. I really owe so much to Dave Malone for that. I remember he emailed me and asked if I would do it. And I said, that sounds really scary. And he said, that's why you should do it. But it was really
Tresta: Awesome.
Callie: something else. I I really appreciated that. And I and I think Shakespeare in general is about being willing to go back to the story. and and interact with it. I don't know if it's necessarily about understanding everything. I think it's more about, yeah, messing around with the language, playing around with the language and and returning to it again, which is in itself sort of a theological I don't know, maybe a a concept of faith. Like we
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: don't understand everything about what's going on in the Bible, but we return to those stories again, at least I do, again and again and again, especially the ones that are really hard, like Isaac and Abraham, the crucifixion. Like
those things are
Megan Willome: Yeah. Right.
Tresta: Yeah, when it's
Callie: really tough. to yeah.
Tresta: And it's such a different thing to read them. Talking about scripture, it's such a different thing to read to get information versus to get a s a story and to to know
Callie: Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Tresta: a person in in g you know. I and I think so when you talk about being a slow reader, I describe myself as a slow reader as well,
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: but it's more Well, for one thing, I start too many books at once, so it takes me forever to get through them. But
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: I wasn't a slow reader. I mean, you know, they put you in those awful reading groups. I was in the yeah, I was in the advanced group.
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Tresta: But I look back at books I've read and I'm like, I just I don't remember what that was about. And part of it is
Callie: Just
Tresta: that I don't you know, I was heavy on having my kids narrate when we were homeschooling, narrate what they read. So we always
Callie: sure. Yeah.
Tresta: did that orally, but I never did that for myself. And my
Megan Willome: And one thing.
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Tresta: husband is so great. He'll read something, he'll read, you know, three paragraphs in the morning and then spend the next half hour telling me about what he's read. And that's so good for us. but
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: I I just haven't had that. So I feel like I'm a It doesn't matter if I'm a fast reader if I'm not getting anything, you know.
Callie: Right. Sure,
Megan Willome: No. Yeah, no brownie
Callie: sure.
Megan Willome: points for that. Yeah.
Tresta: Yeah. But
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: I will say too, I I read a quote from A. W. Tozer once, or maybe it was in the preface of one of his books. He talked about he doesn't remember who said what, you know, he like he read a lot and he doesn't remember who said what, but he had like assimilated it into himself. So it was almost
Callie: yeah.
Tresta: I think there's some of that in me, but I don't, you know, I want to be able to recall what book. thought came from because it's not my original thought.
Callie: Sure. Yeah.
Megan Willome: Which is something she's advocating in this chapter, like
Tresta: But mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: not just going deeper, we talk about deep, but I think she's also talking like breadth and width and length and depth and this you know, she uses metaphors of entering the text and eating the text and breathing the text.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: If as Callie, you said, making it very physical.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: So trespass.
Tresta: And those things require slowness.
Megan Willome: They do. They all require slowness. So why why are we hard on being slow? Read slow. Read slow. Slow cooking. Yeah. Slow food. That's right. Slow reading. There you go. There you go.
Callie: Right. Right. Yeah. Read s read slow.
Tresta: Read slow. Yeah. Slow food. So yeah.
Callie: Yeah. Yeah.
Megan Willome: Well, Trista, what stood out to you in this chapter?
Tresta: so I have a quote. It's pay starts on page seventy three in my version. It says if you're reading slowly, listening to be addressed, one word or another will summon you. Those are the places where instead of going on, you go in. You pause. You do that countercultural thing you can't do at the movies. You stop. You go into a zone. You let associations come up. You watch the dots connect and a constellation of meaning and message occur in ways that are often subtle, intuitive, and hard to track, whose character is that gift is that of gift or epiphany. I had marked that and then we were talking about slow reading and I forgot that that was that was what I was
Callie: How do you have to mean?
Megan Willome: Yeah, like this that's the definition of slow reading.
Tresta: Yes. Yeah, the the part about letting associations come up for me, that's because I usually have two or three books going at once. and then conversations throughout my day. I just love seeing those things. I love seeing connections. you know, like if I'm reading a book that was written 50 years ago and I'm reading a book that was written this year.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: they're having they can be having conversations with each other. I love
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: seeing those associations. And I mean just today I was listening to an audiobook and I had a thought. I had an association come up and I had to, I paused the audiobook and just let myself think for a while. You know, just have some silence and think for a while about okay, I I have these two different thoughts that have come up. Are they connected? And just thinking through the
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: ways that they're connected. somewhere else in
Callie: Yeah. I love that.
Tresta: this somewhere else in this chapter she talks about a a question, what reactions might be worth taking the time to articulate. And I yeah.
Callie: Hm. I li I underline that one too. I love that. I love that. Mm-hmm.
Tresta: We gotta just take the time to let the associations, you know, let the connections happen.
Callie: Reserve Louis.
Megan Willome: And that requires
Tresta: articulate.
Megan Willome: slowing down, which isn't how
Tresta: Yeah. Yeah.
Megan Willome: we're we're wired these days. You know, like anytime I open my Kindle, my Kindle app is trying to give me points for reading streaks and all sorts of nonsense that I don't care about. But
Tresta: Yeah. Badges, yep.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: that's the way everything is ordered, you know, that you're consume, consume, consume, point, point, point, point, point.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: Instead of doing what you did, Tresta, which was hit pause and think ponder and
Callie: About it. Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: give space.
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: I love that. Yeah. What's what's is it the shakers in their church services? Somebody says something and then there's like five minutes of shaking. Yeah. And maybe it's not even the Quakers. The Quakers.
Tresta: Silence. I
think it's the Quakers. Is it the Quakers? Yeah.
Megan Willome: I think quite Yeah. Yeah.
Callie: I'm like, that sounds like a really nice thing.
Megan Willome: Yeah,
Tresta: Yes.
Megan Willome: definitely, definitely different.
Callie: It is. And I I do think though that there is something to be said for the order of church, the liturgy and and the Lord's Prayer, for example, when like the things that you return to again and again. I'm not saying those are fast, but I do like to I do like to think to think about things on a w you know, return to things again and again, especially those things that I don't really understand or that, you know, disturb me or bother me or something along those lines, which is like all the stories in the Bible.
Tresta: Right.
Megan Willome: Well, yes, and they're also in the in the rereading, it you're gonna hear it at a different place. So,
Callie: Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: for this coming Sunday, I was reading our readings and the gospel readings about the storm, Jesus calming the storm.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: All right, yeah, that's one I've read a thousand times. July
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: fourth is the one year anniversary of the Kerbal Floods. And I'm actually gonna be singing on July 4th. So it is on everyone's mind. So that story just hits differently
Callie: Wow. Wow.
Megan Willome: than it did a year ago. and I just read, speaking of reading, Texas Monthly is a wonderful magazine that's been around for forever. I didn't realize that their story on the floods won the Pulitzer. And I just read it this week when the
Callie: Wow.
Megan Willome: follow-up came out and Yeah, it was Pulitzer worthy. You know, it just it put me there. And it's so hard to write well about about tragedy and this was someone's personal story. so
Callie: Mm-hmm. Wow.
Megan Willome: yeah, that's part of why we return to things.
Callie: Yeah. That reminds me of the the hymn Peace Like a River.
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Callie: I guess the backstory was the father, the a family was escaping somewhere and the his wife and children were on the other side of the river and he couldn't he couldn't cross. And I think that they I think they drowned. And then
Megan Willome: Okay.
Callie: that's where that hymn came up. It is well with my soul. So I can never Yeah. Yeah.
Megan Willome: yeah, I know that's true for it as well. Yeah. It crossing the ocean and
Callie: yeah, yeah. so to think I mean that's one of my favorite hymns and it's just I can't ever sing it without sobbing because knowing this piece of art came from this tragedy, but like what if he had decided like it's too painful to do that? Like the the fact that that hymn I think is not to you this word is used so many times in and you know got the hashtag and all that, but it I think it blesses people over and over and over again. And I mean that in like a really serious way, not like, bless. You know, like it it is a a palpable hymn for for so many people. Even in in the
everyday, it's just to be reminded of of peace like a river, of what that and really rivers are not peaceful. they're they're very scary. You don't know what's what's going to happen. So what does that mean? You know, what kind of and so to think about you know, that that simile is also I mean, I think this is all an act of faith. Is this is how at least the three of us read with these with this lens of faith.
Megan Willome: For sure, for sure. And we
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: did do that hymn. that was one we added in last year after and
Callie: Mm.
Megan Willome: my pianist said they will want to sing it. And it was right. Everyone needed to sing it. We're not,
Callie: Hmm. Are you guys gonna sing it this this week?
Megan Willome: we're gonna I'm working with someone different, but yeah,
Callie: Okay.
Megan Willome: we we are trying to be sensitive.
Callie: sure, sure.
Megan Willome: While also being in a town that loves loves singing the patriotic songs, so
Callie: well yeah. I mean this is a big one. Two fifty.
Megan Willome: yeah. And but but we're believe me, we're like that all the time. Absolutely. Absolutely. Well,
Callie: Exactly. Hmm.
Tresta: It's Texas.
Megan Willome: I enjoyed this chapter a lot, but what was interesting is I read it and then a couple of weeks ago I got to go on the close reads retreat. And they do a book every year. The reason I went is they were doing Lonesome Dove,
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: which I just love. And it was so much fun to spend five days talking about a book in community. That that was what we did. And there were a variety of people. There were people like me who had read it a few times and for whom this was a favorite. There were people who were reading it for a first time. there were a couple people who came to the retreat and said, I can't believe you made me read this. I hate it. Which was great. Okay.
Tresta: no. no.
Megan Willome: And then by the
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: end of the retreat, they're like, I want to read this again. So as we
Callie: Mm, I love that.
Tresta: you converted him.
Megan Willome: talked and people had such different perspectives, people living in different parts of the country and reading different things. it was a like a live experience in reading well. listening to other people, learning from them. I have a lot of thoughts on the book. I've written about it. And I came away thinking, I need another week. Like we
Callie: Mm.
Megan Willome: didn't near cover everything.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: And I think that it's that that physicality and that community.
Callie: Mm-hmm. Yeah. I that's how I felt. though th that was my favorite part of of grad school. We had weekly or not weekly, daily when we went in for those residencies, daily discussions for hours on the common text that we were reading. And I would go in there and think, I want to reread this book because of what they're saying about it. You know, I didn't quite understand it, but now I, you know, I want to go back and look. And it is a communal, it's a communal thing to gather around a story, literally. yeah, I love that experience.
Megan Willome: And and we're kind of doing that here, you know, even though this is not fiction, we're we're reading in community, the three of us, we're writing.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: that's what we're doing. We're we're making it real. Making it real. Okay. Well,
Callie: Yeah. They were making it real.
Megan Willome: it is my turn to be critiqued, to be in the trouble seat.
Callie: Ha ha ha.
Megan Willome: So are y'all ready for me to read? So and
Callie: I'm ready. I'm gonna
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: I'm using this to kind of segue what part of the book did or what part of the chapter did you like. That's what I wrote from. So I liked on page 79, she quoted from chapter three of Ezekiel. And I had
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: randomly just been reading the book of Ezekiel as we
Callie: No.
Megan Willome: talk
Tresta: Mm.
Megan Willome: about, and I was like, I want to do this. I want to do Lexio Divina on this. And I've I've done Lexio Divina. Here and there, I don't do it regularly. So that's what this is.
Callie: Mm-hmm. Okay.
Megan Willome: In the chapter, you know, she writes about what Lexio is and how to do it. So I I have the numbers in here as you can see and everything. So I will read and then you guys, you know, give me some trouble. Give me some trouble. Okay, so
Callie: Ha ha ha.
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: Lexio Divina. the passage is Ezekiel three, one through three. And on this page seventy-nine, Marilyn McIntyre writes, The intimacy of eating is attested to in the Eucharist. So that also inspires. you're supposed to begin with a word. So number one, my word is eat. You start off with a word or a phrase and then read it again and kind of let that phrase be a focal point. So number two. So the word is eat, number two. I'm Catholic. I'm reading this as I text with my pianist about hymns for the feast of Corpus Christi this Sunday. The solemnity of the most holy body and blood of Christ. The introit for this feast comes from Psalm eighty-one seventeen. But Israel I will feed with the finest wheat. I will satisfy them with honey from the rock. In Latin it begins chibavit Eos. There's a whole chant. Why have I never learned to sing this? I'm gonna learn it. I teach this idea of eating and pair it with intimacy when I teach my rosary workshop based on Song of Solomon. I've written a hymn about this. I'm singing it at the feast. Okay, then you read through it again. Is there another word that stands out to you? So, number three, on my third read through, the word is honey. I think this word works because honey not only refers to the sweet thing bees make, but also to the sweet nothings we say to our beloveds, as in, hey honey. The word honey comes from an older word meaning gold. This type of gold is not simply harvested by the bees. There's a whole process forage, flour, nectar,
storage, transfer, break down, fill up, evaporate, seal, store for years, eat. And then in the fourth part, what what are you being invited to in the text? So I wrote, It was fairly recently that I realized Ezekiel, a priest, had a wife. She dies in chapter 24. In 24, 17, the Lord tells Ezekiel to sigh, but not aloud. He tells the priest to not eat the bread of mourning. And like so many things in Ezekiel, this is a sign. Not words on a scroll, but it is real, and he has to eat it. He has to eat it and eat it and eat it and eat it, and fill his stomach with it, and know that the scroll in his mouth will become honey, become sweet, become her. At the five PM Mass we have a visiting priest who came to the San Antonio Archdiocese from Poland. He is tall he is tall and thin and has not shaved in, I'd guess three days. His voice is exceedingly gentle. He talks of his homeland. He recalls coming to Texas and feeling so out of place, learning English and Spanish at the same time, learning to drive a truck. He says he would spend time in this sanctuary when no one was here, kneeling before the statue of Jesus and his sacred heart. Me too, Father, I have knelt in that very spot and sighed. I have wept and I have prayed a cussing prayer. Sometimes I have knelt gently. I have eaten my losses until they became honey, became words, became poems.
Callie: craving for honey now.
Tresta: It was the bread for me. It's always the bread.
Megan Willome: Make yourself.
Callie: And bread. Take some bread, please. Yeah. I one thing that I guess captured me in this was the the scripture in Ezekiel. He says, sigh but not aloud. And you know, I I kind of I associate honey with something sweet, with something good. And this feels like something that he really is going to struggle with or has to struggle with in order for it to become honey. so this idea of grieving in order to turn something into gold is something that's I think I would struggle with or I think I struggle with, you know, to not want, you know, I don't I if I sigh, I usually want to be loud about it, especially if it's something that I'm grieving. so I really liked that. and I like the the the it it seems as if it's getting more intense as the essay progresses. You start with a word eat and then each section gets a little bit more intense and I like that a lot.
Tresta: I wanted to ask why you have the asterisk. Why the asterisk next to I'm Catholic.
Callie: Mm.
Megan Willome: I I had these simply because my asterisk I didn't I felt like they were disconnected thoughts
Callie: Hm.
Megan Willome: that might I don't know if they all belong, but they all came to me. And
Tresta: Mm.
Callie: Sure.
Megan Willome: so I'm not sure if I mean I'd love y'all's opinion on this. Should I Do you have opinions on things that should stay or not? Or should it be more that that especially that section two, should it be more wrapped together?
Tresta: I it feels mystical to me and I like that. And I think that the asterisks add
to that. I mean, I would want to it it feels weird for me to critique this because this is your experience of Lecto Divina as you read these scriptures.
Callie: Hm.
Tresta: but I would want to know why did that why did the fact that you're Catholic come to you on your
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: second reading of it?
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: of the passage.
Megan Willome: Okay.
Tresta: But I don't know that y I mean I I I tend to think, well leave it leave it a mystery.
Callie: That's yeah, I I'm trust, I completely agree. there's the one part of yeah, you could you could leave it as is. But as a reader, I'm also curious about I really like the I'm Catholic, just leaving it at that. But I'm wondering if the next three asterisks could sort of call back to Catholicism and and eating, you know, to and and maybe maybe that's what what you've done here, I I think I I just wanted a little bit more understanding.
Megan Willome: Okay, yeah. What else did y'all notice or have questions about or suggestions?
Tresta: I'm still trying to I know there's a connection there. Just like we were talking about earlier, I need to take the time to pause and figure out what the connection is for me, but between his grief about losing his wife and the honey and the scroll, the word of God and what God calls him to do. I wonder if there's more connections that you could make for the reader.
Callie: Mm-hmm. I was also curious. the Lord tells Ezekiel or he tells the priests to not eat the bread of mourning, but then he does eat he is supposed to eat the scroll. Was was that what was he directed to do that? I'm sorry,
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Callie: I should know this.
Megan Willome: Yes, that and that's from the the passage that Marilyn McIntyre gave us. The scroll
Callie: Okay.
Megan Willome: part is the Ezekiel 3, but then when I went to look up the wife dying, that's in 24.
Callie: Hm.
Megan Willome: But yeah, I'm interested in what you're saying, Tresta, about exploring those connections more.
Callie: I love how you go you hearken back to it in the last paragraph. So there's I mean,
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Callie: I think you're I think you're doing it. You're you're beginning to move toward you know, you had then you you talk about the visiting priest and you sense that there's struggle there and you know, he's moving through something, and then you say, Me too, father. But I love the repetitiveness of become honey, become sweet, become her. And then you add became honey, became words, became poems. and and you and you I don't even know if hint is the right word because it's pretty clear that you've been through something. You say wept, you you pray a cussing prayer. I love sometimes I have knelt gently, which makes me think, what are the other times? You know, and I don't think you're gonna say that, but I I like that, you know, you're saying sometimes I've I've knelt gently, but not all the time. I I love I love that that choice that you made there. But yeah, I think if you wanted to, you could you could explore a little bit more without saying, you know, giving us the the details, you know, give us the cardinal.
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: and then two things that I noticed, and this could just be this could be a deliberate decision, but in Ezekiel's story, it's become honey, become sweet, become her. That feels like it's still happening, like it's one of those things that we have to do over and over again when we are in that mourning grieving process. And I think grief comes to us, you know, it never it never ends. maybe it does, I don't know. But then you have at your in in your story became honey, became words, became poems. And I guess that seems to suggest that it's been resolved. Whereas I just knowing who you are and you know my friendship with you is that the that is your that is part of your faith is your you take those losses, that pain, that weeping and you turn it into a a poem. so I don't know if you if you would want it, I don't know how it would feel to say, I will continue to eat my losses until they become honey, become words, become poems.
Megan Willome: that's that's really interesting. Okay. Yeah, because you're right. There's no dumbness to it.
Callie: There's no duness to I love that line. There's no dunness to it. Yeah.
Tresta: And what Callie just just said, Megan, about who you are as a person, most of your readers maybe wouldn't know that about taking so I think a little bit more about turning your losses into poems.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: But I love that line. I have eaten my losses until they became honey, became words, became poems.
Megan Willome: Yeah, and that talking about about the process of things becoming poems, I I love of talking about that. And that's easy to share about. So
Callie: Hmm. I I also think that I mean I'm I'm just turning over the concept of eating a loss until it becomes honey. And what a that seems like an act of faith to me to to think about what losses in my life can I turn over, can I chew on until they have become honey. And then it until I can turn it into something, which I think is what we're called to do. Right? We're we're called to create from what we have and what we've been given. And so, I don't know. I it it feels it feels like a a prayer to God. I think also like this is a promise. This is what I promise to do, even though it's it's very difficult. And again, I don't know if that was a decision, a deliberate decision, but to say me to father to direct it to the priest. I know you're not directing it to the pr I mean, I know you're directing it to the priest, but the word father makes me think you're talking to God.
Megan Willome: I I deliberately wanted it to kind of be both. Okay.
Tresta: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Callie: I love that. I love that.
Tresta: Yeah, I the first my first reading was God and then when I read it again, I'm like, she's talking to the priest. Maybe.
Megan Willome: It's kind of a yeah. Okay, this is really
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan
Willome: helpful. I will say again, because I can never say it enough, that the feedback I always get is can we have a little bit more? You're holding back on us.
Callie: Yeah,
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: yeah.
Tresta: Which which like I said, I love that sense of mystery. But this this is a pretty short. I think you have a lot of room to pick one step and go deeper, a little bit deeper. But
Callie: And and also, if you're like how, go to your poems and
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: and and you will see how you've done it. Because I know I yeah, yeah, when we have these tough stories, it's like I don't wanna tell all of the details, but is there one one thing that can get at the universality of of it? Like I'm I'm thinking of that poem in your most recent book about the hike. And I know
Megan Willome: Awesome.
Callie: that I projected my own situation into into that. And so I could have been wrong, but like the fact that there was a tense hike, Make that was enough for me to be like, okay, there's there's struggle here. It could be the intense hike, or it could be other things that are going on. And that was enough. So anyway, my my suggestion is if you get overwhelmed with at least for me, when I get overwhelmed with my story, the facts of it, I go and look for a scene, you know, some kind of a situation.
Megan Willome: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Which is what we talked about recently with you. Okay, I like that. And Callie, I was actually thinking of that specific poem. I just so
Callie: were you?
Tresta: Hmm.
Megan Willome: that would be an interesting place where I could explore. Here's
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: what led to that poem.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: okay.
Callie: The other one that does it for me is and gosh, I don't I think I every time I try to read it, I can't read it without crying, but the when Jesus walks into the store and says there's a party. I love that. And there that's another thing where I'm like, he, you know, he's like, let it go. Let this, you don't have to take this with you or whatever. And I I just I mean you have the shivers now, even thinking of it. But again, I don't need to know the specifics. I know what you're holding on to is special. And I also know that you want to follow him. And that and that's enough for me. So
Megan Willome: Man steals heart, no charges filed.
Tresta: Mm.
Callie: I love that.
Megan Willome: That's okay. see now I'm excited. See, when we do this, I know
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: y'all feel the same way too. You're like, okay, I'm ready to go. Ready to go for you.
Callie: I can get back at it. I can get back at it. Yeah. You know, the the other thing that it reminded me of was our conversation a few minutes ago about the communal act of reading, which is what this scene does with the priest and you. You know, he tells you a story, you have bared it, and then you've you've you've turned that into A living of your own experience too. So he's given you a I mean, it's almost it's
it feels like bread, like the breaking of bread. You he's broken something off of himself and given it to you, and then you're receiving it, and y in some ways this is how you've been nourished. And that's and then you're passing it along to us.
Tresta: It's never ending. It's like the loaves and fishes. Like why do we
Callie: Yeah. It is.
Tresta: why do we ever run out of stuff to write about? Why do I ever run out of stuff to write about?
Callie: I I I know, I know.
Megan Willome: Amen. that's so good, y'all.
Callie: And then the last, my last comment was in section three, the second paragraph. I love all these words of of the process. The only word that feels very different is evaporate.
Megan Willome: Okay, yeah.
Callie: And and I I'm not saying take it out, but it's It just made me pause.
Megan Willome: Okay. Anything else from you, Tresta?
Tresta: No, I think you have a lot that you could do to take the reader a little bit deeper. Like Callie said, the universality it's there, but I
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: feel like a little bit more would help it connect.
Callie: Good stuff. Thank you. Hmm.
Megan Willome: Thank y'all. Thank y'all. It's written all over my page. And then I know
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: you also have comments in the Google Doc, which I waited to look at. I wanted to I knew if I read them I would be so tempted to start revising.
Callie: Yeah, yeah. I get that way too. Yeah.
Megan Willome: So I I have held off.
Callie: I don't know.
Megan Willome: So thank y'all. This is yeah.
Callie: Good stuff.
Megan Willome: Yeah, we need to do this together. We need to do this together.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: So and y'all were y'all were reading my piece well, right? You're reading
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: it, you're bringing not only your reading and writing experience, you're bringing scriptural experience, you're bringing friendship experience to this. you're bringing experience of reading other things that I've written. I mean, that's
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: like you guys are reading well in action.
Callie: Mm.
Tresta: She's yeah, she says something about that in this chapter on page sixty seven. She says to read well is to enter into living relationship with another whole self,
Callie: Hmm.
Tresta: which of
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Tresta: obviously is easier when you know the author,
Callie: Mm.
Tresta: but asking good questions can help you get to know the author
Callie: Yes.
Tresta: better too.
Megan Willome: Yeah. Yeah.
Callie: Yeah, I love that.
Megan Willome: Well, thank you. Well, normally at this point in the podcast, one of us will share a tip about reading or writing. But since the chapter is on reading well, and since all of us value reading and practice it, and we make it part of our writing practice, I just wanted to hear a little bit from each of us about How do you read well? How do you approach this as writers? So who'd like to smile?
Tresta: I think our reading teacher should go first. Our pastoral reader.
Megan Willome: Or a pastoral.
Callie: Well
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: w one one thing that well, okay, so when I'm reading you know, s something that I couldn't I shouldn't say is easy, but I'm really into it. I I don't always take the time to do this. But when I am thinking that I'm going to write about it or I'm talking about it with say you guys or like when we read Kristen. I do a I keep a reading journal and I after after I read, let's say it's a half an hour, I take some time to journal about it and I follow these questions. What happened? what did I connect with? if there's any quotes that I want to re copy out. and then what is this telling me about writing? And that's where the that's the hardest thing for me is what is this telling me about writing? So if I'm looking at a a sentence that I find descriptive, for example, I'm looking about, I'm looking at how the piece works. and that's much different than saying, I just loved this book.
Megan Willome: Wow.
Callie: You're saying why it works and how it works. And I think that is the most helpful for me in my own writing. And then finally the last step is does this give me any ideas for blog posts, essays? books, anything like that. So I just kind of have a running log of of things to go back to if I want to. That's how I read creative nonfiction or fiction. When I'm reading a poem, I'll either copy it, depending on if it's in a book that I'm that I'm reading, or I'll print it out and then I go through the senses who what where, you know, what do I not who what where What do I smell, taste, touch, etc.? And then and I Megan, I don't know if this is from your book or Tanya's, but where does this poem take me? How does this poem make me feel?
Megan Willome: I think we both talk about it. We have kind of different
Callie: Okay. And
Megan Willome: words but the same idea.
Callie: Okay. I know that I know that I I know I read both of your books kind of back to back. And so this is just what I've this was the practice that I kind of came up with. and then I always look for an anchoring image for i in poetry. And and if I can't find one, that doesn't mean that it's a bad poem. It just I I really It's it's it feels like messing around with a mystery is okay, what you know, what is this anchoring image and what is it telling me, what is it pointing to? so that's that's the anchoring anchoring image. yeah.
Tresta: That's a great book title, by the way. No, messing around with what did you say, messing around with a mystery? Is that what you said? That's a good book title. Yeah.
Callie: messing around with mystery. Yeah, it is a good one. Ooh, I like it. It's kind of flirty. It's kinda I love it. That's my next book, maybe.
Megan Willome: So you you do this pretty much every the reading journal you do as you're reading, you don't wait until the end.
Callie: I don't wait until the end.
Megan Willome: That's really interesting.
Callie: If I wait until the end, I will miss so much of you know,
of what it I don't know. It it it depends. I mean, I don't do this if I'm if I'm reading like I I just finished Elizabeth Strout's Amy and Isabel. I don't know if you're or maybe it's Isabel and Amy. I know if you guys have read that or not. It
Megan Willome: Not that one.
Callie: it would be I If if I'm gonna go back and do that, I it would be because I'm studying it and I think that would be a book to study. But I got so captured in that, in the plot of it all, that I couldn't I couldn't stop. And I I was it was like I I had to finish it. Not because it was like so suspenseful. It was like I I was just like in the story. I needed to get out of it. And the only way to get out of it was to plow through it. I really liked it. I really did. But yeah, so it but up like right now I'm I'm reading Middle March and I know that that is a very difficult book for me. and my friend Melissa Reesar Poulin and I are reading it together. and that's how I'm reading it is I take a Time where I'm gonna read it. I and also if it's a reading, if I'm reading something difficult, I have to read it at the same time every day. It's like my body is like, okay,
Tresta: Mm.
Callie: this is what we're doing. So
Tresta: Mm.
Callie: middle March is first thing in the morning. yeah. Yeah,
Megan Willome: Okay. Reading in community. There you go once again.
Callie: yeah, there you go. Yeah. I wouldn't have been able to do, I wouldn't have read Kristen without you, Megan,
Megan Willome: Right.
Callie: and Flannery O'Connor without Melissa. I it I I couldn't have done it, but man am I glad I did.
Megan Willome: What about you, Tresta?
Tresta: I'm not near as disciplined as Callie, but I would like to be it's my goal to be
Megan Willome: Hashtag goals.
Callie: Has I go.
Tresta: I know. And you you've given me all the tools
Callie: Ha ha
Tresta: to to read well. like it was said earlier, I tend to I just start too many books because there's so many books I want to read.
Callie: How many bloods? Yeah.
Tresta: what I try to do when I'm reading my best, I have a hard cop or you know, a a paper book that I'm reading. And I have something on Kindle that I read at night in my bed, because I don't have
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: to have the light on. And then I have an audiobook. And that's that's where I'm at right now. So in the mornings I have I have a nonfiction book that I read at night. I'm reading a fiction book. and then the audio book I just started is is fiction as well. But I'm a big book marker. I underline, I highlight, I
Callie: Mm. If you
Tresta: write notes, I just totally deface my print books. So for me, that's why fiction I mu I usually read on the Kindle. And I I have part of my story is coming to terms with the fact that it's okay for me to read fiction as an adult, as an adult Christian woman. In fact, it's good for
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: That is definitely a new book.
Tresta: me.
Callie: Yes.
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Tresta: because I went through years of just reading
for information, reading to be better, to do better.
Callie: Mm.
Tresta: so recovering from that. I I finished the Emma Lyons series on my Kindle. Yeah,
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Tresta: loved it. Well, I loved it except I there there was no resolution. And I know she's writing more, but I just feel like the angst just prolonged and didn't
Callie: Yeah, we know.
Tresta: resolve. So that was frustrating to me. But
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: but when I'm reading on my Kindle, I'm highlighting, I'm using the highlight feature and then I'll go back when I'm when I'm my best self, I will go back and copy quotes in my commonplace book.
Callie: Mm.
Megan Willome: Mm, okay.
Tresta: and with this book, With Caring for words in a culture of lies. I'm defacing the book and then I'm also writing quotes from it in my commonplace journal. and that helps, but I I always struggle with starting too many different ways to track. Like Callie, you said you have a you keep a reading journal.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: Is that where you write your quotes as well, or just your thoughts on the
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: book? Or
Callie: Yeah, I'll do I mean I also underline and mark things up, which is funny because you know, if I ever want to go to you know, give my books away, you know, for thrift stores or whatever, I'm always like, I'm not I'm not I'm
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Callie: not gonna I don't want anyone to read this. So
Tresta: Right. Yeah.
Callie: that's the problem. But yeah, I i it it's all in one journal. And I try to keep that separate from my writing stuff because then it it just gets all I you know, I like to be able to come back to the jo I I c I tend to keep the reading journals and I my writing once it's if it's been published or whatever, I you know, can
Megan Willome: Hmm.
Callie: recycle it or whatever.
Megan Willome: That's interesting.
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: That's interesting. Yeah, I like the variety of what we do. I will say for a long time I was just guilty of reading quickly and being that person who then a month later, I could hardly even tell you that I had read the book, much as it
Callie: Ha ha ha.
Megan Willome: was. You know, I was real yeah, I liked that one. And it was
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: when I was working for T S Poetry and for a while there I was reviewing two books a month. one was
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: children's book and then one was for grown ups. And
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: I usually did fiction because that's what I love. But
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: that made me a better reader because I was preparing to write about books.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: and so even though I'm not doing that anymore, what began to happen as I got more comfortable, I think I did it for five years, I'm not sure, I started having these poems sneak out about books over that last year. And so once I you know stopped doing that regularly for them, I was like, You know, I could continue to write poems in book reviews online. and so I decided to focus on good reads rather than Amazon for a list of
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: that are not important, but that's what I did. And so now I find that I am reading so much differently and the notes that I'm making, because for example, I just finished a book yesterday and this one was on Kindle. And it was it was a cozy murder mystery by none other than A.A. Milne.
Tresta: What? What?
Megan Willome: He wrote a mystery called the Red House mystery that is a lot of fun. And so I could not wait. Like, okay, tomorrow, like I finished the book today, tomorrow I get to look back through all my highlights and they're in different colors and start to think. What on earth is this poem gonna be? What do I wanna do? And whatever I think it's gonna be, it's almost never that.
Callie: Sure.
Megan Willome: But because of this discipline that I've now been doing for another few years, it has made reading so much more fun for me. Because
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: I'm I'm moving toward this poem, which You know what I realized like no one really wants to read this poem. Like this poem will not be published anywhere if I don't put it on Goodreads because no one cares about Megan's
Callie: Sure, sure.
Megan Willome: poem for an AA ML mystery, right?
Callie: Love that though.
Megan Willome: But it's fun to put
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: up there to share. So
Callie: Yeah. What are your highlight colors? Like what what's the significance?
Megan Willome: Yeah, so okay, I feel like I'm burying my soul here, you know.
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Megan Willome: Like the stripies music. So blue
Callie: Ha ha ha.
Megan Willome: is usually just like basic. Like I just wanna remember this.
Callie: Okay, okay.
Megan Willome: Yellow means it reminds me of me in
Callie: Okay.
Megan Willome: some way. And then pink is always gonna be in like that beauty and love idea.
Callie: Mm.
Megan Willome: So it 'Cause that that's what matters to me. You know, I'm not the one who wrote a
Callie: Sure.
Megan Willome: book called More Beautiful Than Necessary. But I certainly feel a kinship with you, Tresta. And so, yeah. I did write a lot of another mysteries, yes.
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: Ha ha ha. That's right. There you go.
Megan Willome: So, and then usually the the orange is like words I want to look up or things that are like unusual.
Callie: Okay.
Megan Willome: Th those are my my basic ones.
Callie: I love that.
Megan Willome: So that's one reason I like Kendall a lot is being able to do that with ease. And sometimes
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: I change my colors when I go back, but I love reading back through and then I'll I'll just kind of rewrite, you know,
Callie: They're kinda Yeah.
Megan Willome: maybe an essay first, maybe I'll play with a poem. I don't I don't know.
Callie: Yeah. They're kind of cues though. You know, like, this is
Megan Willome: Vertues one.
Callie: pink. So this means, you know, what what was I thinking or yeah, I love that.
Megan Willome: I kind of
know what I was thinking when I when I did it. Some of these things are just special to me that
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: I wouldn't want to share on Goodreads.
Callie: Sure.
Megan Willome: but I might take an idea like I recently read George McDonald's Fantasies, which I didn't like at first and I liked more and more as it went on. And there's several quotes that I've thought, ooh, if I if I write a collection you know, like my next collection, I might want this for a epigraph. And it's maybe
Tresta: mm, mm
Megan Willome: some of those things I highlighted are going to inspire and have inspired other poems that aren't of the review variety.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: So I
Callie: So interesting.
Tresta: I have a I have a lofty goal. and I'm I'm gleaning from both of you. because so I I talked about keeping a commonplace book and I've I've done it
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: in different ways and so therefore I have I have quotes in all different places.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: Generally when I want to find something I from a a quote from a book, I'll know okay, it's about three quarters of the way through on the right hand side of the page. Right. But
Callie: Yeah, that's yeah.
Tresta: I would like to have an index. So I want to formalize, I guess. more of a reading journal like what Callie's talking about and take my highlights by subject like what Megan's talking about and make an index kind of a bullet journal style index by topic so that I can, you know, with the front of my reading journal, I can have an index. and I can just, you know, it's just gonna be a running list of page numbers, you know, on the topic of love, the topic of beauty, grief, whatever.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: so that that way I can Just go through the journal as I'm reading and not have to worry about where the quotes are gonna fit. but if I can if I can narrow the quotes down to a a topic, then
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: I can keep that in my index. That's that's my
Megan Willome: It's a great name.
Callie: I would love to do that. I think that is
Tresta: call.
Callie: yeah, that's great. Twenty twenty seven. Trust it, we're gonna do it. Yeah. Yeah. Also another good book title.
Tresta: Yeah, I know. I gotta start practicing now. Learning to read, yep. Fifty years old, still learning to read.
Megan Willome: Here we go. Learning You know doesn't she say that at the
Tresta: Yes.
Megan Willome: beginning? I think that's like her first sentence. Hold on. Yeah, learning to read
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: is a lifelong process.
Callie: Hmm, Amen.
Tresta: Yep, yep.
Megan Willome: So yes, we are all still learning. All right.
Callie: But we are. I love it.
Megan Willome: Well does anyone have anything else?
Tresta: I just saw the title of chapter five. I obviously haven't read ahead, but it's it's so good.
Megan Willome: Chapter five, stay in conversation.
Callie: my goodness. Wouldn't it be funny if the next episode we just I don't have anything to say to you guys.
Megan Willome: Ha ha.
Tresta: Yeah, sorry. No words today.
Callie: I have nothing.
Megan Willome: All right. Well, thank y'all so much for reading in community. We will
Callie: Hm.
Megan Willome: stay in conversation as we move forward into chapter five. And
Tresta: Ooh, good. Good job.
Megan Willome: our our blessing for this episode.
Callie: Mm.
Megan Willome: This is funny because I wrote this this afternoon before we talked about slow reading. This is from her the part of the chapter where she talked about haiku. And haiku being a poem that you say in one breath. So
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: our blessing is may we both breathe and read long, slow, and deep.
Tresta: Mm. So good. Thank you. All right.
Callie: Amen. Thank you. Thank you. See you guys next time.
Megan Willome: Thank y'all so much. Okay. Thank you for listening to Necessary Trouble as we read Marilyn McIntyre's Caring for Words in a Culture of Lies. Follow us at NecessaryTroublePodcast.substack.com. For more writing and trouble from us, visit our websites listed in the show notes.