UDSKRIFT 🔗
speaker-0: Welcome to Field Notes, the Operator's Playbook for Brand, Creator, and Growth. This is the influencer marketing podcast for people actually doing the work. Real strategies, real examples, and the parts the other shows leave out.
speaker-1: Welcome back to Field Notes, everybody. On today's episode, we have a very fun and very special guest, Molly Laychee, is here with us. we are gonna be talking about all things creator economy versus influencer marketing, because the three of us have some feelings about the terminology of creator economy. before I kind of get into the overview of what we'll be talking about, Molly, do you wanna introduce yourself?
speaker-2: Yeah, sure. Hey guys, I'm Molly Lachey. I am formerly influencer marketing manager at Epic Gardening and Botanical Interests. And now I am at Superaffiliate working on something super special and a little secret. but I can give you a hint it has to do with connecting brands and creators.
speaker-1: Exciting, especially since I know what you're talking about. Very
speaker-2: Mm-hmm.
speaker-1: cool. Yes. Fun. All right. Well, today, we're gonna try to limit ourselves. We actually like prepared. We have a flow of conversation because the three of us will will go off on tangents if we're allowed to. Today we're gonna be talking about the language problem, the creator versus influencer, who's actually who, the business model disconnect. So comparing the economic incentives of independent creators with the objectives of brands investing in influencer marketing and then end with the consequences for brands when it comes to this interchangeable terminology that is just running amok. and finally just where we go from here. So our first question, I'm gonna hand it over to Sarah.
speaker-0: Sure. This is a long, this is a long time coming. Like I am very nervous to breach this topic. because I think it's going to potentially ruffle some feathers. But do we my gosh, Molly, I'll start with you. Do you think we actually understand the difference or have we just collectively decided that creator sounds better? When we're talking about creator versus influencer, like I Lily and I have talked on this podcast before that influencer is such an It almost turned into a nasty term and we're not really sure why. And now creator economy has rebranded it, but now we're seeing it spike off into a bunch of different directions. So have we all just cr decided creator sounds better or are they actually different?
speaker-2: There's probably a lot of different things going on with that. But to sum it up, I think that we decided that creator sounds better. And I think that yeah, influencer became a dirty word. And not to like throw us on this tangent right now, but could it possibly be because influencer is associated with women having opinions and making money? Because that could be kind of a big part of it. And the Other side of that. I know. I know. That's that is one side. And then the other side is that
Load full transcript
Creator does like sound more encompassing of what influencers could also be doing. Like they are creating businesses and creating other types of content and other things. So sometimes influencer doesn't fully encapsulate everything that they're doing. but like we're gonna get into like some people are influencers. And some people are creators. Can they be the same? Can they overlap? You don't think they can overlap at all?
speaker-1: I think they can overlap. I don't I think I don't necessarily think that a creator can be an influencer or that an influencer is necessarily a good content creator. there are some partners, that I there are some in content creators that I pitch to brands where I'm like, don't judge their content. They convert like crazy. We're just gonna ignore it. Okay. We're just gonna ignore the type of content they create because they are highly influential. There are fewer people like that than I would say, but it it can't, it is not a two-way street. In my opinion. And I also think, Sarah, going back to your earlier question two, or even just observation, that influencer is becoming a dirty word. I think it always has been. you remember 10 years ago when we were all starting out in this industry and we were like on business development and partnerships team because no one wanted to explicitly say that they were working with influencers because it was embarrassing and new and no one understood it. that is still the same to this day. Yeah. Even though and so I think like influencer marketing falling under. The creator economy, it's like people are equating the two and they're actually very, very, very different. And, you know, I think that there is this like people that are newer to influencer marketing felt the need to legitimize it by calling it something economic, which, you know, we could dissect that a lot. I I don't think it was even necessary to call it like what even the fuck is creator economy?
speaker-0: I yeah. I have two quick takes. My first one is all influencers are creators, not all creators are influencers. I would rather go on the the air of yeah, some influencers are not that good at creating content, but they have to create content because that's their job. Whether it's good or bad content doesn't really matter and doesn't define them as a creator, but not all creators are good at influencing people or can influence. and I think that's the part that's It was a defining moment to call us a creator economy because I think it gave us a little more leverage. It was less embarrassing. Although I think I think people that come from that time of this might sound elitist, people that come from the time of it being embarrassing to work in this industry approach it a lot differently than the people that are like newer to it. And I think that's what the creator economy opened up is a lot more people coming in and claiming the space as their own. deciding that different terms mean different things when we've all been operating with the same glossary and the same playbooks for this certain amount of time. So that kind of rubs me the wrong way, if I'm being honest.
speaker-2: Yes. No, I share the same feeling in that all influencers are creators. Like you're saying, Lily, even if they're creating like content that's not great, like they're still creating and then not all creators are influencers. And yes, we opened up the creator economy to kind of anybody that's like touching content. And that's where the definitions and everything got confusing to people that are like coming in to influencer marketing and creator and Content in general, it just got really confusing and we were assigning the same words to a lot of different types of content and a lot of different goals as well. Like UGC.
speaker-1: one size fits all type approach. Yeah. Yeah. And I also think the broadening of the creator economy also new very much neutralized its impact because everybody was given, everybody is being given the same goals or they're all trying to fit this, you know, what is it? What's the saying? A s a circle into a square peg.
speaker-2: A round around a square into a round peg, a peg round.
speaker-1: thing, and it's and that that type of strategy is coming from people that are highly uninformed about what it actually takes to be successful in with with content creators and with influencers and the massive distinction between the two. and I also think, you know, influencers become, and I don't I've I've had my fair contribution to this way too performance focused.
speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah. Wait, on that similar topic, I was about to say, Molly, name one and you did, which is UGC.
speaker-1: Do
speaker-0: Can the can the three of us come on record and say what UGC actually means to influencer marketers versus what it's now being turned into?
speaker-1: I think what's interesting is we may have different answers to this too. Yes. Because and also just like because of the evol like what it actually stands for and where it actually originated from. And also the fact that like UGC is under the creator economy as a type of content that is created, but it is not. Yeah. So you go ahead. You go first, Molly.
speaker-2: Okay. I have many different takes on this. Let me see if I can be eloquent. UGC, user-generated content, is a it is a type of content that is created by a creator to be used in marketing assets. It is not posted on an influencer's channels that makes it not UGC. If you're using an influencer to make these types of user generated content assets. If we want to get confusing, I sometimes call that IGC influencer generated content because you're using that influencer. It's a better term. It is a better term for it. But then I'm like, d we're introducing all these terms, does it get confusing or does it actually get more clear? It's because
speaker-1: to the right person.
speaker-2: Right. Because with IAGC, influencer generated content, you are using that influencer to create
content that is not posted on their page to use in marketing materials such as your paid ads, your emails.
speaker-1: Or beta ads, yeah.
speaker-2: Predominantly your paid ads, but also your emails and your your
speaker-1: Okay.
speaker-2: organic social, your website or other marketing things that you might need, like you can use that for that purpose as well. But yeah, UGC is a type of content. It is not posted on an influencer's page that makes it not UGC.
speaker-1: Well and now there are dedicated UGC content creators. So it doesn't you don't even the thing with UGC is you don't even need to work with an influencer who has a significant audience. It's an asset type. It is not a person, even though there are UGC creators. Yes. They are creating an asset or a deliverable that is considered UGC. It's not necessarily an influencer. and it's a content creator. and the funny thing about UGC. To me, is like I remember distinctly in 2018, 2019 at Thrive Market, how we would use UGC just for like organic social in feed content, but it was employee generated content or from customers. Like it was true users of the brand creating content and like we are now manufacturing user generated content, which is not a bad thing. because I think also nowadays, like fewer and fewer normal people feel comfortable posting on Instagram for fear of being judged, you know. Correct.
speaker-2: Perceived as an influencer.
speaker-1: This, because again, being an influencer is a dirty word. and I also think that's so like so so many I think the creator economy is manuf. Manufacturing things that used to feel authentic, which is also why the word authentic makes us all want to vomit. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
speaker-2: Yeah. I it is odd. Sarah, you go, I know you have a take. We could talk about how much time do we have?
speaker-1: I'm
speaker-0: A lot of take. I fully am aligned with what Molly said 100%. I love the influencer generated content because to me, UGC, too, part of the definition is you are not borrowing someone's audience, their likeness it means nothing in the context, as opposed to like and it just feels like organic content to Lily's point. When I ran a what I considered a UGC program at Aloha Collection, it was photographers, it was a group of five photographers. That I had set deliverables from every month. And I worked with them on the rolling three month contract. And they delivered us stuff. We use it in ads. We use it in organic social. We use it sometimes in sales, collateral, whatever. My biggest hot take and where my hill that I will absolutely die on here is that is not influencer marketing. Period.
speaker-2: Completely agree.
speaker-1: it it's and the reason Sarah is be and correct me if I'm wrong is because the benefit isn't to the influencer team necessarily it is to the paid media team. Yeah. So we also have to think about how these tur who these terms actually benefit and is it your influencer team? Just
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: getting the credit for those wins.
speaker-0: Yeah. And we've almost overcorrect corrected by like bypassing the influencer marketer and not really listening to them and going back to the paid media team and saying, whatever you want, we'll do whatever you want. yeah, there's some creators, our influencer team will handle it. Even though now it's just another thing added onto that person's plate when usually that person is one of the most stretched thins emplo stretched thin employees at a company ever.
speaker-1: And it's creating so many silos. the influencer team has always been naturally siloed because no one knows where to put it within the org. So like I have in, you know, this is where like I almost have a devil's advocate opinion to what you were just saying, Sarah. because I've always exclusively reported to a head of growth. And I've always been held to a CPA goal or a ROAS goal, and that is very much the culmination of that is what we do at Superbloom. And we have a whole we need to refrain from profanity. Our producers like, do you want me to remove that? so I'm gonna I'm gonna split it up.
speaker-2: Just bleep it out.
speaker-1: I'm gonna say it again. we have a whole offering that's called Performance Creative UGC. And it is working with influencers who have large audiences to create UGC assets because ultimately those ads perform really well when you're able to run that ad. From the influencers handle because you get to leverage their audience size and targeting. So I love that. I love that.
speaker-0: It's not UGC. But it's that's IGC.
speaker-1: That's that correct. It is IGC. And it's also a reason why we made up the term performance creative. But I also think a lot of agencies use that too, because it that's what it is. It's like it's create we work with an influencer to make an asset that is only exclusively ran as an ad. And the benefits at Usab the benefit used to before before IG before UGC became IGC and is like running rampant and it Those deliverables from an influencer used to be very cost efficient and now they're not. rates are a whole other thing, a whole other fish to fry. But now UGC rates are astronomical when a year ago they weren't. They were like a great way for brands to start testing and start learning the influencer channel. And now talent and talent managers are outpricing brands that want to get into influencer marketing. that's a whole other thing. But I do think that UGC by influencers is a great way to get started in working with influencers, but it's also it's not influencer marketing and it's not UGC. It's but it's not really I it's IGC, but it's also performance creative, you know. And I yeah, anyway, I don't know if you want to react to that. I have another thought about what you said too, Sarah, about like silos. because yeah. I have other Yeah, yeah, yeah.
speaker-2: Well throw out the other thoughts 'cause I feel like they'll
speaker-1: other thought, so one of our clients, actually two two of our clients,
like they have an influencer team that we don't even work with because we are w we are reporting directly to the head of growth to just help them work with influencers in a paid capac in a in a IGC UGC capacity. Then we have another client who we are building their influencer, you know, their creator influencer program, traditional in the traditional sense, influencers posting about the brand to their communities. And their paid team also has an influencer agency. And and we are stepping on each other's toes constantly, where it's like, good golly, good golly, you wait, what who? you got you rebooked that partner? Wait, why? that's our partner, which can cause it causes so much frustration and confusion, not only to your agencies that you're hiring, but to creators. It's a nightmare.
speaker-2: So it's like cohesion. Yeah.
speaker-1: People. In exactly. It's causing it's causing so much disconnect.
speaker-2: Yeah. And I think that happens internally too with brands and depending on the size too. Like at Epic Gardening, I was in charge of building our influencer program, our affiliate program, our talent network. And then I also did UGC for paid ads. And the language that everybody was using to talk about it could sometimes get confusing because what UGC is or getting content from influencers for ads like can get confusing, especially if it's like this is an awareness play, or we're working with this creator to get content for our YouTube channel and they're like a, they're a correspondent type partner, not specifically for paid ads. I think all of that can get confusing. In this case, Lily, are you seeing like the different sides are contracting an influencer or andor a creator for paid assets, meaning UGC, and that That contract is different, so the influencer creator is also signing two different contract. That's confusing as a terrible.
speaker-1: So messy. It's it's so messy. And luckily it's not something that I see all the time, but it it's weird enough that I'm like, god, this is just like the reason this is like yet another example of how misunderstood this channel truly is. And when it comes to an org structure, like your influencer team should be sitting in between ahead of growth and ahead of marketing. Or a head.
speaker-0: I wanna about this. I wanna talk about this because I was gonna ask since you said you already always reported to a head of growth. Yeah. I think that also just showcases in your work at Superbloom and just like how you think about influencer a lot. Molly, who did you report to?
speaker-2: for my first year at Epic, I reported to our founder, who is also an influencer creator founder, Kevin. and then I reported to our head of content for a couple of years, and then I switched to head of growth. And I also like I came from agency side as well, where you would think that I would be like more performance based, but I was really like. influence based. It was like let the influencers influence. So it yeah. And it switched my it was just hard to like go into the growth mode because of course I was growing the programs, but like then thinking about it in terms of strictly growth and strictly is this worth it and not thinking about like the cultural impact of the content made it it just was confusing. so I think depending on what your company's goals are, that's where the influencer Team should report to. if you're gonna report to a head of content or marketing to grow the culture of the brand and some of your KPIs are gonna be associated with awareness, impressions, tops, top of funnel types of metrics, that makes sense. And if it's like we're strictly going performance on this thing, then maybe you report to just the head of growth. I reported all over the place.
speaker-0: And those are probably two different types of marketers at the end of the day, realistically. I was very brand and culture for influencer. I like we would make decisions based on culture, not if you brought me someone and you were like, this person's gonna make a million in sales, but they were so off base for us culture and brand and whatever it was, we would never sign them ever, period. End of sentence. We were so focused on the culture and brand aspect and like building our program that way and our awareness that way. so yeah, sometimes to me, and I worked really well with our digital marketer and our agency team there, like just giving him content and he would come to me and just say, like, hey, let's perform really well. Anyone else that you have? And I'd Yeah, sure. Because also that was big culture for us. And to me, Aloha wouldn't be where it is today if it if it was centered around just what was delivering the bottom line number. But what's really hard is brands that come to I think all three of us at this point that want both at the same time. And I think that's really, really hard to deliver on effectively.
speaker-2: Both at the same time with the same person, with the same creators. Yeah,
speaker-0: Because
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-2: right. Like we should you should have all of the things. And same thing in your paid media structure. Like you should have the UGC, the IGC, the whitelist, dark posting, all of the different things. But is the same person gonna be responsible for getting all of it? And no. Like, is the same creator influencer piece of content the thing that's gonna get all your KPIs done? Hell no. Sorry, Ramsay. Hell no. that is an insane thing. And I yeah, I'm sure we all see that all the time. It's just not realistic. It would be like giving an employee like six different job titles. Well, which also happens.
speaker-0: But here we are.
speaker-2: Yeah, yeah. It's not
speaker-1: I like my hope and what what I hope happens and what I think is happening is while I I don't like the term creator economy because I think it it's just gross it's just ugly. Just ugly and it's not act and it's inaccurate. especially in the way that it's currently used. But I think
the benefit is yeah, it actually has given the channel a bit more legitimacy. Like because it's it it sounds a little bit more Serious, right? It's not just like cutesy girls being influencers. It's a creator economy. But my g my wish is like to your point, Molly, that brands begin thinking about w the type what benefit a certain creator has. you have because ideally, when you look at your org chart, you've got ahead of growth, ahead of brand, and ahead of influencer. There are plenty of people who could f who could fill that role nowadays. The influence the the industry is old enough. There are plenty of people who have 10 years of experience or even five to eight years of experience who could crush a head of influencer role. And their primary job is to collaborate with head of growth and head of brand, because I believe that your influencer channel and your team should have multiple goals. It shouldn't just be ROS, it shouldn't just be CPA, it shouldn't just be EMB. That in order to stay, in order to be relevant in the creator economy and just in your relationships with influencers, to your point, Molly, and to your point too, Sarah, like. You need to have a you have your whole budget, a portion of it goes towards brand goals and a portion of it goes towards growth goals because the influencers in those buckets are very different looking. And like they're they look they just look very different. And how you source them, how they're what their SOWs look like, who they benefit looks very, very different. But yeah, I really don't wanna see growth teams and brand teams working with different agencies to work with influencers when your influencer team can do it. I think we just need to stop giving them such narrow focuses.
speaker-2: Yeah. Yeah, or too much focus on the wrong things. I'm also wondering misdirected focus. Yeah, misdirected focus. I think marketing as a discipline. There's now so many specialized marketing roles. You can be a lifestyle market lifestyle marketing. A life cycle life cycle marketing. Like there's all these lifestyle marketing. there's all these different paid out. Lifestyle marketing. Maybe that I okay, I have two thoughts. One, this, where marketing now has all of these different specializations, email, SMS, life cycle, paid, like all these different things. But influencer marketing is just influencer marketing. But we're expected to do carry out all of those different components still. and then in the creator economy of it, all the terminology, that Would have happened probably anyway. We would have come up with some sort of word to make it more legit and it just happened to be creator economy. I wonder what would have happened if there was another term associated with it, or if it just would have never been legitimate. Like there was something that had to happen in order to make it a more legitimate space. No. This is up for the.
speaker-0: Really frustrating for me is I always think back to madmen style era of advertising. That was very male dominated and it's advertising. That is my degree is graphic design and advertising. I love studying advertising. Why couldn't we have just been advertising? Why?
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-0: That we're doing is using celebrities, people of influence, like as influencers, whether that's a commercial, whether that's an ad on your feed, whether that's in a magazine, these are all different. people of influence. Sometimes they're not just influencer as we see with UGC now. But I to me, I would have loved to just be advertising. And my hot take would be that we would be making more money and have more authority at our companies if that was the case. I'm so sad and sick of talking to incredibly smart, mostly women, but sometimes men, because this industry is female dominated, not because the men in it are not that smart. Where they are severely underpaid for how much they're doing too. So
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: as much as it kind of legitimized us, I wish we would have just stuck with, we work in advertising. That sounds so like yummy to me.
speaker-2: No, I like that. I like that take. I never watched Mad Men, unfortunately. That's on my list. I'm watching the Sopranos right now.
speaker-1: That what is that book? It's yep, there it is.
speaker-0: Always at my desk. by George Lois, the advertiser that Mad Men is based off of. I'm doing actually a book club with my team right now on it because it's so important to me. but yeah, it's also like advertising. It is.
speaker-1: It's true. and there I so I posted about this the difference between the creator economy and influencer marketing on my LinkedIn. And someone commented, I don't remember, but they said the term like influencer advertising versus influencer marketing. And I also kind of liked that because, you know, I also think consumers are really sick and tired of being sold to and they're craving marketing. They're craving like Campaigns, things that are thought provoking or heartfelt or make you feel something because you go on TikTok and I f I feel nothing.
speaker-2: You got
speaker-0: I think that's a discussion.
speaker-1: I need to have with my doctor, but I feel nothing. Yeah.
speaker-0: Advertising is that. Yes.
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-0: It really is. you should not feel sold to no matter what.
speaker-1: Mm-hmm.
speaker-2: Right. Because it should be building the culture of the brand and building the our culture in general, not just of the brand, but how do you, the brand, want your audience or people interacting with you to feel you have an opportunity to execute that and come bring that to life through influencers and other content creators through whatever marketing materials you want to put out. Like you have options there. And there it's never been more accessible, sort of, and it's never been more Not easy. I don't want to say easy, but in a way. it's never been easier to do these things. but
speaker-1: Or ex it I think maybe not easy, more
accessible.
speaker-2: Yeah, yeah, maybe accessible is just the right word there.
speaker-1: it's never been more accessible. But I think Sarah to your point, Influencer marketing is female dominated. Is it underpaid? Is it overlooked? Yeah. But is that kind of h what it means to be a working woman also? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
speaker-2: Yeah. Everyone turns off the podcast.
speaker-1: Ha ha ha ha.
speaker-2: we'll see you guys later. You know, it should have been like we could have been creator economists. Are we economists then?
speaker-1: Well God, don't even get me started on that title, Molly, because I accidentally said that. I accidentally said that as a comment on LinkedIn.
speaker-2: wait, maybe I saw that on your LinkedIn. Okay. I do not call me an economist.
speaker-1: I was like, ain't nobody ever gonna tell me or call me I'm a fucking creator economist because I'm not I don't know anything about micro or macro economics, but I damn sure know about micro and macro influencers. No,
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-1: you're not gonna call me a creator economist. Like that, that is such a the channel didn't, I think the whole thing point we're trying to make here is like we didn't need to be legitimized. It was it's always been legitimate. It's just based on who's listening, if they view it as legitimate or not.
speaker-2: Okay, well to push back on that, did we need a PR did we need some PR going on, some good PR in influencer marketing to make people understand the
speaker-0: I thought you were going with the drink
speaker-2: Going with that we
speaker-0: also cover PR because that also PR blended into influencer.
speaker-2: Yes.
speaker-1: Yeah, well PR agencies are offering influencer services now too and it's like, my, everybody's doing influencer which I
speaker-2: But what are they and what is everybody doing? Yeah. And are they all doing it differently? Are we all doing the same thing? Is so is everybody just going to get UGC?
speaker-0: It's for their pain teams, because
speaker-1: well, literally that the everyone's just gonna be like, god.
speaker-2: Yeah. I can't. Yeah.
speaker-0: We overcorrected for sure.
speaker-1: I think we overcorrected. I think what's also influencers like the most debated marketing channel comparatively. Like you don't see these hot, hot debates about CRM and SMS strategies. And yeah, you see it about like paid media, but it also kind of feels good to also work on a channel that is so polarizing to people. And so wide widely misunderstood, but I do think that it needs better PR to your point, Molly.
speaker-2: And does it feel good?
speaker-0: Does it feel good?
speaker-1: like a fight. I'm a fighter so
speaker-2: I'm like I'm a little bit stressed.
speaker-0: I would really love to retire one day, but I fear I can't retire from this industry until I see the overcorrection come back. I yearn
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: for the day when I speak to an executive that says, I actually don't care at all about like about influencer in terms of I don't want to know your CPM. I don't want to know your ROAS. I don't want to know how many conversions they got. If this is a good influencer that has influence on their audience, yeah. Pay him for it. Like that's all I want to see. Cause that's what I'm I mean, that's how we really started here. I want to see us go all the way back. Cause I also think it'll give creators the freedom back again. I think it'll just I feel like we're shackled up right now with all of these teams. Like I literally feel like this every day where I can't, I don't know, I can't really maneuver through it without hitting some type of new KPI, whatever. I can't wait to go back to that and revert back.
speaker-2: I agree. Because that's art.
speaker-0: Yes.
speaker-2: let the influencers influence. And by the way, this is an art form also. Mm-hmm. It's like making movies or like I mean, just like making art. Like we're cultivating and creating culture around brands through influencers who are influencing society on how they buy, think. Yeah. I mean, day in and day out. That's that's what it is. And if you tie everything to a KPI. You're gonna kill us and we're all gonna be dead. You're
speaker-1: Kill us.
speaker-2: gonna kill us. Please help us. We want to live. I I know you do.
speaker-1: like a KPA it doesn't but but but it doesn't have to be CPA or ROAS like it can also be sentiment
speaker-0: Exactly. It can be sentiment, awareness, how how well was this perceived by the audience? did it make s all of the that's why I'm like advertising
speaker-1: Qualitative. I think we've become obsessed and I've had I've my bad. We're we've become obsessed we've become obsessed with quantitative results for the influencer and like I'm so sorry.
speaker-0: And you know what? You were taking that ownership from
speaker-2: For taking ownership. And like we said, like it's still important. All those things are still important.
speaker-1: And some, I think it's because some brands will always be successful with a quantitative influencer program. Some brands are absolutely gonna always crush a CPA or a ROA ROAS based influencer program. It is so brand specific. I can't say that loud enough. some brands should only do influencer marketing that elicits a qualitative analysis after the campaign is done. And there are some brands that can do both. And they're and you just have to test. And learn. And you have to be open to learning what the results are versus having that expectation right out of the gate and then being disappointed and then canceling the whole thing.
speaker-2: Can I say push what are wait, not to we're we're like all at the same time always being like, my god, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, but Lily, what are those brands that you think are the ones that should be looking at the qualitative results only? Like Are they Are they the cool brands? Like is it Is it cool? Does it have anything to do with being cool? I know. But like it's
also kind of not.
speaker-1: That's not true. I think in order for any brand to be, I think, and I think in order for in order for any brand to be successful with influencer, they need to have a cool factor. They need to be cool or legit. So like you either need to have kick ass marketing, you need to have a spicy tagline, you need to be sexy and interesting and like bold, or you need to be hella scientific and and like fast. and evidence-based. Like it's almost polarizing. If your brand is kind of like lukewarm bathwater, you're gonna have to think about the way that you work with influencer a little bit differently. But I think that brands, the brands that will have who could have like qualitative goals like sentiment, top of tofu, top of funnel, EMV based goals are they they find their customers in retail and not online.
speaker-2: Mm-hmm.
speaker-1: That's the biggest distinction or the thing that I've observed the most. And then the brands that are a hundred percent e-commerce D to C can stay in the lane of focusing more heavily on CPA and ROAS because the attribution software is there, truly. It sometimes just boils down to what's available to them for attributes.
speaker-0: gonna push on that though because if we're all getting really oversold to and way too oversaturated with advertising and ads and everything in our feed feeling like we're being sold to,
speaker-1: Will
speaker-0: will we start to go backwards? Because I know you said before too and this like will all these brands continue to see success with that or will we have to go back almost an era like
speaker-1: I think there will be periods where the again, what we're all screaming here is fluidity and flexibility. there will be periods with your influencer program where the goal should actually just be more top of funnel and then, we're getting closer to bottom of funnel things here. there can be this cyclical and it it's it can also be boiled down to the seasonality that you experience as a brand. when there's gonna be low, low sales for you over the summer months, Scratch the CPA goal for your influencers and do some really cool campaigns.
speaker-2: I don't want to be sad.
speaker-1: Like be like, your influencer channel can mimic the other more establ quote unquote air quotes established marketing channels. Like, yeah. Yeah. That could be really fun and interesting to be a little bit more fluid.
speaker-0: Unless we never forget that paid media moves a even faster than influencer, you could some
speaker-1: Well in the re
speaker-0: reason why influencer came to to be where it is today too is because CAC went through the roof. meta ads went through a whole phase of it's way too expensive to win here. And so budgets moved to the influencer team who hopefully had one person on social media to help get it off the ground at the time. And now like We're seeing the cyclical nature of paid media because influencers so attached to it. So to your point, yeah, we're gonna have to go through several cycles with it.
speaker-1: I
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: three years ago was screaming and I still scream to the at from the rooftops that the influencer team needs to be better integrated into paid media. And I still believe that, but I also think that it's over it needs to overcorrect. It needs to go back the other way. Yeah.
speaker-2: It's just like boundaries and just you wouldn't go to the gym and only work out your left arm for the rest of your life. you should probably hit a leg day. So yeah, but they're they shouldn't be doing that. Like we should all be hitting leg day. We should all be, yes, you should be boosting, dark posting, whitelisting, whatever it is, all the things,
speaker-1: And learn.
speaker-2: testing and learning. but your influencer channel should not become the place where you are just like. Getting your paid media and the paid media team should not be bullying the influencer team to just go get
speaker-1: Exactly.
speaker-0: Bullying. No more.
speaker-1: I think our clients are just angel cherub babies. I love them. Yeah. But nobody bullies us. If anything, we bully them a little bit. We're like, no, that's a bad idea. The heart is
speaker-0: comes out and meta says pay high volume wins. We want to see a
speaker-2: God.
speaker-0: thousand a thousand UGC this month. And that's when the bully comes in.
speaker-1: Yeah. Well, and that's also when AI starts to take over. we didn't even talk about AI influencers also being falling under the creator economy.
speaker-0: Because we don't have to, right? We don't
speaker-2: No, like obviously I mean you guys all hate that, right? I hate that. Hate it.
speaker-1: I don't want you to talk about
speaker-2: About that. No, that can't be real. Also, for just an actually no point.
speaker-1: And that's one more.
speaker-2: people aren't gonna like that. Like if your brand starts posting fake people, which I've seen a lot of on TikTok specifically, n we're human beings are watching that, and the real human beings are the people I think that they're trying to get to buy their product. Nobody's gonna like that. That's weird. We don't like that. Even people that like
speaker-1: People.
speaker-2: don't like that, yeah. Yeah. People.
speaker-1: An AI remix it like we had an incident a couple years ago where we were booking a lot of influencer content with whitelisting rights and they used like AI voices to change the voiceover and the influencers saw it and we were like, that's a big no no.
speaker-2: yes.
speaker-1: Yeah big no no. You have to get approval.
speaker-2: A way Yeah. A way to help that in your contracts is adding AI clauses that protect both brand and creator. And creators and brands should put that in there. I at Epic and other places have put that in there proactively, just being like we can't use we can't use your image.
speaker-1: We won't use it's like the brand's promise to the influencer or something. Yeah, we're not gonna do that. Influencers are
getting burned, just like how influencers got burned with the paid media team just running their content without usage rights. now they have the legitimate usage rights, but they're going hog wild on the AI editing for what's
speaker-2: Yeah. AI editing, like there's tools that people use to like make short form that has AI, but you can't use the person's image and likeness or voice.
speaker-1: Make their likeness is a big no no.
speaker-2: That's weird. That's super weird. Nobody do that. And it's super weird to put an AI voice over just think, is this really weird? I'm a human being person, I think. Is this really weird? Would I want to see this from a brand? I think everybody needs to ask that. Well, that's what I'm saying. People need to ask. Am I a human being person? Yes, I think I am. Would I like this as another human being person seeing this on the internet? Yes or no?
speaker-1: There are some weirdos. Do you guys get targeted by like the fruit people on TikTok?
speaker-2: You mean the wait the fruit, the AI fruit videos where they're like cheying and stuff?
speaker-0: Yes. my god. You guys sane story recruit people not
speaker-2: And it's like that song.
speaker-0: interested so fast on everything AI is.
speaker-1: Those videos have my retention.
speaker-2: Yeah, I'm watching this. I don't like it, but I gotta know. here's the thing I'm gonna
speaker-1: But it's like that saxophone sound.
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-1: my gosh.
speaker-2: Yeah, I'm unfortunately watching those. Yeah. There's something really crazy going on there. Yeah. On that though, are you guys seeing the TikTok the TikTok AI like ret kids retin? I sent this to you, Sarah. Maybe I sent this to also.
speaker-1: We need to have a whole goddamn sorry episode talking about kids' products. There are now protein shakes for kids.
speaker-0: It's fake product.
speaker-2: yeah, it was a fake product.
speaker-1: Because it was real.
speaker-2: It might I don't know, it might be it. The the ads were completely fake and it was like yeah, it was like fake AI women talking about how they use this children's retinol for their like eleven year olds in the eleven year olds ten step like skincare routine. Was it I was like, what is happening?
speaker-1: Where did it did it direct traffic somewhere?
speaker-2: TikTok shop.
speaker-1: What was the product?
speaker-2: Kids' retinol. Like a kid's that
speaker-1: Scary.
speaker-2: No, it was really crazy. I haven't seen them recently, but for like a week it I was seeing so many of them and I was like really scared.
speaker-1: Really weird reasons why I hate TikTok shop.
speaker-2: I know, me too. I that also like Yeah. That also can't be put on the influencer marketer's plate. Exactly. That's not influencer marketer.
speaker-0: Exactly. Another thing that's marketing.
speaker-1: TikTok shop is not influencer marketing. It is, however, the creator economy. Yeah. I thought you guys were gonna show
speaker-2: I agree. Agree. No, no, no. Of course. Because TikTok shop
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: Okay, we're talk about that distinction.
speaker-2: those are creators. TikTok shop people are creators. They are creating content to sell to people. It is just not influencer marketing, although they are influencing people to buy content or to buy things. But it's they're not influencing based on their image and likeness. Correct. They're they are creating content to make sales. And it's like It's a prescriptive type of I know it's like, hold on, wait, wait, I had an idea. Wait, smell But it's a prescription of a actually I'm gonna go. no. It it is such a prescriptive type of content. Like the way that they speak, their cadence of speaking, the the hooks, all the things, like it's really crazy to watch. Like
speaker-1: But if you're gonna get fired for this. well, it's also not creative at all. no influencer will ever
speaker-2: Alright.
speaker-1: be caught dead making content like we what you see from the creators on TikTok shop, but it worked.
speaker-2: It works and it's like we know some of the like big TikTok shop creators' faces. Like there's a couple of people where you're like, I see them promoting all the time. Or it's just like Kayla something, her. Like, or it'll be like specific brands have obviously their top partners that you see all the time, good American or whoever. Like they have these people that they use. Medicude. You got the Medicude girl with the eyeliner that's always popping up, like, you know, and but they're not influencers because I don't know like their name and I'm not their
speaker-0: They I don't know anything about them. They could have been promoting
speaker-1: Is the e commerce and paid media. Yeah.
speaker-2: Yeah. And that's not influencer marketing. Nope.
speaker-0: I want to be influenced by someone who I watch day in, day out, and I'm like, that's the fourth shampoo they've used this month. And I'm clocking you. Like, obviously, those are not the people I want to be influenced by, but I want to be that ingrained in them. And those are the people I get influenced by because I'm like, I see your routine, I see you, I connect with you. I'm influenced by you as a person.
speaker-2: Yeah. And it's complex. you might not you might be influenced by that influencer that you're talking about to buy the shampoo that they're using, but because that you trust her opinion on her politics or like her the shirts that she's buying, like it's not that you are like, she said X. She read all of the lines about that shampoo and I want more keratin in my shampoo. You might just be like, I bought a shirt. It's parasocial. She recommended it's parasocial. And it's very round and crazy and you're like making connections that you might not even be aware of. but you'll trust their opinion because you parasocially know this person.
speaker-0: Right, for both of you, if you're paying a creator ten thousand dollars for content that nobody in their audience ever sees, is that
influencer marketing?
speaker-1: Wait, follow up why don't they why does no one see it?
speaker-2: Last question.
speaker-1: That was a question I have a follow-up to my own question.
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-0: Okay, we don't have to do hot laughs.
speaker-2: No what, let's do hot laughs. If you're paying a creator ten K for content that nobody in their audience ever sees, is that influencer marketing? Will he ask you?
speaker-1: it's a UGC aspect.
speaker-0: Content and it's U G C
speaker-2: okay, that was the okay, yes, of course. Yeah,
speaker-1: Sorry.
speaker-2: yeah, yeah. But if it Okay, yeah, yeah. No, I'm aligned on that.
speaker-1: No, that's not influencer marketing.
speaker-2: No it's not.
speaker-0: I agree. I agree. Last one before a closing one. Should last
speaker-1: Okay. Last last
speaker-0: lap the final lap, should brands be expected to pay a premium just because someone has built a successful personal brand even if their audience doesn't drive meaningful business outcomes?
speaker-2: Meaningful business outcomes. Yes. Yeah. Because that's
speaker-1: Because that is
speaker-2: what you're buying.
speaker-1: influence. That is the immeasurable benefit of working with an influencer. And that is a hill I will die on. That there are you know, as you guys know, have a measurable outcome. There are also immeasurable outcomes. Suck it up and pay them what they're worth. Yeah.
speaker-2: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Or just move on from the deal. Be like, that's not that's not where I as a brand am at right now with what I can for
speaker-1: Or bring on an agency that knows how to better negotiate than you do.
speaker-2: Yeah. Mm-hmm.
speaker-0: Okay, closer. If we could change one thing about how brands, creators, and agencies talk about influencer marketing tomorrow, what would that be?
speaker-2: I kept like I've been thinking about this question for days. I don't know what the one thing would be, but I think part of it would be that we all go to like definition school and we all agree on what is reasonable for the paid team to take on, the influencer teams to take on, and what KPIs are associated with those things.
speaker-0: I love that.
speaker-2: I feel like that's not a good way to say there's so much in my heart that I wish I could rip out my heart and show it to everybody and everybody would understand.
speaker-0: Yeah. Mine mine would be that we are still a legitimate channel, even separated from paid media.
speaker-2: Yeah. That's a good way to say it. Yeah, that's fabulous.
speaker-1: My one my one thing. Rumma.
speaker-2: Eyebrows.
speaker-1: Just because you don't understand it doesn't mean it's not legitimate.
speaker-2: Mm-hmm. That's a good way to say it too. Yeah.
speaker-1: That's all. That's all. It's like the the one thing. If we could change one thing about how brands, creators, and agencies talk about influencer marketing tomorrow, what would it be? Yeah, maybe it's like a definition school. It's just like there doesn't need to be, there needs to be better listening, not better legitimizing. Cause it's already we have it.
speaker-0: Let's sponsor the glossary.
speaker-2: For that one.
speaker-0: And and let's define a salary range. That is acceptable.
speaker-1: Yeah. Let's do that. What a brand what KPIs for like a brand specific program could look like versus a growth specific program versus just like a influencer specific campaigns.
speaker-2: Yeah. I think at the end of the day, all of this stuff w is just oversimplified and it is categorized as influencer marketing, or it's categorized as the creator economy. And really influencer marketing is this huge thing that has many different specialties in it. Lily, you have so many different hats that you wear. Sarah and I are probably more on the culture side of things. but like I I very much feel like CPA ROAS, those things, I care about them. It doesn't, I am not like the girl to go for for those exact things. I can help you build a talent network and culture around your brand that really resonate. And you might not be able to be like, yes, CAC, yes, ROAS, all these things. You will be able to do those things. but that's not the like number one thing that some of these disciplines can bring you. So I think it's a much bigger market than what we're giving it credit for. And we there's more specializations. And I think honestly, that's what's gonna happen over the next five to ten years. It's it's gonna be different specializations in influencer marketing. There's gonna be a a culture person. There's gonna be a performance influencer marketing person. there's gonna be probably like a IRL community based type of people as well. Yeah, I know. I love
speaker-1: see that happening. There was a job there I saw on LinkedIn the other day there was a job description for a performance influencer marketer and I was like you already know what your roles are. Let's go.
speaker-2: Yeah. And events people too. Like there's events rolls for influencer marketing, which is really cool. Mm-hmm. Love to see it. Love to see it.
speaker-1: Cool. Well if you're still here, thank you for tuning in. We'll see you next time.
speaker-0: Yeah. Find us on Spotify, Apple, and YouTube and anywhere you find your podcasts. Please find Lily and I on LinkedIn. Send us a message if there's anything you want us to cover on the podcast. We're very excited to cover all the things.
speaker-2: Yay. Thanks everyone. Bye.