UDSKRIFT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.002 --> 00:00:01.042
Where's
00:00:01.062 --> 00:00:01.735
the cloud?
00:00:01.735 --> 00:00:01.836
Yeah,
00:00:01.877 --> 00:00:01.917
so...
00:00:01.917 --> 00:00:03.415
How do I know you're in a grumpy mood?
00:00:03.415 --> 00:00:04.076
Because I know you.
00:00:05.958 --> 00:00:08.542
Why am I so grumpy all of a sudden?
00:00:08.542 --> 00:00:09.023
I don't know.
00:00:09.023 --> 00:00:10.105
I don't know either.
00:00:10.105 --> 00:00:12.829
No, you know why?
00:00:12.829 --> 00:00:17.155
Because I literally was thinking today and I was like, I don't know if I have it in me.
00:00:17.876 --> 00:00:18.797
I know, I was too.
00:00:18.838 --> 00:00:20.579
Like two recordings was great.
00:00:20.579 --> 00:00:22.902
And then I'm like, you've got to be fucking kidding me.
00:00:23.143 --> 00:00:23.484
I know.
00:00:23.484 --> 00:00:26.288
I think podcasts are a commitment.
00:00:26.428 --> 00:00:27.370
It's annoying.
00:00:27.370 --> 00:00:29.172
Like, I'm like, why are we doing this a third time?
00:00:29.772 --> 00:00:30.173
Well, so...
00:00:30.173 --> 00:00:36.661
Maybe this is how we like start this whole thing, which is like, why, why are we doing this?
00:00:36.661 --> 00:00:41.148
Like, why do we think us doing a podcast is important and relevant?
00:00:42.109 --> 00:00:43.331
I think, yeah, that's a good question.
00:00:43.331 --> 00:00:54.426
So I think, well, I think we bring a couple perspectives to the table that are interesting and maybe helpful.
00:00:54.426 --> 00:00:55.286
So, you
00:00:56.128 --> 00:00:58.411
know, so before we launch, actually,
00:00:59.792 --> 00:01:00.253
who are we?
00:01:00.253 --> 00:01:03.322
I was thinking that we should start with like intros.
00:01:03.322 --> 00:01:04.082
Yeah.
00:01:04.082 --> 00:01:04.823
Yeah.
00:01:05.724 --> 00:01:05.745
I
00:01:05.765 --> 00:01:09.290
was thinking we could do, you know, welcome to Extra Session.
00:01:09.290 --> 00:01:12.634
I'm Rose Miller.
00:01:12.634 --> 00:01:14.277
And...
00:01:14.277 --> 00:01:17.301
I'm Danielle Shaloff.
00:01:17.301 --> 00:01:22.007
And do you want to talk a little bit about who you are?
00:01:22.908 --> 00:01:24.611
Yeah.
00:01:24.611 --> 00:01:26.733
So...
00:01:26.733 --> 00:01:30.350
I'm a clinical psychologist for almost 20 years.
00:01:30.350 --> 00:01:34.516
And I have been working in the field of eating for that long, which is kind of crazy.
00:01:34.516 --> 00:01:39.043
And Rose was one of my very first patients.
00:01:39.043 --> 00:01:43.891
And we have sort of lived a lifetime together.
00:01:43.891 --> 00:01:47.275
And our relationship has evolved.
00:01:47.275 --> 00:01:55.948
But she, as my patient, has really been a constant in my life as a clinician and as a human.
00:01:55.948 --> 00:02:10.436
And I think that our perspective on the world of eating is so unique because not only was her treatment provider, but also Rose is somebody that knows the pulse of the world.
00:02:10.436 --> 00:02:25.461
So as she's recovered and stayed recovered, and I've continued to be her therapist, and then in many ways become a mentor and now about to become a colleague, Right.
00:02:25.461 --> 00:02:30.046
I think that our perspective on food and eating and bodies.
00:02:30.046 --> 00:02:30.828
Right.
00:02:30.828 --> 00:02:37.175
And also the difference in our generations is a very unique combination of information and insight.
00:02:38.377 --> 00:02:38.776
Beautiful.
00:02:38.776 --> 00:02:38.997
Yeah.
00:02:38.997 --> 00:02:40.438
I mean, I completely agree with that.
00:02:40.438 --> 00:02:40.900
I think.
00:02:40.900 --> 00:02:47.387
You know, you have so much experience working in this field.
00:02:47.387 --> 00:02:49.469
I will be a clinical psychologist and.
00:02:49.469 --> 00:02:51.355
Five days, officially.
00:02:51.355 --> 00:03:27.747
But more than that, I think my experience of having an eating disorder has always been really tied up in my tendency to consume a lot of information, be really, like you said, on the pulse of social pressures and really interested in the way that bodies and food and beauty and health are kind of politicized and interwoven into a kind of broader cultural context.
00:03:27.747 --> 00:03:41.847
So it's been a really big part of my own personal eating disorder and recovery journey is thinking about those things as they apply to me and my own eating and behaviors and also just kind of more broadly.
00:03:41.847 --> 00:03:54.073
I was really inspired by how life-changing my work with you was to kind of pursue clinical psychology as a career path.
00:03:54.073 --> 00:04:25.687
And I think that, like you said, our conversations can hopefully be helpful because not only do we have sort of a dual perspective in terms of the provider and the patient, but we also have you know, different angles that we come at it with personally, uh, because of, you know, our generations and like the different things that we care about as people.
00:04:25.687 --> 00:04:32.956
Um, I remember when you and I first started working together, um, I remember I knew you as like the yoga person.
00:04:32.956 --> 00:04:36.298
Cause I, you know, when I met you, you were really into yoga.
00:04:36.298 --> 00:04:41.884
You were teaching yoga at the place where I was getting treated and, uh, you had done your dissertation.
00:04:41.884 --> 00:05:33.536
Um, having to do with mindfulness and yoga and so you know that's like one perspective that i know you bring to the table that is totally different than the perspective that i had which is like for a later conversation but of someone who like didn't exercise for 20 years and like really had a hard time approaching exercise because of how intertwined it was my disordered eating so i think that hopefully we can have today at least a conversation about eating disorders and some GLP-1s and food noise that can be helpful for people who are either kind of thinking about these topics, maybe for people who are
Load full transcript
considering getting treatment, considering going on a GLP-1 or anyone kind of related to that intersection of things.
00:05:35.559 --> 00:05:35.738
Right.
00:05:35.738 --> 00:05:40.706
And the other piece is that, you know, not everybody has access to therapy.
00:05:40.706 --> 00:05:44.526
Sometimes people are hesitant to go into it.
00:05:44.526 --> 00:06:02.014
So the more that we can normalize and validate this entire process without contaminating the process, which just shows all the ways in which therapy can be used, I think, and to just make it accessible, that could be a huge thing for us to do here.
00:06:02.014 --> 00:06:03.475
Yeah, absolutely.
00:06:03.475 --> 00:06:03.516
I
00:06:05.959 --> 00:06:07.601
was thinking, I was wondering kind of...
00:06:07.601 --> 00:06:16.937
How would you describe, you know, someone, I'm sure you get this a lot, but how would you describe your approach to treating eating?
00:06:16.937 --> 00:06:19.939
I get it all the time.
00:06:22.744 --> 00:06:31.834
You know, and I really, I shy away from saying like, I have an eclectic way of treating eating because I think that says nothing sort of.
00:06:31.834 --> 00:06:47.230
Well, like, you know, but I, I would say that my perspective is nutrition forward and is what I've landed on, which is that I don't think you can treat eating disorders without simultaneously treating the food.
00:06:47.230 --> 00:07:00.230
And so as, as much as some people don't want to hear that and don't want to do that, like they just want to, they think they can just come in and talk about their feelings about food.
00:07:00.230 --> 00:07:07.161
If they're not eating and their brain is not being nourished simultaneously, then therapy is sort of impossible.
00:07:07.778 --> 00:07:22.440
And once I sort of made that determination for me as a clinician, it sort of made things very straightforward because somebody that is actively starving and not working on starving is not really going to be able to do very much dynamic work.
00:07:22.440 --> 00:07:24.463
Yeah.
00:07:24.463 --> 00:07:30.634
And so I would say I'm a nutrition forward therapist, you know, and then I use whatever I think is going to work.
00:07:30.634 --> 00:07:32.214
Right.
00:07:32.214 --> 00:07:36.139
If I think they need some things to take home with them at the end of the session, they can do that.
00:07:36.139 --> 00:07:36.721
Right.
00:07:36.721 --> 00:07:42.910
If I think they need some homework, if I think they need to see the nutritionist more than me for a little while, they can do that.
00:07:42.910 --> 00:07:57.432
So but my goal is to make sure that someone is no longer alone with their eating disorder, that they have a teammate in the fight and they have somebody who empathizes with the fight.
00:07:58.954 --> 00:07:59.033
Yeah.
00:07:59.033 --> 00:07:59.134
Yeah.
00:08:00.418 --> 00:08:01.038
Yeah, absolutely.
00:08:01.038 --> 00:08:32.284
I think the nutrition forward piece is huge, because I think for a long time, there was a, you know, I think it's huge because I think it plays into something that I've struggled with a lot in terms of how eating disorders are approached, which is they're you know, used to be this idea that nutrition forward was really important for someone who came into, let's say an inpatient situation, very underweight, very like with an AN diet, with an anorexia nervosa diagnosis, right?
00:08:32.284 --> 00:08:36.628
So the idea was there had to be some kind of stabilization.
00:08:36.628 --> 00:08:41.472
You had to be on a certain number of calorie meal plan in order to be able to access that treatment.
00:08:41.472 --> 00:08:56.028
But for anybody else, anybody with a bulimia diagnosis, with a binge eating diagnosis, whose primary presenting concern wasn't being underweight, nutrition was more of an afterthought or it wasn't as important.
00:08:56.028 --> 00:09:18.787
And it really like, you know, I know we used to talk about this a lot when I was younger, but like, I think that really plays into a weight biased kind of approach to eating disorder treatment that I think that you've done a really good job of neutralizing in your practice, but that not Not everybody does.
00:09:18.787 --> 00:09:30.201
And so I'm sure I don't know what it's like right now because I don't currently treat eating disorders, but I have a feeling that there is still a lot of that where there's kind of an idea that nutrition matters more for some people than others.
00:09:30.201 --> 00:09:38.591
And it sort of perpetuates a stigma in eating disorder treatment that mirrors fat stigma in the broader culture.
00:09:38.631 --> 00:09:46.782
Yeah, I think it's funny because as you said, it was such an unconscious thing.
00:09:46.782 --> 00:10:11.087
thing for me to do to treat from this perspective and it was really just the realization that if we are going to continue to practice something it's going to get stronger and stronger right so if we are going to practice restriction and binging right and if we're just going to keep doing that i don't care what your weight is Right, that is an eating pattern that needs to be broken.
00:10:11.087 --> 00:10:15.294
And the only way it can be broken is by eating in a more normalized way.
00:10:15.294 --> 00:10:18.779
And so the weight really isn't important.
00:10:18.779 --> 00:10:22.225
It's the rituals, it's the patterns, right?
00:10:22.225 --> 00:10:27.955
And it really is like what we teach ourselves to do and how we teach ourselves to behave.
00:10:27.955 --> 00:10:30.339
And that's what needs to get treated.
00:10:30.339 --> 00:10:38.167
So like, I mean, you worked with me forever, like, I don't have a scale in my office, right?
00:10:38.167 --> 00:10:39.509
I don't even want one.
00:10:39.509 --> 00:10:47.320
I do need you followed by a nutritionist because I need to make sure you're healthy and that what you report to me is accurate, right?
00:10:47.320 --> 00:10:54.330
If someone is telling me that
they're eating three meals a day and two snacks, the only way to know that is so they get weighed.
00:10:54.330 --> 00:10:58.916
But I just don't, I'm so not weight focused.
00:10:58.916 --> 00:11:00.097
Yeah.
00:11:00.238 --> 00:11:00.317
Yeah.
00:11:01.601 --> 00:11:03.644
Right, which
00:11:03.684 --> 00:11:08.010
I think is unique.
00:11:08.010 --> 00:11:38.524
incorporation of new approaches to the substance of food in order for someone to recover.
00:11:38.524 --> 00:12:02.626
But there's really such a huge piece about weight stigma and like what role weight plays in our culture that is really, you know, I think Carolyn Koston, like one of the OG eating disorder treatment people referred to people with eating disorders as the canaries in the coal mine.
00:12:02.626 --> 00:12:35.333
And I always think about that, because there is an element of truth to people with eating disorders being sort of reflective of something wrong with our culture and how we approach weight and how we are so focused on thinness and appearance and tie that so much in with health and this idea of kind of like what you need to do to be healthy is being in a body of this number BMI or whatever.
00:12:35.333 --> 00:12:42.224
And eating disorders take that to an extreme with an obsessive kind of level of focus on those kinds of metrics.
00:12:42.224 --> 00:12:57.375
And I think, yeah, It can be challenging for the providers who work in a medical model to kind of stray from that or to push back against the framework that kind of made the eating disorders possible, which is this focus on weight.
00:12:58.558 --> 00:13:05.432
So when you say canary in the coal mine, was it like these are just the people that are getting attention for our weight focus culture?
00:13:05.432 --> 00:13:06.195
Yeah.
00:13:06.254 --> 00:13:06.534
Yeah.
00:13:06.534 --> 00:13:07.115
Yeah.
00:13:07.115 --> 00:13:20.077
It's like, these are the people who are showing us that there's something wrong because they are taking the, the kind of status quo of thin, good, fat, bad, and just bringing it to its logical extreme.
00:13:20.077 --> 00:13:22.621
But everyone else is playing a role in this culture.
00:13:22.621 --> 00:13:32.357
It's just that the people that even sort of happen to have the genetics and the environment and the, you know, psychological makeup to kind of get to a place where they might die because of it.
00:13:32.577 --> 00:13:42.816
Right, so I'm so happy you said that because working in the field, and I feel like you know this too, but for me, I'm like, Everybody's got an eating disorder, people.
00:13:42.816 --> 00:13:43.635
Right.
00:13:43.635 --> 00:13:46.619
And so, you know, well, you know, I wrote a book.
00:13:46.619 --> 00:13:47.220
Right.
00:13:47.220 --> 00:13:53.125
And the first time I was like shopping this book around trying to find an agent because that's what you have to do is like get an agent or whatever.
00:13:53.125 --> 00:14:02.394
And I remember I was kind of far down the road with these two male agents and they were just like, I just don't think this is that relevant to everybody.
00:14:02.394 --> 00:14:05.577
Like, how do you make this more salient to everybody?
00:14:05.577 --> 00:14:09.662
And I was like, everybody has disordered eating.
00:14:09.662 --> 00:14:10.610
Right.
00:14:10.610 --> 00:14:12.693
Like maybe 5% of people don't.
00:14:12.693 --> 00:14:13.534
Right.
00:14:13.534 --> 00:14:15.618
Like it's wild, you know?
00:14:15.618 --> 00:14:22.990
And so, but I was like, but the issue is that it's so normalized that in fact, disordered eating has become normal eating.
00:14:22.990 --> 00:14:24.312
Right.
00:14:24.312 --> 00:14:32.845
Like not eating anything until dinner is what people do when they're having a big dinner without the idea that like, that's not what we're supposed to do.
00:14:32.845 --> 00:14:34.067
Right.
00:14:34.067 --> 00:14:36.049
We shouldn't starve so that we can binge at dinner.
00:14:36.706 --> 00:14:37.226
Right.
00:14:37.246 --> 00:14:39.009
We should just eat in regular amount.
00:14:39.009 --> 00:14:45.379
And it was really, and it was, and not to like take in too many things at once, but.
00:14:45.379 --> 00:14:46.961
That's my job.
00:14:47.562 --> 00:15:02.745
But in order to like, sort of bring it back full circle and full culture, which is like only when this like sort of food noise term went viral is everybody like, Oh yeah, I do.
00:15:02.745 --> 00:15:04.489
I do have an issue with food.
00:15:04.489 --> 00:15:07.500
And I'm like, I think you and I are both like, no kidding.
00:15:08.663 --> 00:15:11.567
So did you notice, I'm so curious about that.
00:15:11.567 --> 00:15:16.936
So you mentioned the food noise term kind of gaining traction in the mainstream.
00:15:16.936 --> 00:15:18.818
Do you have an example?
00:15:18.818 --> 00:15:25.910
Are there ways that you noticed that kind of coming up in, you know, for people who are not your patients maybe, or.
00:15:25.910 --> 00:15:27.212
Well,
00:15:28.014 --> 00:15:30.437
first of all, I started seeing it in the paper.
00:15:30.437 --> 00:15:31.620
Sure.
00:15:31.620 --> 00:15:34.148
Like in the, in the times, right?
00:15:34.148 --> 00:15:41.782
And like, you know, in every op-ed, in every article, all of a sudden it was like, you know, scientists are discovering this thing called food noise, right?
00:15:41.782 --> 00:15:51.298
Which seems to be, you know, which is, and like definition of non-defined food noise, which is basically just like a, it's like your inner critic.
00:15:51.298 --> 00:15:52.600
We know what food noise is.
00:15:52.600 --> 00:16:01.993
It's somebody telling you what to eat, when to eat, how much to eat, when not to eat, like, Anybody with an identified eating disorder is familiar with their food noise.
00:16:01.993 --> 00:16:07.003
And all of a sudden people were sort of like, I think I have that.
00:16:07.003 --> 00:16:14.076
You know, like friends of mine would just say like, is
that what you're talking about?
00:16:14.076 --> 00:16:18.203
Is food noise like what eating disorders are?
00:16:18.203 --> 00:16:21.629
And I was like, kind of, yeah.
00:16:21.889 --> 00:16:24.013
I mean, it's a really, actually, it's a good question, right?
00:16:24.013 --> 00:16:29.240
Is what differentiates like garden variety food noise from an eating disorder?
00:16:29.240 --> 00:16:34.427
What would you say, you know, if someone's listening and thinking like, I think I do have that.
00:16:34.427 --> 00:16:35.969
Does that mean I have an eating disorder?
00:16:35.969 --> 00:16:37.150
Where do you draw a line?
00:16:37.171 --> 00:16:42.398
First of all, I always go to preoccupation.
00:16:42.398 --> 00:16:45.605
And so again, I don't care about your weight.
00:16:45.605 --> 00:16:54.479
What I really care about is how much time do you spend thinking about, obsessing about food, exercise, behaviors, your body.
00:16:54.479 --> 00:17:09.602
And so literally I'll say, as you've seen me do, I'm sure like get out a pie chart, section off your life, how much of the theme of that life is like perseverating and thinking about food and bodies.
00:17:09.602 --> 00:17:14.740
And the higher that percentage is, the more I would say you have an eating disorder.
00:17:14.740 --> 00:17:19.990
So most people in my office that are in real treatment are somewhere around 90% and up.
00:17:20.931 --> 00:17:21.131
Wow.
00:17:21.131 --> 00:17:22.393
Right.
00:17:22.393 --> 00:17:24.676
So they're spending 90% of your time thinking about
00:17:25.198 --> 00:17:26.480
eating while doing other activities.
00:17:26.480 --> 00:17:29.023
That's not, they're not just sitting in a room thinking about it.
00:17:29.064 --> 00:17:33.990
And so if you are listening to this, think about it, right?
00:17:33.990 --> 00:17:39.652
Like how many times do you make a plan to go out for dinner and think about like, What am I going to be able to eat there?
00:17:39.652 --> 00:17:41.054
Let me look at the menu.
00:17:41.054 --> 00:17:43.518
I should go to the gym if I'm going to go out for dinner.
00:17:43.518 --> 00:17:48.705
Even that sort of gentle negotiation is negotiation.
00:17:48.705 --> 00:17:49.567
It's noise.
00:17:50.449 --> 00:17:50.729
Yeah.
00:17:50.729 --> 00:17:51.871
Yeah.
00:17:51.871 --> 00:17:53.313
Totally.
00:17:53.353 --> 00:17:54.515
It's
00:17:54.535 --> 00:17:56.038
so funny because I don't remember that.
00:17:56.038 --> 00:18:01.807
I love for me that I had amnesia about how much time you could spend thinking about that.
00:18:01.807 --> 00:18:04.190
It's funny.
00:18:05.352 --> 00:18:06.334
Yeah.
00:18:06.334 --> 00:18:07.946
But so you're a great example.
00:18:07.946 --> 00:18:13.794
You're the perfect example of how when we stop practicing something, it can disappear.
00:18:13.794 --> 00:18:20.121
You stopped practicing your food noise and it no longer exists.
00:18:20.961 --> 00:18:35.438
I mean, and maybe this is a good time to talk about the GLP-1 because I actually think now that I'm thinking about it in your pie chart way, I do actually think that since I've been on a GLP-1, it's been...
00:18:35.438 --> 00:18:39.368
like maybe 14 months now.
00:18:39.368 --> 00:18:41.029
It's been like maybe a little bit over a year.
00:18:41.029 --> 00:18:47.037
I think that my percentage has probably gone down even more.
00:18:47.037 --> 00:18:57.567
Like I think probably when I started the GLP-1, I would have put my, how much time I spent thinking about my body or food or whatever, probably like 20%.
00:18:57.567 --> 00:18:59.990
Yeah, maybe like 20%.
00:18:59.990 --> 00:19:06.238
I think now it's probably like between five and 10.
00:19:06.753 --> 00:19:07.816
You
00:19:07.836 --> 00:19:10.378
know, like a really, a pretty manageable percentage.
00:19:10.378 --> 00:19:13.223
And it's not distressing.
00:19:13.223 --> 00:19:16.288
And I think that's another key piece.
00:19:16.288 --> 00:19:23.659
I think I would add to your kind of conceptualization of it, like how much distress are you having about how much time you're thinking about it?
00:19:23.659 --> 00:19:31.590
Because when I, even in the past, you know, before the GLP-1, when I was at like 20%, it wasn't distressing.
00:19:31.590 --> 00:19:33.394
Like I wasn't upset thinking about it.
00:19:33.394 --> 00:19:41.875
It was more like, I would think, Oh, like, I'm excited to try this new recipe that I saw on TikTok.
00:19:41.875 --> 00:19:49.365
And I'm gonna go to the gym because like, I feel sluggish and want to get a workout, right?
00:19:49.365 --> 00:19:58.496
Like, there's a difference between having thoughts about food, because I love food, and it's a big part of my life.
00:19:58.496 --> 00:20:02.173
And, you know, had an eating disorder for a very long time.
00:20:02.173 --> 00:20:08.344
And I'm just very used to spending a lot of time thinking about it versus I think thinking about it in a way where I'm like upset about it and fretting.
00:20:09.726 --> 00:20:09.886
Right.
00:20:09.886 --> 00:20:12.872
I think there's a difference between interest and compulsion.
00:20:13.252 --> 00:20:13.452
Yeah.
00:20:14.114 --> 00:20:14.355
Right.
00:20:14.355 --> 00:20:18.642
And so being interested in food is, is a great thing, right?
00:20:18.642 --> 00:20:23.711
We need food to live and eating healthy and well is really good for us.
00:20:23.711 --> 00:20:38.490
But when we can't stop thinking about it or when it interferes with us doing what we want to do that's when we cross the line yeah right like we never wanted to organize our life we wanted to be a part of our life
00:20:39.191 --> 00:20:51.055
yeah totally it's it's i completely agree i mean i am called to think of how one of my favorite things about my relationship with will is that we have the same taste in food
00:20:51.075 --> 00:20:52.217
and
00:20:52.317 --> 00:21:10.461
so whenever we go out to eat we don't have to choose we can get like two things and split them so you have to
decide which one we want um and this weekend he we were uh we were traveling we were about to drive home when there's screaming happening outside my window and
00:21:10.621 --> 00:21:10.981
we can't
00:21:11.021 --> 00:21:30.162
hear it i feel like this is good because it's very loud for me um and he said he was like we're about to leave boston he looked at me he was like yesterday was a really good food day and i was like yeah it was and i was like i think today can be better and he was like yeah And so then we were like, okay, we're going to go, we're going to drive through New Haven.
00:21:30.162 --> 00:21:34.307
We're going to get Frank Pepe's and then we're going to go home and we're going to get a Caesar salad and fries.
00:21:34.307 --> 00:21:41.136
Like this was, you know, and it was like, we did organize our day around food is my point, but it was in a fun, pleasurable way and not.
00:21:41.136 --> 00:21:47.065
And so I think it is possible to, you know, like you said, interest versus compulsion.
00:21:47.105 --> 00:21:47.586
Yeah.
00:21:47.586 --> 00:21:49.167
Like all due respect to foodies.
00:21:49.648 --> 00:21:50.569
Right.
00:21:50.569 --> 00:21:53.854
How can we make this the best Saturday food day possible?
00:21:53.854 --> 00:21:55.757
It's like mission accomplished.
00:21:56.218 --> 00:21:56.478
Right.
00:21:56.478 --> 00:21:57.507
Exactly.
00:21:57.507 --> 00:22:00.210
It's just like, is it, is it like fucking you up?
00:22:00.210 --> 00:22:00.851
Right.
00:22:00.851 --> 00:22:03.535
Like we don't want something to dominate us.
00:22:03.535 --> 00:22:05.096
We want to dominate it.
00:22:05.958 --> 00:22:06.157
Yeah.
00:22:06.157 --> 00:22:07.660
Right.
00:22:07.660 --> 00:22:09.061
We should talk about the New York times article.
00:22:09.583 --> 00:22:09.863
Okay.
00:22:09.863 --> 00:22:11.164
Yes, we should.
00:22:11.445 --> 00:22:13.689
So I guess technically there's a podcast, but I think we both read it.
00:22:13.689 --> 00:22:16.071
Yeah.
00:22:16.071 --> 00:22:18.095
But let me pull it up.
00:22:18.095 --> 00:22:19.096
Yeah.
00:22:19.096 --> 00:22:19.817
Let me pull it up too.
00:22:19.817 --> 00:22:23.241
Why the right is obsessed with thinness.
00:22:23.905 --> 00:22:24.967
It's
00:22:25.007 --> 00:22:27.088
the title of this opinion piece.
00:22:27.088 --> 00:22:55.353
And so we have two New York Times opinion columnists kind of talking about the way that Finness and whiteness also, but have really become weaponized by conservative Christian American culture to kind of push a narrative of morality I'm glad you sent it.
00:22:55.353 --> 00:23:04.566
I definitely had heard about a lot of these different like touch points before.
00:23:04.566 --> 00:23:08.311
What did, what was your reaction to this?
00:23:09.393 --> 00:23:13.219
Well, I just feel like this is like an old horse that's bringing back.
00:23:13.219 --> 00:23:17.925
It's like being like, you know, shined up and rubbed down, you know, it's like, oh, right.
00:23:17.925 --> 00:23:20.209
This was the OG everybody.
00:23:20.249 --> 00:23:21.832
Let's not forget.
00:23:21.832 --> 00:23:25.324
Like you can still, make everyone be obsessed with Kate Moss.
00:23:25.324 --> 00:23:26.085
Like, let's go.
00:23:26.125 --> 00:23:27.846
Like, Hey guys, guess what?
00:23:27.846 --> 00:23:37.598
Like, and also let's attach it to religion, piety and morality, which is what we did in the good old days when it really took off.
00:23:37.598 --> 00:23:38.439
Right.
00:23:38.439 --> 00:23:41.282
Like, and throw in some racism, right.
00:23:41.282 --> 00:23:42.304
And body difference.
00:23:42.304 --> 00:23:47.029
And like, that is how eating disorders took hold in our country.
00:23:47.029 --> 00:23:48.451
Yeah.
00:23:48.451 --> 00:23:48.590
Right.
00:23:48.590 --> 00:23:50.653
They're just dusting off an old theme here.
00:23:51.137 --> 00:23:51.798
They are.
00:23:51.798 --> 00:23:58.588
And it's so wild too, because it's like, it's also such a last ditch effort.
00:23:58.588 --> 00:24:04.657
It feels like to, to, it's like the gender roles of it all.
00:24:04.657 --> 00:24:33.688
You know, I think that dusting off the thinness ideal and the obsession with women in particular being thin and having, you know, being good because they're eating well or whatever that means like is, um, It's so insidious because it also is very much aiming at traditional gender roles in a way that, you know, I think is really on message for the conservative right.
00:24:33.688 --> 00:24:35.029
Absolutely.
00:24:35.049 --> 00:24:37.053
There's a line I want to read, right?
00:24:37.053 --> 00:24:37.814
Yeah.
00:24:37.814 --> 00:24:43.423
Like, less Prozac, more protein, I think is in here.
00:24:43.423 --> 00:24:43.502
Did
00:24:44.124 --> 00:24:45.727
you, had you heard of that girl?
00:24:45.727 --> 00:24:49.932
Because I had, and it was, I think that I had, it might have
00:24:49.952 --> 00:24:51.903
been from- Yeah.
00:24:52.423 --> 00:24:55.349
It might have been from a different Diabolical Lies episode.
00:24:55.349 --> 00:24:56.672
It was from that one?
00:24:56.672 --> 00:24:57.473
Okay.
00:24:57.473 --> 00:24:57.934
Yes.
00:24:58.355 --> 00:25:00.720
But I had heard of her even before.
00:25:00.759 --> 00:25:01.181
You had?
00:25:01.181 --> 00:25:06.351
I've been lucky enough to never have heard about her until Diabolical
00:25:06.371 --> 00:25:06.550
Lies.
00:25:06.550 --> 00:25:11.580
I have heard of her because this is my business.
00:25:11.580 --> 00:25:12.722
And I...
00:25:12.722 --> 00:25:20.695
I just think that this, and, and, you know, there is some controversy over if this convention was even as big as they're saying
00:25:20.756 --> 00:25:21.017
it was.
00:25:21.017 --> 00:25:21.237
Right.
00:25:21.237 --> 00:25:23.278
Diabolicalized at a pretty good, like debunking.
00:25:23.278 --> 00:25:25.881
It seemed like they paid a lot of the women to be there.
00:25:25.881 --> 00:25:25.980
Yeah.
00:25:25.980 --> 00:25:28.044
It wasn't like a real, yeah.
00:25:28.044 --> 00:25:34.169
The New York times sort of on, I have to say, they sort of like uncritically talked about it as a, or it's a real thing.
00:25:34.169 --> 00:25:36.271
And I'm just like, Oh my God, you know, like a
00:25:36.291 --> 00:25:36.872
massive thing.
00:25:36.872 --> 00:25:39.134
Like they made it seem like it was a UN summit.
00:25:39.134 --> 00:25:40.015
I feel like.
00:25:40.255 --> 00:25:40.375
Right.
00:25:40.375 --> 00:25:47.859
And it seems like it was like 500, like, homeschooled high schoolers who were shipped in from across the country.
00:25:47.859 --> 00:25:47.940
But
00:25:48.540 --> 00:25:51.845
I do think, I do think thin, you know, it's interesting this weekend.
00:25:51.845 --> 00:25:58.133
I was my, like one of my close friends has, has a 20 year old and a 23 year old daughter.
00:25:58.133 --> 00:25:58.633
Right.
00:25:58.633 --> 00:26:02.057
And like, they had like a bunch of friends out and I, I had some access.
00:26:02.057 --> 00:26:08.045
So I was like talking to them and just, and they were totally talking about that.
00:26:08.045 --> 00:26:11.990
Thin being thin is like very, very in.
00:26:11.990 --> 00:26:14.019
It is way back.
00:26:14.019 --> 00:26:16.202
And so is food morality is back.
00:26:16.202 --> 00:26:29.862
Not that it ever left, but this whole idea that when they're in the dining hall at school or in the cafeteria, they feel funny if they're sitting with a big group going to get a burger.
00:26:29.862 --> 00:26:32.885
They don't.
00:26:32.885 --> 00:26:38.513
They will once in a while, but they think about it and it's not sort of reflexive.
00:26:38.513 --> 00:26:41.178
Much easier for them to get a salad with chicken.
00:26:42.145 --> 00:26:42.807
I hate that.
00:26:43.627 --> 00:26:44.349
But so true.
00:26:44.349 --> 00:26:45.852
So true.
00:26:45.852 --> 00:26:46.633
So real.
00:26:46.633 --> 00:26:48.537
So real.
00:26:48.537 --> 00:26:51.862
And it's like, am I a better person because I got the salad with chicken?
00:26:51.862 --> 00:26:52.983
Right?
00:26:52.983 --> 00:26:56.169
Or are people going to think I'm gross because I got the burger?
00:26:56.169 --> 00:26:59.114
Even though I want the burger.
00:26:59.114 --> 00:27:01.959
Right?
00:27:01.959 --> 00:27:04.864
You know, it's really...
00:27:04.864 --> 00:27:08.128
So this article for me is just literally...
00:27:08.128 --> 00:27:13.441
digging in the archives of eating disorder history and finding some real goodies
00:27:14.221 --> 00:27:43.756
yeah i agree and i think um i think something they say that's so accurate is it's very obvious like once you've been around the block a little bit to see how um you know the thin is in thing right now is such a direct response to the body positive fat acceptance movement of like, you know, that I think they said peaked in like 2016 or so, which I think is about right.
00:27:43.756 --> 00:27:49.804
An interesting, an interesting year to have things
peak before they go back down, but right.
00:27:49.804 --> 00:27:51.465
Not, not necessarily surprising.
00:27:51.465 --> 00:27:53.008
That's funny.
00:27:53.008 --> 00:28:21.644
Because yeah, there really was a moment in culture and I remember really feeling like, so happy to be part like a young person during that time when it finally felt like there was a movement towards a more inclusive size range towards like shaming people for using like body negative language, right?
00:28:21.644 --> 00:28:25.670
Shaming people for policing other people's food choices.
00:28:25.670 --> 00:28:26.971
Like, I think that was great.
00:28:26.971 --> 00:28:38.468
You know, I think, I think it was so lovely as someone who had recently recovered from an eating disorder around that time to be like, okay, cool.
00:28:38.468 --> 00:28:39.849
The culture is actually catching up.
00:28:39.849 --> 00:28:45.738
Like we're getting a little bit, you know, a little bit more with it and there's not going to be fat talk everywhere.
00:28:45.738 --> 00:28:53.309
And, you know, maybe, um, you know, I can buy a size 16 pair of jeans at Abercrombie, right?
00:28:53.309 --> 00:29:14.333
But it's so sad and also predictable to kind of like see how the right will of course have grabbed onto this kind of like thin idealization because it's such a good tool for suppressing women, making people feel inferior about their bodies.
00:29:14.333 --> 00:29:18.397
If you're hungry, you are not hungry.
00:29:18.397 --> 00:29:23.397
able to do good therapy but also probably not able to do good activism right
00:29:23.858 --> 00:29:43.611
i think that's true i think that's true and even like just more like yes that is like sort of the the the crushing soul of being a woman right which is like stay thin and stay quiet right but But if we can really, I mean, I completely blame the Kardashians for the swing in both directions.
00:29:43.611 --> 00:29:48.361
I was so grateful to them for their body positivity and their curves.
00:29:48.361 --> 00:29:57.861
Like Kim's curves were critical in shifting the needle towards like curves being in and like a good booty and like all that talk that was...
00:29:57.861 --> 00:29:59.522
I was so happy.
00:29:59.522 --> 00:30:06.711
And then the second she started injectables and like cranked herself in that Marilyn Monroe dress.
00:30:06.711 --> 00:30:07.771
I was like, we're dead.
00:30:07.771 --> 00:30:09.113
It's over.
00:30:10.694 --> 00:30:12.336
Well, they were an interesting case too.
00:30:12.336 --> 00:30:15.640
And like, I would need to like really think about it to have a conversation.
00:30:15.640 --> 00:30:17.563
Cause it's been so long since I thought about them.
00:30:17.563 --> 00:30:18.604
Cause I really try not to.
00:30:18.604 --> 00:30:21.686
But there was a moment where I watched a lot of their shows.
00:30:21.686 --> 00:30:26.597
I think back during COVID, I think I told you, I was like, I watched like all, I had never watched it before.
00:30:26.597 --> 00:30:27.681
And I was like, oh, this is fun.
00:30:27.681 --> 00:30:34.076
And I got really into it, but they did have this interesting kind of arc because they had one, right?
00:30:34.076 --> 00:30:41.059
Chloe was so clearly, the one of the girls who had a weight problem, right?
00:30:41.059 --> 00:30:43.303
She was always changing her body.
00:30:43.303 --> 00:30:46.027
She obviously had very low self-esteem.
00:30:46.027 --> 00:30:56.803
She was also always dating men who were treating her poorly publicly in a way that like really fit with this kind of like archetype of woman, right?
00:30:56.803 --> 00:30:59.686
Who really struggled with her self-image.
00:30:59.686 --> 00:31:04.213
And yeah, the Kardashians like,
00:31:04.897 --> 00:31:23.820
like i didn't really watch the show um i just could never get hooked even though i definitely do my fair share of bad tv but um or reality tv but like kim what was kim's body type in that show considered was it just like she was sort of like you know the ring
00:31:23.861 --> 00:31:25.083
she was the archetype
00:31:25.282 --> 00:31:26.223
she was the one
00:31:26.525 --> 00:31:27.766
right so what happened
00:31:27.806 --> 00:31:30.890
when she lost the weight on the show right
00:31:31.150 --> 00:31:31.371
she
00:31:32.451 --> 00:31:32.872
do we know i
00:31:33.573 --> 00:31:35.855
don't know I don't know.
00:31:35.855 --> 00:31:36.998
I don't remember really.
00:31:36.998 --> 00:31:39.942
I think it was just like, I don't know.
00:31:39.942 --> 00:31:41.084
They were such an interesting thing.
00:31:41.084 --> 00:31:49.817
Cause they were also just like, they were so, it was a matriarchal family, right?
00:31:49.817 --> 00:31:59.853
It was very women focused, but it's so interesting how they actually evolved to this place that makes so much sense and is so much worse than it had to be.
00:31:59.853 --> 00:32:13.259
But like where they, um, the way that they kind of presented was actually like I think they ended up being pretty gross in a way that we should have been able to clock.
00:32:13.259 --> 00:32:18.909
You know, they kind of have this like racially ambiguous thing going, but they still really benefit from white privilege.
00:32:18.909 --> 00:32:23.976
A lot of them like date black men and then kind of discard them when they're done.
00:32:23.976 --> 00:32:32.087
So they sort of have like proximity to blackness and in what like cool factor that gives them until they no longer want it.
00:32:32.087 --> 00:32:38.796
Like all their babies are mixed race, but then like, you know, Kim's X is a Nazi.
00:32:38.796 --> 00:32:41.780
So, you know, there's like, there's a lot.
00:32:41.780 --> 00:32:46.709
And then, and then of course, like, I remember this year, I really don't look at their stuff anymore because it makes me sick.
00:32:46.709 --> 00:32:56.243
Like, I'm not even being like exaggerating, but they, you know, she's sort of posting, she posted like in front of a cyber
truck back when the cyber truck came out.
00:32:56.243 --> 00:33:00.309
And we were like, okay, like, it's very clear, you know, and now she posts all these selfies of like Ivanka Trump.
00:33:00.309 --> 00:33:04.537
It's like very clear, like what, what they've decided to do.
00:33:05.198 --> 00:33:05.278
Yeah.
00:33:05.377 --> 00:33:14.470
But it's interesting how, for a moment, she did have this like curvaceous body and that became popular.
00:33:14.470 --> 00:33:29.911
And as soon as that was popularized, it's like the classic, you know, the royal move of once the common people can achieve a certain aesthetic, you must do the other one, the one that's more unachievable.
00:33:29.911 --> 00:33:34.278
Because you know, that's how you elevate yourself above the masses.
00:33:34.278 --> 00:33:34.739
Right.
00:33:34.739 --> 00:33:50.938
And so like, and so it may, I mean, it does make you wonder, and then we can kind of talk about GLP-1s, but it makes you wonder like what's going to happen now that, people are going to have access to GLP-1s and it's going to be more common for people to be able to be at a lower body weight.
00:33:50.938 --> 00:33:55.583
Like I wonder what will happen to the thin ideal over time, right?
00:33:55.583 --> 00:33:58.125
Because the conservative right, I think is grasping at straws.
00:33:58.125 --> 00:34:03.550
Like I think this is a really important article and they are definitely- Grasping at what kind of straws?
00:34:03.550 --> 00:34:03.912
What do you mean?
00:34:03.912 --> 00:34:13.416
I think they're grasping at straws to try to maintain some kind of power and control over, you know, like they need the gender binary to stay, right?
00:34:13.416 --> 00:34:19.311
Like they, even though it's very clear that like, I think that it's not, they're not gonna ultimately be successful with that, right?
00:34:19.311 --> 00:34:25.264
Like good luck getting Gen Z to go back into a gender binary in any like real way.
00:34:25.264 --> 00:34:33.259
We as a culture have, have moved past that in so many different ways that it's not going to be that easy, I think.
00:34:33.259 --> 00:34:38.503
I think they're grasping at straws to try to, you know, like the whole Hannah Nealman, ballerina farm shit thing.
00:34:38.503 --> 00:34:40.806
Like they really want women back in the home.
00:34:40.806 --> 00:34:43.447
They really want us to not have credit cards and not have jobs.
00:34:43.447 --> 00:34:45.088
And like, they're going to do their absolute best.
00:34:45.088 --> 00:34:50.094
And obviously they are doing a pretty good job, right, by restricting abortion access.
00:34:50.094 --> 00:34:55.237
But I do think that culturally speaking, the right is ultimately losing.
00:34:55.237 --> 00:35:10.523
And I think that the grasping of thinness is going to be another aspect of them losing because of GLP ones, which actually might be like a, a nice thing about GLP ones is that like, it's actually not, I don't think it's going to be, although we should talk about the morality around.
00:35:10.543 --> 00:35:18.438
And also like, I just want to, I want to point out another reason why I think this meeting is so important of you and me, which is that like, I don't know what they're losing.
00:35:18.438 --> 00:35:22.050
You seem so different perspectives.
00:35:22.050 --> 00:35:25.436
And like, I think, you know, I'm worried that they're not losing as much.
00:35:25.436 --> 00:35:26.478
I hope you're right.
00:35:26.478 --> 00:35:27.300
Right.
00:35:27.300 --> 00:35:33.813
But I worry that like, I got sort of fooled into thinking that like they were not winning.
00:35:33.833 --> 00:35:35.355
Yeah, they won.
00:35:35.355 --> 00:35:38.782
So, you know, I, I don't, I hope you're right.
00:35:38.782 --> 00:35:39.494
And time.
00:35:39.594 --> 00:35:40.516
I hope I'm right too.
00:35:40.516 --> 00:35:46.121
I mean, I think it's a bigger conversation about like why I think they're losing and we can absolutely table it.
00:35:46.382 --> 00:35:47.224
Let's flag that for
00:35:47.264 --> 00:35:48.826
flag it for a different time.
00:35:48.826 --> 00:35:53.110
I think it's actually a really important conversation that we can have, but
00:35:53.291 --> 00:35:56.835
a really important conversation also is, am I getting targeted with different shit than you are?
00:35:56.835 --> 00:35:57.956
Like, why do
00:35:58.237 --> 00:36:15.021
I, you are all on a different internet is another thing that's real, but that's part of why I think that the right is ultimately going to lose that battle because the the kind of fascist, like Christian nationalist ideology really requires a very, very small lane.
00:36:15.021 --> 00:36:17.623
It requires a really small worldview.
00:36:17.623 --> 00:36:28.014
And for better or for worse, the internet exists and we are all able to be exposed to really different things.
00:36:28.014 --> 00:36:37.423
And I think that ultimately in order to keep people small and not knowing what other options are, they can't have access to information.
00:36:37.423 --> 00:36:37.804
I was
00:36:37.824 --> 00:36:39.226
about to say, then they would have to eliminate.
00:36:39.266 --> 00:36:49.818
I just think there's, there's, I, I have faith that they are losing because at the very least it's too much information, too much internet for them to tamp down.
00:36:49.938 --> 00:36:50.780
Yeah.
00:36:50.780 --> 00:36:50.880
Okay.
00:36:50.880 --> 00:36:52.583
Let's put a placehold in that.
00:36:52.583 --> 00:36:54.505
Cause I, I hope you're right.
00:36:54.505 --> 00:36:58.530
And I am sort of like going with the millennial.
00:36:58.530 --> 00:37:07.976
But I, but I do want to say that I have for years said that, GLP ones are going to be taken right along with the daily vitamin.
00:37:07.976 --> 00:37:12.932
I think it's going to be like that old school book, the giver.
00:37:12.932 --> 00:37:14.876
Remember, it's been
00:37:14.956 --> 00:37:15.396
so long.
00:37:15.396 --> 00:37:16.418
Okay,
00:37:16.697 --> 00:37:17.840
I'll remind you.
00:37:17.840 --> 00:37:30.717
So basically, the giver is like a little, you know, utopian community where everybody, you know, take certain types of drugs that like tamp down their sex drive, all the colors are muted, there's no extreme weather, right?
00:37:30.717 --> 00:37:39.230
Because the like, when the people came into power, they were sort of like, oh, it's these extremes and these differences and passion that causes war.
00:37:39.230 --> 00:37:39.927
Right.
00:37:39.927 --> 00:37:41.331
That's sort of the premise of the giver.
00:37:41.331 --> 00:37:47.909
And so but there's one person in the community that holds the memories of of old times.
00:37:47.909 --> 00:37:51.762
And that person is called the giver, the giver and the receiver.
00:37:51.762 --> 00:37:52.163
Right.
00:37:52.163 --> 00:37:58.391
And so Every generation of this community, this utopian community has a giver, right?
00:37:58.391 --> 00:38:02.094
Who has received the memories of generations past, right?
00:38:02.094 --> 00:38:07.679
And finally, this like, you know, spoiler alert or whatever, but like this- Spoiler
00:38:07.699 --> 00:38:09.340
alert for this book you read in eighth grade.
00:38:09.340 --> 00:38:11.023
I did
00:38:11.083 --> 00:38:13.826
read it to my children and like, we were all obsessed with The Giver.
00:38:13.985 --> 00:38:14.927
It was a great book.
00:38:15.586 --> 00:38:16.949
I have fond memories.
00:38:16.949 --> 00:38:17.628
Right.
00:38:17.628 --> 00:38:18.250
And there's a movie.
00:38:18.250 --> 00:38:26.010
So, but, and basically he was like, people- Like we are not living our real lives.
00:38:26.010 --> 00:38:37.681
And he sort of escapes this utopia, this dystopia with the memories and like sort of gets out of this bubble and sort of stops taking all the medications and we don't really know what happens.
00:38:37.681 --> 00:38:48.914
But I think that this is sort of in that context, which is like finding a body weight that becomes achievable to all people by just popping a pill Right.
00:38:48.914 --> 00:38:52.621
And so it will no longer sort of like separate the haves from the have nots.
00:38:53.222 --> 00:38:53.443
Yeah.
00:38:53.443 --> 00:38:55.206
There's going to be something else.
00:38:55.206 --> 00:38:57.789
It will, they'll find, we'll find something else.
00:38:57.789 --> 00:38:59.012
Right.
00:38:59.012 --> 00:39:17.175
Because that's the thing is like, I actually think that from that perspective, GLP ones could be a real foil in, in the kind of landscape of, um, oppressing people for their body weight, right?
00:39:17.175 --> 00:39:20.280
Like, you know, and the haves and the have-nots.
00:39:20.280 --> 00:39:25.807
Obviously, there's pharmaceutical industry and, like, how much are they going to charge for this and all that kind of stuff.
00:39:25.807 --> 00:39:26.710
Like, there's a lot there.
00:39:26.710 --> 00:39:32.418
You know, most people's insurances don't cover it right now.
00:39:32.418 --> 00:39:33.179
Right.
00:39:33.179 --> 00:39:35.382
And even, you know, if they do, it can be expensive.
00:39:36.965 --> 00:39:37.126
Right.
00:39:37.126 --> 00:39:44.012
And will the Christian right want everybody– to be thin or will they only want people with access and privilege to be thin?
00:39:44.572 --> 00:39:45.594
Probably that, right?
00:39:45.594 --> 00:40:15.387
Because there was part of it where it's like this idea that if you're, and it's funny, I've so, I think I told you that I am on this subreddit that's anti-diet GLP ones, which I found really incredibly helpful because when I first started taking it, I felt very alone and I felt like, um, conflicted about taking it because it kind of, you know, I have a lot of thoughts about thinness and all that kind of stuff came up for me when I decided to start taking this medication.
00:40:15.387 --> 00:40:17.068
I was like, wow, I'm really going to lose weight.
00:40:17.068 --> 00:40:18.612
Like what's that going to actually feel like?
00:40:18.612 --> 00:40:20.715
And do I need to take this forever and all this kind of stuff.
00:40:20.715 --> 00:40:25.322
And then I also was having like normal side effects and things like that, that I was trying to learn how to manage.
00:40:25.322 --> 00:40:26.023
And I felt very alone.
00:40:26.023 --> 00:40:39.608
I didn't know who to talk to about it because a lot of the internet on, you know, talking about GLP ones is a lot of people like, without an eating disorder history or without kind of like the language that I like to use to talk about my eating.
00:40:39.608 --> 00:40:50.565
And so I found this community of people who mostly have eating disorder histories and like have taken kind of an anti-diet approach and health at every size and have also started GLP-1s.
00:40:50.565 --> 00:40:53.789
And so they kind of have a shared language that I find very helpful.
00:40:53.789 --> 00:40:58.878
And so I started reading a lot of their posts and like things they do to combat nausea or whatever, X, Y, Z.
00:40:58.878 --> 00:41:07.289
But there are still people who post there and talk about how others have said to them, like, what does it feel like to be cheating?
00:41:07.289 --> 00:41:11.708
You know, like this idea that taking a GLP-1 to lose weight means that you're cheating.
00:41:11.708 --> 00:41:13.552
And I was like so perplexed by that.
00:41:13.552 --> 00:41:19.221
I genuinely don't understand, but I think it really falls in line with this kind of like that Christian morality, right?
00:41:19.221 --> 00:41:22.565
Of like, if you're doing something without suffering, we talked a little bit about it in the article.
00:41:22.565 --> 00:41:25.150
If you're doing it without suffering, it's not real.
00:41:25.150 --> 00:41:26.211
It doesn't count.
00:41:26.211 --> 00:41:27.994
The suffering is part of it.
00:41:27.994 --> 00:41:31.760
You should be suffering because you are fat and that's bad.
00:41:31.760 -->
00:41:37.050
And I think there's also this really like make America healthy again, right?
00:41:37.050 --> 00:41:41.755
RFK stuff of like medication is bad period, right?
00:41:41.755 --> 00:41:43.277
Pharmaceuticals are the devil.
00:41:43.317 --> 00:41:44.418
And I
00:41:44.617 --> 00:41:55.188
think that's a really interesting thing that's probably gonna come up more and more with the GLP-1s and this kind of like conservative right approach to things.
00:41:55.849 --> 00:42:09.831
And I think, and I just, I know we're gonna have to stop in a minute or two, but I also think Like the other piece of it is that, I mean, if you put on your old eating disorder, disordered hat, that's such eating disorder language to say you're cheating.
00:42:09.831 --> 00:42:14.436
If you know, you're taking a GLP-1 because you're not like a really good anorexic.
00:42:14.436 --> 00:42:15.056
Yeah.
00:42:15.056 --> 00:42:23.824
You know, like, like, you know, it's like when people, you know, in residential treatment or in, you know, day treatment would say like, you look so healthy.
00:42:23.824 --> 00:42:25.347
Right.
00:42:25.347 --> 00:42:45.750
Like that was like the biggest, like, cloaked criticism of all time it was basically like oh you're fat and I'm still thin that was you're so healthy and so it's it's just again been appropriated right like it's cheating it's it's like why because my body's actually healthier now
00:42:45.769 --> 00:43:30.882
right it's like I'm not suffering through uh you know the kind of like haywire hunger cues that i normally have right so there's this sort of idea that like you should be suffering for what you're doing right and there's always been that kind of thing it's punitive very punitive yeah that's right yeah um i wanted to ask you or say one more thing um but i'm i'm blanking okay what are we is there anything else we need to like touch on for this i feel like i feel like this is a good start it was good it was a good start is there anything should we end with something let's
00:43:30.902 --> 00:43:46.568
see um also like we want to talk about what other people are thinking about right so right it'll be good to get feedback yeah yeah 100 let's get feedback and like let's if you're watching this like what do you want to hear us talk about
00:43:47.110 --> 00:43:50.461
yeah yeah totally 100% we'll take questions
00:43:51.123 --> 00:44:00.438
you know give us like we we are here to talk about what's going on and whatever people want to hear about because we can talk all day um that's that is true
00:44:01.259 --> 00:44:32.286
that is true uh shoot I did have one more thing though um no it doesn't matter rfk Oh, no, you know, my only other thing was just that I was thinking about the GOP ones is like, um, just how rampant the kind of anti medication sentiment is for people in psychology more generally, you know, like, I can't tell you how many patients I've had, who are just like, so depressed or so depressed.
00:44:32.286 --> 00:44:33.356
anxious.
00:44:33.356 --> 00:44:36.342
And I've said to them, like, can I refer you to psychiatry?
00:44:36.342 --> 00:44:37.385
And they're like, absolutely not.
00:44:37.385 --> 00:44:38.730
I know.
00:44:38.730 --> 00:44:44.103
And sometimes they'll come back after, you know, like a little while of working together and be like, I think I'm ready, right?
00:44:44.103 --> 00:44:46.650
Like, I think I don't need to suffer this much anymore.
00:44:46.650 --> 00:44:51.023
And that's always really love a great moment.
00:44:51.023 --> 00:44:51.905
I love that.
00:44:51.905 --> 00:45:02.023
But it's really, it's gotten into people's brains a lot, like how wrong it is to be, you know, using something that's not natural to kind of like help yourself.
00:45:02.023 --> 00:45:13.083
And I hope that like, you know, if anything, like, sort of like to go back to what your approach is, like, let's do what works to help people feel better, right?
00:45:13.083 --> 00:45:16.503
Even if it's a little bit of this, a little bit of that, right?
00:45:16.503 --> 00:45:17.925
Maybe it's a little bit of medication.
00:45:17.925 --> 00:45:27.838
Maybe it's a little bit of something else, but like kind of like being willing to be flexible in how you're approaching feeling better and changing your brain because it is possible to change it.
00:45:27.838 --> 00:45:34.565
But if we're stuck in the rigidity of doing things the old way, then we're not going to be able to change.
00:45:35.146 --> 00:45:35.527
Exactly.
00:45:35.527 --> 00:45:39.972
And the parallels between GLP-1s and psychiatric meds are huge, right?
00:45:39.972 --> 00:45:44.018
It's just like, it doesn't matter if it's helping, let's use it.
00:45:44.018 --> 00:45:45.338
Right.
00:45:45.338 --> 00:45:48.711
Let's use it, you know, and keep you safe in the process.
00:45:48.711 --> 00:45:50.679
Exactly.
00:45:50.679 --> 00:45:52.387
All right.
00:45:52.387 --> 00:45:53.911
Perfect.
00:45:53.911 --> 00:45:54.434
All right.
00:45:54.434 --> 00:45:55.237
I'll see you soon.
00:45:55.237 --> 00:45:55.840
Bye.