UDSKRIFT 🔗
0:00
People don't distinguish between biological aging, that is those mechanisms that breaks those down and chronological aging. The fact that it's a good thing to be alive. Hey, welcome to an especially existential episode for you today. If you watch some of the previous videos, we've been focusing on the exciting future of medicine and a promising paradigm shift that will allow us to prevent, treat and maybe even reverse age related diseases. We will do this by targeting the underlying mechanisms, meaning the root causes of these diseases, rather than trying to cure the diseases one by one, which hasn't been proven very successful. Some people think this means that we're heading toward a world where aging is resolved and we have to deal with big questions like immortality. But for better or worse, we are still very far from place where a scenario like this is plausible, even though the science is accelerating really fast. And it's quite fascinating. That said, the mere idea of being able to eliminate the suffering involved in biological aging today does steer the imagination and raises philosophical questions about life and death that I think most of us have very strong feelings about. So for that, I have with me today author and philosopher Patrick Linden, who will share his view on death and on why we might want to reevaluate our relationship to it, whether we can do something about it or not. Anyway, I hope you enjoy this one and let's get to it. How do people usually react when you say that you wrote a book about death? Many of them will immediately say something that belongs to the wise view that I describe in the book. Namely, they will say something along the lines that, well, people are afraid to talk about death and but death is really important and it gives meaning to life or something along those lines. And it's good to talk about it because we need to learn to accept it. So most of them don't quite understand what I'm doing in this book. Right. Right. Interesting. I feel that, too, that that's the common maybe common starting point is usually that we need to talk about it more. But most people, when they say that, they mean accept it and others think maybe more boldly about it. So why? Why do you feel it's important to even deal with it? If I mean, right now, you and I know that the science is it's not feasible. It's not even close. Right. To argue with a biological fact of death. So why is a philosophy fair? Do you take the time to actually work on that? What is the value in talking about it if it's not even necessarily possible? Well, as a philosopher, you try to find out the truth of the matter no matter what. And you don't. You're not supposed to care about conventional thinking or conventional attitudes, and you're not supposed to care also about what the outcome of knowing the truth is. So I just got very provoked by the fact that people are always trying to come up with excuses on behalf of death. And I thought that was a lie or an untruth or maybe comforting truth, but not the truth. And so that was enough for me. I was I was triggered by what I saw as an untruth. And the untruth is that death is good and acceptable and the foundation of meaning and so on. All those things, all those things, I think we just say to cope with the fact that death is terrible if death is the end. So even if you could travel to the future and you know that humans will never solve this problem, you still feel it is important to recognize that as opposed to how we've been conditioned to see it, it's not a positive or an act like it's not a desirable thing. It is still important to recognize that it's a bad thing as you see it. Well, there's a certain dignity in wanting to believe what's true, and that would remain even if we can't do anything about it. You can think of living under a dictatorship and you can say, well, we're never going to change this dictatorship. So let's just love the dictator, love Big brother. Right. But we think that something tragic in 1984 and ending, you know, in some sense, he suggested now he loves Big Brother, Right. Maybe maybe it's going to be easier for him as he goes forward. But we still think that something is lost. And so therefore, I think there's a value in in holding on to the fact that the limits that we have aging and death are unacceptable for a human being. So I would love to get into our little game of going through some of the responses. You probably hear a lot when you talk to people about this topic. People have there are a lot of concern that come up. Moral concerns, also practical concerns when it comes to the idea of possibly avoiding death in the future. One of the main ones is that people say that it's self-serving, egotistical and vain. But what do you say to that? First of all, I think definitely that survival is a self-interest, but I don't think that it's an illegitimate self-interest. I think it's a very reasonable interest to have wanting to survive. And I think that the U.N. Declaration of Rights, the first right, is the right to life. And also the US Constitution recognize that people have a completely reasonable, legitimate interest in personal survival. So, yes, it's selfish, interested, but it's not selfish or egoistic in any way. Secondly, everyone who works in this field wants everyone who want it to have use in life. And for me personally, I'm thinking more right now about my parents survival. It's important that we speed up this science so that they can benefit from it. But it could very well be that the people who benefit the most from my work and other people's work in this field are the coming generations. And I think we would let them down terribly if we do nothing. We are condemning billions of people to unnecessary aging, suffering, loss and death by our passivity. So I would find it selfish not to do something about the brevity of life. I think linked to that comes the concern that, you know, this sounds very
Load full transcript
first world like, we don't want to. We have such great lives and we feel sorry for ourselves that we actually mortal at the end of the day. While there is starvation, there is malaria there. People are fighting for their lives and the world has, some would say, more urgent causes. And it's just not justified morally to work on helping already privileged people live even longer or healthier when other people are barely even living their short lives. I think that objection comes from a good place. Of course, you have limited resources and you need to spend them where you can relieve the most suffering. That's a quite moral premise, and I like that. But I think it's built on a faulty understanding of the world mostly. So even in, let's say, the poorer one third of the world, the most common cause of disease and death is aging. That is even in the poorest one third of the world. It's an aging that is the big problem. Secondly, age related diseases are causing about 80% in developing countries of their health expenditures. So it's incredibly expensive to have people aging and getting sick. And so we would save an enormous amount of resources by slowing aging that could then be spent on all the other priorities. But I don't think there is a kind of trade off here. We can both cure malaria and do aging research. I mean, if you want to look at priorities, you should look look elsewhere. I mean, you should look at how much money is spent on war. For example, you have the Afghanistan adventure that costs $2 trillion that could probably have been spent better taking care of of poverty and basic diseases and so on. Now, another thing is that aging makes us more vulnerable. So even if you take viral disease, you're much more likely to suffer and die from them if you're older. So aging and stopping aging really is the key here. And what would you say about if we just keep living longer and fewer people die? How? I mean, the planet is limited, but there will also be a scarcity issue of just not enough resources for everyone. Yeah, the overpopulation argument in one version or another have been us with us for thousands of years. It's it's a mentioned in Gilgamesh in one way and like 2000 before Christ or even earlier than that and it's mentioned in Lucretius 100 B.C. and this was in a time when there were about 100 million people on the planet in total. So it's just a very natural worry to have it mostly associated with Malthus, of course, who argued that the problem is that population always increases exponentially, but resources only increase linearly. So that will be necessarily always. As soon as we get ahead of the advanced, we'll be consumed by having too many mouths to feed right? That's a motivation trap right now. When Malthus hypothesized this that there were about a billion people on the planet, and now we have 8 billion people on the planet at the same time, never, ever have each person had as many calories to consume. So we're going in completely the other direction. We are more people and we have more resources. And this is only the beginning. Of course we are always developing more efficient ways to take care of what we already have and produce more as well. And this will continue. So it's it's based on a faulty view of resources as something completely fixed resources all relative to technology. To a large extent, you can just think about energy, for example, how much more efficiently we produce stuff than burning wood. Just a few hundred years ago, that was the only way, basically, or having slaves or any other really, really bad way of producing energy. So that's one way of answering it. Another way answer is to look at the the states state of countries that have a very aged population. Usually these countries also have no growth or they have negative growth, they actually shrinking. So if you look at Japan, for example, Japan stands to lose half the population this century. At the same time, they have one of the oldest populations. So it looks like how long we live, it doesn't really matter much to population growth at all. So it's about fertility and not mortality. So it's just an objection that it's incredibly popular, but it really is incredibly weak as well. Of course, people would say, well, what if we cure aging completely? So if we cure aging completely, then we may live to 1000 or maybe 2000. That means sooner or later we'll have an accident, unfortunately. But we can maybe we'll have an average life expectancy of a thousand, like in the Old Testament or something like that. And then they say that would be a problem. And yeah, also, if we don't have any wars and no, no calamities, natural kind and so on, perhaps. And also if we continue to have a lot of children and so on. Yes. But we also have a thousand years to adapt to the new condition. We also have ways of dealing with this. I mean, we are an adaptable species and that is who we are. So it's almost like like these these objections are, first of all, assuming no growth in efficiency in any way and assuming that we're not rational. So we can't adapt our behavior to the new conditions. It's like they think we are like rabbits and or something like that. And we just have to, you know, go into this inevitable overpopulation and I mean, overpopulation not right. That is when you have more people than resources. And it doesn't look like we're heading that way. I mean, the U.N. says, well, we're going to to around ten, nine, 8 billion people on this planet. So I don't see this as a a big worry. Yes. And you mentioned fertility. And I've been wondering about it because, yes, we see that as lifespan extends in certain countries, it seems the motivation for having kids decreases, which, by the way, also is associated in society with being selfish. And how do you explain the connection between the two? Why in societies where people live longer? Why doesn't motivation for having kids early decline are both. Caused by the same
thing? And you can call it modernity. It's simply the modern society that creates both of these. They both create longevity and decreasing fertility. So one reason is that we have an equal rights for men and women to join the workforce. And so many women prioritize education and work over having big families, for example. That's one of the reasons. Another is that we have more children surviving so we don't have to have spares, so, so to speak. There is a decline in religion and there's a positive correlation between religion and having children. We have urbanization, that is, people move into the cities and the space in the cities is not as as generous as in the countryside. That is, it's hard to have a family of eight or 12 kids if you live in a two or two room apartment. And it's very hard if you live in a in a in a big city to have an apartment that's, you know, five, six, seven rooms, that would be very, very expensive. Right. So all of these things conspire to having fewer children. And so it's not really that longevity is causing this. It's just longevity is another sign of modernism. Modernism has to do with science and expanding rights and urbanization and all the other things I mentioned. When people say it is a just, what do you think about that? That, you know, aging is a beautiful thing and we shouldn't we should look at it as something that we need to fight. I think that's an absurd accusation. I mean, if you really didn't like older people, then you would like them to suffer from aging and and then dying quickly. I mean, that's seems to be the more logical view. I mean, we are exactly the opposite. We want the old people to stay around longer and in better shape. I mean, what can be less ageism? That if I may make a comparison, it's a little bit like if you say, well, I'm trying to fight diabetes, and then somebody would complain. Does that mean you're against people with diabetes? It's like, that's not it. It's because, you know, I want people with diabetes to live healthy and long life. And that's what we want. Footfall people. I mean, all people are great and they have you know, they can be happy. And I hope to get there myself and and so on. But they have a problem. They are aging and it's it's a little bit also people don't understand what aging is. I mean, not at all. They don't understand it. Aging. What it really is is something that happens on a cellular level that breaks down things. They they malfunction in various ways and they turn to pathologies that then hurts the organism. And finally, we can't resist cancer and other killer diseases. I mean, that is what aging is. Right. And they're conflating the fact that it's great to be alive and to have experience and to be 60, 70, 80, 19. But but it's despite all of these horrific changes in your cells. Right. They don't contribute. They don't contribute anything. The quality of your life. I mean, the proof that we should live longer is exactly that. It is good to have lived
a long time chronologically, but that has nothing to do with the kind of biological mechanisms of damage. Right. Damaged at least a pathology that leads to suffering and death. Right. So it's just a it's a under-explored area. People don't distinguish between biological aging, that is those mechanisms that breaks us down and chronological aging, the fact that it's a good thing to be alive. I agree. I also think it's there's this reductionism that happens. And maybe because of that, it's so important to discuss definitions before going into any discussion, because what does aging even mean? So different people have completely different ideas. And as you say, if, if, if aging can be seen as a biological process, but also there is the chronological aspect, it is helpful to separate the two and emphasize that, of course, it is not about being against people who have lived a long time, but it is about the what, what what happens to the body, the damage that a body inflicts on itself over time, and how we can help the people. These people suffer less and suffer less of the consequences of having an older body. You're completely right there. And it's it's surprising like you hear this objection from very intelligent people. I'm curious before we move on, but what really when you speak to people, you really appreciate intellectually what is usually the main argument that you hear from those people? I mean, I like the idea they have that there are other priorities in the world. I can see where they're coming from there. But as I explained, it's not a good objection. And the other one is when people say that if we changed this, we would no longer be human as we're used to being human, that it looks like it's something good, but we are kind of putting our hands in, in changing things that may actually destroy our essence as humans or something like that. So, you know, sensitive people who make that point that they say, well, you know, to be human is to have this life span and to go through these stages and to also be weak and vulnerable at the end of life and and also to have your priorities and your possibilities and so on, narrow down at the end and all of that is part of the human experience and it's all kind of beautiful and so on, right? Yeah. I mean, what I think at the end of the day though, is that even if you could find some positive things about falling apart, which aging is, it's not worth these good things. So, so the cost. Right? Completely. And a million fold outweighs the benefits. If you could find some benefit with being like decrepit, you might say, well, it means that I don't have to try anymore. People say this kind of relief, they don't have to try anymore because there's no point. So they can just relax and enjoy the weather or, you know, sit in the park or, you know, they're kind of liberated from the pressure of having to perform or or kind of, you know, people in our age, we, you know, we are chasing our dreams and it's a bit stressful and. It is like that. But I can see I can feel the difference, you know, as as as the years go by, I feel I feel the door is starting to closed. You know, I understand. I completely get what you're saying. It's almost like there's a part of you that is relieved, like, okay, I won't like, I don't know, be an Olympic champion. We know that already. So I can, like, you know, there are so many dreams you can put to sleep now so you feel less anxious about about life and about yourself. And I can see that people see something positive in it because perhaps it makes us less self centered. It's like. Yeah. Why should the world care how accomplished I am? Maybe, maybe that does. Like there is a humility that comes with growing older where you accept certain things and you're really less. Yes, there's less hubris, maybe. Do you also see a good thing in that process? Yes. So I think if you if you dig really hard and deep, you might find something positive to say about about aging that, you know, removes all hope of certain dreams to be realized and then you can relax. But, you know, that's also said at the same time. And it's not for everyone. I mean, personally, I would prefer to have the vitality to pursue my various dreams and goals and so on, rather than to, you know, just resign and sit on the sidelines and I think that, you know, Plato writes that it's a good thing to be old because, you know, you don't have all these ideas about, you know, sex and desires and so on. So you have more time to think about philosophy. But I think, like, you know, when you kind of early a middle age person that you're mellow enough, you can think about philosophy enough. And very often older people, it's not like they because they're kind of enfeebled, they start to think about philosophy. I mean, I go, You're a philosopher or you're not. And it's not like they start stop thinking about their bodies. They just start thinking about them in much, much, much, much, much more boring and sad ways. It's amazing the types of conversation. I mean, you know, this is a time where I know my my, my husband, his wife. It's like conversation with the parents or the friends of the parents. It's always about a health issue. It's extremely boring. And in a way, like it's kind of sad that this is what a big chunk of of their life has become. And but I was I was wondering because you talked about the essence and, you know, people do say even younger people I heard say that they can't imagine having motivation to do things if there is no expiration date and that living longer would be boring. It kind of loses the essence of what it is, what it is to be a human being. This game of having a beginning, an end. What what do you think about that? Can you relate to that? Well, I think it's like a meme or, you know, cultural shibboleth or it's something that they heard and that they repeat. Most of them, if they're not, you know, normally deep thinker thinkers, it's like like this
really. I mean, what do we care about doing? You know, we care about learning, for example. Okay. We like to learn things. We are curious. Is that dependent on also knowing that you don't have much time? I absolutely don't think so. I think on the contrary. But the fact that we don't have that much time makes it almost meaningless to learn something new. Things. I mean, I've had people in the classes I've taught who are like in their thirties and they say, I wanted to be a doctor, but now it's too late. And so we kind of our motivations shrink because we're living in this horrible, horrible box of time, right? So we don't know what it would be like to have much, much more time. We could have many, many more ambitions and they would be reasonable to have because we would have the time. Right. So so I see the time limit as a limiting motivation rather than a as necessary for all motivation. Now, is it necessary, as they seem to assume in this argument, to know that you have a deadline, that you're going to die rather soon in order to motivate them to be motivated to do things? Well, as I said, you have curiosity that seems to be built in, right? And you have it before you have any awareness of how short your life is or how long your life is. Right. So children, right, have no concept of how long their life is and still they're super motivated. So we know it's not necessary. I mean, that's just a complete proof animals as well. I mean, we have a drives, we have that curiosity. It's just one of them, right. Just to stick with that. And as long as we're healthy, we have curiosity and that drives us forward. The only pushback I have to that is that, you know, for kids, life is still fresh and everything is new. So of course, there are still motivation. I think what some people are saying and I think it also changes from person to person, it's a matter of personality structure. It's like my mom is still, you know, I'm going to like interesting, like learning things, going to concerts, and she's so busy. And then there are people her age who just don't want to do much. So maybe, yes, we kind of run out of steam after a while, but this makes me think that really different people are built in a different way. And maybe it is helpful to emphasize that even in a world where we don't necessarily die, the person who feels that they they're done. They can always, I think, still choose to die if they want to. Nobody is going to force them to live longer. If they if they feel they don't have any more interest in this. But what you say also reminds us that we are in some sense humoring the person who's making this objection, because in reality there will always be death. So it's really a very theoretical argument. So if it's really the case that we need death, well, we will always have this in the physical world. There will always be some ways, some way that you can die. Right? So like like even if we succeed in the practical endeavor to to stop aging, there are many other ways of dying. Death will always be around, so we will always be motivated. But I think we can make the stronger claim that you really don't like it. Like even if you fixed death so you don't have to die, you would not necessarily be bored and that's because I think that I mean, we mustn't lose sight of how absolutely outrageous a situation in this universe is. I mean, we don't know if it has a beginning or an end. We sit here. Perhaps the most fascinating thing about this universe is the human mind. And we have one or we are one. So, so, so perhaps the most amazing and miraculous thing in the universe is, is you in some sense and I'm talking about not just you, GOGLIA, but the but but everyone. And it's because people believe that they are living in a in a normal everyday and there isn't a normal everyday, really. So I think this this kind of boredom argument, this is just built on a on a mistake in this misperception. And it's an error. And I think that rather than condemning people to falling apart and dying very after a very brief time of life, we should work on attitudes. We should those who don't understand this, we should work with and try to to teach that, you know, life. This is a a wonder and the existence is a mystery and it's inexhaustible. Interesting. And that that's that's a correct view. And if you don't see it, you're mistaken. And instead of, you know, you, Amy, you know, dying, we should try to learn these things. That's interesting because I can think of people in my life that would argue with that, saying, and they're not that old, but they feel like, know I got the idea. I don't feel strongly about this life thing. It doesn't feel like all in wonder most of the time. And it's also because life is life is work, you know, even just taking care of your, like, every day, like brushing your teeth. And even if you even if in a world where we might not need to work any more like it's dealing with people, like it's it's it's a lot of it's it's there is also like it seems that suffering is built into life or let's even call it discomfort and I can definitely say there are people who who just feel that it's not it's not a desire to extend this thing unnecessarily. Yeah. So, so on the one hand, you have what we have today. The solution to to these nuisances of life is that we fall apart, get sick, experience, loss and die. And I'm suggesting a different model, and that is that we work on our minds so that we understand that it's a miracle to be alive. And it's it's fantastic. And what about because, like, sometimes I think I'm the only person in the longevity world who thinks this, but in a way, I feel like euthanasia is the goes hand in hand with longevity, with, with, with the life extension. Because what what we really I think and I'll agree on that we want to eliminate is the suffering related to aging. But if you know there are people for whom the mind doesn't turn on to the wonders of the world or the mysteries that
end this, we started just wanting to have more and more of this experience. They can just shut it down when they want you Like why do they even need to have permission? Why do they need to be very sick to say, I don't want to continue Like this is not I didn't choose this experience. I'm out. So in my head it's like in a maybe a more moral we evolved world. We can do both. We can both have legitimacy for those who want to extend life and also those who want to end their own lives when they do. Yeah, I mean, this should be the end. The escape, the possibility of escape for those who who cannot appreciate. But I think there should be culture of life. And how can you describe how this culture will be different to ours in practice? A little bit, perhaps. I mean, so so with so much time on our hands and if we get this life extension, then it will come together with other technologies as well. So we might have more opportunity, some more people will have an opportunity to have more time on their hand, more or less on the hand. And so the question will be what do we do with it? So we will have to have much more talks and thinking about ultimate goals, that is, we will have to do more philosophy. And so I hope that the future will be more philosophical, a future. And of course we will all, you know, struggle with the new condition that we hypothesizing now when we don't have aging. And so, you know, if we have a free society where people are, you know, freely exchanging the ideas on this topic, we will work force of culture, a culture that's adapted to the new circumstances. The way I see this, we have a current circumstance and people have adapted really, really well to it that they've learned to construct a narrative that says it's it's it's a long life to live to 80 or 90, 100. It's completely sufficient. It can do any anything that you need to do. And then it's a great thing to die because it's a long rest. It's something of that sort, you know, because it's it's like sleeping or you go to heaven or something. So we've been incredibly good at adapting to a terrible situation and they make it, you know, quite good for most people who believe this. So I think it would be easier for us to adapt to a society where we have, we are so healthy and youthful for so long. You know what, what what a problem, right? How are we going to adapt to that? You know? we don't die soon, you know. How are we going to adapt to that? Well, I say it's probably easier than what we done. I mean, the kind of edifice of ideas that I'm trying to tear down here in my book, The Wise View, as I call it, namely the the cope, the coping with the human condition, which is, I think, an inhuman condition. I mean, it is a punishment if you read the Old Testament, right. We do live such in such brevity as a punishment. And you mentioned, you know, how we continue being young and vibrant biologically. So I think that's an important maybe point to clarify that in a world where we have we have a physical aging under control, as they say, it's not that we will extend years of frailty in, but we will continue aging chronologically and bodies that are biologically young. And I think that that, too, can contribute to your sense of well-being just because you feel better mentally and physically. That's also a very common misunderstanding that people think about life extension as something of what they've seen in hospital with old relatives and so on, when they, you know, really, really enfeebled and suffering and they're trying to extend it and they can't let go. Right. That's not what we're talking about at all. We're talking about, would you say, youth span or are we talking about health span? I mean, because in practice, the only way we can I mean, our paradigm is to go to the heart of the matter and it's preventative because it's trying to slow down aging. And if we do that, then we will be more youthful and robust and healthy and so on for longer. It's the old paradigm of trying to attack each particular disease as they arise, which is react of that is not going to give us what we want. That is the health span. So it's very, very important to do this, this this shift. Some people might say, well, you just this is wishful thinking, but it's not wishful thinking because we have extended life in animal species of various forms. Right. And when we have, we also seen that they're healthier longer. But but it's a it's an old myth as well. I mean, the Greeks feared this. You know, if you wish for a long life, you may get it, but you may also age at the same time and not be able to enjoy it. The myth of tetanus. Just in terms of societal perception, why not just deal with aging in the context of age related diseases and frailty? And I think this is something that everybody can get on board with. Nobody likes to see people in nursing homes. So as you say, there is a paradigm shift happening in medicine or right now it's not like mainstream medicine yet, but it's kind of happening. So we're hopefully going in a direction where we're going to target the target physical, physical aspects of aging in order to prevent or even reverse it or deal with age related diseases, rather than attacking each each disease at a time which doesn't seem to be working. So why why even talk about death? I mean, if we do this like this very practical thing that people can understand intellectually and really okay, that's very clear. There is suffering in the world. We are trying to cure the suffering. We now have a smarter way to do it. So why even talk about death if like this and I know you talked about the importance of recognizing what you feel is true, but isn't it doesn't it make it more difficult for people to to cooperate or to understand where you could get the same result by just, you know, talking The language that people do relate to that is let's let's prevent suffering. Yeah. I mean, so I agree that it's good to lead with health because in society
there is no real taboo surrounding wanting to always be healthy. But if you say that you want to always live, that's a taboo. So you which, which is, you know, illogical in some way, you say you want to age healthily, that's fine. But to say you don't want to age, that's not fine, that's taboo. So but I mean, I am really afraid of researchers and doctors who have this idea that we should kind of manage aging. And the important thing is to age healthily. You know, even if, you know, we die early like 80, 90, 100, that doesn't matter as long as we kind of healthy up to death or something like that. I think it's much it's it's very, very dangerous because we also need to recognize that the horrific tragedy of an individual human being dying and we need to get rid of this taboo against expressing a wish to live longer than a natural lifespan and so on. I mean, our ambitions need to be much higher than simply manage our decline and try to be relatively healthy. So so so on the one hand, I completely agree with you. The way to sell longevity is to emphasize life quality for sure. But when you look at the research priorities and so on, we mustn't settle. We mustn't settle for managing aging, which is a decline, managed decline. We need to go and be much more ambitious. And also, you know what I think personally, I think that that health is is a great value, but it's sometimes overvalued. So I've had a personal experience of this of my dad, who's 87, had pneumonia on both sides a year ago, and he was at the hospital. And the doctors basically said, you know, he only had days left and basically wanted him to kind of focus on on on dying rather than living. And, of course, we wouldn't have nothing of that. And we we we just, you know, did all we could and he did all he could to get through this and he didn't get through it. And, you know, we celebrate Christmas with us. He saw his new grandson just a couple of months ago and he said, what a great day. I had just you know, I was there now for Easter and visiting them. And and I mean, he had fantastic days. He had he's had a stroke. His mind is fine, but he can't move around very much. He's quite tired. He's, you know, in some sense not a very good state at all. I mean, he you know, he can walk a little and so on, but he loves life. He wants to live. We all love him and we want him to to live. And when you think about that, then, you know, that's my own kind of so frightened by doctors and researchers in particular who have this kind of easygoing view of death. They just kind of, you know, when you're not healthy enough, then death is it's not a big deal. Right. And that's I mean, of course, I think doctors, because they see it's often they bit desensitized and and I mean, how how how are they going to deal with it if they don't have this kind of approach as persons? I mean, as a doctor, can you really fathom the immensity, the enormity of of an individual ceasing to exist? I mean, that might be too much, right? So doctors are you know, like dentists are a little bit desensitized to people's pain. Probably so. So yeah. So this is a long way of explaining why why I think that you also need to be against death. I mean, does it make sense? Yes. It's it's just it's a very unusual position. Really interesting. I'm thinking about my dad, who spent six years in a nursing home. And I'm sure that I'm not sure, but he was in a state where really I couldn't see other than from time to time maybe enjoying a meal. Hardly. His life was completely void of of I don't know if I can say meaning, but he was he was suffering more that and then benefiting from this thing. And you know, the thought was yes when when time comes, it's probably like we won't be happy, but it's probably better for him. So I understand that on the level of on a level of essence, the idea of losing, losing a life and I would want to hear you more talk more about why it why it is so tragic, because it happens every day and people don't think it's tragic. But I can accept that argument in a more theoretical realm. But when it comes to an individual who is suffering, is it to them tragic to die rather than live in suffering? So first of all, I do believe that there are cases where life has so little value that to the person who lives right, that that death is not a much worse or even a better right. So death is terrible, but sometimes some things are more terrible than death, right? So there are cases where death is not good, but it's the least terrible thing. So you can compare it with amputating your leg. It's not good, but if it's to save the whole body, then it's better than the alternative. So death is like that, right? It's an amputation that sometimes is warranted and but still terrible, right? Just like losing a leg is terrible. If you have diabetes and have to amputate, it's terrible. But something else was more terrible. And so. Yeah. So yeah. So that's true. So I don't think we disagree there. I enjoy saying that sometimes and there is a tendency perhaps to overvalue health, to think that a life that's not, you know, fully healthy is not worth living. I mean, that's something I saw in my students a lot, right? So they said I asked, why would you want to be the you know, why wouldn't you want to be 85? And someone said, well, because I don't want to be in a wheelchair. And I said, you know, did you know there are people who live their whole life in a wheelchair, you know, And some of them might have, you know, comparable life quality to yours, Right? So those people talk about ableism, right? So this is this so this is this is something that's more in the arrow of ages and abilities and and so on that people think it's better to die because they have such a negative view of being disabled. This is so interesting because I feel like you're departing here from a lot of the crowd in the longevity community that is a very I can say it people is necessarily, but you know very much about
biohacking and like almost like a health fixation that really. Yes. This this belief that life life, your quality of life definitely depends on being the best, the best condition you can. You can you can be. I feel it's really refreshing and interesting to think about it, that it doesn't have to be like you don't have to be in a perfect medical state for your life to still be worthwhile. It sounds so obvious saying it, but in the context of the conversations about longevity and biohacking, yeah, I think people sometimes miss that. Yeah. I mean, not not not being able to to, to work properly and only being able to, you know, play the piano with one of his hands and so on. He had, you know, a better day than a lot of young people with all their faculties intact. He has often better days than they have. Right. Talking to talking about my dad, despite. So of course, I'm not against the biohackers and the scientists trying to make us as healthy as possible. As long as you don't think that perfect health is a prerequisite for enjoying life or wanting to live or having a value in your life. Yes. And there is one last piece. I mean, there are a few more things we won't be able to cover today, But one of the biggest, biggest concerns that come up it comes up is with inequality. If we have better technology to help us to live healthier and longer and possibly much longer, what does it mean in terms of wouldn't it really increase inequality, creating a class system where there are people who can afford it and then there are people who just suffer maybe even more from all these diseases and the consequences of aging. I think the inequality argument is quite weak, and I don't think there are any good reasons for thinking that a longevity treatment must be so expensive that it's only for the very rich or something like that. I mean, what is it that make would make a drug, for example, expensive? It's it's the research and development, right divided by potential uses number of potential users. So so if you if you have a drug against aging or something that could slow down aging how many users do you have potentially. Well you have 9 billion users or 8 billion users potentially. So it would be incredibly strange if we couldn't recuperate the research and development very quickly. Right. So there's absolutely no reason to think that it would have to be so, so expensive. Right. So, I mean, especially if we're just talking about drugs, right? I mean, there is an incredible incentive, right, to socialize, for example, something like this, especially if you look at, you know, in any modern state, really, but in particular, of course, states like like Japan and Sweden and Germany and and perhaps even, you know, Canada and so on, it would be an incredible social investment that would pay off incredibly much. And so, yeah, I mean, it's very odd when this this idea comes from. But it must be I mean, of course, any any kind of invention will first have its effect in a certain place among certain people like a cell phone. But and it's disseminated, right. I mean the fact that everyone couldn't immediately get a heart transplant, that was not a reason for not trying to develop heart transplants. I mean, it's just it's incredibly irrational, this objection. Do you know a rough number of how much say the US is spending on, you know, the consequences of AIDS related diseases yearly. ALS, Alzheimer's alone costs the United States 30 billion a year or so. So if you take the expenditures on AIDS related diseases and together it's an enormous amount of money. So 80% of health care goes to age related issues, right? So the savings are enormous. And so the aging scientist, Sinclair, David Sinclair and two economists, Scott and Ellison from from England, calculated that society in America would save 38 trillion by slowing aging with one year. So that, of course, would then be able to be spent on a lot of other things that we need in the world. I mean, there is another thing, too. I mean, that people don't think that much about them. That is during Corona, the average age of people who died in Corona was around 80, in America was slightly below 80. And in Sweden, for example, it was above 80. And the deaths from it happened. 90% of deaths happen for people who are over 50. Right. So even a kind of viral thing is something that we wouldn't have the same kind of problem with if people weren't so aged. Well, Patrick was a pleasure is always seeing. You until next time. God, it's always a great pleasure talking to you.