ကူးယူချက် 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.960 --> 00:00:05.870
Tonight, two men in police uniforms arrive at a Boston museum.
2
00:00:06.750 --> 00:00:12.849
It's March 18th, 1999. A guard lets them inside. By morning,
3
00:00:12.849 --> 00:00:17.769
13 works of art are gone. The uniforms help them
4
00:00:17.870 --> 00:00:23.750
gain entry. The men wearing them were thieves. That uneasy
5
00:00:23.879 --> 00:00:28.859
distance between appearance and intention runs through the seven stories
6
00:00:29.339 --> 00:00:34.829
we're sharing tonight. In Circleville, anonymous letters turn private lives
7
00:00:34.890 --> 00:00:39.390
into public accusations. On a New York street, an attack
8
00:00:39.530 --> 00:00:45.189
on Dan Rather leaves behind a question stranger than any explanation.
9
00:00:45.869 --> 00:00:50.390
In France, Terry Tilley uses an elaborate conspiracy to draw
10
00:00:50.490 --> 00:00:56.030
a family into his control. For Marty Markowitz, the person
11
00:00:56.090 --> 00:01:00.789
entrusted with helping him gradually takes over his entire life
12
00:01:01.380 --> 00:01:06.400
For Brian Barrett, deception unfolding through online identities ends in
13
00:01:06.439 --> 00:01:10.879
a murder he did nothing to deserve. And in California,
14
00:01:11.280 --> 00:01:16.829
Dorothy Jane Scott disappears while an unidentified voice continues to
15
00:01:16.890 --> 00:01:21.590
intrude on her family's search for answers. As the November
16
00:01:21.750 --> 00:01:26.689
evening settles outside, we return to the recorded accounts behind
17
00:01:26.750 --> 00:01:32.640
these cases. Some lead to convictions... others leave crucial questions open.
18
00:01:33.459 --> 00:01:37.680
We'll examine what happened, what can be verified, and why
19
00:01:37.760 --> 00:01:42.739
these encounters still trouble us. Just how much danger can
20
00:01:42.819 --> 00:01:48.269
hide behind an ordinary introduction? We're telling that story here tonight,
21
00:01:48.829 --> 00:01:52.269
and make sure you're subscribed for brand new terrifying and
22
00:01:52.349 --> 00:01:58.349
true stories every single Monday. Now let's begin with the
23
00:01:58.450 --> 00:02:06.090
Circleville Letters. Circleville, Ohio was a typical small American town
24
00:02:06.930 --> 00:02:11.770
when letters began to arrive, revealing the locals' dark secrets
25
00:02:12.289 --> 00:02:18.650
through the mail. The Circleville letters are a result of divorce, murder,
26
00:02:19.289 --> 00:02:27.729
attempted murder, false imprisonment, police cover-ups, and overall, one big mystery.
27
00:02:29.219 --> 00:02:32.759
No one has known the identities of the Circleville letter
28
00:02:32.800 --> 00:02:42.240
writer since 1976. Circleville, Ohio, located approximately 25 miles south
29
00:02:42.659 --> 00:02:48.610
of the state's capital, Columbus, is home to approximately 14,000 people,
30
00:02:49.110 --> 00:02:54.250
Ohio Christian University, and is best known for the Circleville
31
00:02:54.310 --> 00:03:00.139
Pumpkin Show, which has been held every year since 1903.
32
00:03:00.139 --> 00:03:04.599
No one ever suspected such a small town to be
33
00:03:04.740 --> 00:03:10.300
full of so many secrets. Mary Gillespie, the local school
34
00:03:10.360 --> 00:03:15.120
bus driver, received a postmarked letter from Columbus with no
35
00:03:15.199 --> 00:03:20.659
return address in the summer of 1976. The letter accused
36
00:03:20.740 --> 00:03:25.919
Mary of having an affair with Gordon Massey, the school superintendent,
37
00:03:26.780 --> 00:03:31.469
which she denied. The writer informed Mary that he or
38
00:03:31.590 --> 00:03:35.250
she had been watching her home, as well as her
39
00:03:35.349 --> 00:03:39.969
husband and children, for some time and demanded that she
40
00:03:40.229 --> 00:03:44.210
end the affair. According to the letter, it said, Ron
41
00:03:45.090 --> 00:04:00.770
Gillespie also received a letter saying Mary was in danger
42
00:04:01.110 --> 00:04:04.909
if he did not stop the affair. According to the letter,
43
00:04:04.930 --> 00:04:09.009
The letters were revealed to Mary and Ron Gillespie's close
44
00:04:09.289 --> 00:04:33.220
family members. They informed Karen, Ron's sister, her husband, Paul Fresher,
45
00:04:33.660 --> 00:04:37.800
and Paul's sister. Paul worked at a local factory and
46
00:04:37.860 --> 00:04:41.899
was once a prison guard who survived a 30-hour hostage
47
00:04:41.959 --> 00:04:47.889
situation at the Ohio State Penitentiary in 1968. The five
48
00:04:47.949 --> 00:04:51.889
got together to talk about the suspects. Mary claimed that
49
00:04:51.930 --> 00:04:55.829
it was David Longberry, a bus driver, who was romantically
50
00:04:55.889 --> 00:04:59.160
interested in her, and she was not. and that David
51
00:04:59.220 --> 00:05:03.500
became resentful of her. They decided that Paul Fresher would
52
00:05:03.560 --> 00:05:06.100
write David a letter in which he stated that he
53
00:05:06.139 --> 00:05:10.860
was aware that David was threatening the Gillespies. And then
54
00:05:11.560 --> 00:05:19.750
the letters stopped. August 19, 1977. Ron Gillespie received a
55
00:05:19.829 --> 00:05:23.129
phone call that enraged him. No one knows what the
56
00:05:23.170 --> 00:05:26.300
call was about. he took out his gun and informed
57
00:05:26.360 --> 00:05:28.759
his children that he was going to speak with the
58
00:05:28.819 --> 00:05:34.139
person who was sending the letters. Ron Gillespie was discovered
59
00:05:34.220 --> 00:05:39.519
dead after crashing his truck into a tree. A bullet
60
00:05:39.560 --> 00:05:43.040
was missing from his gun, indicating that he fired it
61
00:05:43.600 --> 00:05:47.639
before he died. There was no bullet casing found at
62
00:05:47.680 --> 00:05:52.879
the scene, and Ron's blood alcohol content was. 16, which
63
00:05:52.920 --> 00:05:56.639
was twice the legal limit. His friends and family were
64
00:05:56.699 --> 00:05:59.769
shocked to learn of
Load full transcript
his death because Ron was not
65
00:05:59.810 --> 00:06:04.290
a heavy drinker. So many people began to speculate that
66
00:06:04.329 --> 00:06:08.439
his death was a police cover-up, that something more serious
67
00:06:08.509 --> 00:06:13.079
occurred and they simply ruled it as drunk driving. Sheriff
68
00:06:13.120 --> 00:06:17.379
Radcliffe stated that he initially suspected foul play, but after
69
00:06:17.420 --> 00:06:20.750
the suspects, who were not identified, passed a polygraph test,
70
00:06:21.290 --> 00:06:24.589
they concluded Ron died as a result of a drunk
71
00:06:24.610 --> 00:06:29.839
driving accident. It should be mentioned polygraph tests are notoriously
72
00:06:29.920 --> 00:06:33.920
inconsistent and inaccurate and are not admissible in a court
73
00:06:33.939 --> 00:06:40.060
of law. Following Ron's death, letters began to arrive, this
74
00:06:40.189 --> 00:06:44.009
time claiming that Sheriff Radcliffe was involved in some sort
75
00:06:44.029 --> 00:06:47.790
of cover-up with Ron's death and that Mary and Gordon
76
00:06:47.829 --> 00:06:52.290
Massey were to blame. Mary admitted to having an affair
77
00:06:52.329 --> 00:06:56.060
with George Massey after Ron's death, but she claimed it
78
00:06:56.100 --> 00:07:03.500
began after the letters began to arrive. On February 7, 1983,
79
00:07:03.500 --> 00:07:06.980
Mary was driving her usual bus route when she noticed
80
00:07:07.120 --> 00:07:11.139
signs posted along the road. According to the signs, they
81
00:07:11.220 --> 00:07:16.990
accused George Massey of raping the Gillespie's 12-year-old daughter. Mary
82
00:07:17.110 --> 00:07:21.149
stopped the bus and tore down the sign, when she
83
00:07:21.189 --> 00:07:26.850
was almost killed. The sign was a booby trap, set
84
00:07:26.910 --> 00:07:31.180
up to shoot whoever took it down. The serial numbers
85
00:07:31.259 --> 00:07:34.480
on the firearm were scratched off, but the lab was
86
00:07:34.579 --> 00:07:37.740
able to read them, and the gun was registered to
87
00:07:37.779 --> 00:07:43.949
Mary's brother-in-law, Paul Fresher. Paul denied having anything to do
88
00:07:44.009 --> 00:07:47.829
with the trap, saying, quote, I admitted the gun was mine,
89
00:07:48.149 --> 00:07:50.439
but I hadn't seen it for a long time. I
90
00:07:50.480 --> 00:07:52.620
had no reason to check up on it or anything,
91
00:07:53.000 --> 00:07:54.800
and I don't know when it had come up missing.
92
00:07:55.519 --> 00:07:57.459
I really don't know what happened to it, and I
93
00:07:57.519 --> 00:08:00.420
told them that, and that's the truth, and that's how
94
00:08:00.480 --> 00:08:04.459
it was. Paul claimed the gun had been stolen, but
95
00:08:04.560 --> 00:08:08.060
never reported it stolen. He was then asked to provide
96
00:08:08.139 --> 00:08:13.060
handwriting samples for comparison to the Circleville letters. The test
97
00:08:13.120 --> 00:08:16.980
was not standard. Instead, Paul copied one of the letters
98
00:08:17.060 --> 00:08:20.069
rather than writing a sentence in his own handwriting. and
99
00:08:20.129 --> 00:08:24.730
comparing the two. After that, Paul Fresher was arrested and
100
00:08:24.790 --> 00:08:31.189
charged with attempted murder. His trial began on October 24, 1983,
101
00:08:31.189 --> 00:08:34.029
and while he was never charged with writing the letters,
102
00:08:34.600 --> 00:08:38.860
they were brought up in court. A handwriting expert testified
103
00:08:38.899 --> 00:08:44.220
that Paul was indeed the Circleville letter writer. Mary testified
104
00:08:44.500 --> 00:08:47.539
that she suspected Paul was the writer because his wife
105
00:08:47.639 --> 00:08:52.190
Karen came to her, with the same suspicions. Paul's boss
106
00:08:52.309 --> 00:08:56.019
also testified that when the booby trap was discovered, he
107
00:08:56.080 --> 00:08:59.320
was not at work that day. For the majority of
108
00:08:59.379 --> 00:09:03.620
that day, Paul had a solid alibi, but he never
109
00:09:03.679 --> 00:09:06.679
took the stand in his own defense, which would only
110
00:09:06.759 --> 00:09:10.700
hurt him in the end. Paul was found guilty of
111
00:09:10.759 --> 00:09:13.820
attempted murder and sentenced to 7 to 25 years in prison.
112
00:09:16.600 --> 00:09:19.700
One can only hope that now that Paul is incarcerated,
113
00:09:19.779 --> 00:09:24.860
the letters will stop. The mystery in Circleville, however, was
114
00:09:24.940 --> 00:09:30.440
far from over. The letters still kept arriving. Paul received
115
00:09:30.480 --> 00:09:34.250
a letter from the Circleville writer stating, Now when are
116
00:09:34.259 --> 00:09:36.110
you going to believe you aren't going to get out
117
00:09:36.129 --> 00:09:39.309
of there? I told you two years ago, when we
118
00:09:39.370 --> 00:09:42.950
set them up, they stay set up. Don't you listen
119
00:09:42.990 --> 00:09:47.289
at all? Paul was in solitary confinement, where he had
120
00:09:47.389 --> 00:09:52.529
no access to anything, but the letters kept coming. Even
121
00:09:52.620 --> 00:09:56.799
though Paul was in prison in Lima, Ohio, and the
122
00:09:56.860 --> 00:10:02.200
letters were postmarked from Columbus. The police searched Paul's cell
123
00:10:02.259 --> 00:10:05.440
and discovered nothing that would indicate he wrote the letters.
124
00:10:06.340 --> 00:10:10.490
The secrets in the new letters were far worse. According
125
00:10:10.529 --> 00:10:13.909
to one letter, Roger Klein, the prosecutor in Paul's trial,
126
00:10:14.330 --> 00:10:18.809
murdered a pregnant schoolteacher. The writer stated that unless Roger
127
00:10:18.850 --> 00:10:21.690
Klein admitted to killing the woman and her unborn child,
128
00:10:22.149 --> 00:10:24.870
they would dig up the victim's graves and mail the
129
00:10:24.909 --> 00:10:30.090
bones to the police. Paul was denied parole in 1990
130
00:10:30.090 --> 00:10:33.750
after serving seven years in prison because the board
believed
131
00:10:33.809 --> 00:10:37.870
he was still the Circleville letter writer. Paul Fresher was
132
00:10:37.929 --> 00:10:42.629
released on parole in May 1994 after serving 10 years
133
00:10:42.710 --> 00:10:45.429
in prison and claiming he had nothing to do with
134
00:10:45.490 --> 00:10:50.090
the letters. or the attempted murder. The enigma that is
135
00:10:50.169 --> 00:10:55.029
the Circleville letters was featured on an episode of Unsolved Mysteries,
136
00:10:55.840 --> 00:10:59.080
after which they received a letter that read, The episode
137
00:10:59.620 --> 00:11:16.350
was still aired on November 11, 1994. the sheriff and
138
00:11:16.389 --> 00:11:20.029
Mary Gillespie declined to be interviewed for the story. And
139
00:11:20.090 --> 00:11:26.470
that is the last of the Circleville Rider. According to rumors,
140
00:11:26.970 --> 00:11:30.919
Roger Klein, the prosecutor in Paul's trial, was having an
141
00:11:30.960 --> 00:11:33.980
affair with the schoolteacher and was the father of the
142
00:11:34.059 --> 00:11:38.759
unborn child. And her death is still a mystery. In
143
00:11:38.840 --> 00:11:43.950
December 1993, Dr. Ray Carroll said, the coroner who performed
144
00:11:44.029 --> 00:11:48.220
Ron Gillespie's autopsy, was exposed in the letter for being
145
00:11:48.299 --> 00:11:52.039
a pedophile. He was then charged with 12 counts of
146
00:11:52.120 --> 00:11:57.710
gross immorality, sex crimes, corruption of a minor, pornography, obscenity,
147
00:11:58.139 --> 00:12:03.830
and indecent exposure. David Longberry, the bus driver Mary suspected
148
00:12:03.870 --> 00:12:07.110
of being the writer, raped an 11-year-old girl in 1999,
149
00:12:07.090 --> 00:12:13.500
went on the run, and died by suicide. With so
150
00:12:13.539 --> 00:12:17.409
many secrets exposed in the small town, there are numerous
151
00:12:17.529 --> 00:12:21.870
theories as to who the Circleville writer could be. Some
152
00:12:21.970 --> 00:12:27.309
still suspect bus driver David Longberry, while others suspect Paul Freshour.
153
00:12:28.870 --> 00:12:32.190
Or Karen Fresher, who was going through a divorce and
154
00:12:32.250 --> 00:12:36.750
could use Paul's gun to frame him. Since the first
155
00:12:36.840 --> 00:12:40.000
letter was targeted at Mary and Gordon Massey to end
156
00:12:40.059 --> 00:12:44.120
their affair, some letters were signed with a W, leading
157
00:12:44.240 --> 00:12:48.460
some to suspect it was William Massey, Gordon Massey's son.
158
00:12:49.759 --> 00:12:53.379
Others thought it was Mary Gillespie, and many wondered how
159
00:12:53.480 --> 00:12:56.299
she knew where to stop the bus and pull down
160
00:12:56.360 --> 00:12:59.740
the one sign that was a booby trap, and how
161
00:12:59.820 --> 00:13:02.340
she didn't get hurt if it caught her off guard.
162
00:13:03.769 --> 00:13:06.850
She admitted to having an affair with Gordon Massey after
163
00:13:06.909 --> 00:13:11.250
her husband passed away. But some question whether she would
164
00:13:11.289 --> 00:13:15.200
have put up signs claiming her 12-year-old daughter had been raped.
165
00:13:16.480 --> 00:13:20.100
Many people still believe Paul is the writer. He still
166
00:13:20.159 --> 00:13:25.960
maintained his innocence up until his death in 2012. Nobody
167
00:13:26.019 --> 00:13:29.620
knows who the Circleville writer could be, whether it was
168
00:13:29.740 --> 00:13:34.120
one of the suspects or another resident. People are still
169
00:13:34.220 --> 00:13:38.220
curious about who wrote the letters. Was Ron's death an
170
00:13:38.379 --> 00:13:42.899
accident or a murder? And who created the booby trap?
171
00:13:43.840 --> 00:13:48.539
Many people speculated that perhaps everyone began airing out secrets
172
00:13:49.080 --> 00:13:51.840
and that there was no single person behind all of
173
00:13:51.919 --> 00:13:57.210
the letters. Since 1993, no one has heard from the
174
00:13:57.250 --> 00:14:01.389
Circleville writer and the last letter they ever sent was
175
00:14:01.429 --> 00:14:12.649
to Unsolved Mysteries. The mystery of Kenneth. What is the frequency?
176
00:14:19.889 --> 00:14:24.049
It's a pretty catchy song, right? Well, this song by
177
00:14:24.090 --> 00:14:27.960
the band R.E.M. made quite an appearance in the music
178
00:14:28.000 --> 00:14:32.919
industry upon its release on their album, Monster. Unlike most
179
00:14:33.059 --> 00:14:36.919
singles or albums produced, these lyrics have a story to them.
180
00:14:37.669 --> 00:14:43.279
a story which easily became pretty famous and infamous in
181
00:14:43.340 --> 00:14:47.950
popular culture, but was more of a once-in-a-lifetime nightmare for
182
00:14:47.970 --> 00:14:52.470
the one who went through the ordeal, Mr. Dan Rather.
183
00:14:54.090 --> 00:14:58.289
Dan Rather is a journalist, analyst, and former national nightly
184
00:14:58.350 --> 00:15:02.269
news anchor from the United States of America. When his
185
00:15:02.309 --> 00:15:07.429
reporting during Hurricane Carla in September of 1961 helped save
186
00:15:07.549 --> 00:15:11.629
hundreds of lives, Rather, who started his career in Texas,
187
00:15:12.049 --> 00:15:18.759
gained national recognition. From 2006 to 2013, Rather aired Dan
188
00:15:18.820 --> 00:15:22.700
Rather Reports, an investigative news program in the vein of
189
00:15:22.700 --> 00:15:27.860
60 Minutes, on the cable network AXIS TV, formerly known
190
00:15:27.940 --> 00:15:32.559
as HDNet. For AXIS TV, he also hosts a number
191
00:15:32.600 --> 00:15:35.840
of other programs, such as The Big Interview with Dan
192
00:15:35.899 --> 00:15:41.340
Rather and Dan Rather Presents, where he conducts in-depth interviews
193
00:15:41.399 --> 00:15:46.759
with singers and other entertainers. Dan Rather Presents offers in-depth
194
00:15:46.820 --> 00:15:50.730
reporting on a range of issues, such as adoption and
195
00:15:50.830 --> 00:15:55.409
mental health care.
While all of these achievements were milestones
196
00:15:55.490 --> 00:15:59.679
in his career, Something entirely unexpected got him to go
197
00:15:59.779 --> 00:16:04.590
viral even before the internet. So much so that his
198
00:16:04.710 --> 00:16:09.309
story became a common reference and, in many cases, a
199
00:16:09.389 --> 00:16:15.210
joke amongst the masses. On the evening of October 4th, 1986,
200
00:16:15.210 --> 00:16:18.610
CBS anchorman Dan Rather was traveling back to his apartment
201
00:16:18.929 --> 00:16:21.740
down Park Avenue in New York City at around 11 p.m.
202
00:16:23.289 --> 00:16:26.299
Two nicely dressed men were following Rather to his building
203
00:16:26.340 --> 00:16:29.519
in the dark night. When Rather finally got close to
204
00:16:29.580 --> 00:16:32.580
his building, one of the two men came closer to
205
00:16:32.620 --> 00:16:38.340
him and asked him, What is the frequency, Kenneth? Perplexed,
206
00:16:38.779 --> 00:16:41.750
Rather replied by saying that the men must have mistaken
207
00:16:41.799 --> 00:16:47.529
him for someone else. That's when the culprit started kicking
208
00:16:47.850 --> 00:16:53.929
and hitting the anchorman violently while repeatedly asking, the bizarre question.
209
00:16:54.889 --> 00:16:58.070
Rather cried for help while the men assaulted him, but
210
00:16:58.169 --> 00:17:02.610
then the building's doorman arrived to help. Naturally, the two
211
00:17:02.669 --> 00:17:07.950
assailants ran away and escaped the crime scene. Later, when
212
00:17:07.990 --> 00:17:10.750
the news broke out and Rather narrated the story to
213
00:17:10.769 --> 00:17:14.650
the media, no one wanted to believe him. The assault
214
00:17:14.710 --> 00:17:17.369
might have been believable, but the question that the culprits
215
00:17:17.410 --> 00:17:22.789
kept repeating sounded made up. It was only after the
216
00:17:22.809 --> 00:17:26.589
doorman confirmed the story that police and other media houses
217
00:17:26.990 --> 00:17:32.410
started taking things seriously. But even so, upon inquiries and notices,
218
00:17:32.869 --> 00:17:35.549
no one was found guilty and the case was left
219
00:17:35.630 --> 00:17:41.009
hanging for years. Interestingly, nothing of the sort happened again
220
00:17:41.069 --> 00:17:44.359
in the future, and it was judged as clearly not
221
00:17:44.430 --> 00:17:49.160
an assassination attempt. All the years that the case remained unsolved,
222
00:17:49.690 --> 00:17:53.430
Kenneth What Is The Frequency became a phenomena in pop culture,
223
00:17:54.150 --> 00:17:56.980
having the phrase be featured in a scene from Daniel
224
00:17:57.039 --> 00:18:00.759
Clow's graphic novel Like a Velvet Glove Cast in Iron.
225
00:18:01.500 --> 00:18:03.980
Kenneth What's The Frequency is the title of the first
226
00:18:04.039 --> 00:18:11.170
song on Game Theory's Lolita Nation album from 1987. On
227
00:18:11.190 --> 00:18:15.569
their album Monster from 1994, the band
REM included the
228
00:18:15.630 --> 00:18:19.710
song What's The Frequency, Kenneth? But that's not all. During
229
00:18:19.750 --> 00:18:22.289
a sound check for a performance at New York City's
230
00:18:22.349 --> 00:18:27.890
Madison Square Garden, the anchorman actually performed with R.E.M. The
231
00:18:27.930 --> 00:18:31.150
performance was captured and aired the following night on The
232
00:18:31.190 --> 00:18:36.240
Late Show with David Letterman. On Wednesday, the Daily News
233
00:18:36.279 --> 00:18:39.000
broke the story of the unsolved mystery of the attack
234
00:18:39.099 --> 00:18:42.279
on Dan Rather. The person who kicked and beat Mr.
235
00:18:42.359 --> 00:18:46.259
Rather appears to be the same person who fatally shot
236
00:18:46.299 --> 00:18:52.359
an NBC stagehand outside of Rockefeller Center. in 1994, according
237
00:18:52.420 --> 00:18:57.339
to Mr. Rather and law enforcement. According to Dr. Park Dietz,
238
00:18:57.720 --> 00:19:02.279
a forensic psychiatrist who interviewed William Tager after shooting 33-year-old
239
00:19:02.359 --> 00:19:07.420
stagehand Campbell Theron Montgomery, both incidents were motivated by mistrust
240
00:19:07.779 --> 00:19:11.519
and suspicion of the media. Mr. Tager, who is currently
241
00:19:11.619 --> 00:19:15.829
serving a 12- to 25-year sentence for manslaughter, thought that
242
00:19:15.940 --> 00:19:20.930
messages were being broadcast to him directly on the evening news,
243
00:19:21.480 --> 00:19:25.420
according to Dr. Dietz, who stated this in a telephone interview.
244
00:19:26.299 --> 00:19:31.200
John Esposito, the attorney of Mr. Tager, had stated on
245
00:19:31.299 --> 00:19:35.519
record that he was not certain his client had assaulted Mr. Rather.
246
00:19:36.720 --> 00:19:40.240
The five-year statute of limitations prevented the police from looking
247
00:19:40.299 --> 00:19:43.289
into the attack on Dan Rather, even though Mr. Tager
248
00:19:43.369 --> 00:19:46.809
claimed responsibility for it when he was apprehended for the
249
00:19:46.849 --> 00:19:51.250
fatal shooting. Dr. Dietz, however, was interested in finding out
250
00:19:51.309 --> 00:19:54.509
if Mr. Tager was telling the truth regarding the assault
251
00:19:54.589 --> 00:19:57.779
on Dan Rather on the Upper East Side. So, he
252
00:19:57.839 --> 00:20:00.190
got in touch with Mr. Rather to check of his
253
00:20:00.279 --> 00:20:03.980
recollections on the crime to see if they were consistent
254
00:20:04.000 --> 00:20:07.880
with those of Mr. Tager. Both Mr. Rather and Mr.
255
00:20:07.940 --> 00:20:11.039
Tager remembered the same specifics about the building where a
256
00:20:11.079 --> 00:20:17.180
portion of the attack took place, according to Dr. Dietz. Mr.
257
00:20:17.259 --> 00:20:20.569
Rather recognized Mr. Tager as his assailant after looking at
258
00:20:20.640 --> 00:20:23.970
pictures of Mr. Tager that the Daily News had given him.
259
00:20:25.509 --> 00:20:30.430
Following the attack in 1986, Mr. Rather's detractors cited both
260
00:20:30.509 --> 00:20:33.849
the attack and a second event in which he stormed
261
00:20:33.910 --> 00:20:37.640
off the set, and cost the network valuable airtime as
262
00:20:37.779 --> 00:20:41.740
evidence that he was losing his cool. Now that the
263
00:20:41.799 --> 00:20:45.460
culprit was caught and the victim had recognized him, you
264
00:20:45.500 --> 00:20:49.049
must be thinking it's a happy ending to an odd
265
00:20:49.119 --> 00:20:54.150
pop culture story, but there's even more to it. Tager
266
00:20:54.210 --> 00:20:58.369
told a doctor that he was a time traveler from
267
00:20:58.450 --> 00:21:03.619
a parallel universe in the year 2265. giving his tale
268
00:21:03.680 --> 00:21:07.259
a bit of a science fiction twist. The man had
269
00:21:07.299 --> 00:21:09.769
the nerve to claim that he was a volunteer test
270
00:21:09.829 --> 00:21:13.769
pilot in a risky time travel project and was a
271
00:21:13.869 --> 00:21:17.809
felon in the future. He would often claim that his
272
00:21:17.910 --> 00:21:20.930
sentence would be vacated and he would be freed if
273
00:21:20.990 --> 00:21:24.470
he was successful in his mission. Of course, these are
274
00:21:24.490 --> 00:21:28.589
the crimes he had committed in the future, not in
275
00:21:28.630 --> 00:21:32.450
the present day or past now. I know, right? Time travel...
276
00:21:32.819 --> 00:21:34.579
It makes me dizzy, gives me a little bit of
277
00:21:34.619 --> 00:21:38.720
a headache, but I digress. Tager further admitted while being
278
00:21:38.779 --> 00:21:43.220
interrogated that he had attacked Dan Rather because he thought Mr.
279
00:21:43.279 --> 00:21:49.519
Rather was Kenneth Burroughs, the vice president of his imagined future.
280
00:21:50.440 --> 00:21:55.119
But we're not done here. There's still yet another thrilling subplot.
281
00:21:55.960 --> 00:21:59.869
Paul Limbert Ullman speculated about the occurrence in a column
282
00:21:59.910 --> 00:22:04.680
for Harper's Magazine in 2001. Allman had found a reoccurring
283
00:22:04.720 --> 00:22:08.940
character named Kenneth, and the phrase, what's the frequency, in
284
00:22:08.980 --> 00:22:13.900
the works of postmodern fiction author Donald Barthelm. Both Rather
285
00:22:13.960 --> 00:22:17.940
and Barthelm were young men who worked as journalists. They
286
00:22:17.980 --> 00:22:21.920
were both from Texas, Houston to be specific, and were
287
00:22:22.160 --> 00:22:25.599
the same age. Allman believed it to be plausible to
288
00:22:25.619 --> 00:22:30.809
speculate that their paths may have intersected. Furthermore, Rather is
289
00:22:30.880 --> 00:22:35.609
reminiscent of the character Lather, a pretentious editor who appears
290
00:22:35.690 --> 00:22:40.960
in one of Barthelm's books. Barthelm passed away in 1989,
291
00:22:40.960 --> 00:22:44.099
and his brother Frederick, a writer as well, has declined
292
00:22:44.140 -->
00:22:48.059
to discuss any relationship to the attack on Dan Rather.
293
00:22:49.460 --> 00:22:52.740
There was also the possibility that Rather had made up
294
00:22:52.880 --> 00:22:57.839
or misheard his attacker's statements. This was a newsreader after all,
295
00:22:58.400 --> 00:23:02.019
famous for his outrageous comparisons and descriptions of that became
296
00:23:02.099 --> 00:23:07.880
known as Ratherisms. Typical phrases include, this thing is as
297
00:23:07.980 --> 00:23:10.859
tight as the rusted lug nuts on a 55 Ford,
298
00:23:11.480 --> 00:23:15.269
and you would sooner find a tall talking broccoli stick
299
00:23:15.509 --> 00:23:20.210
to offer to mow your lawn for free. Back in 2010,
300
00:23:20.210 --> 00:23:23.630
Tager was released from the prison on good behavior, but
301
00:23:24.130 --> 00:23:26.829
he was to be monitored by parole officers and mental
302
00:23:26.849 --> 00:23:30.900
health caretakers, considering the man came up with his time
303
00:23:30.940 --> 00:23:34.000
traveler story. For the most part, it seems like a
304
00:23:34.059 --> 00:23:37.680
case of a madman creating chaos, and he somehow ended
305
00:23:37.740 --> 00:23:41.940
up targeting a media personality, and became big and bold
306
00:23:42.000 --> 00:23:47.200
in the headlines. However, many conspiracy theories counter the attack's
307
00:23:47.240 --> 00:23:51.539
circumstances and claim that Rather had done this deliberately, as
308
00:23:51.579 --> 00:23:55.980
a publicity stunt, because... In all honesty, the man did
309
00:23:56.039 --> 00:23:58.380
get quite a bit of attention from the media, and
310
00:23:58.440 --> 00:24:03.400
Tegger's absurd story just added to the narrative. All Things Considered,
311
00:24:03.519 --> 00:24:08.240
either of the parties, is a pretty good storyteller. Coming
312
00:24:08.279 --> 00:24:11.599
back to the song that made this story even more sensational,
313
00:24:12.299 --> 00:24:16.920
on September 5th, 1994, the song, which was the album's
314
00:24:16.940 --> 00:24:20.980
debut single, was made available to the public. Its highest
315
00:24:21.079 --> 00:24:25.980
positions were number two in Canada, number four in New Zealand,
316
00:24:26.059 --> 00:24:29.960
and number nine on the UK singles charts. It also
317
00:24:30.019 --> 00:24:33.809
reached number 21 on the US Billboard Hot 100. It
318
00:24:33.829 --> 00:24:36.450
spent four weeks as the number one song in Iceland.
319
00:24:37.230 --> 00:24:39.950
It was the first song to ever enter at the
320
00:24:40.009 --> 00:24:43.769
top of the Billboard Modern Rock Tracks chart. What's the
321
00:24:43.809 --> 00:24:48.490
Frequency Kenneth was included on R.E.M. 's compilation albums Part Lies,
322
00:24:48.569 --> 00:24:53.829
Part Heart, Part Truth, Part Garbage... in 2011, and In Time,
323
00:24:53.950 --> 00:24:58.410
the best of R.E.M., in 2003, with it being the
324
00:24:58.509 --> 00:25:02.630
only track from Monster to appear on either. The song
325
00:25:02.670 --> 00:25:05.450
was one of the band's most played at live performances
326
00:25:05.880 --> 00:25:09.859
and was heard at every stop on their 2008 Accelerate Tour.
327
00:25:10.579 --> 00:25:14.500
What's the Frequency, Kenneth, is a powerful song, but according
328
00:25:14.559 --> 00:25:18.450
to Cashbox's Steve Bolton, quote, It isn't as much of
329
00:25:18.490 --> 00:25:20.670
a single as it is the opening track to the
330
00:25:20.710 --> 00:25:25.950
most highly-awaited album of the autumn. That front, its resounding triumph.
331
00:25:26.490 --> 00:25:30.250
Before Michael Stipe's distinctive vocals enter the tune, the song
332
00:25:30.349 --> 00:25:33.490
actually erupts onto the airwaves with a modernized rendition of
333
00:25:33.529 --> 00:25:37.269
traditional guitar rock. The song continues on from that point
334
00:25:37.329 --> 00:25:40.269
in a variety of rock tempos without ever losing the
335
00:25:40.329 --> 00:25:48.099
enthusiasm it had before. According to Chuck Campbell of the
336
00:25:48.119 --> 00:25:52.700
Knoxville News Sentinel, the, quote, powerful but not grungy guitar
337
00:25:53.059 --> 00:25:56.660
by Buck is the focal point of the satisfying debut single.
338
00:25:58.049 --> 00:26:01.769
The song itself isn't a narration of the incident, nor
339
00:26:01.829 --> 00:26:04.450
has it attempted to solve the mystery of the case.
340
00:26:05.349 --> 00:26:09.069
Just the question, what's the frequency, Kenneth, has been used
341
00:26:09.109 --> 00:26:11.670
by the band to create some rhymes in the song
342
00:26:11.769 --> 00:26:15.779
here and there. According to Alan Jones of Music Week,
343
00:26:15.910 --> 00:26:19.380
it is, quote, the most straightforward rock song the group
344
00:26:19.400 --> 00:26:24.019
has done in years, a full-throttle oral assault, and very intense,
345
00:26:24.339 --> 00:26:28.009
with bonus live tracks this one will sell. Paul Evans
346
00:26:28.049 --> 00:26:31.890
of Rolling Stone called it REM's toughest single, and Howard
347
00:26:31.930 --> 00:26:35.690
Hampton of Spin said that it, quote, lifts its catchphrase
348
00:26:36.009 --> 00:26:39.000
from the Dadaist mugger who attacked Dan Rather a few
349
00:26:39.039 --> 00:26:43.589
years back. Who knew someone could become a milestone in
350
00:26:43.630 --> 00:26:47.869
popular culture by getting beaten up by a madman? It
351
00:26:47.930 --> 00:26:52.910
just goes to show you, truly, there is no business
352
00:26:53.009 --> 00:27:06.880
like show business. Like no business I know. The Conspiracy
353
00:27:06.980 --> 00:27:13.259
Con Man, Terry Tilley. chances are somebody has at one
354
00:27:13.339 --> 00:27:17.420
point or another conned you out of something. Whether it
355
00:27:17.460 --> 00:27:21.119
be related to money, food, fame, a romantic partner, or
356
00:27:21.180 --> 00:27:24.569
anything else you hold in any kind of positive regard,
357
00:27:25.329 --> 00:27:27.210
think back to when you were a child and a
358
00:27:27.250 --> 00:27:29.710
classmate or neighbor told you that they would give you
359
00:27:29.789 --> 00:27:32.789
something they claimed was more interesting or special for, say,
360
00:27:32.809 --> 00:27:36.150
a rare trading card or video game or even a
361
00:27:36.730 --> 00:27:40.119
toy that you possessed. You took the trade only to
362
00:27:40.140 --> 00:27:42.740
later find out that it was in fact all a
363
00:27:42.799 --> 00:27:46.029
ruse for the said friend to cheat you out of
364
00:27:46.109 --> 00:27:50.930
something you considered valuable. That, my friends, is a con.
365
00:27:51.710 --> 00:27:55.049
Cons are something done every day, all around the globe.
366
00:27:55.690 --> 00:27:58.250
Quite a few people will cite things such as holidays
367
00:27:58.329 --> 00:28:00.769
as cons, and there are those who will state that
368
00:28:00.930 --> 00:28:04.720
anything or everything a particular government does is a con.
369
00:28:05.579 --> 00:28:09.200
People who specialize in conning others are known as con artists,
370
00:28:09.640 --> 00:28:12.700
or simply as a con man. The term coming from
371
00:28:12.740 --> 00:28:17.180
the shortening of confidence to con, as it is usually
372
00:28:17.220 --> 00:28:21.180
those who exude confidence that make the best con artists.
373
00:28:22.000 --> 00:28:24.940
Our terrifying tale today is about a con man, one
374
00:28:24.980 --> 00:28:29.019
of the most notable and possibly the best. We have
375
00:28:29.059 --> 00:28:31.519
to go to France and England today just for this story,
376
00:28:31.819 --> 00:28:34.559
but it is a trip well worth taking for an
377
00:28:34.619 --> 00:28:39.859
intriguing and hypnotically diabolical scheme such as this, one that
378
00:28:39.900 --> 00:28:45.039
includes embezzlement and even torture. This is the story of
379
00:28:45.099 --> 00:28:50.420
Terry Tilly and Howie Kahn, the Davidrines family. The story
380
00:28:50.480 --> 00:28:54.799
begins in the year 2000 and with the French family Davidrines.
381
00:28:55.359 --> 00:28:58.500
The de Vedrines family is an aristocratic family that was
382
00:28:58.559 --> 00:29:04.619
established in Agencies. Guilhermet de Vedrines, who was born in 1912,
383
00:29:04.619 --> 00:29:09.799
had three children, Felipe, Jelaine, and Charles Henry de Vedrines.
384
00:29:10.519 --> 00:29:13.539
Felipe worked for an oil company. At the time of
385
00:29:13.579 --> 00:29:16.000
the event, he was in his 60s and lived with
386
00:29:16.039 --> 00:29:21.480
his wife, Brigitte Leroy-Martin. Jelaine was running a secretarial school
387
00:29:21.549 --> 00:29:24.720
in Paris. She was married to an economic journalist with
388
00:29:24.779 --> 00:29:29.920
two children. Charles Henry was an obstetrician in Bordeaux and
389
00:29:29.960 --> 00:29:33.910
married to Christine, a documentarian by profession. They lived in
390
00:29:33.950 --> 00:29:39.529
their ancestral chateau, Montflanking. As for the master conman named
391
00:29:39.569 --> 00:29:43.220
Terry Tillerson... he was born in Boise, Columbus, which is
392
00:29:43.299 --> 00:29:46.619
northwest of Paris. By all accounts, he led a normal
393
00:29:46.660 --> 00:29:50.019
life and even married a model. However, he was never
394
00:29:50.200 --> 00:29:53.319
able to live his dream of becoming a lawyer as
395
00:29:53.359 --> 00:29:57.069
he dropped out shortly after enrolling. It was Ghislaine who
396
00:29:57.119 --> 00:29:59.819
first met with Tilley. She gave him a job as
397
00:29:59.880 --> 00:30:04.119
a deputy director. Eventually, he became her right hand, and
398
00:30:04.180 --> 00:30:07.440
she introduced him to the rest of the family. She
399
00:30:07.500 --> 00:30:10.599
shared every detail about them and their property with Tilly.
400
00:30:11.440 --> 00:30:14.420
After winning the hearts of other family members, he offered
401
00:30:14.460 --> 00:30:18.910
to become their financial advisor. Tilly presented himself as a
402
00:30:18.940 --> 00:30:23.690
descendant of the Austro-Hungarian Habsburg nobility and claimed that his
403
00:30:23.769 --> 00:30:29.259
communist grandmother had salons with former socialist president François Mitterrand.
404
00:30:30.079 --> 00:30:33.769
And they all, of course, believed him. But once he
405
00:30:33.849 --> 00:30:36.450
earned their trust and became their right hand, Tilly set
406
00:30:36.490 --> 00:30:39.849
to work with his plan for taking advantage of his
407
00:30:39.970 --> 00:30:45.819
new so-called friends. Tilly claimed that the de Vadrines were
408
00:30:45.940 --> 00:30:51.160
soon to become the victims of conspiracies. In September of 2001,
409
00:30:51.160 --> 00:30:54.119
he persuaded 11 members of the group to seek refuge
410
00:30:54.160 --> 00:30:59.009
in their family castle in Montflacquine for their safety. Jean Marquin,
411
00:30:59.410 --> 00:31:02.990
Ghislaine's husband, was left out by their relatives whom Tilly
412
00:31:03.049 --> 00:31:06.349
revealed to be a partner of their enemies. The eleven
413
00:31:06.450 --> 00:31:10.410
family members included Goulamay, the matriarch, who was 88 years
414
00:31:10.490 --> 00:31:13.039
old at the time, her three children, two sons and
415
00:31:13.119 --> 00:31:17.859
one daughter, two daughters-in-law and five grandchildren. As per Tilly's script,
416
00:31:18.279 --> 00:31:21.720
Ghislaine and her family's lives might be in danger. He
417
00:31:21.779 --> 00:31:25.160
convinced them that the Freemasons were focused on getting their land.
418
00:31:26.119 --> 00:31:28.740
Tilly appeared to have some knowledge of the dark side,
419
00:31:29.099 --> 00:31:31.299
and when they asked him about the field he had
420
00:31:31.339 --> 00:31:35.390
worked in before, he answered with one palm raised, Do
421
00:31:35.430 --> 00:31:39.970
not inquire. I cannot discuss. The neighbors of the Devadrin's
422
00:31:40.029 --> 00:31:43.490
family said they were living a pretty normal life before
423
00:31:43.559 --> 00:31:47.200
they met with Tilly. They were a respected family and
424
00:31:47.259 --> 00:31:51.819
greatly liked as well. It was in the middle of 2001, however,
425
00:31:51.880 --> 00:31:54.559
when the 11 members cut their ties with all of
426
00:31:54.599 --> 00:31:59.319
their friends and other family. The Vadrines began shunning everyone
427
00:31:59.359 --> 00:32:05.579
in their lives, even their spouses and children. On January 4th, 2002,
428
00:32:05.579 --> 00:32:08.690
a neighbor came to see what was wrong. They didn't
429
00:32:08.750 --> 00:32:11.890
open the door. She looked through the window and saw
430
00:32:11.930 --> 00:32:16.240
them all, sitting, motionless in the dark. No one was
431
00:32:16.309 --> 00:32:19.009
allowed to visit their house. If someone tried to enter
432
00:32:19.049 --> 00:32:23.150
through the gate, they started shouting and even attacked some visitors.
433
00:32:24.130 --> 00:32:27.509
Since all the Vadrin's family quit their jobs, they stopped
434
00:32:27.529 --> 00:32:32.890
paying taxes. In 2003, the tax authority seized their property's furniture.
435
00:32:33.710 --> 00:32:36.569
Tilly managed to convince the family to sign over all
436
00:32:36.589 --> 00:32:41.309
of their property to him. But after 2001, Tilly had
437
00:32:41.329 --> 00:32:45.809
been missing in actions. He was giving them orders from
438
00:32:45.869 --> 00:32:49.349
a distance, and they all became puppets in his hands.
439
00:32:50.410 --> 00:32:54.519
Ghislaine's husband, Jean Marchand, was the only one in the
440
00:32:54.579 --> 00:32:57.140
family who was able to get out of the trap.
441
00:32:58.420 --> 00:33:01.640
Jean had found an email from Tilly de Ghislaine that
442
00:33:01.680 --> 00:33:06.539
included the following instructions. Throw the glove and flowers his
443
00:33:06.599 --> 00:33:09.640
way to inform him that these are indications that his
444
00:33:09.720 --> 00:33:13.269
network is evil, and give him 30 minutes to pack.
445
00:33:14.579 --> 00:33:17.779
He tried to alert the authorities, but the Vedrines kicked
446
00:33:17.799 --> 00:33:20.440
him out of the castle for his attempts at freeing them.
447
00:33:21.480 --> 00:33:25.059
When Tilly ran into significant legal problems in France, he
448
00:33:25.099 --> 00:33:29.779
began shifting his base to England. Tilly then had each
449
00:33:29.880 --> 00:33:32.740
member of the family move to his home in Oxford,
450
00:33:33.420 --> 00:33:38.740
one by one, starting in 2006. Felipe de Vedrines and
451
00:33:38.779 --> 00:33:44.599
his wife Brigitte Leroux-Martin left the family in February 2008,
452
00:33:44.599 --> 00:33:47.819
Tilly forced the other nine Vadrines to move to Oxford.
453
00:33:48.619 --> 00:33:52.240
Tilly's family and the Vadrines were living together there. The
454
00:33:52.299 --> 00:33:58.319
aristocrats were now penniless. Christine worked as a caterer salesperson,
455
00:33:59.200 --> 00:34:02.769
and Charles Henry, the former obstetrician, had to work as
456
00:34:02.809 --> 00:34:07.750
a gardener, and their salaries went directly into Tilly's account.
457
00:34:08.869 --> 00:34:12.039
Yet of all that was done to the Vadrines, The
458
00:34:12.079 --> 00:34:16.800
most serious was the physical abuse of Christine, the wife
459
00:34:16.880 --> 00:34:21.559
of Charles Henry. Tilly convinced the Vedrines that Christine was
460
00:34:21.619 --> 00:34:25.219
hiding treasure from them. One of the family members tied
461
00:34:25.269 --> 00:34:28.750
her to a stool for two weeks and prevented her
462
00:34:28.809 --> 00:34:32.849
from sleeping. With the help of her employer, Robert Pogge,
463
00:34:33.369 --> 00:34:36.880
Christine was able to leave Oxford. He listened to her
464
00:34:36.920 --> 00:34:41.039
entire story of torture and the endless list of family
465
00:34:41.099 --> 00:34:46.039
possessions that had been lost. In March of 2009, she
466
00:34:46.079 --> 00:34:50.329
arrived in Bordeaux and met with lawyer Daniel Picotin, where
467
00:34:50.369 --> 00:34:54.889
she told her story. Terry Tilley's good fortune was about
468
00:34:54.949 --> 00:34:59.349
to end. He became a target after Christine's testimony, and
469
00:34:59.389 --> 00:35:02.449
the French government brought charges against him in response to
470
00:35:02.510 --> 00:35:06.989
claims of torture and abuse. When Tilly traveled to Zurich
471
00:35:07.110 --> 00:35:11.840
on October 21, 2009, he was arrested, and the events
472
00:35:11.880 --> 00:35:16.199
that followed quickly brought the Vedrines' family back together. Tilly
473
00:35:16.260 --> 00:35:22.000
was prosecuted by the French justice system in Bordeaux for fraud, abuse, kidnapping,
474
00:35:22.119 --> 00:35:25.699
and torture. Explaining the verdict, the court said Tilly had
475
00:35:25.780 --> 00:35:29.719
created a state of submission amongst his victims, encouraging, quote,
476
00:35:30.159 --> 00:35:36.059
group paranoia and mental destabilization. In 2012, he received an
477
00:35:36.159 --> 00:35:39.889
eight-year prison term and was ordered to compensate his victims.
478
00:35:40.789 --> 00:35:45.309
Jacques Gonzalez, his accomplice, was sentenced to four years in prison.
479
00:35:46.130 --> 00:35:49.789
Tilly's sentence was extended to ten years following an appeal
480
00:35:50.309 --> 00:35:56.679
in 2013. Charles Henry de Vedrines would later say that, quote,
481
00:35:57.159 --> 00:35:59.760
he stole ten years of our lives, but he did
482
00:35:59.840 --> 00:36:05.449
more than that. He destroyed everything along the way. And
483
00:36:05.489 --> 00:36:09.010
there you have it, a man with a hypnotically tight
484
00:36:09.110 --> 00:36:13.130
grip on a family that slowly turned against their friends, associates,
485
00:36:13.170 --> 00:36:16.969
and eventually each other, but looked to this man for
486
00:36:17.070 --> 00:36:20.059
trust only
for it to later be revealed that it
487
00:36:20.099 --> 00:36:24.739
was he who had conspired against them. Truly a diabolical
488
00:36:24.920 --> 00:36:27.320
act if there ever was one made even more so
489
00:36:27.679 --> 00:36:31.000
by the fact that the con artist had began formulating
490
00:36:31.099 --> 00:36:34.570
how to do it all since watching a made-for-television movie.
491
00:36:35.369 --> 00:36:38.829
that featured a similar plot. While they had to live
492
00:36:38.889 --> 00:36:42.349
in social housing for some time, Charles and Christine were
493
00:36:42.510 --> 00:36:45.449
able to get their lives back on track, as were
494
00:36:45.489 --> 00:36:48.900
the other members of the Vadrin's family. They were even
495
00:36:49.000 --> 00:36:52.019
able to reconnect with one another and put their distrust
496
00:36:52.059 --> 00:36:56.559
of one another into the past. Tilly, however, will always
497
00:36:56.639 --> 00:37:00.159
be a dark specter in their lives. His ten years
498
00:37:00.219 --> 00:37:03.489
are up, and unless he's learned better, he might just
499
00:37:03.550 --> 00:37:08.110
be on the prowl if not already playing another family,
500
00:37:08.809 --> 00:37:13.360
like a fiddle. So when in doubt, trust those you
501
00:37:13.420 --> 00:37:17.340
know well, especially when it comes to your finances or
502
00:37:17.420 --> 00:37:22.400
any other prized possessions. After all, you wouldn't want to
503
00:37:22.440 --> 00:37:25.429
be a victim of a guru spending all of their
504
00:37:25.510 --> 00:37:29.929
time lying and conning you out of everything, would you?
505
00:37:36.920 --> 00:37:43.489
Marty Markowitz, The Shrink Next Door. Allow me to tell
506
00:37:43.550 --> 00:37:48.130
you a story from New York City, a place where
507
00:37:48.210 --> 00:37:53.230
dreams are chased, but sometimes, hidden under those bright city lights,
508
00:37:54.050 --> 00:38:00.199
some tales are both surprising and a bit unsettling. This
509
00:38:00.300 --> 00:38:03.599
is one such story about a man named Marty Markowitz
510
00:38:04.380 --> 00:38:10.760
and his psychiatrist, Dr. Isaac Hershkoff. Together, their story explores
511
00:38:10.820 --> 00:38:16.300
the themes of misplaced power, vulnerability, and the unexpected twists
512
00:38:16.719 --> 00:38:21.179
life can throw at us. Marty was a businessman with
513
00:38:21.239 --> 00:38:25.769
a big heart, known for his successful endeavors. Yet, like
514
00:38:25.849 --> 00:38:29.969
many of us, he faced tough times balancing work pressures
515
00:38:30.050 --> 00:38:33.909
and family issues, especially dealing with the loss of his
516
00:38:33.969 --> 00:38:37.630
parents and disputes and over the family business and the
517
00:38:37.670 --> 00:38:42.869
fabric industry. In search of guidance in 1981, Marty crossed
518
00:38:42.909 --> 00:38:47.010
paths with a psychiatrist named Ike. Marty saw in Ike
519
00:38:47.420 --> 00:38:51.119
a trustworthy advisor, someone who
could help him through these
520
00:38:51.539 --> 00:38:56.559
tough patches. But his hope led him down an unexpected journey,
521
00:38:57.179 --> 00:39:02.579
far from the normal bounds of a patient-doctor relationship. Ike
522
00:39:02.949 --> 00:39:06.760
had a charm that Marty was drawn to. appearing kind
523
00:39:06.820 --> 00:39:10.789
and supportive at first, before long Ike had woven himself
524
00:39:10.849 --> 00:39:15.130
into every aspect of Marty's life, acting not just as
525
00:39:15.190 --> 00:39:20.050
his psychiatrist, but as his friend. They shared meals and
526
00:39:20.090 --> 00:39:23.250
attended events together, and Ike was even a part of
527
00:39:23.329 --> 00:39:28.130
Marty's family gatherings. Marty found himself relying on Ike for
528
00:39:28.170 --> 00:39:33.610
advice on almost everything. far beyond just matters of mental health.
529
00:39:34.670 --> 00:39:39.889
This shift in their relationship was gradual, yet intentional. Over
530
00:39:39.929 --> 00:39:44.920
the next 30 years, Ike manipulated his position, making decisions
531
00:39:44.980 --> 00:39:48.340
for Marty that isolated him from his family and increased
532
00:39:48.380 --> 00:39:52.849
his dependence on on Ike. Marty was convinced by Ike
533
00:39:52.909 --> 00:39:57.300
to cut off so-called toxic family members and allowed Ike
534
00:39:57.360 --> 00:40:01.159
to get involved in his financial matters. But perhaps the
535
00:40:01.199 --> 00:40:05.280
most audacious move was when Ike started using Marty's Hamptons
536
00:40:05.340 --> 00:40:10.039
house for lavish personal parties, acting as if he owned
537
00:40:10.079 --> 00:40:14.199
the place himself. What had begun as a simple search
538
00:40:14.239 --> 00:40:20.820
for guidance unraveled into a much, much darker reality. This
539
00:40:20.900 --> 00:40:24.980
story is a cautionary tale about how a professional relationship
540
00:40:25.280 --> 00:40:29.239
meant to provide care and protection can deviate so far
541
00:40:29.820 --> 00:40:34.780
from its intended course. This remarkable story caught so much
542
00:40:34.840 --> 00:40:37.860
attention that it even turned into a show on Apple
543
00:40:37.900 --> 00:40:43.159
TV called The Shrink Next Door. The tale originally came
544
00:40:43.219 --> 00:40:46.539
to light through a podcast with the same name. This
545
00:40:46.639 --> 00:40:50.969
podcast dived deep into the life changes Marty Markowitz went
546
00:40:51.010 --> 00:40:56.260
through and his long fight to reclaim his life. The
547
00:40:56.300 --> 00:41:00.739
man behind this podcast is Joe Nocera, a writer for Bloomberg,
548
00:41:01.059 --> 00:41:04.320
who decided to share this story after a personal encounter
549
00:41:04.780 --> 00:41:09.530
with both Marty Markowitz and Dr. Ike. His curiosity was
550
00:41:09.630 --> 00:41:12.349
piqued when he moved into a house right next to
551
00:41:12.409 --> 00:41:16.789
Marty's in the Hamptons. This proximity provided a unique
vantage
552
00:41:16.869 --> 00:41:21.420
point to peel back the layers of Marty's tormented experience.
553
00:41:22.139 --> 00:41:25.519
As Nocera dug deeper, he uncovered a story that was
554
00:41:25.599 --> 00:41:31.219
as incredible as it was distressing. Marty, a wealthy businessman
555
00:41:31.360 --> 00:41:36.139
due to his family's venture associated Fabrics Corporation, found himself
556
00:41:36.239 --> 00:41:39.230
ensnared by the very person he trusted to help him,
557
00:41:39.889 --> 00:41:45.960
his psychiatrist, Dr. Ike Hershkoff. Dr. Ike Hershkoff, an individual
558
00:41:46.039 --> 00:41:51.480
whose flamboyant behavior and obsession with high status were starkly evident,
559
00:41:51.960 --> 00:41:57.059
seized his influential position to direct Marty's personal and financial decisions.
560
00:41:57.880 --> 00:42:02.809
As the years passed, Dr. Ike's manipulation deepened, isolating Marty
561
00:42:02.869 --> 00:42:06.650
from his loved ones, positioning himself as the president of
562
00:42:06.730 --> 00:42:11.530
Marty's company, and launching a charity foundation primarily funded by
563
00:42:11.610 --> 00:42:15.570
Marty's resources. This was not just a betrayal of the
564
00:42:15.639 --> 00:42:22.940
doctor-patient trust, but a masterclass in manipulation. The gravity of
565
00:42:23.000 --> 00:42:28.420
this manipulation came to the foreground in a July 2021
566
00:42:28.420 --> 00:42:32.860
interview with Marty. He revealed the depth of his entanglement
567
00:42:33.280 --> 00:42:36.960
in which he described it as the cult of Ike.
568
00:42:38.480 --> 00:42:41.880
Marty painted a vivid picture of his life under Dr.
569
00:42:42.079 --> 00:42:47.659
Ike's influence. From transcribing sessions to attending meticulously orchestrated parties,
570
00:42:48.320 --> 00:42:53.079
he recollected how his pursuit of romantic relationships was systematically
571
00:42:53.179 --> 00:42:58.670
sabotaged by Dr. Ike, who painted everyone around Marty as
572
00:42:58.889 --> 00:43:05.230
adversaries out to exploit him. Ike was so convincing that
573
00:43:05.250 --> 00:43:08.849
he got Marty to change his will. He made Marty
574
00:43:08.929 --> 00:43:12.079
sign over everything he had to a group called the
575
00:43:12.139 --> 00:43:18.090
Yeren Foundation. And imagine who was running this foundation. Ike
576
00:43:18.639 --> 00:43:22.860
and his wife, Rebecca. It's like something out of a movie,
577
00:43:22.920 --> 00:43:27.960
but for Marty, it was all too real. Circumstances got
578
00:43:28.099 --> 00:43:32.329
even wilder when Marty gave Ike access to his Swiss
579
00:43:32.429 --> 00:43:37.050
bank account, which was no small feat. We're talking about
580
00:43:37.170 --> 00:43:41.070
almost a million dollars in cash here. And just when
581
00:43:41.090 --> 00:43:44.719
you thought it couldn't get any more bizarre... Marty changed
582
00:43:44.760 --> 00:43:50.179
his will again in 1991. This time, everything was to
583
00:43:50.219 --> 00:43:54.460
go to Rebecca if he passed away, and Ike was
584
00:43:54.500 --> 00:43:58.360
given power of attorney, which means Ike had control over
585
00:43:58.639 --> 00:44:03.300
all of Marty's decisions. All the while, Ike was playing
586
00:44:03.360 --> 00:44:07.500
an entirely other game. He was busy telling Marty that
587
00:44:07.679 --> 00:44:12.210
anyone he dated was only after his money. Can you imagine?
588
00:44:13.260 --> 00:44:16.579
Marty later said that no one in his family shook
589
00:44:16.619 --> 00:44:20.579
him back to reality, even after their repeated attempts to
590
00:44:20.659 --> 00:44:26.320
tell him he was being fooled. The total damage, Marty
591
00:44:26.380 --> 00:44:31.139
thinks he lost around $ 4 million because of Ike. That
592
00:44:31.199 --> 00:44:38.199
includes around $ 2. 8 million in payments for therapy and around $ 1. 5
593
00:44:36.760 --> 00:44:40.480
million in a bad investment, a Ponzi scheme no less.
594
00:44:41.730 --> 00:44:45.570
The moment of truth came in 2010 after Marty had
595
00:44:45.670 --> 00:44:49.909
surgery for a hernia. That's when everything started to click
596
00:44:50.219 --> 00:44:53.619
and he realized just how deep he was in Ike's trap.
597
00:44:54.559 --> 00:44:58.019
It's a story that might leave you thinking twice about
598
00:44:58.099 --> 00:45:02.739
who you trust. So the plot thickens in this eerie
599
00:45:02.789 --> 00:45:07.289
tale as Marty falls deeper into the psychological maze crafted
600
00:45:07.329 --> 00:45:11.489
by his therapist, Dr. Ike. But money isn't the only
601
00:45:11.590 --> 00:45:16.710
casualty in this harrowing story. Family ties fray and break
602
00:45:16.849 --> 00:45:21.480
under the strain. Marty's sister, Phyllis Shapiro, who also put
603
00:45:21.519 --> 00:45:25.039
her time and loyalty into the family fabric business, grows
604
00:45:25.099 --> 00:45:29.199
wary as she notices her brother isn't calling the shots anymore.
605
00:45:29.940 --> 00:45:34.300
She even visits Dr. Ike herself. But alarm bells ring,
606
00:45:34.619 --> 00:45:38.050
and she finds herself not trusting the man who's slowly
607
00:45:38.130 --> 00:45:44.730
taking over. her brother's life. Things between the siblings take
608
00:45:44.789 --> 00:45:48.989
a sour turn. Marty, under Dr. Ike's influence, starts to
609
00:45:49.050 --> 00:45:52.469
see his sister as a slacker, a mere thorn in
610
00:45:52.510 --> 00:45:56.030
his side at the company. The tension builds until she
611
00:45:56.090 --> 00:46:00.670
can't stand it any longer, and she leaves. With her exit,
612
00:46:01.110 --> 00:46:07.239
the once close brother and sister stopped talking altogether. In
613
00:46:07.280 --> 00:46:13.000
a desperate move to reconnect, Marty's sister does something absolutely drastic.
614
00:46:14.260 --> 00:46:19.059
She steals from him. But instead of mending fences, Dr.
615
00:46:19.260 --> 00:46:22.880
Ike fans the flames, urging Marty to
sever ties with
616
00:46:22.920 --> 00:46:28.849
her completely. And so, another bridge is burnt, and they
617
00:46:28.869 --> 00:46:33.269
wouldn't exchange a word for many years to come. As
618
00:46:33.349 --> 00:46:36.829
Marty looks back on those years, he realizes just how
619
00:46:36.949 --> 00:46:40.679
much he's been ensnared. It wasn't just about money or
620
00:46:40.760 --> 00:46:44.320
the business. It was about his will, about having the
621
00:46:44.489 --> 00:46:48.369
agency to make his own choices. Dr. Ike's grip on
622
00:46:48.409 --> 00:46:52.590
him was so tight because Marty felt cornered with no
623
00:46:52.650 --> 00:46:57.250
other way out. The manipulation was so blatant that one
624
00:46:57.289 --> 00:46:59.989
would have to be willfully blind not to see it.
625
00:47:00.639 --> 00:47:06.079
And yet, for a very long time, Marty simply couldn't.
626
00:47:07.329 --> 00:47:11.210
It's only now, after finally breaking away, that Marty faces
627
00:47:11.309 --> 00:47:15.809
the daunting task of piecing his life back together, salvaging
628
00:47:15.849 --> 00:47:18.150
what he can from the wreckage left by years of
629
00:47:18.230 --> 00:47:23.150
control and deception. The real struggle lies not in the
630
00:47:23.190 --> 00:47:27.210
enormity of what was taken, but in the silent, painstaking
631
00:47:27.329 --> 00:47:31.449
efforts to rebuild a life that was once his own.
632
00:47:33.179 --> 00:47:36.519
The culmination of our tale comes with a surprising twist.
633
00:47:37.360 --> 00:47:42.199
the liberation of Marty and the unmasking of Dr. Ike.
634
00:47:43.659 --> 00:47:47.750
After years of deception, a somewhat innocuous event served as
635
00:47:47.809 --> 00:47:52.769
the trigger for Marty's big awakening. He underwent surgery and
636
00:47:52.869 --> 00:47:56.760
noticed that during his recovery, Dr. Ike, who was practically
637
00:47:56.820 --> 00:48:00.679
his only companion by then, hadn't bothered to check on him.
638
00:48:01.619 --> 00:48:06.119
This sparked in Marty a realization that perhaps their relationship
639
00:48:06.829 --> 00:48:11.789
wasn't a real friendship at all. Marty bore years of manipulation,
640
00:48:12.130 --> 00:48:15.829
endured unending tasks that Dr. Ike dumped on him, and
641
00:48:15.909 --> 00:48:19.760
watched as his wealth dwindled, trusting that Dr. Ike had
642
00:48:19.800 --> 00:48:24.340
his interests at heart. But this silence after his surgery
643
00:48:24.420 --> 00:48:28.900
forced Marty into an introspection. Quote, It was as if
644
00:48:29.099 --> 00:48:31.519
all the disappointments and all the rage that had been
645
00:48:31.559 --> 00:48:36.960
bottled up came surging out, Marty recalls. With newfound resolve
646
00:48:37.239 --> 00:48:40.519
and the subtle support from some employees addressed by Dr.
647
00:48:40.699 --> 00:48:44.590
Ike under a different name, Marty decided enough was enough.
648
00:48:45.230 --> 00:48:48.309
He cut all ties with Dr. Ike with a firm
649
00:48:48.369 --> 00:48:53.250
letter making it clear that he no longer required Ike's services.
650
00:48:54.530 --> 00:48:57.579
Although Ike tried to dissuade him and warned him of
651
00:48:57.699 --> 00:49:03.659
dire consequences, Marty stayed resolute, reclaiming his home and his life.
652
00:49:04.349 --> 00:49:08.420
and eventually working towards reinstating the bond with his long
653
00:49:08.480 --> 00:49:13.679
estranged sister. In the next chapter of Marty's life, we
654
00:49:13.760 --> 00:49:17.769
find him rekindling long lost family connections and setting off
655
00:49:17.849 --> 00:49:22.099
on adventures that seemed a distant dream during his darker days.
656
00:49:22.980 --> 00:49:26.159
After severing ties with the therapist who had overshadowed his
657
00:49:26.219 --> 00:49:31.039
life for three decades, Marty reached out to his sister Phyllis.
658
00:49:32.119 --> 00:49:35.519
Their bond, once severed and left to wither for 27
659
00:49:35.519 --> 00:49:40.019
years by the manipulations of a trusted professional, began to
660
00:49:40.119 --> 00:49:45.480
heal and grow strong once more. Together, Marty and Phyllis
661
00:49:45.539 --> 00:49:49.119
reclaim more than just familial ties. They take back the
662
00:49:49.159 --> 00:49:53.469
Hamptons estate that had slipped from Marty's control and embark
663
00:49:53.570 --> 00:49:58.309
on a journey across China and Italy. These travels became
664
00:49:58.409 --> 00:50:02.650
not just explorations of distant lands, but a reclamation of
665
00:50:02.730 --> 00:50:07.110
Marty's path, untethered from the strings once pulled by another.
666
00:50:08.179 --> 00:50:12.099
In 2012, Marty took a stand not just for himself,
667
00:50:12.559 --> 00:50:16.219
but for others who may have suffered silently. He filed
668
00:50:16.260 --> 00:50:19.380
a grievance against the psychiatrist with the New York State
669
00:50:19.420 --> 00:50:24.280
Department of Health. His action sparks a lengthy probe, extended
670
00:50:24.360 --> 00:50:28.559
over years, into practices that had gone unquestioned for far
671
00:50:28.639 --> 00:50:32.599
too long. Finally, in a move that must have brought
672
00:50:32.639 --> 00:50:36.420
a sense of closure to Marty, the investigation culminated in
673
00:50:36.420 --> 00:50:42.960
2019 with the revocation of the psychiatrist's medical license. Marty's
674
00:50:43.000 --> 00:50:47.760
life took on new hues. With his fabric business concluded,
675
00:50:48.440 --> 00:50:52.070
he stepped into retirement with an eagerness for life's next chapter,
676
00:50:52.829 --> 00:50:56.289
planning to weave through the landscapes of Thailand with his girlfriend,
677
00:50:56.789 --> 00:51:00.550
signaling a future Marty could look forward to with optimism.
678
00:51:01.690 --> 00:51:05.170
Reflecting on the journey, the years of shadow followed by
679
00:51:05.230 --> 00:51:09.170
a decade of seeking justice, Marty shares a simple truth.
680
00:51:09.949 --> 00:51:13.269
He's now living a life filled with joy and freedom
681
00:51:13.929 --> 00:51:18.489
previously unknown to him. His story is a testimony to
682
00:51:18.510 --> 00:51:22.849
the fact that even after the most prolonged night, dawn
683
00:51:22.969 --> 00:51:29.510
does break, bringing light and hope for renewed beginnings. But
684
00:51:29.590 --> 00:51:32.610
now let's take a look at the elephant in the room.
685
00:51:33.679 --> 00:51:38.250
Ike Hirschkopf. Where is he now? The tale takes a
686
00:51:38.309 --> 00:51:43.800
dark turn with Isaac Ike Hershkoff, a once-trusted psychiatrist whose
687
00:51:43.860 --> 00:51:48.199
career came crashing down in a storm of controversy. The
688
00:51:48.280 --> 00:51:52.320
unraveling began not with a bang, but with Marty Markowitz's
689
00:51:52.519 --> 00:51:55.380
bold step to erase Ike and his family from his
690
00:51:55.440 --> 00:52:00.550
will in 2010. For years, the truth lay dormant until
691
00:52:00.590 --> 00:52:04.269
the explosive revelations of the Shrink Next Door podcast in
692
00:52:04.269 --> 00:52:10.110
2019 caught the public's attention. In April of 2021, the
693
00:52:10.869 --> 00:52:15.130
climax of Ike's professional saga came to fruition. The New
694
00:52:15.170 --> 00:52:19.039
York State Department of Health made a decisive move, demanding
695
00:52:19.199 --> 00:52:23.119
Ike to surrender his medical license. The charges against him
696
00:52:23.159 --> 00:52:30.280
were severe and numerous. Gross incompetence, undue influence, fraudulent practices,
697
00:52:30.539 --> 00:52:35.570
gross negligence, and a profound lack of moral fiber. 16
698
00:52:35.570 --> 00:52:41.760
Counts of professional misconduct in total. Ike, however, did not
699
00:52:41.820 --> 00:52:47.440
accept these findings quietly. He vehemently denied all accusations and,
700
00:52:47.539 --> 00:52:50.619
speaking to the New York Times in November, announced his
701
00:52:50.699 --> 00:52:56.309
intention to challenge the verdict. Nevertheless, his efforts to clear
702
00:52:56.369 --> 00:53:00.849
his name were thwarted. Bloomberg reported that his appeal to
703
00:53:00.969 --> 00:53:06.489
overturn the charges was unsuccessful, marking a significant setback to
704
00:53:06.510 --> 00:53:10.449
the former doctor. After living in the shadow of Ike
705
00:53:10.510 --> 00:53:14.010
for so long, Marty's life took a modest turn for
706
00:53:14.050 --> 00:53:18.409
the better. Without Ike's meddling, his life flourished with experiences
707
00:53:18.469 --> 00:53:21.199
and delight, and he restored the familial link with his
708
00:53:21.239 --> 00:53:24.420
sister that Ike had chipped away at. As his career
709
00:53:24.460 --> 00:53:28.039
took a nosedive, Ike had no choice but to face
710
00:53:28.099 --> 00:53:32.460
the music. His medical license and reputation were both tarnished
711
00:53:32.519 --> 00:53:37.110
when his appeal was denied. Regardless, Ike who felt mistreated,
712
00:53:37.630 --> 00:53:41.170
could not perceive anybody else but himself as the protagonist
713
00:53:41.809 --> 00:53:46.170
of his narrative. The world watched as their convoluted tale
714
00:53:46.590 --> 00:53:50.519
became a hit TV show, serving as a sobering reminder
715
00:53:50.579 --> 00:53:54.219
of how vulnerable we are to abuse of trust and
716
00:53:54.260 --> 00:53:57.780
how difficult it is to resist. At the end of
717
00:53:57.820 --> 00:54:01.860
the day, Marty's narrative serves as a potent reminder that
718
00:54:01.900 --> 00:54:04.260
it's never too late to climb out of a pit
719
00:54:04.280 --> 00:54:08.449
to and find joy again, while Ike's downfall shows us
720
00:54:08.489 --> 00:54:13.849
that our choices have an impact, and that sometimes justice
721
00:54:14.869 --> 00:54:31.699
is served. The Murder of Brian Barrett Friday, September 15th, 2006.
722
00:54:33.170 --> 00:54:38.130
The second shift is ending at Dynabraid Corporation in Clarence,
723
00:54:38.210 --> 00:54:45.050
New York, east of Buffalo. At 10.16 p.m., 22-year-old Brian
724
00:54:45.139 --> 00:54:50.219
Barrett punches out. He's spent most of the day moving
725
00:54:50.320 --> 00:54:54.380
between college classes and the factory job that helps him
726
00:54:54.480 --> 00:54:59.059
pay for them. Now he walks into an isolated section
727
00:54:59.099 --> 00:55:02.599
of the employee parking lot. opens the door of his
728
00:55:02.699 --> 00:55:07.719
white pickup truck, and gets behind the wheel. Three shots
729
00:55:07.840 --> 00:55:13.079
tear through the driver's side window. Investigators will later identify
730
00:55:13.139 --> 00:55:18.500
the likely weapon as a. 30 caliber carbine. The gunfire
731
00:55:18.579 --> 00:55:23.550
strikes Brian in the neck, jaw, and arm. He has
732
00:55:23.650 --> 00:55:28.409
no meaningful chance to escape. The attack suggests the shooter
733
00:55:28.889 --> 00:55:32.329
knew where his truck was parked, knew when his shift
734
00:55:32.489 --> 00:55:36.630
ended and came close enough to make certain the ambush
735
00:55:36.730 --> 00:55:41.070
would be fatal. Then the shooter leaves Brian in the
736
00:55:41.130 --> 00:55:47.699
cab and disappears. Just before midnight, an instant message appears
737
00:55:47.780 --> 00:55:51.280
on the computer of a young woman in West Virginia.
738
00:55:52.360 --> 00:55:56.500
It comes from one of Brian's co-workers, a much older
739
00:55:56.579 --> 00:56:03.440
man named Thomas Montgomery. Quote, You waiting for your BF?
740
00:56:04.599 --> 00:56:08.860
The boyfriend is Brian. By the time that message is sent,
741
00:56:09.380 --> 00:56:14.820
Brian can't answer anymore. His body will remain in that
742
00:56:14.900 --> 00:56:19.940
truck until Sunday when a co-worker notices the vehicle still
743
00:56:20.059 --> 00:56:25.400
sitting in the lot. Detectives will find no robbery, no
744
00:56:25.539 --> 00:56:31.650
random quarrel, and no mystery enemy from
Brian's past. Instead,
745
00:56:31.730 --> 00:56:38.369
they'll find online conversations, invented identities, a missing rifle, a
746
00:56:38.429 --> 00:56:42.969
peach pit carrying DNA, and a jealousy that had been
747
00:56:43.050 --> 00:56:49.110
typed out almost line by line before it became murder.
748
00:56:50.469 --> 00:56:54.889
The woman at the center of those conversations called herself Jessie.
749
00:56:55.909 --> 00:57:00.929
Brian believed she was an 18-year-old high school student. Thomas
750
00:57:01.010 --> 00:57:04.989
believed the same thing, but the girl in the photographs
751
00:57:05.449 --> 00:57:10.199
had never spoken to either man. Of the three people
752
00:57:10.340 --> 00:57:14.579
trapped in the online rivalry, Brian was the only one
753
00:57:15.139 --> 00:57:20.760
who hadn't concealed his face, age, or real life from
754
00:57:20.800 --> 00:57:27.820
the person he dated. Before his name became attached to
755
00:57:27.900 --> 00:57:34.079
phrases like Internet Love Triangle, and Chat Room Murder. Brian
756
00:57:34.139 --> 00:57:38.480
Barrett was a son, a brother, a student, a friend,
757
00:57:39.099 --> 00:57:42.710
and a coach. He grew up in western New York,
758
00:57:43.190 --> 00:57:46.909
attended Star Point High School, and stood out in baseball
759
00:57:46.989 --> 00:57:51.710
and soccer. The adults who coached and taught him remembered
760
00:57:51.809 --> 00:57:58.750
more than just athletic ability. They remembered his character Tom Sarkovics,
761
00:57:59.130 --> 00:58:04.630
Brian's former baseball coach and Starpoint's athletic director, described him
762
00:58:04.710 --> 00:58:09.789
in the simplest terms possible. Quote, he was just a
763
00:58:09.849 --> 00:58:16.840
nice kid, a gentleman. That's important because the sensational version
764
00:58:16.880 --> 00:58:20.920
of this case often rushes past Brian to get to
765
00:58:20.960 --> 00:58:25.590
the twist. He was 22 years old. studying at Buffalo
766
00:58:25.650 --> 00:58:30.090
State College to become an industrial arts teacher, the kind
767
00:58:30.130 --> 00:58:33.570
of teacher who could show students how to build, repair,
768
00:58:33.750 --> 00:58:37.840
solve problems, and take pride in work done with their
769
00:58:37.920 --> 00:58:43.659
own hands. Paying for that future required a punishing routine.
770
00:58:44.440 --> 00:58:49.349
Brian's father later described weekdays that began around 6.30 in
771
00:58:49.389 --> 00:58:54.210
the morning, ran through college classes until about 3, then
772
00:58:54.309 --> 00:58:59.570
continued at Dynabraid until ten o'clock at night. The factory
773
00:58:59.610 --> 00:59:03.090
job was not his destination, it was how he was
774
00:59:03.170 --> 00:59:08.289
trying to reach one. Outside school and work, his life
775
00:59:08.369 --> 00:59:12.260
was ordinary in the best way. sense. He met friends
776
00:59:12.380 --> 00:59:17.079
for wings, beer, and pool. On Sundays, he volunteered
as
777
00:59:17.119 --> 00:59:20.800
a little league coach and also helped his father coach soccer.
778
00:59:22.039 --> 00:59:25.539
There is a temptation in true crime to polish every
779
00:59:25.639 --> 00:59:30.409
victim into perfection as though a person must be flawless
780
00:59:30.489 --> 00:59:35.250
before their death can be treated as an outrage. Brian
781
00:59:35.670 --> 00:59:40.929
didn't need that. He joked, he flirted online, made immature
782
00:59:41.030 --> 00:59:47.099
choices and sometimes underestimated danger. None of that diminishes what
783
00:59:47.159 --> 00:59:52.340
was stolen from him. If anything, it makes him recognizable.
784
00:59:53.639 --> 00:59:57.570
A young man still learning while already giving his time
785
00:59:57.670 --> 01:00:01.820
to children and working toward a life in the classroom.
786
01:00:03.099 --> 01:00:07.559
At Dynabraid, Brian was one of the younger employees. Thomas
787
01:00:07.619 --> 01:00:12.400
Montgomery had worked there for approximately 12 years. He was
788
01:00:12.480 --> 01:00:15.960
old enough to be Brian's father, but the two men
789
01:00:16.039 --> 01:00:19.840
were friendly enough to play poker together and cross paths
790
01:00:19.960 --> 01:00:25.039
in online games. In the factory, there was nothing remarkable
791
01:00:25.159 --> 01:00:32.800
about that connection. Online, Brian used the screen name Beefcake1572.
792
01:00:33.840 --> 01:00:37.269
It was playful, but the person behind it was largely
793
01:00:37.349 --> 01:00:41.190
who he said he was, a 22-year-old college student in
794
01:00:41.250 --> 01:00:46.730
western New York. He wasn't inventing a military career, borrowing
795
01:00:46.809 --> 01:00:52.449
another person's face, or pretending to be a teenager. Thomas Montgomery,
796
01:00:52.750 --> 01:00:57.690
on the other hand, was doing all three. By spring
797
01:00:57.730 --> 01:01:02.550
of 2005, Thomas had created the screen name Marine Sniper.
798
01:01:03.349 --> 01:01:07.670
Behind it, he began erasing nearly three decades from his
799
01:01:07.750 --> 01:01:15.409
life and building an imaginary young man named Tommy. Someone stronger, braver,
800
01:01:15.710 --> 01:01:21.510
more exciting, and more desirable than Thomas believed himself to be.
801
01:01:22.630 --> 01:01:27.150
Thomas was 45 years old, a former Marine. a machinist,
802
01:01:27.610 --> 01:01:31.710
a husband of 16 years, and the father of two daughters.
803
01:01:32.449 --> 01:01:36.670
He took his children to swim practice, played cards with co-workers,
804
01:01:37.130 --> 01:01:40.409
walked the family dog, and went to the same factory
805
01:01:40.469 --> 01:01:44.429
he had worked at for more than a decade. Nothing
806
01:01:44.489 --> 01:01:49.900
about that life was imaginary. But Thomas appeared to experience
807
01:01:50.000 --> 01:01:55.849
it as confinement. On the gaming site Pogo, Marine Sniper
808
01:01:55.929 --> 01:02:00.409
could be someone else. Thomas used a
photograph from Marine
809
01:02:00.489 --> 01:02:05.659
Boot Camp, taken roughly 30 years earlier, and presented it
810
01:02:06.000 --> 01:02:10.400
as current. He told other users he was an 18-year-old
811
01:02:10.440 --> 01:02:16.179
Marine named Tommy, bound for Iraq and trained as a sniper.
812
01:02:17.199 --> 01:02:21.980
Military records later obtained by ABC News showed that Thomas
813
01:02:22.079 --> 01:02:26.409
had served for six years in and qualified as a sharpshooter,
814
01:02:27.090 --> 01:02:30.369
but had not trained as a sniper and had not
815
01:02:30.929 --> 01:02:36.300
seen combat. The lie did not remain a false age
816
01:02:36.760 --> 01:02:41.320
attached to an old picture. Thomas built Tommy a history,
817
01:02:41.920 --> 01:02:48.500
a personality, a body, emotional wounds, military adventures, and a future.
818
01:02:49.570 --> 01:02:54.760
When maintaining the role became difficult... he invented another character,
819
01:02:55.519 --> 01:03:00.800
Tommy's father, Tom Sr. Thomas could then write as both
820
01:03:01.079 --> 01:03:05.860
the young Marine and the older man, supposedly passing messages
821
01:03:06.019 --> 01:03:12.730
and packages to him. In May of 2005, Marine Sniper
822
01:03:12.809 --> 01:03:18.989
began corresponding with a user called TallHotBlonde. She presented herself
823
01:03:19.110 --> 01:03:23.800
as Jessie, a West Virginia high school student who was
824
01:03:23.800 --> 01:03:29.300
17 and approaching 18. Her photographs showed a smiling, athletic blonde.
825
01:03:29.949 --> 01:03:35.809
Her messages described softball, school, family frustrations, and the emotional
826
01:03:35.889 --> 01:03:41.289
turbulence of being a teenager. Thomas later said he initially
827
01:03:41.389 --> 01:03:45.960
justified the deception by telling himself they would never meet.
828
01:03:47.059 --> 01:03:51.960
But distance made the lie safe, and that safety allowed
829
01:03:52.019 --> 01:04:00.409
it to grow. Tommy and Jesse exchanged instant messages, telephone calls, gifts, letters, videos,
830
01:04:00.639 --> 01:04:07.179
and intimate photographs. Packages arrived at Thomas' real home, carrying
831
01:04:07.300 --> 01:04:12.760
symbols meant for the imaginary marine. Each object moved the
832
01:04:12.840 --> 01:04:17.489
fantasy farther into the physical world, and each new piece
833
01:04:17.550 --> 01:04:21.989
of the relationship required Thomas to protect the identity he
834
01:04:22.010 --> 01:04:26.989
had made. In a recorded interview years later, he described
835
01:04:27.030 --> 01:04:33.280
the result with unusual clarity. Quote, it became more real
836
01:04:33.360 --> 01:04:43.900
to me than real life. Thomas also compared the daily
837
01:04:44.000 --> 01:04:49.480
contact to a drug. That language didn't excuse him. but
838
01:04:49.539 --> 01:04:55.150
it revealed how completely he had surrendered responsibility for his choices.
839
01:04:56.110 --> 01:05:01.570
He repeatedly chose the fantasy, reinforced it, and punished anyone
840
01:05:02.090 --> 01:05:07.570
who threatened it. By late 2005, he was talking at
841
01:05:07.630 --> 01:05:12.679
work about leaving his family for Jesse. At home, he
842
01:05:12.739 --> 01:05:16.639
spent long hours at the computer and pushed away the
843
01:05:16.679 --> 01:05:21.320
people who actually knew him. On a pad at work,
844
01:05:21.400 --> 01:05:27.960
he wrote that on January 2, 2006, 46-year-old Thomas Montgomery
845
01:05:28.460 --> 01:05:32.690
would cease to exist and be replaced by an 18-year-old
846
01:05:33.090 --> 01:05:41.230
battle-scarred Marine moving to West Virginia. The date came. Nothing changed.
847
01:05:42.030 --> 01:05:49.210
His body, marriage, job, and obligations remained. The contradiction did
848
01:05:49.269 --> 01:05:53.739
not end the fantasy. It made him more desperate to
849
01:05:53.780 --> 01:05:59.039
defend it. His wife, Cindy, eventually found the gifts and
850
01:05:59.119 --> 01:06:05.000
messages being sent to the supposed young Marine. She confronted Thomas,
851
01:06:05.559 --> 01:06:09.530
then made a decision that placed the truth directly in
852
01:06:09.610 --> 01:06:14.550
front of Jesse. Cindy wrote to her, enclosed a current
853
01:06:14.670 --> 01:06:21.940
family photograph, and explained that Tommy did not exist. Tom Sr.
854
01:06:22.059 --> 01:06:27.980
and Tommy were the same 46-year-old married father. The boot
855
01:06:28.039 --> 01:06:33.760
camp photo was Thomas decades earlier. Then Cindy offered seven
856
01:06:33.840 --> 01:06:40.670
words that should have stopped everything. Quote, Do not trust
857
01:06:40.769 --> 01:06:47.179
words on a computer. The person writing as Jesse claimed
858
01:06:47.320 --> 01:06:51.179
not to know whether to believe her. Thomas had layered
859
01:06:51.280 --> 01:06:55.139
the deception so deeply that even a photograph of his
860
01:06:55.260 --> 01:07:00.659
real family could be interpreted as another trick. To find out,
861
01:07:01.079 --> 01:07:04.960
she looked for someone Thomas had mentioned from work, a
862
01:07:05.019 --> 01:07:11.610
younger co-worker who also played on Pogo. The username was Beefcake1572.
863
01:07:11.630 --> 01:07:20.429
The person behind it was Brian. When Jessie contacted Brian,
864
01:07:20.829 --> 01:07:26.050
she was looking for confirmation. Was Thomas Montgomery truly a
865
01:07:26.489 --> 01:07:33.889
middle-aged married man? Was Tommy entirely invented? Brian knew the answer.
866
01:07:35.230 --> 01:07:39.670
He confirmed that Cindy's photograph was real and that Thomas
867
01:07:39.750 --> 01:07:44.949
was the man behind both entities. For Jessie, at least
868
01:07:45.070 --> 01:07:50.110
as she presented herself It was devastating. Brian became the
869
01:07:50.170 --> 01:07:55.530
person who could verify reality, explain Thomas' life at the factory,
870
01:07:56.030 --> 01:08:01.909
and listen while she reacted to the betrayal. They began
871
01:08:02.010 --> 01:08:06.639
playing lotso together in a pogo room called Princess Priceless.
872
01:08:07.659 --> 01:08:12.840
They moved to Yahoo Instant Messages. The conversations became friendly,
873
01:08:13.579 --> 01:08:21.039
then flirtatious, then openly romantic and sexual. Brian believed he
874
01:08:21.100 --> 01:08:24.949
was speaking to an 18-year-old. He talked about meeting her.
875
01:08:25.750 --> 01:08:30.329
She delayed or discouraged an actual visit while continuing to
876
01:08:30.390 --> 01:08:36.100
send messages and photos that made the relationship feel immediate.
877
01:08:37.199 --> 01:08:43.460
For Thomas, Brian's involvement was not merely romantic competition. Brian
878
01:08:43.520 --> 01:08:49.039
knew who he really was Worse, Brian was physically present
879
01:08:49.119 --> 01:08:52.760
in the part of Thomas' life the fantasy had been
880
01:08:52.819 --> 01:08:57.930
designed to escape. The conflict spilled into public game rooms
881
01:08:58.310 --> 01:09:03.500
and the factories. and Jesse mocked Thomas online and called
882
01:09:03.539 --> 01:09:07.819
him a predator for posing as a teenager while pursuing
883
01:09:07.920 --> 01:09:12.579
someone he believed was a high school student. Jesse shared
884
01:09:12.680 --> 01:09:17.189
passwords with Brian and he sometimes entered her accounts and
885
01:09:17.289 --> 01:09:21.619
spoke to Thomas and while pretending to be her. At work,
886
01:09:21.720 --> 01:09:26.840
Brian boasted about the relationship. According to a recovered exchange,
887
01:09:27.260 --> 01:09:32.399
he also left printed copies of conversations on Thomas' toolbox.
888
01:09:33.279 --> 01:09:38.329
Those actions were humiliating and reckless. They were also the
889
01:09:38.470 --> 01:09:43.970
actions of a 22-year-old confronting a 46-year-old co-worker who had
890
01:09:44.010 --> 01:09:48.829
constructed a fake teenager to pursue a supposed high school student.
891
01:09:49.890 --> 01:09:52.989
Brian may have believed he was exposing a liar who
892
01:09:53.050 --> 01:09:58.720
deserved ridicule. He couldn't have known that Thomas was converting
893
01:09:58.800 --> 01:10:06.899
embarrassment into homicidal grievance. The distinction must remain clear. Mockery
894
01:10:07.039 --> 01:10:12.609
can be cruel, but it is not consent to be stalked, ambushed,
895
01:10:13.289 --> 01:10:17.909
or killed. Brian did not cause Thomas to to choose
896
01:10:17.970 --> 01:10:25.069
a rifle. That decision was Thomas' alone. The messages show
897
01:10:25.149 --> 01:10:30.550
Thomas experiencing the exposure as the destruction of both identities
898
01:10:30.930 --> 01:10:34.949
he had been living. He complained that co-workers saw him
899
01:10:35.149 --> 01:10:39.050
as a loser and a predator. He threatened to make
900
01:10:39.109 --> 01:10:45.449
himself and Tommy disappear. He blamed Jesse for replacing the
901
01:10:45.600 --> 01:10:50.420
fictional young Marine with the real young man
who worked
902
01:10:50.539 --> 01:10:56.079
beside him. Quote, Half the company knows now. But the
903
01:10:56.140 --> 01:11:00.010
person riding as Jesse did not make a clean break.
904
01:11:00.869 --> 01:11:05.369
She told Thomas she still ached for Tommy. She promised
905
01:11:05.449 --> 01:11:10.729
to stop speaking to Brian, then continued. At other moments,
906
01:11:11.090 --> 01:11:16.060
she told Thomas the relationship with Brian had begun as revenge.
907
01:11:17.010 --> 01:11:23.449
She alternated reassurance, rejection, affection, and silence while hiding the
908
01:11:23.489 --> 01:11:28.479
most fundamental fact of all. She was not the teenager
909
01:11:29.100 --> 01:11:34.300
in the photographs. By the summer of 2006, Thomas was
910
01:11:34.380 --> 01:11:39.789
sleeping little and exercising intensely. He told Jesse he was
911
01:11:39.890 --> 01:11:45.500
training for war. At Dynabraid, His vague threats made at
912
01:11:45.539 --> 01:11:50.270
least one co-worker feel uneasy enough to wear a bulletproof
913
01:11:50.390 --> 01:11:55.029
vest as a grim joke. In one message, he warned
914
01:11:55.090 --> 01:11:59.210
that if he discovered more lies, she would lose something
915
01:11:59.409 --> 01:12:04.029
close to her. The target didn't need to be named.
916
01:12:04.829 --> 01:12:09.239
Brian was the person Thomas saw at work. Brian was
917
01:12:09.300 --> 01:12:13.399
the person whose messages could be placed on his toolbox.
918
01:12:14.220 --> 01:12:18.979
Brian was the person who had replaced Tommy without having
919
01:12:19.060 --> 01:12:24.170
to invent youth, strength, or a future. And Brian's work
920
01:12:24.229 --> 01:12:30.590
schedule was predictable. Two weeks before the killing, a co-worker
921
01:12:30.649 --> 01:12:34.609
would later tell detectives Thomas stood near the time clock
922
01:12:35.149 --> 01:12:40.010
and asked exactly when Brian finished his shift. The same
923
01:12:40.109 --> 01:12:45.670
co-worker recalled Thomas making a chilling comment. If he ever
924
01:12:45.770 --> 01:12:49.979
killed someone, he would not be stupid enough to leave
925
01:12:50.060 --> 01:12:56.340
shell casings behind. At the time, the remarks passed without intervention.
926
01:12:57.359 --> 01:13:09.510
After September 15th, they would sound like a rehearsal. The
927
01:13:09.590 --> 01:13:16.159
final escalation unfolded in messages investigators would later read in sequence.
928
01:13:17.079 --> 01:13:22.859
In the early hours of September 13, 2006, Thomas sent
929
01:13:22.939 --> 01:13:29.340
Jesse an abusive message and received almost no response. He
930
01:13:29.399 --> 01:13:35.050
continued trying throughout the day. On September 14, he sent
931
01:13:35.100 --> 01:13:40.390
another crude message that named Brian, On the morning of Friday,
932
01:13:40.449 --> 01:13:45.890
September 15th, Thomas telephoned Jessie. According to the woman on
933
01:13:45.930 --> 01:13:51.090
the other end, he was screaming and deranged. She hung up.
934
01:13:52.289 --> 01:13:56.229
Thomas knew Brian would be at Dynabraid later that day.
935
01:13:57.109 --> 01:14:01.779
Brian completed his second shift routine with no known reason
936
01:14:01.880 --> 01:14:06.800
to think the argument had crossed from online threats into
937
01:14:07.539 --> 01:14:13.239
physical planning. There's no indication that he expected an armed
938
01:14:13.319 --> 01:14:19.329
man in the parking lot. He punched out at 10.16 p.m.
939
01:14:20.550 --> 01:14:25.550
The attack was not a spontaneous fight. Brian was seated
940
01:14:25.609 --> 01:14:29.789
in his truck when three rounds came through the driver's
941
01:14:29.829 --> 01:14:36.939
side window at close range. Investigators identified the ammunition as
942
01:14:37.060 --> 01:14:41.659
consistent ammunition. with a. 30 caliber carbine, and believed the
943
01:14:41.729 --> 01:14:47.289
killer approached in camouflage and a ski mask. No property
944
01:14:47.350 --> 01:14:51.850
was taken. The location and timing indicated that Brian had
945
01:14:51.909 --> 01:14:57.479
been selected and waited for. Thomas returned to his computer
946
01:14:57.520 --> 01:15:02.619
that night, just before midnight. He asked Jessie whether she
947
01:15:02.659 --> 01:15:06.939
was around waiting for her boyfriend. Around 2.15 in the morning,
948
01:15:08.760 --> 01:15:13.319
He sent another message, suggesting that Brian would not mind
949
01:15:13.420 --> 01:15:18.060
her talking to him. The cruelty of those messages is
950
01:15:18.199 --> 01:15:24.380
in their ordinary tone. There's no confession or dramatic announcement.
951
01:15:25.180 --> 01:15:30.819
Thomas simply writes as though Brian is unavailable while knowing
952
01:15:30.979 --> 01:15:37.819
he will never log in again. Saturday passed. Brian didn't
953
01:15:37.939 --> 01:15:43.279
come home. His parents, Dan and Deborah, had gone camping
954
01:15:43.319 --> 01:15:47.970
with their youngest son and another family. When they returned
955
01:15:48.069 --> 01:15:52.189
Sunday morning, they noticed Brian had not fed the cats.
956
01:15:53.010 --> 01:15:56.710
It was a small disruption, but it told them something
957
01:15:57.369 --> 01:16:03.680
was wrong. Brian was responsible. He didn't vanish without explanation.
958
01:16:04.680 --> 01:16:09.470
At Dynabraid, a co-worker saw Brian's white pickup still parked
959
01:16:09.550 --> 01:16:13.800
in the isolated lot. Inside was the young man who
960
01:16:13.840 --> 01:16:17.779
had worked late to pay for college. His body had
961
01:16:17.819 --> 01:16:22.399
been there for nearly two days. About an hour after
962
01:16:22.460 --> 01:16:28.079
the Barrett family returned home, police and sheriff's deputies arrived
963
01:16:28.159 --> 01:16:33.140
at their door. Daniel Barrett later remembered opening it and
964
01:16:33.220 --> 01:16:40.029
understanding before anyone explained that the news... was bad. The
965
01:16:40.090
--> 01:16:46.189
first public descriptions emphasized the apparent absence of motive. Brian
966
01:16:46.229 --> 01:16:50.210
had no known criminal ties and had not been robbed.
967
01:16:51.170 --> 01:16:58.189
But inside the factory, rumors formed quickly. Coworkers knew about Thomas, Jesse,
968
01:16:58.369 --> 01:17:04.369
and the public arguments and the humiliating printouts. They remembered
969
01:17:04.470 --> 01:17:09.930
Thomas asking about Brian's schedules and talking about killing without
970
01:17:10.029 --> 01:17:16.560
leaving shell casings. Detectives also recovered Brian's mobile phone. In
971
01:17:16.640 --> 01:17:21.779
it was a number for Jesse in West Virginia. Lieutenant
972
01:17:21.859 --> 01:17:25.859
Ron Kenyon called to warn the young woman that Brian
973
01:17:25.920 --> 01:17:29.729
had been murdered and that she might also be in danger.
974
01:17:30.529 --> 01:17:35.710
A female voice answered. To Kenyon, she sounded exactly like
975
01:17:35.750 --> 01:17:41.229
the teenager Brian believed he knew. The next morning, a
976
01:17:41.289 --> 01:17:45.640
police officer knocked on the door, connected to that number.
977
01:17:46.939 --> 01:17:50.020
The blonde girl in the photographs was not the woman
978
01:17:50.159 --> 01:17:54.260
who answered. The house was in Oak Hill, West Virginia.
979
01:17:54.960 --> 01:17:59.989
The officer, J.L. Kirk, asked for Jessie. The woman at
980
01:18:00.029 --> 01:18:04.350
the door identified herself as the girl's mother, Mary Sheeler,
981
01:18:05.260 --> 01:18:09.350
and said her daughter was away. She claimed there was
982
01:18:09.430 --> 01:18:15.369
no way to reach her. That explanation created an immediate contradiction.
983
01:18:16.270 --> 01:18:21.050
Kenyon had spoken to Jesse only hours earlier at that number.
984
01:18:22.029 --> 01:18:28.739
Kirk continued asking questions. Mary became nervous, and eventually, the
985
01:18:28.819 --> 01:18:36.310
second major deception collapsed. Mary Sheeler was indeed Tall, hot blonde,
986
01:18:37.069 --> 01:18:41.199
she was a 45-year-old married mother who had been writing
987
01:18:41.319 --> 01:18:46.149
as her teenage daughter and using the daughter's photographs without
988
01:18:46.210 --> 01:18:51.829
her knowledge or consent. The real young woman, whose face
989
01:18:51.909 --> 01:18:56.439
had been sent to Thomas and Brian, had not conducted
990
01:18:56.500 --> 01:19:01.319
the romances, had not written the messages, and did not
991
01:19:01.399 --> 01:19:06.810
know her identity was being used in this way. Kenyon
992
01:19:06.869 --> 01:19:12.479
later described how, persuasive the voice had been. Quote, She
993
01:19:12.560 --> 01:19:17.510
sounded like an 18-year-old girl to me. Mary portrayed the
994
01:19:17.609 --> 01:19:23.250
early messages as harmless play. She said she regarded Brian
995
01:19:23.449 --> 01:19:26.909
as a sweetheart and had not known how to reject
996
01:19:26.949 --> 01:19:31.960
him without exposing herself. She also claimed she stayed in
997
01:19:32.039 --> 01:19:36.399
contact with Thomas because she feared what he might do.
998
01:19:37.710 --> 01:19:43.260
Whatever the original impulse, the surviving record showed sustained choices.
999
01:19:44.100 --> 01:19:48.659
Mary used her daughter's photographs, spoke by telephone in a
1000
01:19:49.060 --> 01:19:55.670
younger voice, discussed school and prom, accepted romantic attention and
1001
01:19:55.829 --> 01:20:02.649
shifted affection between Thomas and Brian. Even after Thomas was exposed,
1002
01:20:03.050 --> 01:20:09.279
Mary did not expose herself. She wasn't charged in Brian's death.
1003
01:20:09.770 --> 01:20:13.430
There was no evidence that she ordered the shooting or
1004
01:20:13.529 --> 01:20:17.010
helped plan it, or even knew Thomas was going to
1005
01:20:17.090 --> 01:20:24.050
attack Brian that night. Her deception caused profound harm, especially
1006
01:20:24.130 --> 01:20:27.550
to her daughter and to the people who believed the persona.
1007
01:20:28.449 --> 01:20:32.439
But Thomas alone made the decision to bring a firearm
1008
01:20:32.600 --> 01:20:38.409
to Brian's workplace and pull the trigger. For detectives, the
1009
01:20:38.449 --> 01:20:43.850
discovery in West Virginia clarified the emotional landscape. Proof of
1010
01:20:43.939 --> 01:20:49.539
the shooter began accumulating much closer to Brian's truck. Near
1011
01:20:49.579 --> 01:20:54.800
the vehicle, investigators recovered, of all things, a peach pit.
1012
01:20:55.739 --> 01:21:01.250
DNA testing linked it to Thomas Montgomery. They also found
1013
01:21:01.350 --> 01:21:06.409
a leather ammunition case bearing dog hairs that investigators believed
1014
01:21:06.829 --> 01:21:11.949
could have come from Thomas' family dog, Shadow. The shell
1015
01:21:11.989 --> 01:21:18.619
casings were absent, but other pieces of preparation remained. When
1016
01:21:18.680 --> 01:21:23.899
detectives questioned Thomas, he mentioned peaches in his car and
1017
01:21:24.050 --> 01:21:28.710
asked to retrieve his lunch before they spoiled. That detail
1018
01:21:29.170 --> 01:21:34.109
sharpened their interests in the pit found beside Brian's truck.
1019
01:21:41.329 --> 01:21:45.069
A search of Thomas' home produced a photograph of his
1020
01:21:45.130 --> 01:21:49.520
gun cabinet. In that picture was a. 30 caliber rifle.
1021
01:21:50.439 --> 01:21:54.899
By the time police searched, that rifle was missing. The
1022
01:21:54.939 --> 01:22:00.060
suspected murder weapon was never recovered. Thomas claimed he had
1023
01:22:00.119 --> 01:22:04.359
gone to a restaurant and returned home between 10 and 10.10 p.m.
1024
01:22:04.380 --> 01:22:13.100
before the shooting. Cindy placed his arrival as later. Cell
1025
01:22:13.189 --> 01:22:17.829
phone records located him in the vicinity of Dynabraid, around
1026
01:22:17.909 --> 01:22:26.010
the relevant time. On November 27, 2006, Thomas
Montgomery was
1027
01:22:26.090 --> 01:22:31.899
arrested and charged with second-degree murder. He denied killing Brian.
1028
01:22:32.960 --> 01:22:37.270
After the arrest, investigators monitored a jail call. in which
1029
01:22:37.350 --> 01:22:41.920
Thomas appeared to acknowledge why dog hair might be found
1030
01:22:42.039 --> 01:22:47.779
on the leather ammunition case. Then, there was the archive
1031
01:22:47.920 --> 01:22:54.520
Thomas had kept himself. Hundreds of pages of messages, photographs, notes,
1032
01:22:54.739 --> 01:23:01.699
and exchanges documenting the invention of Tommy, the exposure, the jealousy,
1033
01:23:02.340 --> 01:23:08.229
the threats, and the fixation on Brian. The computer did
1034
01:23:08.270 --> 01:23:14.920
not contain a single tidy confession. It contained something more extensive,
1035
01:23:15.779 --> 01:23:21.819
a record of motive developing over months. By then, investigators
1036
01:23:21.920 --> 01:23:25.260
knew the woman he had killed over was not the
1037
01:23:25.319 --> 01:23:29.600
woman in the photographs. At the time of his early questioning,
1038
01:23:30.119 --> 01:23:34.590
Thomas reportedly didn't know yet that Mary had deceived him
1039
01:23:34.970 --> 01:23:40.000
as well. The revelation changed nothing essential about the crime.
1040
01:23:40.640 --> 01:23:45.039
Brian had been real. The rifle had been real. The
1041
01:23:45.140 --> 01:23:49.939
shots had been real. Only the romance Thomas claimed to
1042
01:23:49.979 --> 01:23:56.289
be defending had existed entirely on a screen. Thomas initially
1043
01:23:56.369 --> 01:24:01.409
pleaded not guilty. In August of 2007, he accepted a
1044
01:24:01.449 --> 01:24:10.289
plea agreement, pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter, The plea avoided
1045
01:24:10.369 --> 01:24:14.930
a murder trial and reduced his exposure. It did not, though,
1046
01:24:15.430 --> 01:24:22.069
leave the central questions unresolved. Thomas Montgomery killed Brian Barrett.
1047
01:24:23.489 --> 01:24:28.760
Before sentencing, Thomas tried to withdraw the plea, claiming coercion
1048
01:24:28.960 --> 01:24:35.239
and confusion about his possible sentence. Judge Penny Wolfgang rejected
1049
01:24:35.279 --> 01:24:38.579
the request and said, and the later appellate record found
1050
01:24:38.640 --> 01:24:43.989
that his own plea statements contradicted the claim. At the
1051
01:24:44.050 --> 01:24:51.470
November 27, 2007 sentencing hearing, Prosecutor Frank Sedita asked for
1052
01:24:51.510 --> 01:24:56.689
the maximum term of 25 years. He described the messages
1053
01:24:56.840 --> 01:25:00.859
as evidence of an obsessive desire to make Brian suffer
1054
01:25:01.500 --> 01:25:07.329
after Mary's attention shifted away from Thomas. The defense argued
1055
01:25:07.369 --> 01:25:11.670
that fantasy and reality had blurred, and that Thomas was
1056
01:25:11.770 --> 01:25:18.189
suffering from diminished capacity. That description may help explain how
1057
01:25:18.310 --> 01:25:24.310
he rationalized his behavior. It doesn't erase the planning reflected
1058
01:25:24.369 --> 01:25:30.039
in the work schedule question, the missing rifle, the close-range ambush,
1059
01:25:30.340 --> 01:25:35.770
or the messages sent after Brian was dead. Thomas chose
1060
01:25:35.850 --> 01:25:42.250
not to address the court. Daniel Barrett, however, did. Quote,
1061
01:25:43.109 --> 01:25:46.770
To gun down a boy over simple jealousy does not
1062
01:25:46.869 --> 01:25:52.649
make sense to us. Judge Wolfgang sentenced Thomas to 20
1063
01:25:52.649 --> 01:25:56.569
years in prison. A New York appellate court upheld the
1064
01:25:56.630 --> 01:26:02.529
judgment in 2009. Recent reporting based on New York Corrections
1065
01:26:02.600 --> 01:26:07.279
records shows lists Thomas as released to parole supervision as
1066
01:26:07.359 --> 01:26:15.550
of January 11, 2024, after roughly 17 years. A prison
1067
01:26:15.609 --> 01:26:21.399
term can end. The sentence imposed on Brian's family doesn't.
1068
01:26:22.529 --> 01:26:26.760
Mary Sheeler was never prosecuted in connection with Brian's murder.
1069
01:26:27.500 --> 01:26:34.090
Public anger toward her remains intense and, understandably so, Her
1070
01:26:34.170 --> 01:26:41.550
impersonation kept the conflict alive, but responsibility must be accurately depicted.
1071
01:26:42.489 --> 01:26:48.850
Mary created and manipulated the persona. Thomas created Tommy, became
1072
01:26:49.020 --> 01:26:55.300
violently obsessed, selected Brian, armed himself, waited for him, and
1073
01:26:55.399 --> 01:27:00.020
killed him. The case is often called the Tall Hot
1074
01:27:00.140 --> 01:27:05.600
Blonde Murder or the Internet Love Triangle murder. Those labels
1075
01:27:05.720 --> 01:27:10.439
are catchy, but they pull attention toward the twist and
1076
01:27:10.520 --> 01:27:15.979
away from the person who died. There was no ordinary triangle.
1077
01:27:16.840 --> 01:27:20.720
There was a middle-aged man pretending to be a teenage marine,
1078
01:27:21.470 --> 01:27:25.869
a middle-aged woman pretending to be her own teenage daughter,
1079
01:27:26.590 --> 01:27:31.170
an uninvolved young woman whose face was taken, and Brian.
1080
01:27:31.899 --> 01:27:36.520
A real 22-year-old who did not conceal his age, face,
1081
01:27:36.779 --> 01:27:41.640
or life. Brian made mistakes within the conflict, no doubt.
1082
01:27:42.260 --> 01:27:46.550
He mocked Thomas and treated a volatile older co-worker like
1083
01:27:46.930 --> 01:27:52.050
an opponent in a game. Those details belong in an
1084
01:27:52.170 --> 01:27:56.189
honest retelling, but they do not make the killing in
1085
01:27:56.350 --> 01:28:03.619
any way mutual, inevitable, or understandable. Humiliation does not explain
1086
01:28:03.760 --> 01:28:08.680
stalking a co-worker's schedule, carrying a rifle into a parking lot,
1087
01:28:09.239 --> 01:28:14.199
and firing through a truck
window. Brian's father did not
1088
01:28:14.260 --> 01:28:17.899
remember him as a username or a point in a
1089
01:28:18.430 --> 01:28:25.250
sensational triangle. He remembered a big, strong, happy young man
1090
01:28:25.970 --> 01:28:29.289
who went from school to work, met his friends for
1091
01:28:29.369 --> 01:28:33.050
wings and pools, and gave his Sundays to Little League.
1092
01:28:33.920 --> 01:28:38.729
A teacher remembered a helpful student. A coach remembered a gentleman.
1093
01:28:39.899 --> 01:28:43.760
His obituary named the network of real people left to
1094
01:28:43.840 --> 01:28:50.020
absorb a death caused by invented lives. Had Brian lived,
1095
01:28:50.539 --> 01:28:54.510
he would now be in his early forties, perhaps nearly
1096
01:28:54.689 --> 01:28:59.250
two decades into teaching students how to repair what was broken.
1097
01:28:59.810 --> 01:29:05.710
and turn raw material into... something solid. That future cannot
1098
01:29:05.770 --> 01:29:10.369
be measured in the prison years... that Thomas served. The
1099
01:29:10.430 --> 01:29:15.710
warning is not simply that... people lie online. The deeper
1100
01:29:15.789 --> 01:29:20.569
warning is that... fantasy becomes dangerous... when a person treats
1101
01:29:20.729 --> 01:29:27.000
other human beings... as supporting characters. People to possess... punish
1102
01:29:27.239 --> 01:29:33.760
or erase... whenever they threaten the preferred narrative. Thomas Montgomery
1103
01:29:33.880 --> 01:29:37.689
tried to make his real self cease to exist and
1104
01:29:37.770 --> 01:29:43.250
replace it with Tommy. When Brian embodied the distance between
1105
01:29:43.310 --> 01:29:48.229
the fantasy and the man, Thomas did not abandon the lie.
1106
01:29:48.710 --> 01:29:52.579
He chose to kill the real young man who made
1107
01:29:52.640 --> 01:29:58.829
that distance impossible to ignore. But Brian Barrett was never
1108
01:29:58.949 --> 01:30:04.119
merely a witness to someone else's deception. He was a son,
1109
01:30:04.819 --> 01:30:10.579
a brother, a friend, a coach, a future educator, and
1110
01:30:10.659 --> 01:30:15.159
he is the person that must be remembered from this story.
1111
01:30:22.439 --> 01:30:30.140
The Unsolved Murder of Dorothy Scott Dorothy Jane Scott lived
1112
01:30:30.260 --> 01:30:34.239
in Stanton, in Orange County, with her aunt and her
1113
01:30:34.340 --> 01:30:39.729
four-year-old son. Her parents, Jacob and Vera, lived in nearby
1114
01:30:39.930 --> 01:30:44.369
Anaheim and helped care for him while she worked. Those
1115
01:30:44.449 --> 01:30:49.189
places can blur together in accounts of her disappearance, but
1116
01:30:49.449 --> 01:30:54.890
they belong to different parts of her life. Stanton was home.
1117
01:30:55.609 --> 01:30:59.069
Anaheim was where she worked. and where her parents could
1118
01:30:59.109 --> 01:31:03.380
look after her son. The hospital in Orange would enter
1119
01:31:03.439 --> 01:31:09.779
the story because a co-worker who needed medical attention. Dorothy
1120
01:31:09.880 --> 01:31:14.739
worked as a secretary for two jointly-owned shops in Anaheim.
1121
01:31:15.460 --> 01:31:22.640
One sold the sort of psychedelic merchandise associated with the era. Beads, lamps, gifts.
1122
01:31:23.560 --> 01:31:27.199
The other was a head shop. Her job placed her
1123
01:31:27.239 --> 01:31:31.600
in the working life behind those storefronts, handling the office
1124
01:31:31.640 --> 01:31:36.319
side of the businesses. People who knew Dorothy described a
1125
01:31:36.380 --> 01:31:40.500
woman who preferred being at home. Her Christian faith was
1126
01:31:40.619 --> 01:31:44.739
part of her life. So was her closeness to her family,
1127
01:31:45.409 --> 01:31:49.329
whose recollections would eventually provide much of what the public
1128
01:31:49.970 --> 01:31:54.430
would learn about her. The more revealing picture comes from
1129
01:31:54.470 --> 01:31:59.970
the arrangement's that kept her days moving. A job, a child,
1130
01:32:00.569 --> 01:32:04.590
an aunt sharing a home, grandparents who could help when
1131
01:32:04.689 --> 01:32:09.630
work kept her out. She was part of other people's routines,
1132
01:32:10.270 --> 01:32:15.130
and other people were part of hers. Then someone began
1133
01:32:15.390 --> 01:32:20.689
inserting himself into that life without giving her a name.
1134
01:32:21.949 --> 01:32:27.310
In the months before her disappearance, Dorothy received disturbing telephone
1135
01:32:27.369 --> 01:32:31.369
calls at work. The man on the line alternated between
1136
01:32:31.810 --> 01:32:38.640
declarations of affection and threats. Vera later said her daughter
1137
01:32:38.779 --> 01:32:43.859
didn't know who he was. He could address Dorothy personally
1138
01:32:43.939 --> 01:32:49.640
while keeping his own identity out of reach. His anonymity
1139
01:32:49.899 --> 01:32:53.100
left her without a person to connect to the words.
1140
01:32:53.760 --> 01:32:57.380
The telephone gave him access to a place where she worked,
1141
01:32:57.520 --> 01:33:02.189
but it gave her no view of the person using it.
1142
01:33:03.189 --> 01:33:07.250
A call could end without an explanation and another could
1143
01:33:07.310 --> 01:33:13.710
begin on his terms. The accounts preserve what she reported hearing,
1144
01:33:14.350 --> 01:33:18.060
but not the face of the speaker. The caller reportedly
1145
01:33:18.159 --> 01:33:22.800
referred to things Dorothy had done, presenting himself as someone
1146
01:33:22.859 --> 01:33:28.100
who could observe her movements. Whether every claim was accurate
1147
01:33:28.600 --> 01:33:32.119
is harder to reconstruct. What he was asking her to
1148
01:33:32.159 --> 01:33:36.779
believe was clear. He could reach her on the telephone
1149
01:33:37.439 --> 01:33:43.390
because he already knew where she was. One incident moved
1150
01:33:43.470 --> 01:33:48.289
the threat beyond the
receiver. Vera later recounted that the
1151
01:33:48.329 --> 01:33:53.340
man told Dorothy to go outside because he had something
1152
01:33:53.449 --> 01:33:58.460
for her. On the windshield of Dorothy's car, she found
1153
01:33:58.479 --> 01:34:04.119
a single, dead rose. A telephone call could arrive from
1154
01:34:04.539 --> 01:34:09.039
somewhere unseen, but the rose occupied a place where she
1155
01:34:09.060 --> 01:34:14.560
had to return to. Someone had apparently approached the vehicle,
1156
01:34:15.479 --> 01:34:19.960
left something on it, and gone away. In her mother's account,
1157
01:34:20.060 --> 01:34:25.079
the call and the object were connected. The windshield made
1158
01:34:25.140 --> 01:34:30.470
the gesture difficult to overlook. The caller had directed Dorothy
1159
01:34:30.520 --> 01:34:35.449
towards something waiting in her physical world, on an object
1160
01:34:35.489 --> 01:34:39.210
that had belonged to her. She did not have to
1161
01:34:39.289 --> 01:34:43.449
accept his account of watching her all day to find
1162
01:34:43.510 --> 01:34:48.270
that disturbing. There was something on the car that her
1163
01:34:48.350 --> 01:34:53.260
mother said had been announced by the voice. His language
1164
01:34:53.359 --> 01:34:58.880
also became violent. Vera described a threat that Dorothy would
1165
01:34:58.939 --> 01:35:04.250
be taken when she was alone and made impossible to find.
1166
01:35:05.329 --> 01:35:08.970
A person she could not name was speaking about an
1167
01:35:09.050 --> 01:35:13.670
encounter she could not know how to avoid. These were
1168
01:35:13.689 --> 01:35:19.680
not invitations she was obligated to answer. Whatever affection the
1169
01:35:19.720 --> 01:35:26.390
man claimed, He was describing harm. Dorothy considered buying a handgun.
1170
01:35:27.210 --> 01:35:31.810
An early newspaper account says she decided against it because
1171
01:35:31.869 --> 01:35:35.710
she was worried about her young son, who might accidentally
1172
01:35:35.770 --> 01:35:39.869
hurt himself with the weapon. She had to think about
1173
01:35:40.229 --> 01:35:43.970
the danger outside her home and the safety of the
1174
01:35:44.029 --> 01:35:49.369
child inside it. She also began taking karate lessons shortly
1175
01:35:49.449 --> 01:35:55.369
before she disappeared. Her family described someone taking precautions while
1176
01:35:55.729 --> 01:36:00.170
continuing to work and care for her child. The calls
1177
01:36:00.210 --> 01:36:02.970
had become a problem she was trying to act on,
1178
01:36:03.630 --> 01:36:08.609
even though identifying the caller remained out of reach. The
1179
01:36:08.649 --> 01:36:12.789
year matters too. In California, they would not enact the
1180
01:36:12.829 --> 01:36:17.770
country's first specific anti-stalking law until 1990, a decade later.
1181
01:36:20.239 --> 01:36:25.560
after Dorothy's disappearance. The legal response to a continuing pattern
1182
01:36:25.579 --> 01:36:30.779
of pursuit was still developing. The behavior itself was older
1183
01:36:30.880 --> 01:36:36.720
than the specific law. Following someone, making unwanted calls and
1184
01:36:36.819 --> 01:36:41.510
threatening them could form a continuing pattern, even when each
1185
01:36:41.659 --> 01:36:47.470
incident arrived separately. In Dorothy's account, the same channel carried
1186
01:36:47.550 --> 01:36:53.289
both supposed affection and the threat of violence. The declarations
1187
01:36:53.369 --> 01:36:56.789
did not cancel one another out. They made the next
1188
01:36:56.890 --> 01:37:03.470
contact upsettingly unpredictable. What we can follow is the behavior
1189
01:37:03.550 --> 01:37:09.600
described by her family. Unwanted contact, claims of observation, a
1190
01:37:09.649 --> 01:37:15.500
threatening object, and language about getting her alone. The pattern
1191
01:37:15.539 --> 01:37:21.039
gave the telephone calls a significance beyond any single conversation.
1192
01:37:21.850 --> 01:37:25.770
On the evening of May 28th, Dorothy attended a meeting
1193
01:37:25.829 --> 01:37:29.729
at work. Her son was being looked after by her parents.
1194
01:37:30.529 --> 01:37:34.369
Among the other employees were the aforementioned Pam Head and
1195
01:37:34.770 --> 01:37:41.350
Conrad Bostron. During the meeting, Conrad became unwell. Accounts describe
1196
01:37:41.409 --> 01:37:44.909
a red mark or streak on his arm. Dorothy and
1197
01:37:44.949 --> 01:37:48.430
Pam decided to take him to the emergency room. at
1198
01:37:48.590 --> 01:37:53.369
UCI Medical Center. The decision brought Dorothy into the story
1199
01:37:53.449 --> 01:37:58.390
through something she did for another person. Someone needed help.
1200
01:37:58.949 --> 01:38:02.229
She had a car and could take him. Pam would
1201
01:38:02.270 --> 01:38:06.510
come along. Before going to the hospital, Dorothy stopped at
1202
01:38:06.550 --> 01:38:09.369
her parents' house to check on her son and let
1203
01:38:09.409 --> 01:38:12.880
them know what was going on. She also changed the
1204
01:38:12.939 --> 01:38:18.510
scarf she was wearing. That small alteration easily passed over
1205
01:38:18.590 --> 01:38:22.449
in an ordinary account of an evening, would later attract
1206
01:38:22.510 --> 01:38:29.649
investigators' attention drastically. For now, there were three co-workers traveling
1207
01:38:29.689 --> 01:38:34.020
to a hospital. because one of them was ill. The
1208
01:38:34.060 --> 01:38:38.819
destination had been added to Dorothy's evening by an unexpected problem.
1209
01:38:39.439 --> 01:38:43.079
The man who had been calling her had spoken about
1210
01:38:43.199 --> 01:38:47.699
finding her alone. At this point in the night, she
1211
01:38:47.760 --> 01:38:58.819
was still with friends. At the hospital, Conrad was treated
1212
01:38:58.899 --> 01:39:03.359
for what reports identified as a black widow spider bite.
1213
01:39:04.109 --> 01:39:07.810
Dorothy and Pam waited while medical staff looked after him.
1214
01:39:08.630 --> 01:39:14.529
Contemporary reporting describes the two women watching television and reading magazines.
1215
01:39:15.329 --> 01:39:19.649
Nothing about the scene suggested that This ordinary wait would
1216
01:39:19.689 --> 01:39:23.329
become the final stretch of time in which a friend
1217
01:39:23.390 --> 01:39:28.350
could account for Dorothy's movements. The scarf Dorothy had changed
1218
01:39:28.430 --> 01:39:32.750
at her parents' house was white. The sheriff's account also
1219
01:39:32.829 --> 01:39:37.920
described her wearing jeans, a long-sleeved maroon blouse, and a
1220
01:39:38.350 --> 01:39:44.439
round turquoise ring. Those details would soon shift from ordinary
1221
01:39:44.560 --> 01:39:51.600
clothing to the descriptions. Pam said she remained with Dorothy
1222
01:39:51.640 --> 01:39:55.149
in the waiting area, aside from a brief trip Dorothy
1223
01:39:55.210 --> 01:40:00.210
made to the restroom. As Conrad was being released, Dorothy
1224
01:40:00.310 --> 01:40:03.890
offered to bring her car closer, making it easier for
1225
01:40:03.949 --> 01:40:07.460
him to load in. Pam and Conrad dealt with his
1226
01:40:07.539 --> 01:40:12.520
prescription while Dorothy went outside. The car was a white
1227
01:40:12.520 --> 01:40:18.430
1973 Toyota station wagon. When Pam and Conrad were ready
1228
01:40:18.470 --> 01:40:23.649
to leave, Dorothy was not waiting for them. Then they
1229
01:40:23.750 --> 01:40:28.390
saw the Toyota approaching. Its headlights were so bright that
1230
01:40:28.470 --> 01:40:31.470
Pam could not make out the person behind the wheel.
1231
01:40:32.329 --> 01:40:36.449
She and Conrad waved, the station wagon passed them, and
1232
01:40:36.510 --> 01:40:40.829
turned out of the parking lot without stopping. There was
1233
01:40:40.890 --> 01:40:45.979
no useful identification of the drivers. At first, Pam and
1234
01:40:46.079 --> 01:40:51.229
Conrad considered an ordinary explanation. Perhaps Dorothy had learned of
1235
01:40:51.289 --> 01:40:55.630
an emergency involving her son and had to rush away.
1236
01:40:56.489 --> 01:40:59.029
But the plan had been for her to pick them up,
1237
01:40:59.270 --> 01:41:04.689
and she did not return. A later Los Angeles Times
1238
01:41:04.750 --> 01:41:08.149
account says they waited two hours while the night of
1239
01:41:08.229 --> 01:41:11.479
May 28th gave way to the morning of May 29th.
1240
01:41:12.920 --> 01:41:17.119
Before dawn, police in Santa Ana found Dorothy's station wagon
1241
01:41:17.760 --> 01:41:21.979
burning in an alley in the 800 block of South Townsend.
1242
01:41:23.079 --> 01:41:27.739
Dorothy was not with it. Whatever explanation might have existed
1243
01:41:27.819 --> 01:41:31.359
for the car leaving the hospital, a burned vehicle in
1244
01:41:31.420 --> 01:41:35.920
another city changed the nature of the search. Police had
1245
01:41:35.979 --> 01:41:39.399
the Toyota, but they still did not know who had
1246
01:41:39.460 --> 01:41:43.279
driven it away and what had happened to Dorothy in
1247
01:41:43.319 --> 01:41:48.399
the parking lot, or where she had gone afterward. The
1248
01:41:48.510 --> 01:41:53.050
unexpected hospital trip also sharpened the question created by the
1249
01:41:53.149 --> 01:41:57.649
earlier threats. If the caller was involved, how had he
1250
01:41:57.710 --> 01:42:01.090
found Dorothy during an outing that had not been planned
1251
01:42:01.189 --> 01:42:05.399
in advance? The record does not establish that he followed
1252
01:42:05.460 --> 01:42:09.920
her continuously, and the hospital trip alone cannot prove that
1253
01:42:09.979 --> 01:42:14.140
he was there. But the possibility could not be ignored
1254
01:42:14.239 --> 01:42:18.279
because Dorothy had already described a man who wanted her
1255
01:42:18.319 --> 01:42:23.420
to believe he knew all her movements. In the first days,
1256
01:42:23.560 --> 01:42:27.960
Dorothy's father kept the disappearance out of the newspaper. Early
1257
01:42:28.020 --> 01:42:31.819
reporting says police asked the family to maintain a low
1258
01:42:31.920 --> 01:42:36.689
profile in case a ransom demand were to arrive. Her
1259
01:42:36.750 --> 01:42:39.789
young son was initially told that his mother was away,
1260
01:42:40.310 --> 01:42:45.569
caring for a friend. As the days passed, that explanation
1261
01:42:45.649 --> 01:42:50.960
became harder to sustain. About a week after Dorothy disappeared,
1262
01:42:51.520 --> 01:42:56.939
the telephone rang at her parents' home. Vera answered. The
1263
01:42:56.979 --> 01:43:03.510
caller said, I've got her. Then he hung up. More
1264
01:43:03.619 --> 01:43:09.250
calls followed. Some claimed Dorothy was being held. Others claimed
1265
01:43:09.649 --> 01:43:14.470
she had been killed. The statements contradicted one another, and
1266
01:43:14.510 --> 01:43:17.850
the man never gave the family what they needed most,
1267
01:43:18.609 --> 01:43:23.510
a location that could be checked. In June, the Santa
1268
01:43:23.609 --> 01:43:28.890
Ana Register published a story about the disappearance. On June 12th,
1269
01:43:29.229 --> 01:43:33.310
according to the paper's follow-up reporting, a man called editor
1270
01:43:33.430 --> 01:43:38.229
Pat Riley and claimed he had killed Dorothy. He described
1271
01:43:38.250 --> 01:43:41.979
her as someone with whom he had a romantic relationship
1272
01:43:42.560 --> 01:43:45.460
and said he had killed her after catching her with
1273
01:43:45.520 --> 01:43:50.239
another man. That was his claim, but it was not
1274
01:43:50.300 --> 01:43:55.100
an established relationship or motive. What made the call difficult
1275
01:43:55.159 --> 01:43:59.270
to dismiss, though, was the information he appeared to possess.
1276
01:44:00.229 --> 01:44:04.289
Contemporary reporting says the caller knew that Conrad had been
1277
01:44:04.369 -->
01:44:08.569
treated for a spider bite and that Dorothy had changed scarves.
1278
01:44:09.100 --> 01:44:14.199
before reaching the hospital. Those details reportedly had not appeared
1279
01:44:14.260 --> 01:44:19.239
in the register's first story. Their omission from the article
1280
01:44:19.399 --> 01:44:23.649
made his knowledge significant, but it did not prove that
1281
01:44:23.810 --> 01:44:27.189
only the killer could have known them. Other people had
1282
01:44:27.229 --> 01:44:31.810
been present during parts of Dorothy's evening, and investigators could
1283
01:44:31.869 --> 01:44:36.829
not reconstruct every route through which information might have traveled.
1284
01:44:38.090 --> 01:44:42.329
The caller also said Dorothy had telephoned him from the hospital.
1285
01:44:43.130 --> 01:44:46.989
Pam disputed that account. She said that she had been
1286
01:44:47.029 --> 01:44:50.399
with Dorothy and had not seen her make such a call.
1287
01:44:51.109 --> 01:44:55.960
That contradiction was very important. The man seemed to know
1288
01:44:56.100 --> 01:44:59.380
something about the night, while at least one part of
1289
01:44:59.420 --> 01:45:04.539
his story was challenged by a witness who had been there. Meanwhile,
1290
01:45:04.619 --> 01:45:10.340
the calls to Dorothy's family continued. Vera described a pattern
1291
01:45:10.420 --> 01:45:15.930
of brief contacts, often on Wednesday afternoons, when she was alone.
1292
01:45:16.909 --> 01:45:20.649
Efforts were made to record or trace the calls, but
1293
01:45:20.710 --> 01:45:24.350
she later said some arrived when monitoring was not active,
1294
01:45:24.930 --> 01:45:29.930
and others ended too quickly to locate. No caller was
1295
01:45:30.010 --> 01:45:34.890
identified through those efforts. By July, Jacob and Vera were
1296
01:45:34.989 --> 01:45:41.180
offering $ 2, 500 dollars for information leading to Dorothy or to
1297
01:45:41.220 --> 01:45:45.439
her body. They were still allowing for the possibility that
1298
01:45:45.789 --> 01:45:49.510
she might be alive, while also asking for the chance
1299
01:45:49.630 --> 01:45:54.090
to bring her home if she wasn't. The anonymous caller
1300
01:45:54.189 --> 01:45:58.380
kept speaking, but he never supplied the answer their reward
1301
01:45:58.899 --> 01:46:03.500
was meant to obtain. The calls continued beyond that summer
1302
01:46:04.239 --> 01:46:08.869
and beyond that year, Police suspected a connection between the
1303
01:46:08.930 --> 01:46:13.789
threatening calls and Dorothy's fate, and Vera believed the voice
1304
01:46:13.890 --> 01:46:18.850
contacting the family belonged to the same man. But belief
1305
01:46:18.970 --> 01:46:24.550
and suspicion never became a public identification. Then, in the
1306
01:46:24.609 --> 01:46:29.829
spring of 1984, Jacob answered one of the calls. According
1307
01:46:29.890 --> 01:46:32.649
to later reporting, he told the man he had the
1308
01:46:32.689 --> 01:46:37.869
wrong number. After that, the calls stopped. for several months.
1309
01:46:39.369 --> 01:46:43.300
Four years after the hospital, the silence still had no
1310
01:46:43.539 --> 01:46:49.800
answers to the central question. In August, a construction crew
1311
01:46:49.880 --> 01:46:55.170
working near Santa Ana Canyon Road in Anaheim Hills came
1312
01:46:55.229 --> 01:47:10.170
across skeletal remains. The discovery was made on August 6th, 1984,
1313
01:47:10.170 --> 01:47:14.770
near a bend in Santa Ana Canyon Road. Reporting described
1314
01:47:14.829 --> 01:47:19.850
a subcontractor preparing for telephone cable work when human bones
1315
01:47:19.930 --> 01:47:24.750
were found alongside the bones of a dog. The area
1316
01:47:24.789 --> 01:47:29.090
had changed during the years Dorothy was missing. Soil and
1317
01:47:29.189 --> 01:47:34.390
vegetation surrounded the remains, and later reporting quoted police as saying,
1318
01:47:34.829 --> 01:47:39.029
They had not been buried. Erosion had partly covered them.
1319
01:47:40.149 --> 01:47:43.920
Some of the bones were charred. A brush fire had
1320
01:47:43.960 --> 01:47:49.579
swept through the area in 1982, offering a possible explanation
1321
01:47:49.680 --> 01:47:53.579
for the burning without establishing when the person had died
1322
01:47:53.779 --> 01:47:59.279
or how the remains first reached that location. Investigators now
1323
01:47:59.359 --> 01:48:03.020
had to determine whether the discovery belonged to the case
1324
01:48:03.060 --> 01:48:08.149
that had remained unresolved For years, among the items found
1325
01:48:08.189 --> 01:48:12.680
with the remains was a turquoise ring. Dorothy had been
1326
01:48:12.739 --> 01:48:18.020
described as wearing one when she disappeared. Vera recognized it
1327
01:48:18.619 --> 01:48:22.649
as her daughter's. The ring was meaningful to the family,
1328
01:48:22.890 --> 01:48:29.239
but identification required more than recognition of an object. Dental
1329
01:48:29.319 --> 01:48:35.579
records supplied the official answer. The remains were Dorothy Jane Scott's.
1330
01:48:36.460 --> 01:48:39.340
For four years, her parents had lived with an absence
1331
01:48:39.890 --> 01:48:45.329
that anonymous callers repeatedly claimed to understand. Now they knew
1332
01:48:45.449 --> 01:48:50.729
where Dorothy had been found. They still didn't know who
1333
01:48:50.829 --> 01:48:54.229
had taken her from the hospital, who had driven her
1334
01:48:54.340 --> 01:48:59.800
station wagon, or who had killed her. The condition of
1335
01:48:59.859 --> 01:49:03.960
the remains prevented investigators from determining a cause of death
1336
01:49:04.439 --> 01:49:09.600
in the reporting that followed. Exposure, soil, time. and the
1337
01:49:09.640 --> 01:49:13.510
later brush fire had affected what was recovered. The evidence
1338
01:49:13.590 --> 01:49:17.789
could give Dorothy back her name, but it couldn't reconstruct
1339
01:49:17.850 -->
01:49:20.989
the missing hours after she walked into the parking lot.
1340
01:49:21.949 --> 01:49:25.470
Jacob and Vera went to a mortuary to arrange their
1341
01:49:25.489 --> 01:49:30.989
daughter's funeral. While they were away, their son Alan answered
1342
01:49:31.050 --> 01:49:37.060
the telephone at the family home. A caller asked, Is
1343
01:49:37.100 --> 01:49:41.770
Dorothy home? According to a register report, there were two
1344
01:49:41.909 --> 01:49:45.989
such calls. Alan received both while Jacob and Vera were
1345
01:49:46.029 --> 01:49:50.739
making the funeral arrangements. Jacob believed the voice belonged to
1346
01:49:50.760 --> 01:49:55.159
the same man who had contacted the family before. No
1347
01:49:55.279 --> 01:50:00.119
public evidence established that identity. The timing made the calls
1348
01:50:00.760 --> 01:50:06.819
especially cruel. Dorothy's remains had just been identified. Her parents
1349
01:50:06.880 --> 01:50:11.020
were arranging a funeral. Someone called the house and asked
1350
01:50:11.079 --> 01:50:14.890
for her as though she might simply come to the telephone.
1351
01:50:15.850 --> 01:50:19.909
For months, the calls had been silent after Jacob answered
1352
01:50:20.069 --> 01:50:24.350
one in the spring. Now, with the parents away and
1353
01:50:24.430 --> 01:50:30.859
another family member answering, the voice appeared to return. The
1354
01:50:30.899 --> 01:50:35.600
family still had no name to attach to it. On
1355
01:50:35.739 --> 01:50:41.489
August 22nd, 52 mourners gathered at Forest Lawn in Cyprus.
1356
01:50:42.289 --> 01:50:47.390
The Los Angeles Times described flowers, a framed photograph of Dorothy,
1357
01:50:47.909 --> 01:50:53.899
and ribbons bearing the words, Sis and Beloved Sister. A
1358
01:50:53.989 --> 01:50:58.260
service had originally been planned for Dorothy's uncle, who had
1359
01:50:58.319 --> 01:51:03.899
died the previous week. The family was now mourning both losses.
1360
01:51:05.220 --> 01:51:09.619
Her brother Jim spoke about Dorothy's generosity and about the
1361
01:51:09.659 --> 01:51:13.220
help she had given other people during her last known hours.
1362
01:51:14.199 --> 01:51:18.789
That detail is important because the final confirmed sequence of
1363
01:51:18.850 --> 01:51:24.569
Dorothy's life did not begin with recklessness or secrecy. It
1364
01:51:24.630 --> 01:51:27.899
began with her taking a sick co-worker to the hospital.
1365
01:51:28.819 --> 01:51:33.359
Her son had been four when she disappeared. He was
1366
01:51:33.539 --> 01:51:37.640
eight years. when her remains were identified, and Jacob and
1367
01:51:37.699 --> 01:51:42.100
Vera were raising him. The discovery ended one kind of
1368
01:51:42.189 --> 01:51:45.909
uncertainty for the family, but it did not provide the
1369
01:51:45.970 --> 01:51:51.510
person responsible or the reason Dorothy had been taken. The
1370
01:51:51.590 --> 01:51:57.060
investigation remained open. At this point, the documented record gives
1371
01:51:57.140 --> 01:52:02.039
way to theory. Any explanation for Dorothy's murder has to
1372
01:52:02.119 --> 01:52:06.500
account for something unusual about that night the trip to
1373
01:52:06.520 --> 01:52:10.640
the hospital we remind you was not planned dorothy did
1374
01:52:10.680 --> 01:52:14.970
not leave work intending to go to uci medical center
1375
01:52:15.619 --> 01:52:18.909
conrad became ill dorothy and pam decided to help him
1376
01:52:19.590 --> 01:52:23.470
and the evening changed course so if the man who
1377
01:52:23.529 --> 01:52:28.250
had been calling dorothy was also responsible for her disappearance
1378
01:52:28.989 --> 01:52:33.420
how did he know where she was One possibility is
1379
01:52:33.460 --> 01:52:36.840
that he did not have to know in advance. He
1380
01:52:36.880 --> 01:52:40.560
may have been following her. If the caller had already
1381
01:52:40.619 --> 01:52:45.060
been watching Dorothy closely enough to describe her movements and
1382
01:52:45.590 --> 01:52:49.229
leave a dead rose on her car, he could conceivably
1383
01:52:49.310 --> 01:52:52.649
have followed her from work, to her parents' house, and
1384
01:52:52.729 --> 01:53:07.029
eventually to the hospital. She walked outside, alone. There is
1385
01:53:07.109 --> 01:53:12.739
another possibility hiding inside the caller's own story. When he
1386
01:53:12.840 --> 01:53:16.760
contacted the newspaper, he claimed Dorothy had been his love,
1387
01:53:17.380 --> 01:53:20.699
and that he had caught her with another man. There
1388
01:53:20.800 --> 01:53:25.789
is no evidence Dorothy was romantically involved with Conrad Bostron.
1389
01:53:26.609 --> 01:53:29.449
She had taken a sick co-worker to an emergency room,
1390
01:53:29.550 --> 01:53:34.039
but an obsessive person watching from a distance... might not
1391
01:53:34.100 --> 01:53:39.739
have understood or cared about the difference. If the caller
1392
01:53:39.800 --> 01:53:44.399
had convinced himself that Dorothy belonged to him, seeing her
1393
01:53:44.510 --> 01:53:47.989
arrive at a hospital with another man could have become
1394
01:53:48.069 --> 01:53:53.909
something entirely different inside his own mind. An ordinary act
1395
01:53:53.970 --> 01:54:00.350
of kindness might have been interpreted as betrayal. That remains speculation.
1396
01:54:01.289 --> 01:54:06.100
So does another possibility, that the newspaper caller really did
1397
01:54:06.199 --> 01:54:11.859
know something about Dorothy's murder, but lied about why it happened.
1398
01:54:12.960 --> 01:54:18.140
He reportedly knew about Conrad's spider bite and Dorothy changing scarves,
1399
01:54:18.640 --> 01:54:22.869
details that gave investigators reason to take the call seriously.
1400
01:54:23.569 --> 01:54:26.890
Yet he also claimed Dorothy had called him on the
1401
01:54:26.949 --> 01:54:32.319
phone from the hospital, something first-hand accounts challenged. Those two
1402
01:54:32.399 --> 01:54:37.220
things can exist together. A person can know genuine details
1403
01:54:37.300 --> 01:54:42.340
and still tell a false story around them. The supposed romance,
1404
01:54:42.439 --> 01:54:47.529
the accusation of cheating, even Dorothy supposedly calling him. Those
1405
01:54:47.609 --> 01:54:51.750
may have been described reality. Or they may have described
1406
01:54:51.850 --> 01:54:56.569
the reality the caller wanted everyone else to believe. And
1407
01:54:56.630 --> 01:55:02.260
that distinction remains unsolved. More than 40 years later, the
1408
01:55:02.380 --> 01:55:07.239
Orange County Sheriff's Department still describes the unidentified man who
1409
01:55:07.659 --> 01:55:12.590
repeatedly called Dorothy and her family as a potential murder suspect.
1410
01:55:13.529 --> 01:55:18.170
But they still don't know his name. Today, the Orange
1411
01:55:18.210 --> 01:55:22.630
County Sheriff's Department continues to list Dorothy's death among its
1412
01:55:23.029 --> 01:55:28.710
homicide cold cases. Its account describes the unidentified caller as
1413
01:55:28.770 --> 01:55:33.979
a potential suspect and asks for new leads. That language
1414
01:55:34.100 --> 01:55:37.640
is telling. The calls are central to the case, but
1415
01:55:38.079 --> 01:55:42.760
the public record does not conclusively establish that every call
1416
01:55:42.859 --> 01:55:46.619
came from the same person, or that the man who
1417
01:55:46.680 --> 01:55:51.920
made them was necessarily Dorothy's killer. What can be established
1418
01:55:52.300 --> 01:55:58.199
is disturbing enough. Before Dorothy disappeared, an unidentified man called
1419
01:55:58.239 --> 01:56:02.229
her at work. claimed to know her movements, left a
1420
01:56:02.310 --> 01:56:05.710
dead rose on her car, according to her mother's account,
1421
01:56:06.430 --> 01:56:11.270
and threatened violence. On May 28th, Dorothy took a sick
1422
01:56:11.409 --> 01:56:15.409
co-worker to the UCI Medical Center. Near midnight, she went
1423
01:56:15.470 --> 01:56:19.470
outside to bring her station wagon closer. Her friends then
1424
01:56:19.550 --> 01:56:24.449
saw the car leave beneath headlights that prevented useful identification
1425
01:56:24.489 --> 01:56:28.409
of the driver. Then, hours later, the Toyota was found burning,
1426
01:56:29.050 --> 01:56:33.899
in Santa Ana. After Dorothy vanished, the anonymous calls reached
1427
01:56:33.920 --> 01:56:37.640
her family. One man claimed to have her, a caller
1428
01:56:37.680 --> 01:56:40.500
to the newspaper claimed to have killed her, and new
1429
01:56:40.579 --> 01:56:45.760
details reportedly absent from the first article, while also making
1430
01:56:45.819 --> 01:56:50.079
a claim about a hospital phone call that Pam disputed.
1431
01:56:51.079 --> 01:56:55.500
The family continued receiving calls for years, then Dorothy's remains
1432
01:56:55.539 --> 01:56:59.529
were found in Anaheim Hills and two
more calls reportedly
1433
01:56:59.590 --> 01:57:02.930
reached the house while her parents were arranging her funeral.
1434
01:57:03.970 --> 01:57:08.260
Those are all of the known points. The threats, the hospital,
1435
01:57:08.319 --> 01:57:12.380
the departing car, the burned Toyota, the calls, and the remains.
1436
01:57:13.260 --> 01:57:17.729
What connects those points has never been established, not publicly.
1437
01:57:18.529 --> 01:57:22.010
The discovery site added one more location to the map
1438
01:57:22.109 --> 01:57:26.050
of the case. The hospital in Orange, the burned car
1439
01:57:26.130 --> 01:57:29.600
in Santa Ana, and the remains in Anaheim Hills were
1440
01:57:29.720 --> 01:57:34.739
all real places investigators could examine. What the evidence could
1441
01:57:34.800 --> 01:57:38.970
not supply was the route between them, or the moment
1442
01:57:39.010 --> 01:57:44.069
when Dorothy's movements stopped being her own. There is a
1443
01:57:44.149 --> 01:57:47.649
temptation in an unsolved case to let the unknown person
1444
01:57:47.689 --> 01:57:52.069
become the center of the story. The caller's words are
1445
01:57:52.109 --> 01:57:56.029
dramatic because he chose when to appear, what to claim,
1446
01:57:56.189 --> 01:58:00.569
and when to hang up, but his anonymity should not
1447
01:58:00.670 --> 01:58:07.710
give him ownership of Dorothy's story. Dorothy was a mother, daughter, sister, co-worker,
1448
01:58:07.909 --> 01:58:12.100
and friend. She worked... cared for her son, stayed close
1449
01:58:12.159 --> 01:58:17.220
to her family, and took precautions when someone began frightening her.
1450
01:58:18.300 --> 01:58:21.619
On her final known night, she saw that a co-worker
1451
01:58:21.680 --> 01:58:25.899
needed help and drove him to the hospital. Then, when
1452
01:58:25.939 --> 01:58:30.060
it was time to leave, She offered one more small kindness.
1453
01:58:31.000 --> 01:58:33.560
Conrad had just been treated and did not need to
1454
01:58:33.600 --> 01:58:37.779
walk far. Dorothy went to bring the car closer anyway.
1455
01:58:38.960 --> 01:58:43.229
Her friends saw the station wagon leave, and they were
1456
01:58:43.310 --> 01:58:57.340
still waiting for Dorothy. The Stolen Masterpieces of the Gardner
1457
01:58:57.399 --> 01:59:02.979
Museum Heist On the night of March 18, 1990, the
1458
01:59:03.079 --> 01:59:08.100
Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston was transformed from a
1459
01:59:08.159 --> 01:59:12.439
place of artistic wonder into the site of one of
1460
01:59:12.500 --> 01:59:17.270
the most infamous heists in history. Two men disguised as
1461
01:59:17.319 --> 01:59:21.289
police officers gained access to the museum under the cover
1462
01:59:21.489 --> 01:59:26.470
of darkness. What followed was a brazen robbery that would
1463
01:59:26.550 --> 01:59:33.909
see 13 invaluable works of art stolen, including masterpieces by Rembrandt, Vermeer,
1464
01:59:34.350 --> 01:59:40.039
and Degas, and left the art world reeling. In the
1465
01:59:40.079 --> 01:59:43.880
hours after the crime, investigators were left with little more
1466
01:59:44.420 --> 01:59:49.489
than question. The stolen artwork, valued at hundreds of millions
1467
01:59:49.529 --> 01:59:55.960
of dollars, vanished without a trace. the Isabella Stewart Gardner
1468
01:59:56.000 --> 02:00:00.560
Museum heist remains a chilling mystery. And what happened to
1469
02:00:00.579 --> 02:00:06.590
the stolen masterpieces? The unanswered questions continue to haunt investigators,
1470
02:00:07.060 --> 02:00:13.729
the museum, and art enthusiasts around the world. The Isabella
1471
02:00:13.789 --> 02:00:17.909
Stewart Gardner Museum was constructed under the guidance and vision
1472
02:00:18.649 --> 02:00:23.140
of their namesake, an art collector who dedicated her life
1473
02:00:23.659 --> 02:00:29.159
to assembling an extraordinary personal art collection. Gardner was an
1474
02:00:29.220 --> 02:00:33.159
influential figure in the art world, known for her deep
1475
02:00:33.239 --> 02:00:38.289
appreciation of beauty and culture. She was an American art
1476
02:00:38.329 --> 02:00:42.289
collector as well as philanthropist and a respected patron of
1477
02:00:42.329 --> 02:00:46.760
the arts. Her passion for art and her desire to
1478
02:00:46.840 --> 02:00:49.979
share it with others led to the establishment of the
1479
02:00:50.020 --> 02:00:54.869
museum in Boston. She aimed to create a unique and
1480
02:00:54.989 --> 02:00:59.850
intimate environment where visitors could engage with masterpieces from around
1481
02:00:59.890 --> 02:01:05.609
the world, displayed not in the traditional gallery style, but
1482
02:01:06.069 --> 02:01:11.569
in a way that reflected her personal aesthetic and artistic philosophy.
1483
02:01:13.100 --> 02:01:18.140
Gardner's pursuit of art was driven by her energetic intellectual curiosity,
1484
02:01:18.859 --> 02:01:24.319
an adventurous spirit, and her privileged financial position. Her wealth
1485
02:01:24.399 --> 02:01:29.159
allowed her to travel extensively, collecting rare and valuable artworks
1486
02:01:29.220 --> 02:01:35.369
from Europe, Asia, and beyond. These travels exposed her to
1487
02:01:35.409 --> 02:01:42.869
diverse cultures and artistic traditions, shaping her distinctive taste. Gardner
1488
02:01:42.909 --> 02:01:46.720
was not only a collector, but a well-connected figure in
1489
02:01:46.840 --> 02:01:51.949
artistry and literary circles. She formed close friendships with some
1490
02:01:51.989 --> 02:01:55.010
of the most notable artists and writers of her time,
1491
02:01:55.770 --> 02:02:01.640
including painter John Singer Sargent, artist James McNeill Whistler, landscape
1492
02:02:01.699 --> 02:02:08.020
painter Dennis Miller Bunker, Swedish artist Anders Zorn, novelist Henry James,
1493
02:02:08.600 --> 02:02:15.140
watercolorist Dodge McKnight, Japanese art historian Okura Kakuzo, and novelist
1494
02:02:15.220 --> 02:02:21.880
Francis Marion Crawford. These relationships influenced her collecting habits and
1495
02:02:21.960 --> 02:02:27.760
inspired her approach to arranging her museum's displays. The museum,
1496
02:02:27.840 --> 02:02:32.840
designed to resemble a 15th century Venetian palace, officially opened
1497
02:02:32.880 --> 02:02:38.369
to the public in 1903. Gardner oversaw every detail of
1498
02:02:38.409 --> 02:02:44.869
the museum's construction and interior arrangement. She carefully curated the collection,
1499
02:02:45.529 --> 02:02:51.829
arranging the artworks, sculptures, tapestries, and decorative objects, according to
1500
02:02:51.890 --> 02:02:56.489
her vision. Each room was designed to offer visitors a
1501
02:02:56.529 --> 02:03:03.779
multi-sensory experience, blending visual art with architectural elements and lush gardens.
1502
02:03:04.659 --> 02:03:07.640
Gardner believed that the setting in which art was viewed
1503
02:03:08.060 --> 02:03:13.409
was as important as the art itself. Her unconventional approach
1504
02:03:13.770 --> 02:03:18.520
defied the rigid display methods commonly used by museums of
1505
02:03:18.569 --> 02:03:23.880
her time, creating an atmosphere that invited personal reflection and
1506
02:03:23.920 --> 02:03:30.640
emotional connection with the pieces. In 1919, Gardner's health began
1507
02:03:30.699 --> 02:03:38.500
to decline after suffering the first series of strokes. Though
1508
02:03:38.579 --> 02:03:42.779
her physical condition weakened, she continued to reside in her
1509
02:03:42.840 --> 02:03:47.880
private quarters on the museum's fourth floor. Her connection to
1510
02:03:47.920 --> 02:03:51.619
the museum remained strong as it was not only her legacy,
1511
02:03:52.239 --> 02:03:56.199
but also her home. Over the next few years, her
1512
02:03:56.270 --> 02:04:03.289
health continued to worsen until she passed away on July 17, 1924,
1513
02:04:03.289 --> 02:04:06.890
at the age of 84. She was laid to rest
1514
02:04:06.970 --> 02:04:11.319
in the Gardner family tomb at Mount Auburn Cemetery a
1515
02:04:11.359 --> 02:04:17.340
historic resting place situated between Watertown and Cambridge, Massachusetts. She
1516
02:04:17.399 --> 02:04:22.300
was buried alongside her husband, Jack Gardner, and their only child,
1517
02:04:22.819 --> 02:04:28.770
who died in infancy. Upon her death, Gardner left behind
1518
02:04:28.909 --> 02:04:32.970
not only an artistic treasure, but also a clear vision
1519
02:04:33.430 --> 02:04:40.060
for its preservation. She provided a $ 3. 6 million endowment, to
1520
02:04:40.119 --> 02:04:45.939
secure the museum's future. Her will included strict instructions. The
1521
02:04:46.000 --> 02:04:50.840
collection was to remain precisely as she arranged it. This
1522
02:04:50.920 --> 02:04:55.729
requirement ensured that her vision would be preserved for generations,
1523
02:04:56.369 --> 02:05:00.949
making the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum a timeless reflection of
1524
02:05:00.989 --> 02:05:06.050
her passion for art, her personal taste, and her unwavering
1525
02:05:06.109 --> 02:05:12.119
dedication to creating a cultural sanctuary in Boston. However, in
1526
02:05:12.159 --> 02:05:26.619
the years to come, financial challenges would arise. By the 1980s,
1527
02:05:26.689 --> 02:05:31.890
the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum was grappling with serious financial
1528
02:05:31.949 --> 02:05:37.460
difficulties that affected nearly every aspect of its operations. The
1529
02:05:37.520 --> 02:05:41.810
endowment left by Gardner had significantly declined in value over
1530
02:05:41.859 --> 02:05:46.850
the years, leaving the museum struggling to cover its operational costs.
1531
02:05:48.090 --> 02:05:51.729
Lack of sufficient funds led to a noticeable decline in
1532
02:05:51.770 --> 02:05:57.170
the building's condition, with essential maintenance being delayed or ignored.
1533
02:05:58.310 --> 02:06:02.579
The museum did not have a climate control system, placing
1534
02:06:02.619 --> 02:06:07.409
its valuable collection at risk of damage... from fluctuating temperatures
1535
02:06:07.869 --> 02:06:13.569
and humidity. Additionally, the museum was operating without an insurance policy,
1536
02:06:14.310 --> 02:06:18.350
meaning that any damage to or theft of its artwork
1537
02:06:18.909 --> 02:06:24.659
would result in an irreparable financial loss. These financial constraints
1538
02:06:24.739 --> 02:06:30.199
left the institution vulnerable, both structurally and in terms of
1539
02:06:30.300 --> 02:06:36.840
safeguarding its priceless collection. Concerns about the museum's security heightened
1540
02:06:37.119 --> 02:06:41.199
in 1982 when the FBI uncovered a plot by a
1541
02:06:41.270 --> 02:06:46.369
group of Boston criminals to rob the museum. This alarming
1542
02:06:46.430 --> 02:06:52.829
development prompted museum officials to prioritize security improvements despite the
1543
02:06:52.949 --> 02:06:59.399
ongoing financial strain. Funds were redirected to install 60 infrared
1544
02:06:59.479 --> 02:07:04.710
motion detectors throughout the building, and a closed-circuit television system,
1545
02:07:05.350 --> 02:07:11.069
with four cameras positioned around the museum's exterior. However, the
1546
02:07:11.140 --> 02:07:16.359
Board of Trustees deemed the installation of interior cameras too costly,
1547
02:07:17.020 --> 02:07:22.439
given the museum's budgetary limitations. Instead, they opted to increase
1548
02:07:22.479 --> 02:07:27.600
the number of security guards monitoring the premises. These upgrades
1549
02:07:27.680 --> 02:07:32.380
marked an improvement, but the absence of internal surveillance left
1550
02:07:32.479 --> 02:07:37.939
significant gaps in the security system. Despite the adjustments, the
1551
02:07:37.960 --> 02:07:45.199
museum's security remained notably inadequate compared to other institutions. The
1552
02:07:45.300 -->
02:07:48.939
only means for guards to alert the police were by
1553
02:07:49.069 --> 02:07:54.010
pressing an emergency button located at the security desk. Unlike
1554
02:07:54.090 --> 02:07:59.149
neighboring museums that had more comprehensive systems requiring night watchmen
1555
02:07:59.189 --> 02:08:02.560
to place hourly calls to local law enforcement as a
1556
02:08:02.600 --> 02:08:07.579
safety check, the Gardner Museum relied solely on this single-point
1557
02:08:07.659 --> 02:08:13.760
alarm system. This approach left the museum particularly exposed during
1558
02:08:13.840 --> 02:08:18.060
overnight hours, as any failure to reach the security desk
1559
02:08:18.649 --> 02:08:25.539
could delay a response to suspicious activity. In 1988, recognizing
1560
02:08:25.579 --> 02:08:31.039
the ongoing concerns, museum officials sought an evaluation from an
1561
02:08:31.100 --> 02:08:37.189
independent security consultant. The review concluded that the museum's security
1562
02:08:37.229 --> 02:08:42.189
measures were generally on par with those of similar institutions,
1563
02:08:42.729 --> 02:08:47.930
but recommended additional upgrades to strengthen its defenses. Around the
1564
02:08:47.989 --> 02:08:51.550
same time, the security director at the Museum of Fine
1565
02:08:51.609 --> 02:08:56.390
Arts in Boston also advised Gardner Museum officials to implement
1566
02:08:56.510 --> 02:09:03.300
further security improvements. However, the board of trustees, facing persistent
1567
02:09:03.399 --> 02:09:09.060
financial limitations and adhering to Isabella Stewart Gardner's directive against
1568
02:09:09.140 --> 02:09:15.199
making significant alterations to the building, ultimately decided against pursuing
1569
02:09:15.260 --> 02:09:22.720
these recommendations. The museum's staffing situation further compounded these vulnerabilities.
1570
02:09:23.479 --> 02:09:27.800
The security director requested increased wages for guards in an
1571
02:09:27.880 --> 02:09:33.779
effort to attract and retain more qualified personnel. This proposal
1572
02:09:33.859 --> 02:09:38.250
was rejected by the board, leaving guards earning only slightly
1573
02:09:38.329 --> 02:09:42.909
above minimum wage. As a result, many of the security
1574
02:09:42.970 --> 02:09:47.840
staff were inexperienced and lacked the training necessary to handle
1575
02:09:47.899 --> 02:09:54.699
sophisticated threats. The museum's security shortcomings became widely known among
1576
02:09:54.739 --> 02:09:59.090
the guards, creating an environment where internal knowledge of these
1577
02:09:59.189 --> 02:10:05.890
weaknesses could potentially be exploited. These unresolved issues left the
1578
02:10:05.930 --> 02:10:11.329
Gardner Museum in a precarious position, relying heavily on underpaid
1579
02:10:11.430 --> 02:10:17.760
staff and an incomplete security system. to protect its priceless collection.
1580
02:10:18.819 --> 02:10:24.220
Everything appeared routine at the
Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum until
1581
02:10:24.279 --> 02:10:30.729
the early morning hours of Sunday, March 18, 1990, when
1582
02:10:30.770 --> 02:10:37.449
an unprecedented crime unfolded. At approximately 12.30 a.m., a group
1583
02:10:37.489 --> 02:10:41.949
of St. Patrick's Day partygoers making their way home noticed
1584
02:10:42.050 --> 02:10:46.520
two men sitting inside a parked hatchback. along Palace Road,
1585
02:10:47.050 --> 02:10:51.970
near the museum's side entrance. The men wore police uniforms,
1586
02:10:52.529 --> 02:10:56.789
and their presence seemed ordinary to the revelers, who assumed
1587
02:10:56.829 --> 02:11:00.949
the officers were responding to a disturbance common on a
1588
02:11:01.029 --> 02:11:06.840
night of heavy celebrations. Inside the museum, two guards were
1589
02:11:06.920 --> 02:11:12.020
on duty, 23-year-old Rick Abbath, a regular night watchman, and
1590
02:11:12.039 --> 02:11:18.159
25-year-old Randy Hestand. working his first night shift. Their routine
1591
02:11:18.239 --> 02:11:22.420
involved one guard patrolling the galleries while the other remained
1592
02:11:22.479 --> 02:11:27.819
at the security desk. During Abbott's patrol, fire alarms suddenly
1593
02:11:27.880 --> 02:11:31.760
went off in several rooms, but he found no signs
1594
02:11:31.840 --> 02:11:36.689
of fire. Believing it was a system malfunction, he turned
1595
02:11:36.810 --> 02:11:41.550
off the alarms and continued his rounds. Before returning to
1596
02:11:41.569 --> 02:11:45.720
the desk, he briefly opened and closed the side door
1597
02:11:46.310 --> 02:11:52.829
without notifying Hestand. At 1.20 a.m., the disguised men approached
1598
02:11:52.890 --> 02:11:56.670
the side entrance and rang the buzzer, claiming to be
1599
02:11:56.710 --> 02:12:02.170
the police investigating a disturbance. Abath saw their uniforms on
1600
02:12:02.189 --> 02:12:06.010
the security camera and, assuming it was related to the St.
1601
02:12:06.050 --> 02:12:11.460
Patrick's Day festivities, allowed them inside. Once in the foyer,
1602
02:12:12.090 --> 02:12:16.109
they asked Abbath to call Hestand back to the security desk.
1603
02:12:16.810 --> 02:12:21.760
It was then Abbath noticed one man's mustache appeared to
1604
02:12:21.800 --> 02:12:26.680
be fake. But before he could react, the men claimed
1605
02:12:26.760 --> 02:12:30.020
he was wanted on a warrant and ordered him away
1606
02:12:30.100 --> 02:12:35.189
from the desk. As Abbath stepped out, one intruder pushed
1607
02:12:35.229 --> 02:12:39.909
him against a wall and handcuffed him. When Hestand arrived,
1608
02:12:40.470 --> 02:12:44.600
he was restrained in the same way. The thieves then
1609
02:12:44.680 --> 02:12:49.039
revealed their true intentions, taping the guards' heads and eyes
1610
02:12:49.140 --> 02:12:52.539
before leading them to the basement, where they were handcuffed
1611
02:12:52.600 --> 02:12:56.579
to a pipe. The intruders warned the guards not
to
1612
02:12:56.640 --> 02:13:00.619
alert authorities and hinted they would be rewarded if they
1613
02:13:00.659 --> 02:13:06.090
stayed quiet. Within 15 minutes, the guards were subdued and
1614
02:13:06.130 --> 02:13:10.939
the stage was set for the theft. The thieves' path
1615
02:13:10.979 --> 02:13:15.310
through the museum was tracked by infrared motion detectors, providing
1616
02:13:15.369 --> 02:13:19.670
investigators with a detailed timeline of their movements. It was
1617
02:13:19.729 --> 02:13:24.770
not until 1.48 a.m., 13 minutes after restraining the guards,
1618
02:13:25.390 --> 02:13:28.109
that the first motion was recorded in the Dutch room
1619
02:13:28.609 --> 02:13:33.090
on the second floor. This delay led authorities to believe
1620
02:13:33.149 --> 02:13:36.649
that the thieves likely waited to ensure no police had
1621
02:13:36.670 --> 02:13:42.199
been alerted before beginning their operation. Upon entering the Dutch room,
1622
02:13:42.779 --> 02:13:46.039
a sensor designed to warn when visitors got too close
1623
02:13:46.079 --> 02:13:51.090
to the artwork activated, prompting the thieves to smash it.
1624
02:13:52.659 --> 02:13:57.109
Once inside, the thieves wasted no time targeting valuable pieces.
1625
02:13:57.949 --> 02:14:01.010
They removed the Storm of the Sea of Galilee and
1626
02:14:01.050 --> 02:14:04.810
A Lady and a Gentleman in Black, throwing both onto
1627
02:14:04.850 --> 02:14:09.909
the marble floor, shattering their glass frames. Using a blade,
1628
02:14:10.300 --> 02:14:14.159
they cut the paintings from their stretchers. They also removed
1629
02:14:14.239 --> 02:14:18.000
a large self-portrait oil painting by Rembrandt from the wall,
1630
02:14:18.579 --> 02:14:22.350
but left it leaning against a cabinet, likely due to
1631
02:14:22.430 --> 02:14:26.949
its size and wooden backing. Instead, they took a small
1632
02:14:27.050 --> 02:14:31.909
self-portrait etching by Rembrandt that was displayed beneath the larger painting.
1633
02:14:32.819 --> 02:14:36.819
The thieves continued by cutting landscape with obelisk and the
1634
02:14:36.880 --> 02:14:40.239
concert from their frames. and they also took an ancient
1635
02:14:40.300 --> 02:14:46.159
Chinese gu, a bronze vessel. While one thief continued looting
1636
02:14:46.220 --> 02:14:49.420
the Dutch room, the other moved into the short gallery,
1637
02:14:50.079 --> 02:14:54.359
located on the opposite end of the second floor. Eventually,
1638
02:14:54.439 --> 02:14:58.850
both men worked together in this narrow hallway. They began
1639
02:14:58.970 --> 02:15:03.710
unscrewing a frame holding a Napoleonic flag, appearing to intend
1640
02:15:03.750 --> 02:15:08.840
to steal it, but ultimately abandoning the effort. Instead, They
1641
02:15:08.899 --> 02:15:14.020
took only the eagle-shaped finial from the top of the flagpole. Additionally,
1642
02:15:14.100 --> 02:15:19.229
they seized five sketches by Edgar Degas. On the first floor,
1643
02:15:19.810 --> 02:15:26.289
the final piece stolen was Che Tortoni from the Blue Room. Strangely,
1644
02:15:26.750 --> 02:15:30.789
the museum's motion detectors recorded no activity in the Blue
1645
02:15:30.869 --> 02:15:35.590
Room during the heist. Only Abath's footsteps had been detected
1646
02:15:36.189 --> 02:15:48.619
earlier during his patrol. Before leaving, the thieves checked on
1647
02:15:48.659 --> 02:15:53.649
the guards, asking if they were comfortable. They then entered
1648
02:15:53.689 --> 02:15:58.750
the security director's office, seizing the videotapes that contained footage
1649
02:15:58.810 --> 02:16:03.979
of their entry and data printouts from the motion detectors. However,
1650
02:16:04.680 --> 02:16:09.020
they overlooked a hard drive that had also recorded movement data.
1651
02:16:10.039 --> 02:16:13.500
The empty frame of Shea Tortoni was left on the
1652
02:16:13.539 --> 02:16:19.260
security director's desk, At 2.40 a.m., the side entrance doors
1653
02:16:19.300 --> 02:16:24.460
were opened, and again at 2.45 a.m., marking their final
1654
02:16:24.500 --> 02:16:31.100
departure after 81 minutes inside the museum. Later that morning,
1655
02:16:31.159 --> 02:16:34.659
the next shift of guards arrived and found they could
1656
02:16:34.700 --> 02:16:39.719
not gain access. When their calls went unanswered, they contacted
1657
02:16:39.760 --> 02:16:44.049
the security director, who unlocked the building and discovered the
1658
02:16:44.120 --> 02:16:48.819
empty watch desk Police were summoned, and a search revealed
1659
02:16:49.000 --> 02:16:54.370
Abbott and Hestand still bound in the basement. In total,
1660
02:16:54.370 --> 02:16:58.930
13 works of art had been stolen, initially valued at
1661
02:16:58.930 --> 02:17:04.840
$ 200 million by the FBI in 1990. The estimated worth
1662
02:17:04.899 --> 02:17:10.209
increased to $ 500 million by 2000. By the late 2000s,
1663
02:17:10.350 --> 02:17:13.989
some art dealers speculated the stolen works could be worth
1664
02:17:14.069 --> 02:17:18.850
as much as $ 600 million. It remains the most valuable
1665
02:17:18.930 --> 02:17:24.819
museum heist in history. The FBI swiftly took control of
1666
02:17:24.860 --> 02:17:30.000
the investigation, suspecting that the stolen artworks could be transported
1667
02:17:30.079 --> 02:17:35.360
across state lines. However, the case proved challenging due to
1668
02:17:35.399 --> 02:17:40.659
the lack of concrete physical evidence. It remains uncertain whether
1669
02:17:40.700 --> 02:17:45.510
the thieves left behind any DNA, and although fingerprints and
1670
02:17:45.610 --> 02:17:50.479
footprints were found, they couldn't be definitively linked to the crime. criminals,
1671
02:17:51.190 --> 02:17:55.659
as they could have belonged to museum staff. As forensic
1672
02:17:55.700 --> 02:18:01.559
technology evolved over time, the FBI pursued DNA analysis, but
1673
02:18:01.700 --> 02:18:05.940
some of the evidence
went missing within the agency's records,
1674
02:18:06.700 --> 02:18:13.639
complicating the investigation further. Witnesses provided descriptions of the two thieves.
1675
02:18:14.520 --> 02:18:17.559
One was described as around 5 feet 9 inches to
1676
02:18:17.559 --> 02:18:22.079
5 feet 10 inches tall, with a medium build, likely
1677
02:18:22.120 --> 02:18:24.899
in his late 30s, while the other stood about 6
1678
02:18:24.899 --> 02:18:28.219
feet tall, with a heavier build, and appeared to be
1679
02:18:28.260 --> 02:18:33.729
in his early 30s. In 2015, the FBI released footage
1680
02:18:33.790 --> 02:18:37.129
from the night before the heist, showing Abbott letting an
1681
02:18:37.209 --> 02:18:40.690
unidentified man into the museum to speak with him at
1682
02:18:40.729 --> 02:18:45.409
the security desk. Abbott claimed not to remember the interaction
1683
02:18:46.149 --> 02:18:51.709
or recognize the man. Later on, former museum employees identified
1684
02:18:51.770 --> 02:18:56.770
the man as the museum's deputy security chief, casting doubt
1685
02:18:57.090 --> 02:19:01.530
on the significance of the footage. Throughout his life, Abbott
1686
02:19:01.590 --> 02:19:05.719
maintained his innocence and denied any involvement in the theft.
1687
02:19:06.680 --> 02:19:12.260
He passed away in 2024, at the age of 57.
1688
02:19:12.440 --> 02:19:17.829
Despite extensive investigations, the stolen artworks, now worth hundreds of
1689
02:19:17.950 --> 02:19:24.569
millions of dollars, remain missing. Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum continues
1690
02:19:24.610 --> 02:19:30.250
to offer a $ 10 million reward for information that leads
1691
02:19:30.350 --> 02:19:36.299
to their return. The FBI has relied heavily on informants, interrogations,
1692
02:19:36.729 --> 02:19:42.469
and undercover operations to track down leads. But progress has
1693
02:19:42.530 --> 02:19:47.930
been slow. Investigators suspect the robbery was masterminded by a
1694
02:19:48.030 --> 02:19:53.479
criminal organization. The FBI's focus has been on the Boston Mafia,
1695
02:19:54.159 --> 02:19:57.559
which was in the midst of internal conflict at the time.
1696
02:19:58.459 --> 02:20:03.239
One theory suggests that gangster Bobby Donati orchestrated the heist
1697
02:20:03.889 --> 02:20:07.209
in order to negotiate the release of a key associate
1698
02:20:07.709 --> 02:20:12.690
from prison. Donati was murdered a year later, only adding
1699
02:20:12.750 --> 02:20:18.440
to the mystery. Another possibility involves a gang from Boston's
1700
02:20:18.479 --> 02:20:24.319
Dorchester neighborhood. Although no members have admitted involvement, despite several
1701
02:20:24.360 --> 02:20:30.620
individuals facing sentences after a sting operation, The Isabella Stewart
1702
02:20:30.680 --> 02:20:34.989
Gardner Museum heist remains one of the most perplexing crimes
1703
02:20:35.190 --> 02:20:40.489
in history. The mystery of how two thieves pulled off
1704
02:20:40.569 --> 02:20:45.430
such a sophisticated and daring robbery and the whereabouts of
1705
02:20:45.450 --> 02:20:49.670
the priceless artworks continues to haunt law enforcement and the
1706
02:20:49.770 --> 02:20:55.059
art world alike. The theft not only shattered the museum's
1707
02:20:55.159 --> 02:20:59.469
sense of security, but also left a lasting scar on
1708
02:20:59.500 --> 02:21:05.270
the families and communities connected to the stolen works. The
1709
02:21:05.329 --> 02:21:07.909
sense of loss is not just in the absence of
1710
02:21:07.950 --> 02:21:12.620
the art, but in the unanswered questions that linger with
1711
02:21:12.780 --> 02:21:19.280
every passing year. The leaves outside can explain a rustle,
1712
02:21:19.379 --> 02:21:23.500
but they can't explain a stranger who seems to know
1713
02:21:23.579 --> 02:21:29.059
your personal routine. Tonight's stories leave us with the people
1714
02:21:29.100 --> 02:21:33.270
who endured that fear, the evidence they left behind, and
1715
02:21:33.350 --> 02:21:38.270
the questions that deserve careful answers. Thank you for spending
1716
02:21:38.329 --> 02:21:42.069
this autumn evening with me. If you'd like more Company
1717
02:21:42.209 --> 02:21:47.090
After Dark, follow Weekly Spooky wherever you listen. I'm your
1718
02:21:47.129 --> 02:21:50.370
host and narrator Enrique Couto, and I hope the rest
1719
02:21:50.409 --> 02:21:55.590
of your night is wonderfully uneventful. Put the kettle on.
1720
02:21:56.129 --> 02:22:00.489
Pull the curtains and enjoy a little ordinary quiet. And
1721
02:22:00.569 --> 02:22:04.989
if that old telephone rings after midnight, I believe the
1722
02:22:05.149 --> 02:22:11.040
equally antiquated answering machine still works too. Next time.