ကူးယူချက် 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: The other thing about Ben Carroll is I don't really know how he gets out of bed every morning at the moment. I mean, it's just getting worse.
00:00:05
Speaker 2: I suppose on the basis that he's not going to be doing it for very long.
00:00:08
Speaker 1: It just gets worse and worse and worse.
00:00:10
Speaker 2: Go on.
00:00:11
Speaker 1: Well, I mean, we just.
00:00:13
Speaker 2: Well, the polls are terrible. The polls are awful. No one I speak to inside the ALP who's privy to what we might call the relevant information is pretending that they're heading for anything other than a flogging.
00:00:27
Speaker 1: Yeah, they are. I mean, some of them are actively preparing for opposition.
00:00:32
Speaker 2: Now. Welcome back to The Splash, the Herald Science Podcast on all things state politics. With, I don't know, quite a bit less than one month to go, the polling seems to suggest that there are very, very hurty things heading Labor's way at a rate of knots. Shannon Deary, what has been happening?
00:00:59
Speaker 1: Well, I think if you look at the last three polls we've published, it appears to be game over. I know there's still three weeks to go until polling day, but early polls open next week. So we're a week away from people beginning to cast their votes. We know that 50% of people will vote before November 28, and Labor are just falling further and further behind.
00:01:21
Speaker 2: So what are the numbers in these polls that have been published?
00:01:24
Speaker 1: Well, the first poll we had had Labor at a primary vote share of 22%.
00:01:27
Speaker 2: That was the Lighthouse poll, which is an internal News Corp poll. We've got our own pollster now. Then we had what?
00:01:35
Speaker 1: Then we had the Demos poll on Monday, which had Labor at 18%.
00:01:40
Speaker 2: That's no good.
00:01:42
Speaker 1: Then we had another Demos poll, which was a seat poll of the seat of Pakenham, which had Labor at 14%. I mean, this is really... This is no good. diet time.
00:01:52
Speaker 2: So... That Pakenham seat poll, run through the primaries in that.
00:01:58
Speaker 1: So we had, Pakenham, of course, is the seat that Warren Pickering, the leader of One Nation, is trying to win. He polled 40% of first votes, primary votes.
00:02:11
Speaker 2: Good.
00:02:12
Speaker 1: The coalition liberal candidate there polled 23. Labor was 14. The Greens were 13. And then there's a whole bunch of, independence.
00:02:22
Speaker 2: And so what is what is labor plus greens plus the coalition it's about.
00:02:26
Speaker 1: 14 to 13 is 27 and 23 is uh 50 so so on those numbers while it looks good on the surface for warren.
00:02:36
Speaker 2: And he's close but no cigar yeah and this is going to happen all over the place yeah i suspect yeah we have this weird situation in which the preference system that we having this country is going to favour the Liberal Party for once. It usually works against it. It's interesting, too, that we're looking at a seat that Labor hold. They're now being knocked into third place.
00:03:01
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, there's... I mean, I think there's different reasons for that in Pakenham. Obviously, you've got the overall anti-government, anti-Labor sentiment that is here in this election. You've also got a retiring MP in Emma Vaughan. So there's no incumbency... you know, fresh candidate for Labor. So they lose that sort of benefit as well.
00:03:22
Speaker 2: Yeah, it's terrible. It's diabolical. It's also part of a narrative that if you talk to pollsters, they all seem to agree on, which is that however many seats One Nation wins, whether it's six, seven, eight, four, whatever, the general view of people I speak to is that most of those seats are going to come off the ALP, not the coalition.
00:03:45
Speaker 1: Mm. I mean, at this point, you have to wonder, A, why Ben Carroll took the job from Justin Durant.
00:03:54
Speaker 2: Well, his fans say, because it would have been worse. Have you heard that? Yeah, yes.
00:04:00
Speaker 1: But I don't think there's any evidence for that at this point.
00:04:03
Speaker 2: Well, there can't be any evidence one way or the other. It's only what you want to believe. No, it's true.
00:04:07
Speaker 1: But, you know, other people say, well, he stemmed the bleeding. Again, you can't know one way or the other. But he certainly hasn't stopped the decline yet. in support for Labor. The other thing about Ben Carroll is I don't really know how he gets out of bed every morning at the moment. I mean, it's just getting worse.
00:04:23
Speaker 2: I suppose on the basis that he's not going to be doing it for very long.
00:04:26
Speaker 1: It just gets worse and worse and worse.
00:04:28
Speaker 2: Go on.
00:04:29
Speaker 1: Well, I mean, we're just.
00:04:31
Speaker 2: Well, the polls are terrible. The polls are awful. No one I speak to inside the ALP who's privy to what we might call the relevant information is pretending that they're heading for anything other than a flogging.
00:04:45
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, some of them are actively preparing for opposition now.
00:04:51
Speaker 2: What does that involve?
00:04:52
Speaker 1: Well, just the sort of the idea that we need to save as much as we can seat-wise so that we're actually an effective opposition. If they're obliterated, then what good are they and how many terms do they spend in opposition?
00:05:07
Speaker 2: Someone made a joke to me, another journalist from another newspaper, said after reading there was a poll in the other newspaper, which was very similar to the White House one, and had One Nation well ahead of the Labor on primary vote, said, well, at least there's now a decent argument for why Warren has to be in the debate, because on these numbers, he's going to be the opposition leader after the election.
00:05:36
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, we've written about this, you know, in our paper, the fact that it would be possible. Now, when we wrote that, Cos
Load full transcript
Samaras came out and said it was ridiculous and that there is no chance that Warren could be the opposition leader.
00:05:53
Speaker 2: I still don't think that there is either, but, you know.
00:05:56
Speaker 1: No, no. But, you know, the polling is good for One Nation. I think better than they thought it would be.
00:06:06
Speaker 2: At this point. Yeah. The one thing I would say about One Nation is that There is a genuine split between conservative pollsters or liberal-aligned pollsters and what we might call, for better or worse, Labor-aligned pollsters. Labor think the One Nation is doing much better than the Liberals do. There's a genuine division about that. Now, in each case, they're probably saying what they want to say. Obviously, the Liberal Party doesn't want One Nation to be doing well. They want to be flogging them everywhere. And clearly, the Labor Party wants to believe that there's a One Nation surge that might, in some cases... Save them from preference leakage. We'll see.
00:06:46
Speaker 1: You'd think there would be a bit of a decline in support for One Nation, I think, as people actually head to vote. I think there's a difference in, you know, saying you will or might vote for them and actually doing it on the day.
00:06:57
Speaker 2: Well, you know, Warren might smash it out of the park next week when we have the debate, which we've finally settled on one debate.
00:07:06
Speaker 1: One debate so far. I don't think there's going to be another.
00:07:09
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:07:11
Speaker 1: Yeah, look, he may. But I just think you've got both major parties campaigning on not voting for One Nation. Surely that has some impact on people.
00:07:23
Speaker 2: We shall see. I mean, it's interesting. I was driving up the Western Freeway yesterday and there are big Labor signs. Don't risk it. Like massive, like the most sort of expensive billboards you can buy. Picture of Jess on the left, picture of Warren on the right. Don't risk it. But there's no reason why not to risk it, right? It's such an inside football pitch, right? Don't risk it. Why not risk it? It's just, it's taken as a given to the people they're appealing to that, oh, you don't want the Liberals and One Nation together. And I'm not sure that the evidence for that is there at the moment in a lot of these places. If you go on the primary vote in Pakenham, which is an outer, you know, it's outer east, but you know, demographically not that different to some of the seats that Labor's in deep trouble in in the West. As a scare campaign, it's just not working.
00:08:17
Speaker 1: Well, it doesn't explain why not to risk it. What's the risk? Perhaps the risk is just the great unknown, but, you know, we've had the known for 12 years and I think people just want to change now.
00:08:34
Speaker 2: Changing the subject, I think one of the problems that Labor's having at the moment in Victoria is... The news from Canberra is terrible for the ALP. We've just had a whatever it is... Umpteenth. Umpteenth interest rate rise.
00:08:48
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:08:49
Speaker 2: I mean, normally, when there's a state election on, the Liberal Party in Canberra finds a way to ride to the ALP's rescue in Victoria. They do something in Canberra that causes them enormous difficulties. In one time, I think they.
00:09:08
Speaker 2: Tony Abbott, I think, put up petrol prices at one point. He hugged Dennis Napthine in a press conference, which Dennis's press secretary, who was standing in the back of the room, was so pleased that she used the word that can't be used on a family podcast quite loudly. I remember this. I might have been, oh, yeah. So, so far, the Liberal Party hasn't done anything in Canberra to damage their prospects of Jess Wilson winning. In fact, I suspect they're holding off on doing some things. I think things are going to get a bit spicy up there at the moment. This is over. But from the government's point of view, if you look at the polling, federal polling, and the Prime Minister is now woefully unpopular in Victoria. Have we seen Albo? down here in this election? No.
00:10:02
Speaker 1: No.
00:10:03
Speaker 2: I don't think we will. I don't think we will either.
00:10:05
Speaker 1: But it's interesting what you say about Liberal Party and not doing anything. And they're doing the same here, I would say. They are, for the most part, walking around holding their breaths.
00:10:16
Speaker 2: Behaving themselves.
00:10:16
Speaker 1: Well, they are... They're doing everything they can not to put a foot or a word out of place because they know how quickly something can go bad because they've seen it before and they've done it before and they've caused it before. And they are all really, I mean, as disciplined as you've seen from this mob in 12 years, you know, I'm told there are certain candidates, Liberal Party candidates, who have been told they are not to, under any circumstance, agree to any sort of community forum agreement or public speaking, uh, offer because, uh, you know, um, the campaign.
00:10:54
Speaker 2: Headquarters, I think it's not a small number of them either.
00:10:56
Speaker 1: It's almost all of them. I think, um, uh, they, they don't want anything to go wrong. And we saw something a few weeks ago with one of the candidates who said, you know, um, vote for me in the lower house and vote for one nation in the upper house. And that was a scare enough for the party to know that you've got lots of candidates out there who aren't particularly experienced. Um, They don't want anything going wrong. They are keeping things very, very tightly controlled. And they just know they've got two and a half, three weeks left to go. And they can't risk anything blowing up.
00:11:32
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:11:33
Speaker 1: You know, because things can turn quickly. I mean, I personally think things have gone too far now.
00:11:40
Speaker 2: No, I agree with you. I don't. I mean, unless it's an absolute....
00:11:46
Speaker 1: But even if we're talking about, you know, something blowing up and that.
00:11:50
Speaker 2: But what I'm saying is it has to be epically massive at this point.
00:11:54
Speaker 1: To ruin their chances. But even something that's not so epic.
00:11:58
Speaker 2: I mean, they are capable of it, but I just don't see it.
00:12:00
Speaker 1: No, I know. But even something that's not so epic that results in the difference between majority government and minority government, for example.
00:12:06
Speaker 2: That's what they're mostly worried about.
00:12:07
Speaker 1: They don't want anything to go wrong. So you'll see a lot of candidates aren't doing much as far as publicly... And most MPs are just keeping to themselves.
00:12:18
Speaker 2: I mean, yeah, the news is just sort of bad for Labor.
00:12:23
Speaker 1: You've got the Royal Commission hearings that started.
00:12:24
Speaker 2: You've got the Royal Commission hearing that started. It hasn't really got to, there's not too much blood on the walls down there yet, but, you know, it's early days, it's 10 days. I note that Nick McKenzie was on the radio saying it was all going to be very bad for Labor by the end of the week. We'll see what that amounts to.
00:12:40
Speaker 1: You know, from Ben's point of view as well, you've got this weird situation where he is as part of his campaign for re-election, promoting the fact that he has called the Royal Commission into corruption that his government presided over. He's campaigning on the fact there is a Royal Commission. It's a bizarre situation.
00:13:00
Speaker 2: They are campaigning in very different ways. It's interesting to look at where their money's going. I was talking to a Labor person on the weekend who was genuinely bewildered and wanted to know if I understood why they were doing this. He said there are a lot of their money, the Liberal Party's money.
00:13:24
Speaker 1: Liberal Party?
00:13:25
Speaker 2: Liberal Party's money. He was looking at their opposition. This Labor guy said they're spending most of their money, as far as Labor can see, on broadcast, broadcast television and radio. Labor is spending most of its money, as I can see, as far as I can make out, or this guy said, we're spending a lot more on digital. And he was sort of bewildered as to why.
00:13:46
Speaker 1: They're both sort of speaking to their own audiences, aren't they, in that regard?
00:13:50
Speaker 2: Well, the thing I would say is, yeah, well.
00:13:55
Speaker 1: Which you don't necessarily need to be doing.
00:13:57
Speaker 2: Well.
00:13:59
Speaker 1: Or you shouldn't need to be doing.
00:14:00
Speaker 2: I mean, it might be simply that the Labor Party has moved beyond this stuff and is now very, very, you know, so online versus the Liberal Party. There are other reasons why it could be so, starting with the fact that, as we've said, Labor doesn't have an overarching narrative. If you want to run broadcast ads, you need an overarching narrative
because you're not targeting them to individual seats, right? You can target digital ads for individual candidates and as much as possible try and make them look like they're not a Labor candidate. If you're running a broadcast ad on the TV or in the radio... You need an overall narrative, and Labor really hasn't got one, apart from don't trust it. That's where we're down to at the moment. So that might be a reason. But it also, I suspect, comes down to a fact that the Liberal Party's possibly not quite sure where they're going to win. And so it makes sense to go as wide as possible. Whereas Labor at this point is, as we talked last week about the sort of seats that they're spending their money in, They're really inside the fort at the moment, which is surrounded. So going back to that poll on Pakenham, which gives Warren on 40%, which I don't think is going to get him there. The reason I don't think it's going to get him there is because I don't think Labor, certainly not the Greens, are going to give warrant their preferences under any circumstances and I don't think Labor's going to give them their preferences anywhere. Do you think that?
00:15:39
Speaker 1: I think that's right but I think in a way it's foolish because Labor could have struck some deals with One Nation all over the place where they could have helped One Nation beat the Libs in some spots and in return they could have got.
00:15:56
Speaker 2: One Nation's support. Why is it smart?
00:16:00
Speaker 1: Why is what smart?
00:16:02
Speaker 2: Well There's three things strike me about that. If that causes a liberal One Nation coalition, they'll be accused of vandalism. They could rightly be accused of putting One Nation into government, which given their message is that One Nation, the devil incarnate, is not a very smart thing to do. The other reason I don't think they should do it is, well, two other reasons. One, it would cause enormous internal problems for them, like a lot of their... People wouldn't hand out those cards. And thirdly, there's no evidence, there's not much evidence anyway, that their voters would follow a card that did that.
00:16:44
Speaker 1: No. I just would have thought there are some circumstances in which they could have done some deals. It's very difficult for them to do that, as you say. The voter base won't support it. Their whole campaign has been anti-One Nation. But it puts them in a difficult spot.
00:17:04
Speaker 2: On the other side, of course, there's the perennial question about what are the Liberals going to do about the Greens? Are they going to preference run open tickets, not hand out? Well, let's face it, it's quite a few seats now. Northcote, Richmond, Melbourne, Footscray, Pascoe Vale, Albert Park, and of course, Pran. There's a stack of seats where Liberal preferences will probably be decisive. And we've got a listener in Northcote who's very, very interested in this. Hello, Theo. I'm just not sure that the Liberal Party internally can
do that at the moment. What do you think?
00:17:45
Speaker 1: In which regard?
00:17:46
Speaker 2: Well, I just don't think... I think the days when the Liberal Party could play games with preferences with Labor are kind of over. You can't be having a policy saying you're going to criminalise the phrase, globalise the intifada, And then preference the Greens, can you?
00:18:01
Speaker 1: No, you can't. Something I'm told, though, is that Labor are having a real hard time getting preference deals sorted. Really, really hard time.
00:18:10
Speaker 2: With whom?
00:18:12
Speaker 1: With everybody all over the place as far as trying to... Yeah.
00:18:15
Speaker 2: Well, they're pissed off about the group voting tickets thing, aren't they?
00:18:18
Speaker 1: Correct.
00:18:18
Speaker 2: Correct. So explain this. So explain what happened.
00:18:22
Speaker 1: Yeah. Well, essentially, the government passed legislation that has killed off the chance of micro-parties to be elected to government.
00:18:29
Speaker 2: So before, until about two months ago, the rules in Victoria were basically you ticked one above the line and the preferences were the way the party allocated them. And so they could all do deals, safe in the knowledge that those deals would stick. Now, you've got to get people to follow the ticket to get in. People have got to fill in their own.
00:18:51
Speaker 1: So we're likely going to see a wipeout of the micro-parties in this state. So your animal justice parties, your shooters and fishers, libertarians potentially, family first. I mean, these parties really don't stand a chance.
00:19:04
Speaker 2: I have noticed they've got a few astroturfed parties, new ones. Have you noticed this? There's a few Labor astroturf parties.
00:19:10
Speaker 1: Yes. Oh, there are certainly efforts being made. But it's, yeah, it's caused a big headache for Labor I always said to.
00:19:20
Speaker 2: The Liberals, why don't you AstroTurf here? Why don't you AstroTurf there? And the answer always came back, we're going to be so flat out running one campaign. The idea that we've got the resources to AstroTurf something, it's just not going to happen. Obviously they knew it was wrong too, but apart from being wrong, it was also very, very resource hungry doing that.
00:19:39
Speaker 1: I mean, we will know within the week how the preference deals have fallen, how the vote cards will be printed, because obviously early voting opens next week.
00:19:49
Speaker 2: Well, that doesn't tell you anything because they can print as many as they want. It's which one they hand out is what you want to know. Well, true. True.
00:19:58
Speaker 1: We'll know this week what the out-of-vote cards look like.
00:20:02
Speaker 2: We'll know what they've registered. We won't know what they hand out. True. They could always register more than one in every seat.
00:20:08
Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah, but ideally it needs to be sorted. I mean, they've got to go to the printers, be sorted, be
delivered and ready to hand out from next Wednesday. So it will be interesting to see how many people, compared to the last election, vote early. I think it was 50% last election. You'd expect, I would have thought, significantly more numbers. And if you do, you'd expect that that is a very, very bad sign for Labor.
00:20:36
Speaker 2: I'll tell you one thing that's interesting about this election. As you know, I live in the inner north. And my candidate for Labor started talking about if you vote for the Liberal Party, which is not really a great risk. I don't think many people are at great risk of doing that either. One of the shock horror things that they will do is abolish the whole treaty process. And it was interesting to me because I haven't heard any other Labor candidate talk about it. Have you?
00:21:08
Speaker 1: No, no one talks about it. I don't think, I mean, Jess doesn't really talk, Jess Wilson doesn't really talk about it. I think a lot of people don't know that that is one of her policies.
00:21:17
Speaker 2: And it's a hard policy, right? Like it's going to, if she wins and she has a majority in the upper house, which she will with One Nation, and you would assume One Nation would be up for this. I'd be shocked if they weren't. The whole treaty thing is going in the bin.
00:21:33
Speaker 1: I don't really know for what purpose. And I say that because the fact that she's not talking about it, and the fact that Labor's not talking about it, makes me think that people don't really care about it. I mean, you will have a minority of people who really care and think we shouldn't have a treaty. You'll have an opposing minority who really care and think we must have a treaty. I think the vast majority of people couldn't care less.
00:21:54
Speaker 2: So we're changing governments from a government that responds to the concerns of their minority to a government that responds to the concerns of a different minority. Correct. It is going to be I actually.
00:22:07
Speaker 1: I mean, do you agree? Do you think anybody... Sorry, not anybody, but do you think generally people care whether there is... I mean, the treaty has come. It's here.
00:22:15
Speaker 2: Well, yeah, but it's not fully operational yet, is it?
00:22:18
Speaker 1: Well, it's pretty close, but yeah.
00:22:20
Speaker 2: There's a lot of local... The devil's in the local detail. Yeah. The expense will be in the local detail.
00:22:28
Speaker 1: But I think Jess could have addressed that without repealing treaty altogether. You know, I don't think it's going to impact her... electoral prospects at all um which is why i don't i don't really see the need for her to have done that particularly given.
00:22:42
Speaker 2: Maybe she hates it maybe they all hate it maybe they think it's no good and should be repealed maybe it's they're acting on.
00:22:49
Speaker 1: Principle i don't think she quite does really but you know you think.
00:22:52
Speaker 3: She's got a little bit of there's a little bit of teal in there well let's face it she's kind of they've marketed her whatever her policies are the presentation is pretty tealy that's.
00:23:02
Speaker 1: Right um So yeah, the whole treaty thing. So it's interesting that your local candidate is talking about treaty. But not unsurprising where you live.
00:23:13
Speaker 2: I just thought it was interesting that a lot of people have been saying, oh, this is a small target strategy. It's a small target strategy. Ripping up the agreement with the Indigeni is not a small target strategy.
00:23:26
Speaker 1: No, and that's why I think it's quite a bizarre play, really. Because I don't know how many votes it wins you. Maybe it wins you a lot. I'm not sure.
00:23:35
Speaker 2: We will see. You have been listening to The Splash, the Herald Sun's state politics podcast in the lead up to the state election, which is almost upon us. If you liked it, give it a review. Give it a rating. Press the little button when you subscribe where you get your podcasts, a little bell so you get an alert when the next one drops. We'll be back later in the week.