ကူးယူချက် 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: This is the muster on Hokanui.
00:00:07
Speaker 2: Elliot Smith is the voice of rugby on Newstalk ZB and joins us. He's moved on to London after what occurred at Cardiff over the weekend. We're going to have to go back over this because nobody except the most ardent Welsh fans would have looked at a Welsh victory. Nothing pointed towards us. Elliot, good afternoon slash good morning once again. What the heck happened?
00:00:30
Speaker 1: That's a good question, Andy. I'd love to unpack it with you.
00:00:34
Speaker 3: 24 plus hours on, I still don't really have... many answers other than the fact that the All Blacks were poor and you can't get away from that, but the Welsh were excellent and belied their 10th ranking in the world. And as you say, even perhaps the most ardent of Welsh supporters didn't think this team would be the one to knock off the All Blacks. They've had some wonderful teams through the years, teams that have won Six nations teams that have, uh, you know, one grand slams and gone close to being in rugby world cup finals and some wonderful players, you know, through the years and none of those players, um, you know, the, the likes of a Sam Warburton and, um, Gareth Thomas and wonderful Alan Wynne-Jones and some of those great players in the 1970s as well and 80s that Wales had. None of them could beat the All Blacks in a Welsh jersey, yet this team that was completely written off, and look, to be honest, rightfully so. The evidence suggests they were capable of even getting close to the All Blacks. They've won, and they deserve to win, and It's a day that will live in Welsh rugby history and a black mark against the All Blacks.
00:01:52
Speaker 2: Stu Wilson was captain of the All Blacks back in 1983 when they lost to England at Twickenham. He was playing on the wing. Bowden Barrett was captain at fullback. Does this tell us something about captaincy in the All Blacks?
00:02:04
Speaker 1: Yeah, quite possibly.
00:02:04
Speaker 3: And, you know, it was a game that was forward-oriented and Bowdoin Barrett was away from the action. And, you know, I think there's probably a reason that most teams in the world do have their captain close to, The scrums, you know, half back down, basically, and you thought for maybe a one-off it might be all right, but it proved anything but, and I do, I wouldn't say it was the main reason, but it was one to add to the list of reasons why the All Blacks weren't as sharp and as effective as they could have been, is that Bowden Barrett... wasn't getting the close-up view that maybe a member of the full pack would have. So, look, he's a richly experienced player, Bowden Barrett, but the All Blacks lacked a bit of leadership and finesse out there yesterday, and I think he's got to cop that on the chin.
00:02:55
Speaker 2: Is it fair to say some players have played themselves out of consideration for next year's Rugby World Cup?
00:03:01
Speaker 1: It was a bit cool.
00:03:03
Speaker 3: But those are the opportunities you give players to see what they're made of. And there are few and far between opportunities between now and the World Cup.
00:03:13
Speaker 1: This was one of them.
00:03:15
Speaker 3: And Dave Rennie's clearly got a sense of what his first-choice 15 is. But I think there has to be questions around the number of players that came in yesterday. We still have not seen the best of Richie Mwonga since he came back from Japan. He's had, obviously, a couple of injuries that he's had to deal with. But I thought he was disappointing yesterday and didn't show the playmaking that we're used to. I think there are other players as well that will have question marks over them as a result. And for Dave Rennie, there's not a.
00:03:49
Speaker 1: Lot of time.
00:03:49
Speaker 3: He's, as I say, got his first choice team and there are a number of players that will come back in for England. We could pretty much probably reel that team off now. But perhaps the depth that maybe Dave Rennie thought and maybe I thought and maybe others thought was there for the All Blacks isn't quite there. I think that's a worrying sign ahead of the World Cup is that if you lose a key player, is there another option to come in? The All Blacks are already dealing with 10 or so injuries of players they had to leave behind in New Zealand. But I think yesterday was a bit of a wake-up call in terms of the depth that New Zealand rugby actually may not have thought it did.
00:04:30
Speaker 2: Where does this sit for Dave Rennie then in a coaching sense? If this was Scott Robertson, he'd be under the blowtorch. And you've got to remember, like, Dave Rennie's win record now is in the 60 percentile somewhere by the sounds of it.
00:04:43
Speaker 1: Yeah, absolutely. You've got to think about that.
00:04:46
Speaker 3: And I think he was given a bit of grace around South Africa. Obviously, the fact that he barely got into the job and having to play four tests in South Africa. But it did feel, prior to yesterday, that they were making some good ground and getting that trajectory that we want to see from the All Blacks. And this was a major step backwards.
00:05:08
Speaker 1: And so.
00:05:09
Speaker 3: Look, his job is not on the line. He'll go through the Rugby World Cup. But I think it would have been a wake-up call, as much as it was for the players yesterday, but for Dave Rennie around, even if you are 5% off in the Test Arena or do change things, then you've got to be ultra-certain around the reasoning for some of that. Now, I think some of the selections they made yesterday were actually justified. I don't think the selections were the issue. And the changes were the issue yesterday. And I think the players that came in just didn't take the opportunity. So, yeah, I think he's got to wear his fair share of the blame.
00:05:47
Speaker 1: Ultimately, he's the coach and the buck stops with him.
00:05:50
Speaker 3: And, you know, big couple of weeks coming up
Load full transcript
for him heading into the summer.
00:05:55
Speaker 2: I think that's the biggest issue from yesterday, Elliot. The fact that Wales made 200 more tackles in the ABs and yet we've seen void of ideas near their line.
00:06:04
Speaker 1: Yep.
00:06:04
Speaker 3: And the attack, which had looked pretty sharp, actually, so far this year and a number of games, I thought was, as I say, one-dimensional and wasn't driven by the key playmakers in Mwonga and Bowdoin Barrett and, you know, Cortez Rathamon.
00:06:23
Speaker 1: I used to own some of that as well. I thought the kicking was.
00:06:25
Speaker 3: Really poor, out of hand, by and large, or not targeted or it didn't happen enough. Some of the tactics I thought were weak. Think about that five-meter tap they took repeatedly when they had penalties inside the Welsh 22 when they maybe would have been better off going for a line-out drive. Um, so yeah, there's no shortage of, um, finger pointing and, and, and blame that you can apportion as a result of this.
00:06:52
Speaker 1: Um, but the tech really did look, um, poor.
00:06:56
Speaker 3: It felt like it was back to the last couple of years where there was no real attacking shape and you're hoping for. some individual to stand up and bust through the line and set something up. I think that's a big wake-up call for Mike Blair and his attack and the All Blacks must respond this week at Twickenham because the walls will close in on them with the attention that will be on them this week and they've got to rise to the occasion for sure.
00:07:22
Speaker 2: We always get told about this response, as you alluded to then, Elliot. I think, though, England, they're going into this game with nothing to lose. They beat us there last year. They've got a brass young players on their bench. But we talk about this response. What are we going to see? How do you see this playing out?
00:07:40
Speaker 3: Well, it's funny because the response will be the number of key players that come back into the team. De Groot, Taylor, Holland, Vi will all come back in. Roy Gard, McKenzie, Geordie Barrett will all come back into the mix. So there's some experience that comes back in and a whole bunch of world-class players. So I think instantly the team gets better. And the ones that are worthier against Wales, well, you've got to demand excellence out of them and show why they deserve to be in the All Blacks jersey because there were not many of them, you know, Wallace Atidi and Peter Lakai may be excluded that could hold their heads high out of that. So they have to deliver a response. It's funny how things quickly can change in the world of rugby. You know, England, a couple of weeks ago, there was a story that came out here in the Times of London about Steve Borthwick and the pressure he was under and the fact that he'd almost begun to lose the dressing room in the July tests. Well, went over Australia last week, a thrashing of a poor Japan side yesterday, and they come in with their tails up in the All Blacks, all of a sudden, you know, going, kicking stones. So, they've got to deliver that response. It's going to be swift. It's going to be brutal. It's going to be all-blacks rugby that we know. Otherwise, there are going to be some serious questions.
00:08:59
Speaker 1: And you know what?
00:08:59
Speaker 3: They can still make that Nations Championship final. So that is a secondary thing. But first and foremost, the win over England has to be locked in this week.
00:09:08
Speaker 1: Good on you, Elliot. Always appreciate your time. Anytime, Andy. Elliot Smith of Newstalk ZB. Up next, we wrap up with Tom O'Brien.