ကူးယူချက် 🔗
00:00:03
Speaker 1: This is Outsiders.
00:00:08
Speaker 2: Good morning and welcome to Outsiders, the show that wishes to remind Victorian voters that come November you have one job and one job only.
00:00:19
Speaker 1: Put Labor last.
00:00:23
Speaker 3: What a victory for Premier Ben Carroll. Nobody expected this. After all the scandals, all the corruption, all the crime, Victorians face four more years of Labor. And it's all thanks to voters who didn't remember to put Labor last.
00:00:34
Speaker 4: Yes, this is, of course, an AI ad, so no nasty queries from Media Watch, please. It's an AI ad put out by Advance predicting what will happen if voters in Victoria do not put Labor last. And it ain't pretty. What a night!
00:00:53
Speaker 5: I especially want to thank One Nation and Liberal voters who didn't put Labor last and every voter who thought their preference wouldn't matter.
00:01:01
Speaker 4: This one's for you.
00:01:03
Speaker 6: And just to really drive the message home, the creatives at Advance have even given us an AI Dan Andrews.
00:01:10
Speaker 7: This really is the stuff of nightmares.
00:01:13
Speaker 3: What a result.
00:01:15
Speaker 8: Everyone forgot to put Labor last and now look at this.
00:01:30
Speaker 6: This election, every number on your ballot paper matters. Don't just vote for who you want to win, but also who deserves to lose.
00:01:41
Speaker 9: Remember, put Labor last.
00:01:45
Speaker 1: Great out there from advance.
00:01:46
Speaker 2: Yes, and while we wait for every single Victorian coalition and One Nation voter to do just that, let's grab the latest Outsiders news. Well, interesting what's been happening in the electorate of Graindler. This is all following, well, how many years of Anthony Albanese being one of the most disappointing individuals, I think, to ever represent that seat. Certainly that's the opinion of people, ABC's people like Kerry O'Brien, who this week came out and said, oh, very disappointing.
00:02:21
Speaker 1: James.
00:02:22
Speaker 2: Someone's going to run against him. Who could it possibly be?
00:02:25
Speaker 4: Yeah, so Albo's got a little trouble back in the home electorate of Grayler. Now, I can speak about this because I actually live in the electorate of Grayler for my sins, but it's a wonderful place with, you know, some fairly lousy representation. Now, Albo has held the seat for, I think, something like 30 years now. He's spent his entire life pretty much doing this job. But he now has a challenger in the form of this young media doyen, Hannah Ferguson. Now, she's got a sort of a glorified feminist website called Cheek Media. She goes online and emotes about politics and things like that in that very sort of Gen Z or whatever sort of And she said she is going to challenge Albo from the left as an independent. Now, here's my mail on this. I think this could be very interesting because... particularly if, and it's already been floated, this idea, particularly if Albanese decides not to contest the next election or the one after that, the person who's going to come in to take his seat, anointed by Labour, is his very good friend Darcy Byrne, who is the mayor of the Inner West Council. An exceedingly disappointing mayor, I have to say, and they can't even get the trash collection right, so, you know, why not put him in federal parliament where that level of competence is rewarded? But against... A young female hard left independent in an area, particularly around Marrickville, which is no longer, you know, dominated so much by ethnic Portuguese, Greeks and, you know, that sort of wave of people. It's all being jammed full of apartments, full of very left wing, very young, very hip sort of voters. I reckon I think you get a very entertaining contest here between, you know, old Labour and and the sort of the new left.
00:04:21
Speaker 2: Well, Caroline, regular viewers of Outsiders will be familiar with Hannah Ferguson, who has starred.
00:04:28
Speaker 1: Frequently in Wally of the Week.
00:04:29
Speaker 10: Yes.
00:04:29
Speaker 2: I'm not sure if she's won any yet. I'm sure she must have picked up a couple of gongs along the way.
00:04:33
Speaker 1: But tell us about her.
00:04:34
Speaker 6: She's a very good candidate for Wally of the Week on an almost weekly basis. Now, as James pointed out, she is a very far-left media doyen. She runs this independent media website called Cheek Media. She has a lot of followers online and she appears regularly on the commercial networks. And she appeared this week talking about the attack on Helen Haynes. And she told, I believe it was Sunrise, that, you know, how awful this attack is and how... I'll talk about a little bit later in my editorial about how she tried to frame it as an act of gendered violence and.
00:05:14
Speaker 7: isn't it awful that we have this political violence?
00:05:16
Speaker 6: But then no sooner had she made those statements, a lot of people were bringing up the fact that she herself, on the day of Charlie Kirk's assassination, when he had been shot dead speaking at a university campus, she had said herself that violence is sometimes necessary. Here she was on 2GB radio trying to justify those comments.
00:05:42
Speaker 11: There are occasions throughout history where a group or people have needed to rise up against another oppressor where violence has been necessary to overcome hatred, to overcome oppression. But my point being that that was not one of those instances. And I think also what's important to say is that Charlie Kirk was someone that advocated for violence and incited violence.
00:06:01
Speaker 6: She doesn't give any examples of how he advocated violence apparently and I think that is just an abhorrent remark to make.
00:06:08
Speaker 7: He was one.
00:06:09
Speaker 6: His catchphrase was, I think, you know.
00:06:12
Speaker 4: Change my mind.
00:06:13
Speaker 7: Change my mind.
00:06:13
Speaker 6: He wanted people to use civil debate.
Load full transcript
00:06:17
Speaker 4: This is the thing, though. This is the thing, Carolyn. You know, that was such a disingenuous sort of walkback because... She's trying to walk back the comments where she got in trouble for it. But then she says, 30 seconds, 10 seconds later, oh, no, no, no, no, no, no. But actually, Charlie Kirk, though, he did advocate violence. But here's what we've got to understand, Rowan and Caroline. The thing with the left is... They see words as violence. Words from the other side are violence. Once you redefine that, Charlie Kirk never hated on anybody. Charlie Kirk was, you know, he was the best of the right. He was the best. He was the least inflammatory, but he stuck to his guns and argued and used rhetoric and reason. And for the left, which is all emotion... That was kryptonite.
00:07:05
Speaker 2: Yeah, well, here are her original comments, which she tweeted on the day of Charlie Kirk's assassination. Am I glad Charlie Kirk will no longer spread his extremist messaging?
00:07:15
Speaker 5: Yes.
00:07:16
Speaker 1: She's answering her own question.
00:07:17
Speaker 2: Am I happy that someone shot him in the neck in broad daylight?
00:07:21
Speaker 1: No, she says.
00:07:22
Speaker 2: Do I believe he empowered the violence that ended his life? This is classic Charlie. lefty-speak that James was just talking about. Yes, yes, she does believe he was responsible.
00:07:34
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:07:35
Speaker 6: As the left would say, it's victim-blaming.
00:07:38
Speaker 2: And the final one is, do I believe he caused more harm than good? Yes.
00:07:42
Speaker 1: Kind of.
00:07:42
Speaker 2: Does that justify shooting someone? And she answers the next question, is violence sometimes necessary?
00:07:49
Speaker 4: Yes.
00:07:50
Speaker 2: I mean, this is just wickedness, in my opinion. Wickedness, stupidity, a deadly combination of If she wants to talk about what we've seen through history time and time again, what we've seen through history is the damage that stupid people do when they set themselves up on their moral high horse and justify violence, justify killings. because of their moral situation. They think they have some kind of moral superiority over everyone else. That is what's dangerous, Hannah. That is what people should be focusing on.
00:08:21
Speaker 1: But back to her run for Graingler.
00:08:24
Speaker 4: Yes.
00:08:24
Speaker 1: She could be your MP.
00:08:26
Speaker 4: I think that would be.
00:08:26
Speaker 1: She'll invite you in for tea. Oh, that would be great.
00:08:29
Speaker 2: You can sit down and go play old Charlie Kirk videos together.
00:08:32
Speaker 4: Laundry list of complaints about things that we need in the electorate, but I'm sure she'll just turn the whole thing into a bike path.
00:08:37
Speaker 12: But.
00:08:38
Speaker 4: You know what else, though, is appalling, just to stick on Sydney, and I know everybody's, let's take a city, but we've got to talk about this, this one, too, and, you know, is
what they're doing to Victoria Barracks here. And this is the great historic spiritual home of the ADF, which employs, you know, there's still a huge number of ADF staffers that work there. offices, soldiers, and it is getting flogged off by Richard Marles, the disgraceful defense minister. I don't know what he's doing in that job in the first place. But this is an absolute indication of the utter lack of respect labor has for tradition for the military, both serving, past and future. And it's just an... I've spoken to so many people involved with this. The Daily Telegraph's been going very hard on this as well. It is an absolute kick in the teeth to our serving military, and they want to just put them in offices that they don't even have and treat them like another bunch of public servants.
00:09:45
Speaker 1: Well, the Victoria Barracks is the heart of, originally, the colonial..... forces.
00:09:51
Speaker 2: That's how the left would view it. This is colonialism. This is the settler colony.
00:09:56
Speaker 4: Correct.
00:09:56
Speaker 2: And this is how the left, the Labor Party, are fully on with this entire leftist agenda of disliking our history, disliking our past.
00:10:05
Speaker 1: So, for them, it makes sense to.
00:10:08
Speaker 2: As Richard Miles himself has said, oh, it's just an old wine cellar. They have no respect for history. In fact, they hate history. They have no respect for the military services. We've seen that again and again and again. And I'll be talking about Ben Roberts-Smith later on in the show. But also, let's just point out there is today, in a couple of hours, there is a big protest outside the Victoria Barracks on the Moorpark side.
00:10:31
Speaker 1: Lots of people going along.
00:10:32
Speaker 2: I urge you, if you care about our history, if you care about our colonial history... If you care about the history of the British Empire on these shores, then toddle on down there, because that's the place to be.
00:10:44
Speaker 4: It's not just the history, though. The history is vitally important. And, yes, I agree with you completely, Rowan. This is an effort by a left-wing government that hates Australia's colonial history and wants to rub it.
00:10:56
Speaker 1: Scrub it out.
00:10:57
Speaker 4: Scrub it out.
00:10:57
Speaker 1: Sell it off.
00:10:58
Speaker 4: Scrub it off the map. You know, and they're going to get what? $ 1 or $ 2 billion, perhaps, for this site, they're saying, which covers, what, about three and a half days of NDIS fraud? I don't know.
00:11:07
Speaker 1: It covers a couple of golf courses.
00:11:08
Speaker 4: Yeah, a couple of golf courses, you know, and maybe a new bar for, you know, Albanese's golf course down, again, in Graydler. But, no, this is emblematic of what they're doing. And people have also said, made the point... that, you know, if, God forbid, there was a military incident, a terrorist incident in the city, where's your closest military facility then? Holesworthy? That's
not a lot of help.
00:11:32
Speaker 7: Well, I mean, yes, that's the point, too, I think.
00:11:34
Speaker 6: Yes, it has been the home, spiritual home of the Australian Army.
00:11:39
Speaker 7: It's been there.
00:11:39
Speaker 6: Since 1848, and that history is important. But at a time when our defence veterans are already.
00:11:46
Speaker 7: Their morale.
00:11:46
Speaker 6: Is at an all-time low, and it's not just the Ben Robert Smith incident and his arrest. but the treatment of our veterans by those in power, like the Veterans Affairs Minister, and how they tried to cap the compensation for them before there was such outrage that they had to turn back on that decision. At a time like this, you know, not only the threat that we're facing from China, the relatively small proportion of our GDP that we spend on defence, And now this decision to sell it off because the government has been so bad with spending our money.
00:12:24
Speaker 4: What are you talking about? What are you talking about? You know, the handsome boy has stabilized relations with China. All we need to do is make sure that we buy all our solar panels. all our windmills, all our vehicles and everything else from China and everything will be sweet. What are we wasting money on a military for? Come on, that's old-school thinking. Now, you mentioned the golf club. We were talking about Albo and all the money, $ 6 million that was promised by Albanese before the election and this whole nonsense where he didn't know if he was a member or he wasn't a member.
00:13:03
Speaker 1: I mean, this bloke. as they say, couldn't lie straight in bed.
00:13:05
Speaker 2: But have a look at this bit of footage that has surfaced of the folk down at the golf.
00:13:10
Speaker 1: Club getting ready for their.
00:13:12
Speaker 3: getting.
00:13:12
Speaker 2: Very excited about their gift from the Albanese government.
00:13:15
Speaker 1: Have a look.
00:13:17
Speaker 13: Well, we're here at Marrickville Golf Club having a conversation about the $ 6 million renovation that is soon to take place here at this clubhouse, which is going to be even better. I'm here with the Deputy Mayor, Matt Howard, and with Andrew and Matt from Marrickville Golf Club. And thanks to the Federal Labor Government and to Prime Minister Albo for the $ 6 million grant that they.
00:13:36
Speaker 3: Committed to during the campaign.
00:13:38
Speaker 13: The council's now been able to make the decision that we're going to bring forward the design process for this renovation and we'll fund the designs while we're waiting for the grant to come through.
00:13:46
Speaker 3: So what are you guys thinking about how this will improve the club?
00:13:50
Speaker 2: So every Australian taxpayer should watch that. That is your money, and they sit around and they chat about, we've got a new bar, we've got some tables out here. I mean, seriously, this is our money. The country is a trillion dollars in debt. We're paying a fortune in interest every year. And these characters get to sit around and go, oh, Albo's given us six million. How do we spend it?
00:14:10
Speaker 1: Stick an umbrella over there? Oh, I reckon we could put... pave some of this here.
00:14:13
Speaker 2: It is disgraceful and it is disgusting and this stuff has to stop. Canberra just spends and spends, particularly Labor, but all the parties in Canberra just spend our money recklessly, relentlessly, and get us further and further into debt. And it's an absolute farce. All these things should be cancelled. We don't have the money for them.
00:14:34
Speaker 4: And I can tell you something else for free. Anthony Albanese is incredibly thin-skinned and sensitive. about this particular issue, the golf course, because he knows he's vulnerable on it. So every time people go out, talk about it, ask him about it, it just drives him nuts. He doesn't want to be asked about it. And that's why, and I know we're going to talk a lot more about this later on in the program, that's why that dirt sheet that they circulated on Helen Haynes after Helen Haynes, who is to her credit, has been one of the greatest campaigners for this sort of integrity in the parliament. You know, and they knew that if she's on to it, you might have a problem. They said, oh, well, you know, she, she had the temerity. There were all sorts of things in this sheet. She had the temerity to ask for a grant for her ski field in her area where she once went skiing. Has anybody thought about that? You know, it's so disgraceful. But it was.
00:15:33
Speaker 6: Particularly damaging coming from Helen Haynes because she's not the typical right wing. She was independent, more like.
00:15:39
Speaker 7: A teal really.
00:15:40
Speaker 4: Well, she's a true independent. But it's more like a true.
00:15:42
Speaker 7: Regional independent, right?
00:15:43
Speaker 6: So that's particularly damaging. But you know who would rescind that grant in a minute? Anthony Albanese's political rival, Hannah Ferguson. She'd probably say golf clubs are a remnant of toxic.
00:15:57
Speaker 2: She would steamroll that thing.
00:16:00
Speaker 1: Turn it into a corroboree centre or something.
00:16:02
Speaker 4: No, no, no, she would turn it into a combination, you know, dog park, public, social, affordable housing, you know, and jam it full of union members.
00:16:12
Speaker 14: I think.
00:16:13
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think James might be secretly thinking about voting for Hannah here.
00:16:16
Speaker 1: Ooh!
00:16:17
Speaker 6: I think the cornflutes are going to turn up after.
00:16:20
Speaker 4: It's called strategic voting, friends. Strategic voting.
00:16:23
Speaker 2: Well, speaking about voting, you'll remember we had Luke Hertogen, the One Nation guy who won the seat of Secret Harbour, best-named electorate in Australia, Secret.
00:16:34
Speaker 1: Harbour, not long ago.
00:16:36
Speaker 2: For One Nation. It was a big night there for One Nation in WA. That was the seat right
next to Andrew Hastie's seat. And he made his first speech in the WA Parliament.
00:16:46
Speaker 1: Have a look.
00:16:47
Speaker 12: ANDREW HASTIE, I begin by acknowledging all those who came before us, the explorers, the pioneers, the first, and the battlers who carved our nation from an unforgiving land.
00:17:01
Speaker 15: They arrived in a hostile land of immense distances, punishing heat, drought, flood and fire. They turned isolation into community, hardship into opportunity, and they turned a divided land into one nation.
00:17:20
Speaker 2: Now, that should terrify many, many Labor seat holders federally in Victoria and in New South Wales because.
00:17:29
Speaker 1: That is the classic.
00:17:31
Speaker 2: larrikin, working class, Aussie, proud of their history. He did the gag of, you know, like a welcome to country, but from the other point of view, it was terrific, it was serious, and it shows what.
00:17:45
Speaker 1: One nation can do.
00:17:46
Speaker 2: If they can be the quality and calibre of a guy like Luke, who's just an everyday bloke, got up and stood up, then those, you know, the stranglehold... that Labor has on the federal parliament, they should be getting very, very scared.
00:17:59
Speaker 4: You know, that's an interesting point you make, too, about candidates, because it's the thing that when you talk to people about One Nation, this is the biggest concern a lot of people have about One Nation. They say, oh, look, you know, I want to vote One Nation, I want to send a message, but who are they putting up? for candidates. That has to be the bar. That has to be the bar because, you know, they're going to be trying to run, I think, a candidate in every seat in New South Wales. That's a lot of seats. They got to get really good people like that. And I reckon they ought to be putting out more vision of him nationally as part of their, you know, recruitment process to do two things. Number one, say to potential candidates, hey, if you can do this, talk to us. But number two, say to potential One Nation voters or to One Nation voters, this is the calibre that we're putting up.
00:18:47
Speaker 6: I think the other group that should be scared is the coalition, because One Nation consistently shows that they're not afraid to tackle these topics.
00:18:55
Speaker 7: That might be seen.
00:18:57
Speaker 6: As politically scary to talk about things like acknowledgement to country and indigenous rights and the rest of it. I mean, the coalition did well with the referendum and the no vote, but then has shied away largely from this topic.
00:19:16
Speaker 14: But Australians care.
00:19:17
Speaker 4: It's a great, great, great example of that this week. You know, again, I'm sorry to keep sort of New South Wales focused, but there was a proposal that Labour was putting up that was basically going to outlaw disposable coffee cups at the cafe and you'd have to bring a disposable cup and effectively would have put another cost burden
on, you know, both the customer and the barista on the cafe, cafe owners. But, you know, One Nation was right out of the box. They said, first they came for the straws, then they came for the bags, now they're coming for the cups. What's next? Come on, leave it alone. And the libs were still trying to work out their lines. What do we say? Oh, we've got all these sort of people, you know, in our sort of eastern suburbs electorates who might not like disposable coffee cups because they give them the ick, you know. And so they didn't quite know how to do it. And so they get caught flat-footed every time because they are seen as trying to and get their message just to.
00:20:11
Speaker 1: You know.
00:20:11
Speaker 2: Yeah, and you're right that Mike Newman came straight out as recognising, as any common-sense person does, that governments should not be telling the local coffee shop.
00:20:21
Speaker 4: How to serve a coffee!
00:20:22
Speaker 1: how to serve a coffee.
00:20:24
Speaker 2: And there was some discussion on radio and talkback about, from cafe owners, saying, do you realise what this is going to do to me? It's probably going to send me bankrupt because I've got to do this, I've got to have that, I've got to have that extra health thing and all the rest. The instinct from Mike Newman, before he even looked at the economics of it, was, this is rubbish. This is like a time warp, going back 10 years to when governments thought they could save the planet one straw at a time or one paper bag or whatever at a time.
00:20:50
Speaker 7: I still miss plastic straws.
00:20:52
Speaker 2: I do too.
00:20:52
Speaker 6: It's just, those paper straws are so awful. And if they're going to charge twice as much for a takeaway coffee, like, that's it. You know, they are like, in some suburbs, they're like $ 8 to get a takeaway coffee.
00:21:06
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:21:07
Speaker 7: It's ridiculous.
00:21:08
Speaker 2: But it's symptomatic of government interfering at every level, particularly with small businesses. Small business cannot cope now with what the Labor government is doing to this country, what it's doing at a federal and at a state level in so many places, the impositions, the regulations, the climate garbage. the Indigenous stuff, endless unions, regulations. They've destroyed so much of, for example, Sydney's restaurant nightlife or whatever by regulations, businesses. You walk up and down any high street, you see shops closing, shops closing, shopfronts up for lease, up for sale.
00:21:47
Speaker 1: Businesses just going, we can't cope anymore, we're done.
00:21:50
Speaker 4: But what... Like, I'm interested more also in, like, What's the psychology? What's the psychology that attracts somebody? And how does labor wind up with this whole mob of people who have this cluster of personality disorders that look at something like, look at all those people getting their coffees. Takeaway coffees. That's got to... I mean, like, this impulse to interfere in people's lives in every... You know, the temperature of your shower, how you drink your Coke from Macca's, how you drink your macchiato. Like, every... How you get your groceries home. Every little bit of your life has to be micromanaged in the name of some higher good. But it's just all of these student government weenies who just think that they, you know, can reorganize. It's like the whole world run by Lisa Simpson.
00:22:40
Speaker 1: Well, they got a taste for it during COVID.
00:22:42
Speaker 4: Oh, yeah.
00:22:43
Speaker 2: And it's the whole COVID mentality of, we know best, don't question us.
00:22:46
Speaker 1: We're your sole source of truth and we will decide everything. And that is why.
00:22:50
Speaker 2: That is why we need to shrink our governments, shrink our federal governments, shrink our state governments, get them out of our lives so that Australian people and get back to doing what they do best, which is being entrepreneurial, having ideas, having a go, getting out there and making life better for themselves, their families and therefore the community, without this endless, endless stifling blanket of control from Canberra and from Macquarie Street and elsewhere.
00:23:17
Speaker 1: All the state governments.
00:23:19
Speaker 2: Caroline, let's talk a little bit about what's happening with our dear old friend Emmanuel Macron.
00:23:24
Speaker 1: So, we've had all the chaos in Europe.
00:23:26
Speaker 2: And Macron's made a goose of himself several times this week. First of all, he tried to discount the riots as AI, which is pretty funny.
00:23:36
Speaker 1: Have a listen to him here.
00:23:37
Speaker 16: For me, there is no foreign interference visible in the events that have happened. On the other hand, there has been a foreign manipulation of information, which has led to unacceptable and stupid comments from many, including foreign leaders. That is to say, we have seen images of artificial intelligence See, even AI sounds better in French.
00:24:08
Speaker 1: Intelligence artificielle. But he goes on to say.
00:24:12
Speaker 2: He claims that the scenes we've all seen, of all those horrific scenes that look like something out of.
00:24:17
Speaker 1: A war zone, oh, no, that's AI. He went on to.
00:24:21
Speaker 2: Because Donald Trump was very strong, saying, this is an Islamist takeover of Europe, we're saying. So Trump doesn't mince his words, and that's got Macron all up in arms saying.
00:24:32
Speaker 1: Donald Trump, he does not know what he's talking about. There is no Islamic invasion of Europe.
00:24:37
Speaker 2: Well, the evidence of one's eyes might suggest otherwise.
00:24:41
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:24:41
Speaker 6: Well, I mean, he's also said that the people, the only people who are being sensationalised about these riots, who are supercritical of them, are people... who hate France. And that's not true at all. In fact, it's the people who love France, who wanted to protect France as the beautiful,
historic European nation that it is and respect its history that are so opposed to what's happening right now that the police have finally brought out water cannons. We were talking last week about why are they not doing more about it. Now there's the tear gas. It's really turned super violent there.
00:25:20
Speaker 4: It's turned super violent and You know, the judges, the first round of sentences that were reported, the judges bent over backwards to make sure the sentences were non-custodial. Only a couple of people got anything, and it was just a little bit. The rest was sort of like, hey, tut-tut, don't do it again. So, you know, you've got the same two-tier policing and judicial system happening in France that you do elsewhere in Europe. Its weakness, it shows the government is afraid of the rioters, afraid of the protesters. And, you know, actually.
00:25:50
Speaker 4: It's not just Islamism. It's actually, we've talked about this before, it is Islamo-leftism, and it is the fusion of the secular revolutionary left, which hates the West, and the Islamist population, which also wants to overthrow the West for its own purposes. fusing together, and you see what we saw. The burning of the town hall in Limoges, that incredible desecration, that was not AI. Pardon, Monsieur President.
00:26:20
Speaker 6: And all the looting of the designer shops, what does that have to do with anything? You know, do they just want a few Louis Vuitton handbags?
00:26:27
Speaker 4: It's about school students. They need a new Chanel school bag.
00:26:31
Speaker 1: Come on.
00:26:32
Speaker 2: And Macron also made the ridiculous statement, which he's now walked back from, that this was the first time there had been any ethnic violence.
00:26:39
Speaker 1: or deaths in France.
00:26:41
Speaker 6: That was about it. He said that it was the first time there'd been a racist attack after a white Frenchman took a World War Two machine gun and shot at Muslim people.
00:26:52
Speaker 7: It did kill a man.
00:26:54
Speaker 6: And there were, I think, five others injured, including a 12 year old girl.
00:26:58
Speaker 7: Awful attack.
00:26:59
Speaker 6: But for him to make such a comment, I mean, we're talking about a country that had the Charlie Hebdo attack. There are so many examples that even Emmanuel Macron, after saying this is the first racist attack, had to retract the statement. They actually know Jews, Christians, they've all been attacked in this country. But it just shows you how quickly the race of the attacker came out in this instance.
00:27:23
Speaker 11: Yep.
00:27:23
Speaker 6: To fit a particular narrative that leaders are so wanting to suppress anything.
00:27:30
Speaker 7: Yeah.
00:27:30
Speaker 1: That's what it's all about.
00:27:31
Speaker 2: We're going to take a short break after this. James' truth bomb, and then we've got Matt Canavan on the show. Can't wait for that in a tick.
00:27:43
Speaker 4: Hello, you're watching Outsiders with your hosts, Rowan Dean, Carolyn Marcus, and myself, James Morrow. Now, of course, this week the news here in Australia has been dominated, and rightly so, by the horrifying alleged vehicular assault of independent MP Helen Haynes outside her Wangaratta electorate office. And while I know that all of us at Outsiders and News 24 are keeping Helen and her family in our thoughts and prayers, this attack on a sitting MP has a deeply political component, particularly because despite the motivations behind the attack remaining quite murky and unclear, and Caroline's going to delve a bit more into that a little bit later in the program, well, our own Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, he has other ideas. He has decided... to make this a very political issue indeed. Unable to blame the horror on his political opponents, Albanese has gone down the collective guilt route, implying that we all bear a bit of responsibility for what happened Monday because we have failed to turn down the temperature.
00:28:52
Speaker 5: Look, we have made a range of comments that I have made. Go look up The interviews in which I've done and called for the temperature to be turned down when it comes to political discourse. We all have a responsibility to turn the temperature down. It is something that I have spoken about on countless occasions.
00:29:21
Speaker 4: Ah, yes, turning the temperature down. His entire life in politics, that's all Albanese has ever done, turned the temperature down. It started when he was a young man, when he was a young pro-Palestinian activist and grabbed the microphone to turn the temperature down around Israel.
00:29:41
Speaker 14: In the grainy video, Mr Albanese can be seen protesting against Israel's occupation of Palestine next to a sign that reads, stop the Israeli slaughter, free Palestine now. Mr Albanese also used a microphone to condemn the Israeli military.
00:29:57
Speaker 15: Children throwing rocks with helicopter gunships, with tanks and with missiles.
00:30:06
Speaker 4: And then there was that time in 2015 when, sitting on the opposition benches, Albanese issued this instruction to Catherine King to turn the temperature down when she was responding to health minister, then health minister, Susan Lay, at the dispatch box.
00:30:22
Speaker 7: The new.
00:30:25
Speaker 2: This is the only way the members of Ballarat can actually get a question.
00:30:28
Speaker 1: The member for Ballarat, on a point of order.
00:30:31
Speaker 11: Thank you.
00:30:34
Speaker 4: Or when, just a few weeks before the devastating attack on Haynes, Albanese's very own office turned the temperature down by circulating a so-called dirt sheet on Helen Haynes, the woman whose integrity he spent the past week praising, suggesting that she may have acted improperly requesting grants for various projects in her own electorate. This dirt sheet was, of course, in retaliation, for Haynes is raising very legitimate questions about just how Albanese's local golf course and watering
hole was promised $ 6 million by the prime minister for a new clubhouse, bar and pro shop through a secretive invitation-only grants program. Now, Albanese, of course, denied that there was anything untoward about that, and he and his ministers have run a million miles from suggestion that this was some sort of political hit. Heaven forfend.
00:31:27
Speaker 10: So, did the office send that out? Do you regret that in hindsight, given the events of recent days?
00:31:33
Speaker 5: Well, Helen Haynes is a strong advocate for her community, and she advocates for funding, just as the Coalition made more than 1,000 commitments worth... $ 1. 644 billion during the election campaign. That's what local members do for their local communities.
00:31:55
Speaker 10: Yeah, so if it was a dirt sheet, you're sounding like it was not much of a dirt sheet, that it was more of a rap, given your assessment of it.
00:32:01
Speaker 1: Let's talk about the.
00:32:03
Speaker 10: Or a compliment, I should say.
00:32:04
Speaker 1: Let's look at the News 24... Well, people advocate for their electorates. That's what Helen Haynes does. No, I get it. And that's what other members do.
00:32:12
Speaker 4: Yeah, well, finally, there he was turning down the temperature when the heat was on him. But wasn't it just lovelier of your office, Prime Minister, to highlight Haynes' achievement like that for the press? She's not even in your party. What a mensch. Sure thing, Prime Minister. I believe you. Millions wouldn't. Yet what is just as galling about Labor's attempt to turn the attack on Haynes into a plea for civility, and by this I mean a demand to pass net censorship laws, a.k.a. the digital duty of care, is the number of times they have been silent about others' uncivil behavior. For example, remember the time Anthony Albanese's great pal Grace Tame rocked up at a Palestine protested and screamed this.
00:33:00
Speaker 17: From Gadigal to Gaza, globalize the Intifada!
00:33:04
Speaker 1: One more time!
00:33:05
Speaker 2: From Gadigal to Gaza.
00:33:07
Speaker 7: Globalize the Intifada!
00:33:11
Speaker 4: Now, surprisingly, Albanese, who loves to turn down the temperature, wants other people to turn down the temperature, refused to condemn Tame's words and actions, instead again urging everyone else to, you guessed it, turn down the temperature. That means the people criticizing Tame not tame herself, just in case that wasn't clear. Oh, and then there was a time Anthony Albanese and his mate, Home Affairs Minister Tony 3000 Visas for Gaza Burke, got chased out of Lakemba Mosque and down the street by locals. Well, just like the time he denied he fell off a stage despite everyone seeing it, Albanese claimed they were not run out of town and that the reports were not accurate. Don't believe your own eyes there. It never happened. No need to turn down the temperature in Lakemba, that's for sure, because, hey, that's where Labour gets a lot of their votes from. Nor, apparently,
is there a need to turn down the temperature against One Nation, particularly not those recent school protests that looked something like the two-minute hate sessions George Orwell predicted in his dystopian novel 1984.
00:34:22
Speaker 1: Guys, what would you do.
00:34:23
Speaker 7: If Pauline Hanson were here today?
00:34:25
Speaker 2: I'm not.
00:34:26
Speaker 7: I would f * * * ing shoot her. I would f * * * ing hit her. It's like, beat.
00:34:30
Speaker 6: Her the f * * * up!
00:34:32
Speaker 11: Kill her!
00:34:34
Speaker 4: Now, Albanese went to the Brisbane Labour Conference around that same time and said, in fact, actually, the problem was that people like Pauline Hanson and populist parties like hers were, quote, dangerous, divisive and downright dishonest. Points for alliteration to your speechwriter there, and what a great way to turn down the temperature, Prime Minister.
00:34:59
Speaker 1: Great stuff. Thanks, James.
00:35:00
Speaker 2: Now I'm pleased to say we're joined by Nationals leader Matt Canavan. Matt, great to see you and thanks so much for coming on the show. I want to ask you about the Victoria Barracks thing. As you know, there's a big protest about to..... in a couple of hours outside Victoria Barracks there, and I know you're passionate on that topic.
00:35:14
Speaker 1: Also, the EU free trade deal.
00:35:17
Speaker 2: So, this morning, I heard that one of the large groups, I think Grocers or Fruiters or something, have come out saying, we want to go in on a trade deal. You're a staunch opponent. Tell us why it's a mistake for Australia to sign up to this.
00:35:34
Speaker 18: It's a mistake because this deal doesn't amount to free trade. We have signed lots of free trade deals. We signed one with the UK a few years ago. Under that deal, eventually Australia will get unlimited access for beef, for dairy products, for a range of agricultural and other goods. Under this deal, we barely get any access to the European Union. And so the worst thing about this deal is it just absolutely undermines our negotiating position for the long term. I mean, Don Farrell's got to be the worst negotiator in Australia history. He actually walked away from this very deal three years ago. He said he didn't think it was a good deal for Australia, notionally holding out for something better. And then he crawled back three years later and signed exactly the same deal. I mean, Australia has never been a pushover when it's come to trade agreements. The coalition government was not a pushover, demonstrated by the great deal we got with the UK by taking a tough negotiating stance. This deal completely weakens that. Now, I can understand why vegetable growers are struggling under the... cost of living crisis that Labor has imposed on them would like to see increased access.
00:36:45
Speaker 1: They do get increased access.
00:36:46
Speaker 18: But I don't think it's fair or right to sacrifice some farm industries for the benefit of others. It's
not so much just that this deal doesn't do, doesn't give us that free trade. It's also that it would actively harm some Australian industries. So, for example, the EU subsidises its dairy industry to the hilt. About 30% of a European cheesemaker's income comes from government support.
00:37:10
Speaker 1: None of that goes under this deal.
00:37:12
Speaker 4: All of that stays.
00:37:13
Speaker 18: Yet a tariff that we have imposed to protect our dairy industry against an unfair competition will be removed by this deal. That is a bad, bad arrangement for our dairy industry. It would send our cheesemakers to the wall, and I can't support that.
00:37:26
Speaker 4: Well, Matt, I think you're absolutely right to highlight just how incredibly protectionist the European Union is. And in some ways, they make Donald Trump look like a Chicago School of Economics free trader. But another issue that has been coming up this week in discussions is the Paris targets that are part of it. Apparently, I understand that the trade agreement would bind Australia to Paris targets, even if the coalition or some other future government changes Australia's net zero targets. But if the coalition is still committed to not getting rid of Paris, what is the disagreement there?
00:38:08
Speaker 18: Well, look, you're right to say, James, what the government has announced here is that this deal, for the first time, would make the Paris agreement legally binding. That's the words they have used. And there's another reason why we can't support that, because trade deals shouldn't be used... to restrict the sovereignty and independence of other countries, especially in this case where the European Union and Australia account for just 7% of the world's carbon emissions. What is the point of making a legally binding deal on something that we will have no impact on? Now, yes, look, I've always found the Paris Agreement pretty non-objectionable for the very reason that it is not legally binding. James, that's the point. It doesn't stop us or restrict us from doing anything. And I like to focus on things that really matter in life. And what matters is our net zero targets, our net zero legislation, which is holding back our country and forcing energy prices and the cost of living.
00:39:03
Speaker 4: Through the roof.
00:39:04
Speaker 18: Now, this deal, though, would change that, would change that and make the Paris Agreement legally binding. That is why we cannot support that. I mean, look, I'd love to do trade deals with other countries. I'd love to see us have better access to European markets and And I wrote to the Trade Minister just days after he announced this back down and his signing of a bad deal that he'd walked away from three years ago and said, look, we'd like to be constructive, but you've can't make the Paris Agreement legally binding then expect our support we have to have substantively increased access to agricultural markets and we can't hurt farm industries like dairy to get our support and another issue has been the EU has doubled its steel tariffs to Australia while we have been negotiating this deal And they remain. We'll face a 50% steel tariff. Half our hot-rolled coils go to the EU, and they'll face increased tariffs even with this deal. It's so bad on so many levels. It is a dud deal, and the Liberals and Nationals and the Coalition cannot support this in its current form. I don't know where One Nation is at. You'll have to ask where One Nation is. They apparently are opening the door to the deal. Barnaby said, he's still considering it. I don't know what it is about Europeans and Barnaby rolling over, but he did the same thing with Glasgow and net zero. But we're steadfast against these sort of international agreements which tie our country down.
00:40:27
Speaker 1: Excellent. Caroline?
00:40:29
Speaker 6: Well, Matt, I have to ask you, your Nationals colleague, Michelle Landry, she won't contest the next election. There's been a lot of reporting over the past day that you are going to be running for the seat of Capricornia.
00:40:42
Speaker 7: Will you confirm it here on Outsiders?
00:40:47
Speaker 4: I love you, Caroline.
00:40:48
Speaker 1: I love the outside of this show.
00:40:50
Speaker 4: It's fantastic.
00:40:52
Speaker 1: I love all the people watching.
00:40:53
Speaker 18: And I'm going to have to disappoint you when I've got no news on that this morning. Look, yeah, Michelle built her career on being a local champion. We've built our success here on just doing things for local people.
00:41:06
Speaker 1: We've built.
00:41:06
Speaker 18: We've built dams. We've built the Rookwood Weir. It's growing 800,000 macadamia trees. We got the Adani Carmichael mine going. We faced a global green, massively funded movement. And we got that mine going. It's employing 2,000 people now. The Rocky Ring Road is being built right now, thanks to the rallying we did with our local community. So, you know, the Nationals and my political career has always been focused on locals.
00:41:31
Speaker 4: You know, I've I'm in this.
00:41:33
Speaker 1: I do this. I'm about to fly away from my.
00:41:35
Speaker 18: Local home and my local family this afternoon to go to Canberra again. I do that to represent them and fight for them. And so any announcement on my future or the LNP counter for Capricornia will be made here locally. And so I'm sorry to disappoint you on a national show today, but always love coming on Outsiders.
00:41:53
Speaker 2: Matt, just quickly, you know, up in Townsville, many of your constituents are..... in Rockhampton are ex-Army, vets or Army, in the Army. Your thoughts on the Victoria barracks, the selling off of all those military assets, and your thoughts on the Ben Roberts Smith.
00:42:12
Speaker 1: speeches during the week and interviews.
00:42:16
Speaker 18: Yeah, look, I just think the government has had its head in the sand with regards to veterans' issues and is just not listening
to the veterans' community. We saw that with the Allied Health Cap. They put in place in the budget without any consultations, discussions with veterans. They don't deserve to be treated like that. Thankfully, the veterans' community rallied so strongly that the government has backed down on that. Likewise here, there seems to be no involvement with the locals around the Victoria Barracks and the veterans that use that facility. And We should just not be selling off our nation's heritage and history. We need to have pride in our nation. We need to restore that. So this is such a nonsensical decision. But just like the allied health cap.
00:42:54
Speaker 1: I think the.
00:42:55
Speaker 18: The campaigning of the veterans community is going to win this. So we're standing side by side with them. I know Jess Collins there in New South Wales is doing a tremendous job. And I believe she's hosting that rally today. So good on Jess and good on the veteran community. There's so many great people who have served our nation. They backed us. They fought for us. We're very proud to fight with them and back them in this fight. And then on Ben Roberts-Smith, look, this has gone on way too long. I think this has exposed something that's horribly wrong with how we handle these sorts of allegations. About 20-something years ago, we did change the law so that these would go from being..... war crimes would go from being evaluated by a military tribunal to a civilian court process, and I think we have to look seriously at whether this is the right way to do these things. I feel terribly for Ben Robert Smith and the trauma he's had to go through. Of course, though, we also have to have a military that's based on rules and standards and there has to be a way of evaluating allegations of these kinds. So we maintain a fighting force that is disciplined, that is subject to routine. But I'm not sure this way is the right way to.
00:44:10
Speaker 1: Go about that.
00:44:11
Speaker 2: Matt Canavan, love having you on the show because you completely pre-empted my 10 o'clock editorial word for word.
00:44:16
Speaker 1: You got into my head and took the words out of my mouth. But I'm so glad you said what you've said.
00:44:21
Speaker 2: Matt Canavan, and I hope you'll be watching later on on the show. You have a great day, and thanks so much for coming on, Outsiders.
00:44:26
Speaker 1: We love having you on the show.
00:44:28
Speaker 2: Matt Canavan there, great job he does. We're going to take a short break, then we come back and we've got some Emissions Impossible in a tick. You're watching Outsiders, and thank you so much for watching us. Every Sunday morning, we certainly do appreciate your company, and we're delighted to have the company of Caroline Marcus filling in for Rita and doing a sensational job, as always. Caroline, can't wait for your editorial coming up later. Well, this is The Hannah Ferguson Show this week, because we're going to kick off our Emissions Impossible, which.
00:45:04
Speaker 1: Is when we... our.
00:45:05
Speaker 2: Mission, which is to look at all those madness, crazy net zero policies and the whole climate change grift.
00:45:12
Speaker 1: Have a listen to Hannah Ferguson. We talked about her earlier.
00:45:15
Speaker 2: She's a lefty popular media figure. Yesterday in Sydney, it was a beautiful day, went walking in the park, but Hannah Ferguson had something to tell those people outside the town hall here in Sydney yesterday.
00:45:30
Speaker 1: Have a listen.
00:45:31
Speaker 19: We are here today and we have hundreds if not thousands of young people.
00:45:35
Speaker 3: Standing in the shade.
00:45:38
Speaker 11: In October.
00:45:39
Speaker 20: Because we can't stand in the sun because of the overwhelming heat that we are facing.
00:45:45
Speaker 3: We are staring down the most dangerous summer of our lives in this country.
00:45:52
Speaker 21: And we will say that next year, and the year after that, and the year after that. And we all stand here fighting on our Saturday afternoon in the sun because our leaders do.
00:46:05
Speaker 1: Not represent us.
00:46:08
Speaker 7: Down with the sun. Down with the sun.
00:46:11
Speaker 4: I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Stupidity.
00:46:15
Speaker 8: This is.
00:46:16
Speaker 4: Idiocy. This is so hilarious. I mean... It's Australia, Hannah. It's Sydney.
00:46:21
Speaker 1: You're standing on an October afternoon in the sun.
00:46:24
Speaker 4: It's... It's Australia. Land of sun. It's Sydney. It's late October. It's... Coming into summer, it's a beautiful, sunny Saturday. And, you know, normal people.
00:46:37
Speaker 19: Say, hey, this is great. I'm going to go to the park. I'm going to hop in the pool. I'm going to do whatever. And, you know, say, isn't it lovely? We've got this beautiful Sydney day. Sydney is so glorious on days like this. And imagine what's going on in this woman's head today. to say, oh, no, it's not a hate crime, it's a heat crime that we're all suffering here and being miserable about the weather. It's like, again, I spoke about.
00:47:06
Speaker 4: Whatever combination of personality problems you've got that, you know, you look at a plastic coffee cup and you go, oh, my God. And then you go, oh, no, you're drinking a cup from a disposable cup on a sunny day. Like the incredible neurosis that goes backing up this side of politics here. It's so miserable and so unhappy, and I feel bad for them. I legitimately feel bad that you can't enjoy a lovely late October day.
00:47:35
Speaker 7: It wasn't even that hot.
00:47:36
Speaker 6: It was about 24, 25 degrees. It was a little warmer. It was nice. We've had very cold days recently, too, though, unlike exceptionally cold days, but that doesn't.
00:47:46
Speaker 3: Fit the narrative.
00:47:47
Speaker 4: That's climate chaos, Caroline. That's climate chaos.
00:47:49
Speaker 7: I'm sorry.
00:47:50
Speaker 6: Still climate change in some form or another. It's sad, isn't
it? It makes me feel sad too for young people because this sort of climate anxiety is rife.
00:48:00
Speaker 1: I know. And it's being taught in schools too.
00:48:02
Speaker 2: I don't know whether to be more scared by the fact that she actually believes what she's saying or that she's just going along because she wants to grandstand up there and this is all part of the lefty narrative. But if she believes that nonsense, she's a product of the Australian education system.
00:48:20
Speaker 1: That's it, full stop. She's a product.
00:48:23
Speaker 2: of the last 20 years of people like Zali Steggles, girls crying at Zali Steggles rallies because of the climate and all this sort of stuff. They have the... This is child abuse, what they've done to this generation. If you were standing around yesterday in Sydney fretting that it's going to be the most dangerous summer ever and the one after that's going to be the most dangerous summer ever and the one after that's going to be the most dangerous summer.
00:48:47
Speaker 1: Well, hang on.
00:48:48
Speaker 2: At what point, you know, do you just give up?
00:48:50
Speaker 1: I mean, it is insane.
00:48:52
Speaker 2: But worse than that, it destroys the ambition and the aspiration and the optimism of an entire generation who should be planning great futures. No generation in history has had the living standards that young Australians have ever.
00:49:09
Speaker 1: They're the top of the tree. They're the greatest that.
00:49:13
Speaker 2: Any humans have ever had. And they're miserable. And they're miserable because the sun's shining. This is child abuse. The entire education system, the political establishment of both parties are completely responsible for having traumatised these kids.
00:49:30
Speaker 1: And look at the result of it. It's disgusting. Meanwhile... Meanwhile.
00:49:35
Speaker 2: Chris Bowen is out spending billions and billions of dollars trying to push water uphill, defying gravity, to make energy, which we have an abundance of anyway, and the taxpayer's going to pay for this as well, James.
00:49:49
Speaker 4: Well, how many metres of... that boring machine that gets stuck, keeps getting stuck in the mountains, Florence, how many meters can they advance Boris, Florence, sorry, not Boris, Florence, with the proceeds of the sale of Victoria Barracks? I mean, this is how incompetent this government is. Of course, we do have to pay tribute to the intellectual father. of Snowy 2.0, and I think you know who I'm referring to, the member for Wentworth, Malcolm Turnbull. But, no, we are now talking... This is going to cost $ 25 billion, but this is before you even hook it up to the grid. And, you know, this... The great thing about Snowy is that it illustrates the point with all of the problems, with all of these renewables projects, is that they are all so distant from where you actually need the power in such often inhospitable turf that... you know, they just do a back-of-the-envelope costing to make it look good, get the investment and so on and so forth, and then the reality of these things, whether it's, you know, the Humulink transmission line or it's, you know, pushing water uphill to run it back down the hill again in the Snowy Mountains with this sort of Jack and Jill project here, is it never stacks up. It never stacks up.
00:51:02
Speaker 2: Yeah, but this is why, seriously, in Parliament... You should be allowed, ministers and prime ministers should be allowed to make whatever predictions they want, but there must be an accountability. I would like to see Malcolm Turnbull cough up the $ 23 billion that is over and above what he promised us this thing would cost.
00:51:20
Speaker 1: That's what I would like to see.
00:51:21
Speaker 4: Malcolm?
00:51:22
Speaker 2: Put your money where your mouth is. Prove to us what a great legacy is. You pay the $ 23 billion.
00:51:25
Speaker 4: You might have to sell the palace.
00:51:26
Speaker 2: Because otherwise we have to pay it. And it comes out every one of our pockets.
00:51:29
Speaker 6: Maybe they could sell his Point Piper mansion instead.
00:51:32
Speaker 1: Of Victoria Barracks. You'd pick up a few, Bob, for that?
00:51:35
Speaker 4: Sell the pink palace!
00:51:36
Speaker 9: Yes.
00:51:36
Speaker 1: We're going to take a short break.
00:51:38
Speaker 2: Coming back, I'll be chatting about Ben Roberts-Smith in a tick. Hello, you're watching Outsiders with James. You wouldn't Adam and Eve it, Mauro. Caroline, just one bite of the apple, Marcus. And myself, Rowan the Serpent, Dean. This week, because of his PR campaign, the interview on this network and on 2GB with Ben Fordham, every shopfront galah has had his or her say on the Ben Robert Smith affair. So I'm going to have my say, but I begin, obviously, by saying I am making no judgment on the guilt or innocence of Ben Robert Smith.
00:52:18
Speaker 1: I'll start off with a riddle for you.
00:52:21
Speaker 2: What have giggle versus tickle, the insane case where, under Australian law, a biological man can be a woman, COP 31, Chris Bowen and his insane multi-billion dollar destruction of our cheap and reliable energy system and pristine farmland, and the insane criminal prosecution of Ben Robert Smith all got in common.
00:52:45
Speaker 1: I'll tell you, all three share the same original sin.
00:52:50
Speaker 2: And that original sin is when the Australian government, without consulting the people, signed us up to various international treaties. That is the bottom line. That is the original sin. All three of these travesties of politics, travesties of justice, and travesties of common sense share not only the fact that they are completely bonkers and incomprehensible to the average Australian, gender insanity, climate insanity and judicial insanity. All three are also the direct result of federal governments, Liberal and Labor, disgracefully signing Australia up to idiotic international treaties when they should have known
better. The Declaration of Human Rights, the Paris Climate Agreement and the Rome Statute.
00:53:41
Speaker 1: In my opinion, all.
00:53:43
Speaker 2: Three have proven to be an unmitigated disaster for Australia and have wreaked havoc on individual Australian lives. Without getting lost in the legal weeds, I'm not a lawyer, the original sin that led to Sal Grover having her life and livelihood turned upside down is because in 1984, the Hawke government established the Sex Discrimination Act, under the auspices of the Australian Human Rights Commission. In 2013, Julia Gillard changed the Sex Discrimination Act at the behest of the Australian Human Rights Commission to supposedly provide stronger legal protection against discrimination for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender and intersex people, blah, blah, blah. In Sal Grover's High Court case, which she lost, the ruling was specifically built around the insane Sex Discrimination Act as it stands now. And under that ruling, a biological man is a woman if he says he is, which defies logic, biology and common sense. But even the High Court is powerless to disregard international treaties.
00:54:48
Speaker 1: If we'd never signed up to human rights.
00:54:51
Speaker 2: Legislation in the first place, if we'd never amended the Sex Discrimination Act at the Human Rights Commission's behest, Sal Grover would right now be a wealthy and happy Aussie woman running a highly successful and popular woman's only app. The original sin behind the idiocy of COP 31, Chris Bowen, and the madness of the multi-billion dollar net zero renewables transition nonsense was when the Howard government signed us up to the Kyoto rubbish and then the Turnbull government signed us up to and ratified the Paris Agreement. The destruction to our economy and to our landscape from this madness is, in my opinion, unprecedented in this nation's history. If we'd never signed up to that climate change nonsense in the first place, in my opinion, nearly every single Australian would today be far more relaxed, far more comfortable and much, much wealthier. And Ben Robert Smith. Well, there the original sin was when Australia, under the Howard government, adopted the Rome Statute into Australian law to ensure that domestic laws were compatible with international standards. But this required that Australian military law be compatible with the International Criminal Court, the ICC. This was completely unnecessary. America refused to do it and we could and should have refused too. Indeed, the Trump administration regards the ICC as a rogue outfit they want dismantled and they have implemented sanctions against some of the individuals. As Louise Clegg, brilliantly wrote in April in The Spectator Australia, of which I'm the editor, quote, In 2002, Australia enacted sweeping amendments to the Commonwealth Criminal Code, inserting Division 268. Its purpose was clear, to create offences of international concern and ensure Australia's jurisdiction
was complementary to that of the International Criminal Court. Under the Howard government, Parliament ensured that if war crimes were committed, Australia could prosecute them itself rather than leave the matter to the Hague.
00:57:12
Speaker 1: What was once the work of courts.
00:57:14
Speaker 2: Martial became proceedings in the ordinary criminal courts.
00:57:19
Speaker 4: End of quote.
00:57:20
Speaker 2: But, writes Louise, the principle of complementarity does not require what Australia did. That, these are my words, that was the original sin. Had the Howard government refused to sign us up, BRS would not now be in the ruinous position he is in. Yes, he would have possibly faced a court-martial.
00:57:43
Speaker 1: Full stop. End of conversation.
00:57:46
Speaker 2: That is the only way, in my opinion, a soldier should ever be accused, charged or tried with a war crime by a military court.
00:57:56
Speaker 1: Because, in my opinion, civilian.
00:57:58
Speaker 2: Juries and, more importantly, woke lefty civilian judges should never be trusted with interpreting and determining the moral and legal complexities of the battlefield. Signing us up to international legal compatibility with the ICC was the original sin.
00:58:15
Speaker 1: But then it got a lot worse.
00:58:18
Speaker 2: The federal attorney general in the first Albanese Labor government, Mark Dreyfus, changed Australia's war crimes law in September 2024. His amendment made it easier in certain circumstances, to prosecute alleged war crimes involving people who were already out of combat, out of combat.
00:58:38
Speaker 1: And it applied.
00:58:39
Speaker 2: Retrospectively to conduct, dating back to 2002. And what was their rationale for this? Oh, of course, the government said it was correcting a drafting error to bring Australian law into line with international law.
00:58:55
Speaker 1: There we go again.
00:58:57
Speaker 2: Same as sex discrimination, same as climate change. This is an absolute disgrace, in my opinion, and the Coalition, to their eternal shame, went along with this travesty.
00:59:10
Speaker 1: Why?
00:59:11
Speaker 2: Who in the Liberal Party room, in the Liberal Party room, convinced the rest of them that this was a good idea?
00:59:18
Speaker 1: I'd love to know. Any guesses? Again, it's complicated.
00:59:22
Speaker 2: But basically, simply by changing the word and to the word or, it meant that a prosecution could go ahead and if only one of three conditions were met rather than all three. And Dreyfus made it retrospective, which, in my opinion.
00:59:38
Speaker 1: Is despicable. But still, it gets even worse.
00:59:43
Speaker 2: On Friday, Liberal Senator Michaelia Cash raised serious questions in Parliament around the Ben Robert Smith prosecution regarding whether the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecution, Raylene Sharp, had a potential conflict of interest in prosecuting Robert Smith. Michaelia was asking whether Sharpe's previous work with the Office of the Special Investigator, which investigated alleged war crimes, created an actual or perceived conflict of interest. Senator Cash also highlighted disclosures that Sharpe and the OSI's Director-General met with the Attorney-General on 1 April 2026 to discuss the prosecution the same day consent was granted. As one social media post asked, How can a trial be fair when the person choosing who gets immunity already helped lead the initial hunt? Then there's the fact that the Australian government ran ads funded by the taxpayer in Afghan language newspapers in Australia, appealing for information about possible breaches of the laws of armed conflict by Australian forces in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016.
01:00:49
Speaker 1: It's just my opinion. I am not a lawyer. And I make no judgment on guilt.
01:00:57
Speaker 2: Or innocence regarding the charges against Ben Robert Smith. But as far as I'm concerned, this entire affair stinks to high heaven. Then there's the reality of Bondi. Future historians may well be baffled as twice. the same Australian authorities who failed to protect 15 Australians from being slaughtered and another 40 from being mowed down, allegedly by two radical Islamists at Australia's most popular and crowded beach, spent hundreds of millions of dollars prosecuting a Victoria Cross winner for actions carried out attempting to protect Australia from the threat of radical Islamists. It was Mahatma Gandhi who said there is a higher court than courts of justice and that is the court of conscience.
01:01:47
Speaker 1: It supersedes all other courts.
01:01:51
Speaker 2: How can any Australian in all good conscience look at what our governments have done in relation to the Ben Robert Smith affair and not be appalled? I'll be blunt and perhaps a little unkind here. But to me, you only had to look at Ben Robert Smith and.
01:02:06
Speaker 1: See the toll.
01:02:08
Speaker 2: That this entire affair has already taken on him. And this, unless something dramatic happens, will continue for him and his family for possibly five or more years.
01:02:19
Speaker 1: As usual, the process is the punishment.
01:02:25
Speaker 2: On day one of a new coalition and or one nation government, this charade must be put to rest. The new attorney general must drop all the charges against Ben Robert Smith and any other current war crimes cases. revoke all our Rome Statute international obligations and return military law to the Australian military.
01:02:43
Speaker 1: That's in the morning.
01:02:44
Speaker 2: In the afternoon, we also need to pull out of the Paris Agreement, disband the Australian Human Rights Commission and revoke the Sex and Racial Discrimination Acts.
01:02:52
Speaker 1: It'll be quite a busy day.
01:02:59
Speaker 2: Now, I'm pleased to say we're joined by our great mates over there in London, Reform UK, former Reform UK candidate Myron Semple-Nathan.
01:03:06
Speaker 1: Myron, great to see you.
01:03:07
Speaker 2: And again,
more chaos across Europe, although Macron tells us it's all AI.
01:03:13
Speaker 1: It's all in our minds.
01:03:14
Speaker 2: There is no Islamic invasion of Europe. It's all just Donald Trump making stuff up. Myron, you're closer to it than we are. Tell us what's going on.
01:03:24
Speaker 17: Well, if you take the broader picture, I would simply say Europe has lost its soul, to be frank with you.
01:03:30
Speaker 3: I mean, over the last few decades, we've built.
01:03:33
Speaker 17: A society, we've tried to build a society and make it flourish under a bureaucratic block. And effectively, what's happened is we have a post-national society without borders, without heritage, without an identity. And what happens is economic and cultural nihilism. And that's effectively what's happening across Europe. And when you have a swelling state, which is hyper-regulated, it gives no prospect to the younger generation. When you teach the younger generation about white guilt, when there's mass immigration with multiple generations now, which are increasingly non-integrated, into the host country. And as you said, an Islamist component that is now compounding the situation, along with a kind of Marxist zeal, a radical zeal of revolution that often affects the younger generation in particular. And so this is what's happening across Europe. It's happening across France and Italy and Belgium. And that contagion is now starting to spread even potentially to the UK. And as you said, Emmanuel Macron, he's like the arsonist who is wondering why the house is on fire. And he's asking why are French people committing these crimes to France? And my question to him is, how do you know who is French anymore? What does it mean to be French?
01:04:48
Speaker 3: And I think that's the underlying problem.
01:04:50
Speaker 4: Well, that is an underlying problem, Myron. But I mean... Watching the footage from the riots in France and the horrific things that have taken place, part of it, obviously, yes, those are the children, second and third generation migrants that are heavily involved with it, but you've also got a lot of people from Antifa and groups like that involved, and you have the white French children who were educated by the children of 1968, which is the last time the demons of revolution really took over the streets of France. of France and were eventually put down. These kids have been taught their whole life, you know, France doesn't exist. France, to the extent it does exist, is racist and colonialist. You're a European now. You're not French. You don't have an identity. Is this why we are seeing so many people join up with this idea to just burn it all down?
01:05:45
Speaker 3: Absolutely.
01:05:45
Speaker 17: I mean, if you don't have an affiliation to your country, to your institutions, to your history, what do you have?
01:05:51
Speaker 3: What do you call yourself?
01:05:53
Speaker 17: And so what we have to look at is the kind of excitement and the furore around burning down the very institutions that these individuals have benefited from. But the problem is, they would argue, we haven't benefited from these institutions. They would argue that France hasn't given us anything. We have no skin in the game. We have no stake in the nation. And that's the fundamental problem I'm talking about. Whether it's indoctrination through ideology or whether it's through economic means or whether it's through mass migration, they have no skin in the game. And as a result of that, through frustration, through exasperation, through excitement, they are turning to riots of this epic proportion.
01:06:34
Speaker 1: Hold on.
01:06:35
Speaker 6: Myron, I want to ask you about this former producer from the BBC who's come out and blasted the public broadcaster. Therefore, it's pro-Palestine bias. Interestingly, this guy, Phil Craig, also worked for our own ABC here as the head of Factual, who knew.
01:06:52
Speaker 7: There was something.
01:06:54
Speaker 6: But he's had this to say.
01:07:00
Speaker 3: News makes mistakes. We all know news coverage can be faulty. There are wars, people spin them, both sides spin, and there's propaganda. But all the mistakes in this particular war seem to be in the same direction. Mistakes of hiring people with.
01:07:15
Speaker 4: Incredibly partisan views, or maybe hiring people who, or employ people who are actually part of Hamas.
01:07:24
Speaker 6: How bad has the BBC got over there?
01:07:27
Speaker 17: Well, I would say the BBC used to be a national treasure, and I look upon the BBC as an old friend that has gone rogue.
01:07:35
Speaker 3: And the reason why the BBC.
01:07:37
Speaker 17: Is so important is because, in many ways, as a state broadcaster, it holds the reins to the Overton window. It kind of lays the platform for what is permissible debate, what is misinformation, what is disinformation, what is acceptable opinions. And because it has been captured by the left... It has effectively changed the whole narrative upon which we can discuss politics and the issues of today.
01:08:02
Speaker 3: And in many ways, I would.
01:08:03
Speaker 17: Hold the BBC responsible for many of the woes that Britain faces. And one thing you have to give the left credit for is that they know how to play the long-term game. They know how to infiltrate the education system, the quangos, the NGOs, and also the public institutions. And the BBC is another victim of that. And as this ex-producer was saying, it is expected to be hijacked by radicalized youth who are very much pro-Palestine. And let's face it, the Palestine issue is no longer about the humanitarian crisis in Palestine.
01:08:36
Speaker 3: It's about an anti-Western agenda.
01:08:38
Speaker 17: It's about climate change, open borders, LGBTQ, all sorts of things that go well beyond the Palestine situation in Gaza.
01:08:46
Speaker 2: And Myron had to laugh at Andy Burnham at a time when all the chaos is going on and all the
different things that are happening that he decides to go on a thing called Gogglebox, that TV show. It's Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister. And have a listen to Kemi Badenoch, the opposition leader, talking about it.
01:09:06
Speaker 20: What I'm amazed at is that Andy Burnham's got time to go on Gogglebox. When you get a new job in politics, it's so difficult. There's so much work to do. It's like drinking from a fire hose. So many papers to read. Even as a junior minister, as a secretary of state, I never had time.
01:09:21
Speaker 4: To go on Gogglebox.
01:09:22
Speaker 1: Are you saying you think you should not do it?
01:09:24
Speaker 20: Well, I just don't know how he's got the time. There's a budget next week and he's going on Gogglebox. I mean, the last people who did that that I remember, I think Nigel Farage did it in 2014, Jeremy Corbyn did it in 2017.
01:09:35
Speaker 1: They weren't Prime Minister. What did you make of that, Myron?
01:09:42
Speaker 17: Yeah, I mean, I'm no fan of Kemi, but I agree with what she's saying. I think you have to understand who Andy Burnham is. He is desperate to be liked, and he has a specific brand, and his brand is this. I am the guy next door who just happens to be prime minister, but really, I'm.
01:09:58
Speaker 3: Just like you and me. We're just the same.
01:10:00
Speaker 17: And so all of his TikTok videos about how to make tea, what snacks he likes, what's his favorite band, is all feeding into this brand of I'm just a guy next door. And people say, look, he's doing it for charity. He's doing it for cancer. But my rebuttal is to say he's the prime minister.
01:10:16
Speaker 3: He could do a lot more.
01:10:17
Speaker 17: To help cancer patients that then appear on a reality TV show.
01:10:21
Speaker 3: And we've got... On one side, we've got the.
01:10:25
Speaker 17: Defence secretary telling us to stockpile food and resources in case of a cyber attack. And on the other hand, we've got Andy Burnham appearing on these reality TV shows. So mixed messaging, very unserious government. But what Andy Burnham is doing is he's preparing the electorate for an early general election, I would say... in the first three or four months next year. That is what he's trying to do. Because he has no mandate, he knows it, he's softening the public mood to say, I'm the nice guy and vote for me next year.
01:10:55
Speaker 3: That is what this is all about.
01:10:57
Speaker 1: Fantastic. Great prediction there, Myron.
01:10:59
Speaker 2: Can't wait to see that coming true. And we'll speak again soon. Thanks so much for coming on Outside. It was always great to have Myron on the show. Don't go away, plenty more. Caroline's got plenty to say about the Helen Haynes affair in a tick.
01:11:13
Speaker 6: Hello, you're watching Outsiders with your hosts, Rowan Dean, James Morrow and myself, Caroline Marcus, filling in for Rita Panahy. Now, it's entirely predictable how the left has spun the most shocking attack on an Australian politician since New South Wales Labor MP John Newman was shot dead outside his home in 1994. after receiving death threats over his war on crime and Asian gangs in Sydney's Cabramatta. Yeah, I know, a Labor MP who's tough on crime.
01:11:45
Speaker 7: The 90s were a different time.
01:11:48
Speaker 6: Very quickly, after the alleged car ramming of federal independent MP Helen Haynes outside her regional Victorian electorate office, we learned telling details about accused attacker Brendan Nugent. He'd been an environmental activist, a plant.
01:12:05
Speaker 7: Person, as he called himself on social media.
01:12:08
Speaker 6: But after October 7, like so many on the far left, Nugent seemed, at least online, to have abandoned the climate cause and focused his fanaticism instead on the war in Gaza and railing against Israel. In post, still available for all to see, Nugent even went so far as to call the PM and his foreign affairs minister, Penny Wong, lapdogs for the US. And honestly, if you think two of the most hostile to Israel politicians in Australian history are lapdogs for Trump and his support of Netanyahu, you've got to be far, far to the left. And over the weekend, the Australian unearthed a tranche of deleted tweets posted by Nugent, including retweeting why I don't condemn Hamas for October 7. And propaganda there was no physical evidence of rape.
01:13:05
Speaker 7: By Hamas militants.
01:13:08
Speaker 6: Sounds like the bloke may have been radicalised by none other than our very own Greta Thunberg, Grace Tame, who of course said this to the ABC earlier this year.
01:13:18
Speaker 22: Timney's texted in saying, can you please ask Grace why she's selective in her outrage? She says, I've never heard her condemn or speak out on behalf of the Israeli women who were raped and killed by Hamas on October 7th. Have you spoken about that? Have you expressed outrage about that?
01:13:35
Speaker 23: I'm not going to sink to the level of entertaining any kind of propaganda, Hamish.
01:13:41
Speaker 22: What's the propaganda included in that question?
01:13:43
Speaker 23: Those things have been debunked.
01:13:47
Speaker 19: Yes.
01:13:48
Speaker 6: The fact Brendan Nugent appeared to sympathise with a violent terror group and has reposted extremist views will, mark my words, continue to be dismissed by those on the left.
01:14:01
Speaker 7: They shouldn't.
01:14:02
Speaker 6: Whatever the direct motivation for this attack, and we may never have a clear answer to that, the fact remains this kind of deep, irrational hatred and obsession with Israel is has become a pretty telling clue someone has become dangerously unhinged. Just ask the Bondi gunman, who police have alleged filmed a video railing against Zionists in the lead-up to the massacre. Now, we now know that Nugent was a deeply troubled loner, estranged from his family, living in absolute squalor with a history of chronic pain, drug use and mental illness. But I can bet you one
thing, if there was even the slightest whiff Nugent held far right extremist views, that would have been the story over the past week. Instead, our MP has spent recent days bleeding platitudes like this.
01:14:58
Speaker 5: Go look up the interviews in which I've done and call for the temperature to be turned down when it comes to political discourse.
01:15:08
Speaker 7: Oh, please.
01:15:09
Speaker 6: Albanese spent the last three years doing next to nothing as people openly cheered for terror groups on our streets. Our universities were overrun with extremists calling for intifada and from the river to the sea, code for wiping Jews from Israel, and attacks on a daycare centre, a Jewish leader's former home and a stream of cars and businesses became at one point an almost daily occurrence. Well, nothing, that is, until 15 people were shot dead at Bondi. But back to Helen Haynes, and despite not knowing the motivation here, that didn't stop progressives from immediately framing this attack as an example of gendered violence. Now, let's put aside Nugent appears to be a far-left extremist with mental issues.
01:15:57
Speaker 7: He is, after all, a man.
01:15:59
Speaker 21: I think these actions sometimes are supposed to want to remove women from public life. But when we see a woman like Helen Haynes target, I think it speaks to a bigger issue of male violence against women in Australia as well.
01:16:10
Speaker 6: Now, as we told you at the start of this show, this Hannah Ferguson, this left-wing activist and political hopeful in Anthony Albanese's own seat, said after Charlie Kirk's death, violence was sometimes necessary. I guess it depends on what side of politics you're on. But it wasn't just Ferguson who was keen to make this attack about gender. A pervasive narrative this week has been what impact the so-called gendered violence would have on women considering a tilt at politics. But to care about women's ambitions would imply the left actually knows what a woman is. Even the usually sensible New South Wales Premier Chris Minns showed us this week that's too rarely the case. after his government's attempts to remove references to women and mothers in official policy documents and sneak in insidious gender neutral language instead.
01:17:08
Speaker 23: Only women breastfeed babies. Well, apparently not according to New South Wales Parliament, who released an updated list of policies today, including the breastfeeding policy. On page one, it says that Parliament recognises the importance of breastfeeding for both the parent and the baby and that they aim to provide a family-friendly workplace that enables parents to balance their work responsibilities and breastfeeding.
01:17:33
Speaker 7: Parent?
01:17:34
Speaker 6: Last time I checked, only women have breasts. At least Mins tellingly from Labor's right isn't too proud to admit when his people missed the mark, scrapping the changes almost as soon as they were exposed.
01:17:49
Speaker 13: And
I don't think that we need to be in a situation where these documents should have anything other than common sense language like mother and breastfeeding.
01:17:59
Speaker 6: A man, or as many may insist now, a non-binary person? If only Albo could take a leaf out of the Premier's book and admit when he gets it wrong. Instead, we were left with his pathetic yet entirely characteristic evasion, as James showed you earlier, when Kieran Gilbert asked him about his office's dirt sheet on Helen Haynes distributed in the weeks leading up to her attack.
01:18:25
Speaker 10: Do you regret that in hindsight, given the events of recent days?
01:18:29
Speaker 5: Well, Helen Haynes is a strong advocate for her community and she advocates for funding, just as the Coalition made more than 1,000 commitments worth $ 1. 644 billion during the election campaign.
01:18:46
Speaker 6: Note how the PM not only doesn't answer the question but... tries to somehow shift the blame to the Coalition. Accountability and leadership should be a deal-breaker for voters, but so too is recognition the threat may be coming from your own side.
01:19:07
Speaker 1: Great stuff. Thanks, Caroline. Yeah, I mean, that... The way Albanese just now... He's jumped the shark now. He really.
01:19:15
Speaker 2: He just thinks he can just lie and say anything. It's really depressing stuff. I want to talk quickly about what's happening in Israel. There's the election this week. That'll be interesting to see, whether Netanyahu gets back in. There's been a breakout of violence in the West Bank.
01:19:30
Speaker 1: Caroline?
01:19:31
Speaker 6: Yes, well, two Israeli soldiers were shot dead by a Palestinian terrorist in the West Bank. And that has led to Netanyahu saying that he's going to take a more hardline approach to security there and military operations. Now, obviously, the focus has been largely on Gaza over the past few years after the October 7 attack where 1,200 people were slaughtered. and more than 250 people taken hostage. But there has been.
01:19:58
Speaker 7: A problem in the West Bank as well.
01:20:01
Speaker 6: And Hamas hasn't taken credit for this attack, but they did praise.
01:20:06
Speaker 7: It in the aftermath.
01:20:07
Speaker 6: Now, this is all in the context of the Israeli elections coming up on Tuesday, where security will, of course, be the main issue for Israelis living there. So people are watching very closely as to what is happening in this case.
01:20:21
Speaker 11: James?
01:20:22
Speaker 4: Yeah, it's interesting. I mean... You've got Netanyahu going to the polls here, desperately seeking that re-election. It is apparently a very tight race, from what I understand, and the candidate most likely to potentially win apparently is not as much of a lefty squish as some people might think. So, you know, there may be a sense there that Bibi has had his run and that there could be an it's time factor that's working against him there, especially around some of the concerns that still remain about the security leading up to October 7th, and was enough done to prevent it and to have IDF forces in the area on the day? Because, of course, we all remember when that happened, the absolute chaos of trying to get soldiers to the area to fight back against the invaders.
01:21:13
Speaker 6: Yeah, there was a huge intelligence failure. There had been warnings that something big was about to happen, and they seemed to have gone ignored. So I think there's this idea that leadership had become too complacent. Of course, in Israel, Netanyahu is a divisive figure himself, but not because people don't think that Israel doesn't have a right to exist, which is what the anti-Netanyahu crowd bleat outside of Israel, but because of specifics about the handling of the war. Did he get the hostages back soon enough? Were too many hostages killed in the process?
01:21:48
Speaker 7: So I think....
01:21:50
Speaker 6: It'll be fascinating to see how it plays out. But Israel needs a strong figure right now, more than ever.
01:21:55
Speaker 2: I don't think Israel would be insane if they don't keep Netanyahu, particularly at this time. If, you know, his experience, his intelligence, his commitment, his knowledge... Donald Trump, for example, has come out and firmly backed Benjamin Netanyahu, although JD Vance apparently was less... No surprises there, was less keen on the idea. But I still come round to the thing that the biggest, the real end game over the next couple of years is the liberation of Iran. And for the liberation of Iran, you need Netanyahu running Israel and Trump running America and a determination to finish off the job, which may well happen after the midterm elections, as well as this Israeli election are out.
01:22:38
Speaker 4: Of the way.
01:22:39
Speaker 1: We shall see.
01:22:41
Speaker 2: The West Bank, Caroline, I don't know if you've been there.
01:22:45
Speaker 1: I've been there.
01:22:45
Speaker 4: I have, yeah.
01:22:46
Speaker 2: It's a depressing place. It is, of course, originally Judea and Samaria. The clue to the name Judea might suggest that it was the kingdom of the Jews. I mean, I'm just, you know, using basic linguistic skills to make that determination.
01:23:04
Speaker 1: But it was in the.
01:23:06
Speaker 2: When I visited the West Bank with Laura Jays and a few other people, some ABC journalists and others, Joe Astin and that, we went into Ramallah and we went to the PLO's headquarters there in Ramallah. We were shown a slideshow, this lavish guilt palace that was the headquarters of the PLO, and a spokesman for the PLO asked us to ask any questions, and.
01:23:30
Speaker 1: I asked the question.
01:23:31
Speaker 2: If you, you know, what is the two-state? Because we're talking about two-state solution. He said, there's two states. There's one which is called Palestine. And I said, OK, well, what's in that state? How many Jews in that state? No Jews in Palestine, no Jews. OK, what's the other
state called? And he said, we don't care what it's called. And I said, oh, OK, can it be called Israel?
01:23:51
Speaker 1: He said, no, not really. I said, well, whatever it's called, how many Jews in that state?
01:23:57
Speaker 2: And he.
01:23:58
Speaker 2: The three of them looked at each other and started muttering in Arabic and came back and finally said, maybe a handful. So that's the two-state solution as viewed by the PLO official spokesperson.
01:24:09
Speaker 1: Laura was there, others were there and witnessed.
01:24:12
Speaker 6: I mean, that's the tell, isn't it?
01:24:12
Speaker 1: Only a handful of Jews left in the land.
01:24:14
Speaker 6: And I've been into Ramallah as well, and I couldn't... And I also went on a journalist trip. because you can't make a big deal about being Jewish or being visibly Jewish, going in, which I am. But the issue is.
01:24:30
Speaker 7: That everyone complains, well, not everyone, but these hard left.
01:24:33
Speaker 6: Activists complain about Israel being an apartheid state, whereas in the West Bank, there are, of course, Israeli settlers, and that's a very contentious issue. But they're the Palestinian leadership doesn't want Jewish people living in the West Bank, and yet 20%, 25% of the population, I think it's 20%.
01:24:51
Speaker 7: In Israel is Arab... Yes.
01:24:54
Speaker 6: and there are lots of Palestinians living there. So I don't understand why they're not being accused of apartheid.
01:25:00
Speaker 4: Because the hypocrisy is... And this is before we even get to the other issue, which is, of course, what's happened to the Middle East's Indigenous Christian population since 1948.
01:25:10
Speaker 1: And....
01:25:12
Speaker 4: Everything that has been done by these Muslim governments to chase them out, persecute them out, and kill them, too. So, I mean, that's another issue. Look, I'll throw a... I'm going to trump both of you here. I've actually been to Gaza and went in the 1990s during one of the intifadas with my father, who was a journalist covering that at the time. And, you know, the thing that strikes me is having visited this region so many times over my life, you know, as a young man and then later as a journalist here on the same sort of trips that you guys were on, is hearing the exact same rhetoric, an eliminationist rhetoric from the Palestinian side and the sense that there was no Jewish right to be on that land and that this was always theirs and, you know, the idea that that eventual eviction would come. But unlike every other... You know, were there a lot of people displaced and moved around in 1948 after World War II? after the creation of the state of Israel, 100%. Yeah. And, you know, you have to acknowledge that and be real about that. But the fact of the matter is, too, everybody else who moved around after World War II and after 1948, moved on to something else and something bigger and something better. And this generational idea pushed by the United Nations and
the corrupt UNRWA. And I remember seeing when I was a kid, you know, not just the palaces, but the big UNRWA Range Rovers and Land Cruisers while everybody else, you know, lived on handouts. It's a very cruel thing to people to tell them that their refugee status passes on for generations. That, to me, is much of the original sin of why they're in this position right now.
01:26:47
Speaker 6: And we should spend the whole segment on Israeli history, but in 1948, the Arab nations, when they decided.
01:26:53
Speaker 7: To invade Israel.
01:26:55
Speaker 1: To destroy it.
01:26:55
Speaker 7: To destroy Israel and get rid of it.
01:26:59
Speaker 6: Before that, Israel had given people an option about whether to take citizenship and stay, and a lot of people made a voluntary decision to leave, keeping the Arab nation's would win the war and they would just come back and it would be an Arab nation. So it is a bit more complex, that decision.
01:27:17
Speaker 2: Yeah, and some of the Arab leaders were telling them, you leave, you come back in a few hours once we've wiped out Israel.
01:27:21
Speaker 6: Exactly, and then they blame Israel for their displacement.
01:27:24
Speaker 2: Now on a slightly lighter note, but there's a bit of a segue here because mummies... Egyptian ones, not mummies like me.
01:27:31
Speaker 1: Egyptian mummies from that neck of the world. This is too funny for words.
01:27:35
Speaker 4: Hang on.
01:27:35
Speaker 1: Sorry, Rowan.
01:27:36
Speaker 4: Are they Egyptian mummies or are they Egyptian parents or caregivers?
01:27:41
Speaker 2: Egyptian mummies have been... There's a museum that... This is in Canada, is it? There's a museum which is saying.
01:27:48
Speaker 1: Scotland.
01:27:48
Speaker 4: Scotland.
01:27:49
Speaker 1: Of course, Scotland.
01:27:50
Speaker 4: Scotland are not so brave.
01:27:51
Speaker 2: A Scottish museum have said they've taken the mummies away because... from the display in the museum, because the mummies never gave consent.
01:28:01
Speaker 1: To be in the museum. There you go.
01:28:03
Speaker 6: They're saying it's a mark of respect, because to have human remains where.
01:28:07
Speaker 1: A person didn't consent to being in a.
01:28:09
Speaker 7: Museum 2,000 years later would be disrespectful.
01:28:11
Speaker 2: When you think the lefties have reached peak stupidity, they always go one step stupider.
01:28:17
Speaker 4: And this is before we get to the hieroglyphics involved. They finally worked out the great rule of Egyptian hieroglyphic grammar. I before egret except after cat.
01:28:27
Speaker 1: Very good.
01:28:28
Speaker 2: Going to take a short break while James comes up with some more gags in the next segment.
01:28:32
Speaker 1: We're back in a tick.
01:28:40
Speaker 2: Yes, it's Wally of the Week, and I think Le Grand Wally of the Week has to be Macron. But there's another Wally Francais who we pulled out to have a listen to this guy. I said before, how stupid can the left get? This
is the so-called intellectual left in France.
01:28:55
Speaker 1: Have a listen.
01:28:57
Speaker 24: So that bloke is a best-selling French author, his name is Edouard Louis, and basically he was justifying the burning of Paris and the rioting and the looting on the grounds, classic lefty, of the oppressed.
01:29:24
Speaker 2: The poor, oppressed Louis Vuitton looters, you know, and how he was... In his words, he would rather see Paris burn, he would rather see the shops smashed than live in a world where oppression takes place.
01:29:37
Speaker 1: These people are insane. That's it. The left, it began in France. They're still insane, James.
01:29:45
Speaker 4: It's more than insanity, which ascribes something medical to it. I think that it's something deeper, more spiritual and, frankly, demonic. And I think that what we're talking about here is something that was unleashed in the French Revolution.
01:29:57
Speaker 11: Yep.
01:29:58
Speaker 4: And it flares up. Constantly in France, but that's been exported around the world. This idea of justifying violence to tear down the civilization that has been built up to try and create a new one that is in this sort of nonsense idea of liberty, galate, fraternité. which we all know is just, you know, a three-word triad code word for communism. That's where it all comes from. It all comes from the French Revolution. We are seeing this again today. France has not exercised its demons. We are on the Fifth Republic now. I predict that very soon we'll be on the Sixth.
01:30:32
Speaker 1: There we go. And all that from just Le Wally du Vic.
01:30:36
Speaker 17: Le Wally du Vic.
01:30:37
Speaker 4: Sorry to be so serious, but it's true.
01:30:39
Speaker 6: Well, I've got an equally, I think, credible candidate, and that is a local one, David Shiraz. He's probably better known as Brittany Higgins's husband. He was found by Justice Michael Lee during the defamation proceedings brought by Bruce Lerman to have been an absolutely shonky figure. That wasn't the words of the judge, those are mine, but... He helped cook up this conspiracy, political conspiracy, that the coalition and Linda Reynolds and her chief of staff had been involved in helping to cover up the crime. He's also the guy who was made bankrupt by defamation proceedings brought by Linda Reynolds, but more recently behind the political stunt at the press club when Pauline Hanson spoke and that banner came down damaging.
01:31:27
Speaker 7: The.
01:31:27
Speaker 6: Press Club are fittings now, though he works as a head of media for GetUp, the left-wing organisation. And he has the temerity to lecture us about integrity.
01:31:39
Speaker 7: Take a look.
01:31:40
Speaker 8: You see, we have the gall to register presscouncil.com.au to campaign for a harder-working press regulator. You know, one built for the 21st century that can issue complaints, force corrections and does it all transparently.
01:31:51
Speaker 4: A crazy ask.
01:31:53
Speaker 8: But it
turns out the Press Council is working hard to get its website back.
01:31:57
Speaker 6: Now, he talks about how the tabloids fund the press council and the evil tabloids, of course, must be reined in abscess bloc.
01:32:06
Speaker 2: Hang on, hang on, hang on. He also has on his CV, he was also Lewali Duweek when he was living in France.
01:32:11
Speaker 1: Oh, yes, of course. They had their little cottage.
01:32:13
Speaker 4: There is a French connection. But, you know, the tabloids actually, and News Corp, help fund the press council. You know who does it? The Guardian. So, you know, that's the first thing here that Lewali Shiraz needs to keep in mind here. But secondly, you know, this idea that the left is all in favour of press regulation, when they used to be all about free speech, that tells you enough. I would say Shiraz is my nominee for the most unpalatable Shiraz in Australia.
01:32:39
Speaker 7: Good one.
01:32:40
Speaker 3: Excellent.
01:32:40
Speaker 2: OK, we've also got the Irish government hugging.
01:32:44
Speaker 1: More lack of consent.
01:32:45
Speaker 4: Oh, Faith and Magora, guys. You're going to love this here. You know, the left has never shied away in its efforts to undermine the family, family relations, family affection, and use all sorts of nonsense excuses to try and, uh, make that happen. Well, have a look at this public service ad that Ireland, which has no other troubles, by the way, is running.
01:33:07
Speaker 7: Granny!
01:33:11
Speaker 4: Grandad!
01:33:11
Speaker 3: Great to see you!
01:33:14
Speaker 24: Oh!
01:33:14
Speaker 3: Great to see you!
01:33:17
Speaker 7: Great to see you!
01:33:19
Speaker 2: Oh!
01:33:21
Speaker 7: Not everyone wants a hug, even from the people who love them.
01:33:26
Speaker 1: Awkward?
01:33:26
Speaker 11: Maybe.
01:33:27
Speaker 3: Important?
01:33:29
Speaker 1: Absolutely.
01:33:31
Speaker 3: We-consent.ie is here to help.
01:33:35
Speaker 4: You see the really sinister thing that they're doing there. They are comparing a hug from a grandparent who loves you and they're putting that on the same plane, essentially, as a lot more unpleasant things that happen when there's not consent. This is, again... This is terrible stuff. And, you know, Ireland, a very family-friendly nation, you know, to be pushing this, again, it shows the whole thing about the Irish government, the Irish elite, and how much they hate their own country. So many countries in the West, their elite and their leadership hate their own people and their own culture, and they're trying to undermine it and they're trying to destroy it. Seems like a silly little thing, but it's part of a much bigger program.
01:34:14
Speaker 1: Well, it is, and that big program is communism.
01:34:17
Speaker 4: Thank you.
01:34:17
Speaker 2: And the communist ideal was always to separate the family so that your loyalty as a child and adolescent growing up is to the state rather than to the family, because the family is the strongest
unit that can combat and defeat concepts such as socialism and communism. And the idea of saying that you have to have consent from your grandparents.
01:34:37
Speaker 1: for a kiss, to make the girl.
01:34:39
Speaker 2: The girl in the ad is cringing at the thought of her granny or her grandfather coming.
01:34:45
Speaker 1: Close to her. It is... You used the word earlier.
01:34:47
Speaker 2: Demonic, James, and I would put this very much in that category. For the state to be running ads saying, do not love your grandparents, do not love your parents.
01:34:57
Speaker 4: And be suspicious of them.
01:34:58
Speaker 1: And be suspicious of them.
01:34:59
Speaker 6: I think the suspicion is the really, really insidious part of it. And there has been a movement across the West.
01:35:07
Speaker 7: to.
01:35:08
Speaker 6: Ask for consent for children, even babies, to change their nappies.
01:35:13
Speaker 7: You may recall that story.
01:35:15
Speaker 6: And I think, you know, as a mother, I really want children to learn from a young age about body autonomy and protecting themselves and that there are bad people in the world.
01:35:24
Speaker 7: But this is shameful.
01:35:25
Speaker 6: I think, instead, countries need to be harder on hard crime like rape and sexual assault instead of putting everything back on be wary of every person in your life, every family member.
01:35:40
Speaker 1: Let's have more of a deterrent.
01:35:40
Speaker 4: It's a two-tier justice system. You know, every day out of Europe, we see cases of crime committed by migrants, including a lot of sexual assaults that are dealt with very leniently by the courts. But, you know, across the water in England... 12,000 people a year are pulled up for their social media posts. And it is, again, it is the two-tier assault on the country.
01:36:03
Speaker 2: The worst thing about that is it is an assault on the unconditional love that a parent or a grandparent has for the child. So it is actually trying to sever that and make kids suspicious of that.
01:36:14
Speaker 1: Evil.
01:36:15
Speaker 4: Evil.
01:36:15
Speaker 1: Absolutely. We're going to vote for our Wally.
01:36:17
Speaker 2: I can't go past your Shiraz gag, so I'm... Let's.
01:36:20
Speaker 1: Uncork the Wally of the Week. Le Shiraz Wally de Week.
01:36:25
Speaker 4: Yeah, oui, oui. Do we vote? Do we agree?
01:36:27
Speaker 1: Shiraz.
01:36:27
Speaker 4: Give it a swirl.
01:36:28
Speaker 7: Yes.
01:36:30
Speaker 2: He can put it on the mantle up next to his get-up mantle and his whatever.
01:36:34
Speaker 1: That guy is... Anyway, Wally of the Week. That's who he is after the break. I'm a celebrity, stupid.
01:36:48
Speaker 2: So we all remember Kamala Harris's great philosophical concept that you could be, you could raise yourself up to be what you want to be, unburdened by what you had been, or something like that.
01:37:00
Speaker 1: She's now struggling for a new philosophical.
01:37:02
Speaker 2: Concept to take to the
2028 election, which is, one assumes, what the goal is behind all her current.
01:37:08
Speaker 1: shenanigans. This one is very, very profound.
01:37:12
Speaker 2: It is never let someone else's limited ability to see your capacity limit you from your ambition. So in other words, you can have ambition despite what other people think of how useless you are. Maybe I can think of a few people who could do with that advice, but here she is Kamala, the philosopher.
01:37:32
Speaker 23: Never let someone else's limited ability to see your capacity be a limitation on your ambition.
01:37:43
Speaker 1: Let me repeat that. Yep, and she does repeat it. Waiting for the applause from the crowd.
01:37:50
Speaker 2: But if you break it down, I think she's saying, people don't recognise what a genius I am, but that's not gonna stop me being president.
01:37:59
Speaker 4: And, you know, the really funny thing about that, too, Rowan, is that she asked them to, or she said, let me repeat that, because she didn't get enough cheers the first time. So this was Kamala Harris's. This is really interesting because we're going into the 2028 campaign. That campaign is going to start in earnest in about, you know, 13, 14 days' time, right after we have all the midterm results. This was her Jeb Bush please clap moment here when she wasn't getting the love she wanted from The crowd. That's going to damn her, I reckon.
01:38:33
Speaker 6: Well, I mean, it's always a word salad with her, isn't it? It's just I think she wanted to repeat it because I don't think she quite understood what she was saying herself and it still didn't make sense.
01:38:43
Speaker 1: The second time.
01:38:44
Speaker 2: It's the Prince Harry autocue problem. So the autocue had maybe stuck and she was stuck on her great moment of philosophy. Philosophical thought, so she thought. I'll just repeat it. Rather than doing what Harry normally does.
01:38:56
Speaker 1: Well, speaking of Prince Harry.
01:38:58
Speaker 4: Speaking of.
01:38:59
Speaker 7: Yay!
01:39:00
Speaker 2: The, you know, empathy there is just incredible.
01:39:03
Speaker 4: Telepathy.
01:39:04
Speaker 1: Telepathy.
01:39:05
Speaker 6: Very, very kind of you to give me the segue into my celebrity stupor, which is Prince Harry, who has come out and done yet another interview.
01:39:15
Speaker 7: Privacy, please, for me, but except.
01:39:17
Speaker 6: For when I do interviews... with GQ magazine, and he's talked about the most important thing being to reconcile, but word is sources close to his brother have ruled out any chances of him mending his relationship with Harry. I mean, can you blame him after the amount of... I can't say the word on morning television, but crap that he's thrown over the past few years? I mean, the royals are too busy actually doing their duty as royals, helping... Catherine the Duchess get over her cancer Battle to worry about what.
01:39:54
Speaker 7: This what this ginger thinks about things.
01:39:57
Speaker 4: He's the winter. He is the winter The ginger winter I got a winter. Yes. I got a winter for you. Um f1 champ Lewis Hamilton here He has managed to insert himself into global geopolitics, which is an interesting place. I mean, I guess being an F1 driver, you do fly around the world, so, you know, you see a lot of airports, I guess. But have a look at what he had to say here.
01:40:25
Speaker 9: And I guess I'll finish it off with, you know, I think we need to make sure we're pushing to free Congo, free Sudan, free Syria, free Palestine. I think there's a lot of peace that I'm hoping that at some stage we get to.
01:40:38
Speaker 4: Does he even know what he's talking about? Free Syria, free Congo, free... I think he's thinking more like... This is just... It is celebrity guff.
01:40:47
Speaker 1: He left out free.
01:40:48
Speaker 2: Louis Vuitton bags, if you get down the Champs-Élysées.
01:40:51
Speaker 1: They're free, aren't they?
01:40:53
Speaker 4: No, but I just love these incredibly wealthy, you know, people. You know, Lewis Hamilton has previously complained about racism again while coming to the absolute top and pinnacle of this incredibly elite society. feel, oh, yes, so racist, so racist that is, you know. But, like, you know, what is this, from Singapore to Monaco, Palestine will be free? I don't get it.
01:41:10
Speaker 7: Free Palestine from Hamas.
01:41:12
Speaker 6: But I think that, you know, why are we hearing what a race driver has to think about international geopolitics?
01:41:19
Speaker 1: Like.
01:41:20
Speaker 6: Just stick in your lane, literally.
01:41:23
Speaker 4: It's 1968 all over again.
01:41:24
Speaker 1: Stick in your lane. There you go.
01:41:26
Speaker 2: On that note, that's it for Outsiders for this week. Make sure you watch... You're still filling in for Rita?
01:41:31
Speaker 4: Yes.
01:41:31
Speaker 1: Yes. So that's every evening.
01:41:33
Speaker 2: Watch James filling in on Lefty's losing it and everything for Rita Panahy's show.
01:41:38
Speaker 1: And thanks, Caroline, again, for doing a great job here.
01:41:40
Speaker 7: Thanks for having me.
01:41:40
Speaker 1: Filling in for Rita. And that's it. And we'll catch you soon. Fantastic.
01:41:44
Speaker 2: We'll see you next Sunday morning, bright and early. And now it's Ross Greenwood with the Business Report.