ကူးယူချက် 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00.993 --> 00:04.632
And the bill was due, and we had to find hundreds of thousands of dollars,
00:04.760 --> 00:07.886
and it came out of our own pockets. And this was after I'd been laid
00:08.386 --> 00:12.054
off. This is after Asher's been laid off. This is after I quit my job
00:12.198 --> 00:15.356
to do this full-time, and my wife had been laid off.
00:16.767 --> 00:19.957
This is Open Work, a look inside the watch industry,
00:20.133 --> 00:23.179
a podcast from Collective Horology. I'm Gabe Riley,
00:23.259 --> 00:26.930
co-founder of Collective, and I'm Asher Rapkin, co-founder of Collective.
00:27.363 --> 00:30.313
Collective Horology is an independent watch retailer based in Ventura,
00:30.329 --> 00:33.599
California. We carry a wide range of independent brands including
00:33.712 --> 00:36.819
J.N. Shapiro, Fears, Arkanaut, and more.
00:37.353 --> 00:39.749
To learn more about us and check out the watches that we carry,
00:40.440 --> 00:45.122
visit collectiverhorology.com. This is episode number 1
00:45.461 --> 00:49.158
plus 100. 1 plus 100, or 100 plus 1. So this
00:49.255 --> 00:50.531
was my 11th birthday.
00:52.604 --> 00:55.359
Not a fan of The Hobbit, I see. No, I have no idea what that
00:55.859 --> 00:59.175
is. As I said to you before recording,
00:59.224 --> 01:02.515
some of us have lives now. Wow. This was
01:03.015 --> 01:06.160
supposed to be episode 100, but obviously we had
01:06.417 --> 01:09.805
the Zenith news, which is probably some of the biggest news in the
01:09.869 --> 01:13.064
watch industry that's happened this year and in
01:13.161 --> 01:16.886
a long time. So we are— we postponed this episode.
01:17.416 --> 01:20.964
It was supposed to be episode 100, but it's 101. And it's actually kind
01:21.464 --> 01:24.705
of befitting because it's sort of like Collective 101.
01:25.443 --> 01:28.476
And, you know, one of the things— this came up in my
01:28.492 --> 01:31.605
mind at least, well, we talked about this at the end of that Zenith episode—
01:31.621 --> 01:35.168
which is one of the things we do on this podcast is we discuss
01:35.668 --> 01:39.260
the business of watches, analyze the business of watches. We offer a lot of
01:39.760 --> 01:42.855
opinions, hopefully most of them informed opinions on the
01:42.871 --> 01:45.647
business, on brands and how they're operating.
01:46.787 --> 01:51.569
But talk is cheap, you know. It's easy for us to sit here and offer
01:51.633 --> 01:52.869
those opinions. It is.
01:55.771 --> 01:59.457
Well, that gets to today's topic, which is the
01:59.473 --> 02:02.712
business of Collective. And this is something that I think we are
02:02.920 --> 02:06.719
reticent to do because we don't really like to talk about Collective all
02:06.767 --> 02:10.470
that much. You know, we talk about the business of watches because
02:10.518 --> 02:14.205
we want to talk about other stuff, not even brands that we carry or
02:14.705 --> 02:18.052
things like that. But it's come up enough and it was episode
02:18.552 --> 02:21.547
100. So we wanted to do something different and special.
02:21.675 --> 02:25.411
We thought about doing a live podcast recording in New York, but I I
02:25.443 --> 02:29.421
hate live podcast recording, so we didn't do that. So we're doing this, but we've
02:29.437 --> 02:33.368
gotten questions and requests to do this. So I'll give
02:33.868 --> 02:37.555
you the most recent request. You know, when we ask for you
02:38.055 --> 02:40.972
to send us emails, we're not kidding. We really do want you to send us
02:41.069 --> 02:45.176
emails and people actually do. So this was the listener question from
02:45.676 --> 02:49.459
Steve, which we'll use as the basis here of Collective 101,
02:50.229 --> 02:54.079
which is, You guys should do an episode about Collective
02:54.579 --> 02:58.698
itself, how you got the idea slash strategy, raised capital, setbacks along
02:58.810 --> 03:02.146
the way, all the sorts of things you discuss when analyzing
03:02.323 --> 03:05.514
watch brands. It would be interesting to learn about the stuff. It would
03:05.546 --> 03:09.524
be interesting to learn about that stuff and hear how you think about your own
03:09.781 --> 03:13.582
business. Thank you, Steve, for the question. And thanks to others who said
03:14.082 --> 03:16.774
in one form or another, speaking of being in New York, this came up with
03:17.274 --> 03:20.463
a few folks saying they'd love to hear more about the
03:20.963 --> 03:25.033
story of Collective, the business of Collective, and how we think about it. So we're
03:25.533 --> 03:28.930
going to do that today. And this is a story
03:29.042 --> 03:31.640
that starts all the way back. Was it 1994?
03:32.490 --> 03:36.275
Must be 19— no. Yeah, because I started 7th
03:36.323 --> 03:39.691
grade in 1994, graduated from 6th grade, PS6,
03:39.707 --> 03:43.171
class of 1994. Yeah. So yeah, Asher,
03:43.299 --> 03:47.324
I say this because Asher and I met in homeroom in 7th grade,
03:47.340 --> 03:50.626
it was like freaks and geeks. We were in like the back table of the
03:51.126 --> 03:54.441
7th grade homeroom, which was in a science lab. And it was like
03:55.179 --> 03:59.282
you and me. Shout out Mr. Krupka. Yeah. Mr. Krupka's homeroom
03:59.782 --> 04:02.521
is like you and me and like the kid in the wheelchair. Like literally we
04:02.617 --> 04:05.422
were, we were like the freaks and geeks in the, in the back of the
04:05.922 --> 04:09.253
classroom. And I say that because this is worth knowing.
04:09.526 --> 04:12.956
This is the collective is not our first business together. The kid in the wheelchair
04:13.456 --> 04:17.124
was my first financier. Yeah. Yeah. So, so that kid, Michael, shout out
04:17.624 --> 04:20.106
Michael. He He was Asher's loan shark,
04:21.910 --> 04:25.403
but also, you know, the Freaks and
04:25.903 --> 04:29.106
Geeks is really about you and me because our first business, we started our first
04:29.606
Load full transcript
--> 04:32.830
business. Collective is not our first business together. We started our first business in 7th
04:33.330 --> 04:36.722
grade fixing computers. So that's how
04:36.866 --> 04:39.131
cool Asher and I were.
04:41.991 --> 04:45.413
Yeah. You know what though? What a time.
04:46.016 --> 04:49.607
Yeah, but I mean, hey man, we still, we still, we still made some money
04:49.639 --> 04:53.181
doing it. Then remember the name of the company? Northern Digital Computing.
04:53.229 --> 04:57.093
Boy, doesn't that sound like a front? It sure does. We've joked about having like
04:57.593 --> 05:00.940
a, you know, some anonymous holding company, division of El Pollo Loco. Yeah.
05:01.020 --> 05:04.354
Like the, the, the, you know, the Uber holding company that owns
05:04.386 --> 05:08.105
Collective should be Northern Digital Computing. So we have a better name
05:08.218 --> 05:11.408
actually. We have too many. Do you want, do you remember? So this is
05:11.504 --> 05:15.239
a, this is a throwback for some early Mac folk, but there
05:15.287 --> 05:18.413
was a way at the time to, it was like a
05:18.913 --> 05:22.549
little WYSIWYG tool that you could use to edit system resources called
05:22.565 --> 05:25.963
ResEdit. Remember ResEdit? Oh, where you could change your startup screen. That's exactly right.
05:26.011 --> 05:29.458
So we would like change the macOS Happy Mac face, uh,
05:29.474 --> 05:33.561
from like macOS 8 to the Northern Digital Computing logo.
05:33.722 --> 05:36.928
It's brought to you by NDC. Yeah, we got
05:37.428 --> 05:40.871
in over our head on some repair jobs. We like got hired by some like
05:40.999 --> 05:44.237
business to like fix their whole like network and we
05:44.737 --> 05:48.085
had no idea what we were doing, but eventually we figured out how to get—
05:48.585 --> 05:52.557
Shout out to HALO. I was like trying to figure out
05:53.057 --> 05:57.061
how to set up a server using Windows NT, but whatever,
05:57.110 --> 06:00.700
we got it. We got the job figured out. But, but I guess if
06:00.796 --> 06:04.660
nothing else, it proves that we were enterprising and in over our heads long before
06:04.740 --> 06:08.555
we ever got into the watch industry. So which I think is an important
06:08.571 --> 06:11.937
thing to, to keep in mind as we tell this story,
06:11.953 --> 06:15.672
because how to prevent yourself from drowning when you're— when people are pouring water on
06:15.705 --> 06:19.231
your head, I think is a key factor not only in owning a small business,
06:19.247 --> 06:22.743
but existing in the watch industry in general. Yeah. And I think there was
06:22.855 --> 06:26.256
always this feeling as we go forward now, like we were always
06:26.449 --> 06:30.572
looking for like, maybe there's a future for another business. Uh, well, we sort
06:31.072 --> 06:33.139
of grabbed, there are some funny ideas along the way of like, what would be
06:33.639 --> 06:35.096
a nice future? We worked on a few things
along the way. Yeah. I mean,
06:35.112 --> 06:38.497
we worked together at, at TechServe in New York City for, for a short
06:38.997 --> 06:41.641
period of time where some guy who was high on angel dust and had some
06:41.706 --> 06:44.898
giant wolf of a dog threatened to throw you down a flight of
06:45.398 --> 06:48.523
stairs, as I recall. Yep. That was a good one. Yeah. And by the way,
06:48.604 --> 06:52.163
prepared me for the watch industry. I'm fairly certain that there
06:52.211 --> 06:56.652
is no hyperbole in that sentence, by the way. No, none of that is factual
06:56.765 --> 07:00.308
report. Yeah. So I guess if nothing else, we're demonstrating that
07:00.808 --> 07:03.579
the tech industry and the IT world is way more interesting than you would have
07:03.595 --> 07:06.898
thought. My other insight from TechServe was about you, which is
07:07.398 --> 07:10.874
you bought so much gear from TechServe yourself. I knew that if we ever
07:10.954 --> 07:14.450
opened up a shop, you would keep us afloat. Yeah,
07:15.700 --> 07:18.156
I I am a consumer,
07:18.991 --> 07:22.330
but they had a great— TechServe had a great employee purchase policy.
07:22.603 --> 07:26.488
You could buy for 10% above cost, which is an incredibly generous
07:26.680 --> 07:30.036
employee purchase system. It was also where I learned,
07:30.308 --> 07:33.278
and this was an interesting thing about retail, where the money is made.
07:34.242 --> 07:37.308
Computers, for example, at that period of time had very low margins.
07:37.372 --> 07:41.401
I suspect they still do. It was under 15% for
07:41.546 --> 07:44.693
a Mac computer, but And the same thing for printers. Printers,
07:44.741 --> 07:48.450
notoriously low margin. Oh, but ink and cables,
07:48.466 --> 07:51.790
extraordinarily high margin. Like I remember you
07:51.822 --> 07:55.403
would sell somebody a, like an Epson inkjet
07:55.515 --> 07:59.401
printer for $150. Maybe the store would gross
07:59.529 --> 08:02.869
$15 of net profit on the printer. And so it's a loss essentially,
08:03.302 --> 08:06.771
but the cable, the 5-foot USB cable that
08:06.819 --> 08:10.254
you'd sell with it was $30. And it costs about $0.10.
08:10.688 --> 08:14.171
And don't forget those ink cartridges that you constantly need. So the
08:14.219 --> 08:17.767
LaserJet cartridges. So it was really, it was really kind of insightful to me
08:17.991 --> 08:21.250
just to sort of see how the sausage was made in that regard.
08:21.747 --> 08:25.247
Opposite of the watch industry, though, because, because the margin is not
08:25.439 --> 08:29.580
in straps or accessories. Those are, those are very challenging businesses.
08:29.693 --> 08:33.256
Yeah. And in some cases you just lose money on those. But, but yeah.
08:33.337 --> 08:36.675
So and then you and I parted our separate ways and you went into the
08:37.175 --> 08:40.929
advertising industry. I went into television and marketing and tech. And we ended up back
08:41.429 -->
08:44.043
together again in 2014.
08:44.252 --> 08:47.526
2015, you joined Facebook. Yeah. And you
08:48.026 --> 08:50.785
had been there, I think, for a year or two before me. Yeah. And,
08:51.844 --> 08:54.910
you know, I think it's probably no secret to anyone that
08:54.974 --> 08:58.008
I ever worked with, let alone any listener to this
08:58.040 --> 09:01.555
podcast, that when I was at Facebook, you know,
09:01.956 --> 09:05.873
in addition to traveling the world like I did for that job, I traveled
09:05.985 --> 09:08.522
international watch retail as well.
09:09.501 --> 09:12.789
And, you know, I can— I mean, look, I think one of
09:13.289 --> 09:16.957
the best lessons for becoming something is to experience
09:17.457 --> 09:20.275
it. And that doesn't mean you're going to be good at it. That's for sure.
09:20.820 --> 09:24.122
But it does mean that you have some degree of empathy for
09:24.972 --> 09:27.264
all sides, because obviously as a retailer now,
09:28.178 --> 09:31.256
I have a lot of empathy for my colleagues in the retail world.
09:31.464 --> 09:34.910
I understand a lot more about how this business
09:35.007 --> 09:38.533
operates and all the constraints that, that exist
09:39.033 --> 09:42.188
both for those that make watches, those that import them, and those that sell them.
09:42.910 --> 09:45.907
But of course, I've also spent far more time on the other side of that
09:46.407 --> 09:49.867
table buying things and buying watches and collecting them and selling
09:49.915 --> 09:53.810
them and all those things. And it's really, I think, a special
09:53.906 --> 09:57.369
gift to have that kind of holistic thing. I think about this like when we
09:57.869 --> 10:01.232
talk about, and when you and I are like talking about how big tech,
10:01.296 --> 10:04.518
for example, discusses small business, you know,
10:04.967 --> 10:08.894
and, you know, I look, I, there was a period of time where I had
10:09.394 --> 10:11.908
no business. You were that guy. I was that guy. I like, I like ran
10:12.020 --> 10:16.156
some component of Meta, nay, Facebook. Books small business
10:16.204 --> 10:19.554
marketing team. So I, you know, me and the folks I worked with
10:20.054 --> 10:23.144
would write some of the marketing, a lot of the marketing copy that would go
10:23.160 --> 10:26.943
out to people. And so much of it I look back on now and I'm
10:27.443 --> 10:30.982
so embarrassed and ashamed of because the advice and the language and the
10:31.030 --> 10:34.444
way that I would talk to small businesses. And mind you, this did not come
10:34.556 --> 10:37.249
from a place of anything other than wanting to do a good job. I just
10:37.749 --> 10:39.252
had no idea what I was talking about because I had— How could you have
10:39.268 --> 10:42.250
known? Yeah, it's the same thing of like trying to give advice to a parent
10:42.750 --> 10:44.991
if you're not a parent. And if you are a parent, you're smart enough to
10:45.491 --> 10:46.690
know not to give advice to another parent.
10:47.203 --> 10:50.072
But my point is,
10:50.761 --> 10:54.080
it's impossible to know what it's like. So some of the stuff that we would
10:54.096 --> 10:57.975
say was just absurd. In that time, though,
10:58.921 --> 11:02.496
we found within Facebook that there was a significant affinity
11:02.592 --> 11:05.862
group of people there that wanted to collect watches. Zuck, interestingly,
11:06.279 --> 11:09.581
couldn't have cared less at the time, which I find hilarious given
11:10.081 --> 11:13.957
his newfound interest. But there were a lot of folks inside the company
11:14.069 --> 11:17.340
that were really passionate collectors. At every level, at every level.
11:18.061 --> 11:21.251
And it was an interesting thing because it also was
11:22.726 --> 11:26.301
ironic for an expensive good, but it was kind of a democratizing force within
11:26.333 --> 11:30.901
the company because people would have access to extraordinarily
11:31.401 --> 11:35.262
senior folks inside the company based on a shared interest and passion that
11:35.310 --> 11:39.109
would develop friendships and connections that crossed reporting
11:39.141 --> 11:42.892
structures. And in some cases like that actually
11:42.908 --> 11:46.050
led to like friendships that were really incredible, not just professionally,
11:46.066 --> 11:48.871
but just personally, because people I would never have had the chance to meet.
11:48.936 --> 11:52.671
Like, for example, there's a very big watch collector used to run Asia Pacific at—
11:53.007 --> 11:56.422
oh yeah, you know, a good dude, phenomenal human being who
11:56.614 --> 11:59.403
was way more senior than I ever was at the company.
11:59.660 --> 12:02.048
And I got to spend a lot of time with him and get to know
12:02.064 --> 12:05.575
him as a person, which I never would have had that opportunity to do,
12:06.264 --> 12:10.708
you know, but for these affinity groups. And around
12:11.045 --> 12:14.481
2018, 2017, I was
12:14.738 --> 12:17.965
in a retail shop in the Bay Area called
12:18.465 --> 12:22.123
Davidson& Licht. Shout out to Davidson& Licht. Incredibly good folks,
12:22.364 --> 12:25.703
wonderful people with their sales director, who was a salesperson at the time,
12:25.751 --> 12:28.609
a guy named Jeremiah, still there. Incredibly good person.
12:29.026 --> 12:33.136
Like, also pause just to say, not only Jeremiah
12:33.636 --> 12:36.379
is one of those folks in the watch industry that I aspire to be,
12:36.893 --> 12:41.102
he is a thoughtful, a kind and open-minded
12:41.166 --> 12:44.508
and just phenomenal salesperson. And this is what I mean
12:44.540 --> 12:47.576
by there's a lot of value in being on both sides of that table.
12:47.833 --> 12:51.593
Yeah, I got to experience people like Jer who are incredible
12:52.093 --> 12:55.754
salespeople and then some folks that are just, you know, like putting on
12:55.786 --> 12:59.321
their clown makeup while I'm talking to them. And it really, I think, helps to
12:59.821 --> 13:03.241
see all of that and understand the difference between someone who goes to a job
13:03.741 --> 13:07.011
and someone who's a true professional. Or someone, you know, who you as an enthusiast
13:07.091 --> 13:10.425
actually look forward to dealing with and someone— well, totally. You know,
13:10.473 --> 13:13.567
they follow you around the store like a lost puppy. Exactly.
13:14.144 --> 13:17.382
Anyway, so the reason I bring up Jeremiah is that he approached me
13:18.151 --> 13:22.544
around 2018, 2017, 2017, 2017 about making
13:22.880 --> 13:26.423
a Tudor watch for Facebook. And you got to
13:26.923 --> 13:30.719
remember, at this period of time, that wasn't really a thing. I mean,
13:30.735 --> 13:34.406
there were a couple of like maybe here and there projects from Tudor, but it
13:34.502 --> 13:38.894
wasn't a common occurrence. And while club watches
13:39.007 --> 13:42.517
and affinity things like that happens, of course, it wasn't,
13:42.694 --> 13:45.932
it wasn't something that you saw a lot of. And I mean,
13:46.204 --> 13:50.580
I jumped on that and I talked to Gabe about it, who also ran
13:50.613 --> 13:54.380
the group with me. And we sort of spun out on all
13:54.880 --> 13:58.275
these different designs. The original design that I wanted for this watch, if you remember,
13:58.644 --> 14:02.170
was to do this, to do the white background, black text version of the Facebook
14:02.670 --> 14:05.104
logo. So it would have had that kind of Comex vibe. Well, yeah, that was
14:05.200 --> 14:08.069
my idea, but I thought it was mine. I Photoshopped that one.
14:08.150 --> 14:11.100
One. But we wanted to do that one. It was a good idea.
14:11.450 --> 14:15.110
But Tudor said no to that. It was too close of a reference, I think,
14:15.610 --> 14:18.170
to Rolex. Yeah. And this was also where we didn't realize what we couldn't do.
14:18.670 --> 14:20.430
So we were like, oh, let's, let's, you know, like, let's try to do this,
14:20.930 --> 14:24.070
like, throwback to that Rolex reference or whatever. Anyway, long story short, we ended up
14:24.570 --> 14:27.510
making a very simple watch, a Black Bay 58. Wearing it today. Yep. Says Facebook
14:28.010 --> 14:32.070
on the dial. With Facebook on the dial. And, you know, no great creative achievement,
14:32.570 --> 14:36.104
no offense to us. Nope. But But sometimes restraint is what's called
14:36.604 --> 14:40.135
for. I mean, what's funny is the thing that shocked me about that from a
14:40.635 --> 14:43.909
creative perspective was we sent this over to Tudor and they're like,
14:43.974 --> 14:47.266
okay, cool, here's some other options. And they actually sent back some stuff
14:47.346 --> 14:51.168
that was pretty crazy. Yeah, not exactly tasteful
14:51.618 --> 14:54.958
and probably violations of like Facebook's own corporate identity
14:55.054 --> 14:57.961
guidelines. And of course, you should tell the story about how we
had to get
14:58.461 --> 15:00.932
this thing approved at the highest level. Yeah, I mean, this had to be approved
15:01.432 --> 15:04.592
by Zuck because at the time, and I think this is kind of quaint looking
15:04.624 --> 15:08.842
back on it. Zuck's office was like genuinely concerned about the perception
15:09.580 --> 15:12.772
of Facebook employees wearing $4,000 watches
15:12.964 --> 15:16.429
with the Facebook logo on it. Or a brand that was associated with Rolex.
15:16.477 --> 15:20.214
You know, they could, you can imagine in 2017, as there
15:20.262 --> 15:23.518
are today, but in 2017, there were a lot of, there's a lot of negative
15:23.806 --> 15:27.030
news and sentiment around Facebook. And remember,
15:27.046 --> 15:30.190
this is coming out of the 2016 election and
15:30.270 --> 15:33.654
then Cambridge Analytica, and they were terrified of a
15:34.154 --> 15:37.488
headline of like, you know, Rolex— Facebook employees lavish themselves
15:37.988 --> 15:42.012
with Rolex watches. You know, that's how that thing could, could have gotten twisted.
15:42.092 --> 15:45.573
So you had to get this approved. Yeah. And to
15:45.605 --> 15:48.685
do that, I had to go obviously to the corporate marketing team. Makes sense
15:49.185 --> 15:51.862
because we had to do an intellectual property release, as anyone who does something like
15:52.362 --> 15:56.546
this has to. But I also needed Mark Zuckerberg's explicit permission and
15:56.674 --> 16:00.203
he gave it. We offered him a watch, which he denied because at
16:00.703 --> 16:03.235
the time he said, I don't really care about watches. Do you think he regrets
16:03.735 --> 16:07.506
that? Oh, he's regretting it every night. Yeah. Losing sleep over it.
16:08.613 --> 16:11.311
I hope this is not— crying into his shoulder. If he's losing sleep, I hope
16:11.423 --> 16:15.453
this is not what he's losing sleep over. But long story short,
16:15.934 --> 16:19.226
I realized in that time, and I'd be curious if you did, if you had
16:19.726 --> 16:21.859
the same sort of thing, because at this point I was just a little bit
16:22.359 --> 16:25.889
under 40. I think it was like 37, 38. I started
16:26.389 --> 16:30.047
to realize like, I like doing this. Yeah. A lot. Well, we, you did a
16:30.547 --> 16:33.965
few of them too. There was a Seiko, like a, Ninja watch
16:34.013 --> 16:37.500
that you did with Topper for Facebook employees. There was a, oh, the Nomos
16:37.596 --> 16:40.473
was really great. So there were a few things that happened.
16:41.228 --> 16:44.457
So we realized how much we liked doing this. And to be very clear,
16:44.522 --> 16:46.900
by the way, Gabe and I didn't make any money doing this. This was just
16:46.916 --> 16:49.872
a project that we did. We ran the whole deal through Davidson and Licht.
16:50.226 --> 16:53.343
Davidson and Licht delivered the watches, you know, but we got
16:53.843 --> 16:57.102
to see for the very first time the sausage making of all this.
16:58.163 --> 17:01.600
And I had a lot of fun with it and I started talking to
17:01.632 --> 17:04.650
another friend of mine in the Bay Area, Rob Kaplan of Topper Jewelers,
17:05.309 --> 17:08.793
another person who, who has been an incredible friend to Collective
17:08.922 --> 17:12.326
over the years in helping us get started. And he said,
17:12.374 --> 17:15.425
well, why don't we— let's do another one. So we did and we did one
17:15.925 --> 17:18.251
with Nomos. That was a really good— I think that is one of the best
17:18.751 --> 17:21.479
ones. Did you buy that one? I did not buy it. I'm, I'm one of
17:21.979 --> 17:25.156
those people who like intellectually loves Nomos, but it's so its
17:25.656 --> 17:28.769
own thing. It's just not my vibe. But I appreciate them from a design and
17:29.269 --> 17:33.153
a creative standpoint. Yeah, I, I really loved
17:33.653 --> 17:36.928
that watch. I still have that watch mostly because I love Nomos, you know,
17:37.090 --> 17:39.898
and, and it turned out great. And then from there, Rob asked me if I
17:40.398 --> 17:42.732
wanted to provide some input for him on a watch that he was going to
17:43.232 --> 17:46.182
make with Seiko, the Seiko, the Topper Ninja, as it was known.
17:47.224 --> 17:50.216
So I contributed a little feedback on that one and that watch came out.
17:50.265 --> 17:53.515
That was now the third one. And at this point,
17:53.580 --> 17:56.507
I think you and I started to look at each other and just say like,
17:57.578 --> 18:00.371
I think there's something here. I don't, I don't know what it is.
18:01.044 --> 18:04.623
And I, I had never, you know, I mean, Northern Digital Computing notwithstanding,
18:05.040 --> 18:08.025
I'd never imagined being an entrepreneur. So I didn't know how to write a business
18:08.525 --> 18:11.427
plan. I didn't know really how to approach it at all.
18:12.117 --> 18:15.535
Oh, come on. You had some harebrained ideas along the way. I remember you pitching
18:15.551 --> 18:18.792
me. That's not a business plan. Maybe like it was like 2015 or something.
18:18.840 --> 18:21.921
You're like, we should open a menswear shop and whiskey bar.
18:22.403 --> 18:25.420
It was a menswear shop and watch bar actually, but the whiskey bar was in
18:25.436 --> 18:29.078
between. Oh, okay. I don't think I was that far off.
18:29.126 --> 18:32.335
I mean, how far off is that from the Armory? Yeah,
18:32.576 --> 18:35.721
but I don't, I don't have any business. I would have failed. I don't have
18:36.221 --> 18:39.074
any business working at the Armory. Maybe you do. No,
18:39.540 --> 18:42.380
less so, but whatever. Anyway, so long story short,
18:43.070 --> 18:47.659
we write an initial idea for Collective and
18:47.739 --> 18:50.852
the first thing that you and I promised to each other is what?
18:51.494 --> 18:54.943
Remember? No idea. We will never be a retailer.
18:55.024 --> 18:58.540
I don't know. Well, Was that the first thing we— Yeah, you were
insistent.
18:58.653 --> 19:01.865
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's the idea of being a watch retailer
19:02.365 --> 19:06.042
is terrifying because I think we saw through these few collaborations
19:06.106 --> 19:09.415
what was actually required to sell watches. Yeah. But I think
19:09.915 --> 19:13.238
the other side of it too was that you and I were not emotionally
19:13.655 --> 19:16.852
or like intellectually or professionally prepared
19:16.884 --> 19:20.530
to admit that we were open
19:20.578 --> 19:24.015
to a different career. I mean, that's how I look at it. Like at that
19:24.031 --> 19:27.436
period of time, what was the, what was important to me in a career?
19:27.548 --> 19:30.648
I wanted to be a director at Facebook, right? Yeah, that's true. That's what I
19:30.696 --> 19:33.570
wanted to achieve. Yeah, that's what I wanted to achieve because I thought it meant
19:34.070 --> 19:37.424
something, you know, and I was already planning my exit
19:37.924 --> 19:41.487
at that point. I wasn't, I honestly, like at that period in my career,
19:42.403 --> 19:46.080
I thought that like I wanted to be some
19:46.193 --> 19:49.885
pooh-bah, you know, at these companies. The big kahuna,
19:50.205 --> 19:54.183
numero uno. But yeah, no, I mean, my point on the dealer or
19:54.199 --> 19:57.504
the, the retailer thing was less about that. And for me it was
19:57.568 --> 20:02.653
more like, I know what I'm good at and— yeah,
20:02.717 --> 20:06.181
you were way ahead of me on that one. The things that are or
20:06.310 --> 20:10.480
what I'm interested in doing and spending my time. And, you know, I realized
20:10.980 --> 20:14.041
having my eyes opened through the projects with Topper
20:14.105 --> 20:17.473
and Davidson and Licht and those brands was like, Wow, you know,
20:17.537 --> 20:20.230
being a retailer is serious business. Like, it never occurred to me,
20:20.904 --> 20:24.510
you know, like basic things like shipping insurance. Yeah,
20:24.847 --> 20:27.396
there are things you don't know about, right? I mean, we talked about this early
20:27.476 --> 20:30.586
on with Mike Margolis in one of the early episodes of Collective—
20:30.634 --> 20:33.471
or I'm sorry, of Open Work— where, you know, people don't understand, like, when,
20:33.888 --> 20:37.527
when you walk in the door of a retailer, all the costs.
20:37.655 --> 20:41.085
Yeah, that have all been sunk long before you ever ask to see a watch
20:41.118 --> 20:44.372
in the case. And that— and that's— I just had no idea, and my eyes
20:44.468 --> 20:48.027
were opened. Yeah. To what it was actually required. It's not just like, let's open
20:48.527 --> 20:52.066
a store and sell sell watches, like the capital investment, the security risks,
20:52.098 --> 20:55.577
the insurance requirements, like all these sorts
20:55.641 --> 20:59.167
of things, logistical demands of it. And having an
20:59.216 --> 21:01.877
eye into that, I was like, oh, I'm not interested in that. Yeah, I don't
21:02.117 --> 21:05.179
blame you. But times change. So anyway,
21:05.323 --> 21:07.856
long story short, we create Collective.
21:08.449 --> 21:12.456
This is in 2018 where we have the idea. The business officially is formed
21:12.956 --> 21:16.272
in 2019. And well, we worked on it all through 20—
21:16.304 --> 21:19.638
the business was formed. Yeah, but I mean, like the, the, the LegalZoom filing was
21:19.734 --> 21:23.261
2019, we were working on it all 2018. And the
21:23.277 --> 21:26.611
basic concept originally, which is deeply flawed,
21:27.108 --> 21:31.100
was we're going to make 50 collaborative watches
21:31.196 --> 21:34.578
with watchmakers of all variety, and you have to apply to be
21:35.078 --> 21:38.025
a member. And I'll get into the application thing in a second. But if you
21:38.525 --> 21:41.920
are approved as a member, then essentially you are committing to buying
21:42.818 --> 21:45.911
a collective watch from us every time we release it. And then we had some
21:46.344 --> 21:50.336
fakakta scheme of like, but you're allowed like one skip every 5 years or something,
21:50.769 --> 21:54.428
because we knew as we did this like, uh-oh, if we don't sell all
21:54.460 --> 21:57.753
these watches, we're screwed. But we also knew in our heart,
21:57.833 --> 22:01.077
like, something about that model was a little weird because asking
22:01.126 --> 22:04.515
people to commit to buying stuff before they
22:05.015 --> 22:09.205
know what it is or how much it costs or any of that is very
22:09.237 --> 22:12.337
challenging. And as we would learn as we go down the road,
22:12.433 --> 22:15.052
might've even been questionably legal in terms of our ability to,
22:15.887 --> 22:18.858
like, not require people to buy things, but like, what if we were late or,
22:19.019 --> 22:22.775
you know, all the things that go into all that. So, but not knowing any
22:22.807 --> 22:26.784
of that, that naivete is largely what I think powered us. And we started—
22:27.217 --> 22:30.858
and this was again in partnership with Rob Kaplan— started looking for
22:31.131 --> 22:34.434
brands that would be willing to do this with us. And, you know, we got
22:34.934 --> 22:37.770
a lot of very polite head nodding and, you know,
22:38.107 --> 22:40.593
people kind of just were like, oh yeah, that's kind of interesting. You know,
22:40.609 --> 22:44.507
I don't know. No, though, until we met a guy named Terry.
22:45.325 --> 22:48.949
Oh yeah. And Terry at the time was the U.S. sales director
22:49.449 --> 22:53.550
for Zenith Watches. And he got it. He understood
22:53.582 --> 22:57.366
what we were trying to do. Now, I should add that Gabe comes from a
22:57.606 --> 23:01.357
creative stand part of the business that I didn't. So he came from the advertising
23:01.857 --> 23:05.140
side of the business, and the advertising side of the business has a very famous
23:05.640 --> 23:08.058
document, right? The creative brief. You want to talk about that?
23:09.404 --> 23:12.963
Not really. All right. Basically, the idea was we, instead of us designing
23:13.059 --> 23:16.233
a watch by, you know, mocking something up
23:16.265 --> 23:19.824
ourselves, we started with a more traditional document that basically
23:20.324 --> 23:23.815
said, here's what we want the watch to feel like, here's what we want people
23:24.315 --> 23:27.134
to take away from it, here's the creative story we wanted to tell,
23:27.663 --> 23:31.333
and then turned that over to the designers. And so the brief was essentially
23:31.833 --> 23:34.251
to Zenith once they agreed to sort of take a flyer on the project.
23:34.315 --> 23:38.162
And they were interested, I think, one, because Topper was— probably
23:38.662 --> 23:42.122
still is— a very strong Zenith retailer. Sure. So it was an important— they
23:42.154 --> 23:45.392
also saw a marketing opportunity. They saw a marketing opportunity in that, like,
23:45.456 --> 23:48.919
you know, here are some guys from Silicon Valley, this is a
23:48.983 --> 23:51.964
kind of client base that we want to grow, and it's a client base that
23:52.012 --> 23:55.848
we see is growing, like there's a growing interest in this community
23:55.896 --> 23:59.477
around watches, and we believe Zenith is an interesting brand
23:59.977 --> 24:02.175
that they should be considering and taking a look at. So they took a flyer
24:02.287 --> 24:05.547
on us, and our brief to them was like, let's do something with the El
24:05.596 --> 24:08.422
Primero Chronomaster, because in our mind, that's like,
24:08.631 --> 24:11.232
well, first of all, we need to sell 50 of these things. So what's the
24:11.732 --> 24:15.424
most iconic, sort of most understood quantity in,
24:16.114 --> 24:19.840
in Zenith? It's that watch. But our brief to them was bring the
24:20.113 --> 24:24.427
reductive product design language of Silicon Valley to
24:24.700 --> 24:27.586
the El Primero. Because keep in mind, at that point, you know,
24:27.602 --> 24:30.969
that El Primero Chronomaster was a kind of a,
24:31.257 --> 24:34.432
a very loud watch from a design perspective. You had the
24:34.544 --> 24:37.719
overlapping sub-dials in with the tri-colors.
24:37.767 --> 24:41.326
It was a very busy watch. They've since explored different
24:41.599 --> 24:44.405
versions of that watch. There's the Chronomaster Sport.
24:44.501 --> 24:47.692
There's been a lot of design riffs. But at that point in time, that was
24:47.852 --> 24:51.939
kind of the El Primero. Yeah. And they delivered a
24:52.439 --> 24:56.187
watch that absolutely nailed that brief, but they designed the watch. It wasn't
24:56.687 --> 24:58.671
like we, the Watch Club, approached them and said,
25:00.033 --> 25:04.104
change these dial colors or whatever. We gave them that, that creative inspiration,
25:04.136 --> 25:07.406
and that ended up being our process for every other brand we worked with on
25:07.906 --> 25:11.316
a collaborative piece. What's interesting as I think back on it too, so I had
25:11.412 --> 25:14.618
to be bizarrely, and I'm sure much to everybody's shock,
25:14.634 --> 25:18.625
I was so sad that I was sent by Facebook to go speak
25:18.865 --> 25:22.570
at and the last SIHH before it became Watches and
25:23.070 --> 25:26.420
Wonders. This is in 2019, in January. And I go out
25:26.920 --> 25:29.003
there, and while I was out there, Terry was like, well, why don't you go
25:29.503 --> 25:33.928
meet this guy Roman, who's like an up-and-comer inside of our design department?
25:34.682 --> 25:38.580
You can go meet him and go over the final design of the watch.
25:39.414 --> 25:43.408
Yeah, great. So I do my song and dance for Facebook
25:43.489 --> 25:47.098
in Geneva. You can go on YouTube and watch me jibber-jabber
25:47.598 --> 25:51.075
about why, like, Messenger is going to be important to the watch industry. Smash cut,
25:51.364 --> 25:54.955
it's not. But anyway— Shocking! But, you know,
25:55.115 --> 25:58.497
hey, it's your fault. Maybe then I could have been. So, yeah, probably would've.
25:58.898 --> 26:02.264
Anyway, and then I go in and meet Roman, who, of course, turns out
26:02.764 --> 26:04.413
to be a friend of ours over the long term and a guy that we
26:04.429 --> 26:07.699
adore. But you know who else I met at that meeting? No. And this
26:08.199 --> 26:11.177
just, I think, shows how, like, fate kind of rolls out. There's a guy right
26:11.677 --> 26:13.758
in front of me that Roman was like, oh, you should meet this person.
26:13.806 --> 26:17.653
You'd really like him. He owns a store in Colorado.
26:17.814 --> 26:21.629
This is our friend Jeremy Oster. Jeremy Oster. All right. So, I meet Jeremy
26:21.725 --> 26:25.480
Oster, for the very first time sitting in front of Romain
26:25.512 --> 26:28.658
Marietta. Did he carry Zenith as well? Oh yeah, sure. And we,
26:29.685 --> 26:33.039
so we talked and of course now Jeremy Oster is a retailer of Ming and
26:33.539 --> 26:37.469
we're colleagues. So it's funny how these things, these things sort of evolve
26:37.969 --> 26:41.497
and, and, and, and turn into what they turn into. Anyway, long story
26:41.997 --> 26:45.284
short, we launched Collective, you know, you and I have a, have a,
26:45.557 --> 26:48.141
you know, podcast appearance on Hodinkee Radio.
26:48.702 --> 26:51.733
With Steve. That was like the peak, man, showing up
26:52.233 --> 26:55.374
to Hodinkee to be on the pod. I mean, we flew out to
26:55.874 --> 26:59.142
New York to do that. We did. No small thing. We did. And we did
26:59.642 --> 27:01.259
it with Stephen Pulverin, who of course is now a good friend of ours.
27:01.789 --> 27:04.868
So that was, that was quite, quite a, quite an event. And,
27:04.964 --> 27:07.786
and we started making these collaborations. So we did that one, then we worked with
27:07.851 --> 27:11.234
Moser and then we worked with Urwerk and we did work with Shapiro, then we
27:11.734 --> 27:15.211
worked
with IWC and it really began to become a business.
27:15.387 --> 27:19.090
And ultimately we moved away from partnering with retailers and doing it ourselves
27:19.427 --> 27:22.874
about halfway through. But through the middle of the pandemic,
27:23.403 --> 27:26.785
as the community continued to grow, we started to realize that that model just
27:27.285 --> 27:30.488
didn't work. And we changed it. The model of requiring people to buy every watch.
27:30.552 --> 27:33.758
So that meant that we had to increase membership and grow and grow and grow.
27:33.838 --> 27:36.050
And it became apparent to us 2 things. One,
27:37.445 --> 27:40.555
that this membership thing felt elitist and
27:41.055 --> 27:43.296
we didn't like it, but we couldn't figure out a way, because remember, this is
27:43.796 --> 27:45.909
during the pandemic, we had to figure out a way where people weren't just going
27:45.925 --> 27:48.993
to take our work and then just immediately resell it. Yeah. Which is really frustrating
27:49.058 --> 27:51.805
because, you know, it seems like you make a lot of money doing this sort
27:52.305 --> 27:55.630
of thing. You don't. And not when you amortize it over the course of
27:55.646 --> 27:59.117
2 years of work. And we began to
27:59.181 --> 28:02.491
also get a little nervous because we started to look at that structure because basically
28:02.991 --> 28:05.271
what was happening is that we were making these financial commitments to these brands.
28:06.267 --> 28:09.851
You know, some of them anywhere between half a million to over a million dollars
28:09.883 --> 28:13.029
of wholesale. We didn't have that money. You know,
28:13.478 --> 28:17.132
no, we were, we were collecting that money from people in preorders.
28:17.180 --> 28:19.584
And basically the idea was, well, once we sell them all out, we place our
28:20.084 --> 28:23.447
deposit and then we pay the balance and it's all good, which is ultimately
28:23.495 --> 28:26.171
how it played out until it didn't. Yeah. And,
28:27.101 --> 28:30.082
you know, we, we were able to make it work, but we knew in our
28:30.582 --> 28:34.072
heart that, that like that was a very like dangerous business model.
28:34.473 --> 28:37.646
Well, I want to back up for, for a second because I think there in
28:37.694 --> 28:41.669
that time period, a key thing changed. So for our first few watches,
28:42.263 --> 28:45.875
we generally worked together with retailers. So we launched,
28:45.891 --> 28:49.727
as you said, the Zenith El Primero together with Topper. So Topper
28:50.227 --> 28:53.467
was the authorized retailer for it. When we did the Moser, Topper was
28:53.500 --> 28:56.710
the authorized dealer. We did— when Urwerk, it was Danny
28:57.210 --> 29:00.322
Goldsmith at Goldsmith& Company. We did it through Danny Goldsmith. And this was all under
29:00.822 --> 29:04.881
the notion that, like, we're not good at the back end of retailing watches with
29:04.897 --> 29:08.782
point of sale, safe,
and security, and shipping,
29:08.910 --> 29:12.121
and insurance, and all these sorts of things that
29:12.185 --> 29:15.582
you need to import that you need to like do
29:16.126 --> 29:18.497
as a retailer. Like it's a profession.
29:19.106 --> 29:23.015
So we partnered with retailers, but in this time period we end up,
29:23.640 --> 29:27.341
and I should back up for all of the
29:27.901 --> 29:31.442
things that we say about Facebook and all the criticism we lob
29:31.942 --> 29:35.383
at Facebook and Meta. But we had explicit permission to run
29:35.431 --> 29:38.491
this business from them. Yeah. One of the things they deserve
29:38.539 --> 29:41.759
tremendous credit for in terms of the way they, at least
29:42.259 --> 29:45.893
at that point, they treated employees was you could get permission. You needed
29:45.925 --> 29:49.436
permission, but you could get permission to have your own business as
29:49.936 --> 29:53.363
long as it didn't compete or wasn't— yeah, it wasn't competitive with their— with
29:53.863 --> 29:55.896
it. And for this, people were like, yeah, sure, whatever. You want to have a—
29:56.088 --> 29:59.519
you want to have a little watch club? Sure. But what ends up happening is
29:59.952 --> 30:03.639
because of the time, energy, and effort to do
30:04.139 --> 30:07.518
this well, we're putting a lot of our time into
30:07.726 --> 30:11.141
Collective. You know, there are watches to design because
30:11.253 --> 30:14.828
of the importance of really selling the business model. Like, we need to sell these
30:14.860 --> 30:18.196
things out. We're not just thinking about the design of these watches. We're developing
30:18.228 --> 30:21.324
entire campaigns. We're hiring people to develop video.
30:21.997 --> 30:25.446
We're doing tons of marketing and advertising work. We're managing a
30:25.946 --> 30:30.034
community of members. Like, this becomes not just a part-time
30:30.098 --> 30:33.707
job on the side, but yet another full-time job for us. So we start
30:34.207 --> 30:37.749
to look at the amount of our own time, energy, and effort
30:38.182 --> 30:42.080
we're investing into Collective. And we start to say, like, right now
30:42.433 --> 30:45.690
we're, we're essentially sharing the margin, the retail margin
30:45.738 --> 30:49.153
on these watches with a retailer. And for us to continue
30:49.169 --> 30:52.263
doing this at the level that's required to do it well,
30:53.193 --> 30:56.719
we need to capture that full margin. And so we start
30:57.219 --> 31:00.358
to make investments in things like an office,
31:01.064 --> 31:05.135
a safe, insurance, a Shopify storefront,
31:05.360 --> 31:09.479
all of this sort of infrastructure to allow us to retail nothing
31:09.543 --> 31:12.910
more than just the collaboration. So by the time— and a hat. And a hat.
31:13.391 --> 31:16.180
By the time we get to our, our project, I think it was with,
31:16.260 --> 31:19.338
with Chapek, the Antarctic that we did. No, we, we did the—
31:19.402 --> 31:22.863
we did Armin Strom on our own platform. We did Armin Strom
31:23.071 --> 31:25.731
first. Okay. Right. Just before Czapek. So we did Armin Strom.
31:26.212 --> 31:29.513
We end up doing that ourselves. Now, at this time, though, I think
31:29.577 --> 31:32.910
prior to that, about a year prior to Armin Strom, we started retailing. And part
31:33.410 --> 31:35.522
of the reason why we started retailing was that we wanted to create a more
31:35.570 --> 31:39.208
steady revenue flow for the business that we could have a more stable business.
31:39.272 --> 31:43.005
But we also realized that if we wanted to support independent watchmaking, we could do
31:43.021 --> 31:45.809
that more effectively by also retailing watches.
31:46.402 --> 31:50.137
Wouldn't you know it though, when you start knocking on the door of
31:50.234 --> 31:54.193
independent watchmakers and saying, I want to retail you, they're a bit
31:54.257 --> 31:56.678
skeptical. Sure. And rightly so,
31:57.127 --> 32:00.749
because we were approaching it saying, well, we understand the infrastructure
32:01.249 --> 32:04.933
now, we understand the operations of a retailer, sort of.
32:05.558 --> 32:09.326
But what we didn't fundamentally understand was probably the most
32:09.826 --> 32:13.429
important thing about it, which was— which we were told in a dinner that
32:13.477 --> 32:16.796
you and I will never forget. Yes. By a watchmaking idol of
32:17.296 --> 32:19.716
ours who we went and And we asked if we could open their brand and
32:19.748 --> 32:22.542
they very clearly and abruptly said no.
32:23.602 --> 32:26.235
And the reason why was you don't have the clients.
32:27.054 --> 32:29.993
And they were right. We didn't at the time. And,
32:30.587 --> 32:34.312
you know, sure, we'd sold a few collaborations and made a couple million dollars gross
32:34.424 --> 32:37.732
over several years doing that. Well, we didn't make— when I say,
32:37.957 --> 32:41.907
I said gross, Collective did. You and I barely made
32:42.147 --> 32:45.227
anything. But, but all of that to say,
32:46.557 --> 32:50.611
we walked home in the like icy rain back to our terrible Ibis
32:50.723 --> 32:54.377
hotel at that first Watches and Wonders that we went to as like Collective.
32:54.826 --> 32:57.967
Destroyed. Utterly destroyed. But we decided we're going to do this.
32:58.015 --> 33:01.829
So, well, thank God we didn't. He was right. But thank God we didn't realize
33:02.262 --> 33:05.915
he was right because we wouldn't have done it. Well, that's, that's the mantra
33:06.415 --> 33:09.201
of the business. All that to say. So we started retailing with our friend Nicholas
33:09.313 --> 33:12.486
Bowman Scargill at Fears. God bless him, because that's why Collective as
33:12.518 --> 33:14.649
a retailer exists is— So Fears?
33:15.629 --> 33:18.954
J.N. Shapiro and Arkanaut, they're in the, in, you know, the plug at the beginning
33:19.002 --> 33:22.150
of the episode. Those
are the oldest brands in our shop. That's why I put
33:22.650 --> 33:26.053
them in there. Nicholas was the first one who said yes. Yeah. And,
33:26.551 --> 33:29.522
you know, so we, so we started, we built the infrastructure, we started doing wind-up
33:30.022 --> 33:33.313
watch fairs, we started retailing Fears. Wouldn't you know it, when you
33:33.813 --> 33:36.188
put watches on your website, people don't just show up and buy them. So we
33:36.688 --> 33:39.866
had to figure out exactly how that all worked. And then I think I made
33:39.882 --> 33:43.186
the choice, as did you, that, you know what, I think I want to do
33:43.686 --> 33:47.609
this. And we started talking about this with our wives and, you know,
33:47.978 --> 33:51.585
mentally preparing. I started doing the thing, which I think every entrepreneur who,
33:51.681 --> 33:55.367
or every wannabe entrepreneur does, because it's the reasonable, rational thing. You were a
33:55.431 --> 33:58.413
wannabe entrepreneur. I was a wannabe entrepreneur. Is that we say,
33:58.557 --> 34:02.099
I'm going to start saving money for this. I'm going to
34:02.599 --> 34:06.523
save a year's worth of salary. And when that happens,
34:06.747 --> 34:09.087
which in my head was going to be at the end of 2024,
34:09.938 --> 34:12.440
I will quit Facebook, nay Meta,
34:13.387 --> 34:16.258
and I will do this full-time. Well,
34:17.093 --> 34:20.413
in 2022, the day our collaboration with Armin Strom
34:20.461 --> 34:24.071
was about to launch, or was going to launch, I got laid
34:24.571 --> 34:27.873
off. And you were at Disneyland. I was at Disneyland. And I
34:27.905 --> 34:31.531
remember 3 distinct feelings. One was that everything that
34:32.031 --> 34:35.461
goes into being laid off, all of the self-doubt and misery and sadness
34:35.961 --> 34:39.389
and fear, Which was then amplified by the fact that that day,
34:39.709 --> 34:43.044
I think we sold like one piece,
34:43.140 --> 34:46.362
maybe 2. So that amplified my fear
34:46.862 --> 34:50.642
and terror about, you know, this followed then by me
34:50.915 --> 34:53.897
looking at this and saying, well, how on earth am I ever going to make
34:54.397 --> 34:57.872
a living if our collaboration isn't like flying
34:57.969 --> 35:01.463
off the shelf like it was in 2022 and I don't have a job anymore?
35:02.057 --> 35:05.927
And I didn't save up all the money. So let's put this, let's put things
35:06.427 --> 35:09.395
in perspective here. Here we are at the end of 2022.
35:10.102 --> 35:13.683
At this point, where is Collective? The core business is still these
35:13.715 --> 35:17.199
collaborations. You know, it's funny, I looked at our, our sales, our retail
35:17.263 --> 35:20.796
sales. So putting collaborations and pre-owned versions
35:21.296 --> 35:25.292
of collaborations aside, I looked at our like authorized retailer
35:25.693 --> 35:29.579
sales. Yeah. Our number one product that we sold in 2022 was
35:29.595 --> 35:32.662
the Fierce Brunswick Jubilee Edition. Oh, that's a great watch. Great watch. Yeah. Yeah,
35:33.528 --> 35:36.656
in all 2022, this was our top-selling retail product.
35:37.153 --> 35:40.650
We sold 4. So this gives you an idea of, of,
35:40.827 --> 35:44.212
of where we are right now. Okay, so we have 2 businesses going on
35:44.712 --> 35:48.447
here. We've got our collaborations, which is still frankly, just by
35:48.947 --> 35:52.072
virtue of those numbers I just gave you, is our core business. Okay,
35:52.794 --> 35:56.211
we've got a small fledgling retail business where we've pretty
35:56.227 --> 35:59.756
much just got like Fierce and JN Shapiro
35:59.772 --> 36:03.461
watches that are available. I think Formex was the next year. Oh,
36:03.526 --> 36:07.676
Interesting. And that's right. Yeah, no, it's 2023 and
36:07.932 --> 36:11.698
Asher just lost his job. And so
36:12.660 --> 36:16.923
the, the, the, this is where we are and the
36:17.067 --> 36:20.512
collaboration business itself, this is 2022,
36:20.608 --> 36:23.942
is just starting to show cracks because of course
36:24.518 --> 36:27.723
we're coming out. The market is on, is at the very peak of
36:28.223 --> 36:30.928
the roller coaster and it's just rolling downhill. Yeah,
36:31.025 --> 36:35.015
exactly. And so then we head into 2023.
36:36.217 --> 36:40.128
And oh my gosh, the, the wheels really
36:40.160 --> 36:43.334
come off the bus of the kind of the collaboration
36:43.366 --> 36:46.940
business, not just at Collective, but in general. There's a lot of fatigue in
36:46.972 --> 36:50.034
the market in general because there's been such a bonanza around
36:50.402 --> 36:54.426
collaborations and limited edition watches and fear of missing out
36:54.926 --> 36:57.776
as a marketing strategy and all this sort of stuff. 2023 is also, I think,
36:57.792 --> 37:00.901
that giant market correction, you know? Yes. Where people were like,
37:00.917 --> 37:04.252
wait a minute, my, my 5711 isn't a quarter million
37:04.284 --> 37:07.891
dollars? What do you mean? I, you know, you won't buy my Daytona
37:08.391 --> 37:11.595
for 50 grand, you know? And of course, all of this is happening now.
37:12.444 --> 37:14.929
And without getting into it, like, I tried— I interviewed a couple times with,
37:15.090 --> 37:18.521
you know, in tech before I admitted to myself that this
37:18.553 --> 37:21.358
is what I wanted to do. I had some interview with some jerk of a
37:21.438 --> 37:25.046
CMO who, like, was such an asshat on the
37:25.546 --> 37:28.701
interview with me that I literally, like, basically asked him if he was paying
37:28.749 --> 37:31.683
attention and could repeat back the last thing that I said to him because he
37:32.183 --> 37:35.373
was so distracted. Shout out to the CMO of The Trade
37:35.873 --> 37:39.546
Desk. Have fun with that one, chief. Toxic guy. Anyway,
37:39.627 --> 37:43.254
he's still there. Who cares? Anyway, how do you really
37:43.754 --> 37:46.688
feel? I
think it was one of the most disrespectful interviews I was ever a
37:47.188 --> 37:49.995
part of. So enjoy being roasted, guy. Anyway,
37:50.556 --> 37:54.168
but you know what? Also, thank you to that guy because he was what
37:54.668 --> 37:57.201
pushed me over the edge saying I can't work for like, you know,
37:58.100 --> 38:01.984
clowns like this anymore who can't even be bothered to listen
38:02.352 --> 38:05.976
to the work that they assigned you to do for them in a
38:06.476 --> 38:10.208
30-minute review. Yeah. And I think that structure was like the final straw for me
38:10.708 --> 38:15.018
in the corporate world where I'm like, if somebody can't even show the respect to
38:15.518 --> 38:18.625
hear the free work that they asked you to do, what are you even gonna
38:18.705 --> 38:22.312
do at this place? Well, you had another moment when we went to Geneva that,
38:22.857 --> 38:26.529
that spring. Remember we bumped into Mike DiMartini? Mike DiMartini
38:26.785 --> 38:29.847
pushed— was also the— because I was actually at the time, I was waiting for
38:30.347 --> 38:33.807
like the whether, you know, whether I was gonna the outcome of this job.
38:34.560 --> 38:38.182
And I remember telling him about,
38:38.406 --> 38:40.586
you know, my one foot in, one foot out thing. And he was the guy
38:41.086 --> 38:42.653
who told me like, you got to, you got to just make the choice,
38:42.669 --> 38:45.650
man. Like, you can't do it this way. And he was 1,000% right. When I
38:46.150 --> 38:49.705
saw him at the hotel lobby a couple of weeks ago
38:49.721 --> 38:53.327
at New York Watch Time, I repeated to him my gratitude for that because
38:53.551 --> 38:56.757
I really was— you needed to hear it. I needed to hear it. So anyway,
38:56.773 --> 39:00.186
so you're all in. So it's spring. When do you think you really kind of
39:00.202 --> 39:04.230
resigned yourself to doing collections? Active, truly full-time?
39:04.730 --> 39:08.190
Was that spring of 2023? I know exactly when it was. It was April of
39:08.690 --> 39:12.090
2023 because you and I were on the airplane to New York because we
39:12.590 --> 39:16.150
had bought a table at the HSNY. Oh, right. And you approved
39:16.650 --> 39:20.050
a raise for me to $2,000. I think we were making $2,500 a
39:20.550 --> 39:24.390
month in salary. So I was taking home $2,500 pre-tax.
39:25.030 --> 39:27.950
Like my, for context, my mortgage is $3,100.
39:28.790 --> 39:32.170
So, you know, it gives you an idea of what we're talking about here.
39:33.060 --> 39:36.840
And sure, I had severance from Facebook and some savings, of course,
39:37.340 --> 39:41.000
but like, that's at 40 years old, like this is not—
39:41.500 --> 39:42.940
41 years old, like this is not what you want to be doing with 2
39:43.440 --> 39:46.180
kids and a mortgage and the rest of it. But, but I did, as did
39:46.680 --> 39:50.440
you. And then you left Facebook shortly thereafter and we decided to do this full-time.
39:50.620 --> 39:54.240
I quit. You quit. Only to find out that if I had stayed another
39:54.740 --> 39:56.740
few weeks, I would have been laid off. Yeah, you should have. And I had,
39:57.060 --> 39:59.220
at that point I had been there for 10 years and it was, that would
39:59.720 --> 40:02.040
have been a pretty nice severance package. But you know what? I left on my
40:02.540 --> 40:06.367
own terms. There you go. My head held high. And we decide we're
40:06.399 --> 40:09.910
going to do this. And I think at this point we're realizing,
40:10.166 --> 40:13.998
okay, we're all in on Collective, the collaboration business.
40:14.094 --> 40:17.220
Let's put that to the side for a second. But for Collective
40:17.720 --> 40:20.907
to work, to employ us full-time, both of
40:21.407 --> 40:24.049
us, and to, and to do something that we truly love and really, frankly,
40:24.081 --> 40:27.463
to live our dream, we needed to fully
40:27.495 --> 40:31.375
evolve the business away from a core of
40:31.583 --> 40:34.885
collaborative watches with sort of a smattering of retail to
40:34.933 --> 40:38.572
almost the opposite. Because the— let's— before
40:39.072 --> 40:43.413
we talk about like the market correction on collaborations and all that, it's an inherently
40:43.445 --> 40:47.100
risky business because you put all of your eggs in
40:47.356 --> 40:51.043
just a couple of baskets a year. That's it. You know, we would work
40:51.620 --> 40:55.130
for a year or years on these collaborations and
40:55.630 --> 40:59.474
you'd launch them and hope they sell. Meanwhile, with retail, if you
40:59.974 --> 41:03.225
can build up a diverse slate of brands and product to sell,
41:03.883 --> 41:07.142
then you have a client book and a client book. But just, I'm saying,
41:07.239 --> 41:10.080
from what you're stocking in your store perspective, like,
41:11.252 --> 41:14.623
diversification of your portfolio is really important.
41:14.720 --> 41:18.525
And having a variety of things at a variety of price points that suit
41:18.589 --> 41:21.896
a variety of tastes and interests and kinds of watchmaking that
41:21.928 --> 41:25.781
you fundamentally believe in, that is a more sustainable
41:26.038 --> 41:29.554
proposition. And we knew we're gonna need to change
41:30.054 --> 41:34.016
the business, and thank God we did, because that year from a
41:34.065 --> 41:38.077
collaboration standpoint, it was tough. That was the year we did Montblanc
41:38.141 --> 41:41.447
and we did, and we did Aurus. And, you know, look,
41:41.607 --> 41:45.266
I think the thing about both of those projects is that
41:45.363 --> 41:48.572
those were 2 of my favorite projects from a design standpoint. Oh yeah.
41:49.134 --> 41:52.328
I am so very proud of what we accomplished with Montblanc. I am,
41:52.665 --> 41:56.115
from a design standpoint, I'm very proud of the—
41:56.292 --> 41:59.325
there you go— of the, the, you know, the piece that we did with Aurus.
42:00.447 -->
42:03.701
But, you know, the Montblanc did not sell well
42:04.070 --> 42:07.179
initially, and it was very, very tough going. And what
42:07.679 --> 42:11.122
happened— ultimately, ultimately, these watches sold, but that
42:11.622 --> 42:15.417
wasn't the business model. The business model, to your point, was we need
42:15.450 --> 42:19.601
to sell all of these either on a preorder or as quickly as possible,
42:19.937 --> 42:23.608
because otherwise you and I would be personally on the hook
42:23.848 --> 42:28.032
for whatever was unsold, which we were. And what happened at the end of 2023
42:28.754 --> 42:32.379
You know, part of that question from Steve was, you know, how were you financed?
42:32.428 --> 42:36.053
And the answer is we weren't. You know, we've said this several times on this
42:36.553 --> 42:39.872
podcast, but it's true. We don't have investors. And all the money
42:39.968 --> 42:42.856
that came from this business comes from Gabe and me or from money that the
42:43.356 --> 42:46.578
business itself has generated. And at that point in 2023,
42:47.204 --> 42:50.011
the music stopped and there weren't chairs for Gabe and me.
42:50.653 --> 42:54.086
And we each coughed up hundreds of thousands of dollars. And mind
42:54.586 --> 42:58.402
you, we had invoices of hundreds of thousands of dollars from,
42:58.899 --> 43:02.653
from— and, and rightly so. Like, these guys made the watches.
43:02.750 --> 43:06.504
They said these were agreements. These were agreements. And they delivered watches.
43:06.841 --> 43:10.242
And guess what? We'd sold some of them, but not all of them. And the
43:10.306 --> 43:13.338
bill was due. And we had to find hundreds of thousands of
43:13.838 --> 43:16.627
dollars. And it came out of our own pockets. And this was after I'd been
43:16.724 --> 43:20.045
laid off. This is after Asher's been laid off. This is after I
43:20.093 --> 43:23.410
quit my job at Meta to do this full-time. And And
43:23.910 --> 43:27.010
my wife had been laid off that year. Yeah, I forgot about that. So,
43:27.510 --> 43:29.890
you know, this is what we're, we're dealing with. And it's not like we were
43:30.390 --> 43:33.350
sitting on mountains of, of cash. You know, there's a funny, you always like to
43:33.850 --> 43:36.390
bring this up. Oh yeah, there was this comment once on Hodinkee where some guy
43:36.890 --> 43:39.409
was like, uh, you know, commenting about like you and I and was like,
43:39.909 --> 43:42.710
doesn't matter if they sell all these, they're executive Facebooks, they're rolling in money.
43:43.210 --> 43:46.210
And I'm like, bro, let me tell you something. Yeah, so we, we, we very,
43:46.710 --> 43:49.250
very far from that. So like we were, I mean, I'll tell you, like I
43:49.750 --> 43:53.030
tapped into a credit line to put money, like, oh, me too. Personal credit line
43:53.530 --> 43:56.539
to put money into into Collective because we had to make it. We had to
43:57.039 --> 44:00.405
make it work.
We maxed out our tiny little line of credit for the company.
44:00.790 --> 44:03.085
Thank God we had. Yeah. We had a line of credit for the business,
44:03.165 --> 44:06.294
which we had to turn to. We had to personally, you know, take out money
44:06.390 --> 44:10.160
and like literally remortgage my, from, I'll say from my perspective,
44:10.240 --> 44:14.075
remortgage my house to do this. It was a very
44:14.187 --> 44:17.556
dark and terrifying time. So this is almost
44:18.056 --> 44:21.485
4 years ago. Yeah. That's where we were. And we looked
44:21.985 --> 44:24.499
at it 3 years ago. 3 years ago, we looked at ourselves in the eyes
44:25.092 --> 44:27.625
and we basically said like, do you think this business is going to survive?
44:28.218 --> 44:31.584
And you were more realistic about that than I was. And we're probably like,
44:31.729 --> 44:34.566
I don't know, man. And ask me again in a few months and then we'll
44:35.066 --> 44:38.573
make a choice. And no, I said, I will know in June of 2024
44:39.073 --> 44:42.966
if this business is still around. And, and I wasn't
44:43.466 --> 44:46.124
willing to go there with you because in my mind I'm like, well, as I
44:46.172 --> 44:49.618
just did on this podcast, I just torched the— I like, I literally like,
44:49.682 --> 44:52.922
you know, blew up the bridge to the last big company that was going to
44:53.067 --> 44:56.807
be willing to hire me, Trade Desk. And then I went back and
44:56.903 --> 45:00.322
reblew it up. Yeah, well, I just did that again. But yeah,
45:00.675 --> 45:04.623
but anyway, we both needed this to work. I wasn't about
45:05.123 --> 45:08.267
to like go back to working in advertising or something. And as we've now
45:08.395 --> 45:11.911
learned, looking at the market, I don't know that we even could. Yeah. Oh yeah,
45:12.087 --> 45:15.522
that's a great point. Keep in mind what the rest— not only were you laid
45:16.022 --> 45:19.470
off, not only was my wife laid off, not only would I have been laid
45:19.970 --> 45:23.707
off, but if you look at the rest of the market for jobs in The
45:23.723 --> 45:27.636
things that you and I know how to do, technology, advertising and media
45:28.136 --> 45:31.500
and entertainment, those are all the industries that are totally cooked.
45:31.821 --> 45:35.333
It's really dark out there. So we had no other option
45:35.509 --> 45:38.347
but to figure it out. And we did. So what'd we do? We're still here.
45:39.117 --> 45:42.693
We are. So what'd we do? Well, we put one
45:42.725 --> 45:46.541
foot in front of the other and we learned our lessons about finance,
45:46.573 --> 45:50.197
about money and overcommitment. We paid every single
45:50.261 --> 45:54.036
dollar that we owed, not just to the businesses, but to ourselves back over
45:54.536 --> 45:57.585
the course of however, about a year and a half. Yeah.
45:57.649 --> 46:01.585
We paid off the last dollar owed to you and me in
46:02.085 --> 46:06.242
the beginning of
2025. Yeah. And around
46:06.742 --> 46:08.507
that period of time, I wouldn't have guessed we were, we would be able to
46:08.571 --> 46:11.993
do it that quickly. Yeah. And now around that period of time,
46:12.651 --> 46:15.847
this is towards like mid-'24, another friend of ours,
46:16.361 --> 46:19.140
a guy who was another amazing salesperson that I had worked with, with.
46:20.294 --> 46:22.827
Well, there's something before that that was critical to the business.
46:23.580 --> 46:27.251
You remember in January of 2024, our darkest
46:27.331 --> 46:31.098
hour was the dawn of this here podcast.
46:31.980 --> 46:35.571
Yes, that's true. And actually there was a proto version of Open House in January
46:35.603 --> 46:38.969
too, which we did on a folding table at Josh Shapiro's workshop. Oh,
46:39.450 --> 46:42.816
sure. And, you know, it's, it's, you can look back on those things
46:43.316 --> 46:44.419
and you can be like, that's dark. Or you can look at it and be
46:44.919 --> 46:48.427
like, you know, these were the beginnings of, of what really, I think, have helped
46:48.507 --> 46:51.473
turn the business into something more sustainable. Yeah.
46:51.537 --> 46:54.327
Which where it is right now, you know, an incredibly sustainable and— It was us
46:54.600 --> 46:57.936
figuring it out. Necessity is the mother of invention,
46:58.032 --> 47:02.073
actually. Indeed. So in the middle of '24, I get a phone call from
47:02.217 --> 47:05.617
a guy who's a friend of mine and somebody who I
47:05.665 --> 47:09.755
really respected massively as a salesperson named Jeff Souter.
47:10.797 --> 47:14.405
And Jeff— That name sounds familiar. Doesn't it? And Jeff says to me, listen,
47:14.886 --> 47:18.256
I quit my job at Shreve& Company. Company in the Bay Area.
47:19.139 --> 47:22.656
I'm— you know how much I believe in what you're doing at Collective,
47:23.459 --> 47:26.752
and you know how much I love independent watches, and I, I want
47:27.252 --> 47:30.622
to come work with you guys. And I say to him, dude, like,
47:31.425 --> 47:34.782
yeah, Gabe and I can barely pay ourselves. Yeah, what are
47:35.282 --> 47:37.817
we gonna do? I mean, I like— I love that, but come on. He goes,
47:38.572 --> 47:41.238
let me come down and pitch you. I'm gonna drive down and pitch you.
47:41.929 --> 47:44.994
Just, just hear me out. It will cost you Nothing. Okay.
47:45.715 --> 47:48.904
So Jeff drives down, sits with Gabe and me for an hour,
47:49.561 --> 47:52.911
and the sum total of his pitch, aside from, you know, who he is and
47:53.411 --> 47:56.741
his impressive background in watch retail and his passion for independent
47:56.757 --> 48:00.539
watches, was basically, let me work here on commission only for 6
48:01.039 --> 48:05.267
months as a 1099 employee. I am so— Not an employee. Or 1099
48:05.767 --> 48:10.139
contractor. I am so confident— He was not an employee of Collective Horology
48:10.155 --> 48:13.409
LLC doing business as Northern Digital Computing.
48:14.643 --> 48:19.147
And if I'm successful in those 6 months, I'd like you to hire me full-time.
48:19.933 --> 48:23.059
And Gabe and I look at each other and we're like, I mean, I don't
48:23.559 --> 48:26.714
know how you say no to something like this, except for one thing, which is
48:26.746 --> 48:30.112
that up until this point, everything about Collective was you and
48:30.612 --> 48:34.280
me. And introducing a third party into that introduces
48:34.780 --> 48:37.213
a whole other variable. Now it's not just you and me talking to people.
48:37.502 --> 48:40.660
It's not just you and me selling things. It's a different person.
48:41.093 --> 48:44.074
And that really brings up a broader question of like, what is Collective and how
48:44.574 --> 48:47.684
does it present and who are we? How do we make sure that our
48:47.973 --> 48:52.389
ethics and our morals and the way that we do business is consistent
48:52.889 --> 48:55.985
when it's not you and me? Well, turns out the answer to that is hiring
48:56.082 --> 48:59.839
right, which we did. And in hiring Jeff, who many
48:59.871 --> 49:02.264
of you I'm sure have met, and if you haven't, I hope you do,
49:02.344 --> 49:05.812
because aside from being an exceptionally talented sales professional,
49:06.214 --> 49:09.361
he's one of the most decent human beings I've ever had the opportunity to
49:09.409 --> 49:13.244
work with. Yeah. Lo and behold, Lo and behold, Jeff did
49:13.292 --> 49:17.254
exactly what he said he would do. And what he helped us understand
49:17.847 --> 49:21.472
was something that Nicholas Bowman Scargill from Fears had told us a year prior,
49:22.418 --> 49:25.129
which is we had sort of been kicking around the idea. I didn't say this
49:25.629 --> 49:27.406
to Jeff, but we had sort of been kicking around the idea of hiring a
49:27.906 --> 49:31.560
salesperson. We knew that was the next thing we needed to do. We also knew
49:32.060 --> 49:35.939
that we didn't have the money for it. And we mentioned this to Nicholas over
49:35.971 --> 49:38.634
what was a tradition at the time, which was steak dinner on Saturday night.
49:38.698 --> 49:42.017
Sunday night after wine tasting. And he said to us,
49:42.065 --> 49:44.422
he's like, well, you're making, you're making a mistake because you're never going to be
49:44.470 --> 49:47.597
fully ready and you should just hire the person and the work will go to
49:48.097 --> 49:50.692
them and the money will come to them. And of course, coming out of everything
49:50.708 --> 49:53.866
that we just described, you can understand why I was reticent about making a decision
49:54.366 --> 49:57.666
like that. Also, I take hiring people very seriously, you know,
49:57.923 --> 50:01.146
and I don't, I don't view that as like something you do on a lark.
50:01.611 --> 50:05.282
Long story short, Nicholas, as he often is, was completely
50:05.539 --> 50:08.569
right. And we hire Jeff full-time.
50:09.146 --> 50:13.667
In early '25, which is, I think, what sets us off into
50:13.731 --> 50:17.290
where we are now as a 6-person company carrying the lines that we do,
50:17.434 --> 50:20.464
etc. And the biggest lesson that I've taken away
50:20.964 --> 50:24.279
from all of this, you know, because, you know, throughout all of this,
50:24.936 --> 50:27.934
you know, you, you're like Neo dodging the bullets, right? Because sure,
50:28.078 --> 50:31.637
it's like one is our like problems of our own making or our own naivete,
50:32.086 --> 50:35.837
followed then by, you know, you know, challenges around
50:35.853 --> 50:39.315
balancing the growth of a company. And then come tariffs, you know, and then come
50:39.363 --> 50:42.569
all these other things. That are lobbed at you that, that may not be
50:43.069 --> 50:47.026
your fault, may not be even something you can control, but are fundamentally your responsibility.
50:47.074 --> 50:50.056
And you have to ask yourself, how do I build a sustainable business in that
50:50.556 --> 50:54.256
environment? And I think what, what we've boiled it down to fundamentally is
50:55.250 --> 50:58.360
we are very deliberate about the choices that we make.
50:59.241 --> 51:02.928
And we think very hard about what growth looks
51:03.428 --> 51:08.587
like for us and our clients, especially, and I think most
51:09.087 --> 51:12.466
most notably because we touched the hot stove. Yeah. I'm looking back
51:12.966 --> 51:16.137
on it now. I mean, that the end of 2023, early 2024 was
51:16.266 --> 51:20.033
a really harrowing time. I mean, sure, for you it was 2022
51:20.497 --> 51:23.912
when you were laid off through 2023 into 2024.
51:23.960 --> 51:26.541
Yeah. It was a harrowing time. That was tough.
51:28.096 --> 51:32.216
And to be honest, like I think we were our,
51:32.424 --> 51:35.149
you know, the old saying with kids is like, you know, your eyes are bigger
51:35.649 --> 51:38.499
than your stomach. I think that that was true when it came to the collaboration
51:38.997 --> 51:42.707
And sure, we quite literally paid the price and it was painful,
51:43.012 --> 51:47.316
but thank God we did because we learned the lesson about one,
51:47.927 --> 51:51.203
being needing to be very conservative and deliberate
51:51.299 --> 51:54.158
in the way we plan the business and the way we spend money.
51:54.897 --> 51:58.575
2, the other great advice also from Mike DeMartini of Manta
51:58.607 --> 52:01.465
and Everest, who gave you the advice that you needed to go in full-time,
52:01.562 --> 52:05.079
was like, never take a dime from anyone. Do not give
52:05.175 --> 52:08.851
up a piece of your business unless you absolutely have
52:08.883 --> 52:12.731
to. And somehow through all of that, we managed
52:13.231 --> 52:17.011
to hang in and hang on and not do that, not give up a piece
52:17.123 --> 52:20.954
of the business. And I think those are the things that
52:20.970 --> 52:24.208
have ultimately served us. But you know what they've also done? And I
52:24.708 --> 52:28.007
don't want to go back to those times, but I'm glad we got through it.
52:28.440 --> 52:30.732
I think it's also been very valuable for us because,
52:31.726 --> 52:34.932
and you know who said this as well, I think was Xavier de Roque Morel
52:35.432 --> 52:39.677
when we had him on the podcast, which is having no money creates
52:39.886 --> 52:44.143
the clearest vision. And when
52:44.643 --> 52:48.079
I started in this job, I remember like when I got back from Disneyland
52:48.579 --> 52:50.441
after I was laid off, you and I met up at a bar and you
52:50.489 --> 52:54.056
came up to me, you're like, congratulations, Mr. CEO. And I remember
52:54.556 --> 52:56.691
like— It was a big promotion. Yeah. And I remember changing my, you know,
52:56.707 --> 52:59.856
my like LinkedIn and like CEO. And I was like, I'm such a clown,
53:00.209 --> 53:03.695
you know, like I'm not a chief executive officer of anything. You are now.
53:04.065 --> 53:06.539
I am now. But, you know, back then,
53:07.518 --> 53:11.065
I wasn't, and I had to sort of grow into that and learn how to
53:11.565 --> 53:14.900
do it. And what's interesting to me is that the last, you know,
53:14.916 --> 53:18.623
4 or 5 years have been the most difficult
53:18.688 --> 53:22.106
in, you know, for me in business, but I've
53:22.202 --> 53:26.182
learned more than I ever could have imagined about how real
53:26.616 --> 53:30.130
business works, which I've actually,
53:30.162 --> 53:32.971
to my surprise, have learned that I actually, I very much enjoy it.
53:33.837 --> 53:37.671
And I think the takeaway is because of that, we're now because
53:37.783 --> 53:40.763
we know what it was like to have a bank account with, you know,
53:41.052 --> 53:43.792
less than $10,000 in it, you know, 5 years ago,
53:44.913 --> 53:48.454
because we know what it feels like to be laid off,
53:48.919 --> 53:52.828
because we know what it feels like to hear no, which is the most common
53:53.328 --> 53:56.626
thing you hear in this business, it's taught us a
53:56.690 --> 54:00.231
level of patience and resiliency and
54:01.497 --> 54:05.936
to have backup on backup on backup because the thing that you and I I
54:05.984 --> 54:09.481
think, think about all the time is how are we going to
54:09.513 --> 54:12.529
be the best for our clients and our customers?
54:12.705 --> 54:14.662
What is the— and I know, you know, someone's going to hear that and be
54:15.162 --> 54:18.143
like, shut up, everybody says that. But the thing is, I really,
54:18.576 --> 54:22.329
really, really take that seriously. When we take a deposit
54:22.829 --> 54:26.291
from someone, when we place an order from someone, God, you know, God forbid something
54:26.791 --> 54:30.205
goes wrong. It may not necessarily be our fault,
54:30.670 --> 54:32.884
but it is completely our responsibility. Yes.
54:33.733 --> 54:37.725
And in that regard, like I have built
54:38.225 --> 54:41.684
with you and
everybody else at this company, something that I'm really proud
54:42.184 --> 54:45.580
of, which is a company that is not just, you know,
54:45.596 --> 54:49.395
profitable and operating well and all that stuff, but where,
54:49.908 --> 54:53.338
you know, barring catastrophe on a global
54:53.370 --> 54:56.015
level for a sustained period of time,
54:56.961 --> 55:00.488
we have protected our clients and our brands and everything
55:00.988 --> 55:04.720
that we need to do because we've learned that if you don't anticipate the worst
55:05.220 --> 55:08.322
case scenario, you know, you will fall
55:08.822 --> 55:12.714
victim to it, which is the thing that honestly, if I boil entrepreneurialism down
55:12.827 --> 55:15.886
to one thing, it's really this.
55:16.938 --> 55:20.612
It's very easy to look at an opportunity for
55:20.855 --> 55:23.975
its best possible outcome. You know, like, oh my
55:24.475 --> 55:28.432
God, we're going to sell $1.5 million of watches and we're going to make half
55:28.932 --> 55:31.162
a million. I'm making these numbers up. Half a million dollars doing it. It's going
55:31.662 --> 55:33.776
to be great. What are you going to spend your half a million dollars on?
55:34.002 --> 55:37.998
You know, but the thing that a lot of business owners don't say
55:38.498 --> 55:41.240
is like, okay, well, that's the best case. We all hope that happens.
55:42.026 --> 55:45.396
What's the more rational case? What happens in that scenario?
55:46.199 --> 55:50.500
And then the really important one is what happens if it absolutely
55:50.516 --> 55:54.031
goes to hell? Yeah. When we started this business and,
55:54.063 --> 55:57.754
well, hang on. And, and if it goes to hell, can you survive that?
55:58.219 --> 56:02.135
Correct. When we started this business, business, I think the question
56:02.808 --> 56:06.306
we asked ourselves for the first few years of this business, and we got away
56:06.418 --> 56:09.691
with it because the watch market at that point was going nowhere but up.
56:09.867 --> 56:13.397
Yeah. The question we asked ourselves was, what happens if everything
56:13.477 --> 56:16.943
goes right? The painful lesson we
56:17.071 --> 56:20.536
learned and where we are today after all the
56:21.036 --> 56:24.740
things we just talked about and after actually running a business now
56:25.414 --> 56:28.912
for gosh, 8 years. The question
56:29.412 --> 56:33.277
now is what happens if everything goes wrong? Right. And that's
56:33.777 --> 56:35.250
how we operate. And if the answer to that question is, I don't know,
56:35.636 --> 56:38.893
or I can't survive it, then the answer is very simple to the partner,
56:38.909 --> 56:40.434
which is I can't do that. Yep.
56:41.541 --> 56:44.718
And that's some— that's the best advice that I
56:44.766 --> 56:48.441
would pass. Mike, Mike DeMartini gave me his best advice, and thank you for that.
56:48.762 --> 56:51.827
The advice I give to anyone on this podcast listening to, you know,
56:52.309 --> 56:56.417
or imagining their own businesses, make sure you ask yourself all those
56:56.917 --> 57:00.252
questions. On every deal of significance. Because when you
57:00.752 --> 57:04.408
do that, it— I'm not encourage— I'm not trying to discourage you.
57:04.665 --> 57:07.393
In fact, I'm trying to empower you. It's a form of insurance.
57:07.649 --> 57:10.586
It's a form of insurance and a form of control. Because one of the things
57:11.086 --> 57:13.923
that I think is the hardest about being a nascent business is that you have
57:14.036 --> 57:17.871
very little control and you feel the pressure of
57:18.047 --> 57:21.786
everything coming down on you because there's regulatory stuff
57:21.834 --> 57:25.364
you don't understand, taxation that you've never experienced, I'm not even talking
57:25.864 --> 57:29.198
about tariffs here. I just mean like understanding sales tax or corporate taxes or business
57:29.698 --> 57:32.920
licenses or insurance or all these things that you
57:33.420 --> 57:37.443
don't know about bearing down on you for which you have no gravitas,
57:37.491 --> 57:41.341
ability, or weight to throw around in order to negotiate.
57:41.405 --> 57:44.822
Down the road you do. Down the road when you have value to somebody,
57:44.934 --> 57:47.806
to a business, to an insurer, to a bank, to whatever,
57:48.303 --> 57:52.681
you can negotiate with them because they believe that you're going to be there in
57:52.713 --> 57:55.566
the future and they believe that line go up for your business.
57:56.079 --> 57:59.108
But in the beginning, you know, when there's no evidence of that,
57:59.669 --> 58:02.617
all they're going to do is protect their own interests, which again,
58:03.130 --> 58:07.569
can you blame them? No. Right. So it's
58:07.697 --> 58:11.608
so important to ask that question. So now as I sit here and
58:12.108 --> 58:14.236
I look at where we are and where we're going to go and our plans
58:14.268 --> 58:17.922
for the future and how we're going to expand, I feel much better about making
58:17.954 --> 58:21.496
those choices, even though obviously with, you know, 6-person company
58:21.640 --> 58:24.816
and multiple offices and millions
58:24.912 --> 58:28.091
plus dollars of stuff in the safe and all that. There's a lot there,
58:28.620 --> 58:32.312
but I feel more secure about it because you and I have built
58:32.812 --> 58:36.517
the systems and the infrastructure to anticipate the
58:36.710 --> 58:40.049
what happens if it all goes bad structure, which then
58:40.177 --> 58:44.029
once you've done that allows you to put that, the break
58:44.529 --> 58:47.850
glass in case of emergency thing into an intellectual safe and close
58:47.946 --> 58:50.739
the door and focus on the actual growth of your business,
58:51.236 --> 58:54.382
which is of course why we did this in the first place was that we,
58:54.702 --> 58:57.106
we have, we're passionate about this and we want to be the best at
it.
58:57.747 --> 59:01.321
So, you know, I try not to
59:01.353 --> 59:05.070
think too hard about how hard that was
59:05.570 --> 59:08.532
because I bet somebody listening to this is like, dude, only 2 years, you know,
59:08.564 --> 59:11.865
like it was that bad. The thing is, and this
59:12.365 --> 59:16.384
is another interesting reality about entrepreneurialism, is that time
59:16.640 --> 59:19.877
inside the vortex feels different than time outside
59:20.377 --> 59:23.835
the vortex. And that day-to-day when you're building
59:23.931 --> 59:27.473
it from nothing is interminable. But to
59:27.973 --> 59:31.431
the outside world, blink of an eye, blink of an eye. So I
59:31.543 --> 59:34.203
think about that a lot as well, especially when somebody talks to me about like,
59:34.219 --> 59:36.879
hey, I just started my business and like what it must feel like for them
59:37.792 --> 59:40.340
and what's involved in that, whatever industry it is.
59:40.933 --> 59:44.475
So, but mostly, and you know, I also
59:44.523 --> 59:48.453
realized that this might come across as like a little whatever, but I mean
59:48.953 --> 59:52.097
it. Literally every single person listening to this podcast right now,
59:52.723 --> 59:55.437
anyone who's ever bought so much as a t-shirt from us all the way up
59:55.937 --> 59:58.311
to, you know, multi-hundred thousand dollar watches,
59:58.905 --> 01:00:02.486
my gratitude to you is so extraordinary and extreme
01:00:03.481 --> 01:00:07.013
because this is— and I hate
01:00:07.513 --> 01:00:09.903
saying this, I feel like, I feel like it's so hackneyed, but God, I don't
01:00:10.403 --> 01:00:14.447
know a better way to say it. Like, It, there is nothing
01:00:15.282 --> 01:00:19.184
without you. Yeah, no, that, that's true. I remember the
01:00:19.216 --> 01:00:22.620
other, well, we can end on this bit of business advice because it's, it's good.
01:00:23.311 --> 01:00:26.699
I remember when we were starting to get into retail and recruiting brands, one of
01:00:27.199 --> 01:00:31.435
the, one retailer who's been nothing but good
01:00:31.500 --> 01:00:34.936
to us, good friend, given us plenty of advice, worked together
01:00:34.952 --> 01:00:37.521
on a number of projects with us is Pietro Tomahart.
01:00:38.483 --> 01:00:41.949
The guy who runs the limited edition. Good guy in the UK.
01:00:42.157 --> 01:00:45.831
Wonderful person and a champion of independent
01:00:46.168 --> 01:00:50.018
watchmaking. One of, one of the first and— yes, yeah,
01:00:50.098 --> 01:00:53.467
and a pioneer of different forms of retail too. Yeah, interesting human. There would really
01:00:53.967 --> 01:00:57.429
be no Collective without Pietro. I mean, he really blazed a
01:00:57.493 --> 01:01:01.327
lot of the tracks that we've, we followed. In any
01:01:01.827 --> 01:01:04.520
event, we were talking to him— I think you were talking to him about something
01:01:04.648 --> 01:01:07.215
about like, you know, I got to get these more, you know, brands into the
01:01:07.715 --> 01:01:11.598
stores and, you asking him some questions about some brands maybe
01:01:12.098 --> 01:01:14.826
he had that we were interested in, getting his advice on them and talking to
01:01:15.326 --> 01:01:18.263
him about, we were just trying to build up a roster of brands. And he
01:01:18.681 --> 01:01:21.957
said to you, and this is true, your biggest asset
01:01:22.118 --> 01:01:25.474
as a retailer and as a business is not the brands you carry,
01:01:26.454 --> 01:01:30.517
it's your clients, that they are the core of your
01:01:30.646 --> 01:01:33.938
business. And you only matter to a brand and
01:01:34.438 --> 01:01:37.517
you only have a business this if you have clients. And so he was
01:01:37.549 --> 01:01:41.319
right. The advice that you got on that rainy night
01:01:41.819 --> 01:01:45.266
in Geneva was correct, is it's the people who fundamentally
01:01:45.766 --> 01:01:49.598
support this business that make it work. So you heard us wax poetic for
01:01:49.902 --> 01:01:53.079
an hour on how we went through hell and back to
01:01:53.579 --> 01:01:57.523
make this thing work, but fundamentally it doesn't work without the people who listen
01:01:58.023 --> 01:02:01.501
to this podcast and support this business in ways,
01:02:01.838 --> 01:02:05.395
shapes, and forms. So thank you all. We truly
01:02:05.895 --> 01:02:08.713
mean it from the bottom of our heart because we have,
01:02:09.386 --> 01:02:14.290
we have tasted failure, and it's thanks to you that we're,
01:02:14.338 --> 01:02:17.319
that we're where we are now. So thank you. Right on.
01:02:17.800 --> 01:02:21.262
All right, I guess we leave it there, huh? Mm-hmm. We're not leaving it here.
01:02:21.326 --> 01:02:24.804
We got hundreds more episodes coming. All right, well, we leave it there
01:02:24.916 --> 01:02:28.971
for episode 101, or 1 plus 100.
01:02:29.019 --> 01:02:32.301
Eleventy-one. Eleventy-one. This, of course,
01:02:32.464 --> 01:02:35.884
is Open Work. It's a production of Collective Horology. You can
01:02:35.901 --> 01:02:39.743
find us online at collectivehorology.com. And seriously, keep sending
01:02:39.840 --> 01:02:43.079
those questions in because, you know, we love them, we do use
01:02:43.095 --> 01:02:46.869
them. Today is proof positive. And to do that, you can email podcast@collectivehorology.com.
01:03:07.082 --> 01:03:09.730
Some of the stuff that we would say was just absurd.