ကူးယူချက် 🔗
Transcript
00:00:11 Simon Gaisford
Welcome to Life Sciences at University College London, the podcast where we explore the science and the scientists working at University College London.
00:00:21 Simon Gaisford
With me today in the studio are three guests from the Medawar Laboratories, Professors Lorenzo Fabrizi, Sandrine Geranton and Stephanie Koch.
00:00:30 Simon Gaisford
Welcome to the studio.
00:00:32 Simon Gaisford
Very nice for you to come in.
00:00:34 Simon Gaisford
I'm going to go around in turn, just an easy starter for ten, which is just tell me a little bit about what you do.
00:00:40 Simon Gaisford
Lorenzo, I'll start with you.
00:00:41 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So I study brain development in preterm neonates mostly.
00:00:44 Lorenzo Fabrizi
In particular, I study the development of pain processing and somatosensation in this population in collaboration with the hospital and clinical colleagues.
00:00:53 Simon Gaisford
Very good, Sandrine.
00:00:54 Sandrine Geranton
So I see myself as a preclinical neuroscientist, which means I work with animal models.
00:00:59 Sandrine Geranton
And I'm really interested into the factors that could predict whether or not certain individuals, but modelled into animals, are actually more susceptible to developing chronic pain.
00:01:09 Simon Gaisford
Very good.
00:01:10 Simon Gaisford
Might come back to that in just a minute.
00:01:11 Simon Gaisford
And Stephanie?
00:01:12 Stephanie Koch
So I'm also preclinical in my research and I'm looking at how we are able to use our sensory environment to move and how those circuits are shaped with our early experience.
00:01:24 Simon Gaisford
Between the three of you, your research spans developmental neuroscience, pain and lifelong brain health.
00:01:29 Simon Gaisford
What first drew you to this field?
00:01:32 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I'd say there's a, it was a, do you say it in English?
00:01:36 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Like appetite comes while eating.
00:01:39 Lorenzo Fabrizi
We are saying that in Italian.
00:01:41 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So it was a bit of an accidental finding.
00:01:43 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So I was studying brain imaging in another kind of condition, epilepsy.
00:01:48 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And it was in my PhD.
00:01:49 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I got to know Maria Fitzgerald, who has been my mentor after that.
00:01:54 Lorenzo Fabrizi
and which was using brain imaging to understand the pain and preterm neonates.
00:01:59 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And that's how we started.
00:02:00 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And once you get into working into a field, you understand the importance of that field and what your contribution can be in order to improve understanding in a specific field.
00:02:09 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So I have to be honest, I say to all my students, I could have been studying anything in reality.
00:02:14 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It just happened to be the right person, the right time, in the right place.
00:02:18 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And then I ended up being working on this.
00:02:20 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And of course, now I cannot imagine myself working anything else but this.
00:02:24 Simon Gaisford
And that is the beauty of university, actually, isn't it?
00:02:26 Simon Gaisford
When a student is thinking, shall I go to university or not?
00:02:28 Simon Gaisford
Or what do I need to study?
00:02:30 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It doesn't really matter.
00:02:32 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Just do something.
00:02:32 Simon Gaisford
Just go to university and let the university happen to you, because something will happen.
00:02:36 Simon Gaisford
You'll find your own niche.
00:02:37 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, that's very good.
00:02:39 Simon Gaisford
Sandrine.
00:02:39 Sandrine Geranton
So I'm going to follow up by saying for me it was also by luck that I got to study what I'm doing now, because actually I'm an organic chemist by training.
00:02:46 Simon Gaisford
Good Lord.
00:02:47 Sandrine Geranton
So I really thought whether a good Lord or a bad good Lord.
00:02:52 Sandrine Geranton
So I felt like
00:02:53 Sandrine Geranton
In my life, I was going to be working with fixed things around me, like tables and walls.
00:02:57 Sandrine Geranton
And then I realized actually the science of the living things became a bit more interesting to me.
00:03:03 Sandrine Geranton
And then the more you think about, I hated biology actually when I was studying at school.
00:03:08 Sandrine Geranton
But understanding the flexibility, I think, in biology and in organisms led me to understand how much flexibility there was that I never saw in organic chemistry, in a brain or in a nervous system.
00:03:20 Sandrine Geranton
And that's how I think the interest for the pain field came from the fact that there's so much flexibility around the way one individual may or not develop chronic pain.
00:03:29 Sandrine Geranton
So understanding how we are all different in the way we experience chronic pain and how that comes from the plasticity that comes from a brain that at some point we may have thought that you know what's kind of fixed by the genes you may have been born with.
00:03:42 Sandrine Geranton
So understanding that flexibility like in this context was much more interesting.
00:03:46 Sandrine Geranton
I shouldn't say that out loud but that the organic chemistry like you know training I got and that's how like I fell by a chance in the field of pain research as well.
00:03:55 Sandrine Geranton
But there's so many components of it that I found exciting that you can put together that I stayed.
00:03:59 Sandrine Geranton
And again, I'd never imagine myself not working in that context.
00:04:03 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, that makes sense.
00:04:04 Simon Gaisford
I think what we won't do is we won't ask the Royal Society of Chemistry…
00:04:07 Sandrine Geranton
No.
00:04:10 Simon Gaisford
Stephanie, what made you get into this field?
00:04:12 Stephanie Koch
So similarly, I was a pharmacist in my previous life.
00:04:15 Simon Gaisford
Okay, very good.
00:04:17 Stephanie Koch
So I was working with patients in community
Load full transcript
pharmacy and seeing all these different patients
00:04:23 Stephanie Koch
with sort of lifelong chronic ailments really made me feel a little bit helpless, to be honest with you, in terms of the treatments that we can offer them now, especially with pain, but also depression and addiction.
00:04:37 Stephanie Koch
They're all just sort of band-aid treatments.
00:04:39 Stephanie Koch
And so that's when I decided to go back into academic research and preclinical to try to understand the underlying mechanisms to find real-life solutions.
00:04:50 Stephanie Koch
And through that, I became quite obsessed with plasticity, very similar to what both Sandrine and Lorenzo were talking about here.
00:04:57 Stephanie Koch
as a way of trying to look at prevention of these clinical ailments as opposed to a cure, which may never really come in a fundamental way.
00:05:06 Simon Gaisford
Sure.
00:05:07 Simon Gaisford
And just for listeners who don't understand the term, what do we mean by preclinical?
00:05:11 Stephanie Koch
Preclinical is essentially just anything that is not in humans and in the clinic that will be used by doctors and in hospitals, for example.
00:05:20 Stephanie Koch
So
00:05:21 Stephanie Koch
It can be with humans still at a very basic level, or it can be with animal models or cell lines or any of those sort of things.
00:05:30 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I consider myself pre-clinical, even though I work in humans, because we're not working towards a...
00:05:36 Lorenzo Fabrizi
a drug development or a kind of a randomized control trial for the efficacy of a drug.
00:05:40 Stephanie Koch
It's a basic science.
00:05:41 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It's basic science question, but it happens to be in humans.
00:05:44 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, and it should hopefully ultimately translate into humans in clinical trials.
00:05:48 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, not necessarily, not necessarily.
00:05:50 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I think it's a bit of a, it's a bit of a thing that we suffer people who work in human participant is a fact that there is the expectation that eventually there is going to be a clinical discovery event at the end of it, but it can also be just for us.
00:06:06 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Basic science understanding.
00:06:08 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Could translate into something or not.
00:06:10 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, for the MRC, I have to say yes, as good as it is.
00:06:15 Simon Gaisford
I often say to our students, actually, it's because the students have got this real focus on I want to cure people, especially as I'm in the School of Pharmacy.
00:06:22 Simon Gaisford
And so I always tell them about the laser.
00:06:23 Simon Gaisford
When the laser was first invented in the 1960s, I think, the authors couldn't get the paper published.
00:06:28 Simon Gaisford
They actually sent it off to a journal to get it published.
00:06:30 Simon Gaisford
And the editor said,
00:06:31 Simon Gaisford
This is too, it's interesting science, but I don't see an application, so they refused it.
00:06:36 Simon
Gaisford
And now the world runs on lasers.
00:06:38 Simon Gaisford
It's very important that we do stuff.
00:06:40 Simon Gaisford
We don't know where it's going.
00:06:43 Simon Gaisford
Okay, so let's think a little bit about babies then.
00:06:46 Simon Gaisford
So you're looking at how babies experience and feel pain.
00:06:49 Simon Gaisford
And obviously you can't ask a baby “how are you feeling”
00:06:55 Simon Gaisford
How do you do that?
00:06:56 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, so that's, it's an important thing to understand.
00:06:59 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So first of all, we will never be able to understand whether a neonate experience pain or not.
00:07:04 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's so we had to take it out of the, you know, off the table.
00:07:07 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's not going to happen.
00:07:08 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So everything we base our judgment on is all on proxies or whatever may be related to pain or may not be related to pain.
00:07:15 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So in terms of what we know from, in terms of hard evidence, what we know is that neonates do mount a response to a stimulus that could be perceived as painful in an adult.
00:07:29 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So they mount a physiological response, they mount a behavioural response, and they also mount this kind of cortical activity, which I'm very much interested in.
00:07:38 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So that's, we know.
00:07:38 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So that means that information does reach the brain.
00:07:42 Lorenzo Fabrizi
which is a condition necessary, however, not sufficient for the experience of pain.
00:07:47 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Now the other thing we know, we know that activity changes quite dramatically over the last semester of gestation or in the premature period.
00:07:54 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And even at term age, it's very different from the activity you may get in an adult.
00:07:59 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So the suggestion then being that the way the brain of a neonate processes the same information that comes from a periphery as one gets into an adult is entirely different.
00:08:11 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Another thing we know that we found recently is that the infrastructure that is necessary, that we know is necessary for processing pain in an adult is not, is very weak in preterm neonates.
00:08:23 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It develops over the equivalent of the last semester of gestation.
00:08:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It doesn't develop linearly, it develops at different time, different bits of it, develops at different time, which also means that whatever is needed for us as adults to process
00:08:40 Lorenzo Fabrizi
noxious information coming from the body and perceived as painful is not there just yet.
00:08:49 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So the implication being that the information does reach the brain, however, very likely the experience that arise from it is entirely different from what we understand as pain.
00:09:01 Lorenzo Fabrizi
What we conceive as pain is probably very different for a neonate.
00:09:06 Lorenzo Fabrizi
However, we'll never be able to
00:09:08 Lorenzo Fabrizi
to close the circle because.
00:09:11 Simon Gaisford
No.
00:09:12 Lorenzo Fabrizi
You don't remember what you’re experiencing
00:09:16 Lorenzo Fabrizi
If I ask her, how was?
00:09:19 Simon Gaisford
That birth you went through?
00:09:20 Simon Gaisford
You know what?
00:09:21 Simon Gaisford
I don't remember.
00:09:22 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So, yes, in terms of what science tells us is that the activity is there, however, it's very much different from what we have in adults, and therefore very likely the experience itself is different.
00:09:34 Simon Gaisford
That raises a number of questions, doesn't it?
00:09:38 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Philisophical questions, political questions.
00:09:44 Simon Gaisford
Maybe if we've got 5 minutes left at the end.
00:09:46 Simon Gaisford
I was thinking, does that mean that a neonate can't feel pain?
00:09:51 Lorenzo Fabrizi
No, yeah, we'll never be able to say that.
00:09:54 Lorenzo Fabrizi
The experience is there.
00:09:56 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So let's say that very likely it can't feel pain as you think of it.
00:10:01 Lorenzo Fabrizi
As a definition of pain is not going to experience, very likely is not going to experience as you experience it.
00:10:10 Lorenzo Fabrizi
The thing we know though that, and think that Sandrine and Stephanie can then back it up with basic science evidence, that whatever is happening during a critical period of development will shape how the brain or the nervous system in general develops, and it's going to have long-term consequences.
00:10:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So, if you think about it, a preterm neonate comes out of the womb too early for when it's meant to come out, and then it’s exposed to tissue damaging procedure which are not meant to occur.
00:10:38 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So, whatever that activity is on the developing nervous system is not meant, it was not meant to be there, it should not be there.
00:10:47 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So, even though they're not experiencing pain as we understand it, however, that
00:10:52 Lorenzo Fabrizi
kind of that kind of input should not have been occurring.
00:10:56 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And then we indeed we know that early clinical procedures in preterm neonates do have long-term consequences on cortical development later on in life.
00:11:05 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So I want to make that clear, the importance of understanding how the brain handles spinal cord as well, handles this kind of information is not important only for whether they experience pain or not.
00:11:17 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It's because it's going to have an impact no matter what, no matter whether it's pain or not.
00:11:22 Simon Gaisford
Is there any way of quantifying that?
00:11:24 Simon Gaisford
So, it's studies where on.
00:11:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Animal models, we can do that.
00:11:28 Simon Gaisford
Well, okay.
00:11:29 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:11:30 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I guess.
00:11:30 Simon Gaisford
No, before we look at the animal models, are there any studies where, say, in adults,
people have done studies where they've looked to see whether an adult who was born prematurely experiences pain differently from...
00:11:43 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, There's a lot of, actually a colleague of ours works a lot, even in childhood, the
00:11:51 Lorenzo Fabrizi
pain thresholds of a child that was born preterm are very much different from the one that went through normal normal gestation.
00:11:59 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And even more so if they had a surgery.
00:12:01 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So even around the area where the surgery occurred, there is like hypersensitive.
00:12:06 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It's actually very funny the way the pain changes.
00:12:09 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It depends on the modality.
00:12:11 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So if it's mechanical stimulation, I think, I don't remember, I never remember which way around it is.
00:12:16 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I think it's mechanical, they are hypersensitive mechanical stimulation, they are hypersensitive to thermal stimulation.
00:12:22 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It's also sex dependent.
00:12:25 Sandrine Geranton
There's also, I think, a difference between the differences in their threshold, so what they would consider as pain when they, grown into like younger children or adults, and the way they respond to a pain insult, if you want, after.
00:12:38 Sandrine Geranton
And sometimes you may see them, I think they're actually hyposensitive at baseline, but maybe less responsive to an injury.
00:12:44 Sandrine Geranton
So
00:12:44 Sandrine Geranton
These differences between the development of a resilient phenotype with a susceptible phenotype is very difficult to pinpoint, right?
00:12:52 Sandrine Geranton
The mechanism, we're still looking for these, and it also depends greatly on the individual themselves.
00:12:58 Sandrine Geranton
We also don't really understand, if I may say so, I work mainly with mice, but very often I understand a little bit what happens with children.
00:13:04 Sandrine Geranton
we still don't understand what the trauma was in itself.
00:13:08 Sandrine Geranton
Is it being separated from their parents when they're in the incubator when they're born, or is it the surgery they would have undergone, right?
00:13:14 Sandrine Geranton
So whether it's a physical impact that's led to these differences in the way they respond to pain later on, or it was more like what we call a stressful response from being away from your parents, we can't really dissect out all of this, but that's true that it leads to differences in your normal, what we call a pain threshold, or what you say you're sensitive to or not, but the way you also respond to an injury after.
00:13:36 Sandrine Geranton
So the image is very complex because you could be more resilient to one than you are to the other.
00:13:41 Sandrine Geranton
But all we know, I think for sure, we would agree that they won't respond to this thing, to the stimuli in the same way than if nothing happened to them in, you know, in infancy, I would say.
00:13:51 Simon Gaisford
That is an incredibly complicated picture to try and dissect as well, isn't it?
00:13:55 Simon Gaisford
I can see that, yeah.
00:13:57 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And brain is different as well.
00:13:58 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So the brain imaging studies have shown that
00:14:01 Lorenzo Fabrizi
preterm born neonates have different myelination pattern than term-born neonates, which are likely to impact their behaviour response to.
00:14:11 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And then we know that they also have like wider implications.
00:14:14 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So if you're born pre-term, you're more likely to have all sorts of.
00:14:18 Lorenzo Fabrizi
neurodevelopmental conditions or diagnoses later on in life.
00:14:21 Simon Gaisford
Okay.
00:14:21 Sandrine Geranton
And any chronic diseases as well.
00:14:24 Sandrine Geranton
So then you can package it all up and the increased likelihood of developing anything you can claim.
00:14:28 Simon Gaisford
I know.
00:14:33 Sandrine Geranton
But that's when Stephanie’s work comes into play looking at reversibility.
00:14:36 Sandrine Geranton
So that's another question you could all ask.
00:14:38 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, reversibility and plasticity.
00:14:40 Sandrine Geranton
Yeah, we all work on plasticity and some of us sometimes are a bit like, you know, I've been focused on increased susceptibility to condition for a long time.
00:14:48 Sandrine Geranton
I think Stephanie believes more in the potential for reversibility because early life plasticity may mean that you have better chances for reversibility.
00:14:57 Sandrine Geranton
And I wonder, I mean, I still haven't found the solution and I don't know if a trauma occurring in early life or in adulthood lends itself better for reversibility because all these windows of developmental
00:15:09 Sandrine Geranton
development, I was going to say, not very clear.
00:15:12 Sandrine Geranton
It's quite complicated as well, but I know you believe greatly in reversibility potential, right?
00:15:17 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:15:17 Simon Gaisford
Tell us about that.
00:15:18 Simon Gaisford
And also, this is the second time you did define something for the listeners, plasticity.
00:15:22 Stephanie Koch
So plasticity is actually a really interesting concept in that it's just the possibility of change.
00:15:32 Stephanie Koch
So
00:15:33 Stephanie Koch
People think of our nervous system as something that's really fixed and that once it is like that, people often, I did when I first got into neuroscience, think of you're born with the ability to move, to feel, to sense, and that never changes over time.
00:15:52 Stephanie Koch
But this concept of plasticity means that essentially we're learning all the time.
00:15:57 Stephanie Koch
So we talk about these critical windows, which is times in development, windows of time in development, over which the ability to learn, our nervous system's ability to learn, is greatly enhanced.
00:16:09 Stephanie Koch
And you can see that in a child, right?
00:16:11
Stephanie Koch
They crawl, they start to walk,
00:16:16 Stephanie Koch
They grasp, they can catch things, they talk.
00:16:18 Stephanie Koch
And those moments of heightened plasticity are somewhat fixed genetically, I would say, when that happens.
00:16:25 Stephanie Koch
But what happens between that, between those windows, is really amazing because it's essentially a time in which the baby or the child is learning what the world is, which means we are little unique packages
00:16:42 Stephanie Koch
that are born to purely interact with whatever environment you're born into.
00:16:47 Stephanie Koch
It's actually incredibly beautiful.
00:16:49 Stephanie Koch
But the fact is the plasticity, A, continues to a certain degree throughout our whole lives, which is why we can learn new skills.
00:16:56 Stephanie Koch
And B, can fall back into more of a pathological or sort of negative framework in the case of injury.
00:17:04 Stephanie Koch
So chronic pain states, for example, you go back into this plastic state.
00:17:08 Stephanie Koch
So here we come into theory.
00:17:10 Stephanie Koch
My theory is..
00:17:17 Stephanie Koch
It's more like a different lens because science essentially is like you're brought up in a way of seeing and it shapes how you see the world later on in a very romantic sense, I guess.
00:17:28 Stephanie Koch
But my way of seeing is that the plasticity or the openness to learning that you have when you're a child is the same as if you go into a chronic pain state later on.
00:17:39 Stephanie Koch
It's the same thing, which means you can reteach it how to interact with the world.
00:17:45 Stephanie Koch
That is my, yeah, what are they gonna say, like rose-tinted glasses.
00:17:51 Stephanie Koch
My rose-tinted glasses is that if we learned correctly the first time, then we can relearn correctly the second time.
00:17:59 Stephanie Koch
That's how I see it.
00:18:00 Simon Gaisford
Okay, let's drill down into that slightly then.
00:18:02 Simon Gaisford
So someone chronic long-term pain, I mean, that could come from a number of different sources.
00:18:06 Stephanie Koch
Correct.
00:18:08 Simon Gaisford
So what are we saying here?
00:18:09 Simon Gaisford
Is that something that the brain becomes tolerant of?
00:18:13 Simon Gaisford
So you've got something that's constantly causing pain, but you in some way manage to dampen that down?
00:18:20 Simon Gaisford
Or is it something that maybe you become more sensitive to it?
00:18:23 Simon Gaisford
So it's the same level of pain, but you're becoming more and more sensitive
00:18:27 Simon Gaisford
So it feels like it's worse and worse.
00:18:29 Stephanie Koch
So I'm going to go into more granularity in asking what pain is in the first place.
00:18:34 Stephanie Koch
And I think there are endless different forms of pain.
00:18:38 Stephanie Koch
And the more we delve into it, the more different subsets of pain there are.
00:18:43 Stephanie Koch
We start off with joint pain, right?
00:18:46 Stephanie
Koch
Umbrella.
00:18:47 Stephanie Koch
And then you go into osteoarthritis or juvenile idiopathic arthritis and so on and so forth.
00:18:53 Stephanie Koch
So
00:18:54 Stephanie Koch
For me, the way that I think about it is what aspect of the pain is affecting the patient the most?
00:19:00 Stephanie Koch
Is it their movement?
00:19:01 Stephanie Koch
Is it their anxiety, like Lorenzo was saying?
00:19:06 Stephanie Koch
Is it the sociability, which is something that Sandrine looks into too, and the sort of more affective parts?
00:19:11 Stephanie Koch
Or is it just the fact that they have the spontaneous pain?
00:19:14 Stephanie Koch
And then you can go into what aspects of the circuit of your brain, of your spinal cord, of your periphery
00:19:22 Stephanie Koch
could be responsible for that type of symptom and can we reteach that?
00:19:26 Stephanie Koch
I wouldn't say it's like, I don't know, wave music over someone in chronic pain will suddenly cure everything that they have.
00:19:35 Stephanie Koch
You have to be very targeted in my mind.
00:19:38 Simon Gaisford
But not necessarily medicate our way out of it, you think?
00:19:41 Stephanie Koch
So at the moment,
00:19:43 Stephanie Koch
I don't think we are there in terms of medication.
00:19:46 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:19:47 Sandrine Geranton
And I think, I mean, I would want to say actually the more we talk with patients that we try to do a lot in our work, especially Stephanie and I, because working with animal models more than with patient, we need to really understand what we're dealing with.
00:19:58 Sandrine Geranton
So not creating questions that actually the patients don't have, you know, they might want us to deal with something and like, no, we want to help you get better from that point of view.
00:20:07 Sandrine Geranton
But they're like, no, we actually don't really care.
00:20:09 Sandrine Geranton
But basically the more we talk with patients, the more we realize that actually
00:20:13 Sandrine Geranton
Some of them, obviously I can't say that I've talked with all the patients in the world, but there's some of them that are not looking for novel like pharmacological treatment.
00:20:20 Sandrine Geranton
And actually pain is one of these conditions that a lot of people want to be treated by more like holistic approaches.
00:20:27 Sandrine Geranton
And like, so you know, like the first line of therapy now for joint pain is exercise.
00:20:31 Sandrine Geranton
So, and patients, it's very hard because it actually hurts more when you start doing exercise.
00:20:36 Sandrine Geranton
So trying to understand why is this working.
00:20:38 Sandrine Geranton
But I think patient, that's what they want to hear.
00:20:40 Sandrine Geranton
So I was talking with some patient groups with arthritis
00:20:43 Sandrine Geranton
And they were like, we actually don't want to take any more tablets.
00:20:45 Sandrine Geranton
They actually no longer want their tablets to treat their condition, but they don't want the tablets for pain.
00:20:50 Sandrine Geranton
So we already, we also, sorry, we need to think about like these two aspects in this work because we work for trying to understand the pain phenotype.
00:20:58 Sandrine Geranton
So the pain aspect, if you want of a condition.
00:21:01 Sandrine Geranton
And then we have what we would call our clinician colleagues that try to cure a disease that actually is at the source of the pain.
00:21:08 Sandrine Geranton
But on our side here, we are actually trying to understand the pain in itself.
00:21:12 Sandrine Geranton
So it was a bit funny because at the beginning in our field, we were all thinking that we were comparing all different type of pain and thinking we're going to try find that magic bullet to cure all of this pain because we all assume that the CNS, the central nervous system or your brain would have changed in the same way if you'd been in chronic pain for a long time.
00:21:30 Sandrine Geranton
And the more we understand the individual characteristic of all these different pain states, even for the same disease, we could be two persons with the same joint pain.
00:21:39 Sandrine Geranton
And I could be in excruciating pain and Stephanie feel nothing, whereas my joint could be not damaged whatsoever.
00:21:44 Sandrine Geranton
And Stephanie's joint could be, you know, completely destroyed.
00:21:48 Sandrine Geranton
But the fact that Opus or characteristic or personal characteristics and previous history is contributing immensely to this pain state, there's no way we're going to true, you know, we're going to find, sorry, this match.
00:22:03 Sandrine Geranton
So, basically, I don't think we're anywhere near finding a new pain medication.
00:22:07 Sandrine Geranton
I shouldn't say that out loud.
00:22:09 Sandrine Geranton
But on top of it, I do think we, a lot of the patients wouldn't want an oval pharmacological treatment anyway.
00:22:16 Sandrine Geranton
Obviously, I am not talking about patients who are in so much pain that their life is being, completely, changed and can't live a normal life.
00:22:24 Sandrine Geranton
So please, like if anyone is listening to that, I'm just talking to talking about like the standard population that we could be talking about.
00:22:31 Sandrine Geranton
But yeah, I don't think pharmacology is what people want right now.
00:22:35 Sandrine Geranton
So we have to find other ways.
00:22:38 Simon Gaisford
See, what you've said has raised so many questions and I have to remember to ask them all and not forget to ask.
00:22:43 Simon Gaisford
I'm going to start with this one, which is I'm a scientist because when I was a kid I used to watch science programmes on TV, in particular Horizon, which is a fantastic BBC series.
00:22:53 Simon Gaisford
And there was one episode there, I'm looking at you Stephanie because this question is going your way, where someone had lost a limb, a hand in a car accident, but they
00:23:03 Simon Gaisford
obviously the
last moment of that car accident was their limb being deformed, which was horrendously painful before it was amputated.
00:23:09 Simon Gaisford
And so they were having phantom pain as it were, that they could still feel that limb, they could feel the pain and it felt as though the limb was completely twisted, even though it wasn't there.
00:23:18 Simon Gaisford
And I can still remember watching the episode where the cure, he said, was to put a mirror in front of that person so they could actually physically see
00:23:29 Simon Gaisford
what was the reflection of their remaining hand and they uncurled it and almost instantly the pain went away.
00:23:35 Simon Gaisford
Right now where does that where does that sort of...
00:23:39 Simon Gaisford
What it says to me, and that was an unscripted question, so fair point.
00:23:44 Simon Gaisford
What it says to me is that, you know, there's a memory there in the brain of that pain response, which is so great.
00:23:50 Simon Gaisford
It's overridden the fact that limb's not there.
00:23:53 Stephanie Koch
I think that's a really good point.
00:23:54 Stephanie Koch
And I also would go...
00:23:56 Stephanie Koch
to say that for me it also tells you how important movement is to how we perceive the world.
00:24:03 Stephanie Koch
That sensation comes very rarely without movement.
00:24:07 Stephanie Koch
So there is a lot of literature on phantom limb pain.
00:24:13 Stephanie Koch
A lot of it seems to be driven by the periphery, actually.
00:24:17 Stephanie Koch
But the thought is there are plastic changes that occur, for sure.
00:24:23 Stephanie Koch
Is there reorganization?
00:24:24 Stephanie Koch
Probably not, in terms of how our body is coded in the brain.
00:24:28 Stephanie Koch
But there is this plasticity becomes wired in such a way that the body no longer understands itself.
00:24:37 Stephanie Koch
It is an un-match between the brain's perception of what you should be and what you are.
00:24:43 Stephanie Koch
But the fact that you, this mirror, I don't know how widely effective it is.
00:24:51 Stephanie Koch
But this mirror therapy does work in some patients, I think blows my mind and is reassuring because I have a career for a long time.
00:25:02 Simon Gaisford
I probably watched hundreds of episodes of Horizons as a child and I can only remember a handful and that is one because it was because it is such a mind-blowing demonstration.
00:25:12 Simon Gaisford
In that instance, it's tricking your brain
00:25:18 Simon Gaisford
Because what that says to me at least is the visual imagery of being able to straighten that limb that's no longer there was so powerful.
00:25:26 Simon Gaisford
It's then overridden the phantom pain that was coming from the accident.
00:25:31 Stephanie Koch
I think there's a part of this also about prediction.
00:25:33 Stephanie Koch
Your brain is always trying to guess what is happening to you at all times.
00:25:39 Stephanie Koch
And if there's a mismatch, it kind of
00:25:43 Stephanie Koch
Scientifically freaks out.
00:25:45 Stephanie Koch
It's just there's something there's an error signal that comes through, and I think a lot of that is exactly what you're talking about.
00:25:50 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, like seasickness.
00:25:51 Simon Gaisford
It's the same as mixed signals.
00:25:53 Stephanie Koch
Yeah, exactly.
00:25:54 Simon Gaisford
Okay, and this might be a social media question, but I'm going to ask anyway.
00:26:00 Simon Gaisford
My wife asserts that women have a much higher pain threshold than men.
00:26:05 Simon Gaisford
Views on this?
00:26:06 Sandrine Geranton
I would say, have they given birth or not?
00:26:10 Sandrine Geranton
I do think, okay, so officially your pain threshold is established throughout your life.
00:26:16 Sandrine Geranton
It changes with your past experiences.
00:26:19 Sandrine Geranton
So, I don't think there's any data.
00:26:21 Sandrine Geranton
There is some genetics data on differences in pain threshold according to genes you're expressing.
00:26:26 Sandrine Geranton
So men and women have different pain threshold.
00:26:30 Sandrine Geranton
I don't think we have a higher pain threshold actually.
00:26:32 Stephanie Koch
So what I read is it depends on the type of pain.
00:26:36 Stephanie Koch
So a delta pinprick pain.
00:26:38 Stephanie Koch
So if you have like a very sharp pain that's short lasting, then men have higher thresholds than women.
00:26:44 Stephanie Koch
But this deep ongoing what we call C fiber pain, which is like the burning, endless
00:26:49 Stephanie Koch
inescapable pain, women have higher thresholds because of the fact that we're sort of primed, supposed to have to give birth.
00:26:56 Sandrine Geranton
And I think we need to think of the difference, I'm sorry, about like pain threshold and tolerance.
00:27:00 Sandrine Geranton
And very often we mix the two together.
00:27:03 Sandrine Geranton
So I do think that women have a higher tolerance.
00:27:05 Sandrine Geranton
It's painful, but we're going to put up with it.
00:27:08 Sandrine Geranton
But it could have been more painful before that it was for men.
00:27:11 Sandrine Geranton
So you could find it painful very quickly, but you might be ready to like
00:27:15 Sandrine Geranton
You put up with it for a very long time.
00:27:17 Sandrine Geranton
So tolerance is a very different characteristic, right?
00:27:22 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yes, cultural differences, depending on the country you're asking whether it's going to be different.
00:27:28 Stephanie Koch
Red hair, right?
00:27:29 Sandrine Geranton
So red hair, definitely.
00:27:31 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's genetic.
00:27:31 Sandrine Geranton
That's genetic.
00:27:32 Lorenzo Fabrizi
You always bring that as an example.
00:27:33 Sandrine Geranton
As an example, higher pain threshold, definitely.
00:27:36 Simon Gaisford
Oh, is that right?
00:27:36 Sandrine Geranton
Yeah.
00:27:37 Simon Gaisford
My dad's got red hair, so...
00:27:39 Simon Gaisford
I shall have this
conversation with him.
00:27:40 Sandrine Geranton
Do you have the gene?
00:27:42 Sandrine Geranton
Exactly.
00:27:42 Sandrine Geranton
Maybe he passed it over to you.
00:27:43 Sandrine Geranton
Not the hair colour one, the one relevant to there.
00:27:46 Sandrine Geranton
But there's always these fun studies when they do these pain tolerance tests when they would have students from universities with or without the girlfriend in the room and the tolerance.
00:27:57 Sandrine Geranton
They ask them with or without partner.
00:27:59 Sandrine Geranton
And then you can see how you can really dissect out the tolerance versus the pain threshold.
00:28:04 Sandrine Geranton
Because ultimately, you know, for me, when I think when I teach the student and say,
00:28:09 Sandrine Geranton
Your threshold depends on a receptor you have expressed in your fibers that open at a certain time, a certain heat exposure, for example.
00:28:18 Sandrine Geranton
And we have very little variations in those genes that carry these receptors that are going to respond to a stimulus.
00:28:24 Sandrine Geranton
So officially, our thresholds are more or less the same.
00:28:26 Sandrine Geranton
But what's really different between individual is the tolerance, not the threshold.
00:28:30 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, it's interesting.
00:28:31 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So in neonates, the way the brain responds between male and female to the same exact same stimulus is different.
00:28:39 Lorenzo Fabrizi
There's a lot of people believe that kind of difference comes with puberty.
00:28:43 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So that's the main difference with male and female that whatever you're thinking about comes at puberty.
00:28:49 Lorenzo Fabrizi
But in neonates, there's already a difference between male and female.
00:28:53 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Well, female have like a more widespread response.
00:28:56 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Males much more localized.
00:28:58 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Of course, again, we don't know whether that means more or less pain.
00:29:01 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Let's not ask that.
00:29:03 Lorenzo Fabrizi
But we know that the brain processes it differently.
00:29:07 Lorenzo Fabrizi
From very early on.
00:29:09 Simon Gaisford
So a friend of mine at UCL, Anna David, you know Anna David?
00:29:12 Simon Gaisford
Institute for Women's Health.
00:29:15 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:29:16 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Davis.
00:29:17 Lorenzo Fabrizi
No, Anna Davis.
00:29:19 Simon Gaisford
No, Anna David.
00:29:19 Lorenzo Fabrizi
OK, sorry.
00:29:20 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah.
00:29:20 Stephanie Koch
He's a friend.
00:29:22 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, I was right.
00:29:23 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I don't know if it’s the same person.
00:29:25 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, no, there may be multiple.
00:29:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, exactly.
00:29:28 Simon Gaisford
So, Anna, we did a leadership programme many, many years ago, it’s how I know her.
00:29:32 Simon Gaisford
And she was late one day for one of the sessions and she said, I'm terribly sorry I'm late, but we had an emergency in the hospital.
00:29:39 Simon Gaisford
I've been operating on a preterm baby in the womb.
00:29:43 Simon Gaisford
Oh my goodness, that's amazing, isn't it?
00:29:46 Simon Gaisford
So what would happen there?
00:29:49 Simon Gaisford
If there was a need for surgery on a preterm baby, would that baby be anaesthetised?
00:29:54 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah.
00:29:55 Simon Gaisford
So we wouldn't at that point take a risk of saying, well, we're pretty sure they can't feel anything.
00:29:59 Lorenzo Fabrizi
No, that's a completely, we went completely the other way from the 80s.
00:30:05 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Years ago, they would have just got muscle relaxant and paralyzing agents in order to get the surgery going without movement.
00:30:12 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, there's been that change.
00:30:14 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So overall, we're having a very much conservative approach today.
00:30:18 Lorenzo Fabrizi
However, the point is that the two things kind of, we have to be careful because by having a conservative approach, you may manage the
00:30:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
the situation as it occurs, we don't know the long-term consequence of exposure to morphine, for example.
00:30:33 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So we don't know what that actually, so there's no evidence on which we can base the right amount of morphine that a baby can be exposed to.
00:30:42 Lorenzo Fabrizi
But yeah, the pain has to be managed at the time.
00:30:49 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So we are having this conservative approach to it.
00:30:52 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Apart to the research we are doing in order to understand those kind of use of analgesic and an anaesthetic better in order to see whether we can modulate their use.
00:31:03 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:31:03 Simon Gaisford
Wow.
00:31:04 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, I know.
00:31:05 Lorenzo Fabrizi
it's crazy.
00:31:06 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I mean, yeah, so exposure to morphine, it may have an impact on the development of the thalamus, for example.
00:31:12 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:31:13 Simon Gaisford
What happens?
00:31:14 Simon Gaisford
I'm going.
00:31:15 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, because we don't know.
00:31:16 Lorenzo Fabrizi
We don't know how much you have to give.
00:31:18 Lorenzo Fabrizi
There is no way.
00:31:19 Simon Gaisford
I'm going I'm going way off topic here now, but what happens if
00:31:24 Simon Gaisford
If a mother is addicted to, say, morphine and become, it's during pregnancy, is there any evidence that a child will...
00:31:33 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, you have to wean it off on a child.
00:31:36 Simon Gaisford
And would you think there'd be a long-term consequence for how that child develops and feels pain?
00:31:41 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I have no idea about this.
00:31:43 Stephanie Koch
I actually, when I was a pharmacist, I saw those children.
00:31:47 Stephanie Koch
They're often in the neonatal ICU intensive care unit because they're born so small.
00:31:53 Stephanie Koch
And then they are in, they're just screaming.
00:31:58 Stephanie Koch
They're just in a huge
amount of stress.
00:32:00 Simon Gaisford
Oh, because they're in withdrawal.
00:32:03 Stephanie Koch
And the idea behind it is also you're activating everything in your nervous system.
00:32:09 Stephanie Koch
So our sort of natural way of stopping pain in the body is an endorphin, right?
00:32:16 Stephanie Koch
So it is, it acts on the same receptors and suddenly you've removed that.
00:32:19 Stephanie Koch
So the idea is that maybe the infant is feeling too much physically.
00:32:24 Stephanie Koch
But those children, those infants go on to be much more likely to become drug addicts themselves, suffer from chronic pain, suffer from anxiety, everything under the sun.
00:32:36 Stephanie Koch
They never fully recover.
00:32:37 Simon Gaisford
No.
00:32:38 Simon Gaisford
Wow.
00:32:40 Stephanie Koch
Yeah, it's a sad story.
00:32:42 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, that's a sad story.
00:32:43 Simon Gaisford
Absolutely.
00:32:43 Simon Gaisford
Sandrine, you said something earlier I was going to come back to as well, which is about the separation of a child from the mother when born pre-term.
00:32:53 Simon Gaisford
So I was just going to delve a little bit more into what we meant by separation there.
00:32:57 Simon Gaisford
Do we mean by biochemical separation?
00:32:59 Simon Gaisford
I mean, so no placenta and and whatever nutrients coming from the mother.
00:33:04 Simon Gaisford
Do we mean emotional separation?
00:33:06 Sandrine Geranton
Yeah, so I can tell you a little bit about what I know from the preclinical models and then Lorenzo can tell you about the work he's doing in terms of, so it is proven that the proximity of the child and the mother at birth is very important.
00:33:18 Sandrine Geranton
So that's why Lorenzo and his team has worked a lot on that.
00:33:21 Sandrine Geranton
So what I was thinking is for me, so even when a child is born and is being like early and put in an incubator, not being like in direct contact with the mother.
00:33:29 Sandrine Geranton
plays a massive role.
00:33:30 Sandrine Geranton
And then even in early life, which is something I thought a lot when I was dropping my children at nursery, being dropped at nursery for a few hours a day when they're six months old is also a mother bond separation.
00:33:41 Sandrine Geranton
And then indeed we can study that in animal models because we can separate the pups from the mothers from a few hours a day.
00:33:47 Sandrine Geranton
And just doing that, so in my lab we looked at it from the point of view of epigenetic changes, so you know changes which are not linked to gene mutation but to the way your chromatin, exactly, your genes are going to be expressed
00:33:59 Sandrine Geranton
And so a lot of work has been done in this model.
00:34:02 Sandrine Geranton
We know this has a huge impact on the way these, so animals may experience, for example, inflammation later on in life or the way they will, exactly.
00:34:10 Sandrine Geranton
So similarly to like maybe having been injured in
early life, having been separated from their mother for a few hours a day for just a few days, would lead to them responding completely differently to an inflammatory response, which tends to last much longer, which we would call kind of a model of persistent pain.
00:34:28 Sandrine Geranton
So we can exacerbate, if you want, the duration of a pain state purely from having separated pups from the mother in early life.
00:34:36 Sandrine Geranton
And we've linked this through a change in epigenetics, so in their epigenome, in stress-related genes, but in the central nervous system.
00:34:44 Sandrine Geranton
So that's quite interesting to see that you can modulate the way you respond to an inflammation that you could perceive as something being highly peripheral, but only by having affected, if you want, your central nervous system through epigenetic changes on the stress axis.
00:34:59 Sandrine Geranton
So, every time you drop your children at nursery you think twice, because you wonder which of these genes you modulated.
00:35:06 Sandrine Geranton
But, so then Lorenzo's put actually looked into this in real people in the hospital, right?
00:35:12 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So, one of the main things that is called the non-pharmacological intervention to managing pain in the neonatal unit, which is called skin to skin, where basically whatever the baby has to undergo, like a clinical procedure is put on the mother’s chest, on skin to skin without clothing and there's a specific set of recommendation or that can be done with a specific angle in which the mother has to be reclined in order to kind of maximize the contact and epidemiologically has been demonstrated that more the babies have been in skin to skin with
00:35:48 Lorenzo Fabrizi
with the mother.
00:35:49 Lorenzo Fabrizi
We don't know much about the father, weirdly enough, but the more the baby's been skinned to skin with the mother, the better their outcome and their prognosis is.
00:35:57 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So all the things I was telling you about the preterm birth is associated with neurodevelopmental difficulties.
00:36:02 Lorenzo Fabrizi
All those things are kind of risk of that is reduced if they spend.
00:36:07 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And what we've shown ourselves is that when if the baby is getting a
00:36:12 Lorenzo Fabrizi
a heel prick to test their blood while in skin to skin with their mother, their cortical response is actually dampened.
00:36:19 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So remember I was telling you about the fact that we don't really know whether it's pain or not.
00:36:22 Lorenzo Fabrizi
The important thing is that the brain does not receive too much of that input because it's not meant to be there.
00:36:28 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So the fact that brain response is dampened in skin to skin is a good indication that somehow we are reducing, potentially we are reducing the impact
00:36:37 Lorenzo Fabrizi
of that experience.
00:36:39 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And behaviourally, you can see, behaviourally is also very obvious.
00:36:42 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Babies are doing, receiving a heel prick in skin to skin, they have not such a kind of strong behavioural response as if they are in the cot.
00:36:52 Simon Gaisford
You can say no to this question, but I mean, when a baby is first born, it cannot recognise its own mother, presumably, because it would never have seen her before.
00:37:00 Simon Gaisford
So do we know what the mechanism is by which a child
00:37:04 Simon Gaisford
Skin to skin's contact is it simply the feeling of another human?
00:37:09 Lorenzo Fabrizi
We don't know.
00:37:10 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Could it be anything?
00:37:10 Lorenzo Fabrizi
We're actually trying to break it down.
00:37:12 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It's quite funny you're asking that.
00:37:13 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Is it the odor?
00:37:15 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Is it the temperature?
00:37:16 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Is it the heartbeat?
00:37:18 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So we are actually trying to look at the heartbeat at the moment, whether the heartbeat of the mother is synchronised with the heartbeat of the baby while in skin to skin and whether
00:37:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Because basically what you can check is whether if the mother is anxious during the painful procedure, the heartbeat goes up.
00:37:33 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Does the baby heartbeat goes up together?
00:37:35 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And then the baby gets stressed.
00:37:37 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So it's better if he's not in skin to skin.
00:37:40 Lorenzo Fabrizi
If the mother is stressed.
00:37:42 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So we are looking at that basically.
00:37:43 Lorenzo Fabrizi
What is the level of synchrony between the maternal heartbeat and the beat of the baby?
00:37:50 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And if the maternal heartbeat is not calm is not kind of is not controlled does that negatively impact the baby, and then that would be very helpful to know, because then, in order quite funnily, in order to manage the experience of the baby, what you do, you intervene on the parent.
00:38:08 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, exactly.
00:38:08 Lorenzo Fabrizi
You actually have cognitive behavioural therapy with the parent to try to tell them, yeah, this is not nothing too bad, you know, it's going to be okay, so the parent can calm down, and that can be translated to the baby.
00:38:20 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Because you cannot do CBT with the baby.
00:38:22 Simon Gaisford
No, absolutely.
00:38:23 Simon Gaisford
I imagine that would be quite difficult because.
00:38:25 Simon Gaisford
And a lot of people I know, just seeing someone in a white coat raises them.
00:38:30 Simon Gaisford
And then if you're in a situation where your child born preterm, say, is about to have some sort of surgical operation.
00:38:37 Simon Gaisford
It's very difficult to imagine that a mother in particular could be calm about that.
00:38:41 Lorenzo Fabrizi
But you can see like in the playground, I mean, we've been in the playground before, you can see different kind of, it's called parental attachment because there were different styles.
00:38:50 Lorenzo Fabrizi
The parent that kneels down at the level of the baby is like, Oh, you hurt yourself, it's going to be, do you want to cuddle?
00:38:56 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And then the parent is like, Oh my God, what happened? What have you done? Cut your leg off now!
00:39:03 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And then you can see, you can see, yeah, exactly, yeah.
00:39:07 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So then you can see the different effect it has on the baby.
00:39:10 Lorenzo Fabrizi
The baby that has the kind of calm approach regulates straight away.
00:39:16 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Eventually learning that actually it's not that bad.
00:39:18 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So they actually then learn how to auto-regulate later on in life.
00:39:22 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:39:23 Simon Gaisford
Because ultimately pain is presumably a survival mechanism, isn't it?
00:39:28 Simon Gaisford
It's like saying, don't do that again.
00:39:31 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's the learning.
00:39:34 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Sorry.
00:39:35 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, so that's basically, isn't it?
00:39:36 Simon Gaisford
So I mean, the questions about what is happening to a baby born preterm is super interesting, isn't it?
00:39:44 Simon Gaisford
Because presumably, without modern medical intervention, they would never have survived.
00:39:50 Simon Gaisford
And physiologically, therefore, a baby isn't designed to to deal with those stimuli, so that's just a huge issue in its own right in the first place.
00:39:58 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's how we moved it, so the answer to one of the scripted question, I love those ones, yeah.
00:40:07 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Why is it important is because now the kind of medical care has advanced, so that a baby born at twenty-three, twenty-three weeks, but viable.
00:40:17 Simon Gaisford
I thought it was twenty-four, twenty-three.
00:40:18 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Twenty-three is viable, so they can survive.
00:40:20 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Of course, they're very likely to have a lot of issues with the retina and all, because nothing has developed the lungs and all stuff.
00:40:27 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:40:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
But then basically now, okay, now we ensured their survival.
00:40:32 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Now we have to shift our attention to, okay, what is the impact of this kind of early experience?
00:40:37 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Also because you can't, it's unavoidable.
00:40:41 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Because the fact itself that you want to ensure that survival means there to go under clinical procedure.
00:40:47 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So you can't say, okay, I do less than that.
00:40:50 Lorenzo Fabrizi
No, you can't.
00:40:51 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So, okay, that's what is the impact, and how can we modulate how can we kind of dampen that early impact?
00:40:57 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So, that's why that's why it's quite it's quite actual, it's quite present, and modern modern need that was not maybe not as needed like a few years ago.
00:41:06 Simon Gaisford
And that's an incredibly difficult thing to prove, isn't it?
00:41:09 Simon Gaisford
Because ultimately,
00:41:11 Simon Gaisford
One needs to take measurements of a child born prematurely and follow that child through to adulthood and start to make some correlations.
00:41:18 Simon Gaisford
But by definition, that's the 30-year-long experiment, isn't it?
00:41:22 Stephanie Koch
They've done that.
00:41:23 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Very good, very good at spotting.
00:41:25 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Yeah, but yeah, very few, very few.
00:41:28 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I actually often ask to people around this kind of longitudinal studies, how do you, how do you get funding for?
00:41:34 Lorenzo Fabrizi
It's because it's, I mean, you create a cohort and I've been sitting to an MRC panel discussion.
00:41:40 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So you create a cohort which is very be robust and then they must see themselves, they're actually interested in not losing their cohort.
00:41:47 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Of course, every single grant has to be related to a different question on the same call, but it's quite hard.
00:41:54 Lorenzo Fabrizi
There are not many studies like that.
00:41:56 Stephanie Koch
I do think what has come out of this though, from my view, is that the impact of that kind of very stressful, as Sandrine said, loud,
00:42:08 Stephanie Koch
They don't have much touch, as Lorenzo was saying, and they have more pain.
00:42:13 Stephanie Koch
The impact is that everything kind of is not quite right.
00:42:18 Stephanie Koch
They are more likely to have movement disorders.
00:42:23 Stephanie Koch
Their brain development is delayed.
00:42:26 Stephanie Koch
Speech, pain, addiction, you name it, it's affected.
00:42:32 Stephanie Koch
So in a way, those kind of studies are very useful to know the impact.
00:42:35 Stephanie Koch
but then to understand what to do with it.
00:42:37 Stephanie Koch
I just don't think we can do that with clinical studies.
00:42:40 Stephanie Koch
I just don't, because there's too many moving parts.
00:42:44 Stephanie Koch
I think for me what's really interesting is what Lorenzo was saying, this idea of the bonding, we know it's likely to be smell and touch because those are the two earliest developed senses in an infant.
00:42:57 Stephanie Koch
That's what
00:42:58 Stephanie Koch
they learn first, which tells you that's what they need to survive.
00:43:02 Stephanie Koch
And then comes sight and hearing and then comes pain responses and stuff.
00:43:07 Stephanie Koch
So it's all in these stages which can tell us when to intervene, how, and also what the infant is learning from.
00:43:14 Stephanie Koch
What are the cues?
00:43:15 Stephanie Koch
Because you don't want to get rid of all of it, right?
00:43:18 Stephanie Koch
No, They have to have touch.
00:43:20 Stephanie Koch
Yeah, And they have to have the smell.
00:43:22 Stephanie Koch
But it's just enough to dampen it so that they can have a long and healthy life.
00:43:26 Stephanie Koch
That's the point.
00:43:27 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's for feeding, by the way.
00:43:29 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Because the most
important thing, they have to be able to find the breast and latch.
00:43:32 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's the only thing they have to do when they're born.
00:43:34 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Nothing else.
00:43:35 Lorenzo Fabrizi
They don't have to walk.
00:43:37 Lorenzo Fabrizi
They don’t have to go anywhere.
00:43:39 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Just have to spot it and then feed.
00:43:43 Sandrine Geranton
But I think the positive aspect of our work at the moment is that now that we're aware of all the consequences that we were not aware of, that they're not limited to just one of the sensors or something, is that we can start thinking about how can we make things better.
00:43:57 Sandrine Geranton
And we said it might not be like pharmacology.
00:44:00 Sandrine Geranton
Sometimes what scares me as well is you think about all these children and they're all going to go back to different households.
00:44:05 Sandrine Geranton
And one will have a household that might be ready to put loads of things into, you know, in action to like whatever they've been deprived of could be provided.
00:44:12 Sandrine Geranton
The more we understand what we need to provide.
00:44:16 Simon Gaisford
Guidelines, isn't it?
00:44:17 Sandrine Geranton
Exactly, for that plasticity to kind of go back on track at some point.
00:44:20 Sandrine Geranton
And therefore, I think all this plasticity that we're all interested in, the more we understand it, the more maybe we can harness it to actually what Stephanie was saying, reverse the system or allow them to catch up because we all think it's possible, right?
00:44:33 Sandrine Geranton
But it won't be if we don't do anything.
00:44:35 Sandrine Geranton
No, We need to put in place some action so that things can be recovered.
00:44:40 Sandrine Geranton
And I think they can.
00:44:41 Simon Gaisford
Okay.
00:44:44 Simon Gaisford
Right, in the 8 minutes we've got left, I'll ask two questions and then I'll ask you each what you think is your most exciting thing that might happen in your, you know, what you're looking forward to in your research careers.
00:44:56 Simon Gaisford
So my two questions are, and you can say no again, where chronic pain is caused by nerve damage, can that be undone?
00:45:09 Sandrine Geranton
That's the hardest one, I would say.
00:45:12 Sandrine Geranton
So, I mean, they will always have, so the nerve damage, like chronic pain issue, is that there is an actual damage.
00:45:20 Sandrine Geranton
We talk a lot about chronic pain when actually we think there's no more damage, everything's been healed.
00:45:24 Simon Gaisford
It's psychosomatic.
00:45:25 Sandrine Geranton
Exactly, but that one, and I think you are always going to have a peripheral drive.
00:45:29 Sandrine Geranton
But we also know that some patients manage to actually live with this peripheral drive because they know that they have the strength to kind of silence it.
00:45:38 Sandrine Geranton
And some patients don't seem to have that possibility.
00:45:40 Sandrine Geranton
Of course, there's never going to be two similar patients.
00:45:43 Sandrine Geranton
So there's always one that's going to say that, the injury is more likely to be like have a stronger peripheral drive.
00:45:50 Sandrine Geranton
But I would say out of all the chronic pain states, it's probably the one that might be more responsive to any pharmacological treatment.
00:45:59 Simon Gaisford
Yeah.
00:46:00 Sandrine Geranton
But the one that's the most likely to always have something?
00:46:04 Stephanie Koch
Yeah.
00:46:05 Simon Gaisford
Okay, that's tricky.
00:46:06 Simon Gaisford
As we said, the common theme here is this is complicated and multifactorial.
00:46:13 Simon Gaisford
And my other question was, because of my own interest really, with gut health.
00:46:18 Simon Gaisford
So a child, newborn child has no gut flora.
00:46:23 Simon Gaisford
And so their gut flora develops over the first two years of life.
00:46:28 Simon Gaisford
How do we know how being born preterm and the gut flora also affects development, pain response?
00:46:36 Lorenzo Fabrizi
No, I didn't even know what you just said.
00:46:41 Lorenzo Fabrizi
New information to me.
00:46:42 Lorenzo Fabrizi
That's interesting.
00:46:44 Lorenzo Fabrizi
No, I had no idea.
00:46:45 Sandrine Geranton
But there's lots of work done on the microbiome and how it interacts with chronic pain states.
00:46:50 Simon Gaisford
So gut-brain access.
00:46:52 Sandrine Geranton
Exactly.
00:46:53 Sandrine Geranton
So it is, but no one has looked at it in the context of preterm infants, I would say.
00:46:57 Sandrine Geranton
So maybe.
00:46:58 Stephanie Koch
I think that's a fascinating subject.
00:46:59 Sandrine Geranton
Exactly.
00:47:00 Sandrine Geranton
That's it.
00:47:01 Simon Gaisford
It comes back to that what you said before about.
00:47:03 Sandrine Geranton
Do you have any money for us?
00:47:06 Simon Gaisford
Back to what you said before about, guidance and what best practice while a baby's in an incubator, this thing about how do they develop their own gut flora is also kind of important.
00:47:16 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I had no idea.
00:47:17 Lorenzo Fabrizi
Good question.
00:47:18 Sandrine Geranton
So what would you say then, because you're the specialist, would you like have special like feedings?
00:47:22 Simon Gaisford
I don't know what the answer is, but there's a species called Bifidobacterium infantis, and the reason it's called that is because when you look at a newborn's gut, that's the only bacterium which is there, that's where the name comes from.
00:47:35 Simon Gaisford
And then that is slowly, it's like a barrier coat of bacteria lining the gut.
00:47:40 Simon Gaisford
And then as that child is exposed to various external stimuli, or not stimuli, but foods, then different bacteria start to take over.
00:47:51 Simon Gaisford
And it's one of the reasons why caesarean birth versus a vaginal birth, breastfeeding versus formula milk, is so important because
00:47:59 Simon Gaisford
because of the bacteria.
00:48:01 Simon Gaisford
There is actually a fantastic spin-off company at UCL called Booby Biome, and they're looking at trying to deliver probiotics with formula milk because they recognise that the child on formula only is at risk of not having.
00:48:18 Simon Gaisford
Amazing.
00:48:18 Simon Gaisford
Yeah, so that's very cool.
00:48:20 Simon Gaisford
To finish, I'll ask each one of you, what's the most exciting thing that you would like to achieve in your research over the next few years.
00:48:26 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So one thing which is quite frustrating about doing human research is that you have a lot of observation but not much explanation of what those things you observe are.
00:48:34 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So I think what we are trying here to do at the Medawar Pain and Somatosensory Labs is try to integrate what different scales from macro in humans to micro in animal models and cell culture.
00:48:46 Lorenzo Fabrizi
So I think what I would love to see the three of us, or the Metawar Pain Somatosensory Labs, to come together to try to carry out some sort of integrated vision of what it means for the pain to develop over the early days of life.
00:49:01 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And then what we observe in humans, what does it actually mean?
00:49:05 Lorenzo Fabrizi
And that would also lead to what can we do about it.
00:49:08 Lorenzo Fabrizi
I think that would be, so basically more collaborative project between us.
00:49:14 Sandrine Geranton
So for me, I've been putting my money on trying to find a biomarkers of chronic pain susceptibility in the shape of epigenetic marks.
00:49:21 Sandrine Geranton
So if we could get anywhere near that in the near future, working with preclinical models as its limitation, but I think there's a lot of work that could be done in humans.
00:49:30 Sandrine Geranton
And very often then I'm being told, and what would you do if you knew someone was going to have a chronic pain?
00:49:35 Sandrine Geranton
That will be for the next invitation.
00:49:36 Sandrine Geranton
That would take too long.
00:49:37 Sandrine Geranton
But I think if we could find, I think molecularly epigenetics really lend itself as a biomarker of susceptibility.
00:49:44 Sandrine Geranton
or resilience.
00:49:45 Sandrine Geranton
So that would be what I would like to see happening.
00:49:48 Simon Gaisford
I'm going to follow up that one anyway.
00:49:49 Simon Gaisford
I mean, that would be a funny thing, wouldn't it?
00:49:50 Simon Gaisford
If you did the test on someone, you said, oh, your epigenetic test says you are actually more susceptible to pain.
00:49:55 Simon Gaisford
Have you then primed that person to be more susceptible to?
00:50:00 Sandrine Geranton
Pain?
00:50:00 Sandrine Geranton
It's a bit like.
00:50:01 Sandrine Geranton
telling someone that they might have the early onset Alzheimer’s for example.
00:50:06 Sandrine Geranton
No, but I think what people said, and again, I'm not a clinician, don't take my word, but if someone is going into surgery and they know they're more likely to have chronic pain, depending on the outcome of the surgery, you can give more, and then Stephanie would know more than me, but you can
00:50:19 Sandrine Geranton
give more painkillers at the moment when they wake up after the surgery, making sure that morphine is topped up.
00:50:24 Sandrine Geranton
So that's my understanding.
00:50:25 Sandrine Geranton
But I think knowing very often we say is better than not knowing.
00:50:28 Simon Gaisford
Absolutely.
00:50:29 Sandrine Geranton
I'm not sure.
00:50:30 Sandrine Geranton
I'm not sure I believe it, but yeah, at least being aware and for the clinical team may be worth it.
00:50:35 Simon Gaisford
All knowledge is good.
00:50:36 Simon Gaisford
Only the uses to which you are put are good or bad.
00:50:41 Simon Gaisford
And Stephanie?
00:50:42 Stephanie Koch
For me, it's really I'm so keen on this idea of prevention of pain.
00:50:48 Stephanie Koch
in all sense, prevention versus cure.
00:50:52 Stephanie Koch
As Sandrine was saying, just to jump in, if you take ibuprofen, paracetamol, as you're supposed to regularly,
00:51:01 Stephanie Koch
three times a day or four times a day, depending on the medication.
00:51:04 Stephanie Koch
It's an extremely useful analgesic.
00:51:07 Stephanie Koch
It's not good at stopping pain, it's good at preventing pain.
00:51:09 Stephanie Koch
So I feel very strongly about the fact that we should be thinking about pain much more about how can we prevent chronicity from taking hold within our nervous system.
00:51:19 Stephanie Koch
And that means identifying some common cues across all the different stressors that we're talking about, whether that's sort of cell types or signaling pathways.
00:51:29 Stephanie Koch
That's what I would really want to do.
00:51:32 Simon Gaisford
Excellent.
00:51:33 Simon Gaisford
That was a fantastic conversation, which has always raised way more questions.
00:51:39 Simon Gaisford
So I hope all the listeners found that super interesting.
00:51:41 Simon Gaisford
I know I did.
00:51:42 Simon Gaisford
And thank you very much for coming along.
00:51:44 Stephanie Koch
Thank you very much.
00:51:46 Stephanie Koch
Thank you.
00:51:46 Stephanie Koch
Very fun.