ကူးယူချက် 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:08.800
Welcome to EU Tech Loop Radio, our series of conversations to dive deeper into the issues surrounding EU's technology, consumer, startup regulations, and more.
00:00:08.800 --> 00:00:11.519
This episode is dedicated to EU Inc.
00:00:11.519 --> 00:00:14.800
or the EU's ambition to create its own Delaware.
00:00:14.800 --> 00:00:19.199
We spoke with Simon Schaefer, one of the co-founders behind the EU Inc.
00:00:19.199 --> 00:00:20.079
petition.
00:00:20.079 --> 00:00:23.839
Hope you'll enjoy the episode as much as I did.
00:00:24.239 --> 00:00:26.640
Hi Simon, thank you for joining us today.
00:00:26.879 --> 00:00:28.399
Hi Egle, thank you for having me.
00:00:28.879 --> 00:00:31.716
Now let's bring a bit of transparency here.
00:00:31.716 --> 00:00:33.969
What's your role within the EU Inc.
00:00:33.969 --> 00:00:34.719
community?
00:00:35.039 --> 00:00:35.981
Yeah, happy to.
00:00:35.981 --> 00:00:37.182
We started EU Inc.
00:00:37.182 --> 00:00:41.036
some two years ago—Andreas, Vojtech, Philipp, and myself.
00:00:41.036 --> 00:00:43.091
We've grown a little bit since.
00:00:43.091 --> 00:00:45.234
We're a team of almost eight now.
00:00:45.234 --> 00:00:49.774
But we are unfunded and we are not any type of company or anything.
00:00:49.774 --> 00:00:56.198
We're a group of passionate Europeans who all work in some form, way, or another in technology.
00:00:56.198 --> 00:01:04.079
And we've set this goal to make the impossible possible and hopefully create a new company framework for Europe.
00:01:04.400 --> 00:01:11.262
For those of our listeners who are not too familiar with the subject, what's the 28th regime EU Inc.
00:01:11.262 --> 00:01:11.695
about?
00:01:11.695 --> 00:01:13.519
What was the initial idea?
00:01:13.840 --> 00:01:14.435
Yeah, sure.
00:01:14.435 --> 00:01:19.123
Maybe explaining where it came from or what the initial intention was there.
00:01:19.123 --> 00:01:42.268
When looking at the countries that are not as developed in terms of their technology ecosystem—countries that are at a significant disadvantage even inside Europe, not even looking at them moving to Delaware or anywhere else abroad, but even inside Europe—it's sometimes very hard when you're from a smaller member state to raise capital, to raise awareness, and to gain momentum.
00:01:42.268 --> 00:02:10.323
And the obvious challenge that we have there is, if you are accustomed to investing in Germany or France or the UK, having to understand the legal framework of every member state is an inefficiency of our current status quo in the European Union.So we thought, what if we had—similar to Delaware in the United States—what if we had one standard for all of Europe, so that all member states shared the same risks and opportunities when it comes to startup investment?
00:02:10.323 --> 00:02:20.368
And the same is of course true for the founder, on the other side of the table, when raising capital or governing or maintaining or
Load full transcript
working with their companies, right?
00:02:20.368 --> 00:02:30.415
And even all the way down to taxes and any reports you need to submit to the government.Now, the 28th regime is an old term used in the European Union for quite some time.
00:02:30.415 --> 00:02:48.052
And it was the idea of a virtual member state, so to speak, in which legislation can be made available and member states choose to opt in to this legislation.After we went through collecting traction and gaining momentum from the community, a lot of people signed up for our initial petition.
00:02:48.052 --> 00:02:59.289
We went through the effort of creating a legal framework with law offices from across Europe and the US in order to make sure it's a tangible solution and not just an idea on a white paper.
00:02:59.289 --> 00:03:10.453
And then the Commission made a proposal this year in March.And it's not a 28th regime; it still relies on 27 member states, as in, for example, dispute resolution when it comes to the courts.
00:03:10.453 --> 00:03:19.158
But it enables a free choice of seat, so anyone in Europe can choose to incorporate anywhere else in Europe, which is precisely what Delaware is.
00:03:19.158 --> 00:03:35.009
You can sit in Massachusetts, but your company is in Delaware, and that enables the community and the member states to build the best possible system for startups, which is ultimately the same goal.It's not quite as European in its current form as it was proposed.
00:03:35.009 --> 00:03:45.280
It's not a proper pan-European solution as one standard, but it is standardizing or harmonizing as much as possible within the legislative frameworks at your disposal.
00:03:45.599 --> 00:03:54.591
Sometimes we hear a bit of a cynical approach from smaller EU member states or less bureaucratic member states saying, "Why do we need EU Inc.?
00:03:54.591 --> 00:04:08.944
We have a pretty good regime back at home." Our companies—including in Lithuania, including in Estonia—often scale within the US, and once they have enough money, they come back to Europe and deal with all the bureaucracy here.
00:04:08.944 --> 00:04:10.758
So what's your answer to that?
00:04:10.758 --> 00:04:13.439
Why should all Europeans care about this?
00:04:13.759 --> 00:04:20.185
So initially that sentiment is not wrong; the only problem there is that they go somewhere else to scale.
00:04:20.185 --> 00:04:21.696
That to us makes no sense.
00:04:21.696 --> 00:04:24.946
Europe has an internal market of 450 million people.
00:04:24.946 --> 00:04:51.475
I think if we look at geostrategy and geopolitics, we are in a place where our old contracts are not as stable as they once were, so for us to build a European perspective on technology is an approach very much worthwhile.Bearing in mind we have failed to do so for every significant past step in innovation: the internet in the beginning, web 2.0, and everything in frontier AI we're seeing right now, Europeans are barely playing a role.
00:04:51.475 -->
00:04:56.011
And you know, if times become more challenging, that also becomes an issue.
00:04:56.011 --> 00:05:14.906
We go as far as saying our sovereignty, our social cohesion, and the survival of our democracies to a degree depend on our sovereignty—not independence, but at least the ability to meet other incumbents at eye level.So, you know, being able to scale inside Europe without hurdles is really a low-hanging fruit.
00:05:14.906 --> 00:05:21.935
And if you look at Delaware, it's really interesting to think that even that framework is from before the internet.
00:05:21.935 --> 00:05:29.797
So not only should we have a standard that's comparable, but why aren't we innovating this and doing even better than Delaware is?
00:05:29.797 --> 00:05:52.170
Why are we not having something that's so purely well developed for startups that our startups have an unfair advantage in the global economy?And you know, as an entrepreneur, the glass is always half full, and we're now trying to find the compromise that the European Union is built on in order to make that a reality, and I think that's where it touches all Europeans.
00:05:52.170 --> 00:06:01.920
It is not just about creating hyperscalers; it's about having our economy use the full potential of Europe, and this is in the interest of every single one of us.
00:06:15.759 --> 00:06:17.790
Let's talk about the hurdles.
00:06:17.790 --> 00:06:21.059
Today is Thursday, October 15th, and the EU Inc.
00:06:21.059 --> 00:06:26.800
pages shared disappointment in the way the negotiations are currently going.
00:06:27.120 --> 00:06:31.509
So I think the saying "the devil's in the details" is never truer than here.
00:06:31.509 --> 00:06:34.990
When we look at the tools required in order to make EU Inc.
00:06:34.990 --> 00:06:37.639
work, we have defined five non-negotiables.
00:06:37.639 --> 00:06:55.120
And this is—you know, it's very polemic, the way that we stated it, probably too polemic.But these five—and I'm giving you three quick examples: the free choice of where to register the company, an employee stock option program, and a central registry, meaning a central interface for EU Inc.
00:06:55.120 --> 00:07:16.084
to administer, to found, and to manage the companies.These three plus the other two—the five in total—are the ones that need to be in there for it to be adopted by the community.And I think the real challenge we're facing is not a lack of willingness or a lack of ambition, but really a lack of understanding of the innovation economy and startups.
00:07:16.084 --> 00:07:37.803
Because, of course, over the last decades, everyone that has been working with the European Commission has been trying to protect national member state sovereignty, taxation, and labor law—all these complex parameters—and not give up too much to the European Union, because it was a peace project, it was built on compromise, and it's slow in its behavior.
00:07:37.803 --> 00:07:44.387
And it's like, "If it works, why
touch it, and why not look at it on a national level first?"That does not make sense.
00:07:44.387 --> 00:07:52.108
It just does not make sense when you're trying to create a digital market or a single market—forget digital, one single market.
00:07:52.108 --> 00:07:59.221
And the challenge here is we have the highest level of support, I think, that we could ever find for any of these files.
00:07:59.221 --> 00:08:07.016
We have prime ministers in the Council asking for the single market to be created by the Commission before the end of the year.
00:08:07.016 --> 00:08:12.920
We have Ursula von der Leyen, of course, and Commissioner McGrath and Commissioner Zakharieva.
00:08:12.920 --> 00:08:27.298
They are all extremely in favor of this because, obviously, this is an institutional solution for a problem that is the outcome of any one of their policies.So we have the highest level of ambition; we have the highest level of support.
00:08:27.298 --> 00:08:47.201
But then it goes into where these files are being negotiated—the Parliament, the meetings of the ambassadors to the European Union, the so-called permanent representations—and the majority of the people working on these files have been defending their fiefdoms, their own little worlds, for so many years, if not decades.
00:08:47.201 --> 00:09:14.294
And that's where we're losing the teeth, that's where we're losing the ambition, that's where a free choice of seat is debated away because it raises the concern that the meatpacking industry could avoid local legislative environments.It is all not really optimized for the initial goal, which is to be better than Delaware or equal to Delaware, and mainly focused on startups and fast-growing companies that want the European market as one.
00:09:14.294 --> 00:09:25.798
And that's a lack of knowledge; it's a lack of leadership, political leadership, because it's probably not the startup economy's job to lobby with prime ministers to actually get this right.
00:09:25.798 --> 00:09:32.080
But we take on the challenge as entrepreneurs; we see the issue and we're being as loud about it as we can.
00:09:32.320 --> 00:09:33.600
So let's talk specifics.
00:09:33.600 --> 00:09:36.567
Are the notary requirements still in?
00:09:36.567 --> 00:09:47.001
Most people in Central Eastern Europe, for example, cannot imagine what kind of Dante's hell steps you have to take in Germany, for example.
00:09:47.001 --> 00:09:55.200
Is the notary requirement still in, and what are the other very specific points of criticism from your side?
00:09:55.519 --> 00:09:59.929
Yeah, so I mean, you need to look at when and where notaries are relevant.
00:09:59.929 --> 00:10:11.922
And I think there is a role for notaries to play in the identification of the individual they're dealing with, certain background checks, and making sure to have checks and balances on fraud.
00:10:11.922 --> 00:10:15.094
So I think notaries need to define their own roles.
00:10:15.094 --> 00:10:33.275
Being a monopoly in Germany—where every document that you sign needs to be read out loud so that the notary actually has to read the document to you, which can take forever, as you just mentioned—let me say, there's innovation potential in the process.These are not the really big ones, though.
00:10:33.275 --> 00:10:39.155
I'll give you one concrete example that is really challenging for us: employee stock options.
00:10:39.155 --> 00:10:47.125
Employee stock options always sound like this "nice-to-have" thing, but in reality, it goes to the core of what startups are doing.
00:10:47.125 --> 00:10:52.385
First, you have employee stock options to retain talent that can be very expensive.
00:10:52.385 --> 00:10:56.951
The best people in the world often go where they have the highest salary.
00:10:56.951 --> 00:11:23.566
For a company with less funding, the only way to compensate for that is to award stock in the company—employee stock options.Another really important outcome is what is famously known in Silicon Valley as the "PayPal Mafia." These were former shareholders of PayPal that had enough money and funds from those initial exits to eBay in order to be able to found the next generation of companies or invest in other companies.
00:11:23.566 --> 00:11:38.111
So it's part of the flywheel that makes it all work.Now, the member states that are positioning themselves against the employee stock option as suggested by the Commission in the proposal are not against stock options in general.
00:11:38.111 --> 00:11:54.359
They are against this specific regulation based on this specific legal article to regulate taxes because they are afraid they would open a loophole for further regulations by the European Commission to also further interfere with their own tax rules.
00:11:54.359 --> 00:12:06.119
So it's really a technicality.And you know, for me as an entrepreneur, it's just like, "Oh my God, how?" If that sentiment is successful or if this is taken out of the regulation, what does that mean?
00:12:06.119 --> 00:12:19.504
Either the Commission pulls back the proposal and rewrites it over another three years, or it is removed from the legislation, but the regulation passes, and there needs to be a new one designed for stock options.
00:12:19.504 --> 00:12:25.693
And if you are focused on the outcome and not the procedure, then that's not a really viable process.
00:12:25.693 --> 00:12:33.275
One possible way forward would be to create an exception just for this one regulation in order to not stall the process.
00:12:33.275 --> 00:12:42.715
I think the urgency and the drama inherent in this innovation crisis are not fully understood by the upper echelons where this is being negotiated.
00:12:42.715 --> 00:12:47.279
We don't need this in five years; we need this as fast as freaking possible.
00:12:47.600 --> 00:13:03.965
I think the point on free choice of registration and a single digital registry opens up much wider and bigger problems that we have in
the EU—a completely fragmented picture or map of how registers work.
00:13:03.965 --> 00:13:08.597
In Lithuania, for example, everything is super digitized.
00:13:08.597 --> 00:13:12.639
You have a personal code; everything is connected.
00:13:12.960 --> 00:13:17.052
Let me say one more thing about that, because this is one of my key points.
00:13:17.052 --> 00:13:18.251
Two things, actually.
00:13:18.251 --> 00:13:21.003
First, the registries are changing their shape.
00:13:21.003 --> 00:13:32.927
Where we came from, they used to be just, "Okay, this company exists, it has an address, and this is its tax identification number." In the future, it should have ultimate beneficial ownership checks and KYC checks.
00:13:32.927 --> 00:13:34.620
It should give you a cap table.
00:13:34.620 --> 00:13:50.778
It should be able to do simulations on the cap table depending on how much credit you take, et cetera, et cetera.And secondly, for the customer—for the startup or the venture capitalist—having to log into 27 systems instead of one is just ridiculous if the goal is creating one market.
00:13:50.778 --> 00:13:53.105
Of course we need to log into one product.
00:13:53.105 --> 00:14:02.984
So ultimately, this digital registry is the translation of a regulation, a policy, or legislation—whatever you want to call it—into a tangible product for the end customer.
00:14:02.984 --> 00:14:06.299
And that's what I'm really lacking: the customer foresight.
00:14:06.299 --> 00:14:09.475
What do the people need who are actually going to use it?
00:14:09.475 --> 00:14:15.120
Because then this question of whether we should have a central registry simply does not survive.
00:14:15.360 --> 00:14:24.559
And registry, in full honesty, is just a database from old times when everything was paper-based, everything is digitized at most places.
00:14:24.559 --> 00:14:27.759
So we have it to treat it as a database.
00:14:28.080 --> 00:14:32.139
Regarding the point of the scope that the EU Inc.
00:14:32.139 --> 00:14:37.759
regime would apply to: What kind of companies is this relevant for?
00:14:37.759 --> 00:14:50.663
Previously, we saw a lot of discussions on what an innovative company should entail and what criteria companies should meet so that they can use EU Inc.
00:14:50.663 --> 00:15:06.067
We saw a lot of naysayers saying that it should only be spin-offs from universities and companies super heavily involved with the European Innovation Council, Horizon Europe, etc.
00:15:06.067 --> 00:15:09.398
But that's what the tech sector is about.
00:15:09.398 --> 00:15:12.000
So what's the status quo on this?
00:15:12.399 --> 00:15:13.740
So currently it is not.
00:15:13.740 --> 00:15:27.826
But if you look at how something like this develops over time, you have the Commission making a proposal, you have the Parliament and the Council finding an opinion, and then they all meet in the trilogues to define a final file, right?
00:15:27.826 --> 00:15:29.167
That's still to happen.
00:15:29.167 --> 00:15:31.923
And at that point in time, anything can change.
00:15:31.923 --> 00:15:47.946
So it's almost behind closed doors; nobody really knows what goes in and what comes out.Now, I think we need to look at this constraint—innovative or not innovative—again through the lens of: Are we adding bureaucracy and complexity, or are we taking complexity away?
00:15:47.946 --> 00:15:49.287
That's the first point.
00:15:49.287 --> 00:16:04.116
So if it's a non-binary decision, like "a little bit of innovation, but not enough," then it's debatable, and then it simply does not work, because you need administrative instances, conflict resolution, etc.Finding a binary definition is really hard.
00:16:04.116 --> 00:16:14.028
Otherwise, we would probably also want to suggest one, because then we wouldn't have to deal with the complexities of making this applicable to the entire economy.
00:16:14.028 --> 00:16:27.366
But most importantly, nobody knows where innovation is heading.If we exclude the meat industry as an example, who knows what meat-replacing product will be produced in the future that could solve our meat supply chain?
00:16:27.366 --> 00:16:36.980
Or if you look at agriculture and automation in agriculture—robotics that could start existing in certain verticals that are then excluded by definition.
00:16:36.980 --> 00:16:49.126
So I think trying to anticipate where innovation is heading and providing a constraint on the basis of this is flawed, because neither Brussels, nor venture capital, nor startup founders can do that.
00:16:49.126 --> 00:16:56.131
That's looking into a crystal ball that we simply don't have.And the constraints created are based on fears of abuse.
00:16:56.131 --> 00:16:57.399
So let's tackle abuse.
00:16:57.399 --> 00:17:01.943
We're not against tackling abuse; abuse is not our optimization potential.
00:17:01.943 --> 00:17:07.011
Our optimization potential is the first trillion-euro company to exist in Europe.
00:17:07.011 --> 00:17:19.680
And that's why I think working against the constraints that are the real problem—meaning abuse—needs different tools than trying to anticipate innovation, where everyone else in the industry says you can't.
00:17:20.079 --> 00:17:26.134
Is the free choice of registration being called residency—I don't remember the exact name—shopping?
00:17:26.134 --> 00:17:28.720
Is that the term that the critics are using?
00:17:29.039 --> 00:17:31.271
Yes, "forum shopping" is what it's called.
00:17:31.271 --> 00:17:45.454
Yeah, so a race to the bottom, trying to find the best environment and the member states competing for that environment to be created.Though being kind of an anti-European principle, it's the only thing that's possible in the current construct.
00:17:45.454 --> 00:18:00.068
So the reach of the Commission and the Union doesn't go deep enough unless you go through unanimity, which means every member state has to consent to it and agree to it.It's not deep enough to really create these rules that are universally applicable.
00:18:00.068 --> 00:18:08.924
There is variation, and there is local adaptation necessary.Which, of course—that's what Europe was built on; we're not saying that it shouldn't have that.
00:18:08.924 --> 00:18:14.324
What we are saying, though, is the direct example to compete against is and remains Delaware.
00:18:14.324 --> 00:18:16.195
And Delaware is not great, right?
00:18:16.195 --> 00:18:20.804
Delaware is simply the most applicable standard through a high volume of use.
00:18:20.804 --> 00:18:25.770
So many people have used it so successfully that it has become the de facto standard.
00:18:25.770 --> 00:18:35.417
But that doesn't mean that, A, it can't be done better, and B, if it's also from before the internet, there's not significant innovation potential in this entire framework.
00:18:35.417 --> 00:18:44.130
So that's why, for us, saying free choice of registered seat is what enables the same principle as Delaware for the Union as it is for the United States.
00:18:44.130 --> 00:18:51.184
That means we leave the innovation potential on the table because individual member states can do better than others.
00:18:51.184 --> 00:19:04.000
And you can call it a race to the bottom, you can call it forum shopping, but we call it the only surviving principle if you do not create one single standard for all of Europe that everyone has to unanimously subscribe to.
00:19:04.319 --> 00:19:22.381
t's a bit of a double standard, if you will, because federalists in Europe—including Mario Draghi—are talking about the need for the EU to become a "pragmatic federation." Lots of companies are lobbying for increasing European competitiveness, but for whom?
00:19:22.381 --> 00:19:27.069
And we're at least theoretically working towards a single market.
00:19:27.069 --> 00:19:28.720
What's stopping us here?
00:19:29.039 --> 00:19:30.480
Towards more federalization?
00:19:30.880 --> 00:19:32.160
Towards common standards.
00:19:32.480 --> 00:19:39.080
I think in reality it's a definition of where Europe comes from and where it needs to be heading to.
00:19:39.080 --> 00:19:54.955
So we're coming from the result of a Second World War, in which we desperately needed to grow together, and it's a peace project that formed alliances in order to make sure it never again comes to the situation it was in the decade before.
00:19:54.955 --> 00:20:01.891
I believe that's not a complete summary, but it's an outcome of the previous phase of the European Union.
00:20:01.891 --> 00:20:10.663
And you know, to our benefit, I grew up in peace, and I'm very grateful for that—and I could not imagine, as you are, being so close to a war.
00:20:10.663 --> 00:20:23.699
It's one of my big fears, and I think it's also one of the driving forces behind a potential for more federal thinking, because in the end, the only thing that drives this is an externalized threat.
00:20:23.699 --> 00:20:48.765
The only time in which we
as Europe really acted as one, took on collective debt, and made sure that we have collective rules was during the coronavirus pandemic.And that's also why, in my book, we're not talking enough about an innovation crisis and a sovereignty or security crisis when it comes to technology, because that would give us different tools to act together.
00:20:48.765 --> 00:20:53.277
Instead, Europe is still European; it's still doing what it's used to.
00:20:53.277 --> 00:20:57.454
It's slowly meandering through the implementation of a file.
00:20:57.454 --> 00:21:17.340
And here we are, where everyone in the European Union tells us no one has ever processed a file as quickly as EU Inc.—if it succeeds at closing or being done by the end of the year, which we highly doubt given the status it's in.That already means, again, over three years for its final implementation.
00:21:17.340 --> 00:21:27.200
So I think the real challenge is that we're not scared enough as Europe, or not afraid enough of the future without it, so that we actually act for it.
00:21:27.519 --> 00:21:33.743
You've mentioned that the involvement of the EU Commission was quite good—exemplary, if you will.
00:21:33.743 --> 00:21:36.423
What about the governments, the PermReps?
00:21:36.423 --> 00:21:40.913
I'm sure you're trying to reach out to them through individual members.
00:21:40.913 --> 00:21:43.119
Have they ever contacted you guys?
00:21:43.440 --> 00:22:04.742
Yeah, so, one challenge that we surely have is resources, being a small group, and that's also why we work with associations where we have standing relationships, or where these associations have standing relationships with PermReps and members of the Parliament.We do have a lot of exchange with members of Parliament on specific elements of the file.
00:22:04.742 --> 00:22:09.550
And beyond the Commission, we do have a standing relationship with the Council.
00:22:09.550 --> 00:22:16.652
We've just had a meeting last week—I was unfortunately unable to travel—with the Taoiseach [Prime Minister] of Ireland.
00:22:16.652 --> 00:22:19.832
Several prime ministers have voiced their support.
00:22:19.832 --> 00:22:24.713
The Greek prime minister met us during Panathenaia when we were there in Athens.
00:22:24.713 --> 00:22:30.854
There is a very high level of support.But as you mentioned, the PermReps—I think this is the exact forum.
00:22:30.854 --> 00:22:40.692
The permanent representatives—maybe not everyone in your audience knows who they are: they are the permanent representatives of the member states in Brussels.
00:22:40.692 --> 00:22:48.531
They all have an office, they invite people for discussions, and then they have Coreper, which is their forum in which they discuss.
00:22:48.531 --> 00:22:59.923
And that's where I think the majority of negotiations happen, often to the detriment or negative impact of EU Inc., because it feels like that's how things have been done over the last decades.
00:22:59.923 --> 00:23:06.211
That's where the fiefdoms are—where member states defend their sovereignty within the European Union.
00:23:06.211 --> 00:23:25.073
And I think that's where we need to open up and think more about Europe and less about its individual member states.It's logical: if you're representing a member state, then you have a single mandate, and your mandate is not to grow Europe; your mandate is to protect your country or to advocate in favor of your country.
00:23:25.073 --> 00:23:27.218
I think that's a systemic challenge.
00:23:27.218 --> 00:23:35.428
We're more or less entering a phase where using the design of the European Union to find a compromise on such an innovative file as EU Inc.
00:23:35.428 --> 00:23:41.271
is probably a challenge for the institution itself.But that said, there are other options, right?
00:23:41.271 --> 00:23:52.737
We can do it privately, we can find a coalition of the willing, or we can work further with the Commission if it fails to develop a group of member states that get together to implement the file.
00:23:52.737 --> 00:23:55.029
So there are many other ways to do this.
00:23:55.029 --> 00:23:57.101
It just all means we're losing time.
00:23:57.101 --> 00:24:04.645
And for the most part, it's because of a lack of understanding of the innovation economy and protectionism for member states.
00:24:04.645 --> 00:24:08.640
That's not a good combination, because it leaves a lot to be desired.
00:24:08.960 --> 00:24:10.750
PermReps, especially from smaller countries, also face a shortage of resources, including human resources.
00:24:16.079 --> 00:24:16.240
Yes.
00:24:16.559 --> 00:24:18.464
So if anybody's listening, EU Inc.
00:24:18.464 --> 00:24:22.200
is available for comments and for sharing knowledge with you.
00:24:22.200 --> 00:24:24.983
We've seen some labor unions protesting EU Inc.
00:24:24.983 --> 00:24:25.717
in Brussels.
00:24:25.717 --> 00:24:27.401
What do you think about that?
00:24:27.401 --> 00:24:31.356
Would we ever see a similar protest by European startup founders?
00:24:31.356 --> 00:24:38.799
This is a little bit sarcastic because you're all busy, but
00:24:38.799 --> 00:24:44.114
To be honest, I wish we would be emotional enough to go to the barricades for it.
00:24:44.114 --> 00:24:52.719
Regarding trade unions, the first thing I want to say is that we are actually in agreement with the majority of their demands.
00:24:52.719 --> 00:24:57.105
We are against the abuse of any tool to the detriment of workers.
00:24:57.105 --> 00:25:00.142
That's never an outcome we would ever desire.
00:25:00.142 --> 00:25:10.263
Obviously, we're humans first, right?Secondly, and most importantly, the innovation economy has different tools for addressing a similar problem.
00:25:10.263 --> 00:25:17.012
So trade unions and workers' rights protection is a mechanism that stems from the Industrial Age.
00:25:17.012 --> 00:25:21.820
Of course, that's when children were sent to work for no salaries, right?
00:25:21.820
--> 00:25:24.013
Obviously required and needed.
00:25:24.013 --> 00:25:27.304
There, though, is a need to adapt to new realities.
00:25:27.304 --> 00:25:30.424
In our playbook, it's obviously stock options.
00:25:30.424 --> 00:25:42.993
We'd rather have employees become owners of the company and protect minority shareholders.Now, last but not least, abusing a company form has always been and will always be possible.
00:25:42.993 --> 00:25:53.369
No safeguard that we have in the world today—not the notaries, not the trade unions—has made it possible to 100% prevent fraud in whatever circumstance.
00:25:53.369 --> 00:26:07.540
So I think instead of being against a file that directly drives GDP and helps Europe compete globally, we should have a discussion about safeguards against abusing a system that is inherently imperfect.
00:26:07.540 --> 00:26:08.721
And even if EU Inc.
00:26:08.721 --> 00:26:14.037
is launched as it is, it will not be perfect and will need adaptation over time.
00:26:14.037 --> 00:26:26.015
But does that mean we should block the growth or the potential of Europe's founders to create the next big companies and be part of a sovereign discussion around technology?
00:26:26.015 --> 00:26:41.282
Obviously not.And again, I know it's a sarcastic question, but in the end, I actually wish we would be there by the tens of thousands in front of the Berlaymont —or demonstrating as founders to say this is so desperately needed.
00:26:41.282 --> 00:26:44.319
But I'm afraid we don't have the time to do that.
00:26:44.640 --> 00:26:46.324
We'll have to doodle that.
00:26:46.324 --> 00:26:47.334
Last question.
00:26:47.334 --> 00:27:03.920
What's your call to action for those who are listening to us today—be it a founder, a person who's interested in tech policy, a person who's in favor of the EU becoming more competitive, or a PermRep representative or a Commission representative?
00:27:04.240 --> 00:27:08.751
So in our publication today, we've also posted the work of our legal teams.
00:27:08.751 --> 00:27:21.294
We did very, very acrobatic deep dives into all of the challenges—our five non-negotiables predominantly—but we also provided red lines for every one of the compromise texts that we've received so far.
00:27:21.294 --> 00:27:22.747
We have the body of work.
00:27:22.747 --> 00:27:33.682
If you do not just want to trust our statement and that of those who signed our petition and supported our work—if this is not enough—then dive into those files and argue with us.
00:27:33.682 --> 00:27:55.172
Because what's easy to do is to say, "I'm not like you; I'm from a different part of the economy than you, and that's why I don't like what you're doing." What's really hard to do is to discuss with me tools against abuse and fraud, but not be in favor of the growth of the European market and founders in Europe.And that discussion, unfortunately, is not happening.
00:27:55.172 --> 00:28:00.143
It's either "for" or "against," and that's too polemic; that's exactly what we don't need.
00:28:00.143 --> 00:28:03.584
We need to be talking about the details, and we are ready.
00:28:03.584 --> 00:28:17.119
We just need to be heard, and we want to be sitting at the table when these details are discussed—not just to give our opinion, but to convince everyone in the room that this is absolutely necessary and the right way to go.
00:28:17.359 --> 00:28:24.155
And make sure to stay educated about the cause because we have a lack of knowledge on the topic.
00:28:24.155 --> 00:28:32.365
Everywhere I travel to Central Eastern Europe, people are not that involved.Simon, thank you for joining us today.
00:28:32.365 --> 00:28:33.865
Great conversation.
00:28:33.865 --> 00:28:34.571
Godspeed.
00:28:34.571 --> 00:28:41.279
Follow us at eutechloop.com for fresh insights into the EU's tech, consumer policies and more.
00:28:41.599 --> 00:28:42.720
Thank you for having me, Egle.